Episode Summary
In Episode 28 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jared Childress are joined by Dave Heller, Senior Vice President of Safety and Government Affairs for the Truckload Carriers Association (TCA), to discuss a significant regulatory development: the FMCSA's Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) soliciting public comments on a potential overhaul of its Safety Fitness Determination process. This is a topic of considerable consequence for motor carriers, as a carrier's safety rating — currently classified as satisfactory, conditional, or unsatisfactory — can have fleet-wide operational implications, including the possibility of a full shutdown order for those deemed unfit. The hosts and guest also briefly address the FMCSA's separate and unexpected move to solicit waiver requests from its meal and rest break preemption ruling, which could once again expose interstate carriers to California and Washington state labor laws.
The discussion provides important context on the distinction between safety ratings and CSA scores, two systems that are often conflated but measure carrier performance in fundamentally different ways. Safety ratings result from compliance reviews conducted by FMCSA investigators, while CSA scores are derived primarily from roadside inspection data. A central concern raised throughout the episode is the FMCSA's proposal to tie safety ratings more directly to CSA scores — an approach the agency attempted in 2016 but ultimately withdrew following significant industry pushback and Congressional scrutiny. The hosts and Heller identify several persistent shortcomings with CSA data that make this linkage problematic, including disparate enforcement practices across states, the limited percentage of carriers that receive a compliance review in any given year (estimated at around two percent), and the fact that existing safety ratings can be decades old, rendering them effectively meaningless as a current measure of carrier safety.
A recurring theme in the conversation is the inadequacy of the current DataQ appeal system as a mechanism for due process if safety ratings are to be based on CSA data. The hosts argue that allowing carriers to challenge erroneous roadside violations through a process adjudicated by the same state agency that issued the violations is fundamentally insufficient — particularly if those CSA scores could ultimately determine whether a carrier is permitted to operate. Heller echoed this concern, noting that expecting a state agency to rule against its own officers is an unrealistic standard. The group expressed optimism about a suggestion raised in the live chat from a recently retired FMCSA official that the agency may consider taking over the DataQ appeal process, which the hosts agreed would be a meaningful step toward a more equitable system.
The hosts and Heller also discuss what a better Safety Fitness Determination framework might look like, emphasizing that compliance and safety are not synonymous. Heller advocates for incorporating "beyond compliance" factors — such as the voluntary adoption of advanced safety technologies like automatic emergency braking, forward-facing cameras, and other fleet safety tools — into any carrier safety assessment. The group agrees that an effective system should not only identify and remove bad actors from the industry but also recognize and reward carriers that go above and beyond regulatory requirements to improve road safety.
Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to actively participate in the ANPRM comment process, as this is the industry's primary opportunity to shape how the rulemaking develops before a formal proposal is issued. Comments can be submitted directly to the FMCSA's docket, and Trucksafe Consulting intends to file its own detailed comments with constructive recommendations. Those interested in collaborating on comment submissions can reach out through trucksafe.com. Additional resources, including a written breakdown of the ANPRM, are available on the Trucksafe website, and the prior episode covering the meal and rest break preemption issue is available at trucksafelive.com.