Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 36 - Continuing education for fleet safety teams

Tuesday, April 2, 2024 at 4:22 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 36 - Continuing education for fleet safety teams

About This Event

In this episode, the Trucksafe team discusses the importance of continuing education for fleet safety professionals and where they can best get it. We’ll also discuss Trucksafe’s own upcoming Fleet Compliance Bootcamp and how we’re helping equip fleet safety teams with cutting-edge regulatory and safety training.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 36 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by colleagues Brian Runnels and Jerad Childress to discuss continuing education for fleet safety teams, a topic they frame as increasingly urgent given the complexity and constant evolution of DOT regulations. The conversation is timely, coinciding with conference season and a broader industry push for more rigorous compliance standards. Throughout the episode, the hosts weave in several related regulatory topics before arriving at their central theme, giving listeners a well-rounded look at the current compliance landscape. Before diving into continuing education, the hosts cover several notable industry developments. They recap recent attendance at the Mid-America Trucking Show (MATS) and the Truckload Carriers Association (TCA) annual meeting, noting that FMCSA's presentations focused heavily on the login.gov rollout and fraud issues like double brokering. The hosts also discuss the DOT road test regulation, emphasizing that while not overly complex, carriers must be deliberate about whether to use available exemptions — such as the CDL exemption or a prior road test certificate — and should have a written policy either way. A sobering segment covers a fatal Texas crash in which a CMV driver admitted to cocaine use the morning of the collision and had three prior Clearinghouse violations, prompting discussion about the risks carriers assume when hiring drivers with past drug and alcohol testing violations. The hosts also flag a growing problem with FMCSA's mass removal of approximately 40,000 medical examiners from the National Registry, which has left thousands of drivers in limbo and created potential compliance exposure for motor carriers who may unknowingly be relying on medical cards certified by examiners who are no longer listed. On the main topic of continuing education, the hosts argue that the need extends well beyond safety directors to include operations staff, dispatchers, maintenance personnel, and risk managers — groups that are frequently overlooked. They stress that even a basic familiarity with regulations across departments can help employees "issue spot" problems before they escalate. The hosts draw a parallel to mandatory continuing legal education requirements for attorneys, noting that while no formal mandate exists for fleet safety professionals, a reasonable goal would be attending at least one industry conference per year and engaging with peer networks on a regular basis. Brian Runnels highlights the value of cross-departmental meetings between safety, risk, and maintenance teams, describing how one carrier's quarterly internal meetings produced significant compliance improvements simply by getting those groups talking to one another. In terms of actionable resources, the hosts point to several free and low-cost options. These include Federal Register notifications, studies published by the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), and the free Trucksafe Fleet Compliance Network, which brings together roughly 1,000 safety professionals from fleets of all sizes to share information and ask questions. For those seeking more structured education, the hosts highlight Trucksafe's upcoming Fleet Compliance Boot Camp on September 25th and 26th in Indianapolis — a two-day, in-person event focused exclusively on DOT safety regulations in an interactive, question-driven format. Brian also mentions NAPARS, a reconstruction and claims management resource available for $60 per year, as a valuable tool for professionals involved in claims. The episode's overarching message is that continuing education for fleet safety teams should be treated as an ongoing operational priority rather than a periodic checkbox. As Rob Carpenter notes, carriers that handle compliance best tend to be the ones who ensure that anyone touching the driver relationship — from dispatch to maintenance — has at least a foundational understanding of the regulatory environment. The hosts encourage safety professionals to be proactive about seeking out training, leveraging free resources, and building peer networks, rather than waiting for a compliance failure or a catastrophic accident to prompt a closer look at their team's knowledge gaps.

Full Transcript

n yeah yeah he yeah call me the Joker call me theol when calls I always lose my baby I'm and you know that you a train got no class all attributes don't know if I'm talking about me and you baby no one get me like you do I you hey everyone welcome to episode 36 of truck safe live the show where we our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon truck safe children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs glad I remembered all that it's been a while it's been a while since you've had to say all that yeah we're back uh took a little bit of a Hiatus there um uh for a couple of months spent some time redoing all of our online courses which was a bigger lift than I anticipated it being but well they just leave stuff alone you wouldn't have to go in there and change that's true that's true but glad that was done but here we are back in uh back in the studio here I got Brian rynolds with us our friend Brian thanks for being here absolutely got Jared up there and then we've got Rob got a full house today so uh excited to be here with everybody uh if you're tuned in with us say hey in the comments so we know everybody that's here and as always as we go along if you have any thoughts or comments on what we're talking about throw them in the comments and we'll bring them up on screen as long as you're not cussing at us or something like that um but anyway today's topic is continuing education for Fleet Safety professionals it's a topic that uh seemed pretty timely now kind of in conference season um a lot of folks going to different industry events a lot of educational sessions throughout those types of events so I thought it would be a and it's a question that we get I know pretty frequently from our Motor Carrier clients all about hey where can we send our safety team so that they can get caught up with what's going on in the industry and some of the changes from a regulatory perspective so that's what we're talking about today before we get to that we've got a few other things let's see let's see who's here with us we've got some comments already Lewis is here can't see his comment let's fix it here Wayne yeah Wayne Andrews oh Wayne does it say Lewis hold on lisis I'm gonna fix your comment here so we can actually read it okay there we go Lewis Wayne what's up Marvin Johnson associate safety rep hey thanks for being here with us sorry that was anticlimactic um the payoff was real low that we're glad you're here but sorry I made it made it not seem like it um anyway a few other things going on before we get to the main topic um first up uh things going on at trucks actually I should say first off thanks to our sponsor of this show which is taking the higher Road a legacy Builders and Freight waves production uh taking the higher road is a special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and compliance each week host Jeremy rer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast thanks to taking the higher Road for sponsoring this episode all right some things going on at truck safe uh like I said took a little bit of a a break there but we've got a ton of stuff in store and so first up first thing I want to mention is our upcoming Fleet compliance boot camp this one always seems to get quite a bit of Interest a lot of folks asking when our next one is going to be here it is September 25th and 26th in Indianapolis Indiana uh boot camp presented by USI thanks to USI for sponsoring this one uh this is our two-day in-person conference where we talk about pretty much nothing but dot safety regulations it's a riveting event it is but you know in the the events that we we have done on those we haven't had anybody jump out of the building or so you know enough yeah right it could have happened afterwards um yeah so we get a lot of good feedback from it um so far uh it's a great place to network with other uh like-minded folks folks that are in a um safety and compliance position we also have a lot of insurance folks there risk advisors that type of thing we we try and keep the group pretty small I think um last one we had about 70 people there and this one will be open up to a similar number of of folks and uh yeah just two days worth of in-depth dot discussion and that's really what it is we trying to keep it pretty informal so folks can ask questions it's not just us up there you know talking the whole time um the the the hope is that people will bring their questions and we'll have a dialogue about these types of issues because they can be pretty nuanced in some situations you know I so so often people have the yah but and well what if and and things like that and if you're just reading a regulation or you're just taking some sort of online training you don't get the opportunity to say okay well what happens if yeah so and you know we we address that throughout the day yeah what if I'm a Hazmat hauler how do these regulations play into my operations or if I'm a passenger carrier those types of things and I think we get a lot probably more value out of the answering of the questions than we do of our caned speeches so I'm looking forward to that if you're interested in joining us for that um we actually have early bird ing which is ending here soon it ends on a April 15th so if you want to save 100 bucks on registration be sure to get your registration in before April 15th you can do that over at trucksafe bootcamp.com that is where you will find details and where you can register yourself uh guys you looking forward to boot camp Jared and and Rob will be there as well yeah I'm excited this will be our third one um they're getting better and better I feel like um the content's getting better uh the Third will be the the best one yet got a nice reception plan too that'll be fun something to look forward to third times a charm indeed indeed hopefully some pessimism in there somewhere um no I liked it I I think it's great from a practical perspective too I mean it's not all about just reading from a rag book so I think it's good for a lot of different reasons yeah yeah looking forward to it Matt here's calling me the wise man it's uh yeah that's a stretch it's a stretch we have a hard enough time getting him through a doorway now just matter if his head swells yeah what are you saying Brian that you have a hard time getting me through a doorway what exactly you trying to say I'm just going to stick with the yeah my name's always I'm always a popular character around Christmas time um so anyway uh okay so that's the boot camp um what else we got so truck safe manag Services Rob I'm going to let you talk about this one this is something we launched not too long ago we're really excited about this is a new service that we're offering it's called truck safe manag Services take away Rob yeah so our our ultimate goal is to help companies manage their practical day-to-day uh DOT compliance risk programs driver screening Etc so the uh obviously there's a saturated Market of these things out there but I think we bring some some different elements to the table not only from a legal perspective with um and Jared but from a practical perspective with with uh Brian and I and some other helpers that we have in behind the scenes so um yeah if uh if you need manage services we're we're here for you helping you keep track of your driver files your expiration dates your vehicle files drug and alcohol testing all that type of stuff uh check it out over at trucksafe manage.com reach out to Rob if you have any questions we'd love to talk to you about it um last thing I will mention in terms of truck safe is our Fleet compliance network uh join that if you haven't it's free to join over at trucksafe network.com we've also got an iPhone and an Android app which you can find in the respective app stores or you could scan that QR code that's on the screen right now um we've got a lot in store for the network this is the place where uh we've got I don't know about a thousand folks in the network now Safety Professional Forum style Town Hall type deal then it's also where we deliver a lot of our content so we've actually got um a pretty cool thing in store for network members coming up it's going to be a a webinar series that I think a lot of folks are going to be interested in so join that if you haven't already again that's trucksafe network.com all right enough about us uh let's talk about some things going on in the industry first thing I wanted to talk about this kind of goes hand inand with our topic today which again is continuing education for Fleet safety teams um are some of the recent conferences that are going on that both Rob and um Brian have attended uh namely Matt's Min America truck show and TCA truckload carrier association annual meeting so just wanted to get your feedback on on how those things went Brian I know you spoke at Matt's how'd that go it went great I had about 50 people in the room uh so that's a that's a great turnout at at an event like that you know that one's really aimed more towards the driver the owner operator the small Fleet operator um a lot of vendors to to see a lot of different products and and services to check out uh I was able to to speak on vehicle maintenance requirements uh during an audit so there was uh got some good feedback on that a lot of people wanted the slides and the some of the information I had in there but yeah that's a great show that's a big one it it it take you all day plus to to get around that one it's in Louisville right yeah that one at the Kentucky Exposition Center uh every year so it's usually the last the last weekend of March is typically when they do that and Brian how many of the giant wagons did you see rolling around collecting all the swag the swag wagons well you know I I T I stayed there on Saturday in a past life when I was recruiting um or part of the recruiting team down there for a trucking company and yes Saturday is a is an interesting day it's you know people just loading up on the on the Trinkets and stuff like that time it's fun to see Jared and I were there it was funny just watching they would bring their wagon pull it up next to a vendor and just take armfuls wipe them out how many Koozies do you need yeah Koozies and pins and cheap pins yeah oh man rob you went to mats as well too what was your experience I didn't think the the uh swag grabbing really got bad until Fridays Thursday was pretty uh pretty normal but after that it kind of got crazy and um no I thought mattz was good well they were both good I liked Matts better than I like TCA uh but you know they're both good so did you uh did you stay for the whole thing at mats did you go to all the I didn't stay Saturday uh because I was trying to get to TCA TCA I just drove uh Friday night and got got back to TCA so did either of you guys I think FMCSA was speaking at Matts did either of you guys go to the FMCSA session yeah I did I sat in on that and theirs was really really heavily based on the cyber security that they're putting it that they' put in place the login.gov yeah the login.gov and um probably because it was a disaster roll out is probably why they're talking about yeah there there was quite a few questions and there somebody I I caught I couldn't catch everything that she was saying but um there was one person in there that was really really hot about something to do with that ended up walking out but you know they were I think they talked to her after the fact and hopefully got things smoothed over sure they did yeah they um that was the main part of their talk that I saw her name was Karen right it could have been okay sorry if that was you they had a lot you say that one for uh you know different things and I think the one that you're probably talking about Brian at towards the end I think they really were trying to push more into like the um the fraud piece especially you know double brokering issues and basically the FMCSA said we we don't regulate that so we we can't help you basically but we can talk afterwards and we obviously we were part conversation but um and she was also Eastern European so um was a little confused but that was her question so anyway Wayne says there were some off-road lifted wagons that doesn't surprise me yeah I believe yeah as much as they weigh those things down they got to put some extra suspension under there oh man did you guys see any new sexy trucks I know Volvo has a new truck that they've launched anybody else present a new truck old school or new school ones at Matt but the new one uh TCA only had the Volvos you know it's interesting that I think some of the oems have backed away from doing a lot of these shows because it mats I don't remember seeing if Freightliner was there I don't remember seeing International um I don't REM packar was there really but I don't think they had a Peter belt there I think it was just a k the new Kenworth that they were showing yeah so they had a uh Rotator truck I don't remember who that was it was that was Kenworth I I think yeah I think you're right yeah rob you had posted some pictures of some pretty cool looking old school trucks yeah they had some great ones there there's a um I think uh I don't know who ultimately won the build the bu the custom build competition at Matts but the guy I was talking I don't know probably an hour and a half with he married the guy who own he married not the guy that owned the truck he married his daughter um but anyway they uh I think they had like 600,000 in this truck and at the Afterparty that I missed Thursday night um he outlined you know highlighted his uh he has speakers that run along the rails inside the the bed of the the trailer and uh I thought that pretty neat but they spent a fortune on these things so it was good to see them get something out of it yeah that's cool all right well that's Matts and TCA well TCA any other noteworthy thing coming out of the TCA Rob any particular sessions you found insightful no Sue Lawless um I was sitting down did she speak at that too yeah I actually was doing some work and I had I had not met her before and I was sitting down at a table by myself and then some lady walks up and says can I sitp down here and then before you know it I realize I'm sitting here talking to sue Lawless for 45 minutes before she's the new interim FMCSA administrator for those not she's a great lady I mean she's really down to earth if you actually sit down and talk to her she's yeah Jared and I worked with Sue quite a bit she used to be um she used to be she's an attorney she used to be in the fmcsa's office I think office of administrative hearings or something like that so every time we would file an appeal on behalf of one of our clients usually it would be Sue who would be intaking that and yeah she was always great to work with so I'm glad to see her in that position now um hopefully hopefully it'll she'll be there for a while I I fear that with the this being an election year that um we may be seeing some other shakeups here pretty soon but I guess we'll just have to wait and see on that yeah I wonder if that'll delay all the changes that they're implementing I if they're going to get pushed even farther out I worry about it because the news I saw come out of I don't remember if it was Matt's or TCA where a lot of the um Publications had kind of published stories on the FMCSA sessions and they noted that there was no talk in any of those sessions about the safety rating rule making that was a big deal last year and that we talked a lot about which which would be a significant rule change if it were to take effect but now they're not even talking about it anymore which makes me think that they may be kicking the can on some of these some of these things so it's it's it's hard to tell especially like I said in an election year what we're going to get maybe they just we see this quite a bit I think every time there's an election year we see them kind of go a little bit quiet right beforehand um and and just waiting to see who's going to be installed in new positions and what their priorities are going to be and stuff like that so um I guess that's what we'll have to look forward to I think the other piece to that too is that you know they're going to hold off on making any of those decisions so they can say after the election whoever's in there see we were able to get this done yeah of course so oh I all right so that's uh Matts and TCA uh the next thing I want to talk about was this was an article that we put out yesterday if you're not subscribed to our newsletter um I recommend you do that we're constantly pushing out um articles on breaking regulatory news and also just kind of do issues we put out one yesterday on do road test and um kind of breaking down what the regulations require this isn't all that of a complex regulation I wouldn't consider it to be but there are some nuances to it and some exemptions from it that we get a lot of questions about uh a lot of carriers uh take advantage of the so-called CDL exemption to the road test requirement and they often want to know whether that's a good idea or not so we tried to break that all down in our our most recent article um but if you want to get those types of uh that type of content delivered right to your mailbox you can do that at trucksafe so I just wanted to get all your takes uh just brief takes on um on DOT road test and whether there are any uh landmines there that carriers need to watch out for I know you had had one to mention Brian yeah the I think in a road test uh you can get a lot of knowledge that's not even based on you know how they perform driving you know is there a flow to their pre-trip you know do they do they do one if you just if they say you know do you tell them hey go do what you normally do and they hop right in the truck um or their their body posture or their uh how how they manage their defensive driving and stuff like that as they're taking the road test I think those are some of the things to look for in addition to how yeah actually physically driving the truck but the pre-trip is the big one if if if they've got a good pattern to it it's muscle memory no matter what truck it is they they know what they're looking for if they're just kind of Here There and Everywhere You know it's a good training opportunity if the if the driver is a good driver it's an opportunity to to do some training with them but you know if they don't do that well and then they don't drive well yeah there's some red flags there Jared Rob any thoughts yeah I think yeah as you mentioned Brandon I mean it's not a real complex topic to to master however there are those exemptions that you can take advantage of you know if the driver took a um a driving portion to get their CDL you can use a copy of their CDL or if they've completed a road test with a prior motor carrier in the past three years you can use that certificate of road test uh the question is should you do those two things that's where it gets a little complicated and more of a business question to to mitigate risk right because you know driver qualification often comes down to one of the biggest issues in a crash you know every single document related to that driver is going to be poured over and if you have a policy to not road test if you're going to use one of those exemptions that needs to be put in writing most likely that if we have a driver that we can use their CDL if we can use a prior uh road test from another motor carrier that's what we do um and and have that as a policy don't just do half here there that that's that's problematic to me so that's the biggest issue with that article and you point that out in the article yeah I would say that's probably the most common question we get about road tests is whether a carrier should take advantage of those exemptions or not I would say it's probably split pretty evenly half and half in terms of our clients that take advantage of that and those that voluntarily choose not to I I see the arguments on both sides of it on the one hand if you take advantage of it it helps to speed through the driver qualification process particularly through like Acquisitions if you're acquiring a big Fleet of hundreds or thousands of drivers the prospect of having to road test all of that big chunk of drivers all at once is pretty um is pretty scary um and timec consuming so to be able to take advantage of that in that situation helps out a lot but on the other side of things like you said Jared are we really comfortable that just because the driver holds a CDL and has ostensibly passed a skills test to the satisfaction of the state that they are in fact a safe driver I I don't know um some carriers say that that they're not comfortable with that so I see it on both sides you're just like Jared said you're going to have to make a decision that works for your Fleet and uh and go with it another another aspect that complicates things is is if you have different configurations in your Fleet or specialized Vehicles then it's much more of a good idea to do the road test you know for every single driver that comes through um just because that specialized equipment obviously is not going to be tested by the state drivers's licensing agency so um doing that a good it's one we probably should have raised in the article but the regulation says that technically if you are bringing on board a driver who was Road tested in a different type of commercial motor vehicle than the one you're expecting him to operate then you can't take advantage of that exemption they have to be Road tested in the type of vehicle that you are expecting them to operate so if you've got straight trucks and you've got combination units and this particular driver is going to be expected to operate both of those types of trucks for you then the regulation requires you to do two road tests essentially one in the straight truck one in the combination unit that's a Miss I think we find occasionally in carriers DQ files is they're not doing the road test in the equipment that is is like the type that the driver is expected to operate in a couple things that go ahead Rob no the only thing I was going to add is that you know outside of what everyone else said which which is all you know logical they um I was always surprised when I really got into claims and Brian you probably have experienced this in the insurance side as well but when I got into managing claims and doing a lot more depositions um especially working with with carriers that I was managing I was always surprised at how many of these things actually go to the road the road test and how many PL if attorneys actually go directly to the training that they received where they tested for proficiency why did you not sign this form why did you not enter the mileage for the road test um it's a whole slew of things I've seen but it's a big point that these plaintiff attorneys focus on whenever you have these claims and one of the ones that we did in Georgia ended in like $800,000 um in terms of settlement so um and it was all because of a we couldn't prove that we had trained and Road tested this person so couple things on the the actual road test uh itself when they're deciding to you've decided that you're you're going to do road tests as a uh requirement so two things one don't pencil whip the form you know they're there are simpler road test forms out there that are more Broad in their wording and I think a lot of people have seen that one where there's 800 check marks on this thing and Rob's point every one of those check marks can be brought up uh in a deposition and if you've just or just drawing a line all the way down it yeah I've seen both of those um that that could come back to haunt you the second thing is to have a and it's not a requirement but it's a best practice to have a documented route that you're doing the same route with the same with all drivers all the time uh so there's no possible disc ratory you know he took me a different way because he didn't want me to pass and you know so you just have a doc have a documented route on file yeah yeah that's a good tip yeah in terms of the content of the road test the regulation it's in our article if you go to our website but regulation lifts out I think a dozen or so things that have to be tested in the road test and for sure those are the ones that you would expect to see on the road test form but to your point some of them are very basic and other others of them are very overly complex probably so anyway uh that's road test uh let's see here a couple of other things uh I saw this ccj article come out today I wanted to get you guys' thoughts on it this is about this Texas accident uh I know Rob's posted about it on on LinkedIn uh I'll just read it here the title is truck driver shut down after fatal School Bus Collision FMCSA has effectively shut down a Texas licensed commercial driver and ordered him to immediately cease operating any commercial motor vehicle in Interstate or intrate Commerce on March 22nd he was operating a large concrete pumping truck for a carrier when he crossed the center line and hit an oncoming School Bus transporting pre students as a result of the crash school bus flipped over and a 5-year-old child was killed the 33 year old driver of the car behind the bus was killed and dozens of passengers were injured uh following the crash the driver admitted to the commercial driver admitted to in uh to law enforcement that he had smoked marijuana the night before the crash and had used cocaine in the early morning hours before the crash according to fmcsa's imminent Hazard order in addition to the recent crash the driver had a history of using Controlled Substances while being uh employed as a professional CMV driver um I think it had mentioned in here three times yeah three times in the Clearing House um so that is just a crazy story uh lots to talk about there but um yeah what are your thoughts on it Rob I'll let you start since you kind of posted an article about it no I think it was it was a uh it was a disaster obviously but the um I I think a lot of people that I go to especially on the captive side that aren't true motor carriers and this company only has one driver listed with its business so it's limited um I would say but you know I go to some of these and they're not traditional motor carriers in the sense of over the road or they operate you know big trucks and they don't even know what clearing house is so it's it's a lot of people that also jump um and we had this discussion a couple weeks ago you know you may fail a drug test as a CDL driver and then just go get hired on as a non CDL driver and a lot of companies don't run it based on whether you hold a CDL they run it based on whether you're going to operate CDL equipment so I don't know there's a lot of U misconceptions on these things and I think ultimately some of this could have been prevented but um it's hard for me to you know we don't get to see the driver file of this guy so we don't get to see what everyone else saw when they hired him but it's hard for me to look at it to say I doubt there was a red flag anywhere in that application or driver qualification file that said hey maybe we should dig a little further here and obviously I can't cast blame on the company because I don't know enough about it but it's hard for me to to expect or to believe there wasn't something that would have given you some inclination that something wasn't right yeah this obviously brings to the Forefront the question well to your point Rob first of all we don't even know if the carrier had run a Clearing House query but it brings to the Forefront a question probably one of the more common questions that we get from our clients which is should we continue to engage or hire drivers who have a drug and alcohol testing violation in the past or not um a lot of motor carriers choose not to do that as a matter of company policy which is their prerogative not to hire drivers who have had a previous testing violation others say hey as long as they follow the regulatory process uh the return to duty process they've gone to the sap they've done the uh return to duty test they've done the follow-up test well then they're clear to go so I'm I need drivers and this is a qualified driver under the regulations so I'm going to hire him I think this case brings that issue back to the Forefront and it worries me a little bit for that latter group of carriers because we've always advised carriers that there you have some exposure if you're going to hire these drivers I mean regardless of whether it's legal under the regulations to hire that driver back if that driver then goes and kills somebody like in this worst case scenario here and you knew about his drug or alcohol testing history you're going to have to explain that to a jury in the context of that subsequent litigation and it's just not going to look good for you and so that certainly has to weigh into the equation but the thing that this case brings up that I'm that adds to that concern for me is that the FMCSA is stepping in and saying that this guy's an imminent Hazard based on all of his previous drug and alcohol testing violations the article doesn't get into details of whether he had gone through the return to duty process every time for those prior three violations I assume he had but maybe he hadn't but let's say that he had gone through the required steps to to be qualified to operate but now FMCSA is saying now that he's caused a crash he's an imminent Hazard I just think that that looks bad for any carriers that have it as a policy that we hire these drivers going forward that the FMCSA is weighing in now this is an egregious case obviously with so many violations but FMCSA is weighing in here and saying that these guys are imminent hazards when they have a previous drug and alcohol testing history so that's something to take into consideration I think as well I think there's there's something to be said about that because obviously this guy was still operating trucks until this happened right so how many other people haven't had that crash yet that have the same issues as this driver and it's not going to get discovered until some catastrophe happens and somebody takes a deeper look at it so to some extent there's got there's some hole there that needs to be fixed and you know we had one um at at the Enterprise carrier that I was running one of the do numbers one of the the terminal managers hired this guy even though our policy said we don't do return to duty testing we don't participate in return to duty programs he he did this on his own fruition he hired someone who had had four four he had been to the return to duty process four different times four different prohibited statuses that had now got him to this non-prohibited status because he's been able to do the return to duty process x amount of times and it's like how many times is too many you know how many times for instance it's like if somebody's got a cell phone problem and you coach them 160 times at some point you have to say hey this guy's not coachable we need to take him off the road yeah I don't even know how that works because a lot of times those follow-up testing schedules have like a five-year tail to them yeah so that guy's got been through it four times has he had a fiveyear follow-up testing tail for each of them that's just crazy well before the clearing house that's true really you know got going there was ways to skate around this so we don't know how to your point if it had a five-year tail on it you know this the other three yeah no one no one really ever discovered true uh to your point Rob about closing a gap I think one of the things that will go a long way is actually coming down the pike here in November uh as part of the Clearing House rule uh as of November of 2024 the state driver's licensing agencies are going to have to automatically downgrade a driver's CDL license anytime they are put into prohibited status in the clearing house so the problem that we've had to date for states that don't do that is that a driver could be in prohibited status in the clearing house yet still have a valid CDL and so if he goes to a a carrier like you mentioned Rob that isn't doing the required Clearing House checks just checking his license they're still going to see that he has a valid license but they're not going to know about his drug and alcohol testing history and so maybe they just put him out on the road so this step I think is a necessary one that will um that will hopefully close that Gap to some extent interes you know and looking at this article the thing that pops out to me is it highlights the importance for me of interacting with drivers either through at the dispatcher level or at the driver supervisor level uh granted this is a small carrier so not necessarily the case here but interacting with your drivers that's a chance to take a pulse on that driver because this guy smoked weed the night before and did Coke that morning I mean if you interacted with this guy you'd probably be able to pick up on some signs of impairment that's why with dispatchers a driver supervisors they got to be trained on reasonable suspicions so they can call that out and you can start that Reasonable Suspicion testing process yeah I got to think that carrier is dunzo uh in that litigation so all it takes is one of these accidents with these types of facts to be the end of the line for you so obviously critical IAL things to keep in mind as you're running a fleet let's see here FMC here's a comment FMCSA continues to shorten the process of acquiring a CDL due to the need for drivers but do you think shortening of the process is not is not a safe thing I can't think of anything that has shortened the process off the top of my head um they've added the entry-level driver training requirement which I think probably lengthened the process a little bit it does for the the schools because it it definitely puts in place some training modules that weren't there before oh I think I know what they're talking about there there was a recent rule change it's a proposed rule uh we reported on this a while back but I think they are like shortening the time frame from like there was a certain time frame you had to hold a a CLP before you could you could get a CDL or something to that and I think they shortened that a little bit but it wasn't dramatic as far as I could tell but what are your overall thoughts the the question is uh do you think the CDL process as it stands now is uh affect L weeding out drivers who shouldn't be on the roads not necessarily and it really isn't the the school's job to do that their job is to get them through now where the to me where the fault or where the um most of it lies is on the carriers that hire these drivers after they've come out of the schools that's where the real training happens now you know I've always been against training students as teams and you know there was companies out there that would put two students together after their training process for a period of couple months three months and I've never been a big fan of that it's it to me training drivers is is not a shouldn't be a huge Money Maker really yeah um but you get good drivers at the end of it and more reliable safer drivers so I I think what you're talking about about the the actual CLP process you know that is what it is if they can pass that test because that's what a school's job is is to get drivers to pass the test yeah if they if they do that they've done their job that's so it's it's on the motor carriers after the fact Matt saying accountability ultimately falls on the MC that is correct and LF here is clarifying it was the 14-day CLP rule okay um all right uh let's see here trucker 18wheeler is saying I'm looking to add Hazmat I know where to get the eldt training but I don't know where to get my fingerprint background checked where you get that stuff where did I get um it depends like I I got mine renewed if you have twick you can use your same T your same Homeland Security twick fingerprint screening for your HazMat endorsement um like so in Virginia I don't have to pay for both but um in Virginia you have select areas where you can go to get fingerprint you can't just go to any DMV like the one in Richmond the one in Virginia Beach there's different ones that offer it so you have to go to one that can take your electronic fingerprints um and I'm sure some states probably still do the old ink fingerprint cards but um most places are are in the electronic stage of taking fingerprints at this point yeah I've done both and it seems to me that the the name of the company in Indiana that I used was it's like acue check or something like it's a third party provider that you can go to and it was I I don't remember how much it costs but you can just pay for it to have it done there identigo yes that's ideno I used that for TSA pre-check I think y people anyway man you gotta love Google all right last thing before we get to our main topic uh and for those folks watching this is how we're going to start doing shows going forward we're just going to pick a handful of topics I think each show things that are going on in the industry this keeps me from having to come up with a unique topic every every show which is becoming more and more difficult the the further we get into this but anyway hopefully it's been useful I I think this kind of conversation is is helpful to me at least getting others takes on these common issues uh this last one here I got an email from a truck safe subscriber um this past week that I thought was interesting that I want to get you guys' take on uh she said just read your January 2024 article on this top topic wondering if you've ever had any problems with um medical examiner provider shortages locally or in general have heard any updates on this issue according to the FMCSA they removed 40,000 providers all in one day on February 27th of this year they told me it was mostly those providers who did not log into their account nor complete the required 10-year medical examiner training I was on the removal list and neither of the above applied to me they told me it was because I didn't update my State medical license expiration date from 2023 to 2024 I did that some months ago but they said it likely I did this during some sort of FMCSA quarterly portal update and therefore it didn't take I got no notification within the portal and no email notification of the removal they didn't even notify me that they had removed me until a week later she runs an O occupational Medical practice and in one week we do several CDL exams I only disc it when a local employer caught it it has been a month and all FMCSA can tell me is that I'm in line with 2800 other providers trying to get back on the registry and that they have no anticipated turnaround time they only have four people on staff handling this this lady's Clinic is in a small area with many drivers and the ripple effect that we mentioned in our article is in full swing she has a list of 70 plus drivers waiting for resolution so this was the problem I was concerned about so FM CSA sent out a notice probably in January uh indicating that they were planning to remove I think in the in the notice it was around 50,000 medical examiners from their list of self-certified uh or or certified medical examiners and the rationale for it in the notice was that when they had moved to this login.gov to factor authentication um a lot of the the 50,000 medical examiners hadn't logged into their account and so they had no way to update their records and stuff like that so they're just going to remove them from the registry and the question I posed at the time was well what's that mean for the drivers that have been certified by these particular medical examiners and uh didn't really hear any more from FMCSA or anyone so I just assumed it wasn't a problem but here it turns out it looks like it is a problem um this this particular doctor alone has more than 70 drivers who are awaiting FMCSA to fix the issue get her back on the registry have you guys run into this issue yet with anybody else and what are your thoughts on it no it's a thing the uh the post that I put up yesterday where um the driver you know he he came on with a carrier that I work with and basically said hey I'm good to go and the carrier was hey can we use this but unfortunately that that doctor had no idea that they had been removed from the registry until we caught it on a registry verification and it actually said in there that um you know that it was no longer good but um anyway there's there's been a handful of those that we've gotten I would say in the past two weeks where people have S it and said hey can we still use this and I mean sometimes you can because the date superseded you know preceded the uh the revocation from the from the registry but in some cases you can't some cases yeah because that's the rub right I mean motor carriers have a regulatory obligation to check to make sure that the medical examiner that's listed on any of their drivers medical cards is on the National Registry and if they're not on the National Registry then they cannot use that driver and the whole point of this registry system was to avoid fraud we we were having issues with some drivers putting in fake doctors or some doctors not really being qualified to do these types of exams and so that's the whole point but now if we are if we have removed inadvertently if the FMCSA has inad ently removed legitimate doctors certified doctors from the list that have performed potentially thousands of medical exams do we have thousands of drivers out there operating now on technically invalid Med cards and if we do what are we to do about that because I my mind always goes to litigation again if one of these drivers gets involved in an accident today you better be sure that that driver's qualification file is going to be under the spotlight as Jared mentioned in that litigation and that plaintiff's attorney is going to see if that doctor was on the registry and maybe we're in that Gap period now where that doctor isn't on the registry uh because FMCSA removed him and so do we as motor carriers need to be doing something right now do we need to be we've already done these checks on the drivers that have brought Med cards to us do we need to be going back through our entire roster of drivers and looking at their medic medical exams and see if they've been rendered invalid because of this issue do we I can't remember the National Registry when you look up a a medical provider do they have if they're expired is is there a date that the expiration kicked in where they were actually kicked off the registry so initially no so like you've got the face value uh which is kind of like hey this doctor does or does not accept clients right now patients right now but if you click on that doctor and it opens up the broader full page full profile it'll say it was revoked on like the one I posted on LinkedIn yesterday I think it was revoked on 33 okay she did the physical on 3 so yeah three days after her revocation he got that that provides me a little bit of comfort for motor carriers but at the same time if that driver that was certified by an examiner that's now uh not on the list anymore because they were revoked um that's going to be ammunition for the plaintiff's attorney to say well this medical examiner wasn't even qualified clearly because now they're removed from the list so why else would they be removed from the list unless they were disqualified hey Rob do you have a registry number handy that that I can look up here just do a screen share I'll do a screen share if you read off a number to me I'll look it up yeah hold hold one just so we can see what it looks like here do we know if the State Licensing um departments are involved in this as far as you know if if somebody's been revoked does is the state automatically downgrading the are we seeing I don't think so okay but that's another issue yeah another layer of this isn't working I mean clearly on this the the math works right you've got four employees on this so you're going to revoke 40,000 providers in one day I mean it makes total sense you know you're gonna be able to cover phone calls well I I forget so the notice that FMCSA pushed out listed how many total examiners they have in the registry and it was hundreds of thousands so they were trying to make it look like it wasn't going to be a big deal and so I just took them at their word that this wasn't going to be a problem but it it seems like it may be a problem yeah I've got the you got 5 yeah um 405 4433 this is the one that happened yesterday where we we had a client that came through and said hey um she's not in the registry anymore um um and obviously so click on her name so when you open it up it'll give you her removal date was 33 and this guy had his physical done on 36 so she shouldn't have done the physical but she had no idea and there's no telling how many she's done since 33 he obviously wasn't the only one um but we you know we basically advised that they couldn't use that med card they needed to send him for another one he went and got another one obviously all right so that that could be an issue I don't know that it at this point that it warrants a full particularly for large carriers a full look back at all of your existing Med cards unless you've got a vendor that's doing that on your behalf maybe it'll be worth it but um maybe we just hold off a little bit longer and see if fmcsa's able to get their stuff together here and and fix this issue for you but it could be an issue um all right so then with what time we've got left we want to talk about continuing education we've already talked uh about it in some circumstances namely the boot camp I think um Shameless plug for for what we've got going on that's that's really why we built the boot camp we wanted it to be a a venue for continuing education for Fleet Safety professionals um but with that coming up it brought to mind this topic and so just some some basic questions here your thoughts on um if you're running a fleet you've got a safety team who within that safety team do you think needs continuing education and what are your favorite go-to resources for that type of training if if you think it's necessary we'll just go around TR of course right yeah is that where to go to this is just one big ad for everything we've got going on at truck safe I think anybody that you know is when you're dealing with the compliance side um knowing and refreshing your your memory on all the things that the compliance side entails you know everything from uh the hours of service to the driver qualifications to equipment files um you know unless you're using somebody like a managed services or some sort of program where where they're taking care of that for you uh it's probably a very good idea because if you for if you start forgetting Small Things those can add up to a very large issue and ideally you want to make sure you're refreshing yourself on all those small things so I I think anybody involved in the safety department especially on the compliance side since that's where we're talking you know it needs to be something that's done on a regular basis just like when we train our drivers with Hazmat even if they don't haul hazmat but you're a Hazmat carrier you got to train them and it falls no different for the folks inside I know just from Jared and my perspective as as lawyers we see this in several different industri Industries right as lawyers Jared and I have to get a certain amount of continuing legal education every year what do we have to get Jared like uh it's not very much it's like 30 hours every three years it's like 30 some hours every three years yeah but the point the whole point is you know things change in whatever industry you're involved in particularly heavily regulated Industries like Trucking things are evolving particularly as as Brian said on the compliance side of things and you got to be keeping up to date with those things or you're going to be left in the in the dust um when when those things take effect and so if you're not deliberately getting yourself out there in into some uh venue that is offering training I mean you're just going to run yourself into problems so it makes sense uh to to do that um Jared Rob thoughts on on maybe like uh frequency at which you think Fleet Safety Professional should be doing continuing education because there's no mandate for it right it's not like the rules set out some kind of requirement like they do for lawyers um so what frequency and and where would you recommend folks go to get continuing education in this field well I'll I'll comment in that but first I want to say um who needs it there's a couple of groups that I've consistently seen not getting continuing education in the safety space uh folks that are in Risk and we're talking about larger fleets obviously at this point folks that are in Risk are looking for that information a lot of times and they don't necessarily get training in those areas maintenance is another um place within a motor carrier uh some motor carriers have pretty sophisticated maintenance departments and some of those folks don't get that training which always blows my mind uh so risk and maintenance are two categories of folks at a larger motor carrier that I think should be getting some training that oftentimes don't um and as far as Cadence goes you know I I think you should make it a goal uh talking about safety directors at this point um you should make it a goal to go to one conference and collaborate with other safety directors get some educational content attend uh sessions ask the questions you need to ask uh because you know this kind of Skips to the next topic but resources I mean uh your peers should be some of your biggest resources if you don't have a group of folks that are in similar POS phans uh to ask questions to share information with because safety shouldn't be uh proprietary right we should share practices that are improving safety because that's not business that's just safety so that's what I would say just you know you should strive to attend at least one educational conference uh per year for sure yeah and when it comes to that kind of collaboration among even among different fleets this is going to sound like another plug but this is a free service we offer so I don't feel so bad about about it that that's one of the big reasons we set up the truck safe Network in the first place as a space for safety teams to join together and and learn about things that are going on whether it be from us or from others within the network like I said we've got about a thousand folks in there now from all kinds of fleets big fleets small fleets private fleets For Hire fleets all dealing with issues that are unique there to their operations but may be valuable to you as you infrequently encounter those those types of issues a good example is maybe maybe you're a a long haul Fleet most of your drivers are operating Long Haul but occasionally maybe you have a driver that that needs to operate under the short Hall exemption and it's just something that you're not used to well there are other fleets within the network for example that are using short raw all the time so they know the ins and outs of how that how that exemption works so it's really just a place to to ask those type of types of questions and get some feedback on it but again Network's not the only place as Jared said conferences have historically been the way that I've done this I know you guys are are pretty active in in going to Industry conferences uh whether it be ATA conferences or TCA or local trucking associations are another big one uh a lot of value there in in the networking alone not to mention the sessions that they put on and I've generally found a lot of those sessions to be pretty good in terms of keeping you up to date on the things that that are important so yeah and and if you're a A specialized carrier if you're flatbed if you're a car hauler if you're driveway toe away you go to a conference just pull up the list of attendees find other car haulers find other flatbed carriers and find those people talk to them um it's it's pretty easy to do and most people are really willing to talk about these sorts of things one good thing is the app I mean you you touched on it when we first got on this call but I know that when I first how I first saw the app was Brian was commenting on someone else's question inside the truck Safe app they had a total safety related question and she and Brian went back and forth for some time on it was basically just free information just by being in that network of of other people inside the truck Safe app but um from my perspective with if you're with Nat me for instance and you're a CDs or a cdme or a CDT you have to have so many credits every three years to get renewed or you won't get renewed so um I think there's just 30 30 credits and they they break it apart in different ways how you can get those credits one of them is conferences so if you go to a conference it'll give you x amount of points for that for that renewal but um I think it depends on what your position is it's kind of what Jared was saying if you're if you're a safety director there's so many things that you have to be fluent in and um you know one of the things that I was was back and forth earlier on LinkedIn was um accident reconstruction I have no business in accident reconstruction I make no money in accident reconstruction but I started doing accident reconstruction stuff because I was working claims and where you going to learn more about claims management and how it unfolds and how it happened than in reconstruction so there's all different kinds of elements that you can kind of take in at different places whether it's IPM or Northwestern or um even truck safes programs that are online I mean you're you're going to pick up information that's that's valuable for your everyday practical purposes well I think you also add in there are so many companies of a smaller size that do safety by committee um and they've got their operations folks and in there and you know it doesn't necess they don't necessarily need to know all of the compliance things but the things that like the hours of service okay they need to they need to know it and understand it so you can kind of cherry-pick different pieces of it to to get to the people that really need it yeah we would call this like the ability to issue spot on the legal side of things it was always valuable as a Young attorney to even if you weren't proficient in one area of the law if you at least knew enough to be able to spot that there's an issue there that I need to get to somebody who knows that particular area of the law that was very valuable I think it applies equally in this context if I if I'm a a mechanic for a fleet uh it would be valuable to me to know at least a little bit about how the hours of service regulations work May maybe just so that maybe if you encounter this probably a bad example but maybe you encounter something um maybe you're looking in the truck and you see that there's a something wrong with the ELD or something knowing just enough about the hours of service rules may be able to key you in to spot a particular issue that you should raise to somebody else before it balloons into a big ISS a big problem for you yeah this this brings up um a story from we were doing a mock audit with carrier once and we got risk maintenance and safety in the same room to meet about one issue right and then this sharing of information started happening and it's never happened before with this group obviously and all these compliance aspects starts pouring out and so now this particular carrier has a a quarterly meeting with risk maintenance and safety where they go over issues that are spilling over into each other's space that that kind of coordination is what you have to do not only externally but internally too inside the carrier you need to be doing that yeah I think your operations folks are the prime example of folks who need to have some basic understanding of the regulations and so I know this is getting a little off topic but because it's not really continuing education it's education in the first instance but I The Fleets that seem to have compliance the best under control I feel like they get anybody who is tangentially involved in dealing with drivers dispatchers operations folks they give them some basic education on the regulations so they know the environment within which they are expecting the drivers to operate and then they can raise these issues that that come up well that just actually intensifies the continuing education because you know they're doing their their dispatch or their operations job the whole time they're there that like you said the safety stuff comes up here or there so it does need to be on a reinforcement Cadence right that you know keeps it fresh right and it doesn't have to be all that involved I mean like we were talking for the CDs would you say 30 30 points or 30 hours roughly equivalent to what Jared and I are doing on the legal side of things 30 hours every 3 years we're not talking about a t a huge time commitment here a couple hours uh you know every couple of months just bringing yourself and the other thing is you can get a lot of this stuff for free I mean there's no shortage of free webinars that are going on if you if you're on social media LinkedIn or whatever and you follow kind of the trucking Publications and stuff like that there's probably a webinar going on every week about ongoing compliance topics and and other things that you could pop on to for free and and bring yourself quickly up to speed so uh lots of resources that's for sure um all right guys any last thoughts here before we close it down for the day I think continuing to train your train your folks we we always stress hey train your drivers but don't forget to train your office staff your management your maintenance folks um you know I I have a definite passion on that that vehicle maintenance side I I get to do that at boot camp and do the other presentations about vehicle maintenance and you know it's there's a lot to be left to be desired a lot of times in in that so getting that training out to those folks and and have it be a a normal or a common thing is super important for sure yeah join us at the boot camp 25th 26 on the resource side uh register to get emails on the Federal Register notifications that's a huge resource to to just stay in touch with what's going on with the agency and then the other thing free resource that I would mention is atry American Transportation Research Institute I mean those studies are fantastic really drop some knowledge on you those are the free resources that I'd throw out there Rob anything else free no there's a lot of free ones out there like like they said but um you know the the one I was posting about earlier was Nappers it's $60 a year and you get about 40 years worth of content that that the Reconstructionist Community is kind of put together if you're in claims management so for $60 a year um it's it's well worth it nice all right guys well that's going to wrap it up for today appreciate everybody joining us um stay tuned for announcements for our next shows uh like I said early on in the show we've got lots of content in store not just through trucks they fly podcast but also uh an in-depth webinar series uh we'll announce that here in the coming weeks uh it's going to be a seven part webinar series that I think uh folks are going to get a lot of value out of so stay tuned for that best place to keep on top of things we've got going on at trucksafe is through our newsletter trucksafe docomo uh and then don't forget about the boot camp this is the last week to save 100 bucks on registration if you want to join us in Indianapolis uh September 25th and 26th go over to truck safy bootcamp.com that's where you'll find the details and you'll be able to register uh that's all I got thanks everybody we'll talk to you soon thank you see you see you guys

Event Completed

Tuesday, April 2, 2024 at 4:22 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube