Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 29 - The future of DataQs

Thursday, September 21, 2023 at 8:43 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 29 - The future of DataQs

About This Event

We’re joined by Rob Carpenter and Brian Runnels to discuss the FMCSA’s DataQs system and the agency’s recent proposal to stand up an independent appeals board for challenges to roadside inspection violations.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 29 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Brian Runnels, VP of Safety for Reliance Partners, and Rob Carpenter of Carpenter Compliance to discuss FMCSA's recent notice of its intention to establish an independent appeals board for the DataQs system. The topic is particularly timely given ongoing discussions about potentially tying carrier safety ratings to roadside inspection data, which would make the accuracy and fairness of that data more consequential than ever for motor carriers. The hosts provide an overview of the DataQs system, explaining that it allows motor carriers, drivers, and other stakeholders to challenge roadside inspection violations, crash data, and adjudicated citations recorded in FMCSA's information systems. A central criticism of the current system is its lack of due process: appeals are typically reviewed by the same state agency that issued the original violation, creating an inherent conflict of interest. Success rates are low, estimated at roughly 38 to 65 percent depending on the category, and carriers who lack supporting evidence face near-certain denial. The hosts share firsthand examples of meritorious appeals being rejected, including cases involving personal vehicle use mistakenly treated as interstate commerce and emergency exemptions inconsistently applied across states. The discussion turns to FMCSA's proposal, which would allow certain previously denied DataQs challenges to be escalated to an independent appeals board, but only for matters involving significant legal interpretation or FMCSA policy and guidance. The hosts express cautious optimism about the proposal while noting its limited scope as a key concern. Brian Runnels raises the additional complication that proposed SMS scoring changes, which would collapse the current one-to-ten severity weight scale down to either one or two points, could render the adjudicated citation pathway largely ineffective, potentially eliminating one of the more reliable tools carriers currently have for reducing violation weights. Rob Carpenter emphasizes that without broader access to independent review, the proposal may fall well short of delivering genuine due process. For fleet safety professionals, the hosts offer several actionable takeaways. Carriers should file DataQs challenges promptly after violations are uploaded to the system, as delays reduce the likelihood of success. Challenges should only be filed when supported by concrete evidence, as factual disputes without documentation are almost never resolved in the carrier's favor. When a driver receives both a roadside inspection violation and a corresponding state citation, pursuing adjudication of that citation through the state court system remains one of the most effective strategies available under the current framework. Carriers should also ensure that maintenance-related inspection violations are matched to driver vehicle inspection reports, that those reports are retained for one year, and that corrected inspection reports are returned to the issuing state within 15 days. Finally, the hosts encourage carriers and industry stakeholders to submit comments to FMCSA during the 60-day comment period on the proposed appeals board, as public input remains one of the primary ways the industry can influence the outcome of these regulatory changes.

Full Transcript

thank you foreign foreign everything everybody thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you hey everyone welcome to episode 29 of truck safe live the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs uh today we're talking about data cues so if you are a nerd like me and my guest today and you follow uh dot safety and compliance news then you're undoubtedly aware of uh the news from late last week FMCSA publishing a notice about the potential changes to the that that accused system and uh an independent appeals board that they are thinking about standing up so it would be a big change if that were to take effect so we're going to talk about that today I got a couple great guests good friends on with me today before we get there a few things going on um last chance to join us in Orlando Florida October 12th and 13th if you want to join us for our Fleet compliance boot camp uh We've sold out once and we opened up a few additional seats so we've got like one or two seats left for this this is our two-day conference where we dig deep into DOT regulations and uh talk about best practices for managing an effective Fleet Safety and compliance program so like I said October 12th and 13th in Orlando Florida if you want to join us you can check out the details over at trucksafebootcamp.com we hope to see you there uh if you're not a member of our truck say Fleet compliance Network I recommend you join that this is our online social network for Fleet Safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also have access to all of our DOT related content our articles our videos our podcast you can check that out over at trucksafenetwork.com we've also got an app in the app store in the Google Play store which you can find just by searching truck safe in those app stores and you'll find it so we hope to see you there um and then lastly truck safe related I would just encourage you to subscribe to our newsletter if you're not already trucksafe.com subscribe we are sending out uh pretty regular newsletters breaking down all of the um all of the regulatory related news that comes out some research articles on meal and rest break changes safety rating uh potential changes to the safety rating methodology changes to the SMS there's a lot going on right now in in the dot regulatory world so we've kind of got articles on all of those topics and the best way to keep up to date on that and everything else we've got going on at truck safe is through our newsletter again trucksafe.com subscribe couple things going on in the industry safety and compliance related that are worth mentioning before we dig into today's topic I saw a couple of Articles this week uh first up FMCSA has announced 80 million dollars in Grant Awards including a 65 increase in funding for truck parking projects across the U.S much needed investment uh most would say um according to Transportation secretary Pete bootage there are countless ways to thank America's hard-working truck drivers during National truck driver Appreciation Week and we are doing so by addressing a serious issue that consistently ranks as one of their highest concerns crispier ATA president and CEO added that the funding being announced will help to alleviate a shortage of truck driving spaces that too often puts drivers in a no-win situation so um hopefully that will manifest itself into additional parking I don't it's frankly it's probably just a drop in the bucket but uh something is better than nothing obviously so hopefully that gets put to good use and we start to see uh this issue being taken care of sooner rather than later all right second up uh government accountability office this this was an interesting article I I read this week uh the federal government accountability office GAO issued a report where they are telling FMCSA that the agency needs to release carrier complaint data they say specifically FMCSA does not make public any information on complaints against truck companies bus companies or electronic logging device providers as a result FMCSA may be missing the opportunity to improve transparency and collaboration with industry partners um so that's an interesting slap on the wrist from the GAO to FMCSA about kind of their complaint hotline or website that they have available this is where anybody can go and Lodge a complaint against usually against trucking companies and this is what we see this is the database that we see sometimes prompts a DOT audit sometimes drivers go in there file a complaint about their motor carrier you know carrier XYZ forced me to violate the hours of service rules and drive beyond my limits and sometimes those complaints uh will be investigated and then could lead to a an audit for that particular carrier but today those complaints are not made public for everyone to see they are just investigated by FMCSA so the GAO is weighing in here saying that they think that the FMCSA needs to make those complaints public so I just thought that was an interesting read not sure if that's going to go anywhere if I had to guess probably not that would be my best guess there's probably not going to be any action taken on that recommendation uh based on past experience with these types of things but we'll just wait and see anyway all right that's enough about us enough about other topics let's segue into today's topic which again is the future of the data queue system as I mentioned late last week which is mid-september 2023 if you're watching later the FMCSA surprised us a bit by issuing a notice of its intention to stand up some type of an independent appeals board to review data Q's appeals filed by carriers drivers or other stakeholders that get denied in their initial reviews we and others in the industry have long criticized the static queue system as a poor substitute for due process as most appeals filed through that system are reviewed and ruled on by the very same agency and often the same officer that wrote the violations to begin with obviously a little biased there to say the least this is particularly a timely topic now with talks underway by FMCSA to potentially tie a motor carrier's safety rating to its roadside inspection data that was the topic of our last truck safe live show if you missed that be sure to check that out so anyway today we're talking about the fmcsa's recent notice of its intention to stand up some kind of an independent appeals board for the data Q system I'm excited to be joined once again by a couple of good friends compliance gurus Mr Brian runnels VP of safety for Reliance partners and Rob Carpenter owner of carpenter compliance welcome guys hey guys how are you doing all right Rob is your mic working nope it's not working you're gonna you're gonna figure that out come on Rob Brian's gonna have to steal the show here I think we're good there we go we're good it's uh it's this fancy Mackie um thing that I don't know how to use so because causing you trouble causing you trouble well hey thanks guys really appreciate you joining me as always um these guys have all been on a few past episodes with me so go back and check out those prior episodes talked about a lot of different compliance related topics uh today we are talking about data cues oh by the way both these guys are going to be at our boot camp uh they're going to be talking on on different topics so they're going to be with us down there in Orlando you guys are ready to go for that trip yep I am I am ready to go Orlando's never a bad place to go unless it's 107 degrees Yeah the plane rides have a tendency to to be a little tedious but you know everybody's gotta go down and see Mickey Mouse yeah for sure Rob last time you and I were there I think it was like 110 or something wasn't it yeah it was a little bit much oh I took my daughter there on her birthday I think it was obvious second week and it was it was I was mad the whole time it was raining you know it's not gonna be like that though for the boots perfect weather um I'm predicting uh which I can do just about as well as the weather people um but uh yeah it's gonna be great I'm really looking forward to it we got a lot in store uh so hope to see you all there but anyway so moving back to today's topic we're talking about data cues um so starting off for folks who may not be familiar or all that familiar with the data queue system I know between among us three we're constantly in the system on behalf of our clients and uh filing these types of appeals but I wanted to start with some background on the data queue system what it is uh who it's for how it works so maybe you guys can break that down whoever wants to go first brand you want to draw strolls well I think you know when when they put the data queue system in to challenge the you know initially it was the violations um looking for the simple violations that would come up or the the simple mistakes that would come up maybe it was a wrong DOT number maybe it was a wrong company name um you know violations that were put under a wrong code you know initially I think that's where it started from but as it's grown and then they added the accidents or the crashes I hate that word accidents I have to add the crashes um and the adjudicated citations you know that it's grown quite a bit since its initial conception but you know we still got a ways to go and and I think the steps are taken now is is great but that's where that's where it all started from Rob how do you tend to use the data queue system uh or have you over the over the years oh I typically use it it usually is an inspection related deal not a crash related deal as much but um I think one way or the other you're you're a likelihood of success isn't always that great I think what is it like 65 at the most and 40 40. I haven't been able to find those numbers have you seen those numbers somewhere and success rate on data cues yeah I actually read it I guess it was maybe a week or two ago when we first you know threw this up for you we were coming on here I found it I want to say it was like 38 on the low end 40 for uh inspections 38 on crashes and uh 64 and 65 which was kind of odd for them to both be the same range for both inspection and uh crash related almost that accident but I didn't want to hit Brian lose his mind but the uh no I I typically use it more for violations and it's not always it's not as much drivers but I have had some driver but it's mostly most of the carriers wanted to get information taken off yeah yeah so overall I mean the data Q system has been around since the start of CSA it is essentially the the online system available to mainly motor carriers but really anybody to challenge data that gets put in the fmcsa's information systems primarily inspection violation data that comes from roadside inspections so if I'm a motor carrier one of my drivers gets tagged with an hour as a service violation and I've got some reason to believe that the officer got that violation wrong maybe they misinterpreted a rule or maybe that driver was short haul and shouldn't have had a a logging violation I can go in log in through my data queues account find that particular violation and then submit a challenge to it explaining the basis for my appeal and then potentially get that violation taken off my account if I am successful with that appeal but you both have already kind of hinted at some of the problems that we've seen over the years frankly Rob I'm I'm surprised that those numbers are as high as they are with the success rate I would say having filed these hundreds of these over the last decade or so my success rate is nowhere near the the 48 or whatever it was on the low end it's just the the fundamental problem with the system as I see it and I'd love to get your thoughts on this has been the fact the way that it's administered so right now the FMCSA has kind of taking a hands-off approach to the system altogether from the start they push it off onto their state Partners so state law enforcement agencies whoever wrote up the violation in the first instance is usually going to be the very same agency that's reviewing the appeal that gets filed so if the state Indiana State Police wrote up that hours of service violations and I file an appeal through the data accused account it goes right back to the Indiana State Police to rule on my appeal rather than FMCSA even though this is an FMCSA system so as I said at the start quite a bit of bias there but uh what are your thoughts on kind of the the problems that we've seen over the years with data queues I think that's the biggest one is the due process piece it kind of I've compared this to uh I know it's a bad comparison but dcse uh CDL license suspension so if you forget to pay child support one month and all of a sudden you don't know it you you just don't have a license anymore um so it's that just that lack of due due process to where you you know can actually argue your piece and uh and have an unbiased review of it and I did go back and look and it's out of 47 000 inspections uh 64 were successful by motor carriers 45 over what over what time period was this uh was it last year 2019 to 2022. okay so a couple years there I'm sorry I cut you off so out of those how many were successful 64 and 45 64 for uh motor carriers and 45 for drivers and 57 for carrier service providers and law firms that's for uh violations specific Not Crash so crash is not much different um but just having that bad due process piece you know it's bad when you have you know law enforcement a gives you a ticket and then basically you're going in front of the law enforcement a to get that ticket reviewed it just never made a lot of sense to me you're not I don't see how you have a non-bias process there yeah got some comments here let's see what we got yeah the other one that I would oh you could go ahead and do that one uh let's see Silas says I worked for a motor carrier in North Carolina one of my drivers got hit head on by Passenger car that hydroplaned there were no tickets or citations given to my driver which category do you think I should use I believe the category exists so there should be um you should be able to do it on that basis yeah so I think it's that isn't it the cross Center Line category I think that would be the one where it would be most applicable but the problem with that category and one of the main criticisms of the crash preventability demonstration determination program as it exists currently is that those categories are so narrow in scope so I think on that cross Center Line one if I'm remembering correctly if there is evidence that the the entire car wasn't across the center line in other words if only if only the front of it was across the center line and not the back of it then I've seen those types of Crash preventability determination program uh appeals denied because the car wasn't all the way across the center line so stupid stuff like that where it shouldn't matter it turns out it does matter that's one of the many reasons why the data queue system is not all that useful as it exists currently um so but Silas I think that would be a cross Center Line uh if you if you've got some kind of evidence to prove that the car or the other car was all the way across the center line you're going to be better off ideally you'd have some kind of um you know camera footage but if not you're going to run into a a an issue that we're all familiar with here on this call which is you know do you have enough evidence to support whatever appeal you're filing that's one of the things I found over the years filing these things is that if if it's if it comes down to your word against the officers or against whoever it is whose data that you're challenging you're going to lose that battle almost 100 of the time you got to have some evidence to back it up has that been your guys's experience yeah and I think I think it's safe to say that you have to be able to self-reflect and discern and say hey we have a real evidence-based argument here to file this and if you don't and you realize in that self-reflection that it's a frivolous one there's no point wasting your time because even even the evidence back was don't have a high likelihood of success you're still probably going to end up following it again for a second attempt but uh I'd like I said I wouldn't I wouldn't go crazy with the system if you don't have an Evidence base argument yeah to tag on to what Rob said about the what the driver's license uh being suspended the other one that you know carriers have no recourse on I mean now the alerts are happening through the Clearinghouse but you know when a driver would go apply for another job and fail a drug test and then come back to work and then get pulled over because he was denied in the Clearinghouse and the carrier no there's no way to challenge anything like that you know it's one of those was he denied when the officer spoke to him on the roadside yep okay so be it that's it there's nothing you can do so yeah having some sort of recourse on things like that and what Rob said I I wish those things were there but currently they're not yeah I have had more success you had mentioned early on Brian kind of the Advent of the adjudicated citation option uh to the data queue system so originally I don't know when that was brought on was that in a later Edition or had that been in in since the start you know no that wasn't in the start that I remember I think that so that came on later down the line but before that if you had if if you're challenging a violation from a roadside inspection um then then the data Q system was your way to do it to to potentially get that violation off your scores but with the adjudicated citation option in data cues this is a a process where if your driver in addition to getting the violation on a roadside inspection report if they also happen to get a state citation a ticket a traffic ticket that is associated with that same violation and you go and challenge that you appeal that state citation through the state court system and you Prevail in that state court you get it dismissed or you get it downgraded to a lesser violation and don't have to pay any court costs associated with that if you get that done and then you come back into the data queue system and you file proof that you got that done at the state court level then it is much easier to get it taken off your scores on the dot side of things in other words really at that point if there's a an adjudicated citation and the state has either dismissed it or downgraded it the state agency who is reviewing your data queues really doesn't have any discretion they have to Grant your data accused appeals in that scenario and they have to either take it off your scores completely if it was dismissed by the state or they have to downgrade it to a severity weight of one if it was downgraded by the state to a lesser charge so I've always had a lot more success with that at assuming your driver got a ticket and I know that has become problematic for folks with drivers not with officers understanding that and then not writing up a ticket because they realize that it's going to be worse for the driver and for the carrier than have they given the ticket to begin with has that been your experience yeah we live we live in the state Brandon you and I that um is pretty famous for not writing tickets and you know there there's a lot of violations written but there's not many tickets written here yeah uh yeah the the police the cops don't want to show up in court to to defend their their violations and like I said they know that by not giving a ticket then the possibility of the carrier or the driver getting it taken off their record is much less than it would have been had they been able to adjudicate it with the state so it's frustrating to say the least but if you can if you have a situation where you've got a ticket and you can go get that challenged in state court I think you're much better off even if it's one thing that we would always do a lot of for our clients and I think you guys have done it as well is you know even if even if you don't have a chance of getting it dismissed completely at the state court level a lot of times you could go work with the prosecutor the traffic ticket prosecutor of the state and you can negotiate a deal with the prosecutor and get that violation downgraded to something less than what was originally charged and that's really all you need to get that violation on the dot side of things downgraded to a severity weight of one so we always had quite a bit of success doing that as well so that's something else to keep in mind well I know we're kind of jumping ahead but you know if the the changes to the SMS come through where the points are are you know much more uniform in the way it's either a one-point violation or two if it's out of service something like that those adjudicated citations if they don't change that structure they really don't won't do any good because the one point violation is a one-point violation that turns out I don't think the new review process it has to be something um I don't think that's going to cover that piece I think it has to be some significant matters of legal interpretation for that one that's what I don't like about the new proposal it's like you know how how much are you actually how much of the unbiased issues are you actually solving with that because there's the scope is so limited to that to that review that it's I don't think it's going to make a lot of difference yeah I I I tend to agree with you because a lot of I suspect I haven't seen the data on this and it probably doesn't exist but I said I I expect that the majority of the data queues appeals they get filed are not matters that dot would consider to be significant matters of legal interpretation or interpretation of FMCSA guidance they're probably more often than not a factual dispute the officer says my brakes were out of adjustment but I know they weren't or something to that effect and it's a he said she said type deal I understand why they don't want to take on those types of appeals in whatever kind of board they set up just because then they would just be reviewing every single you know appeal that gets filed so they got to control the line somewhere and uh you know kind of my opinion on it overall is that I would rather have this than nothing at all because right now we have nothing at all it ends with the state States review of the of the data queue but I want to go back real quick so I want to get a fly fight around my face uh Brian's point which was this kind of adjudicated citation um deal with proposed changes to SMS so we had discussed this we had done a show a few months back when FMCSA was first proposing pretty substantial changes to CSA scores and one of the changes that they are proposing is doing away with that one to ten scale of severity weights for violations that get put on a carrier's CSA scores and moving to a vile a severity weight of either one or two two being the out of service type violations and then all other violations just getting a severity weight of one and this was an issue we raised Brian in our comments to that proposal which is okay if you're going to do that fine but to your point Brian if if we have relied on the adjudicated citations option if data cues to reduce the weight of a violation that gets adjudicated in our favor now it does us no good anymore because it's it's already just a a weight of one or two it will be under the new system so it's not we're not gaining any benefit by adjudicating that citation that we would have that we would have gained otherwise and so I don't know if FMCSA has has really thought that all the way through they had some listening sessions on those SMS changes and I I had raised that in one of those listening sessions and their response at the time was that they have plans once they finish reviewing all the comments to the SMS changes to go evaluate how those changes are going to impact their other systems namely data queues and PSP and see if they need to make any changes to those systems to account for these changes so it will be interesting to see how they address them because otherwise maybe adjudicated citations option really goes away and you know on the flip side of that if it if it was an out of service deal where it had two points attached to it and you were able to have the uh citation adjudicated down to something that wasn't out of service or thrown out altogether I mean if it's still there if you can get it thrown out all together that's going to have an impact but it will have an absolute huge impact if you take an out of service violation or citation and have that adjudicated to nothing and then that comes off your SMS when with this new scoring system that would be that would be a big swing yeah going from two to two to zero yeah essentially um so yeah that will be interesting to see how that plays out we got a couple of comments here let's pick these up this covers this goes right over your mouth rob it looks like you're uh looks like you're cussing up a storm and we have to blur out your mouth uh I was told I was told in a recent nap me class that officers have started just giving the violation without the citation because the court can't remove the CSA violations like they could uh when they dismiss a ticket so yeah that's kind of what we were talking about that has been our experience as well it's not the court that removes the CSA violation though keep in mind so the Court's going to do what it's going to do uh and then you still have to file the data queue to get it potentially taken off your CSA scores but if if the officers aren't writing you up for a ticket in the first instance that's not even an option for you you're just gonna have to fight the battle through a regular incorrect violation data queue and uh your chances of success for all of the reasons we've already talked about are very low at least in our experience uh let's see Mia here is saying do we have to mail or email the inspection report after the mechanic fixes the issue that's not a data accused thing that's just a normal inspection report thing it's down there at the bottom you've got 15 days to get that thing turned back in so yeah there should be for a year so yeah carrier has to keep it for a year yeah I always been an audit last week is why I brought that up they didn't keep any of them so yeah I did that get written up for that Rob yeah so I had one recently too where carrier got actually written up in a DOT audit for not returning those things within 15 days to the state that issued them so before this before these two examples I had rarely ever seen the FMCSA write those up in a in a in an audit context so I always said that that I didn't really see any consequences for not turning those in in time but I am starting to see them enforce that more so make sure you do get those in on time for sure I think that's I know we're getting off topic a little bit but I know I think that's piggybacking on the dvir versus what's written up on an inspection report if you know it was written on an inspection report it should be on a dvir okay now yeah you didn't have that let's follow the paper trail did the inspection get turned in no okay there's another one so yeah it's another very common another very common violation to see in an audit and uh again a little off topic but important nonetheless dvirs if you if and Mia mentioned a mechanical issue if there's a maintenance violation written up on one of your roadside inspection reports your driver better have a dvir for that day because if you get audited first thing FMCSA is going to do in their maintenance review is they're going to pull a list of all maintenance related violations that have been discovered over the last 90 days during a roadside inspection and they're going to expect to see a dvir for all of those and if you can't produce them it's going to be written up as a missing dvir and if you're missing more than 10 percent of them then it's going to be a critical level violation in your audit and you're going to potentially fail that maintenance part of your audit so very important thing to do is make sure you're you're consistently watching your roadside inspections and if there's a maintenance related violation written up make sure you're having your driver submit the dvir you fix the issue you sign off on the fix you keep a record of the the repairs along with the dvir along with the inspection report and you send a copy of that inspection report back to the state that kind of wraps up the paperwork uh Trail that's associated with that piece of cake piece of cake um most carriers struggle with it from what I have seen uh I've yet to go in and audit a carrier that had that process really buttoned up but it is what it is it's easy picking for DOT in a in an audit um so be careful there um Okay so we've kind of hit on the current data queue system and we started to hint at the proposed change but let's dig into what exactly FMCSA is proposing here uh rob you want to kind of break down what you saw what you read coming out of that notice that FMCSA issued last week well basically from from what I from what I gathered it'll kind of take some limited um uh some items a limited scope and push it out of the state into I guess an appeals process that you can you can kind of push certain significant matters of legal interpretation or what is the rest of it Brandon implementation guidance yeah policy or guidance or whatever but uh that's kind of like I said but earlier it's it really limits that and I think I think and I think what really needs to happen and when you said earlier they had listening listen or you said uh listening I was thinking they had hearing sessions but um you know what I think they really should hear is that you need a process to where every day anything can be pushed up there has to be some recourse if you're going to have real due process to to really fight these things out so the a real independent board that can that's open to here anything would be great but I don't see that happening but that's a portion of the proposal that there's going to be somewhere outside the state realm in which to push these uh previously rejected data challenges do Brian did you take anything out anything else out of that notice when you read through it who me yes Brian did you did did you take anything away from that notice that from csa's notice on the potential changes to that accused when you read through it no no nothing more than Rob said yeah it's uh it was short it was short on the details for sure um and so they are accepting comments on it for the next 60 days and uh so if you've got any thoughts on it be sure to get your comments in we're always preaching that that's that's the best way to be heard but as Rob said it's more of kind of uh you know are they gonna really take to heart what we're saying I mean this is our only shot so you got to go in and submit your commas I think the thing that I took away from it is is kind of what you mentioned Rob which is you know there's going to be some kind of a board we don't know what it looks like we don't know who's gonna be on that board um but they are going to limit their review to reviews of matters of significant legal interpretation so if the officer made some kind of a mistake in their version of the law that they applied to the violation at hand or to matters of FMCSA policy and I it kind of made me think back at one example of a data queue that that I had filed recently on behalf of a client that I think would probably be a prime candidate for this type of an appeal it was a it was a Wyoming Bay it was actually colorado-based carrier but they got pulled over in Wyoming it was a small carrier um and they you know the owner of the company was kind of using his own truck um in on this day in particular he was transporting a new vehicle for one of his family members as just a favor for that family member across state lines it wasn't part of his business he was he had picked it up wherever they had purchased it from and it was taking it to the family member's house he gets pulled over by Wyoming Highway Patrol and written up for all kinds of violations um you know med card violation all kinds of stuff that would apply only if you're operating in Commerce and so we filed a data queues appeal saying hey this was for personal reasons he was not involved in interstate commerce the regulations just don't apply in this situation I thought it was a pretty clear-cut case yeah um and it was a matter of illegal interpretation it was the officer was misinterpreting the application of the federal safety regulations they don't apply to non-commercial use of vehicles and uh got denied unsurprisingly by the state in the first go-around so I filed my second take my second bite at the Apple which you get under the current debt accused rules and I added some additional legal analysis to my appeal and I said you've clearly got this wrong you're clearly interpreting it wrong and they just stuck to their guns and they just denied it again so under the current system that's the end of the line there's nowhere else to go with it um me being me I tried to go somewhere else with it I uh I sent an email to my contacts at fmcsi said you know this is I said it in nicer terms than this but I said this is uh the state is misinterpreting your laws and you're letting these violations subsist on your system and it's a it's it's just Incorrect and I S and this particular client of mine he had lost his insurance already because the insurance all these violations pop up on his on his account and they had already canceled his insurance so he was literally going to be out of business because of these violations FMCSA just put through their hands up said nope we don't deal with these issues these are dealt with by the state so frustrating but that's the system that we've lived with now for 13 years but uh having somebody having an appeals board kind of sit on top of that process as somewhere else to take that type of deal I think would be beneficial but maybe not to the extent that we all would want obviously you guys have any other experiences like that in the past with those types of particularly frustrating data accused Appeals I had one and we actually had it pretty frequently to the point where I actually printed the exemption and put it in all the company's Vehicles because uh this was this was an interstate carrier but it wasn't trucks it was cargo vans and these cargo vans uh had an exemption for exhaust and it had like a seven year exemption on these things but they kept getting these they kept getting pulled over getting these exhaust tickets and I got to the point where I got the basically made contact with the captain of this state highway patrol Motor Carrier deal we talked we got some Rapport together I got a cell phone and then it's hey if you ever get pulled over and you get a citation for exhaust you call this guy Rob's cell phone number and he'll get you off the side of the road because it ultimately was It was kind of crazy but it was still an out of service so we we got to this point where we had this Rapport and you just call the captain up and it never got to the data Q piece he would just eliminate it it just kind of went away and uh you had to get it right there like once you were gone that was it but um you know even with the exemption if we didn't catch it there and it got put in the system and you had to data cue it even though you had the exemption we've been rolled against where it clearly says there's an exemption that allows for a shorter exhaust um anyway it's you know it's aggravating because in a lot of these cases like with yours you're talking about State agents state law enforcement agencies implementing Interstate Federal regulatory guidelines but yet they've compartmentalized state agencies to where where the feds have compartmentalized state agencies to where it's like hey they're the bad guy you got to deal with them only we don't have any say in that so I think if it's the reason I'm in favor of more like an independent board to review these things is if it's your rule and it's an in it's an interstate rule fan rule then you should have some recourse to go to some independent War to argue at the federal level that the state didn't interpret Federation the correct way and then somebody has to make a determination on that so I I've always been in favor of that but the likelihood of it happening I don't think is good because you know you've said it before they just don't have the resources to enforce safety regulations to begin with not not at the scale we needed and uh yeah that's just Where We Are Brian any similar I'm sure you've got dozens of those types of examples where it was just so frustrating you thought you had a slam dunk and then it just blows up in your face yeah it was a simple one uh business owner was using his own personal F-450 uh to go get an engine for his brother's tractor um and since he had a CDL and since that truck was big enough to be older because it didn't have a D.O.T number on it because it was his personal vehicle they considered it interstate commerce yeah and you know that one was frustrating yeah it's almost the same example I had it it's yep the thing that I've always leaned on kind of thinking this through on the legal side of things the thing I've always complained about is that you know Congress kind of delegates to FMCSA what its Duties are supposed to be FMCSA only has the powers that it derives through its its Congressional mandates and FMCSA has then delegated some of those to the states and in my view it has done so impermissibly in these contexts because it's essentially washing its hands of its own responsibilities Congress has statutes out there that say FMCSA has a responsibility to make sure that all of the data that it has in its various information databases is accurate and I've always argued that by washing your hands of this and letting the states interpret your federal laws and then getting it wrong on so many of these cases you you are not discharging your duty FMCSA to make sure that the data in your systems is accurate and obviously that's gotten us nowhere nobody really cares what I think about it I know FMCSA has gotten sued on this issue specifically there was a case probably five or six years ago that made its way up to Federal Court where somebody lost a data accused appeal and uh the hearing nothing from FMCSA they decided just to sue FMCSA and they made this argument that um you know FMCSA is not doing its duty to make sure the systems are right and the court agreed with FMCSA they threw that case out so it is good to see finally that we are starting to get movement on this particularly like I said now that we are starting to see FMCSA want to make tweaks to CSA and make tweaks to safety ratings that's the other thing we haven't really talked about but just within the last couple of weeks FMCSA came out with their notice where they are proposing it's an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking so it's not to the rule-making stage yet but they are soliciting comments on a potential change to carrier safety ratings so satisfactory conditional unsat whereby they are thinking about potentially tying those safety ratings to a carrier's SMS scores which is something they tried in 2016 and was ultimately abandoned because it got so much blowback but the my biggest concern with that back then and now has been okay if we're going to tie carriers safety rating which could potentially get it shut down to this violation data from roadside inspections we have to have a system in place with an independent review board to for us to be able to appeal the violation data because otherwise we could potentially get shut down by a state's erroneous interpretation of of the laws which just is not fair um to anybody so I I was glad to see that that they uh they came out with this rule or that this proposal if for nothing else than that what are you guys thoughts on that I know that's off topic but I know you both are kind of tracking that as well those potential changes to safety ratings yeah go ahead Rob I don't think it worked before and I don't think it's going to work any better now I mean if anything changes it kind of I don't think I don't think the environment of uh of truck transportation has gotten to the point where you know it's going to be any different of a result than it was in years past when it failed Brian my my question is is when they bring to the table those changes and you know how are they going to put the review board together you know I'll be curious to see if the cvsa is involved um to see if that you know if it runs up through that if they're going to put some sort of guidelines down you know you have your your out of service guide it comes out every year is there going to be some cut and dry if this mistakes made on an inspection um it's an automatic yeah automatic withdrawal of the violation kind of like the crash preventability program you know something like that and and that would help it would give at least some guidance to you know folks like like us that are trying to do these data cues for people uh and kit motor carriers having the opportunity to say yep it falls into this category it it needs to be taken off so that's that's what I'm looking forward to seeing let's see what Jared has to say he's he's uh skipping school on us today he says lost a crash challenge after the state's questionable interpretation of the application of safety change chains when dash cam video showed the other driver coming across two lanes of traffic and hit my uh let's he's got another one here hit my driver head-on toxicology submitted and the other driver was drunk and high lost the challenge because of the safety chain yeah I remember that one that one was just nuts I mean what else cleaned up on they were chained up for bad weather and is that what they're talking about um no Jared was gonna have to explain it a little bit better that's not I don't think that was the issue I think it was well it could have been it could have been the issue I think the point was the officer said we had a violation in connection with the accident even though our violation had nothing to do with causing the accident and then and because of that they went they would not remove the accident because they said we had some kind of a violation that was found in connection with the investigation of the accident oh he's saying yeah this okay I remember it was steel coils it was it was whether the cargo was properly secured with steel chains and that had nothing to do with what caused the accident the drive the other driver was high and drunk and crossed the center line and and yet they wouldn't remove the they wouldn't determine it to be not preventable on our driver's part because we had not allegedly uh properly strapped down those steel coils type of stuff to to go back to what uh Brian was saying in terms of cvsa I I could accept them because I I think cbsa is a pretty objective Jared says he almost retired after that [Laughter] cvsa I think is a pretty objective group you know I think I'd rather have them than anybody else but I I think it's made up of other stakeholders other than just yeah yeah interesting but I'd like to see them play a part in it yeah or at least some of their objective crap material that play a part in it and kind of advise a piece of it but the other piece of it is based on how how the proposed rule is you know the proposal is is written and what it's what its scope is I have a feeling that you're going to have a bunch of people who are just lawyers Jared oh so I do I think because you're you're talking about legal interpretation and I don't see how you're gonna how you're gonna fit cvsa people or other industry representative but you know other people from other people from the industry represented on that if you're trying to get true interpretation generally when you start talking interpretation you're talking somebody with a legal right now yeah I think it could be broader uh because virtually every data Q challenge I ever file I would classify as a legal interpretation whether FMCSA agrees with me or not I don't know I guess that we'll have to wait and see on that but I always avoid filing challenges on any kind of factual disputes unless I've got evidence to to back up my version of the story because otherwise like I said if it's just he said she said you're going to lose that battle and so I I always caution carriers and drivers don't be the boy that cries wolf and just try out challenge everything pick your battles wisely pick the ones where you've got evidence to back up your your case where it makes it difficult for the state to look at that evidence and still stick to their guns and so with that in mind I would argue that virtually every data Q challenge I file is some kind of a legal interpretation if not if not a strictly you know here's what these words mean in this law it's hey here's how the officer is applying that law to this particular situation and it's erroneous I would say that is still I would stay that is still a candidate for this type of appeals board but again that's I guess we're just gonna have to wait and see on that actually one thing I had I do have pulled up here that is worth talking about is these were a couple of tables that were put in The fmcsa's Proposal where they are proposing to stand up this kind of independent appeals board they gave some examples of requests that would be possibly acceptable for FMCSA appeal and then they gave some examples of requests that are not gonna be acceptable for FMCSA appeal I'm not going to run through them all here this is on our website if you're interested trucksafe.com we have an article on this topic but here are a couple of examples of violations that would possibly be accepted for FMCSA appeal I'm going to read number two here uh drivers using a portable electronic logging device mounted to the center console driver was cited for a violation because the ELD was not in view of the driver while operating the CMV driver claims to be uh claims the violation isn't error because visible quote unquote means not hidden and the driver only needs to access it when changing Duty statuses and then FMCSA says the reason why this would be an acceptable appeal to this new appeals board is to interpret the ELD and hos supporting documents final rule where they talk about portable elds If a driver uses a portable ELD the motor carrier shall ensure that the ELD is mounted in a fixed position during the operation of the commercial motor vehicle and visible to the driver when the driver is seated in normal driving position it's funny they give that example as one that would be an acceptable appeal and then based on that uh that wording there it looks like they're going to deny the appeal if it does happen to get filed but they do list that as one as kind of an interpretation of of the law uh one other one here a driver was cited roadside with violating hours of service regulations after claiming to be operating under a Regional Emergency declaration in support of Hurricane Relief efforts State contended the commodity was not part of the relief efforts FMCSA says the reason this may be an acceptable appeal is to assess whether the state correctly applied the waiver in response to the declared uh hurricane emergency I actually had one of those not too long ago where it was actually the covid emergency exemption that was in place for several years I had a carrier that was transporting bottled water but also Pepsi products and uh and so it was a mixed load of arguably emergency relief Commodities water and arguably not Pepsi uh and the officer wrote it up as a as a violation because the driver was in violation of hours the service rules we followed data queue saying hey this this fits under the covid emergency relief declaration because if nothing else it's a mixed load of water and you've got your own declaration says if it's a mixed load we're not going to be nitpicking how much is how much is emergency relief and is not anyway got that data queue they got cited in several States for that uh we had a couple of the States agree with us and take those violations off and then we had a couple of States stick to their guns and leave those violations on so under this uh new proposal that would be the type of thing that would be a good candidate for a an appeal to this appeals board I think that'd be a good one that we have to deal with a lot uh we work with quite a few tracking companies on the southern border uh which they use B1 drivers and so depending on the states we've had very very good success challenging the English-speaking violations and then other states they just won't even look at them and it's the same argument in both States on a with a federal uh using a federal guideline and some states take it some states won't explain that that argument I think you and I have talked about this in the past but I kind of forget how it goes there's guidance out there that I'm not familiar with off the top of my head that says that if they're a B1 driver that they don't have to meet the English speaking language requirement is that what you're saying is that well it yes and no the English-speaking requirement is to get the light get your license well they did not get their license here they they carry a Mexican license and they're able to converse but they're they're able to ask for assistance roadside whether it's through an interpreter whether it's through like Google speak whether it's something like that and um if that's denied and they do a level two or level one inspection especially if they do one of those two and then right up on the inspection that they couldn't complete the inspection because the driver couldn't speak English how did they complete the inspection yeah yeah no kidding so you've been successful in some of those but not others yeah depending on the state it's state to state did you send me that guidance I think you may have in the past yeah if not send it to me because I I have I have several of those situations that come up from time to time all right we've got a comment here let's see if we can address this one it's a multi-part one again here Tom says the inspector provided to driver in a California citation after three days I saw this violation on my CSA portal as an inspection report I filed a data queue Challenge and they said it was okay because the police officer noted on the ticket so the question is that possible to for the police officer and data Q inspector to act like that Tom I gotta be honest I don't know what you're asking here you may have to rephrase it for us if you're just saying that you weren't aware that the violation was going to be put on your account until after it was done and then you saw it and tried to dedicure it um uh then yeah I mean unless you have some valid reason to contest the underlying violation in other words unless you have some evidence that it wasn't a violation then it's going to be put on your account so maybe I'm just misunderstanding did you guys understand that better than I did I did uh I was lost on that one but yeah let me just clarify that for us one of the things that I was going to throw out there too was um and then I probably should wrote a beginning is the time frames that you have to challenge these things you can't challenge these things forever so you know typically this as soon as what Tom said actually reminded me of it was you know as soon as you know then you need to challenge it I mean it's soon after the fact the better chance you have of winning these things I mean you have longer I think it three three years for inspections five years for accidents or something but that's insane no one's going to approve that so um yeah because you're asking the officer to recall what happened three years ago and it's just gonna say if he still works there he's just if he does he's just gonna say well screw it I don't remember what happened three years ago I'm not changing my mind now yeah so and you know if it's a if it's a violation for a mechanic with the effect the odds are has been corrected anyway so yeah that is another another good tip is to get those filed as quickly as you can I always like to wait at least until the inspection report gets uploaded to the system sometimes if you go in and try and file a data queue before it's been uploaded it won't pre-populate all of the inspection information and so I just I usually wait a few more days and then once you start typing in the inspection number if it pre-populates all of the information you know it's in the system and and they'll be able to tie it to whatever that is I wanted to before we uh leave here show some of the a couple of these examples of things that would not be an appropriate use of this new uh appeals board that accused appeals board according to FMCSA so here's here here are a couple of them again this is a table that was in the fmcsa's notice I'm gonna read the second one again here uh commercial driver received a violation during an inspection for driving during off-duty hours the submitter claims that the ELD was malfunctioning and the inspector was not provided accurate information the request did not include supporting evidence and the reason this would not be a good use of the appeals board system according to FMCSA is that the request disputes facts regarding whether the ELD was working correctly at the time of the inspection it also does not require an interpretation of the regulation or policy so you can kind of get a feel for the types of things that they're going to be looking to accept and the things that they're not here it's it's what we've said if there's there's a question of the interpretation of the regulation or the officer's application of it then maybe the board accepts it but if it's a he said she said type deal and you don't have any evidence to support yourself then it's just going to get denied you're going to have nowhere to go we're going to see so many just like with the the crash preventability program when that first came out we were all excited hey we got 17 crashes 17 types that we can challenge then we realized once it was here damn we need 20 more to make it realistic and this is going to be the same thing they that that information you just showed us that is scratching the surface to all the what-ifs and ands and you know yeah but that people are going to want to use the system for it I I think that that system depending on how many people they have working it and looking at it it's going to get bogged down fairly quickly oh yeah I have no doubt all right guys well that's all the time we got uh great discussion appreciate you joining me uh great to have your Insight on this topic um where can folks find out more or get in touch with you guys if they have questions Brian reliancepartners.com uh you can look up uh them on the website and I'm on most of the socials LinkedIn and and Facebook so if you have questions feel free to ask I'm happy to answer Rob uh Carpenter compliance.com or LinkedIn all right all right guys I'll see you in Orlando if I don't talk to you before then thanks again for joining me uh uh that's gonna wrap it up for this show um appreciate everybody tuning in today uh stay tuned for future episodes we usually announce those a few days ahead of time like I said at the start subscribe to our newsletter that's the best way to get uh up-to-date information about what's going on over at truck safe uh also follow us on our various social media channels we're pretty active there with all of our uh you know breaking news whatever's going on in the industry and also articles and videos on the topic uh LinkedIn Facebook YouTube all of those different channels also check out our online DOT compliance courses for safety managers and for drivers we have those available several of them now over at trucksafeacademy.com uh that's all I got thanks for tuning in we'll catch you next time foreign

Event Completed

Thursday, September 21, 2023 at 8:43 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube