Episode Summary
Episode 15 of Trucksafe LIVE! focuses on the anatomy of a commercial motor vehicle accident, walking fleet owners, safety directors, and drivers through the critical steps that should be taken before, during, and after a CMV accident. Hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by Jess Stenzel of PayneWest Insurance and Brendan Morris, Vice President and Director of Accident Reconstruction at ARCCA. The conversation is framed around a sobering statistical backdrop: fatality accidents involving large trucks increased 47 percent between 2009 and 2019, with preliminary 2021 data suggesting a further 13 percent rise. Average verdict sizes in trucking litigation are up over 50 percent in the past decade, making proactive accident response a financial and operational imperative for motor carriers of all sizes.
The guests and hosts emphasize that preparation before an accident occurs is just as important as the response itself. A key recommendation is placing a laminated accident checklist in every cab, guiding drivers through the who, what, where, when, and why of an incident at a moment when adrenaline and stress can cause critical details to be overlooked. Brendan Morris stresses that from an accident reconstruction standpoint, drivers should set the parking brake, turn off the ignition, and remove the keys immediately following an accident, as doing so preserves valuable electronic data stored in the engine control module and other onboard systems. Moving the vehicle or restarting the ignition before these steps are taken can permanently erase data that might otherwise prove essential to a carrier's defense.
The discussion covers post-accident DOT obligations in detail, including the regulatory requirements for drug and alcohol testing following certain types of accidents. Jess Stenzel outlines the three triggering conditions for mandatory DOT post-accident testing, summarized as fatality, medical transport with driver citation, and tow-away with driver citation. The hosts note that carriers unable to complete testing within the required time frames of eight hours for alcohol and 32 hours for controlled substances must document the reasons every two hours. The group also addresses a common practical challenge: some testing facilities are not equipped to administer blood alcohol tests, and in remote areas accessing a collection site within the required window can be extremely difficult. The hosts clarify that a blood or breath test administered by law enforcement can satisfy the carrier's post-accident testing obligation, provided the employer obtains a copy of the results.
On the topic of evidence preservation, both guests underscore the importance of prompt notification to insurers, thorough scene photography, and an understanding of onboard data systems before an accident ever happens. Morris warns that some dash camera systems only retain video footage for a short window before converting it to still frames, meaning a carrier that waits even a week to retrieve footage may lose critical video evidence. Stenzel adds that back-office documentation, including driver qualification files, vehicle maintenance records, prior drug and alcohol test results, and inspection logs, will all be subject to discovery if litigation follows. The hosts reinforce that legal counsel should be engaged promptly following any serious accident, ideally at the same time as the insurance claim is initiated, rather than waiting to see whether the matter escalates.
Fleet safety professionals walking away from this episode are encouraged to review and update their accident response checklists, ensure all drivers are trained on those procedures through regular safety meetings rather than simply placing the form in the glove box, audit their telematics and dash camera systems to understand exactly what data is captured and for how long, and establish a clear internal protocol for notifying their insurer and legal counsel following an accident. The overarching message from the panel is that the fleets best positioned to defend themselves in litigation and regulatory scrutiny are those that treat accident preparedness as an ongoing operational priority rather than an afterthought.