Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 34 - Contractor Catastrophe

Wednesday, January 17, 2024 at 5:48 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 34 - Contractor Catastrophe

About This Event

We’re joined by transportation attorney Doug Grawe of the Grawe Group to break down the Department of Labor’s Final Rule governing independent contractor status under the FLSA and what it could mean for trucking companies and owner-operators.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 34 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Doug Grawe, transportation attorney and CEO of the Grawe Group, to discuss the U.S. Department of Labor's final rule on independent contractor classification under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), issued in January 2024. The topic is particularly significant for the trucking industry, which relies heavily on owner-operators classified as independent contractors, making it one of the most exposed industries to potential misclassification liability. The final rule replaces the Trump-era interpretation, which had emphasized two core factors above all others, and returns to a broader six-factor "economic realities" test. Those six factors are: opportunity for profit or loss based on the worker's own decision-making, investment by the worker in their business, degree of permanence of the working relationship, nature and degree of control exercised over the worker, the extent to which the work is integral to the potential employer's business, and the skill and initiative demonstrated by the worker. Importantly, Doug clarifies that this rule is not the ABC test used in California, is not a sweeping change to existing law, and applies specifically to FLSA enforcement by the Department of Labor — not to state labor claims, workers' compensation, unemployment, or motor vehicle accident liability. Doug and Brandon walk through how each factor tends to play out in the trucking context, noting that several present ongoing challenges for fleets. The permanence-of-relationship factor is complicated by federal leasing regulations, the integral-part-of-the-business factor is difficult to overcome when a trucking company works with truck drivers, and the control factor creates a frustrating tension between maintaining independent contractor status and exercising the kind of oversight necessary to prevent highway accidents. On the enforcement side, Doug notes that FLSA claims most commonly arise from disgruntled contractors and can be pursued directly in court by private plaintiffs' attorneys through class action lawsuits — often representing a greater financial exposure than a Department of Labor audit alone. Key takeaways for fleet safety and compliance professionals include the importance of documenting the business decisions made by independent contractors — such as adding equipment, hiring drivers, negotiating rates, and managing fuel and maintenance costs — as evidence that supports legitimate independent contractor classification. Doug also emphasizes that trucking companies should focus their oversight on driver qualifications and safety standards rather than day-to-day operational control, and should be prepared to treat the final rule as enforceable on its March 11, 2024 effective date, even as legal challenges are expected. As Doug notes, "Trucking companies that treat people well don't have these problems," underscoring that solid relationships and fair business practices remain the most practical first line of defense.

Full Transcript

o w yeah yeah oh you n call me the Joker call me the fool when she calls I always here to lose my cool baby I'm just a m to your plane and I you know that loveing you there a train W waiting to happen don't you know that you there's a train W waiting to it is got no class all attributes don't know if I I'm talking about me and you baby no one get me like you do I see Ling you the train waiting to don't you know that you a hey everyone welcome to Episode 34 of truck safe live the show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon the truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs excited to be with everybody today uh first show for 2024 welcome back to those who have watched before if you're here with us today say hey in the comments so we know who's watching uh got a lot in store for this season of truck safe live pretty excited about it uh for this first episode we're talking about a uh a contractor catastrophe or maybe not um we'll have to answer that question once we bring our guest on but um some breaking news that came down early in the year uh last week in fact January of 2024 related to independent contractor status which is obviously always a big deal in the uh in the trucking industry so wanted to uh talk about that get others thoughts on it and see what it could mean for fleets across the United States so that's what we're going to do today uh before we get there a few things going on actually first thing I want to do is say thanks to the sponsor of this episode which is taking the higher Road a driver reach and Freight waves production it's a weekly show and podcast airing every Thursday join host Jeremy rmer founder of driver reach as he interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insight to the driver life cycle as they discuss the industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting and retention be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast so thanks to taking the higher Road for sponsoring this episode um few things going on over at truck safe and in the industry before we get to today's topic over at truck safe we had some big news that we announced yesterday we launched our truck safe manage services uh this is our White Glove DOT compliance Management Service it's designed to help shoulder a lot of the compliance burdens that uh that fleets bear uh and help them more efficiently onboard drivers electronically store driver and vehicle files track key expiration dates run required background checks drug and alcohol testing all of that fun stuff all through our partnership with a company called Hall they have a pretty slick AI based software solution for fleets to uh to store all of these compliance documents track them read them um and keep everything up to date and keep fleets out of the Crosshair so that's kind of our mission with truck safe manage services uh hoping to help out a lot of fleets like I said kind of shoulder some of that compliance burden for them so if you're interested in that you can check it out over at trucksafe manage.com uh what else we got going on at truck safe um as always if you're not a member of trucksafe Fleet compliance Network recommend you join it trucksafe network.com free to join uh this is a space for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions um provide details about your business and also access all of our content that we release through truck safe including our detailed articles videos podcast uh and everything like that you can check that out over at trucksafe network.com hope to see you there uh then lastly I just mention as always um subscribe to our newsletter if you're not already trucksafe docomo news and uh and our analysis of it uh and uh kind of everything that's going on from a safety and compliance standpoint um you could follow along there so again that's trucksafe docomo on in the industry um not a ton yet year-to date uh um which is hopefully not all that surprising since today is just the 17th of January but there have been a few things um first of all I saw a notice come out from FMCSA I think it was last week where they are um notifying the public that there are some studies and Publications that the agency is going to be considering in the context of their safety Fitness determination Ru making you may remember this uh from last year late last year the FMCSA put out an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking where they indicated that they are thinking about changing up the way that they do motor carrier safety ratings you know the three- tier system we have now satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory they're thinking about making changes to that we don't know what those changes are going to be uh I have a suspicion that they are uh potentially going to be tying uh Motor Carrier safety rating in part at least to their CSA scores that's something they tried to do back in 2016 never really went anywhere got a lot of blowback from the industry but uh long story short we're going to have to wait to see where the safety Fitness determination rule making goes but this past week they came out with another related notice that said that there are some studies and and uh and Publications that they're going to be considering in the context of that rule making and I thought there's a whole list of them and you could find this um you could find this on their website but I thought it was interesting a lot of the studies that they reference in that notice are about safety Technologies and and the installation of those devices on trucks uh like forward Collision warning devices and Lane departure warning devices and cameras event recorders all of that type of stuff and I haven't read the studies but I suspect that they are looking at um to what extent the installation and use of that type of Technology tends to minimize crashes on a go forward basis so it's interesting to me that FMCSA cites those specifically in the context of its safety rating changes and uh what it could mean for that I don't know maybe uh we're going to get something around the Beyond compliance initiative that we've heard the FMCSA talk about for decades at this point maybe giving some kind of credit to motor carriers that have voluntarily installed that type of technology I don't know I'm just speculating at this point what that could mean but I did think it was interesting again that was notice that came out last week um and then uh I guess that's kind of the biggest thing that has come out so far this year um uh if you didn't watch it already our last truck safe live episode was all about what could be in store from a regulatory and Rule making uh perspective uh FMCSA um for 2024 so if you missed that be sure to check that out you can get that wherever you get your podcast or at trucksafe live.com we walk through probably a half dozen or so rule making initiatives that are likely to uh be pushed forward this year by FMCSA and Nitsa um that could impact Trucking so again be sure to check that out we've we've also got a detailed write up on it on our website over at trucksafe outcom all right that was a lot to go through there um but definitely want to turn to today's topic so again today's episode is titled contractor catastrophe we are of course talking about the final rule issued by the federal department of labor last week that addresses how we determine whether workers are employees or independent contractors under the fair labor standards act FL LSA this is of course a huge issue in our industry one of the longest running and most widespread use of the independed contractors is in trucking um a significant percentage as we know of drivers in the US or owner operators who are often uh classified as independent contractors Visa The Fleets to whom they lease their equipment uh and so there's this constant battle waging in all kinds of context in all different venues about whether these drivers are properly classified or not and um you know misclassification can be extremely costly in terms of fines and damages from private lawsuits so it's important that fleets get this right uh but it seems like the goal poost are always moving um and the do's recent rule is the latest example of that so I'm excited to be joined once again by our good friend Doug gr Transportation attorney independent contractor Guru and CEO of the gro group Doug welcome to the show again thanks Brandon look happy to be here appreciate the opportunity Doug lives in Minnesota right Doug what's the uh you dealing with blizzard conditions up there yet uh it not not blizzard uh thankfully it's sunshiny and like five degrees uh so at least it's sunshin and so we'll take it that's all that matters um right yeah yeah we were talking before the show we're dealing something kind of similar here in Indiana uh about I think it was Zero when I woke up this morning so uh not looking forward to what could be in store over these next uh few weeks here but we'll just have to wait and see anyway Doug uh appreciate you joining me again as always um always interested in your Insight on the latest independent contractor developments and like I said at the start got a pretty uh what seems like a pretty big development uh this past week with the Department of Labor's final rule that they came down with um so I'm just wondering maybe to kick things off here uh broadly speaking if you could kind of break down what the Department of Labor's final rule is doing um and and what it might not be doing yeah uh so it is a big deal I I don't want to say it's not a big deal because any time an agency with this much uh influence and impact on our industry issues a final rule uh which means it's it's their rule that they are going to uh adhere to and follow and enforce upon uh that we we need to make sure we understand what it is and so forth we had heard that this was coming uh they the way the ru making process works is the agencies have to issue a proposed Rule and then after a variety of machinations they issue a final rule so we got a proposed rule a year ago now we got a final rule the uh good news is the final rule is about what we expected maybe slightly better than the proposed rule the bad news is the proposed rule was going to be bad and and we didn't like the proposed rule on the front end so uh kind of depends on on what perspective you want to look at it uh the the here's what the new rule is first of all what it is not it is not the ABC test uh the US Department of Labor did not imp implement California's ABC test um we can get into the weed sometime if you really want to about why they couldn't in the first place but but they didn't um they are going to determine that a a person is or is not an independent contractor using a six Factor independent contractor test called the economic realities test uh and those six factors uh in simple terms can the contractor make a profit or loss and can they make the decisions do they make the decisions that lead to their profit and loss I'm not ranking these I'm just listing them did the independent contractor make meaningful investments in their business I.E do they own the truck did they invest in the truck do they invest in the technology and their Workforce and so on how permanent is the relationship is this a relationship that extends on for years and years and is Evergreen and keeps Auto renewing as there starts and stops things along those nature how much control does the contractor have over their day-to-day lives their day-to-day business and and what they're going to do how integral is what the independent contractor does to your business as a motor carrier are you in the same business or are you not in the same business and how much skill or business initiative does the contractor have and did the contractor use so it's a six Factor test it is not hey did you did you pass four and you didn't pass two so you win it's not a uh you have to pass all six uh really what it is is the agency is going to look at all six of those they're gonna balance them in the air somehow some way and they're going to pick something um we all know totality of the circumstances right exactly exactly and one of the uh the the the gripes the beefs the frustrations I think uh not only the trucking industry but a lot of uh business folks have with the Department of Labor is we we all feel the deck is stacked against us it's a totality of the circumstances uh and you don't really know the way they're going to evaluate things and how they're going to see things and what they're going to rank as more important or not important and that's what the industry really liked about the old rule the old rule which was passed during the Trump Administration said yes there are six seven different factors and yes we will look at six or seven different factors but we're really going to focus on two of them and if you contracting company and independent contractor are clear that the independent contractor can make a profit or loss based on their own Merit their own decision making not just working more but their own Merit and they're free from control then you're going to pass the test that's the way it worked under the Trump Administration funny little fact about the the Trump Administration rule I would agree it looked like the more favorable rule uh and and it was a more favorable rule in the sense that it was clear it was not a more favorable rule in the sense that it was easier and I think that was the misnomer there were actually more decisions ruling a contractor was an employee under the Trump rule than there was under the six Factor test prior to Trump so the this notion that the Trump rule was easier I think was misleading that's that's simply not the case so I want to I think it will be useful in a in a little bit to kind of break down each of those uh factors again and kind of maybe explore how they tend to work in our in our industry but I want to back up first and and uh and and talk about um in what context this test is is being used I mentioned at the start the flsa for those who aren't familiar with it what is the flsa who does it govern to whom does it apply that type of stuff yeah great great question great point to make sure we we cover so the US Department of Labor's rule is their Rule and it is their rule that says that the rule says this is what the Department of Labor interprets the fair labor standards act to mean the fair labor standards Act is a federal law about overtime and minimum wage and uh what how you how you calculate pay and so forth um this has nothing to do with the state of Texas the state of Alaska uh this has nothing to do with motor vehicle accidents this has nothing to do with workers compensation or unemployment claims this has nothing to do with anything except the US Department of Labor enforcing the fair labor standards act against employers and and and their workers um so it really is going to impact are you audited by the US Department of Labor does someone bring a claim against you with a a realistically a worker or a contractor bring a complaint against you with the US Department of Labor the Department of Labor's rule would could be influential to a state case meaning some plaintiff lawyer just suing you on some kind of a class action because the Department of Labor might be seen as some kind of a an expert or a guiding principle but it's not binding this rule is binding on the US Department of Labor bringing an action against you Trucking Company um they're a big agency with a lot of reach but don't mistake that for meaning this is the law of the land on independent contractors anywhere and everywhere and and um the other thing I think is important to note as well is that this is an independent contractor test that is that is supposed to be broadly applicable to all Industries not just Trucking I think uh you know we uh it's easy to get caught up and thinking that this is an attack on trucking and and in some regards you know like I said at the start Trucking is probably one of the the the the industry that has a a huge independent contractor um population so it's not surprising that we view this as as maybe impacting our industry more so than others but I think just the point is hey this is this is the test that the Department of Labor uses in all Industries in all context to determine whether a particular worker is an independent contractor or or not um and and I think you pointed out earlier that we are essentially just returning back to the six- factor tests that we have had all along in this context if I understood correctly it's just that we are moving away from the Trump era interpretation of that test that had focused more on two of the factors more so than than all six is that about right yes think of it this way the Department of Labor is interpreting the law the law is the fair labor standards Act and the fair labor standards act someone says someone is an employ employee if they are s if they suffer or permit to work some phrase along those lines for 80 years the courts have decided what that phrase means and over those 80 years the courts keep coming back to five six seven factors it's always usually around there sometimes a court might lump two of them together another time they might split them up a little bit more but the courts keep coming back to these five6 seven factors and so what the Department of Labor is saying is they're they're they think they're saying is consistently the courts keep looking at these six things and so that's what we're going to do um what the Trump administration's version of the rule did is it said you're right that the courts have always looked at these you know five six seven factors but if you really studi the decisions the the out come is always down to these two they may talk about these other three or four but it really comes down to these two so um so so the answer is the Department of Labor is interpreting a very very old law and in some ways this is massaging the existing factors more than it is introducing something brand new um and if I can pivot for a minute you you made the comment that uh you know Trucking always kind of feels like this is an attack against them and and they do and I think one of the reasons we do as an industry there there are other Industries who who have more independent contractors than Trucking but I would I think you'd be hardpressed to find an industry with more staunchly proud to be independent independent contractors uh you know the the industry numbers are kind of all varied but but C somewhere between 300 and 600,000 independent contractors in the industry and I you know just my own number 80% of them love it and they want to be it and and to heck with anybody who's going to try to tell them otherwise uh and and the idea that the government of all people might be the one telling them otherwise uh I think gets them fired up and credit to the industry a lot of people in the industry everything from the Independent contract themselves to individual trucking companies to the trade associations did speak up about this and when the Department of Labor issued their rule it's kind of funny the rule is like three pages long but the commentary that goes along with the rule is like 189 pages long and in there there's lots of references to the Trucking Association said this this Trucking Association said that so we adjusted this we adjusted that uh the IND industry was heard in this even if we didn't get what we think it should have been um the industry was heard so I want to talk about enforcement you had already kind of hit on this a little bit but um I am curious I I I don't know enough about this area of the law about how how the flsa is typically enforced in what situations would it most commonly come up where a an independent contractor an owner operator is alleged to have been misclassified under the flsa is it is the Department of Labor going out there and auditing folks on any regular Cadence or how does that work in your experience the I there is a process for the Department of Labor to look up in the phone book and just pick a company that they do have that ability in that process they can do it uh that is not realistically how cases start cases uh with the department of labor typically start with a complaint uh and there are things called memorandums of understanding and those M are agreements between state and federal agencies to share information about enforcement actions so if you have a problem about independent contractor status with your State Department of Labor or you or the IRS or the Federal Trade Commission uh which yes that's another agency that gets involved in this stuff uh you you there could be some information sharing so a claim could start there but I would say even more fundamentally these complaints these claims these audits start because an independent contractor doesn't like what's going on and typically speaking it's not because they feel like hey I think I am being misclassified what it really is is my settlement wasn't right two times in a row and so now I'm I'm upset um they took think think lease purchase they took my truck uh at the at the end of the uh at the end of the lease and and and I couldn't get it back uh they they they didn't they they canceled my contract because I turned down too many loads uh my dispatcher is a jerk and I just I can't stand the guy or the gal and and I want to be done with this in my experience trucking companies that treat people well don't have these problems forgetting how good or bad they are at the legal ease stuff it that you you don't sue people you like yeah well it doesn't help anything that we have such a high turnover in this industry so with such a big churn at a lot of The Fleets it's we see this in the dot safety context as well you'll have a disgruntled worker who who gets uh terminated or or or or gets frustrated and leaves and in retaliation for that they will go file a complaint with the do alleging safety violations hours of service you know this carrier made me exceed my hours of service limits or something like that and that will often prompt the do to come in and do a safety audit and it sounds like it's essentially could play out that same way on the labor and employment side of things with a disgruntled worker going and and Reporting you to the to the do or to the to their State labor Association and then they share the information with with the do well um along similar lines I'm curious under the under the flsa is there a private right of action in other words if if driver independent contractor John Doe is is disgruntled uh with his job with carrier X and let's say a plaintiff's attorney approaches John Doe and finds out about this and is able to get together a bunch of drivers for that particular carrier can they file a class action lawsuit for violations of the flsa and is that a common thing that happens yes and yes uh they can uh and it is a a good money grab uh Frankly Speaking for for the plaintiff's bar uh there are lawyers that specialize in this this is the type of claim that they bring is a misclassification claim a class action misclassification claim under the fair labor standards act um so uh short answer is yes uh the numbers can get high fairly quickly uh and uh when you're trying to defend yourself against one of those types of claims uh if you're already in it you're going to have a tough time but but the key is preventing it and one of the ways to prevent it is making sure you can prove that the independent contractors you work with made business decisions daily weekly monthly whatever it is that impacted their profit and loss yeah this is getting into the nerdy legal stuff but if they pursue that that type of private right of action do they have to exhaust their administrative remedies first do they have to first go to the Department of Labor and get the Department of Labor to weigh in or can they go straight to the court with that they can go straight to the court they don't have to they don't have to go through the Department of Labor first no that would be that that type of claim there's a variety of contexts where what you described is the case uh the most common within the Department of Labor world would be more of a a what would be called an EEOC claim more of discrimination claim in that context yes you what you have to do uh the the the legal parament is you have to exhaust your administrative remedies first um okay meaning you have to go to the agency first that is not the case with a fair labor standards that claim yeah I mean that could be huge right because you know certainly this is again I'm I'm relating it to the to the safety world that I know better than this world but you know on the safety side of things I'm always worried about um you know on the dot side of things the fines that could come if we don't do things on the safety side of things correctly but I'm always more more concerned about the highway accident exposure that comes with doing things uh incorrectly or or um not in compliance with the regulations it seems like we've got kind of a similar situation on the labor and employment side of things we've got we've certainly got a risk of you know if we are misclassifying this particular driver we've got a risk of Department of Labor coming in and maybe slapping us on the wrist with some with some fines but it seems to me that maybe the the bigger exposure could be that type of situation where plaintiff's attorneys gather together a class particularly for the larger carriers and uh and then they pursue you know yearslong litigation class action litigation uh alleging misclassification under the flsa it seems like that's a pretty big exposure for fleets you're right and I would say that that yes the the private uh plaintiff lawyer class action is the bigger dollar exposure um but the do compared to to your analogy of what the Department of Transportation can and does do from A Fine perspective the Department of Labor can get much worse than the Department of Transportation can um so you you can be looking pretty quickly and easily at 10 20 $30,000 a contractor for for for for fines on from a Department of Labor audit just the do bringing the claim um so the numbers can get big they don't always get big there are tons of factors that go into to what that calculation looks like but if you want to paint your worst day uh as a trucking company dealing with the Department of Labor the Department of Labor is going to say you you if you've misclassified this person then you have to make them whole and pay them as if they're an employee so one of the things you got to do is you got to reimburse business expenses so fuel expenses Truck Leasing expenses Insurance expenses repairs maintenance and all down the line so if you think about it you got a contractor uh working with you for three years and you got to reimburse all of that stuff then potentially pay some fines and pay some minimum wage or stuff like that on top of it that's where the numbers can get pretty big it brings to mind like a I've dabbled in independent contractor cases over the years and it brings to mind um and I know we've talked about it on prior shows Doug but this uh this idea of this two check system where you know for owner operators that own their own trucks and they're you know paying them for the use of their truck and also uh a separate check for essentially what would be akin to their to their wages so that in the event of this type of reclassification then you at least have an argument that hey the the payments for for the reimbursement for the expenses we already did that type of thing and really the only thing that we should be uh uh potentially paying on with has to do with the the check for their wages um but I I like I said I just dabble in that and that that brought to mind that type of thing yes there there is something called the two check system um it uh there are some companies out there that do it there's some Services out there that offer it um I I have a little bit of experience with it I can tell you it was very popular in the SE not really the 70s more like the 80s is when it had a lot of populator into the early 90s um what the companies that that did it experienced um is a lot of issues on the tax side um because there's a lot of arguments then that come up about well how much of this did you allocate towards the equipment versus how much did you allocate towards the driver and did you do it appropriately and so forth and uh you you really find yourself trading One agency's problems for another agency's problems and oh by the way you still don't actually solve the Department of Labor's issues because they still might have an issue with whether or not you've you've classified the money appropriately and so forth um so what I would say is I actually do like the concept I remember when I first learned about it I'm like oh yeah this seems like it would work this seems like a really big deal and then spent some time with some people who lived it uh and said yep we thought so too and two years into it we're like this is a lot of administrative work and we didn't get the relief that we thought we would get yeah as you talked through it it it brought to mind that the context where it makes more sense I think to do that type of an arrangement are situations where you are taxed on the wage portion of the of the payments to the driver so like unemployment tax where unless you're doing that two Che system then generally the state's going to consider the entire amount you paid to them as a taxable wage and so the two Che system I think the idea is that no hold on a second a big portion of what we're paying to the drivers is not akin to a wage it should not be taxable it's essentially a reimbursement for the use of their trucks uh is the big part of it so anyway neither here nor there really uh I wanted to break down kind of each of these six factors that the Department of Labor looks at uh in this economic realities test and kind of talk about how in your experience um these factors tend to play out either in favor of the trucking company or uh in favor of uh employment status so let's start then at the top uh you mentioned opportunity for profit or loss what is this Factor getting at and how does it play out usually for like owner operators yeah so what what the what the courts or what the Department of Labor wants to see here is if you think about you as a trucking company how do you earn a profit and loss well one thing is you work on the revenue side uh what do I got to do to get more customers get better rates and so on and you also do work on the cost side what do I got to do and manage my my fuel expenses my maintenance expenses my Personnel expenses and so forth so they want to see can you prove that the contractors made at their level you know things are all relative and comparative but at their level did they make decisions that impacted their revenue did they make decisions that impacted their cost now one thing that that the the Department of Labor did say specifically just deciding to accept more loads is not B business decision making business decision making is did you decide to add a second truck or a third truck did you decide to add a second driver or a third driver were you able to negotiate your rates with the trucking company that can impact your Revenue side uh did you choose if if the trucking company has maybe like some dedicated and some over the road and some Regional and all sorts of stuff did were you free to make decisions about which operation you wanted to be in to impact your revenue and conversely did you have the freedom to make decisions to hire somebody could you hire a driver and decide what you're going to pay him could you decide where you're going to fuel and how you're going to maintain the truck and I think the we know in the industry I think others don't always appreciate it an owner operator that's really good at fueling really makes a big difference in their bottom line if they're good at maintenance and repairs and fueling and and and I will readily claim to be an idiot when it comes to how to fuel efficiently as an over the road owner operator I don't know how to do it uh but I know the guys and gals that are really good at it make a lot more money than those that aren't um that's what they're they're looking at and I would tell you Trucking Company can you prove that the contractors made those decisions what technology what data do you have what documentation do you have that says they made those decisions so as distinct from like traditional employees who are getting a salary or who are getting an hourly wage where kind of regardless of their own decision making they're going to get paid what they're going to get paid what the do is interested in here is does this truck driver influence his or her ability to increase revenue and and affect expenses through his or her own decision making sounds like exactly exactly all right uh second Factor here is investment by the worker and the potential employer what do they mean here yeah so one of this is where there was a a slightly positive uh change between the proposed Rule and the final rule in the proposed rule the Department of Labor was talking talking about that that the the Investments needed to be comparable so a lot of us in the industry were thinking holy smokes if if does that mean the contractor got to spend $10 million on trucks and trailers to to say that he's he or she is spending the same amount of money that that we are um there was good clarification that no that that's not what they mean um but what they do mean is are they making Investments that make sense for a business owner it makes sense for a business owner to invest in equipment uh the truck uh to the extent they they they invest in trailers or they invest in elds or cameras or other safety related technology their own laptop and so on do they invest in uh Personnel do they invest in marketing efforts to to increase their their presence uh those types of things is this contractor uh demonstrating investment in their business and not just working more the the interesting thing about I mean we said at the start this is a kind of a totality of the of the uh of the circumstances kind of analysis so no one of these factors is dispositive of of the driver's independent contractor status or not they're supposed to be taking a holistic look kind of exploring each of these factors as we're doing now and then based on the totality of the evidence we're supposed to be making a decision is that an independent contractor or an employee the thing I always find interesting is that even in those of those types of test it's inevitably always a situation where you know if they render a decision that goes against you they find that the driver is uh is an employee you could see how how their decision making is is often colored by how much weight they give to each of these particular factors even though it's supposed to be a totality like for example in in this alone you know they may give more weight to the fact that the driver actually owns the truck truck but in a in a situation where uh they're inclined to find that that driver is an employee you may see very little mention of them owning the truck and they may uh Elevate the fact that the trucking company provided the trailer and provided this and that so it's it even though it's supposed to be that totality of the circumstances it can be easily manipulated in my experience by the language used in the opinion to elevate certain evidence over over other evidence you're you're you're exactly right and I think it's it's critical when you are working on these types of cases that you do a good job I love your word of elevate do a good job elevating in in making sure people appreciate just how hard it is to be an owner operator in the trucking industry uh and what all that takes and all that kind of stuff and outside of our industry in our industry there's all the respect in the world for for those that get behind the wheel and deliver our freight and and and all that good stuff outside of the industry there's a little bit of they're just a truck driver and that's insulting first of all and and and and no one is just a truck driver it's a heck of a of a responsibility and a career and all that stuff um but you need to elevate that this person is a truck driver they're a business owner they're an equipment manager they're a dispatcher they're a customer service person if you don't get the court the agency the judge thinking like that that's exactly what what you you were getting at Brandon the totality if the the decision maker makes up their mind early on that this is just a truck driver yeah it's gonna you could see them start to cherry-pick the evidence that supports their their conclusion that's the that's the cynical way of looking at it and I feel like often time that's the way it plays out but uh all right so factor three degree a permanence of the work relationship what does this mean this is one that personally frustrates me a little bit but but what they're trying to say here is hey if you have a relationship that really never ends there's no clear start and stop time that is indicative of employment and I I see it uh if this is one that causes trouble for Trucking in particular has been my experience it does it it it does uh in for for two reasons one there is a Federal Regulation that says that a truck must be exclusively leased uh for at least you know a certain amount of time and so on so um actually take about the 30-day requirements gone but but the gist of it is is you have to be exclusively lease so from a contractual standpoint the Department of Transportation is saying you need to have some permanence to this relationship and setting that aside is I'm an independent contractor I have got clients that I've been working with for years and I hope to work with for years and years years to come why is it bad that we found out that we like working together that shouldn't be seen as as a negative um but that's my commentary what is the rule the rule is uh if if the the the more permanent the relationship uh seems and feels and and reads and so on uh the more likely it is to be seen as anlo an indication of employment yeah I think what they're trying to bounce this up against is I always use like the plumber is the classic independent contractor example a plumber is working on a kind of a project by project basis there is no permanence usually to the relationship that that plumber has with his or her clients so that's you know that's kind of on the one side of the spectrum versus the other where it's a a potentially an owner operator that has leased onto this carrier for 40 years and hasn't done any other kind of Project based stuff for other motor carriers so that's kind of what they're what they're weighing with that particular Factor all right uh fourth Factor here is the nature and degree of control this is kind of the classic Direction and control type deal yep uh and this is uh every test in the country uh is going to have some version of this factor involved uh so this is how much control does the independent contractor have over their dayto day their week to week and their month-to month do they have the freedom to to accept and reject Freight do they have the freedom to negotiate any rates uh I think the the definition of negotiate is a little bit flexible but but but do they have any say in what their rates are do they have the ability to hire and and fire their own personnel there would always be a safety qualification component to them bringing on another D another driver but within uh the trucking company qualifying them can the the the the contractor hire and fire Personnel uh can the contractor do they have freedom to wear what they want to wear or do they have to wear a uniform uh what flexibility do they have over the way they manage their business on a day-to-day basis um this is a whole another test within a test essentially yes it is yes it is uh and the one of the biggest challenges that the trucking industry runs into here is uh I would say three things first is we already mentioned it the Department of Transportation has a Federal Regulation that says that the truck has to be exclusively leased to a trucking company and there are certain regulations that everybody has to follow if you're driving a truck no matter whether you're an independent contractor or an employee so there's now our our our counter to that would always be yes there is language there number one the dot has inserted language within that same regulation that says that's not intended to affect the driver's independent contractor status number two that there even though the vehicle has to be exclusively leased to a particular carrier the point of that is to essentially via legal fiction transfer Highway accident liability onto the motor carrier that's going to be in a better position to answer to the public for any damages caused by that driver that's the point of that exclusivity language um but there are still ways that a driver who is exclusively leased to a particular Motor Carrier can go and work for other motor carriers at the same time via subleases VIA uh doing work that doesn't require operating Authority stuff like that so that was always our counter to that argument that hey the contract itself says that this is an exclusive uh relationship yeah not really when you really dig into it yep you're you're exactly right that's the reason is is all to do with that legal fiction of Motor Vehicle acccident liability and and I would one of the counters I always make in that argument Brandon is the driver does not have to be exclusive the driver can do a variety of different things it's the truck that has to be exclusive uh and it's just for that legal liability purposes one good thing that came in the final rule in the proposed rule there was no talk of um well if the if the if the law says I have to comply with this that shouldn't be controlled yeah the luckily uh good thing the the final rule does admit that if some government agency is telling me I have to do this that can't be considered control on my part so that's a good thing I can't even get in my mind how they were thinking of of saying otherwise than that how can you even start to think hey if that's a government rule but I'm a motor carrier that's passing that government rule down I'm saying hey contractor we expect you to comply with the hours of service rule how could that even be in any realm of reasonableness considered employer type control over that that is clearly the government saying that these drivers have to do something so yeah I mean obviously good development but I just can't even I can't even fathom that they were thinking otherwise yeah there there's some logic in here that that really strains the brain there there's no doubt about that um what about what about customer requirements because I remember you know again dabbling in this over the years we would always argue on the one hand that any government related requirements are government control they're not employer type control and then a related argument we would always make is that some of these other requirements that we motor carriers push down on our drivers the Genesis of those requirements are our customers pushing those down to us and then we put pass them along to the contractors and it's kind of a customer relationship thing and I think we had gotten some agencies and some courts to kind of buy into that that those are customer requirements they're not our employer type control does the final rule have anything to say about that or not uh yes and all of what you said is is exactly correct because that is that has been an argument that we as an industry of made and you're right we have made inroads in some courts and in some agencies and so on this agency with this rule no we did not make inroads uh they they expressly uh state that control for other purposes whether customer service requirements or just safety uh they those are not okay uh they would be considered uh evidence of control back to your comment it's always a totality of the circumstances just because you exercise control in one spot doesn't mean you automatically lose this is all totality of the circumstances because a big Challenge and this is where our worlds converge uh Brandon is motor vehicle accidents and safety and so on the the Department of Labor is saying if you carrier are exercising control to uh to comply with a regulation or a law or whatever that's okay that's not control but if you are going above and beyond that which I think you and and I would probably Echo similar Sentiments of the law is the minimum but you should go above and beyond when it comes to accident prevention and so on the Department of Labor is saying hey that's control uh so we didn't get everything we wanted because again I think I think you and I would be similar in the sense of we want to prevent accidents it's one of the most frustrating one of the most frustrating things in my practice over the last 15 years has been that tension that exists between contractor status on the one hand maintaining contractor status on the one one hand and minimizing highway accidents on the other hand you want to do everything you can on the one hand to prevent accidents and that necessarily for an independent contractor Fleet that necessarily involves some control over those independent contractors uh operations being able to tell them when they screw up that you screwed up and there's going to be consequences for your screw up we're going to not give you loads or something like that but the more you do that the more you take steps to try and minimize highway accidents if you're a contractor Fleet the greater risk you have then on the independent contractor reclassification front because of it so there's always that tension and it like I said it's frustrating so and and my coaching point maybe I shouldn't be say saying this here uh to to the public without getting a check from the public but but but something I would say to to clients is always remember what it is you're wanting from the independent contractor you want from that independent contractor that person to provide a truck that meets your standards that Pro and then you want them to provide a driver that meets your standards and you want them to ensure that Freight gets delivered safely legally on time with professionalism so on in my experience the trucking company doesn't really care if Joe or suie is the one delivering it they just care that Joe or suszie is safe and legal and professional and and all that good stuff so I would say Trucking Company you f from a safety and accident prevention you focus on who is driving the truck if the person driving the truck is not meeting your standards then you have a conversation with that driver about qualific disqualification if that driver is an independent contractor then there is a discussion with independent contractor okay Joe you're not meeting our standards as as your own driver do you have someone else that can drive your truck because there's no issue with your truck truck's fine yeah but do you have someone else that can drive yeah um all right so that is nature and degree of control we've got two more here extent to which the work performed is an integral part of the potential employer business another big one this yes this is a big one this one is close to the B factor in the ABC test uh the the the big test that that uh we don't like as an industry uh is the ABC test out of California and it's really that b prong that talks about uh are you and the worker in the same line of business and again let's let's pretend for a moment that none of us know anything about Trucking and and if you're if the person making the decision about independent contractors says this person is a truck driver and this is a trucking company how are they not integral to one another that's what this argument is getting at and so what's what's critical to do is to remember and focus on as a trucking company you are in the business of finding Freight and billing for Freight and dispatching Freight and soliciting uh and and keeping up with compliance and so forth you are not in the business of managing equipment and managing the driver and uh and and so on that's what the independent contractor's business is uh so here you want to separate the focus of your business I'm not gonna sugarcoat this one this is a hard factor for Trucking to meet it it always sounded like a a good argument when you're making it that uh because we would always argue something similar we would say hey the these these contractors they're in the business of providing capacity truck capacity to the carriers to whom they lease their equipment and and then the trucking companies are kind of more of a logistics type thing like you said getting uh you know the contracts with the customers and and that type of deal and like I said it always sounded great on paper very rarely in my experience off uh convinced anybody y similar similar experience all right so last one here skill and initiative yeah so the great thing here a great uh positive that happened in the final rule is the the industry did or the excuse me the the department of later did acknowledge that being a truck driver uh being an owner operator is a skill uh so so that was good that that that was a good development and so what what the indust what the Department of Labor is looking for here is not only does the person have skill and and it's really less important about um oh this person is an artisan uh that has a skill set that very few people can do it's really not about that kind of skill it's more about business management skills and business initiative skills do they have it and do they use it uh it's one it doesn't really matter that much if they have it in their head but they don't ever do anything with it what matters is again can you prove that this person made decisions to add trucks add drivers uh negotiate r R switch to more profitable Lanes within your operation whatever the case of is do they make those business decisions yeah all right so that's the six factors um I've got a few questions here we're running out of time but I want to hit on these I think these can go pretty quick what's uh when does this final rule take effect March 11th of 2024 so not a lot of time before it goes effective um my read of the regulation is the Department of Labor was not a friendly agency before this this final rule it Remains Not a friendly agency after this rule uh I don't read anything in there is you need to change your business because something is new in this rule if it it's it's still bad guess that's my my point but technically speaking it goes into a fact on March 11th all right well you answered a couple of my questions there my last one is do you think this rule is going to be challenged uh if you had to uh kind of look in the crystal ball here and uh and and what kind of form would that take and is it going to have any potential of delaying the implementation of the rule what are your thoughts on this 100% this will be suit that there will be litigation over this and whether or not it's enforceable and all that kind of stuff no doubt about it I'm sure there are people working on the paperwork right now um so there will be litigation um and no one can give you a great prognostication as to to whether or not uh those efforts will be successful um I would say is uh like companies did when during all the ab5 uh litigation prepare for this to be the rule if we get pleasantly surprised that it gets kicked out someday great um but we need to prepare that this will be the rule but I would be remiss if I didn't kind of conclude here by saying that it seems like and correct me if I'm wrong you're out outlook on this one is not nearly as Doom and Gloom as when weal when we had you on earlier to talk about California's ab5 is that is that about right yeah the California ab5 is definitely the far worse rule than this economic realities test and and the expansion of ab5 um which this isn't an episode about ab5 a ab5 is is is is tailored to go after Trucking they can say all they want otherwise it's tailored to go after Trucking all right well hey Doug really appreciate you joining me that went very quickly uh if people have any questions for you or want to uh get your take on how this might impact their uh their fleets how can they get in touch with you yeah uh happy to help them however I can they can reach out the Grog group.com uh doug. grthe group.com awesome appreciate it Doug we'll talk to you later uh let's go wrap up the show everybody thanks for joining us thanks for spending some time with us here um like I said stay tuned for announcements about future shows uh you can check out past episodes and also kind of keep up to date on future shows over at trucksafe live.com uh if you haven't checked out our online courses be sure to do so trucksafe academy.com we have all kinds of courses uh devoted to safety managers and drivers all about DOT compliance so check those out over at trucksafe academy.com uh it's all I got we'll talk to you guys next time

Event Completed

Wednesday, January 17, 2024 at 5:48 PM EST

Watch on YouTube