Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 19 - Preparing for autonomous trucking

Tuesday, February 21, 2023 at 6:13 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 19 - Preparing for autonomous trucking

About This Event

In this episode, Brandon & Jerad break down the current regulatory landscape for autonomous trucking, including the FMCSA’s most recent supplemental advanced notice of proposed rulemaking.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 19 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress of Trucksafe Consulting dive into one of the most consequential developments in the transportation industry: the emergence of autonomous trucking and the regulatory framework being built around it. The episode centers on the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's (FMCSA) Supplemental Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (SANPRM), which solicits public comments on how existing regulations should be updated to accommodate autonomous vehicles operating at SAE levels four and five. The hosts emphasize that autonomous trucking is not a distant concept — level four autonomous trucks are already hauling freight commercially in the United States, particularly in southwestern states, making regulatory clarity an urgent matter. The hosts walk through the three primary areas on which the FMCSA is soliciting public comment. The first concerns notification requirements, including whether motor carriers should be required to notify the FMCSA before engaging in driverless operations and whether certain safety thresholds — such as satisfactory safety ratings or strong Safety Management Controls — should be prerequisites for operating autonomous trucks. The second area addresses the regulation of remote assistance personnel, the human operators who monitor autonomous vehicles and intervene when the technology encounters situations outside its operational domain. The hosts debate whether existing driver regulations such as hours of service, drug and alcohol testing, and CDL requirements make sense when applied to remote assistants who are not physically operating the vehicle. The third and arguably most significant area involves vehicle inspection and maintenance, including how pre-trip inspections should be conducted without a human driver, how frequently autonomous trucks — which could theoretically operate around the clock — should undergo maintenance checks, and whether real-time diagnostic data should be transmitted wirelessly to law enforcement. Throughout the discussion, the hosts highlight several important distinctions that fleet professionals should understand. They explain the difference between remote assistance and remote drivers, note that product liability will likely shift heavily toward autonomous vehicle manufacturers in the event of crashes, and point out that vehicle maintenance and inspection will become the dominant area of regulatory focus as driver-centric regulations such as hours of service become less relevant. They also note that the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) will play a significant parallel role in regulating the manufacturing standards for autonomous vehicles, and that coordination between federal agencies will be essential. The most pressing actionable takeaway from this episode is the March 20th deadline for submitting public comments on the SANPRM. The hosts strongly encourage fleet operators, safety managers, and industry stakeholders to participate in the rulemaking process, warning that those who do not submit comments often become the loudest critics after regulations take effect. They suggest that comments go beyond broad skepticism and instead address specific, well-reasoned concerns about how proposed regulatory approaches could impact real-world fleet operations. The hosts also recommend that fleets begin educating themselves now on SAE autonomy levels, the role of remote assistance, and how inspection and maintenance obligations may evolve. The hosts close by previewing future episodes on autonomous trucking, including planned discussions with highway accident litigators on liability implications and conversations with motor carriers already deploying the technology. As a broader theme, the episode reinforces that autonomous trucking will represent the single largest transformation the industry has seen in a generation, and that fleet safety professionals who engage proactively with the regulatory process today will be far better positioned to adapt as the landscape evolves.

Full Transcript

we're still money all on you honey baby sweet redemption I Will Never Let You Down you say you will yeah it doesn't really matter baby I'm calling your addicted foreign say you live foreign foreign foreign this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign welcome to episode 19 of trucksafe live the show where we are guest tack of a hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon this is Jared hey everybody we are with trucksafe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs Today's Show we are talking about autonomous Trucking and kind of preparing for that new world that we're all about to enter whether we want to or not yeah this this is an exciting show if this topic doesn't get you excited not necessarily the regulatory piece of it but if the autonomous piece doesn't get you excited you probably don't have a pulse of all the topics we talk about it's probably the most interesting I'd have absolutely I mean it's definitely going to be the biggest thing that happens in trucking in the transportation space in my lifetime for sure yeah definitely so that's what we're talking about today especially in light of um fmcsa's recent notice that it came out with it's a supplement final advanced notice of proposed rulemaking so we wanted to talk about that and what exactly the FMCSA is looking for in terms of of public comments before we do that a few things going on at trucksafe that we wanted to mention uh first up has to do with the truck safe compliance network if you are not this is going to go right over my face I just realized that as I was clicking the button we will take that off but if you're not part of the truck safe compliance Network make sure you check it out we've got an iPhone app and an Android app over in the app store or the Google Play Store search for truck safe you'll find it the the network is a space for safety professionals and risk advisors and folks who are involved in the day-to-day management of a DOT compliance program we wanted to create a space for those folks to get together learn from one another ask questions so that is through the trucksafe network you can also find more information at trucksafenetwork.com and it's free and it's free to join so there's there's no excuse for you not joining it um we do a lot of DOT compliance content free content as well through there we're doing monthly webinars we just did a webinar all about the top hours of service related problems that fleets are facing and more importantly what they can do to avoid them um so join it participate uh hopefully you'll find it useful uh one other thing I'll mention is our most recent truck safe live we did a special episode last week we try and do these monthly but we had a special one last week about the breaking news in the industry having to do with fmcsa's announcement that is it is considering pretty significant changes to the CSA CSA scores the safety measurement system um which surprised me did you have any idea that was coming I had no idea it was coming but I mean I think that's just proof uh you know in accordance with this s-a-s-a-n-p-r-m as well that this administrator is not afraid to use regulatory tools and we're going to see a lot of activity with this Administration in the years to come yeah so we broke that down in our most recent episode go back and watch it if you're interested in that um like I said pretty significant changes if they end up taking effect um the agency is soliciting comments on it I guess what I will say is that it wasn't necessarily surprising that this would ultimately happen because we knew going back five years or so Congress told FMCSA that they had to um number one commission an independent study of the SMS based on widespread criticism of that platform over the years and they commissioned that study and so we've been waiting to hear what the agency's response to that study was going to be and uh this was the response um spoiler alert it's not moving to an IRT model item response theory model which is what we expected to happen but they said screw that we're not doing that yeah well the IRT model had its strengths and weaknesses I think that it was just going to be really really complicated for folks to understand including ourselves and so moving away from it in that regard makes a little bit of sense yeah I thought it was funny in their notice the FMCSA they listed out five reasons why they're not going with the IRT model and the one that really stuck out was essentially this model is confusing as hell so we're not going so anyway go back watch that if you're interested in that um what else we got going on Jared uh we've got a couple of events coming up where we're speaking at the Indiana motor Trucking Association on the 23rd we're actually going to be talking about this same subject the autonomous regulatory landscape um so if you're gonna go to that pop in say hi we'll also be at ata's SS and HR conference which is in Minneapolis April 4th through 6th so stop in and say hi to us I believe we're gonna have a booth on that one right um are we maybe I thought maybe we were well anyways possibly if you see us around say hi yeah we're gonna uh we're definitely gonna be speaking there and we're gonna be speaking on uh driver qualification issues at the ATA conference so yeah like Jared said stop by say hey uh we would love to see you there um and then lastly the last thing we'll mention before we get into autonomous trucks is our Fleet compliance boot camp um this is coming up April 19th and 20th uh seems like it's been forever since we first announced this and it's finally coming up April 19th and 20th first one's going to be in Indianapolis uh this is going to be a two-day conference where Jared and I and some special guests potentially are going to be really digging into DOT compliance and helping attendees really build out a robust safety program a Cutting Edge safety program that's the whole point of it is to really get into the nitty-gritty of what it takes to um to manage or effectively manage a safety program so if you're interested in joining us for that we've got uh limited spots open we're trying to limit these to a small group of folks so we can spend more time with you one-on-one and really go through your existing program and and what tweaks you can potentially make to it to really take it to the next level trucksafebootcamp.com is where you will find more information about that if you are interested alright enough about us let's talk about autonomous trucks Jared you want to kick us off here yeah sure before we kind of get into the subject I I just want to point out there's a very limited amount of time to issue your comments on this San PRM they're due March 20th obviously ATA State Trucking associations all the big players are going to be issuing their comments so now is definitely the time to reach out to those entities that you may be a member of and kind of get your point of view across or start drafting your own comments up because you know we see a lot of these regulations pass and some of the folks that don't issue comments are the loudest complainers after the regulations so if only there were something they could do about this um yeah so come up with your comments that are you know better than you know we should be skeptical of AI altogether and this is going to kill the trekking industry you know intelligent comments definitely get those out there because now is the time because these we're gonna have to live with these regulations that uh go into play at this point this is your opportunity to participate in the rule making process this is your one and only chance so be sure to do it absolutely so uh before we get started the s San PRM is really focused on levels four and five if you're not familiar with the SAE levels there's level zero all the way up to five and you can look this chart up it gives great detail and this is the chart the SAE chart which is what the FMCSA has been relying upon for the different levels of autonomous operations like I said levels four and five is what the San PRM is focused on level zero through three we see some of these levels already on the road obviously level two is what you're going to see in like the Teslas there's a lot of negative press on level two with the Tesla I mean take that for what it's worth I mean it's uh it's a system that is intelligently designed it may be pushing the limits in certain areas but level two is out on the road at this point we were talking about this beforehand I was surprised to learn that the Tesla autopilot functionality where it's essentially driving the car is still considered a level two on the autonomy chart um I would have thought it would have been at least a three yeah certainly well with with levels two and three there is a human element involved which is why a lot of the autonomous vendors have chosen to to go after level four to take the human element out of it because you can issue as many disclaimers as you want um with level two saying you have to be ready to take over at a second's notice and people are still going to be doing their makeup eating their breakfast falling asleep uh in level two and we see that I mean there's plenty of videos out there where people are rolling down the road in Tesla's dead asleep on the highway so levels four and five just carving out levels four and five the main difference between four and five is operational domain and operational domain is essentially where that technology can operate either geographically or you know what kind of inputs like weather topography things like that level five has no operational domain limitations level four which is what we're seeing Freight movement happening right now we have have autonomous vendors that are moving Freight actively in level four there's limitations on the operational domain I.E you know snow rain those those things coming into play could limit the operational domain and geographically speaking too we have level fours operating in you know Geographic areas I.E like maybe just a certain city has been mapped out by the system and that's the way uh level four typically operates is you know the different autonomous vehicles will go out and map out the terrain map out where merges happen where hazards typically happen and the system is ready to anticipate those in level four and so it's a limitation on the operational domain I don't think enough people realize that we currently have autonomous Trucking going on in the country right now because you'll see a lot of people post online about oh this will never this is never going to be a reality we're always going to have a human driver you know open your eyes because this is going on Jared's I know you've ridden in these vehicles I know we have worked with clients that are right now engaging in commercial operations in level four autonomy uh particularly in the the South uh some with Southwest states they are fully autonomous trucks loaded with cargo moving in this country right now 100 um and like you mentioned the Southwest is is optimal for operational domain because the geography is a little more stable the weather is obviously more stable and so there's less variables that can Muck up the operational domain even Freight aside there's ride sharing Services right now that are 100 percent autonomous at certain cities so if you can get your hands on one of those it's a pretty cool experience I've done it myself it's a little scary at first but it's pretty cool I mean so long story short this is a reality now so this is why in my pers from my perspective at least we need to get a handle on this from a regulatory framework because we are already behind the a ball at this point we need to get something on the books so that we know how we are going to kind of regulate these things I mean I don't think it's any secret to anybody that the the existing Federal Motor care safety regulations which we're always talking about have historically been geared towards there being a human driver in the in the seat of the truck and so there's going to have to be some changes to them to account for the fact or the the fact the reality that there is no longer always going to be a human driver sure and there's there's absolutely a sense of urgency at the agency at this point um that I can sense because the states have started enacting their own laws and so testing is occurring at the state level I mean we know that it's hard to have truly intrastate loads period when you're talking about Freight at this point but a lot of the states are far ahead in allowing testing to occur and allowing driverless testing and driverless movement of freight and so these we're forcing the Dot's hand at this point sure and and maybe that's a good thing not sure but the the agency's trying to catch up with the states which is essentially driving the train at this point yeah so um maybe first thing for first things first here we'll start with a brief timeline of how we got to where we're at now in terms of the rule making process um you know first thing we kind of saw on this front when it comes to autonomous Trucking was an original full request for public comments on potential regulatory barriers to autonomous Trucking this was a request filed or published by the FMCSA back in May of 2018 It ultimately led to a report from the Volpe Center which is a um a center that the FMCSA relies on pretty regularly to do studies and research on complex topics that they're tackling so Volpe ended up issuing a report as part of that initial notice and that's in the docket if you have interested in looking at it you can go search for the Volpe report on barriers to autonomous Trucking in terms of regulations essentially what Volpe was looking at was they were going through all of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations and figuring out what potential revisions we need to make to each of those sections to account for the prospect of of driverless vehicles and so they issued the report there weren't really any surprises from what I could tell in reading that report there it was the the the topics that you would expect would have to be changed to account for uh driverless vehicles but ultimately FMCSA uh then issued an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking an PRM in May of 2019 this kind of kicks off the rule making process we see this it's not always a necessary step in the process we've seen plenty of rulemakings that have just start with start with a proposed rule rather than an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking essentially this advanced notice of proposed rule making concept is usually reserved for the more complex rule-making activity where the FMCSA is essentially soliciting comments from the public to even give them a feel for where they need to go with their regulations in the first place in other words it's kind of an admission that we don't even really know where to steer the ship here where where should we go and and this this step is by far the most complex regulation that we're going to see for a long time even though at this point we're focused on adjusting the regulations to allow for autonomous vehicles and driverless Vehicles it's still going to be a very very complex complex task for sure and it's going to involve multiple agencies this is not just an FMCSA problem obviously it's the ones that immediately come to mind that are going to have to be involved to some extent even just with under under the umbrella of the dot or Nitsa national highway traffic safety administration which is uh you could probably give a better explanation of kind of their scope of jurisdiction sure yeah so Nitsa essentially regulates the manufacturing of vehicles including commercial motor vehicles and they use the safety act as their body of authority and they issue fmvss Motor Vehicle Safety standards on how those vehicles have to be produced to the fmvss and I attended listening session a couple months ago that really focused on nitza's activities in this space and they have tons and tons of studies that are ongoing right now studying autonomous vehicles and how they're going to be regulating them how they're going to be ensuring compliance with the fmvss that are going to drop and there's going to have to be some level of certification for um for these for this technology for sure think about how ELD was handled I mean we had a self-certification on ELD certainly we're not going to have a self-certification on these autonomous vehicles there's going to have to be some level of testing that's uniform and nits is going to have to figure that out I will say that a lot of those studies aren't going to have results tangible results for maybe two years three years out from now so while nitz is very very busy right now there's not going to be findings from a lot of those studies until a couple years from now yeah I think all we have now from Nitsa is what's called a general standing order or something to that effect where it's essentially a mandate that any manufacturers of autonomous vehicles report certain accidents involving their technology yeah that's all manufacturers so any manufacturer that has level one through three on their vehicles if there's a crash say that has some autonomous operations level one or two involved that has to be reported under this sgo and so there Gathering all this information at this point the the levels one through two that I tend to think of and correct me if I'm wrong but it's things like adaptive cruise control and Lane departure correction stuff like that yeah so it's driver assistance technology largely so these are things we have on most of a lot of our commercial motor vehicles and personal vehicles sure so it's driver assistance Technologies essentially okay and and I guess I'll say going back to kind of knits's role in this I mean I think most of our clients and our audience here Motor Carrier clients they probably don't have a whole lot of run-ins with Nitsa on a kind of day-to-day basis so they may not even know but um you know Nitsa has a big role to play in in how we enforce our current Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations if you look in part 393 I think the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations they essentially adopt all of nitza's Motor Vehicle Safety standards and incorporate them by reference into the safety regulations which is to say that if you're a motor carrier Opera rating a commercial motor vehicle you have a legal obligation to make sure that your trucks comply with those Vehicle Safety standards in other words you can't be messing with placements of lights and stuff like that on your truck and expect to get away with it you are whether you know it or not subject to those Vehicle Safety standards that normally apply to vehicle manufacturers because the FMCSA has adopted them by reference and I expect that we will see something similar when it comes to autonomous Trucking regulations that are ultimately promulgated by nitsum certainly so that took us to the anprm back in May of 2019 I was looking at the docket today I was surprised to see that there were only 181 total comments submitted to that initial amprm which may explain why we haven't seen any activity on it since 2019 also we've had an administrative Administration change in the interim now we're under the Biden Administration so long story short there wasn't much common activity to that first one so that took us to uh where we are just last week with uh was it last week no it was in Janu January January of 2023. um FMCSA comes out with its supplemental advanced notice of proposed rule making essay in PRM and that's where we are currently that's what we are uh talking about today and with the an program 181 comments is not much I'll definitely give you that it could be a sense of you know where do we even go from here a lot of people may have been frozen in the industry like this is not happening anytime soon um you know why comment on this it's confusing anyways but this San PRM we're going to walk through some of these uh comments from the agency that they're soliciting comments for and they're not that complicated as long as you understand some of the basic concepts and where they're trying to go uh this San PRM I think is more digestible than the Ampere was but if you just even compare it to like the ELD rule making how many comments that docket received we're talking tens of thousands of comments to the ELD um rulemaking versus 181 for the initial stab at autonomous Trucking so hopefully we'll see some more here with the San PRN but let's just run through there's essentially three main points or three main topics that the FMCSA is soliciting comments from the public so let's just run through those one after the other we'll start first with the kind of the general topic is notification of ads activity yeah so there's 1.1 through 1.5 and essentially the FMCSA is trying to get their hands around what kind of information they should be gathering what kind of gatekeeping they should be doing and 1.2 was pretty fascinating to me I'll jump right to that one and it essentially gets to the point of of how are you as a motor carrier going to be vetted in a way to run an interstate commerce with are we going to are we going to let everybody do this or no is that a bad idea the language that I found was pretty interesting and 1.2 was whether or not you have appropriate Safety Management controls in place and that's kind of magic language that you see during compliance reviews or Audits and that made me think are we going to go to a point where we have almost like a new entrant DOT audit for those motor carriers that want to use autonomous technology ie45 in Commerce yeah that's something I hadn't thought of are we going to say that only satisfactory rated carriers can operate autonomous trucks and if so does that mean that in order to fit into that group you have to maybe volunteer for essentially some kind of a new internet audit because right now the only way you get a safety rating is through a compliance review and so there's lots of carriers most of the carriers out there don't even have a safety rating so how is the F if the FMCSA is asking us hey should we only allow certain categories of carriers namely those that have effective Safety Management controls in place to operate autonomous trucks well The Logical conclusion to that is there has to be some way or some Metric that we're using as the cut off and maybe that safety ratings maybe it's CSA scores that's essentially what FMCSA is getting at here and and the sentiment is somewhat logical if you can't Hall Freight with physical drivers and have Safety Management controls in place in traditional Trucking that would cause a lot of hesitant hesitancy with the agency and allowing you to operate autonomous vehicles under the manufacturer specifications if you can't do traditional Trucking with Safety Management controls in place so that's that's one that I would definitely want to comment on um in make sure that we don't end up with a new entrant audit type of situation that's evaluating Safety Management controls I could have negative impacts on carriers that just want to get into this space because it's just setting up another wall yeah I think obviously it makes sense to me that if we're gonna you know FMCSA is charged with making sure that commercial trucks and buses on the roads are safe and if we're talking about putting driverless trucks out on the road which you are then we would want presumably the FMCSA to at least know that it's happening so I think that's kind of the takeaway from this first set of questions is how how is it that we should modify the regulations to ensure that FMCSA has visibility into who out there is actually operating these trucks that's kind of the the takeaway from this first set and then taking it slightly to the next step is once we know about it is there a certain safety cutoffs that we should Implement to only allow the safest motor carriers in the country to operate these types of trucks and then the threshold question on this notification issue is whether or not you should have to notice the FMCSA in the first place if you're going to be operating in interstate commerce without a driver in the seat and and that's the information that the FMCSA I believe is absolutely going to want to get their hands on what carriers are doing this how many are doing it without a driver now does that mean if you have a safety driver in the driving position ready to take over that you're not going to be reporting that's something that's going to have to be fleshed out in the comments in the regulation I kind of view this one as a no-brainer it seems like we should all get behind the idea of notifying the FMCSA that we're going to engage in driverless operations I would I would think I would agree with that but I haven't seen a lot of vendors doing that actually moving Freight in Commerce on public roads without a driver in this position yeah just ready to take over because like I said before these it's level four that's being operated in Commerce right now and if if the AV if the brain of the AV senses anything outside of operational domain or anything that's questionable it it forces the driver to take over at that point and that's it doesn't have to be that way but that's the way that it is for many of the vendors that are testing at this point and moving Freight they still have that driver so from a cost standpoint you're not getting rid of the driver at this point you're you're strictly testing but you're generating Revenue by hauling Freight so it's it's the safe way to do it yeah I kind of view this similar to what we do with our current registration process just for normal motor carriers non-autonomous where you know through the MCS 150 that you filed a first Regis register to get a DOT number and then with your periodic updates you're answering questions to the FMCSA about what type of freight you're hauling so I kind of view it as almost just another question on your MCS 150 are you engaged in autonomous Trucking or not and and maybe you say yes and that's that's the end of it I'm that's one option I suppose when it comes to this notice requirement yeah I think that makes a lot of sense to do it that way all right is that it for this first group here yeah there was a couple of confusing kind of questions 1.4 and 1.5 asking about I think the perception of how many ads equipped commercial Motor Vehicles are going to be out there um and what size the population will be in 10 years maybe that's just strictly folks opinions in the industry on how that might look yeah smarter people than us can forecast how many driverless trucks we can expect uh okay let's move on then to the second big category of three categories that the FMCSA is soliciting comments on and this has to do with the regulation of so-called remote assistance what are remote assistance yeah that that's an interesting interesting one there remote assistance I mean I kind of think of them as kind of the air traffic controllers for the AVS they're defined in the A and PRM as a human who provides remote information or advice to an ads equipped vehicle in driverless operation in order to facilitate trip continuation when the ads encounters a situation it cannot manage and most of the time like I said you you have that driver in the seat in level four at this point that's going to take over whenever you have a whenever the AV encounters a problem that's outside operational domain and it needs a driver to take over well in the long run we're going to see levels four and five where we have a remote assistance and they're going to be interacting with law enforcement they're going to be making sure the vehicle gets off to the side of the road if it encounters a problem then it can't handle and that's typically how the vehicles work in the first place if you see them on a test track and they and they purposefully encounter a problem that's outside of operational domain the vehicle will automatically default to getting off the road safely and get to a point where that issue that prevents operational domain is no longer in place that's its Fail-Safe is yes to get off the side of the road and and the remote assistance I think are going to be involved in ensuring that that is also the case so these are distinct from remote drivers right it looked like the a the San PRM kind of Drew a distinction between remote drivers and remote assistance and I thought it was interesting you know remote drivers it kind of talks about them as being almost like operating the controls of a remote remote control toy car where you are actually physically manipulating the throttle you're manipulating turn signals stuff like that but what this notice seems to be focused on are remote assistance folks who are somehow involved in the process but not taking control of the vehicle throttle and and turning and stuff like that right so in in testing environments right now that I've observed it's like I said it's that driver in the seat as the Fail-Safe and then you also have a technician um some kind of engineer uh that's that's monitoring the brain of the AV that's sitting in the passenger seat that's probably going to be the look of the remote assistant but in an off-site location so they may be responsible for a handful of different AVS in the Diagnostics making sure those Diagnostics are continuing to feed into the back office and the the commercial Motor Vehicles reporting appropriately Let's see we got a comment here Mike says human drivers must be trained tested and licensed the same should hold true for autonomous commercial Motor Vehicles via some regulatory processes I I generally agree with that sentiment and I expect we will have something to that effect especially when we start talking about these remote assistance because it looks like FMCSA is kind of resting on what it knows best when it asks some of these questions because it's asking things like to what extent should our existing regulatory scheme on things like hours of service and drug and alcohol testing things that apply to traditional drivers to what extent should we graph those Concepts onto these remote assistance yeah I would generally agree with the comment as well to the extent that remote assistance would be responsible for actually operating a commercial motor vehicle that's outside of Av status so once it goes out of Av mode and that remote assistant may be responsible for operating that commercial motor vehicle on a public roadway then I would I would think that those driving standards should apply as they do to CMV drivers but if the remote assistant's not actually going to be tasked with operating the CMV on a public road yeah I think we'd be doing a disservice to this whole process by requiring them to have CDLs go through the same qualifications have the hours of service restrictions it just didn't make a whole lot of sense when you try and graph that onto these assistants and then if if they're responsible for potentially taking over the truck um in in operating in Commerce then how many of these remote assistants can cover a certain Fleet of trucks maybe maybe they're going to be covering five trucks as remote assistance but if they have to take over two trucks at once it's obviously not possible and so you get yourself into muddy water really really quick so that is one of the questions right is if should we place a limit on the number of trucks that a remote assistant should be responsible for overseeing something to that effect and I think that does make sense absolutely there's there's got to be a limitation on that otherwise you could have one remote assistant because let's be honest this is going to get rid of hours of service and the new hours of service is going to be Diagnostics and maintenance which we're going to touch on here a little bit but the Temptation is to run for eight 24 7 if you can and the other temptation is to have one remote assistant with as many trucks that it's responsible for at once which is going to get us into a dangerous situation for sure it's a whole new set of concerns that we haven't really had to think about in the past versus the other side of this which is FMCSA asking should we apply some of our traditional rule set to these assistants like for the reasons we've already said I just don't think that makes a whole lot of sense it makes a heck of a lot more sense when we're talking about remote drivers who are actually physically controlling the vehicles for the same reason we don't want fatigued drivers behind the wheel of the truck we presumably don't want fatigued remote drivers who are physically driving them potentially remotely from a remote location so and also kind of the CDL requirements too I imagine we want some kind of similar construct when it comes to regulations for remote drivers but I think the construct for remote assistance who are not going to be physically controlling the vehicles has to change dramatically it doesn't make sense to me to graft what we have currently onto remote assistance yeah this section of the San PRM clarifies that the remote assistant who is not going to be expected to take control of the dynamic driving task of the ads equipped CMV operating at level four so we're talking about remote assistance that are not going to be expected to operate the commercial motor vehicle so in my mind I certainly don't feel like the same requirements should apply to CDL drivers that apply to these remote assistants that's just me it just seems like we're shooting ourselves in the foot before this thing even gets off the ground you're going to get all kinds of blowback and negative comments from all the drivers out there that's that's all right bring it on Jared said Jared said that not me and it's not going to kill the trucking industry you know the the operational domain is limited um I I just don't think the application is going to be great for short haul it's not going to be great for urban driving where you're doing deliveries and things like that how could it uh take over the trucking industry at this point at this stage I think it's going to be medium segments Long Haul segments with defined corridors for the these AVS are going to be areas where this is just optimal and that's I think that's where we're going to see it initially Jared's email for any hate mail here is uh okay anything else here on remote assistance that we haven't hit on yet see one one interesting thing too is who's going to be responsible for these remote assistance is it going to be the AV vendor the AV company are they going to be the ones that are responsible for putting these remote assistance over certain fleets is it going to be the motor carrier that has to train these remote assistants based on the AV technology I mean that's another area that's really really interesting because it seems like there's going to be a lot of special knowledge that's required of these remote assistants that's something we don't have a whole lot of this is another area that's kind of um novel to our how we've kind of traditionally regulated Motor Carrier operations we don't have a situation now that I can think of off the top of my head where we have motor carriers relying so heavily on manufacturers to kind of um you know Steer the ship on certain on certain things whereas you're exactly right I anticipate that when it comes to autonomous trucks we're going to be relying the motor carriers are going to be relying very heavily on the manufacturers of that technology to help them in the at least in the implementation of this and so you may have a situation where these remote assistants are completely outsourced from the motor carrier and so if that's the case I think FMCSA is going to have to figure out where it gets jurisdiction to regulate those uh those remote assistance I don't think that that has been um really kind of played out here in this San PRM and and if I'm a motor carrier that wants to get into AVS and wants to Hall Freight with AVS I want no part of this remote assistant business because I want because it's really going to turn on product liability when you have a crash with an AV you know if it was operating within the operational domain and got in a crash well that's product liability that's not motor carriers fault necessarily and so if I'm a motor carrier I want to step back from anything involved with this remote assistant to say well that's up to the AV vendor honestly arm's length here it's kind of similar to how it would play out in a product's liability case involving a vehicle component now I mean we could still have those types of lawsuits now where a large truck gets involved in a catastrophic accident and it's alleged that it wasn't necessarily the driver's fault that caused it something failed on the vehicle itself and so we get wrapped up into a product's liability type lawsuit against the manufacturer of that vehicle so yeah presumably it could play out even more likely to play out in that type of lawsuit when it comes to autonomous Trucking that's another one of those topics that I'd love to do a show on and have a really experienced Highway accident litigator come on and talk about where this might morph into we got to find someone that's comfortable doing that yeah for sure all right let's then uh talk about the last big group of questions that the FMCSA is asking in this San PRM which has to do and I think this is the biggest topic of them all needless to say it has to do with vehicle inspection and maintenance yeah so I mean essentially the FMCSA is trying to get to the point of what additional requirements are there going to have to be for pre-trip inspections and mechanical and ads components like how how are we going to do a pre-trip on this AV and how in-depth should that be because we have a lot of those physical requirements where you really do need a driver to walk around and look at tire tread depth look at brake lines things like that that you can't necessarily get a diagnostic on tire tread depth that I'm aware of but maybe I'm wrong on that there's going to be physical pre-trip inspection requirements in addition to ads requirements I'm sure there's some kind of lasers they can shoot into the tire tread depth and figure out what it's at at any given moment you work on that that's a good idea put that in our notebook for something to consider now we have this conversation a while back I think it's an interesting one where you know number one with autonomous trucks we've talked about how vehicle maintenance and inspection becomes the main category of regulated conduct where traditionally it has been driver related obviously we have vehicle maintenance regulations now but that is just one of many existing regulatory parts that we deal with including a very driver focused driver-centric uh body of laws hours of service drug and alcohol testing driver qualification those have been a big Focus but now those kind of slip away and now we're left with vehicle maintenance and inspection becoming the big one and uh yeah we've had those conversations about how does this play out especially when it comes to things like pre-trip inspections and also just roadside inspections with interactions with law enforcement so I think that's what generally speaking these particular questions have to do with yeah and and cvsa has been on top of the issue of inspecting um AVS for some time they've been talking about it for I want to say years um how do you issue an inspection bulletin on an AV and at this point you know just like just like we had in like 2016-17 like long time ago whenever we had a vehicle that rolled through um a shack that had an ELD on it a lot of enforcement would say well that's Anil D I don't know how to do that I'm not going to do that and so it's the same effect that we have now with AVS in a lot of cases they see the AV Equipment and they're not um they're not jumping at the chance to inspect that vehicle for obvious reasons it's going to get really complicated really quick but cbsa issues all those inspection bulletins and they're working on the best way for enforcement to go about inspecting these AVS I think one of the questions FMCSA is posing is whether because I as I understand it cvsa already has some kind of document out on this I don't know if it's an inspection bulletin or what but FMC has say is seeking comments from the public on the sufficiency of that cvsa document that's one of the questions in there and then I think the other big one here in this topic is a good point that we need to be considering which is this idea that unlike traditional commercial Motor Vehicles which are somewhat Limited in their ability to operate both by you know the driver's hours of service and stuff like that we're just not going to have that with autonomous trucks where it's theoretical or theoretically they could just be operating non-stop 24 7. obviously they'd have to stop to get fuel or well not even all the time if we're talking about electric vehicles but stopping to be recharged or whatever it happens to be but theoretically they could be operating a lot longer for a lot longer periods of time than traditional commercial Motor Vehicles so because of that do we need to consider more stringent inspection and maintenance requirements than what we have currently like for example under the current regulatory scheme motor carriers have an obligation to make sure that all of their commercial Motor Vehicles are receiving annual inspection do we need to do something more than that for these types of autonomous trucks yeah the this piece of vehicle inspection and maintenance is really has a lot of focus on Cadence of the the maintenance because a lot of motor carriers now will do like say a 90-day preventative maintenance schedule well in 90 days one of these AVS that can run almost non-stop is going to put on a lot more miles than a 90-day vehicle that's subject to hours of service Etc so the Cadence of special maintenance and special Diagnostics is going to have to be figured out for sure and that's that's going to be something that's very interesting to see play out I will say that a lot of the data points that are going to come from the AVS while the av's rolling down the road I mean it's just constant Diagnostics running on these AVS it's really interesting all the data points that are being gathered anything that is automated like transmission fluid temperature things like that it's a diagnostic that's coming through the system at all times pressure tire pressure stuff like that so that's kind of another interesting concept under this topic asking the public to weigh in on whether and to what extent we should be requiring motor carriers or their technology partner to transmit that data about the Diagnostics of the vehicle to law enforcement whether it's when they're passing away station do we because we we saw FMCSA come out with this notice last year about whether we should be doing that as a matter of course just for regular operations should we be requiring that they be equipped with transponders that communicate information about their truck ahead to law enforcement so that we know whether to stop that truck or not not this is taking in the next step which is do we need to be requiring these autonomous trucks to wirelessly transmit diagnostic data to law enforcement so that we can get it pulled over if it turns out that there's something wrong with the truck and it hasn't stopped for whatever reason yep it's it's interesting and the actual physical operations will be interesting too to see how motor carriers adapt to this because like we kind of touched on there's going to be a physical pre-trip inspection element that can't go away necessarily and so you know is it going to be a situation like if you're pulling out of a port you know there's these inspection Bays where drivers stop and do their inspection on the vehicles before they take off with their container and are we going to have Motor Carrier facilities that have these inspection areas where a truck will pull up an AV will pull up before it goes off into into Commerce and gets a physical inspection all those physical inspection components from someone at the motor carrier that's qualified to do that and the Diagnostics are doing their thing as well that kind of brings that same question that we talked about earlier which is who's going to be is that going to be a carrier employee that's doing that or more likely are they going to be Outsourcing that to somebody who's who's there that could do that and if that's going to be the case if we're going to be Outsourcing the pre-trip inspections uh then how do we regulate that because the mo the FMCSA from its perspective is regulating the motor carrier so I think that's something that will have to be addressed and then also another big part of this section of the San PRM is do we need to add additional components to the list of components that have to be inspected in a pre-trip inspection the obvious answer is yes because these vehicles are going to be equipped with technology that traditional vehicles are not so yeah there's like we said there's going to be this component of technical knowledge that's required and that individual that conducts that inspection that portion of the inspection may be provided by the vendor and then we may have a physical inspection that occurs and that individual could certainly be provided by the motor care area that has the ability to do the pre-trip inspections at this point yeah because I think it goes without saying that we want somebody taking a look at the sensors that we're relying so heavily on before the vehicle starts to operate to make sure that they're good to go so yeah these are the things that have to be commented on at this point because the regulations are going to come out and we're gonna have to live with them going forward so yeah for sure all right so that kind of wraps up I think um the three main areas of focus in the fmcsa's snrm yikes um so as we said at the start make sure if you've got thoughts on these that you go get your voice heard by submitting comments as Jared said we're going to continue to dig into these issues we're going to probably have a series of truck safe live episodes on this topic as Jared said love to get a highway accident litigator in here to talk about that aspect of it we'd love to get motor carriers who are starting to roll out this technology on here drivers Safety Drivers we've already had some of those conversations so there's a lot to talk about for sure and and we're going to keep hitting on these topics and if you have topics that you think would be great for us to address and bring someone on please email us drop a comment we'd love to hear about those because there's just so many topics so many directions that this can go we'd love to just find those experts that we can bring on the show and pick their brain and talk to them to the extent they're comfortable doing that yeah for sure all right so that's going to wrap up today's episode appreciate everyone being here with us a few things to wrap up here we mentioned some of the things that we've got going on at truck safe earlier one last thing I'll mention kind of as always is our online D.O.T compliance courses we've got several courses now that are available we've got our safety manager course which covers pretty much all aspects of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations everything again that it takes to effectively manage a DOT compliance program we've got a reasonable suspicion course for folks who are charged with kind of managing a drug and alcohol testing program that's a required training we've got a Hazmat course we just did an article today on the website about required Hazmat training that's one of the courses that we offer through our truck safe Academy so if you're interested in either yourself or any of your team members kind of going through online training on these types of D.O.T compliance topics be sure to check those out over at trucksafeacademy.com and then the last thing I'll mention is make sure to subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com if you're interested in getting the latest Highway Transportation news and Analysis right to your inbox lastly thanks again to log Rock for sponsoring this season of truck safe live really appreciate you teaming up with us and making this possible anything else put your comments together check out that essay in PRM it's not that big of a lift check it out issue those comments and if you have any questions or issues for us just reach out all right that's it see you guys thanks

Event Completed

Tuesday, February 21, 2023 at 6:13 PM EST

Watch on YouTube