Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 23 - The top telematics considerations

Thursday, June 1, 2023 at 4:44 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 23 - The top telematics considerations

About This Event

In this episode, we’re joined by Rob Carpenter of Carpenter Compliance, LLC to discuss the current state of fleet telematics solutions and what factors and functionality motor carriers should be taking into consideration when evaluating their options. We’ll address common use cases, functionality, reporting, risks, and much more!

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 23 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter of Trucksafe Consulting dig into one of the most consequential technology decisions a fleet can make: selecting and managing a telematics solution. With telematics devices becoming increasingly prevalent — and in the case of electronic logging devices, federally mandated — the episode explores the full spectrum of considerations fleets should weigh when evaluating vendors and systems, from basic regulatory compliance to advanced AI-powered camera technology. The conversation begins with a foundational overview of what telematics encompasses, including ELDs, event recorders, forward- and inward-facing cameras, GPS tracking, and vehicle diagnostics. Brandon and Rob emphasize that the ELD mandate remains the only federally required telematics component for most carriers operating in interstate commerce, and that fleets sourcing a new ELD should verify their chosen device appears on FMCSA's self-certification list. Rob draws on his experience managing telematics programs across a 14-DOT-number private equity fleet to illustrate the real-world differences between vendors, including firsthand examples of non-compliant installations and meaningful gaps in AI accuracy between platforms. He notes that lower-cost systems can carry hidden expenses in the form of labor hours required to manually review inaccurate event alerts, potentially making a more expensive but more accurate system the better financial decision overall. The hosts devote significant attention to the growing use of AI-powered dual-facing cameras and the benefits and risks they present. On the benefit side, Rob describes how camera footage enabled his team to reduce auto claims by more than 40 percent in roughly 18 months by identifying individual driver behaviors and delivering targeted coaching rather than broad, generalized training. The hosts also discuss the legal value of video evidence in litigation, noting it can serve to exonerate drivers and carriers or, conversely, help a carrier recognize fault quickly and settle efficiently. Privacy considerations, particularly around inward-facing cameras and varying state consent laws, are flagged as an important area for carriers to evaluate before deployment. Perhaps the most critical takeaway from the episode is the data management challenge. Brandon recounts a cautionary example from a mock DOT audit in which a carrier was unknowingly generating driver performance scores through their telematics platform — scores that could be devastating in litigation if a low-rated driver were later involved in a serious accident. Rob reinforces this point by highlighting the risks of accumulated diagnostic codes and unmanaged event data, stressing that carriers must understand the full universe of data their system collects and have a documented, consistently enforced process for acting on it. As Rob puts it, carriers need good policies in place and a culture that enforces accountability within the management process, because the system will tell on itself and on the managers who fail to use it. The hosts close by agreeing that the answer to the data management challenge is never to forgo telematics altogether, but rather to invest in understanding the system, build structured event management protocols, and pair technology adoption with a coaching-oriented culture. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to thoroughly vet vendors on accuracy, compliance, total cost of ownership, and data transparency before signing contracts — and to revisit their existing platforms to ensure they are fully aware of what data is being collected and how it is or is not being managed.

Full Transcript

call me the Joker call me the fool when she calls I always hey there goes on planes got no crash all attributes you don't know if I'm talking about you baby have fun you know it's true yeah yeah baby foreign foreign foreign foreign this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com thank you hey everyone welcome to episode 23 of trucksafe live a show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon truck safe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting-edge safety program great show in store today um talking about telematics and some considerations that all fleets should be thinking about when they are sourcing a solution that will work for them looking forward to talking with a good friend and uh um industry expert on these type of issues Rob Carpenter so we will do that here in just a few minutes before we do that a couple of things going on at truck safe and also in the industry that we should talk about here in terms of truck safe news uh wanted to announce um our next truck say Fleet compliance boot camp which is going to take place on October 12th and 13th this time in Orlando Florida at the Rosen Plaza Hotel uh we held one of these earlier in Indy you probably remember us talking about it heard nothing about great things uh from it so we're excited to to do it even bigger and better in Orlando later this year uh going to show a real quick video here um to uh to kind of preview that here we go hey everyone Brandon here with truck safe I wanted to take a second to tell you about our Fleet compliance boot camp an immersive two-day conference that we hold in person twice a year this boot camp is designed to equip a small group of trucking professionals whether it's an owner safety team member dispatcher risk advisor or otherwise with the knowledge and tools that they need to develop a Cutting Edge safety program at their Fleet we hold two boot camps each year one in the spring and one in the fall and recap attendance at around 50 so that we can offer more personalized instruction and assistance and to facilitate more collaboration among our attendees and this isn't your typical conference where you take some notes and then try to implement what you learned on your own back home boot camp is comprised of discrete and intensive sessions targeted at Key areas of DOT compliance where attendees not only receive industry-leading educational content from industry experts but more importantly get Hands-On and participate in specially developed extra exercises like driver log audits accident simulations driver qualification reviews and more all to help equip them to apply these lessons at their own fleets all boot camp attendees receive top of the line compliance related content like detailed topic outlines workbooks a full library of DOT compliance forms and more to kick-start their compliance back home the fleet compliance bootcamp is ideal for folks just getting into Trucking and also those who play a role in an existing carrier's dot safety and compliance program our goal is to help demystify dot safety regulations and to help folks Implement robust safety programs to keep them compliant and out of the crosshairs we hope to see you at one of our upcoming events check out the details and register online at trucksafebootcamp.com thanks for watching all right so lots in store for that forward to it early bird registration is open today until the end of June spots will fill up quick so be sure be sure to do that if you're interested in joining us if you register now you'll save 100 bucks over at trucksafebootcamp.com all right uh enough about us let's talk about a couple of things going on in the industry that are worth mentioning first up oral fluid testing uh we had a show about this our last show in fact uh earlier this month we had the lead author the d.o.t's lead author on this rule making that actually takes effect today June 1st 2023 uh the oral fluid rule making takes effect this is a rule that authorizes motor carriers and other modal entities so um you know airline pilots railroad workers those types of folks anybody that's subject to part 40 of the Federal Motor Carrier of the usdot regulations can now use oral fluid in addition to urinalysis um as a testing method for purposes of dot regulated drug screens the important Point here though is that even though that rule takes effect today we are still waiting on the Department of Health and Human Services to certify a couple of labs to be able to process the specimens that are collected for those tests until that happens uh carriers cannot use use those test types so that's an important point we have to wait even though this rule is in effect today we have to wait until the at least two Laboratories get certified to process those results so hold off on it uh don't transition over to oral fluid testing unless and until we hear back from the usdot will inevitably announce once they once HHS has officially certified a couple of laps so just wanted to make you aware of that last thing I'll mention is Road check Road check was uh what was it last week a couple weeks ago we did another show on that recently where we talked about the things to watch out for with Road check my concern back then was whether we were going to have such a high out of service rate like we saw last year where uh nearly a quarter of all commercial vehicles that were stopped during that three-day Blitz of roadside inspections were pulled out of service for serious maintenance related violation missions and so we were we were asking ourselves on that show we had Brian runnels on from Reliance Partners we were asking ourselves whether we were going to see a repeat of that and well now we have the data in and it looks like we actually saw some improvement this year still not great I think we ended up around 12 out of service rate or something like that half of what it was last year which is good news but still a significant percentage of of trucks are being placed trucks and buses being placed out of service for serious violations so still obviously a concern but at least we saw some improvement there uh be sure to subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com if you are interested in keeping up to date on all of this type of compliance related and Industry related news we are constantly pushing out updates and breaking news and detailed analysis of all of these types of issues to those that subscribe to our newsletter you can do that trucksafe.com subscribe all right so moving on to today's topic which is telematics as I said if you're new to our show I'd recommend you go back and watch I believe it was episode two which we talked about a related topic which is how fleets can best manage the sometimes overwhelming amount of data that is collected by these types of devices on today's show however we wanted to focus more on some of the top considerations that fleets should consider when sourcing telematics options telematics types devices have been around for a long time now but they are becoming more and more prominent and prevalent in our industry and in some regards mandated by regulations elds for example lots of new features and lots of consider considerations so I'm glad to have with me a good friend long time safety and compliance expert former Trucking Company owner and current owner of carpenter compliance Rob Carpenter Rob welcome hey how are you doing all right thanks so much for being with me thanks for having me how's uh how's Virginia this time of year it's not bad actually it's uh it doesn't know if it's gonna rain snow going to be hot cold you know it's 90 degrees 90 degrees in Indianapolis today is it that bad out there I know we might have 70 here today so we're nice we're good all right uh for those who don't know Rob Carpenter uh tell us a little bit about your background how you got involved with Trucking that type of stuff so actually I didn't even I know you and I have been through this but it's you know the I didn't start in transportation at all I started on a farm with some grandparents and you know it was just a lot of work a lot of machines a lot of trucks a lot of tractors so you kind of knew what work was and uh then when I got old enough to really have a real job um where somebody actually paid me to work it wasn't just slave labor um I went into the restaurant industry like a lot of other people do Food Service busboy dishwasher and you know at some point you get you get tired of smelling like a french fry you don't want to be greasy every day and uh doing it for very little money and um so ended up coming home one day at that point I owned some restaurants I told my wife speaking of that by the way sorry to interrupt you but this is an interesting aside last night uh I get an alert on my neighborhood app that our main thoroughfare through Greenfield Indiana which is where I live is shut down and uh and sure enough I look out my window the whole there's a bunch of police out there and the rationale for shutting down the road was that there had been a spill of animal fat all along the main thoroughfare of Greenfield that had turned the roadway into like a like a skating rink it was so slippery and it took him like five hours to clean this up only in Indianapolis only in Indiana yeah so anyway the french fries brought that to mine so that's it so anyway I you know at that point I owned some restaurants and I just got tired of that because it's you know it's really it's kind of it's a lot like Transportation when you're talking hours it's 365 days a year seven days a week 24 hours a day and uh you've got a lot of the same problems people that that don't come to work they call out so it gets old quick and uh one day I came home and I told my wife I'm like hey I'm gonna I'm gonna attract I've sold this place I'm going to truck driving school tomorrow and she's just looking at me like you're gonna do what and uh so yeah I went to truck driving school and the whole reason behind it was really that you had this you knew they were always going to need truck drivers and it was something where I didn't have to deal with people all the time I could just go and just be left alone so that was kind of where I was at that time I'd been wrapped up with people every day forever in so long that I just wanted I just wanted some peace so went into Trucking for the piece and uh it just snowballed from there but uh you know did you find much peace I did actually in trucking it wasn't really that bad shippers could be you know shippers uh Walmarts were terrible but generally I mean it was it was fun it was it was a good environment but uh ended up obviously not wanting to be a truck driver I just wanted to learn transportation from a practical perspective left Trucking went into being a broker uh ended up running rail truckload and ocean for for blue Grace and here in Virginia and uh then got the opportunity to manage the company so went there ended up buying that company when that company sold out bought their truck inside and then owned that started my own brokerage and I eventually went into uh managing a 14 dot operation for private Equity back group so that's that's where I recently left and uh here we are doing risk control compliance for for big companies and insurance companies and all that good stuff yeah I know you do a lot of compliance now including a lot of work with us and we're excited to to work with you on these types of things what what kind of compliance roles have you served over the years so we've done uh both Fleet and and just general compliance but the biggest piece is was probably working for uh for the Enterprise carrier where you're you're constantly acquiring new companies for private equity and when with those you're obviously having to acquire the business contracts that they have whether that's with lytics or samsar or whoever so you know you get this huge background from a telematics perspective that's broad-based because you're not just dealing with one vendor it's you know you buy this one you get lytics you buy another one you get samsara and eventually you have to consolidate those just from a management perspective it's not manageable so that's that was that but then you also had the Fleet Management aspect of drug and alcohol vendor selection um and you're talking thousands of drivers so it's it was a big job it was a lot but uh I I enjoyed it it was it was a challenge uh just like anything yeah and I know you've you've worked a lot as you said in the telematics space you know working to find the right solution that worked for a large uh trucking company uh and and smaller ones as well and so that's why I wanted to get you on today to talk about this kind of idea of what considerations because we get this question a lot I'm sure you do too from fleets of all types and sizes hey we're thinking about uh going with a particular telematics vendor what are your thoughts on this particular vendor and we always you know give our thoughts based on our experience working with other fleets that have adopted those Solutions there's no one-size-fits all uh solution obviously but I wanted to just kind of spend some time talking through the things that we think that fleets should consider at least from our perspective uh on this so um tell us I guess kind of starting out maybe for folks who may be new to the industry or just getting started with telematics devices let's break that term down for them what do we mean when we're talking about telematics devices the way I look at it it's it's like you're converging uh telecommunications and information that you're Gathering From whatever it is that you're you're trying to whatever data you're trying to get so um and a lot of people just use it as this overarching term to to cover all these encompassing Parts whether it's cams or elds and most of the time they're referencing cameras but it covers all these things event recorders elds cameras um one of the good things that some of the bigger ones have samsara Automotive you've got full-time Diagnostics so that in itself is telematic status so um it covers a broad range of things but everything that all the data that you would want you can get from somebody on the market and yeah and it could be simple and it can be complex has been my experience you can get a simple solution that serves just to meet your regulatory responsibilities we'll get into that with elds or you can get a solution that is monitoring all kinds of stuff tire pressure uh like you said cameras event recorders harsh braking all of that type type of stuff kind of rolls up into telematics as we kind of think about it like I said at least from my perspective um I mentioned elds we should talk about you know historically like I said telematics devices have been around for a long time and and particularly the larger fleets have been using them for various purposes uh for decades at this point but only more recently has a particular telematics type been mandated by regulation with with the ELD rule so maybe we can break that down a little bit and what that ELD rule requires and how that kind of plays into these devices as a whole yeah um you know I remember when this first started you know we were truck drivers and you know pre-2010 and we were all talking you know no matter where you were it was hey have you heard this electronic log thing is coming it's like no it'll never happen you know it's just something that they're talking about and then the next thing you know it's it's a proposal and it's you know it's a real rule um and now there's even less exemptions to it so after 2019 so now if you basically if you have a truck 2000 or or newer you've got to have this and um there's a huge section and and nobody really I don't I don't know if anybody's actually read the whole thing I have read portions of it um but there's an appendix of 395 that breaks down in my new detail every single thing uh that you could possibly want to know about an ELD yes the technical specifications yeah so it's it's full of all this good stuff you know who who has read that entire thing is Tom Cuthbertson who we had on our second show he used to be with omnitrax he's retired now but I know that man has read that appendix forward and backwards probably 10 times Tom if you're on say hi um but yeah yeah it is a it is a thick section of the regulations yeah I was talking to Travis Baskin one time at motive well keep trucking at that point Travis like there's only like eight people in the world who've read it and it's so tired um and I think he's one of them um but I have I had I have a life you know opposite of what some people think so I don't have time for but I can't tell you everything Dylan Dylan says he's he's read through it on LinkedIn there you go We Salute You yeah for real um but it's got a lot of different pieces to it and one of the things that I found out and and actually it's kind of funny I I had streamlined a bunch of vendors and we were kind of making this decision between uh hopefully you're not going to get mad if I name any offenders but we were kind of trying to figure out like who do we who are we going to consolidate all these into is it going to be samsar is it going to be motive and that was the final two yeah and we uh we already had some with samsara at the time I mean hundreds of them with samsara that were already under a three-year contract um that was signed before I had gotten there and um it at the end of the day what I looked at was not only which one was the most compliant there was a lot of the different things that I looked at but one of the things that I found out with samsara when I started was I was inspecting some vehicles and I found some uh some that were bypassing the ECM and that we're going straight to power so that it looked like it was working from a from a dashboard perspective but it wasn't compliant because it wasn't reading the data that you needed to read from the ECM um as far as engine data is it moving mileage Etc so it wasn't a compliance system and uh one more you know the more I got into that I realized hey how did we get to this point where we're powering these things and come to find out samsar had guided this company to do this so it was like you know it was that was kind of It kind of took me down a different Road from a principal perspective and that's you know we ended up with uh with motive ultimately at the end but that's a that's an important thing to consider is what's in 395 you don't have to read the whole technical specification to be able to be regulatory compliant but you do need to understand the basics of it it does need to read the ECM um it does need to be able to gather certain data from the vehicle uh engine speed and uh different things like that some diagnostic information models Etc the good news there is you know those technical specifications are really geared towards the manufacturers of the device to your point Rob if your device doesn't happen to be compliant it's not going to necessarily be an excuse that that was a rule meant for the device manufacturer so you still have uh some responsibility but the Comfort I think we can take in that is FMCSA has its list of self-certified devices uh where manufacturers of these required devices have to certify that they're that they meet these standards that are set out in the appendix to part 395 and what we are seeing more and more recently is FMCSA actually becoming active in policing that and removing from that list of self-certified devices devices that turn out to be non-compliant so I guess that's a good point a good starting point is number one the only required telematics type device is at least from a DOT perspective at this point is the ELD system the electronic logging system everything else we're going to talk about today is not technically required will it be in the future potentially but ELD is the one that you have to have as a base if you're like like Rob said you know there are very few exceptions to the ELD mandate if you are operating in Interstate or intra state in Most states most states have adopted that rule as well Commerce you got to have these ELD devices and your drivers have to be using them to track their Duty status but the first point there is if you are sourcing a new ELD device the first place I'm going if I'm looking at a solution is are they on the list of self-certified devices because if they're not on the list then it's not permissible for you to use them so you got to pick somebody on the list and if you're looking at any of the big names out there they're they're going to be on the list but if you're looking at a lesser known device then for sure you need to be checking that that list and make sure they're on there you can find it just to fmcsa's website and search for ELD self-certification list or something like that you have the specific I'm looking for but no the uh yeah I mean that's that's kind of where I I start you know you want to make sure that it's a compliance system that that you're actually able to be you that you actually can use um from uh an FM FMCSA perspective but then you know there's there's so many other things that you have to look at because it's like you said at the you know earlier in the in the call it it was I get this question a lot and I can't give everyone the same answer because you might not need motive or samsar you might be fine with some smaller program um whereas if you're an Enterprise level operation you may need more data and and you have a board and you have you know real Executives that want real data and high level reporting um it's great to have good diagnostic information that's in real time so you get you the bigger you get typically the more data you're going to want so you can't change things if you you don't have a big picture of what's going on so yeah that's what I found is a lot of the smaller fleets that we work with are usually fine with a solution that is just doing the bare minimum which again ELD compliance and that serves them well but as they start to grow and you become a fleet with 20 trucks 50 trucks 100 trucks then the data that you could be gathering from these devices if you upgrade them either to a different solution or adding on to your existing solution if your provider offers it is is can be very valuable to you and so I think maybe that's where we can go from here is what are some of the benefits of telematics devices particularly when we start to look outside the context of just elds but also the more granular type things like event recorders um cameras those types of things what are some of the benefits in your view Rob on that well for me with especially with cameras obviously with cameras it's it's the visibility thing and no matter what you're really looking for whatever you need the visibility for whether it's uh complaints say you're a passenger carrier and you've got that complaint where hey they left me standing in the rain at a bus stop uh they missed my stop or they called me of this or that so there's some driver indemnification aspects of it from both pasture and property you know you get in your driver gets in a wreck he says it wasn't his fault at that point you don't have the visibility to really know whose fault it was you're just going to have to go with whatever law enforcement or whoever work the scene is going to tell you what and that's typically what they determine but they didn't have visibility either so it's he said she said game until you have that visibility but uh it can it can go all kinds of different ways theft prevention and Recovery through tracking units um reduction in Insurance costs um you know one of the things did you see those things play out in your when you we did we did it we've done passenger and property so one of the things one of the biggest things that we use cameras for was um let's just say Mayo Clinic or MD Anderson Cancer Center places like that where you have passengers who are getting picked up on a closed loop basis and they might have a complaint that they got left in the rain at a stop or um we have we've had some where the driver fought the passenger or the passenger fought the driver or um all kinds of different things during riots there were bricks thrown at buses and uh so you kind of had that visibility of what really happened in that situation which is in in some cases it can be pretty intense but it gives you that ability to kind of build different things one how are you going to solve the issues that you have what are the issues that you have um is it something that needs accountability or is it something that you can build incentive programs around and ultimately that's how I got to where I got at the end was I needed a lot of different things not not just the visibility aspect that I could get from you know a 80 camera from Walmart with an SD card in it um I wanted to be able to see real time what's going on and be able to go back you know in some cases indefinitely through cloud-based systems so that's it's just so much to take in but ultimately the visibility gives you the ability to hey I see that this driver has a close following problem or a speeding problem or they use their phone a lot and a lot of drivers hate training I mean I don't I I didn't like sitting in eight hours of training uh periodically but there's no point in sitting a driver through that much training if their only issue is close following and yeah this gives you that visibility to kind of isolate that training and uh Focus the training on close following or speeding or whatever that issue is so you keep coaching on them and coaching them and coaching them and then hopefully you can enact some change in that but without the visibility you can't do anything because you really don't know what your problem is it goes it's that old saying you can't improve what you don't measure and so unless you have a good tool to help you measure or to keep on top of where you are having gaps and how do you ever expect to improve I know we we harp on this I know you harp on this over and over is you know the the solution if you're running into safety and compliance problems there's no magic wand to fix these things it takes work but you first have to get your arms wrapped around what's causing your problem before you can then start to work to fix the problem and so these types of devices are critical in a lot of cases to help you understand where you are having those problems which drivers are having these issues with uh Alliance or harsh braking or these things that are making us as a fleet less safe or less compliant if I've got more visibility into that then I could take it the next step and do what is required to curb those Trends and get them moving in the right direction but without without that then you're kind of shooting in the dark at that point has been my experience yeah and accuracy is a big one you know you've got Cloud base you've got SD card you've got um AI you've got non-ai that's just hey you're getting run-of-the-mill footage but the good thing I was going to ask you about that with cameras in uh specifically you've kind of already kind of mentioned this but and I know you keep up to much more up to speed on the current state of this type of Technology than I do I only hear about it when fleets are coming to me with questions about their particular device I'm curious what kind of progression you've seen with camera devices over the last several years and you know what did we start out with and where have we come what do we have now in terms of The Cutting Edge camera technology that's out there so I I remember programs that we used they were called Janus and uh it was just it was just another little camera I mean it didn't do anything but it recorded that's all it did but it had like series sister or something right yeah and and so what you'd run into is drivers would take that you know they'd get an accident and they'd know it's their fault so they'd take the SD card out they just vanished I don't know they didn't have one in there throw it out the window yeah so that's another thing that you have to consider it's like you know the cloud-based systems are they're not tamper proof but you know how how hard is it for a driver to tamper with what's been recorded or to keep it from being recorded um you know it was cases with samsar and motive where I got a disconnect notice and you could go back and watch the minute it got disconnected and you could see them just you can't see him unplug it but you can see them under the dash so you know take what you want um but it's um it's kind of developed from there and you've now you've got these AI systems and that goes a big part of that AI is accuracy and I'll just tell you what it is you know I've I've tried these I've used these systems from a practical perspective it's it's I'm not a guy who just got paid to sponsor Moto doesn't give me any money to sponsor them I just like their product and uh part of the reason I like their product and this isn't a show to promote motive it's just a show to tell you things that you should look for both in companies and systems uh motive might not be the thing for you you might fit with Verizon or lytics or whatever but at the end of the day I found that um you know in trying to figure out where we gonna go with samsara motive at this Enterprise carrier for these 14 dot numbers and thousands of vehicles it was one of those things where I got units to try and I'm even trying some right now um for something that we're going to talk about in a few minutes but um one of the things that I looked at was the accuracy in the AI because I think a lot of a lot of people look at a lot of carriers look at the prices of these things and they'll say wow this is only 15 a month and then you know they don't realize that there's an added cost of admin and management time in these systems so a lot of times you get that pitch it's Ai and it manages it manages this for you and you don't have as much work to do and that that is a good selling point some of them do that but you need to look at how accurately they do that as well so you know with samsara when I trialed them and we used them actually for years under contract and we were looking at 70 accuracy then we tried motive uh we were in the 90s percentile and what I mean by that is if you get an event notification that Rob has been on the phone and then you go and look at that event and Rob is putting a piece of gum in his mouth that's not Rob on the phone but the system the AI is detecting that as being on the phone so there's two issues with that accuracy piece one it takes a lot of time for someone to then go through event by event to manage that and determine hey is this depicted as what it really is and if it's not it creates a trust issue not only with the buy with the driver and it's going to make it harder to get driver buy-in on it uh but then it limits what you can do with that program right so if you wanted to create an incentive based program based on events and trends it's difficult to do that with something that's not trustworthy because the next thing you have is drivers complaining well I should have got a bonus because I was just shoe and go or or whatever the case was so it's um you know accuracy is a big thing and if you're into if you end up paying like in my case with samsar I was paying someone a group of people 120 hours a week to manage events that's all they did they just checked hours of service and events for for samsara and if you break that down divided by trucks it's not 15 a month anymore it's now like 75 or 80 dollars a month so if you're looking at you know for me that was one of the big deciding factors from an Opex perspective it was like Hey I can pay 25 or 35 or whatever for motive and I don't have to pay someone 120 you know I don't have to put out that labor cost so yeah there's different costs that have to be considered in it but Robert's asking on LinkedIn when you you mentioned this earlier Rob when you guys found someone tampering with the equipment how did you approach it so we had we have they still have an awesome HR Director um I'm not going to tell your name but she's great so she has a very streamlined set of she's very pro-labor she's very by the book but what we created in that was one we had a committee for accident so if you got in an accident we had a committee we would look at the video it was between me the general counsel and her who was like the VP of HR and we would kind of determine like what do we do with this and historically what have we done with people in these same situations but really if it was an everyday event close following or whatever it was or you disconnected the camera we tried to go the coach not cop route and that goes a lot to driver buy-in because if every time you turn around you're firing someone for whatever and Cisco at one time had a really bad reputation for if they caught somebody without a seat belt they were terminated on the spot you don't really get good buy-in with that I mean Cisco's a big company they've been successful I just don't believe in that that hard and fast rule I I think in some cases it's warranted but in in most cases it's a simple hey let's talk about this this is what we saw you do here's the coaching and how we ultimately did is we created coaching bundles for different behaviors so if you had a close following problem you took the close following bundle with 10 Street yeah and uh eventually that coaching kind of picked up and you know it changed things I mean we reduced Auto claims more than 40 percent in like a year and a half yeah he's a motives AI system but um that was kind of like the name to fame with that it's really the coach not cop yeah Tom's asking a follow-up question Tom Cuthbertson here in the house with us uh was there a did you have a published policy on tampering with your drivers we did and we also um had a published policy on hey you are being watched and recorded because um not all states allow you to record audio and video uh without someone's consent and even you know we even ran into some issues with passenger carriers because and so in Most states the law is everyone in the vehicle has to understand they're being recorded So you can't use that footage if not everyone's aware of and if there's 50 people on the bus the odds are someone's not aware of it yeah so uh you have to it's important to understand the regulations around it too but yeah I was going to say you know we're kind of getting into pitfalls at this point um but that is something to consider it is a big big consideration is if you are going to move to a system that includes video you know we kind of looked at the history of it you talked about the old systems that we're recording on an SD card or an SD card and now we move to more of a cloud recording type system but another big transition was we had historically been relying on forward-facing cameras that were recording the the you know the movement ahead of us what's going on ahead of us or behind us but now and more and more we're starting to see a transition to both forward-facing and inward facing so facing towards the driver and that's where you start to get into either the AI capabilities that you're talking about and I know there is still a big debate out there and it's a it's a it's a reasonable debate to have I think at least from my perspective on the legal side of things as to whether inward facing cameras make sense or not the reason it's important that we discuss that uh and that we debate it is because there are some pitfalls if you choose to go that route and have recordings of what's going on in the cab you've mentioned them Rob which are essentially privacy concerns like you said a lot of state laws um require folks to consent to being recorded and if we are installing devices in our trucks that are recording you know then maybe we are at risk of running afoul of whatever state laws those happen to be um and so that is something that has to be taking in into consideration before you just pull the trigger on those types of inward facing devices I think the Saving Grace there one of the saving Graces there is that we are involved in such a highly regulated industry because if the concern is privacy what we have learned from the courts particularly federal courts over the years is that there is in a highly regulated industry like Trucking a diminished expectation of privacy truck drivers whether we like it or not do not have the same expectation of privacy that you and I have in our personal vehicles they don't have the same right to those privacy to that privacy as we would in our personal vehicles because this is such a potentially dangerous profession to be involved with we have to take measures from a safety perspective to make sure that that they are safe and so we have these same privacy issues raised like when the ELD mandate was pushed out folks will remember the legal battles that ensued after the original ELD mandate was published that that they battled that out in court it's primarily oida and the uh and the FMCSA battling it out in court over whether those ELD devices which aren't even recording video or audio whether they violated the driver's privacy and and that's where we learn from the courts about the diminished expectation of privacy stuff like that but it is suffice it to say an important consideration when you're talking about cameras in particular well I mean these drivers you know when I was when I worked over the road I mean that's that's your life that's where you live that's your home so you know a lot of the complaints that that you've probably seen I get on LinkedIn when I advocate for these things is well that's where I live that's my house you shouldn't be able to film in my house well there's four Duty statuses and and I'm 100 in agreement that when you're in sleeper birth or you're off duty and the truck isn't moving then I I 100 think it should be able to be disconnected or turned off but um you know that requires some level of self-management um unless there's some automatic feature that turns it back on when you know the truck starts moving but um yeah I I kind of see it from both sides but it's like you said there's it's such a dangerous occupation this might be your home but it's also your workplace and then you're driving on the roadways with tens of thousands and millions of other people and uh it's important not only to to consider that but it's you have to think about the identification aspect on on the driver's part as well I mean there's been drivers that have been exonerated with these things so um companies that have been exonerated with these things yeah that's the other side of calculus right is the the benefit potential benefit of that type of evidence I mean that's what you're weighing against the driver pushback the privacy concerns and all of those potential pitfalls you are weighing against that the potential exoneration benefits of that device name namely you know because we've seen this over and over again in litigation um the the benefit that video evidence has even if it's not to exonerate your driver to at least let you as the trucking company know that hey this was truly our driver's fault we need to get out of this case quickly it serves a benefit both ways and so you certainly have to take that into consideration when you're when you're talking about cameras in particular uh in addition to the other benefits that come with it one of which is uh potential Insurance savings Dylan says on LinkedIn insurance discounts alone will probably pay annually almost three times the cost of the cameras I wanted to ask you about that Rob because you had mentioned Insurance earlier did you see any savings when you kind of rolled out stuff like this was how big of a influence were insurance cost on the calculus we saw at some in our Fleet but and in my personal Fleet but in in the Enterprise realm we didn't see as much because we were we were self-insured through a captive um so you saw a little bit but it really wasn't a lot yeah and well I think to that point and I think this has been your experience as well we are starting to see you know with insurance costs on the rise skyrocketing due in part to the you know social idea of social inflation we've talked on previous shows about nuclear verdicts and what's contributing to those huge multi-million and billion dollar verdicts uh including this concept of social inflation where folks in society are being desensitized to all of these huge verdicts and so it's causing these numbers to Skyrocket and it's it's making Insurance costs uh go up as well um and a lot of these insurance companies are as I understand it uh you know barely scraping by and we've seen some exit our industry all together um and and so what we have seen over the last couple of years is an emergence of like ensure tech companies that are heavily reliant on telematics type uh devices installed in the trucks as a condition to being insured with them you have to agree to install these devices on your trucks and then they use that uh kind of part and parcel with their underwriting process to set your premiums and maybe give you discounts if your drivers are are you know operating safely and that type of stuff so there is at least a segment of the industry where Insurance costs um and potential discounts uh heavily influence that concept of whether to move forward with these types of devices or not well I think they I mean insurance companies you know when I work with Gallagher basket I do a lot of risk control for insurance companies and I don't see that they get a lot of financial reward out of of subscribing to these Technologies in most cases I mean there is some but I think if you're looking at it from like a personal Auto liability perspective it's definitely there you know you've got these uh usage-based programs like Progressive developed one uh I don't know a few years back it's one of those you know plug it in plug it in your uh USB your OBD2 port and it'll you know give all that data to Progressive but uh that has that has a negative side effect too so since I've been trying this current system I have in my truck I uh I also use Allstate and I've used within 15 years not trying to sell Allstate again not sponsored right um but I've been with them like 15 years and they started this program where they make you download the app you give them preparations as long as you have your phone they're going to tell you what you've done and uh I think last month it ended up costing me money because you know I've kind of driven like a fool for a month and a half um so anyway it's kind of got goods and bads but yeah uh Tim says I've always been an advocate of dual Vision AI technology if clients manage it well if you do not Monitor and manage the data it will result in less defensibility and enablement of poor behaviors that's an important point one that I wanted to get to another potential Pitfall and I love your thoughts on this Rob is the overwhelming amount of data that can be generated by these systems and whether or not the fleet is equipped to deal with all of that data that is coming in this was the topic of our show that I mentioned earlier that we had Tom on this kind of concept or idea of drinking from a fire hose you know these systems are are gathering literally terabytes of data if you've got a big Fleet and now you have all of that coming to you if you put your head in the sand and you throw your hands up and say I can't manage this are you in a worse position at that point then you would have been otherwise if you had not adopted the systems to begin with what are your thoughts on that well I think it's going to come back to how you manage your business and the program so one of the things that that I put in place when I put in these programs was what's called event management so there's a very specific protocol like you get this event you coach it you make sure that there's no unassigned time as well at the same time but you're showing one you're doing something with this this event that you see you realize that Rob Carpenter talks on his phone all the time while he's driving that's his Trend that's his problem but you can't just continue to let him do that and then he wrecks and kills someone next month plaintiff's lawyer is going to have a field day and ask for this information give us all the footage you have of Ralph Carpenter and it's going to show you he's on the phone 131 times before this why didn't you do something about it well we did well what was the limits to your event management so you have to have a well-defined event managed program as well so hey he's on the phone we'll coach him three times after three times if he continues to do it that to us determines he's not coachable and then accountability comes into play so a lot of it has to do with company culture which flows into accountability but event management accountability and one good thing about that you know 10th Street we use the bundles and when the driver would complete these bundles you had a certificate that automatically went into the driver qualification file that said hey they've completed uh the Telecommunications bundle hands-free driving Etc so you had the certificate show one you've watched it you've addressed it you've trained on it you've coached on it and then if ultimately at least the accountability you've got some kind of written written warning to where hey you're on your third time just understand the next time it might not be a coaching him the site this data management problem is probably my biggest concern out out of all of them just because I've seen it play out and it worries me a lot you know the like I said some of these devices are capable of gathering so much data and they're sending it somewhere and so first I think if you're sourcing a solution you need to First understand exactly what data is being gathered and make sure you you fully understand what Universe of data is out there because let me give you an example I worked with a fleet a while back and uh we we were helping them with a mock dot audit and as part of our audit we're always looking at in addition to DOT compliance issues we're also looking at Highway accident exposure and stuff like that and as part of that review we asked for back office access to their telematics system so they gave us that and we started digging in and looking at all of the reports that were available through that particular system it was a well-known vendor that they were using and what we found in the context of that review was that the system they were using was taking telematics data primarily harsh braking events following too closely that type of stuff and it was using it to generate a score for those drivers a graded score so a through F and then it had those grades for every one of the carrier's driver we're talking thousands of drivers problem that carrier had was they were relying primarily on the device just primarily on the ELD capabilities of the device and also the camera activity they didn't even realize that the system was grading their drivers and that they were using drivers who had an F and so my concern as as you mentioned Rob is if if one of those drivers then goes and kills somebody and you end up in litigation and now the plaintiff's attorney is going to get access to all of that same reporting and they're gonna the story that's gonna be told to the jury is how could you have been using a driver that had a grade of f right it would play terribly to the jury if that were to happen and so had they just known that the system was gathering that data then that potentially they could have either Managed IT or they could have turned it off or something like that but that's the point there is you need to understand the universe of data that's coming in and then have a plan to manage it yeah and they're they're all doing different things you know it kind of goes back to it it kind of goes to Diagnostics as well you know there's um there's fleets that I've done mock audits on where they have two million miles on these vehicles and they they're not showing any interest in buying new ones um and they have say motive or samsara then it's got most Vehicles out of 150 diagnostic codes that are live right now and if that vehicle gets in an accident the first thing they're going to say is one well it's junk it's got two million miles for one but two it's not just good junk it's bad junk it's got 150 live Diagnostics you think that's wise to have on the road and uh so you know it's it's Gathering a huge amount of data but that's it kind of goes back to the beginning of it it's when you're buying these systems and you're really looking at their full capabilities and what you're what you're purchasing and their features you have to understand the system or you can't manage it and then lose into the management piece you have to be able to manage it and manage the events and manage these diagnostic codes um or it can it can end up costing you and showing you some exposure later on and so inevitably the follow-up question to that is going to be well would we be better off just to not have these devices at all and I hate that question and I want your thoughts on it Rob I I hate it because it's binary it assumes that the the answer is binary that it's either better to have it or better to not I think that is a terrible way to look at it I think I think you should have the devices and I think you should be managing the data yes that is the best case scenario it doesn't have to be either or it should be both you should figure out a way to manage it within your capabilities and you should have the devices right and I look at it the same way it's you're better to have it you just need good policies in place you need a culture that's going to enforce accountability with the management process um because you know there are there are managers you know even in the company I just left there's managers that didn't do a good job managing the program but the system tells on itself so it'll let you know that manager XYZ hasn't you know updated their dashboard for coaching in 37 days so that's the other good thing about it is a lot of these systems kind of have accountability built in I mean yeah it's not set it and forget it well we're running out of time I wanted to spend some time going over some examples he brought with you some uh some interesting footage that you have captured over the years and doing on the devices that you have so I want to kind of walk through these uh and kind of talk through them so let's do that before we run out of time here so I'm just gonna plan one after the other other and I want to get your commentary on them so here we go first one what do we got here we got somebody that's hit a bike the this is uh this is a passenger carrier I'm not going to tell you who um but so the important thing to look at here and the reason I added this one in is one you can't tell who it is you can't tell who the driver is you can't tell what the driver's doing and uh I probably could have cut some out of this but basically what ends up happening in just a second um is he's gonna wreck but you don't know what that driver was doing and when you see this wreck the question is going to kind of be what was he doing and it's kind of like the LinkedIn thing I posted this morning it's like we don't know because we don't have the in we don't have the inward uh in-cab dash cam to know what exactly doing at this time it took his attention off the road so the good thing about this there is in cab to this it's just not being played right now but the uh basically he got into a daze and he started daydreaming and just got totally unfocused and didn't even realize where he was next thing you know it's 120 000 in claims so yeah I think his bike is toast too yep all right here's another one now this is a uh this is a property carrier and it kind of goes to uh anytime you stop you should keep some some distance between you and the other vehicle even if no one's in front of you keep it from the intersection that way if you're hit from the back you're not being pushed into the car or into the intersection so now this is actually a bike cam uh this came from just a guy riding a bike and uh he made it forward facing and backward facing on his helmet or something on his helmet so what happened in this case was it got sent to the company or you know the basically the company but yeah they were able to then pull telematics footage from the cab where you know he basically made a dangerous maneuver on a 90 degree turn blind and again facilitates discussions with the driver about that type of thing yeah so you got to coach that I mean you've got to do something about it uh here's another another passenger carrier this is probably one of the closest wrecks of non-rex I've ever seen uh oh it goes to what were they doing at the time were they on the phone were they asleep were they just not paying attention were they eating their food so if you don't have that in-cab visibility you don't know what caused this so you don't have the ability to to change that behavior yeah that was inches so here you are um and I think I'm actually leaving Richmond Airport here I think I just left you in Indianapolis actually and uh I put this in there because one you can see me I'm on the phone and the good thing about this this is a motive trial unit and motive basically tells on me every day I drive and it's always telling my wife hey Rob's been on the phone today Rob's speeding today Rob almost cut this car off and uh sometimes I do drive like this on a normal basis even though I teach people how to drive but you know I get in a hurry and you know things happen but everybody watching here Rob's doing this on purpose to test the device yes um and sometimes I I have I've tried to slam on the brakes with no one around just to see you know hey it's my street there's no one here and kind of see like what does the system detecting you know how many feet per second does it take for it to like really flag you as that hard break or you know yeah take off here's another one got a couple more here so what's confusing with these is these are samsara units and the flags on these are actually for um front end crash detection but there's no crash detection so what's happening is every time and this is what we're talking about with accuracy with AI with the samsara unit it's detecting the vehicle in the lanes beside it and it's setting off a front Collision warning based on just bad AI data so somebody's going to have to go through and weed all these videos out to say hey that's not really what it says it is this is another samsar video uh and what you're going to want to see there for that crash is hey what was this guy doing did he fall asleep did he have a medical emergency what was the case and that way you can change the behavior or coach uh and have you know protocols built in in the future to handle whatever this driver was doing or not doing at the time so yeah all right last two here same thing this is another samsara footage that's another thing look at Clarity of the films you can definitely see the difference between vendors but in this case it's the same thing we're getting front-end Collision warnings but it's not there's no one in front of him it's setting it off for due to vehicles in lane on the side so all right last one we have an honorable mention here this is an exciting one I you shared this today on your LinkedIn post uh a little off topic but but uh interesting to watch nonetheless here we go I'm sure most people have seen this yeah my wife said this is you in real life you would have done this so the questions of Hazard style yeah it goes back to the same thing it's like you know you don't have visibility into that car you don't know what the guy was doing but you know generally somebody can say hey he was probably on the phone uh all right all right Rob we're out of time really appreciate you joining me today uh been a great discussion we've hit on a lot of things tell people where they can find you if they have uh questions or want to reach out to you and get your assistance uh with some of their compliance efforts you can find me on LinkedIn or you can find me on my website carpentercompliance.com or you can come to the dot boot camp in Orlando where uh we'll be speaking talking with Rob with uh with Brandon yeah come join us for sure well thanks again Rob great having you we're gonna wrap things up here again check out the boot camp we'd love to have you there with us got a lot in store for that truck safe bootcamp.com uh also check out our online courses we've got a lot of uh content through our truck safe Academy at trucksafeacademy.com we've got DOT compliance courses that are built for safety managers on all kinds of compliance topics hours of service driver qualification vehicle maintenance Reasonable Suspicion Hazmat everything like that check it out trucksafeacademy.com follow us on social media subscribe to our newsletter stay tuned for our next episode of truck safe live uh we we announced those through our newsletter and on social media uh thanks again to its sponsor uh of this season of truck safe live log Rock appreciate you teaming up with us to make this possible uh that's all I got hope to see you on the next show thanks everyone thank you

Event Completed

Thursday, June 1, 2023 at 4:44 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube