We’re joined by transportation attorney Doug Grawe of the Grawe Group to discuss the FMCSA’s recent notice of its intent to accept waiver requests from its 2018 and 2020 determinations that CA’s and WA’s meal and rest break rules are preempted. We’ll discuss the details and what such waivers might mean for fleets with operations in those states.
Watch the Recording
Episode Summary
In Episode 27 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman and guest Doug Grawe, transportation attorney and CEO of the Grawe Group law firm, discuss a surprising development in trucking compliance: the FMCSA's August 2023 notice inviting public waiver requests from its 2018 and 2020 decisions that had determined California's and Washington's meal and rest break laws were preempted by federal hours of service regulations. The hosts explain why this matters to fleets with operations in those states and why it could signal a broader rollback of federal preemption protections that the industry has relied on for years.
The conversation covers the history of this issue in detail, tracing it from the FMCSA's initial 2008 ruling that California's rules were not preempted, through the 2018 and 2020 petitions filed by the American Trucking Association and other trade groups that successfully reversed that position. Wiseman and Grawe explain the three-factor legal test under 49 USC 31141 that the FMCSA used to determine preemption, noting that in both the California and Washington decisions, the agency found all three factors satisfied. They also break down the specific requirements of California's and Washington's meal and rest break laws, including mandatory 30-minute meal breaks, additional 10-minute rest breaks for every four hours worked, and strict employer liability for ensuring those breaks are actually taken — burdens that are far more demanding than the current federal 30-minute rest break requirement tied to drive time.
A central theme throughout the episode is the real-world operational impact on carriers and drivers. Grawe and Wiseman highlight that the truck parking shortage makes compliance with state-mandated timed breaks extremely difficult, as drivers may spend an hour or more simply locating a legal parking spot before a break can even begin. They also discuss the compliance complexity for interstate carriers operating across multiple states and the risk that other states could follow California and Washington's lead if federal preemption is weakened. Both hosts express the view that the FMCSA's decision to actively solicit waiver requests — rather than wait for petitions to arrive — is highly unusual and strongly suggests the agency intends to grant them.
For fleet safety professionals, the key takeaway is to act now. Wiseman urges carriers operating in California and Washington to submit detailed, data-driven public comments if and when the FMCSA opens a comment period on these waiver requests. He notes that while trade associations like the ATA will likely submit formal legal arguments, individual carrier experiences, real operational data, and documented examples of the truck parking crisis can carry significant weight — both with the agency and in any subsequent litigation. Grawe reinforces this point, noting that public comments have been cited in court cases challenging agency decisions and should not be dismissed as futile.
Grawe sums up the broader frustration concisely: "The FMCSA should be focused on safety regulations, not doing the US Department of Labor's work." Both hosts agree that the preemption decisions were well-reasoned and well-supported by data, and they encourage the industry to continue engaging aggressively on this issue. Fleet professionals are advised to monitor developments closely, subscribe to the Trucksafe newsletter for updates, and consult legal counsel to begin assessing how their operations in California and Washington might need to be adjusted if the waivers are ultimately granted.
Full Transcript
foreign
foreign
thank you
thank you
thank you thank you
thank you
this season of truck safe live is presented by logrock log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than active setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com foreign
hey everyone welcome to episode 27 of truck safe live the show where we in our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with trucksafe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs Today's Show we are talking about meal and rest breaks the topic I thought we were done with in this industry to be honest with you but we are being dragged back into it for reasons that uh elude me I'm not sure what we're doing here but uh here we are so it was uh breaking news earlier this week and uh worth talking about for sure particularly if uh you're a fleet that has drivers in operations in California and or Washington State so that's what we're going to talk about today before we get there a few things going on always uh always something going on over at trucksafe uh first up I'll mention our upcoming Fleet compliance boot camp this is going to take place in Orlando Florida October 12th and 13th two-day conference in-depth DOT compliance information um conversations networking with fellow safety professionals uh that's what we got going on we did one of these earlier in Indianapolis uh went very well got a lot of great feedback from it so we're gonna do this again in Orlando and then we're going to try and do it twice a year uh every year thereafter so if you're interested in joining us we've got just like one or two spots left open uh we're already pretty much full but uh if you're interested in joining us hope to see you there you can check out the details over at trucksafebootcamp.com
um aside from our boot camp also wanted to mention our truck safe Fleet compliance Network this is something we've always kind of got going on in the background here but this is our online social network for safety professionals it's free to join if you haven't already joined us over there be sure to do so at trucksafenetwork.com we also have an app available that's what we're showing here in the App Store in the Google Play Store it's a space for safety professionals to gather together ask questions learn from one another and also gain access to all of our DOT related content our videos our articles uh Network exclusive webinars we just did one of those a couple weeks ago we try and do them periodically on uh particular areas of compliance our last one we did was on uh building out defensible drivers safety policies so anyway check that out over at trucksafenetwork.com we hope to see you there um lastly about truck safe I'll just mention our newsletter uh if you're interested in receiving um breaking industry news or our analysis on various issues including things like what we're talking about today fmcsa's notice on meal and rest breaks uh check out our newsletter trucksafe.com subscribe and uh and we'll send that over to you we send these out pretty regularly like I said a lot of analysis a lot of breaking news that type of stuff all kind of geared around or focused on DOT compliance so check that out uh all right anything going on in the industry aside from our topic for today not a whole lot um over the last couple of weeks um I did notice and it's worth pointing out that uh Pipeline and hazardous materials safety administration published a notice last week or so about um 200 or so cargo tanks I think they were MC three hundreds and 330s that it discovered were not properly inspected these are cargo tanks that were I believe manufactured by the meter equipment company in Fresno California anyway fimsa conducted an investigation and found out that around 200 or so of these cargo tanks had been inspected by someone who wasn't properly certified to conduct those inspections so they all have to be reinspected so if you are using these tanks then you have until November 20 uh November 10th to get those reinspected you could check out more information on those I don't know how many fleets out there are using these tanks but uh significant enough for it fims it up published notice on this but you can check out more information on fims's website again that's the pipeline and hazardous material safety administration for the details all right so that's all I've got going on uh truck safe and and what I wanted to talk about going on in the industry so let's segue in today's topic which again is the notice published by the FMCSA and the Federal Register earlier this week uh this is August 2023 when we're recording this that notice invites the public to file waiver requests from the agency Zone 2018 and 2020 decisions where it had held that California's in Washington's meal and rest break rules are preempted by the Federal hours of service regulations anyone who's been in this industry for any amount of time knows about the huge legal battles that have been and continue to be fought in California and Washington concerning those States labor laws and their applicability or inapplicability to commercial drivers operating through those States one major aspect of those cases are states meal and rest break laws which the FMCSA again determined previously that those laws were preempted and unenforceable at least against Interstate regulated drivers but the agency's noticed earlier this week has the potential to once again um upend our understanding of those laws and their application to commercial drivers so that's what I wanted to talk about on today's show I'm grateful to be joined once again by my good friend Transportation attorney CEO of the garage group uh Grog group law firm and independent contractor status Guru Mr Doug graul Doug thanks for joining me thanks Brandon happy to be here happy to help out Doug I have one question for you and the question is WTF that's the question that came to my mind immediately when I saw this Notice come through so that is my question to you WTF what is going on here no kidding uh I'm not gonna lie I didn't have this on my radar as something the FMCSA was going to bring up either I hadn't I'm not going to say that some of the trade associations hadn't been talking about it but I had missed it if they were um that this would be coming up since it is has come out you know you start going down the rabbit hole of what are they thinking why are they doing this and so forth and I am not one of those people that sits there and thinks that Joe Biden is sitting in the president's uh chair in in dictating every last little thing that every agency under his his thumb is doing he's not doing that that that's impossible but you do have to think to yourself that uh anytime uh anybody starts to take over new agencies uh secretary budajig or or the acting FMCSA director she's confirmed now so she's confirmed now yeah she's a Robin Hutchinson um you you are thinking about Legacy and what you can get done while you're in control and doesn't matter what the polls are saying or not saying anytime you start approaching re-election time which we are fully in re-election time you are thinking to yourself okay what do I need to get done um but just in case we we lose and I and I lose my spot so somewhere on a whiteboard uh in somebody's office in the FMCSA is a list of things they want to get done and somewhere someone wrote down on that whiteboard I want to get rid of the Trump era preemption ruling that they made on California in Washington and somebody looked at the calendar and said oh crap it's August we gotta publish this you would hope on that whiteboard at the FMCSA that you would see a bunch of safety related stuff and not political politically driven stuff but I couldn't help you know when I saw that Notice come through it came through the first thought in my mind was this is completely politically motivated this issue has been settled for three to five years now and there had been back and forth even back then and that's and we'll talk about that in a second but it had been settled this is what we were used to this is what we knew in our industry for the at least the last five years and so now we are in what was incredible to me is the way that this was done it was it's an invitation from the FMCSA for the public to file waivers from their preemption decision I have never seen the FMCSA do something like that where they issue a ruling and then they invite the public to request exemptions from that ruling yeah I it they're they're standing on the uh on the street corner waving and jumping up and down saying California Washington please ask us to reverse this because we can't wait to reverse this um I'm never going to say they've never done this because I haven't been around forever but I can't I lie I'm like you I can't think of another time when they advertised they want to change a rule and asked people to help them do it by saying please petition us for an exemption for an agency that always complains about being short staffed and not having time to do what Congress tells them to do to imagine a situation where they are inviting more work on themselves on an issue that has already been resolved is just absolutely crazy to me but you're you're exactly right but but then again stuff would have to make sense and uh that's not a rule with anything that comes out of the the agencies it doesn't have to make sense what what's frustrating about this well there's a lot of things that are frustrating about this but to your point about this was settled Not only was this settled in terms of the preemption argument was settled but we we just Revisited hours of service uh you know better than I do exactly when hours of service all got revamped but it's kind of like we did a lot of work a lot of litigation as an industry to come up with uh better uh hours of service rules you're better at speaking about this than I am but I think the the current rules are pretty good and and to think this this is this is another way of the FMCSA saying we actually don't like our hours of service rules we think California is better at it than we are yeah yeah so 2019 was the latest major revisions to our hours of service rules um coming on the heels of the ELD mandate in uh 2015 we had pretty substantial changes to the hours of service rules in 2019 and these were changes that were pretty widely heralded in our industry because they gave fleets and their drivers some much needed flexibility that was absent uh before these changes took effect namely they revised the current uh rest break requirement that is built into the Federal hours of service regulations so before 2019 we had a rest break regulation a 30-minute rest break regulation that said that a Interstate regulated truck driver had to take a 30-minute rest break within the first eight hours of coming on duty during his day so anytime within the first eight hours of First starting his work his or her work for the day he would have to stop for a 30-minute off-duty rest break well that was all well and good but then in 2019 in addition to some other changes that that gave additional flexibility the FMCSA saw fit to change the way that we did rest breaks and what they what they changed it to and what is currently the rule under under the federal regulations is that the driver truck drivers now only have to take a 30 minute rest break once uh at any time before they have accumulated eight hours of actual drive time so it used to be tied to when they first started working uh during the day but now it is tied to drive time so you don't have to take a 30 minute rest break unless it until you have accumulated eight hours of driving time the idea being that what they need rest from is the activity of driving it's the monotony of the driving activity that causes the fatigue and necessitates a rest break not so much the paperwork or the office work that they may be doing at the start of the day you know maybe maybe you have drivers out there who work who work at a warehouse for you know six hours at the start of their day and then they only drive later in the day well we're not so concerned from a a rest break perspective for those folks as we are for the drivers that have been sitting in the same seat for eight hours straight so that's what changed in 2019 that's how our current rest break rule Works in addition to that change we also changed it so that now commercial drivers can get can accomplish that 30 minute rest break with a combination of off-duty and on duty not driving time so it used to they had to be completely off duty to accomplish that 30 minute break now they can accomplish it with a combination of off-duty and on duty not driving so for example driver pulls over into a gas station and goes and is getting fuel which is going to be on duty not driving time they're not driving but they're still on duty they're doing some work they're fueling up the vehicle previously that time couldn't count towards their 30 minute rest break but now they're not driving anymore they're doing something else they're out of the truck they're moving around so we're going to count that time in any off-duty time as long as it's 30 minutes then that gets them the uh the rest that we were concerned with so that has been the rule since 2019 that's the rest break requirement and so that kind of takes us in then to what it exactly is going on here and I and my question to you is maybe we could talk a little bit because this is going to be critically important if these waivers are granted then we're thrust back into a point where in addition to that required federally required 30-minute rest break we could have not just California and Washington those are going to be the first states to do it but presumably we could have every state in the country come up with their own meal and rest break requirements and if you've got drivers in those States then you're going to have to comply with those rules potentially so let's talk about California's in in Washington's meal and rest break rules what are they generally and uh and and how do they apply so California's uh requires a second there's two issues that California and Washington meal and rest break rules do uh that are more stringent or more cumbersome or hazardous towards carriers and drivers compared to the the federal rules the first is like you alluded to in your comments it it's a little bit more going back to we are going to dictate when you take a break based on when you start your day as opposed to based on how much you're driving or how much how long you've been doing a certain task it's it's back to okay you start at noon so between two o'clock and um and uh six o'clock you have to take a 30 minute break and then if you work Beyond more than six hours you work 10 hours then between uh it'd be about five o'clock and uh ten o'clock you've got to take another 30 minute break so it's going to be more restrictive and more um specific in in prescribing when you have to take a break and it's also going to require that you take a second break Washington's are there's some nuanced differences but it's essentially the same thing it's prescribing not only when you have to take the breaks but also that you have to take a second break and the way California and Washington work now I would argue it's probably good practice anyways for for carriers to to be um you know engaged in in ensuring that that drivers take breaks but in California in particular it's not enough to say Joe by the way you can take your break whenever you want to take your break you have to make sure every day Joe takes his break and if Joe doesn't take his break there is no defense of saying here's the email I told Joe he could take a break here's the phone call like when I called and told Joe he could take his break if you don't make sure Joe takes the break you are responsible and and you're liable um and it's it's that combination of uh kind of you know putting you on the hook for policing every minute of your driver's life uh plus the prescription of when and where they take breaks that make this less safe and more cumbersome for drivers and for trucking companies uh and like you said with these two states doing it you can see others following suit I live in a state that loves everything that California passes so I'm assuming at some point in time Minnesota would like this rule too yeah and the other thing to point out is you know California is in Washington's meal and rest break laws are applicable not just to truck drivers these are these are broadly applicable laws to to all workers within the state and so they're not designed specifically for Trucking obviously and so that has been the big uh from what I could tell the big um impetus for our industry really getting up in arms about that is that those laws they may work for an office worker who can who can easily go and take a break uh you know go to the break room and you know get some coffee for 10 minutes when when it when the clock hits those times but if you're in a truck you're out there operating on the street it's not like you can just pull over wherever you're at and take a 10 minute break I mean you may be in the middle of the city uh and now your your clock's up and now you've got to take your second break it takes time and it takes effort and it takes availability parking space to be able to make that happen you're right and and I can see now our audience is typically going to be people who who are living and breathing Trucking all day long but I'm I'm picturing someone who doesn't know Trucking here what you just said and they're like okay so it takes them five minutes to find a parking spot no it does not it takes hour at best sometimes two three four hours to find that Trucking spot so okay so if I'm gonna if I have to do two breaks uh with within that that 10 hours okay and it's going to take me at best an hour each time to take that break I'm looking at three hours I'm losing during the day to either on my break or having to get to a place where I can take my break uh who by the way that that's time just driving around or idling and more pollution in the air uh and that and that finding finding spots is not accomplishing the break that is still on duty work that is work and so it's not like you get a out that time that you're trying to find a spot as the required break once you get to the spot that's when you can start your break time yep spot on so it it you're right it their rules designed for quote unquote all employers and and you're right that they they serve a perfectly good purpose for a lot of Industries um I'm not going to say Trucking is the only one that that that uh has its own issues and unique issues that that should exempt it from these rules but Trucking is definitely one of them I I'm picturing a a planner and a dispatcher and a driver trying to work together uh the dispatcher and the planner are based in Iowa uh the driver lives in uh in Tennessee uh he and he operates Nationwide so every couple of weeks he is going to have everything is going to have to get adjusted because he's got a load through California uh there's a lot of things that have to get adjusted to deal with one-off issues in California and Washington this is not an easy thing to manage and and to this point we've only talked about meal breaks so in addition to the meal breaks there's also a rest break requirement so you got the 30 minute meal break requirements you said two two potentially in a ten hour period and then California and Washington also have a 10 minute rest break requirement for every as I understand it for every four hours you have to have a 10 minute rest break requirement what I don't know the answer to I don't know if you know the answer to this Doug does the do the 30-minute meal breaks count as the 10 minute rest breaks or are those in addition to those those 30 minute meal breaks that you have to take my understanding is they are in addition to that I do a ton of work in Washington California but that is my understanding yeah that's that was my understanding as well and and it's consistent with fmcsa's previous preemption determination where they said that if California and Washington are allowed to enforce these rules that truck drivers in those States would have to take three times the number of breaks that they are required under the federal hours of service rules which would be right then you would have the two meal breaks in that 10 hour period and you would have the one or two potentially rest breaks as well so it's uh it's huge uh potential change here with all that same parking challenges for I guess so now I got to spend an hour to take a 10 hour finding a place to take a 10 minute break yeah exactly that let's let's talk about efficiencies huh yeah no kidding so let's walk through kind of backing up we kind of dug right into it there but um looking back at kind of the history of this um and I tried to kind of lay it out at the start but this is not a new issue this has been uh resolved and looked at many times in the past so maybe you walk us through um kind of where this all started where we've been in terms of fmcsa's action or inaction on the topic and how that got us to today yeah so the FMCSA first issued an opinion on this issue of of whether or not a state and specifically California at the time whether California's meal and respite rules could be enforced against an interstate truck driver okay knowing the interstate truck driver is already governed by the Federal hours of service and and all the federal safety regulations in 2008 a group of trade associations in the industry and carriers in the industry uh petitioned the FMCSA for an opinion a ruling on whether or not California's meal and rest break rules were preempted under federal law by the um uh by by federal law so the FMCSA ruled in 2008 uh on unfortunately for the industry that no they were not preempted now I think it's it's critical to keep in mind that in 2008 we had different hours of service rules and when we get kind of later on in the history we'll explain a little bit more about why that's significant but it is significant they were different rules at the time with not Frankly Speaking as many rests uh in there and not as prescribed of rest break options uh for and requirements for drivers and yeah I don't think we had a rest break requirement at the time exactly so I think you and I would both agree though the existing rules are better they're better for safety they're better for operations they're they're better today than they were in 2008. um but in 2008 the FMCSA said no these are not um California's rules can can take effect fast forward to 2018 and the American Trucking Association coupled with a couple other trade associations California bus Association and some others that I know I'm forgetting but but a handful of trade associations that all deserve credit for it uh and specialized carrier and rigging Association was part of that yes I I believe you're correct um uh petition the FMCSA again in 2018 uh to revisit this uh one of the things they talked about a couple of things that that differentiated it from 2008. I'm not ranking these but one of which was a case out of the uh the ninth circuit called The dilts V Penske case uh which talked about this issue and the dilts case kind of signals in its opinion while the dilt case in general is not a good case for for Trucking what it does signal in its opinion is because the the dilts V Penske case had to do with local delivery um kind of some final mile stuff it didn't relate directly to over-the-road truck drivers and the the dilts court essentially says Hey California's rules apply and they're not preempted by federal safety regulations but they signal in there we're not making this opinion based on over-the-road driving which may be different okay I'm not saying that's what what tipped the trade association's off to let's go petition this but I think you can understand why because you know over the road truck drivers the concern then becomes differing rules in the different states through which they're passing versus local drivers which are just you know one state one set of rules potentially you're exactly right you're exactly right so uh 2018 the FMC uh the the ATA and these other trade associations petitioned the FMCSA to to look at this again uh and arguing hey we've got this dilts case uh you you so you can see how this is impacting the industry and this is a trucking company uh that is now going to have to deal with dealing with California's meal and respic rules as well as the FMCSA rules so we've got a real life carrier being impacted by this two truck parking has just gotten exponentially worse in 10 years uh between 2008 2018 and I would argue it's exponentially worse today than it was in 2018. okay then you've got um the hours of service rules change uh and also and I don't again you'll know better than I do exactly when the ELD rules went into effect you've got the hours of service with the the new break rules coming into effect and now you actually have elds which are dramatically increasing compliance with hours of service rules so the app so the ATA and other trade associations are arguing hey this is not a safety issue this is entirely a labor and employment issue though that is impacting safety and it's hurting carriers ability to comply with the law and and it is hamstringing driver's ability to make safe decisions out on the road there it is um taking power away from the drivers to do what is good for them from a safety perspective in 2018 the FMCSA agrees with the ATA and grants the petition and says that California's meal and rest break rules are preempted by federal law Okay so we've got a 10-year stretch here 2008 bad decision for the industry 2018 good decision for the industry and when I say industry I'm not just talking about trucking companies I think that's good for drivers good for safety good for the public good for a lot of things oh and by the way there has been a change of political parties between those two decisions 2008 to 2018 right yes and no 2008 is that the the first petition is still issued under uh W it's okay yeah you're right you're right I was thinking is that Obama that yep uh he he comes into power in 09 he wins the 08 election okay so is this still a republican uh appoint so this was still a republican appointed FMCSA administrator at the time yes okay and then in 2018 then we have a Trump trump appointed administrator okay correct so so the Trump Administration uh does it fast forward then to 2020 the um Washington uh a couple of Washington trade associations make a very similar petition now I don't want to lump California Washington together in the sense of saying they're the exact same thing because there are differences between the two but in the grand scheme of things the logic the arguments are pretty much the same um so but it but a very very similar petition goes to the to the FMCSA relating to Washington and its preemption uh or the preemption of Washington's meal and rest break rules and for similar reasons using similar Logic the FMCSA grants that petition so since 2020 we've had two specific uh uh it's not a rule making that that's not the process what it is is it's a it's a petition for a ruling or a determination or a decision uh uh by the FMCSA is granted in favor of saying the federal safety regulations Trump slash preempt these California and Washington meal and rest break rules that's where we've been for three years and uh like we we started the show off with uh we were all surprised that apparently this was on their radar to to blow back up so since 2020 then California and Washington have been unable to enforce their meal and rest break rules against Interstate regulated drivers is essentially what it comes down to and uh and correct me if I'm wrong but since that time those rulings have been tied up in court cases is that right so some groups have challenged the fmcsa's preemption determinations in federal court yes in some ways I do always feel sorry for agencies just in the sense of no matter what they do they're getting sued uh it doesn't matter what determination what ruling they make they're going to get sued by somebody that is one of those things uh it is it's not alone in being that the teamsters that challenge them but the the teamsters the states themselves uh some other trade groups have uh have been litigating and challenging the uh the preemption determinations by the FMCSA but those have been upheld to this point that's no no court has struck down the preemption decisions that's correct the the good thing is is uh there's a statute out there that really gives the the the feds a lot of leeway when it comes to saying that that something is preempted and the the way this rule works for uh in trucking as it relates to safety regulations there is a law and if anybody really wants it cited 49 USC 31 141 uh if you really want to nerd up and go read it uh but the gist of the of the law says hey if the Federal Motor Carrier safety administration if if if if there are already regulations on the books related to to safety okay it's going to look at a state Rule and it's going to say okay is this state rule about commercial Motor Vehicle Safety and the arguments against the preemption usually focus on that first point is it about commercial safety in there and California and Washington are always going to argue hey these rules are not about commercial Motor Vehicles safety they're about labor and employment rules for all employees this is not only applicable labor laws is what they always say exactly exactly uh and like I said you you and I have have already discussed a little bit about how that that's not really accurate but the first first threshold issue is is this about commercial Motor Vehicle Safety then after that then you start to look at okay is this regulation or law from the state less stringent than the federal rule is it as stringent or is it more stringent okay if it's less stringent pretty easy not enforceable the federal rule trumps okay that we always want to hold the the the the trucking companies and the drivers to at least the federal standard okay then it if is equal to okay it is it it it's enforceable because it's the same rule okay those two are pretty straightforward the third one is what if it's more stringent okay if it is more stringent then you start looking at okay is this going to be a is it how does this impact safety how does this impact Commerce okay what are the other impacts of this rule and usually what's going to happen is you're going to say this is going to be preempted because it is going to be such a burden on interstate commerce or while it may have some safety benefits in one spot it actually has an overall worse safety impact and this is a classic example we've already talked about it it's that truck parking thing yeah so this is the analysis that FMCSA undertook and it's 2018 and 2020 decisions it ruled that number one California is in Washington's meal and rest break rules are laws on Commercial Motor Vehicle Safety we're not going to get into the details of that they essentially say hey it governs the same content as our hours of service rules so it's going to be considered a law on Commercial Vehicle Safety they then progress to The Next Step determine that those rules are more stringent than than the Federal hours of service rules and so then they are it is up to the FMCSA administrator to determine I think there are three factors that would render for it potentially preempted you if you meet any one of those three then it's going to be preempted number one is going to be does it benefit safety I want to make sure I get these right hold on I got these do you have these written down too not compatible not compatible with the federal law and then an undue burden on interstate commerce if it if it's if either any one of those is true then the FMCSA administrator can rule that it's that it's preempted and the interesting thing here is that in those decisions FMCSA found that all three were true yeah and I will say is um they're they're worth we talk a little bit about you know which Administration was this there were things issued by agencies under the Trump Administration that I would say you write you read them as a lawyer and you're like uh that's I don't know if that's the strongest argument that I've ever seen um these preemption determinations were very well written and very well argued uh they they built that case very well uh and you're right they only needed one and they clearly spelled out why all three apply supported by studies on truck parking on driver fatigue on burdens on data that they got on the potential uh burdens on interstate commerce including decreased efficiency and additional cost and lost time all of that was built in baked into the fmcsa's analysis and they ultimately concluded back then they yeah these laws are preempted and they're not going to be enforceable what what it's what was great about those answers is someone who does I do just a a touch of of lobbying uh in my practice and and help some companies and some organizations out uh with with making comments to uh to the FMCSA and other state and federal agencies from time to time it was a great example of the power of comments now don't get me wrong there's a lot of times when a proposed rule or a proposed rule making uh comes out where you can kind of read the tea light Tea Leaves of what's going to happen I'm not going to argue that uh that that doesn't sometimes happen but what those determinations showed you is when the trade associations took on the heavy lifting of the legal arguments you know we're going to cite the cases and the statutes and the legislative history and all that kind of stuff the trade associations are great at that stuff okay but what the companies did what the drivers did was they gave real life examples in real life data and the the agency used that data to back up why the parking issue is a real issue the burdens on interstate commerce are real and so on so I hope our listeners take the take that home and realize speaking up matters it may feel like you're you're spitting into the wind and sometimes you are but you never know uh when your comments when your data might get used so I encourage you speak up yeah for sure and especially if FMCSA is going to give the public the opportunity to weigh in on these waiver requests that they are soliciting you know I've said this in some of the posts that I've made and I believe this to be true the FMCSA would not be actively soliciting these waiver requests if it doesn't fully intend to grant them so I don't think there's going to have to be much of a showing made by California and Washington to get the FMCSA to Grant these requests but if they are going to give the public the opportunity to weigh in which I think they should I don't think they're required to under this law but if they do give the public the opportunity I highly recommend that the industry come in hot and heavy with their comments I have no doubt that the ATA will and the American bus Association will they've already expressed their displeasure with fmcsa's action in this and so I expect that they will on behalf of the industry submit their data but at any Motor Carrier out there with operations in those States should be submitting comments uh if they are given that opportunity for sure they should not just you're right that the the FMCSA has signaled where they're probably going to go and and I can hear see a listener going well then I'm not going to waste my time waste your time because it's not wasting your time honestly because it also gets used in the litigation I'm not an expert of some of the procedural rules that that go into how agencies can and can't do some things but I do know there are rules about what they have to do with comments how they have to take them into consideration and uh I do know that it gets brought up in the litigation of well you disregarded you know comments you know one through 1476 that all spelled out this this type of data this type of argument so um do share your story do share your data uh when when they when they ask for that public comment and you're right I don't think they had to but they've signaled they're going to ask for public comments so we've got to be ready I hope that they do and uh you know it's kind of a unique feature of this particular federal law sometimes when you see preemption uh legislation like f4a is a prime example if something is preempted on under f4a it's just preempted it doesn't give any discretion to the agency to make the determination of whether it is or not but but this particular law 49 USC 311 31141 actually gives the FMCSA administrator the discretion to accept petitions for preemption rule on them which it did here and then also to accept waiver requests and that's kind of what brought us to this most recent notice is that you know normally you don't you don't see this if the FM if somebody has determined that a state law is preempted by federal law then the federal law just trumps the state law and that's the end of the story you don't see people being able to request waivers from that preemption decision but that's what's unique about this particular federal law is that it gives the FMCSA explicitly the authority to accept waiver request and that's what it's doing now I don't think Congress envisioned FMCSA actively soliciting them on them unprompted but that's what they're doing they're taking advantage of that last part of that legislation which says hey even though you agency have determined a state law to be preempted you can you can accept requests for waivers from determination and there has to be certain showings made to be able for you to be able to Grant those waivers so um so kind of looking at this for the future so FMCSA has solicited these requests I fully anticipate California and Washington will submit those requests you know their Departments of Labor will probably be the one or their Attorneys General will submit those requests and uh in FMCSA they're they're asking for those states to address particular questions you want to run through those real quick yeah so uh it's as a side I have to think to myself I assume that California and Washington did know this was coming otherwise I'm picturing someone in the Attorney General's office in Washington going well now I got to do what Merry Christmas to us it um yeah so they are yes you're right Washington California either directly or someone on their behalf will submit these petitions uh the FMCSA has signaled that they're gonna they want the petitions to address uh and shoot I should be looking at exactly what it is but it's it's parking uh that they specifically want uh feedback on parking they want feedback on whether or not uh and and whether or not the the California and Washington rules impact uh parking and and how parking interacts with those rules they want to know what kind of Burden it adds to trucking companies and to drivers and to agencies and administrators they're they're going to be looking at that side too um for enforcement uh and and what enforcement of these rules look like uh and and yeah poor me I I didn't bring up the list of all three I got them here so the first question is whether and to what extent enforcement of a state's meal and rest break laws with respect to intrastate property carrying and passenger carrying has impacted their health and safety so they want to see they want to see both sides of this they want to see hey do the states have data that their inability to enforce these rules has negatively impacted workers in those States and then on the other side of the things they want to hear from they want to hear about industry concerns tell us about the truck the parking shortage and what you States intend to do about that if that is a problem and then also tell us about how this will uh they say here's here's the third question whether enforcement of a state's meal and rest break laws will dissuade carriers from operating in those States and whether any such effect will weaken the resiliency of the national supply chain and whether the applicants the states intend to take any action to mitigate or address those effects so they they know that these are going to be concerns and they want the states to address them because this is inevitably like you said going to end up in litigation yeah and the the frustrating thing is is that and I I share this with people a lot of times is all of us will bemoan California uh and and what they do and and rightfully so it is still like the fifth largest economy in the world um so there there's I I hear a lot more talk of we're going to leave the state than I see actually I'm not going to say I don't I see action I do definitely see people leave the state of California so I know it happens um but I probably hear about it more than I actually see it so that is going to be a little bit Challenge and I do encourage those that have left California or intend to leave California please do speak up when that happens because that will be powerful powerful stuff yeah the other thing that I anticipate from California in Washington is especially when you go back to that first question that health and safety of of the drivers and so on what I anticipate will happen is we'll get just a little bit of data from the states but uh I think back to the USA Today article uh that's probably a 10 year old article um of the the rigged expose which the poor drivers right yeah the poor drivers I'm not gonna we we all know there are bad trucking companies there are bad truck drivers there are bad you know Financial brokerage companies there are bad schools there are bad whatever organization you can pick any organization pick any trade and there are Bad actors in it that article uh chose to we're really going to pick on one or two Bad actors to make an industry look absolutely abhorrent um and I fear a similar type of arguments will come from California and Washington as they'll they'll find a bad actor and they're going to tell a a graphic story a a very tug at your heartstring stories of some people whose health and safety have been negatively impacted by the inability to enforce California meal and respect rules I don't think it'll be heavy on data I think it'll be heavy on here's a sob story for you yeah which will probably be a true story but I think that will shade their arguments a lot uh in in what we have to come back with data about as an industry yeah I'm cynical but I I don't think there's going to have to be much of anything included in those waiver requests for them to be granted like I said I agree I've just never seen FMCSA solicit these and because they are doing so I have to think that they just intend to grant them that's why they they solicited them but we'll wait and see uh we got a couple questions here before we wrap things up uh that time flew by there uh Brian is asking this question I have and I can't maybe you don't have the answer to it Doug I'm not quite sure how this works but how would the rule be enforced once a driver crosses the state line does the time start then or did it start when the driver came on duty originally so I guess the broader question is how how would this work if California and Washington are able to then enforce their meal and rest break rules does it apply only to California resident drivers or to drivers that just happen to be operating in there how do you see that planet so it's a great question it's a question that gets asked on a lot of California's rules whether you're talking about ABC tests and independent contractor status or you're talking about meal and rest break or any number of different California labor rules so there is not actually for as much litigation there is there is around this there's actually not been a ton of clarity brought to this what is absolutely clear that courts agree with that I think you know all the industry agrees with is that the driver lives and and operates primarily what everybody's definition of primarily is is a little bit gray but let's just say use a reasonable determination of primarily if they live and work primarily in California they're going to be subject to these rules even if they they duck into Arizona for an afternoon if the person lives in you know Nevada or Arizona or Oregon but regularly comes down into California daily weekly something along those lines these rules are going to apply there is actually not much definitive there's been district court but we're talking about court of appeals Supreme Court kind of stuff to say when do some of these rules apply to a true over-the-road driver that lives in uh in Illinois and go and it hits California once every couple of months what I can tell you is California thinks their rules apply the minute that guy hits the border so if he hits the Border halfway through his day California is going to argue we govern the whole day yeah that's what yeah you calculate your time from when you started working even though that was in Nevada or Arizona or whatever correct I think California is wrong and I think uh and so that if I'm a carrier you just have to figure out okay well how much am I fighting that how much am I litigating that um I I think my personal opinion is the the way the law works is if the guy or gal is not primarily operating in California regularly operating Cal California some kind of threshold along those lines the California rules do not apply to him or her it's been my understanding as well yeah but but to your point don't underestimate California thinks its rules apply to everything yeah just look at carb and and all the other rules so yeah it's it's hard to say I mean it's one of those things we'll have to wait and see but it's hard to tell a carrier that that is trying to plan out how this is going to affect you know their operations so I think if FMCSA is going to do this we need to come up with a plan to let fleets know that have operations out there how this exactly is going to work for them because you know FMCSA has is ostensibly also working on the truck parking shortage but now they're gonna enact or they're going to take action that's going to have a negative impact on their own work it's just you know there's several reasons why this is just crazy to me um things just do not make sense it's we we talk about this beginning the Federal Motor Carrier safety administration should be focused on safety regulations not doing the US Department of Labor's work exactly uh let's see here a couple more questions some of these may not be related let's see here let's see what Angela's saying here Angela's saying question about short haul 30 minutes do we have to take them or no can my job forced me to take them um short haul exemption kind of plays into this analysis a little bit so it's worth talking about real quickly um short haul exemption is an exemption baked into the Federal hours of service regulations that essentially says that if you're a driver that stays within a 150 air mile radius of your normal work reporting location and you don't work more than 14 hours in a day then you are exempt from the onerous driver logging requirements the record-keeping requirements the ELD requirement it does not exempt you from the hours of service rules except for the rest break requirement so short all drivers if you meet those criteria are exempt from the federal 30-minute rest break requirement completely so that is an interesting question is okay we got these short haul drivers that are operating maybe into California they're still within 150 air mile radius of their normal work reporting location they're normally not subject to any rest break requirement under the federal rules now they are going to potentially be subject to three different meal and rest break requirements so what you'd have to think about is if you're a carrier you you if this preemptive these waivers uh get granted which I'm with you and I'm pretty sure they're going to you're going to end up with a two grids on the on the wall okay what are my California rules or my Washington rules and my federal rules okay which one is more strict in this scenario that's the one I've got to follow yeah and you're just going to go down the line of all of the rules whichever one's more strict I got to follow and that's exactly what federal preemption is designed to avoid is the so-called Patchwork of state laws on a particular topic that result in Interstate businesses having to evaluate the law the differences in the laws in all of the states that they operate that's the point of federal preemption that's why the FMCSA determined this to be preempt in the first place and that's why it is so frustrating and confusing to us as to why we are contemplating going away from that and back to a patchwork of state laws on this particular topic so anyway uh any closing thoughts Doug anything we haven't hit on this topic before we wrap things up here I feel like I should add some words of wisdom 10 but I'm not sure I really do uh uh I I always applaud uh trucking companies uh the hits keep coming uh that they always do but I'm still awfully proud to be a part of this industry uh because I know the good work we do every day and and yes this feels like another hit um we'll keep fighting back on it we're not going to take this one laying down and keep fighting the fight Doug where can people find you if they have questions for you or want to reach out yeah uh go to the website
www.thegrawgroup.com you can email me doug.graw my last name g-r-a-w-e at thegrogroup.com all right Doug thanks as always for joining me really appreciate your Insight on this topic and and all kinds of topics if anybody's interested Doug and I have done prior shows in the past uh on independent contractor status we had a discussion about ab5 when uh in the Supreme Court's involvement in those issues so go back and check out those episodes if you're interested but anyway thanks again Doug really appreciate you joining me all right so that's going to wrap up the show for today appreciate everybody joining us and participating with us a very interesting topic we will continue to provide updates on any developments uh on this issue particularly when we get waivers that are waiver requests that are filed we'll let you know we'll send out um you know newsletters and stuff like that so stay tuned um follow us on our social media Pages that's where we publish our most timely information um so you can follow us on LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Youtube all of those channels stay tuned for our next episode of truck safe live we try and do these a couple times a month uh you can find Details you can watch prior shows on trucksafelive.com or wherever you happen to get your podcast you can subscribe to us thanks again to the sponsor of this season of trucksafe live log Rock appreciate you teaming up with us to make this possible that's all I got thanks everybody for joining us we will catch you next time
yeah yeah that that went really quick and I think we got everything in so really appreciate it I didn't know you have drivers uh that listen in uh so our YouTube channel so we we this goes live on LinkedIn Facebook YouTube our YouTube channel we've got like 7 000 subscribers now and most of them are truck drivers because we you know we do a lot of content on how to understand the hours of service regulations stuff like that so we do have a lot of truck drivers that listen in so awesome awesome good work well let me know if you have anything else will do thanks Doug talk to you later thanks see ya all right