Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 20 - Combatting the Reptiles Redux

Wednesday, April 12, 2023 at 8:10 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 20 - Combatting the Reptiles Redux

About This Event

The team at Trucksafe is joined by Alix Miller, President and CEO of the Florida Trucking Association, and Bill Kanasky Jr., Ph.D, Senior VP of Courtroom Sciences to discuss ways carriers are fighting back against the so-called reptile theory and lawsuit abuse leading to a huge uptick in nuclear verdicts. We address Florida’s recently-passed HB 837 tort reform legislation and proper witness preparation.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

Episode 20 of Trucksafe LIVE! revisits the topic of nuclear verdicts and reptile theory litigation, exploring how the trucking industry is fighting back through tort reform and proactive litigation preparation. Host Brandon Wiseman is joined by two guests — Alix Miller, President and CEO of the Florida Trucking Association, and Dr. Bill Knasky, Vice President of Courtroom Sciences — to examine recent legislative developments in Florida and offer practical guidance for motor carriers navigating an increasingly hostile legal landscape. Miller discusses Florida's newly signed House Bill 837, described by Governor DeSantis as the most significant tort reform legislation in the state's history. Miller explains that the bill addresses several long-standing issues that have made Florida particularly difficult for trucking companies, including inflated or "phantom" medical damages, a shift from pure to modified comparative negligence (barring recovery when a plaintiff is more than 50 percent at fault), and a reduction in the statute of limitations for negligence cases from four to two years. Miller emphasizes that tort reform is not about denying legitimate compensation to injured parties, but about eliminating abuses such as wildly inflated damage awards that bear no relationship to actual losses sustained. He credits a coalition approach and a favorable Florida Supreme Court ruling in Dial v. Colusa Palms as key factors in moving the legislation forward swiftly and intact. Dr. Bill Knasky offers a deep dive into the reptile theory of litigation, explaining that despite its pseudoscientific framing, it functions primarily as an aggressive plaintiff strategy designed to destroy key defense witnesses during deposition and leverage early, outsized settlements. He identifies two major failure modes in witness testimony — poor listening and cognition habits that lead to inaccurate answers, and fight-or-flight emotional responses that cause witnesses to become argumentative, evasive, or overly talkative under pressure. Knasky notes that the psychological pressure of reptile tactics is aimed less at jurors and more at creating friction between trucking company owners, defense counsel, and insurance claims specialists, ultimately forcing unfavorable settlements. Fleet safety professionals should take several actionable steps away from this episode. First, companies should audit their websites and internal policies and procedures to remove idealistic safety language — such as "safety is our number one priority" — that plaintiff attorneys routinely use as a basis for cross-examination. Second, key witnesses including corporate representatives, safety directors, drivers, and HR personnel should receive professional training before any litigation arises, not after. Third, when an accident occurs, companies should engage immediately with their insurance company and defense counsel rather than taking a reactive, wait-and-see approach. As Knasky puts it, "have your plan well before a lawsuit's filed," comparing litigation preparedness to hurricane readiness — proactive planning dramatically changes both the strategic and financial outcome of a case. The episode also touches on several broader industry developments, including FMCSA's announced expansion of its Crash Preventability Determination Program to accept a wider range of accident types, and proposed changes to the Safety Measurement System that represent the first significant revisions to CSA scoring since 2010. Fleet operators are encouraged to review their scores on FMCSA's preview site and submit comments before the mid-May deadline if the proposed changes appear to negatively impact their scores.

Full Transcript

darling whether it's true all the things always together today I'm way too long time you through the night when I thought I was done you screamed to come I wonder what I am chasing Jesus it's not even fun anymore foreign thank you thank you thank you this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign hey everyone welcome to episode 20 of trucksafe live the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon truck safe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs uh it's been a busy week busy month I should say thus far for us at truck safe a lot of travel Spring Break um and then Jared and I just got back from the American Trucking association's sshr conference in Minneapolis we had the opportunity to talk about minimizing exposure through driver qualification seems to be a pretty popular topic uh recently so I had a good time there met a lot of great people um glad to be home and so uh excited about today's show it's one that's been in the making for a few weeks now a lot of build up to a lot of folks uh telling us that they are particularly into interested to hear about this topic so I'm really excited to have on a couple of great guests to talk to us about combating the reptiles you may recall if you've watched our prior shows we did a similar topic episode 13 I think it was last year where we had on Steve Bryan of blue wire to talk about how fleets are using technology to combat the so-called reptile theory of litigation and to protect themselves against nuclear verdicts and uh and it was great discussion with Steve always great talking with Steve and and seeing what he's got going on um but we thought it was the a perfect time to revisit this topic in light of some recent developments um particularly in Florida with Florida's tort reform that was just recently signed by Governor DeSantis so I'm looking forward to talking about that today with our guest before we get there a few things going on at truck safe and then in the industry truck safe we've got an even busier month to come so this uh coming up next week actually April 19th and 20th we are having our truck say Fleet compliance boot camp in uh like I said in Indianapolis it's going to be a two-day conference where we are going to spend a lot of time talking about DOT compliance topics and how to build out a Cutting Edge safety program if you are a safety director or safety manager or someone who is responsible for managing the compliance of your Fleet we're going to spend a lot of time talking about those topics that are pertinent to to your day-to-day tasks and we got a couple spots left so we're trying to limit that to a small group of of 25 or so we got just a couple spots left coming up next week if you're in town if you're going to be if you're close by or you're interested in in attending be sure to check out trucksafebootcamp.com you can see all the details there you can register and hopefully we will see you there so that's next week um something else we've always got kind of going on in the background is our truck safe compliance network if you haven't heard of this I'd encourage you to check it out we have a uh whoops that was the wrong button we have a an app in the app store where the Google Play Store where you can join the truck safe compliance Network this is free to join this is a resource that we have available to uh to fleets against safety professionals those that that need to know kind of the nitty-gritty of dot safety regulations this is a social network for safety professionals to gather together ask questions of one another answer questions for other other folks and it's also how we distribute a bunch of our DOT related content including Network exclusive webinars that we're trying to do on a monthly basis so if you haven't checked that out check it out trucksafenetwork.com or download the app on the app store or the Google Play Store uh enough about us let's talk about a couple of things that are going in on in the industry that are worth noting before we jump into today's topic most notably today FMCSA published a notice uh regarding its crash preventability determination determination program uh we sent out uh an email blast on this this is kind of breaking news it's um it's important news we've got an article about it on our website if you want to check that out go to trucksafe.com it's our most recent article the crash preventability determination program if you're not familiar with it is the way that regulated motor carriers can can essentially request that the FMCSA review the preventability of the accidents that get put on the motor carriers safety measurement system account and if the agency determines that it's non-preventable on the carrier's driver's part then that accident does not weigh on the motor carrier score anymore and it improves their their crash indicator score so it's a very important uh for that reason the the program itself has only been around for a few years now I think 2020 is when it was first stood up one of the criticisms about the program over the years has has been how narrow it is um it started out as a pilot program and uh and has grown a little bit since that time but right now the system is set up so that it only accepts certain types of accidents as eligible for a preventability determination and it only accepts those specific I think there are 16 types of accidents that are eligible for a preventability determination program if it doesn't meet that eligibility guide then it's not even going to be you can't even submit the request and get it reviewed the reason that the agency did that was because especially when it was just a pilot program they wanted to make sure that they were looking at accidents that were very clear or very easy to tell whose fault it was and so they picked the accident types that are the that are usually uh the most clear when it comes to who's at fault for that accident and those are the types of accidents that they have accepted into the program and have determined or are either preventable or non-preventable even despite that the the narrowness of the program I think they said in their notice this morning that since 2020 they had received well over 35 000 submissions through the program for preventability determinations over that three-year time period And I think they said that of those approximately 40 000 that they received uh 75 percent or so of them were deemed to be eligible for the program and then of those 75 percent that they reviewed in the program like 96 percent of them were determined to be not the the fault of the commercial driver they were determined to be um to be non-preventable on the commercial driver's part and so that's a lot of accidents coming off of those Motors carrier scores so again that just another reason why this is such an important program uh all that is to say FMCSA this morning said that they are going to broaden the program and allow more accident types to qualify as eligible for preventability consideration which is great news this is something that folks have been complaining about for a long time be included trying to broaden that program so that we can can push more data into it and hopefully get accidents that are not our driver's fault taken off of our scores and therefore improve our scores so again if you haven't seen that be sure to check out our article on the topic at trucksafe.com uh what else is going on in the industry I should have mentioned as we go along here um if you're here with us uh say hey in the comments so that we know you're here and as we go along if you've got questions or you've got comments on whatever we're talking about throw them in the comments and we'll bring them up on screen uh good to see all of you here um one other thing kind of going on in the industry that's worth mentioning is the fmcsa's proposed changes to its safety measurement system um this happened probably about a month or so ago this was big news at the time so clearly the FMCSA is kind of ramping up it's it's uh it's regulatory work here and those proposed changes to the safety measurement system are are very significant we did a full breakdown of this on a prior episode of truck safe live we've got an article on the topic on our website it's essentially the first would be the first substantial revisions to CSA scores since CSA was first implemented back in 2010 so big news there worth looking into the FMCSA has been holding some listening sessions on the topic over the last few weeks or so I've attended a couple of those so make sure you understand what what is changing there because it could have pretty significant impacts to your CSA scores um FMCSA last thing I'll say about it is the agency has a preview site set up for those changes right now so if you want to see how your scores are going to be impacted by these proposed changes you can log into your account right now and see exactly how your scores are going to change make sure you do that because the comment period for those changes closes in mid-may I believe so if you go in there and you're seeing something screwy with your scores because of the changes make sure you file your comments with the agency so they so they uh so they are aware of the problems that you're seeing and they can fix them before before they push this out in a final form I don't expect that will happen until later this year at the earliest if not if not then it'll probably be next year but we'll see check that out if you haven't already um let's see here I think that is it let's um let's talk about the topic of today's show again I'm excited about it um today we are like I said we're taking a slight Twist on that topic that we've already discussed not only in that episode 13 our very first episode of truck safe live was all about nuclear verdicts in ways that the industry is fighting back back against these types of cases including through tort reform like I said we're excited to have a couple of guests with us who are working tirelessly to help motor carriers minimize their risk to these types of verdicts first up we have Alex Miller president and CEO of the Florida Trucking Association welcome Alex thanks for having me on hey thanks so much for joining me really appreciate you uh taking the time to speak with us today I know you've been pretty busy here over the last couple of weeks so thanks so much for for taking the time hey my pleasure excellent so to get things kind of started here I wondered if um for folks who aren't part of the Florida Trucking Association may not be familiar with you can you give us a little bit of your background how you got into the trucking industry to begin with well I have a background in Communications and legislative affairs so in a lot of ways Trucking found me uh this was a this was a job opening several years ago where those two skills were kind of in need they were looking for a position to be filled and it was the vice president position so I started out and learned all I could about Trucking uh and so then I guess five years later became the president and CEO there's a lot that goes into Trucking as I'm sure you've uh become painfully familiar with especially on the legislative and Regulatory front and that's kind of why we wanted to talk with you especially in light of recent developments in Florida particularly before we dive into exactly what has happened within the last few weeks here can you kind of give us a sense of generally for folks who may not be who who may not be operating in Florida or in that area of the country what the trucking landscape is like in Florida for those who may be curious Florida is a is a pretty tough state to do business in for Trucking uh we're not a drive-through State we have a lot of challenges when it comes to our geography and our population uh you know we I think last year the record number of 137 million tourists visited Florida we have a thousand people moving here A Day In the state and that's a lot of retirees and then obviously with tourists first of all a lot of people who are not familiar with our roads but also people who are consuming a lot of things and not manufacturing so we really require the Lion's Share of freight to come into Florida and it's pretty inefficient to deliver it and to get back out of the state for example you know you're coming from North Carolina or Georgia and delivering down to Miami it's a full day just to leave so um and and most of the time when you're leaving Florida you're leaving um you're deadheading or uh you know leaving you know empty so uh it we we really do have a lot of challenges and not to mention hurricanes and our wonderful ports who you know obviously require a lot of trucks as well yeah and count me as one of those tourists I you uh I was honored to have uh to be at your safety Summit Florida Trucking Association safety Summit earlier this year brought my family down and uh did the whole Disney World thing uh had a lot of fun doing that but I can imagine you know with that being such a big part of uh of the economy down there that passenger Transportation plays a big part uh when it comes to to Florida which uh really raises the stakes um uh preaching to the choir here but when you're transporting loads busloads of of passengers that that really causes some uh or create some unique exposure for sure um I want to talk about you know as we get into talking about tort reform um you mentioned kind of Florida's challenges from the trucking industry at large but why has Florida in your view become such a problematic state for Highway accident litigation involving large trucks and buses what about Florida's judicial system has made cases like the we'll talk about I'm sure the recent one billion dollar jury verdict case um what what has set up that type of possibility in Florida well I think the system has gone largely unchecked for more than 20 years in Florida trial attorneys have really run the show and if you are a visitor in in Florida uh driving on I-95 I-75 I-4 I-10 you're inundated with these Billboards you know with with um some of the biggest names and the biggest law firms are based in Florida advertising uh you know truck accidents and what they can do for you legislatively and even the Supreme Court or state supreme court in the past it has always been um really leaning towards the tri The Trial Bar versus defendants or small business yeah I take it then that you probably have some billboard hammers down in Florida we've got the hammer here in in Indiana that you can't drive five miles without seeing at least five of of his Billboards so yeah so um with that in mind um can you tell us about HB House Bill 837 in that legislation and kind of set that up for us what is it uh and what happened with it here within the last few weeks sure so the governor is has touted it as the most historic and biggest tort reform legislation in the history of the state and it really it incorporates seven or eight major issues uh across most Industries uh you know it includes modifications to bad faith for insurance contingency fee multipliers one-way attorney fees uh uh premises liability which is becoming another big issue of kind of Apartments lawsuits but for for Trucking we we set out years ago to kind of develop a priority list of the things that would move the needle the most for Trucking at large um and we identified a few key things which all get got into the bill the first one is transparency of medical damages or to combat those inflated medical damages and also level the playing field when it comes to the evidence that plaintiffs and defendants are allowed to submit and for the jury to see uh we also have modified our comparative negative negligence system Florida has been a pure comparative negligence system meaning that if you're one percent at fault you could be awarded that one percent and I always say there's a there's a law firm in Tallahassee that actually played an ad during legislative session shame on them saying that if if you're only if you are 90 at fault don't worry we'll make a windfall out of that 10 percent so now we are going to be if if a plaintiff is more than 50 at faults they no longer can recover damages and then the third is also uh changing our statute of limitations for negligence cases from four years to two years yeah I think that compared to fall uh scheme most a lot of folks aren't familiar with it but every state kind of handles it a little bit differently um you've got you like like you mentioned Alex you got Pure comparative fault States some states will say that uh if a plaintiff is injured or or it is killed in a highway accident and they bring suit against somebody else as long as they can establish that that other party is is one percent at fault they are still entitled to recover damages that equal one percent of whatever the jury ultimately Awards and that I mean it could be huge it sounds kind of comical saying it that way but if you got a billion dollar jury verdict and and they're looking at recovering one percent it was it's still a huge problem so the move to a um a modified comparative fault which a lot of States also have um I I think is a good move and I think it should cut down on some of that abuse that we're seeing because like you said what it does is essentially says that uh you got to be 51 at fault or more before we're going to Levy damages against you so uh yeah I think that's a huge move so I'm curious how did the how did the Florida Trucking Association what was its role in this process of getting the the legislation across the finish line here well we were really um one of the leading faces on it along with other kind of members of a coalition we really you know across the board industries in Florida for you know 5 15 20 years have been trying to change things and improve uh the the climate the legal climate in Florida mostly to no avail and you know FTA has been involved in trying to get bills fire filed for years I think one of the one of the key issues for us or moments of change was we we had filed a couple of um amicus briefs with the Florida Supreme Court the first one was summary judgments but the second more important one that we also received a favorable opinion on was what's known as dial versus Colusa palms and this was about paid medical damages and it brought attention to the Supreme Court Justices of these Phantom damages and that the jury would not be hearing about paid damages that we paid presently and in the future therefore a verdict is wildly out of line with what that plaintiff is actually going to be paying for so this really set us up a couple of years ago when we really kind of hunkered down on this and this um as a priority for the association of taking this kind of judicial win and bringing it to legislators of this has been a ruling this is kind of where it's going there's now precedent to make some changes uh because you know we've really seen that these Phantom medical damages you know that aren't filed you know all of the these three things that that are in the bill or in the law now really compound with one another so the inflated medical damages results in you know it could be nuclear damages or nuclear verdict um the you can hold on we we have a lot of cases that uh they're one percent at fault the trial attorney holds on to it for three years because it's not a good case but hey that truck was there we can make the argument that that's one percent is just being being present at the intersection so let's just go for it so all of these things um we really feel are going to uh positively change the the legal environment for Trucking and and cut down on these really you know frivolous lawsuits that clog up the court cost a ton of money and put us in these the Sue and settle cycle because the fact is Florida Florida trucking companies for the most part aren't going to go to court they're not going to risk risk their business and risk their insurance to go to court when you know these trial attorneys know that and they'll just you know quickly Sue to settle yeah and I think that's an important point for folks to understand because it can be a sensitive subject we're talking about usually in most cases somebody who is seriously injured or somebody who dies in an accident and so I think it's important to clarify that when we're talking about tort reform we're not talking about depriving injured plaintiffs or their families of the relief that they are entitled to the best that we can do through monetary damages um so what we are talking about instead and and love to hear your thoughts on this is doing away with what we consider lawsuit abuses which is taking it beyond that those compensatory damages and looking more into what we consider like punitive damages in intended to punish the other party for their actions or inactions in the case and it's often those punitive damages that Skyrocket the total award like the billion dollar case that we talked about that I think kind of brought this all to a head in Florida at least from my perspective if you look at that case there were a hundred million dollars in compensatory damages awarded to the family of the deceased plaintiff in that case but 900 million dollars of that award was punitive damages intended to punish the two motor carriers involved in that particular case and it's that that section of the damages that is really the focus of this kind of lawsuit abuse and tort reform that we're talking about you're absolutely right and the first message that we we told legislators and we tried to communicate to the public much to the trial attorney's kind of misinformation campaign that they tried to launch during this process is if a trucking company is wrong if they do wrong if they are negligent they 100 should be responsible they they need to make things right they need to make people whole take care of that person or it you know in in some instances take care of the families who are need to take care of that person or their family we are 100 in support of that but that's not you're right that is not what was is happening and one of the messages was that this bill would prevent people from getting their medical bills paid or prevent them from recovering damages and we had to be very quick and and quite frankly pretty aggressive uh in communicating back that this bill has nothing to do with punitive or non-economic damages or also what is known as pain and suffering um you know sky is still the limit in Florida however with those if we're not seeing inflated medical damages if the jury is seeing what is true what these bills actually cost or what they should cost for an insurance company to repay a jury is able to then come to a verdict for future medical damages the future medical damages the percentage at fault directly relates to how high that pain and suffering because if you know if if you see as a jury member that you know someone has a sprained ankle and that medical bill is two million dollars uh and so then you assume that the medical future damages for that bad ankle is 10 million dollars now you're starting to talk huge pain and suffering or punitive damages so to get you know to get the evidence accurate and in front of juries is really the first step to wash the rest of the system yeah yeah that's uh a good point and I think uh another important thing to take away from that a lot of people get caught up I think in the number like for example when you hear folks talk about nuclear verdicts and people are debating whether that's a a bad thing or a good thing or whatever and they talk about 10 million dollars kind of being the the number that we use to when we're talking about nuclear verdicts that's just a number that I think the American Transportation Research Institute used as kind of its uh it drew the line somewhere and it picked 10 million dollars but I think what we're actually concerned with more so than the number because as you say sometimes you may run into a situation where an injured plaintiff incurs damages that exceed 10 million dollars but I don't that is not our concern our concern our case is where the awarded damage just do not line up with the actual damages sustained in the particular accident there's no correlation between the two and so we end up with these multi-million dollar now billion dollar jury verdicts uh out there in these various jurisdictions throughout the country that are really causing problems uh for trucking companies in particular they're just being put out of business because of this and it is causing their insurance premiums to inflate because the insurers are now having to deal with this it's this whole idea of like social inflation where where Society at large is becoming numb to these huge numbers we we previously I think before the billion dollar case the the largest jury verdict against a trucking company was somewhere in the range of 400 million dollars or something and that was incredible at you know at the time but now we've got a billion dollar case so 400 million dollars doesn't seem like all that much in comparison and you start to think like that and it's uh it's easy to to go down that path for sure I was curious kind of what it what your impression was I know you were in the room when Governor DeSantis finally signed the bill here just within the last few weeks give us kind of your take on on what that was like being in the room for that oh it was it was great it was it was really positive it was as you can see by the photo a very intimate group it was the bill sponsors um Tommy Gregory representative Tommy Gregory uh Tom Fabrizio and Senator Travis Hudson and then you have Senate President Kathleen pasodomo and um the Speaker of the House Paul Renner three FTA members myself and a couple of other industry leaders and you know it was just it it's always it's always wonderful to uh you know be acknowledged uh and supported you know is it was such a team effort for what we were doing uh both from the association and across different Industries because one of the I think one of the main reasons that this moves so quickly it stayed the same from for the most part from filing to signing is that we all really stood together and you know instead of backbiting or us trying to you know everyone trying to throw little amendments here and there or changing things it's you know this is what we requested here's the bill you know we're going to support you we're going to support our legislative leaders our governor to get this done yeah that's huge because that's what a lot of folks may not know that's where Things Fall Apart in the legislative process when people are trying to get their own small agendas put into bills that have nothing to do with what what the Bill's talking about so little things like that can really derail legislation so congrats on uh getting this across the the finish line for sure um so Florida is just the latest in a line of of states that seem to be passing they're not all the same but but tort reform uh legislation I'll just call it what's your outlook on this for the rest of the country well you know there are so many people that ask me ask me that question right now especially because you know everyone kind of sees it's an easy layup we've got a a strong you know super majority Republican uh legislature and then the governor is very powerful right now um versus other states say with Democrat leadership and we really based a lot of our research our best practices uh and language on what was working with other states because obviously you can't translate translate specific laws or languages from say Montana to Florida um but we you can use those ideas and so really working together with different states and seeing what was working and then also how what was the outcome um because if they're you know me being able to go up to a legislator and say this this happened in Texas and this is what we have seen so to be able to get that information from other state Trucking associations was incredibly important but I will say for these for states that maybe are reticent to do it or what's the point we all really need to remember that this while it people may make it a partisan or political agenda it's it's really it really should not be um and people need to kind of avoid that Avenue for it because good policy is good policy and you need to tell the story of not the trial attorneys versus the insurance companies because no one likes either uh in general uh you need to find a face for it and a story and a narrative of really how it affects real businesses real people and so this year it was it was Trucking um and and trucking got to tell its story but you really other other states really need to step away from the Democrat versus Republican and really show what a positive you know a positive judicial system will do for everyone yeah for sure yeah if anybody's interested like I meant I mentioned our very first episode of truck safe live we had uh um we talked about nuclear verdicts in that episode as well and we had John Esparza from Texas Trucking Association on that show to talk about at the time Texas had just passed their HB 19 which was their version of tort reform so if you're interested in seeing how the two kind of compare go back and watch that episode um running out of time here Alex appreciate you joining us like I said congrats on the big win here I really appreciate hearing it about it from you directly um what else I'm just curious what else does Florida Trucking Association have going on now and and where can folks find out more about what you're doing for the state well we are about to launch our uh our Statewide uh Outreach for Workforce education and Workforce we have received a lot of great funding for CDL Drivers and Diesel Techs in the past couple of years we received a state Grant so we'll be watching a website and a documentary so people can learn more about the trucking industry to try to bring in that next Generation we have our of course our truck driving championships in Daytona Beach which is open to the public uh June 15th through the 17th it's one of the biggest in the country our dinner our dinner award ceremony has about 1200 people so it's a really intimate intimate event um and that you know always you know we're still keeping one eye open with the legislature we still have a few a few weeks left uh to push some forward push forward some bills try to kill some others um and and then hopefully uh take a little take a little rest yeah well deserved rest well thanks again so much Alex appreciate you joining us and uh we'll we'll definitely keep watching what all you've got going on down there in Florida so thanks again thanks for having me all right uh great discussion there with Alex about Florida's uh recently passed HB 837 tort reform uh very interesting topic um if you want to find out more about exactly what it does in uh in the state with respect to these types of cases that we're talking about you can find more information about it on Florida Trucking association's website uh next up I wanted to bring on our next guest which is Bill knasky Dr Bill knasky of uh vice president of courtroom Sciences welcome bill how's it going you know I'm not I'm not upset because I'm still I did not get the invite to the DeSantis Bill signing I don't know I didn't see you in the picture it was like where's Waldo yeah my uh my invitation got lost in the mail let's see if we see yeah well everybody there has hair well actually two of these guys the three look at that three boys they'd be wearing my hat I'm a little disappointed so I just got I gotta start off my with my podcast I start off with the rant I just start off with the rant I'm a little I'm a little upset but the sandwich is great I'm happy you signed the bill and created complete total chaos in the State of Florida yeah for sure well we'll uh we'll let Alex know that you need to be you need to get the invite to the next bill signing for sure hey kind of like we did with Alex I think you were on listening um for folks who aren't familiar with courtroom sciences and and what you're doing over there can you kind of just give us a background uh how you got into Trucking and what you do through courtroom Sciences yeah uh courtroom Sciences is a full-service litigation support firm and we really focus on uh really two areas your standard Jury consulting so doing Jury Research in the form of focus groups mock trials and in court you know jury selection consultation uh that's half of what we do the other half of what we do is a lot of time training Witnesses key Witnesses for both deposition and trial testimony and uh we're all psychologists I'm trained as a clinical neuropsychologist and and I was on the academic track I got to tell you Brandon I was on the academic track you know I had told my family hey I'm going to be a professor at a big time University here we go and then I took this wicked left turn in my career it turned out to be turned out to be the best move of my uh well one of the best moves of my life yeah I think we're a little similar in that regard probably yeah yeah it was not it was not the plan it was not the plan but when I got into it I completely fell in love with it because I could use uh Clinical Psychology neuropsychology every day both in studying jurors and and helping Witnesses uh prepare to testify and as I started getting really good at this I started writing papers publishing them nationally doing a lot of of public speaking and that's really where the trucking people found me and said hey hey we've got problems we need your help because we have problems with juries and our Witnesses do oftentimes struggle when they're testifying and get beat up by plaintiff attorneys and if you could help us with that and uh that was uh was I'm in my 20th year so I've been doing this uh quite a while and uh absolutely head over heels in love with it as well as the trucking industry these are the best people I mean I work in medical and I work in products I work in construction all of that but the best people in the country are the people in the trucking industry and I love working with those companies and those people well our viewers will be glad to hear that I think so yeah so you've been on the front line fighting against so-called reptile theory of litigation this is something that Alex and I hit on a little bit but for folks who aren't familiar with the concept of the reptile theory of litigation wondering if you can give a 30 000 foot overview of what it is in the in the trouble that it tends to cause yeah okay so for anyone in the audience that has never heard of reptile Theory I'm not sure what what rock you've you've been living under since 2009 please people come on uh wait wake up uh yeah it's been around for a while uh big picture well there's kind of it's kind of a double-edged sword so the way the plaintiff's bar it's the number one air that the plaintiff's bar goes for training to attack defendants and uh the trucking industry is uh in the you know in the crosshairs right uh of of the of the planet's bar it always has been and it continues to be because of these uh the size of these verdicts uh that we've been seeing and what they will say is that they've come up with you know special ways to uh go into a courtroom to access and Trigger the reptile brain in the uh jurors and then blah blah blah blah it's it's a bunch of it's a bunch of it it's garbage it's absolutely garbage science but it's a really cool sales pitch right but I've broken down the whole Theory I think I've published like nine papers on this topic uh they're all out there uh for free so you should re-up on them but what the reptile Theory strategy really is it's a very very very aggressive plaintiff strategy When approaching litigation in which they're really focusing on two areas to what I call getting the lead early in the game okay so remember the span of a a of litigations pretty long it's typically you know several years and what they want to do is they want to go into the locker room at halftime and they want to be up 42 to 10. that's what they want to do and that's where how that's how they get what I call nuclear settlements which is the bigger problem versus nuclear verdicts we could talk about that later but that's what they're doing they're being very aggressive with number one absolutely destroying these key Trucking Witnesses at deposition and videotaping it when I say key witness I mean the corporate rep or person most knowledgeable uh the safety directors they're a huge Target and of course uh the drivers oftentimes the director heads of HR are another Target and they beat these Witnesses up bad with reptile types of questions and these Witnesses Crash and Burn and when that happens the value of the demand the value of the case skyrockets so a large part of what I do is traveling around the country to these trucking companies working with these witnesses to train them okay to be bulletproof against reptile Theory so then when they when they they are deposed and they Testify the those depths are effective the value of the case comes down so that's kind of the first part of reptile attack the second part of reptile attack is and I gotta I mean hats off to the plans bar they do a lot of Jury Research and they do it early they figure out which cases are the lottery tickets and how do they do that well they do focus groups they do mock trials something that the defense typically Waits on they kind of want to wait things out a very reactive approach well when you have a reactive approach going against a proactive approach that's a recipe for disaster so those are the two areas that the reptile plaintiff movement they've done very very well on that catching both trucking companies and insurance companies catching them with their pants down and when that happens and it's it's half time of the game and it's it's 42 to 10 well financially economically and strategically you're in big trouble and so that's really what they've been doing uh there's a whole chapter on you know we could talk about courtroom stuff but you know 98 of cases settle this is a discovery issue and that's where the vast majority of money is being lost in nuclear settlements not nuclear verdict yeah you really can't put the toothpaste back in the tube once it's come out so they're banking on that happening early in the case and then taking advantage of that to leverage a huge settlement out of it um even if folks are familiar with the reptile Theory kind of generally I I bet that that many people don't know that there are like there's a published book on this topic on how to prosecute using the reptile Theory there's conferences that the plaintiff's bar has on on teaching folks how to pursue this type of questioning and and I'm curious as a as a psychologist how much of this Theory hinges on psychology and how so about zero percent okay here's the funny part I gave them too much credit yeah yeah that's the sales pitch it's it's really the sales pitch is a bunch of garbage all the the brain talk when they have um I I happen to have a copy of the reptile book and by the way if you were your audience like a copy if you go on eBay I think it's about fourteen hundred dollars right now fourteen hundred bucks or just get a billion dollar case I mean just just read my articles here's where the real psychology is in the reptile Theory and there is a chapter about this that's very quiet right where the psychology has nothing to do with the jury the psychology is against three people and to get these three people at each other's throats in litigation because that's how they get their money okay the owner of the trucking company number one number two the defense attorney number three the the insurance claims specialist right those three people the psychology between them that's what reptile theories is designed to do is they go up 42 to 10. what do you think the coaching the coaching meeting is like in the locker room during a football game right your team's down 42 to 10 and you and your assistant coach are yeah your assistant coaches are meeting Brandon what do you think that discussion is like in the locker room it's it's not very positive right I can imagine it's similar to most of the discussions at halftime of the Colts games this past season that that would be it that would be it as a disgruntled Bears fan you know yeah a study that's not even go there hey number one pick baby but but listen that's the stuff they traded that away yeah yeah well Hey listen they're still going to get a top of my finger and so what happens is the the the owner of the trucking company uh the insurance claims person and the defense counsel are all looking at each other like we're down 42 to 10. what are we gonna do right and there's a lot of finger pointing going on there's a lot of pressure there's a lot of stress and it ends up that's the formula to get your money that's what that's what they're doing and and it works so I've developed a system to say hey let's go into halftime with at least a score tide hey and maybe we're up a touchdown because then all of your economic leverage changes in the case for sure and and you said you said early on that you've helped hundreds of trucking companies over the years and their Witnesses prepare for these types of cases and I've had the the uh I've been able to sit through a lot of your talks at various conferences over the years and see some of these these videos that you that you show of witnesses getting themselves in trouble in these types of cases and they're just incredible yeah it's um and they're very good learning tools and I use that in my witness training program and I have I have a bunch of bad examples of here's what not to do and I probably I mean back to my sports analogies I I break them down like game film to yeah the witnesses and hit pause and say Here's what's going on in this witness's brain here's the mistake they're making here's why and here's how we're going to train you to avoid that mistake so they're very very useful tools and then we have the other set of videos that are all the Great Performances and we break that down too so there's a lot of training that goes into effective testimony and listen defense counsel does a great job but they're not clinical psychologists they don't understand the the effects of you know faulty cognition or you know fight or flight response patterns things like that so when you team up a well-trained uh clinical psychologist you team them up with a really good defense counsel you've got a pretty devastatingly effective team there and that's what I do yeah we talked about trying to show some of those examples here and we just couldn't get it to work I'm curious if you could kind of give folks a feel for maybe some of the worst one of the worst uh fails that you've seen on the witness front over the years man there's there's there's too many that counts uh kind of more generally witnesses witnesses tend to fail for a couple different reasons I can outline for you and I cover this with all my witnesses number one um this is people in this Society okay our brains are not wired to listen very carefully or to think very carefully okay and if you get a witness that doesn't listen really carefully to the whole question they make silly mistakes when they don't process the information very carefully okay they don't they don't think long enough they make silly mistakes okay so if you don't listen well you don't think well you're gonna make what I call cognitive errors you're going to make cognitive errors and you're going to say things that are inaccurate or harmful in your testimony why because you're going too fast you're going too fast you're at a conversational Pace with a assassin right who's the plaintiff attorney does this every day and you have no chance so one of the top skills I have to teach Witnesses is to slow them down maximize their listening skills their cognition skills and that will lead to more accurate answers but that's not enough the other big big problem that I see are witnesses that go into what we call fight or flight response patterns so plan of attorneys can get ugly during deposition and trial testimony with Witnesses and your brain is wired for survival and so if you have somebody attacking you you're subcortical fight or flight right mechanism takes over and you want to you want to fight for survival or you want to run away for survival and the way Witnesses do that is if they want to fight you know they become argumentative they become defensive they become evasive and they start yapping away okay trying to go go to go to war with a professional assassin and you've never been to war before it's it just leads to very very bad things when people get emotional particularly angry they will say crazy things and it's going to hurt the case Drive the value of the case up but they could also go flight um I've seen several of of people in the truck and by the way I I've met some of the toughest people males and females in this Industries but some people do have the flight mechanism the more susceptible to that so when the heat gets turned up they want to run away and the way they do that is they just start talking and okay okay let me explain meaning I will say anything to get out of this damn chair anything and they will then say crazy things because that fighter flight process takes over so another part of the training is to desensitize the witness we have a very special training program so that they can keep their cool if the plan of attorney reptile or not is pounding the table and smoke is coming out of their ears our Witnesses are still going to be affected because they're very very highly trained and what I don't think people realize is that you know number one the Witnesses are getting lulled into a false sense of security with these assassin plaintiffs attorneys who are making it look like they're the best friend up there just just have a conversation with me we're just talking here and and then they end up getting emotional or they they're doing they're they're running away from it and they're just jabbering on and what they don't realize is that what what feels like they're being clear at the time in person does not translate well on paper and on paper it just looks terrible what you said about the company when it's reduced to paper and then that that testimony from your your deposition is out there for all to see on that paper forever so it just causes a lot of trouble particularly with the corporate rep and that's a big deal with the corporate reps and I know a lot of people ask me well like do we only like do we really need to do all this stuff for small cases immediately like is this the big cases well listen your 30 B6 corporate rep testimony lasts forever it followed you forever so if you gave a Deb four years ago that depth's gonna be used against you and and subsequent uh litigation and particularly in those steps which are so economically important and where the the reptile folks have gone is all the safety language and that's really where the that's kind of the main theme of the reptile attack is they go after all the safety language which by the way this industry along with Healthcare has painted themselves into the worst Corner I've ever seen in my life and so some advice I can give to your audience right now and I do this when I'm on stage I did it last week in Vegas when I was on stage do a mongoose method for for two days I by the way I spoke for 17 hours over a three day period I lost my voice my knees hurt my back hurt uh oh is this is this terrible did you win anything I know right where these Planet fraternities go where these plan of attorneys go which is a smorgasbord it's a treasure Trove of ammunition is they go to they go to the trucking company website where you have put the dumbest things in the world on your website so when I say safety is our number one priority oh it's the worst it's the worst thing ever because hey it's not true it's not true but that's going to be a cross-examination question and you've just raised the bar of responsibility and accountability from something reasonable to something completely idealistic and unrealistic so when I give speeches to the trucking organizations or the companies around I'll bring up their websites or the like the people in the audience I bring up the company website and go through it and everybody's like this I'm like all right um who's the owner of XYZ trucking company and you see this guy in the backlight I'm like okay let's go through your website and I'm like cha-ching cha-ching and like delete delete delete but the great thing is is um I give them the information how they can fix that fix that very carefully because that's the first place that the Players Bar is going the second place they're going to go which is equally as destructive policies and procedures and training manuals the dumbest thing I mean the dumbest things I've ever seen in my life are put in policies procedures training manuals awful awful awful and then you hand it over to the players Council and they just beat you over the head relentlessly with it over you know over and over again during the depth so two things that you can do go to your website and analyze it get the word say anything safety really just get it off of there it's not it's entirely unnecessary and then be very careful with how you're describing safety and rules and things like that your policies and procedures because that's going to be the top source of cross-examination questions yeah where I see it go wrong a lot is a lot of those policies will start out with some kind of a high level mission statement or something like that where they're they're putting that type of language that idealistic language in there and then like you said that that's just used to beat them over the head with when when it gets down to litigation I think that is um so curious we're running out of time here um we could talk about this for literally 17 hours apparently but um what's your advice what's your advice for trucking companies your overall advice uh for those companies that get tied up in in any type of case you mentioned doesn't really matter how how small or big it is what's your your advice to them okay well first thing okay I live in Florida like Alex um but I work all over the country um so I'm uh I just happen to be home uh here in the Orlando area today but every June 1st uh you're not June 1st is here in Florida yeah holiday because it's my birthday Brandon number one okay so first off everybody June 1st is my birthday I'm expecting inbox yeah I'm expecting emails I'm expecting cards and gifts right but the second thing going on in Florida besides my birthday on June 1st is to start a hurricane season in my family and I and even our neighbors we all get together and we plan we plan we make a list of things we need I go to Home Depot on a regular day I load up okay I have a plan I sit down with my family if this happens here's what we're doing if this happens here's what we're doing well before the storm comes Brandon and if the storm comes by the way we get hit by two hurricanes in 46 days last year I was ready and the year before we got hit by another one the year before we got hit by none thing is have your plan well before a lawsuit's filed so you know what to do a crisis management plan take care of these websites policies all that do that before the storm comes when the storm comes and it's not a matter of if it's a matter of when the first thing you do is get on the horn with your insurance company and your defense counsel and get moving and hopefully they'll call me too because it's a race every second is precious from the moment that accident happens to get going because the plaintiff attorney will they will be in deep as fast as they can and that's how they get that 42 to 10 lead you have to be very very proactive work with your insurance company work with your defense counsel and start to prepare as early as possible be proactive just like the bad guys because that's what they do be just as proactive with them not reactive and you're going to be in a much much better position both strategically and financially as the litigation goes forward yeah it's similar message that we're preaching to our clients every single day is the the need to be proactive from our perspective on DOT compliance because if not then when you're in the in the you're in the fire it's too late at that point to do anything that you should have been doing to to prepare yourself to keep you out of that fire to begin with so um all right uh that wraps up our time here really appreciate you joining us Bill where can where can folks find out more about what you're doing over at courtroom sciences and tell us about your podcast that you do yeah I just go to courtroomsciences.com okay the the because this is my baby I'm glad we say this for last and and many trucking companies their employees and even drivers are uh listen to my podcast it's called the litigation psychology podcast and it's the only one of its time kind and we talk about all these jury issues you know um uh witness training we talk about uh the impacts of depositions trial testimony everything that has to do with litigation cover reptile Theory constantly all this fun stuff it's a really good and very unique mix of Neuroscience that we use in litigation to help our Trucking clients resolve these cases much much cheaper or win a trial it's a it's a it's a very clever combination of that combined with Unapologetic just hilarious humor it's a myth you've got to laugh during this podcast it's got to be entertaining so we do a mix of both so you're gonna learn something you're gonna learn something and you're gonna laugh your ass off I mean what more do you want the podcast come on exactly that's something you don't get here much of is the yeah yeah maybe we'll bring you on we'll bring you on in each of our episodes and we'll have you kind of be the comedic relief to the uh to the to the podcast well I'm going to get you on my podcast if you like I'd like to invite you to my podcast right now and we I will email you we'll get you on let's do it and we'll switch seats and then uh you'll be on the litigation psychology podcast and then you'll we'll have a little fun how about that all right sounds good to me hey Bill really appreciate you uh joining me uh we're gonna wrap things up uh thanks everybody for joining us today um a couple things here before we wrap up uh make sure that you uh subscribe to our newsletter if you haven't already like I said one of the things that we pushed out today was a a notification about that um notice that came out from FMCSA about the crash preventability determination program and changes to it so we're constantly pushing stuff out like that not only uh on our social media channels uh but also through our newsletter so I'd encourage you to sign up for that follow us on social media we're pretty active on LinkedIn Facebook uh Twitter um YouTube uh if you're interested in all these types of DOT compliance topics that we post about pretty frequently stay tuned for our next episode of truck safe live we usually do one or two of these episodes per month uh you can find it uh live on our social media channels but also you can download the podcast wherever you get your podcast thanks again to the sponsor of this season of truck safe live which is log Rock really really appreciate you teaming up with us and and helping us make this possible uh that's all I got really appreciate you joining us uh stay tuned like I said for the next show and we look forward to seeing you there thanks everyone foreign

Event Completed

Wednesday, April 12, 2023 at 8:10 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube