Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 28 - Safety rating shakeup

Tuesday, September 5, 2023 at 4:16 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 28 - Safety rating shakeup

About This Event

Brandon & Jerad are joined by TCA’s Dave Heller to discuss the FMCSA’s advanced notice of proposed rulemaking on potential changes to carrier safety ratings, including potentially tying them to CSA scores.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 28 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jared Childress are joined by Dave Heller, Senior Vice President of Safety and Government Affairs for the Truckload Carriers Association (TCA), to discuss a significant regulatory development: the FMCSA's Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) soliciting public comments on a potential overhaul of its Safety Fitness Determination process. This is a topic of considerable consequence for motor carriers, as a carrier's safety rating — currently classified as satisfactory, conditional, or unsatisfactory — can have fleet-wide operational implications, including the possibility of a full shutdown order for those deemed unfit. The hosts and guest also briefly address the FMCSA's separate and unexpected move to solicit waiver requests from its meal and rest break preemption ruling, which could once again expose interstate carriers to California and Washington state labor laws. The discussion provides important context on the distinction between safety ratings and CSA scores, two systems that are often conflated but measure carrier performance in fundamentally different ways. Safety ratings result from compliance reviews conducted by FMCSA investigators, while CSA scores are derived primarily from roadside inspection data. A central concern raised throughout the episode is the FMCSA's proposal to tie safety ratings more directly to CSA scores — an approach the agency attempted in 2016 but ultimately withdrew following significant industry pushback and Congressional scrutiny. The hosts and Heller identify several persistent shortcomings with CSA data that make this linkage problematic, including disparate enforcement practices across states, the limited percentage of carriers that receive a compliance review in any given year (estimated at around two percent), and the fact that existing safety ratings can be decades old, rendering them effectively meaningless as a current measure of carrier safety. A recurring theme in the conversation is the inadequacy of the current DataQ appeal system as a mechanism for due process if safety ratings are to be based on CSA data. The hosts argue that allowing carriers to challenge erroneous roadside violations through a process adjudicated by the same state agency that issued the violations is fundamentally insufficient — particularly if those CSA scores could ultimately determine whether a carrier is permitted to operate. Heller echoed this concern, noting that expecting a state agency to rule against its own officers is an unrealistic standard. The group expressed optimism about a suggestion raised in the live chat from a recently retired FMCSA official that the agency may consider taking over the DataQ appeal process, which the hosts agreed would be a meaningful step toward a more equitable system. The hosts and Heller also discuss what a better Safety Fitness Determination framework might look like, emphasizing that compliance and safety are not synonymous. Heller advocates for incorporating "beyond compliance" factors — such as the voluntary adoption of advanced safety technologies like automatic emergency braking, forward-facing cameras, and other fleet safety tools — into any carrier safety assessment. The group agrees that an effective system should not only identify and remove bad actors from the industry but also recognize and reward carriers that go above and beyond regulatory requirements to improve road safety. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to actively participate in the ANPRM comment process, as this is the industry's primary opportunity to shape how the rulemaking develops before a formal proposal is issued. Comments can be submitted directly to the FMCSA's docket, and Trucksafe Consulting intends to file its own detailed comments with constructive recommendations. Those interested in collaborating on comment submissions can reach out through trucksafe.com. Additional resources, including a written breakdown of the ANPRM, are available on the Trucksafe website, and the prior episode covering the meal and rest break preemption issue is available at trucksafelive.com.

Full Transcript

foreign welcome to episode 28 of trucksafe live the show where we and our guests tackle hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon this is Jared hey everybody uh we are with trucksafe and Childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs excited to have Jared back with me here in studio yeah it has been a while he left me out on my own to do the rest of the shows well I saw Dave was going to be on today I didn't want to miss it so yeah yeah Dave brought you in so glad for that um before we get to today's topic which is safety rating shake up um we have a few things going on truck safe and in the industry that are worth talking about so let's hit those real quick uh first up is our truck safe boot camp yeah October 12th and 13th are going to be in Orlando we did one of these earlier uh in the spring this year in Indianapolis thought we'd go someplace a little bit warmer so we're going to go with Orlando this fall we have a couple of seats left I believe we're capping attendance around 60 and so if you're interested in that let us know um and and we'll probably have another one here uh spring of 24. and we're looking to shoot big on that one so look for that announcement yeah so if you're interested in joining us like Jared said we've got a few spots open uh trucksafebootcamp.com is where you can find information on that and where you can register hope to see you there uh what else we got going on so our truck safe network if you're not a member of our truck safe Network we recommend you join it it's where we offer a lot of free content on DOT compliance articles videos courses uh it's also a network for safety professionals to learn from one another ask questions that type of stuff it's available at trucksafenetwork.com we've also got an app in the app store in the Google Play store which is what we're showing on screen so hope to see you there uh digitally so you check that out like I said trucksafenetwork.com uh last thing I'll mention about trucksafe is our newsletter if you're interested in receiving breaking industry news our analysis of it videos articles all of that fun stuff all about dot safety and compliance subscribe to our newsletter over at trucksafe.com subscribe and you will get the latest uh and greatest from us for what it's worth yeah of course let's forget about the courses we as member of courses including you know Reasonable Suspicion training we have a safety manager course a lot of different courses check those out check them out check them out trucksafeacademy.com all right enough about us uh what's going on in the industry a couple big things recently including a couple of FMCSA notices that have come out recently our last show was on uh on the last notice before the one that we're talking about today which was a notice from FMCSA soliciting the public to submit waiver requests from its meal and rest break preemption ruling this was something that kind of came out of thin air was not expecting it it came down a few weeks ago now we did a show a couple weeks ago with Doug Graw Transportation attorney Doug Graw of the Graw group where we broke it down and what exactly the FMCSA is thinking about doing with me on rest breaks um it's it's pretty shocking news uh you know we've gotten used to over the last couple of years uh at least for Interstate regulated trucking companies not having to worry about other states meal and rest break laws like Californians and Washington's because of fmcsa's earlier determination that those rules as applied to Interstate truck drivers are preempted by the Federal hours of service rules but now all the FMCSA is actively soliciting waiver request from its own ruling in that regard meaning that it is going to accept requests for waivers from that preemption decision likely from California and Washington Labor departments and if it Grant if the FMCSA receives those requests and grants them then those states are presumably going to be able to enforce those meal and rest break rules against Interstate regulated truck drivers I was I was thinking about this I was wondering are we going to start seeing kind of a cyclical nature of this type of thing when we're dealing with the FMCSA going forward depending on the administration much like the nlrb is it's kind of what it seems like yeah we've we've already seen that back and forth with just that meal and rest break issue FMCSA originally determined that California is in Washington's rules were not preempted and then in 2018 it decided that they were preempted and now it's going to accept waiver requests so very well could be seems to be pretty politically driven but in any event they're accepting those waiver requests and we anticipate those States will file them we anticipate the FMCSA will grant them and then if you've got operations in California and or Washington then it's going to be not fun for you probably so anyway be on the lookout for more information on that we've got an article about it on our website over at trucksafe.com and catch that last show if you missed it all right so that's all that we had to talk about before we transitioned to today's topic so uh which is the advance notice of proposed rulemaking published by FMCSA last week which was the end of August 2023 if you're watching this later in that advance notice of proposed rulemaking the FMCSA is soliciting public comments on an overhaul potential overhaul to the agency's safety Fitness determination process more commonly known as safety ratings in particular the notice suggests that the agency may be considering tying a motor carrier safety rating to its CSA scores which is something that it tried to do back in 2016 before ultimately withdrawing that proposal due to outcry from the industry and and a risk slap from the U.S Congress um so what exactly are they proposing this time and what might it mean for fleets in the U.S that's what we're discussing today uh on today's show and we're excited to be joined by industry veteran senior vice president of safety and government Affairs for the truckload carriers Association Mr Dave Heller Dave welcome thanks guys thanks for having me on I appreciate it I'll tell you what bro that introduction you have to question who poked the bear over at FMCSA right they just have a lot of things coming out recently don't they it's been a busy month for them for sure and uh you know we kind of saw this one coming because it's been in their regulatory agenda we didn't see that meal and rest break one coming did you no I didn't in fact I you know we were like oh this is a done deal you know we put this to bed a few years back so we're good to go on that and all of a sudden this comes out of thin air and it was like okay great and it kind of raises that flag of where do we go as an industry if states start you know getting preemptions of that in Interstate rule if you will so I hate to be one of those truck drivers who say he's driving from DC up to Massachusetts in one day how many state lines did they cross if they all have different meal and rest breaks that would not be a fun day to say the very least yeah especially parking shortages we've got that problem to begin with now we've got the potential if these waivers are granted and we have that this is one of the big impetus for the fmcsa's original preemption decision you know you got truck drivers who now under Californians and Washington's laws are having to potentially take three times as many rest breaks as they do under the federal hours of service rules and it's hard enough to get that one rest break in under the federal rules and now you're potentially having to take three breaks a day and find parking for that just eats up a ton of time and and and you know fills up the parking spots it seems like so yeah there's no doubt about it to me it goes back to like my high school days when I used to work in like a retail establishment and I think the rules were designed for that type of environment it was not designed for professional truck driver to say the very least so it brings us to where we are today and they're looking at exemption requests which is not the way to go I don't necessarily know if FMCSA is thrilled to be going down this road either you know they issued that Proclamation and that you know saying it's the federal rules that matter and this is what's coming up so it goes into that caveat or that bucket if you will and we'll see how this plays out yeah and just thinking about all the work that they put themselves into it you know granting the preemption decision now they're going to be undoing essentially what they did just a couple years ago so anyway oh yeah well we were just talking before we got on here um it seems like every speech I've ever given in the industry you were also there giving a speech a regulatory update of some sort so if you've never had a chance to see Dave give one of those speeches definitely get out there and see that but tell us a little bit about yourself how you got into industry how long you've been in the industry and a little bit about TCA as well oh well myself I guess I would say it's a dumb luck if you will just kind of uh fell by the wayside it was one of those things way back when after I got out of college I was I was working retail coming out of college got to the point where I was like I need to do something else and I ended up getting a job with ATA working on programs like the National Truck Driving championship and their Safety Management Council which then life kind of came at me and you know my career grew and that's how I came here to TCA and I've been to been a TCA for almost 18 years if you can believe that so it's wow it's been a long time to say the very least it's home and it's comfortable um and they they're a great Association there's no doubt about it and for those that don't know TCA we're an organization that strictly represents the truckload segment of the industry they're over the road people um we're can we're a growing Association to say the very least our membership uh seems to be skyrocketing these days which is great and you know you guys are on LinkedIn and you probably keep seeing our new member notifications that continually go up and up so it's a good position to be in where we have a great group of members that that are the best in the industry um the best hauling Freight out there safety conscience you name it they are the one so um we here at TCA we do our best to represent them on Capitol Hill and within FMCSA and we put educational programs out there host meetings for networking and you know we have members in Canada and Mexico so we're International uh to say the very least so it's a it's a great environment to be in excellent yeah and TCA usually does their big annual conference and they also do a Safety and Security conference those are the two that happen every year but I looked at the calendar and you guys have piled on a lot of different events as well it's interesting we do in fact at the end of this month we have our fall business meetings and call on Washington where our membership will be coming into town here in Washington DC and we'll be Walking The Halls of Congress talking about the issues that we're talking about today or we'll talk about truck parking or we'll talk equipment we'll we'll run the gamut of range of topics in which we'll be having with our Congressional representatives and then again before you know in November we're going to be going north of the border to Canada where we have our bridging Board of barriers conference because let's face it we have Canadian members that are constantly crossing the border and coming south so this is that our one opportunity in November to go north uh Into The Frigid cold of Canada and have a meeting to talk about the stuff that matters to them so it's a great event it really is and even that one is growing by leaps and Browns so it's one of those situations where our members are embracing the messages that we're giving or that they're giving us and and going from there and then no more does that show with our call in Washington when they come into town and speak on the issues that we get to speak on yeah for sure if you haven't been to a TCA event I highly recommend it Jared and I have uh have been there as attendees we've been there as speakers and we had a booth at the last one so it's it's just they put on a great event so check that out if you haven't already um all right Dave so obviously discussion today is about safety Fitness determinations uh and the fmcsa's anprm on that issue specifically for anybody who's tuned in that may not be familiar with safety Fitness determinations I was wondering if you could kind of just break down basically what they are and why they matter oh safety Fitness determination for lack of better term rates that is that it rates that carrier in their safety performance if you will and rates it into one of three categories satisfactory conditional and unsatisfactory it's a program that has been around forever as you said at the beginning of the show it's one in which they have continually tried to update if you will based upon compliance reviews um and have continually tried to update it to get it a better working system and and those updates or that conversation has been going on for years so we don't know we obviously because of the presence of this inexact science um here it is actually 2023 where they rolled it out again for more conversation previously happened in 2016 it's been on that regulatory docket for years and they've continued to say we're going to do something about it we're going to do something about it and here they're saying we're going to do something about it but that doesn't necessarily mean they'll get to do something about it I think but us three guys can all sit there and say hey there's some shortcomings to this and and certainly they the way they want to go about doing it probably is not the best case scenario and they're looking for comments from industry to highlight the ways they want to go doing it they want to go about doing it yeah so the existing safety rating like you said has been around the process has been around for decades at this point as long as I can remember um and you know it's it's it's got its flaws I think one of the rationales the FMCSA raised you mentioned you know when they tried to change this up a few years ago 2016 I think was the last time they they made any significant strides at it they pointed out that the existing safety rating process one big concern with it is that number one it's it's uh it requires a lot of Manpower from the FMCSA because it requires a compliance review conducted by an investigator so they actually have to send somebody out or they do more and more of them off-site nowadays and put eyes on records and spend whatever amount of time they need to for uh to look at the records and then they go through a complex methodology of rating you in several different factors ultimately to come down to one of three safety ratings satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory and they do this at the direction of Congress this is in in their enabling legislation where Congress has said that the FMCSA has to have a system or process in place for measuring the safety Fitness of motor carriers essentially and so this has historically been the way that they have done it and but I think it's important to note that safety ratings are distinct from CSA scores and I think some folks get those conflated so maybe run through kind of the distinction what's the difference with CSA scores versus safety ratings well you're right and and that's always been the wait aren't people are like aren't they the same you know when that becomes that classic which leads to a conversation certainly probably more time than we had today but you know safety Fitness determined as you said comes from that compliance review right and that compliance review unfortunately doesn't touch everybody um in fact we have carrier members that probably have drivers that were born after their last compliance review they've got reviews that were still in the 90s if you will and and so in saying that you know it does take a lot to send somebody out to put eyes on what that is and that safety Fitness determination is exactly that CSA is a whole nother ball game right it is involves roadside inspections and what have you actual boots on the ground roadside type stuff that they're pulling over looking at the truck and judging and putting the performance on the scores that are happening at the side of the road or actual performance as that truck is going down the roadways if you will so entire two entirely different measurements the question becomes and again we can probably sit here and poke holes in just about all of them um do they figure out a way to marry them together I think that was their first initial thought process in 2016 which didn't work you know TCA was not in favor of that then um we'll still poke holes in CSA now even with the the new CSA um and I'm dating myself here I remember when it was CSA 2010 and first talked about and and so we'll poke holes in it again and continue to do so because it's probably not the best way to go about doing it um and that's at the same point you guys both know there's a difference between compliance and actual safety they're not the same category they're they're two entirely different subjects in its entirety compliance does not always equal safety in in vice versa so that becomes the big caveat is where do we go from here I think the oldest safety rating I've ever seen you mentioned 90s I think the oldest one I've seen recently was like an 87 or 86 safety rating uh which is just crazy I saw a few of them just when this rule came out I decided to just start looking and I was like yep 90s 90s 90s sit there like really is this really what's going on right now so that becomes the big kicker the increase in regulated carriers I mean that's something that plays a huge factor in this conversation just because with the FMCSA having around 1100 employees and there being 700 000 plus regulated carriers I mean they have to find a way to escalate those carriers that have problematic scores uh in in the defense of the FMCSA a little bit I mean they have to figure out a way to do this because with 1100 employees there's no way that they can touch even remotely close to enough what's the number is it Dave you may know what what percentage of the regulated carriers have a safety rating it's like less than two percent isn't it I I think it is in fact I think in 2019 they only did safety compliance reviews and two percent of the industry well an industry that has what 550 000 560 000 motor carriers that's not a lot of motor carriers to touch in one year there needs to be a better way to do it and there's Avenues I know as I said earlier somebody poked the bear at FMCSA I mean they're even talking about a a carry proficiency Examination for new entrant carriers and is this kind of a caveat to incorporate into this is is there a glue that attaches these things all together so that they can touch base with new carriers that are getting into the industry rather than the new entrance audit process that they again fell behind because they just don't have enough manpower to do so so is there proficiency we should do Dave is we should we when they release that proficiency exam I think we get all three of us together on a live show and take it and see who can score the highest I bet you guys score the highest so my money's on you guys I think that'd be fun uh so anyway so okay so that's kind of the background of safety ratings and one of the big things as aside from FMCSA not being able to uh audit any significant percentage of motor carriers each year the other thing about safety ratings that can be problematic is that they are really just a snapshot of that carrier's compliance as of the date of the audit it's it's essentially stale the day after the audit's Complete because it's looking backwards at records that they had available on the date of the audit so if they've made any improvements or or if they have have slipped in their compliance efforts after that audit that that safety rating has nothing to say about what has happened after the audit so I think that's one of the big concerns at least that's what the fmcs says anprm suggested is as one of the big concerns is that's more of a snapshot whereas CSA scores as you mentioned Dave is more I kind of like to view it more as like a moving picture a more up-to-date look at the motor carriers compliance efforts as judge by roadside inspections primarily so that that's really the distinction but to your point Dave the question is is the solution to the safety Fitness determination issue to meld the two systems together are we at a place where we feel comfortable enough with CSA scores to really marry the two so that we are essentially issuing safety ratings based on CSA scores and I know that was The Proposal in 2016. um and so maybe if you can give us a rundown of of that 2016 rule-making effort because we had we had progressed to a notice of proposed rulemaking back then right yeah in fact it was one in which they wanted to just label carriers unfit right it was just you wanted a carrier to be late if you weren't in compliance or or weren't have good safety practices they wanted to throw that unfit label at you and nothing else and and it became one of those situations as you know we have the three now you have satisfactory conditional unsatisfactory so if you were given an unfit wasn't that the death blow so to speak and and were you shutting down your doors and who wants to do business with a carrier that's unfit to do business and again this goes back um to 2016 so you're you're calling on my memory which is foggy at best but at the same time it's one of those situations that it probably was not the best direction to go with and I think FMCSA even realized that because here we are and I'm doing the math here but seven years later trying to have the same conversation albeit a little bit differently they're looking for more input at the start of the game because it's an advance notice they're they're literally just trying to get a bullseye on what that conversation looks like and there's a lot of things out there that can go into what that carrier safety performance looks like and and where does it go from here becomes that question when it comes to filing comments on what it is that they're looking for or what it is what can industry do to provide a better idea of a path going forward which is the nature of one of those Advanced notices yeah that's an important Point uh is that this is just an advanced notice of proposed rule making the FMCSA is looking for industry feedback which we are strongly encourage anybody listening to this go in submit your comments give your thoughts we've we've been accused of whining about this uh this amprm including by some former FMCSA officials and I want to make it very clear that we plan to submit our own comments with our own suggestions of how this should should run we did so in 2016. I remember like it's yesterday because I just went back and read my comments from the 2016 uh rule making and we offered a ton of suggestions back then of how we think this should play out and that that rule making was ultimately withdrawn the FMCSA decided not to move forward with it uh largely from what I could tell because of the concerns that were raised about the reliability of the CSA data and some of the other concerns that we've heard over the years and that we've shared over the years with the agency but you mentioned new CSA talk to us about new CSA and why this may put a little Wrinkle In things this time around well I mentioned new CSA and I do so in a manner of you know the changes that they made and and Jared you alluded in this I go out and talk to a lot of groups in front of a lot of people I get a lot of carrier feedback and so the conversations I've had with carriers under new CSA because they've all looked at their preview scores and I've said I've asked them I said what what do you think of the preview scores what do you think of new CSA and there's some very highly technical answers out there a lot of them include yeah or so be it or doesn't really make much difference you know those very highly technical comments where it doesn't really matter they don't have an opinion on what new says CSA can be or what it does for them so um I think they're kind of sitting there it doesn't change the fact of what was wrong with CSA is still what was wrong with CSA again and I'm glad they didn't incorporate IRT into it because I would hope you guys would be able to explain it not me because I had no idea how to do it so my my point is is while they they're recommending some changes with the previews and carriers have seen their preview scores it's not like people are jumping for joy saying this is a great fix this is something we really needed certainly you know breaking out the maintenance aspects certainly that is more reflective of what's going on in the industry but at the same point none of these are real game changers none of these are people saying this is the best way to go this is what we've always imagined it no that's not the case it still hasn't changed some of the things that have always been wrong with CSA in the first place and and I'll say I mean we've been a part of several actual D.O.T audits in which you know we're walking in to help this carrier thinking look at these scores this is going to be a difficult situation here and and they end up faring well in in the context of an audit and so had you based strictly fit or unfit on just their scores not their safety management process you know they would have been deemed unfit most likely which kind of leads me to a question here um in a long roundabout way uh there has to be a remediation process with this if you're going to tie CSA scores to the fit or unfit category you have to have a robust remediation process for carriers how do you think that might look I know we don't have details on that but what what would you envision oh man you're asking me to rub the crystal ball here you know I I wish I had a vision on what that looks like you know when that becomes the bigger case in point is you know if you have a carrier that's and deemed unsatisfactory what is their what's their path out of purgatory because once they have that deep that issue um who who's going to do business with them in the first place that becomes problem number one um and then keeping them profitable becomes problem number two and let's not forget there's you know we're going back a ways here we're doing so with the 2016 rule making but there's still that Avenue out there that was called Beyond compliance that we used to always talk about you know maybe there's opportunity to incorporate some of those you know we've got comments due on AED today to the agency on that rulemaking is their opportunity to incorporate some of that technology that carriers are using outside of compliance outside of safety requirements to improve the safety performance of those fleets maybe now is the time for that opportunity opportunity to incorporate some of these things showing that a safer carrier is the one that's using these Technologies outside of the need from the federal motor their safety regulations so there's a lot of things that go into this when you look at it and and what does coming out of purgatory look like how do they get out of purgatory all of these questions certainly come to mind based on the fact of this is a wide open playing field right now I've always said carriers should never be afraid to have their safety Fitness determined they should insist to be determined correctly and that becomes the very process yeah and that those become the answer is not is not the data queue system I know that much because and to your point Dave you said it I think perfectly which is the changes that they have proposed to CSA which haven't taken effect yet they're all well and good I don't have any problem with the changes that they propose necessarily any substantial problems with it but it doesn't get to the heart of the issues that we were concerned with with CSA that caused us concern with tying a motor care safety rating to them namely my biggest concern is the due process issue because if we're going to tie a carrier safety rating to their CSA scores which are premise largely on roadside inspections how are they how is the carrier to challenge erroneous violations in from a roadside inspection that could shut them down if they get an unfit rating because of those CSA scores and right now the answer is data queue system and the data Q system is is just it's not the right solution it offers no due process no meaningful due process to the carrier the the appeals are determined by the same state agency that issued the violations to begin with a lot of times the very same officer and uh it's just if we're going to have a system where we could potentially shut a motor carrier down we cannot tie it to a a an appeal system where the appeals are adjudicated by the same state agency that issued them in the first place my thoughts no and you're not wrong you're basically asking the state agency to say at that point yeah we were wrong um and that becomes the big issue is how often is that going to happen you know my son tell me all the time Dad you are you're always right aren't you I'm like every time you every day you wake up I am but it's that same basic principle you know you're asking that state agency to say yep I was wrong in doing that and that doesn't that's not always going to happen you know you're not going to go against themselves and at the same point you know you have different levels of carriers who may be better at data queuing than other carriers could be and you know there's always a different story if they had an appeals board or some some kind of FMCSA oversight where you could appeal to the next level but we've we've sued the FMCSA in the past on this issue specifically saying we should be able to challenge these in court because the the FMCSA is not stepping in and it's leaving erroneous data out there on its systems and carriers are being judged by that erroneous data and the courts have refused to step in so I think that's the thing that has to be taken care of uh first and foremost if we're going to even contemplate this is figuring out better way for carriers to have due process in this uh in this system and and based on my experience how how hard certain carriers are willing to fight to protect that safety rating and if you're going to escalate even more motor carriers into that Purgatory as you call it Dave I like that that could result in a ton a ton of work a title weight of work for the FMCSA which is already basically saying we can't keep up with the compliance reviews that we're trying to do at this point yeah uh uh let's see let's see what Jack has to say here from uh from FMCSA former FM FMC say recently retired congrats Jack um at this point yeah sipping on a a nice cool beverage hopefully uh at a public meeting with cvsa there was discussion of FMCSA taking over the appeal process specific to data cues I would love to see that oh yes that's what it should be please yeah please do that Jack uh exert your influence over that and make that happen please but anyway I think I think that would alleviate some of my concerns with tying them to to CSA scores if we had a better appellate system because we still we still have with safety ratings now there's an appeals process uh that goes along with it there's actually two processes available to carriers that get a downgraded safety rating you have the 385-15 appeal process which is essentially almost like a court proceeding you file your appeal with the fmcsa's headquarters it gets reviewed by the chief safety officer which was Jack in the past and uh and ruled on you get to submit your briefs you get to submit your evidence and there's actually due process and then there's the 385 17 process which is a safety rating upgrade based on corrective actions you're essentially admitting the violations but you have taken corrective actions to fix those problems and you're begging the FMCSA for mercy and so I imagine that whatever system we get eventually and this is one of the questions I know FMCSA is asking is do we need to make changes to those 385 15 and 385 517 processes I think you probably do back in 2016 if I remember correctly they were envisioning a a corrective action process similar to what we have now but they were going to make the motor carrier as a condition to upgrading their rating from unfit to fit they were going to make them sign a consent agreement essentially a contract with FMCSA where they agreed to keep their CSA scores below the intervention thresholds over a certain amount of time and if they didn't then that unfit rating would come back to life so it's things like those that just really caused me a lot of heartburn but I guess we'll just have to submit our comments on that point and hopefully plays out for the best yeah and notably that appeals process is in my experience really rare to actually go through that process it's most often times that Safety Management plan that the motor carrier would submit which is actually a whole lot of work on the motor carriers part a lot of motor carriers don't understand how much work that actually is to go through that process and to do well Jack Jack says no more influence oh man oh too bad Jack uh all right so that's kind of the current status of things I know there were several questions being asked in the A and PRM if anybody's interested in checking out what exactly the questions are we've got an article on it uh trucksafe.com you can see I think they're asking a dozen or so questions um I wanted to ask you Dave how do you uh you know we've kind of already talked about this in pieces but I'm wondering if you have thoughts on a better way to assess a larger swath of motor carrier safety Fitness if it's not just CSA scores do you have you given thought to a better way that we can assess safety Fitness other than CSA scores uh you know and there's got to be there has to be caveats in there that truly have their roots in safety right and and I alluded to some aspects of it certainly Beyond compliance does have an issue what is the carrier doing to indeed make themselves safer I mean compliance is one thing safety isn't entirely a different Beast altogether so do they have cameras on their trucks you know forward-facing cameras at Best inward facing cameras which are starting to get into the industry now for those that have put him on there but you know what other pieces of Technology as I said we're we're in the midst of a rule making on aeb but there are carriers that have had aeb on their trucks for for years now I mean where are the bonus points for those so while they're in the business of catching people to rate them safety how does that incorporate into that performance or that safety Fitness and where is that blue ribbon safety operator that kind of operates on our roadways today how come we're not highlighting some of those things I think you know with the bad you still got to look for the good too you got to highlight the good players as well and I think this is that opportunity to really incorporate that yep performance is one thing and and what you see at the roadside and what those inspectors are seeing versus the equipment that they're pulling over and taking a look at I get that and I understand that and that should play a role in it because it is reflective of what's going on on the roads as we speak right now but there also has to be aspects of safety management practices and safety culture Incorporated to that which shows in some of the technology that carriers are putting on their trucks right now Brian's asking is there a thought of making anything less than a full audit to get a rating yeah I mean that would be that's kind of what we talked about it would essentially be uh how how can that's what the FMCSA is asking essentially how can we do this how can we assign a safety rating without having to do the full-blown audit the most obvious way is tying it to CSA data which is again what they tried to do in 2016. um and so I guess we'll we'll just have to wait and see how this plays out we're coming out of that coveted environment where they were doing the focused audits too that were not on site full-blown on-site compliance reviews they're doing focused audits so does that play a role into it so that they can touch more people in less time to basically come up with a better system but I think there's a whole bunch of things that need to be included in this type of program if they're going to paint that picture let's paint that picture and do so in the most accurate way possible so that you are seeing the entire safety performance of the carrier question and and speaking of those off-site audits the remote audits that the FMCSA certainly been ramping up have you noticed in your membership that you've had any of your members getting on-site audits or have you have you been hearing that it's all off-site or remote audits for the most part the ones I've been hearing have been all remote audits I haven't heard of any um doing a compliance review coming out and visiting them and again and some of these folks haven't had a review and 30 years so it becomes a question of what's going on next where do they go from there and I'm not saying all sudden you have to start going down that road and visiting everybody with an expiration date no when they don't have the manpower to do that but the reality is is there's got to be a better way and certainly some of those focused reviews are probably one of those ways they can do that yeah but it is important to remember that that CSA is essentially the prioritization system that's what it's intended to do it's intended to float to the top the worst performing Motor Carrier so that then they could be targeted for an audit and then ultimately potentially a safety rating uh and and that's kind of the whole idea is if we don't have the Manpower as the agency to get out and audit a significant number of motor carriers we need some way to prioritize the worst offending so that we can go out and audit them and CSA has always kind of been that prioritization system at least since 2010 and uh and you know there have been studies over the years including the National Academy of Sciences study that was just recently released on whether how effective it is at actually doing that and that's kind of what FMCSA is addressing with their recent proposed changes to CSA um and trying to you know always iterate with it and make it more effective at doing that job so I think there is still room for that type of system where we've got a way to prioritize the worst offending motor carriers and then do an audit of the of the worst performing and get them a safety rating I don't think it necessarily has to move entirely over to a system that's based entirely on CSA I think there still has to be some room to put eyes on the motor carriers that we're potentially going to assign a safety rating because you know we all know here but maybe folks don't realize the the consequences of a of a unsatisfactory safety rating or unfit as it would be proposed in 2016 is that your entire fleet gets shut down it's it's a fleet-wide shutdown order you are prohibited from operating and so you know doing doing something that extreme where we're going to potentially shut down a carrier based on CSA data which studies and folks in the industry have have shown over the years is not all that reliable there are problems with it Brian here is mentioning one of them which we have heard a lot about over the years it's a disparity in enforcement from state to state so depending on where certain carriers operate could show a difference in the sheer number of violations you know that's one that's been raised since 2010 this idea that carrier if I'm a carrier that has a lot of operations in Indiana then my unsafe driving basic is going to be relatively higher than carriers in other countries because Indiana has so many speeding violations relative to other states it shouldn't it's not fair to treat that carrier differently because they happen to be in a state where their drivers get stopped more frequently and get written up for speeding violations in other other states so it's just little issues like that when you start to add them up that cause the concern I think from my perspective yeah you do need an equal playing field depending on the state that you're operating in in order for this to truly work you may have seen one of those Freight heat Maps or whatnot pre-csa and then it changes where the freight obviously goes around Indiana um so that they're avoiding what I call a CSA aggressive state so that because not every state is the same and yeah you highlight that very issue States states are not the same when they report some of these things some are more aggressive than others and that's you know one of those geographical biases that is CSA and certainly comes into play when you're looking at some of these systems and interestingly that FMCSA specifically declined to take any action on that issue with the CSA proposed changes they specifically say in their notice where they are proposing changes tweaks to the CSA program that they don't that they're not doing anything with the disparate treatment among the states I can't remember what their rationale was for that but I remember that distinctly yep and even Jack just said in the chat says I'm reading it too there's a huge range of disparity in both inspection violation and added service violations across all the states so yeah without a doubt it exists there's no no doubt about that in my mind it's been around forever I think everybody knows about it so the question is is how do you put something like this in a safety Fitness determination when we've already just talked about the way CSA comes up short and don't get me wrong you know there's bad apples in our industry and I think we all can admit that we've all heard the horror stories of that and how do we get rid of those players becomes the biggest question not necessarily penalize the great ones but get rid of the bad ones and that's the angle we got to look at when it comes from this because we all know a ton of great carriers out there that are operating on the roads today we need to continually put them on the pedestal and get the Bad actors out of the industry yeah I I think you're exactly right with whatever the solution we ultimately land on it needs to take into account that Beyond compliance it's something we've talked about as you said for decades at this point giving credits giving carriers credit where credit is due for the things that they do that goes beyond and above and beyond what the regulations require of them because that's what we're doing with safety Fitness we're trying to trying to punish the unsafe carriers so it just seems natural that we should be giving some credit to carriers that go beyond what they are required to make the roads more safe and we're just currently not doing that she has something else yeah I was going to ask uh since this anprm dropped last week and Dave have you started receiving comments uh from your members and if yes what kind of hot button questions are they touching on well the comments I've gotten are they really coming back out with this right now I mean it's I thought this was a debt issue and the one comment I've had it was it's been on the agenda for ever I think they're finally just getting around to doing something with it um so yeah it has we haven't dove into the specifics yet of that I know we're going to be doing a little bit of that at our fall business meeting here in Washington DC the timeline is sets up perfectly to discuss this um so we'll have that conversations with members live and in person but I think most are just what are the chances of them really moving forward with this and I you know I the only thing that we have to go on is past performance always equals future performance in the past one shows that in 2016 they weren't able to get it right here we are 2023 they're coming out with that again and does this really what's that Avenue to go forward and certainly there are shortcomings which we've already discussed and those shortcomings still exist they existed back then they exist today and does that change and are they willing to move with some of those other caveats to start looking at this I you know it's anybody's ball game at this it's an advanced notice so it's very early in the stage right it's kind of trying to get to that Bullseye and this is throwing the dart and at least trying to hit the wall not necessarily the dart board so it's one of those situations just to try to get more and better information what industry's thinking on this yeah yeah for those who aren't familiar with the process so this is an advance notice of proposed rulemaking they're essentially just soliciting public input on kind of what are some ideas that the public has if they the next step in the process would be for them to you know review all the comments that they receive and then potentially put together a notice of proposed rulemaking where they outline specifically what they're thinking in terms of a rule change potential rule change then they would open up for comments again uh and then they would evaluate those comments and eventually if they feel like they they can progress to the next stage they would issue a final Rule and that's just kind of how the regulatory process tends to play out but like you said Dave we're very early on here it's still uh still necessary that we have these conversations and they are looking for our input so I have no doubt that TCA and you Dave will be putting together your your comments you'll be working with your members to come up with some ideas and putting together your comments to file with the agency again I recommend anybody listening if you have any thoughts on this be sure to get your comments in because this is how we this is our way to affect change with the regulations that that may be problematic to us so it's important that we participate in the process Dave we are running out of time we really appreciate you joining us I really enjoyed the conversation a lot to look forward to here with this potential rule making and we'll be interested in watching uh your thoughts on it and and what you have to say about it here in the future where can folks learn more about what you guys are doing over at TCA or or get in touch with you if they have any questions if they can find everything they want to know at truckload.org or just follow Jared wherever he's speaking usually I'm speaking as well so at the same point we'll bump into each other from time to time but yeah anything they want to know about TCA and what we're working on they can see right at truckload.org right on our website awesome thanks so much for joining us today really appreciate it thanks thanks for having me guys I appreciate it all right take care all right well uh we'll have to see I like all the most things that we talk about it's kind of a waiting game at this point you have to wait and see how it plays out but uh we will continue to put together some ideas uh on on the topic and I know we're going to work on uh preparing our own comments if anybody's interested in teaming up with us in some capacity to put together comments for you feel free to reach out uh you can get in touch with us over at trucksafe.com uh anything else we need to talk about here yeah good show uh appreciate everybody who tuned in and participated our prior episodes over at trucksafelive.com you can you can subscribe to the podcast whatever you happen to get your podcast and look out for our next shows not sure what our next show is going to be on but it'll be in a couple weeks probably uh best way to keep up to date on is either trucksafelife.com or subscribing to our newsletter to get updates about future shows so anyway thanks for watching really appreciate it see you guys next time thank you

Event Completed

Tuesday, September 5, 2023 at 4:16 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube