Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 32 - Drug & alcohol testing misnomers, myths & lies

Wednesday, November 29, 2023 at 4:17 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 32 - Drug & alcohol testing misnomers, myths & lies

About This Event

In this episode, we tackle some of the most common misnomers, myths & lies told in the DOT drug & alcohol testing context. We’ll try to bring some clarity to this oft-misunderstood area of DOT compliance.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 32 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter of Trucksafe Consulting tackle one of the most misunderstood areas of DOT compliance: drug and alcohol testing. The episode was prompted in part by a recently published Trucksafe article on the applicability of federal drug and alcohol testing rules to CDL student drivers, a topic that generated significant interest and revealed just how much confusion exists in this space. The hosts work through a wide range of misconceptions, drawing on their combined experience working with large fleets and individual carriers to clarify what the regulations actually require. Among the most significant topics discussed is the question of whether CDL holders are automatically subject to drug and alcohol testing and Clearinghouse queries. The hosts clarify that it is the type of vehicle being operated, not the license held, that determines testing obligations. They also address the applicability of federal drug and alcohol rules to both interstate and intrastate commerce, noting that unlike hours-of-service regulations, drug and alcohol testing requirements apply regardless of whether a carrier operates across state lines. The student driver issue receives extended treatment, with the hosts explaining that FMCSA currently places the burden of compliance on the students themselves when enrolled in independent CDL training programs, a position the hosts find practically problematic and likely to result in many student drivers slipping through the cracks. The hosts also dispel several other common myths, including the belief that drivers can use CBD products without testing risk, that hair follicle testing is an approved DOT specimen type, that drivers have up to two hours to report for a random test after notification, and that completing a substance abuse professional program allows a driver to immediately return to work without further testing obligations. On CBD specifically, the hosts emphasize that FMCSA does not recognize a good-faith defense for a positive marijuana test resulting from CBD use, and that mislabeled products have caused real consequences for drivers across the country. They also discuss the proper use of split specimen testing as a driver's primary recourse when contesting a positive result. For fleet safety professionals, the episode offers several actionable takeaways. Carriers should ensure that any employee operating a vehicle over 26,000 pounds on a public highway, including mechanics performing test drives, is properly enrolled in a drug and alcohol testing program regardless of how infrequently they drive. When a driver receives a safety concern letter from a medical review officer following a verified negative test, carriers should send that driver back to a DOT medical examiner before allowing them to continue operating. Carriers who hire drivers with prior positive test results must strictly adhere to the follow-up testing schedule prescribed by the substance abuse professional, as failure to do so constitutes a regulatory violation. Finally, random test notifications must result in immediate reporting to the collection site, and any significant delay risks being treated as a refusal.

Full Transcript

yeah n yeah e a a we hey everyone welcome to episode 32 of truck safe live the show where we in our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon this is Rob we are with truck safe which is dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs welcome everyone uh looks like we got a lot of folks in in the uh various places where we are streaming so good to see you all have you all here with us uh say hey in the comments if you're around uh so we know who's here and as always as we go along if you have any questions or thoughts particularly for this topic which is drug and alcohol testing misnomers myths and lies uh we're interested in what what are some of the most prevalent um issues or or um misconceptions you all deal with when it comes to drug alcohol testing uh this comes on the heels of uh an article that we published on our website trucksafe do.com last week uh having to do with applicability or non-applicability to of drug and alcohol testing regulations to student drivers CDL student drivers uh and I thought it would make a good topic for discussion today so I'm glad to have Rob here with me Rob what's going on in your world not a whole lot just uh putting together myths misnomers and out like outright lies about drug testing so Rob sent me a list of like like 25 of these I had prepared like five of the of them and then Rob sends me an email last night he's got like 25 of them so he's ready to roll well you get these at you know from the driver world you know drivers used to just sit around and you hear the craziest things from truck drivers and sometimes and it's like hey you know I heard this and we can't do this anymore so some of those I added in there just because you know I know I know a lot of it floats around the truck driving realm yeah there's definitely a lot of them um so look forward to tackling those before we get there let's talk a little bit about some things going on over at truck safe first up as always if you're not a part of our trucksafe Fleet compliance Network make sure you join it's free to join uh you can find it at trucksafe network.com you can also download the app on the app store or the Google Play Store uh this is a social network for Fleet Safety professionals to get together learn from one another ask questions and also have access to all of our content that we put out frequently on do compliance issues videos articles podcast everything like that so check it out trucksafe network.com uh what else we got going on at truck safe Rob I know you've been uh working on a lot of things for for various clients here over the last couple of weeks um maybe worth High highlighting some of those yeah what's the deal with the the crashes that you got going I did a post today on uh crash uh pre preventability pro program so um you know we're doing a lot of those and um you know it's it's the typical runaround you got to run around and hunt down police reports and crash reports and videos and and all kinds of stuff so besides that it's just just the norm crash preventability it's an important thing to do if you're not doing it um we've talked on other shows about kind of the the program that FMCSA has set up for motor carriers to challenge the preventability of certain ACD ENT categories that they have deemed uh eligible for that type of program but uh if you're not taking advantage of that program right now you should be because it can significantly influence your crash indicator score uh one of your seven basics in your in your CSA score so uh Rob's working with some of our clients now on doing those on their behalf so certainly if that's something you have trouble with or or need help with uh you can reach out to us and reach out to Rob and he'll get it done for you uh also doing a lot of safety rating upgrade work I know you're you've been working on that type of stuff so yeah I think we're I think I'm kind of all over the place right at this moment it's you got a lot going on we do anyway give us a give us a ring if you need any help if there's anything we can do to help you uh and we will be happy to um other than that some recent truck safe content that we've put out like I said uh one of which is kind of spurring the this particular show um you can check out these articles on our website like I said trucksafe decom also if you um subscribe to our newsletter you will get these delivered right to your email inbox we're always putting out articles on the latest uh DOT compliance issues so the most recent one uh one of the most recent ones that we did was this one on drug and alcohol testing for student drivers uh where we break down exactly what the fmcsa's current thoughts seem to be with respect to the applicability of drug and alcohol testing for CDL Drivers uh spoiler alert um you student drivers are subject to drug and alcohol testing but we'll get into that a little bit later uh some other things going on in the industry also uh highlighted on our website I saw this come through uh it's probably been a couple of weeks ago now FMCSA is making uh issued a final rule making some changes to their broker and Freight forwarder financial responsibility rules so they're not changing the amounts so it's still $75,000 shity bond that is required to maintain your broker or Freight forwarder Authority but they are changing some things notably um the things that you as a broker or Freight forwarder have to have available as essentially collateral for your sh bond to make sure that you're good for the money that that uh if um if folks are collecting on your bond and then also some additional protections or or uh automatic things that happen if your shy if your shy bond is drawn down below the minimum $75,000 requirement including potential suspension so be sure to check that out if you are a broker or fre Freight forwarder uh pretty important changes there again you can check it out on our website trucksafe dcom Rob did you see those changes did you have any thoughts that you used to run brokerage I I did and I thought for sure that it would go higher but I mean I feel like it should I think when I started it was like bucks and then it was uh went up to 75,000 we all thought it was going to put all the little guys out of business and you have places like Pacific Coast Financial and stuff like that that'll charge you you know a couple thousand bucks a year and you don't have to put up anything so um you know you go out of business and you know how do carriers get paid so I I think it's a big problem but yeah what the solution is it's not it's not not it's not leaving it at 75 ,000 so yeah the thing that they didn't do which is not surprising is address the issue of double brokerage at all which uh seems to have become an increasingly big problem um in the industry but um they didn't do anything about it with this particular rule making we knew that they weren't going to do anything about it because it wasn't in the notice of proposed rule making that they issued last year but regardless uh still haven't tackled that particular issue so no uh no relief in that regard yet uh okay what else is going on in the industry the the only other thing it's been pretty quiet last month or so um scary compared to yeah compared to uh summertime where we saw a bunch of uh rule making activity um so it's a little bit quiet over the last couple of months but one thing to to keep in mind if you're a motor carrier that uses your portal account to uh update your Dot registration information or access your CSA scores or access the Clearing House all those things that you that you could do through the portal um FMCSA issued a notice a few weeks ago about changes to their security uh web security um uh platform so now you're going to in order to continue logging on to your portal account beginning December 1st so the end of this week uh you're going to have to create a login.gov account and then you're going to have to use use that to access your portal account this is a multiactor authentication type system that the US government has in place to secure accounts so if you don't get that set up by the end of this week you're not going to have access to your portal account anymore and you're going to be uh up the creek potentially so make sure you do that that's coming up here in a couple days um did you see that post I I posted Rob about the the tweet that FMCSA so yesterday I think it was yesterday um it was hilarious to me probably to nobody else but it security and then they they uh posted some trash fmcsa's Twitter official Twitter account they have one post I think it was yesterday or two days ago one post about this uh cracking down on web security and then the very next post they have is either they got hacked or somebody who runs their social media accounts mistakenly posted on on the FMCSA account not their person personal account some nonsense about something unrelated to Transportation I just thought that was hilarious and pretty typical of federal government but anyway neither here nor there all right so that's go that's all that's really going on in the industry from a DOT compliance perspective we're still waiting on um some updates for the big rule makings that are going to be happening some of them are rules some of them are not really rules but they they are still going to impact carriers pretty significantly and those are potential changes to the safety rating process we've had other shows about that uh a significant overhaul to CSA scores and how uh those are calculated that is still coming and then also um potential changes to the data Q system and setting up some kind of an independent appeals board so those are all big things that are coming down the pike at some point um I think I think probably in December we will have kind of a yearend review and then also a 2024 Outlook show here on truck safe live so be sure to tune in to that if you want to know more about kind of uh the significant rule makings that happened this year and what we can expect for regulated motor carriers next year so we've got U speed limiters right 29th of December is that when it's anticipated I think so speed limiters is always seems like it's always kind of sitting out there and then it just never really comes to be but that sounds about right I can't remember what the current out I looked at the date this morning I'm thinking oh man we got we got days till speed limiters happens but that'll be just for newly manufactured trucks I think right it won't be any retrofitting for existing trucks so uh so don't buy any new trucks if you're worried about that apparently uh okay anyway so moving on then to segue into today's topic again titled drug and alcohol testing misnomers myths and lies like I said stems from some content we put out over the last couple of weeks in response to some questions we'd received on the applicability or the inapplicability ility of the federal drug and alcohol testing rules to drivers enrolled in CDL schools for whatever reason that particular topic gained some interest over the last month or so so we wanted to tackle that head on with our detailed article on the topic on our website uh but it did get me thinking about some other questions or or misunderstandings that tend to arise in this context and so I thought it would be a good good idea good forum to address those other issues all in one place try and dispel some of the most common myths that we hear um and so that's what we're going to do on today's show like I said Rob and I have both independently developed our own common misunderstandings I've got five Rob's got 25 so this is going to be the Rob show today but uh common misunderstanding of the drug and alcohol testing context and so we're going to work our way through those Rob I'm G to let you kick things off with uh with the first one on your list all right I'm not going to start with the first one um I kind of highlighted some on my list but we're going to we're going to float through them the I think one of the biggest ones on that I get is um there is guidance from CSA that says CDL holders um but who has to be who has to be queried in the Clearing House so CDL holders it's ultimately up to the company the carrier to decide whether they're going to do holders uh but generally it's reserved for equipment so if you are a CDL holder but you operate CDL equipment you must be queried at the time of hire and then annually so uh that's what the regulations say but there there's that big myth out there that says that all holders have to be queried and that's not really true so that's that was the big one that I think gets some people yeah in other words if you're a if you if you hold a CDL but you are employed by a carrier to only operate a vehicle that doesn't require a CDL the fact that you the mere fact that you hold a CDL is not what necessitates a a Clearing House query it's it's it's whether you are operating or whether there is a reasonable expectation that you're going to operate a CDL size vehicle for that particular carry that necessitates the query yeah and that's true even of drug and alcohol testing in general I mean that's a common myth too is that hey if I'm if I'm employing drivers that happen to hold CDLs even though I'm only requiring them to them to operate smaller vehicles vehicles that don't require a CDL then I I still have to drug test them because they got CDLs it's just not the case it what matters is are they going to be operating vehicles that require a CDL for you or not and if not then you're not subject to drug and alcohol testing that's just the way it is yeah vehicle Focus equipment Focus not license Focus necessarily yeah what about mechanics and uh non-traditional Drive uh you know folks who may occasionally jump in a truck to test drive at Mechanics for the classic example but maybe you got got a manager or something who occasionally jumps in a vehicle uh I know that's kind of a related issue but what's the deal with those with those folks well we we actually we had this come up recently but the um so generally you've got you know you have we have mechanics that don't have CDLs that are operating 10 to 26 pound, pound Vehicles so obviously that's not Clearing House related but anybody that's operating 26,000 And1 plus down vehicles on the public Highway for for any reason I mean there's obviously the regulation aspect of it that they have to have the query at time of hire and they have to be qualified generally not just by drug and alcohol but the overall compliant you know U qualification compliance piece but there's the highway exposure uh Highway litigation exposure piece as well so if you you have this mechanic that's out there test driving you don't know that the regulation covers them that they have to be qualified to drive for whatever reason Reon they're out there on the highway driving your truck and they get in an accident that's going to be a problem for you actually I think post earlier in the week about this because it it popped up but um company had a mechanic that was operating just moving a a class eight truck from a road tractor by itself from one one place to the next and had no anything not even a license on file so um yeah if they're gonna oper it only takes one trip that's it literally the first time you're out on a public Highway in a vehicle that requires a CDL you better have a CDL and you better be enrolled in the drug and alcohol testing program well that's violation first time is viol there's no Dom Minimus exception or anything like that um nothing like that so and the other thing to point out this kind of goes along with a misnomer as well could be an independent one in its own right but is a lot of folks are under the misunderstanding that the federal drug and alcohol testing rules are only applicable to Interstate Commerce and and uh I won't fault you for that understanding because that's typically how it works with the other safety regulations when we're talking about the Federal hours of service rules for example those only apply to interstate commerce but the CDL requirements and the drug and alcohol testing requirements are distinct from all other categories of of the safety regulations not just because of the the weight applicability of them but also because they apply to both interstate and intrastate Commerce doesn't matter if you are only engaged in intrastate Commerce if you're operating a vehicle that's more than 26,000 lb or hauling a placable quantity of hazmats or uh a bunch of passengers 16 or more passengers you're going to need a CDL and you're going to be subject to drug and alcohol testing like I said even if you're engaged in inate Commerce so there's your bonus um your bonus Mis understanding there uh let's see somebody's asking a question here Jill is asking what is is a safety sensitive job is it only driving Jill you're in luck because I went ahead and pulled up the regulation here so we can just read it together safety sensitive function is defined in the regulations Section 38217 to mean again this is this is always the case but they FMCSA likes to use like a thousand words when they could have gotten it done in like a hundred so here we go I'm going to read it off safety sensitive function means all time from the time a driver begins to work or is required to be in Readiness to work until the time he or she is relieved from work and all responsibility for performing work safety sensitive functions shall include all time at at an employer or shipper plant blah blah blah or any public property waiting to be dispatched unless the driver has been relieved from Duty by the employer alltime inspecting equipment all time spent at the driving controls of a commercial motor vehicle in operation all time other than driving time in or upon the CMV except time spent resting in the sleeper birth all time loading or unloading a vehicle supervising or assisting in the loading blah blah blah all time repairing obtaining Assistance or remaining in attendance upon a disabled vehicle these various examples that they're giving here are largely tracking what it what constitutes on duty time within the hours of service regulations but the key takeaway here and the way that I always view it and Rob I'm interested in your thoughts on this is what really matters when we're talking about a safety sensitive function is driving time if it if you it's driving uh that's going to be the primary safety sensitive function but it it can include tangential stuff including like inspecting equipment stuff like that but Far and Away the most common thing that you're going that is going to be considered a safety sensitive function is driving time no that I I agree and I think one place where it kind of goes off the hinges is dispatchers a big question that we've always had or that we we have um from carriers is are dispatchers considered safety sensitive roles and you know there there's different organizations in the government so you have you know do FAA FMCSA and there and under some of those a dispatcher is considered safety sensitive so um it just depends on on you know what organization you're operating under whether they classifi dispatchers as or or crew as SA sensitive so one of the main reasons this term is is important in this context is that if a driver fails or refuses a do required drug or alcohol test then the implication the result of that is that they are prohibited from performing safety sensitive functions un less and until they go through the return to duty process so uh the the obvious answer is if I'm a driver that test positive or I refuse a required test then I'm not going to going to be able to drive anymore one question that comes up that I haven't looked at in a while but it does occasionally come up that's an interesting kind of uh uh question is if I'm a CDL driver who tests positive for drugs or alcohol on a DOT test now I'm prohibited from performing a safety sensitive function am I prohibited from driving any class of vehicle or just a CDL size vehicle am I permitted to operate a non-cdl vehicle if I'm in prohibited status in the Clearing House Rob let's put your your knowledge to the test here yeah that's going to be I I don't know on this one I would say no because um for non CDL you're not subject to drug and alcohol so if we're 10 10,000 And1 to um 26,000 uh in one you're not subject to you're you're subject to all regulations except drug and alcohol testing so I would say that would say yes yes that they are allowed to operate those Vehicles yes in a prohibited status from we I think it's the opposite I think the answer is no based on this definition of safety sensitive functions we're just doing this off the cuff by the way this requires some some analysis and some digging in but I think the answer is no I think safety sensitive functions is is Broad enough to Encompass driving even a a a commercial motor vehicle that does not require CDL so I think if you test positive for drugs or alcohol on a do test you're not even allowed to operate a non-cdl vehicle if it's a commercial motor vehicle so 10,000 to 26,000 pounds until you go to through the return to duty process like I said I could be wrong it's been a while since I've looked at that but that has been my understanding I'm gonna bet on that okay let's let's uh that's you're right no let's uh let's let's bet on it and then uh well anyway in any event we're going to put an article together after we uh do this show on our website and we will uh we'll clarify that we'll figure out what the the actual answer is uh okay so that was uh the first one let's see let's hit one of mine here so um I'm going to start with the one that kind of prompted this entire show which is a misnomer or not a misnomer but a a Mis uh representation that students enrolled in a truck driving school are not subject to drug and alcohol testing I've heard I've heard folks say that and um turns out it's just not the case um FMCSA has been pretty clear over the years that student drivers assuming they have a CLP a commercial learner permit are in fact subject to drug and alcohol testing in fact they've got guidance that says specifically that available on their website I think where the disconnect comes in here is the regulations use of the the term employer in this context so in other words it's clear that student drivers are again assuming they have a CLP are subject to drug and alcohol testing I think the the more pertinent question is who's responsible for actually testing those administering those tests you know because you know if if you just got a driver that's working for a carrier it's clearly the carrier's responsibility to have that driver enrolled in a drug and alcohol test uh testing program but but if it's a CDL school they're not the legal employer usually of those student drivers and so who who is it that administers the test whose random pool are they in who's doing the pre-employment test stuff like that that's the more pertinent question and that's the one that's where it starts to get confusing that's why our article is as long as it is on this on this topic because uh I think even FMCSA confuses themselves on the answer to this question because they used to have one stance probably 10 years ago suggesting that it was the school's obligation in those situations to test those drivers but nowadays based on a from what I can tell the fmcsa's ex current stance on this is that it is the students responsibility the CDL students responsibility to make sure that they themselves are complying with the drug and alcohol testing rules and where I'm gathering that that is the FMCSA stance is from a a an administrative appeal that was filed and tried by the FMCSA uh I think in 2019 their published opinion is available uh it's it's cited in that article that we put out on our website where they kind of go through the analysis it's like a 20page analysis where they're breaking down their regulations and how they think they apply long story short FMCSA in this context drug and alcohol testing is taking a different view of what the term employer means than they do in all of their other regulations so normally when we're talking about safety regulations like hours of service and vehicle maintenance and stuff like that the regulations use the term employer in terms of who's responsible for for managing those things but they they Define that term employer very broadly in their in their non-drug and alcohol testing regulations so in in part 390 they Define to include even like independent contractors essentially what it comes down to in that context the non-drug and alcohol context is it's the motor carrier under whose DOT number the work is being done that is responsible for ensuring that drivers are complying with hours of service and doing the pre-trip inspections and stuff like that those burdens rest squarely on the shoulders of the entity whose DOT number is being used so if you're if if you're using logic you would think that that same analysis should apply to drug and alcohol testing so if I look at the student driver situation it's the school's DOT number that those operation should be conducted under because who El who who else would have a DOT number in that situation unless it's a motor carrier that has set up their own school or something like that somebody's DOT number has to be used to operate these vehicles on public highways so it's most often going to be the CDL schools and in my view it should follow then that because the students are operating the vehicles under the DOT number of the of the school and under their control essentially that the school should be responsible for the drug and alcohol testing just like they would be responsible for hours of service and vehicle maintenance and stuff like that but it turns out FMCSA doesn't view it that way they take a more narrow view of the term employer in the drug and alcohol context and say that what they mean in that context is legal employer and because the schools aren't the legal employer they're not paying w ages to these drivers then they're not responsible for uh drug and alcohol testing and so uh like I said long story short FMCSA says it's the students problem well that creates practical issues obviously because how do how if I'm a CDL student how do I discharge my obligations to make sure that I'm being tested and that I'm in a random pool and that I go through a pre-employment test stuff like that how do I do that and my thought on it is that practically it's probably just not happening very often unless you've got a school that's really on the ball here and making sure that their students are doing this on their own um it's probably just these students are probably just slipping through the through the cracks uh um that's not to say there aren't like I said some schools that are kind of on the ball here because FMCSA does leave open the possibility that says hey even though it's the students responsibility the CDL school could essentially serve as a third-party Consortium for those students so those students could enroll in that third party school's Consortium and then the the school would manage it on their behalf but ultimately the burden falls on the students I hope that makes sense I tried to dumb it down as best as I could but FMCSA is doing you guys no favors by over complicating this rob you have any thoughts on that yeah they actually put out guidance in um January 2022 is um basically called uh student driver rooll Aid and in that they they spell out if you're enrolled in an independent CDL training program you basically are self-regulated as a student so you have to designate your own uh TPA um you have to purchase your own quer uh query plan since tpas cannot purchase query plan and then you have to query yourself um in the Clearing House and under your own account or get your TPA to do it um unless you're enrolled in an employer-based CDL training program and then it all falls under the employer but it it as a student of an independent CDL training program you're largely self-regulated so it's like I I don't know how we've we've gotten to the point to self-regulate drivers but especially student drivers so yeah my fear is if if students are enrolled in a CDL school that that is just taking the hands-off approach saying hey it's not my responsibility so good luck to you yeah and then the students aren't doing it themselves well then we've potentially got a big universe of student drivers out there operating on public highways who have not been drug or alcohol tested which seems like a problem to me U this is that guidance or or one place where that guidance that Rob was mentioning lives this is uh in the Clearing House this uh but this is also referenced in that article that I mentioned that we put on our website if you're interested in the full analysis of this check it out on our website trucksafe decom but uh like I said long story short Stu CDL students again assuming they have a c LP are indeed subject to drug and alcohol testing um and then the question is who is going to be doing that for them and regulations just put it on the shoulders of the students themselves practically how it should work is that the CDL school should be setting themselves up as a thirdparty administrator and should be doing it on behalf of their students to make things easy and to make sure things aren't slipping through the cracks is really how it should work um let's see here we got some comments Matt says I agree the logic is that likely the only driver's license held at all is CDL the impact is on the CDL thus would trickle down to operation of other oh he's going back to that situation of is a driver who tests positive for drugs or alcohol on a DOT test going to be prohibited from operating a any CMV regardless of whether it uh requires a CDL sorry I miss that earlier Matt I think where my mindset goes with that is you know we had we had we had a couple dot numbers that were operating in Colorado so you know obviously you have marijuana everywhere dispensaries everywhere you know anything you want anywhere you want to get it and what we had was a portion of that maybe 40% were non doot drivers they were operating still cmvs 10,000 to one plus but they're not subject to drug and alcohol Tes so uh we eventually started a a non-dot program for oral fluid testing for non-dot drivers even though we didn't have to we did it from a polic policy perspective and what we found was probably 20% of our Workforce was driving our non-dot vehicles high as gas most of the time so it was kind of that well they're not regulated obviously from our policy perspective we're not going to continue to employ them and but um you know that was kind of where my mind was going with that is you know if you were to not have tested for that do program that that do test would it would it matter you know so that's where my mind goes to a related note I mean how is this even going to get caught right because if I'm hiring that driver to operate a non CDL required vehicle I'm not required to run a Clearing House query on him so I'm not going to know necessarily that he's in prohibited status now the regulations address that by saying I still have to ask him questions about that on the application and assuming he's truthful which he would never be if that's that's your your situation and you've tested positive are you going to answer no to that or yes to that question on the application if you're trying to get a job no so but that's how the regulations uh purport to deal with that situation is they expect those carriers to be asking their drivers that question and the driver should be answering honestly and if they do then that driver would not be qualified to operate the vehicle I think is how it is supposed to work but you could you could very easily see how this just slips through the cracks because um of uh dishonesty it's kind of like the hours of service deal for short Hall you know you you're still you're it says in the regulation you can you can work 14 hours but yeah you still can't drive more than the regulation says so but there's nothing in the regulation for short Hall that says you have to differentiate drive time from anything else so they don't know so how's it ever gonna get caught yeah so same thing same thing yeah uh Tom on LinkedIn is saying I think he's uh referring back to the situation with student drivers uh being responsible for complying with the drug and alcohol testing regulations he says isn't that the isn't that similar to a single unit independent owner operator I think that's right Tom I think I think that's fmcsa's intention you know for what they call owner operators I hate how they use that phrase in in uh their Clearing House guidance when they refer to an owner operator uh when FMCSA refers to an owner operator they're talking about a a guy or a girl that that has their own DOT number and is operating just a single truck that's not historically how the industry views owner operators owner operators can be leas operators who are leasing on to another motor carrier and operating under their DOT number uh I would say that's the more common situation and in those situations it's the least carrier that is responsible for administering the drug and alcohol testing rules just like that's their own driver but in I think you're right Tom I think for what the FMCSA considers a true owner operator it requires them to um to enroll in a Consortium and then have that Consortium make reports and do queries on them and stuff through the clearing house so I think it's expected to work that same way for student drivers all right Rob you're up what do you got on your list all right I've got um drivers can't take over the counter medications um can or some cannot uh but you can actually um that's that's not factual so you can actually take overthe counter medications and and a lot of times what happens is if it's a medication that'll trigger say say it's adderal and it it causes you to test positive for meth which obviously you're not on meth you're on adero for what you know ADHD what ends up happening is the mro then has to do their investigation following that positive um and they'll contact you and ask you are you on any medications who prescribed it what did they prescribe it for who was the doctor where did you get the prescription filled what was the prescription and once they complete that investigation which could I've seen it take a couple weeks actually depends on how how fast they can contact these places to validate all that then you know you generally what we would get back as a carrier is a letter saying hey result is negative but understand that this this Rob Carpenter is operating under vicadin or or whatever the prescription is um which could affect their safe operation of a vehicle so that's these I call them safety concern letters um this is a fairly new thing I think I think this came about probably five or six years ago uh where mro started doing this um where they are because essentially like Rob said the process is driver is going to test positive on the initial drug test because of the over-the-counter medication whatever happens to be not obviously not all over the counter medications uh uh cause a positive drug test it's only the it's only the typ that would pop positive on the the five panel test that we're testing for but anyway you test positive on that test the mro the process is the mro calls you and and tries to figure out is there a legitimate reason for the positive test if he's satisfied that the the legitimate reason is that you are on a a prescription that's causing that positive then he can he can turn that positive into a negative through the verification process but sometimes sometimes that'll be the end of the story you'll just get a a verified negative if you're the carrier and that'll be the end of the story but other times they may say hey I'm going to verify it as a negative because it wasn't some nefarious thing you weren't using illegal drugs but I still have a concern as a doctor for you operating commercial motor vehicles uh while using that particular drug and that's where you get those safety concern letters and so question for the motor carriers is what do we do with that and um you know that's where the lawyer and me always gets a little concerned because you know technically under the regulations he's still that driver is still able to operate for you there's nothing if you get a negative with a safety concern they're still legally allowed to operate but the question is from a risk standpoint Can Am I comfortable with him still out there operating with a doctor having told me that they're concerned about this driver's ability to safely operate a vehicle on this medication and I would say in those situations the an your answer should be no you you you should not not be allowing that driver to continue operating with that safety concern letter because you can you you can be sure that if that driver then gets involved in a bad accident that that letter is going to come out in litigation and you're going to have to explain why you thought it was okay to continue using them after a doctor told you that it was probably a bad idea to continue using them so I think at minimum at least my guidance to to our clients usually is at minimum if you get that type of letter you need to send them back to a a do medical examiner and have them go in for a new uh uh DOT medical examination take that safety concern letter with them and get a new doctor a do medical examiner to sign off on whether they are comfortable with them continuing to operate on their med card with uh W with that safety concern Rob thoughts on that no that that was our policy too you know I think we'd get these from Todd Simo at high right and then it would be like hey this driver has this safety issue while he's taking this medication and it's like well you know now that we know know this how do we put them out there on this you know driving our vehicle and then they get in you know some kind of litig have an accident then goes litigation the plane floyer starts asking questions about did you think it was wise to let them drive with the safety notice knowing that there was a safety concern so you sending them back we're not medical professionals we're just dot people so um we sending them back to a medical examiner that's in the registry that that knows do regulations and if they put them back on there you kind of have that buffer uh Todd seimo may have his mro office protected and now you're protected through having another doctor review it so yeah yeah I think that's best practice for sure all right moving on here Matt Matt brings up a another question here which leads right into one of my on my list here he says believe you guys have discussed in a prior video about CBD products that are over the- counter but may have misleading labels about THC content which could trip a positive result yeah so on my list one of the most common misunderstandings in the drug and alcohol realm that I'm dealing with on a pretty regular basis is CBD use among drivers and like Matt said we've got a ton of content out there on this issue specifically but um yeah the misconception is that it's it's okay for truck drivers to use CBD products and that's just not the case because there are literally at this point thousands of instances across the country where a driver has taken some type of CBD product whether it being you know gummy or or drops or whatever it happens to be and they think that they're okay because the oftentimes the label on the package says that it contains little to no THC which is the psychoactive compound that causes the high effect so they think they're good to go but it turns out that label was inaccurate and then that driver tests positive on a do drug test and the problem is FMCSA and Dot say we don't care what the rationale or what the reason is for the positive test test even if it was a legitimate use of what you thought was lawful CBD we don't care it's still the same consequences they've got guidance on the books that says that it's it's out there and that's that's their enforcement policy is that if you test positive for drugs for marijuana and it turns out that the reason was because you were using a CD CBD product doesn't matter you're still going to have a positive test and now you're going to be prohibited from performing those safety sensitive functions because of it and for thaton reason why are we in this situation we're in this situation because nobody cracks down on the manufacturers of CBD in this country yet in terms of their representations on their packaging the FDA believe it or not has not stepped in to regulate that those types of representations on the packaging and so there's nobody to to uh to keep that stuff in check there's nobody that's cracking down on the manufacturers of those products so they are just misrepresenting the phc content in their product and then drivers are unwittingly taking it relying on those representations and then they're screwed over because of it and so we're we're seeing some class action litigation pop up across the United States against manufacturers of these CBD products for this for this reason and so it's a real risk right now that if you are taking a CBD product that and you're a regulated driver that you could test positive on a do test and then you're screwed so for that reason I um I strongly C caution drivers and my motor carrier clients that until FDA starts regulating in this space it's too risky for drivers to use CBD products in my view Rob thoughts I had the same I had the same question coming up but um you know I mentioned this actually in a post not too long ago because it's the holidays right everybody's going and eating at other people's houses and uh I have a friend Danny Myers he is a truck driver but he grows a lot of stuff and it's CBD it supposed to be CBD so I think it was last year year before last he sent me a bunch of brownies for the holidays I didn't eat them because I don't eat things like that during the holidays because I you know um but anyway I gave some to my mother-in-law who's the wife of a rabbi oh no and uh she was high as gas the rest of the night I I don't know how much DAC was in them but I guarantee you had I I would have failed a drug test but anyway U so watch watch what you during the holidays um you don't know what's in the brownies so yeah good advice has your has she come down from the the high at this point she did but she was terribly sick afterwards because she's like she doesn't eat anything she's not supposed to so I think it was just a shock to her system but that's good news okay uh all right we got a little bit more time here what's what's next on your list I've got uh hair hair follicle testing can be used for FMCSA drug testing and it was it was one of those fearmongering thing I in the driver circles years ago where they're going to go to hair and they're going to find out that I did drugs 95 days ago or whatever and um that's not the case so urine and oral fluid are the only two approved specimen types for regulated drivers oral fluid we can't do yet but it is it is legal as a specimen it's just there's nobody we don't have no no labs to test it yeah so for now we have urine and oral fluid but the only one we can actually do is urine so um that's that's a no on the hair follicle testing for FMCSA drug testing now with that said motor carriers can and many do voluntarily or or uh on their own authority test drivers with hair follicle testing uh those are non supposed to be non doot test and uh if you test positive on one of those then you were going to be out of that job at that particular carrier or or not eligible for a job with that particular carrier but because it's not a DOT test they are not supposed to be reporting that to the Clearing House um uh when that happens so just be aware of that that certainly uh carriers can use those tests it's just not recognized as a DOT test at this point um all right let's see oh one one other thing on the CBD use uh it's kind of a related issue and it has to do with um legalizing marijuana we just put out a a video on on our YouTube channel Ohio recently became the most recent state to legalize recreational marijuana use I think it was the 26th state in the country to do that and so the premise of our video was what does that mean for regulated truck drivers that are operating in Ohio uh the answer is um I I'll I'll let you get out of having to watch our other video here the the answer is it does nothing um it is still unlawful for regulated truck drivers to use marijuana even if they are in a state that has legalized it for either medicinal or recreational purposes if you are a regulated truck driver um it is still unlawful for you to use it and if you test positive on a on a drug test for marijuana you're going to be prohibited from operating regardless of whether it's legal in your state or not so just be aware of that and and that's going to be the case un last and until the federal government steps in and uh desch schedules the U marijuana it's still a schedule one drug on the federal Controlled Substances Act so all right uh let's see here what's what else is on my list oh one that I hear pretty commonly is this idea that drivers have up to two hours to report for a random drug and alcohol test once they've been notified that they've been SL selected for a random test that is not true they are whoever is saying that is conflating a couple of different rules um they are conflating post accident testing which has some some concrete time frames if you're involved in a DOT recordable accident that that requires drug and alcohol testing there are specific discrete time frames within which you have to be tested one of which is you're supposed to be tested within the first two hours uh for alcohol um but you get up to 8 hours if if you're not able to get it done within the first two hours so I think that's where folks have pulled this two hours from but in the random context the regulations very clearly say that as soon as a driver is notified that they've been selected for a random test they have to report immediately to the testing site to get tested uh what does immediately mean it's not defined in the regulations but immediately means immediately so if there's delay and you going to the testing site it is going to be a ref it should be a refusal and uh and you're going to have the same consequences as as if you tested positive Rob how did you control that when you're working as a safety director for for large fleets how did you control that timing of folks making sure folks are getting immediately to a testing site once you've notified them it it was difficult because you had it was we had 1004 managers that you dealt with at at like the Frontline level that were really actually interfacing with these drivers every so they would they would schedule the test and then they would notify them but a lot of times the ball would get dropped so it was this never ending cycle of training for managers those 104 managers that oversaw this because you know you'd have managers who we would hire we would train they didn't really retain it as much as they should have and they would let a driver know hey tomorrow you have to go take your random test when you come before you come into work and it's like you no you can't do that so generally what we would do is Mark them on available retrain the manager and then we would get an alternate in their place that's not the best way to do it it's just the way that we had to you know under the circumstances but generally it's once once they scheduled the test they sent them for it and you had managers that would manage it better to say hey I know that this driver's coming in and you know what they have to do isn't going to start until 10: we've scheduled them for eight we're going to send them to get this test done then then send them on their way to work so yeah the regulations leave it up to the carrier to decide what is a reasonable amount of time for them to report uh but the longer that gets the more risky it is for the carrier that uh if if you allow a a any significant portion of time to elapse between when you notify the driver and when they reported you're risking being written up for a violation in the context of an audit if FMCSA were to come in and and look at your drug and alcohol testing file so the the quicker the better uh is is always my advice uh all right let's uh let's pick maybe two more and then we'll call it a show what do you got right uh drivers can avoid testing by using synthetic urine or other adulterants and that is not I I'm not going to say you can't do it um there's people who try it but there there's um methods used to detect this so generally when we would have this happen and we' actually had this happen a lot in Georgia in the Atlanta area when we had different offices in that area we would routinely get something from the clinic saying hey something's not right with this we think it's synthetic we want to do an immediate observed uh specimen so that's kind of how that that has always flown you know flowed out for me after that's detected um so I I don't think it's ever a thing where they actually visibly see them using something they shouldn't um I think it's actually detect ected you know through the process of of reviewing the urine and the temperature pH Etc so yeah I mean like you said there are controls in place to to weed that out and and detect it and and it does get detected I've had I've had truck drivers call me and ask me hey can you help me I purchased some fake urine on the internet and uh got caught and and what can I do um well you're you're out of luck buddy um not much I can do for you shouldn't have done that so yeah good advice there all right uh I'm going to give you the last one here all right we've got um man I don't know I've got like 20 left pick your best one drivers can never challenge a positive test result and that's that's not true it and it depends I on my side of things when I've when I've managed big carriers a lot of our drivers were non so what we found in the EUR in the oral fluid test on that side for non doot you could still use oral fluid and you didn't have a split split specimen to test so what would happen is if they were positive for that one yes you can do it easier it's faster the results come back faster but you don't have a split specimen so once they're positive that's it there is no there is no challenge to that changed by the way with with the new oral fluid regulation there is now there is now a split but anyway yeah now for FMCSA that's not that's not the case with urine you're you're hey put this much urine in this cup we're going to split it into two specimens if you argue the fact of the positive on the first one we'll just do the second one and you have a time frame in there you can't just come back a month later and say Hey I want to go back and test that month old urine uh but you can file a challenge and then you can go in there and they can retest that yeah this is a critical point and this gets so so many drivers in trouble you know they a lot of times drivers will come to us after the fact and say hey I legitimately was not using drugs and and the test it was a false positive what can I do you need to you you had an option at that point your your your recourse was to request a a test on the split specimen that that's your only recourse at that point and like Rob said you have a specific time frame within which to do that the OM should advise you of that fact when they call to talk to you about a positive result you should you should request a test on the split and if you don't request a test on the split then you're pretty much out of luck I've had some drivers try and kind of go the back door way of of escalating the issue up through FMCSA headquarters they usually doesn't go anywhere so the point is there uh if that happens to you and and it's legitimately hey I'm not there's it was a false positive you need to request a test on the split all right anything else we're about out of time here Rob no I mean I'll throw one more out there I think we got four minutes but um once a driver once a driver completes a sap program they can return to work immediately with no future testing required and that's not the case so if you if you complete your evaluation with the substance abuse professional um you got to do return to duty testing but then that's going to lead into or could lead into follow-up testing for who knows how long so up to it's not as simple yeah not as simple as just going and completing sap and then hey I'm going back to work you know 30 days later or whatever there's there's some testing regimens that that'll follow you for some time and those are going to be observed test right yep yeah so you know the process is you finish the sap program the educational part of it the you're still prohibited from operating unless and until you pass the What's called the return to duty test so this will be the first test after you finish the sap program it's oftentimes a a pre-employment test for a new motor carrier that can also serve as the return to duty test if you pass that you can operate you can legally Now operate a commercial motor vehicle but you are now subject to follow-up testing random follow-up testing at a certain Cadence for a certain period of time the regulations say the sap can prescribe a follow-up testing schedule to extend up to five years and many of them are for a full five years and they usually you know within the first year there's going to be more test and then they start to kind of scale down uh over that over that time period but um yeah you're going to be there's going to be a long tail to it and uh if you're the motor carrier that has hired that driver um after they've tested positive and now that's now your problem those follow-up tests if you don't do those follow-up tests if you don't if you don't follow that testing schedule to a te that's a violation on your part um so just realize that for for that reason and because of the highway accident risk a lot of motor carriers just say as a matter of policy we don't hire any drivers who have who have tested positive in the past they just don't want to deal with it and I get it uh but it puts drivers in a tough spot for sure all right well I think we better wrap it up there um thanks everybody for hanging out with us today uh I think we covered a lot of ground obviously Rob still had 20 or so more more uh misconceptions that maybe we'll address some of them in the article that we put out so be on the lookout for that like I said best way to keep in uh keep up to speed on what we got going on over at truck safe is by subscribing to our newsletter over at trucksafe docomo if you haven't checked out our online courses we have several online courses available for uh Trucking Company owners safety managers drivers over at our trucksafe Academy trucksafe academy.com uh be sure to check those out anything else Rob nope that's it for me all right we're going to wrap it up there thanks everybody for joining us talk to you later

Event Completed

Wednesday, November 29, 2023 at 4:17 PM EST

Watch on YouTube