Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | AB5: What's Next?

Friday, July 1, 2022 at 2:26 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | AB5: What's Next?

About This Event

In this special episode of Trucksafe LIVE!, we'll be joined by transportation attorney Doug Grawe who will break down the U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision to deny review in the California Trucking Association's case against the state's AB5 legislation. We'll discuss the implications of the court's decision to owner-operator fleets with operations in California, along with recommendations for next steps.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In this special episode of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by guest Doug Grawe, CEO of the Grogg Group LLC, to discuss a breaking development in one of the trucking industry's most closely watched legal battles. On June 30, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court denied review in California Trucking Association v. Bonta, the case challenging California's Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) on federal preemption grounds. With the injunction that had shielded carriers from enforcement expected to lift within days of the decision, the hosts and Gross break down what the ruling means for motor carriers operating in California and beyond. The conversation covers the procedural history of the case, from California's passage of AB5 in 2019 through the district court injunction, the Ninth Circuit's reversal, and the Supreme Court's ultimate decision not to intervene. Central to the discussion is AB5's ABC test for worker classification, and specifically its "B prong," which requires that an independent contractor perform work outside the usual course of the hiring company's business. As Grawe explains, this standard is particularly difficult for trucking companies to meet because federal truth-in-leasing regulations simultaneously require carriers to maintain exclusive control over leased equipment, creating a direct conflict with the state's independence requirement. The hosts also note that while a circuit split between the First and Ninth Circuits gave the industry some hope the Supreme Court would weigh in, the high court's one-line denial leaves the Ninth Circuit's ruling in place without endorsing or explaining it. Grawe and Wiseman discuss the practical consequences for carriers with California operations, emphasizing that enforcement could begin almost immediately and may be applied retroactively. Grawe cautions that previously stayed misclassification lawsuits could be revived and that a wave of new claims from both the plaintiffs' bar and state agencies is likely. Among the compliance options discussed are converting independent contractors to W-2 employees, adopting a broker-carrier model in which the carrier becomes a broker and the owner-operator obtains their own motor carrier authority, and exploring route-buying agent models. Each option carries significant operational, contractual, and insurance implications, and Grawe stresses that no single approach is a silver bullet. Several actionable takeaways emerge from the discussion. Fleet professionals with California operations are urged to assess their exposure immediately, including the extent of their physical presence and operational activity in the state, before deciding on a path forward. Carriers considering the broker-carrier model are warned that it requires fundamental changes to customer contracts, equipment arrangements, and insurance structures, and cannot be treated as a paper-only restructuring. Those evaluating conversion to employee drivers must account for practical challenges such as truck ownership and compensation structure. Gross also encourages industry stakeholders to engage with trade associations at the state and federal level, noting that legislative advocacy is now the most viable long-term avenue for change given that judicial remedies in California have largely been exhausted. Grawe offers a pointed observation that underscores the broader stakes: "It's not hyperbole to say this could significantly impact the whole industry, not just California." He also pushes back on the narrative that independent contractors are uniformly exploited, noting that most owner-operators actively choose the independent model and that forcing reclassification often results in drivers leaving the industry rather than accepting employee status. Both Wiseman and Grawe agree that while bad actors exist and should be held accountable, applying California's strict standard universally risks harming the drivers and carriers who have built legitimate, mutually beneficial independent contractor relationships.

Full Transcript

do give me your retention and your sweet redemption i would never let you down will it ever get funny oh i want it honey baby how you make i'm protection i will always be around will it ever get sunny oh i wanna honey you're addicted yes so so so hey everyone welcome to a special episode of truck safe live the monthly show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation i'm brandon with truck safe consulting and childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs uh like i said special show today some breaking news in the industry um yesterday within the last 24 hours june 30th of 2022 if you're watching later news out of the u.s supreme court that they are denying review uh they have denied review in the cta versus banta case which is the california ab5 case this has gotten a lot of attention in the industry over the last couple of years we've been watching it pretty closely over that time and uh waiting on the supreme court to to um issue its decision on whether it's going to even hear the case or not so that's what we're going to talk about in today's show it's like i said breaking news with the potential to have big impacts at least to fleets that have operations in california so that's what we wanted to tackle today um just briefly i wanted to kind of run through the procedural history of the case for those who aren't as familiar with the case so in 2019 state of california passes what was called assembly bill 5 or ab5 which essentially codifies the abc test for work worker classification determinations in the state individuals who are uh classified as independent contractors whether or not that person is an independent contractor is going to be um determined based on this abc test which we'll get into detail later um that's ab5 essentially for the reasons we'll discuss in a little bit that test is kind of the thorn in the side of every trucking company that utilizes independent contractors making it nearly impossible to use independent contractors in california california trucking association sued to enjoin california the state from enforcing that test against trucking companies arguing that that law is preempted by a federal law known as the federal aviation administration authorization act f4a uh sometimes called or f quad a uh in the sense that uh the argument by cta was that california's ab5 is a law related to the price route or service of motor carriers that's kind of the standard used by f4a as to whether it's going to preempt a state law or not cta got a federal district court in california to agree uh at least in the preliminary stages granted an injunction in 2020 prohibiting california from enforcing ab5 the state then appealed that to the ninth circuit court of appeals in california which sided with the state and held that ab5 is not preempted because it's a generally applicable labor law not a law specifically targeted at targeted at a motor carrier's rates routes or services um so that happened and then the cta from that point sought discretionary review from the u.s supreme court and as we've talked about in prior shows you the u.s supreme court except in very narrow circumstances is not under obligation to take appeals uh that are that are brought to its attention it has the discretion to decide under the circulary process what cases it wants to take up it's generally going to take up very few cases that get brought to its attention i think the numbers are like west less than one percent or something like that crazy so very rare for them to take up a case they typically only take up the cases um in very specific circumstances those that are generally going to have a big impact on on a big portion of the country generally speaking are the cases they're gonna take up and so we have been in this um kind of limbo phase where we've been waiting for the supreme court to decide whether it was gonna take up this cta case or not and that's where we came that's where the decision we got yesterday um scotus denies review which um is going to have like i said earlier uh pretty uh wide implications across the industry so that's the topic of today's discussion um wanted to bring on um a guest with us today who is intimately familiar with this topic so um i would like to welcome on doug gross so doug is ceo of grogg group llc a lawn professional consulting firm focused on the transportation industry doug has more than 15 years of experience as a general counsel at a large family-owned truckload intermodal logistics and warehouse provider and more than 10 years in private practice he's also currently general counsel for open force technology driven business service providing industry leading services to independent contractors and motor carriers including driver onboarding settlement processing and many other solutions welcome doug thanks brandon i really appreciate it thanks for having me on happy to help appreciate you being here with us and uh couldn't think of anybody better to to have on uh with all your work that you've done over the years um on the independent contractor uh reclassification issue specifically uh for those of you who are who are here watching if you haven't seen our past show we have doug had doug on um a few months ago along with wendy greenland from open force we did a whole show on independent contractor classification best practices go back and check that out if you missed it it's on our various social media channels and on our youtube channel and at trucksafelive.com but doug is here with us today to talk about um this uh this this case so doug let's kick things off here uh tell us kind of give us a general sense of your involvement in in the ic issues over over the over the years yeah uh i um i was very fortunate early in my career with uh with my big in in-house uh client that i had for for many years and uh some of the mentorships i got early on the family that that owned uh my original client um and and i can say the oren family uh they very much believe in being involved uh they they believe in being engaged in the industry with your trade associations and so on so they encouraged me early on to get involved um so that was just great to have that uh that backing that support and so i did uh so i got involved in in some of the lobbying that's that's gone on over the years on independent contractor status i got involved in you know it's a good sized company and they had their own shares of of of matters over the years so i got some experience through that as well um but they also had an attorney there he has since passed on but his name is jim hardman uh jim hartman really was one of the lions of the industry uh started out in the 1950s his very first case went to a state supreme court when he got out of law school um and and i remember that he could write articles only citing himself uh just a prolific writer on all things independent contractor he got me into it so i've published a handful of articles over the years about independent contractors but more specifically on this case a couple of trade associations and clients reached out to me and asked me to write briefs to the u.s supreme court encouraging the court to to do this so i was able to team up with another very good lawyer mike glover mike and i worked together to put together what what i thought were some pretty good briefs uh kind of explaining why trucking companies use independent contractors why independent contractors like being independent uh just to kind of give that background to the court so they knew there's real people that are impacted by this decision unfortunately it didn't go our way but it wasn't for lack of trying the industry definitely was engaged on this issue that's for sure yeah so let's get right into that case so the case is cta versus banta i kind of gave the brief procedural history at the start um but can you give us a better feel for kind of the primary issues involved in that case yeah um so there there are some you know heady constitutional law kind of stuff you know does the federal law preempt uh states from being able to enforce laws that impact the services that trucking companies can provide that's that's really the issue does this federal safety regulations do federal regulations and economic regulations related to trucking companies prevent states from enforcing laws that impact the services trucking companies can provide unfortunately the ninth circuit court of appeals said no they don't not in this context and the us supreme court it's not like the us from court said we're we're endorsing the ninth circuit's decision and and it and they didn't then they absolutely nailed it i think use the sports analogy uh the the the uh officials in the booth said we're not gonna take a look at that we're not saying we agree with it we're just saying we're not gonna take a look at it so it stands uh that's really what happened yeah so interesting you mentioned ninth circuit and as i understand it one of the reasons we had more hope than normal of potentially getting to the supreme court was because we've got what's called a circuit split on the issue we've got some circuit courts of appeals that agree with california then we've got other circuits i think first circuit maybe has come out with a decision that says there is preemption in this type of arena is that true yes that that is so to a little bit more context for folks so in the judicial world in the court world the country is broken up into circuits okay and each circuit represents a handful of states and like you said when the circuits disagree when they get the same issue or very similar issues and one circuit starts saying the law means you know applies this way and another circuit starts saying the law applies another way that's what the supreme court does like to get involved to say hey children you're not doing this right this is the way the rules should be applied um and and that that really is is kind of what it is so we thought as an industry that there was a clear line of cases coming out of the first circuit so that's that's some east coast states with the ninth circuit largely the west coast states okay and we said hey the first circuit we thought as an industry applied the rule correctly and we thought the ninth circuit didn't we thought it was pretty clear now i don't want to bore people with too much of the the wonky details it wasn't quite as clean as i'm making it sound um one of the and again when the court decided not to take this case they didn't write out a long opinion explaining why they didn't they just didn't and you know it's one line says denied so we can only really speculate why they didn't i think one of the reasons they may not have is there still some facts that needed to be flushed out more uh and and what i mean by that is one of the arguments that the industry makes is hey this rule in california is so arduous so painful so strict whatever term adjective you want to use we can't really meet it there's no practical way to meet it if i'm an opponent of the trucking industry i could make an argument that there were not there was not enough facts in the record to make that claim i'm an industry person so i think that's a bogus argument but i could see the court basically thinking to themselves you know what honestly there's there's too much mud here it's not clean enough for us to make a decision so one of the things that might still happen now i i'm in the kind of the inner sphere of this i am not one of the attorneys that is that is representing california trucking association i am not their attorney uh they have i know who those attorneys are they're very good attorneys they're doing an excellent job but they will decide whether or not they're going to continue to fight this there actually are more things that they can do but it's going to take a lot more money and a lot more time and while the lawyers try to figure out all those nuances of arguments what what our listeners needs need to understand right now is california can start enforcing any day now i think technically it's seven days so sometime next week they can start enforcing this yeah and i forgot to mention this at the start anybody watching live if you've got any questions or comments about these you throw them in the in the comment box uh and we'll get to them as we go here doug you had mentioned something interesting it's something that you don't see very often in our industry but vast support it seemed like for the supreme court to take up this issue including against what we often see as traditional foes like the american trucking associations in oaida the owner operator independent driver association we're kind of on the same page here that we think california has done something wrong here and that the supreme court should step in and clarify why is that the case why is this the issue where we see vast support in the industry for uh essentially what the district court did in joining the application of ab5 and then uh to try and get that up to the supreme court yeah great point and i think the reason you see that uh that unification that alignment is um all industries trucking is not special in this this this regard but all businesses sometimes can get in in the habit of oh the sky is falling this is going to be the worst thing that's ever happened to our us and all this kind of stuff and after a while if you're a politician or a judge like that you get a little bit tired of of that argument um i'm not gonna say truly the sky is falling but it was pretty clear early on when this legislation was being considered much less past it's not hyperbole to say this could significantly impact the whole industry not just california we can all badmouth california all we want um and and i can get on both sides of that there's some really good things about california too but i think the way that yeah well the weather and everything and but um it's i think the fifth largest economy in the world all right so you kind of have to deal with it yeah it's pretty tough to say we're just not going to going to worry about the the fifth sixth largest economy in the world um so i think you saw the alignment because there there was a a significant chance or a a huge chance this was going to have a significant outcome on all parts of the industry coupled couple that with owner operator business model has been around literally for over a hundred years okay and it's it's not this there's i think there's this myth out there that that trucking and transportation just uses independent contractors and we just abuse independent contractors and all that kind of stuff well depending on who stats you want to look at there are somewhere in the three to four million professional drivers out there okay there are a few hundred thousand independent contractors i don't think i've seen an estimate that's as high as a million i i think the estimates that i usually see here in that 3-4 i've seen as high as 600 000 okay so it's a big part of the industry but it's not all of the industry i say that to mean is it's big enough that everybody cares about but it's not the only thing which to me means we can all get on board with drivers should have choices trucking companies should have choices in california is taking away one of those choices probably yeah i guess we should back up and talk about ab5 more specifically just so for folks who aren't as intimately familiar with it what exactly does ab5 do and why is it such a potential game changer now that it could it's going to go into effect so ab5 is that's the legislation name it was when it was passed it was assembly bill 5. that's why it's called ab5 it is a what it does it puts into play what's called the abc test now it only puts the abc test into play for certain types of claims in california it's not for everything it's not for taxes uh for example it's not for work comp but it is for some wage and hour stuff um so the abc test is used in a variety of states it is not just used in california so we all need to make sure we understand that first of all but california's version of the abc test is worse than other areas and it's the be prong it's an abc test because it's a three factor test you can call it the one two three test if you want to uh it's three factors the middle factor the second factor says to be independent the worker must be engaged in work that is outside of the contracting company's business so if you are a trucking company it is difficult to say that a truck driver is not engaged in the same business that you as a trucking company are now your software engineer that you might use to to work on a project for you that's pretty easy to say i'm not a software company i'm a trucking company so the engineers in a different business but california's strict interpretation of you must be engaged in a separate business that is difficult to meet because trucking has something that no other industry has and i'm speaking specifically when you get over 26 000 pounds here truth in leasing regulations when you start talking about truth and leasing regulations and and and and brandon this is very near and dear to your world we're talking safety here okay and for very good safety reasons we can argue about whether or not the laws is correct but i can understand the spirit of it 90 years ago the federal government said whether you call them independent contractors or employees we are going to hold you trucking company responsible for any accidents they cause okay that's in in common terms we call that logo liability that's why you got to have your do your name and your dot number on the side of the truck okay well that rule that put that that makes carriers responsible for motor vehicle accidents also says the truck must be exclusive to the trucking company so if i've got the the the mighty u.s federal government telling me that i must maintain exclusive control over this truck and i've got and i don't say this in a belittling way that california big state influential state saying i cannot have exclusive control over this truck that is a really tough nut to crack because essentially what the federal leasing regulations are intended to do at least this was kind of their primary intention as i understand it was to create this legal fiction so traditionally under the law the contracting entity that contracts with an independent contractor most laws in every state will recognize that the contracting entity isn't going to be liable for any conduct of the independent contractor because the independent contractor is independent they're responsible for their conduct but what we were having was uh some probably not a lot it probably wasn't widespread but people were wise to this idea and so they were structuring their businesses so that we consider these drivers to be independent contractors so that when they go get involved in an accident we can push it off on them and minimize our own exposure well we didn't want that in the trucking company uh inherently dangerous company we wanted the the parties that have the you know the the deep pockets and that have the insurance coverage to to be on the hook and so what we did through the federal leasing regulations was create this legal fiction where even though these are independent contractors in every other sense we're going to say that they are under exclusive lease to the motor carrier and through that legal fiction that legal um you know fiction that is the lease it's not a traditional lease agreement but we're going to call it a lease so that we can create this uh the situation where the motor carrier takes on primary responsibility highway accident exposure for any accidents that those contractors are involved in is that generally speaking well set okay very very well described and and it leads to this this whole there's always a little bit of friction uh in any trucking company that uses independent contractors of i got safety issues i got to deal with and i've got independent contractor status and and how to respect freedoms and all that kind of stuff and we're not going to go too far down that path in this discussion i can tell you you can do it you can be a good safe trucking company that uses independent contractors and i would argue a lot of data suggests that they are very good when they use independent contractors independent congress tend to be pretty safe um but you're exactly right that the federal government essentially said we don't want arguments about independent contractor status to impact safety yeah so it was never intended as i understand it though to say anything about the economic relationship between the two in other words the federal government very explicitly they say this in the regulation we're not weighing in on whether these are your employees or not what they should have said frankly is that these are not your employees but regardless put that aside they say we're not weighing in on it we're only doing this for very specific reasons and so over the years we've used that language in the federal leasing regulations uh to to point to the fact that clearly just because they're leased on to you as the motor carrier that's the government is saying that has no impact on their on their uh employment classification but unfortunately that just hasn't carried the day in a lot of these states especially california um and you know and so there are some states that buy into that in other states that don't um and so that kind of leaves us you know where we're at currently um so and what so you kind of got into this a little bit and and what i'm i'm curious what areas is ab5 is the abc test that is now going to be the law of the land in california and what areas of the law is that going to impact at least for carriers with operations in california yeah most specifically i mean directly it's going to be in your wage an hour issue so it's it's it's a if you you stand the risk of a misclassification claim related to minimum wage overtime meal and rest breaks that kind of claim the abc test will be used and california gets even more complicated than just the abc test because if i'm on the other side of this let's let's pretend for a moment that that i i can't stand independent contractors and i hate trucking and all that kind of stuff i'm going to say wow trucking it's not as bad as you think because even if you can't meet the abc test there's this business to business exception and you can meet the business to business expansion uh uh exemption um that's that's gobbledygook uh no it's i i i don't wanna say here you cannot use independent contractors in california i'm not on this call here we're not being anybody's individual attorney it's always a case-by-case analysis there are ways you probably can still structure something but that business this business exemption is not an easy standard to meet it's multiple factors right yes and and so let me back up make sure we walk through this uh for a moment if if you have a lawsuit that is on your desk tomorrow that says i you know we're we're all independent contractors in california and we're suing you because we think you've misclassified us the first thing that any judge is going to look at is they're going to say is do you meet the the abc test if you do meet it you win there you go we're done if you don't meet all prongs right you have to use all three prompts yes and we we just established why that would be very difficult for a trucking company to meet so let's assume for a moment you cannot meet all three or don't meet all three then what's going to happen is you are going to go into do you meet the business to business exemption which is going to use another is it 10 factors 12 factors it's a lot of factors barello test which you also must meet all of the factors it's not a majority it's it's all of the factors and it's difficult for trucking companies to to meet this second set of factors because it's going to say things like does the independent contractor advertise their services to the public um well it just doesn't make a lot of sense in trucking to have a uh a google ad for an owner operator when they're carriers giving them all the business they they need and or want and oh by the way we just talked about all those truth and leasing regulations and the difficulty of working with multiple carriers at once and all that kind of stuff there in this 12 factor 10 12 factor whatever it is a secondary test there are a number of those that just don't make practical sense in trucking which makes it still very hard to meet it's almost like they didn't draft these laws with the trucking companies in mind well and and i would say is they they did draft them and not to get too much into the politics politics of this but but i think we do need to understand some of the politics of of ab5 okay there is a long history against it this didn't this bill and this law didn't come up out of nowhere and get passed in a year it took a long time for its proponents to get it passed uh and its proponents are a variety of different groups yes organized labor is one of the proponents environmental groups are some of the proponents community activists and community organizations are some of the proponents of this legislation and now i'm not going to say trucking is the only industry they cared about and and they targeted but make no mistake about it we were at the top of the list uh and you can go back to clean air issues in and around the ports and old trucks that's really where a lot of this starts and that starts you're talking early 2000s uh when that stuff's happening and the argument was hey our air is very polluted and i don't actually discount this point there are plenty of reports out there that the communities in and around the ports have significantly worse air quality and there are health outcomes in those areas that are are sad honestly the cause of those and who shares the blame for that i think is a different discussion but the facts are there's some air issues there so the argument went by the proponents that you trucking companies are using independent contractors and these independent contractors are using old dirty trucks and you should be buying brand new trucks to to run in these areas now a couple of different things there first is there's the business aspect we all know that when you get a brand new truck you don't want to put that in local operation you want to put that over the road like let it get the miles as it gets older and you need to get maintained more that's when you bring it closer to home that's just good business okay that's not how to keep your eyes on on that trucking and and get your money out of that investment okay um but that whole notion of the argument that trucking companies were being too cheap and using independent contractors to skirt uh getting new clean trucks in that's the start of ab5 and that's who was in favor of publishing these rules um so that's why trucking is a target we saw even some even more brazen efforts at the start uh i think of like the port of la case where essentially the ports came in and said you're not allowed if you're a trucking company coming into the ports you can't use independent contractors we're not even going to let you in and i think that case did eventually get held to be pre that that rule eventually did get held to be preempted but so then they have come up with other ways to put the pressure on on trucking companies knowing they can't go quite that far but what we're going to do is implement a test that's virtually impossible for trucking the trucking industry to pass and and let's get back to that prong b why why exactly is that so tough at least cal because we've talked about the abc test being uh in place in other states other than just california why is california's b prong of the abc test so hard for the trucking industry to pass in other states the b-prong says that you do not that that the person can be independent if they are performing a service that is either different from what the contracting company's business is okay that's the same as california or that it is performed outside of the offices or locations of the contracting company truck driving by its very nature is going to be outside of the physical locations of the uh of the contracting company so that's why in other states the abc test is usually something you can you can still meet because it's written differently the california version is written more strictly and if so if your business is i am a trucking company i have us department of transportation authority to hall freight that's what a carrier motor carrier is u-haul freight if you are using an independent contractor who hauls freight it is difficult to argue you're in different businesses i think you can make an argument it is difficult to make a winning argument and there have been some courts in other states that have latched on to those arguments i think of the one that always has been has always been persuasive to me at least is if you look at what what the services are being provided right so you look at owner operators who are essentially providing truck capacity their customers are the motor carriers their customers aren't necessarily the shippers and the brokers they are working uh they're selling their capacity in their trucks to the motor carriers whereas the motor carriers are are selling services to their shipper and broker customers and we've seen some some courts and i think in the midwest states that have latched on to that to to help motor uh carriers prevail in these types of reclassification suits but not california it's not going to fly in california yeah you're right and i i think there there's also some cases out there that that i think is rightfully recognize what a motor carrier does in in in this arrangement is hey we provide you access to bigger shippers um friendlier freight you know that that you you independent contractor would not otherwise get access to we help you get access because we can provide higher liability insurance levels we can do the billing and the collections we can do the the sales work we can do the data interchanges we can do all that back office stuff and that risk management stuff so that you independent contractor can focus on hey how many trucks do i want to have who do i want to have driving my trucks how do i want to make sure that i have a a a good fuel purchasing and fuel utilization strategy which as an aside i think we all know recognize how if you're good at that you're going to be a good owner operator you're going to make a lot of money if you're not good at that you're not going to make good money um so don't tell me they're not business people uh the those are big decisions how new a truck are you going to get you know and and all those those types of things and hiring your own employees and hiring your own drivers to work for you um so i think one of the interesting most interesting things about this is who stands to benefit from ab5 going into effect in the trucking industry because i think a lot of proponents of the of ab5 will try in and throw the the wool over your eyes and say that it's going to be the drivers who are going to benefit from this the the folks who are who have been oppressed they will say and who have been misclassified as independent contractors granted there's going to be some of those out there who they're they are oppressed and they should be reclassified but in my experience and i'm sure it's the same with you doug and the vast majority of these that's not the case and so my question to you is who's going to benefit from who really stands to benefit from the uh from ab5 legislation yeah it's who you think it's going to be uh or organized labor definitely stands a chance uh at uh at um um benefiting from this because when someone is not is an employee not an independent contractor they can be organized and hey i have no issues with people who want to organize being able to organize that is their right they should be able to do that i think a lot of the surveys out there and a lot of the the the evidence suggests most not all most independent contractors enjoy being independent and when forced to become employees or not have work they're not going to choose to become employees they're going to adjust and they're going to go someplace else and do something different some will some will become employees but not all um and it's not just organized labor i mean you can make some arguments that um that there'll be some other tangential benefits here and there the big one i think of is the plaintiff's bar right because especially in california we're seeing we have been for the last 10 years as we talked about on our independent contractor show this um this rash of cases where plant the plaintiff's bar has become wise to this the ways to win on these reclassification suits on behalf of a class of drivers and they just make bank doing those cases and so now they've got some more leverage in the form of ab5 to to prevail on the on those cases it definitely makes their job easier uh that if um there's a strong likelihood you don't have to worry that much about going to trial uh it's a matter of your work is all in just collecting that class uh to start if you're a plaintiff's lawyer so yes they very much will will benefit from this it unless the industry changes um changes the business model a lot then you may you know prevent them from ever having to claim in the first place um but but yes you're right they stand to gain no doubt about it so that's one question i did have early on is is whether the courts the supreme court's decision to deny review here and ab5 going into it so it's not currently in effect right when when will it go into effect you mentioned seven days or so yeah it so the ninth circuit when they made their decision um the i may not use the terminology correctly because i'm not a constitutional law expert but they stayed the case they stayed their decision which me which essentially what they said is we're ruling against you trucking industry and we're ruling in favor of the state of california but we're our ruling will not go into effect unt unless until the supreme court says something we're going to give you an industry time to appeal this so that's left that injunction in place yes that's left the injunction in place uh yes that's the better word than stay they they they left the injunction in place so the um but their decision did say once the california once the state or the supreme court speaks or doesn't speak which chooses not to speak then our ruling goes into effect and it doesn't go into effect six months from now it goes into effect now i again this is where i i'm not saying i 100 know this but it is my understanding is i believe it is seven days from the day the supreme court denied review that the ninth circuit's injunction uh or stay will be lifted um so regardless we're not talking about uh months or years we're talking about days maybe a couple of weeks and of note this can be retroactive yeah i was gonna ask you about that go backwards um this is not just okay we can go after you for whatever you're doing now california can go backwards um whether or not they choose to i would assume they will um but i don't know uh i'm not a part of their brain trust and figuring out how best to go about this but um i i don't know what their workload is at the state of california i i don't know where this will be on the priority list but i assume it will be pretty high um it there it's no secret state of california does not like the way the transportation industry functions and you hit it on it earlier brandon the transportation industry is huge it is absolutely huge yes there are some bad actors out there i firmly believe and i think you believe this as well brandon that drivers should have the right to choose no one should force them into either bucket and i believe 98 of the time that's what happens but there are some bad actors out there and i don't feel sorry for them if if they get the book thrown at them um the problem is i think california and some other states assume the whole industry is acting like the two percent yeah yeah i know we were talking earlier again in my previous life i did a lot of unemployment tax litigation work on behalf of motor carrick clients and some in california and through that experience i i got the chance to really talk with a lot of owner operators for our clients and and ride along with them and sit with them and understand their lifestyle and yeah they were completely of that mindset that if i can't be an independent contractor with my own truck and running the business as i see fit i don't want to have anything to do with it that's the lifestyle i want so when you hear these stories um you know out there about how how oppressed the drivers are through this system of having owner operators and independent contractors it's just like that's that's not the world i know i mean like you said maybe there's the two percent or something where it's like that and and again i feel the same way i don't feel sorry for them but that's to apply that same mindset to everyone else is just completely uh yeah it's the wrong thing to do for sure so the the um the big rig the the usa today article uh and unfortunate that and and this is not a railing against journalism in america there's plenty of great journalists in america but there was a very very unfortunate expose if you will which told a very sad story i have no idea how much of it's true for that individual but i can tell you even if all true uh and and and how sad that person's individual situation was that was not an accurate description of of what's going on in the trucking industry throughout the united states um not at all representative of any of the trucking companies that i work with and and me either i i can say the same thing for my clients as well um and it's it's a shame how powerful that um that article became in some legislators in some agency people's minds uh brian's asking here do you expect to see a flood of misclassification lawsuits coming out soon because of this uh i don't i don't know what the the threshold for flood will be uh but but but yes i do expect that there are i am sure there are some attorneys who probably have been quietly putting together uh some lawsuits that are now like okay i'll just wait for the time wait for my time uh to bring some uh you also have the state agencies uh or agency i should say uh chomping at the the bid as well so no i i definitely do expect a a material spike in activity uh in in california now again this is the california thing it doesn't mean anything else is going to happen anywhere else but in california yes there'll be a big spike the thing that's interesting to me i've been out of the game for a while so i don't even know how this has played out but the cases that were started prior to the implementation of uh or prior to the injunction being issued have those just been stayed have those just been held in a band's pending resolution of this issue or what happened to all those cases i'm not involved i don't have a case that is in that bucket but that's my presumption uh maybe that that some some uh some went away via settlements and and stuff like that but yes that would be myself so now not only do you have the possibility of all new lawsuits you have the possibility of the reinstatement of of lawsuits that have been pending for several years now waiting on the supreme court's ruling on this yes it could be a huge issue uh and then you know you'd brought up also state agency potential enforcement of this so and i think we we got on to another topic before we finished the how how um how wide-ranging the the ab5 is going to be we talked about it coming into play in the wage and hour context is it your understanding that it's also now the abc test is now also going to be used in some of the the state actions you had mentioned potentially not workers comp but unemployment do we have any idea whether that's going to be the test for unemployment i think traditionally it had been the barelo test so i i just don't know i haven't tracked it close enough it is my and it's a great question i don't i think it is just wage an hour it is not a unemployment work comp uh you know uh department of re you know california department of revenue uh rule um that being said regardless of what the rule is we know what the um attitude is in california even before ab5 there was already a a stories and i'll just call them stories because i didn't i didn't handle anything but there were stories of of how aggressive california was being pre ab5 uh on enforcement and and that they really weren't even listening to what the carriers had to say i'll take the next step not stories to me because i was involved and they were very aggressive i mean we would have carriers with uh thousands of independent contractor drivers owner operators in in california and they would just go after them so aggressively flying in the face of the legal precedent that was in place in california and and the the tests that were supposed to be used so yeah it's uh so like you said even if it turns out that that the abc test is now not applicable not necessarily applicable in those other contexts it's still those are still other huge areas of exposures to carriers with owner-operated fleets in california needless to say um exactly right okay so let's see we've got a couple other questions here and i think this is the big one that everyone's here to to get the answer to so what will this mean for 109 independent contractors if anything will they need to be changed over to w-2 essentially employees so i guess the question is what what are the options for for motor carriers that have owner operator fleets in california so um a handful of things the first thing is is you this was part of your question there towards the end is you have to determine how much of this rule applies to you so if you are a trucking company headquartered in california this very much applies to you in just about everything that you do do you have terminals in california do you have no physical facilities in california uh do you have dedicated runs or just have people that go in and out do they are they different people that go in and out or is it the same joe and susie going in and out every day you have to figure out how much exposure you have in california because one of your solutions might be you know what 99 of our business is outside of california we can deal without the one percent that might be your answer we're just we're just going to do do things a little bit differently um so so first of all take a look at yourself operationally in your business and what's going on and how much this applies to you the second thing is if you do say this does apply to either all or a portion of my business i'm not going to say it's easy uh by any stretch what you can do and and and i'm not here to tell a carrier hey here is the model do this you're going to be fine we all know it it's a case by case and you got to talk about people's individual situations there are a handful of ideas out there uh the most prominent and likely the the most realistic is the broker carrier model so you trucking company stop being a trucking company you start being a broker and if you're going to do that and and the next step of that is then the independent contractor becomes a carrier the independent contractor goes and gets dot authority and they do all the things that that you teach carriers how to do in in the safety in the regulatory world and all that kind of stuff that they have to take on all that on and the idea right the idea right with that is that gets you around that b-prong potentially in that they are now your argument would be they are now clearly in a different line of business than us we are a broker whose business is to tender freight two motor carriers they are a licensed motor carrier in their own right that that's the argument essentially that that is that is the argument and people just have to understand that's not just a little bit of paperwork changes if you're going to do that model it's a good model i i like the model uh and and it works um but you got to kind of go all in it's going to change the way you do your customer contracts it's going to change how your insurance works it's going to change uh your your uh your your equipment obviously because it's not going to be your equipment anymore you're not gonna have anything to do with the equipment it's gonna be a big burden on those owner operators because they're gonna have to go get motor carrier authority now they're subject to all of the safety regulations that you have traditionally been handling driver qualification hours of service that is now their burden to where yes and and i think when you use the word burdens it's a great word because let's say that you're a carrier today using independent contractors in california and you've got a shipper that requires five million dollars in auto liability insurance okay um so if you're gonna do the broker carrier model then you need to make sure all of those independent contractors have five million dollars of auto liability insurance tough and that's gonna be tough that's a burden and and i don't i don't having any issues with insurance companies but but i can see insurance companies going wait a minute you want me to give a whole bunch of five million dollar auto liability policies to uh all these folks with one truck and and i don't have the history and i don't have the safety practices that i knew that you had as a carrier and all that kind of stuff that's a tough ask of insurance companies i think that's the biggest hang up to this model right is is the feasibility of getting the owner traditional owner operators to be motor carriers in their own right particularly on the insurance front from my experience getting them even 750 000 which is the minimum insurance with no history of operating on their own et cetera is is a tall tall task so maybe i might answer this question that way that is probably the most tested um new model i'm not going to use the word solution i'm not going to use the word workaround i don't like those terminology to me that that suggests you're trying to get away with something uh that that's not what we're here to do uh but if if you believe in in in wanting to use independent contractors because of how good they are and what they can do for you and your business uh then the broker carrier model and there are some other variations too uh but that's realistic we're looking looking at or yeah they go they become employees one question on that broker carrier model real quick somebody's asking we use settlement carriers in ca which are essentially it's the broker carrier model we have a broker carrier agreement with them several of these are single truck carriers any risk to us in that scenario um you're first of all you're right settlement carrier is another way to call the the same thing um yes there can be risks uh there are there is history in california pre-ab5 of california uh accusing brokers just the traditional broker model um of being either employers or joint employers of the drivers that the carriers used so there's already precedent that california might still go after brokers in the broker carrier model second thing is is your risk increases with how much you don't do the broker carrier model right and that goes back to this if you're going to do it then you got to do it right and that's a different type of contract with your customers it's different type of contract with the carriers it's a different type of equipment model and financial model and all that kind of stuff it can't be just a different contract yeah and even so what i saw so so frequently were carriers who were hot to trot on this new model they didn't even they didn't even take the effort to change their contract so their contracts are still calling them the motor carrier it's like yeah this very clearly is you're trying to make this just a paper change it's not a paper change correct yeah correct yeah so sorry i kind of cut you off there so the so putting aside the broker carrier model so the other option is is converting to employees if you want to still do business i know several carriers who said the risk is too high we're getting out of california all together folks will tell you that's not happening but it is happening i know a lot of carriers that are do have done that already so assuming you want to stay in california for the reason you mentioned doug which is a huge part of the economy transitioning to employee drivers at least for your portion of your fleet in california right so this isn't necessarily saying you have to change your entire fleet if you've got operations nationwide maybe you consider some kind of you know compartmentalizing this and and setting up a new entity where you do business differently uh in california than you do elsewhere in the country i think that's an option as well yes that that's an option uh there are also uh carriers out there that do more of a i don't really know what the the right phrasing would be to use this but but when you start and this actually is less to do with the abc test and more to do with with a different test called the economic realities test but when you can say that the contractors can buy and sell routes that is a very meaningful factor in saying that someone is an independent contractor now they're not in in those examples those independent contractors are not buying and selling them for a hundred bucks yeah they're buying and selling them for real money i think we would always kind of call it like an agent model or something like that where the where the owner operator is an agent of the carrier and is essentially a sales agent at that point yes yep that that's that's one way to to describe it as well so it broker carrier or settlement carrier is not the only one in california uh it's it's probably the most common that we're seeing so far but but there are other variations i don't want anybody to think this is an automatic death knell to independent contractors in california it is significant it requires very thoughtful analysis of what to do next and and it likely requires some pretty fundamental changes uh to how you're going to do business uh no matter which path you take so get your trusted advisors around your lawyers your your your numbers people your your operations people your sales people because it's going to impact all of it because even if you take the position that okay i'll just transform them all to w-2 to employee drivers there's a lot that goes into that too so it's not like that's going to be an easy change because i just think of like these these drivers all own their trucks their owner operators employees don't provide their own trucks so now you've got to come up with a solution for dealing with the trucks whether it be some kind of reimbursement or that two-check system that we've heard about in the past it's like you got to think through these that there's going to be a lot that goes into it it's funny when i hear two checks start coming up because there's got to be a whole bunch of people that are retired from the industry that are going holy smokes you people think you're gonna do the two check system again uh it's been a long time since the two check system has been uh relatively common or or prominent uh and just a quick version of what the two check system is really what you're doing is you're saying hey instead of paying you making up a rate instead of paying you contractor a buck 20 a mile i'm going to pay you 40 cents a mile to drive and i'm going to pay you 80 cents a mile to lease your truck from you so that the truck lease payment is it's a lease payment it's not a there's no w-2 wages and taxes and everything to get deducted but you driver are an employee and i'm going to deduct taxes and give you benefits and all that kind of stuff that's the two check system and it makes a burden it's a burden but it makes sense because the the thing that we were always battling on the at least on the unemployment side was the state would come in reclassify all of the drivers all the owner operators and then consider all of their payments to be wages and tax you based on what you paid to them but that's that's not a wage clearly a huge portion of that is meant to compensate them for the use of their truck you know i think the the numbers were always like two-thirds of that payment it's for the truck and only one-third could really be considered akin to a wage so by kind of doing the two check system you're you're you're kind of trying to limit your exposure to uh to just what would be considered a reasonable wage for their actual service and then you're not being taxed or or have other exposure on kind of that truck payment so i understand that yeah the the two check system philosophically makes a lot of sense and i think it can work um when i've seen it in action people get confused by it it's administratively very difficult um i've seen tax people on you know on the government irs the department of revenue side go what the heck are you doing uh and and have problems with it and and i've seen companies get in trouble on the tax side with it um so it's it's it's not a a a golden solution to it's not a silver bullet uh but i'm curious if in if there are trucking companies that go down the two check path so i think long story short you said it best it's not a solution that you should take it's not a something you should take lightly you're gonna you need to talk with your tax advisors you need to talk with your lawyers figure out a solution that works best for you before you pull the trigger on any one solution uh let's see here we're running out of time we've got let's see brian's got one other question here i think it's a good one what states fall next do you have any you have any thoughts on that doc uh so i mean we we can guess and speculate what it what i will and and maybe we'll throw some out here in a minute but what when we think about the politics of this um this is my plug for get engaged in engage with your trade associations at the state level at the federal level um and and really what it's about is telling the story of the real people that are impacted by this um you know we need independent we need to to to share the story of the independent contractors that enjoy being independent uh the independent contractors that grow their business and so forth so i would encourage you first of all to get engaged on the issue at the at the political level both at the state and the feds what states go next it's not necessarily just blue and red this is not 100 a blue and red thing yeah it's kind of a blue and red thing but there's some red states that are not good on independent contractor status and there are some blue states that are very good on independent contractor status so um don't immediately go there uh where i where you you just keep keep your eyes and ears open um because sometimes it surprises where it uh pops up next um yeah that i think that's really all i can say here other than going down through a laundry list of all 50 states but that's i think is the best advice yeah and i think you know we're at the end of the line at least in california in terms of judicial solutions to this and so really the only solution if if enough people decide that they want to change the way that this is then the solution is through legislation and and that's the only way anything's going to get changed i i agree but i'm not a complete expert in the litigation uh currently but it is my understanding is um the ninth circuit's decision essentially just says this goes back to trial to the trial court so to litigate on the facts of the case yeah california shark condition could still litigate this that's they've already spent millions of dollars how many more millions they're going to spend on this i don't know um because i if if i can and i know some of the cta folks um and they're good people uh and part of them is going to be going how much longer are we going to flip the bill for everyone else in the country yeah because i mean just kind of thinking through that i mean really in my view the only thing they could be arguing at that point is the facts of that case so the the contractors that are before us in this particular case they they pass the b prong and so i think in my view at least the writing's on the wall and that b prong but yeah this is not putting an end to litigation that you'll still be able you still have the option to bring uh you know a case to challenge that that they meet the ab that they meet the abc test but you know the the chances of success on a substantive um trying to argue that substantively i think are pretty low i i agree with i i don't want to say that you know give the people there's this grand hope but i just i it is my understanding is that it can go back to trial and what the cta then would be trying to do is actually to prove that you cannot meet the b prong or the business to business exemption because part of the arguments that the proponents of ab5 were making in their side of all this litigation is is this is not the end of independent contractors that you trucking industry claims oh i got you so there's there there still could be hope for a preemption type argument it's just we got to get more into the weeds on whether it is impossible to pass this b test in our industry or not that is my understanding i i could very well be corrected by by some some litigation wonks um out there uh but but that is my understanding procedurally what could happen but regardless of that that's that's a years long process and in the meantime california can enforce so if i'm a trucking company i'm probably not willing to just take my chances yeah yeah that the litigation turns my way over time all right well you heard it here thanks doug really appreciate you joining me obviously a huge topic for a lot of both of our clients and and uh and and carriers all over the country so we'll keep a close eye on it uh and uh i really appreciate you joining me today you're welcome thanks for having me brandon hey tell us real quick before you leave tell everybody where they can find you if they have any questions or anything like that yeah www.thegroggroup.com we do a lot of work with independent contractor programs and uh and just helping trucking companies however we can so we got a team of people who used to be in the chair uh former c-suite execs from a variety of trucking companies and that's what we do to help awesome thanks doug all right so we're going to wrap it up there before we do i just want to kind of give you a quick look at what's going on here at truck safe we've got a ton of stuff going on uh this first and foremost august 11th and 12th we've got our first annual truck c fleet compliance summit doug's going to be one of the speakers joining us we've got about 21 speakers booked for this to talk about all kinds of issues that are impacting motor carriers and weight practical tips to try and reduce exposure in those various areas things like nuclear verdicts independent contractor status fleet technology insurance cargo claims all of that type of stuff it's going to be a two-day multi-session event it's a virtual conference i come for one or all eight of the sessions that we're gonna have with our various speakers and then also we're gonna have a um a pretty cool virtual event uh or a virtual expo hall where we've got dozens of vendors industry vendors that are going to be there setting up virtual booths for you to check out the latest and greatest products and services available to trucking companies speak with representatives check out screenshots and and and materials on their services and and products so check that out trucksafesummit.com if you're interested registration is open again that's august 11th and 12th next up is our is our library of online courses that we have available at trucksafeacademy.com if you have any interest in um getting more uh up to speed on dot safety regulations we've got courses built specifically for safety managers anybody in a position of managing a regulated driver whether it be a small trucking company owner or a safety director dispatchers those types of folks we've got courses built specifically for them where we focus on the dot safety regulations and walking them through them and exactly what they need to know we've also just recently launched a hazmat course for folks that are involved in the transportation hazmat check those out trucksafeacademy.com and then lastly be sure to tune in for our next truck safe live show again this is a monthly show this was a special episode but our regularly scheduled episode is coming up on july 21st at 3 p.m eastern time uh it's called the doc is in we're going to have with us uh dr mark minera and dr matthew nuece who are uh who are very heavily involved in uh driver health and fitness issues uh and so we're gonna spend some time talking with them and kind of best practices uh for for driver health and fitness and what we're seeing kind of in that area so tune in again july 21st at um at 3 p.m eastern time with that we're gonna wrap it up appreciate you all joining us and uh we'll see you soon you

Event Completed

Friday, July 1, 2022 at 2:26 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube