Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 16 - Regulatory year in review and 2023 outlook

Tuesday, December 20, 2022 at 4:09 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 16 - Regulatory year in review and 2023 outlook

About This Event

With 2022 coming to a close, Brandon and Jerad will take a look back at the past year and highlight some of the biggest regulatory developments and trucking industry news. They'll also look forward to the new year and what's in store. Trucksafe Consulting, LLC is a full-service transportation safety consulting firm, offering one-on-one consulting services as well as industry-leading training resources and compliance forms. Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress, Trucksafe's owners, are transportation attorneys who have worked with the nation's largest and most sophisticated motor carriers on USDOT safety regulations. They focus their efforts on helping carriers develop and foster state-of-the-art safety programs. For help managing your DOT policies and procedures, mock DOT audits, safety rating upgrades, DataQs appeals, and much more, contact us through our website: https://www.trucksafe.com

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 16 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress of Trucksafe Consulting deliver a comprehensive regulatory year-in-review for 2022 and preview the key rulemaking activities expected in 2023. The episode is essential viewing for fleet safety professionals, as it covers a wide range of developments that directly affect how motor carriers hire drivers, manage compliance programs, and operate their fleets on a day-to-day basis. On the 2022 side, the hosts walk through several significant developments. The Safe Driver Apprenticeship Pilot Program, launched in January, opened the door for 18-to-20-year-old drivers to operate in interstate commerce, though participation has been limited due to the program's extensive requirements and potential insurance concerns. The Entry-Level Driver Training rule took effect in February, establishing a standardized curriculum for new CDL applicants and certain endorsement seekers, with the hosts noting that online training options exist at a fraction of the cost of traditional truck driving schools. The elimination of the annual Certificate of Violation requirement was highlighted as a welcome reduction in administrative burden for carriers. The hosts also discussed the Supreme Court's decision to deny review in California Trucking Association v. Bonta, effectively allowing California's AB5 independent contractor law to be enforced against trucking companies, a development with significant implications for carriers using owner-operators in that state. Additional topics included the expiration of COVID-19 emergency declarations, the confirmation of a new FMCSA administrator, and the agency's guidance on property brokerage and dispatch services. Looking ahead to 2023, the hosts outlined several items on the FMCSA's regulatory agenda that fleet professionals should monitor closely. Oral fluid testing is being considered as an alternative or supplement to urinalysis for DOT-mandated drug testing, with a formal rulemaking expected. Speed limiter requirements and automatic emergency braking mandates for newly manufactured heavy vehicles are both on the agenda, with the hosts noting that automatic emergency braking is likely to face far less industry opposition given its potential to reduce rear-end crashes. The FMCSA is also exploring electronic vehicle identification devices for commercial vehicles, potential changes to the new entrant audit process including a possible written examination requirement, and revisions to the Safety Fitness Determination system, which the hosts identified as one of the most consequential items given its potential to tie safety ratings more directly to CSA scores. Changes to the ELD mandate were also flagged, including movement away from self-certification toward third-party certification, clarification around malfunction procedures, and a potential revisiting of the exemption for pre-2000 engine model year vehicles. Finally, the hosts noted that autonomous vehicle rulemaking is overdue and expected to advance in some form in 2023. For fleet safety professionals, the most immediately actionable items from this episode include ensuring full compliance with the Entry-Level Driver Training rule when hiring new CDL holders, verifying that drivers are no longer relying on the expired COVID-19 emergency declaration for hours-of-service relief, and preparing for the January 6, 2023 Clearinghouse milestone, after which the Clearinghouse becomes the exclusive source for drug and alcohol history checks on prospective CDL drivers, though previous employer inquiries for non-drug-and-alcohol questions must still be conducted manually. Carriers should also stay engaged with upcoming rulemakings by submitting public comments on proposals that could affect their operations, particularly those related to ELD changes and safety fitness determinations.

Full Transcript

foreign foreign foreign foreign foreign foreign foreign foreign let alone you there's a dream this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign welcome to episode 16 of truck safe live the monthly show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon this is Jared hey everybody we are with truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs so this is it Jared uh year in review always look forward to these shows looking back at what has happened over the past year uh from a regulatory perspective and more importantly what's to come next year I feel like this year went by extremely fast I don't know about you but it felt it feels like we were just here a handful of months ago doing a recap for last year so yeah and uh even more surprising given how much stuff has happened over the past year last year when we were doing it we were struggling to find stuff to talk about luckily this year well I won't say luckily because more regulations isn't always uh isn't always the greatest thing obviously but uh it is what it is so we've got a lot to talk about today before we get to that um if you're here with us live say hey in the comments uh we'd love to know you're here and certainly as we go along if you have any thoughts on the topics that we're discussing or any questions or anything like that throw them in the comments wherever you're watching and we'll bring them up before we get to today's topic let's talk about some stuff that's going on at truck safe as always we've got a lot of stuff going on uh first up I just wanted to mention the truck safe compliance network if you haven't heard about this it's our own social media social network platform that we developed specifically for safety professionals Trucking Company owners safety managers Insurance professionals those types of folks to gather together and and really be resources for one another to ask questions about you know whatever's going on with your Fleet from a compliance standpoint and get answers and uh and besides that we also do a lot of network exclusive content trucksafe pushes out a lot of content we're doing monthly educational webinars all this is free to join if you're interested check it out at trucksafenetwork.com we'd love to have you in there um and uh and participating with us so again check that out trucksafenetwork.com uh our most recent webinar was on the most common violations that fleets tend to occur incur during roadside inspections we had a lot of good participation in that webinar um folks interested in that topic more importantly what fleets can do to avoid those violations going forward so check that out uh if you're interested uh next up I want to talk about the truck safe compliance boot camp this is an in-person conference that we're uh kicking off in April of next year where it's going to be a two-day conference the first one's going to be in Indianapolis our hometown and we're going to gather together around 25 or so it's going to be a small group fairly small group of again safety professionals Insurance folks truck trucking company owners safety managers to really dig into compliance at their respective fleets and and you know detailed information about regular various parts of the regulations and more importantly best practices what fleets can do to really improve their safety programs and make it Cutting Edge so we're really excited about that again first ones in April next April check it out trucksafebootcamp.com we're running a promo now if you're interested in attending check out trucksafebootcamp.com and enter the code holiday 20. you'll get 20 off your registration for that we're already starting to fill up so if you're interested in come and hang out with us for a couple days in Indianapolis talking all about Fleet Safety and compliance I'm sure there'll be some some Adventures along the way indeed some non-compliance yeah looking forward to that boot camp that's going to be exciting it's going to be like Brandon said very small it'll be a great chance to talk about specifics of programs and really dig into some of the issues that you're facing as opposed to just more of a cookie cutter as many people as you can pack into the conference type of a situation so I tried to convince Brandon to do it in Las Vegas but he chose Indianapolis instead maybe next year we'll see hey we're gonna do one in Orlando at the end of the year I think if this one if this one does well then we'll do one in Orlando then we can all go to Disney World when we're done perfect yeah it sounds good perfect for those of us with kids maybe um not so much everybody else so anyway again if you're interested check that out truck safe boot camp.com all right that's it for truck safe news here kicking things off excellent so as as Brandon said in the introduction uh today we wanted to do kind of a year-end recap um and again we did this last year um and and in doing the the year-end recap we're going to talk about the fmcsa's activities throughout 2022 but then we're also going to go into 2023 because we actually do have a regulatory agenda this year to talk about which is fantastic we have an administrator and an agenda so we have some things to talk about with 2023 too so we'll start out with 2022 and and get through these key topics from 22 and then move on to 2023 so the first of which is the safe driver apprenticeship pilot program so this was rolled out in January and and we did a show on this and talked about it pretty extensively but essentially uh the goal of this program is to alleviate uh the perceived driver shortage in the industry by allowing those drivers that are 18 to 20 years old to operate in interstate commerce whereas at this point many states most states have not all allow these drivers 18 to 20 year olds to operate in intra State Commerce so there was a limited amount of registrations in this program I believe it was 3 000 and my understanding is that it's still open and there wasn't a lot of traction with the registrations for whatever reason but that's what do you make of that Brandon that's pretty fascinating yeah I don't know I mean I always heard that maybe some insurance groups were hesitant to ensure motor carriers who were using younger drivers I don't know if there's any truth to that that's kind of the sense I got so I don't know if that's driving some of it or you know the other thing probably more likely is just I haven't seen a whole lot of publication about the about the pilot program I don't know if the word got out broadly enough to get people interested in it so yeah I will say certain industries like the construction industry I mean they're great opportunities to to utilize those younger drivers but I think in an intrastate capacity and over the years a lot of those companies and that industry generally has expressed hesitance maybe like you said it's from an insurance standpoint or maybe it's from the leadership standpoint well and the other thing is there's a lot of strings that come along with participating in the program we hit this we hit on this on on our earlier show but um you know participating carriers have a lot of thing a lot of boxes to check when they participate number one they have to apply to participate and they there's kind of a vetting process where the agency goes through and make sure that they're it's comfortable with that carrier participating based on its safety scores but then once they're in the program and they have drivers enrolled those drivers have to go through a kind of a two-part um apprenticeship program it's a it's an apprenticeship program in the true sense in that during those two parts the carrier has to be kind of um testing them on various on various topics um safe driving techniques stuff like that and evaluating them and then have somebody riding along with them an experienced driver riding along with them to make sure so you know I don't know for for carriers who uh who have a lot going on obviously that's that's a big ask for them but certainly if you find yourself in a predicament where you're lacking drivers maybe this is an option for you yeah but like you said the some of the some of the hurdles that you have to to jump over to comply with the apprenticeship program may have been prohibited for a lot of carriers I mean it's 400 hours two different phases of the apprenticeship program and at the same time even some of those larger more sophisticated carriers I mean they're they're happiest when they're not talking to the dot so that's just uh that's just a fact if you are interested in it I'll recommend that you go check out the Next Generation and Trucking Association if you're not familiar with next-gen Trucking it's an awesome organization that's all about bringing up the next generation of truck drivers and getting them the education they need to be safe drivers we've had Lindsay Trent on from Next Gen she's great to work with they're doing a lot with this safe driver apprenticeship pilot program so if you're a carrier that's interested in potentially participating reach out to Lindsay Trent over at next-gen Trucking and she can get you the information you'll need all right next up that was the safe driver apprenticeship pilot program the next big rule making that we saw last year was early last I'm sorry early this year was the entry-level driver training rule this was a significant rule making many years in the making essentially it establishes a uniform curriculum for those that are seeking to complete certain CDL transactions so drivers who are seeking to get a Class A or Class B CDL for the first time or those that are looking to upgrade a Class B to a class A or those who are getting certain endorsements to their CDL namely Hazmat passenger and school bus endorsements traditionally they have not had to go through any kind of standardized curriculum in order to be eligible to take the skills test to go get those or to complete those transactions FMCSA changed that up earlier this year with its entry-level driver training Rule now those particular drivers affect of February 6th I think of this year have had to go get this they have to Source this training from a registered training provider a provider that's registered with the FMCSA get the training both a theory portion and a behind the wheel portion they have to progress through that they have to complete it to the satisfaction of the training provider and then only then are they eligible to then go take the skills test to get their um to get their CDL or complete their CDL transaction So Gone are the days of uh learning from your brother how to drive a big truck and then going to take the test and being good to go that's how you learned right well yeah okay that's how I learned um I mean it's it's a Improvement without a doubt it's going to create safer entry-level drivers for sure the the registered training provider list has gotten pretty large um so make sure that you understand if you're going to be uh looking at one of those training providers if you're going to be getting an online Theory course or you're getting an in-person Theory course benefits to both but just understand what you're getting yeah I think a lot of folks I'm judging by the comments we get on our YouTube channel where we've done a lot of videos on our YouTube channel about entry-level driver training and it gets a lot they get a lot of views from from folks who are confused about the rule um and a lot of them don't realize you can even you can get the theory part of the training from an online training provider I think a lot of folks are under the the misimpression that you have to go to a truck driving school in order to complete this to to then be eligible to take the skills test that's not true there are online training providers because the other thing I hear them say is oh it's going to cost me 5000 dollars that may be true if you go to a traditional truck driving school or something like that but my my advice to you is do your due diligence go to the fmcsa's training provider register your website and just search for training providers and figure out what they're charging I I know of online training providers that are offering it for a couple hundred bucks the training part obviously the behind the wheel part is more involved and is going to cost more and you can get your hands on an outline of the course find out generally speaking how long the course is I mean if you're just checking the box and you're not going to get anything from this just the ability to take the CDL exam I mean it doesn't seem like it's a great deal on your part if you're going to be paying the same price but yeah anyways next 2022 item we wanted to talk about was the elimination of certificates of violation this occurred in March and it was the FMCSA eliminating that requirement for drivers to annually submit certificates of violation to carriers and the agency's reasoning on this was sound they thought that it was duplicative of requirements to already review annual mvrs I mean it seemed like an absolute duplication so the fact that they're getting rid of this clear win for the industry clear win for motor carriers in my opinion yeah it was always a pain although uh carriers still have to do their own annual reviews of the nvrs as you said and traditionally we would see the the paper versions that would have the annual review on the top of the paper then the bottom half would be the certificate of violations and so you know practically carriers would end up doing those at the same time so maybe it wasn't a huge issue and if we're talking about paperwork reduction they were on the same sheet of paper so I didn't always see it that way same piece of paper and then other times I'd see even if it was on the same piece of paper sometimes the top would be filled out and the other part wasn't filled out it's just a paperwork driven violation that motor carriers unnecessarily would get in the context of audits so that's gone yeah I agree uh it's good don't ever say that the FMCSA just enacts new rules and never gives you a break throws you a bone they they threw the industry a bone here but it was a small bone true uh okay next up big news this year less regulatory in nature more um litigation focused was the Supreme Court's uh decision in the um the ab5 case so the California Trucking Association versus bonta case this was big news earlier this year we had a couple of shows devoted to it we had Doug Grau on from the Graw group who is much more knowledgeable in this area than either Jared or I uh but the case had to do with the independent contractor status of owner operators um and whether or not California's ab5 legislation which essentially is a codification of the ABC test if anybody's familiar with the various tests that are used throughout the country to determine whether a worker is an independent contractor or an employee the ABC test is a common test used throughout the country California's version of the ABC test is unique from others in the country um it's b-prong ABC because there's three prongs aprong B prong C prong the B prong in California is very restrictive and essentially I don't think there are many that disagree with this but there may be some um essentially makes it impossible for a trucking company to Prevail on an argument that their owner operators who are leased to them and operating under their DOT number are properly classified as independent contractors under California's restrictive ABC test so anyway California Trucking Association sued um sued to enjoin the the implementation of ab5 at least in the trucking industry um they actually prevailed at the trial court trial court uh issued a ruling in favor of California Trucking Association and and put a stop to the enforcement of ab5 in the trucking industry for for many years and that was you know litigated up through the ninth Circuit Court of Appeals um and the ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the trial court in that set up that set the stage for it to go to the Supreme Court of the United States um and we were the whole basis of that argument was that California's ab5 legislation is preempted by a federal law known as the Federal Aviation authorization no Federal Aviation Administration authorization act f4a and which is a which is a law that uh prohibits States from enacting laws that affect the rates routes or Services of a motor carrier in any event um me explaining this in in five minutes here is not going to do any justice so go back and watch our previous show on if you want the nitty-gritty about it suffice it to say scotus denies review in that case which then leads to California now enforcing ab5 in the State against trucking companies and you saw that in the news a lot of folks up in arms about it and what it means for their operations and having to potentially change their business model uh to account for it and so it's pretty big Fallout at least from what I can tell yeah the the misclassification cat and mouse game in the ninth circuit continues unfortunately and I don't see where Clarity is going to come from uh do you no unless well so that case is not done completely there are still some arguments I think California Trucking Association and even oida Owner Operator Independent driver Association they're still fighting in that case and I think they're making a constitutional argument now to try and get ab5 uh enjoined again we'll see if that goes anywhere I don't I don't have high hopes that it will but we'll see yeah that was my understanding of it as well um so moving on from ab5 we've like I said earlier we finally have an administrator there from CSA confirmed Senate confirmation occurred I believe at the end of September Robin Hutchinson so um following uh her confirmation through the Senate we got a regulatory agenda released which is fantastic we're going to talk about 2023 and some of those items on that regulatory agenda later but again it's pretty exciting that we have an administrator now for the FMCSA hopefully some agenda items can be moved along um one of which that's getting moved along is the end of covid-19 emergency declaration we've had these emergency declarations in in effect in some form or fashion since March of 2020 essentially it's just broad regulatory relief for those that are providing direct assistance to emergency relief efforts and we've seen the definition of direct assistance and emergency relief efforts we've seen that stretched to its limits most definitely yeah I've worked with a lot of carriers who were operating under that exemption purportedly and uh who who were kind of Walking the Tightrope it was right on the edge of what qualifies as emergency relief efforts the FMCSA didn't do them any favor by issuing such a broad exemption um but regardless that has now Sunset so as Jared said it was in place since March of 2020 FMCSA quietly let it lapse without any Fanfare so it is no longer in effect so if you if you're still taking the position that you're operating under the emergency exemption it no longer exists so stop that which also this is something we don't even have on our list but it also I think prompted something that just came out recently we have an article about it on our website FMCSA issued a was it a final rule or was it a proposed rule I think it was a proposed rule where they're thinking about completely revamping the way that they do emergency declarations to no longer be so broad so historically when a a governor or president in the case of covid-19 issues an emergency declaration carriers who are and drivers who are providing emergency assistance or really assistance to the emergency relief efforts they have historically been exempt from a large swath of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations everything from driver qualification to hours of service to vehicle maintenance very broad exemption we saw with the covid-19 emergency declaration FMCSA actually stepped in later in that declaration and and narrowed it down to just hours of service relief so you still had to qualify drivers um still had to make sure your vehicles were annually inspected which frankly makes sense but regardless the revamp the potential revamp they're thinking about is is narrowing the scope of of those declarations going forward to only Encompass hours of service in certain situations so and there was a Distinction on when the federal government places an exemption and when uh Governor replaces an exemption so the time distinction that the time allowance that a governor could have an exemption in place an emergency declaration in place is limited yeah shortened quite a bit obviously the dot could extend it if they wanted to but the the default time period for governor issued emergency declarations is going to be shorter so I think that will end up going into effect if it hasn't already again I can't remember if it was a proposed rule or a final one I think it was a proposed one uh okay and then the last thing that we wanted to talk about that happened this year this was one of the newer things that occurred was the fmcsa's guidance that it recently issued on brokerage so uh earlier this year FMCSA had requested comments from the public on whether the agency needed to step in and clarify the definitions that apply to property brokerage and when property broker Authority is needed and and that garnered a lot of comments and then the FMCSA just within the last uh let's see it was in November came out with guidance on this topic where they essentially said what constitute bro they were looking at what constitutes brokerage how do we Define brokerage or do we need to change our existing definitions of brokerage and what constitutes a bona fide agent of a shipper because there's this concept in federal law that if you are essentially serving as a bona fide agent of a shipper um then you don't necessarily need a brokerage authority to then tender that Freight to a a motor carrier because you're acting on behalf of you're acting in the shoes of that shipper because shippers don't need broker authority to Tender their own frame so what what I think the FMCSA was taking aim at were these are these so-called dispatch services that exist out there that are kind of fitting again in the gray area I think in most cases where they are they are tendering freight potentially to multiple carriers under the auspices of a dispatch services so they're not getting broker Authority um and so that was the the big deal with this uh regulatory guidance where FMCSA steps in and essentially in my View kind of punts the issue because what they say is it's a case-by-case analysis we have to look at all of the the facts of the circumstances and figure out they list out a dozen or so factors that are going to weigh in favor of the entity being considered a broker and that way against the entity being a broker and really in my mind it really comes down to is this entity handling the monetary transactions between the carrier and and the shipper and are they allocating shipments between multiple motor carriers rather than dedicating those shipments to one Motor Carrier are they are they you know potentially handing it off to to one or more carriers and those things according to the fmcsa's guidance tend to weigh in favor of the entity being a broker and requiring broker Authority ultimately everyone that had their hopes up that they were going to get clear guidance on this massive letdown that it's now considered a case-by-case analysis but we did get some factors and a little bit of clarity there but it wasn't it's kind of like the personal conveyance Guidance just a ton of factors maybe not that bad but yeah um yeah if you're ever waiting on clear guidance from a federal agency then um yeah you're not going to get it well you know we're we're moving into the 2023 uh regulatory agenda at this point and unfortunately we can't tell you that personal conveyance Clarity is on this agenda list but uh first of the is the oral fluid testing Brandon you want to jump into that one yeah so oral fluid testing this was something we talked about uh earlier this year actually because the FMCSA sought some comments from the public on it essentially what what the agency is looking at is potentially moving away from the current system where that only authorizes your analysis as the only approved method for conducting dot mandated drug test your analysis right now is the only way you can conduct a DOT mandated test no hair test no mouth swabs it has to be urinalysis except blood draws in certain very limited circumstances like when the when the police do it but regardless your analysis has for decades been the way that we have conducted DOT drug test in this industry and now the agency is contemplating expanding that to include not only your analysis but also mouth swabs too according to the agency make things a little easier for motor carriers and collectors to manage mouth swabs obviously are less invasive and more importantly you know the problem with your analysis most in in a lot of cases is they're not observed so driver goes and pees in a cup nobody's watching him urine gets substituted in that situation and now you're dealing with fake urine is it more of a convenience and a less invasive and more difficult to cheat perspective or is it more oral fluid testing is more accurate or are you so I think the date there's data in the fmcsa's rule making on that topic I don't think that it was necessarily more accurate I think it may have actually detected the use of drug certain drugs for longer periods of time but not all of them so there were some trade-offs but I think the big thing is convenience and and making sure because a mouth swab those are all going to be observed it's going to be a person sitting there taking your swab so they're harder to cheat so but again the way that the the notice was structured it wasn't necessarily saying that mouth swabs are going to replace your analysis it was almost like they're going to give carriers the choice of doing your analysis or mouth swabs so right now where it stands we're just kind of waiting on FMCSA to take the next step which would probably probably be a notice of proposed rulemaking which could come out next year we don't know for certain but it could excellent so next thing on the list and this is another one that's uh very contentious is speed limiters um and an automatic emergency braking I think that speed limit is obviously much more of a Hot Topic and and combative topic than what you would find with automatic emergency yeah if we want participation on the show we can just ask people what they think about speed limiters yeah tell us what you think about speed limiters put it in the comments and we'll see the perfect speed for a speed limiter is 65 miles per hour uh tell me why I'm wrong that's that's part of the problem is where do you draw the line with the speed limit I mean no one is going to dispute that increased speed creates more severe crashes and potentially creates more dangerous driving however if you're going to limit a large commercial motor vehicle to any kind of speed 68 miles per hour they're going to be on a highway say in Texas where the speed limit could be 80 miles per hour everyone's going to be going 90 miles per hour I mean obviously you do the math there that doesn't create a safe environment that creates a dangerous environment that's where a lot of people are coming from here yeah I mean literally thousands of comments mostly in opposition from what I could tell I didn't read every one of them but a lot of them opposed to the rule for that reason namely but essentially where we're at so FMCSA kind of did this joint rule making with Nitza back in 2016 where they originally proposed requiring new heavy Vehicles so we're talking about trucks over 26 000 pounds trucks or buses uh I think buses regard less that was The Proposal they hadn't set a speed but they were requesting comments on where to set the speed and then radio silence over the last six years on that and so now in the fmcsa's agenda regulatory agenda they noted that they are planning to move ahead with some sort of speed limit or device I have no idea what kind of form that's going to take but we will wait and see we might have it pretty easy with this one because we might have autonomous vehicles before we have speed limiters possibly it was a joke but it's moving very slowly it would look like you know a regulation that required oems to place these speed limiters on newly manufacturers it wouldn't be any kind of retrofit right mandate as far as I could tell and kind of along these same lines is also another proposal that's um that's probably going to come to fruition next year which is automatic emergency braking I don't know much about this rulemaking I know that it's been proposed for several years now and I think it would probably take the form of another joint Nitza and FMCSA rule making where it would be a requirement on heavy newly manufactured heavy trucks going forward so it's in the regulatory agenda for next year yeah I think that would be that would be an excellent move I think that there's going to be a lot less pushback on that one just because I mean in my experience and looking at a lot of dash cam footage and looking at a lot of Highway accident litigation I mean it's it's those rear end crashes that are just extremely nasty and this would this would go a very long way to to stopping the large majority of those uh rear end crashes on the highways yeah next up um not necessarily on the regulatory agenda but um this comes out of a request that we saw FMCSA publish earlier this year this is another one where we've got a detailed article on it on our website if you're interested in learning more but the FMCSA was requesting public input on a potential requirement that commercial Motor Vehicles be equipped with electronic vehicle identification devices so we're all familiar with these types of devices now when we talk about like weigh station bypass devices where they uh you know a driver installs a transponder type deal in the truck and then as they pass by a Way Station it reads the transponder and gives the way station information to know that that truck is clear to go past the weigh station without stopping FMCSA is garnering public input on whether to mandate that type of device in all commercial Motor Vehicles not necessarily just to pass weigh stations but to transmit data about the operating Motor Carrier to the weigh stations so that they know that there's a problem or not ahead of time things like DOT number stuff like that kind of identifying information about that truck that's getting ready to pass by so they know whether to to tag that truck for an inspection so this is another one that got a lot of a lot of comments people not in favor of it but we'll see if it goes anywhere thing another one that is going to Garner a lot of commentary is changes to the new entrant audit process you know as everyone knows if you're a new motor carrier you're going to get a new entrant audit within the first 12 months of you receiving that DOT number operating Authority and the the new intro audit is pretty cursory I won't say it's something that you don't need to worry about or prepare for but you can get a couple of bites at the Apple with these you can have a chance to fix the problems that are discovered and it's mostly just those big red flag issues that you absolutely have to get right to be able to continue in operation well one of the proposed changes that are that's kind of in discussion is a potential examination of the motor carrier meaning someone's going to get a written test I'm really interested to see where this is going it's bringing back bad memories yeah law school and college and we've seen a really big increase in new motorcycle barriers and I wouldn't say that that means that there's just a bunch of new motor carrier operations out there operating people grabbed up Authority and Dot numbers thinking that things were going to potentially change in the future and um nonetheless if you're going to select someone that has to get a written examination how do you go about doing that I'm interested to see just some specifics on what this might look like yeah this is just in the agenda there's no details about what they're thinking but they do mention in the agenda that they're thinking about a mandatory examination requirement for all new entrant motor carriers which is not completely out there there are certain permits I know a lot of states have um you know if a state has like a Hazmat hauler or a hazardous waste hauler permit some of those States will have a mandatory examination that the responsible individual who's going to be overseeing that program has to take a written exam to to demonstrate their knowledge about the topic so it's not completely unheard of but doing it in this space is completely unheard of so actually forcing motor carers to take an exam I don't know apparently FMCSA is a little concerned with what they're seeing with the with the new motor carriers that are coming uh coming about I will say there could certainly be some quality problems I'm not gonna do disagree with that assessment but I'd love to see some details on how that's going to shake out yeah we should um if that comes to fruition we should do a live show where you and I take the test and then grade each other all right next up is uh is potential changes to the safety Fitness determination process wouldn't be a regulatory agenda without something like this no this one scares me the most out of all of them um safety Fitness determinations are safety ratings so those watching are probably familiar with the three-tier system that we have had in place for decades at this point where motor carriers that have undergone a a full compliance review by the FMCSA are scored based on how many violations are discovered and they end up with either a satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory safety rating and then those ratings are displayed publicly for all to see and they have a big impact on customer relationships a lot of customers don't want to do business with carriers that have anything less than a satisfactory rating they also have a big influence on your insurance premiums and and certainly in Highway accident litigation and so we've been under the same system for like I said many years there's a whole methodology that goes into how the FMCSA scores and assigns these safety ratings Jared and I use this scoring methodology when we go in and conduct mock Dot audits for motor carriers and so the agency occasionally starts to toy with this and and decide whether they want to change it up last time they did this I think was probably back around 2016 or so back then they they got to the stage of proposing a rule that would have completely changed up the way we do safety Fitness determinations in the country and they were actually going to tie at motor carrier's uh safety rating to their CSA scores so carriers with cert with scores at certain levels based on roadside inspection would get an unfit safety rating and then they would be shut down you can imagine that that um that did not go over well with the public or with the U.S Congress so U.S Congress stepped in and told FMCSA uh we don't think so not until you FMCSA addressed the deficiencies with the CSA program that many in the industry have have battled about for years well now Congress told FMCSA to commission a study of the CSA program FMCSA did that they got a study they got a report with recommendations on how to improve CSA FMCSA to my knowledge has been working to fix those issues and now I feel like they think they're at a point where they can can tackle this issue again and potentially propose it again which makes me really worried if it's going to be anything like that one they originally proposed yeah it's we don't really know where this one's going to go but it is interesting to talk about and potential changes to that three-tier system I don't really see a problem with a three-tier system if you're going to move away from the three-tier system potentially having just a thumbs up or a thumbs down I mean I'm sure that you know folks that are hiring motor carriers and potentially vetting motor carriers based on Public Information would love that thumbs up or thumbs down I just don't know how you would go about doing that yeah I mean I could see it from the agency's perspective right now the agency is so uh so small relative to the universe of motor carriers that they're charged with regulating that we're in a situation now where they're having to prioritize motor carriers for audit and they can only you know go and audit so many carriers per year so not very many are getting safety ratings and so there's potentially thousands of carriers out there on the roads who shouldn't be out on the road and so if we can tie it to a system like CSA that's tracking their compliance on a day-to-day basis through roadside inspections well then we can broaden our reach and potentially get more unsafe carriers off the road but I'm concerned with it's the it's the old CSA issue do we trust the data that that CSA is pushing out and and identifying unsafe motor carriers yeah I mean once it can be even for some good carriers I mean if they start getting a handful of violations ISS score goes up and they start getting a lot more inspections a lot more violations and then you could have good carriers that get the thumbs down I mean relying strictly on the data you have to be a lot closer to a perfect solution and I don't feel like I've seen a perfect solution I don't understand the new theory that they proposed I don't think many people do it it's called the item response Theory and um IRT yeah last I heard that that hasn't gone anywhere it's been literally like three no probably more than that probably five years now where we were under the impression the agency was going to switch to that type of model and it just hasn't here's the worth millions of dollars and not much to show for it yeah nothing to show for um okay next up uh Clearinghouse changes so we we are quickly approaching the full implementation date of the Clearing House which is going to be January 6 2023 and that's going to be the date in which you no longer have to do the manual previous employer requests regarding those drug and alcohol issues I mean obviously you're still going to have to look at um prior employers for accidents and inquire about those accidents and employment verifications but uh this will be again another one of those steps that you know motor carriers can take out of their uh driver qualification process so we've done a couple in-depth webinars on this topic specifically so check out our website trucksafe.com if you want more information but yeah that's essentially it you know the whole idea with the Clearinghouse originally was you know this is going to be the central database where all motor carriers who are hiring CDL Drivers go to see if their prospective drivers have tested positive or had a drug and alcohol violation in the past because of the problems that we faced with those manual inquiries where we would reach out to previous employers and just not get a response the response rate was just abysmal on those yeah that's that one you know that one's always tough too you know I know we we do a lot of mock Audits and we so we see a lot of files from a lot of different types of motor carriers a lot of different Industries and the previous employer checks is always one of those instances where you rarely see a carrier that just nails that and gets that right so hopefully this takes some of that pressure off yeah so yeah as of January 6 2023 if you're hiring CDL Drivers the Clearinghouse will be the exclusive means by which you obtain drug and alcohol histories for your prospective drivers but as Jared said the important word is you're still going to have to reach out to the previous employers to ask the non-drug and alcohol questions that you have historically ask namely verify their employment and were they involved in any accidents that you want to tell us about that you have to tell us about so uh last couple here potential ELD revisions yeah ELD revisions this is one that I'm excited about so we have a handful of items that are going to be looked at in 2023 requesting comments on potential revisions to the ELD mandate so specifically around the areas of malfunctions which has been a really confusing area for the industry you know if if your device goes into a state of malfunction that prevents the accurate recording of records of Duty status then you can switch to paper logs and you can do so until the device is replaced or remedied you have eight days to do that however drivers have no idea typically how to determine whether or not a malfunction is preventing the accurate recording of rods if if they could do some digging that potentially they could figure that out but they're going to see the malfunction icon on their ELD interface and a lot of drivers have used that as a chance to switch to paper because they're more comfortable doing that maybe or they just aren't sure if the accurate recording of rods is occurring and they want to be safe and to switch to paper whatever the reason is there's a lot of confu Fusion around that so getting some clarity on that issue would be really huge for the industry in my opinion and again that's just been one of those many confusing areas is malfunctions yeah I mean this rulemaking surprised me I think it surprised a lot in the industry I didn't really see it coming so the these would be the first big changes to the ELD mandate since it was implemented five years ago or something like that 2017 was the start with the grandfathering period Then 2019 was that everybody was on Andy at that point so this came in the form of a request for comments um that was filed by FMCSA or published by FMCSA uh in September and I expect we'll see some movement on it next year but so Jared mentioned the one big thing another big component of that is uh and and perhaps the biggest is a potential move away from the self-certification process yeah the move away from self-certification is is an interesting move and I see the reason for it and the benefit of it I think we're going to have you know some some negative commentary from multiple different angles you know I think that we've we've observed the Canadian third-party certification regime go into place and I think that a lot of the larger ELD vendors are done with that process or still kind of going through that process or wrapping it up uh getting that ELD certification through the third part 30 and they're probably not very excited about jumping into another third party certification so I think there's going to be some pushback there but I would say this this will probably benefit those larger ELD vendors because they have the resources to go through this third party certification process and what it's going to do is get rid of a lot of those devices that are just kind of languishing in the industry we may have non-compliant devices where motor carriers have tried to save a few bucks and entered into a three four year contract with an ELD that's not very compliant so this self-certain this moving away from self-certification is going to vet out a lot of those devices that don't belong in the market in my opinion well and this comes on the heels I think FMCSA revoked its first ever self-certified ELD device this year I think it was called Eld it was El Dorado it was El Dorado which I thought was a creative name but regardless they're no longer an acceptable yeah if you go to the fmcsa's website you can see the full list of the self-certified devices you can also see the full list of revoked devices now most of the devices have been self-revoked because of business changes uh device changes updates things like that they've self-revoked uh there's there's another provision in in these ELD changes uh that relates to the revocation process and I think that the theme that you see in in this proposed uh asking for comments on the elds ETC you're look you're you're seeing the agency looking to police elds more heavily and I think that that's been a long time coming and it's welcome by the industry so the last big component of those potential ELD changes there were there were a few more but the the big one the last big one has to do with the existing exemption that applies to trucks with a with an engine that is model year 1999 or older so those trucks are currently exempt completely from the ELD mandate the idea being that the FMCSA had to draw the line somewhere because they were hearing that uh certain older model your trucks were not compatible with ELD technology they weren't able to make that necessary connection with the ECM to to be able to report the things that have to be reported and so they drew the line at 1999 and said anything older anything 1999 or older in terms of the engine is exempt well in this most recent notice from FMCSA they are toying around apparently with potentially either doing away with that exemption completely or modifying it yeah that's that's an interesting one I think that I mean how long are drivers going to be able to continue resuscitating a 1999 or older vehicle you know I've seen a gentleman driving a a commercial motor vehicle with a Caterpillar diesel engine that had millions and millions of miles it just blew my mind it was the original engine and it was older than 99 so I guess it in theory it could continue going on like this but you have to draw the line at some point right yeah well that that component of the notice particularly is is garnering a lot of negative comments so um we'll see with if that one comes to fruition or not it's early on in the regulatory stage so yeah so if if that upsets you then submit your comment most definitely all right last but not least autonomous trucks interesting in 2019 we got requests for comments on some of the changes that might be necessary to the fmcsrs and there's a vast amount of changes that would be necessary to the fmcsrs but uh were were supposed to see some activity uh in 2023 on this front um it's it's a super fascinating area it's moving very slowly but we know that it's coming at some point one of the interesting things for me and this probably won't happen in 2023 but we're going to see the new hours of service is going to become maintenance on the vehicles and Diagnostics on the vehicles and and are we going to see any kind of movement in the language in the fmcsrs towards that type of approach and others that are necessary yeah I mean for literally 100 years now our our Motor Carrier safety regulations that have existed have all contemplated a human driver in the seat and now for the first time we were faced with the reality I mean these trucks are operating on the highways in various parts of the country now we are faced with how do we what do we need to do what changes do we need to make to these regulations that have grown up with a human driver in the seat to accommodate those types of operations it's going to be a tall task presumably the agency has been working on it for a while now I haven't seen anything about it but they were supposed to come out with the with their proposed rule in November of this year that has come and passed so now it's on the regulatory agenda for next year so we'll see yeah I mean they frankly they can't wait any longer they really can't because the states are allowing autonomous vehicle technology manufacturers to operate in certain States and the federal government's kind of getting left behind because the states are dictating how this can be done and I've been in uh fully autonomous 18-wheeler going down the highway and the technology is absolutely here so people that say that this is science fiction at this point it's absolutely not it is here and the federal government has to catch up or the states are going to dictate how this is done yeah they're booking loads for these things and primary really Southwest yeah Southwestern State in Commerce that's happening it's happening so anyway all right that's going to wrap things up for us today we talked a lot we talked we had a lot of ground to cover so we did that um last thing I I'll just wrap up here with a few more notes about truck safe if if you haven't already checked out our online courses be sure to do so at trucksafeacademy.com uh Jared and I built these courses specifically for safety managers and and trucking company owners to kind of go through the nitty-gritty of all of these safety regulations that regulated fleets are expected to know and to comply with there's a lot that goes into it so we we tried to break it down in layman's terms and make it easy for for those folks and we also have a Hazmat course we also have Reasonable Suspicion and we're going to be adding some additional courses as well so yeah so check those out trucksafeacademy.com if you're interested also hey if you're not already subscribed to our newsletter be sure to do so you can do that at trucksafe.com subscribe and then we're sending out weekly newsletters with all you know breaking regulatory news and and talking about what we've got going on at truck safe so do that or and or follow us on our social media Pages we're pretty active on LinkedIn Facebook Twitter all of those um so be sure to do that yeah and we're developing you know our our agenda of shows and our topics of shows for 2023 so if you have any items that you'd really like us to touch on please just send us an email drop us a comment we'd love it yeah do it at trucksafelive.com that's also where you can learn about future shows and read guest bios stuff like that lastly just want to say thanks again to the sponsor of this season of truck safe live which is log Rock appreciate you teaming up with us uh to bring this this season to everybody so thanks again to log Rock that's it everybody uh Merry Christmas and Happy New Year we will see you next year happy holidays

Event Completed

Tuesday, December 20, 2022 at 4:09 PM EST

Watch on YouTube