Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 22 - Oral fluid testing

Tuesday, May 9, 2023 at 4:17 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 22 - Oral fluid testing

About This Event

In this episode, we’ll break down the USDOT’s recent rulemaking that paves the way for oral fluid testing (i.e., mouth swabs) in addition to urinalysis for DOT-mandated drug screens. We’re excited to be joined by the architect of this rule and the longest serving Director of the USDOT’s Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance (ODAPC), Patrice Kelly, who now serves on assignment as the Senior Policy Executive Advisor for the National Drug and Alcohol Screening Association (NDASA).

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 22 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman speaks with Patrice Kelly, lead author of the U.S. Department of Transportation's final rule on oral fluid drug testing and the longest-serving director of the DOT's Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance (ODAPC). The conversation centers on the final rule published in May 2023, which authorizes oral fluid testing as an alternative to urine testing for DOT-mandated drug tests. Wiseman and Kelly discuss what the rule means for regulated motor carriers, when implementation can realistically begin, and how the change fits into the broader landscape of transportation industry drug and alcohol compliance. Kelly explains that oral fluid testing does not replace urine testing but gives employers a choice between the two methods. A key advantage of oral fluid testing is that every collection is inherently a directly observed collection, which significantly reduces opportunities for specimen adulteration or cheating. However, no laboratories have yet received HHS certification to process DOT oral fluid specimens, meaning carriers cannot begin using oral fluid testing to satisfy their DOT obligations immediately. Kelly advises fleet safety professionals to subscribe to the ODAPC listserv at www.transportation.gov/odapc and monitor communications from the National Drug and Alcohol Screening Association (NDASA) for updates on when certified laboratories become available. The discussion covers several practical considerations for fleets, including the relevance of oral fluid testing for situations such as post-accident testing, where collecting a urine specimen in a remote location can be logistically difficult, and for employees with shy bladder conditions, where switching to oral fluid testing can save employers significant time and cost compared to the current multi-hour urine collection and MRO referral process. Kelly also notes that under the new rule, oral fluid testing will be required in circumstances involving transgender or non-binary employees when a same-gender collector cannot be identified, removing longstanding procedural uncertainty in those situations. On the topic of detection windows, Kelly cautions that oral fluid testing generally detects drugs over a shorter window than urine, but emphasizes that chronic or regular drug users — including regular marijuana users — should not assume they can simply avoid use immediately before a test and pass. She also reiterates a strong warning about CBD products, noting that they are unregulated by the FDA, frequently contain THC, and continue to generate a significant number of marijuana positives among commercial drivers. Kelly stresses that a positive test result carries the same consequences regardless of the reason, and urges drivers to avoid CBD entirely until federal regulation of those products improves. Wiseman closes the episode by highlighting the scale of the drug and alcohol problem in the industry — nearly 130,000 CDL drivers currently in prohibited status in the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse — and touches on the White House's Recovery Ready Workplace initiative, which encourages employers to consider bringing employees back to safety-sensitive functions after successfully completing the return-to-duty process. Kelly notes that employers are not federally required to terminate employees following a positive test and that the costs of return-to-duty and follow-up testing can be passed back to the employee, creating additional accountability. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to stay engaged with rulemaking processes, subscribe to ODAPC updates, and work with their drug and alcohol program service agents to prepare for oral fluid testing once laboratory certification is in place.

Full Transcript

thank you good morning whether it's true all the things you said you could do not in the mood for a failure always there's ain't no time to pretend together get through the night just when I thought I was dead it's not even fun anymore please thank you Daddy to take you take you through the night thank you thank you thank you this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign hey everyone welcome to Episode 22 of truck safe live the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs excited to be with you today kind of a special episode of the podcast so I'm glad you're here with me if you're here with us be sure to say hey in the comments so we know we're here you're here with us and um yeah like I said special episode today wanted to break down some breaking news uh regulatory news within the industry with respect to drug and alcohol testing drug testing specifically and the final rule that was published last week uh this is May of 2023 when we're recording this uh the the rule last week on oral fluid testing for DOT mandated drug tests so looking forward to talking about that with our guests for today but before we get there a few things going on that are worth mentioning um one thing going on truck safe as always is our truck safe Fleet compliance network if you're not part of this make sure you uh check it out trucksafenetwork.com also in the app store or the Google Google Play Store just search for truck safe you'll find it this is a forum for safety professionals risk advisors for those types of folks to get together learn from one another ask questions and then also gain access to all of our trucks safe uh dot related content that we are constantly pushing out detailed articles a lot of videos on these types of topics so this is free to join and we're doing a lot of truck safe Network exclusive content going on right now so check that out again app store Google Play Store and you will find it uh in the industry a couple things going on um International Road check is coming up next week um if you're not ready for that I suggest you get ready make sure your trucks are ready they're focusing on abs and cargo securement issues this year we did a whole show on this a couple weeks ago with Brian runnels from Reliance Partners had a great discussion about some of the top maintenance related issues that are causing trouble for fleets across the United States so check that out if you missed it over at trucksafelive.com or the replays are available wherever you get your podcast Spotify Apple podcast wherever check that out uh we also put a detailed article on that on our website trucksafe.com you can read more about it there but just make sure you're ready for Road check we um we we talked about in that show how last year during Road check the three-day Blitz where they focus on a particular area of compliance during their road roadside inspections last year I think the number or the percentage of vehicles commercial vehicles that were placed out of service for serious roadside violations uh or serious maintenance violations was was close to 25 percent so a quarter of all commercial vehicles being stopped from operating because of a serious maintenance related issues and that causes a lot of problems as you would expect not only from a regulatory standpoint but more importantly from a highway accident litigation standpoint so you really need to be on top of that stuff so check that out last thing I'll mention uh two other things actually this came out this week I think there were a couple of articles on it I saw in some of the industry Publications a new bill making its way through uh the U.S House of represent it's called the drive act looks like it's sponsored by a few House Republicans that would if it is ultimately adopted obviously there's a long way to go before we get to that point it's just a bill in the house right now but if it if it goes forward this is a bill that would prohibit the FMCSA from moving forward with any kind of speed limiter rule making as as you'll recall maybe um speed limiters have been on the regulatory agenda of the FMCSA and and Nitsa for many years now and we were supposed to see a supplemental uh notice of proposed rulemaking on that topic specifically next month in June but um with this bill making its way through Congress maybe that pushes it back some we'll just have to wait and see but I just wanted to bring that to your attention we'll have to just see how that progresses uh last thing I'll mention is be sure to subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com subscribe we are pushing out all of this kind of breaking news as it comes out when the oral fluid rule came out last week we pushed it immediately just trying to keep the word out on all of these issues that impact regulated trucking companies so if you're interested in keeping up to date on all of that and kind of our analysis of it for what it's worth check that out over at trucksafe.com subscribe alright so getting right into the topic for today over the past few years we've seen a lot of regulatory development specifically in the area of DOT drug and alcohol testing particularly with the implementation of the drug and alcohol Clearinghouse back in 2020 which is shed light on just how big of a drug and alcohol problem we have in the industry the March 2023 Clearinghouse data you can look this up if you're interested in an FMCSA is publishing the data pretty much monthly at this point the the data from March shows that we've had 192 494 positive drug test results reported to the Clearinghouse since 2020 so over a three year period where illness almost have 200 000 positive drug test results posted there most of which are for marijuana as you would probably expect and more importantly the one the number that is continually staggering to me is how many CDL Drivers we currently have in prohibited status in the Clearinghouse meaning they are not authorized to operate a commercial motor vehicle because they have a drug and alcohol testing violation that they haven't gone through the regulatory process to clear up there are again as of March nearly 130 000 CDL Drivers currently in that prohibited prohibited status so clearly a big problem one we anticipate Regulators will continue to Target through periodic rulemaking uh like I said just within the past week usdot published its final rule on oral fluid drug testing which is what we're breaking down in today's episode and to do so I'm excited to be joined by Patrice Kelly the lead author of that rule the longest serving director of The usdot's Office of drug and alcohol policy and compliance odapsy and now on assignment as senior policy executive advisor for the national drug and alcohol screening Association thanks for joining me Patrice thank you for having me and hey listeners hey nurse thanks for joining in it's an honor to be able to talk to you yeah so as you I was just gonna say can I read my little display go for it um because as a U.S Department of Transportation employee I am on detail to the National drug and alcohol screening Association the views reflected in my discussion today are My Views they haven't been cleared or reviewed or approved by the US Department of Transportation and they don't necessarily reflect the views of the U.S Department of Transportation Patrice and I are both lawyers so we have to start out with the disclaimers for any of our shows so very important information I appreciate that uh for for those folks who may not be familiar with you Patrice I I uh I came across you recently uh I've been a member of indesa for a while and I have always enjoyed the kind of content they put out about drug and alcohol testing specifically I watched a webinar that you had recently done for them on the oral fluid testing specifically so that was very insightful and just I knew I had to get you on here to kind of break this rule down and let people know what's going on but before we get to that kind of can you give us our your background and how you got involved in DOT drug and alcohol testing to begin with sure um thanks so I'm in a lawyer by training I went to law school in the Washington DC area Georgetown and uh my first law firm did Trucking as well as Airline and shipping work so I always had a strong interest in transportation and then when I moved into the government I started with Federal Aviation Administration and when I was there drug and alcohol testing was pretty new uh it was the early 1990s and frankly none of the other lawyers wanted to deal with it because they said that's too much science I like doing air traffic control cases where either the guy busted his clearance or he didn't pass disclaire it's kind of it seems a lot more exciting [Laughter] you know it was like either a went below the altitude or he didn't um so I liked the idea of getting into the science and pretty much I stayed with it since then from FAA now to the office of the secretary about 16 years ago and it's been a field that I've watched go through a lot of growth and I have to say you know it started with tragedy there were accidents all three of them related to marijuana that brought us this program they were two New York City subway accidents and an Amtrak Conrail Collision in Chase Maryland in 1987. um I actually personally separately from that lost a good friend in high school to a drunk driving accident because her boyfriend was so drunk that he decided to play chicken with a train and everybody in the van he was driving lost so I think I um I have a certain perspective about a deep respect for transportation employers and operators I have family who drive um with their CDLs all over the country and I have a deep respect but also a deep concern for safety which I know that your entire audience shares in terms of we all want safe operations we may have differing opinions on how we get there but this is about safety to me and a way I've chosen to serve my country for sure yeah I appreciate that background I think what a lot of people don't realize and that is always interesting to me particularly because I work primarily in trucking regulations so I'm working with the FMCSA regulations a lot but the the drug and alcohol testing aspects of it what folks don't realize at least in our industry often is is that they are broader than the rest of the regulations that we're dealing with on a day in and day basis in the in the sense that they apply to all modes of transportation that's right pipelines um and Aviation Coast Guard Mariners are involved as well as CDL school bus drivers and the rest of the family in the rail community and Transit so I was wondering uh I mentioned at the start that you're the longest serving director of The usdot's Office of drug and alcohol policy and compliance odapsy can you explain to folks what is odapsy and how it fits into the broader usdot sure odapsy is part of the office of the Secretary of Transportation and in my job as director I'm the first level below the politicals and I had been advising them as to how to handle these safety issues then also my job as the Director was to work with the Federal Aviation Administration Federal Motor care safety administration pipelines Coast Guard and others to bring everybody together so as you probably know in FMCSA they Define which employers are safety sensitive which employees are safety sensitive and you know what how the testing is going to go down what the actual definition of an accident is for post accident um and it's that way with each of the modes what our office does audacity is we give the procedures for how a test is done so that the same procedures are used for airline pilots as for CDL holders ask for Coast Guard Mariners and so on everybody's subject to the same collection procedures the same same laboratory procedures the same medical review officer procedures and that actually really keeps the costs down believe it or not when I first started in this program well I won't go into my history let's just say when the program first started in the late 80s a drug test cost about fifty dollars and today a drug test is pretty close to fifty dollars and that's I think in large part because the procedures are the same we have not customized them which drives up costs and also the number of tests going on each year continues to increase so in odapsy last year in 2022 we saw about seven million tests conducted so it's an economy of scale and we are very careful not to make huge changes to it so we can try to keep those costs down and in line with what folks need because we understand that your listeners and others in the transportation Industries are not in business to do drug testing do drug testing is something that is necessary to help them with the safety end of things but it's something that shouldn't have to become their overall preoccupation they've got a real occupation to carry out yeah for sure and that's why we have part 40 votes so folks in in the trucking will know we have part 40 and we have part 382 and they're always asking why are they so separate it's because part 40 are the more the the procedural aspects of the drug and alcohol testing program that apply to all the modes whereas part 382 for us is the fmcsa's part small part of that drug and alcohol testing process where they talk about the Clearinghouse among other things and and those things that are specific to trucking um you mentioned kind of not shaking things up trying not to shake things up too much uh for folks but I do want to spend time obviously the the purpose of today's show is to talk about a fairly significant shake up uh for drug and alcohol testing which is oral fluid testing rule you were the lead author on that rule what was that what's that process been like first of all it was a very exciting project and one that we had been trying to carry out for a very long time and finally everything was able to align properly for us to move it forward so oral fluid testing gives employers an alternative type of test it does not mandate that everybody has to switch over to oral fluid it doesn't end your intestine it's all about employer choice so the way the process worked was initially I worked with the team to draw up the notice of proposed rulemaking and go out with what we envisioned and it was more than just oral fluid there were a lot of other things that we wanted to adjust and make more contemporary Within part 40. so we made our proposals and then the public response was fantastic we got 417 comments which is the most we've gotten for any rule making since we rewrote part 40 in the year 2000 and I was part of that team back then too so 417 commenters who each had many issues that they wanted to comment upon brought the total number of actual subject matter comments into the thousands and it was fascinating I personally read every single one and for those of you out there who wonder is it worth it to comment on a rulemaking I can tell you that our colleagues in odapsy and our colleague in the FMCSA really read every single comment and you don't have to agree with us but yeah that's the thing I harp on this all the time to our clients is you know if you've got an issue with a rule that has been proposed that's the rule making process that is your opportunity when it's in the proposal stage to get your thoughts out there and it's not one of those things where your comments don't matter where they just get buried and nobody reads them the agency is in my experience and it sounds like in your experience as well obviously putting eyes on your comments and if you have legitimate concerns that they they need to take into consideration they will take those into consideration and I think if they just read this oral fluid testing they will see that you you and I were talking earlier where you specifically cite or you you quote some of the commenters in the final rule yeah and I think that was we've been working on in the department over the years because I think it really helps to see that you made a difference now some commenters prefer to mark their comment as Anonymous and that's fine you can do that if there's a rule that really makes you annoyed you might want to go Anonymous but um you know you know in all seriousness we're not coming again after you make a comment then we don't like um the issue is you know if you're annoyed it's okay to say I disagree but explain why yeah you know don't just say that I disagree but with that said you know I've I've actually even had cases where the courts uh have quoted back to us from our Preamble and they said c dot actually did listen and this is what some of the people who were going to be impacted by this rule had to say about it and we the court agree so you know the comments actually have saved me in some of my rule makings and helped the courts to sustain them because we do make changes based on what our public commenters say and I think that's so important for people to know you know it's and if if you've been preaching that thank you um but every conference I go to that's one of the things that I say to everybody is it's so important to be heard rather than grumbling about the rule afterwards Wonder rather than wondering if you can sue on it get those comments in up front because the government really does need to meaningfully address what you think yeah for sure definitely uh so tell us the oral fluid testing rule came out last it was it was published in its final form last week from when we're recording this tell tell folks what it does fluid testing now oral fluid testing in many people's eyes is much less invasive than urine because you know there are many people who would come out with an ick factor of carrying their urine out of a bathroom and providing it to a collector so the collector can subdivide it in their presence and send it to a laboratory oral fluid is going to be a scenario where the collector would pass the individual the collection device and the individual will put that device to their mouth themselves and so every collection is a direct observed collection and many people in the trucking industry favor hair testing because it's direct observation so again we're this one has been approved by our scientists at HHS hair has not yet been resolved at HHS but this one was long ago approved by HHS and it is giving us a directly observed collection methodology and some of the other things that we had proposed in the regulation we adopted the commenters were very positive about them in cases where the commenter said hey wait a minute let's use a little Caution here we don't agree then there were a couple of areas where we pulled back and it was not specifically about oral fluid testing in any of those scenarios but there were other scenarios where we were trying to address things and the public said hey you didn't do the right thing um we're we're not happy with this one of them was we set a laboratory we proposed to say a laboratory could get rid of specimen after 90 days saying unless it was challenged they could get rid of it currently they have to retain it for one year Well an awful lot of commenters including unions came in and said we'd like to see those held longer because somebody may not realize that they want to challenge it or somebody may find out that he or she's in the Clearinghouse three months later after they end up in the Clearinghouse and they want to know that they can at least put a litigation hold on that specimen and so we said you know those are excellent points and we were trying to reduce costs we were figuring that if people have been notified by a medical review officer that they are positive that they would do something quickly about their positive but we're learning from the public comments and what we learned from the Clearinghouse too is that sometimes people don't find out right away so we stepped back we did not change that to 90 days we left it at one year to make sure that everybody had and understanding that the due process was going to be there for them yeah that makes sense so in essence oral fluid testing though they're mouth swabs right is that essentially what they are um there are different types so there's also a device that looks like an inverted y sort of picture a piece sign and you spit into the top of it and then it goes down into two little tubes so um it would go down into this tube it would go down into this tube and then it could be subdivided here's the key point in non-dot testing oral fluid testing has gone a long way has come a long way and people usually will just do one specimen collection with a pad in dot because of our empowering legislation the Omnibus Transportation employee testing Act of 1991. there has to be a specimen that gets subdivided in the presence of the donor so it can't be from two different sides of your mouth it can't be something that is consecutive yeah that makes a tricky yeah it has to be one specimen that gets subdivided and we want to see that one specimen go into the mouth come out of the mouth and be divided so that's something HHS sorry the Department of Health and Human Services who are the scientists who approve the Laboratories who do the DOT drug testing HHS has not yet approved anyone for oral fluid testing because none of the Laboratories came forward and again you know we're talking about economies of scale so Health and Human Services in 2019 approved oral fluid testing for federal employees well there are only about 400 000 of those tests that go on each year and that was not enough of a profit incentive for Laboratories to go get certified because it can cost six figures to hold your certification yeah so the labs also okay we're going to wait until there's seven million tests potentially in this market and then here we go so yeah so May 3rd um which was the day we published the final rule kind of gave Laboratories a new incentive now to take another look at Oral fluid testing and go out and get certified so as of this point in time zero labs are approved no one can start oral fluid testing for DOT I have a lot of people asking you know if you had a crystal ball when do you think we could expect to see the labs be certified do you have any insight on that or no I don't yet because it's going to depend on what devices they choose that's another thing too unless you're talking about a device that somebody just cleanly spits into that inverted wide device if it has a buffering pad then there's a special chemistry that goes into that where the laboratory has to have certain chemicals they call them immunoassays where the immunoassays are going to properly discern which drugs are in or not in the specimen all that has to be worked out between the Laboratories and HHS so when the Laboratories go in they're going to be certified to work with certain specific devices so you won't be able to use if you're doing non-dot testing right now chances are non-dot oral fluid testing for your company program chances are it's not going to be the same devices and it may not even be the same Labs who are going to do that moving forward so it's because there are a lot of ifs in this and think about it you know can you tell me what load somebody's going to to be hauling in six months not if they're independent because you got to see what the market is going to bring you and then you're going to be knowing what load you're going to be carrying at that point so I can't tell you right now if this is going to be just a matter of a short period of time or a couple of months but you know I had to guess it'd be a few months so for carriers listening that are eager to start using oral fluid testing to satisfy their dot obligations where should they be on the lookout for notice what will odap see I assume give notice at some point when the labs have been certified www.transportation.gov forward slash which is the question mark key o as well I'll do Oscar Delta Alpha Papa Charlie odamsey so www.transportation.gov forward slash odapsy when you go in there you can pretty easily find your way to listserve and you can click and subscribe to the listserv it's free they won't spam you they're not going to send a good morning hope your day is going well kind of message there will only be announcements when it's important to you regarding the drug and alcohol testing programs so I would strongly suggest for your listeners to plug into that also the national drug and alcohol screening Association the organization to which I'm currently detailed and daisa will have membership emails that go out and another thing they do are called membership minutes or member minutes where they if there's a news flash that comes out they make sure they get that out to you quickly and also every Wednesday they have what they call Town Hall meetings where andesa listens to their members and the members engage in discussions regarding drug and alcohol issues yeah so be sure to if you're listening and you have any interest in this not only this issue but drug and alcohol broadly speaking be sure to to tune in to those channels because they provide a wealth of information I've always appreciated all of the good information that they send out so be sure to do that Patrice you had mentioned uh kind of the the the way that we have it structured in in transportation with the split specimens I find I found over the years that that not a lot of folks really understand what's going on there I was wondering if you could take a minute or two just to explain what the purpose of the split specimen is and and how drivers who find themselves in a position where the initial test comes back positive can can leverage that protection that's available to them with the split sure great question I'm happy to cover that and as a federal employee I actually was subject to drug testing too and what happens is well first of all Congress has guaranteed the transportation industry employees the right to a split specimen and so what happens is one specimen is taken whether it's urine or in the future oral fluid it will be taken and subdivided in your presence so you'll see a bottle a and a bottle B okay and then a gets tested at the lab they both get sent to the laboratory together and then the lab opens bottle a and they test it and that's where they come out with your drug test result if you find out that it was adulterated or it was positive the medical review officer will be calling you and if the medical review officer calls you then and you don't have a legitimate medical explanation for why you had this result then the medical review officer will tell you well you have the right to a split specimen being tested and you have up to 72 hours to request this and at that point if you want that specimen tested the cost of testing it are up to you and that can be a couple hundred dollars but um they will go back and they will send that to a second lab that will then independently test only for the thing for which you were positive or if it was adulterated the thing for which the adulteration was determined to be so it's not going to run a full panel again but if you were a marijuana positive or if you had just way too much nitrate in your urine that's usually a sign of an adulterant um but again you have the right to be able to ask for that to be tested and the cost will fall on you in most situations unless there's a collective bargaining agreement that diverts that um yeah so 72 hours not that much time a lot of folks that come to me after the fact have already passed that that time frame so if you're subject to this drug and alcohol testing be aware that your your clock is ticking at that point once you get notified of the positive test result right you know first of course notified by a medical review officer that something's wrong with their test that's going to be an extremely stressful situation you know even if you know you used something it's still gonna be stressful if you don't if you don't think you're used anything maybe you used marijuana and didn't realize that it was in whatever you consumed I would really recommend if you're having a conversation with the mro first and foremost pull over don't drive secondly just grab a piece of paper and start writing down what the medical review officer is telling you because it's going to be really hard you're going to have a rush of adrenaline it's stressful and you it's really hard to remember everything they're telling you and you might need a few minutes to absorb it also don't be afraid to tell the medical review officer hey wait a minute can you repeat that yeah or you know I just I need a second to take a breath let's talk about this again because it's gonna hit you hard and you have some decisions to make and if you you know like I said I'll use the example of marijuana where you didn't realize that you had consume something with marijuana but now you're in big trouble you can't undo that but at least you want to be able to have a chance to calm down sort your thoughts and have a reasonable discussion yeah yeah important information for sure I've got a couple of people asking I have this down as a question for you as well kind of going back to oral fluid testing specifically what's your understanding from all of the research that you did and kind of drafting the final rule in terms of uh how oral fluid testing compares to your analysis in terms of detection windows and stuff like that HHS was able to come out and say that oral fluid is as scientifically accurate and forensically defensible as urine testing so in other words you're going to get a fair and accurate test that will stand up in a court of law okay so that's first and foremost secondly when we when I originally wrote the nprm and as a team we went over it we tried to gather information on Windows of detection we kept going back and forth to our scientists of eight at HHS and they kept saying well that window's right but then there are circumstances where it's wrong and then so we proposed the rule with a window of detection table and then we decided not to include that in the final rule because none of the commenters really hit it head on um except some commenters thought hey on oral fluid testing it's a really short window so I can use all the marijuana I want for two weeks straight and as long as I don't use it right before the pre-employment test I'm good well it doesn't actually work that way yeah if you're a regular user of marijuana you are actually going to test positive on an oral fluid test even if you didn't use it in the last couple of hours um so usually the windows of detection for oral fluid meaning for all the drugs you're going to detect them over a shorter period of time with oral fluid and generally longer with urine and of course in the area of hair testing where many trucking companies do conduct their company policies you have an even longer window of detection generally speaking for across the board it's oral fluid then you're in then hair but the reality is um with a lot of these drugs if you're a chronic user they're still in your system yeah um one of the interesting things I thought about the rule you mentioned this at the start is kind of a a good way to look at this of how this is an optional test type so this is giving employers the option of conducting either or oral fluid testing or or your analysis they can continue doing things the way that they have been doing if they wanted to this is just giving them one more option why was it important to the department to give them that option rather than just say we're going to go with this particular test type or another there were a couple of this one was that the trucking industry and the transit industry desk really wanted to do oral fluid testing they wanted something other than urine then there were a lot of employees and employee unions who felt that urine was just invasive by its nature as I said that ickiness of carrying warm urine out of the bathroom and giving it to somebody for them to subdivide in your presence had an ick factor that a lot of people wanted to distance themselves from and also to the department from a safety standpoint we have struggled for years with the people who cheat on drug tests and when you allow someone to go into a restroom facility unobserved and provide their urine because remember 90 7 to 98 of people subject to testing are testing negative so generally we're talking about people who are not drug users when you allow them to go in and they are a drug user then it is a lot easier for them to do something to their specimens so that the result will not be positive oral fluid takes away that ability to cheat the test because the collector is going to see if you have anything in your hands they're going to see if they're putting if you're putting anything to your mouth and there's also a mandatory waiting period of up to 10 of 10 minutes so while you're filling out the paperwork and everything else anything that would have been in your mouth at that point will have dissolved and presumably washed away yeah one of the other uh things that kind of spurred this on from what I understand um and maybe not so much as those two things you just mentioned but was this whole idea with shy bladder for folks who have trouble uh providing a urine specimen for for DOT uh drug tests that we've done those historically there's been this concept of shy bladder where some folks have a medical condition that may prevent them from being able to provide a sufficient specimen to be tested is that another driving force for for this type of uh regulatory development absolutely for the last oh my goodness at least 15 years the community of individuals who have shy bladders due to the psychiatric condition known as pyoresis have been asking us to consider something other than urine testing and um in this you know in the scenario that we're proposing again remember now I don't have my D.O.T hat on you know I had to kind of curb myself make sure that I was um staying in my Lane when I was writing this rule but I have to tell you guys if you're an employer the employer has the choice the employee doesn't have the choice as to what kind of test is going to be administered but if you're an employer have a little Mercy for the people who are having a shy bladder issue if you find out from your collection site because they're supposed to call you and say hey this employee is not able to provide a urine specimen can I go to oral fluid or even better if you have a standing order that says whenever any of my folks come in they have a shy bladder let's go to oral fluid that's going to make the whole process a lot more Humane the only time in this changed part 40 where we're going to mandate oral fluid testing is exactly in that shy bladder when there is a transgender or non-binary individual if you have an employee who identifies with a different gender or is a gender x a non-binary then that individual how are you going to find the same gender collector for them it's been a traditional issue for the program for a long time now we're taking away that confusion and we're just saying in the rare circumstance where you have that the person is going to get an oral fluid test period end of story and so you do want to have something set up so that in that rare circumstance where that comes to pass you would use oral fluid but again now I'm just talking to you with the dot hat off think about it be Humane you know be considerate of somebody I've dealt with a lot of scenarios where you have combat vets who come back and they've got PTSD yeah and the next thing you know um they're in a shy bladder situation and because they may or may not have had prior treatment for it and if they have not had prior treatment and not been previously analyzed for it then it's a refusal yeah well I was going to ask you about that and sorry to put you on the spot here uh but if if they have a shy bladder issue and they're not able to provide the initial specimen normally under current rules they would have to get the mro involved to determine whether there was a medical explanation for it with the oral fluid testing once it becomes permissible are they able to switch immediately over to oral fluid testing if they have the shy bladder issue before they talk with the mro yes and yeah but that is employer-controlled I see and frankly for employers it's a whole lot cheaper yeah because once you get the mro involved in the shy bladder process first of all with the shy bladder process the individual has to sit there for three hours trying and drinking water trying to provide enough of a specimen and then you have a metal you have to get the mro involved and there has to be a referral physician who evaluates the individual and determines whether or not they have a pre-existing condition that renders them unable to provide that much urine so just to change you see the dollar signs flashing as I'm talking right it's like the uh it's like the gas tank as you're filling up the fuel tank um you're watching those numbers click in front of your eyes whereas you could just switch over to an oral fluid test and obtain the result and boom you have a fair and accurate test result so while employers are not being in any way forced to do this it is a really useful tool to get a test result without driving up your costs yeah and not only in that shy bladder context but I I get the sense that there may be some carriers out there who because it's their option they may choose to use your analysis for certain mandatory test types but then for other types of tests I'm thinking like in our industry post accident versus random and versus pre-employment they may choose different test types depending on which kind it is right like think about post accident you've got somebody who has had an accident obviously in 99.9 of the case is not very close to your home base so now you're sending out a urine collector you're trying to find a facility where they can go perhaps in the middle of the night early morning hours to provide a urine specimen whereas an or fluid specimen can be done quickly easily on site with minimal compromising of privacy um so you've got a much better option yeah that's the other thing I really appreciate about the rule is how easy they are relatively speaking to administers are you getting the sense that because right now you know there may be some particularly larger motor carriers that have their own collectors on site they may I think you mentioned this in the rule they may have a clinic on site to to do that but that's not very many of them they're they're mostly sending them out to third parties to to do the collections but with oral fluid testing do you anticipate that more employers will have somebody on staff that is certified to take those collections because of the ease you know it's interesting that you say that because that was one of the questions we asked commenters and an awful lot of employers came back and said oh yeah no I am not doing that because I don't want the liability of somebody in my company doing a test on Joe and then Joe's result comes back positive and now we've got all sorts of issues in the workplace yeah so a lot of employers said I don't want the liability of that I you know thanks for offering but no thanks you today collect employers can do their own collections for urine in-house there is no prohibition on that we just don't want direct supervisors doing it but employers can do that today and I tell you honestly very few employers do that coming from the aviation industry years ago I saw two air carriers who did it because they had in-house clinics at the very largest of the trucking companies perhaps they have an in-house clinic and so they're gonna use um somebody who's a nurse there in house Clinic to do that kind of testing but generally they don't do their own urine so even though oral fluid is a little bit easier per se there are still those issues about I don't want to interfere with workplace friendships and relationships and I don't want the liability because if I need to fire that person I need to be able to be objective in and you know clean on this sure makes sense uh jumping back I forgot to ask this we're talking about shy bladder and how how oral fluid testing may help in that scenario specifically but now we've also got on that side of things we've got this idea of of dry mouth so it sounds like we could have a kind of similar issue with the oral fluid testing where people aren't able to give a sufficient oral fluid specimen as well in that case then you could switch to a urine if that's so vice versa so the option there is the important part the issue about um dry mouth from what the scientists at HHS tell us and what people in the oral fluid testing Industries and non-dot testing tell us is much more rare than a shy bladder you know if you just have mild dehydration you actually don't have dry mouth your mouth may feel drier and you're thirsty but it's not true dry mouth you can still do one of these specimens whereas in urine if you just if you're not properly hydrated you can end up in this problem sure so um yeah that's an issue dry mouth we have procedures for that but you can also switch back to urine and get the job done great um one of the last questions I had that I get from a lot of clients about the rule is um understanding about the cost differentials between oral fluid testing and and your analysis you had mentioned kind of the cost of your analysis test being stagnant which has been great over the last however many years 20 plus years what's your understanding it looked like from the final rule that maybe you all had initially thought or got the impression that they were going to be cheaper but then maybe you got some comments that suggested otherwise exactly we thought what we went into the analysis with was what HHS had also used for their analysis which was about 35 dollars per per oral fluid test what we heard from the commenters is that fails to take into account that every oral fluid device is something that a collection site or an employer ultimately ends up paying for each of the devices today costs about four dollars we're talking about split specimen devices so we and those are not yet made so it could be eight dollars a device it could be six dollars a device and those devices expire unlike urine cups urine cups never expire because they're just an empty cup with split specimen empty cups in them inside a plastic bag in this you have buffering Solutions unless you're using a neat device and so we have the issues of expiration dates and shelf life and a collection site having to throw out devices that they've purchased if they don't use them up in the appropriate time so you know those that's all um something that we had failed to take into consideration but with that said while people said hey you estimated too low nobody actually came back and gave us hard numbers so you'll see our economic analysis is more qualitative than quantitative because of the lack of data provided um you know a couple of quick things one of your commenters or one of the folks who's listening has asked for the adapsy website again and it's www.transportation.gov forward slash Oscar Delta Alpha Papa Charlie and the other thing is I'll just tell you guys the way I get it really quickly by looking it up is I'll just go ahead and Google odapsy again Oscar Delta Alpha Papa Charlie and it will give it to you as either the first or second hit so that's a really quick way to look it up and also something in our earlier discussions Brandon you mentioned CBD yeah and I just kind of want to reiterate back in 2020 I wrote a CBD notice if you Google dot CBD you'll hit the notice and it warns people buyer beware the CBD is not regulated by the FDA you don't know what you're taking and in most cases it has a significant amount of THC in it which is going to give you a marijuana positive and that's going to give you something that is going to send you to the sap and remove you in the meantime from safety sensitive functions so please stay away from CBD products they're not safe for you to use yeah another thing that I regularly harp on we've that's probably the topic that we have the most content on out there I just put a an article out with pre-pass on this where it's a huge issue in our industry we have so many drivers now that are testing positive because they took a CBD under the impression from the manufacturer's representations on the packaging that it contain no THC and then they take it and it turns out it did unless and until we get the FDA to to step in and to regulate the manufacturer of the that product I think it's too risky for truck drivers to be using CBD for that reason because like you said Patrice once I test positive dot doesn't care what the rationale for the positive test was it's a positive test and and you're out of a job unless and until you go through the return to duty process right and as you said you're trying to do the right thing as a truck driver you're reading those labels and those boxes and they're lying to you yeah big issue um we're running out of time Patrice I really appreciate is there anything on oral fluid testing that we didn't uh that we didn't touch on that you need that you would like to touch on score for everybody it's not when Laboratories are approved and you can bet that your current folks who are selling you your drug and alcohol um Services your contractors for that are going to be the ones who are letting you know hey guess what this is now ready and here's what we recommend you do so hold tight it's coming but just not quite yet not quite yet almost there um last thing I wanted to mention we had talked earlier about this and I wanted to make sure we gave you an opportunity to kind of hit on it we we talked there at the end about the return to duty process and and I know from working in this industry for many years that a lot of motor carriers and Employers in other Industries are hesitant to bring back drivers or or employees who have previously tested positive for drugs or alcohol because of the liability concerns and I get that but uh you had mentioned something interesting to me I thought it was worth mentioning kind of the White House and usdot initiatives to get drivers back in trucks following a positive drug or alcohol testing violation right thanks for bringing that up um the White House calls it the recovery ready workplace initiative and they are encouraging employers to bring people back to work once you know that they can safely pass a return to duty test and then they're going to be subject to follow-up testing under the DOT regulations which is also going to help keep somebody clean and keep them in a status where they're going to be able to continue to perform and you know honestly for a lot of people they're not ready to lose their career over having a second positive and so that also creates incentive so don't necessarily assume that anybody at least on the federal side expects you to fire an employee after they have a positive you can put them through the sap process at their expense and actually as employers especially small employers you want to keep in mind that unless you have a collective bargaining agreement to the contrary you you don't have to pay for the return to duty and follow-up tests you can Bill them back to your employee so that'll further help keep somebody committed to the cause when they know that they are going to be built back for every test you put them through on the return to duty and follow-up scene and that's going to help to assure that they're going to continue to stay drug free for your purposes yeah it's an important topic especially I mentioned the numbers at the start you know with 130 000 drivers currently in prohibited status that's not an insignificant number of drivers who just are not available now for motor carriers to use but if they go through that return to duty process give granted there are again liability issues notwithstanding if they go through the return to duty process they have done what the regulations ask of them to do to go back to work and and from a regulatory standpoint you are clear as long as you follow that process and do those follow-up testing so important point to consider for sure Patrice I want to thank you so much for joining me today it was uh it was great information uh really appreciate it I appreciate everything you did for your work on putting together that final rule glad to see it across the finish line here and I hope to have you back on sometime thanks for joining me thank you it was a team process and I really am grateful to the whole audacity team and I really want to thank you and your listeners for taking the time today it really was a pleasure being with all of you thank you all right thank you okay we're gonna wrap things up for today's show thanks everybody for tuning in for a little while spending some time with us be sure to follow us on our social social media accounts LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Youtube we're constantly pushing out the latest Highway Transportation news and Analysis so follow us there for uh the latest uh things like this that are going on in the industry also stay tuned for uh information about our next episode of truck safe live visit trucksafelive.com for details thanks again so much to our sponsor for this season of trucksafe live log Rock really appreciate you teaming up with us that's all I got thanks everybody thanks for watching see you later

Event Completed

Tuesday, May 9, 2023 at 4:17 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube