Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 26 - The state of broker liability

Tuesday, July 25, 2023 at 5:02 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 26 - The state of broker liability

About This Event

In this episode, we're joined by transportation attorneys Bryan Nelson and Sophia Bernard of the Taylor Johnson law firm to discuss the current legal landscape of broker liability. We'll break down the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals recent ruling that a negligent hiring claim against a freight broker is preempted by the FAAAA, and what exactly this means for brokers and carriers going forward.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 26 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by transportation attorneys Brian Nelson and Sophia Bernard of Taylor Johnson Law to discuss the evolving legal landscape surrounding broker and shipper liability in highway accident litigation. The topic is increasingly relevant as plaintiffs' attorneys continue to target freight brokers and shippers as deeper-pocketed defendants in trucking accident cases, making it critical for anyone operating in the transportation supply chain to understand their potential exposure. The conversation centers on three landmark cases that have shaped the current state of broker liability law. The Ninth Circuit's Miller v. CH Robinson decision held that state law negligent hiring claims against freight brokers are not preempted by the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (F4A), reasoning that the statute's safety exception applies because the claims relate to motor vehicles. The Eleventh Circuit's Landstar decision and, most recently, the Seventh Circuit's Global Trans decision took the opposite view, finding that F4A does preempt such state law claims and that the safety exception does not save them, since freight brokers do not directly operate motor vehicles. The guests note that the Seventh Circuit's opinion methodically dismantled the Ninth Circuit's reasoning, setting up a clear circuit split that could eventually compel Supreme Court review. The attorneys also distinguish between two separate theories of broker liability: negligent hiring or selection, which focuses on whether a broker adequately vetted a motor carrier before tendering freight, and vicarious liability, which arises when a broker exercises so much operational control over a carrier or driver that it effectively becomes the employer. While the recent preemption decisions offer meaningful protection against negligent hiring claims in most jurisdictions, vicarious liability remains a live risk regardless of where an accident occurs. The guests caution brokers against directly dispatching drivers, imposing punitive terms in rate confirmations, or otherwise meddling in a carrier's day-to-day operations, as these behaviors can blur the line between broker and motor carrier in the eyes of a court. For fleet safety professionals and brokers, the episode offers several practical takeaways. Brokers should maintain a consistent, documented carrier selection policy that at minimum verifies a carrier's active operating authority, insurance on file with the FMCSA, and the absence of an unsatisfactory safety rating. Third-party vetting platforms such as RMIS, MyCarrierPackets, CarrierSource, and Highway can streamline this process, though the attorneys stress that a direct check of the FMCSA's database remains essential. Brokers should also carry contingent auto or truck broker liability insurance not only to address potential judgments but to cover the legal costs of securing an early dismissal, which can be substantial even in cases where the broker ultimately prevails. Brian Nelson offered a particularly useful reframe for how brokers should think about their carrier vetting programs, stating that the goal is not safety regulation — that is the federal government's role — but rather customer service and risk management, ensuring reliable carriers are used to minimize cargo claims, delays, and operational disruptions. Both guests agreed that while the legal momentum is currently favorable for brokers outside the Ninth Circuit, the patchwork of jurisdictional outcomes means brokers cannot afford to be complacent. Maintaining clean contracts, consistent vetting practices, and appropriate insurance coverage remain the cornerstones of a sound broker liability risk management strategy.

Full Transcript

thank you thank you all right foreign thank you thank you thank you thank you this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign hey everyone welcome to episode 26 of truck safe live the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with trucksafe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs a great show in store today uh we were talking about broker liability so we've had a couple shows on a similar Topic in the past um uh most recent one would have been after the CH Robinson case or or the Supreme Court's decision to deny review of the CH Robinson case from the ninth circuit so that was uh I don't know several months ago but um breaking news kind of in that area of the law so I thought now would be a good time to talk about it and provide some updates on it so looking forward to that got a couple of great guests with us today to talk about it before we get there a few other things uh and if you're here with us say hey in the comments always like to see who's here watching with us and as we go along as always if you have any questions or comments or thoughts or anything like that throw them in the comments and we'll bring them up on screen a few things going on over at truck safe I mentioned this in our last couple of shows but wanted to make sure everybody hears about it our upcoming Fleet compliance boot camp coming up October 12th and 13th in Orlando Florida this is our two-day in-person immersive conference dedicated to dot safety in compliance we spend time with a small group of us around 50 or so safety managers safety directors owners of trucking companies uh third party administrators and we really dig in deep to the dot safety regulations and helping fleets to build out Cutting Edge safety programs so we did one of these earlier in Indy earlier this year got a lot of great feedback from it so we're going to do this other one in Orlando registration's been open for a few weeks and we're actually almost sold out so if you're interested in joining us for that again October 12th and 13th be be sure to register ASAP uh registration is open over at trucksafebootcamp.com we hope to see you there also if you are not a member of our truck safe compliance Network be sure to join that this is free to join over at trucksafenetwork.com we also have an app available on the App Store in the Google Play store which we're showing right here the network is the place for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also have access to all of our DOT compliance related content articles videos courses that type of stuff so check that out again it's free to join over at trucksafenetwork.com we actually have a webinar coming up free webinar where we're going to cover safety policies driver safety policies and how you can develop those to best minimize exposure so so be sure to register for the network and for that webinar it's going to be uh next Wednesday August 2nd at 2 pm eastern time so if you're interested check that out trucksafe network.com all right uh enough about us let's talk about some things that are going on in the industry uh just today kind of breaking news from the FMCSA saw this come out uh it's important to highlight FMCSA has revoked four additional electronic logging devices from the list of certified devices so if you are a motor carrier that is using one of these particular devices you're in trouble not by not your fault but uh manufacturers FMCSA has has determined that these devices are not compliant with the technical specifications for these types of devices so if you're using one of these for you have until September 23rd to replace them with a new solution until that time you have to stop using them immediately and you can have your driver switch over to paper logs until September 23rd at which point you have to have them replaced so that came out today so if that is your ELD provider make sure you do something about that quickly all right uh what else is going on in the industry uh not a whole lot within the last couple of weeks not a whole lot of new developments in terms of dot safety regulations but a couple things worth highlighting and we mentioned this last show but um Pipeline and hazardous material safety administration fimsa recently came out with an advance notice of proposed rulemaking where they are contemplating several revisions to the Hazmat rules these are pretty significant changes if they ultimately move forward with them we have a detailed write-up on these on our website over at trucksafe.com if you're interested in learning more things like do we need to remove the Hazmat training requirement for drivers and carriers that only haul limited quantities of class 9 products so bad you know lithium batteries stuff like that so that's just you know one of I think like 46 separate topics that they are contemplating addressing in a proposed rule but right now early stages were an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking so if you're interested in that check it out trucksafe.com our article on that topic also fairly recently Nitsa and the FMCSA have published a proposed a joint proposed rule that would mandate automatic emergency braking technology on new vehicles that's a proposed rule so that's the they're accepting comments on that proposal I can't remember when the comment period closes um but we have another article on that on our website where we provide all the details so if you're interested in that check it out but essentially that proposal as I understand it if it were to take effect as it is proposed would require the installation and the use of aeb Technology on new heavy trucks which the rule defines to mean any vehicle over ten thousand pounds which I don't necessarily consider that heavy of a truck but that's how they Define it um on a certain date and these will be for newly manufactured Vehicles after that date so they they set a one threshold for vehicles over 26 000 pounds and then another threshold for vehicles over ten thousand pounds for vehicles over twenty six thousand pounds the rule is proposing that this will go into effect within four years of publication of the final Rule and then for that other class of vehicles ten thousand pounds to twenty six thousand pounds it would take effect five years they would get an additional year uh before they would have to implement that there's no retrofitting requirement at least in the proposed rule as it stands now meaning that older trucks before those model years would not necessarily have to be retrofitted with those devices if they don't already have them so just uh be aware that that's coming down the bike very likely and if you have anything to say about that I think the comment period's still open so go go get your comments in uh all right so that's kind of all that's going on in the industry that I wanted to talk about today let's segue into today's topic again we're talking about broker liability and shipper liability uh you know we spend a lot of time over at truck safe talking about motor carriers and what they can and should do to keep themselves out of the crosshairs both in Highway accident litigation and from a DOT standpoint um but as we start to see more and more of these cases where shippers and Brokers are being pulled into Highway accident litigation the question is what do they need to do to minimize their exposure um you know more and more like I said these shippers and Brokers are being pulled into the lawsuits plaintiffs always in the search uh for the for the deeper Pockets so that's what we're discussing today broker and ship reliability what it entails what courts have to say about it and what shippers and Brokers can do to best protect them themselves I'm excited to be joined today by two Transportation attorneys who are at the front line of this battle Brian Nelson and Sophia Bernard partners with the Taylor Johnson law firm based out of Florida Welcome Brian and Sophia thanks for joining thanks for having us I really appreciate you being here um before we get started wanted to give folks uh who don't who may not know you uh time to to get to know you so maybe we'll start with Sophia if you just do give a quick introduction about yourself who you are how you got into the transportation field that would be helpful sure I'm Sophia in our transportation company um I work Ed South I served as general counsel I primarily manage the litigation and also work really closely with our safety director and just mitigating risk and um and learning and observing all things transportation and that's honestly you know where I got my passion for the industry and why I'm still here today practicing Transportation law um I then pivoted to you know working Private Practice because I just felt like you know you could be a little bit more like I hope you can touch a little bit more the industry and I felt you know best to serve with more clients in a practice and a private practice context so I spent a lot of time you know managing litigation for a global transportation company and then I joined Taylor Johnson I mean what is not to love about the firm I mean the firm is Shirley Trailblazer so it was surely a good fit and we are all industry and slightly so that's exciting excellent thanks so much for being here Sophia Brian I assume same question so um my path here started in law school actually so while I was in law school I got a bunch of buddies together figured hey let's get together let's have a softball team uh day comes around to collect the money all of a sudden everyone's like oh well you know we're gonna be super busy it's law school and I'm like you guys can't spare an hour of your time so I like The Sandlot man I walk with a bat and a glove down in the fields try to get picked up by a team uh this is probably a few weeks into the season so I'm just waiting to get picked up by a team talking to a team they go hey we we need somebody one of our guys just got thrown out of the league like banned from the league for throwing a bat at an Umpire and of course that was a trucking company uh I played with them all through law school um and then at the end they're like hey would you like to come in house and I said absolutely uh so it was in-house for about 12 years uh came out of house um which is my favorite phrase to say um so I am an outhouse attorney now and so we absolutely love Transportation it's all I've ever known uh it's something that people don't understand uh not only just our colleagues as you know you you have attorney friends right they don't understand Transportation it doesn't fit the mold of everything that we deal with we don't have three cases that we get to rely upon although we'll talk about three cases today uh we don't have those three cases where the factor a you argued this facts or B you argue this facts or C every day is different and we know people we know drivers we know Trucking Company owners we know safety people we know Brokers we know every warehouseman that deal with something new and unique every single day and there's not like a case that we can point to there's a lot that this law is hard just like what um our clients go through every day um only we're a little bit as you know a little bit safer we're not necessarily on the road so uh God bless everyone that that's driving a truck today yeah well thanks so much for joining us Brian really appreciate it that's a great story I wasn't really sure where the softball uh was gonna lead [Laughter] how to throw the you want to throw the company under the bus or the guy that threw the bat at the uh the Umpire probably not yeah he did not work for the company he was some one of their one of the one of the friends everybody that was in the company was very very good man they would never throw bats at umpires no not not in Beer League absolutely not all right well today we're here to talk about broker liability broker and ship reliability um and as I mentioned at the start they've been in the crosshairs for a few years now several years now uh and my first question to you both is how are they typically implicated in Highway accident litigation obviously makes sense when a motor carrier's driver causes an accident that the motor carrier is going to be implicated in that lawsuit but it's it's kind of more of a tenuous thing when you start to involve the next the next level up which are the Brokers and then the shippers so how how is it that plaintiffs end up dragging in Brokers and shippers I'll let whoever wants to take it take it I'll say you know primarily negligent hiring um negative selection that's usually what I see you know the plaintiffs we usually try to employ they try to establish some sort of you know Duty on Brokers to truly vet even the drivers not just the motor carrier but the actual driver too so that's really how I've seen it have you seen it in any different contexts Brian well so to really identify that the question here the difference between the shipper and the broker is usually what the courts view as someone who's skilled and experienced and what your job is is selecting and hiring carriers whereas a shipper is is a manufacturer and or you know distributor of goods so a lot of times where ship reliability comes in isn't necessarily on who they select because that that's very very rare for a negligence election negligent hiring situation to arise against the shipper a lot of times with a ship reliability comes in is possibly on cargo but also shifting of cargo on Whose responsibility it is to load the goods now carriers generally have a duty to make certain that the goods that they're transporting are secured and safe but we all know that there's so many times we're like yeah you're not allowed on the dock sorry you can't come here you know no we got this you can't touch this don't even I don't even want to see you near you know the loading equipment because they're concerned about you getting injured from a forklift not necessarily you getting injured because the cargo falls off now in terms of the broker uh the negligent hiring and then potentially the vicarious liability going back all the way to Schram V Foster uh those are really um the the two methods because vicarious liability saying you had too much control whereas the negligent hiring selection saying you didn't knew enough and let me tell you if a plaintiff attorney has it you never did enough there's not there's nothing you can do where you ever did enough so you mentioned shrimp oh go ahead Sophia even with shippers so you know you get to you go pick up the load and you get access you know to be on the property with via a ID card or some sort of you know way to get on there and I've seen plaintiffs make arguments that you know the shippers should have done something more than just giving the the driver and ID to get on the premise and because they did not do anything more now they have liability for that driver being involved yeah so Brian you mentioned um tram V Foster which folks listening in may may or may not be familiar with but for many years that was kind of the The Watershed case on broker liability at least in my estimation it was we were always kind of asking what Duty do freight brokers have in terms of their vetting of motor carriers and that was kind of the case we always look to as setting the standard of care kind of and so I wonder if you could either one of you kind of run through real quickly because that leads us in nicely into the cases the three cases that we're going to talk about today but maybe we start back with SRAM and what has kind of been the law of the land up until these recent three cases sure I can kind of jump into that so a lot of the work that we do with our broker clients are carrier selection policies right those items that you can put together to say Hey listen this is what our hiring requirements are this is what we're going to do we can't do a lot of things that our shippers tell us to do so when you're facing chip or contract you need to make sure that you can actually do what you're agreeing that you can do and so when you go through shramby Foster there's a general negligence Theory and and cases throughout are sprinkled throughout the jurisdictions not only with cargo liability but Auto liability and we'll talk about the three cases but just a general duty to make sure that you are not providing or hiring a carrier that has you know that is unsafe now our argument the entire time to this industry is saying that they have a license the Federal Motor Carrier safety administration said hey they're good to go so now we as Brokers have to put people out of business and so that was kind of the argument throughout this whole process you Federal Motor Carrier safety administration that they could operate we're just letting them operate if you're saying someone can work but then nobody should hire them tell them tell me they can't be hired then don't go through this process in addition they had a vicarious liability portion of that meaning that they exerted some level of control whether it be through financial means whether through actual business opportunities or through just general instructions directions that they viewed as mandatory they went and overstepped their bounds and the court said hey that's too far you're acting like a motor carrier we're going to hold you liable because you did things Beyond just arranging transportation and we're going to hold you liable so for folks not familiar with vicarious liability we do this all the time in this country uh with employers so if you are an employer and one of your employees uh hurts somebody else and they do so within the course and scope of their their work for you then even though that wasn't you the company that caused that person to get hurt you are going to be vicariously liable for the actions of your employees as if they were your own so I think that's an important point one that folks may not pull out of these recent cases that there is still the potential at least for my view of of there being vicarious liability um where a broker could still get themselves in trouble if they start to exercise so much control over the motor carriers operations and the operations of the driver such that they essentially become the employer of that driver and then when that driver hurts or kills somebody then the broker is is Hell liable under that theory but that's the state think from the other theory that Brian and Sophia mentioned which is the the negligent hiring negligent selection type Theory which is based more on the broker's own actions did was it independently negligent in in how it selected these motor carriers or or its omissions in in that uh in that selection of the motor carriers so that kind of brings us then to those to the to the three recent cases that I want to talk about the first of those three that came down was the ninth circuits uh CH Robinson Miller VCH Robinson case so I was wondering maybe if if you two could kind of quickly run through that case and where that got us and and what the Court ruled in that case all right because Brian has an interesting story for this one since it came on his desk while he was General Counsel yeah so so this this one's fun because um it came through kind of the same ranks you know personal injury um you know fatality accident situation where a motor carrier was hired you know we broker could have always done more you know what did you check what did you look at they had author they they could operate but hey they had some safety issues that you should have seen under the basic scores right uh which anyone who's reviewed or reinstalled or a reapply for insurance knows that your insurance company is asking do you look at basic scores which we constantly say you know and the the lawsuit that got the the contingent language on there saying Hey listen don't look at this for safety this is for internal guidance only so anyways the the court goes through and says Hey listen broker under the federal um under the Federal Aviation authorization um administrator sorry Federal Aviation Administration authorization act uh known as f4a or as the most recent case that fquad a you may not in the the states regarding negligent hiring negligent selection States may not and I'll read this uh verbatim may not enact or enforce a law regulation or other provision having forced an effect of law relating to price route or service of any Motor Carrier or any Motor Carrier private carrier broker meaning that the federal government said hey States you cannot go out and make rules and make laws that impose liability on Brokers if the law potentially could impact having a force on or have force and effect of price route and service well obviously any broker that's doing brokering provides a service of arranging transportation and obviously if there is something that says hey you're going to be liable it affects because we know it affects because we draft carrier selection policies all the time it affects price route or service so from there they say federal state laws you cannot enact these laws and therefore a broker cannot be liable however the court went on to say well there is this exception within F quad a or f4a it's called the safety exception and it said that these rules that the federal government will not preamp mean take effect over any state laws will not preempt in the event a state tries to restrict regular safety regulatory Authority with respect to Motor Vehicles and it goes on and says other things but the respect to Motor Vehicles is really the key here because they talk about and say the court in the Miller VCH Robinson case said well yeah this applies to Motor Vehicles this is this yeah this I think this affects and let me let me say it specifically respect to Motor Vehicles this is respect to Motor Vehicles they didn't really give much detail the fact that most laws state carrier and broker separately this went on and did not mention brokers in terms of this exception the court in Miller completely ignored it uh didn't care what what it had to say and kind of just took a lazy approach and said oh well we're talking about trucks here so sure it applies um and so it really put a bad precedent and we thought for certain that when it went to the Supreme Court uh that the Supreme Court would hear it because it Anyone who reads this can clearly understand and see that that it was bad law that the Supreme Court didn't pick it up but I mean I'm sure they you know they ended it with with plenty of law but what was interesting about that case to me was the interpretation of that you know the motor vehicle um reading the under the safety exception and that it just sort of ignored the entire Transportation process and just focus on as Brian mentioned that there's a motivator there's a motor broker there's a motor carrier and it's transportation and all-involved trucks so it must be related to you know a motor vehicle when that is actually not the definition of a motor broker at all sounds like something California would do so I want to break that down a little bit everybody in the state of California in order to be in order to be hurt by carb compliance but then obviously Brokers anywhere can be yeah that's California never ceases to amaze me but anyway that case came out of California well came out of ninth Circuit Court of Appeals which is the federal circuit court of appeals that covers the West Coast including California uh I want to kind of break that down a little bit because you know us three talking about it obviously kind of following what's what's going on here but folks who are just kind of getting into this probably have no idea what we're talking about and I want to kind of break down f4a a little bit and and what it what it is and what it's trying to accomplish so does anybody want to take on that tall task sure so so F4 I came out and we have these Patchwork rules of liability Patchwork um um laws dealing with what the responsibilities of carriers and Brokers are across the country meaning that if you operated a business in Florida you would essentially be subject to different laws if you operated that same business even though it's dealing with Interstate transport in a different business now when you sit here and say well that doesn't make sense the federal government agreed with you and passed what's called like f quad a as I said before and essentially try to rein in some of these things dealing with various types of liability that ebb and flow depending on which state so if you're on a route from one state to another you may as a broker literally be sitting there going praying hey get in an accident in this state versus this state because I'll have better you know luck in this state than in this state now we still obviously have that based on jury selection and other things that can impact um you know judgments and liability verdicts but you had you had a federal government that recognized this and implemented this coming most heavily on motor carriers and including Brokers on a number of provisions and is specifically excluding them on a number of others and going back to the Miller case the Miller case ignored the fact that they excluded broker from certain language and just said oh well they must have just meant to include them as well yeah so at least from my perspective I think that's exactly right so F quad a as the court actually the court refused to call it that in the seventh circuit case they wanted to just call it the ACT but most people know it as F quad a or f4a but it's essentially a federal law and and our system our system of jurisprudence in this country we recognize that federal law is the supreme law of the land so if there is a uh if there is a conflict between federal law and state law on a particular topic then then federal law is going to win the day and so f4a is as Brian said a federal law coming out of kind of deregulation of the transportation industry so prior to the 90s 80s and 90s Transportation was very heavily regulated at the federal level in terms of setting rates and routes and you had to get approval from the government to serve a particular uh areas of the country and so you know Congress saw fit to deregulate transportation in that respect back in the early 90s and as part of that deregulatory scheme what they didn't want happen happening was for states to then jump in and and create this Patchwork as Brian mentioned Patchwork of state laws where if I'm operating in Indiana I'm subject to one set of rules but then I pass over into Illinois now I'm subject to a whole bunch of different rules that we didn't want that potential for conflict so Congress stepped in passed f4a and at least for Trans for for Highway Transportation said that states cannot enact any or enforce any laws related to the routes rates or Services of motor carriers and then they go on to say Brokers or shippers so it's an attempt by Congress to prevent that Patchwork of state laws on on particular issues but they like Brian said carved out particular areas where states can continue to regulate one of which is the safety of the operation of Motor Vehicles this is why we still have state laws on um you know speeding and the states still have the authority to impose their own safety related laws and that's really what all of these cases come down to is number one are these state law negligence claims against Brokers uh do they fall within the preemptive scope of f4a and even if they do are they then carved out under one of those f4a exemptions namely the safety related exception did I get that about right now the safety exception is the one source of disagreement right I mean the CH Robinson case Landstar and glow trans they all agree that you know that that motor Brokers fall within the FAA but they disagree the disagreement between the knife circuit and everyone else is they say the exception yeah that's that that is the that is the conflict between the circuits is the applicability of that safety exception and whether it saves uh the the cases that are otherwise preempted by f4a namely these these negligent hiring type cases uh okay so that's CH Robinson uh that's the ninth circuit case ninth circuit says we don't think preemption applies here plaintiff you're allowed to pursue your case your negligent hiring case against a property broker Supreme Court refuses to hear that as they are as they often do Supreme Court takes very few cases every year uh CH Robinson petitioned the court to hear that case Court declines to hear it which leaves intact the ninth circuits case at least or the ninth circuit's decision on that issue and so that has been the law of the land at least for courts within the ninth circuit so everybody on the west coast is playing by that rule set then we then comes along the 11th circuits case and I think you all were involved in this case if I'm not mistaken is that right yeah that is correct we uh we represented Landstar in this case which was actually what's unique about this case as opposed to the other two cases is that this is a cargo claim case where the where the judge went out of its way to say Hey listen it doesn't matter whether this was a cargo claim case or a personal injury case the the F quad a safety exception doesn't apply anyways and I thought it was really interesting and if I were to analogize it to hear is that if you spilled water or you walked into a supermarket and there's water dripping on the floor and they didn't do anything about it it doesn't matter if you slip and fell and injured yourself or you slipped and threw your cell phone and the cell phone broke because it hit the ground the negligence part failing to clean up the water or provide some sort of um you know alert or warning of it is the same and so the court in the 11th circuit did a fantastic job of saying listen the safety exception it doesn't matter because you have a duty to to not be negligent and under the under the regulation if it's accepted it's Exempted regardless of what the ultimate outcome is so whether it's personal injury or property damage if it's if it's covered under foa and it's preempted then it has no bearing on what the outcome of that of that action is and so that case and I know because I know the attorney that that argued the global trans case I spoke with him almost the day that our case was released and he's like yeah I'm gonna I'm gonna update this because this is absolutely what we need um in this industry and so when you look at what our case went through was just a systematic understanding it didn't have to it could have just ruled on cargo because cargo had everyone agrees cargo is not not covered by the state the exemption because we're not talking about personal injuries so nobody can say oh well safety in terms of cargo and what they did was a great job in terms of the broker applying or not applying the courts have gone on or regulations they know the difference between a broker and a carrier they know because they defined it in the regulations and they went on to say Hey you know even in the as far removed when we talk about food safety uh the food safety regulations they even made a point to say hey within the definition of shipper we're going to include broker because they know the difference between a broker and a carrier and they've made a point to say something not to mention you look at um regulations regarding 18 months to collect Freight payables well it only lists carrier it doesn't list broker the same kind of argument here they picked and chewed and chose which rules to apply Brokers to and our case came out and identified that and said what are we doing this doesn't apply and it doesn't matter whether it's personal injury or property damage it's preempted by F quad a and the safety exception has no bearing because we're not dealing with Motor Vehicles the broker does not deal with motor vehicles you deal with Motor Vehicles every day right you're talking Motor Vehicles you're talking safety you're you're dealing with this every single day you I would argue yes you deal with you deal with motor vehicles or broker clients they do not Sophie did you have anything to add on that case or no um no I just I you know I thought it was just really helpful that the court made that distinction because there has been you know a bunch of case law before this this uh this is 11 circuit case that Drew the distinction between cargo and personal injury that gave plaintiff's attorneys an Avenue to continue going after Brokers under the negligent hiring Theory because there was a distinct a Distinction on personal injury was involved actually was involved in a case that was cited in this case um where we actually lost because of that distinction of personal injury versus cargo and so I think the court in making this ruling and then the seventh circuit and following that same ruling it's loud and clear that it doesn't matter whether it's personal injury or cargo it Brokers do not fall under the safety exception because they don't relate to the motor motor vehicle safety okay and if I could if I could interject real quick that case just so we're clear we all we know well the three of us know Brokers are not liable for cargo loss or damage unless they hold themselves out as a carrier or they agree to be liable for cargo loss or damage through her contract so just because we're saying Hey listen you're preempted you can waive that preemption essentially say Hey listen I'm going to be liable for cargo loss or damage so that option is always there so just be clear when you're reading your contracts this case this 11th circuit case does not help you if you contractually agreed to be liable for cargo loss or damage it's only in the cases where you are not identifying as a carrier meaning you're signing the right contracts and you are I not agreeing to any type of liability for cargo loss or damage from the carriers that you hire so even though if I'm if I'm understanding correctly so even though the 11th circuit case the Landstar case is not about a highway accident it essentially sets the stage for this split between the circuits you got the ninth circuit on the one hand saying that f4a preemption does not apply in a highway accident case because that claim against the broker in that case is saved by the so-called safety exception now you've got the 11th circuit taking issue with uh with the Court's rationale in that case in in terms of whether the applicability of the safety exception so that kind of sets the stage where you've got two circuit courts of appeals now slightly disagreeing with one another in slightly different context and then Along Comes the seventh circuit case which is the decision that just came out this is the global trans case this is the one that came out uh within the last week or so and this is kind of the one that takes on the CH Robinson case directly it's it's another Highway Act accident case so let's break that one down who wants to talk about that case what's it about what are the facts of that case before it so before it would be fun just I I thought that this be set of fact and the seventh circuit is very important to the industry because if all we had was the 11th circuit um even though the court did say that there is really no distinction between personal injury and cargo because those facts fell specifically with cargo it still gave an Avenue for plant this with attorneys to make arguments and to bring brokers in to try to attack negligence but because this Global trans case dealt with personal injury and not only personal injury dealt with the fatality I think that you know that message is very clear so just to go into the facts just just briefly this this case I believe evolves um a you know the the plaintiff the estate the husband was riding a motorcycle and you know impacted the truck by I believe it was Global shine not Global trans the momentary was Global shine and a fatality you know resulted from the accident um and of course they'd like to say that Global trans should have you know taken more here and apply a higher duty to Global trans and selecting its motor carriers I think they had mentioned maybe that the the carrier in that case had had some hours of service problems in the past and so if we were relying on you know the SRAM case from years ago we would be inclined to think that the broker in this case Global trans did have a duty a legal duty to vet that motor carrier the level of vetting is kind of up in the air in terms of you know what courts you could always do more is what they might always do always do more at minimum there would never be enough vetting by a million broker of the motor carriers if that is the standard yeah because you know I think if you re-tran for what it is I always took the position that it essentially requires Brokers to do to look at three things number one is the motor carrier properly registered with the dot does it have a valid DOT number number two does it have the right Insurance on file with the dot and number three does is it subject to an unsatisfactory safety rating and that and I always read tram to to say that's the extent of the broker's Duty and that's a fairly easy duty to discharge in my opinion you could you could discharge that Duty in 10 seconds of review on the fmcsa's website for Motor Carrier so I was never concerned with that but there are certainly other courts in the country that say that's not enough you got to do something more and so we were starting to get this Patchwork of state laws or state judicial decisions kind of uh disagreeing on what level uh or to what extent Brokers must go in their vetting of the motor carriers and in this case I think my point was you know the the plaintiff's argument in the global trans case was that that the carrier that caused the accident whose driver caused the accident it had some hours of service violations which had the motor carrier or had the broker done its due diligence when looking at this motor care they would have been they should have been easily uh easy to write off the list because of these problems they should have the broker should have uh just disqualified them based on the level of violations that they saw and that was kind of the plaintiff's argument and they say because they didn't do that they were negligent in hiring this broker and that negligence then caused the death of the of the plaintiff's husband so what's the court have to say about that well the the interesting part is they go through the same analysis as the 11th circuit and the ninth circuit regarding hey is this preempted by fquade resoundingly yes it is it is preempted meaning that the state law claims uh of negligence cannot move forward unless it meets one of the exceptions this court went on to say the exception does not apply therefore preemption remains and you can't bring a state law negligence claim negligent hiring negligent selection against a broker now what's interesting here is that the last um I don't know the last eight paragraphs six paragraphs step-by-step dismantle everything the 11 circuits had they said Hey listen um this is way too remote um with respect to Motor Vehicles it has it's not even there there it you put a presumption of drafting that courts have routinely said you don't do that you need to this is the nine the other way right right yeah so this is this is this is a seventh circuit talking about the ninth circuit okay so the ninth circuit put a presumption in terms of reading broker into the language when the seven circuit says the courts in past jurisprudence have said repeatedly do not read that presumption if the legislator specifically mentioned two things throughout and then all of a sudden that one thing's missing don't assume that they intended to include that continuously and it was just wonderful wonderful writing just to really identify this because this not only helps with this case but it almost I don't know if you remember the movie uh what is it Eight Mile with Eminem right where he wraps he wraps preemptively about what the other guy is going to say about him and they essentially do that here so this is this is the Eight Mile argument where they essentially said well I know you're going to argue this but you're wrong I know you're going to argue this you're wrong and I know you're going to argue this and you're still wrong and I feel like any court that tries to use the Miller case that's not in the 11s because right now everyone in the 11th circuit that is still your law until this gets to the Supreme Court but this really sets that up but this is essentially saying hey everybody else if you try to use the 11th circuit just know that we've already went through it and they're wrong and I appreciate how they specifically call out the economic effect that you know applying this higher Duty on Brokers could have on the industry as a whole because that's been our arguments as Transportation attorneys I mean for years yeah so um so that sets up an even more divided circuit split right so now we've got two circuits we've got the ninth circuit on the west coast we got seventh circuit which is Midwest so Wisconsin Illinois Indiana I think is is within the seventh circuit you got seventh circuit directly disagreeing with the ninth circuit and that is fodder for a supreme court uh uh the Supreme Court to take up a case right so uh folks may may or may not know the Supreme Court like I said early on takes up very few cases per year in its certiorary process essentially you don't get an automatic appeal except in very limited circumstances to the Supreme Court you have to petition to them and they take up whatever cases they think are going to have the biggest impact across the country one of the ways that you prove that it's going to have a big impact is when you've got circuits around the country disagreeing with one another that's what we've got here we've got a clear circuit split between the ninth circuit and the seventh circuit and the 11th circuit to some extent where those circuits are now saying the completely opposite things given essentially uh substantially similar facts and so maybe we we see this ultimately end up at the Supreme Court uh what are your thoughts on that uh until the overwhelming majority of the other jurisdiction now this is not a unique situation there's probably people listening right now that their brokerage is being sued for these exact things in jurisdictions that we haven't talked about so this argument will certainly come up if not today tomorrow or the next day so I will see unless those jurisdictions don't continuously rule in favor of the 7th and the 11th which I I don't know how you can't now we've all been surprised before so I won't I won't put that out there that there's a guarantee but I would argue that if as more case as more jurisdictions start falling in line and following the the logic and the the rationale here that we will be in a situation where the Supreme Court is not may or may not take it because you have everybody except for one Rogue jurisdiction saying that this applies now if there's another one that comes up and increase with the 11th then yes I think so but if the dominoes start falling in One Direction then they'll just say oh that'll course correct eventually and they may not take it because if there's a seven to one they're not they're not going to attack it well maybe they will maybe they will attack a one circuit to try to correct them but usually it's where there's multiple circuits fighting and if there's nothing else on appeal that gets up to there then yeah I would I would imagine they'll take it but if like I said if it's if it's ten to one or eight to one when they look at this I would imagine they might not view it as a true contact yeah I I mean I agree with that I think if if we get another if someone else agrees with the ninth circuit positively but as it stands it's the majority right now so I I don't think that this much incentive for it to be taken up by the Supreme Court but we've all been surprised and crazy have happened so yeah yeah so just wait and see I guess but in the meantime what does what do these cases mean for the status of broker liability in this country is there some advice you can give to Brokers out there uh is this something they no longer need to worry about or how should they be viewing this I think they should definitely still be cautious um but I do think that it it sort of provides some hope and some light that you know that course are going to continue to do the right things as long as Brokers are doing the right things and that is acting within their scope so as long as Brokers are not you know overstepping and creating or adding additional duties on themselves I think that you know that they're fine I would say listen you can't control what jurisdiction um you get tuned in because you don't know where the accident's going to occur unless you just don't do business in the 11th circuit which I'd have a number of broker clients that won't go into California simply because of of carb uh but you have situations where you cannot control where an accident happens like I said before and maybe I've said it incorrectly nobody's praying for an accident so let me let me be clear if an accident were to occur you're obviously hoping for a friendlier jurisdiction but really what it what it is is that you will always be brought in the hope is that eventually you will get dismissed early you want to make sure you have contingent Auto coverage or truck broker liability policies if not for purposes of a judgment but to pay the legal fees legal fees can be expensive and if a judge because a lot of times when we go to court we're educating the judge on Transportation like I said at the beginning transportation is not easy it's not easy law and so when we go in we have to educate judges and advise them Hey listen here's what we're why this is important why we're not liable and we go through that process that's still a cost that you don't want to incur so having the insurance policy still makes sense and have a carrier selection policy and I say this all the time to my to my broker client you are not responsible for the safety of the carriers when you create a carrier selection policy this is not a safety the federal government does that this is a service requirement to make sure that you maintain Services because you don't want breakdowns and delays because that goes against your kpis and your contract and all your 98 99 on Time Performance you want to maintain it reduces cargo claims you also can't reduce severity you don't get to pick your plaintiff but what you can do is you can reduce frequency by making sure that you utilize the tools that are out there the information that's there it's not safety it is truly just customer service and making sure that you reduce claims from a cargo standpoint and business operation standpoint what are some of the things you recommend go into that type of carrier selection policy protocol uh well some of the things that I have some clients that love the basic scores right so you have your systems like rmis my carrier packets that kind of can go detailed by detail system you know and some of my clients feel really good about that and I help them develop to make sure that they have consistent policies whatever you do whether it's just I'm looking at these three things you know Insurance Authority and um and Licensing and not you don't have an unsatisfactory safety rating as long as you have those three things you have to be consistent whatever it is all the way to I'm going to nitpick this because a place this attorney is always going to say you can do more and you want to say listen whatever it is I was consistent you don't want to keep having exceptions here and there but there are programs that that are simplify the process like carrier sure you have other process programs like careful one you have Highway you have these other programs out there that help you identify those and again it's not for safety you're just identifying for customer service and the ability to avoid breakdowns and delays in arranging for the transportation of your clients Goods and just risk management yeah exactly um you know and even if you don't subscribe to one of those services that Brian mentioned as I said earlier it's very easy to do this on your own the benefit you get out of the services is that they are some of them at least are continuously watching your carrier pool and alerting you to any changes in their status but if you don't need that if you're just at a point where hey we need to do our initial vetting of the carrier make sure that they got the right registration make sure that they got the you know not they're not subject to an unsatisfactory safety rating you can do that we've got content on this on our Channel where you could do it like I said very quickly just by looking up the carrier's data online in all the cases just to say all the cases that reference a third a broker using some sort of third-party site it's still a requirement that you check the FMCSA so none of these are replacements because there is still a delay there is still potentially lag now some of these offer better Services than others but they still is a requirement that you go out and look at the FMCSA because that's the most up-to-date true data that's out there yeah the other thing I would say and this kind of gets to a point we made early on which is this distinction between direct negligence and vicarious liability my advice to all of our broker clients is be careful how much you meddle in your motor carriers business you know I get concerned when I see Brokers that are directly dispatching drivers and communicating directly with drivers and the more control you exercise over that motor carriers operations the more likely it is the bigger Target you have on your head for a vicarious liability claim where it could be alleged that you are so controlling of that operation that you become the motor carrier in essence you become the employer of that driver and then when that driver kills or hurts somebody then you are vicariously liable notwithstanding these preemption decisions we're talking about so I just caution you to be careful when it comes to meddling in your motor carriers business and a lot of times what I see is that people do it unknowingly right that they don't realize I they send me a contract to review and I'm like great okay we've got your form contract let's let's put that make sure it aligns with the cargo your tran you're arranging well let me see your rate confirmation what do you mean why one do you have terms on your rate confirmation well yeah well now we have penalty Provisions we're inserting fines we're telling them they have to call us these amount of times or they're fine you know they'll never do business all these things not to mention you get into you know your your driver coercion rules so so you're it's a constant look at all of your documents look at all of your agreements and stuff that we do on a daily basis and it is amazing because they'll have terms that someone drafted eight years ago that they haven't looked at because some operations guy went and got pissed off at a carrier and said I don't care I'm going to go ahead and write this and and there's 30 exclamation points all written in in capitalized capitalized letters and you go why did you do that that looks like control to me and you have to kind of walk that back yep you mentioned coercion kind of an interesting aside here I was reading through the seventh circuits decision and uh they spent some time in their opinion talking about how the FMCSA hasn't exercised its regulatory authority over Brokers and that coercion came directly to mind the court seemed to have missed that I don't know if it was pointed out to them in the briefs but the FMCSA does occasionally take direct regulatory action against Brokers or shippers when it has been alleged to the FMCSA that those Brokers or shippers have coerced drivers into violating usually the hours of service rules so I thought that was an interesting Miss by the court in their in their opinion but I would agree I would agree uh all right guys we are out of time that was a very quick discussion uh went by very quickly I really appreciate your Insight on this um uh great job breaking it all down for folks so that they can understand what it means for their fleets if folks have uh if they want to learn more about what you guys have got going on or get in contact with you how can they do it Sophia um they can I mean my email is you know esplanard taylorlawpl.com and Brian B Nelson Bryant B for Brian B Nelson Taylor lawpl.com you can go to our website taylorlawpl.com to a bunch of our articles uh obviously they're not as polished as yours yours are fantastic um I I and and your logo like I said before is absolutely wonderful so if you can buy merch from somebody buy merch from this guy uh are you even selling merchandise do you even sell them oh yeah oh yeah yeah why wouldn't I yeah yeah I've got some I've got some hats coming your way all right yeah all right thanks thanks again guys really appreciate you joining me we're gonna wrap it up there uh thanks everybody for joining us today really appreciate it um follow us make sure you're following us on our social media channels uh LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Youtube We were pretty active there uh we are constantly posting detailed analysis of these types of issues and also uh breaking industry news also be sure to subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com subscribe for the latest uh breaking news and Analysis like I said stay tuned for our next episode of truck safe live you can find details about all of our shows and watch past episodes over at trucksafelive.com uh last thing I'll mention are our online courses if uh if you are a fleet and you have safety managers or safety directors or dispatchers or Ops folks that you want to bring up to speed on dot safety and compliance we've got the courses for you we have built our DOT compliance for safety manager of course that is our Flagship course it's an online course you could take at your leisure attracts your progress includes all kinds of downloads you could take with you includes quizzes it has a completion certificate all of those courses we've also got a reasonable suspicion course a Hazmat course all available over at trucksafeacademy.com so check those out check those out if you're interested lastly just want to say thanks to our sponsor of this season of trucksafe live log rock thanks for all you've done to help make this possible really appreciate it that's going to wrap things up thanks everybody for watching we will catch you next time

Event Completed

Tuesday, July 25, 2023 at 5:02 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube