Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 33 - What's in store for 2024?

Thursday, December 21, 2023 at 2:55 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 33 - What's in store for 2024?

About This Event

Join us for a look back at the most significant FMCSA regulatory developments from 2023 and a look ahead to 2024 for what might be in store for regulated carriers and their drivers.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 33 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman, Rob Carpenter, and Jerad Childress review the most significant regulatory developments affecting trucking companies in 2023 and offer a forward-looking discussion of what fleets can expect heading into 2024. The episode serves as a valuable reference point for fleet safety professionals seeking to understand where the regulatory landscape has been and where it may be headed. The hosts begin with FMCSA's proposed changes to the Safety Measurement System, noting that while the changes have not yet taken effect, carriers can already preview how their scores will be affected through FMCSA's preview website. Key proposals include splitting the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC into two separate categories — one for standard maintenance violations and one for driver-observed violations — which the hosts generally view as a practical and long-overdue improvement. Also discussed are updates to the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, including the new automatic notification system that alerts employers when a driver's Clearinghouse status changes within 12 months of a query. The hosts also cover the final rule authorizing oral fluid drug testing, which remains unavailable to carriers pending HHS approval of certified laboratories, and an expansion of the Crash Preventability Determination Program from 16 to 21 qualifying accident types. The conversation also addresses FMCSA's Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on carrier safety fitness determinations, which could eventually replace the existing satisfactory, conditional, and unsatisfactory rating system with a simpler fit-or-unfit framework tied to real-time safety data. The hosts flag a related proposal to establish an independent appeals board for Data Q denials, which they see as a meaningful step toward addressing due process concerns — particularly important if safety ratings become more directly tied to SMS scores. Rob Carpenter draws on his experience as a former driver to offer a nuanced perspective on the proposed speed limiter rule, acknowledging the safety rationale while expressing concern about removing driver control over a heavy commercial vehicle. Looking ahead to 2024, the hosts highlight several areas of potential regulatory activity, including possible revisions to the ELD mandate, a proposed knowledge test requirement for new entrants seeking a DOT number, and the ongoing development of a federal regulatory framework for autonomous vehicles. On the Clearinghouse front, they remind listeners that a November 2024 deadline will require state driver licensing agencies to automatically downgrade the CDL of any driver placed in prohibited status — closing yet another gap in the existing system. For fleet safety professionals, the key takeaway from this episode is the importance of staying proactive. Carriers are encouraged to log into the SMS preview website to assess how proposed scoring changes may affect them, review and update their drug and alcohol testing policies in anticipation of oral fluid testing, and monitor FMCSA's regulatory agenda closely in the coming months. The hosts also remind listeners that subscribing to the Trucksafe Consulting newsletter at trucksafe.com is one of the most reliable ways to stay current on breaking regulatory developments.

Full Transcript

oh I for w uhoh where's Jared and Rob this is a great start here hey everyone welcome to episode 33 of truck safe live show where winner guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon that's Jared Rob's coming up here in a second there's Rob all right great start here uh like I said episode 33 of truck safe live um today we are kind of doing a year- review yeah you would think after 33 shows I could get this right one time but anyway welcome everybody thanks for being here with us uh happy holidays to everybody who's tuned in if you're here with us say hey in the comments so we could see who's with us and uh yeah you're in review show um today so we're going to take a look back at at um uh what this year had in store for regulated trucking companies in terms of regulatory developments and then also looking ahead to what could be in store for next year so uh should be a good discussion today we published an article about this on our website earlier this week so if you don't want to watch us talk about it you can always go over there and check it out um Matt says happy Holidays happy holidays to you Matt um but anyway before we get to that fun stuff let's talk about some things going on uh over at truck safe uh I usually write this stuff down but I just realized I didn't write this down this time so what do we got going on at truck safe guys we got a ton of stuff going on yeah we got a lot of things that are going to be happening in q1 for sure so look out for some announcements that'll be coming uh q1 but we've been very busy with the Consulting work very busy with the uh course development course sales so if you haven't checked out truck safe acad definitely check out the courses that we have to offer yep we're also in the planning stages for our next truck safe Fleet compliance boot camp we've had a lot of people asking about this so just an update on that we're looking we're targeting uh summer of 2024 for our next truck safe Fleet compliance boot camp uh we're probably just going to do one next year is the plan and it will probably be somewhere around Nashville area um last year we did one in Indianapolis and then we did another one in or Orlando so we're going to try and pick somewhere kind of in the middle this time so be on the lookout for that best way to keep up to date with that type of information is by subscribing to our newsletter which you can do at trucksafe docomo types of updates but also we uh we send out the latest uh breaking regulatory news and our analysis of it and that type of stuff so check that out again trucksafe dcom bootcamp or I'm sorry trucksafe subscribe and then the boot camp information is trucksafe docomo Camp uh anything else Rob what else we what what else we got no we've got some rating upgrades and getting people back in business when they don't do right and U they need that sort of thing is the season to hopefully stay in business yeah right other than that some some general consulting stuff and trying to keep keep it floating yep yeah if uh if there's anything we can we can do to help you guys uh fleets out there watching feel free to give us a shout uh doing a lot of Consulting work as Rob said and you know safety rating upgrades data cues whatever you got going on if there's anything we can ever do to help feel free to reach out so it's pretty much what we've got going on uh looking forward to um like Jared said we got a lot in store for q1 next year a lot of announcements that we will be making um here sooner than lat later so be sure to stay tuned um for that information but anyway enough about us let's talk about regulatory year and review and 20124 Outlook so like I said this kind of started with an article we put out earlier this week um kind of highlighting some of the most significant dot rule making activity and non-rule making activity we'll get kind of get into that in a little bit uh over the course of the last year's fairly busy year I thought it was going to be pretty slow again when the year kind of started out but then it turned out we actually had quite a few regulatory developments um that we'll get into here in a minute um so I think that's the best way to go about this we'll we'll start out with kind of looking back at uh at those developments over the last year and then some of those as we'll talk about are going to bleed over into next year because they haven't been fully implemented yet but then we'll kind of conclude with uh with what could be in store for next year as we go along as always if you have any questions or thoughts on these uh these issues that we're discussing throw them in the comments and we'll bring them up uh all right first things first guys first thing on my list here from uh regulatory developments from 2023 uh perhaps the most significant one of all came early this year in February of 2023 FMCSA announced fairly significant changes to its safety measurement system it's CSA scores um and we had an entire episode of truck safe live dedicated to this particular topic we broke down exactly what the FMCSA was proposing um as we said in that episode this was a little bit of a surprise we knew that FMCSA had been told by Congress that they needed to make changes to the SMS we just didn't know that they were at the stage yet of actually being ready to make those changes but uh in February we got the notice that they are proposing uh it was a handful of fairly significant changes which we can talk about um but that one really uh kind of caught me by surprise about you guys yeah definitely I mean the the movement away from IRT the item response Theory because it certainly seemed like the agency was pushing towards IRT and then the movement away from that uh was a bit of a shock to me uh we knew something was going to happen but we weren't really sure what it was exactly going to look like but a lot of changes yeah yeah I actually like this one U I think a lot of it made a lot of sense um I don't I don't always give give the changes that credit but in this case I think it did make a lot of sense like um combining or splitting vehicle maintenance into two different categories moving drug and alcohol to unsafe driving it was it was just common sense things that probably should have been done a long time ago and we just you know kind of kind of finally got to it and um some of the other things paying more attention to recent violations so so I think it couldn't have been better in terms I'm right there I'm right there with you I think I you know overall My Kind of thoughts on it generally speaking were that they they are welcome changes once they take effect these these haven't taken effect yet so this is one of the uh activities that will bleed over into next year we don't really even have a date yet of when the FMCSA is expecting to roll these out what we know is that they proposed these La this February 2023 and that they set up a preview view website for it so where carriers can log in and see how their scores are going to be impacted uh by these proposed changes if you haven't done that yet if you haven't logged in to look at how your scores are impacted by these changes I'd recommend you you do so uh because it has the potential to um to to change your scores that said I don't know about you guys but I've worked with a few clients to kind of look at what their scores would be like under the new system and it didn't seem to make all that big of of significant changes to their scores did you guys have different experience with that or no no I didn't I think you know besides what I said in terms of liking it and agreeing with it I think there is that piece with carriers that you know I think a lot of carriers didn't really understand how it worked even under the old system so now you're you know they're they're finally in some cases just getting to the place where they're familiar with it and they're understand understanding how they're how they're rated and now there's going to be some changes that could change it but like you said I haven't found where it really affected it all that much so um I don't think they've got a lot to learn but I think it's going to change a little bit of what they may have just figured out from the old system so well you mentioned one that I think is probably one of the more significant ones Rob which is that splitting of the vehicle maintenance category into two separate categories uh FMCSA uh for those not familiar with with this change is essentially you know currently we've got our seven Basics that make up our CSA scores one of which is vehicle maintenance um and the proposal is to split that vehicle maintenance category into two separate categories one will be called vehicle maintenance as it is now and then the new one will be called vehicle maintenance driver observed and the idea with this change as I understand it is um this is the basic that currently has the most data in it uh it turns out that that vehicle maintenance violations are the most frequent types of violations encountered by regulated trucking companies so there's a lot of data in that basic and it makes it difficult for carriers to that that are struggling in the vehicle maintenance basic to understand what is causing what what's the root cause of their problems in the vehicle maintenance category so the idea with this change and splitting it out into driver observed and and just regular vehicle maintenance is that if going forward I have a high vehicle maintenance driver observed category uh but then an okay regular vehicle maintenance category then I I can deduce from that that the issue one of the root causes of my maintenance problems is probably um insufficient pre-trip inspections by my drivers because those drive that driver observe category is going to be uh all of the the maintenance related violations that the FMCSA says should have been caught by a driver in a thorough pre-trip inspection and that weren't for one reason or another any thoughts on that change guys specifically that's that's where my mind went too when Rob was talking about the maintenance changes I I love the driver observed category because a lot of times carriers are confused on how they get maintenance scores under control but with that driver observed category you're clearly like you said going to be able to point back to proper pre-trip post trips in route checks uh to driver observe uh issues that should have been caught in a proper pre-trip or bu trip yeah and sometimes you have that dynamic in in carrier operations where you've got you've got that um lack of um collaboration let's call it that where you know you've got that systemic problem that's maintenance driven you know maintenance isn't doing what everything that You' be doing to run that maintenance department um I I say in a predictive fashion but they're they're typically kind of at war with that Frontline driver piece where the drivers are saying hey it's not us and the mechanics are saying hey it's not Us and nobody can ever really Trend out like who's it's like that Meme with the Spider-Man pointing at at each other kind of yeah yeah yeah exactly but it's it's all one operation so it's ultimately a management issue but it could be both it could be systemic and Driver focused but this will help you Trend it out better to where you know what it is and how to yeah I think it'll be particularly helpful to the carriers of which there are many that don't spend a ton of time digging into the data in other words I I feel like it will give them an easier way to see at a glance what their maintenance problem is is it something that my drivers have better control o over or is it in the vehicle maintenance category where they are more like latent defects actual mechanical issues with the truck that is suggesting that we've got a an actual maintenance problem more so than a than a driver inspection problem so yeah I I think overall like I said um I think the changes make a lot of sense um I get the sense from talking with clients to that they're generally in favor in most of these uh with most of these changes that said there there are some notable absences from the proposals that I think a lot of folks were hoping the FMCSA would address uh through the through the changes including most notably I think uh the long standing problem that many folks have had with the CSA program which is the kind of regional disparity of enforcement of the safety regulations in other words carriers domiciled in in certain States or or that have more Regional operations in certain States uh who are more aggressive in in writing up speeding violations for example Indiana is the classic example um tend to have a higher score in that particular category than than similarly situated motor carriers so what ends up happening is we end up punishing motor carriers just based on where they are domiciled in the country essentially which is obviously not what we want to happen with this type of uh system so I think a lot in the industry were hoping that the FMCSA would do something about that but they specifically declined to in their notice so we'll see um we'll see if that ends up you know because what we're essentially getting to here is US Congress was the one that kind of initiated this and said that they have FMCSA had to make changes to the system ultimately FMCSA is going to have to make changes and then get Congress to sign off on on what changes they made so once we roll out these changes and FMCSA has to go present them to Congress we'll see what Congress has to say I guess uh okay that was the first uh what I would consider significant kind of rule making activity uh although it wasn't really initiated as an actual Ru making um the CSA program for whatever reason uh hasn't been implemented through any formal rule making so this these notices of these changes really just was a notice um there was no um no formal notice of proposed Ru making or anything like that uh which is is fairly significant but in any event next one up on my list here uh changes to the way that we do Clearing House notifications rob you want to break this one down for folks that may have not been up to speed on this one yeah I think this one makes a lot of sense too actually we're they're batting two and O so far so um with the Clearing House notification what was happening is you you might run it in January and then not run it again until next January and then during that time it's kind of like the MVR thing you get a ticket nobody knows about it until next year unless you happen to be using Samba well this is kind of the samba of Clearing House so when that driver doesn't like working for truck safe then they go apply for driver reach or whoever the carrier might be just using those two as an example and you don't know it but they put do their pre-employment drug test and then you get a notice that says hey Rob has new information in his Clearing House file you need to go pull a full query so what could that information be what could it be you get consent from the driver to get that um to pull that again you look at it see what it is and lo and behold you see hey he's done a pre-employment test trying to get another job with another carrier well now he he has an issue with getting that job with the other carrier because he failed the pre-employment test but now he also created an issue with his current employer because he's nowed in the clearing house until he completes that you you really screwed yourself that time Rob yeah I did it happens we actually had it happen we had a driver he let we didn't know he was not happy he he went and applied at USA trucking and sure enough we got it we got the notification I mean this some time ago ago but we got the notification and you know now he has no now he has no job because we didn't do s so yeah I mean it it seems to close a pretty big gap a pretty glaring Gap in the Clearing House process which was as you said you know potential a existing employer potentially being blind to a driver's uh positive test at a different Motor Carrier and so by automatically notifying Motor Carrier now this change has has taken effect so this is how it works now uh you automatically get notified through the system if there's been any change to your driver's status in the clearing house within 12 months after uh after you run one of your own queries Jared anything to add on that one or that was pretty self-explanatory it's pretty great it alleviates a potential 12 month blind spot between limited queries so I mean it's a no-brainer it's a good move now one thing I uh I just realized that this isn't on our uh on our list on our article I should I should um revise that article to put this on there because it's pretty important another Clearing House change that is scheduled for November I think of next year um is the next phase of the Clearing House implementation which is a deadline for State driers Licensing agencies to take action upon receipt of a a driver's prohibited status in the clearing house to downgrade their CDL automatically right now that that doesn't necessarily happen some states do that but it's not mandatory but as of November I think of of next year it will be mandatory that as soon as the states get a notification that any CDL driver domiciled in their state has been put into prohibited status in the Clearing House they have to automatically downgrade their CDL which closes yet another Gap in the system which was if I'm if Rob gets his CDL downgraded because of a drug testing violation then he could theoretically still have a valid CDL to continue operating even though he's technically prohibited to operate because of that drug testing violation so I think that'll be a good change um that is like I said scheduled to take effect next year uh Tom Cuthbertson hey Tom is asking on LinkedIn I think this is going back to our first uh our first topic here are are they also looking at some of the severity waiting uh for the SMS changes yeah my recollection is that that is one they're they're actually considering a complete overhaul to the way that they do severity weightings um because that was one of the big criticisms of the National Academy of Sciences when they came in to study SMS at the direction of Congress one of their criticisms of the system was that the existing severity waiting um severity weights of 1 to 10 for all of the violations are seem to be completely subjective in other words what weight a particular violation got assigned was not as you would expect driven by data to suggest How likely that particular issue is likely to cause a crash you might think that that's the way to do it but apparently FMCSA rather than doing that basing it on data they just had subject matter experts within the agency say yeah I think this particular violation should carry this particular weight so it was completely set very subjectively so to ostensibly address that concern one of the proposals with the SMS changes is that we're going to move completely away from a a 1 to 10 severity weight system into a system where violations have only a weight of either one or two and um which ones get one and which ones get two it it turns out that the ones that are going to be two-pointers are going to be out of service violations essentially so the more serious ones as you would expect so any any violations that cvsa has determined are out of service violations whether vehicle related or driver related those are the ones that are going to have a severity weight of two going forward under this proposal and then all other violations will have a severity weight of one so it'll be either one or two the idea was to remove some of the subjectivity now I think that introduces actually some additional problems which is um you know the fact that essentially violations that probably should be treated fairly differently from one another are going to carry essentially the exact same weight I'm trying to think of an example do you guys have any examples of that like under that new methodology like what would be two violations like a form and manner violation would be a one-pointer uh which is just a minor paper work violation but so would things like speeding violations right so they would carry the same weight in the system but they're clearly not describing the same type of thing or the same type of concern and that's not a great that's not a great example because those are separate Basics but breakes and reflective tape yeah breaks and reflective tape there you go and and part of the issue that you're describing to Brandon is the fact that they're going to take like for hours of service for example they're going to take the 73 separate hours of service violations that are currently in existence and put them into a combined group of nine different violation groups and so that's where you could have broader categories of hos violations being put in group nine um and all being treated the same yeah yeah so that that is one aspect of the proposal that has uh gotten some blowback that I've seen so I I guess we were a little quick to say that they they that we were generally in favor but um you know some of those things I I think we're just going to have to wait and see what the impact is uh but yeah that for sure is uh is being done Tom uh okay we talked about SMS changes we talked about Clearing House notifications next up on the list this was something else that happened in 2023 in April in fact was the fmcsa's notice that they intend to expand the so-called crash preventability determination program another change that I would generally characterize as a pretty good change a pretty welcomed change uh those who aren't familiar with this system it is a or the of this program it is a program in place where a regulated Motor Carrier can go in and essentially challenge the preventability of certain types of do recordable accidents historically all accidents all dot recordable accidents have impact negatively impacted a motor carrier's crash indicator score in the SMS platform and that's never been that fair because why should we be penalized for accidents that were clearly not our driver's fault the the non-preventable accidents and I think fmcsa's rationale for that to date has been well that may be not all that fair but at least we're treating everybody the same every Motor Carrier gets penalized just as heavily for all types of accidents whether or not they were preventable regardless FMCSA set up this crash preventability determination program probably five or so years ago where in limited circumstances motor carriers can file an appeal essentially through the dataq system to challenge the preventability uh of their do recordable accidents and then if they Prevail in that appeal if the FMCSA decides that it was non-preventable on the motor carrier driver's part then that particular accident it'll still show up in the system but it won't weigh on their crash indicator score now that program was initially set up as a pilot program so it was very limited in scope it progressed out of the pilot stage but it was still Limited in scope in the sense that the FMCSA has an eligibility guide for what accidents qualify for consideration for a non- preventability determination and to date until now and currently there are only 19 accident types that qualify for consideration if it doesn't meet one of those if it doesn't fall into one of those 19 categories your appeal is just going to get kicked out without any consideration and it turns out that that those 19 categories are pretty narrow uh it's it's going to be the ones that are easy for the FMCSA to determine are not preventable as you would expect um and so the proposal a long story short here the proposal earlier this year in April is to expand that program to uh add additional categories of accidents that will be eligible for consideration under the program so they're going from 19 to oh maybe I had that wrong 16 to 21 16 to 21 so there's 16 currently and they're going to 21 thoughts on this change guys I mean it's it's a welcome change for sure I mean it you know talking about the uh program and the El eligibility guidelines they're very uh rigidly applied and so if you're going to consider submitting a challenge to a crash make sure that you really study uh the program and the eligibility guidelines because like I said they're very rigidly applied and if you don't fall squarely within one of the categories um it'll be rejected for sure um it is difficult sometimes because you may have two categories that generally apply and how do you decide which one you want to go for uh that is a a strategy question that's an interesting one but I've seen some crashes rejected from the program that seem to be squarely within the eligibility guidelines um and it's a little frustrating but hopefully this addition of uh up to 21 crash types helps with the program Rob what are your thoughts no I think it's a good thing I I just it the whole program is not without its its workload I guess um you know you have to get you have to get the crash report we've done a number of these recently as you two know but um like one I had Kickback yesterday it qualified without question but the driver didn't have a med card that was valid at the time so their response back was we need a copy of his valid med card and it's like what does that happen this crash so anyway we supplied it rather than argue med card and it eventually got approved but that was one of the questions that they sent back so you still have the workload aspect the good part about it is there's more things that qualify as opposed to what used to qualify as something that you could challenge there but um I like ridiculous why why why it was I I think it was Washington so it's it's one of the um one of the more Western States let's put it that way oh man that makes me mad anyway I'll send to you yeah what does the driver because forget it um one of the things that I I noted about this change that I thought was interesting so even though they're still going to limit it to 21 crash types I did notice that the last uh proposed new crash type seemed like kind of a catchall that may Encompass even more accidents than just the 21 because it it was something to the effect of any other accidents in which you have video evidence to support your uh to support your version of The Facts essentially I'm paraphrasing there but if if I understood it correctly if you've got cameras installed on on your on your uh vehicles and the camera footage shows clear enough that it was not your driver's fault even if the accident doesn't otherwise fit into one of the other categories then you may be able to submit that camera footage and get it removed from your score so I thought that was a welcome change too uh let's see here Matt saying Jared's right on point you know you don't get that said very often do you Jaren um you know you have a crash that could qualify but what box do you put it in in the limited types yeah I mean that's the problem um okay that's crash preventability crash preventability determination program next up on the list is oral fluid testing this got a lot of uh news coverage uh in in this past summer uh FMCSA actually the USD more broadly uh issued a final rule where they authorized oral fluid testing uh in addition to your analysis as an approved test type for DOT mandated drug screens and uh that like I said that came out in May um but here we are in December of 2023 and carriers are still not authorized to use oral fluid testing quite yet why is that it's because that rule is contingent on the Department of Health and Human Services approving at least two Laboratories to be able to process those test types and they have not yet approved any Laboratories to process those test types so there's no one to actually process them uh process them so we're still waiting on that have you guys heard any Rumblings of when that's supposed to take effect I keep hearing it get pushed back nothing nothing I haven't heard either um I have heard some folks excited about the opportunity to use the oral fluid testing and I've heard some folks say that it's going to be more accurate some folks say it's going to be less accurate what what's the reality there um on on the accuracy of the testing I mean I know it's going to be a less invasive means uh a little easier to implement ideally once we get the labs up but from an accuracy standpoint is it going to be improved accuracy I think there was some data in the final rule where they kind of studied that and I think it ended up being kind of a wash because for some drug types I think it had a long like a longer detection window and then for others it had a shorter one as compared to your analysis that was my understanding Rob do you have any experience with oral fluid testing from when you managed safety programs we did it we did it from a non-dot perspective because it's it's like $9 a test versus you know the cost of a urine test and if you don't have to have urine for non doot go the cheaper route but what's the average cost for a urine test I don't even know um I don't know 30 35 bucks something like that but it depends on who you're using to it could depend on lab a vendor Etc but um the only issue that we ever ever really had was um for non doot was if you if you had the argument of hey I want to I want to I want to check the second specimen there is no second specimen in the non doot case there is with the new rule for do CDL people but um I never really came into you know it just you either were or you weren't so we never really got into you know trying to figure out yeah I think from what I understand the the big impetus for this is two things Jared you mentioned one of them which is the relative ease of administration of these types of test as compared to your analysis and also perhaps more importantly the fact that these oral fluid tests are by their nature always observed by the collector versus Ur analysis which is very rarely observed and so the the prospect of drivers cheating on a UR analysis test as I understand it was much higher than than their potential ability to to cheat an oral flu test because there's somebody right there in front of their face watching them spit into the into the tube or however they administer them yeah we did find the one another good benefit to it was it usually came back faster um so that's obviously going to depend on the isue and how that works itself out but in our case it it generally came back pretty quick so yeah so I think it'll be good that carriers will have another option for administering these tests um you'll want to if you plan to administer these types of tests you'll want to make sure that you update your your drug and alcohol testing policy um to make sure that it's clear to your drivers that this is a possibility for them um but again they're not authorized quite yet so um be on the lookout for for the notice once the dot sends it out that they've approved um or that the Department of Health and Human Services has approved those labs we'll also obviously notify our clients of it so again another reason to subscribe to our newsletter uh okay that's oral fluid testing next up um this was another big one that we we actually knew this one was coming down the pike but um it's it's in its very early stages now so this is potential changes to carrier safety Fitness determinations also known as safety ratings so um motor carriers who have a safety rating will be familiar with this process but essentially we have had this three- tiered safety Fitness determination process in place for decades at this point carriers that have gone through a comprehensive dot audit will often have a safety rating of either satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory uh this has historically been the way that the motor or or that the FMCSA has inforced its safety regulations is on and off-site audits digging through records and then assigning a safety rating if you get an unsatisfactory rating coming out of an audit then your Fleet is going to get shut down so this has been the primary enforcement tool that the FMCSA has used um but it's it's showing its age at this point um and one of the big criticis I guess two big criticisms with the existing safety rating methodology is number one just so few motor carriers have a safety rating because the FMCSA just is not able to to effectively conduct audits of very many motor carriers um I think upwards of 95% of the regulated carriers in the country don't have a safety rating so that's the first concern is that you know there's just it doesn't touch enough motor care uh touch enough of the uh regulated motor carriers that we have operating out in the country and then also uh another concern with it another big concern with it is that safety ratings and audits in general are by their nature just a snapshot of the motor carrier's safety performance in other words dots coming in do an audit they're looking at your records as they exist today and they're basing your safety rating on how those records look today um but they really those ratings say nothing about what your Fleet is looking like as of the current day so maybe your rating was issued to you 20 years ago and you've since invested a lot in your safety program and made all of these these great ch changes to improve your compliance but you're still living with that same safety rating downgrade that you got from 20 years ago so like I said by their nature these ratings are static and uh vers as compared to like CSA scores which are looking at kind of a rolling uh data set from a month-to-month basis so um FMCSA came out with a notice it's a this is actual rule making it's it's in the advanced notice of proposed rule making stage came out in September uh according in to the notice FMCSA is interested in developing a new methodology to determine when a motor carrier is not fit to operate cmvs in interstate commerce um but what does that look like what how's it going to work going forward we don't know the FMCSA asked the public to weigh in on that question they they listed out several different questions uh and they opened it up for comments and there have been hundreds if not thousands of comments filed um but we won't know until sometime next year probably when they come out with the proposed rule so thoughts on this um topic guys I think you it's one of those things you kind of got to be careful of when you change it because it's it's not just I mean it's a safety rating so obviously it's designed to to indicate whether you're safe or not um or your operations are but it a lot of a lot of people use this from an operational perspective whether they want to give you contracts to haul their Freight or whether um Brokers use it to determine whether they want to let you haul their Freight based on what your safety rating is or isn't so um I'm interested Insurance Groups setting in premiums cab reports Etc a lot of things F focus on the safety rating and and this data so I'm interested in seeing how how they change it and if it's a benefit or something that's going to hurt carriers yeah I've always I've always kind of liked the idea of just a simple fit or unfit getting rid of the middle category of conditional because you know like Rob just kind of mentioned I mean some Brokers refuse to use a motor carrier that's conditional others will do it um is that acceptable it's just different categories of risk for everyone so a simple fit or unfit would be a little cleaner way to do it but that's going to be pretty challenging because then you're going to have a lot of folks that normally would have fallen into the conditional category that are now considered unfit and unable to operate then you're going to have additional Safety Management plan obligations on the fmcsa's part uh with their limited um resources that's just going to be an even bigger Challenge and then also I mean the audit uh you mentioned Brandon I mean that's it's generally a look at the Safety Management controls that are in place at the motor carrier and so if you start looking outside of those um Safety Management controls to consider roadside data as a component of fit or unfit then are you going too far um it's interesting we don't have a lot of details on exact how they're going to do it but that's going to be uh the the most important part is exactly how they're going to do it yeah and we just simply don't know that at this point so yeah for sure I mean that's going to be the challenge and um we do have a little bit of uh insight into what FMCSA might be thinking of doing because um folks listening in may remember that the FMCSA tried to do something similar to this back in 2016 they had actually issued a notice of proposed rulem so it was it was further along in the the process than this one where they had proposed changes to the safety rating process moving to a fit or unfit determination that was driven largely by CSA scores so it was if that had gone into effect it would have tied directly into the carrier's safety measurement system and then they had developed a methodology whereby if you exceed certain thresholds uh within the basics on a given month then you would be in an unfit status and you would be shut down because of that and you know there was just an outcry in the industry rightfully so with that proposal because at that point FMCSA hadn't done anything to to address the concerns with safety measurement system at that point this was before Congress stepped in and and slapped him on the wrist um and there were legitimate concerns that the data in SMS just was not effectively judging the safety of of the motor carriers for several reasons including that desparate Enforcement issue I mentioned earlier and so uh folks just flooded the comments of that rule making with uh hypotheticals of of situations where clearly a motor carrier would not uh should not be subjected to an unfit determination but under the methodology they would so long story short there FMCSA eventually voluntarily withdrew that rule making but I worry my concern is that they are contemplating something similar with this Ru making and I think they are taking comfort in the SMS proposals that they've or the changes that they proposed thinking well hey we've addressed all of these concerns that the industry had with our SMS system so now we should be able to tie a carrier safety rating to them they hinted at this in the aprm that they published my biggest concern with that uh actually leads us into our next our next big change um that happened or that was proposed earlier this year my biggest concern with that was the lack of due process that's available to motor carriers to challenge erroneous data that's in the SMS system you know the platform to do that is the data Q system as we all know but folks who use that system know how the deck is stacked against you when you're filing those data cues appeals because those appeals are in most cases being reviewed by the exact same state agency that wrote you up for the violation to begin with and they're not often inclined to change their mind about their violations so the success rate of data cues is very low and there's nowhere to take further appeals of those violations if your data que gets denied it's not like you can appeal that up to a court system or anything like that so my biggest concern was hey if we start tying a carrier safety rating and shutting carriers Down based on erroneous data and they don't have any mechanism to effectively appeal erroneous data what are we doing and uh that's where FMCSA came in shortly after they had proposed the change to the safety rating system and they came out with another proposal having to do with the data Q system and what they are proposing is setting up an independent appeals board that would be available to review denials data Q denials issued by States and um and I think the idea here is that uh particularly for issues of like legal interpretation so if we file a DAT matters of legal interpretation or implementation of enforcement policies or regulations yeah very specific yeah so the FMCSA is essentially hinting at hey we're not setting this up this appeals board up so everybody can appeal to us we're only going to accept certain types of appeals to this independent appeals board and it's going to be essentially uh where the officers um misinterpreted the regulations or mis misinterpreted FMCSA guidance those are the ones that are going to potentially be eligible for this type of an appeal uh but at least it's something it's an independent appeals board that will sit above the states and that will uh be an additional Avenue for us to get some uh remedy if the officer screwed something up so I I think that's a certainly a welcome change absolutely agree I mean if if you unsuccessfully submit your First Data que and then you take another B at the Apple and submit another data Q request with no additional new evidence there's 100% chance you're getting rejected and so with this independent appeals board uh if you qualify for a submission into this appeals board it's actually going to give you a different set of eyes not only another bite at the Apple but you're going to get another set of eyes looking at the uh request so that ended of itself is a huge Improvement in my opinion yeah yeah we don't have the details on it yet the again the notice was short on details and it hasn't been set up yet so uh I I anticipate that all three of these major changes the SMS changes the safety rating changes and this data Q change will all kind of be rolled into one big change that happens sometime next year is my guess Rob any other thoughts on that data Q appeal no I wish they they did more with it where you could you could actually push more up because I mean there are times where that's not the only thing that needs to be reviewed um so yeah so we'll wait and see how that one plays out um okay so with what time we have left here in this particular show let's hit on some kind of outlooks for 2024 in addition to those things we've already mentioned that haven't been wrapped up this year uh that are going to bleed over into next year what else is there potentially in store from a regulatory perspective for motor carriers first one that comes to my mind is speed limiters yeah this speed limit definitely gonna have some activity uh it was supposed to have some activity here in December right uh we had a congressional hearing that was occurring That was supposed to be on uh budget concerns and uh the FMCSA administrator was in attendance and seemingly got a little blindsided by uh some members of the House related to speed limiters and and this particular rule um that was pretty fascinating I don't know if it has slowed the momentum uh of the agency pushing the speed limiters rule through uh but I was anticipating some activity here in December the month's not over but it seems like maybe that stalled out a little bit what do you think yeah this has been in the works since at least 2016 where FMCSA and Nitsa issued a a combined notice of proposed rul making uh that would have mandated these types of devices uh the installation of these types of devices on newly manufactured vehicles and then that just never went anywhere but according to the fmcsa's regulatory agenda from this year they had planned to pick that back up and issue a supplemental notice of proposed Ru making that would again mandate these typ of devices and you're right Jared it was originally scheduled for December of this year but yeah I agree I I suspect that that that that beating she took at the Congressional hearing from from uh uh a few Congress congressmen congresswomen uh may end up stalling this but we'll have to wait and see I'm interested in Rob's thoughts on speed limers having been a driver I I didn't I I kind of split on this one because there's the safety side of me and the like the reconstru instructionist side of me that says like hey you know speed plays a huge role in in a lot of serious commercial vehicle crashes so I understand why we did you know why we have this proposal to begin with but from a driver perspective that side of me is a little different because having driven a truck um this and um the automatic braking deal takes takes control away from the driver and I'm never really in I'm not a proponent of taken control of an 80 to you know 100,000 lb vehicle from the person that's operating it and trusting it to a system so you know there's there's times when you're especially say let's just use Colorado as an example you may need to um control the speed of your vehicle in mountainous areas or or whatever the case is or you may need to overtake another vehicle uh where you need to go faster than the proposed the formerly proposed 68 miles an hour um so I'm kind of kind of both sides on it I see it but having driven a vehicle I see it less yeah so hard telling where that one's going um but it very well could uh pop uh rear its ugly head in in 2024 so again I have to wait and see uh last few here uh this one kind of went dark so FMCSA had had noted this in 2022 and then I heard nothing about it in all of 202 23 and this has to do with potential revisions to its ELD mandate we talked about this on a on a past show um but some of the things they were toying around with at the time when they came out with this notice was potentially moving away from a self-certification process for elds and to a system that's like Canada's more like Canada's where ELD devices have to actually be certified by either FMCSA or whatever whatever group it certifies to do those uh certifications so that was a proposal as was potential um changes to some of the exemptions that we have for elds the one that they had mentioned was maybe considering adjusting or doing away with completely the older model year truck exemption for elds which says that currently if you drive a a model year 19 uh engine model year 1999 or older then you're completely exempt from the ELD Rule and um there was some some talk and that notice about potentially modifying that uh I assume you guys haven't heard any more news on on anything like this no I think it would probably be good from a third party perspective though yeah I I hadn't heard anything additional about this um you're right Canada requires a third party to conduct a certification of the elds that are on transport Canada's list of elds that are approved for use by motor carriers um my understand is that the FMCSA would be conducting some certification based on the discussions that I've heard which sounds like a huge lift um but the thirdparty testing what we've learned from the Canadian thirdparty testing for the elds is that it's very costly and it can take a long time especially if there's uh fixes that need to be implemented by the eeld manufacturer and so if the agency were to take this on I think it would be a very heavy lift um it would get rid of a lot of the devices that we currently have that are self-certified that are causing a lot of problems for motor carriers in the industry at large so would it be a good thing probably but is it possible um that's another question because like I said it's going to be a lot of work on the part of the agency if they're going to be actually doing the testing yeah I mean to that point we have seen even over the last year FMCSA seemingly being more aggressive at d uh removing from the list of self-certification devices that it finds to be non-compliant with the technical specifications uh I think before this year could probably count on one hand the number of devices that the FMCSA had removed but over this past year I think they've removed an additional dozen or so from the list so at least they seem to be more aggressive in getting those devices off the off the list but yeah I agree if they I was gonna say I can tell you for sure uh previously a lot of the revoke devices that were put on the list were because of business activity or just a business failing to get traction and market share and then closing up shop they go onto the revoked list well I can tell you for sure that the FMCSA is conducting investigations on ELD manufacturers that they know um are having compliance related issues so some of the devices that are getting put on their revoked list are because of Investigations being conducted by the FMCSA so they are policing them at this point yeah yeah and some of these that I've used it's like if you there there's a lot of there's a lot of effort from a carrier perspective that that goes into installing these things and that's why usually I'm pretty big on make sure you select the right one because once you put it in it can be you know depending on how the size of your operation it could be a year-long proposal in getting these put in your vehicles and then having to take them back out to only get a new one that works yeah or that's compliant so if you had a truly objective list um that of ones that were really approved that were really good um or compliant that would that would be good but yeah well like I said this has has seemingly gone dark so this may be off the table completely uh it's not on the agenda anymore from what I can tell so um but that's not to say that it won't come back uh at some point kind of like the U the safety Fitness determination Ru making did so again wait and see uh last two here um this one I suspect that there's going to be a lot of folks that are getting a little worried worried about this one um potential changes to the new entrant audit process to implement some kind of of a knowledge test for motor carriers to be eligible to get a DOT number so right now anybody and their brother can go get a do number there's no there's no test in place to make sure that you know anything about the the dot safety regulations you just go register for one you can have one in 15 minutes uh but there is a proposal on the books um for there to be some kind of a Knowledge Test so that in order to get a DOT number you have to either yourself or at least have somebody on staff that knows something about the dot safety regulations and can pass this type of test this isn't all that uncommon for like different types of licenses out there that that the government that state or federal governments issue you know like contract some contractor licenses you got to take a test and and that type of stuff so thoughts on this one guys it's kind of like it reminds me of e verifi on the human resources side of things if you're going to use ever verify when you go to get an eify account to determine if somebody's immigration status is is good to be employed in the United States the first thing you have to do is do their tutorial and then pass like a 20 question test if you don't you can never open a case with e verify you can't use this so it kind of makes sense and then you have States like um Minnesota for instance um from an intrastate perspective has a test that you have to take on each basic but just like with e verify there's nothing showing that you're the person taking the test I mean we could hire Brandon or Jared or Rob to take it for us as long as we have the certificate with the code we're good so it doesn't really it's not indicative that you know what you're talking about you just hire someone else to take it we're back in high school again it's like I've said this before I think this would be a fun truck live episode where we get our hands on this test and then us three just sit here and take the test and see he can get the best score on it there you go you guys up for it let's do it we probably W pass it and then nobody will ever hire us again I think I've got Minnesota one do you I think I do all right sounds like some good content how much time do we have left three minutes let's do it all right to wrap things up then last one on the list here and this is a big one uh actually Jared and I did an entire show on this I don't know it's probably been a year or so ago Jared and this has to do with autonomous trucks and regulations governing those um we know that FMCSA is is working on this um to what extent they have this done I'm not really sure but it is on their agenda to roll out some regulatory scheme to govern the operation of autonomous trucks and uh there's going to be a lot that goes into that and they kind of started to build a framework for this they they ask for public input on various questions about how these should be structured um but currently there is literally no framework for the operation of autonomous trucks under federal law so right now it's being governed pretty much just by state law uh if the state laws have anything to say on that so we'll have to wait and see if FMCSA makes any movement on this I don't think it's going to be anytime in the near future but it could be in 2024 yeah the originally we're supposed to have a proposed rule in December yet again we haven't seen that as of yet um I anticipate you know Nitsa and FMCSA will be working together very closely I mean they already are but even more so in the future to kind of get the regulation the the regulatory landscape under control a little bit Nitza is working on a ton of studies right now tons of studies on AVS on test tracks um and and a lot of those studies are going to yield results here within the next several years which I think will then speed up the regulatory landscape yeah Rob and inclosing thoughts on that one no I I think you'll see more on it you know wh Mo obviously the taxi company which I've been kind of critical of they they put out a study this morning that said out of seven 7 million mile 7 million driverless miles of analysis showed that there was an 85% um reduction an injury causing crashes in autonomous versus driver you know true human driven Vehicles so they're claiming that weo is um safer than if you're being driven by a human but I don't know that I I go with that but with things like that coming out it can only be a matter of time before FMCSA has to say something about it yeah all right guys we're out of time we're going to wrap it up there uh appreciate everybody tuning in happy holidays to you uh if there like I said if there's anything we can ever do for you feel free to reach out to us and stay tuned next year this is the last show for for this year but um hope to have you join us next year for uh some additional shows so thanks everybody for tuning in we'll catch you next time

Event Completed

Thursday, December 21, 2023 at 2:55 PM EST

Watch on YouTube