Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 24 - When trucking regulations run amok

Wednesday, June 21, 2023 at 3:32 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 24 - When trucking regulations run amok

About This Event

In this episode, we’re joined by Michael Precia, President and CEO of Fleetworthy Solutions. We’ll talk with Mike about he got involved and trucking and went on to build one of the leading fleet compliance software and service solutions. We’ll also discuss the current regulatory landscape and what regulations may be ripe for modification and/or elimination.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 24 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Mike Precia, President and CEO of Fleetworthy Solutions, to examine a question that rarely gets asked openly in the trucking industry: when do regulations go too far, or fail to accomplish what they were designed to do? The conversation is framed around an article published by Trucksafe Consulting exploring where modern trucking regulations have become ineffective or overly burdensome, and what fleets and regulators should do about it. With large truck and bus fatalities increasing 31 percent between 2010 and 2019 and total fatalities still hovering around 5,000 as of 2020, the hosts argue that the current regulatory framework deserves serious scrutiny. Hours of service rules receive particular attention as an example of regulation that may not be achieving its intended purpose of reducing fatigue-related crashes. Wiseman and Pres point out that time-based rules do not account for a driver's condition before they enter the cab, and that human nature often drives people to move faster as their available hours dwindle rather than more cautiously. The hosts also highlight the problem of regulatory exemptions, noting that the sheer number of carve-outs from hours of service rules risks undermining the entire framework. Both agree that regulators need better mechanisms to evaluate whether rules are actually working after they are enacted, and that a more proactive, data-driven approach to driver fatigue would serve the industry better than the current system. The discussion turns to practical compliance challenges facing fleets, including the persistent reliance on paper-based recordkeeping and the difficulty of managing large volumes of safety data generated by modern telematics systems. Pres warns that data collected but not acted upon can be more damaging than no data at all, citing the example of driver scorecards that flag poor behavior which safety teams, often understaffed and overwhelmed, fail to address in time. In litigation, that inaction can be used to portray a carrier as indifferent to safety, fueling the kind of nuclear verdict outcomes that have become an existential threat for many fleets. Among the most actionable takeaways from the episode is the strong endorsement of continuous driver license monitoring as one of the single most effective steps a fleet can take beyond minimum compliance. The hosts note that annual MVR checks, as currently required by regulation, leave carriers blind to license suspensions that occur between reporting periods, a gap that can have catastrophic legal and safety consequences. Pres also emphasizes that training programs are only valuable when tied to observed driver behavior trends and followed up with documented actions, ensuring that carriers can demonstrate a genuine, ongoing commitment to safety if a case ever goes to court. Looking ahead, the hosts identify electric vehicles, autonomous and semi-autonomous technology, and the debate over lowering the commercial driver minimum age from 21 as the regulatory frontiers most likely to reshape compliance requirements in the coming years. Pres notes that questions about how hours of service rules will apply to remote operators monitoring semi-autonomous vehicles are already on the FMCSA's radar, and that the transition away from fossil fuels will force significant changes to fuel tax structures. The episode closes with a shared call for regulators to shift from a purely punitive compliance model toward one that also rewards carriers who invest in going beyond the minimum, a philosophy both Trucksafe Consulting and Fleetworthy Solutions describe as central to their approach.

Full Transcript

call me the Joker baby don't you know how far all right got no crash all attributes feel like you do don't you know back you still dreams thank you thank you foreign foreign this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign welcome to episode 24 of truck safe live the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs excited to talk about Trucking regulations today which is pretty much what we talk about on every show but uh today's show is a little bit different I wanted to spend some time walking through a topic that is always top of mind for most of the fleets we're working with which is when regulations uh become problematic when there is too much regulation or there are regulations that aren't effectively achieving their their stated goal so we published an article on this topic on our website last week and thought it would be an interesting topic to talk about on truck safe life so that's what we're going to do today before we get there a few things going on at truck safe and in the industry um mentioned this last show last show we kind of announced this but we've got our truck safe boot camp coming up you can check out the details on this at trucksafebootcamp.com this is our in-person two-day conference that we're going to hold in Orlando October 12th and 13th the Rosen Plaza Hotel uh this is a conference that is dedicated to all things DOT compliance helping Fleet Safety professionals get up to speed and Hands-On with all major aspects of the dot safety regulations driver qualification hours of service vehicle maintenance all of that fun stuff we're really going to dive in deep and we're going to have you know it's not just one of those conferences where you come and listen to people drone on and on and fall asleep it's going to be Hands-On work we're going to have some simulations and exercises to work through to really get you hands on with the DOT compliance issues so looking forward to that again October 12th and 13th in Orlando registration is now open spots will fill suit fill up soon so make sure you register before July 1st and you'll get 100 off with our early early bird registration over at trucksafebootcamp.com check that I also want to mention our truck safe Fleet compliance Network this is our online community for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions um and also get access to all of our DOT related content our videos our detailed articles on breaking regulatory news and other topics free to join check it out over at trucksafenetwork.com we've also got an app in the app store and the Google Play Store just search for truck safe and you'll find it be sure to join and we look forward to seeing you there um what else do we have going on truck safe uh make sure you check out last episode trucksafe live we did this couple of weeks ago it was a an interesting topic all about telematics devices and some of the top considerations that you should have when you are looking at sourcing a a new telematics device to uh to implement in your Fleet we had Rob Carpenter on from Carpenter compliance we talked about some of the top considerations when you're looking at elds or camera systems or those types of systems some of the things you should be asking the questions you should be asking before you roll those systems out so you can catch that the replay of that on YouTube you can also get it wherever you get your podcast be sure to do that lastly I'll just mention make sure you subscribe to our trucksafe newsletter if you're not already we're constantly pushing out breaking regulatory news and also our analysis of it you can subscribe over at trucksafe.com subscribe all right so some things going on in the industry this week that are worth mentioning uh some of the things that went out on our newsletter just this past week or so the FMCSA came out with its final guidance on property brokerage and so-called dispatch services so this is a topic we hit on a couple of uh well it's probably been it was last year we did a couple of shows on brokerage issues but this is important guidance that the agency has put out that kind of clarifies certain definitions that are within their regulations when it comes to property Brokers and in particular who qualifies as a bona fide agent of shippers in terms of determining who needs property broker Authority if I am working on behalf of a particular shipper and I am sourcing trucks or motor carriers to to haul goods for that shipper am I am I a broker do I need property broker authority to do that the agency is kind of tackling that issue and in particular these so-called dispatch services do those when do those types of dispatch Services need property broker Authority it's a it's been a hot topic for many years go look at it go look at that guidance we have an article on it on our website at trucksafe.com I'm not sure frankly that the guidance brings the type of clarity that we were hoping for on on that issue specifically it ends up listing out a multi-factor test a bunch of different factors that it's not even a test it's not like hey if you meet these factors you are you are a property broker and you have to get Authority it's more like here's a bunch of things you should consider and if if you meet a bunch of these different factors then maybe it's more likely that you're a property broker and need property broker Authority uh the one thing that they didn't do in the guidance that I know a lot of people were hoping they would do but it's not all that surprising to me that they didn't do it was tackle this issue of double brokerage um you know always a a Hot Topic in the industry double brokerage and it's something that to this point FMCSA has kind of uh kept it's it's hands out of and I think you know frankly nobody's asking my opinion but um frankly I think rightfully so I mean we're talking about the Federal Motor Carrier safety administration their their job is to deal with safety issues they are they are not the uh the agency that regulates the commercial aspects of trucking which is how I would categorize the topic of double brokerage although you know there's an argument to be made I think that FMCSA should step in um I just obviously they haven't found it that compelling and so in this guidance that just came out they have once again said that we're not tackling that issue of double brokerage so we will have to see if it comes in some other form or fashion here in the near future or not probably not if I had a crystal ball um the last thing I'll mention kind of industry news here is a another notice that came out from FMCSA this week which was a notice of proposed rule making that would Implement if it's passed and I have no reason to believe that it won't uh it won't be enacted it's a regulation that will Implement an operating Authority for higher operating Authority exemption for certain providers of recreational activities these are going to be companies that are for example transporting passengers they run a company that does like kayaking on a river somewhere and as part of that business they have shuttles that transport passengers to one end of the river along with all of the kayaks or the rafts or something like that those provide those types of providers not just in that circumstance but the the point is the FMCSA is is proposing regulations that would provide an exemption to those types of entities from the requirement for Interstate For Hire Motor Carrier operating Authority why are they doing this because Congress came out with a similar statutory exemption for these folks somebody lobbied to get this exemption and it now exists in statutory form in the legislation that governs Trucking and so now FMCSA is stepping in and making the necessary revisions to its regulations to implement that similar exemption we see this quite a bit with the regulations and so that was published actually I think it's published either today or if not today then tomorrow I believe we have a whole article on it on our website if you're interested in learning more about who qualifies as a recreational activity under this exemption you can check that out over at trucksafe.com all right um let's see here we got some folks commenting on the fmcsa's rulemaking here yes the FMCSA is always as vague as it can be possibly be but it still seems unclear uh who can and cannot uh whether dispatchers can or cannot work with more than one carrier at a time I agree I wish it were more clear I don't know why it has to be so gray but they left it in that state so we're gonna have to deal with it uh unless and until they revisit it again so it is now in final form uh all right so enough about us enough about what's going on in the industry let's move to today's topic the title of uh today's show is when regulations run amok this is like I said based on an article um that we published on this topic last week um over at trucksafe.com where we pondered what areas of modern day Trucking regulations have gone too far or are not not particularly effective at accomplishing their goals and what we should do about that when that happens as we said in the article Trucking is and always has been heavily heavily regulated industry that's no surprise and I think rightfully so I think most would agree with that it's dangerous and the consequences of unsafe operations uh can be devastating so it's unsurprising that we have lawmakers and Regulators out there that are constantly making tweaks to the regulations we're seeing this day in and day out and they are doing that in an effort to minimize the occurrence of large truck and bus crashes but where exactly do you draw the line that is the question we posed in the article that's the question I want to talk about today I wanted to explore that topic even further on today's show and get some other perspectives so excited to have with me today an industry veteran who's no stranger to the ever-changing regulatory environment in which motor carriers operate and that's Mike uh pressy president and C EO of fleetworthy Mike welcome to the show afternoon Brandon hey thanks so much for joining me really appreciate it you're uh you're in my neck of the woods today Indianapolis no I I did I drove down from Madison to Indianapolis I was checking you know I wasn't in a commercial vehicle so I didn't have to check on my I was service yeah you got plenty of hours left to drive back back home and you're not you're not you're not performing any recreational activities so I don't think you get any kind of exemptions this is recreational okay it's enjoyable I'll give you that all right so for those of you uh for those of our listeners who may not be familiar with you I was just wondering maybe if we start off with you giving us a little bit of your background and how you uh how you ultimately ended up in the trucking world yeah so I'm the president and CEO of fleetworthy solutions uh we are a transportation compliance um company we focus on software and Services located in Madison Wisconsin I've been here about going on seven years joined transportation that came from a supply chain software background where I had a lot of trucking companies as customers on more of the sourcing side and and supply chain side so it just was a natural fit so I was excited to when I found the opportunity to join fleetworthy so what exactly does fleetworthy do I I we've been fortunate to partner with you guys over the years on various things that we're doing and we love the product that you offer but for those who aren't familiar with it kind of break down what is fleet Worthy so we are a company that partners with carriers of all sizes whether it be private fleets or For Hire fleets to help them you know meet the the compliance rules and regulations set forth by the FMCSA and the dot and we do that with a combination of Technology you know a platform that we call CP Suite that you know allows our customers to leverage that technology to make sure that their driver Community is compliant to all the regulatory rules and their assets are running legally on the roadways in the U.S per the regulations as well and then we also have a second leg of the stool which is you know a subject pool of subject matter experts that become an extension of their safety departments uh you know we maintain understanding of the rules and regulations we feel that technology will get you so far but you also need you know people to help you keep an eye on all the changing rules and and make sure that you're complying you know most carriers are trying to comply but the rules are changing so fast you know it's hard to keep up yeah definitely I and obviously it's one of the things that we spend a lot of our time doing is kind of counseling our clients on the ever-changing regulatory landscape and that's one of the reasons I wanted to really kind of tackle the topic today which you don't necessarily really see a whole lot of people talking about I think it's an important topic because you know what the last thing we want to do is just kind of follow regulations blindly when it turns out that maybe they're not really accomplishing the goal that they that they set out to accomplish so I think it's it's always good to kind of reflect back on where we are at from a regulatory landscape and and ask the hard questions of are there regulations out there that that shouldn't be or that should be tweaked to better accomplish their mission so I kind of want to first of all get your overall take on the state of trucking regulations today is it too much not enough are they effective I know that's a very broad question but kind of a high level look at the current regulatory landscape yeah I mean I think you know our slogan is beyond compliant so our goal with our customers is to make sure that they're doing more than just the minimum we feel if you're just doing the minimum you're just one accident away from being shut down or a nuclear verdict or you know an unsatisfactory um performance on an audit and things so we're always trying to make sure our carriers are going you know beyond just the minimum being proactive but you know with that as a mission because the bar is always moving uh even even carriers that are really interested in going beyond the minimum are faced with a paradigm where it's really hard to do that right um you know I think the regulations that are put in place are are there to make the road safe but when you step back and look at it from from a real realistic perspective it gets kind of hard right you know we tell we tell our customers we're not in the cab our platform is you know not a device you know but we the Third Leg of our stool is understanding that there's this kind of uneven Paradigm in in trucking and what I mean by that is if you look at trucks themselves and in the cab and the technology and the thing and how it's growing in regards to the steepness of the curb of technology and then you go to the safety departments you know and their dispersed locations and they're using spreadsheets green screen as400s they don't even have the ability to consume all the data that's coming out of the cab yet the government's using that data to you know decide whether you're right you are compliant or not so we're trying to help you know our carriers find a place by leveraging our technology where we consume that data we keep track of what's going on from a regulatory perspective and then create actions and and recommendations of how that carrier can be in front of the the regulations and build them around them from a compliance perspective yeah it is crazy just you know you and I were talking earlier we you know at truck safe and our related Law Firm we're regularly going in and doing mock dot audits of motor carriers I know you guys do some of that work as well for your clients and it's just crazy how how frequently you go into a a motor carrier and they are keeping paper records still of their vehicle files is the number one culprit I've found is it's rarer almost to see a situation where a motor carrier has digitized their vehicle files and so you literally open up the filing cabinet you pull out all of the hanging files and you're digging through those to try and find a an oil change receipt from last year it's just crazy and then when you look at that on the driver file side of things you got so many fleets Still on paper driver files it's you can imagine how easy it is for things to go wrong when that's your system right I think that's that's the thing I've really appreciated about your guys's product is is bringing it leveraging technology like you said to minimize the instances of those types of gaps absolutely and you know to to that example you you know as you're doing things from a you know a paper-based approach and you know you you do get audited and you're you're handing over a paper file that maybe isn't organized correctly or maybe it has out you know outdated material you understand that that just exacerbates it's like an onion because now there are more problems that that you know people can see which creates more audits which creates more penalties and things and you know that's why our mission is to help carriers you know electronic move to an electronic platform that they can control and then layer on top of that alerts and things and work work requests and tasks you know to get ahead of you know fixing the problems rather than being reactive yeah that's one of the things we're routinely preaching to our clients is that organization goes such a long way in a DOT audit it's probably the single most important thing that you could do to get yourself out of an audit quickly in our experience is be organized if you hand over that vehicle file that's three inches thick of documents from 10 years ago that they don't even they're not even entitled to see now you're just inviting them to stay at your place longer and dig through those records and find something uh potentially find something that that you didn't even have to turn over to them in the first place so if you can get to a place where you're able to organize your files get them out of your hair as quickly as possible get them just what they need and nothing more I found that that is the most effective tool to passing an audit more than more than anything else really 100 100 agree that's that is the narrative that we go through with our customers on a daily basis so kind of in this vein of you know regulations and how much is too much um from a if we're looking at this from the perspective of the of The Regulators I guess the the question is how do we strike the right balance between too much regulation and not enough regulation because to your point and I'm in total agreement that you know the regulations are meant as a floor uh if you're not complying with the rules then you've really got no shot in that God forbid you got tied up in one of those nuclear verdict cases um but you should be doing a lot more than that you should be going Beyond compliance as you said but where do we strike the right balance where is the right line to draw for regulations are there are there things that you think uh Regulators should be using as kind of the threshold for that yeah I you know I think there's so much to that question and you know me and my staff are always trying to figure out what what the balance I mean you know I I look at hours of service for instance I mean when you when you study hours of service and you apply it to one driver one truck you know it's pretty simple right um the rules are pretty simple but when that one driver becomes 10 000 drivers across 50 states different time zones you know different D.O.T numbers but all the same you know company how do you know even a carrier that's really serious about compliance how do you keep track of making sure a footprint like that is maintaining compliance right um and especially when really hours of service you're always looking kind of reactively it's after the fact and so on so you know I think it the the concept is to make the road safer but you know we talked about this earlier you're putting a timer in a in a cab that's ticking down and you know I think human nature is when you run out of you're running out of time you don't drive slower you drive faster right um you make decisions based on how much time you have left rather than you know how am I feeling am I fatigued am I you know those things so you know I just think it's a hard it's it's a hard problem to solve and I think you know strict rules based on amount of time in a cab is a part of it but you and I both know it doesn't have anything to do with what that driver was doing before they got in the cab what if they got into the cabin they were fatigued in the very beginning of their you know so yeah what if they just work the night shift at Walmart and now they're jumping and driving a truck yep or their baby was up all night kept them away all you know so you know no ill intent meant but the reality is you know I think regulations that are you know tracked real time but looked at retroactively and don't really test the real problem you know it's how do we fix that yeah I think that's definitely one and then we wrote that in our article that's definitely something I think we should be doing a better job of doing as Regulators than than what we're doing which is looking at taking a closer look at retroactively are our regulations actually accomplishing what we intended them to accomplish obviously anytime the agency is proposing a new rule they kind of set out the basis for the rule at the start uh and here's what we're looking to accomplish with the hours of service rules have been in effect since the 1930s in some form or fashion the idea with those is to reduce fatigue driving and and eliminate those crashes that are related to fatigue and so I think at a very basic level when it comes to drawing the lines with regulations we have to say we have to have mechanisms in place to be able to test our hypothesis is are these regulations actually effective at reducing fatigue driving related accidents or not and you you know I was disappointed I think but not all that surprised to see some recent studies indicating that maybe they are not that great the hours of service rules as they are currently structured are not actually minimizing uh instances of fatigue related driving so um you know another thing we pointed out in our article are you know FMCSA publishes their heavy truck and bus crash data every once in a while I think the last one is 2020. uh there we were still dealing with 5 000 large truck and bus involve fatalities as of 2020 and from 2010 to 2019 we've seen a 31 percent increase in these types of fatality accidents involving large trucks and buses so if the point of the safety regulations is to minimize those but we are seeing trending in the wrong direction do you have any thoughts on why that may be and and what we need to do about it yeah I mean I I think you hit on many of those things I mean I think that the hours of service rules themselves do not identify whether a person's fatigued you know you add to the fact that if you look at Trucking as an industry you know and an aging driver Community our inability to find younger drivers to enter this as a business um we're pushing our drivers to do more and more we saw that during covid I think all those things are a reason why just hours of service isn't really fixing the problem yeah and it seems like you know even outside of hours of service it seems like now more we've had we have more regulations in place now than we've ever had before and yet we are still trending in the wrong direction so I'm always asking myself is it are we what is the Genesis of these accidents if the safety regulations aren't minimizing uh the regular the the instances of those accidents what is the cause is it because the regulations aren't effective is it because we're we've got uh new technology that is causing bigger problems than what we had hoped what is it and I so I think the point is um that we need to have those those checks in place where if we're going to move forward with the regulation we need to be self-aware we need to three years down the road five years down the road ten years down the road really look at these studies and if it appears that our regulations are not effective at accomplishing our goal then we need to do something about it we see this occasionally I think with even in the hours of service context I think in 2019 FMCSA rolled back some of their hours of service regulations they expanded the short haul exemption they uh they they kind of changed up how you do split sleeper birth they made a couple of other things and their point there was we're going to try and make the hours of service rules a little more flexible for drivers was the terminology we kept hearing from FMCSA so we know that they do this occasionally I just don't know that they they do it to the extent that they really need to do it if the studies are truly showing that we are not improving uh we are not minimizing fatigue related accidents then maybe it's time we overhaul the way that we think about drivers hours of service and and I would add you know maybe it's it's time to to take a a an approach of not just regulating but maybe rewarding the the carriers that are being proactive to to help the cause of reducing those accidents and you know I use an example and you know it sounds like it's off topic but you know you're probably not as old as me but I remember playing football and you know when when a kid was they thought it could add concussions back in the day they'd look in the eye look at this light and send you back out in the field right and over the years people realize well that's that's not enough we've got to do more and I think you know being a person that's coached High School football they moved to benchmarking and you know seeing how a person behaves when they're not concussed and then having that as a as a benchmark and then if that person's injured you go back to the Benchmark and and you do something some cognitive tests and if they're if they're performing better you know they're not concussed uh if they're their performance is deteriorating you know they are concussed so to me you know the more we can get to real-time understanding on how a driver's behavior is changing whether it's fatigue or anything else and you know us rewarding carriers for being proactive I think goes a lot further in making the road safer than you know home let's Slide the hours let's try to figure out what works for everyone and it's like it it there's not a one-shoot fits all in my opinion right yeah and you can see that you just talked about the change in this recreational type of of carrier you know things they do or don't have to do you know I'm not saying that are we to believe that in that case the LIE lives in that business are less important than you know someone who's who's Towing some other type of of goods I just don't think that's the case right our goal is let's is to drive safety and I think proactive steps is better than reactive steps yeah I think two good points there one being and this is something we had in our article too and I'm fully on board with it with which is this idea that if we have a regulation where we have so many exemptions from that regulation that the exemptions just essentially swallow the rule what's the point of having the rule and we see this no more prominently than with hours of service if you if anybody wants to pull up part 395 of the safety regulations now if you get into part section 395.1 and 0.3 you will see no less than like a dozen different exemptions for people who are completely exempt from hours of service rules everything from government owned vehicles and to your point Mike it's like you know those people are just as capable of as causing serious accidents as a as a typical truck driver why are we exempting them we are exempting them because they have lobbyists uh that have gone out and sought these exemptions and and we've given them to them but if we have so many exemptions where you know nobody's subject to these rules then we're obviously not going to accomplish our purpose of minimizing fatigue driving because everybody's exempt from the rule so I think that's just another area where we can we could do better from a regulatory standpoint is watching out if we truly believe that a regulation or that a topic is worth regulating then there should be no reason to exempt people from that regulation we need to more narrowly tailor it in my opinion to to fight the the issue that we're trying to fight rather than do a broad sweeping regulation and then have to carve people out here and there it's just ridiculous completely agree and then the other thing you mentioned which I which we do nothing of uh when it comes to trucking regulations or you know frankly hardly any any type of regular regulated body is incentivizing or or rewarding compliance and it's this classic idea we've heard FMCSA talk about this over the years and they use that term Beyond compliance uh which I think your is your guys's tagline but we've heard them kind of hint at maybe we will start rewarding carriers that do more that go above and beyond what the regulations say they have to do because doing so obviously would incentivize people to do more than what is required of them and then maybe reduce uh accidents but to date we just we don't do that we do not reward motor carriers who do more than what is expected of them I think we should be doing that for sure um I was going to ask you uh I've kind of thought of I guess we've talked about hours of service are there any other particular areas of the regulations where you think we are just getting things wrong when it comes to Highway Transportation at this point you know I don't know that I would go as far as saying we go raw you know we're they're doing things wrong I would just say you know you've been talking about you know regulatory piece of it but you now you layer on top of that nuclear verdicts attorneys that are are suing you know carriers because they think they have Deep Pockets I think we're creating this scenario where carriers that are trying to do the right thing you know in a simple example is a carrier that says hey you know we're gonna we're gonna monitor a driver our driver's mbrs because we want to make sure that um you know all of our our drivers have valid licenses they're not suspended they're doing you know they're they're drivers we want to be driving with you know our our local trucks the problem is there's you know go back to that 10 000 driver you know carrier who's trying to do the right things running mvrs not just annually but maybe they're monitoring them you know real time but their staff is overworked they you know and now they have this data that's out there that might be indicates indications of a problem right but because they're understaffed overworked they're not jumping on those those indicators fast enough and now something happens and now all these things that they're doing to try to prove that they take compliance serious it's actually flipped and used custom because now they can say oh lucky this one driver you know had a problem for X number of months may or may not have been involved in the accident that triggered this this lawsuit but now all of a sudden there's more indications that hey the care is this big Banker doesn't care about safety compliance of things and those are some of the things that we're doing with fleetworthy we're trying to leverage technology and you know give our carriers you know another tool that's constantly looking at all these different data sources and giving them actions and and directions of these are things actions that you need to take so that you can continue to show that you're serious about compliance yeah I think that's something that most carriers that I work with at least don't appreciate which is how those types of nuclear verdict cases play out and we've done some other shows with like Steve Bryan from blue wire and a couple of others where we've kind of talked about those types of cases and they always become about the motor carriers reputation as you said Mike it becomes the the circumstances of the accident at hand become the become insignificant in the case the case becomes about well what are this what's this motor carrier CSA scores and what are its out of service rates look how unsafe it is how can we allow this motor carrier to continue to operate when it's got such bad safety scores and that is the story that's told to jurors and that is persuasive to jurors it turns out and so you know it inflames them and gets them mad and makes them want to do something and the tool that they have available to them is to punish the motor carriers usually with some type of punitive damages those damages are intended to punish you for your bad behavior which is in most cases a lot of cases your non-compliance with these things so if we have platforms out there or like Fleet worthy where you can really use it to show that you are doing more than what the regulations require and you are complying with the regulations that is just building up your reputation in those types of cases the blue wire is a classic example I'm on Steve's board or director so you know the mission that they have there is a great one and you know really kind of combines with our vision of what we're trying to do with with our customers and and in the industry um but as you know it's it's just not an easy it's not an easy task Yeah you mentioned uh continuous license monitoring I want to get your thoughts on that because I know we've preached to preached that message over and over again of how much we think motor carriers should be voluntarily subscribing to a continuous license monitoring service what are your thoughts on that yeah we agree and again the only thing the only caveat and you know we we partner with you know the leaders in continuous MBR monitoring because we think that's a you know a huge aspect of running a compliant carrier uh the the thing that we say going back to that going Beyond you know beyond compliance is just make sure that that that you know data that is that MBR that you're monitoring it becomes this data source but it doesn't necessarily be a it's not a destination for your your safety team so we we consume that information and then like I said layer on top of that action so that the moment we see that there a driver has an issue we're notifying you know our the safety department of our customers saying okay here's what you said you would do in these situations make sure that that's done by this amount of time so that you can fix that that risk quickly because the longer it festers and stays there the bigger the risk is right so it's not just enough to monitor it you have to you know do something about it yeah because I think that is one of the biggest gaps you know speaking about regulations going awry I think that's one of the biggest current gaps where I think we actually probably need more additional regulations which is this concept of uh you know annual mvrs so regulations for folks watch and probably know that the regulations only tip uh require of you that once you hire a driver that you check their Motor Vehicle Record once per year but those are just snapshots in time they'll tell you does this driver has have a license as of the day I run this if if John Doe loses his license tomorrow after he ran the report because he didn't pay child support or didn't appear for court date you're going to be blind to that unless he tells you or until a year later when you run his next MVR so you've got potentially a Year's worth of time where you've got John Doe out there driving a large truck or bus without a license and it it that's not theoretical we see that happen catch carriers so many times in that violation and that's what the dot considers a red flag violation is using a driver that doesn't have the proper license to operate their equipment it's a huge deal and you can imagine how that plays to a jury if that driver then goes and kills somebody he doesn't have a license so of all the things the technologies that are coming out for trucking companies nowadays I think uh in this and continuous license monitoring was early but I think it is one of the most effective things that you can do single most effective things that you can do Beyond compliance right now to protect your Fleet yep agree just my two cents on that the other area I wanted to ask you about that I think not enough fleets pay attention to is kind of training continuous training you know the the thing about the regulations is they say very little about training they just basically say Hey you motor carrier have an obligation to make sure your drivers are well informed about their obligations on their regulations and that's all they say except in limited circumstances Hazmat employees and stuff like that there's no specific mandated training what are your thoughts or what are your recommendations to your customers in terms of what training they provide to their drivers and then also to their just their safety staff generally speaking Yeah so you you've kind of so we are not a a training platform but what we do is we go try to find the best of breed vendors that we can partner with we built our product to be agnostic in nature and you know we can integrate these kind of ancillary safety type products in the solution in our solution and then we can thread you know the the behaviors that we're trying to help our our customers Foster with their drivers so it's you know number one you want to make sure that it's a has a library that is is Broad enough to really deal with the day-to-day issues that your drivers are going to be be faced with um but you also have to be monitoring those those situations like it's great to have training available to drivers but if you're not monitoring you know incidents and what are the incidents and what are the trends so that you can red thread that to the right type of educations and and uh classes then it's kind of hard to accomplish so what we do is we partner with great um you know both platforms or Consultants like you good folks and because we're doing a 360 degree view of how a driver's behavior is impacting the clients the moment we see you know events you know whether it's you know swerving or you know it's near misses or things like that we want to get that data connected to the right type of you know class or or education and make sure that that's getting to the driver but then even more importantly making sure that you're monitoring did the driver take the test yeah did they ask the tests did their behavior improve after they took the test do they need to take the test again should there be driver uh you know situations where the driver should be managing or doing something with the driver and then documenting all that so that if an accident does occur you have all the data that shows hey this this was just an accident because we are doing all the things necessary to to drive compliance and and make sure we do our part to make the road safer yeah I think it's key and you've said it a few times now but I think people really need to take it away that you know you can have all of the data access to all of the data out there but if you're not effectively managing that data then it's just going to come back to work against you like we worked with a client a couple years ago now we went down and did a mock dot audit and we looked at their telematics system that they were using they were using it primarily as an ELD device but it also was capturing harsh braking events and stuff like that and what they didn't realize was that that the system was actually giving all of their drivers I think they had a couple thousand drivers it was giving them a great a score of you know a b c d e f based on their driving activity their harsh braking stuff like that and so they had drivers in the system who they were continuing to use who had been graded in F and and they didn't even know it and so you can imagine we told them at the time you know we got to get control of that we either have to turn that functionality off which I'm hesitant to say for other reasons but more importantly we need to figure out a way to manage that and actually act upon that data that we are getting in because if if that driver then goes and kills somebody and now you're in litigation it comes out that you had a system telling you the driver had a problem with their driving behavior and you didn't do anything about it that plays terribly to a jury so you got to understand I think first is is your point Mike that you got to understand what data sources what data is coming into you and then you need to have a plan to be able to manage it completely agree and you know we have a thesis that you know driver scorecarding which is you know has you know been popular and then lost momentum and then popular we think and there's a lot of different ways you can get these driver Square cards and you know I feel that they're going to go the way of credit scores you know it used to be yeah I thought transunion's credit score was the best and someone thought experience was the best but now if you look at it platforms are showing you all the credit scores you choose which one you know now you've got a kind of a blend it's you know credit score well we're trying to do that with driver score we we want we welcome partnering with people that that have uh scores of their own based on maybe this slice of data and we want to leave that data with all the data that we're consuming from different data sources and then have a real what we will hopefully be you know a really clear driver scorecard based on a lot of different kpis rather than just you you know individual ones that give you know you a better picture of how well is this this carrier you know educating their drivers managing and maintaining compliance and things and I think that comes from a lot of different data sources not just elds not just mbrs but a lot of different things yeah for sure all right we're running out of time Mike I just wanted to uh leave with one additional question which is what do you think is going to be the next big regulatory push in our industry we've got some hints from FMCSA about what they're thinking about speed limiters stuff like that do you see anything coming down the pike here that that fleets need to watch out for you know I you know you can imagine I got we look at a lot of different things um you know I feel like the the push for you know moving away from fossil fuels to electric vehicles to things there I think a lot of things are that's going to catalyze a lot of changes right you know the first one's easy it's like okay fuel tax how does that change if they're not you know if they're not filling up with gas then what do we what are we going to calculate is it going to be just miles is it you know so I think that's interesting and I do think you know whether we go partially autonomous you know I don't think full autonomous vehicles are going to be here anytime soon but I think you know how does that affect hours of service rules if if we're leveraging technology for you know not fully autonomous vehicles but vehicles that are doing some of the things that it you know itself does that mean that our service rules should change because now we're not wholly dependent on the driver you know so I think that's interesting I saw one of the things FMCSA was questioning to that point was you know as I understand it in some levels of autonomy there are going to necessarily be folks back at an office kind of monitoring things and also dealing with law enforcement if the truck gets stopped and whether those people who are sitting in an office somewhere need to be subject to some kind of hours of service regulations yep exactly yeah so I think that and then the other one is you know as we are you've seen uh changes in regards to what's the the minimal age for a driver yeah discuss people about that I think as that you know comes more and more into fruition I think that's going to naturally change some yeah some regulatory rules we'll see I I think the last I heard is just abysmal um the numbers on that safe driver apprenticeship pilot program that is allowing limited number of 18 to 20 year olds to operate trucks I think the particip they were hoping to get 3 000 participating drivers I think the last numbers I saw they were like literally three people participating in that program so just uh no it doesn't seem like there's much interest in that program and I think there are a variety of reasons for it including some red tape with that program um but yeah I think that's that's something we'll have to watch closely is whether we start to see that age limit of 21 creep down a little bit all right Mike we're out of time um really appreciate you you joining me today again uh great discussion um if people want to learn more about Fleet worthy or reach out how do they do it uh they can reach us at www.fleetworthy.com a lot of information on our website so feel free to to visit our website and see if there's anything we can do for y'all excellent thanks again Mike really appreciate it all right we're going to wrap the show up thanks everybody for joining us today um be sure to stay tuned for uh announcements about our future shows we're going to try and do these every couple of weeks or so you can catch the replays of these if you miss them live wherever you get your podcast or over at trucksafelive.com I want to mention our courses our online courses we have courses available for safety managers and also drivers we've got Hazmat training Reasonable Suspicion training if you want an online solution for that check out our courses over at trucksafeacademy.com be sure to follow us on social media and like I said at the start subscribe to our newsletter for the latest Transportation news and Analysis thanks again to our the sponsor for this season of truck safe live log Rock really appreciate you teaming up with us on this that's it hope to see you guys later thanks for joining us

Event Completed

Wednesday, June 21, 2023 at 3:32 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube