Brandon and Jerad are joined by transportation attorneys Kristen Johnson of Taylor Johnson PL and Craig Helmreich of Helmreich Law LLC to discuss cargo loss/damage, freight claims, and unauthorized brokerage. This show will be jammed pack with important informations for motor carriers, shippers, and brokers alike, so you won’t want to miss it.
Watch the Recording
Episode Summary
Episode 12 of Trucksafe LIVE! brings together transportation attorneys Kristen Johnson of Taylor Johnson Law and Craig Helmreich of Helmrich Law to tackle two interconnected topics that can have serious financial consequences for motor carriers and brokers: cargo loss and damage claims, and unauthorized brokerage. The hosts frame the discussion around the reality that most trucking companies do not think carefully about these issues until they are already in crisis mode, and that proactive planning and contract awareness can make the difference between a manageable incident and a catastrophic financial loss.
The guests provide a thorough overview of how cargo claims work under the Carmack Amendment, which imposes strict liability on motor carriers with only narrow exceptions such as inherent vice or shipper-caused loss. Johnson and Helmrich walk through how contract provisions — particularly limitations of liability, indemnification clauses, and mitigation language — can dramatically expand or restrict a carrier's exposure. Both attorneys stress that carriers often underestimate their ability to negotiate these terms, and that even large shippers with seemingly non-negotiable contracts will frequently accept a cap on liability when pushed. Helmrich notes that indemnification provisions are increasingly being used as a backdoor to create unlimited cargo liability, making them one of the most important clauses to scrutinize in any transportation contract.
The conversation also covers cargo insurance in significant detail, with Helmrich cautioning carriers and brokers that not all cargo policies are created equal. He points to specific insurers and policy types that routinely exclude high-risk commodities such as pharmaceuticals or provide no coverage for water intrusion on flatbed loads, leaving carriers dangerously exposed. The guests also address the Food Safety Modernization Act and its complications for food freight, explaining that the act can create liability for "maybe unsafe" food even in the absence of provable actual damages, a departure from traditional Carmack standards that some shippers have begun exploiting to manage inventory losses through cargo claims.
On the topic of unauthorized brokerage, Johnson explains that any entity arranging transportation for compensation without proper FMCSA brokerage authority is operating unlawfully, a line that dispatch services and shipper agents frequently blur. Helmrich connects unauthorized brokerage directly to cargo claims by noting that double-broker schemes often involve unlicensed parties and leave motor carriers unpaid and unprotected. Both guests acknowledge that while FMCSA enforcement of unauthorized brokerage rules has been limited, the agency's recent request for public comment suggests increased regulatory attention may be on the horizon.
For fleet safety and compliance professionals, the episode offers several concrete takeaways. Carriers should always attempt to negotiate liability caps in contracts, verify that their cargo insurance coverage matches the commodities they haul, and watch for indemnification provisions that could expose them to unlimited liability. Johnson recommends that carriers, even those without the resources to have every contract reviewed, invest in at least one consultation with a transportation attorney to learn how to identify problematic provisions on their own. Helmrich adds that carriers operating in or around brokerage activities should ensure they have proper authority and bonding in place, as the consequences of unauthorized brokerage can surface in both regulatory and civil litigation contexts.
Full Transcript
this is happening so so
so whether it's true
together
way to take you through the night just when i thought i was
it's not even fun anymore this season of truck safe live is presented by log rock log rock builds technology tools for trucking companies to take their safety and compliance to the next level log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems so you only have to use one logrock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively logrock is smarter we notify you of issues before they happen so you can be proactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logroc.com
hey everyone welcome to episode 12 of truck safe live the monthly show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation i'm brandon with truck safe and childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting-edge safety programs today's show is all about cargo loss and damage and freight claims and unauthorized brokerage what do those things all have in common i'm not sure you have to stay tuned to find out if you're here with us live make sure you say hey in the comments so we know you're here and certainly if you have any questions uh for our guests as we go along drop them in the comments we'll get to them as we have time appreciate you being here with us today it's going to be a great show before we get to the main topic a few things to talk about um a couple things going on with truck safe and then also some things going on in the industry uh that we wanted to hit on real quickly so in terms of truck safe if you haven't checked it out yet make sure you check out trucksafenetwork.com we've now had this running for about two months now it's essentially a social media platform for safety professionals anybody in a position of managing regulated drivers and regulated fleets we wanted to build out a space for those folks to be able to network with one another ask questions share ideas learn from one another so that we can all work to make our roads safer so check that out trucksafenetwork.com we also have um if you haven't checked that out an application for the network uh on the uh for ios and android devices if you just search for truck safe on the app store or the google play store it'll pop up pop right up not only do you have access to the network through that app but also you'll have access to our detailed articles on dot compliance and also our full library of videos covering that that same same content so be sure to check that out again search for truck safe on the app store or the google play store and you'll find that also if you haven't checked out our courses yet make sure you do so at trucksafeacademy.com we have a full library of online courses both for safety managers and for regulated drivers we walk through the nitty gritty of what it takes to remain compliant with safety regulations everything from driver qualification dot registration insurance vehicle maintenance hours of service drug and alcohol testing it's all packed into these online courses uh you can track progress you there are on-demand videos there's handouts there's quizzes there's completion certificates a lot of good material there so check those out trucksafeacademy.com uh and then lastly i'll just mention um keep keep tuned in to truck safe live we have another show actually coming up this month we usually do one show per month but uh this month we're gonna do two uh we're gonna have another episode on august 25th with steve brian from bluewire uh steve was actually our first guest of truck safe live last year um the things that blue wire is doing is is very beneficial to fleets uh in terms of uh helping them to kind of minimize their exposure uh to to these nuclear verdicts that we continue to hear so much about so tune in august 25th uh if you want to catch that episode so okay that's it for uh the truck safe news wanted to hit briefly on a couple of topics that have come up over the last couple of weeks since our last show fmcsa recently opened its applications for motor carriers that are interested in participating in the safe driver apprenticeship pilot program you've probably heard about this if you haven't we've got a whole article on it on our website check that out at trucksafe.com but essentially the pilot program is one that's going to study the impacts of letting a limited number of younger drivers operate commercial vehicles in interstate commerce right now as you probably know you got to be 21 years old or older to operate in interstate commerce although many states in the country have allowed 18 year olds to operate in intra state commerce for many years so the fmcsa has launched this pilot program to open up interstate commerce to a limited number of 18 to 20 year olds 3 000 participants at the start employed by approximately a thousand carriers so there's going to be room for about a thousand motor carriers to participate those that are interested that application is now open you can find that on the fmcsa's website again there's a lot that goes into the program there's a lot of safeguards built into it which makes sense the the students the apprentices will have to have certain technology installed in their commercial vehicles and including inward and outward facing cameras uh the motor carriers that participate will have to make periodic reports etc so if you're interested in those details again look for that article on our website we've also developed for carriers that are intending to participate we spent some time developing a whole package for them to use it includes not only those reporting forms that are going to be necessary but also a detailed policy a written policy that kind of puts parameters around the program so again that can be found on that article that we have on our website check that out okay so that's one thing another uh recent announcement that we received from the dot um top little top level dot not the fmcsa dot is considering moving to electronic record keeping for drug and alcohol testing records so um carriers who are tuning in will know that the fmcsa about probably three years ago now implemented a similar rule for other dot required documents so other compliance related documents driver files maintenance files that type of stuff fmcsa came out with a rule a few years back saying that motor carriers could generate and keep those electronically trying to cut down on the amount of paperwork that we use in this industry obviously historically this has been a very paper driven industry but fmcsa came out with that rule but that rule specifically carved out drug and alcohol testing documents because drug and alcohol testing as you probably know is administered by usdot not just fmcsa because it applies across the modes of transportation airline pilots railroad workers et cetera so it's administered higher up and to date the dot the usdot hasn't allowed for electronic electronic record keeping in that context well just this week in fact um the usdot published a uh an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking um indicating that they are thinking about doing that thinking about moving to an electronic record-keeping system for those records and asking for the public to weigh in on that there's i think 14 questions or so that the dot is looking for industry comments on so um you can check that out we have another article on that on our on our website if you're interested in potentially uh submitting comments to that we're helping a number of um motor carriers submit comments to that and also some third-party administrators so be sure to check that out um lastly i just wanted to mention a couple of uh a couple of things um the big news uh before our last show uh last month was uh the u.s supreme court's decision to deny review in the um in the california trucking association case the the one dealing with california's ab5 legislation and uh and the significant impact that is already having on fleets with owner operators uh owner operator fleets working in california we had a truck safe live show dedicated to that topic we had transportation attorney doug grah on who gave us a great overview of ab5 and what it means for fleets with those operations in california check that out check that out if you uh if you didn't catch that it was a couple episodes ago um and then kind of related uh news recently i just wanted to mention real quickly that the seventh circuit court of appeals recently came out with a decision involving schneider where 7th circuit held that schneider's purported independent contractors were in its view employees for flsa purposes uh under the economic realities test it's a different test than than the abc test that we talked about in the ab5 context but significant news nonetheless at least for motor carriers that are situated kind of in that seventh circuit which is kind of the midwest states so there were several news stories on that case you should be able to find it if you want to read more about that so that's kind of what's going on in the industry at least the issues that we've been tracking so with that out of the way we're going to move on to uh to the topic of today's show and before we do so i want to say quick thanks to the sponsor of this particular episode which is usi insurance as einstein once said insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result the usi transportation group has a drastically different approach to truck insurance which is refreshing in a commoditized industry usi one advantage changes the landscape of insurance buying to yield our customers better coverage results and significant cash flow improvements with over a thousand clients and 500 million dollars in managed premium we can help contact usi to learn more you can check them out online at usi.com so thanks to usi for sponsoring this episode so again today's topic the topic of today's show is cargo and freight claims and also unauthorized brokerage is going to make an appearance in this show so um you know cargo and freight claims at least when it's one of those things that no one really likes to think about until you're forced to but uh as with most most things and i'm sure we'll hear this from our guest today proper planning can really go a long way and so there are per important considerations here that folks just don't realize until it's far too late and the consequences of not planning appropriately can be pretty severe at least in my experience so definitely a topic that's outside my wheelhouse i've i've worked in the area somewhat but more than that i'm lucky to have worked closely over the years with a couple of the leading experts on the topic and we're fortunate enough to have them both with us today on today's show so uh kristen johnson a partner with the taylor johnson firm crain craig helmrich of uh of helmrich loss so want to bring them on here welcome guys hello thanks for having us hey no worries appreciate being here um so we usually like kick things off by giving guests an opportunity to introduce themselves give us a little background how you got involved in in the transportation industry so kristin you want to kick us off thank you i really appreciate this it's always fun to talk about cargo uh cargo claims something i deal with you say you don't deal with it that much it's you know usually what is the beginning of a long and lively relationship with my clients because they call me when literally there's something has spilled on the side of the road so that's always a lot of fun i have been practicing law for about 15 years not not always in this industry i've been in this industry for about the past five and a half six years before that i was in complex civil litigation which um i always say this is almost like one step up from that because it's a very specialized and nuanced area of law that requires the ability to answer new questions every day that no one's ever asked you and i can't tell you how many times i get something and i go haven't seen that one yet but don't worry we'll figure it out and that's kind of what being a complex litigator taught me and applied very well into transportation ever since i've been in it haven't stopped and i absolutely love working in this industry particularly like working with trucking companies uh you know hard-working really core to everything that makes this country happen and so it gives me joy every day to be working in this field and supporting um and that's that's what i do day in and day out awesome couldn't agree more all right thanks kristen craig yeah i've been a transportation lawyer since 2000 so i guess when it's 22 years now it's getting old harder to hide this gray hair it looks cool though yeah i planned it totally planned it uh like kristin you know it's it's super exciting to deal with the problems it's even more exciting though when you get to get out in front of the problems a little bit and have a chance to tell people how to avoid them we don't get we don't always get that opportunity you know a lot of the times the trucks already stolen the pharmaceuticals are already on fire um you know and and then we're saying shoot do we have a contract you know but it's it's it's fun for me both to deal with the problem situations and then take that knowledge from those problems to to try to avoid the next problem awesome so it's fun to have an opportunity like this to try to give people a heads up of how to stay out of trouble yeah i mean with that in mind let's just jump right in we're talking about cargo loss and damage and freight claims topics you're obviously both intimately familiar with for those who don't dabble in the area much like myself can you kind of give us a 50 000 foot view of of these topics and some of the key issues that you know the stakeholders deal with kristin you want to take that sure um essentially it's who bears responsibility when something happens to the cargo who is going to pay is it going to be covered by insurance which hopefully that's what that's there for and this is not a frequent occurrence and it's not causing anyone's insurance rates to skyrocket if there is an insurance or if there's a question as to who is responsible for it maybe insurance has denied um the cargo claim is the process of figuring out who is going to ultimately cover that particular incident when um when freight ends up wherever it might end up except the place it was supposed to go or in the condition it was supposed to be um that is essentially in a nutshell your 50 000 foot uh overview of what a cargo claim is craig any other thoughts on that yeah i mean just everybody probably already knows this it's on this call but but if you're a motor carrier typically carbon claims are going to be governed by carmack so there's a there's a statute a federal statute that provides for strict liability for cargo claims with some very limited exceptions the exceptions uh things things like inherent vice or act of the shipper have to be the sole cause of uh the loss um you know the carrier has to be free from negligence so or or else that exception doesn't work so you know ice melting ice melts is my favorite example of inherent vice you can't ship an ice ice sculpture without taking precautions to protect the ice sculpture or steal rusts same kind of thing something that's going to happen anyway unless we protect against it those are examples of things that could be defenses to the strict liability of the federal statute the federal statute only applies to motor carriers so brokers you're not in the line of fire i like to tell my broker clients they're in the line of squeeze your customer will squeeze you and they will force you to pay it or you will sign a stupid contract uh and i'm not calling the broker stu but i'm saying the contract but they signed is stupid uh they will sign a stupid contract that says they will be liable um but they're not technically in the line of fire by the statute itself um did you draft the stupid contract craig most of the time no okay good oh the shippers force it on everyone what are you talking about yeah exactly that's that's the story you'll hear from from most of our clients um all right craig so you you mentioned contract provisions i'm curious what are some ways uh contract provisions can impact cargo claims against motor carriers yeah motor carriers need to be aware of certain things in all their contracts and the first one is is there a limitation of liability you know has the contract kind of capped what you're exposed to and i'm not talking about cargo insurance you know there'll be two different sections in your contracts typically one will say you have to have you know one hundred thousand dollars of cargo insurance but a different section should say something from the motor carrier's perspective uh capping your liability maybe a hundred thousand dollars per truckload uh maybe 250 000 if you have a shipper that's demanding more than that you definitely don't want to be signing unlimited contracts uh you know for cargo liability unless you're making a decision that the risk is is worth the reward um so that's kind of the first thing um and then you know there's a case recently requiring a choice between levels of liability even in contracts which i think is crazy it's the old hughes test from the 80s when we were in the regulated era i didn't think you had to give a choice between levels of liability in a contract i thought we were talking about implied contracts when when we were using hues back in the day but some courts are still doing that so now i like to tuck into that liability provision also uh that that the parties have have had the opportunity to choose different levels of carrier liability at different transportation rates and they've selected the ones that are in the contract just to make sure that that limitation liability is enforceable in every court including the crazy ones so limitation liabilities one thing that i encounter in contracts a lot is where a contract might have one limitation of liability but then a bill of lading or a shipping document either overrides or tries to override that limitation of liability and you end up with a conflict so making sure you know what you're signing and you know what your drivers are signing is pretty darn important and whose bill of lading is being signed yeah i mean at least in my experience with working with with transportation companies especially the smaller ones um i think they get into the habit of just signing what's in front of them without taking time to consider the implications and and you know we're all guilty of that to some level in our various dealings day to day i'm curious you know we talk about not accepting certain certain terms that are uh you know favor more favorable to the shipper or not and it seems to me that it's always really kind of a matter of leverage and whether you even have the leverage to even push back on some of those terms so and particularly again for for the small to mid-sized carriers so what are your thoughts for those uh carriers that may not be used to kind of go into battle on these terms what advice do you give to them i have i have one kind of solid piece of advice that i regularly go to on this which is if you don't have leverage well number one try okay try see what you can do can't hurt to ask worse that can happen if someone says no often times they'll say yes but if it turns out that you don't have leverage and you can't change whatever the proposed limitation of liability is then make sure you have adequate insurance coverage at least up to that level of liability that you have accepted you have that within your control and if you don't have adequate insurance coverage cargo cargo liability coverage if you don't have adequate cargo liability coverage don't take that load unless you're willing to cover whatever the gap is if something happens to that load and um because it's a strict liability statute for the most part like craig was talking about if something happens that low while a carrier has it that carrier is is 95 times out of 100 going to be responsible for that load so make sure you either have the insurance coverage up to the level of liability that you've agreed or don't take the load or be willing to take it and the tough thing for a lot of motor carriers to understand is you don't have to know what's in the load and you don't have to know the value of the load to be responsible for it you know motor carriers are always telling me but i didn't know it was pharmaceuticals it said general commodities you know how was i supposed to know there was 52 million dollars on that truck that's a real call i did get that call one day uh and you know it it happens um and and it's unfortunate that the shipper isn't telling you but but or or the shipper was wrong you know the shipper a shipper that we're negotiating with this week told one of my clients don't worry nothing is going to be over 50 000 so go ahead and sign this full liability contract and i just wrote right back and said if nothing's gonna be over fifty thousand a hundred thousand is double what you're telling us so that should be fine um but always push back always try to push back i think i think motor carriers sell themselves short on their ability to push back um you know there's a major paper company that's that's sending out contracts this week that's pretending like it's not negotiating at all it's a full liability contract my three clients have all gotten a hundred thousand dollar cap with ease um now the first you know especially when capacity is tight i mean you know shippers and brokers got to get their freight there somehow and so they're going to be more willing to make concessions when capacity is tight so you probably have more leverage than you ever expected so yeah i think that's a great point just give it a try and and i also think it's a great tip to uh compare your insurance coverage because i i mean what's more simple than than just checking that do i have the insurance coverage to cover the liability that i'm assuming here and if not then i then maybe i then i i need to take you know more steps to to deal with that so yeah great tips um kristen one one topic that comes up a lot i know in this area is kind of uh mitigation of damages and salvage when cargo is damaged um so if something does have happened to the cargo and i'm driving down the road and i and i you know tip over and spill out a load of cargo whose responsibility is it in that situation to mitigate those damages and you know maybe some of the product is still uh viable um who whose responsibility is it to to deal with that well do you want me to give you the like one minute answer the one hour answer to that question i want the i want the yeah the abridged version well here's yeah we we charge by the way we use the charge by the work so we're really bad at bridging but um the it's such an important question uh just under the standard federal carmax scheme assuming the absence of a contract that says anything about mitigation of damages if there is a cargo incident it is the responsibility of the motor carrier to try to mitigate damages um and to salvage what can be salvaged and that's really for their own benefit because if they don't and you know they could if they could salvage 50 of whatever was involved in the particular accident or incident um then they're gonna save themselves those damages on the back end if and when there's a claim and they get or and or they get sued for it your insurer also will typically get involved in this and help you mitigate because they would like the damages to be reduced so there is a typical expectation for mitigation of damages however i'm going to go a little bit beyond the abridged version um there are a lot of exceptions to that and one of the things that i see a lot and that i have litigated i have i have in fact won this is the matter of who's responsible for the cargo and win because under the law typically speaking unless it's a whole loss let's say we're just talking about a partial loss to a load for example i had a case where beef was being shipped in large cardboard containers called combos there were like 15 of them in a truck um they all shifted forward and we carrier got sued over this the broker and the shipper considered it a total loss so they just rejected the load the insurer said no in fact the load was delivered and when it was delivered it wasn't a whole loss it was just shifted there was no evidence and there was no inspection which was a problem for a lot of people but um there was no evidence that that beef had actually been damaged like it hadn't come out of the cardboard boxes it simply was a pain in the butt to get it off the trailer because it wasn't as easy to forklift because the cardboard boxes were not standing as upright there might need to be some manual labor involved or something and what the court found is the court found in this particular case that the carrier was responsible and did did deliver the goods in a damaged way however the plaintiff in that lawsuit which was actually the brokerage who took the claim on assignment from the shipper who and they had paid out for the full loss on this claim um they were responsible because it wasn't a total loss after the point of delivery at that point in time when there was a decision to reject the load because it had only shifted and wasn't a total loss it was not the carrier's responsibility to go figure out what to do with the meat it was actually the responsibility of the receiver and the broker that was helping the receiver in that particular instance to handle it and so what the court found in that case is that the whole loss which i'm not going to get into all the details because that is a long story but the whole loss that eventually occurred with this meat was the responsibility of those who were handling it after it was delivered because no one no one tried to mitigate the damages there no one said oh we're going to just take the shifted load and maybe get it onto a forklift or manually unload it or take the extra time that's going to take instead the receiver just said nope total loss i'm done with it and it wasn't actually a total loss and so the court said well it's not really fair to push that whole thing back onto the carrier when the carrier did deliver and they delivered it only in a partially damaged state so at the point in time when that carrier delivered their job was done and their obligations were relieved at that point so i thought that was a really interesting case where the the court kind of said mitigation can be the responsibility of more than just the carrier yeah that is crazy i know craig i've heard stories from you over the years of some of the crazy stories where receivers will reject entire loads just because you know the seal's broken or something like that it seems like and it's almost like okay now we got a whole trailer load of stuff that we just got to burn because nobody wants it it's like yeah how do you handle that situation you arrive at the receiver and there's you know it doesn't appear that there's anything wrong there's just a seal broken what do you do in that case well you hope you haven't signed the contract that says you know that that that a broken seal is is a total loss and that they get to claim the whole thing um because if you have you know you can be in a bind particularly if you're the broker on the shipment um you know and and you may not be able to recover from your motor carrier under those circumstances yeah kristen you had mentioned oh sorry craig you may be breaking up a little bit um kristin you had mentioned that um you know that that's kind of the the fallback uh uh idea if they're you know apps in any contract provisions what are some common ways that folks deal with mitigation in contract provisions how will that come up typically in the contract itself well i would say that the carriers are the one that needs to be uh watching their contracts like a hawk for this sort of stuff what we see in a lot of contracts and that are put out to carriers are provisions that say for example you're responsible for the full loss and damage regardless of any salvage or mitigation or in fact you aren't allowed to salvage it um and you're you're foregoing all rights to salvage to help mitigate the damages and so we see that a lot in contracts and that is one i would definitely want to watch out for like craig said there are other provisions especially surrounding food safety where you pre-agree in your contract that the goods if they arrive without a seal or say in my situation it could they could have had a contract that said if the goods arrived and we can't remove them with the forklift for whatever reason it's a whole loss and at that point you would have agreed to it and and the beautiful thing about our country is that people can basically contract for anything that they want and uh that means that in your contract you can agree to a whole bunch of ridiculous things including like i will treat a partial shifted load as complete damage or i'm not going to be able to mitigate and so that's really what i would watch for um you know on the flip side of that if you're if you're able to push back in a contract say i've got the right if there is a cargo claim to mitigate damages or here's a good one if you're if say you're taking a broker you have a broker carrier agreement and the carrier is reviewing that agreement they could have the broker agree to help mitigate damages because the brokers typically have the resources and the relationships with the shippers and their customers to help figure out what do we do with this loss so you could actually say hey you know what i'm happy to take this load but if something happens to this load i'm gonna need to count on the broker to come and help me and if you don't help me maybe then the broker's shoulder's a little bit of responsibility that would be great i can't imagine a broker actually signing that but maybe in a good world and little changes to contract terms can make a big difference you know if you say if you sign a contract that allows the shipper in its sole discretion to decide everything then the shipper is going to get to decide everything and if you can insert the word reasonable in there so that it's their sole reasonable discretion then somebody like kristen or brandon or i can argue that what they're doing isn't reasonable you know you have a seal that's broken for sure but everything's still palletized and contained around you know somebody opened it up and it was canned tomatoes instead of televisions and they didn't want it and they closed it right away and you can see it all on the truck stops camera the whole thing took 15 seconds you know when the company wants to dump those canned tomatoes there you can say that's not reasonable we can see exactly what happened this seal breach didn't lead to anything but you have to make sure that you don't sign something that gives the shipper the sole discretion to make that determination and that's in a lot of contracts so i guess i'm kind of stuck on this idea of of the trucking companies that just don't even read these terms and short of sending these contracts over to you guys which i advise to anybody to to have kristen or craig take a quick look at these provisions i'm going to put you guys on the spot and ask you what are maybe the top three provisions that if we're not going to look at anything else relative to the contract what what top three provisions should i spend my time looking at if i'm a small to mid-sized trucking company that doesn't have the resources to have every contract reviewed by an attorney cap for limitation of liability and then whatever your insurance requirements are and then my favorite one lately um is indemnification a lot of shippers are using the indemnification provision to get a back door unlimited cargo liability provision in because if the indemnification doesn't exclude cargo there's an interesting argument that you may owe them defense and indemnification from a cargo claim that would otherwise be limited um kristen i'm sure has like three more uh well it was funny before brandon asked the question i was gonna say craig don't you have like three magic words you know that you look for i'm not gonna make you give it away by the way people have to pay you for that but i but you know that you look for in a contract it really i always look for the all caps those worry me the most yeah but um yeah but you know what people can sneak those lowercase whole bunch of problems but um i think that i think craig is absolutely right i actually was talking to an intro the other day and they said man i had to write a check not only for the cargo but for the defense of the claim that was brought against us because of one of those indemnity provisions um you're paying for the other side's attorneys yeah they did a really you know good job i guess in that case really lopsided i think that that's not fair play but i do see it a lot um so i would watch out for those things and you know i'll do a quick pitch feel free to talk to an attorney to go through what's most important to you and you won't necessarily need the attorney every single time although i would highly recommend it but you might not need to you might not want to afford it but at least then you'll know what the things are that you should be looking for in contracts that are important to you that's what i was going to say if nothing else spend the money and the time with a good attorney on these topics that can walk you through how to issue spot in your contracts what issues to look out for then at least you know that if you see that type of issue in a future contract then you know to escalate it and and try and get that fixed i think that's money uh well spent for sure hey craig you had mentioned early on about insurance i think now is a good time to talk about it how does insurance play into the equation for cargo loss and damage and and you know does a motor carrier's choice of insurer matter to the equation it absolutely does and and shippers and brokers should probably listen to this part too um you know somebody like progressive that writes a garbage policy that's right progressive i'm talking about you um that excludes water intrusion uh and then sells that policy to flatbed carriers the only thing that ever happens to flatbed loads is they get wet um and so there's no coverage you know because of an exclusion that's standard in that progressive policy that's why that progressive policy is way cheaper than a great west policy or travelers policy but great western travelers don't get off the hook either you know you have to know what you're buying the travelers policy this year has an exclusion in it for pharmaceuticals unless you pay more and get that exclusion removed and so you can pay a whole bunch of money for a great policy and then you can be moving covid vaccines or covid test kits or you know advil or aspirin or something and now we're going to say that it's pharmaceuticals you know my three biggest cargo claims ever 11 million 21 million and 52 million are all pharmaceutical loads and some of those motor carriers that move those loads at least when we had those cases were buying their insurance from travelers so if they've bought the current traveler's policy you know it's not going to provide coverage there so you have to watch out i'm pretty sure craig just confessed that causing travelers to change its policy and added that exclusion who's the show sponsors i better check this again yeah yeah call us
but you can really you can really look at your exposure you know even if sometimes you wear the broker hat you can look at the the carriers that you use and you can you know the worst cargo policy i've ever seen was the oida cargo policy it never covered anything in my experience um and the second worst is the current progressive policy uh and you know you can look at your uh the carriers that you you work with and see you know how much exposure you may have to cargo claims if you happen to be a broker um using carriers to have those policies you know if everybody has one of one of the great you know there are many great cargo policies out there if all your carriers have those then there's less risk and carriers just know what you're buying you know if you're a flatbed carrier hauling drywall you don't want that progressive policy you want anything else um and if you are a van or a refrigerated carrier hauling pharma you don't want the current traveler's policy without a rider that adds back in pharma coverage so know what you're buying yeah and talk to your agent about what you do to make sure that the type of freight that you typically move is going to be covered and not excluded in those policies and your in a good agent will know that and a good agent will take the time to help figure that out with you so don't be shy about making it really clear hey this is what i move i want to make sure it's not excluded like i can't tell you how much refrigerated we've come across where like seafood's excluded and seafood's expensive and seafood is stolen uh and you know it's like you got you gotta know if you're moving lobster tail that that's gonna be covered if the you know something bad happens we try for it not to happen you know but it does and you just got to make sure you know what's in your policy it should not be the case that you get shocked by your own insurance policy when a loss happens and then come to find out it's an excluded commodity shouldn't happen then you need to watch you need to watch for gaps too right now you know with the food safety modernization act that came across a couple years ago cargo exposure has always been an actual damages exposure under tarmac and so we were always talking about are there actual damages and so cargo policies are all written you know to cover actual damages and the food safety modernization act gave shippers the ability to say that the food might be unsafe and then the rule requires them to pull it from commerce and so there's no proof of actual damages there's just might be unsafe and the instruction to remove it from commerce can't sell it can't mitigate it can't donate it and so if you're in that kind of a situation where there's no actual damages that can be proved um you want to have one of the three insurance policies that we've seen to date that add back in coverage for something more than actual damages one of them even says food safety modernization act coverage um and it's it's in addition to actual damage coverage that's traditional under under carmack and look out for contractual uh expansions of your liability if you're agreeing to something more than you normally agree to there are only a few policies that will cover when you contractually agree to something more so when you're wearing a broker hat like the beautiful hat that brandon has on uh if you're if you happen to be wearing a broker hat that's right uh you know you want you just want to make sure um that that you haven't uh agreed to something to cargo liability you know and expanded your own liability in a way that your policy doesn't cover and again your insurance agent can help you figure that out or your attorney can help you you know see if what you purchased six months ago covers your typical operations yeah that's really important for anyone that that does have the broker hat on because a lot of times brokers do accept contractual liability for loads um and just make sure that's not excluded from your insurance policy because i've seen it a lot so real quickly um and maybe i'll put you on the spot again craig you mentioned the food safety modernization act this is probably a question i get at least once a week about that act and i usually just send them over to you but for those who are unfamiliar with that act all together can you give us another 50 000 foot look at that act and what it does and what it requires uh of of those in the in the transportation industry yeah i love it so so the act really doesn't do a whole lot and i don't see why there was even a need for it i mean the mission statement for the act says this isn't a problem but we're going to address it anyway um but it basically legislation in general i think yeah yeah yeah the the rule says that a shipper has to tell um the broker or the motor carrier what to do to keep food safe the real interesting thing is the definition of food under the act is incredibly narrow it's it's it's things that need a refrigeration to be safe or it's food that's not fully packaged so think of oranges where you can reach through the mesh bag that the orange is in and touch it those oranges aren't fully packaged so they're covered by the act and something that needs refrigeration for safety i guess maybe lunch meat does but certainly beer does not um so beer is fully packaged and beer is refrigerated for convenience or for sellability but not for safety and so neither one of those would be covered by the rule unless you've expanded the definition of food in your contracts which we see a lot of people doing they'll get something from a major food shipper that says everything that we give you it counts as regulated food and if you've done that then the act applies to everything that they give you um and then what is the water with water a lot like water yeah yeah and water counts as food for other things like for for um registering a warehouse is a food handling facility water counts as food shoot my first uh my first introduction of food this dates me a little bit but a client called up that was uh warehousing madonna's hard candy cd uh and best buy was gonna have a promotion where the cd came with hard candy and so we had to hurry up and register all their warehouses across the country as food handling facilities because there was going to be hard candy in those facilities um but i digress um please tell me you at least got a madonna uh autograph out of that i did not i got nothing i got paid i mean so that was okay and i got a client that i still have today so 15 years later it still still matters and the practice area like who else knew about food way back then um but the thing about the food safety modernization act is the instructions that you get on keeping that food safe have the force of regulation behind them you're basically instructed to follow the shipper's instructions and one of the weird things about that act also is brokers are defined as shippers so i know brokers don't think of themselves as shippers but but under the act they are so that means they have to tell the carriers they use what's necessary to keep the food safe um it's kind of you know it's it becomes really important that the contracts in food spell everything out because we're kind of in no man's land on food right now the the rule conflicts with traditional carmack law um actual damages versus maybe unsafe and so really we like to spell it all out in a contract now so my takeaway from the act oh go ahead crystal as gonna say we have seen some cases arguing that fisma violations could amount to actual damage under carmack and the i'd say the case law goes both ways on it depending on where you are um we have we have argued it um and defeated it for a carrier at times partially because they just didn't meet the fisma standard in general so it didn't ever reach that level but it is it is something that is being litigated and i think is being used more and more and people think it's an easy way to find damages if you have someone who rejected goods when they arrive they're just like oh fisma unsafe food we're not it's unsafe food we're throwing out the whole thing you know and so they'll try to rely on that because it sounds kind of sexy to be like oh the food it's gross it's not really sexy but food is gross let's get rid of it and um it it it tends to be used as an excuse when there isn't actually full damage uh back to that mitigation issue so i you do have to be um aware and not just rely on it as an absolute oh the stuff can be chucked now because fisma so and i think in a bad economy we see a lot of food shippers i feel like um managing their inventory with cargo claims so if the economy is taking a turn towards the worst currently you may see more food-based cargo claims where somebody orders something realizes they don't need a full truckload of pizza dough anymore um and they might leave the doors open while they unload it on the dock for eight hours and then say it's a fisma violation um and and try to claim the whole load um you know we saw a lot of that in 2010 2011 2012 and i feel like it's starting to come back this summer all right so i'm going to put you guys to the test here so we're running out of time and uh we said that we're also going to talk about unauthorized brokerage so i'm going to challenge you both to uh to figure out a way to harmonize these two topics that are seemingly unrelated but uh what what do folks need i want to talk about unauthorized brokerage because i know you both are involved in those area in that area as well and i know that we recently saw fmcsa throw itself into the mix here by um uh potentially um kind of looking at revising the definitions of brokerage et cetera so i wanted to get your take on on on these issues um so uh kristen what's what's the deal with unauthorized brokerage and why is it a big deal and why is fmcsa stepping in now to uh to to try and deal with it i'll answer that then i'll let craig figure out what it has to do with cargo claims uh well all right so the definition of brokerage is arranging the transportation of goods for compensation if you're doing that and you are not authorized by the fmcsa as a broker then you are engaged in unauthorized brokerage that's it's as simple as that so where do we see a lot of gray area we see it in dispatch services where they say that they're not engaged in the transportation and the arrangement of transportation they're just simply facilitating something that has already been arranged we see it in the concept of shippers agents people who say well i'm not actually arranging transportation for compensation i'm just a voice of the shipper helping them go place transportation which sounds a whole lot like unauthorized brokerage so there's just a lot of gray area there where it's not your traditional um separate entity that is a brokerage arranging freight but yet you're somehow engaged in the arranging of transportation and you're getting paid for it um we've seen some people actually uh you know a real really kind of creative solutions on this sometimes as where people are arranging the transportation but they're not taking compensation because maybe it's like an intra company passing if a carrier doesn't have capacity they might have been tender to load they don't have capacity they'll pass it off to a brokerage arm it's a related entity that brokerage arm will be authorized and they'll broker out the goods and receive compensation for that was that carrier passing the tender to the broker on authorized brokerage i think there's an open question on that
yeah and i could i can harmonize these topics by saying you all hate cargo claims because they cost you money unauthorized brokerage costs you money also um you know think of all the free charge debt collectors the baxter bailey's the alexander wins the joel weiss and weiss spencer levin i mean all these pretend attorneys that that make up these names for for their for their debt collection firms that that don't even have anybody with those names in those it just sounded really firms that's why they did it really really cool yeah um so you know it's um the unauthorized brokerage a lot of times the the double brokers that cost people money um in in those double broker schemes has somebody involved in it that didn't have brokerage authority that passed it on to somebody else and so maybe we can use it as a defense you know that they've violated map 21 and engaged in the unlaw unlicensed brokerage or at least can't collect on the freight charges that they want to collect on because they took it from somebody that wasn't authorized to give it and motor carriers you got to watch that you know watch when you're on a load board and you grab a load and it's nine thousand dollars for something that you know is a three thousand dollar shipment it's only nine thousand dollars because that's a pretend broker uh you know or or not a broker you know that's in maybe even an imposter um that doesn't plan on paying you for that load that wants to get you to move that load and then you're going to be the uncompensated motor carrier at the bottom you know so unauthorized brokerage is a problem for all of us and the less of it that we see you know the less unpaid motor carriers will have doing the work do you both have a sense of what the fmcsa is trying to do it seemed a little cryptic to me their notice that they proposed it's probably been a month or so ago now where they it looked like they were kind of targeting those dispatch services that that kristen was talking about um what's your if you had a crystal ball where do you think fmcsa is going with that potential rule maybe yeah i wrote some of the responses uh for various clients to that potential rulemaking you know and we all thought from a broker perspective that dispatch services were finally in the crosshairs that these people that don't have to have a 75 000 bond that don't have to be responsible and defined by the regulations you know we're existing in the shadows and and putting all of all of our reputations at risk by doing what brokers do without any of the things that brokers are required to have so i think it's good for brokers if fmcsa is going to kind of define dispatch services out of existence you know it's fine if they want to help i think dispatch services started as a way to help the little guy they were doing back office work for motor carriers and that's fine if they want to collect for motor carriers if they want to do the paperwork for motor carriers if they want to help motor carriers you know route small fleets you know it's great to have to have somebody helping you with all of that stuff but when they go and get the loads for you and they're doing it for 40 different motor carriers uh you know then they all of a sudden they look and smell and feel like a broker and i think that's what's in the crosshairs yeah i think it's interesting that they didn't do it as a rulemaking they simply asked for comment from the public a little bit unusual of the fmcsa to do that it was um one month today actually and so they didn't give us a lot of indication as to what they were planning on doing with it i imagine they're going to be issuing guidances um and guidance is well yeah we like we like guidances they come out and then they get repealed and then everyone gets excused or they have like 15 things and no no one consulted the lawyers on it hopefully they read craig's letters i i don't know um but i you know i suspect that you know let's let's do crystal ball by the end of the month or maybe even two months we'll get some guidance from the f and the csa on it and that will be kind of what propels out maybe future rule making i think the first page of that guidance is likely to say that this is the agency's opinion as of the date it is written and it is not binding and the opinion is subject to change you know so it'll it'll likely be something that is helpful but not enforceable until we get an actual rule yeah uh i just thought it was interesting you don't see fmcsa getting involved in kind of those more commercial type issues very often so um you know they've traditionally been uh you know their rule-making is more focused on the safety side of things as you would expect but people forget that the fmcsa is also responsible for regulating brokerage um uh so yeah we'll just wait and see i guess i mean it has regs like craig mentioned there's map 21 out there that says no unauthorized brokering and if you read it it's kind of scary when you read what the consequences can be but you know are they out there enforcing it every day that's what i was going to say what are the consequences because as far as i've seen there's absolutely no teeth to it personal liability
yeah and you can use it in a private cause of action i mean private a private lawsuit you can use it so i do think that it can be a tool of of lawyers but you know are the agencies out there bringing investigative actions against brokerages and and private individuals if anyone on this uh webcast has that occur please give us a call we would like to talk to you to find out what is going on but i haven't really seen that happening yeah just he just wants to scare the out of the ceos of those guys maybe the fmcsa is listening to us right now and we're just going to screw everyone by causing them to take extra interest in this i don't know but uh it's just it's just not something that's really being enforced right now so it's something to pay attention to to be careful with i think it you know anytime you're blurring the lines and you're you're going outside your lane right if you're not an authorized broker i think you're playing with fire uh so try to stay in your lane and not do it if you don't have authority or go get the authority and get the bond if you need it yeah at least in my experience it's more often pretty innocent than anything else it's a carrier who as you said kristen has excess capacity and they need to hand it off and then they just don't even think about the fact that what they're doing now is actually brokerage but yeah you need to be aware of that for sure all right when they hand it off they give it to another motor carrier there's a cargo claim and that motor carrier doesn't have great cargo insurance to tie it all together there we go there it is so then the officers and directors are in the crosshairs all right give them a prize all right guys it's been great appreciate you being with me today we're about out of time uh before we let you go here tell everybody where they can find more about what you're doing and get in touch with you if they want to kristin you want to go kristen johnson look me up taylorlawpl.com we're based out of florida service servicing motor carriers and brokers nationally um or you can give us a call 863-875-6950
craig craighelm rick helmerich law or if you can't spell helmrich just type basementlaw.com since i'm in my basement uh cell phone 317-979-7105 that's right that's my cell phone give me a call yeah take them up on those offers for sure these are the ones these are the the folks i turn to when i uh when my clients have uh any of these issues so yeah for sure they are the uh experts i know that we're not supposed to use that word experts when we're talking about ourselves but oh florida change the rule you can oh you can use it okay kristin's an expert craig and i are not experts so call cr call kristen all right guys thanks a lot really appreciate it we're gonna wrap things up uh thanks everybody for joining us today um we've mentioned a couple times throughout the show today some of the articles that we post on trucksafe.com we try and do uh an article or so a week and they're pretty detailed articles on all kinds of compliance related topics so be sure to check those out sign up for our newsletter that way they just get sent right to your inbox you don't have to worry about finding them also be sure to follow us on social media we're pretty active on linkedin and facebook twitter all of them um getting a lot of content out there just uh to to like i've said at the at the start try and make our our roadway safer by getting the education out there that we need to get out there so follow us on on our social media channels uh and then lastly i'll just mention again our our next upcoming truck safe live episode again august 25th 1 p.m eastern time steve bryan with uh bluewire will be joining us you can find the details and add it to your calendar calendar over at trucksafelive.com uh thanks again to our sponsors log rock uh for sponsoring the show this season and usi insurance for sponsoring this episode uh we will see you next time thanks everyone
you