Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 14 - Brokers Beware

Wednesday, September 21, 2022 at 4:23 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 14 - Brokers Beware

About This Event

This month, we're  joined by the Armchair Attorney, Matt Leffler to discuss broker liability and where things stand following the Supreme Court's recent decision to deny review in the C.H. Robinson case. We'll also address recent efforts by the FMCSA to tackle unauthorized brokerage.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 14 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman of Trucksafe Consulting is joined by guest Matt Leffler, founding partner of Armchair Attorney, to discuss broker liability in the trucking industry. The conversation centers on the legal exposure that property brokers and shippers face when motor carriers they hire are involved in serious accidents, with particular focus on the implications of the recent CH Robinson Supreme Court case. Before diving into the main topic, Wiseman also covers several noteworthy regulatory developments, including an FMCSA advance notice of proposed rulemaking on potential revisions to the ELD mandate, updates to the COVID-19 emergency declaration, and a new agency notice seeking information on human factors related to semi-autonomous trucks. The hosts clarify a widespread misconception surrounding the CH Robinson case, emphasizing that the Supreme Court's decision not to hear the case did not create new liability for brokers, but rather preserved the longstanding legal landscape in which brokers can be sued under negligence theories such as negligent hiring, negligent selection, and negligent retention. Leffler explains that when catastrophic accidents occur, plaintiff attorneys naturally look beyond the motor carrier's insurance policy, which often falls well short of covering damages, and pursue brokers and shippers up the chain. The concept of joint and several liability is highlighted as particularly significant, meaning a broker found even partially at fault could be held responsible for the full remaining damages after a carrier's policy is exhausted. The discussion outlines what constitutes a reasonable standard of care for brokers when vetting motor carriers. Drawing on prior case law, Wiseman notes that courts have generally required brokers to verify that a carrier holds an active DOT number, maintains proper insurance, and does not carry an unsatisfactory safety rating, all of which can be confirmed quickly through the FMCSA's SAFER website. Both Wiseman and Leffler caution, however, that brokers must strike a careful balance, as going too far in directing or controlling a carrier's operations could expose them to joint employer liability, a separate and equally serious legal risk. The episode also addresses the issue of double brokering, with Wiseman clarifying that while it is not inherently illegal under federal law provided all parties hold the required operating authority, it typically constitutes a breach of contract and can create serious complications in the event of an accident. The hosts discuss a recent FMCSA notice targeting freight agents and dispatch services that may be operating without proper broker authority, suggesting the agency may be moving toward tighter regulation of these arrangements. Leffler emphasizes that obtaining broker authority is relatively straightforward, requiring only an application and a $75,000 surety bond, making compliance accessible and avoidance of it difficult to justify. Key takeaways for fleet safety professionals and brokers include the importance of carrying insurance well above the legal minimum, documenting and consistently following a formal carrier vetting protocol, and utilizing available technology and public FMCSA data to conduct due diligence before tendering loads. Leffler offers a straightforward formula for carriers seeking to attract broker and shipper business: deliver freight safely, on time, and undamaged, and carry robust insurance coverage. Wiseman echoes this, noting that reputation and consistent safety performance remain the most compelling factors in building lasting broker and shipper relationships.

Full Transcript

foreign thank you foreign foreign foreign telling whether it's true all the things you said you could do not in the mood for a failure always feed your Eagle together I'm way too long I wonder what I am Jason it's not even fun anymore this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign welcome to episode 14 of truck safe live the monthly show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs today we're talking about broker liability we're going to give carriers a rest we most of our shows are are all about the uh the problems that motor carriers face today they get they get a break we're going to talk about the problems that property Brokers and even shippers tend to face before we do that a few things going on in the industry uh of course the the big news this past week um it's been about a week I think FMCSA published an advance notice of proposed rule making an PRM concerning elds this is potentially the first substantial revisions to the ELD mandate since it went into effect in 2015 and so it has the potential to be a pretty big deal if you're interested in the the details of it we just put out a detailed article over at trucksafe.com and a video on it but long story short there's essentially four parts to it the agency is soliciting comments from the public in essentially four areas number one is the exemption that exists in uh in current rules for pre-2000 model year engines so as many of you will know those drivers of those vehicles with pre-2000 engines are completely exempt from the ELD mandate as it stands the agency in its notice mentioned that it has heard apparently Through the Grapevine that a certain rebuilt engines older engines um have the the electronic control modules or the ecms that are in fact compatible with elds so they are considering uh doing away with the exemption or potentially modifying it so they're soliciting comments on that so that's a big one uh the other issue that they're looking at are how we handle malfunctions what happens if one of your ELD devices malfunctions and drivers aren't able to uh use them to track their records of Duty status under the current rules there are certain situations where there's been a malfunction and drivers have to transition over to paper logs there's a whole process that that drivers and carriers have to go through when a device malfunctions and the agencies asking whether it needs to be more clear in its regulations about that process I think the answer to that is probably yes it always helps if we can bring some clarity to those uh often com complex issues that drivers and carriers are expected to deal with uh then we have some potential revisions to the technical specifications of the ELD rule these are the specifications that will apply to the devices themselves what do they have to be able to track what types of data do they have to collect that type of stuff the the rules that the manufacturers of the devices have to be concerned with there's a a handful of specific questions the agency is posing and it's notice about the technical specifications the one that really caught my attention was the idea that the agency is thinking about allowing the devices to automatically change a driver's Duty status if that driver forgets to change the duty status before powering down the truck we see this come up quite a bit when we go and do audits of motor carriers where we'll we'll be auditing a driver's logs and we'll see hours on end of personal conveyance time or on duty not driving time which usually indicates that the driver forgot to place him or herself out of that status before powering down the truck and then they just left themselves in that status over the weekend or something like that and that leads to trouble obviously in the event of an audit or roadside inspection so under the current rule the devices can't automatically switch a driver's Duty status in that scenario so the agency is contemplating changing that and then last but certainly not least the agency noted that it is considering potentially moving away from the self-certification process that we have in place in the U.S for device manufacturers so you know this is a a big difference between the US's ELD mandate and the Canadian ELD mandate in Canada if you're a manufacturer of ELD devices you have to have your device certified by the agency that regulates Highway Safety in Canada in order to offer that to motor carriers in the U.S it's a self-certification process so we rely on the manufacturers of those devices to certify that their devices meet all of those technical specifications and we're starting to see the FMCSA be more aggressive in revoking devices that turn out not to be compliant with those rules so the agency is now posing the question should we move away from this self-certification process and to a process where the FMCSA itself or its designees step in and certify these devices obviously that would be a huge change and I imagine it's making the device manufacturers pretty nervous so long story short those are the areas where the agency is contemplating some changes comments are due by November 15th if that's not extended it probably will be extended it would be my guess uh we're a few days into it and there are already several hundred comments so if you want to submit comments look it up at regulations.gov docket number FMCSA 2022-0078 is where you'll find that and then you can submit your comments if you have any questions about how these rule changes potential rule changes may impact your operations or if you want any help submitting comments feel free to get in touch with us we're going to help a couple of different groups submit comments so that's something that we've got on our plate again if you need help feel free to give us a call or Reach Out trucksafe.com all right aside from the ELD um notice there have been a couple of other notices that the agency has recently released uh one is a notice concerning the ongoing covid emergency declaration so this is a declaration that the FMCSA issued way back March of 2020 when when covid was just ramping up and it's a pretty broad exemption from um it started out as a pretty broad exemption from most of the safety regulations for our for drivers and carriers who were engaged in the emergency relief efforts transporting you know testing supplies for for covid testing or or transporting nowadays supplies to restock shelves so it's been kind of an all-encompassing exemption more recently the agency has kind of cut back on it and now it's mainly in hours of service exemption again only available to carriers and drivers that are actually transporting goods that are part of the emergency relief efforts the notice that just came out this month is asking is trying to get a feel for how many carriers are still taking advantage of this exemption and how they are using it uh to me this kind of spells the end for the Declaration it I it would not be surprising to me if the agency were to phase it out completely uh here over the next month or so so we'll see where that goes if you are still using it be sure to get in there and file your comments so that uh so that the agency knows you're still using it and then lastly was another notice that came out yesterday I think um this one was interesting this is a notice from FMCSA seeking some information on human factors pertaining to the operation of semi-autonomous trucks so we've seen some news stories recently of some things that have gone wrong with certain semi-autonomous trucks where there's a safety driver in the seat something goes wrong truck gets involved in a wreck clearly this is on the agency's radar and now they're starting to kind of study this um so if that interests you take a look at the notice again FMCSA just released it we'll see where this goes the agency hasn't really done anything yet with autonomous trucks um you know we've talked in the past that there's going to have to be really a kind of a wholesale revision to the safety regulations as they exist currently because right now the way the safety regulations are structured they they fully contemplate that a driver a human driver is operating the trucks that's just how the regulations are structured clearly as we're moving towards autonomous Trucking we're going to have to revamp the regulations and the agency needs to get on that sooner rather than later in my view because we are there we are at the point where autonomous trucks are are a reality so it is what it is we'll see where the agency takes it all right that's all the news I have for uh industry related news a couple things going on with truck safe if you haven't checked it out already make sure you download our app we have the truck safe Network app in the app store and the Google Play Store this is where you'll have access to our truck safe compliance Network a space for safety professionals risk advisors Insurance professionals to to gather together ask questions learn from one another learn what they're doing well what what's working well for their fleets in terms of managing a safety program the app us also has all of our DOT related articles available and our full library of dot related content so check that out just search trucksafe in the app store or the Google Play Store and you will find it also another related news for the truck safe compliance network if you're not a member of that yet be sure to join that it's free to join we offer a lot of free content to to folks that are members of the network go to trucksafenetwork.com again free to sign up we just recently did a free webinar on drug and alcohol testing and some of the problems that tend to arise from motor carriers in that process we're doing these types of free webinars at least once a month so if you are managing a fleet of drivers and your responsibility is is staying in compliance with the multitude of regulations that govern your business be sure to check that out we're just trying to offer this content get it out there in the open so folks have access to it and they can better manage their safety programs so check that out lastly check out our courses online trucksafeacademy.com we've mentioned this before but we have a full catalog now of in-depth comprehensive courses on DOT compliance we have one for safety managers we have one for drivers we have a Hazmat specific course and we have a reasonable suspicion course so check those out trucksafeacademy.com all right that's it with all of the news that I wanted to talk about so let's turn to the topic of today again um show today is about broker liability and some of the exposure that that property Brokers and to some extent shippers have um you know how Pro how Brokers tend to get implicated in Highway accident litigation and what they need to do to protect themselves uh with me today I am excited to have on with me none other than the armchair attorney Matt Leffler Matt welcome be here thanks for having me on the program awesome hey I've been wanting to get you on for a long time really enjoy your content that you're pushing out excited to have you with me today so give us uh so for folks who aren't following you on on social media or or wherever you post your content give us a little background how you got involved in transportation and what you do for the transportation industry like so many people this is a family business my grandfather hold grain in Central Illinois until polio took his ability to walk and he became a mechanic after that and my father was eight years old when he started turning wrenches to help my grandfather and in 1976 my dad started with roadway as a night shop supervisor and he managed Union Mechanics for most of his career and in the early 90s he had the opportunity to start his own business and the business he started was a company called Outsource Fleet Services and Outsource Fleet Services outsourced Fleet Services we did repair and maintenance for commercial vehicle man uh fleets and our biggest customer the biggest one we worked with to begin with was a company called RPS which eventually became a FedEx Ground we were the largest provider of maintenance for ground for about 20 years and I joined up with the company after completing law school and practicing for a couple of years in in the business and we grew that into an organization with over a hundred mechanics and six different states we sold that business in 2018 to a company called Dickinson Fleet Services and I stuck around with Dickinson for about a year and a half as a vice president of sales and then I had a non-competition agreement and I spent some time in software I went to a company called decisive another one called V Hub and after that I wanted to get back into the maintenance business so what I do today is I have kind of a couple roles that I run one is the you know founding partner of armchair attorney it's a law firm that helps people and and companies create post-employment restrictive covenants and separation agreements and that kind of stuff and I also work with a firm called Epica Fleet Services which is a repair and maintenance vendor we have locations all across the country over 150 maybe close to 200 mechanics right now and it's been an exciting thing so this is what I do I love this business you can't get out of it once you're in it and I'm excited to be part of the the network that is the supply web yeah well I mentioned your content at the uh at the start here that's kind of how I came across you just watching some of your your live shows that you do tell us about the podcast that you do yeah so I I started off by saying what is a website domain that I can get and that domain was armchair attorney so I said well that's a really catchy name it's got some alliteration might as well trademark it and form an LLC which is what I did and then I started producing these um interview shows so before I did the interview shows I was doing just you know content around non-competition agreements or just different legal topics things like the Second Amendment just topics like that and what we did we started doing these live interview shows and they really seemed to catch on and we've had some incredible guests over the last couple of months we've been doing it and we Coons or you with the Apple podcast or Spotify and look up armchair attorney you'll see my vector image face that my wife made for me and you can see the interviews we've had with a whole bunch of really interesting people just last week we had a Britain Ladd who is a global supply chain consultant one of the most brilliant guys I've ever a chance to work with and it's just a lot of interesting things like that yeah that's awesome um you know if you're not following already do yourself a favor do that go to he's on LinkedIn where else are you Facebook yes it's on Twitter you can find me at armchair at it it's a t t y a t t y is the abbreviation for the word attorney uh on Tick Tock I do have that now they're adding as well you can find me there I think I have four followers yeah we were just talking before the show about Tick Tock it's a completely strange world I have no idea how any of it works I'm LinkedIn is where I do but I go on all sorts of different products that's how you and I got a chance to talk earlier was on freight waves together so it's a thing that I love to do I love talking to people I love making content nice yeah yeah um okay so we we are talking today about in fact this is how uh this this topic idea came up we were talking on freight waves together um and one of the topics that came up in that show was broker liability and the CH Robinson case that came out uh it's probably been a month or so ago and uh you know we've heard a lot of talk in the industry about this ab5 case and I know you've you've spent a lot of time thinking about and talking about that case as well but one that I think kind of got uh papered over a little bit uh by the ab5 case was the CH Robinson case I'm wondering if you could give our viewers kind of a high level overview of what this case is what it does and and what its implications are to the industry yeah the main thing to start off with is Don't Panic um this is how the law works but the case goes around where uh Costco hired CH Robinson to move Freight CH Robinson then hired a carrier and that carrier performed the move unfortunately that carrier lost control crashed across the center line and struck another vehicle and what ends up happening is everyone gets sued so when someone has a catastrophic accident you try to figure out where you're going to find the rate of recover for your plaintiff for the injured person and what ends up happening is CH Robinson tries to make the argument that they are essentially immune from litigation that they are preempted by a statue called the f-a-a-a-a that essentially says you don't get to regulate the way that I do my business now the FAA preemption has to do more about pricing and things like that whereas a negligence claim which is what's being alleged in the CH Robinson case is generally looked at as a safety issue as opposed to some sort of means or methods of making transportation and so what ends up happening is every broker starts saying wait a second the whole idea of what I do is to Outsource the risk to somebody else and I'm not responsible under any of these circumstances and a lot of people have been thinking well does this mean that Brokers are now going to be liable more often and first of all no one said CH Robinson's liable the fact that the matter was that you can proceed with litigation against them which just means that you can find out if they might be liable but that's what the meat of that case has to do yeah I think that's the misconception that I've seen quite a bit of uh talking with with clients and and kind of talking about the case it always comes up and everybody says well it's going to be a a sea change now Brokers are going to be pulled into these cases like that's not really changing that's how it's been for decades this is the thing as a lawyer yourself like there's not that things like there are new things but these types of liability and these theories of recovery have been around for decades like negligent hiring or negligent retaining of a motor carrier is not new every state has these every single year what is new-ish was that they brought it to the Supreme Court and they thought they might have an audience maybe the Supreme Court would say yeah let's Grant the root of certiorari and we'll hear the case but the Supreme Court's like no yeah it would have been a huge change had the Supreme Court weighed in and sided with uh CH Robinson it said that f4a preempts these types of of 100 claims and the thing is like all the interest groups the lobbying organizations and the great you know conglomerates of you know truckload carers Association or ATA or Tia we're all filing briefs Amicus brief saying hey take this case it's really important we need to make sure they have no liability and I I just I think a lot of people expected something to happen that didn't and now there's a little level of I wouldn't say panic but as you if you're a broker carry adequate insurance yeah that's a simple thing to start off with like you can have good practices good processes good technology but just carry enough insurance and you're probably going to be okay yeah a lot of the big Brokers are well aware of this exposure and they do just that I don't think a lot of the smaller Brokers even realize that this is a concern uh and they don't realize that there's insurance coverage out there available specifically to address this type of exposure that's one of the things that we've worked with our broker clients on is hey make there's broker liability policies out there you need to go check those out for sure so you would mentioned kind of how these cases play out in the theory on which the Brokers and and even shippers frankly uh get pulled into these types of lawsuits maybe we should break that down a little bit and and kind of explain what is this idea or this concept of negligent hiring negligent retention negligent selection yeah absolutely so negligence is one of the most interesting things you're ever going to learn about in law school and really what it boils down to besides is it really that interesting this is almost every theory of recovery from falling a slip and fall from a car accident to a truckload liability to any type of workmanship I mean this is the question of what is the duty what was the the causation what was the proximate cause and all these other you know how did you relate to that event and then what was the damages so as lawyers we tend to know what the damages are we say what was the injury what was the what was the someone died did someone get you know maimed we know what those things are worth workers compensation is all about understanding what is the relationship of money to injury and the question is I'd go back to is who's responsible who pays now if you are a plaintiff's attorney and you have an injured person you're trying to help make whole and they're not negligent themselves and we can talk about you know contributory negligence but you're asking the question how do I help my client who's responsible you look at the truckload carrier truck carrier and you say how much liability do you have they have a million dollars what does a million dollars by you nothing nothing even the Department of Transportation has the valuation statistical valuation of human life at 11.2 million dollars per human life that's the value that they assign and we know the value of human life in most cases across the country and if someone dies you can't make them whole with a million dollars so you look and say well who else is involved with this and as a plaintiff I have no idea the level of responsibility the communications that took place the processes involved and so I want to find those things out and that's how these other companies start getting Dragged In not just the broker maybe the maintenance provider maybe the tire provider maybe the manufacturer what are the different things that went wrong that causes catastrophic thing to happen yeah so obviously you know it's a completely I won't say completely it's a different Theory than the plaintiff would bring against the the truck driver or the trucking company that employs the truck driver right because in that case you know if the driver was if the truck driver was at fault your your theory is that the the driver was negligent in his operation of the vehicle and his negligence caused my injuries and so he owes me and then the way that we get to the motor carrier in that situation is that type of employment relationship yeah uh you know a vicarious liability you'll hear that term thrown around it it makes employers or even we have a unique thing in the transportation industry where we have a lot of independent contractor relationships and and you know nefarious trucking companies over the years have have tried to sidestep their liability by setting up these independent contractor relationships but the the dot is wise to that tactic and they put into place these leasing regulations that now there has to be a lease agreement in place when you've got owner operators between that owner operator and the trucking company and that in essence then makes that motor carrier liable for the the actions of that driver regardless of whether it's an independent contracted relationship or not so that's how drivers and motor carriers get implicated in this in this in this type of lawsuit but when it comes to the Brokers and even up to the shippers um you know I think your Point's a good one we're looking up the chain to the deeper Pockets if we can only collect a million dollars you know we're lucky if we even get a million dollars from trucking companies I think the uh correct me if I'm wrong I think the minimum insurance of 750 000 for General commodity care has been the minimum since like the 1980s we have not raised that bar and there's not a lot of not a lot of people asking for it to be raised and in my opinion you need to have higher levels of insurance if you want to stay in the business you need to have longer you need to have more but to your point like how did the broker get liable well we look and say well what was the duty of care like what was the process that you used to select this Trucking Company because but for you having selected them my loved one would still be here or my my leg would still be working and it's a harder case to prove but once you get them on the case you have the power to do Discovery you can find out what they were doing and then as we look at what we call joint and several liability it might be the Brokers aren't responsible for 10 of it that's fine I'll take all the money from you anyway because we're being severally liable everybody is fully responsible for the action that takes place yeah I think that's a huge point that so many Miss is with joint several liability being kind of the law of the land if if that motor carrier has a million dollars of insurance let's say you've got a a 11 million dollar lawsuit that motor carrier you know tenders its million dollars they're out of the picture now they're they're lights out and so now you as the broker are on the hook for that remainder remaining 10 million dollars even though you may be only 10 at full absolutely and it gets really complicated so to your point the insurance company for the motor carrier may say all right you've maxed out the policy but I'm still I still have to defend you but that that uh liability insurance provider might turn around and say okay I'm in a subrogate I'm going to go along with you against the broker or whatever so these things get complicated very quickly and if you have that million dollar policy every carrier needs to understand this your limitation of liability is not the amount of insurance you carry but I have leaned assets I have foreclosed on real estate if I have a judgment against you and your your insurance is exhaustive I don't care I don't care I'm gonna get the money from you if you have any resources I will find them I will I will lock your bank accounts I will siphon the money off and I will give it to my client so it is not in your interest to carry what's legally minimum in terms of insurance if you have one cash then you could lose a whole lot more than just a load of freight oh yeah for sure you know we see studies out there the American Transportation Research Institute did a a couple of great studies recently if if folks listening haven't check those out make sure you do so one's on nuclear verdicts that that you hear a lot of uh talk about the others on uh verdicts that are less than 10 million dollars 10 million dollars is the way that the study looks at these these types of groups yeah all right we're going to take a second here Brandon yeah I'm going to plant a flag here I don't like the term nuclear verdict it's not a legal term it's a made-up it's a made-up term and and here's my theory on it and I can tell me I'm wrong I think that nuclear verdict is a phrase used to manipulate people to think we need to have additional tort reform the idea being that avert over 10 million dollars is like a catastrophic end of the world type of situation it's just completely wrong one human life one wrongful death case is going to be over 10 million dollars in most contexts and we don't we don't say oh that's that car actor that slip and fall it's a nuclear verb no it's a it's a verdict it's just a verdict it's just a word for a dollar amount yeah I I see your point I I would disagree with you on the need for tort reform and we could spend you hours on this topic alone I think in my view tort reform is necessary not so much because of the the the way we sensationalize these types of verdict but because of the way we've seen at least some of these cases play out with this whole reptile theory of litigation and because in my view you know certainly the the injured plaintiff needs to be made whole if we're responsible for the accident we need to make sure that they get what they're entitled to get to make them whole what I have a problem with is then taking that the next step and saying uh that's that's not enough for us we want to punish the motor carrier not necessarily for the circumstances of this accident nothing to do with this accident but rather they're safety related reputation what what are their CSA scores look like uh what have they done from a driver qualification standpoint in my view that's less relevant to the accident in hand in making that particular plaintiff hole from the accident and it's really about just uh you know punishing that motor carrier for behavior that may or may not have led to this accident at all and I think that's where most will say that we maybe need some tour reform and I you know there are certainly states that have pursued that Texas for example recently um passed some tort reform in that regard yeah the thing that I get concerned about is that we we make it seem like the plaintiff doesn't deserve what they get and like the the what a jury returns in terms of a verdict for somebody um that's sacred that's when it's very important and we don't want to find a way to make it so that a plaintiff is vilified for simply trying to be made whole for the things that they've encountered am I am I glitching here Brandon you're freezing up a little bit but we're still we're going to push ahead we're going to push ahead hey we've got a we got a question here let's bring it up here let's see what it says well that's that's huge here let's I love smaller Barry says that's like if a broker would put a fine on a carrier for a late pickup or late delivery which now some shippers are starting to do What scenario would come out if the carrier had an accident accident and simply State I was in a hurry because I did not want to get a fine from the broker or the shipper that's a great question I mean if you have a broker who's basically saying Hey I want your skirt safety or skirt these things that's a path to get liability especially if you're telling them which way to go or what direction to use this is the lack of the hands-off control Brokers need to have in place in order not to be liable that's a great question no that's exactly right because I think the interesting thing about broker liability is kind of you're if you're a broker you're having to uh you're on like you're having to balance two things right you're you're balancing one doing enough to make sure that the carriers you hire are safe and should be out on the road but if you start to meddle too much in in that motor carrier's business and start to tell the drivers what to do and start to impose these types of fines that Barry's talking about then you expose yourself to a different uh type of liability which is what we call joint employer liability where now you're you're involved in that motor carriers and that driver's business so much that you almost become an employer of that driver just as the motor carrier and so now you're liable but you're under you're liable under a different Theory which is the same theory that the motor carrier itself is liable on so you've got to kind of balance that scale and find and find kind of that that right balance for sure so I guess that kind of leads to the the the question the million dollar question which is what it exactly is the duty of the broker or the shipper uh in terms of selecting a safe carrier what do they have to do to prove that they've taken the steps that are necessary to to vet these motor carriers essentially well you know the answer to this and the answer is it defends it's all it's always the answer it's going to vary state to state so keep in mind negligence and negligence claims and the duty of care and how they interpret the duty of care will vary from state to state there's no federal negligence statute for lack of a better word and the duty of care that is looked at is what is reasonable for that broker and that'll that'll depend again on the state and other cases that have happened but in a nutshell you always kind of have this duty of reasonable care and the selection process has to be at least kind of on par with the industry uses so if you're just dialing random dot numbers and saying hey can you move this thing for me for 500 bucks and that's the extent of your research that's probably not going to be sufficient you need to whether I'm not going to give any legal advice here yeah but there is technologies that can give you information about a carrier and how they perform typically you can call references that's another way that people have done it for decades and decades and decades and you still can do that but that's a really good question it's going to continue to evolve as technology becomes more ubiquitous in how we select trucking companies so I think this was the concern uh the prime concern with in the CH Robinson case was this potential for a patchwork of state laws on what exactly is the broker's Duty what what lengths do they have to go to to uh to vet a a motor carrier and and the idea or the argument was well the federal law steps in here and preempts this so we don't have to look at it on a state-by-state basis I could kind of see that but at the same time in my view the standard as it stands right now is is fairly uniform throughout the country because it seems like at least in my experience a lot of courts are kind of latching on to Prior CH Robinson cases the there's this case called the SRAM case this this was from a decade or so ago I think it was an out east but this was a federal court case where CH Robinson was implicated in a negligent selection type case and the question was posed what what Duty do Brokers have to vet the motor carriers that they put out on the road and the court in that case set out a pretty in my view easy to follow standard it was essentially what you said Matt check either subscribing to a service that does this for you that's frankly the easiest thing there are several Services out there now that do this for you if you're a broker but you could do this literally in 30 seconds yourself it's essentially the court said in that case you gotta check this motor care as DOT number make first of all make sure it has a valid DOT number second of all make sure that it has the proper Insurance on file for whatever Freight it's hauling and frankly if it doesn't have a Val if it has a active operating Authority it's going to have the right Insurance because otherwise they wouldn't have active Authority and then it's making sure that they are not subject to a an unsatisfactory say reading those are the three things that the court mentioned like I said you could check that within 30 seconds if you just type in the carriers DOT number on the dot website and then you're done I I haven't seen any Court in the country take it any further than that although you'll hear a lot of Brokers and shippers uh Express concern about oh we got to look at the carriers CSA scores and and get into the details about their out of service rates I don't think we're there yet I think you're right I think outline this it's if you were going to hire a contractor to go work in your parents house like what would the level of effort you would have in saying is this someone I want my parents house well you'd probably call them and say can I speak to you and just talk to you have insurance like can I can I see a copier Certificate of Insurance great um but it's it's not it is it is common sense to a certain extent but the liability you face on the other end if you don't do it right so if you're Outsourcing all of your compliance to some foreign area you don't have any control over that that's when liability comes knocking and especially if your motor cares are carrying you know statutory minimums you're going to get dragged into a lawsuit maybe you get it dismissed maybe a motion for summary judgment you get out of it but still it is expensive to litigate and win it's it's not cheap to do any of this stuff the other um the other factor that comes into play here is and um we haven't seen it really go anywhere yet but I'd be I will be interested to see if it gets any legs and that is uh and I don't know if you've you've seen any of this Matt but we've heard talk over the years about a national hiring standard that's the phrase that's used for this but it's essentially Federal legislation where some senators or or congress folks will pass a bill that kind of sets the standard for what Brokers and shippers have to do when vetting motor carriers so that we can potentially avoid this Patchwork of state laws where each state gets to decide what the what the standard is I think that's been proposed uh probably five or so times it hasn't gone anywhere yet so we're not there yet but that's one potential way we could do away with this concern about a patchwork of state laws I think and you still have intrastate drivers are going to have the recommendations and the rules about the state that they operate it will always be a patchwork everybody it will always be a password someday maybe not but this is this is the nature of training reputation it's this it's constant struggle between interstate and intrastate Commerce and whose laws apply it it it's an issue that crosses all kinds of issues including safety regulations um okay so uh if you're a carrier let's let's turn the tables here if you're a motor carrier Matt what what can or should you do to make yourself more attractive to Brokers and shippers that are looking at you for business I love this question and here's the answer safely deliver Freight on time and on damaged like you want to be attractive to a broker do your job safely do it on time and don't damage anything these are the the quintessential things that make good carriers great carriers is that consistency that level of communication I would lean on how much insurance you have I mean that's uh seriously I'd be like I carrying 10 million dollars I carry 10 million really okay and I got a five million umbrella we're ready to go um those are the things that I would look at but also what is the equipment that you're running I mean if you are a carrier you have extra trailing capacity that's really compelling for some of the Brokers out there so it's going to depend obviously that's the answer for everything but the simple blocking and tackling of delivering Freight safely on time and on damage is always going to be a winning recipe yeah it's all about reputation and uh you know the the those Brokers and those shippers experience with you and and you know as you said Matt just uh you know doing things the right way and uh delivering their Freight safely that that will go a long way and then obviously it doesn't hurt to um to make sure your DOT number is active in your operating Authority and that you have the right Insurance on file and you don't have an unsatisfactory safety rating those things would be attractive I think you're right I think you're right all right so um okay so that's a very high level look at broker liability at least the kind of negligent selection side of things I I did want to spend a minute to talk about a somewhat related uh issue that has come up recently and this is the idea of unauthorized brokerage or double brokerage we had one one individual on LinkedIn who asked us to weigh in on the legality of co-broken or double brokering I thought it was an interesting question we recently did a an article on this uh we we have a an ongoing um an ongoing segment on our website called compliance myths and we we tackled this issue of double brokering you hear a lot of folks in the industry up at Arms about double brokering I'm curious your thoughts on the topic Matt well just looking at co-brokering to begin with so co-brokering as far as I understand it is every party knows who's involved everybody knows the insurance that they have everybody has kind of agreed to this thing and where you have a double broken situations somebody doesn't know you did it and that's where the problem is is that we we in supply chain and and just safety generally we want to know who's touching our stuff we want to know what's happening down this process and one of the challenges of deregulation and again I I hate to go back to 1980 and say everything that we deal with today is based off of 1980 but to an extent and when you made it so that you could have everybody moving Freight the way that they do it's a highly fragmented business and because it's so fragmented you can infiltrate other ways to find ways around the regulatory Network like possibly like a dispatching company or something similar that touches the something but not necessarily the freight and so you don't have to want to be liable to create an insurance but that my opinion of this kind of stuff is if you're going to be in the brokering business of either drivers or a freight you probably ought to be regulated and you probably ought to be paying adequate amounts of insurance yeah and to your point Matt the other thing about deregulation is it made these issues primarily a private issue in other words the the government's not going to get uh all that involved although they still issue operating Authority Brokers still have to have operating Authority but I think the the thing that I always um bring up when when I hear Folks up in arms about double brokering is that's a private issue there you're not going to get any help from the FMCSA when it comes to double brokering it is not illegal per se to double broker loads as long as all of the brokers in that chain have the operating Authority that the FMCSA tells them they have to have then there's nothing illegal about that it's it's very well at breach of the contract that you have exactly exactly right yeah and so that that's your remedy is is to go after that first broker that you had the relationship with and but the 10 challenges maybe you don't even know what happened exactly until something catastrophic happens and then they say okay well let's let's see who we can tag and then you get the lawyers like like me and possibly you saying hey let's do some more due diligence into this particular organization but to your point this is a breach of the contract with the shipper and they're not going to be happy you did it yeah well that's not yeah obviously not to say that it's not a big problem it is a big problem it's going to cause it's going to cost you a lot of money potentially when there is an accident um but it's a it's a private issue that you have to take up with whoever it is in the chain that you have the relationship with so uh kind of similar on a somewhat related note so the FMCSA recently came out with a notice uh asking for comments from the public on so-called Freight agents uh and and dispatch Services as you mentioned Matt and um it seemed to me they were a little vague in their notice it seems to me like they're probably after uh dispatch services that are that are um you know trying to skirt the operating Authority requirement they're calling themselves A dispatch service or their work working for a particular shipper and they're avoiding having to go get operating Authority by claiming that their dispatch service so it looks to me like the agency is potentially going to be cutting down on that or trying to cut down on that by regulating it more closely is that your take on it yeah I mean dispatching companies are really interesting so the way I've I've heard them characterize and you know my familiarity is not super strong with that organization style but they will have access to a bunch of drivers and they're gonna the drivers are gonna get the deals with moving the freight but the dispatching company is going to help us schedule away they help with communication they're going to do some of the back office work just like you'd have with a dispatcher for a normal Trucking Company um they're just making sure things are moving but as they get more into what they do it begins to look a lot more like being a broker looks a lot more like being improved when it's all with a trucking company with a dispatcher as a central Hub and all the drivers underneath that same Authority that makes a lot of sense that same apparatus begins to shape up in the you know in the independent or a bunch of small companies and you start asking those questions like what are you yeah and why are you doing it I mean the thing that always amazed me is it doesn't take much to become an authorized broker you have to have you you file an application with the FMCSA and you have to have a bond I think it's 75 000 Bond on file and that's it and you got your broker Authority and you're good to go so not a lot that goes into it so getting that Authority is not that burdensome uh Barry here has another comment let's see what he's got to say also on the FMCSA safer site if you want to get in depth you can click on and see every violation the carrier has had and which truck got what violation by their license plate number um and see who's hauling load then simply go the safer site see if the vehicle has had a violation within the last six months or I believe two years yeah I mean that's exactly right the safer site you can get as deep as you want to get if you're a broker or Carrier when you're vetting the motor carriers um again not legal advice from either me or Matt here but my concern is kind of that Balancing Act again because you know you go to the safer site you see what you see see that they got an active DOT number and and that they don't have an unsatisfactory safety rating and so you've kind of met that standard that the courts have set to date but then you go to the next step and now you're starting to dig into the specific violations and you're starting to call the Carrier and say hey I saw this driver had a violation can you work with them to deal with those issues then you're starting to push yourself more towards that joint employment exposure which I worry about on the other side of things so you have to figure out what what the right balance is and in my view you just got to document what your protocol is going to be for selecting motor carriers and stick to it what I'd also mentioned is very brought that up is a lot of this data that people are paying subscription services for so there's software you can subscribe to that just synthesizes the federal motor Cara State Administration data you can do this stuff without having to pay those fees because it's all there and I still think to your point like you still call them you still talk with them you have to say well I saw you online it's got to be fine and you know everybody's going to have safety violations when it comes to fmcs one of the things we talk about um is like break safety week or International Road check you see numbers that are just staggering 12 15 20 of vehicles inspected are unsafe and they're not out of service this is the nature of our supply web this is how it works most people do not maintain their assets the way they're supposed to yeah significant portion that should concern everybody do not yeah exactly and I think the good thing is because if I'm a shipper or a broker I'm asking myself well where do I draw the line I look online I see all these maintenance violations but everybody's got maintenance violations so how do I know what's good or bad and so the thing I'll mention is that the dot sets metrics for these types of things they set the national average so if you get on the safer website you could see what a particular motor carrier's vehicle out of service rate is as compared to the national average and if they're doing better than the national average then you've got an argument at least that they're doing better than average I don't know if that's the argument I'd want to hang my hat on but uh but at least it's something absolutely absolutely all right Matt we're running out of time really appreciate you joining me I think it was a great conversation to kind of uh talk about these these exposures to Brokers so thanks for so much for joining me um and hopefully we'll have you on again soon where can people find you again if they're looking for you well they can find me here talking to you which is fantastic yeah right now you can find me you can find me on LinkedIn you can find me I think I'm on Facebook still attack our chair Addie at why why because Atty is the abbreviation for the word attorney and I am excited I talk about all sorts of things like non-competition agreements post-employment restrictive covenants and I want to make you a better negotiator everybody I want you all to be better negotiators you also talk about Lord of the Rings I should have mentioned this earlier that was one of my favorite shows of yours you've spent a whole episode just talking about the rings of power show oh it is I want to like it oh my gosh Brandon I want you don't like it I thought episode four kind of redeemed the show it it happened sitting it is immediately overcome I'm locked in the cell I'm in the late oh there's a giant snow cave troll oh it's that pretty Monster don't worry we moved past it it's done we're done we're gonna swim back to from uh Fallon or to yeah well hey if uh yeah my point is if if you like that type of content Matt offers that as well so check out absolutely all right Matt appreciate it thanks for joining me all right that's going to wrap things up for this show um appreciate everybody tuning in today um again go to trucksafe.com if you're interested in learning more about these types of topics again we've got a bunch of articles on broker liability just to name one topic that we that we've recently addressed uh we also have that detailed article on that ELD uh rule making uh the advanced notes that propose rulemaking so check that out also be sure to follow us on social media we are on LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Youtube uh and Tick Tock um if you want to follow us on any of those channels we're constantly pushing out uh breaking regulatory news and our analysis of it the last thing I want to mention is something new we are launching which is our truck safe compliance boot camp and I'm going to roll a video here about it so you can check it out hey everyone Brandon here with truck safe Consulting I wanted to take a second to tell you about our Fleet compliance boot camp an immersive two-day conference that we hold in person twice a year this boot camp is designed to equip a small group of trucking professionals whether it's an owner safety team member dispatcher risk advisor or otherwise with the knowledge and tools they need to develop and maintain a Cutting Edge safety program at their Fleet this isn't your typical conference where you take some notes and try to implement what you learned back home boot camp is comprised of a discreet and intensive sessions targeted at Key areas of DOT compliance where attendees not only receive industry-leading educational content from industry experts but more importantly get Hands-On and participate in specially developed exercises like driver log audits accident simulations driver qualification reviews and more all to help equip them to apply these lessons at their own fleets we hold two boot camps each year one in Indianapolis and the other in Orlando and with cap attendance at 25 so that we can offer more personalized instruction and assistance and to facilitate more collaboration among our attendees in addition to the main event we also offer an optional half-day master class which we limit to five attendees for an even more in-depth experience all boot camp attendees receive top of the line compliance related content like detailed topic outlines workbooks a full library of DOT compliance forms and more to kick-start their compliance back home the fleet compliance bootcamp is ideal for folks just getting into Trucking and also those who play a role in an existing carrier's dot safety and compliance program our goal is to help demystify dot safety regulations and help folks Implement robust safety programs to keep them compliant and out of the crosshairs we hope to see at one of our upcoming events check out the details and register online at trucksafebootcamp.com thanks for watching all right so that's gonna wrap up the show appreciate you all joining us uh tune in next month for our next show again we do these monthly uh you can check out the details add it to your calendar at trucksafelive.com see you later

Event Completed

Wednesday, September 21, 2022 at 4:23 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube