Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 31 - Making good impressions

Thursday, November 9, 2023 at 4:04 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 31 - Making good impressions

About This Event

In this episode, we’re joined by Clara Flaherty of CarrierSource to discuss how carriers can make a good safety-related impression with customers or potential customers. We’ll hit on various safety metrics, as well as review websites.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 31 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter explore what motor carriers can and should be doing to make themselves more attractive to broker and shipper customers. The topic is especially timely given the challenging freight market, with carriers of all sizes feeling economic pressure and many smaller fleets finding themselves effectively blacklisted by brokers or shippers due to poor safety metrics or negative online reputations. The hosts frame the conversation around the idea that building a strong, professional image is not just about winning more business — it is also about long-term survival in an increasingly competitive and scrutinized industry. Rob Carpenter, drawing on his background as both a freight broker and a motor carrier owner, outlines what brokers and shippers typically look for when vetting carrier partners. Safety scores and operating authority are the first things checked, with conditional safety ratings often being dealbreakers for reputable brokers. Beyond safety metrics, Carpenter emphasizes that professionalism, equipment appearance, on-time performance, and adequate insurance coverage all factor into a carrier's attractiveness. The hosts also discuss broker and shipper liability in the event of accidents, noting that the rise of negligent selection lawsuits has made due diligence a financial necessity for anyone tendering freight, not just an administrative formality. The episode's featured guest, Clara Flaharty, co-founder of Carrier Source, joins to discuss how her platform — described as a Yelp for trucking companies — helps carriers build and manage their online reputation. Carrier Source aggregates FMCSA safety and insurance data alongside verified reviews from brokers and shippers, giving carriers a free, claimable profile they can update with equipment types, service lanes, photos, and contact information. Fleury explains that the platform actively combats fraud by flagging carriers that share registered addresses or phone numbers with other carriers, and publishes a monthly list of carriers flagged for double brokering. She notes that the platform is increasingly being used not just for vetting purposes but as a discovery tool, helping smaller carriers get found by brokers searching for top-rated carriers in specific regions. On the practical side, Fleury advises carriers with damaged reputations to start by claiming and fully updating their Carrier Source profile, responding professionally to any negative reviews, and proactively soliciting reviews from existing customers. She notes that a small number of negative reviews is not necessarily harmful and can actually lend credibility to a profile by demonstrating authenticity. Wiseman and Carpenter add that while some carriers consider volunteering for roadside inspections to generate clean inspection data, the strategy carries real risk, as officers may find violations even on well-maintained equipment, and certain states require probable cause before conducting an inspection. The hosts close with a reminder that transparency and consistent communication between carriers, brokers, and shippers remain foundational to building lasting business relationships. Wiseman also touches briefly on FMCSA's extended comment period — now running through the end of November 2023 — on its Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking related to safety rating methodology, urging carriers to submit comments given the potential for CSA scores to be used in assigning safety ratings in the future. Fleet safety professionals looking to improve their carrier's market position are encouraged to visit carriersource.com to claim their profile and begin managing their online presence proactively.

Full Transcript

call me the Joker call me the fool when she calls I always here to lose my cool baby I'm just a to your plane and don't you know that you is a train waiting that don't you know that love you a train wck waiting to fun is it is got no class all attributes don't know if I'm talking about me or you baby no one get me like you do I see Le you there a waiting to Happ don't you know that love you is a train to fun don't youing you a train W I have fun you know it's true you is a train wreck waiting that Happ f yeah yeah loing you is a train wreck way have fun you it you is a train he oh hey everyone welcome to episode 31 truck safe live the show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children's law this is Rob Rob what's up not a whole lot how's it going it's going right Rob's co-hosting with me today how about that we're going to see how that goes you've worked your way up from guest to co-host I guess how's that feel how's that feel good for the first week we're gonna find out we're gonna find out on the next show if I'm coming back yeah we'll see if you make it to the next show or not but uh Jared has left me uh he's out hunting in Colorado this week so uh we'll see what he comes back with it's always interesting uh but anyway this is uh like I said show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation uh this is episode 31 called making good Impressions got a great show in store talking about things that uh motor carriers can and should be doing to make themselves more appealing to their broker and shipper customers or potential customers so uh it's come up a lot recently with a lot of our clients it's always top of mind for particularly the smaller carriers but but everybody really so uh got a lot of thoughts on it excited to have a special guest with us today so we'll get into that in a minute uh before we do if you're here with us say hey in the comments I always like to see who around um and as we go along certainly throw any questions or comments that you have in the chat and we will get to them as they come up few things going on before we get to the main topic uh at truck safe and in the industry uh first up we mentioned this last show but wanted to welcome Rob on board to truck safe officially uh he is now our VP and director of manag services so welcome Rob thank you good to be here we're excited to have going to figure that one out but yeah I we've got great things in store we you know as I've said in past shows we've always got a lot lot of stakes in the fire at truck safe and uh and uh we get to a point where there's only so much that Jared and I can do so we're finally starting to grow and couldn't be more excited to have Rob on board I just have have loved following you over the years Rob with all your content that you're posting and uh all the good work you do for the industry and and your background just um it's it's hard to beat so excited to have you on board looking forward to where we're able to take this to the next step so um let's see what else do we have going on uh one thing I will mention I mentioned a lot of stakes in the fire we actually have some really big news coming up out a truck safe I think it's going to be uh uh pretty exciting for a lot of folks in the industry can't can't release it right now unfortunately but stay tuned um in the next couple of months we should be able to release some information on this new project new exciting project that we've got going on uh so stay tuned for that uh and then also if you haven't already joined our trucksafe Fleet compliance Network um be sure to do so this is available at trucksafe network.com also we have an app in the app store in the Google Play Store this is a social network for Fleet Safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also have access to all of our DOT compliance content that we do through truck safe uh articles videos podcasts everything like that free to join trucksafe network.com um hope to see you there other than that what else is going on in the industry um that's worth talking about over the last couple weeks Rob have you seen anything come through seems like it's been a pretty quiet couple of weeks compared dry spell which means there's a lot coming somewhere soon yeah the the floodgates are going to open soon I fear yeah um no I haven't I haven't seen a lot of anything so it's been you know the quietness kind of makes you worry a little bit but Calm before the storm the biggest noise actually somewhat what we're talking about today is you know the the bottomed out market and what carriers can do to to improve their reputation and get more get more work yeah that seems to be for sure uh one of the top issues in fact we we discussed this on our last show but atrey American Transportation Research Institute recently came out with its uh annual list of top issues impacting motor carriers and drivers and uh the economy was was on that list as it as it has been in the past but not as prominent as it was this time around so definitely a concern a lot of folks feeling the the pain of that um and so hopefully some of the stuff we talk about on today's show can help maybe alleviate some of those issues but uh but we'll see but other than that uh I agree I not much news uh in the past couple of weeks the one thing that that did come down it's been probably three weeks or so now I think um uh FMCSA is extending its comment period on its Advanced notices proposed Ru making related to safety rating um methodology the way that we assign safety ratings uh folks who watch the show will remember we've talked about this on past shows pretty extensively and we've written some articles on it at trucksafe decom but there's a real potential there for a pretty big shakeup in the way that the FMCSA assigns safety ratings to motor care if you're not familiar with that and you're a motor carrier you should really read up on it and you should submit your comments comments were originally du at the end of October but they've extended that um presumably because they're getting a lot of comments and now you have until the end of November of 2023 to get your comments in here here's my biggest concern with that Ru making I've said it before but if I'm reading the tea leaves here it looks like what we are probably going to be uh up against is the potential for the FMCSA to be using a motor carrier CSA scores at least in part to set their safety rating which has never been done historically historically these safety ratings have been uh issued only after a motor carrier has been through a a DOT audit a compliance review that's what it has taken uh historically for a motor carrier to get a safety rating problem is not very many carriers get audited each year um I think the numbers are less than 80% um no less than 20% of motor carriers registered with the do have ever been audited and so that what that leaves is a lot of motor carriers that the FMCSA has just never really evaluated um and so they're trying to they're wrestling with a way to do that where they can uh they can evaluate a bigger Universe of motor carriers and potentially assign a safety rating they they tried this back in 2016 and the proposal back then was to tie it to CSA scores and that proposal just got so many negative comments that they eventually just withdrew it but here we are again 2023 FMCSA is considering it again thoughts on that Rob um I'm not I'm not in love with it um it's kind of I guess it kind of goes to what I was I was reading a story maybe a week ago where they were talking about there was I think it was duner and he was talking about somebody tying your safety scores toh or your insurance I think it was to your um telematics stuff your telematics data so it was like you know how accurate is that data and is it good information and sometimes those sometimes that information can be skewed to too so um you know I I've just never been a fan of that idea so yeah I've always been a little concerned not a little uh very much concerned about uh um the reliability of the CSA data and and particularly a motor carrier's inability to meaningfully challenge erroneous data that inevitably gets put on their scores you know uh they get stopped for a roadside inspection officer writes up a violation it's just an incorrect violation officer uh misinterpreted the law or something like that happens every single day to lots of motor carriers and right now the Avenue that the motor carrier has available to them to contest that is the data cues system but those data cues appeals get reviewed and adjudicated by the same agency that issued the violation to begin with so there's just real no due process available to the carriers that was my that's always been my biggest hesitation to move to a system where we're tying a carrier safety rating it's lifeblood to CSA scores is that lack of due process now to fmcsa's credit after they announced this uh aprm this advanced notice of proposed rulemaking pertaining to safety ratings they came out with another notice suggesting that they are thinking about updating the data cues process and setting up some kind of an independent uh review board that would essentially be more due process available to the carriers so if that goes through and I have no reason to believe it won't go through I bet it gets quite a bit of support from industry folks um then maybe I have a little less heartburn with starting to come up with a different way of handling safety ratings but until we get to that point I just think it's a bad idea so point is uh notice uh comment period is extended until the end of November if you as a motor carrier or driver Whoever has anything to say about that make sure you go in and and file your comments um this is your opportunity to kind of shape the uh the way that that regulation ends up um okay that's going to wrap things up for in terms of what's going on in the industry before we segue into today's topic I wanted to uh say a quick thanks to the sponsor of today's show which is Carrier Source um carrier source is Carrier review website made for trucking companies to build a fair reputation online while providing Brokers and shippers another layer to their vetting process with peer reviews of carriers every active carrier has a free profile they can claim and update to get found by the 250,000 plus Brokers and shippers using carrier source to find their next carrier be sure to check them out online carriers source. thanks to carrier source for uh sponsoring Today's Show and in fact we're looking forward to talking with Clara from carrier Source here a bit later in this episode but to kind of set the stage for today's topic again it's titled making good Impressions the idea is to discuss an issue that seems to be causing a lot of problems for a lot of fleets across the country I would say probably every week I get at least three or four calls or emails uh uh typically from smaller carriers asking for help improving their various safety metrics and telling us that they've essentially been blacklisted by Brokers or shippers for one reason or another and so the question is how do they do that how do they how do they go about improving the reputation uh with their customers or better yet how can carriers keep themselves out of that situation to begin with by building up a good image um and so that's the topic of today's show I'm glad to have Rob with me today as a co-host because Rob I know you've seen this kind of from both sides of the equation you've been both on the broker side you've also owned your own Motor Carrier so I guess I'll start with uh question to you which is what do you think makes what would you say makes a particular carrier attractive to a a broker or shipper what are the things that that uh Brokers and shippers are looking for in a good carrier partner um from the broker side you know one of the first things that we had to do was you know when I first started brokering that was what was really beat Into Me by by the company that I worked for at the time before I got my own broker Authority and then I carried that into mine too so you know their their struggle was constantly to make sure that you're you're an intermediary for this Freight so whoever you ultimately assign it to can have a negative effect on you uh as a broker I mean you had to work you had to do those cold calls you had to get that that shipper to actually allow you to broker their Freight and that's not always the easiest thing in the world to do I hated the C call thing and um people just shippers get finicky and they get uh they get set with their own Brokers and and comfortable but one of the first things that they look at is safety scores they go right into SMS and they look at what are what are your what is your rating first um and do you even have an authority second um so there's a lot of different things to look at to make sure that if they're going to give you that Freight as um as a carrier that you're going to make sure that it gets there for their customer uh beginning to end safe in one piece and on time and um most car Mo most Brokers and most shippers aren't they don't want to see the the conditionals um and obviously definitely not unsatisfactory because you're not going to be running anyway but well really they're looking for satisfactory or unrated or you're just not generally going to get the work unless it's just a garbage broker that'll give it to anybody so um it starts there and then from there you know you can go through and start looking at different sites for for reputation which kind of gets into into where a carrier Source brings brings it into perspective for everybody uh so ultimately it's a safety thing but then it's a time management thing you know are they going to get it their on time so it's all kinds of different things that Brokers look at yeah on that safety side of thing I think it's important to point out you know the reason why shippers and Brokers care so much about the safety aspect of this thing is that they have real skin in the game so said this on other shows before but um you know if they pick a carrier who is an unsafe carrier to haul the freight either on their behalf or behalf of their customers and then the driver for that carrier goes and kills somebody or seriously injures someone you know more and more this wasn't all that common maybe I don't know 10 20 years ago but it is becoming increasingly common for the plaintiffs in those cases to sue not only the the motor carrier but also going on up the chain to the broker and to the shippers looking for the Deep Pockets because often times you know that motor motor carrier it may be a small carrier they're carrying the minimum amount of commercial Auto liability insurance that they're required to carry which is $750,000 $750,000 that has been the limit since the80s $750,000 does not go that far in in in 2023 uh and so an injur a seriously injured plaintiff or or a deceased plaintiff uh the amount of Damages they're looking at for those particular cases is going to far exceed $750,000 the limit of that policy and so the question is where do they go after that well if it's a small carrier they probably don't have anything else other than that insurance and so there so you're not going to get your relief there so now we have to start looking up the chain and this is where you start to see broker and shipper liability and and becoming more uh prominent in the last decade or so um and we've seen cases where Brokers and shippers have been held liable um for substantial sums in connection with highway accidents and so you know they're they're watching this and to minimize their own exposure to those types of Damages they have to do what they can to make sure that they are handing the freight off to Safe carriers that they have done their own due diligence to make sure that the carrier they're going to give the freight to has at least at minimum these things that you've talked about Rob so that they at least have a valid DOT number you you can imagine how it would play to a jury if I'm the broker and it turns out that I handed the freight off to a carrier that didn't even have a DOT number I mean that's going to be you know lights out for you essentially I mean you get you are expected to use reasonable care is the point when you are a a broker or a shipper in selecting the motor carriers that you're going to Tender Freight to and that involves some basic checks making sure they got a valid DOT number making sure they got the right operating Authority making sure they got the right insurance and then safety rating is another common one like you said a lot of Carri a lot of Brokers and shippers don't want to do business with a carrier that has anything other than a satisfactory rating or no rating at all conditional rating causes uh throws up some red flags so the point is shippers and Brokers have real skin in the game here and that's why they are concerned particularly with the safe safety aspects but you also mentioned some others I'm interested to get your thoughts on um just kind of things outside of the safety realm that a broker or shipper might be uh looking at the ones that always come to mind are like how you know I'm always a little bit nervous if I'm a broker about you know the that motor carrier's interaction with my customers how do they you know how are they going to present themselves to my shipper and and receiver customers and stuff like that what other kind of things other than safety related are Brokers and shippers looking at in your experience well price is a big one but outside of that um I mean going a little bit back to that was it's due diligence but just like you would do your due diligence when you're hiring a driver there's due diligence when you're hiring a carrier so it's not all about the paperwork and the safety rating a lot of it goes to you know in some in some ways it's hard to do this because you're not especially with over the road fleets you're not seeing these everywhere you know especially if it's a small Fleet but you look at companies out there like Old Dominion um they they their entire thing their entire premise of it's our brand is good our reputation is good our drivers look clean Walmart's the same way you know you look at a Walmart driver and you know they drive for Walmart their equipment is clean their equipment is maintained their out of service rate is good um so it's it's you you really want to look at the whole picture from a due diligence standpoint like like I said from just like like you would hire a driver you're not just looking at what's on the application you're looking at everything you know in between um and then there's the insurance side of things so if you've got high value Commodities you don't want to give it to somebody who's just got the bare minimum $750,000 in coverage so um it's it's it's a lot more to it than simply just looking at the safety piece and you know going from there one of the things that we did not have when I was a broker was carrier Source these things didn't exist at that time so really what we had to go on was really one of three things um or one of two things actually so we we would throw Bo we would throw the load out on on that we would get depends on the lane I mean if it was like in California to northw you'd get a thousand phone calls it looked like uh Boiler Room uh the movie boiler room but it was just call after call after call and then you were constantly trying to scream people and get the best rate that was the old school way of doing things and then we just had to screen them by what you could get off of line but now you've got carrier source and um and other things like Yelp and trust pilot and all these things that that basically rate everything from Foley safety service to um Old Dominion Freight Lines so you it's everywhere you you have this huge level of public data that that kind of pushes that information to you yeah well that's a good segue into uh to the guest that we're going to bring on today I'm excited to have uh Clara flarey with us from carrier Source co-founder of carrier sorus welcome Clara hey thank you glad to be here hey thanks so much for uh for being with us today we really appreciate you joining us appreciate carrier Source partnering with us to uh sponsor this episode and we're excited to talk to you about this idea of making good Impressions so before we get started for folks who may not be familiar with you uh I wanted to see if you can give us your background and and how you made your way into Trucking yeah absolutely um the beginning of my career was was certainly not uh Trucking I I came from actually G2 which is a competitor to trust pilot Rob which you I'm sorry so that's we'll talk about that after the show but uh I spent you know the the first six years of my career um at G2 and really eating sleeping breathing user reviews and that's really where my background um is and where a lot of my passion is um I found my way into Trucking by one of my uh co-workers at G2 left G2 in no mber of 2020 and started carrier Source um and when he first was starting it I was like okay Rob like cool good luck you know have fun um just because I didn't know really anything about the industry um and then about two years later he gave me a call and he was like Hey what if you came and did marketing and uh you know built out our our user base and our reviews uh here in instead of G2 um and I thought about it a lot and you know it's he was a startup and it was obviously you know leaving a career that I've loved and I've had for a long time coming to um a new space but it was exciting so I joined and I've been here now a year and a half uh helping helping really build out what this site is and and and figuring out more and more how we can help the carriers yeah you're preaching to the choir there in terms of kind of the nerves that get uh built up when you're talking about starting a new Venture I experienced that myself uh starting up truck safe but um nothing more fulfilling uh about it really once you get it going and once it starts to get some level of success so um kudos to you for making that jump and uh so what is Carrier source for those not familiar with the service maybe you get us the elevator pitch uh about carrier Source yeah so the easiest way to explain it and I think the thing that clicks the most for people is is the Yelp for trucking companies so we have a profile for every single carrier out there and you can come in and we we pull in FMCSA safety and insurance information and then we pair that alongside with information that the the company itself wants to provide so equipment type shipment type Lanes they run states of operation um updated contact info if what they registered with the FMCSA isn't anymore the the best person to be um that that main point of contact uh and then we also pull in reviews from verified Brokers and shippers um so for somebody to write a review on our site to review a carrier they need to sign up they need to be able to prove they are who they say they are and they also need to be able to prove that they've worked with that carrier um so so we offer that that extra level of of verification that you know a Google review doesn't necessarily provide what's that verification process look like so a lot of my time at G2 was spent figuring out exactly how we can spot scammers and how we can uh properly moderate so that we make sure that only good reviews are coming through I can't tell you everything because then that is a GU I don't any Trade Secrets here well it's a guideline for how scammers then can like okay like you know figure out the system um but we we do our due diligence by looking you know looking up social media profiles do they have a business email um we ask them for a screenshot when they write a review so reducted Raton emails with them and the carrier um some kind of level of proof that they actually did work with that carrier um we also have a human read every single review before it goes up we're not using any you know machines and that's something that we're really passionate about is just like no we want to have a real set of eyes on every single review because this reviews are important and they do make or break a business and we believe that they are important I I like I said at the start of the show if you were listening in um I would say probably three or four times a week I'm getting calls from uh carriers who who tell me that they essentially they think they have been blacklisted by a particular broker uh or shipper and they a lot of times are referencing some s some sort of review site where they either have a bad review on that on that site or the data that is filtering into that site is casting them as as a um you know as as an unsafe carrier or something uh something like that so I I guess this is kind of the the million-dollar question for those types of carriers but I'll pose it to you you know if a carrier finds themselves in in that type of situation whether it's your site or a competitor's site what what's your advice to them to to start to get things cleaned up and make themselves more appealing to their potential customers yeah and that's a great question and and one of the reasons that we built carrier Source we we are actively trying to invite carriers into the conversation like you see a lot of these other sites that are um that are out there they they kind of block the carrier out like it's like okay like for example carrier 411 will just straight up be like do not call if you're a carrier I'm not speaking to you like do not reach out um and that's that's debilitating for the carrier that stops the trucking company from having any kind of conversation or any kind of resolution um so we encourage you know okay if you get a negative review number one that's not necessarily a a bad thing um negative reviews put some level of um validation to the rest of your reviews you know if I'm looking up a product on Amazon and I see all five star reviews and nothing negative I'm like okay that's probably you know like there must someone had a bad experience but you know that one or two negative reviews automatically gives a layer of verification they're like okay these other reviews are probably correct um and then a negative review also gives you a good opportunity to win back business you don't you don't know what you don't know so if you get get this negative review um that's someone telling you here's what I hated about you know this experience and you have an opportunity to to fix it if if it's something that you you know is fixable if it's not fixable even responding and being like thanks so much for this feedback we're doing our best to you know remedy this we invite you to come back and you know we've made these steps to to figure this out and please come back and work with us again give us another try what do you do to encourage chippers and Brokers to leave reviews because you know just thinking about this this in my own experience it's tough to get people to leave feedback particularly good feedback you're you're more inclined to leave feedback leave feedback when you've got a bad experience obviously but it's tough getting people to give you positive feedback so are there things that you guys do to encourage your shipper and broker uh customers to leave feedback yeah we do offer incentives for for reviews so we'll throw you like a $5 doll gift card uh if you leave a review on your experience um we don't try we don't separate between like you know leave a positive review and we'll give you $5 a negative review just like give write a review share your experience what we have noticed is that so many more of our reviews are positive than negative and I think it's because there is this like the industry has been stacked for a long time in you know not in favor of the carrier necessarily so I think Brokers and chippers who work with great carriers are like yeah I would like to thank them like they've done a really good job for me over the past three years or whatever and giving them some kind of of token of gratitude in in the form of a review um and then you get five bucks out of it you know why not Starbucks gift card yeah Starbucks who could turn that down so I'm curious what are you um I assume in the course of kind of building out the system and and and that type of stuff you got a lot of feedback from Brokers and shippers in terms of what they want to see out of what kind of data they want to see about their potential carrier Partners what what are the main things that you've taken away from that uh those experiences what what is it that shippers and Brokers are looking at um what are they interested at looking at in particular yeah um I think one thing that that we're definitely seeing is people are using us as a as a checkpoint to see like okay does this carrier have reviews even if they're bad reviews like is this person real especially with all the the fraud that's happening now like you know that's very Buzz wordy but like all the double brokering that that is going on and all the scamming that's happening people are just looking for some level of verification they like okay is this person who they say they are and even if they did a bad job like it's like okay well they were real like their truck showed up late but they still delivered it you know what I mean um so people are using us to see like does this carrier have any review does this carrier have some sort of online presence some sort of thing showing that they are who they say they are and they're not just one of these spun up MC's um to you know to take and and re broker Freight um are you finding a lot of situations where Brokers and shippers are weighing in in reviews about double brokering I because I'm with you I mean that seems to for whatever reason over the last three or four years I've seen a lot more chatter online about double brokerage making it seem like it's becoming an increasingly difficult problem to deal with are you seeing that as well we are we we just started releasing um list that we release every month of like here are the new carriers that have been flagged for double brokering in our system um so we're up to we' got 581 carriers so far that have flagged for double brokering um and I think the other thing that that we're trying to do is we're trying to make everything public like I think what's happening is like a lot of brokerages are finding that like okay this this was a double broker and then being like okay don't tell anyone about that that's proprietary information whereas like we're just being like okay here are the double Brokers like check them out don't use them or use them if you if you want but um fair warning you know yeah better to have the information than not rob feel like I'm dominating this conversation do do you have any question the only thing I was going to say earlier is um you know when when we were talking about kind of the voice of customer thing I think that drives a lot and whether it's good or bad that that voice kind of validates that the carrier is real and you know fraud is a big thing and that that was some of my questions that I had had outlined was in the fraud side of things because you know we've seen especially recently with cargo freight where um carrier um basically criminals have been posing as carriers and going and picking up loads and and then that's that's how they're stealing some loads so there's that piece of it but back to the voice of the customer side it's you know I think your site ultimately gives carriers an effective showcase uh or an effective way to Showcase their strength their strengths and their capabilities um to to potential shippers and Brokers through those reviews and that voice of customer even if it's just to say that they're a real carrier because I think just proving that someone is a real carrier in 2023 is is something in and of itself so um that that's where I was going to go with the first piece and and then obviously moving into the to the fraud side um do do you besides the reviews are there any specific tools and resources that that carrier Source has that help shippers and Brokers identify fraudulent carriers or I know you mentioned some earlier in terms of the screen screenshot Etc validation so we also have started implementing a system where if a carrier has the same registered address or phone number as another carrier on our site there's a flag that shows up that's just like hey there are some related carriers uh to this carrier and goal of that is hoping to you know obviously there are perfectly acceptable and perfectly reasonable reasons that um someone might have the same phone number or same address addess as as another carrier not many not not many uh exactly not many so we do we do raise that as another level of like hey you should maybe check this out before you work with this carrier like is this a reasonable you know reason for them having this or is there something something maybe ay yeah I know John Rogers I think on LinkedIn I think he had I think it was him that put uh he had he had found that one of his carriers that he had that he had chosen was at an address with like 22 other carriers so he kind of got skeptical at that point and then realized yeah you know it was it was a double broker deal but um anyway so yeah and I I know there was there's like somebody has been spinning up using the same email of WTF FMCSA aol.com there's like 300 carriers in our site that have been spun up with that email address and it's people trying to alert the CSA that maybe something is up if they are having this easy of a time but it's funny like when we go through new companies that have come up it's like oh there's another one besides the trailer pickups have you seen any other common scams or schemes that that carriers should you know or or or that carriers are being subjected to outside of the broker deal outside of the double brokering I know there's been like you said like a lot of a lot of cargo that um and and a lot of people stealing like we'll get a lot of emails being like this person is using my MC number they are not me um which that one's just a bummer too because then that Blacklist that MC number even though it's potentially good people behind it which is again why the reviews are important because it's like okay here's what happened here are my 12 reviews you know from the last six months that are showing that this is not me anymore yeah Brandon actually has a customer who called me and said hey Rob um I had a customer call me and there's someone using my DOT number with someone else's email and someone else's phone number what can I do and like I don't know let me look into it but it's it's happened more than once yeah yeah we see it pretty often where sometimes it's really egregious like that but other times it's you know maybe a a former owner operator that had been leased onto a carrier uh gets terminated from that particular carrier and then doesn't take off the uh the placards the the markings on the side of the truck and they keep operating and then they get stopped for an inspection and those violations end up on that carrier's uh safety scores even though that driver is not operating for them anymore and so the question is what can you do in there what what can you do other than file a data que and tell them that hey this carrier wasn't operate or this driver wasn't supposed to be operating under our DOT number anymore but how do you get them to to pull off those markings from the side of the truck I mean I've tried everything from calling the local police department to uh to get them involved and see if they can get out there to pull those markings off the side of the truck but it's it's it seems to be a pretty significant issue for for a lot of carriers for sure have the have any of the police departments that you've reached out to like been helpful in thatu no not really they've got other things to do they're like okay but also this murder that just happened and you're like well yeah better go take care of that first and then come back uh but yeah it it's uh that issue comes about in many different ways um so yeah I I likewise have heard that that is a problem for a lot of carriers one of the things you mentioned this CLA that I find interesting about your system as compared to some of the others that I've seen over the years is the ability that you give for carriers to kind of go in and kind of control their own destiny in terms of claiming their account and uh and and making themselves uh helping with their own reputation rather than some other platforms that just don't that that just leave the reviews and then the carriers have no recourse whatsoever so I was curious if you can kind of walk us through how your if I'm a motor carrier how I can use carrier source to to help improve my reputation yeah absolutely um I'm gonna try this share screen uh thing yeah let's see if this works I this will be the first time I've tried to let a guest share a screen but uh we'll give it a shot all right you guys it uh hold on one second here uh this is not looking good there it is found it okay cool awesome um so on our site if if you're a carrier you can you can go ahead and and search your dot or MC number um so or your company name if you want so we'll go to mall transport some free advertising for them um and then uh if you scroll down just a little bit if the if you haven't claimed your profile yet you can go ahead and and claim your profile um and then that'll trigger any email to us that's like hey this person is trying to claim you'll get a verification email to the email that you registered with the FMCSA um and then you can claim it from there and then once you've claimed it you're able to come in here and update all this information and again this is all free like our our our main goal here was to first um create a site that that a base online presence for every carrier um so free to come in claim your profile and update all this info so you can update your truck types shipment types any specialized services that you run I'll show all a carrier that has come in and claimed um that Wiman transport was not me oh looked up one of your names um but he's come in and put in this is Harvey and he's coming and put in you know the the kind of truck he has the shipments he runs and then also his his states of operation um so people know exactly what kind of jobs they can book him for um and how you know how how they can work with him um and then you can also check out his reviews and you know see that you know he's got a lot of a lot of great reviews he responded three days ago um which we obviously encourage and love when carriers are doing that um and you can also throw in pictures of you know of your site and and uh of your of your truck and he he's really proud of how he packs his truck it's always very neat and clean so he was like I'm I want to show pictures of that and we're like cool throw that in there it's pretty cool you're almost giving them like their own personalized website like if I can imagine for smaller carriers that haven't gone to the length of creating their own website and stuff like that that this would be a valuable way for them to uh send potential customers a link to their page on your site um do you have a lot of customers that or a lot of carriers that use it in that way we do yeah and that that was part of the idea was just like okay create a base online presence for everybody um so that there is some kind of where somewhere that they can update their information if they get another truck or if they start running different kinds of shipments like great put that in there have that one one place that you can send to people as a as a resource about who you are and what you do I think I saw link oh go ahead r no I was just going to say I think that's one of the best things I I was surfing your site and uh I think that from from a broker perspective it's a really good thing for Brokers because back in the day before you existed or or yel existed you know I feel old but um when we were doing things like on paper um what what we would have to do is basically keep track of all of our loads over over years and decades and then basically put that in Excel sheet and we would have to basically search by ZIP code to say hey what carriers have we used before that were great in this Lane and sometimes you didn't have any so you didn't have that relationship Builder so you had to go actually out and throw it on Dat and that's where I think going out of house out of those relationship driven um carrier selection processes is when you start to get into people that the unknown you you don't know who you're dealing with and I think one of the things I like best about it was that piece where it kind of shows hey we service this area these Lanes or and you can even search by you know are you conditional or satisfactory or not I don't know who would SE that's a good question how many people G to your site and search for a carrier with a conditional rating we do get people searching for rating for they're gonna be cheaper Rob right right good rate reducer um but no I thought that was great because I remember in the old days of having to do it the old way and then when I saw that I was this is amazing you know we could have made money back then it's no wonder people like John Rogers and Darnell or on LinkedIn shouting how they make so much money but it's their Technology's played a lot in enhancing you know a carrier's ability uh to you know both showcase their strengths um sometimes their weaknesses but you've got these platforms out there that kind of kind of streamline it for brokers in in the shippers so yeah I thought the same thing cuz I think I saw on your homepage it one of the features is to to see the top carriers in a particular region which I thought was was very valuable you just click that you pick out what region you're looking for a carrier in you click that top carriers and it brings up seems like it brings up the top rated carriers through your system in that region is that how that works yeah yeah we default sort by highest rated um and you can search various cities various States whatever whatever you're looking for but um Rob to your point that was originally why Rob founded this company is we were talking to or he was talking to one of his best friends who was a carrier sales rep at a brokerage and he was like wow looks like G2 is raising a lot of money like what do you guys what do you guys even do and Rob was explaining it to him and he was like okay if I had that my life would be so much easier and that got the wheel spinning for Rob no it it was a big thing I don't think people maybe if they brokered forever they realize how bad it was but it's the industry has changed so much in in the data that's available to you now in just a short period of time I mean this we're only talking you know 10 15 years ago where we were kind of in the Stone Age in that space and now you can basically go on your site and look up anything you want um you know where where they're running what their what their ratings are and one of the other things I liked about what you know the piece that Brandon mentioned with top carriers by region or by market you know when I started to select through those on your site it wasn't just you know the big people yellow Old Dominion it was it was small carriers I mean a lot of them were 8 10 20 30 trucks so your your system isn't like shoving all those guys to the bottom to to prioritize the you know the kings of the industry so I like that about it as well but I I just think it's great that we have so much so much data available I mean really there's not not really a whole lot of excuse that you should be using bad carriers at this point yeah and that that is something that we were that we were passionate about when we were you know starting this and as we continue to build it like um carriers oh God I lost my train of thought we're passionate about it but I lost my train of thought about it um oh uh making just making it so that yeah you could it's not only about not working with the worst carriers and the double Brokers it's also about like finding the best carriers whether that be the eight truck 10 truck carrier or the behemoth carrier or the mom and pop owner operator you know um helping those carriers rise to the top where they previously have not been able to the other thing I thought was cool was that it looked like you had a direct link to the safer website from the carrier's profile so I assume you click that it automatically takes you to their dot profile on the safer page yep yeah we wanted to we we very much want to be like we're collectors of the information and we're sharing all the information that we have and it and it's open for you but then it's for you to kind of sift through and be like hey if you need more information on the safety and insurance like go to that you know run into that um yeah have there who kind of used your site you know that going back to the voice of customer thing it's have you've got the reviews carriers can go on there and look at their reviews whether they're positive let's just say they're they have a lot of negative um have you seen anybody using your platform that actually you know blew it out of the water and ju and just really significantly improved that reput or you know in in lie of that their business opportunities by using your platform kind of encouraging people their customers to go to your site and leave better reviews because they're trying to to start changing the way they're doing business yeah 100% and we've we spent a lot of our first couple years just trying to grow the broker shipper audience because it's not a worthwhile place for carriers to be if nobody's looking at it except for us um so we spent a lot of time really growing that traffic so we now have almost 300,000 you know site visits a month um and we're continuing to grow that so when people have those reviews and when they turn around their reputation from that negative to positive we are showing them the brokerages that are viewing them and we've we've connected a lot of carriers with new brokerages that wouldn't have heard of them but found them because they went to that you know top carriers in Louisville Kentucky or top carriers in Seattle Washington um and found this carrier that had risen to the top and it you know checked all the other boxes they needed of equipment type Lanes they run Etc um but we are seeing people make those new connections which is very exciting yeah so it's it's kind of a resource and support as well for carriers you know looking to expand their their networks and find new opportunities with reputable shippers yeah kind of going both ways on that one yeah and we've for the last you know for a while we've been focusing a lot on brokerages but we're really starting to to dive into shippers now too as well and really get more of Branch out and push our site into their their systems too yeah that's probably a good thing because you know as a carrier I coming from being a broker into a carrier um I didn't use Brokers because I just didn't not gonna I'm not here to beat up Brokers today but I just because I was from that world I knew how to call and you know find the carry find the shippers I needed to haul the freight where I wanted to haul it and then call them up and and make the deals myself I didn't need the broker and I think you know adding that piece in there probably would help you know carriers in that regard because it's it's you know just um well help both sides it's not just um the carrier it's the shipper as well it's like are you a legitimate carrier and are you a legitimate shipper so it's almost is flipping the the table right because we talked so much to this point about you know Brokers and shippers using the platform to help them vet their their motor carrier Partners but at the same time if I'm a motor carrier you know is there is there ways I can use the system to vet who I want to do business with as a broker or a shipper yeah as of right now no but in the next like quarter we do want to make brokerage profiles and start there and just being allowing carriers to review the brokerages that they work with um stay tuned so so stay tun so stay tuned and yeah just because it is it is a very one-sided right now and we get a lot of questions from carriers being like well why can't I review them and it's like you should be able to we're gonna fix that um so stay tuned for that what happens we had what was the I can't think of the broker that just went out and I I made a somebody said what what are all these carriers going to do and I said well the $75,000 broker Bond should cover you know the 500 million doll or Freight that's out there oh was Convoy it was Convoy yeah you know when you're a broker that that is that size and you go bad and you only got a $75,000 broker bond to cover it it's like you know it it really goes to who you who should you haul for as well so both ways for sure yep yeah so we've running out of time here but um one of the last questions I had maybe uh because I think Rob was talking about something brought to mind you know in our world Rob we're we're we occasionally get carriers come to us and and they're talking to us about their safety metrics they're out of service rates and stuff like that and and one of the things that they're always looking for is hey if I've got high out of service rates driver or vehicle or Hazmat or whatever how do I get those numbers down to make myself look better to bro Brokers and shippers and and usually the answer is you can't do a whole lot except wait because you know eventually those will fall off your score but the question always comes up well can and should I just go volunteer for a roadside inspection to try and get some clean inspections to dilute some of those out of service violations I had and I kind of see that as akin to the situation with with reviews through carrier source and and and other platforms like it where if I find myself in the situation what things can I do what are some practical tips where I can go and clean up a record that has been damaged by by bad reviews or something like that I know we kind of already hit on it a little bit but maybe I think that would be a good a good place to leave it Claire is your top tips for carriers that are looking to uh improve their reputation what what can they do what should they do to uh to make themselves look better to to Brokers and shippers yeah I I am curious to your answer on the on do you encourage that they just go get an inspect bad idea oh really oh interesting okay yeah I I've heard so many Rob may have different thoughts on this but um you know number one uh most officers won't do it and number two those officers that do do it I worry that that they are inclined to find something wrong I mean you you could probably find something wrong on any on the cleanest driver and the cleanest truck and so if they want to find something wrong they're going to find something wrong so the the the risk of getting a violation written up on your report I think it outweighs the benefit of you potentially getting a clean inspection Rob what are your thoughts on this uh oh we lost your mic Rob I'm good it's the button um I've I've done it before both ways so I've decided not to do it depending on on the on where they are geographically so some states I just won't do it because I know that it's not a not necessarily a trucker friendly state um but in Texas I've done it and in Florida I've done it and especially if you're bringing on you know say we're bringing on 200 new trucks and I know that they're brand spanking new they just got delivered they've got like zero miles on them we're going to run as many as they'll inspect we're gonna send them in there and get their get the cvsa sticker and get as many good inspections as I can to kind of dilute that and I've I've gotten it lowered but I've also failed where we've taken it in and we've gotten gotten some infractions and it and you know it makes it worse so it's essentially gambling it's gambling for sure yeah so sorry anyway off off track a little bit there interesting though thank thanks for answering that because I in my head I'm like yeah you should just go get new inspections so that's interesting that the that the answer is is not that um I think for for our side like definitely be responding to your reviews like know what's being said about about you online like take take pride in that and take pride in how you show up online because people are searching for you um people are Googling your company name when you when you bid on a load or anything like that um so definitely make sure that that you are controlling that narrative if you have a bad review respond to it invite the person back for more apologize you know see if there's any truth to what they're saying um and and and fix it uh and then also ask your current customers that you have four reviews get more from the people who are working with you every day um because that you know not so don't go get new inspections but do get more reviews because the the voice of the majority is GNA is going to drown out those one or two bad things um but those one or two bad things will will offer that you know layer of validity to the whole profile so definitely turn your profile too uh our friend Brian on LinkedIn he says uh some states are probable cause States they need a reason for an inspection they are hesitant to do a voluntary for that reason that's a good point some states the officers have to have a a reason to pull over pull you over and do an inspection so they couldn't do one voluntarily if they wanted to um so something to keep in mind but anyway uh we are out of time CLA that went very very fast so but anyway we really appreciate you joining us where can folks um get in touch with you or learn more about what you guys are doing over at carrier Source if they have any questions yeah absolutely uh people can reach me at Clara CL carriers source. um or you can just go to our site carriers source. um and you you know reach out to reach out to us through there too we've got a live chat so um definitely definitely hit us up make sure to do that uh thanks again Clara appreciate you joining us uh we're gonna sign off um thanks everybody for tuning in today uh stay tuned for um our next show not sure when will when it will be probably in the next couple weeks probably will be the last one before the before the end of the year um we'll see um but if you have any topic ideas or anything like that be sure to send them our way we're always looking for good topics to talk about you can submit those over at trucksafe live.com you can also catch our previous episodes there and subscribe to the podcast stuff like that also be sure to uh follow us on social media if you're not already uh we're pretty active on LinkedIn uh Rob's very active on LinkedIn make sure you're following him uh subscribe to our newsletter trucksafe dcoms subscribe to get the latest uh Highway Transportation news and Analysis delivered right to your inbox Robin anything else I'm missing I've got nothing the only thing I would throw out there is the last piece for Brokers for a good impression is you can't do it at the beginning but you can do it throughout there is the importance of transparency and commun communication between carriers shippers Brokers that that builds a lot of trust and maintains good relationship so that's probably one of the keys biggest biggest points I can thr out there for this topic for sure all right well as always uh Rob it's great talking with you thanks for joining me today thanks for co-hosting uh uh again thanks everybody for tuning in we will catch you next time see you

Event Completed

Thursday, November 9, 2023 at 4:04 PM EST

Watch on YouTube