Episode Summary
In Episode 21 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Brian Runnels, VP of Safety at Reliance Partners, to discuss the critical topic of fleet vehicle maintenance — why it so often goes wrong, and what the consequences can be for motor carriers from both a regulatory compliance and litigation standpoint. The conversation is timely given the approaching International Roadcheck (May 16-18), proposed changes to FMCSA's Safety Measurement System (SMS), and a high-profile lawsuit stemming from the fatal accident that claimed the life of former NFL quarterback Dwayne Haskins Jr.
The hosts cover several industry developments before diving into the main topic, including FMCSA's proposed expansion of the Crash Preventability Determination Program from 16 to 21 eligible crash types — a change widely welcomed by the industry — and the proposed split of the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC into two separate categories: one focused on company-level maintenance failures and one on driver-observed defects that should have been caught during pre-trip inspections. The hosts note that while this change will benefit some carriers, those hovering near alert thresholds should log into FMCSA's SMS preview site immediately, as the changes could push certain scores into alert status before the comment period closes in mid-May.
On International Roadcheck, Runnels and Wiseman highlight that last year more than 21 percent of all inspected commercial vehicles were placed out of service — a figure they describe as staggering. This year's focus is on ABS systems and cargo securement, though inspectors will conduct full inspections regardless of the stated emphasis. The hosts stress that brake violations are among the most common out-of-service findings and warn carriers not to simply adjust brakes and move on without investigating the underlying cause. They also discuss the dvir process in depth, emphasizing that far too many carriers treat the driver's submission of a defect report as the end of the process, when in reality it is only the beginning — vehicles must not be moved until defects are certified as repaired, and that certification must be documented in the maintenance file.
The Dwayne Haskins lawsuit serves as a cautionary case study for the second half of the episode. Runnels outlines how the dump truck involved was inspected two days after the fatal accident and found to have multiple maintenance violations, which have since become central to the litigation despite the unusual and complex circumstances of the accident itself. Wiseman explains that this is precisely how nuclear verdicts are born — plaintiff attorneys use a carrier's overall maintenance record, CSA scores, and out-of-service rates to paint a picture of a negligent company to a jury, regardless of whether those issues directly caused the accident in question. Citing the ATRI report on nuclear verdicts, the hosts note that cases involving regulatory violations result in a plaintiff verdict more than 85 percent of the time, with average verdict sizes rising from below one million dollars to over 22 million dollars in recent years.
The actionable takeaway from this episode is straightforward: fleet maintenance cannot be treated as an afterthought. Safety professionals should ensure drivers are performing thorough pre-trip and post-trip inspections and being held accountable for doing so, that dvir defects are being repaired and certified before vehicles are re-dispatched, that repair records are retained in maintenance files, that mechanic qualifications are documented whether using in-house or third-party maintenance providers, and that carriers are regularly monitoring their CSA scores — particularly their Vehicle Maintenance BASIC — with the same urgency they would apply to hours of service compliance. As Reynolds puts it, a carrier's maintenance record does not just affect roadside inspections; it can define how a jury perceives the entire company if that carrier ever finds itself in a courtroom.