Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 21 - When maintenance goes wrong

Friday, April 28, 2023 at 7:25 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 21 - When maintenance goes wrong

About This Event

In this episode, we’re joined by Brian Runnels, VP of Safety for Reliance Partners to discuss the importance of a robust fleet maintenance program and the many things that can go wrong when commercial vehicles are not properly inspected and maintained.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 21 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Brian Runnels, VP of Safety at Reliance Partners, to discuss the critical topic of fleet vehicle maintenance — why it so often goes wrong, and what the consequences can be for motor carriers from both a regulatory compliance and litigation standpoint. The conversation is timely given the approaching International Roadcheck (May 16-18), proposed changes to FMCSA's Safety Measurement System (SMS), and a high-profile lawsuit stemming from the fatal accident that claimed the life of former NFL quarterback Dwayne Haskins Jr. The hosts cover several industry developments before diving into the main topic, including FMCSA's proposed expansion of the Crash Preventability Determination Program from 16 to 21 eligible crash types — a change widely welcomed by the industry — and the proposed split of the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC into two separate categories: one focused on company-level maintenance failures and one on driver-observed defects that should have been caught during pre-trip inspections. The hosts note that while this change will benefit some carriers, those hovering near alert thresholds should log into FMCSA's SMS preview site immediately, as the changes could push certain scores into alert status before the comment period closes in mid-May. On International Roadcheck, Runnels and Wiseman highlight that last year more than 21 percent of all inspected commercial vehicles were placed out of service — a figure they describe as staggering. This year's focus is on ABS systems and cargo securement, though inspectors will conduct full inspections regardless of the stated emphasis. The hosts stress that brake violations are among the most common out-of-service findings and warn carriers not to simply adjust brakes and move on without investigating the underlying cause. They also discuss the dvir process in depth, emphasizing that far too many carriers treat the driver's submission of a defect report as the end of the process, when in reality it is only the beginning — vehicles must not be moved until defects are certified as repaired, and that certification must be documented in the maintenance file. The Dwayne Haskins lawsuit serves as a cautionary case study for the second half of the episode. Runnels outlines how the dump truck involved was inspected two days after the fatal accident and found to have multiple maintenance violations, which have since become central to the litigation despite the unusual and complex circumstances of the accident itself. Wiseman explains that this is precisely how nuclear verdicts are born — plaintiff attorneys use a carrier's overall maintenance record, CSA scores, and out-of-service rates to paint a picture of a negligent company to a jury, regardless of whether those issues directly caused the accident in question. Citing the ATRI report on nuclear verdicts, the hosts note that cases involving regulatory violations result in a plaintiff verdict more than 85 percent of the time, with average verdict sizes rising from below one million dollars to over 22 million dollars in recent years. The actionable takeaway from this episode is straightforward: fleet maintenance cannot be treated as an afterthought. Safety professionals should ensure drivers are performing thorough pre-trip and post-trip inspections and being held accountable for doing so, that dvir defects are being repaired and certified before vehicles are re-dispatched, that repair records are retained in maintenance files, that mechanic qualifications are documented whether using in-house or third-party maintenance providers, and that carriers are regularly monitoring their CSA scores — particularly their Vehicle Maintenance BASIC — with the same urgency they would apply to hours of service compliance. As Reynolds puts it, a carrier's maintenance record does not just affect roadside inspections; it can define how a jury perceives the entire company if that carrier ever finds itself in a courtroom.

Full Transcript

thank you thank you foreign thank you foreign thank you thank you this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system logrock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com hey everyone welcome to episode 21 of trucksafe live a show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs and this is Brian Reynolds and Brandon Brian I hope that should be fine we'll be fine uh Brian Reynolds VP of safety from Reliance Partners good friend finally got you here in studio with me it's a great Studio otherwise known as the loft of above my garage yeah it's a beautiful Studio good stuff man hey thanks for being here I'm glad we have the budget big enough to fly you in here and uh anytime you need me you just I'll hop on a plane and be here in no time Brian lives like 20 minutes away from me so we don't have any kind of budget for this uh glad he's here with me um we're talking today about Fleet Maintenance um I want to hit on a couple of topics uh in light of some things going on in the industry including International Road check which is coming up what couple weeks from now um so we're going to hit on that and then also some recent cases that we're seeing in the industry where maintenance is the main focus of them so thought this would be a good time to really focus in on that because Brian you and I have both seen how maintenance problems can cause a lot of problems in a lot of different contexts so yeah and it's coming to the surface so it's it could be definitely used against a company where it wasn't used before yeah so sure so good time to do it uh before we get to the topic of today a few things going on at truck safe that are worth mentioning and in the industry uh we just wrapped up our Fleet compliance boot camp had a great time in Indianapolis Brian was there with us he spoke at the event uh I think we had around 30 people or so got a lot of great feedback about that we spent two days uh really diving in deep to the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations and related state regulations walking through everything not everything but most of the stuff that fleets need to know to remain compliant with the multitude of safety regulations that they're expected to comply with in that green book there so it was a great time if you missed us for this particular boot camp we're going to try and do them twice a year I think our next one will probably be in the fall probably in Orlando so sure to follow us on trucksafebootcamp.com we will post there when we decide where our next one is going to be Brian you gonna make it down there if we do it in Orlando I can probably figure out a way to get to Orlando I may have to I may have to pay for your flight for that one so I'm gonna have to start saving up for that let's see I think I can get a picture from our boot camp this year look at that there you are yeah the back of my head back of your head looks good you look good from that angle yeah Jeremy and Jeremy yeah he was the same share the same view from the back so anyway great time thanks for everybody who who came and um and joined us for that uh what else we got going on truck safe Network um this is something I always like to mention uh that we've always got going on in the background our truck safe compliance network is free to join there's an app available in the um in the App Store and also the Google Play Store if you're interested in following along with our DOT compliance related content our YouTube videos our free webinars and and also the network is a mint as a forum for safety professionals to get in there ask questions share things with others all to help help make our fleets more compliant and make our roads safer so find that online at trucksafenetwork.com or again like I said in the app store or the Google Play Store uh uh last thing to mention about truck safe is our courses uh if you're not familiar with our courses we offer a bunch of dot related courses online courses available at trucksafeacademy.com we have a course dedicated to safety managers anybody in a position of kind of managing a regulated Fleet and having to work through those regulations that we talked about we also have courses for drivers and we have Hazmat courses and reasonable suspicion courses so if you're interested in those like I said they're online through our learning management system it tracks progress gives you a completion certificate so check that out trucksafeacademy.com all right enough about us what's going on the in the industry Brian anything interesting uh from your perspective going on I think well before you know we get into the road check and the um some of the maintenance issues we were going to talk about that the crash preventability program uh the changes that are going to be coming there if they go through it's going to be a great thing the only thing that I wish they'd do and I think I'm speaking for a lot of people is they'd make it retroactive to a certain point as of right now there's no retro activity to it yeah I wish they would take it back I agree it's so kind of stepping back the crash preventability demonstration program if you're not familiar with it is the program where motor carriers can go in and challenge or drivers challenge the preventability of the accidents in which they're involved and if they are successful in that appeal then the the accidents do not weigh on their CSA scores or if you're the driver your PSP account the way that they would otherwise so it's a good program problem is it is so limited in scope there are only certain accident types I think there are 16 accident types that are eligible for consideration in the program fmcsa's recent news that Brian mentioned is that they are looking to expand that program they have I think increased it to like 21. yeah 21 or 22 and I think we can still throw out that rare and unusual I mean you got to have somebody jumping out of an airplane and hit your truck to count on that one we talked about that at the boot camp it's just crazy to me that one of the 16 eligible crash types is literally a truck getting hit by a skydiver or an airplane or an airplane yeah but like we said it had to have happened at some time or at some point or else that would not have been an option yeah and you know a couple of them that I really like I I do like the lost control where it strikes a truck in the side you hear so many of those and we get asked all the time hey can I challenge that you can but you're not going to win it um so that one and then the introduction of video yeah for sure I think that one's going to be huge what are they doing about the video I didn't I didn't if the video uh justifies that it wasn't the driver's fault that's right then um so even if it doesn't fit neatly into one of those categories they're gonna accept video evidence as kind of getting you past that barrier right you know whether it's and you see these on on social media all the time whether someone comes over and breaks checks a driver and the only thing it looks like is a rear end accident those are really really hard yeah to to get rid of and now the video can uh exonerate the driver and with as much video is going on uh it you know cameras are what 86 percent of the safety technologies that are in trucks that that is that's going to be a huge one yeah especially at least outward facing cameras yeah and we're starting to see uh pretty widespread adoption of those at this point there are still holdouts obviously as there are going to be but but definitely not as much so as with the driver facing cameras so um yeah I agree I I think this news about the expansion of the crash preventive preventability determination program is welcome news to most of us in the industry I think it's what carriers and we have been petitioning for for a long time now so it was good to see that um also of note is uh potential upcoming changes to the safety measurement system we've talked about this in a prior show we had an episode dedicated to what exactly is changing but these are your CSA scores and FMCSA uh put out a notice it's probably been a couple of months ago now saying that they are proposed closing certain changes to the way that CSA scores are calculated it gets into the weeds very quickly when you start to look at what exactly is changing but those changes have been spurred by the long long time criticisms that we've heard and that we've made against CSA including things like the subjectivity of the severity weight so curious your thoughts Brian on kind of those changes that we're expecting to happen probably not until the end of this year at the earliest but yeah the changes in the the scoring where everything is pretty much worth the same amount unless it's out of service I don't know if that's the exactly right way to do it um you know a five over counts the same as a 15 over uh so I I don't know if that's going to be right I think that that's going to put a big kink in the challenging of you know you get a citation with it and even if you have the citation thrown out or they change it to a dip that's the only way it's going to work is if they throw it out if they change it to a different a lesser violation it's still worth one point it does you no good it does you no good but on the flip side if you do get one taken out it's going to have a bigger effect a bigger impact yeah so that's the that's the really good thing there the other thing that when you get the out of service those out of service points are automatically going towards the unsafe driving basic so you know they've moved drug and alcohol put it in there and then anything that's out of service that extra point goes to your unsafe basic that's right um and then the other big one I I think is probably what's going to lead us to to where we're going to talk about maintenance is the split up of what is basically company owned yeah for the comp that's going to be on the company as far as score and what should have been observed by the driver during a pre-trip inspection um I think this is an important change and I think it's uh I think it will benefit a lot of motor carriers in the sense so the idea is we've got our existing vehicle maintenance basic as one of our CSA scores and what we know from fmcsa's notice is that is the one basic that has the most data in in it it is the one that has the most violations and what they say in their notice of these changes is that because we have so much data in that particular basic it becomes unwieldy it's hard to draw any conclusions from what may be contributing to those violations and so their idea is let's split that out as Brian said into two different Basics we're going to have a a standard vehicle maintenance uh basic and then we're gonna have a vehicle maintenance driver observed and those driver observed maintenance violations are going to be ones that could have been or should have been discovered by a driver had they done a thorough inspection of the vehicle whereas the normal vehicle maintenance category will Encompass more latent defects things that even if the driver did a thorough inspection they may not have necessarily noticed and I think it's good because then if if I'm a company that has a high driver observed basic then I know fundamentally that what I need to focus my attention on is making sure that the drivers are doing thorough inspections whereas if I have a high vehicle maintenance category then the problem is less about the driver's activity and more about what I'm doing to maintain the these trucks I I think we'll see you know especially on the out of service side whether it's the most out of service is usually either a tire or break true um so I'm I'm curious to see how that will affect those scores because so many breaks once the violation is found a lot of times they go out of service so that's going to kind of make the company's number a little bit skewed yeah um when it comes to the out of service rates but uh I think it's a I think it's a really really good change yeah if you aren't familiar with these changes I would encourage you to go back and watch that episode of trucksafe Live it was a couple of episodes ago where we broke it broke it down item by item but more importantly than that if you are a regulated carrier FMCSA has a preview site up now a website where you can go in and see what your how your scores are going to be impacted by these changes you just log into your SMS account and then you go to that preview website and it will tell you here's how you're going to be be performing once these changes take effect I encourage you to do that because if if you see something messed up with your scores or something that is concerning to you that comment period is still open FMCSA is accepting comments through mid-may I think so we're running up pretty close to that comment period if you see something wrong go in and submit your comments would be my encouragement yeah I have I have one account that I'm working with that they're kind of hovering on that borderline right now of alert status and when they put their information in the company side actually went down a couple couple points and unfortunately the driver's observed side went up a couple points above the alert and it put it in alerts so you know I I think that it definitely is going to have an effect yeah for sure and and if you're right at that threshold in any of the basics you're the ones I'm most concerned about about what these changes are going to do to your score we talked we've both done that kind of exercise for our clients and uh and some of our clients their scores get better and some of them get worse so it's kind of all over the board um so go in there check that out play around see uh see how it's going to affect you and uh if you got questions I'm always happy to address them I'm sure Brian is too if you want to reach out to us um or um you know uh like I said watch that prior episode where we really break down how it's going to work so like Brian said that leads us right into maintenance um you know today's topic vehicle maintenance major component of safety and compliance obviously and it's one in my experience at least that is too often either neglected or complete ignored and it's occasionally brought to light through things like the upcoming International Road check which is coming up May 16th through the 18th and certain court cases like one that we are tracking in Florida right now that we're going to spend some time talking about um and what's clear from these these things that are always kind of bubbling up to the surface is that when Fleet Maintenance is not appropriately prioritized bad things tend to happen and so and so the purpose of today's show is kind of is to kind of shine a light on those maintenance problems where things tend to go wrong and helping fleets to kind of improve their processes and procedures in that regard to keep themselves out of the crosshairs here so before we do that Brian for folks who may not be familiar with you I know you've we've had you on a couple shows in the past but maybe give a little background about yourself sure yeah I spent uh 19 years as a driver I've got I've been all the way at the bottom and all the way at the top I think because I did roll a truck over in 1996 what a horrible experience that was after that time I put a little over 2 million miles on safe without getting so much scratch in the paint on anything which was which was fantastic it the last six seven years I drove I was with Gordon Trucking out of the Pacific Northwest they put me in the safety department a great experience there went on to open a school because I was a I was an over the road trainer for for those that time too and then came in to safety and and went to a carrier here in Indiana that I started their training program and and built that up which was fantastic and then moved to the insurance side of things which uh that was that was a heck of a change doing lost control and things like that give us a little sense of how jarring of a change that is coming from the driver's perspective and the carrier perspective to the insurance perspective you know when when you get when I came into the loss control side it was I had always been around big carriers um and when I came into to the loss control with crum and Forester it was it was smaller carriers usually 25 to 50 was about as Max as as we were working with and the differences between structure and setup and resources and you know just a whole Litany of things was so different and it's a learning curve to learn okay how do we work with them to try to be to have them be successful as well um it's a complete shift in mindset right because on the carrier side of things you're you're always kind of thinking that you're working and working and working on issues to help you know bring down your insurance reduce your risk right essentially but on the insurance side of things is you view it more as kind of like a partnership with those carriers that's what I'm hearing from you is how can we work with them to get them to that point yeah and to get them to understand that you know whether it's hours of service or it's maintenance or unsafe driving behaviors things like that it's if you can get those things under control you know I would never say hey your rates are going to go down that's a dangerous thing to say but if you can bring in more competition uh for your business yeah that's how rates change so you know I learned that real quick and and went went on um to be with DMC insurance for a while on the sales side that was very very interesting and a huge learning opportunity and then then I ended up here at Reliance and you know my time at Reliance has been incredible because it they gave us the opportunity to actually start and build a safety program and Robert and I have done a I think a pretty darn good job of building out our resources and um you know we visited as many accounts as we can on a quarterly basis going out to the West Coast next week going to California next week um I've got six or six or seven accounts that I'm gonna go see out there and so when you go out and visit a customer what are you doing general what does spending your time doing it's very customized uh it's what do they need help with yeah um you know some of it is a focus on all right we've got to get our hours of service under control all right well let's look and see what's causing the problems and most often it's a communication issue yeah with the dry drivers and you know it they many many carriers especially in the smaller size I said how should you say it it's they don't they don't enforce it as much as they probably should but and then to try to all of a sudden crack down I give some heartburn so good shock yeah so it's trying to get them to to do it without just alienating their driver's license it's a challenge using them into it can be challenging yeah and how to take care of their equipment and you know getting their guys to do pre-trips and you know whatever that case is that's what we want to help them with yeah so it's very customized what we do yeah customers and I think there's something to be said for that you we work with a lot of insurance companies over the years and our capacity is as outside counsel for a lot of these large carriers and it's it's rare in my experience to see that level of involvement from the insurance uh broker or Carrier and making sure that your program is is up to Snuff and up to the up to your standards to to help you not only on the insurance premium side of things but just risk mitigation to begin with so I'm a big fan of for sure and it's a it's a value that we can bring those accounts to you know keep them sticky keep them involved and give them a service that they're probably not going to get too many other places yeah for sure so you and I were talking you when you were over at our boot camp uh last week you had you had told me that you had gone through recently A A certification process that I thought was pretty cool with respect to performing annual inspection so you can tell us a little bit about that and yeah sure Robert and I both Robert Caffery uh we worked together that Reliance work we are the the lost control side of of Reliance partners and we we both went to Fox Valley Tech in Appleton Wisconsin and got qualified to do annual inspections because there's there's really not a certification process uh you can be either qualified through training or through experience to do that um so it's something that we can take to our customers and and say all right let's let's review this process as well yeah not just safety hours of service you know unsafe driving driver qualification stuff now we're looking at the maintenance side of things too too and it's it's just interesting that all this is starting to flood in at the same time but making sure that they have everything they need if that company is doing their own annual inspections yeah making sure they've got all the correct paperwork they're looking at the right things um and they're doing the things the way they should I think that's what some fleets struggle with to understand mechanic qualifications and I know we're going to get into that a little bit more but I think it fits in here is that you know as you said the regulations aren't very specific in that regard you would think that as many regulations as we have in that book that the regulations would require a mechanic to be to hold certain certifications in order to inspect these large trucks and buses but it's really not the regulations are pretty broad they say by reason of experience training or both you have to be able to uh to identify the parts that are listed out in the appendices and stuff like that and be able to inspect them and that's really about it so we have a lot of clients I know coming to us asking what do we need to have in terms of mechanic qualifications so what are your thoughts on that you know I think it's I think the the regs call for what a year of experience or something like that it's you want to put somebody in that position that you trust yeah because they are the ones that are putting the equipment out on the road and telling you as a company hey your equipment's good to go you know we've checked it over we've repaired anything that we've needed to repair and that truck or that trailer is completely safe to operate yeah so it's got to be somebody that's very trustworthy and that you feel comfortable with saying okay you're the eyes and ears of that you deal with it what about outside mechanics let's say you don't have your own in-house mechanics we get this question a lot too you know we we rely on uh Love's truck stops or you know whatever and and we rely on their maintenance programs to kind of perform the annual inspections what do we need to have in terms of documenting those mechanics qualifications if anything well you can ask I mean you you can physically ask where are there you know do you have a qualification form or yeah qualification form on this mechanic how many years of experience you can ask all those questions um and it's probably wise to do so does it happen probably not very often they and you know when you're dealing with those those types of large companies they're probably putting the people in place that are the right folks to have there because they've got a lot of exposure too yeah um but if you're using yeah a garage down the street you might want to ask you know what qualifications they have and you know it's interesting Brandon they the two things when you were talking about how broad and really there's not a ton of qualifications needed the two things in the regs you've got that and you've actually got the driver qualifications yeah basically if they're 21 and and they can operate the equipment safely and speak English and speak English that's it that's it so it's that's weird it's crazy the areas where you would expect there to be a lot of Regulation a lot of depth to the regulations you'd be surprised that there is not one one that always comes to mind besides those two is school buses school buses are completely exempt from the Federal Motor Carrier safety realizations which makes it absolutely no sense if there's anybody we want to protect yes of school children but they are completely exempt from the photo mode when operating between schools and homes now they are subject to a lot of state regulations is I think the rationale for that but it's just crazy if you're if you are a student of the regulations as I have been uh in my capacity it's just crazy some of those things that really stick out like a sore thumb well you know what it is they put the minimal regulations on the front end yeah and then the book gets that big on the back end because they've got to make up for everything exactly yeah it's uh uh it's uh it's those issues that just never make a whole lot of sense and it's those types of issues I think that lead to a lot of people's frustrations with the regulatory scheme in general why are we focusing on these areas when we're completely seemingly ignoring all of these other areas but that's a conversation for another day I suppose all right so getting into more into maintenance um I wanted to talk first about International Road check for those who may not be familiar with it you want to give us the rundown of what it is and what folks can expect May 16th through the 18th yeah they put a pretty name on what we used to call the 72-hour Blitz um a lot of drivers say well that's a good time for a vacation but what it is is they take those three days and uh basically the whole cvsa network whether it's States uh provinces up in Canada they take that opportunity to focus on a couple points uh while they're doing their inspection and it doesn't stop them from inspecting the other stuff we were talking about it and last year was lights and logs and they wrote more brake violations um but this year's focus is ABS and cargo securement and there's there's quite a few things that we I've seen lately that they're really focused on cargo securement and dry Vans um yeah so it's um you know it's always interesting to watch because if nothing else what we get out of International Road check is a lot of data from those inspections that are conducted during that three-day time frame and I pulled up the numbers from last year like you said the focus last year was on lights and logs but what we saw last year let's see here um there were over 59 000 vehicle inspections commercial vehicle inspections conducted during last year's Road check 12 456 of those inspections ended up with the vehicle being placed out of service for a serious violation that's 21 of all vehicles inspected during Road check last year were placed out of service almost a quarter of all vehicles which just blows my mind yeah that's a big number it's a huge number and like you said the top violations ended up being brakes tires and lights so even though their focus may be on a couple of issues each year like you said that doesn't stop them from doing their their full inspections that they would do do in placing Vehicles out of service for those issues so um it's it's if you're not going to pay attention to maintenance any other time of the year this is probably a good time of the year to start paying attention to it yeah and that was the other you know with the the out of service this was the one great thing for drivers that that came out of the the change in the SMS or the proposed changes is now brake violations don't fall on them which is only fair I mean you don't want your drivers up under there trying to adjust brakes if they don't you know the long stroke Short Stroke you know the measurements and all that so that is a great thing but it's still a big number and you know the the one thing that I wanted to point out on especially the brakes if you do an annual inspection and the brakes need adjusted you just don't adjust them and walk away there's a reason that they need it adjusted and it's probably good to look back at the last time that trailer was serviced and saw that see if the adjustment happened there as well it could be a symptom of something because if you're constantly adjusting brakes on self-adjusting slack adjusters something's wrong yeah so you know and I I think a lot of times they get adjusted and pushed out the door yeah and by the time that the trailers down the street they're out of adjustment again and then they're just constantly it's kind of violations yeah for that type of thing yeah so that's that type of situation what what needs to happen What should be happening at that point to get to the root of the problem obviously just a deeper look yeah a deeper look into is it the s-cams are worn is it you know we can get into all the different parts or the slack adjuster's bad or they're spline are their teeth missing on the splines you know stuff like that so it's something's causing that problem yeah and that's kind of a broader concern and I think not just specific to breaks but is what is if if we're seeing a quarter of all vehicles being placed out of service for serious violations and that's not just Road chat I think that's close to the national average of just all vehicle inspections throughout the year a quarter of all commercial vehicles being inspected being placed out of service meaning prohibited from operating because they are in such a condition that cvsa has said that they should not be able to be allowed to continue operating what what is the root what are the root problems that are leading to that in your view it's twofold and and it explains exactly why the SMS is split up like it is drivers don't do a good pre-check yeah uh or a post trip pre-check preacher sorry gotta get on an airplane going on an airplane Monday they don't do a good pre-trip and you know they don't do a good post trip or they're not checking their equipment throughout the day yeah that's that's my big soapbox that I get on is you know you pull into a fuel aisle what stops you from turning your lights on and walking around or thumping tires yeah you don't want to check the tires when they're hot but to at least bump them in the pre-trip you can check them um because it bumping a tire especially during a pre-trip that's not going to tell you if it's 50 or 70 pounds but that's going to make a huge difference on whether it's an outer service or not exactly so you know it's I don't think that's happening uh as much as it should should be happening boy I I wish I could say it's this reason is it because in my experience it's it could be contributed to a few different things lack of accountability for the drivers the carriers that engage them or employ them are not holding them accountable to performing those types of inspections in other words they're just letting it go their drivers aren't performing the inspections there are no consequences for not performing the inspections or very little uh you know slap on the wrist type thing so that could be one reason um the other one now escapes me um no accountability and then also um drivers not understanding how these are impacting the driver specifically on their PSP report well you know the thing about that the the PSP and I was just about ready to say that when you say no accountability I wonder if and maybe you and I have talked about this before I wonder if the PSP has lost its bite um I wonder and and maybe that's why they're trying to change it up a little bit but I wonder if because of recently the issue that we've had trying to get drivers in and you know companies trying to hire drivers that as long as they don't have a bunch of hours of service violations are unsafe they're letting the maintenance stuff go and these drivers look a lot more attractive now yeah because we're so many short yeah supposedly but when you when you you don't have any repercussions to say wow we looked at your PSP and you you've got all these maintenance violations or for that fact even some of the other yeah drivers Don't Fear the PSP like they did in 2010 when it started yeah and you know I had an app on my phone that that would bring up a driver's score and they would constantly ask me what's my score what's my score I got inspected what's my score you don't get this incident no I don't think that it really means all that much to the drivers anymore or a lot of them primarily because carriers are not relying on it as heavily as they used to if at all it's a voluntary program and a lot of the motor carriers I work with don't even subscribe to it you gotta pay for it it's a small fee uh what are your thoughts on using that as part of the driver qualification process this is kind of a little off topic yeah a little bit off topic but I think it's it's still an important thing because it gives you a track record of what that driver is doing uh and it obviously in the past two years and and if he's got other jobs and he was getting violations at that particular job what would make you think that he's not going to do that to you as well yeah exactly so I mean if you've got great scores and you don't want them to go anywhere or if you're a borderline you don't want to be thrown put pushed over the edge and if you're high you don't need to make a bad bad situation worse yeah I found not just with PSP but but minimum we talked you talked about the fact that the regulations surprisingly say very little about what it takes to be a qualified driver but what we know is that a lot of motor carriers set their own minimum standards that are oftentimes higher than what the the regulatory requirements are and many times that's driven by Insurance a lot of insurance carriers require that which makes sense and I think the the fear that a lot of carriers have is is locking themselves into whatever standards they end up adopting or whatever PSP points they end up adopting we we get to a point where it starts to cut into our driver capacity or our customer capacity is if if we're not getting candidates in who meet those standards that we have set then we're forced with either abandoning the standards or deviating from them here or there and that can come with its own you know problem yeah you start DV you know that was something that we talked about at the boot camp was you know having a policy that you forego because you want to bring this guy in or that guy in or you know this driver that driver and the next thing you know is everything that you held dear to your heart now you're like and we'll let it go for this one um yeah so that comes that comes at a price and it always comes at can you defend that driver in court exactly if you can't that's the question if you want to look at risk mitigation simply as simply as you can my advice is always always be asking yourself how will this play to a jury if I if I go this route that I'm thinking about going it comes up in driver qualification so much how is that going to play to a jury God forbid that driver then gets involved in an accident that's a perfect area to yeah to ask that question uh let's see we got a comment here Michael's asking are the only two FMCSA certifications required for Mechanics for number one annual inspections and number two breaks so number one FMCSA as we said does not require a specific certification so it's not like they're saying you got to go to a certain course and get this certificate to evidence that you meet these qualifications you don't need to be ASE certified and anything but I don't think you're saying that Mike I think what you're asking is are the only two areas where the FMCSA even talks about mechanic qualifications are in those annual inspections and breaks I think that's true right yeah that is true yeah and it's really not it's not certifications uh they just have to be qualified right so you know there's a there's a distinction there that that definitely needs to be made yeah and the regulations dictate various ways that you can meet their qualifications we've talked about experience or training I think for the breaks they get a little more specific they talk about having been a uh you know law enforcement or gone through one of their inspection programs in the past I think there's a list a state or government or it's just listed as a government right yeah government it uh sponsored yeah that's what we were looking for yeah those are in per 396. um so yeah check that out if that's uh an issue for you so all right so that's International Road check um Coming Up Again May 16th and 18th as we said if if maintenance has not been a big focus of yours to this point number one it should have been a big Focus to you but now is a great time to make it a focus particularly in light of of these increased inspection activity that we're about to see let's see Troy saying with ELD having pre-trip certification how does the driver verify repairs are completed with ELD having pre-trip certification I assume he means the ability to indicate that you have done your pre-trip inspection as kind of a on duty not driving is that what you're yeah typically I believe on a lot most of the ELD platforms oh there's a d there's a dvir process within the um within the the ELD as well so I think that's how they can verify because it's it's signed off or they can take a picture of the repair order or something like that and put it with the DVI yeah he says correct yeah he's talking about the electronic dvir functionality that is being built into more and more um uh elds which I think personally is a a great Innovation because dvirs have historically been a paperwork nightmare yeah I mean it helped that the FMCSA amended its regulations a few years back to eliminate the requirement for dvirs on days where there is no defect discovered but for whatever reason I found that a lot of motor carriers even if their ELD has the dvir functionality are hesitant to move away from from the paper DV IRS has that been your experience as well well the only reason they went to the electronic logs they were forced to um yeah I think that anytime you you put change out there it's people are afraid to change they don't it's been working this way for 30 years why do we have to change now but it's not working but it's not working you know we had the the electronic dvirs on the old qualcomms back in 2016 8 2009 yeah before the Mandate came down we were we were on ELD or aor yeah at the time but we had that functionality in there and it was something simple that you could either write the defect in or if it didn't have any defects just click the box that said no defects and you were done it makes it so much easier it was a lot easier the problem not even just talking about the ELD functionality but to your point Troy the the problem I found with the dvir process in general whether you're on paper or or um doing it through your elds is just people's lack of understanding or um or neglect in following that process through they they either don't understand how that process is supposed to work and so they stop at one point in it and then they don't go the rest of the way because the way that it's supposed to work is If a driver of a commercial motor vehicle becomes aware at any point throughout the day whether it be through his own pre-trip inspection or somebody tells him that there's a problem with his truck or he stopped for a roadside inspection by an officer and the officer writes him up for a maintenance related violation if he becomes aware of any maintenance related defect about his vehicle throughout the course of the day that is likely to affect the safety of its operation then he has to note that on a dvir and the idea with the regulations is it doesn't stop there I see too many carriers stop there the driver has well number one if you're even to that point good for you but sometimes carriers stop there they have the drivers submit the DV IRS then that dvir gets lost in in a pile somewhere yeah and never to be seen again that's not the end of the process that's the beginning of the process driver submits the dvir carry the vehicle is not supposed to be moved again all right can't be redispatched until it's fixed and what carriers Miss is that's an considered an acute violation of the regulations an acute violation to allow a vehicle to drive after a dvir has been completed or recorded without the issue being fixed first and so what that means is if you're involved in an audit and I've seen this play out several times if you get audited in in the investigator doing your audit finds one of those instances where you had a driver submit a dvir but then they have evidence that the driver continued to operate the truck but there's no evidence that the issue was repaired and this could be light bulb out if if the dvir is showing a light bulb out and there's no record of repair but there is record on his logs that he continued driving that's an acute violation and all it takes is one of those to to potentially negatively impact your safety rating in an audit and that could be huge yeah and it could be and you know I remember there was plenty of times that well we'd never write it up on a DVR we just fixed the light and keep going but when we talked about that it we're supposed to you know turn that stuff in to show that we're maintaining the equipment as a driver I never gave that a second thought I fixed the light and kept going yeah but to fix or to finish out that process driver submits the dvir then we have to put eyes on the dvir and we have to fix the issue whether it be the driver himself we're not saying drivers can't fix the issues if it's something like that where you got to supply light bulbs in the truck fix the issue but then the next step is you have to certify those repairs on the dvir right certified that they have been repaired and whether that's you the driver saying I repaired these if your carrier lets you do that or if it's a bigger issue a mechanic signs off on it or the carrier itself and then now you have the paper trail to show that an issue is discovered the the issue was fixed vehicle wasn't driven until it was fixed and then the last step of that process is the next driver of that vehicle whether it's the one that wrote it up or or a different driver code driver or whatever has to review the prior day's dvir and be confident or be sure that if there is an issue noted that it is certified as repaired that wraps up the process well you know and on a bigger scale it's the same process for an inspection report it is you know on maintenance related things those inspection reports come in they have to be signed off because you have to show proof that you've you repaired it and get it back to the state it is not enough to just say we found a problem you have to fix the problem right that is the main part of this and then tell them that you fixed the problem exactly because if you don't have that evidence of repair that is where so many carriers in my experience are going wrong in audits that is where if there is a maintenance audit an audit of your maintenance files maybe you have gotten to that point of being able to identify problems a lot of carriers don't even get to that point their drivers just aren't completing dvirs and so we're completely blind to the issues but if you've gotten to that point so many carriers are missing that next step which is having records of repair in the file if it was your driver fixing the issue on the road then you should be having your driver submit certification that he fixed the issue and technically they should have receipts for those light bulbs that go in the file for that maintenance for the maintenance file Mike Michael you're absolutely right you know a PSP does show uh maybe a falsified driver application that they omitted uh if that driver received an inspection you know during his time with a previous carrier and didn't put it on his app then yeah that's a great way to to catch that yeah for sure um okay where were we we were talking about Road check um I before we run out of time I uh great discussion so far but I want to talk about this Florida case yeah um that you had posted about on LinkedIn and that's kind of what got my mind going about having you on to talk about so uh this is a case involving Dwayne Haskins Jr you may have heard about this case in the news it was big news what last year early last year Dwayne Haskins Jr former quarterback for the Pittsburgh Steelers was uh hitting and killed in Florida Broward County Florida by a dump truck a commercial motor vehicle and that case is now in litigation so you want to give folks kind of a rundown of The Facts of that case yeah first of all the the fact that this lawsuit was filed uh on the very last day before torrent reform went in along with roughly 25 000 or number of thousands of of cases so this is going to be a long process maybe before we see this actually go anywhere just because the courts down there are completely overbooked but the actual court case is uh Mr Haskins was stopped on the freeway um because his car his Rental Car Rental Car ran out of gas which by the way the rental car agencies involved in this suit as well yep uh but he was walking on i-575 and you know part of the facts of the case is he was what three times over the legal limit at .24 uh with ketamine in the system as well so he was wandering on the walking on the freeway and a couple cars swerved to miss it was six in the morning uh the fact that he was they say he was dressed in all black and the dump truck didn't either have enough time or didn't have enough room or you know maybe Mr Haskins was wandering and he didn't it's almost like a deer you know you don't know which way he's going to go and he ended up hitting him with the left front of the dump truck uh it killed him uh in fact he was struck a second time by another vehicle by another car that was passing by and so the I tell you all that to tell you this that the lawsuit that was filed uh is naming the driver the truck owner and the shipper as far as defendants in the case and it's all wrapped around in addition to about 20 more oh my gosh the state of floor the Florida D.O.T the contractor that's supposed to be taking care of that area rental car company the bar that served uh two or three bars that served him and then there was supposed to be a couple guys that they're claiming drugged uh Mr Haskins as a black meal type deal or I don't know know about that part but uh so the the drivers being named the truck becoming owner and the shipper and it's all because they didn't take due Care on the maintenance side uh saying that if the maintenance on this truck was better than he would have been able to avoid hitting Mr Haskins the violations that were found on the truck were found two days later during a post accident um inspection by the Florida DOT and once that stuff came back then you know that that gave the attorney some grounds to do it and this is pretty common occurrence especially with High publicity accidents and fatality accidents where they will do a crew a post-crash inspection of the vehicle that will a lot of times result in an inspection report that lists violations not so much in the pedestrian hit cases but in cases where there's rollovers and vehicle to vehicle crashes a lot of that those violations can be attributed to the crash itself which is always a concern like I said not so much in The Pedestrian case no there was you know there's pictures of the truck I honestly don't even think they busted a headlight on this and you know then the truck was also overweight by 700 pounds so you know they there's a lot that's gone into this on why he didn't stop or why he didn't swerve and you know it's I have my own feelings on that piece of it but looking at the company's maintenance stuff they do have some issues in that category so you know I think this is going to be something where ultimately it's they named everybody to see where it can go yeah what sticks and that's what you need to understand if you are a regulated carrier is that it doesn't matter if those things actually Bear out if the evidence actually Bears out that it was a break problem or a tire problem that actually contributed to the accident it doesn't matter what matters is you are going to get pulled into this lawsuit and those things are going to be alleged and if those things are alleged maintenance related problems you know the next question is going to be what's your maintenance program look like that is going to be a focus of the litigation at that point because those things are alleged and so we're going to be looking the plaintiff's attorney is going to be digging into your maintenance program your CSA scores you're out of your vehicle out of service rates and if they paint a bad picture that picture is going to be painted to the jury in that case and that very well could screw you even if the circumstances of the accident at hand may not have been different whether your vehicle had maintenance problems or not the the case becomes less about the accident at hand and more about your reputation the problems that you have with your maintenance program that is what we know about this reptile theory of litigation that we're always talking about that's what we know is a significant contributor to the nuclear verdicts that we're seeing um and you know if we just look at we've talked about this Brian but the Atri report on the nuclear vertex world I know we all are kind of putting that out there because it's important for carriers to understand that you know that study looked at dozens of uh multi-million dollar case uh jury verdicts awarded against trucking companies over the last decade or so and one of the most interesting things about the study number one those those cases are on the rise I mean skyrocketing yeah like like I think if I'm getting this correctly I think in 2004 there were maybe two cases where a verdict had exceeded a million dollars against a trucking company and then in 2018 there were like over a hundred or something like that yeah and the average jury verdict size has gone from below a million to like 22.3 million dollars that is the average verdict size in cases involving trucking companies accident Highway accident cases what I wanted to say though is one of the most interesting things I found out of that study was one table in that study listed some of the common contributors to these types of cases and it showed what percentage of the cases that involved those particular issues resulted in a verdict in favor of the plaintiff so in other words there was a list of about 10 of them hours of service was at the top there were some driver qualification issues there were also maintenance issues on that chart and what was stunning in that chart is that when those regulatory violates type issues were an issue in the case north of 85 percent of all of those cases resulted in a plaintiff's verdict yeah I think the the lowest number on there was 87 or 89. some of them were 100 yeah they were 100 out of 20 well the hours of service one sticks in there it was 26 cases and a hundred percent of the time where there was an hour as a service violation well and not a lot of violation yeah just problems with hours of service within the company because they can paint the picture as you you don't care about their hours of service um and now they're they're focusing they're moving it towards the vehicle maintenance we've seen unsafe driving we've seen you know where they brought in the driver qualification but you know all that stuff you said about the dvir and the maintenance records and things like that they start bringing that stuff in now that's a whole other candle that becomes the focus of the case and that's what influences the jury because if if they hear all of this evidence about how bad you are performing from a CSA score uh perspective or out of service rates that's what's going to stick in their mind this is a bad company I need to do something to punish that company because of it regardless of the circumstances of this particular accident which should be my focus and so absent tort reform like we're seeing in Florida and stuff like that that's how these cases play out and that's why it's important that you understand these things it's not because uh this particular dump truck maybe had some break issues that's the least of my concerns my major concern is now that that's brought up in the case now we look at your CSA scores and we see you have shitty maintenance scores that is going to be the picture that is shown to the jury yeah and you know we're seeing more and more drivers get drug into these things you know it used to be drivers were kind of insulated uh by the company but now they're getting named exactly in these lawsuits because he didn't do they're they're just basically saying he didn't do pre-trip inspections he didn't take due care and I mean there's the a through K here of all these things that he failed to do yeah as a driver and you know that it's getting dangerous for him yeah and and keep in mind obviously plaintiff's bar is always looking for the Deep Pockets and you know I get it when you're trying to when you're dealing with a serious accident where there are significant injuries or a death I'm not I want to be clear we need to make that family or that person whole the best that we can do through monetary damages we need to get them the money that they deserve if the problems that we caused are are attributable to us in our driver right I'm not saying that that's a problem what I'm saying is a problem when we take it the next step and we start to see these these multi-million dollar verdicts that are intended not to compensate the family but to punish the motor carrier for them being for them having bad safety scores that is where we are seeing these uptick in nuclear verdicts that billion dollar case that we saw in Florida last year 100 million dollars of of those were intended to compensate the family of the victim but 900 million of that award was intended to punish the two motor carriers that were involved in that wreck which neither one of them I think they were single operator they were small yeah they were small so you know the million dollars of coverage is all they had exactly and unfortunately it it's funny money and it it nobody's getting a billion dollars it makes headlines and stuff like that and you know for these small carriers shoot a five hundred thousand dollar verdict yeah that could be it for them so but but the point or I think the tactic of the plaintiff's bar is we understand we're not getting a billion dollars but what we are doing at the same time is desensitizing the public to these huge Awards so that the next case well there's been a billion dollar case in the past so what's a billion dollars let's do two billion dollars yeah you know what at some point it becomes it's it's it's you're desensitized to it or the the thing that the next thing that they want to point out I mean I don't want to put anything out there because I don't want to give anybody any ideas but you know what's next okay we now we've gone after their maintenance one after the drivers now we've gone after the equipment what's next yeah you go after the weather I mean it's it's insane again not saying that all we are saying is that in our view the focus of the case should be the case itself it should not be the carrier's reputation except to the extent that the reputation contributed to the accident that is how our judicial system is built it is about a case between two people it is not putting the motor carriers safety related reputation on trial which is what we are doing in these cases nowadays so that's where kind of tort reform comes into play and uh if you missed our last show we had um Alex Miller's uh CEO of Florida Trucking Association on the show talking about how Florida just recently passed tort reform which is um like you said they passed it at the end of March and I think right up the 24th is when it went into effect and was it the last couple days a couple days there was like 25 000. it was just a huge number of cases and I think we just read before we came on the the court docket is now 13 100 cases per judge something ridiculous now the only reason that this may go higher is because of the high profile person that was involved but you know this it could be tied up but this this also gives everybody out there a great chance to to say all right we gotta dial our maintenance in exactly and and regardless of whether this case proceeds to trial if I had to guess I would say it probably doesn't this is going to get settled the facts are just not great on the other side of things um but the the point is if you're pulled into one of these cases you've already lost the battle because now you are faced with a settlement a potential multi-million dollar settlement to get yourself out of this case particularly when the facts are as they are here where the motor carriers scores are just not great and they don't have a great record of well and the other the other piece was they were saying the driver was going too fast and guess what that Basics an alert too so and overloaded which doesn't help the story that he wasn't able to stop so it's just those little things start to add up and then when you start looking at them you know with the bigger picture of how is this carrier performing it just paints a really bad picture so I think that's what we wanted to convey which is you know seeing the the forest or missing the forest for the trees here don't get so caught up in the fact that you know you you have relatively few brake problems or whatever in a particular accident if the bigger story is we've got an out of service rate that exceeds the national average or we've got a vehicle maintenance CSA score that is an alert status that is the story that's going to be told and that's what's going to stick with the jury and that is what is going to screw you over in those types of cases that's a fact uh so that is it we believe it or not are out of time that was it that was it oh it's four o'clock I think we're gonna go for another couple hours we could actually we probably will but just yeah nobody won't be live so uh yeah we'll do maybe an after session with Brian um but anyway hey just want to thank everybody for tuning in today really appreciate you tuning in to these episodes um be sure to stay tuned for uh the next one we're going to try and do a couple of these per month best way to keep in touch with us is through our newsletter you can subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com we will uh alert you to upcoming episodes you can also find them on trucksafelive.com where we post all of our show information follow us on social media Pages we are constantly posting dot related content on there thanks again to log Rock for sponsoring this uh the season of truck safe live appreciate you teaming up with us to do that that's it anything else Dan no man I think we're good all right see you guys thanks for watching foreign

Event Completed

Friday, April 28, 2023 at 7:25 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube