Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 15 - Anatomy of a CMV Accident

Thursday, November 17, 2022 at 4:33 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 15 - Anatomy of a CMV Accident

About This Event

This month, we're joined by Jess Stenzel of PayneWest Insurance and Brendan Morse of ARCCA to discuss the anatomy of a commercial vehicle accident, including what steps fleets and drivers should take immediately following such an accident to best protect themselves and preserve the evidence.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

Episode 15 of Trucksafe LIVE! focuses on the anatomy of a commercial motor vehicle accident, walking fleet owners, safety directors, and drivers through the critical steps that should be taken before, during, and after a CMV accident. Hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by Jess Stenzel of PayneWest Insurance and Brendan Morris, Vice President and Director of Accident Reconstruction at ARCCA. The conversation is framed around a sobering statistical backdrop: fatality accidents involving large trucks increased 47 percent between 2009 and 2019, with preliminary 2021 data suggesting a further 13 percent rise. Average verdict sizes in trucking litigation are up over 50 percent in the past decade, making proactive accident response a financial and operational imperative for motor carriers of all sizes. The guests and hosts emphasize that preparation before an accident occurs is just as important as the response itself. A key recommendation is placing a laminated accident checklist in every cab, guiding drivers through the who, what, where, when, and why of an incident at a moment when adrenaline and stress can cause critical details to be overlooked. Brendan Morris stresses that from an accident reconstruction standpoint, drivers should set the parking brake, turn off the ignition, and remove the keys immediately following an accident, as doing so preserves valuable electronic data stored in the engine control module and other onboard systems. Moving the vehicle or restarting the ignition before these steps are taken can permanently erase data that might otherwise prove essential to a carrier's defense. The discussion covers post-accident DOT obligations in detail, including the regulatory requirements for drug and alcohol testing following certain types of accidents. Jess Stenzel outlines the three triggering conditions for mandatory DOT post-accident testing, summarized as fatality, medical transport with driver citation, and tow-away with driver citation. The hosts note that carriers unable to complete testing within the required time frames of eight hours for alcohol and 32 hours for controlled substances must document the reasons every two hours. The group also addresses a common practical challenge: some testing facilities are not equipped to administer blood alcohol tests, and in remote areas accessing a collection site within the required window can be extremely difficult. The hosts clarify that a blood or breath test administered by law enforcement can satisfy the carrier's post-accident testing obligation, provided the employer obtains a copy of the results. On the topic of evidence preservation, both guests underscore the importance of prompt notification to insurers, thorough scene photography, and an understanding of onboard data systems before an accident ever happens. Morris warns that some dash camera systems only retain video footage for a short window before converting it to still frames, meaning a carrier that waits even a week to retrieve footage may lose critical video evidence. Stenzel adds that back-office documentation, including driver qualification files, vehicle maintenance records, prior drug and alcohol test results, and inspection logs, will all be subject to discovery if litigation follows. The hosts reinforce that legal counsel should be engaged promptly following any serious accident, ideally at the same time as the insurance claim is initiated, rather than waiting to see whether the matter escalates. Fleet safety professionals walking away from this episode are encouraged to review and update their accident response checklists, ensure all drivers are trained on those procedures through regular safety meetings rather than simply placing the form in the glove box, audit their telematics and dash camera systems to understand exactly what data is captured and for how long, and establish a clear internal protocol for notifying their insurer and legal counsel following an accident. The overarching message from the panel is that the fleets best positioned to defend themselves in litigation and regulatory scrutiny are those that treat accident preparedness as an ongoing operational priority rather than an afterthought.

Full Transcript

foreign foreign thank you foreign foreign foreign foreign foreign foreign this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign welcome to episode 15 of truck safe live the monthly show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon truck safe and Childers law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs uh Today's Show we're talking about the anatomy of a commercial motor vehicle accident um pretty popular topic judging by the comments and and the viewers that we've got thus far it's it's an important one obviously but it's uh it's one that nobody really wants to think about until until it happens but we have to think about it because there are a lot of things involved there are a lot of things to think about that you really need to get a handle on before it actually happens so that you're not scrambling when the time comes so that's what we're going to break down in this show I'm excited to uh to bring on some guests to talk about it with us uh before we do that just wanted to hit on some things that are going on in the industry and at truck safe before we get to the main topic also if you're here with us live uh say hey in the comments and certainly as we go along if you have any questions or thoughts on the topic feel free to drop them into the con into the uh into the comments and we'll get to them as we go all right so in terms of things going on in the industry uh FMCSA specifically um you've probably heard by now the uh the U.S Senate has confirmed finally Robin Hutchinson is the next next administrator for the FMCSA it's been a long time in the making she served as Deputy Administrator for the last several months and finally Senate confirmed her as the official administrator of FMCSA first time in I think four years that we've had an actual administrator for the agency which hopefully will um uh hopefully will bring some stability and we've kind of already seen that so we uh we have seen a lot of regulatory developments even over the last couple of months or so um and so I think we'll continue to see that here with uh with Hutchinson recently confirmed so uh also in terms of recent regulatory developments just yesterday uh November 16th FMCSA published a what it's calling interim guidance it occasionally does this so aside from its rule making activity that it does it also occasionally weighs in with what it calls guidance on certain topics which it says does doesn't have the force and effect of law it's just the agency kind of giving its interpretation of how it views certain regulations or statutes it did that yesterday on the issue of Brokers property Brokers so we've done a couple of shows on this topic the agency back in June published a request for comments out to the public requesting public input on whether the definitions the regulatory definitions of broker and bona fide agents are are clear enough and whether the agency needs to step in and weigh in on on so-called dispatch services and whether in certain situations dispatch Services need to get broker Authority or not and so public weighed in there were several comments submitted and so the agency viewed those comments and then came out with the guidance that it published yesterday um essentially where it lands we did a whole article on this um on our website if you want to check that out do so we we kind of broke broke down the guidance in detail but essentially um the agency is clarifying the various factors that weigh in favor of dispatch Services either requiring broker Authority or not it's essentially it comes down to two things are those dispatch Services handling Financial aspects of the transactions that they're dealing with between shippers and and the motor carriers that they represent and are they allocating Freight between two or more carriers as opposed to just working for a single carrier if those two things are present then according to the fmcsa's guidance it's going to be more likely than not that those are actually Brokers and require broker Authority which you know frankly um it doesn't take much to get broker Authority you got to have a 75 000 Bond and you got to file an application with the agency but other than that um it's it's not that big of a deal to get broker Authority so I don't know why it's been um such an issue in the past but it has been so agency weighing in on it here um what else is going on so um the the FMCSA also issued some regulatory guidance on passenger carrier operations and the applicability of various components of their regulations to those types of operations um namely things like operating Authority when is passenger carrier operating Authority required when is uh when and at what levels of insurance do those types of operations have to have and then also applicability of of the safety regulations it was a pretty lengthy guy I think it was 56 Pages or so of guidance getting into the nitty-gritty of like uh what is interstate commerce when is a passenger carrier involved in interstate Commerce and not it gave several examples especially kind of around the idea of Passenger carriers meeting passengers at an airport that had just flown in from out of state and then moving those passengers to places within the same state whether that qualifies as interstate commerce so pretty interesting guidance we're going to put an article out about that here in the near future so be on the lookout for that so that's kind of the industry news got a couple of things going on a truck safe if you haven't already checked it out be sure to check out the truck safe compliance Network at trucksafenetwork.com we also have an app here we're showing in the App Store and also the Google Play Store this is a social network that we developed for safety professionals Motor Carrier owners safety directors safety managers risk advisors those types of folks to to really be able to network with one another and to learn from one another and so we've got the network and then also through the network we we provide a lot of network exclusive content so we're doing monthly webinars on compliance related topics so be sure you check it out again trucksafenetwork.com it's free to join um so so we look forward to seeing you there the other thing I'll mention before we we turned to the topic of today is our Fleet compliance boot camp this is uh we're excited to uh to have coming up our first ever truck safe compliance boot camp next April in downtown Indianapolis this is going to be an immersive two-day in-person conference again for Trucking Company owners safety professionals risk advisors to really gather together and learn what it takes to develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety and compliance programs uh we think it's going to be a one of a kind opportunity for for Fleet Safety folks to network and learn from industry experts we're going to have a lot of guests come in and and give presentations and uh and really work to develop your compliance program we're going to limit registration to 25 individuals so we can devote more time to working to understand and helping helping the attendees really improve their compliance programs specifically so if you're interested seats are going to fill up fast I think so be sure to register we're actually doing a um a promotion um through the end of November so if you're interested be sure to type in the coupon code trucksafe live if you go and and register uh it's trucksafebootcamp.com if you type in truck safe live coupon code you'll get 20 off registration so hope to see you guys there again that's truck safe bootcamp.com okay so enough about us enough about what's going on in the industry let's turn to the topic of today so all right so as I said today we're going to break down the anatomy of a commercial motor vehicle accident according to data from FMCSA the number of fatality accidents involving a large truck or bus actually decreased by 34 percent from 2005 through 2019 um or 2005 through 2009 sorry for that but then after 2009 we've actually seen a a 47 percent increase from 2009 through 2019 in those types of accidents again those involving a fatality and according to the national highway traffic safety administration preliminary data from 2021 shows that we're going to have another uh 13 increase from 2020 to 2021 in those accidents so trending in the wrong direction obviously these accidents are contributing to huge upticks in lawsuits and resulting in in big settlements and multi-million dollar verdicts the American Transportation Research Institute reports average verdict sizes are up over 50 percent over the past decade and the number of verdicts in excess of 10 million dollars continues to rise so this in turn is causing a lot of problems uh primarily increased insurance premiums for motor carriers so there are certainly big Stakes here no one wants to think about these things as I said earlier unfortunately until until it's uh until it's upon them but that's what we wanted to spend today doing is really kind of breaking it down and what fleets and drivers really need to be thinking about when they're involved in these accidents to get ahead of the game here and so you're not scrambling to find answers after the fact so I'm excited to be joined today by a couple of folks who are very very deeply involved in this topic first up is Jess stenzel with paynewest insurance and the second is Brendan Morse uh vice president and director of accident reconstruction for arcca so welcome guys thanks for joining me thanks for having us on Brandon hey no worries really appreciate you joining us um before we get started wanted to uh do some introductions here maybe give us a uh an idea of uh who you are who you work for and and how you got involved in the industry so Jess you want to kick us off yeah yeah some Jess stenzel from Great Falls Montana I work with uh Payton West Insurance in the transportation specialty practice so started out in the oil and gas industry got a petroleum engineering degree from uh Montana Tech and enjoyed the work but was looking for uh you know more of an advisement role of clients so uh made the switch to uh to insurance and then uh really got involved in the trucking space and and realized all the issues that uh the carriers are forced with around compliance safety and uh how integrated those issues are with their insurance programs so I feel very fortunate to be surrounded by uh by a strong team and then uh you know a good agency where we can deploy resources to help carriers um Drive their safety culture in and improve their performance as well so excellent well thanks for being with us again Brandon yeah my name is Brendan Morris obviously I have been in this industry for 12 years now I started as a undergraduate in mechanical engineering at Kettering University did accident reconstruction actually told myself I was never going to do it for career just didn't like it at the time I went on to graduate school for biomedical engineering and biomechanics specifically and ultimately just fell into this job my advisor my my boss now or the CEO of the company had the same advisor that I did in grad school and I kind of fell into this and I've you know enjoyed it and stuck with it for the last 12 years now excellent somebody's dog's not happy that's all right okay so again as you heard at the start today we're talking about CMV accidents commercial motor vehicle accidents and the things that fleets and drivers should be doing immediately following those accidents to that point I wanted to first ask you both if there's some kind of a threshold you all use for accident seriousness that kind of changes your recommend amended approach in other words are there different levels of seriousness that warrant different action I assume there is I'm just curious to hear your thoughts on it Jess you want to kick us off yeah so I think that definitely there's a different levels of seriousness to each accident in each each accident is unique each accident is different I think the biggest thing you can do is just evaluate what's going on at hand where right now we've got winter conditions icy roads and Montana so if you've got a truck and trailer jack knifed across two lanes of Interstate then uh first thing you're going to want to do is get the highway patrol on the scene and get the get the scene secured where otherwise if you're let's say you're a Hazmat hauler and you're you're hauling uh a tanker trailer that is upset and overturned and there's a potential spill that's gonna it's gonna warrant different actions as far as people you need to call and and steps that need to be taken to where you're you're taking the right steps to address the situation at hand and I think really uh it's important for for drivers and and carriers to work with our drivers to have some level of preparation where when they do go through the trauma of being involved in an accident that they've got uh got some training that they can rely on and they're not just trying to think on their toes and and and shoot from the hip going through the situation and and how to properly respond now Brendan same question to you are there different levels of of accidents you know I can imagine that it's going to be the more serious ones where you all get called in that's correct usually it's more serious but I mean we've been involved on ones that you would probably Define as less serious as well but from our perspective we're looking for the same thing we want as much evidence and as much data from all levels of incident you know whether that's photographs or whatever it may be we we treat it as we want every piece of data that we can get to evaluate it and I think that's a trick at least in my experience I'm you never really know when a particular accident is going to explode into something bigger I've seen uh personally been involved in accidents where it looked like there was virtually no damage to the to the involved Vehicles whatsoever and in that case uh you know just explodes into a potential multi-million dollar case because of the injuries involved so do you do you all have any advice on on what we should be doing so I I guess the question is you know and just kind of get into this but got into this a little bit but you know drivers involved in an accident we don't necessarily know how serious it is at this moment What's the very first step that the driver and then his or her employer need to start thinking about once uh once that happens so like I said I would uh I think the most important steps to definitely secure the accident and it's whether you get involved in a fender bender is going to be different than if you're involved in you know in a in a high-speed accident with multiple vehicles but but getting as much information on it as as soon as you can in communicating that uh that plan through your safety director and your drivers where everybody's on the same page as far as the the next steps that need to be taken in in the in information that's going to be important in the the details of the accident where you're not left uh you know days or weeks down the road trying to trying to gather evidence and build a defensible file but you you have good policies and procedures in place that uh you know one thing is an accident reporting form is the best thing that every driver should have in the cabin the truck that's going to guide the driver through basic details of the accident and basic details that need they need to collect another really important thing that that is picking up and getting a lot of steam in the industry is dash cams which can be the the best form of evidence that you can that you can use to defend yourself and really get down to the facts of actually what happened in the accident yeah I think you mentioned the kind of the accident checklist in the cab I think that's critically important because I've seen it come up you know a driver gets involved in an accident sometimes they're they're in shock from that accident they don't know what to do exactly and if you can you know ease the burden on them as as much as you can in that situation give them a step-by-step here's here's the things to follow I think that's the best thing to do I think in our when we published this show we had some commenters say that they're starting to print these out on a sticker that then they can put in the in the visor and the trucks to make it even that much easier for drivers to understand exactly what they need to do when this time comes Brendan do you have any thoughts on kind of first steps for drivers and for their employers yeah I agree with the having a checklist I mean no matter how serious the incident is if you're in a parking lot or if you're on the highway going 60. you want to go through those same steps just to make it repeatable make it make sure you've checked your boxes from my perspective if I could in every ideal situation it would be to pull the parking brake turn the ignition off pull the keys out of the truck that saves any electronic data that could be on that truck at that time and then obviously report it to the office or if your owner operator report it to whatever entities you need to if you have the dash cam get that data immediately if it's streaming to a cloud or wherever it's going just get it done get it collected ASAP yeah Brennan's asking uh or he's he's asking about an accident reporting form I think Jess had mentioned it Jess is there a particular form you have in mind or is that kind of the checklist we're talking about exactly an accident checklist going through who what where when why of the accident you know like you said involved in an accident your adrenaline's running you're you're stressed out and it can be easy to miss details so having some form of structure that you can fall back on as far as Gathering the the details that are going to make the biggest difference yeah I know from a DOT compliance side of things the dot does not require motor carriers or their drivers to actually report any accidents some states may have that requirement I know there are certain states that say if you're involved in a commercial vehicle accident that usually it's going to be the fatality accidents then those have to be reported and then I think Brandon had mentioned earlier Hazmat carriers they have different obligations of when they have to actually report uh certain spills and unintentional releases and stuff like that but uh yeah I think in terms of an actual checklist of things to do I think that's kind of the key there Jess kind of looking at this from an Insurance perspective when in the process after the accident would you like your insured carriers to notify you about the accident uh as soon as possible honestly it's we've gone through both ways where if you get a timely report a claim and not only just having an accident checklist in the jockey box that you hand out to each driver but given it and then let's say you have a monthly safety meeting where you run through some hypotheticals and it's it's different when you actually can walk through the checklist and see why each bit of required information or a bit of information is uh is important versus having it getting all dusty in the jockey box and then two years later you're trying to break it out and make sense of it so but uh we want to be notified as soon as possible the the quicker you can start the claim investigation process and begin Gathering details and gather as much information as possible as as the best thing you can do to protect yourself versus your five or six days down the road and essentially the you know people have scattered from the scene of the incident and you're trying to put together statements and details of the incident which is which is much tougher than getting it done up from yeah so what is the information that you're gonna um you're gonna need what's the basic information that you're going to need from uh from the carrier from your insured when they call and notify you of an accident so definitely the driver involved you know the vehicle involved trailer involved uh which direction you were headed which you know which road you were on uh if you can get pictures of the accident I don't think you can take too many pictures and it doesn't need to be necessarily close-up pictures of the damage but if you can get pictures of you know which of where the accident happened which way you were coming which way the the other involved vehicle was was coming any applicable road signs um get a police report get the police report number as as much information as you can get in that in that first report Tom is asking is the checklist more specific uh based on the type of carrier tank versus flatbed Brandon do you have any thoughts on are there different things that you uh would would recommend to carriers based on their type of operation that they include in that checklist of things to do immediately after an accident for myself and what I'm looking for no I wouldn't I would just it everything document everything that you possibly can like Jess was saying about photographs digital memory is fairly cheap these days cell phones are pretty good focusing on the damage just to the truck or just to maybe the other vehicle without stepping back step take 20 steps back and capture all that but as far as the checklist no I would just document everything uh even whether it's a tank or a flatbed I I want to know what the brakes are like I want to know what the Retro reflective tape was or all the setups on any just the same yeah no good I was going to say on Tom's question that uh you can get a base checklist that's that's very genetic that has uh a lot of the things that we talked about as far as who was involved you know the plates of the other vehicle involved your truck and trailer but you could take a checklist and review it with your team and make it more specific to to your operations that way it uh it's geared more towards uh you know Gathering the right details that are specific to to whatever you're doing yeah Mike's asking a good question here and this is what I was going to mention you know what caution can you provide regarding your photos you know I've heard I've heard mixed things about uh photograph uh you know photographs of the scene and how specific you should get with those photos and showing injuries and and potentially fatalities and how close up to get with the details and stuff like that I think the consensus overall at least on the litigation side of things is that photos are good but then I think the the you know thoughts start to diverge when you talk about what type of detail you want in those photos so do you all have any thoughts on that in terms of are there any uh words of caution to motor carriers and their drivers when it comes to taking photographs of the scene uh from Lost Jess go ahead Brendan yeah from my perspective I don't really think so because I mostly want to know where the vehicles ended up what's the final rest location what does that damage look like that day of in case there's something that changes because the vehicles are towed or or anything that happens in transit um I don't know that there's anything necessarily detrimental also in a lot of these cases if it's a higher severity the law enforcement is going to have photographs as well or video as well especially in this day and age that it'll come out to some degree anyway yeah Jess do you have any thoughts on that kind of words of caution about the photographs taken at the scene I think that uh careful with your photos as far as pictures of any injuries or whatnot you're going to want to steer away from that but uh as long as you're taking pictures of you know equipment uh location what not um you know I think you're good yeah so the interesting thing about photo another interesting thing um about photographs we did a show early on on trucksafe live about the the uptick in nuclear verdicts and about various states starting to look at tort reform to try and uh to try and kind of curb these nuclear verdicts and we talked with John Esparza from the Texas Trucking Association who at the time we did the show was in the midst of trying to get their uh uh House Bill 19 is that right house bill 19 passed which would uh which was eventually passed and made some significant changes in the state of Texas one of which and I didn't realize that this was the case and apparently it's the case in in other states um state courts wouldn't even allow for the admissibility of certain accidents scene photographs and so one of the things that that Texas did in that tort reform was to allow for the introduction of those photos because what we were having is you know the motor carrier would have photograph evidence that would suggest if I'm a jury member looking at the photograph you could see the relative um you know I don't want to say that it wasn't a I guess I would say relative um seriousness of the accident so you may see a photograph where the damage to the truck into the passenger vehicle didn't look that substantial even though the the plaintiff is claiming injuries and so that wasn't admissible in Texas but now with the house bill 19 that has changed so I thought that was something interesting uh we've got a lot of comments here let's see what else we've got Brendan says but it's not my fault why do I need to report it to Jess yeah well uh there's definitely been uh some not at fault accidents that have still resulted in some pretty significant damages so I think you're better off always to report it and uh and have documentation of the claim and then as you learn the details of it you know it it will iron out rather than you fail to report a claim and find out weeks or months later that uh the other involved vehicle is has already retained an attorney and is going to going to pursue litigations it's crazy we've seen some of these cases some of these nuclear verdict cases which end up with multi-million dollar jury verdicts against the trucking company in cases where it very clearly wasn't even the driver's fault there's nothing the driver could have done to to have prevented the accident and yet the trucking company gets tagged with the multi-million dollar verdict so I think for that reason alone to your point Jess it's important that you get in early contact with your insurance company to make them aware because they're going to want to take steps to best protect you in the context of the of that accident Brendan any thoughts on that yeah that's exactly it I mean if you don't consider it your fault you're probably getting rid of evidence immediately you're not going to take photographs you're going to lose any electronic data you might not save a dash camera video all of which made just 100 approve that you were in the right um so I wouldn't dismiss it just on your own just still collect that data but maybe you file it away where it's saved and you think about it less than you would as a more major incident yeah and putting aside Insurance you know from a DOT perspective kind of the world I live in you know historically dot hasn't really cared whether it was your driver's fault or not if your driver was involved in a DOT recordable accident whether it was his fault or not it still impacted your scores as a motor carrier still influenced your your crash indicator score it still influenced your uh your accident rate but now more recently the OT FMCSA has come out with its crash preventability demonstration program where carriers can actually go in and and challenge the preventability of the accident and so to your guys's point you know if if we don't take steps immediately after the accident to preserve the evidence that we need to prove that our driver wasn't at fault then we really have no chance at getting those you know again from a DOT perspective getting those taken off our score so it's it's important for a number of reasons obviously Tom here is asking what are your thoughts on collecting exoneration cards at the scene of the accident Jess do you have any thoughts on that exoneration cards yeah I assume what Tom is mentioning uh is is some kind of statements uh maybe from the other party saying hey you know it was my fault that this accident happened or something to that effect I think uh yeah as much as much other you know witness statements that you can get and uh I don't think that it'll hurt as far as as the driver I would refrain from uh from signing anything unless it's reviewed with your attorney but uh but an exoneration card if you have somebody who's willing to admit fault on it and provide a written testimony of that I don't I don't see a problem with that Brendan any thoughts on that I'm usually getting it later in the process than Jess is obviously so any any description that I can get is is great though because when you're at the scene obviously it's the most fresh and you're writing it down you're maybe still looking at the vehicles you're still looking at everything that happened so that's great for me to have the that detail because sometimes extra details come out of things like that right there right there I mean from the litigation standpoint I'm not a litigator so I'm probably the worst lawyer in the world to be asking this question but uh um I can Envision that you know if you certainly if you can get somebody to make an admission uh at the scene of the accident you're going to be better off for it but I don't know that I you would you could rely on that certainly again this kind of goes back to the issue with you've just been involved in a serious accident maybe you're in shock maybe you're not even thinking straight so you know there's I could I can Envision a potential argument by plaintiff's attorney in that case that hey my client signed and said that it was their fault but they weren't thinking straight because they just you know it was trauma at that point so you know again to your guys's point I think getting witness statements is is important if you get somebody to admit to it being their fault and well then you know you're better off for it but certainly probably not re all that reliable Steve says as a checklist item number one I recommend getting the truck and trailer completely off the travel portion of the roadway to avoid secondary accidents yeah this is something I wanted to ask you guys about because I've heard mixed things about this as well do we move the vehicle as soon as it happens uh as soon as the accident happens so that we can avoid these types of secondary accidents Brendan go for it as far as the data goes like I said earlier I would say no I don't want to but I understand the circumstances that require it the quicker you can set the parking brake turn the ignition off pull the key the better opportunity you have for more data that may be changing in the future that is currently where we're at this industry is consolidating when it comes to accident data it appears like the passenger vehicle industry did in the mid to late 2000s so um I understand it I understand why you want to get them off-road and law enforcement may require it but in some instances you may be overriding or erasing data by doing so are so to make sure I've got that straight up would you be more comfortable with them moving the vehicle if they've taken first taken those steps that you've mentioned which are to set the parking brake turn off the ignition and then if if they need to move it then they can do that do you get better data if they follow that process before they then just move the vehicle off the off to the side yeah I mean if it's towed off to the side of the road absolutely when that ignition is turned off it's not recording anything it doesn't have power to do so so that's essentially Frozen everything for Last Stop data specifically is what what I'm referring to okay so if the driver then turns it back on then it doesn't really help you at that point exactly we see tow truck companies law enforcement uh whoever trying to just check on you know the truck doesn't have power can I move it and it'll erase that data yeah Jess any thoughts on this yeah I was going to say the same as far as from uh from Brennan's point of view you'd be better off to leave the scene as it was but obviously if they're still still traffic trying to move by or uh you know like we said earlier if it's if it's icy and it's white out conditions and your your sideways in the middle of the road try to get get off to the side and get in a in a safer position where you're not going to cause you know further accidents or further uh injuries yeah Rob says I'm I'm historically collected exoneration cards but I've always stressed to my drivers that if it's your fault it's your fault don't sign anything acknowledging that but don't get that exoneration card out I think that's right I um you know a lot of common sense goes a long way here um signing something that says it was my fault is probably never a good idea um so yeah I would avoid that um let's see here Daniel's saying we have an issue with a post-accident drug testing especially the um the the bat the blood alcohol test and getting test in required time frames two to eight hours many Test Facilities don't do that type of test so this is something we haven't even really got into but the kind of the D.O.T obligations post accident um namely drug and alcohol testing so um you know Jess do you have any thoughts on kind of dealing with that issue where hey Art we have a CDL driver who's been involved in a in an accident that requires post-accident testing but we're having trouble getting somebody out to test them yeah so first of all there's three legal reasons for a for a DOT drug and alcohol test and the way I remember it is Nurse hearse until so nurse if uh if anybody is medically transported away from the scene of the accident and the driver was cited it's subject to a DOT drug Now call test purse if there was a fatality uh regardless of citation to the driver requires a drug now called test and then a tow away with uh with a citation issue to the driver has a requirement for a drug and alcohol test as well so uh I know you do you got that eight hours for uh for the alcohol test in 32 hours for the drug test which if you're tied down at the scene of the accident I know that can be tough to do whether they'll administer a BAC on location but for the drug test I just know if if you're unable to uh to get your test done in those uh time frames that you gotta you gotta document every two hours reasons why until essentially if you if you make it past that eight hours then the the reason for the test is yeah it's thrown out yeah this is a problem for virtually every Motor Carrier I've ever worked with we go in and we do mock dot audits where we're looking at all of the same things the dot would look at in the context of a real audit and this is one of them are you doing your post accident testing as required by the regulations meaning within the required time frames as you said Jess fortunately the regulations give us uh instructions on what to do when this happens when we are unable to get the drivers tested within those regulatory time frames and they say exactly what you said which is you have to document exactly why it was that you weren't able to get the drivers tested within those required time frames the problem is and I've seen this come up in real audits where you know you may have done that you may have documented exactly why you couldn't get the test done within those time frames maybe your driver didn't let you know that he or she was cited in one of those two instances that requires citation uh until after the time frames have passed or maybe you you're out in the middle of nowhere you can't get them to a testing site within those required time frames and the carrier goes ahead and prepares a detailed note and puts it in the file as to why that was the case and the dot still writes them up for missing the required test I've always taken the position that that's too aggressive of a an interpretation of the regulations and that the motor carrier has satisfied its obligations by documenting why they couldn't get the test done within the required time frames we've made that argument in a couple of appeals when it impacts the motor carrier safety rating um but it can be a problem if you've got an aggressive auditor despite your what appears to be you following the regulations Brendan here is saying does a law enforcement alcohol test qualify for DOT so I think it does Brendan um I think the regulations say that if you can't get your test done within the required time frame you can rely on a test administered by law enforcement don't quote me on that I'm fairly certain that's the case Jess do you have any idea on that one I've heard I've heard similar uh I've also heard that there's you know using the Law Enforcement test could be subject to some HIPAA violations I'm not absolutely confident on either way though so um I'm going to look that up but uh while I do so Brendan I got a question for you so in terms of accident reconstruction when is that necessary in your view can you kind of give us a feel for a win-win you should be called in to kind of kind of do that analysis sure excuse me anytime you want to know the answers as far as how fast the vehicle is going you know to collect the data obviously in a major accident the quicker I can get there the quicker I can give answers and it all starts with if you have a case send me the VIN number right away VIN number of the truck especially if it's a heavy truck that's what dictates what type of data I might be able to help you with it's not the label or the badge on the truck it's the internals what's the engine what is inside that truck and then I can give you an interpretation of what data we might get how important that's going to be for your specific case if you can give me some photos or a news article or something that tells us what's going on so I mean I get involved in everything where people think they have absolutely no fault and they want me to just collect the data in case something comes up later to the point of you know we have five vehicles in a fatality on the highway I can always collect data always collect evidence and just use it later if it needs to be used so Brennan what's that process like when you first get notified of an accident kind of walk us through what happens from that point sure um sometimes I'm notified day of I've had that before where I'm getting out of work and driving to a scene right away to collect all the evidence that I can and then sometimes it could even be a year later those ones are much more difficult um typically with the heavy vehicles semi trucks uh trailers not the box trucks as much because they kind of fall into um the mid-class class four or five vehicles um I'm involved within a week or two and so I collect that data I want scene evidence I'll wait and get all the police documents as much as I can for evidence there maybe other vehicles I'll access event data recorders or there if it's another semi-truck access that put that all together and then I'll discuss it with the client hey this is where things are and then from there you know if it goes to settlement if it goes to mediation or or to trial from there you can create animations you could issue a full report just depends on what is needed for that specific case yeah so I was going to ask you kind of what's the in in product look like so it sounds like it can differ depending on what the client's looking for yeah absolutely so sometimes it's just a simple verbal of this is what we got for data this is where we're at this is your position um sometimes it's immediately okay I want that but I want to report stating all that laying it all out for me and then if we're going to trial from there we can create animations with perspectives and use that data maybe it's you know dash camera data or or data from the engine control module whatever it might be to apply that all right I've got the answer to the question posed a minute ago let me bring this up uh so here's the regulation in terms of whether a um a law enforcement test can be used to satisfy motor carriers post accident testing obligations it says the result of a blood or breath test for the use of alcohol conducted by federal state or local law enforcement or Public Safety officials having independent Authority for the test shall be considered to meet the requirements of this section provided such tests conform to applicable testing requirements and that the results of the test are obtained by the employer so there's your answer if law enforcement conducts the test then the motor carrier can use that test to satisfy its post-accident testing obligations assuming you get a copy of it a couple other questions came in here Tom's asking how about dot accident reports and SMS that say unknown for driver citation issued is that ever problematic if litigated it's problematic for a couple of reasons including the post accident drug testing I've seen this come up with a lot of our carrier clients where it's not clear whether the driver was cited or not and maybe the driver is not telling you whether they received a citation and you log into SMS and it says unknown and so now you're left in kind of a limbo where you're not sure whether drug and alcohol testing was required because as Jess mentioned that's a component of two of the accident types and so you know the the thing you're up against as a motor carrier is it's a violation if you conduct these tests when you're not supposed to conduct the test and it's a violation if you don't conduct a test when when it's required so damned if you do damned if you don't and so uh yeah the fact that we don't have the information that we need to make that call is frustrating and then certainly if it's litigated hopefully by the time it's litigated you're going to know whether the driver was cited or not through the discovery process and stuff like that but it certainly could be an issue uh let's see here several other questions is there a correlation between the time a claim stays open and the ultimate cost of the claim Jess you want to take that yeah yeah well I would say definitely just in terms of if you want to get it closed out as quick as possible uh just even in defense costs where if you got a claim that's that's open you know it's it's being drawn out there's there's more resources and investment being made into that claim that yeah it's ultimately going to have an impact on on the total claim value so another reason why it's important to to gather as much information as you can try to try to nurture it along get it closed out as soon as possible Brendan what's been your experience with that yeah I mean from my perspective once I collect the information I'm just letting it sit so um the longer it goes obviously we just hold the data from our perspective so it doesn't add costs for us to do any additional analysis later as long as we've got the front end of collecting the scene evidence properly and collected you know the vehicle evidence and the whatever data comes with that it doesn't add a cost for for us so I had a curious uh question come up that and I'm wondering if if you all have had any experience with this you know what what shouldn't drivers do at the scene of the accident have you all ever seen any kind of crazy things that drivers have done that you uh wished had not had happened leave don't leave don't panic um yeah I mean there's we cut we covered a lot of the basics and I think those are really the important uh must to to appropriately handling what to do after the scene of an accident but um I would say be courteous you know just uh once emergency Personnel show up uh you know be courteous to them be respectful Brendan yeah I would say it's you know similar along those lines um just it's an accident you know or a traumatic event for people so responses might be you know different depending on who you are and how you react to those things but if you have to move the vehicles I mean you have to some cases you know like we said the weather not causing other incidents maybe law enforcement moves it but other than that uh try and try not to do that or try to document it at the very least before it gets done if you can yeah yeah I think leaving the scene is is probably one of the worst things you could do I mean uh you know looking at it strictly from a DOT perspective that that gets you in a lot of trouble that disqualifies you if you're a commercial driver and you leave the scene of an accident and you're convicted of that that can disqualify you from operating a commercial motor vehicle going forward for a certain period of time so pretty serious consequences so don't do that um all right so we're running out of time here I got a few uh questions left we've hit on a lot of a lot of good information here um let's see here we've answered a lot of this what about you you know we've talked about the various types of evidence that in your view is crucial that we Preserve at the scene what about back office what about um records or data that the motor carriers may have at their back office what should they be thinking about in terms of preserving that um all things around uh the compliance that they should have on file for their driver qualification files uh vehicle maintenance files related to the driver involved in the accident the vehicle involved in the accident uh because as soon as if it does pursue into litigation I've seen the procurement of information that comes from the plan of attorney that wants everything under the sun essentially they want they want to know about the inquiries you made to uh to the referrals before you hired the driver they want to see the the past drug and alcohol test they want to see um uh proof of recent inspection on the truck that was involved in the accident so all of the all of the compliance matters that you you strive to stay on top of as a motor carrier that's uh that's evidence that is likely going to be a requested yeah driver logs for sure um you know as a service yeah depending on the serious no seriousness of the accident uh you may very well if you're the motor carrier get a litigation hold letter from opposing Council in that case fairly soon after the accident that's going to tell you exactly what they expect you to preserve and then at that point you have an obligation to hold that or else you're going to be potentially charged with some kind of exfoliation charge in the context of that litigation so uh Brendan any other thoughts on kind of back off of stuff that you always hope to see motorcar errors keep in the context of these accidents yeah I'm looking for inspection logs any any notes with regards to that and how the truck's maintained also we touched on a little bit earlier but these dash cameras and these Fleet Management systems and all that before you're ever in an accident understand how it works and understand how to access that data um you know sometimes dash cameras aren't working or it uploads to a cloud and they have no idea how to get it from a cloud or the video is gone after a certain amount of time and convert it to still frames yeah we were talking about that I I can't remember if it was before the show but in your experience there are some that that only hold the actual video data for a certain amount of time a short amount of time and then afterwards it converts it to to Stills that may not be as useful as that been your experience in one particular case yeah it's it streamed to a cloud and they thought it was great but it only saves that video for a week and after that week it converts every a few minutes to a still frame image of the trip so they had gotten to it a little over a week lost the video lost all that evidence which would have been fantastic in that case um so just understanding those systems in the back office to know how to get it where to get it what data is being tracked if you've added a system to the truck in particular and getting on that right away yeah this is something we've harped on uh in Prior shows we talk a lot about the data the significant influx of data that motor carriers have coming at them nowadays in what has historically been a pretty paper driven industry and a lot of The Fleets we work with just don't even realize what data is is coming in and what data they have uh you know filtering into their systems and so getting a handle on what data streams you have coming in and what you have access to is is a pretty fundamental thing that you need to do as a fleet early on right now you need to understand what data is coming in what data you're keeping how long you're keeping it how to access it all kind of being proactive not only just for accidents but also for for DOT audits employment type claims you know a lot of those involve uh working hours and having to get access to Driver's hours of service logs so just having a basic understanding of what data you have and how to access it is key in a lot of different areas I kind of want to wrap things up here guys with uh with one last question which is when in your view should carriers get legal counsel involved in the accidents and maybe it's some question more for Jess but um you know carrier's involved in an accident when should they engage legal counsel or when do you all recommend they engage legal counsel to start helping out with that depending on the severity of the claim I would say essentially immediately which they'll uh you know they're going to be working with the adjuster at the same time but um it really kind of depends on the accident at hand but if if the if the other involved party has retained counsel and uh and we haven't we haven't started making efforts to build the defensible file when things escalate it's uh it's better to be proactive in that measure yeah all right guys well we're about out of time here really appreciate you joining me it was a lot of uh information packed into that short amount of time a lot of great tips I want to give you guys the opportunity to let people know where they can find you how they can reach out uh so Jess you want to kick things off there yeah uh paynewest.com I'm on LinkedIn as well yeah any way you can get a hold of me can Google me find me easy enough Brendan hey I'm out in the Seattle office but you can reach me at arcaarcca.com or on LinkedIn um yeah there's several ways and anybody at our company can help you too if you find other people that are closer to your area yeah make sure you take these guys up on on their offer reach out to them if you have any questions more in-depth questions than uh obviously we only had 30 minutes to get into the topic not nearly enough time to get into the nitty-gritty so feel free to reach out to them they're more than willing to to answer questions or point you in the right direction so thanks again guys so much for uh for being with me today really appreciate your Insight on the topic so uh we'll we'll see you again soon hopefully all right so that's going to wrap up the show today I appreciate you joining us appreciate everyone who submitted comments uh if you have any other questions um if you don't reach out to those guys directly feel free to reach out to us over at trucksafe.com um one thing I'll mention is wrapping things up here today if you're not already subscribed to our newsletter be sure to do so you can go to trucksafe.com And subscribe or send out a periodic newsletter where we're highlighting all of the content that we're pushing out again a lot of DOT compliance content articles in-depth articles uh free videos that type of stuff so again check that out trucksafe.com also um be sure to check out our courses over at trucksafeacademy.com we we offer courses that are devoted to safety professionals so our safety manager course for example is really aimed at going through the nuts and bolts of DOT compliance and what it means to to effectively manage a DOT safety and compliance program we walk through driver qualification hours of service vehicle maintenance drug and alcohol testing all of these types of topics kind of looking at it from a regulatory perspective and so check those out if you're interested trucksafeacademy.com and then lastly just be sure to follow us on social media we're on Twitter LinkedIn Facebook and we post a lot of breaking news they're breaking industry news a lot of our again our content so so be sure to follow us there all right that's going to wrap it up stay tuned for our next episode next month trucksafelive.com for details thanks again to the sponsor of this season log Rock and thanks again to to our guests for this show so thanks everyone for watching foreign

Event Completed

Thursday, November 17, 2022 at 4:33 PM EST

Watch on YouTube