Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 25 - Reining in fleet safety metrics

Friday, July 14, 2023 at 6 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 25 - Reining in fleet safety metrics

About This Event

In this episode, we address the top fleet safety metrics that motor carriers should be tracking, what they say about your fleet, and how to rein them in once they start trending in the wrong direction.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 25 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter of Trucksafe Consulting and Carpenter Compliance, respectively, tackle the critical topic of fleet safety metrics, including CSA scores, out-of-service rates, and Inspection Selection System (ISS) scores. The hosts emphasize that these publicly available metrics are actively monitored by a wide range of stakeholders — including commercial insurers, freight brokers, shippers, the FMCSA, and plaintiffs' attorneys — making it essential for motor carriers to understand what their scores say about their operations and take proactive steps to improve them. The discussion opens with out-of-service rates, which are displayed prominently on the FMCSA's SAFER website and reflect how frequently a carrier's vehicles, drivers, or hazmat operations are placed out of service during roadside inspections over a 24-month period. The hosts caution that these are percentage-based figures and can be disproportionately skewed for small fleets with limited inspection history, meaning a single bad inspection can appear catastrophic even if it is not representative of a carrier's overall safety culture. Rob Carpenter notes that the out-of-service rate is often the first data point a broker, shipper, or underwriter sees when evaluating a carrier, making it a critical first impression that can directly impact a fleet's ability to secure business or obtain insurance coverage. The hosts then dive into CSA scores and the Safety Measurement System (SMS), explaining that these percentile-based scores across seven categories — known as BASICs — serve as the FMCSA's primary tool for prioritizing carriers for enforcement action. When a carrier's score in any BASIC exceeds a category-specific intervention threshold, a warning indicator appears, signaling to regulators that the carrier may warrant further scrutiny. Both hosts stress that the real value of SMS lies not just in monitoring the scores themselves, but in drilling down into the underlying violation data to identify patterns — such as recurring lighting, tire, or brake violations — that point to systemic issues like inadequate pre-trip inspections or maintenance program failures. They also discuss the DataQ challenge system as a mechanism for disputing inaccurate violations, noting that challenges backed by documentary or video evidence, or supported by adjudicated court outcomes, have the best chance of success. The episode closes with a brief overview of the Inspection Selection System (ISS), which assigns each carrier a score from 1 to 100 that determines how frequently their vehicles are flagged for roadside inspection at weigh stations. ISS scores are driven primarily by CSA performance, meaning that improving underlying compliance programs is the most effective way to reduce inspection frequency. Throughout the episode, both Wiseman and Carpenter reinforce a consistent theme: there are no shortcuts to improving fleet safety metrics. Sustained improvement requires identifying trends, holding drivers accountable, investing in training, and maintaining rigorous internal compliance programs. As Carpenter put it, carriers should not rely solely on their SMS scores as an internal benchmark — a clean score can mask a deeply flawed safety program that has simply not yet been detected.

Full Transcript

thank you thank you everything thank you thank you thank you thank you this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign hey everyone welcome to episode 25 of trucksafe live show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with trucksafe and Childress law both of which are dedicated helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs uh excited to be here with you today thanks everybody for joining us if you're here live with us say hey in the comments uh just so we see who's here with us as we go along as always if you have any questions about uh what we're talking about feel free to throw it in the comments and we'll get it as they come up I think today's topic will be a good one for that type of interaction so hopefully you have all of your questions ready uh today we're talking about CSA and SMS and ISS and sfds and whatever other acronyms uh the dot has created uh safety metrics Fleet Safety metrics what they mean how they are calculated what they are saying about your Fleet and most importantly what you can do and what you should do to improve those various metrics and keep yourselves out of the crosshairs so uh looking forward to that discussion I've got Rob Carpenter back with me today from Carpenter compliance so uh should be a great show before we get to that topic though a few things going on um number one a couple things truck safe related I've mentioned this in Prior shows but first up um our truck say Fleet compliance boot camp is coming up this will be the second one that we've done this is our in-person uh two-day conference for Fleet Safety professionals uh to gather together a small group of us uh our next one's going to be in Orlando Florida October 12th and 13th the Rosen Plaza hotel nearby Walt Disney World and Universal Studios uh we're going to gather together like I said a group of about 50 or so of us and really get into the nitty-gritty of DOT compliance uh various sessions planned on all kinds of topics driver qualification hours of service vehicle maintenance drug and alcohol testing I got some great guest speakers lined up I've got a reception planned drinks and live music so if nothing else maybe join us for that so um if you're interested in joining us for that check it out over at trucksafebootcamp.com registration is now open seats are filling up quick uh we're well over halfway there now already and we've still got a couple of months to go here so if you're interested get in there trucksafebootcamp.com register sooner rather than later and we will see you there uh also wanted to mention as always our truck say Fleet compliance Network if you're not a member of this I'd recommend you join it it's free to join trucksafenetwork.com or download the free truck Safe app on the app store or the Google Play Store trucksafe network is a social network for Fleet Safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also have access to all of our content our videos on various DOT compliance topics our detailed articles our podcast and much more so would love to have you there check that out if you haven't already trucksafe network.com all right uh last thing I'll mention about trucksafe is um if you've missed the last show we had a show a couple weeks ago we were joined by Mike preche from fleetworthy CEO of fleetworthy we had a great discussion uh on an interesting topic about uh regulatory overreach what happens or what how do we know when regulations go too far and what should we do about it as an industry when the regulations go too far it was kind of based on an article that we had published on our website a few weeks ago so you can check that out on our website trucksafe.com and then catch the last show wherever you get your podcast Spotify uh Apple podcast or YouTube wherever check that out if you're interested okay enough about us what's going on in the industry a few things here before we get into today's topic um this is something we published on our website last week um the pipeline and hazardous material safety administration femza which is responsible for the Hazmat regulations uh proposing those and rolling them out um for all modes of transportation not just motor carriers but also you know pipeline as its name would imply pipelines uh railroads uh vessels uh they they published the Hazmat rigs but anyway they came out with a proposed rule uh actually it was an advance notice of proposed rule making so this is a notice to the public that fimza is contemplating pretty significant changes to its Hazmat rules I think there were 46 or so proposals in that notice we broke it all down on a article that we published on our website trucksafe.com last week a lot of various topics including training for HazMat employees uh changes to that process potentially changes to certification process for people that uh for folks that are inspecting Hazmat tanks so there's a lot that they are proposing if you're interested in that if it affects you then go check it out over at trucksafe.com it's our latest article you may also want to subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com subscribe where we are pushing out our newsletter where we highlight all of this kind of breaking regulatory news uh the last thing I'll mention kind of industry updates is a proposal that was a proposed rule that was filed a couple of weeks ago it's a joint rule making between FMCSA and uh national highway traffic safety administration Nitza that would if it goes through in final form mandate automatic emergency braking technology on heavy trucks which they Define in that rule to mean anything over ten thousand pounds uh and if it takes effect which I have no reason to believe that it won't um it would be a a phase-in schedule where I think the first trucks that would be required to be manufactured with that technology it would be like four years from the date of the publication of the final Rule and that would be for the heavier trucks over 26 000 pounds and then the trucks between ten thousand pounds and 26 000 pounds it looked like it would get an extra year um but that would be a rule that would apply to newly manufactured Vehicles as of those dates uh as it stands now there would be no retrofitting requirement so again another topic that we have a detailed article on over at trucksafe.com if you're interested so that's kind of what's going on in the industry um let's move then to the topic of today so as I said we're talking about the importance of tracking and reining in various compliance metrics if you're a regulated Fleet the summer Jared and I have been on kind of a tour of the United States visiting with a number of uh regulated fleets our clients to help them with mock dot Audits and one of the things that we spend a lot of time talking with them about are there Fleet Safety metrics and helping them understand what those metrics are saying about them and where things may be going wrong for them you know these metrics as I said include things like CSA scores out of service rates ISS scores accident rates and more and they are fertile ground for the FMCSA and the plaintiffs bar when it comes to targeting motor carriers for enforcement or crucifying them in a highway accident litigation stemming from a highway accident so it's critical that all motor carriers all regulated carriers understand number one what compliance data is out there about their Fleet how it's calculated what it says about them and most importantly as I said how to improve it so with me today is Rob Carpenter of carpenter compliance to help me break it all down welcome back Rob doing all right you're in Orlando today no I am the the background's a little different so it's it's hot it's nasty it's soupy um so other than that it's it's good I almost wore my um my Lilo and Stitch Disney uh where's your mouse ears Rob I almost did it my wife told me I needed more personality in the show so I almost threw it together yeah we're big Disney fans here in the Wiseman household my oldest son's name is Walter named after Walt Disney so uh you would have been right at home here with your mouse ears had you worn them today so uh anyway I'm gonna be down there with you uh here in the in the miserable heat here in a few days I'm coming down we're gonna be meeting with a client together and uh looking forward to it but thanks uh in the meantime for joining me today really appreciate it always interested in your perspective on uh on these types of topics um a little background uh for those who who don't know Rob Carpenter maybe just give us your uh your your quick background so I a little snippet so we don't spend all day but I started as a driver basically went into uh brokering Freight from being a driver and then went into owning a company small carrier management medium-sized management and Enterprise carrier management of all modes household goods Freight passenger uh even a little Hazmat so that's generally how it's been historically and now I run Carpenter compliance which is a consulting firm basically focusing on helping motor carriers and other customers like private Equity groups do due diligence and build defensive based programs focused on compliance and exposure so that's that's the short version yeah any Fleet Safety professionals out there you would do yourself a favor if you follow Rob on LinkedIn uh he's always posting a lot of great content on compliance issues uh really insightful uh articles on that type of stuff so check them out over at LinkedIn glad to have them as a good friend and help certainly helps our clients quite a bit so uh yeah today Rob we're talking about Fleet Safety metrics uh you like us are constantly out there looking at these metrics and we understand them obviously it's kind of our job to be looking at these metrics for fleets but and I'm sure this is true with you as well I found that not enough fleets really understand what goes into these metrics and what they're saying about their particular operations so I thought it would be useful for us to spend some time walking through what we view as the most important metrics and kind of how they're calculated basically we're not going to get into uh the entire methodology for someone of these things if you print out the methodology for CSA scores for example it's like a couple hundred pages so we're going to hit the high points here but uh sound good to you it does all right something we all need so yeah and like I said like I said at the start I want this to be an interactive show we got lots of people on with us today so uh if you've got questions as we go along about these things and how they work throw it in the comments and we'll bring it up and and talk about it we've already got a couple comments here um let's let's take a look here the go-getters here with the questions coming in early I have an employee who has a CDL that has an intra State restriction on his license the motor vehicle Report says he's not required to have a DOT physical is that correct I've never seen this uh no that's not correct uh it's correct for CDL drivers that they don't have to report the status of their medical exams to their state licensing agency so that's probably why you see that notice on their MVR I presume it's not a CDL driver uh oh you know what it could also be the issue with intrastate rob you want to go through kind of the difference for uh exempt and non-exempt drivers yeah so what happens in these cases is you're you're I guess back in 2012 what happened is FMCSA started requiring CDL Drivers to self-certify with their respective DMV whatever state they're licensed in with their CDL and what you're required to do is provide a copy of your medical certification with a form for that specific state that says how you operate so when I say how you operate it could be in this case it sounds like you're an interstate carrier and in that case your driver should be what we call non-accepted Interstate or ni is sometimes what it says on the MVR but what what happens is sometimes drivers will go to the DMV and they won't self-certify in the right way so they'll certify themselves as an Intrust State exempt driver uh CDL driver and that means technically that driver could have a CDL forever and never need a med cert filed with the DMV because they're they're saying that they only operate interstate so they're exempt from med card requirements so what has to happen here is when you're reviewing MVR cars a lot of people just check expiration and what kind of license they have but you also need to think about how you operate as a carrier because if you're an interstate carrier you have to check that medical status on the NVR to make sure that they've self-certified with their DMV not only that they've done it but that they've done it in the right way and in your case it sounds like your driver chose the wrong self-certification so in an audit it if he gets chosen as one of your sample drivers it would be it would be an issue with you being an interesting carrier yeah and to be clear that exemption for intra-state drivers is really only an exemption from them having to file proof of their medical exam with their state licensing agency it's not it's not an all-encompassing exemption from the medical requirement altogether if you look at a truly intra State driver every state in the country has adopted some version of the federal rules for intra-state drivers and virtually all of them I think all of them because I think this is one of the required things that they have to do to be part of the federal mix app program they have adopted a a physical exam requirement for the drivers that are operating intrastate in their state so even if this driver is truly an intra-state driver he's very well potentially subject to a the medical exam request government has to have a medical card maybe he just doesn't have to file it with his State and so maybe that's what the exemption is telling you but if he's operating a commercial motor vehicle for you as a regulated Fleet whether it's Interstate or intro state congress if he is operating a regulated vehicle he's going to have to have a medical card and you need to get a copy of it and he like Rob said he may need to change his certification status on his uh on his with his State licensing agency depending on how you intend for him to operate all right thanks for the question Gina so you've got one more here see what we got Charlotte's asking do sales team member pickups need to be Dot what is the pros cons of IRP tags if under the required weight wow these are some lofty questions uh but important ones uh sales team member pickups I'm not sure what they mean by that do you know Rob I'm thinking that it's probably gonna go I'm thinking uh without being having more information I'm thinking that they're probably talking about the maybe the sales salesman exemption from some oh yeah congratulations that's the only thing I can think of Yeah because sometimes you're exempt from certain things like hours of service under short haul you can leave one place and not have to return to the same place I'm not I think we would need more information on that question yeah if that's true if that's the question Charlotte you've got um uh traveling salesman the classic example are going to be like beverage uh drivers they are delivering beverages Coke or Pepsi to uh to a retail facility but they are also sales people they are selling there is a specific exemption as Rob mentioned for those types of folks from the hours of service rules specifically but it's in hours of service exemption for those for those members it's not an exemption from anything else so for those if that's who you're talking about they are still going to be subject to other DOT requirements like the medical exam requirement and the driver qualification requirements stuff like that uh and then on your question about IRP tags man we could spend probably now we're talking about this uh you know as you said Charlotte there's a weight limit or a weight threshold that mandates IRP tax if you're in if you have vehicles that weigh over 26 000 pounds power units that are operating in interstate commerce they have to have IRP tags if they're under 26 000 pounds twenty six thousand and one pounds uh then they are not mandated to have IRP tags but you can voluntarily get IRP tax and so your question is what are the pros and cons of having IRP tags uh when the vehicles are under that weight from my perspective and then I'll let Rob weigh in you know the pros let me start with the cons so the cons are as I understand the IRP tags are going to be more expensive than than state-based plates for those Vehicles you're going to be paying more for those tags the pros are um if you put IRP tags on those vehicles um then you get some benefits in in terms of federal preemption of State registration fees uh there is a whole document out there a whole uh I forget what it's called it's it's the IRP manual or whatever the states that subscribe to IRP have come together in a kind of a compact of states and they have agreed uh to give reciprocity to to the to the vehicles that are licensed under the program and the benefit you get out of the IRP plates is that if you are paying fees into IRP then you're going to be exempt from certain state-specific registration fees that you may have had to obey otherwise whereas if if you have state base plates you're not going to be exempt from those requirements uh so that's my take on it robbing anything else to add to that I don't have anything else to add but it looks like she added some more context to the question um sales guys that don't deliver products uh but driving company pickup I'm thinking we're we're going in the merchandiser where your guy goes into the store every day and infronts all the beer or the or the bread or whatever they're doing but if it's just a pickup truck I I don't necessarily think that you have any any more benefit than what you already said uh yeah depends on the weight of the truck that's really what it comes down to and whether they're operating in Interstate or intro State Commerce that's really the two things that you have to look at um as to whether the DOT regulations require you're asking now about the DOT number on the side of the vehicle depends on the weight of the vehicle and whether it's moving in Interstate or intra-state Commerce if it's moving in interstate commerce and it weighs less than ten thousand pounds Ten Thousand and One pounds or less no sorry ten thousand pounds or less then you're not going to be subject to any DOT requirements you don't have to put the DOT number on it Etc but if it's Ten Thousand and One pounds or more either by itself or if you've got a trailer on the back that causes the combination to exceed ten thousand pounds then you do have to have the DOT number on the side of it for example and that changes a little bit if you're only staying within a state each state has like I said kind of adopted certain version of the federal rules and some of them change that weight threshold so for example there are some states that raise it up to twenty six thousand so if you stay within the state and are only operating in intro State Commerce and your vehicle weighs less than twenty six thousand and one pounds then in that particular State then you may not have to have the DOT number but others keep it at that ten thousand pound threshold so if that's you if you're operating in trust State you need to know how your particular state has adopted the federal rules all right enough free legal advice people let's move on to uh uh today's topic which again is safety metrics Rob I wanted to kind of start things off by talking about why these Fleet Safety metrics that we're going to talk about are important I don't think enough folks know who exactly is looking at these scores and and what the implications are so maybe we could start with why the scores are important in your view the various scores whether we're talking about CSA scores or out of service rates or ISS scores why are these things important in your view uh there's there's a lot of these things that come up and from when I was a broker obviously we didn't Brokers look at these things and that's a big one for carriers who who need Brokers to find their work for them because one of the first things they look at when they send you the carrier pack if you're bidding on their load is they want to make sure that you're a legitimate carrier um and that your safety scores are good you typically if you're um a conditional or unsatisfactory carrier they're not going to let you haul their Freight so that's a big piece of it if you're relying on Brokers to find your work so that's the first piece but if you know I posted something on LinkedIn a couple hours ago about a carrier that I worked with who does a lot of closed loop passenger transportation and motor coaches and um what happens when you put out these rfps for you to bid on them to get that closed loop contract that could be millions of dollars over 10 years or five years or whatever they're going to look at your your safety scores and your out of service ratings and your accident um your accident rating and all these things to make sure that you're a safe Motor Carrier typically um and then the other piece of that is obviously insurers check these Underwriters want to see them and you know Brandon and I were talking last week because I we have a mutual friend who's an insurance broker who called and said hey I've got this guy and um it was just an unfortunate instant he at instance he had a small Fleet and because he had like two violations about a service his out of service rate went up uh to like 50 percent it made him uninsurable so it all of those things you know are there for people to see publicly and then you have customers I mean if you have a shipper that's going to hire you directly they can check these things or if you're a fair based passenger carrier they're going to date they have the ability to check these to decide if they're going to ride with you or ride with someone else so it's it covers all modes of transportation and abroad broad number of effects on your bottom line and ability to operate yeah if you think about it it makes sense that your customers care about this stuff because you are we are seeing more and more instances of shippers and Brokers being pulled into Highway accident litigation when you go out and get involved in an accident uh you know plaintiff's attorneys are always looking for the Deep Pockets that's the way it is and if you've only got a million dollars of commercial Auto liability insurance you're not the deep pocket but you may have a broker involved or a shipper involved if you're hauling for a well-known shipper a multi-million dollar business they are the Deep Pockets so they're going to get pulled into that litigation and we are seeing this theory of liability that is negligent hiring negligent uh selection type theory of liability where the plaintiff argues that you as the broker or you as the shipper had a legal duty to use reasonable care and selecting the motor carriers that you use to haul Freight and you breach that Duty by picking a motor carrier whose safety metrics should have tipped you off to the fact that maybe there's there's problems with this carrier then the argument is that you're negligent in selecting that motor carrier and because of your negligence but for your negligence the accident wouldn't have happened because you would have not put that carrier out on the road that's the theory that's put forth to the jury and that is catching on it is persuasive to a lot of juries and so Brokers and shippers have real skin in the game here they are potentially exposed to these types of million dollar multi-million dollar verdicts when the motor carrier that they use goes and gets involved in a serious accident so because of that you are seeing more and more Brokers and shippers spend more time on this stuff you know it's always been the case not always but it's been the case for a long time where you would see it's common to see in a shipper or broker agreement with a motor carrier that they don't do business with a carrier that has uh a safety rating that's less than satisfactory so conditionally rated carriers and certainly unset carriers are not going to qualify but it hasn't always been the case that they take it the next step and start to dig into your uh you know your CSA scores and stuff like that and you are seeing that more and more frequently nowadays has been my experience yeah and you got um you know it used to be you had contingent cargo and you could get contingent cargo for Brokers um really it was cheap insurance I mean everybody could get it because it was it was relatively inexpensive and now it's it's somewhat outrageous compared to what it was in the in the 2000s simply because this idea is caught on that hey we'll go after the broker if something happens with our cargo wipes with the carrier that they chose and then you have the same thing with shippers you know I had a client it's a it's one of the biggest oil companies in Texas and they they had no hand in this accident that uh they hired a trucking company they used their truck their trailer their driver and the only thing that tied this oil company to this accident was their oil was in this truck's tank and when they ran into a family and killed them in our service violations the first thing that they did was draw that oil company into that lawsuit so it happens and um it because and if you're in the lawsuit if you're in the lawsuit you've already lost because it's going to cost you time and money to get out of that case and you're going to end up paying a hefty fee to do that so yeah I mean certainly as you said customers are a a big stakeholder uh when it comes to these metrics they are looking at them you mentioned Commercial Auto liability insurers using it to help set your premiums and then certainly plaintiff's bar is going to be looking at it um you know if you get involved in an accident you know it's one of the first things they're going to ask for or look for are what do your your CSA scores look like what are your out of services percentages look like and you could see where they're going with it we've talked about this on other shows when we're talking about nuclear verdicts you know the cases that that end up with those types of multi-million dollar and now billion dollar jury verdicts the case quickly becomes less about the circumstances of that particular accident and more about the reputation of the motor carrier whose driver was involved in it the story that's told to the jury is not focused on what happened in this particular accident it's focused on casting the motor carrier as a bad actor as as uh as demonstrated by their poor safety performance and then that's what inflames the jury and gets them mad at the motor carrier and makes them want to punish that motor carrier for be having trucks out on the road to begin with and that's where you see those multi-million dollar jury verdicts awarded are in cases where a motor carrier safety metrics paint a bad picture about their efforts to comply with safety regulations so you know commercial insurers customers plaintiff's bar certainly the FMCSA whose systems these are there are lots of people looking at your scores if you're not looking at them as the regulated Motor Carrier you stand no chance because all these other people are looking at them you have to know what your scores say about you in order to get them in a place where these where they're not causing you problems in these other contexts yeah so there's a few different big uh metrics that I from my perspective are ones that all fleets should be paying attention to and um you know I I think it makes sense to go through them first one I want to talk about are kind of out of service rates rob you want to kind of go through what those are how they're calculated what they mean essentially yeah so you've got out of service rates and usually this is one of the first things that I look at because when you open uh when you're in safer and you're looking at a company snapshot one of the first things that come up is going to be the out of service rate and it's going to start with vehicle driver Hazmat Etc so it can be kind of skewed kind of like what I talked about earlier with our broker friend and uh basically there's a set percentage for each for driver out of service percentages you get the more out of service you get the more your percentage is going to go up and this looks back 24 months so of course this is going to improve because there are is going to be some data that falls off after it you know is older than 24 months so that's generally what I look at first and then I kind of work down from there but yeah it's going to be the first thing you see you mentioned safer and uh so I went ahead and pulled it up here just in an example carrier uh like Rob said this is publicly available information so this is the FMCSA safer website anybody can access this you can search for any regulated Motor Carrier by name or DOT number I just pulled up a random one here sorry jnb transport if you're watching uh not calling you out here uh but your scores look decent not terrible so uh but anyway this is the screen that you would be taken to if you were to search any regulated carrier you would see their basic registration details up at the top how many power units they they are operating how many drivers they have what type of freight they're hauling whether they're Interstate or interest State and then the section that's right below that are the out of service rates as Rob mentioned how frequent frequently are your vehicles or drivers being placed out of service for serious safety violations as compared to the number of times that your vehicles or drivers have been stopped for an inspection so if you've been stopped 100 times and 50 of those times your drivers have been prohibited from continuing to operate because of a serious violation that would be a 50 percent out of service rate uh and like Rob said it's based on 24 months worth of of data so anybody can see this you can see here in this example a little hard to tell sorry for the small numbers here but it's broken out into vehicle driver Hazmat out of services and then Intermodal equipment providers if you're a chassis provider or anything like that but the important ones here are vehicle driver and Hazmat if you haul it uh you can see here this particular carrier had 30 inspections over the last 24 months three of those resulted in the vehicle being placed out of service for a serious maintenance violation which results in a 10 percent out of service rate which is then compared against the national average for vehicle out of service rates which is currently 22.26 percent and so it goes with vehicles and driver and Hazmat so I found from my perspective that's that's a particularly compelling safety metric that a lot of folks pay attention to uh more so than most people realize because it is so readily available for all fleets and uh it's kind of compared against all fleets it's not like CSA scores where you're put into safety event groups and stuff like that it is simply telling the reader or the user of that data how frequently are your trucks and drivers having serious uh safety type violations and I think that's important thing to understand is kind of the distinction between out of service and and non-out-of-service violations rob you want to kind of give an overview of the distinction between those two groups of violations what you've got out of service that's going to be weighted different than a not out of service but and it's obviously going to take less out of service to increase your score overall um and how it's calculated but you can look at those violations under SMS but all of this all of these things kind of fit under what I would call the CSA umbrella um of this whole scoring system and violation system it's kind of all an umbrella peace and they're all pulling from the same databases really you know whenever your vehicles if you're an interstate regulated Motor Carrier every time one of your commercial vehicles gets stopped for a roadside inspection all of the violations that are listed out on the reports that you get are filtered into the mick Miss database Motor Carrier management information system and then that system is then pushing the data out to the various uh platforms that we're talking about today one of which is calculating you're out of service rates so you're out of service rates are calculated based on your roadside inspection data as are your safety management system CSA scores which we'll talk about in a minute and then you know it's just slicing and dicing the same data set into different metrics that are saying different things about your Fleet so when I'm looking at at fleet's out of service percentages what I'm what I'm taking away from that is the seriousness of the violations that your Fleet is incurring if you've got a bunch of ticky tack violations that aren't serious that aren't out of service type violations so form and manner violations are a classic example if your driver is filling out you know their driver log and they're forgetting to put the the shipper information or or that type of stuff those are foreman Manor less serious violations those aren't going to lead to your driver being placed out of service I'm less concerned about fleets that have a high instance of those types of violations than I am of a fleet that has more serious violations where they're being stopped from operating and how do we know that we know that based on their out of service percentages and it's it kind of goes to that uh first impression piece because when you open safer to look at any of this information whether it's SMS violation specifically um or whether you're just looking for a rating the first thing you're actually going to see is the out of service rating so it's that first impression that you initially get hit with and sometimes it can be overwhelming um and I think I'm not going to say bias um you you can perceive it differently because if you look at UPS's or another large Mega carrier they're percent they're out of service rates aren't going to look that bad from a percentage but if you go down to SMS and look at how many violations they have uh or how many fatal crashes or it's going to look a lot worse but from a percentage aspect it doesn't look that bad but if you have two trucks in your Fleet and you've had two out of services it looks catastrophic but then you may not have any fatal accidents and you you may not have a lot of uh violations but you know it just ends up giving you that first impression that you're you know an unsafe terrible character no that's a great point and it's you know these are percentages so they are they are based on how many inspections you've had and as Rob said if you haven't had very many inspections then one bad inspection is going to seriously impact your your out of service percentages and that's something that I think shippers and Brokers don't don't pay enough attention to you know sometimes we'll have motor carriers come to us and say hey I'm not able to get business because shippers and Brokers are concerned about my high out of service rates and I have to help them help their customers understand that they're relatively High out of service percentages in those case are based on relatively few inspections so they are not we argue in those cases indicative of the carrier Safety Management controls they are just it's bad luck at that point you had few inspections and you just happened to they just happened to inspect trucks or drivers that had a problem um but yeah that's a it's a key point is that these are percentages and and they can vary based on how many relevant inspections you've had yeah and that that getting chosen is another piece of it you know a lot of a lot of what I tell people is uh you know especially during Road check is you know they pull you over 31 percent of roadside inspections are based off what someone visibly sees when you roll through a weigh station or when you're coming down the road and when they pull you over if they happen to just get that wrong truck and you have a two-truck fleet and the other truck happens to be the good truck it's gonna be it could be ugly so uh it goes to that make sure your your trucks look good I know some people just look at it like it's a visibility thing something cosmetic but the better your trucks look the less likely they are to get pulled over yeah and also something else to consider we kind of talked about this beforehand Rob is how difficult it is nowadays to get a clean inspection report uh you know some carriers come to us and ask us what our thoughts are on volunteering volunteering to get their trucks inspected to try and drive they're out of service percentages down and so maybe what we talk about is you know okay so that we've talked about what our out of service rates and what data is filtering into them but the important question is how do we get control of them if we look at our out of service rates on our safer account we see that they're starting to Trend upwards and they're starting to get out of control particularly with respect to the national average I found that that's kind of the metric that a lot of the stakeholders are looking at is how you're comparing to the national average if you're above the national average then then they're less likely or you have a bigger Target on your back if they're below the national average then you're you're faring a little bit better but the most important questions obviously is how do we get control of those scores if they're high what are your thoughts on that um well it kind of let's talk about the first piece first so I'm kind of funny about sending any trucks for voluntary inspections but I have done it and I've been successful at it and I failed miserably at it so I can go either way because you just don't know what you're going to get for instance um we a company that I was managing we got 200 new vehicles delivered and obviously I felt that that was a safe bet to ship those brand new fresh zero mile trucks through a weigh station because they're fresh they're brand new what could be wrong and obviously that watered down that bad percentage of violations because you now have 200 new violation free inspections that are going to improve the bottom line of your score you're increasing your denominator I think is how math works you know yeah right but it can go bad we also had a truck company down in Portsmouth who had one truck and a it was brand new brand new Kenworth I think this was maybe 2020 model 2019. they sent it through the weigh station same same idea and actually got put out of service because it just so happened that year kenworth's studs on the rear tandems um had a recall and two of them were broken so he got out of service on a brand new truck so is it ever safe I don't know that it would ever be safe I mean you have equal opportunity for inspection but I mean for a violation and inspection but uh generally I shy away from it as a general rule but unless I know it's 100 safe from 98 safe you know and it's also heavily dependent on the inspector right because maybe you got a gunner I mean just out of the academy I have had I have had other you know other not brand new but um you know I had a motor coach deal up in Sonoma County California and they uh it was a different entity that I was doing motor coaches so he gets pulled over and in the inspection great inspection I mean this coach had less than 10 000 miles on it but what ultimately happened was they they wanted to get a violation I guess or they wanted to give the violation so they found corroded battery cables and that was the violation so they go through this whole bus emergency exits everything's perfect and they wrote it up for battery cable so it's but it also goes to that you know the nickel and dime violations like that so do I really care about a corroded battery cable to an extreme amount no um yeah but if out of service maybe it would have been a little different so yeah I think I'm of the same mind I think it's too risky uh in most cases to volunteer for a roadside inspection um with the hopes of getting a clean one but that's really your own I won't say the only but it's really the only uh big way that you improve your out of service rates it's dependent on your roadside inspection so uh as you have the old ones fall off your scores after 24 months and you incur no new ones to take their place no new out of service violations that's how your score starts to come down that's the only way your score comes down now the one caveat to that is uh data queue system which I'll save for uh I'll save for our discussion of CSA scores which is coming up next gotcha all right it's the most expedient I think anything else is just not it's all going to be time consuming if you if you can't get it done that way and you know if you're going to try that route it's important to trust your maintenance department if you if you have any questions about your maintenance team um maybe not having them exactly right I wouldn't do it lots of bad things can happen not very many good things can happen uh okay so that's out of service percentages very important safety metrics a safety metric that you understand where you stand as a regulated Fleet and uh work to improve those get those below the national average is kind of the name of the game um that one last thing I'll mention on Hazmat out of service rate specifically so these are going to be things like placarding violations and Shipping paper type violations stuff where your hauling Hazmat and it's an out of service condition um out of Hazmat High Hazmat out of service rates can actually impact uh your your credentialing there's a certain rate that they use for HazMat uh Hazmat out of service rates it's the national average where if you exceed the national average for your Hazmat at a service rate you're not going to be able to be qualified to obtain what's called a Hazmat safety permit if you're a if you're a hauler of particularly hazardous materials there are certain types of materials that require what's called a Hazmat safety permit from FMC USA you're not eligible to get that if your Hazmat rate exceeds the national average and if you have a safety permit and you your rate escalates above um the national average they're going to strip that away from you so that's something else to keep in mind uh okay so that's out of service rates the next big one our CSA scores this is kind of the elephant in the room so Rob take it away what are CSA scores we could spend probably two days talking about CSA scores but from a high level kind of what are they let's just Dive Right In Here so essentially what happens is you get violations and when you're when you're in the safer system there's a you there's a two Links at the top one's going to take you to SMS one's going to take you to the insurance portal where you can check on uh different things like everything from Authority registrations and do they have insurance who their insurer who their insurance carrier is uh but then it also takes you to SMS which gives you the specific violations um that that basically make up the scores of these Basics so when we talk about the seven basic categories what can happen is they go these violations are ultimately going to culminate in a percentage and in that percentage for instance maintenance let's just say their threshold for maintenance each one has their own maintenance let's just say 65 percent and once you get over 65 percent you're going to get this cute little yellow yield triangle over your vehicle maintenance basic that says hey there's a problem with this guy in comparison to other carriers that are like him there's something wrong with his Safety Management controls that in respect to vehicle maintenance what's going on with your program and then from there that's kind of how they correlate everything so if you want to go and see why your cute little yellow triangle is over your vehicle maintenance you can come down to SMS and then use things to select the vehicle summary and it's going to show you well the summary is going to show you the over the high level but the inspection history is going to show you uh you sometimes it's aggravating because you typically only have a license plate or a VIN in which you're going to end up having to do to figure this out it's who drove this vehicle on this day what office did this belong to Etc But ultimately it's going to show you the points that were that were given and the weight that those points carry so out of service is obviously weighted heavier against your score than a not out of service violation so ultimately the more out of services you have and one of the ones that I showed on LinkedIn earlier that I'm kind of in my Friday rant stage about is they have a huge amount of hour out of service violations for serious defects over the past three or four months and their maintenance score went from like 45 to 67 68 so now they have their little cute triangle over their vehicle maintenance and that's kind of how that whole system works in terms of SMS how they calculate the score weighting the scores and this information this system the safer system and SMS system can give you a lot of data on a carrier's general safety practices and how they rate amongst other carriers like them yeah so CSA is the primary prioritization tool that the FMCSA uses to escalate motor carriers for enforcement I've said this on multiple shows before the FMCSA is a relatively small agency it does not have the manpower to audit any significant number of motor carriers every year so it has to by direction of Congress it has to have a system in place to push to the top of their audit list the worst performing motor carriers so how do they do that they do that through CSA scores that's what the system is designed to do it Aggregates as Rob said all of the data from your roadside inspections over the last 24 months and it breaks them out into seven categories known as the basics which they're displayed here on the screen on safe driving crash indicator hours of service vehicle maintenance controlled substance and alcohol Hazmat and Driver Fitness it it puts all of your relevant violations in their categories and then based on the those how many how many of those violations you have in the category how long ago they occurred and how serious they were that's what drives your score in each of these seven Basics those are your CSA scores and as Rob mentioned they are percentile scores they are telling how you are performing relative to your peers who are your peers the system has a complex methodology you can find it if you type in SMS methodology like I said this is like a 200 Page document it's available online but they the peers your peers are going to be other motor carriers that have incurred a similar number of inspections with violations in that same category so if you've had over the last two years 10 inspections with unsafe driving uh violations then you're going to be compared against other motor carriers that have had a similar number of inspections with unsafe driving violations so it's not just the size of the carrier that matters it's how many relevant inspections with violations in each of the categories and then you're put on a on a scale so if there are uh you know depending on how many you have in your safety event group that's going to drive your percentile score so if you have for example in maintenance vehicle maintenance if you have a score of 92 percent uh higher is not better in this system 92 percent means you are performing worse than 92 percent of your peers in the vehicle maintenance category and that's bad news you're going to have one of those warning triangles that Rob mentioned and so that's the thing to know is is this is a prioritization tool used by FMCSA the percentile scores are are in each of the seven Basics they are telling you how you're performing relative to your peers and then as you start to escalate on those scores each of the individual Basics has a what's called an intervention threshold it's set at different levels in each of the basics and it's a different level for different types of carriers there's a Hazmat intervention threshold there's a passenger carrier intervention threshold and there's a property carrier intervention threshold and and it's set somewhere at some level Rob mentioned 65 percent for maintenance Rob is that the passenger carrier threshold for maintenance yes it's eighty percent for property carriers so what those thresholds are telling you is that on any given month if your percentile score exceeds that level then you are going to get that warning triangle on your score and that's what you're trying to avoid because the minute that warning triangle is up that means you're prioritized for enforcement maybe you don't get an audit because of just one warning triangle this month but it could mean that particularly in states where law enforcement or FMCSA has more time on their hands just one basic in alert status could mean an audit for you but in other areas where they're particularly busy maybe they only focus on carriers that have two or more basics in that alert status but that's kind of how it's used by FMCSA I've seen some carriers use this as hey we're good we don't have any yellow triangles or we don't have a lot of violations but I've also seen those same carriers be terrible programs so don't don't get caught up as much internally with this thing uh because it just means you you could have a terrible program and you're just waiting to get caught you haven't yet so I still encourage people to to to not put as much emphasis internally uh from a company from a company aspect when we're talking about corrective action measures but just be proactive about your programs overall one of those proactive pieces is checking your SMS scores regularly I check when I'm running a company I I usually check them every 30 days because just because a driver gets one doesn't mean they're going to tell you about it so you need to check those constantly to find out did any of my drivers get violations that they haven't told us about so um focus on it but only focus on it in respect that you have other other internal focuses of your own own corrective action measures so what I think is most valuable about SMS particularly for fleets that have a lot of roadside activity where there's more data in this system I like to use SMS as an early warning system I like to look for Trends in the carriers data are they starting to incur a lot more hours of service violations and I like to use that as like I said early warning hey you're starting to see your hours of service score Trend upwards so it's time to focus your attention on that it's time for your safety team to get control of that so that you can start to see the curve going down in the right direction it's very valuable in my in my estimation in my opinion to to identify negative Trends in your compliance because it covers a wide range of areas of compliance and then to Buck those Trends before they blow up into a warning triangle or into a serious accident or into high out of service rates like Rob's said I like to look at these on a monthly basis I'm looking at them I'm looking at what the scores are but I'm diving even deeper than that don't just stop at the scores like Rob said sometimes the scores themselves aren't all that valuable it's what's underlying the scores so you got to go down so we're showing here on the screen this is a carrier's SMS account this is the the public version of the account I should mention we should mention that CSA scores those percentile scores and the warning triangles that go along with them uh used to be publicly available for all motor carriers but they were taken down from public view probably 10 years ago now at the direction of Congress for reasons we're not going to get into here for property carriers uh any non-passenger carrier so now if you're looking up a property carrier all you can see are the kind of the data that underlies their their SMS scores you're not going to be able to see what their percentile scores are unless you happen to be that motor carrier and you can log into your account and see what your CSA scores are um but the point is what I like to do besides just focusing my attention on the CSA scores themselves is look at the underlying data so I can click into any one of these categories so I've got a high score in maintenance for example I'm going to go into maintenance I'm going to scroll down and I'm going to look at like Rob said what violations with maintenance violations are contributing to my relatively high score this the system lists out every single violation that is contributing to that score and I can get a sense of what drivers are causing the problem what vehicles are causing the problem what types of issues are most common to my fleet do I have a lot of lighting violations do I have a lot of Tire violations that gives me the ammunition I need to then take it the next step and get control of those if I have a lot of those brake lights and tires violations for example then the problem is probably drivers not doing thorough enough pre-trip inspections because those types of things should be caught in a pre-trip inspection in most cases and so that's the kind of information I need to be armed with as a safety team to then go get control of that start holding my drivers accountable to more thorough pre-trip inspections give them additional training if that's what's needed and then start to watch my old violations fall off and my scores start to improve that's the way you get control of these things yeah and it this is going to help you keep the pulse on your on your compliance Trends in in your violation Trends and like he said if you've got a lot of these these real micro roadside violations like lighting and fire extinguishers it's driver inspections is your problem or you may have a more systemic issue where if you've got you know breaks out of adjustment breaks out of adjustment axle out of alignment serious serious issues that maybe a driver wouldn't have been able to catch during an inspection but it it it more targets uh it's more trending towards a systemic issue on your maintenance team versus the driver inspections or you could have both you could have a lot of lights a lot of extinguish extinguishers a lot of bad tires and your systemic issues so it's helping you keep that pulse on it that's going to help you improve it if you if you keep track of those Trends and what's making it ugly yeah that's the thing carriers don't want to hear is what it takes to fix these scores you know so many of them want to hear that there's a quick fix to this but as I've said over and over and I know you say this Rob there's no quick fix it is recognizing patterns of non-compliance and then putting in the work to Buck those Trends and that often involves holding drivers accountable investing in training investing in spending time with them and walking them through how to do a proper pre-trip inspection all of that stuff is what it takes to get control of these scores and it's not fast either that if that's the way you're fixing the scores it is going to take time for the old violations to fall off your score or reduce in weight they reduce in weight as they become older and for you to incur no new violations to take their place that is the way you get control of your CSA scores and like I said it takes work takes time takes effort there is one other way and that's the data queue system um Rob we've blown through the time here already but let's spend a little time talking about data queue maybe give your one minute synopsis of data queue and how how that works to kind of improve your CSA scores well if you have a legitimate reason to argue a violation or the preventability of an accident whether it was preventable or not you want to make that argument then you can use the data queue system to argue basically appeal the violation and then it kind of has this hierarchy level where it's going to flow to the entity that gave you the violation to start with and then you can kind of flow it up the hierarchy from there to to argue your case but if it's a frivolous argument and you're really in violation it's not recommended to waste your time because I can tell you it's probably not going to go anywhere but if it is a legitimate argument that you have to kill the violation then you know they'll they'll agree with you they're pretty fair process sometimes um but you better be sure you've got some evidence to back up your case because you know what I've found to Rob's point you know even just aside from frivolous arguments what I found is that if it comes if it's going to be a violation that comes down to your driver's word versus the officer's word you're going to lose that battle 99 of the time so I usually like to only focus my attention on violations where I've got some type of evidence to back up my case whether it be in the form of like video you know camera evidence to show that the officer clearly got something wrong is a good example or you know other situations where you've got some documentary evidence to back up your case and where the the officer can't really dispute what it is that you're showing those are the ones you're going to have the best chance of success and getting those violations either removed from your score or in the case of like adjudicated citations if you've got a violation where your driver got the violation but also got a state citation a ticket for that same issue and then they go and litigate that ticket through their state court system if they can get the court to dismiss that violation or that citation or change it to a different violation altogether then there's an option in the data queue system called the adjudicated citation option where you can go in and provide the court documentation if the court dismissed it then then on the FMCSA side of things on the data queue side of things the state no longer has any discretion they have to remove that from your scores same thing kind of if the if the court changes the violation to something else than what was cited you'll see this pretty commonly for whatever reason courts or or state prosecutors are inclined to change violations to something entirely different than what they were cited for maybe the driver was cited for speeding and they end up with a parking ticket or something stupid like that if you can show if you can provide evidence in the data queue system that your driver was through the adjudicated citation was ultimately convicted of a different charge um then that will reduce the violation on your CSA score down to a severity weight of one we didn't even really talk about severity weights there's a scoring system that dictates how how heavily weighted each of these violations are I think there's like a thousand violations in the system uh and they all have their own severity weight and uh they're all published in the SMS methodology but that also dictates uh how weighty these violations are on your score we don't have time to talk about that today we've got another video uh another episode of trucksafe Live actually that we did a few months ago FMCSA is actually proposing some changes to how the scoring system works if you're interested in in more granular details of how SMS works and what those proposed changes are and how they may impact your CSA scores go back and watch our episode a few months ago where we spent a lot of time diving into SMS methodology and what might be changing um we are out of time Rob I the last we can't leave the show without at least mentioning what iss scores are what they mean I think we can dispose of that pretty quickly do you want to run through ISS real quickly say that we'll say that one more time I'm going to run through a couple minutes on ISS just what iss inspection selection system is and what it means yeah so so basically when it's kind of the best way to explain is when you're going through a weigh station they run your numbers and they you're given a score of one to a hundred and if you are priority you're probably going to get pulled over or you can fall in the mid-range you're going to get optional pullover or on the low range that you can get past basically so that's kind of how that is you're you're a priority for a roadside inspection or you're not it dictates how frequently your trucks or buses are going to get pulled over for roadside inspection on that scale of 1 to 100 and how do you get those scores they are dictated primarily by your CSA scores so carriers that have uh one of their basics in alert status with that orange triangle they're going to have a higher ISS score inspection selection system score than a carrier that doesn't have any basics in alert status for example and then the last thing I'll mention about ISS scores is that there's also what's called an insufficient data algorithm where motor carriers that don't have much inspection activity at all are going to have a higher ISS score than motor carriers that do the idea being that if you're a carrier that doesn't have much inspection data we want to get your trucks in more frequently so that we have more data in the system and the data is more reliable in terms of what it's saying about your Fleet so how do you improve ISS scores you improve ISS scores by improving your CSA scores so the same things that Rob and I just spent some time talking about all right so sorry for kind of rushing that there uh we had a lot to go through and we we got to a lot but there's a lot more that goes into it um so we're gonna wrap it up there Rob thanks again for joining me where can people find you if they want to if they have more questions for you or they want to get you to help out with their Fleet uh carpentercompliance.com and um you'll find all my contact information in there and if we can help you we'll help you if not we'll send you to Brandon all right thanks again Rob really appreciate you joining me uh thanks everybody for tuning in today um if you one thing that I should mention is that we have a very detailed webinar on this type of uh safety metrics specifically if you're interested that's available to all members of the truck safe compliance network if you join today like I said free to join if you go in there today you'll find one of our previous webinars where we spent like an hour and a half talking about all of this stuff so that's available to you also check out our uh online courses for safety managers and for drivers over at trucksafeacademy.com we have online courses where safety managers can can work through all of this type of DOT compliance stuff including safety metrics but also the nitty-gritty of driver qualification hours of service Etc check that though out if you're interested trucksafeacademy.com uh stay tuned to whatever we've got going on including uh announcements about future shows over on our social media Pages LinkedIn Facebook Twitter we're pretty active on all of those and then just stay tuned for our next uh truck safe live episode thank you for being here with us thanks again to the sponsor of this season of truck safe live which is log Rock uh we will see everyone later uh thanks for joining us thank you

Event Completed

Friday, July 14, 2023 at 6 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube