Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 30 - Tackling log falsifications

Thursday, October 26, 2023 at 2:55 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 30 - Tackling log falsifications

About This Event

We’re joined once again by Rob Carpenter and Brian Runnels, this time to discuss log falsifications, a serious issue for many fleets and drivers. We’ll address some of the most common culprits for false logs and what carriers and drivers can do to avoid them.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 30 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by Brian Runnels, VP of Safety at Reliance Partners, to tackle one of the trucking industry's most persistent compliance problems: log falsification. According to FMCSA data, false logs rank as the fourth most common driver-related violation discovered during roadside inspections and the number one violation found during DOT audits. With nearly 50,000 log violations discovered at roadside in 2023 alone and hundreds of thousands of dollars in civil penalties assessed against carriers, the hosts make clear that this is not a manageable cost of doing business — it is an existential threat to a carrier's operating authority and financial stability. The conversation covers both the paper log era and the modern ELD environment, exploring how falsification has evolved rather than disappeared. Common ELD-era violations include physically unplugging the ELD device from the ECM, misuse of the personal conveyance designation, failure to assign unidentified driving time, and logging fuel stops or loading and unloading activity as off-duty time. The hosts also discuss the use of "ghost drivers" — assigning trips to former or fictitious employees — and the risks posed by administrative staff making careless or unauthorized log edits that drivers then blindly certify. Reynolds notes that the problem may be worsening due to economic pressures, with both carriers and drivers looking for ways to move more freight with fewer resources. A central theme of the discussion is the outsized regulatory consequence of log falsification compared to substantive hours-of-service violations. Because all falsification violations are grouped together when calculating a carrier's violation rate, it takes only a 10% rate — across however many logs an investigator reviews — to trigger a critical-level violation in the hours-of-service factor. Critically, hours-of-service violations are double-weighted in the DOT's audit methodology, meaning a single critical-level violation in that factor guarantees no better than a conditional safety rating. The hosts emphasize that carriers are often better off allowing a driver to incur an 11-hour or 14-hour violation than to conceal it through falsification, since substantive violations are evaluated separately and carry less systemic risk. Beyond regulatory consequences, the hosts stress the litigation exposure that comes with unaddressed log falsification. If a driver involved in a fatal crash is later found to have a history of falsified logs, plaintiff attorneys will use that pattern to argue negligence and push for punitive damages — a dynamic that contributes directly to the nuclear verdicts increasingly common in trucking litigation. Reynolds recounts a case where a carrier's crash claim was not overturned despite the other party being at fault, simply because the driver had a falsified log in the days prior to the incident. For fleet safety professionals, the episode offers several actionable takeaways. Carriers should regularly run odometer jump reports, unassigned drive time reports, and personal conveyance reports in their ELD platforms rather than relying solely on standard violation reports. Unassigned driving time must be promptly and accurately assigned — not arbitrarily cleared to improve dashboard metrics. Policies around log falsification should be clearly documented, communicated to both drivers and dispatchers at hire and on an ongoing basis, and enforced through consistent progressive discipline. Carriers tempted to tolerate falsification as a routine cost of doing business are reminded that a 30-truck fleet recently faced a $25,000 civil penalty for a single critical-level false log violation — on top of the cost of obtaining a safety rating upgrade.

Full Transcript

n n n a n oh a nah oh hey everyone welcome to episode 30 of truck safe live the show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and CH law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs good show in store today we're talking about log falsifications a uh a huge issue for lots of carriers and certainly lots of drivers it's routinely ranks as one of the uh most common violations discovered during roadside inspections and also in dot audits so uh water are causing these problems and more importantly what can fleets and drivers do to get control of it that's what we're discussing on today's episode excited to be joined Again by my friends Rob Carpenter and Brian Reynolds so should be a great discussion coming up before we get there a few things uh going on at truck safe we just wrapped up our truck safe Fleet compliance boot camp we talked about this uh for many months in advance uh thanks to everybody who joined us in Orlando Florida it was a great conference uh thanks to the speakers and thanks to our sponsors for making it happen um spent two days packed jaming Pack full of DOT compliance discussion uh it was it was a great discussion had a lot of great questions and input from those in attendance so um uh if you didn't catch this one be sure to stay tuned uh we're going to try and do these twice a year once in the spring once in the fall so we're going to start planning our next one in the spring here pretty soon details are available at trucksafe bootcamp.com also if you subscribe to our newsletter which is the next thing I was going to recommend uh you can do so at truck safe.com SLS subscribe then we will push out notifications whenever we finalize the details for the next one of those but uh we hope to see you at one of those in the future uh also I'll mention our truck safe um network if you're not a member of this already I would encourage you to join it over at trucksafe network.com we also have an app available in the App Store in the Google Play Store uh this is a social network for safety Professionals for fleets uh to gather together ask questions learn from one another and have access to all of our content that we push out through truck safe detailed articles videos podcasts everything like that so we hope to see you in there um what else is going on uh that's about it with truck say a few things going on in the industry that are worth talking about it's been a few weeks since we've done one of these shows so glad to be back here with you if you're here with us by the way say hey in the comments so we know that you're watching um things going on in the industry saw a couple things come through last week and this week uh I saw that the FMCSA is extending their comment period for their safety rating safety Fitness determination aprm advanced notice of proposed rule making uh until the end of November November 29th uh this is the rule making that we discussed a couple of shows back where the FMCSA is toying with potentially changing up the way that we do motor carrier safety ratings in the United States uh potentially moving away from that three- tier system that we are familiar with the satisfactory conditional and unsatisfactory and potentially starting to tie those scores to your CSA scores uh or or those ratings to your CSA scores which would be a huge deal um so anyway it's it's early on in the rule making process just in advanced notice of proposed rule making um but the FMCSA is looking for feedback from the industry this is your opportunity to go in there and uh give them your mind on on this topic so make sure you do so you've got until November 29th now to do it uh you can file those at regulations.gov in docket FMCSA d222 d003 uh the other thing I noticed this week um this came through my email uh this was seems like a pretty big deal um but it doesn't seem very WID uh very widely published at this point but I got this email from fmcsa's it folks uh indicating that anybody who's a user of the fmcsa's portal which is essentially going to be motor carriers that are using the portal to access their CSA scores and their Clearing House accounts and everything that you need to to keep your information up to date with the FMCSA um you're going to have to change the way that you log into that system uh as of December 1st of this year so we're talking in the next month or so uh you're going to have to set up a new account through login.gov which is the government website that um allows you to do like two Factor authentication where you got to get text messages to confirm you are who you are um but anyway you're going to have to have that effective December 1st in order to log on onto your portal account and if you don't have that by that date then you're not going to be able to log on so I am I suspect we're going to get to December 1st and there's going to be a lot of confused people out there that aren't able to access their account so be sure you do that um you should have gotten an email if you're a user of the portal you you should have gotten an email about this but But be sure to do that or else you won't be able to access the important data that you need to through your portal account all right so those are the couple things I had to talk about um let's move on to today's topic uh which again is log falsification according to FMCSA data false logs rank as the fourth most common driver related violation discovered during roadside inspections over the past four years and the most common violation discovered in dot audits this year alone 2023 year-to date law enforcement has discovered nearly 50,000 log violations during roadside inspections and the FMCSA has assessed hundreds of thousands of dollars and civil penalties against truck and bus companies for these types of violations so why is this still such a problem now that electronic logging devices are common place and what can carriers do to get control of the issue that's what we're T tackling on today's show again like I said grateful to be joined by my friends and colleagues Rob Carpenter now officially a VP and director of managed services for uh here with us at truck safe and Brian Reynolds VP of safety with Reliance Partners welcome back guys hey Brandon hey how's it going it's going all right glad to have you back uh you both were at the boot camp with me um appreciated your uh Sage advice to all of those in attendance and I know we got a lot of great feedback so uh thanks again for joining me there how was Orlando for you guys it was good it wasn't hot too hot anyway it was a quick it was a quick turnaround because I had to go from there to the MCN conference out in Austin so it was didn't get to spend much time down there that was kind of a drag yeah a little bit I was goingon to ask you how was MC it was good um you know there was with the the talk with the talk of the economy being the way that it is that that pretty much ruled the day um everything from what Chris bear talked about to um just side conversations is like God how how do some people make it through this and you know when's it going to get better that that boy if I knew if I knew the answer to that I was gonna say did anybody have an answer for that no not really I mean that people are saying that it it it may take start taking an upturn Q2 of next year U maybe even to Q3 I mean it won't be a windfall where we see everything go back to 2020 you know 2019 hysteria but you know it maybe we've hit the bottom and we'll start pulling ourselves out somewhat but they don't see it for this Christmas season that's for sure yikes so that kind of goes along with I saw also at at that conference that atrey released its annual report on top issues top industry issues kind of split out by those expressed by drivers and those by motor carriers did you sit in on that session did you make it for that unfortunately I didn't I wasn't I wasn't was n uh able to be there on that because that comes out on Saturday okay uh midaf afternoon so I wasn't able to be at that one uh but I did read the list after the fact and you know economy was number one it's always an interesting report to see what issues drivers think are the top issues that they're experiencing versus what motor carriers see as the top issues and kind of comparing those two lists we'll probably do a show or or an article on that topic here pretty soon but uh that's one of the big things that came out of that ATA conference here recently but anyway today we are talking about log falsifications Brian this was a great idea you had to do a show on this I've been wanting to do something some kind of content on this topic for a long time I just haven't gotten around to it so how big of a problem in your estimation is this in the industry Brian I'll let you kick things off here I think it's getting even more uh prevalent and for a couple of reasons one we're talking about the economy so Trucking trucking companies are trying to move more freight with less people and drivers are trying to make more money because maybe loads aren't as easy to come by as they once were so between those two things I think we're seeing the the falsification happen because of both sides both the motor carrier and the driver um and I I don't know for a fact but hey you know we got to get this load there this broker is not going to use us anymore or they're going to find US $500 or hey can you make it and there's an extra 100 or 200 bucks to do it could that be happening I don't know it doesn't sound like out of the realm of possibilities um and then drivers you guys were both drivers did you do this all the time never all the time I believe we just talked about not lying about being a carrier and doing this Brian like right before the show so just just Brian's falsifying his answers on this show right yeah yeah but I I think it's it could actually be hidden obviously it's hidden better on paper than it is on electronic and I think that might also be part of the issue that it's so easy the different ways to quote unquote Hydra hours in an ELD but they're so easy to find yeah and you know and and I I thinks I even think that a driver would say hey get me through the next seven days and it'll disappear well Rob and I are both finding out this week alone uh from two different carriers that you know we're working on some audit stuff with that six months that stuff just sits there and hangs out and you know when dot comes knocking and they give you that list of drivers they want to see it's going to be drivers that have hours of service viol viations uh maintenance violations you know those are going to be the easy low hanging fruit for them to pick off and there's so many different ways to compare logs to fuel receipts toll receipts uh maintenance repairs you name it there's ways to check logs against it and it's you know carriers can get in trouble with that fairly quickly so speaking of that I wanted to show this so this is from fmcsa's um AI database which is a good place to go if you ever want to see statistical information on violation data across the entire universe of regulated motor carriers in the United States this is the website where you can get that information you can run a lot of cool reports but this I've got a couple of here that I've pulled up so this is the fmcsa's database uh that kind of details safety investigation so dot audits over whatever time period you picked here I've picked the last four years 2019 through 2023 and you can see I'm looking at all of the violations discovered in all of those audits over that time period and looking at what are the most prevalent violations that the do investigators discover when they're in your office or they do these offsite more and more frequently nowadays but looking at your historical records so not roadside inspections but actually doing a DOT audit or compliance review and you'll see number two on the list here false reports of Duty status it's a critical level violation and I think that's to your point Brian what a lot of motor carriers fail to understand is the consequences uh of these violations in the audit context I mean it's not just at that point a matter of uh your your driver getting shut down roadside now we're talking about potential fleetwide shutdowns if you have a systemic problem in this area which is especially scary because if you look we've talked about this on other shows but if you look at the do's auditing methodology The Playbook that they use when they come in and do their audits they're looking if they're doing a full comprehensive review they're looking at six different factors they're looking at General compliance driver issues vehicle maintenance hours of service drug and alcohol testing accident records and Hazmat the only factor in those in those six where violations get double weighted because F FMCSA considers them them to be the most indicative of future crash risk are hours of service violations so practically what that means and I try and Hammer this home with all of our clients is that if you if the do investigator comes in looks at your hours of service records and finds one critical level violation in the hours of service Factor you're not getting out of that audit with anything better than a conditional safety rate it's just it's a matter of fact and that is why we see so many carriers fail in audit meaning getting out of it with a conditional rating or an unsatisfactory rating is because they struggle with hours of service and primarily with log falsifications has that been your guys's experience as well yeah yeah yeah and it only has to be 10% it's not a big number so you know when they're pulling those logs they have an idea who they're going to be looking at and you can probably bet that that number is going to be above 10% pretty quickly and they're not picking your All-Star drivers no no picking the ones that they know have hours of service problems these are not random audits they are they are going to pick your worst performing drivers in all of these categories and that's who you're going to be judged against well one of the things that I pulled I didn't pull it from where you pulled yours but one of the things that I pulled was you know H how much how much has this changed over time you know are we getting better or we getting worse and if you look back it's uh 2018 it was three and a half percent of out of service out of service violations were for frost logs and now in 2021 it went up to five and a half almost 6% so it's gotten worse over time like Brian was saying but I think a lot of that goes to exactly what he was saying earlier it's that that historic thing even when when I was driving trucks and our goal was always I mean I actually had carriers that gave me multiple log books and said hey this Seafood has to be from Miami to Hunts Point New York by tomorrow at two in the morning or you don't have a job anymore and obviously you have that coercion factor in there now but um you know it's it's almost like it's the cost of doing business so if you get a 9,000 fine and then they come back a year from late a year from now and they give you another $9,000 fine finding the same thing it's like it's $8,000 bucks if you have a large enough Fleet what what is that so um there's that piece and then you know the average fine for falsification is $7,000 so it's not cheap yeah well and then one thing I'll I'll tab on top of that is what do they say over 80% of motor carriers out there are unrated because they haven't had a safety review they're not going after account uh trucking companies that are are doing right they're not in alert for hours of service they're going to that 20% is coming from people that are having issues it's just like I was told by an inspector one time we don't want to do clean inspections they that's not really what they're there for so they're not going to look at those trucks they're going to look at the ones that have issues or potential issues um and and work from there so it's been frustr I guess it's just when I brought this topic up to you was because it was coming out of a place of frustration over the last few weeks where I've I've seen so many uh primarily under 100 unit that's kind of where I I work uh of these accounts having hours of service issues and I don't think they understand how critical literally these violations can be and what they can potentially do to them at an audit and then thereafter trying to fix the problem yeah well you mentioned Brian the 10% threshold so that's the so when the do is in your office doing an audit you know they're looking for what are called acute and critical violations so critical level violations are where they are looking for a pattern of non-compliance these are all set out in uh part 385 of the safety regulations you can see the list of violations that they deem critical and acute and when it comes to critical level violations like false logs false logs is a critical level violation in order to establish a pattern of non-compliance what they're looking for is a 10% or more violation rate so that means that if they are looking at a 100 days worth of driver logs if they find 10 or more of them are falsified then that's going to be a critical level violation and that is going to downgrade your safety rating to a conditional and then that's just that one small factor that they're looking at at you know if they're also looking at issues in driver qualification and vehicle maintenance you can imagine that it doesn't take a whole lot more to get you to unsatisfactory and now all of a sudden you're getting a fleetwide shutdown so the point is it take it doesn't take much particularly with log falsifications for these to really cause uh serious problems so you both kind of hinted at and I want to kind of to walk through it you know kind of the distinction between how this used to be a problem with with paper logs and how it is still a problem with electronic logging devices I want to kind of walk through that so when we were when we were in the world of paper logs and you guys know from from experience on kind of both sides of this but what were some of the common most common ways that you would see log falsifications come up in that paper log World well just well guys that were running dedicated they would just wouldn't log a trip or log the trip then pull it out and run the next one uh like they they never run and well you know what I probably shouldn't get into all the ways that you you get around the the signing of B's and fuel receipts and stuff like that I think the statute of limitations for you guys is probably up yeah we're probably you're safe they'd find a way if we told them everything theyd find a way there but Loose Leaf went a long way back then you know when I first started out everybody would give you the book and it was like it was it was hard to tear anything out of that book and make it look normal like it's there's a page missing bro you know something's wrong multiple books didn't you I had multiple books but then I I was turned on to the loose leaf thing you know when I first started getting into truck stops you find out they have loose leaf you buy your little binder you do your page you tear it out you throw it away and you move on with the next page like you you just materialized out of thin air in Missouri um nobody knows how you got there but you're there here you are y so that was the easiest thing to do yeah yeah just not yeah either just throwing away the log or just not accurately logging where you are at particular times and the way that I mean that's sniffed out pretty easily either by law enforcement roadside you had to get there somehow to where you are currently so there there has to be an explanation for it or in an audit the most common way that they would kind of sniff that stuff out is they would compare your driver's paper logs to to supporting documents as Brian said so whatever documentation you as the motor carrier have to kind of show where a particular driver is at a given date and time you're supposed to be retaining that along with your driver logs the purpose of that is so that you as the carrier and the dot can then cross reference those two the supporting documents to the logs and see is driver John Doe actually in Michigan on uh April 6th at 2:00 p.m. when he says he is or is he somewhere else as judged by fuel receipts or toll receipts or dispatch records anything that that the carrier maintaining to to show those things and so that's how they would do it they would they would pick a sample of driver logs in an audit and they would request supporting documents for those logs and they would sit there and cross reference them and if they didn't line up with the driver's actual logs they would Mark each one of those up as a log falsification and like I said if they're looking at a hundred of those and they find 10 or more of them that's all it takes and so that's you know those it was very common occurrence back then and I think the idea with the ELD rule at least one of the main ideas was well we're going to start to get better control of this because no longer are we going to be relying on the drivers to uh you know to manually input their driving status the device is going to know when the vehicle is in motion and so you would have thought that maybe this would have you know with elds being in effect now since 2019 that maybe we'd have would have gotten control of this but it's still the top tops the list for most common violations so what's what's the what are the primary culprits nowadays with elds that are leading to log falsifications rob you want to take this one first well I I have seen some people say well you know I mean everybody knows my thing is motive so we'll start there but like we had this guy who said you know I can beat this motive system you know I can I can falsify this motive log and and essentially what they would do is they would unplug it the Gateway of this device the ELD from the ECM and then they would just drive and then and you know it's obviously not tracking anything so the the problem is still going to come in where it's like Brian said at the beginning you might be able to beat it in these little ways on the front end on the driver facing side but you're almost always going to catch it on the back end because there's such a trail like when you plug it back in and then you realize hey this vehicle moved you know 200 miles and you know when it was unplugged he was in you know kalamazo Michigan and now he's in Maine but he only drove 10 miles you know and I mean it's easy to catch now it's not like it used to be um we we could almost make it extremely difficult for you to catch it especially with loose leaf but now with electronics it's like I said easier on the front harder on the back to get away with so unplugging physically unplugging the device is one way that you end up with log falsifications Brian and what how else are we seeing log falsifications with elds I think the the biggest one is either what Rob was saying or the improper use of personal conveyance that is it it's such a gray area that it's gone too gray and you know maybe somebody does honestly make a mistake thought they could use it when they couldn't but I think it's just a um a way to switch the log over to something else when you're running late and or you're not going to make it somewhere and they just switch it to personal conveyance or they they use it to to get themselves set up for the next load I mean we you know there's a a Litany of things that you can not do with it and that people do do with it and on both accounts what Rob was saying or or the the personal conveyance thing those are both reports within the ELD system that an auditor can ask for you know and yeah it's the the odometer jump report or the unassigned drive time report report any of those yeah we got someone saying finally uh or not finally that's me inserting Rob's words for them FYI Sam Sarah finally got us an odometer jump report so yeah I mean these to Brian's Point these are reports that are not just available to investigators but more importantly available to you as the motor carrier that's in charge of managing this stuff that you should be running periodically probably monthly to see where issues are starting to arise because you better be sure or you better be certain that the do is going to be asking and looking at those reports and they're essentially doing those investigators jobs for them they are pointing them to log falsifications so if you as the carrier don't know where those things are you're only going to run yourself into trouble so you need to at minimum be running not just your violation report that seems like the most obvious one the 11h hour 14h hour 70h hour violation report I found I've said this over and over you know with log falsifications being the number to uh the top in the top violations both roadside and in audits those are my biggest concern on the hours of service side of things no longer substantive violations of the hours of service regulations and the reason is pretty simple because if we look to that um that that 10% threshold for critical level violations that's on a rule by rule basis so if you think about a DOT investigator in your records looking at 100 driver logs they're looking at they're looking for substantive violations uh 11-hour violations 14-hour violations 70h hour violations 30 minute rest break and then log falsifications and missing logs those are the different rule sets that would would uh could potentially lead to a critical level violation but those are all calculated separately so if you've got drivers that are having 11h hour violations it's probably relatively few con uh compared to the universe of drivers who are having log falsification violations because all of the log falsification violations get grouped together with one another so regardless of whether it's a personal conveyance misuse or a driver unplugging his his device or mis logging their fuel time as off duty all of those get to group group together as false logs and then they add up to that 10% threshold whereas your 11 hour is viewed separately from the 14 hour it's viewed separately from the 70 hour so you probably have relatively few 11-hour violations and 14-hour violations and 70h hour violations but when we group together all of your log falsifications it does not take much to add up to that 10 10% threshold so my the thing I always say is your drivers would probably you would be better off as the motor carrier for your drivers to have incurred the substantive hours of service violations than to try and conceal them and then create a log falsification because I would rather I would much rather have 11 11 hour violation than to have 10 log falsifications because of that 10% threshold you guys have any thoughts on of that mindset there do you agree with that no I agree with that say no I don't agree with that that would have been interesting yeah I know yeah I know well I think that you know when it comes to those those violations too on a daily basis you know you're saying running that report every so often one of the things that someone in safety has to do every morning is check that unassigned DriveTime report that stuff's got to be assigned to somebody and I I hear it that yeah we talked to the driver about it and this and that but they didn't assign the hours back will it throw them into violation yes it probably will and yes you'll have to shut them down for the appropriate break whether it's 10 hours or 34 depending on you know how many hours it did throw them over uh and where it was but though all that time has to be assigned back in yeah you're doing yourself no good by allowing that to exist on the unidentified driving report same situation I just described I would rather you assign that to the driver and put them in violation than to have that time sitting out there on an unassigned driving report and then a DOT investigator pulls that report they always pull that report in an in an hour's service investigation and they're going to line that up against supporting documents and they're going to see from your dispatch records that John Doe was actually at a receiver's facility on October 26th but there's only un assign drive time from his truck on that day and they're going to write that up probably as a missing log could be construed as a false log as well but it would probably be written up as a missing log and that's one of like I said one of the things that is going to contribute to a potential critical level violation sorry Rob part part of it is the reporting piece so you got companies have to manage these things too and I I think that's what ultimately we're all going to but it's also only as good as what you put in it so when you're assigning this time I can't tell you the number of times where people have just gone in there saying hey I just got to knock out this so the percentage in that dashboard looks good it's like hey you're 100% compliant because you have no unassigned time or no unassigned segments when in actuality if you actually go in there and look at what that admin did who might be making 10 or $15 an hour they just went in there and started throwing in names and I've seen it done countless times and it's like hey wait a minute this guy doesn't even work here anymore so how is this assigned to him and then dummy admin account yeah and you're like wait a minute these people don't work here and you know it you can run that report all day long but sometimes that report will tell on you and then there's the whole reporting piece as it is so you've got to it kind of goes back to the value of the system you're using too it's like I'm not I didn't have to say it somebody just came on here and said samsara finally got us this report if your system's not giving you the reporting that you need then you need to find a system that's giving you either customizable reports or or better reporting structure but it it ultimately goes back to what the company how they're managing that process so it's it's only as good that report's only going to be as good as the information your admin or whoever's managing that process is putting in it and if you think the consequences are severe from a DOT perspective we haven't even talked about the highway accident litigation concerns here if you if you guys don't have these log falsifications under control imagine if one of the drivers who is routinely falsifying those logs goes and kills somebody and now that now you're thrown into litigation and you better understand that the plaintiff's attorney in that case is going to be well attuned to this issue and is going to be requesting not not just the driver's logs but also supporting documents in the context of that litigation and they're going to find these log falsifications and now it's going to be shown to the jury or the judge or whatever hey here's all of the the situations where this motor carrier allowed this driver to falsify their logs how can we allow this motor carrier to continue operating trucks on the on the roads we have to punish them for this type of bad behavior and that's where we see these jury these jury Awards tick up uh hours of service issues was on the top 10 list of atre's report where they had a a table that showed what are the most common issues that lead to a defense verd or to a plaintiff's verdict in these types of nuclear verdict cases that we're seeing hours of service I want to say was in the top three it may have been the first one um but I just want to be sure we understand that it's not just the do concerns here it's also the highway accident liation concerns and well I mean one of the places I was going to go way off task but so you better go ahead if you want to go but the just a real brief story on that is we had a customer that had a crash um that was somebody did an illegal turn and turned in front of one of our trucks and we hit them um actually no was a a prospect that we were working on and they they hit him and it killed a couple people and when they looked back at the last seven days logs there was a falsification two days before now nothing that impacted the crash at all but they would not reverse the crash because of that because they said he shouldn't have been there to begin with so you know whether we could argue that some more possibly but you know he seemed pretty firm that he was not going to overturn that yeah so from from kind of how I've always looked at this is and this is what I meant when I was going to go way off point here not too far off but it's close um you know as drivers going back to just when I drove and thinking about the mentality that I had to one you know the the driver Persona has changed a little so it's not as bad as it was I don't think but I was 100% money focused when I drove trucks so it didn't matter to me what I had to do to get as much money as possible I was going to run that way and with that kind of mentality a lot of it goes back to carriers articulating their expectations to their employees both at the time of hire and then ongoing throughout it um and not just to the drivers but to dispatchers who are saying hey we need this load to be here by this time I don't care how you get it done a lot of it goes to the company articulating those expectations to their drivers and their dispatchers and their and their employees in general to just say hey this is the culture we have I don't know where you worked before but we don't do that here and really laying out some some objective guidelines to kind of keep them fenced in because if you allow a driver to get that idea in their head that you're good with it then they're going to go with it so a lot of it you kind of got to have to you kind of have to fence people in especially if they're predisposed to to run wild I get the sense that a lot of carriers particularly smaller ones have the impression that this is just the that an issue that every motor carrier has that everybody tolerates a certain amount of log falsification and it's just not the case I mean we we work with the largest carriers in the country a lot of them and they do not tolerate a single instance of log falsification they sniff them all out themselves because they know the consequences that flow from log falsifications they understand this idea that it's probably better to have substantive hours violations than it is to have log falsifications and they take care of it they do the things that Rob's talking about they set it out in their policy this is exactly what happens if you try and falsify a log we're going to f we're going to find it and we're going to do whatever our Progressive disciplinary policy is and then they stick to it because like I said the consequences are too severe uh we got a several comments here let's see what others are saying uh Brian's asking am I allowed to keep myself in Split sleeper birth all the time even if I don't do a split sleeper no I don't even know what that means to be honest maybe you had clarify Brian yeah in some of the well in some of the uh ELD platforms you can switch over to a split sleeper like rule set yeah like a rule set and it'll calculate for you if the system is able to not to notice you went ahead and took a 10hour break and it gives you the normal hours back that you should be getting I don't see why you can't stay in a split sleeper birth uh hour set in the El because are there elds that allow drivers to change the rule set if that's a thing that worries me most of them I have seen it allows the carrier to change the rule set but not the driver I I think it you know what we'd have to do some investigation on that Brian because I think there there's a thing that you can tap on on some of the ELD platforms that hey I'm going to do a split sleeper and it'll do the calculation for you and when you want to come out of it you can kind of preview what things look like if you came out if you didn't split it or you finished the split and now you wanted to get out of it um so so maybe it's not so much a rule set it's more just kind of a a split sleeper option versus the alternative of not doing yeah yeah I think that that's what he's talking about and um yeah I don't maybe that's what Brian's asking kind of along the topic of Today's Show May I don't think that would be viewed as a log falsification to keep yourself with that option turned on even when you're not using it because it wouldn't be changing the the substantive version of your rest break in other words I don't think if you have the split sleeper option on but you're you're not taking advantage of it I don't think the system would be throwing or would be suggesting that there's no violation stemming from the lack of a full 10-hour rest break in other words I don't think the SI I think the system should be smart enough even if you have that turned on to know when there are violations but maybe I have that wrong and I just haven't seen that play out in practice no I believe you're exactly right uh let's see Jill here is asking is there always a fine given when you have a critical or an acute violation in an onsite audit on top of you going conditional or unset for your rating that's been my experience is that whenever there's a critical or acute violation um that it is very likely that you will subsequently get a civil uh uh notice of claim which is how the FMCSA imposes civil penalties and depending on the extent of those violations that's going to dictate the amount is that your guys's experience yep yep Y and let's not let's not stop the money flow there you know let's let's say it's going to cost you some money to get out of that either in manh hours within your own organization or if you have to hire somebody like truck safe um to to help you get out of it um and then what money are you losing in the Brokers that'll work with you or customers that'll work with you or you know your insurance company does is that grounds for the insurance company that you have right now to drop you or to give you notice of uh non-renewal you know there is a ton of consequences that go with that conditional or proposed unsat rating for sure it ain't cheap that's for sure I worked with uh probably 30 truck Fleet couple months ago that had a critical level of our U false logs that ended up with a conditional safety rating uh number one they had to get that conditional safety rating upgraded so they hired us to do that it wasn't cheap because a lot there's a lot of work that goes into getting your rating upgraded it's not just a thing where you go to FMCSA and say hey I fix these issues that that's that's not how it works they want to see lots of evidence that you've retrained the drivers that you have implemented new policies that you have done your own log audit on on your hours of service records and that you haven't incurred any other violations so there's a lot that goes into it there and then the carrier was subsequently fed again 30 truck Fleet for at one critical level violation of false logs they were fin $25,000 for that violation now you can usually get you can usually negotiate a downward reduction of those types of fines and you can usually you could sometimes get up to a 50% reduction but the point is it's it's not just a slap on the wrist this is real money we're talking about here um Jill's also asking how do you help encourage motor carriers to pay hourly instead of by a mile as a measure to help with hours of service issues thoughts on that guys I I have always found it to be difficult to pay drivers by the hour because most of them don't want to be paid by the hour you can't make as much but I mean again there's a different there's a different Persona of driver now than there was when when I was driving trucks so uh I also know people now are more focused on culture stability security and uh where they may be more more apt to accept an hourly rate but uh it just depends on the Persona of driver I think that's a whole another show discussing why the per mile rate doesn't work anymore um you know Freight's changed I we're going a little off off kilter here but Freight's changed it there's very limited Freight now that goes long hul you know the Thousand Mile plus everything is so regionalized that the mileage pay hasn't seen a big enough increase to accommodate the lack of miles that are there so you know the per mile rate for Long Haul drivers yeah you wouldn't want to go to an hourly rate you you're definitely way above the the bar there but Rob like what you said and then you you add the the freight change because was it atri's report came out I think the average driver drives it's like 17 or 1,800 miles a week now mhm I mean that was we were had that done by Wednesday back in the day you know so I hate yeah well I know I I I did sleep sometimes so you know wonder you guys are still alive well that's we don't do what we did because we either got caught doing it or we got away with it and you know we're just lucky James on LinkedIn is asking you guys probably can't see this one but he's asking or he say he says uh then you get exposed when the auditor asks for an edited log and they have a detailed list of admins making numerous log edits that can bite you so that's a whole other issue is is who's making edits to logs and and how are they doing that are these legitimate edits or not have you guys seen that cause any problems I think it depends on what you're how you're editing the log I mean if if we're talking like true electronic logs you have still have to certify that edit so I have seen carriers get irritated and say hey we're we're editing this time to make it correct and you're not accepting it so if we edit it and it comes to you for for certification for your signature on that edit you have to sign them all which isn't right because they can't coer you into signing something that's not correct so the other thing is and the other thing is driving time is not editable it shouldn't be I've heard of some ELD Solutions allowing you to edit drive time which would be which would make that ELD non-compliant but that's the other big that's that's one of the big ways that they're trying to crack down on log falsification is by making drive time uh uneditable so that we at least know how many hours accurately we should know how many hours accurately a driver is driving y Brian have you seen th those you know like carrier edits causing problems in any kind of context audits or anything like yeah it usually comes up when there's too many hands in the pot and too many people have access to make those edits um like Rob said it's still got to be sent back out to the driver to approve but oftentimes I'm Not Gon to say oftentimes but there's sometimes they're not even sure what they what they're looking at yeah yeah right you know they got this edit and they're just like yeah okay fine certify you know it's a huge point though because so often carriers edit the time they they think they're done they they're washing their hands of the issue we've we've fixed the issue but if the driver doesn't certify the log now you've got another issue now you've got potentially missing logs because in my experience at least when the FMCSA investigator is seeing a bunch of uncertified logs they consider them missing they're not complete the driver hasn't taken the last step of certifying the accuracy so then they just group all of those together and they consider them missing logs which again if you get if you're if they're looking out 100 logs and you got 10 or more that are missing you're going to run yourself right back into a uh a critical level violation so definitely a trap to be uh wary of there uh thanks for raising that James uh let's see we got one other comment here off topic you said hours of service each substantive category is looked at individually 11470 what about the other categories such as drug and alcohol DQ files VM are they like uh false log so those are all so those things you've listed there drug and alcohol DQ files vehicle maintenance those are factors and you if dot is looking at all of the factors for you if they're doing a comprehensive audit you are getting a rating in all of the factors and each factor has their own set of critical and acute level violations so in DQ for example if they're looking at driver qualification on your Fleet the two uh critical level violations that can cause problems in that factor are um missing or expired mvrs and then missing or expired Med cards those are the two things that if there's a 10% or more violation rate that could can uh cause problems for your safety rating uh but again those other factors the violations aren't double weighted so you can escape an audit with critical level violations in those other factors assuming there you don't have a ton of them uh with with a satisfactory safety rating but if you get one critical level violation in the hours of service factor it's a conditional rating at best is the point uh okay so we got a little bit off topic there and we're kind of running out of time but we talked about unplugging the device as one uh common way we see log falsifications we talked briefly very briefly about PC misuse although that's that's probably the most common culprit for log falsifications and we could spend probably three shows talking about PC misuse in fact um we've got a webinar an entire like two-hour webinar we did on PC misuse it's available in our Network that I mentioned at the start of the show if you join our Network you get access to those types of webinars um and then we also talked about what was the last one we talked about is log falsification oh unassigned driving time uh can lead to log falsifications any others that we missed there guys Ghost Driver Ghost Driver explain what that is Rob so um you know the way I've seen it done in the past is well I mean it was my aunt and um she worked she worked for a company I'm not going to tell you which one since I'm here and U when she worked Fort under the bus here Rob yeah she just died recently so we're okay we're past that laugh at this anymore then oh my God about so the aunt would she got sick right and she left but she was like Hey look you know you can just use me as the Ghost Driver just leave me on you know pay me a little money and you can use my CDL which is still active which couldn't work so a lot of companies what they'll do is they'll use the Ghost Driver so you know I've seen this not just happen with the aunt but I've seen it happen in other cases so it's you know they you're basically using like a legal Persona so to speak but they're not really working um that's not the person driving right so it's usually running a team a team deal which are are harder to audit um when you have to and it makes it look funnier from from the initial look at but um that's that's one of the ways I've seen it done yeah here's another common one someone raised I meant to raise this but thank you for raising this we've seen issues with drivers not logging fuel or making deliveries pickups as on duty instead of showing off duty I think may have had that one backwards um but yes so that is a very so with paper logs that was probably the the main way that do investigators would catch you in a log falsification is they would take your fuel report your fuel records they would have an entire list of every time that a driver was fueling and they would expect to see a segment of on duty not driving time at that particular moment in time and a lot of times drivers would log that as off duty and and those are situations I think this is another important caveat is that log falsifications a lot of them are nefarious but some of them are just inadvertent like the driver just made a mistake or the driver didn't know this fueling off duty is one where a lot of drivers just don't realize that they need to be logging that as on duty not driving and and then that is a log falsification if that gets discovered not just on paper logs but also on elds that's one of the ways that the dot still catches you is if they see on the ELD log that the drivers logged themselves put themselves in off-duty status and then they run the fuel report they see that there was fueling happening at that time that they're going to mark that up as an easy log falsification same thing with the loading and unloading if they've got evidence to prove that the driver was loading or unloading assisting in those efforts at a particular time but shown his off duty on the log easy pickings for a log falsification Brian any others did we hit them all yeah I think those are those are the big ones you know on on the paper the other I was getting thinking back to some of the things that was that was done uh back then it would be logging at the speed limit or a mile or two under the speed limit no real no matter really how long it took you to get there you know you get pinched in traffic or something like that if it was a 55 mph Zone you'd log it at 53 so they couldn't get you for speeding but you if you were if you were smart enough to know that thing that trick because we saw that all the time too investigators would calculate how many miles he drove on the day and they would divide it by how many driving hours you had logged on your log and they if it was sometimes you would see crazy numbers like in order to get that that amount of driving in that amount or that many miles and that amount of driving time they have to be going like 100 miles an hour or something like that so then they would just write you up for speeding versus a log falsification but yeah that's that's a good point I saw one falsification that a company would use the adverse driving conditions often that that thing's almost impossible to use anyway but that was the one thing that they would do is they would check if not for the whole day a section of the day the mileage or the odometer here and the odometer at the end and divide it up and if you average 57 58 miles an hour for that entire time there was no adverse driving conditions and they I hate that exemption that exemption runs so many carriers into trouble because it seems like it's a it should be useful to you but the how narrowly the dot defines that it's just virtually useless in most situations agreed James on LinkedIn is asking drivers waiting hours at a facility to load can the driver go off duty resting in a park vehicle and then once load is ready go on duty for their trailer Hook is the off duty considered a false log I'm going to say it this way there's a burden of proof If you are in the sleeper birth and your truck is equipped with a sleeper birth the burden of proof is on the officer to prove that you were not in the sleeper birth if you were off duty depending on um you know the definition of resting in a park vehicle and things like that off duty you have to prove that you were off duty that you were free of any uh responsibility to that truck trailer or load so you know you can use that however you want but that was kind of the way that you know we we did is if if you were in that loading facility and you weren't responsible for counting the load or loading it or anything like that and you were in the sleeper birth log it there that's where you were Rob any thoughts same thing yeah it can get uh so I agree I uh you know investigators and law enforcement look at those critically they they see you uh logging long periods of off duty time while you're at a a shippers or receivers facility they're going to look at it critically but I think there are situations as Brian said where you can legitimately log your time off duty the regulation says that in order to log that time is off duty you have to be relieved of all responsibility for performing any work meaning you could do whatever you want during that period where the where the shipper or the receiver are loading or unloading the truck it gets a little tricky and a little gray when you're talking about a situation where hey you have no responsibilities to help with the loading or unloading but you do kind of have a responsibility to stay there with the truck in other words the motor carrier doesn't want you leaving that truck unattended is that a respon a work rated responsibility that would warrant you being left in on duty not driving status uh there are differing opinions on that well for that I would kind of go back to like the labor rule that says do you have to pay truck drivers you know because they're out there for you know just say Long Haul say they're out for 28 days or or whatever it is they're not working but they are kind of they are in possession of your truck they can't go home and spend time with their kids so uh but do you have to log that time as like hey I'm technically on duty because I'm respons responsible to be in this truck for the next 3 weeks no but like he said it's the burden of proof and how you how you log what you log so it's I I I would always do sleeper birth if I was going to be there for an extended period of time that way I could split it and use my time as efficiently as possible what benefit do you get out of logging it as off duty rather than on duty not driving because it doesn't extend your 14 hour rule unless you're on the split sleeper birth so I guess what it yeah so what what benefit does it does it get you no in terms say that again Bri yeah it saves on your 70 on your accumulative hours yeah that's right but for me I would try to I shop for sleeper birth you know if it was especially say if I knew it was a customer that I went to a lot just say sweet potatoes where it might take some crazy number like four or five hours to get loaded I would take full whether I was there or not I was going to go into sleeper birth and then split that later U and take advantage of it that way yeah so those are the two areas split sleeper birth and then the uh the 70 hour rule is the benefit there but if you're not if you're not close to running a foul of the 70h hour rule then it really does you no good and if you're not taking advantage of the split sleeper birth then you're just potentially running yourself into problems it's the same kind of deal with um uh with personal conveyance the thing I always say about personal conveyance is if you don't truly need it to to if you're not at risk of running a foul of your substantive hours of service limits I'm turning personal conveyance off because it is only likely to cause me problems it's only The Fleets that truly need to legitimately use personal conveyance where it makes sense for them to do so in my view if you have drivers who are home you know you know out and back every day and and aren't at risk of going over their 11 hour 14 hour time limits then then turn that thing off because that's just going to cause you all kinds of trouble uh last question here and then we got a wrap here Troy on LinkedIn is asking can fall false logs occur under the short Hall exemption can log falsifications occur for drivers that are under short Hall I guess it depends on what you what you I mean I look at false logs as anything that's unrealistic you're any record of Duty status that's not truthful and your record of Duty status you do have one for short Hall which is your time sheet so if you're if you're pencil whiping the time sheet um which is easy to do because you know you're not differentiating drive time and and on duty by regulation and um provided your back within 14 hours I mean who's to say that you you you drove more than the 10h hour you know or or the or the 11 so it's it depends on what mode you are but um I've never seen a time card I've never seen a time card personally written up as a log falsification what I usually see it written up as let's say a driver has a time card but they should have had a log because they exceeded the short Hall bounds it would be written up as a missing log for that particular day which would contribute to a 10% violation rate potentially that's the most common way where I've seen that but I I agree Rob that even if we don't call it a false log in other words I don't think it would be grouped with the other true log falsifications to calculate a 10% rate but where certainly if the investigator has reason to believe that that time card is falsified they've got other enforcement mechanisms to write that up as a falsified federally required document uh even if it doesn't impact your your rate there Brian any thoughts on that yeah I think if you know you when you start talking about fueling or loading or unloading outside the time boundaries of your time card um that like you said that technically that's not doesn't fall under the the falsification on on the pile that they're checking on a regular e-rod but um that could raise that would definitely raise the eyebrows if something like that happened all right guys guys we could have spent another several hours talking about that appreciate you guys as always great discussion thanks everybody for weighing in with your questions it's always more fun when we got uh questions coming in that we're able to address um we uh Brian where can people reach out if they have questions for you or want to learn more about what Reliance Partners is doing uh Reliance partners.com there's always exciting stuff going on there you can look me up on uh LinkedIn or Facebook I'm on both I'm always happy to answer questions oh and I'm on uh I'm on the truck safe Network too on on that social media platform so that that's probably the best place to get a hold because you'll probably actually get the right answer if you put it on there and I don't answer it also check out Brian just had an article come out it was it Freight waves yeah on freight waves about growing for the sake of growth that we see companies outgrow their infrastructure and this type stuff starts happening yeah for sure so check that out you can check that out Freight waves website Rob where can people find out out more and follow you I'm everywhere but primarily on truck safe so and Linkedin yep LinkedIn you need to follow Rob on LinkedIn if you're not following him he's posting like two times a day something he's got some kind of crazy LinkedIn schedule and it's all doot most of it's do related so be sure to follow him uh if there's anything we can do to help you over at truck safe uh you know safety rating upgrades manage services any of that type of stuff and also all of the content that we're pushing out online courses uh YouTube channel everything like that check us out over at trucksafe outcom thanks a lot guys really appreciate you joining me we're going to wrap it up there thanks everybody talk to you later see you thanks guys

Event Completed

Thursday, October 26, 2023 at 2:55 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube