Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep 39 - Carrier safety ratings

Tuesday, June 18, 2024 at 3:25 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep  39 - Carrier safety ratings

About This Event

In this episode of Trucksafe LIVE!, we’re discussing motor carrier safety fitness determinations (aka safety ratings), their importance, and how they may be radically changing if the FMCSA proceeds with its current rulemaking on the topic. ************************************************ For more in-depth DOT safety regulation training, check out our comprehensive and innovative online DOT compliance courses: https://www.trucksafeacademy.com Follow us for the latest highway transportation news & analysis: Twitter: https://twitter.com/TrucksafeLLC LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/trucksafeconsulting/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TrucksafeConsulting YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@Trucksafe Join the Trucksafe Compliance Network to access free DOT compliance content and network with other fleet safety professionals: https://www.trucksafenetwork.com Trucksafe Consulting, LLC is a full-service transportation safety consulting firm, offering one-on-one consulting services as well as industry-leading training resources and compliance forms. Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress, Trucksafe's owners, are transportation attorneys who, prior to starting Trucksafe, worked with the nation's largest transportation law firm, counseling the nation's largest and most sophisticated motor carriers on USDOT safety regulations. They now focus their efforts on helping carriers develop and foster state-of-the-art safety programs. For help managing your DOT policies and procedures, mock DOT audits, safety rating upgrades, DataQs appeals, and much more, contact us through our website: https://www.trucksafe.com

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 39 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter of Trucksafe Consulting tackle the topic of carrier safety ratings, a critically important and potentially evolving area of trucking compliance. The episode is prompted by FMCSA's Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) on Safety Fitness Determinations, along with upcoming public listening sessions where carriers and industry stakeholders can weigh in on possible changes to the rating system. The hosts frame safety ratings as a motor carrier's "regulatory lifeblood," noting that a carrier's rating directly determines whether it can legally operate, and whether shippers, brokers, and insurers will do business with it. Before diving into the main topic, the hosts cover two notable industry developments. First, they flag that FMCSA is proposing a 25% increase in Unified Carrier Registration (UCR) fees for 2025, a burden many carriers will feel acutely given the current difficult freight market. Second, they discuss a $47 million nuclear verdict against Schneider National arising from a 2017 fatal crash, using the case to illustrate the danger of failing to act on internal driver performance data. The hosts emphasize that telematics data, critical event alerts, and driver behavior records can and will be used against carriers in litigation if management ignores warning signs. The bulk of the episode is devoted to explaining how the current three-tier safety rating system works. The hosts walk through how FMCSA selects carriers for compliance reviews, often triggered by elevated CSA scores or fatality crashes, and how investigators build their document samples by targeting the worst-performing drivers and vehicles in a carrier's SMS profile. They detail the six compliance factors examined in a comprehensive audit, noting that the hours-of-service factor carries double weight, meaning a single critical-level violation in that area can result in a proposed conditional rating. An unsatisfactory rating, the hosts explain, can lead to a complete shutdown of operations until the carrier completes a detailed Safety Management Plan to FMCSA's satisfaction, a process that can take months and has forced many carriers out of business entirely. The hosts then turn to where the regulatory landscape may be headed. They draw parallels to FMCSA's 2016 attempt to overhaul the rating system, which would have tied safety ratings directly to CSA scores before being withdrawn under industry and congressional pressure. The hosts believe FMCSA is once again moving toward linking safety ratings to SMS data, particularly as the agency advances its proposed SMS methodology changes. Brandon Wiseman expresses his primary concern as one of due process, arguing that carriers cannot fairly have their operating authority placed at risk based on CSA scores when the existing DataQ system for challenging erroneous roadside violations lacks a meaningful, independent appeals process. He notes that FMCSA has proposed an independent appeals board for DataQ, which he views as a necessary prerequisite before any such rating linkage could be considered fair. For fleet safety professionals, the episode offers several actionable takeaways. Carriers should proactively review their SMS profiles and prioritize correcting compliance issues tied to their worst-performing drivers and vehicles, as those are the records most likely to be pulled in an audit. Any carrier that receives a compliance review should begin building its corrective action documentation immediately, not waiting until the rating is close to becoming final. Fleets should also audit their internal data management processes, particularly around telematics and driver behavior alerts, to ensure they have systems in place to act on that information consistently. Finally, carriers interested in shaping the future of safety ratings are encouraged to attend FMCSA's upcoming virtual listening sessions on June 25 and July 31, 2024, or the in-person session at the Texas Trucking Show in June 2024.

Full Transcript

w all right hey everyone welcome to episode 39 of truck safe live to show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting Ed Ed safety programs got Rob Carpenter with me today Rob is on assignment somewhere out there driving a truck hey Rob what's up hey not a whole lot I'm on my break you know we got to 30 minute restak yeah it's going to be an hour today but it'll work yeah the show usually goes a little over 30 minutes but if you need to go feel free and go how's the how's the how's the open road treating you today it's good it's uh it's hot you're in the midwest yeah yeah we're in Missouri today so it's a little warm all right well today's uh today's episode is all about carrier safety ratings timely topic FMCSA is uh came out with an advanced notice of proposed Ru making on this topic uh last year at some point and they are starting to revisit the topic they've got a couple of listening sessions in store so we wanted to pop on here and talk about the importance of safety ratings so folks that are going to be attending the listening sessions or uh offering their comments to the rule making can be better informed on the existing state of things and the possibility of where where FMCSA may be taking these things so that's what we want to do on today's show before we get there I want to first thank the sponsor of this episode which is taking the higher Road a legacy Builders and Freight wte production taking the higher road is a special podcast dedic ated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and compliance each week host Jeremy rmer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life life cycle be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast thanks again to taking the higher Road for sponsoring this episode uh before we get to the main topic as always few things going on at truck safe and in the industry that are worth mentioning uh on the truck safe front first up we'll mention our um upcoming Fleet compliance boot camp which is going to be in Indianapolis September 25th through the 26th uh be sure to join us this is our two-day in-person conference where rob me and Jared and Brian and others uh spend that time going into the DOT regulations at nauseum uh hitting on all the major topics driver qualification hours of service vehicle maintenance drug and alcohol testing do enforcement and all that fun stuff really digging into the nitty-gritty and helping to helping attendees to start to develop Cutting Edge safety programs back home we have a lot of uh um in addition to the educational sessions we do a lot of uh um exercises like driver qualification reviews and hours of service log auditing and that type of stuff like I said all to equip attendees with the information and the knowledge they need to build effective safety programs back home uh if you're interested in joining us head over to trucksafe bootcamp.com seats will fill up quick uh again this is going to be September 25th and 26th so be sure to register soon if you want to join us that's the truck safe boot camp what else we got going on EGS you saw the video at the start be sure to check out EGS if you haven't already this is the first app-based digital version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations um available at .a you can try it out for free for 14 days by signing up over there this is the software that we built uh spent the last couple of years building um to help fleets not only just access the regulatory text like you would do with the Green books but more importantly access all of the our educational materials that goes along with it so if you're reading about the short Hall exemption for example then you would have access to all of our videos and articles on that topic right next to the regulation to make it easy to dig even further into those regulations as you're reading them uh which is particularly helpful we found for uh complex topics like split sleeper birth just just to name a few taking advantage of the split sleeper birth Rob while you're out there no no I'm trying to keep I like the schedule you know what I mean it's a lot of truck drivers are just like plac to place where they end up I like to I like to plan this thing and uh stop where I want to stop and sleep at night and be awake during the day and then go home and get it over with yeah makes sense uh anyway you can check that out over at e. apppp also has the fmcsa's guidance for all the regulations right there uh in in a convenient place for you and you also have the ability to annotate the regulations with your own notes highlights and bookmarks check that out .a uh lastly I'll mention truck safe uh compliance Network trucksafe network.com this is our dedicated space for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also access all of our DOT content including our videos articles podcast webinars we're in the middle of a seven part webinar Series right now on improving CSA scores uh we've been through uh hours of service unsafe driving and vehicle maintenance we've got crash indicator driver Fitness Hazmat and drug and alcohol to go but network members get access to that for free along with a bunch of other helpful information so check that out free to join uh trucksafe network.com or download the trucksafe network app in the uh in the app store or the Google Play Store from your mobile device all right enough about us let's talk about some other things going on in the industry before we talk about carrier safety ratings um not a whole lot that I want to talk about today but the first thing I noticed that came out earlier this week was uh an announcement from FMCSA that they are increasing the unified carrier registration UCR fees for 2025 uh this comes on the heels of a couple of years I think where the fees have been lowered slightly or have decreased slightly now they are proposing an increase according to the notice which came out like I said earlier this week uh the fees for the 2025 registration year will be increased above the fees for the 2024 registration year by an average of 25% overall with varying increases between $9 and $99,000 per entity that's quite a big range there uh so be on the lookout for that these will be your UC if you're a if you're an interstate Fleet you are whether you know it or not you're supposed to be paying UCR fees in connection with your do account uh and the fees are based on your Fleet size the smaller the fleet the lower the fee bracket that they are in and obviously the larger the fleet the more you pay in UCR fees but overall they will be increasing by about 25% across the board for 2025 so fleets you have that to look forward to in 2025 unfortunately Rob any thoughts on UCR fees that we need to uh insult to injury uh is the first all but the fact that it's going up you know it's it's just it's it's not a really a good year for I mean a lot of carriers are struggling right now actually most carriers are struggling right now so um they could have just left it lower for another year at least try to let this thing recover there were a lot of comments on it as you might expect um let's see what the numbers are going to be they've got a table in here somewhere man this was a long unnecessarily long final rule that is uh like Hey we're going to raise this 25% and just leave I didn't know it was this long okay so here are the here's the fee table for 2024 and then in 2025 so you could see at the lowest fee bracket for fleets of between zero and two power units which is the majority of uh Interstate fleets in the country it's going from $37 per year to $46 so that's the $9 jump that's that's nothing to write home about but you could see that the highest fee bracket for the Mega fleets a,1 trucks or above in 2024 you paid 35 uh just uh about $36,000 per year and next year you can expect to pay about $45,000 per year so uh like I said 25% uh increase across the board all right so that's UCR fees saw that Notice come through wanted to mention it uh the other thing I saw come through this week was this story that was that is making the rounds about this uh new Schneider uh case it's a nuclear verdict case like we've talked about for the last seems like decade at this point these nuclear verdict cases verdicts against trucking companies in excess of $10 million continue to be on the rise and this is just the latest example of one uh the title of this article is jury slams Schneider National with a $47 million nuclear verdict in fatal crash uh I just wanted to kind of run through this uh you all can read the article on your own time but just wanted to hit the highlights here jur uh Georgia jury recently ly awarded more than $47 million to the family of a 35-year-old owner operator who was killed in August in an August 2017 crash involving a former company driver for wisconsin-based Schneider National Carriers now if if anybody's read this article you'll know that the facts are a little convoluted here in fact that the title of of this subsection here is what happened it's complicated uh according to court documents the owner of n trucken LLC uh was struck and killed in 2017 uh After exiting his tractor uh investigators arrived at the scene of the crash uh uh started well let's see Nance was forced to break suddenly and steer his tractor into the emergency Lane striking the concrete Median on Southbound Interstate 285 Philip Taylor who is driving a uh pickup truck told investigators that um a driver named waim was driving a white tractor trailer for Schneider swerved across multiple Lanes of traffic and into Taylor's Lane forcing him into the left lane and onto the shoulder where he struck and killed Nance so that's Schneider's alleged involvement is a driver who swerve who supposedly swerved into the lane causing the tractor trailer to drive into the the median and kill Nance um it's interesting if you if you read down on about this case into the article uh you'll see that the Schneider driver denies that he was anywhere near the scene they end up uh getting a hold of GPS records and placing him near the scene and um and that's what ends up that's that's the sole hook for Schneider in this case and and we end up with a $47 million verdict against Schneider you you'll also read in that article that there's evidence about the Schneider drivers who who was allegedly the one that swerved and caused the uh the accident there's evidence in the record about his driving history um including some drug and alcohol violations in his past um and the one that I thought was interesting um let's see here yeah his Qualcomm records obtained by N's attorney documented that he amassed several critical driving events for heartbreaking and stability control issues his MVR report showed that he'd been involved in multiple crashes over his seven-month employment with Schneider for days after becoming a dedicated driver uh he testified that his supervisor told him that Schneider's predictive analytic software censed that he would be crashing soon which can't be good uh Schneider allegedly did nothing to help him um and then in his three-month performance Improvement plan at Schneider his dispatcher documented an employment record that he had received five more critical event notices prior to being fired so obviously none of this work to Schneider's benefit in the context of this litigation even though many would argue that all of this stuff in this particular driver's past is really beside the point uh in relation to the accident at hand it clearly uh inflamed the jury and led to a $47 million jury verdict against Schneider so the point is doesn't really matter if you're physically involved in the crash if you've got these kind of skeletons in your closet as a carrier or as a driver you're at risk for a pretty significant uh jury verdict thoughts on that Rob no it kind of bleeds into the the same ratings discussion that we're going to have like obviously the FMCSA rates you based on different criteria but there's different things that you can do internally where you're rating drivers and it can come back to bite you if you're not managing those rating systems effectively so when you're getting those events and you're not doing anything about them it's it's an important consideration because eventually it could come back to bite you in court if you have that crash so it's a big deal yeah we've talked about that on past shows and some of the webinars we've we've had over the years the importance of managing the data that you have coming into you uh flowing into your systems making sure number one you know what data is coming into to your systems and and making sure you have the processes the people the policies in place to effectively manage it because if it turns out that you are turning a blind eye to things that the data is telling you could be a problem namely driver Behavior type stuff um then it is just not going to play well for you if these things happen and um you know obviously these things are rare they don't happen very often but when they do happen uh it's uh if if these things are are going to come out in that litigation it's just it's not going to play out well for you so make sure when it comes to data specifically from telematics devices from your elds from your cameras whatever connected technology you have in the truck uh make sure that you have the processes and people in place to manage it and that you are effectively working it from month to month and taking appropriate action when necessary all right so that's kind of things I wanted to mention about uh industry developments over the last couple weeks since we had our last show uh let's move into the topic of today which we've talked about is is Carrier safety ratings safety Fitness determinations also known as safety ratings which we've described in the past as a motor carrier's regulatory lifeblood they are what dictates whether a carrier is able to operate commercial Motor Vehicles or not and whether shippers and Brokers and insurers want to do business with them or not so critically important safety metrics for many reasons and they could be changing drastically in the future so that's what we wanted to hit on today so first up uh just wanted to mention uh like I did at the start that uh this is all spurred on by the fmcsa's notice from last year it's an advanced notice of proposed rule making which um which essentially says if if you know anything about the rule making process you'll know that this is very early on in the ru making process an advanced notice that proposed rule making is just where the FMCSA is coming out and saying hey we are thinking about changing up our rules in some form or fashion what do you think about it and and usually they'll ask a few questions to get the public to weigh in on and then they will solicit uh comments through the regulatory comment period or comment process and then also they will sometimes hold listening sessions where they either show up physically on site somewhere and uh and have a discussion with folks in attendance or they they do them uh you know via Zoom or or or something of that nature um and that's where we're at in this particular process when it comes to safety Fitness determinations FMCSA published this& PRM last year 2023 open the comment period uh for I think they ended up opening it for about 60 days or so that comment period is closed as far as I know but they are still soliciting public input and they just announced within the last couple of weeks uh that FMCSA will be holding some listening sessions on this rule making specifically over the coming months uh in particular actually this just was published today in the Federal Register let me pull it up if anybody's interested in attending these listening sessions uh the first one's going to be a virtual public listening session it will be held on Tuesday June 25th from 2:00 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. eastern time uh and there's a link in the Federal Register notice where you can um you could see the agenda for the meeting and also where you can register to attend that listening section second one will be another virtual one it will be held on July 31st from 2: to 3:30 p.m. eastern time again uh information is in the Federal Register notice and then they also going to have an in-person uh listening session wanted to see if that information is in this notice I don't think it's in this particular notice but I know they are having an in-person listening session oh was that it yeah here we go inperson listening session in Houston Texas I think at the Texas Trucking show uh June in June 2024 June well yeah I think it's the 7 through the 29th is the trucking show okay so it's one of those days they don't have the date in this particular notice they just say it's in June 2024 but it's I think you're right I think it's uh it's probably the 28th or the 29th would be my guess of June uh if you're at the Texas Trucking show then then maybe you can attend in person but anyway that's kind of where we're at in the in the ru making process but um before we get into the specific questions because I think it'll be interesting to walk through these questions at the FMCSA is asking in both the advanced notice and proposed rulemaking and also in their notice about the listening sessions to First Take a look back at kind of where we are at currently with safety ratings and how they are assessed or how they are um how they are generated currently so we know that so we we know what to expect if FMCSA uh goes through with their with the rul making process so just kind of walking through the current uh safety rating process anybody familiar with this knows that the we currently have a three- tier rating system uh right now a motor carrier can have a safety rating of either satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory we have had this rating system in place for decades at this point this is the way that the FMCSA the primary way historically that FMCSA has judged the safety Fitness of motor carriers that it regulates as Congress has directed it to do in its uh enabling statutes that set up the the FMCSA to begin with Congress has told FMCSA that they need to have a a method by which to judge the safety Fitness of motor carriers that it regulates and historically safety ratings The three- tier rating system has been the way that they have done it um that rating system currently and historically has has required fmcs to conduct a compliance review in order order to issue a safety rating to a motor carrier it requires the FMCSA to physically look at records for the motor carriers to whom they issue the safety ratings that either on-site compliance reviews or more frequently nowadays off-site reviews um it doesn't matter whichever way they are looking at your records if they are uh snooping around in your driver qualification files or your maintenance files or your drug and alcohol records that's what it takes for the FMCSA to issue you a safety rating and what that practically means is that most of the motor carriers operating in the United States today have no safety rating because they haven't gone through that type of of a compliance review from FMCSA in fact I think I've got the data here me pull it up yeah it's the majority for sure but it's I've always thought this was kind of scary because it's I I've we've we've seen carriers and we've been to different ones and it's like if you look at their systems it can be just abysmal and they might have an unrated which means you know your broker is still going to work with you and most cases because you're not conditional um and you're still out there able to operate so it's I've always thought it was a little bit a little bit off but maybe it made more sense back when FMCSA had fewer carriers to regulate but nowadays we're up over 700,000 motor carriers uh which fall under the purview of the FMCSA and you can see from this data that we're showing on screen here uh this data is is already old at this point this is from the fmcsa's I think uh 2022 large uh bus and truck crash study they show here a chart which indicates how many motor carriers there are registered and how many of them have no safety rating and you could see that that as of 2021 there were 700 over 738,000 regulated motor carriers and only 690 or I'm sorry 690,000 of those carriers have no safety rating which I think ends up being about 95% of the regulated motor carriers in the United States are unrated and to Rob's Point uh that means that they have never been reviewed by FMCSA at least in depth and in terms of kind of a records review and so they are out there operating um with no safety Fitness determination and is that a good thing is that a bad thing that's what we're going to get into that's what the FMCSA is looking into in the context of this rule making for sure but that's kind of the where things stand currently and one of the major uh uh driving forces for this rule making in my in my view and not just my view this is what the FMCSA says and it's notice a proposed advanced notice of proposed ruem is that their inability to effectively go out and and uh do compliance reviews for any significant percentage of the carriers that they regulate is is a problem in their eyes and it's what's driving this rule making going forward well I I think a lot of it gets started on the wrong foot when you know a lot of these companies will get started they have no idea what they're doing and they're just ignorant to what they should you know the processes that and the systems that they should have in place you know there was this especially true with like the old school carriers who came along and were created years before a lot of these rules even came to be so there was one carrier that that I know of that I worked with that was 50 years old and they had no DQ files at all they had no drug testing program they've been in business for 50 or 60 years and had never had a compliance review so they're still operating and it's they just don't have any programs in place because they never have had them so yeah U the new interest piece I was glad to see because I think the new entr piece kind of sets the educational tone piece when you're starting your motor carrier operation to say hey you need the following systems you need the following processes and if you don't have them we're going to educate you on what you need and that was a good I think initial step to kind of guiding carriers into what they should have and um how they should operate but I think prior to that there was a lot that started just on the wrong foot so yeah the new entr program I agree is is a a good step um but those new entr audits uh as many will know are not the types of audits that result in a safety rating so even if you fail a new entn audit and then ultimately you get put back in service you're not going to get a safety rating out of a new intern audit so it takes a more thorough compliance review to get assigned a safety rating and uh just kind of looking at the methodology for this um in the regulations if you go to part 385 of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations that's where you'll find the detailed methodology that the FMCSA currently follows to when conducting its compliance reviews and issuing a safety rating and again that's what we've been going off of for decades like for example when Rob and I go do mock do audits for a lot of our carrier clients we try and follow the same methodology that the FMCSA uses to give carriers a good feel for uh how they may Faire in the event of a real audit and so here's how it works generally speaking and Rob fill in the gaps here as we go if I miss anything but when the FMCSA comes in and well first of all how do they decide who is who is going to be audited in your view Rob who who who who are the carriers that get selected for compliance reviews so once you go over each basic has its own threshold so a lot of times it's basic it it starts with basic violations so your VI your violations are going to increase your threshold for each basic category and then that kind of starts with the letter that's going to say hey we've noticed an uptick in your maintenance violations at the roadside and if you don't get this under control and you don't figure it out on your own we may be coming to see you soon so if you don't take some kind of action to determine what your problems are whether they're systemic or or whatever the issue is and then you address them and try to get that threshold percentage drawn down then you may have a compliance review other other other ways you can have them is I've seen fatality crashes um kickoff compliance review so different ways different different pieces but a lot of times I think they really focus more on habitual Behavior so it goes more towards the threshold piece than the fatality piece yeah and then also I think that's right those are the two most common contributors to a a compliance review Far and Away the the um CSA scores and alert status or kind of what triggers audits nowadays SMS as if anybody who is following us following along along with us on our webinar series on improving CSA scores you'll know that uh High CSA scores are a very common contributor to uh to do Audits and the reason being the SMS system the CSA score system is really intended at identifying patterns of non-compliance so systemic problems in a carrier's safety and compliance across the seven Basics that Rob mentioned and as your scores start to tick up in one or more of those Basics the more likely it is you're going to get a knock at the door from the FMCSA to conduct a a compliance review but also fatality accidents certainly can prompt an audit they don't always prompt an audit but sometimes they do particularly if they're they're bad accidents that get a lot of publicity and then the other one that we see uh pretty regularly prompt a do audit are complaints from drivers so if you tick off a driver and the driver leaves and he files a complaint with FMCSA alleging hours of service systemic hours service violations for example which is pretty common thing to happen uh FMCSA will sometimes investigate that and that could prompt a do audit so uh several things could prompt the audit once they are in there once they have selected you for an audit uh they can conduct a couple of different types of audits I'm using the term audit generally uh they have different names for these compliance review is is the most common um but they can do what are called focused audits or they can do comprehensive audits or they could do some combination of both usually in my experience particularly nowadays audits will often start out as a focused audit mean they meaning they are focused on a particular area of compliance so in that example that I gave If a driver complains that you are having you are a fleet that is running drivers into hours of service violations they may come in and look at at the start at least just at your hours of service program and see if they can corroborate that driver's complaint um but what often happens um is that an audit may very well start out as a focused one in a particular area of compliance and it may balloon into a more thorough audit a comprehensive audit ultimately there are six factors that the FMCSA would look at if it were going to be a comprehensive audit um those factors are General compliance which is going to be things like do you have the right Insurance um and stuff like that then you've got the driver factor which is Factor two that encompasses both driver qualification files and also drug and alcohol testing if you have CDL Drivers factor three would be the operational factor which are hours of service rules um primarily uh factor four is the vehicle maintenance factor factor five is Hazmat If You Haul any Hazmat and then factor six is your accident rate how many accident how many dot recordable accidents have you incurred Cur per million miles that your fleet has traveled and those are the six factors that if the dot is conducting a comprehensive compliance review the investigator will be looking at they are going to be selecting a sample of Records in each of those factors according to a sampling methodology that they have detailed in a very a a very voluminous document called their e photom electronic field operation training manual I think is what it stands for uh and they're going to pick their their sample of driver files for example hours of service records vehicle maintenance records and they're going to send you information requests and then you are expected to have the documents that they've selected to them within 48 hours that's all you get um and these are not random samples they are not randomly picking the driver files that they want to see or the vehicle maintenance files they want to see what they are doing is going into your safety measurement system account they're seeing which drivers are having driver Fitness problems which drivers have been operating without the right license uh from roadside inspection data that they have available to them they're going to pick those drivers that are struggling they're going to pick the drivers that have had the most hours of service violations they're going to pick the vehicles that have been uh have been incurring the most vehicle maintenance violations roadside and those are who you as the motor carrier are going to be judged against are your worst performing drivers and your worst performing vehicles at least that's what I seen is that what you've seen as well Rob yeah usually I tell people that count on getting the ones that have the most violations the ones that are on the accident registry the most frequent and um if you happen to need space fillers just going to be somebody yeah but usually it's definitely not random so they uh they usually have a pretty good list to choose from so so if you want to prepare if you're a fleet right now out there that wants to prepare yourself for for a mock dot audit the best thing you can do right now is go in your SMS account look at your worst performing drivers your worst performing Vehicles get all of those issues taken care of first and start to work your way down because like I said you're going to be judged by your worst performing so go ahead and if you have drivers that have been uh tagged with CDL violations or Med missing med card violations get all that stuff taken care of ahead of time and that will go a long way in in preparing you for an audit if if it ever comes to be and so that's how it works the investigator picks their sample from that list they will send you an information request the audit will either be offsite or onsite depending on their preference and uh you better have those documents available for them when they are ready to look at them yeah I think the the only piece that I've seen the big I've seen it happen at least three or four times where you know they'll exhaust their bad drivers either from violations or who the drivers who are constantly on the acent registry and then they'll say all right we need four more give me the four drivers that drive for you the most frequent and I've had that one come up a lot where they want the drivers who are operating all the time so that's another one that they like to choose from yeah they obviously have to do their own diligence and make sure that if they're going to write you up for a violation as the motor carrier that they have evidence to prove that that driver was actually subject to the regulations when the when the alleged violation occurred so for example if they're trying to prove a um a driver has an hours of service violation one of the things they have to prove is that the driver was subject to those rules to begin with meaning were they operating a commercial motor vehicle in interstate commerce at the time and so then you'll see a lot of times that they are also requesting um supporting documents to help them prove that the driver was in fact subject to the rules and then violated them so things like bills of lading uh that type of stuff to prove that this driver was oper was hauling these goods from this location to that location on this date uh in a vehicle that weighed this much and that gets them the information they need to substantiate their violations but anyway in those six factors that's kind of what they're doing they're going to look at all of the documents you've produced and they're going to be looking for paperwork violations essentially in all of those six factors that I mentioned if they're doing a comprehensive review and then they are they are keeping track of every little VI ation that they discover um there is a list in part 385 uh in appendix B I think to part 385 of the safety regulations that uh dictates what are called acute and critical level violations these are it's a list of probably 100 or 200 or so um particular sections of the regulations and uh those are the ones that are either acute or critical what does acute critical mean these are the more serious violations acute violations uh are the most serious violations that an investigator could discover in a DOT audit and it only takes one of them only one instance of that violation to potentially negatively impact your safety rating if they find one of them then it's going to uh potentially impact your safety rating a good example would be uh continuing to use a driver after he after you know that he or she has tested positive for a a DOT driver alcohol test for example without them going through the return to duty process um critical level violations are still serious but it takes a pattern of non-compliance to amount to a critical level violation so they're looking for not just one violation they're looking for multiple violations of that same kind across the the files that they've been provided uh and the violation rate that would amount to a critical level violation is 10% or more so a good example of this are log falsifications in the hours of service Factor they are going to be digging through a certain number of drivers logs uh over a certain time period And if they find more than 10% of the driver's logs that they're looking at are falsified well then that's going to amount to a critical level violation in Factor 3 the hour is a service factor and so I mention this because like I said these acute and critical violations are the ones you're trying to avoid at all costs because they are the ones that set your safety rating you can get away with all the Ticky Tac violations and maybe only get a slap on the wrist in in the in terms of like a fine coming out of that audit but if you start incurring critical Andor acute level violations that's when your safety rating is at risk uh and uh and and so that's what we're we're trying to avoid in in these audits uh Sean says here sorry I probably missed it how many drivers do they select so in the eodem uh that I mentioned earlier it it sets out the the sampling size in each of the different factors that they're looking at or for each of the different document types they're looking at that used to be publicly available but I think they've redacted it since they published the eodem uh on their website I don't know why they've redacted it I don't know why that is considered um uh proprietary or or confidential I think Motor Carrier should have access to that information so that they can do their own uh their own mock dot Audits and stuff like that but in any event U it depends largely on uh the size of the fleet so the larger the fleet the bigger the sample size is going to be and and the sample size differs in each of the different factors so how many DQ files are they going to pull is different than how many driver logs they're going to pull they're going to pull but it's all generally driven by how big the fleet is based on the based on the fleet size I think I generally when I'm doing mocks I'll do like 25% but that's not their rule that's just me trying to get a big picture of of how you operate and and things that you may need to improve so that's a good rule of thumb I think so that's that's generally my go to yeah I pulled down an old copy of that sampling methodology so I've got it saved so there FMCSA take that um I've got it saved on my computer so I know what the sampling sizes are unless they've changed them which I don't think that they have but um but yeah I mean for a fleet of uh 100 drivers I think it roughly equates to maybe 25% of the of the files um in each of the different factors but yeah I think like the largest sample size of hours of service records for example for the Mega fleets the the the highest they go though is like uh 30 days worth of logs for 27 drivers I think is always what it was so 800 and some on duty days of logs that they're looking at for the largest carriers in the country and that's what they're basing their 10% threshold on for purposes of determining whether there's been a critical level violation or not um so that's how it goes from factor to factor they're identifying critical and acute violations and then there is in part 385 a table that dictates what your safety rating is going to be based on how many critical and acute violations they find you get a rating in each of those six factors of either satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory and then you get an overall proposed safety rating based on the ratings in each of those individual factors the thing that a lot of fleets don't understand but it bites a lot of them and it's probably the number one reason we uh we have fleets coming to us with a downgraded safety rating is that of all those six factors I mentioned there's one of those factors that the FMCSA apparently deems more important than the others and it double weights all violations that are discovered in it and that's the hours of service factor factor three uh and practically what that means is that if they find a single critical level violation in Factor 3 so 10 % of your logs are falsified for one reason or another because of the double weighting in that factor that means that you automatically fail that factor of the audit an unsatis you get an unsatisfactory rating in factor three and if you if you've seen the table for the safety rating uh methodology you'll know that you can't get out of a DOT audit with a unsatisfactory factor with anything better than an overall conditional safety rating so all it takes is one critical level violation in our hours of service and you have a proposed conditional rating coming out of that audit so like I said Far and Away the most common contributor to conditional safety ratings or downgraded ratings in general that we see coming in uh I know Rob you're dealing with several at any given moment helping carriers get their ratings back after they were downgraded that's probably the most common one you see isn't it yeah we we actually had a significant one recently uh I guess it was end of last year early this year and the carrier was closed for 3 or 4 months and and 146 of their violations were critical hours of service so um you know that that's that's it's a large It's a larger company so they had a huge driver population that had no work so they can't they couldn't operate and um I think a lot of carriers miss that piece that they can be shut down and closed um based on compliance factors so this is why we call safety ratings your regulatory lifeblood because if you get an unsatisfactory safety rating that becomes final after a DOT compliance review your entire fleet is going to be shut down not just one truck not just one driver not just the ones that they found violations on your entire fleet is going to be prohibited from operating commercial vehicles in both interstate and intrastate Commerce and less and until you do the work to get that rating upgraded which takes a lot of work uh a lot of fleets don't realize that either that it's not just a a thing where you go and beg for mercy and then maybe you say hey we've corrected these issues no it requires you to put in the work to actually correct the issues and the FMCSA is going to check you on that you have to submit what's called a Safety Management plan and it has to document in excruciating detail the steps you've taken to fix all the critical Andor acute violations that were discovered in that audit and they have to be to the satisfaction of the FMCSA and if if it's not to their satisfaction they're not going to let you back in business so an unsatisfactory rating coming out of a DOT audit can be the death nail uh for carriers that uh aren't interested in putting in the work to fix the issues or maybe they get shut down and they and now they have no revenue flowing in they just don't have the means to to fight that battle anymore so a lot of carriers fold because of uh of unsat ratings but that's the biggest consequence uh that's the most serious consequence coming out of an audit but conditional ratings are also serious that's the middle ground rating that you could get following a compliance review um they don't end up shutting your entire fleet down with a conditional rating you can continue operating vehicles on the roads at least according to FMCSA but it does have serious consequences in other context uh for example a lot of shippers and Brokers nowadays they have in their contracts uh with you that we don't do business with a carrier that has a conditional safety rating they won't Tinder loads to you if you have a conditional rating because of of the exposure they have from using a carrier that's been tagged with a conditional rating uh it also Jacks can jack up your insurance premiums uh if you get a conditional rating and it certainly places a bigger Target on your back uh from a highway accident litigation standpoint if you got a conditional rating yeah and I I have um we we have pretty frequently insurance companies who will reach out and say hey you know I've got this guy he wants to renew his policy we can't renew it because his safety record from this past so many months has just gone abysmal so can you work with them to do data cues and to actually fix their program because the insurance companies won't want to renew your insurance um if you already have a policy in some cases and um until you fix some of these things and Brokers before they'll even when they accept your carrier pack before they'll even let you come on as a carrier they want to make sure that you're ratings generally either unrated or satisfactory because if you're conditional they're not going to pick you up in most cases I mean there's probably some out there that would but your reputable Brokers that you want to work for are not going to want to do business with you with a conditional rating and that unsat is just a killer because like Brandon said if you don't have the financial ability and the financial backing to to last for in some cases months to get that rating improved to get back open you could you could easily run out of funds because when you're at that unset level you're really at a place where they don't really have to do anything for you because You' they've kind of got you over a barrel you're already unsat you're not operating so you're not really a priority for them so you have to basically do the back and forth to get that rating upgraded and it can go back and forth several times before they finally agree to let you open back up yeah now there is some timing to it so last thing I'll mention about the current rating process is that there are appeal options that there are options for carriers that end up with a the rating is considered proposed for a certain period of time after it's issued following an audit if you're a Hazmat carrier it's considered proposed for 45 days if you're a non-hazmat carrier it's proposed for 60 days and within that time frame you have two options essentially available to you you can either appeal the rating if you believe that it was uh the rating was assigned in air meaning that the investigator made some kind of a legal issue or legal mistake in in assigning violations those appeals get Tried by the fmcsa's chief safety officer uh at fmcsa's headquarters there's some briefing involved uh you get to brief the issues the FMCSA service center that that uh issued the rating gets to brief the issues and then the chief safety officer decides the matter uh and then if you lose on there then there are some options available to you to take it to Federal Court um the more common option though is the um corrective action option so this would be in section 38517 of the safety regulations this is where you aren't necessarily contesting the violations that were issued um in the audit but you are telling the FMCSA you acknowledge them but you've corrected them since the audit and here is the evidence of our corrective action it's it's a Safety Management plan that you file and like I mentioned it ver it better be very detailed and thorough or else it's just going to be denied but anyway um if you are successful in either of those options within the time frames uh then maybe your rating gets upgraded before it ever becomes final and then nobody ever knows that you had a a close call with a downgraded safety rating but otherwise uh if those time frames expire and the FMCSA hasn't ruled on your request or they've denied your request or you waited too long to file the request then those ratings will become Final on those deadlines 60th or the 45th day and if it's unsatisfactory that's when you'll be shut down your Authority will be revoked the state police will show up at your door in some cases and and start pulling the plates off your vehicles and uh and you're you're done for at that point if it's a conditional rating then it becomes effective on that particular date and then it's going to be publicly available for anybody to find after that on the safer website and and SMS and stuff stuff like that it's also going to be distributed out to all the platforms that are watching those types of metrics uh for your customers carrier 411 carrier sure all of those things are going to get notification that you now have a downgraded safety rating and that's going to cause problems for you undoubtedly one of those things to consider is the time frame of that back and forth so if you get that unsat it's very real so it may not go into effect immediately but it will go into effect after that pending period and if you contact somebody like truck safe for us to help you get that safety upgrade nine days or a week before it goes into effect keep in mind that you're probably going to still be closed because we can't do that back and forth process with FMCSA in a matter of five days so once you submit it um if you submit it on your own or whether we submit it for you it's still going to take that go that back and forth between us and the FMCSA to kind of NE negotiate that piece out and to work out any kinks that are in that that Safety Management plan so if you're going to start working on it you need to start working on it the day the compliance review is over so that you kind of have the ball rolling and hopefully you never have to face the finality of it you can resolve it beforehand yeah because the best case scenario obviously aside from showing what correc of actions you've done to to hopefully fix the issues ideally you would like to show the the FMCSA not only that you've done the corrective actions but that they are effective in mitigating the issues going forward and you only do that as time passes right it's not like you're going to fix something on day one and then all of a sudden it's it's not happening anymore it takes time for your corrective actions to get implemented and then to start to prevent those things from reoccurring in the future so it it's kind of um it's kind of a catch 22 right you want to start work immediately on corrective actions and you want to try and get your Safety Management plan into the FMCSA as quickly as you can but not too quickly where you aren't able to demonstrate the effectiveness of your corrective action so there's some art to it um and that's something that we've we've helped carriers with as Rob mentioned for for many years so anyway that's we spent a lot of time on the current process um let's talk let's then turn to kind of what we may be seeing coming down the pike here with the fmcsa's advanced notice of proposed ruem next step in the process would be a notice of proposed rul making uh usually after the FMCSA holds these types of listening sessions uh the next stage in the process would them would be them drafting up a proposal of how they think these are going to work in the future and then publishing that for public comment for the public to weigh in on and then ultimately they would publish a final Rule and then the final rule would set the new changes and then the compliance date uh we're still a long ways off before this this would ever take effect um the rule making process depending on the nature of the rule making and its complexity and how much blowback it gets from various groups dictates how long it's going to take this one will undoubtedly be complex it will undoubtedly get a lot of blowback regardless of what the FMCSA proposes there will be some group inevitably that's not happy about it and they will Express their displeasure uh in the in the docket and so I have to believe that we're probably we're at at least a year out from any changes to the process if not a couple years out just looking back at the ELD rule for example that thing was was like five years in the making after all of the litigation uh about it and all of the different iterations of the ru making it would not surprise me at all if we see something similar come to fruition with a safety rating change in fact uh if anybody on on listening in has kind of followed along with fmcsa's um safety rating rule making in the past you'll know that FMCSA tried to change up safety ratings back in 2016 they actually published a notice of proposed rul making back then that would have shaken up the process significantly what they were proposing back then essentially it was more complex than this but I'll break it down into its Basics was moving away from a three-tier rating system and two a single rating of either unfit that would be the only rating unfit or not rated and the way that they were going to they were proposing to assign that rating of unfit or not was in part based on your CSA scores as a fleet right now your CSA scores only dictate whether you get escalated for an audit they don't dictate whether you get a safety rating or not but the proposal in 2016 was we are going to assign safety ratings in part by CSA scores the worse your CSA scores the more likely it was you were going to get an unfit rating and they had different there was a whole methodology to it it wasn't just it wasn't just scores above the alert thresholds as you might think they had set special thresholds where if if your scores uh exceeded those special High thresholds in a particular month uh then then you get an unfit rating but it was still going to carry the same consequence if you got an unfit rating out of uh CSA scores or also an audit they were still going to have an auditing component to it then you were going to be placed out of out of business whole idea with this is kind of coming back to where we're at now why is the FMCSA doing this why were they proposing it back in 2016 they want to broaden their reach as we said at the start FMCSA is hamstrung to be able to conduct any significant uh percentage of uh uh audit any significant percentage of the carriers that they regulate so they they just don't have enough folks to be able to do that so how do they widen their reach well in 2016 they thought the best way to do that was to tie your your your safety rating at least in part to your CSA scores we have CSA scores for a a much bigger percentage of regulated carriers out there than have safety ratings um there are some carriers particularly small ones and and newer ones that don't have CSA scores because they don't have enough inspection data in the system but lots and lots of carriers have CSA scores so the idea was if if we start tying safety ratings to CS a scores then we're going to have a bigger percentage of carriers that uh that get a safety rating and um that as you would expect that led to a lot of of outcry within the industry several different groups including ATA and uh and and Congress got involved and ultimately FMCSA had to withdraw that rule making back in 2016 it was also around the same time that the fast Act was passed by Congress which essentially slapped FMCSA on the wrist for their CSA program told them they had to go get it evaluated by an independent third party and uh and so that's where we're at now that that analysis of CSA has been done FMCSA has proposed changes to the SMS system based in part on that study and uh those we're waiting on those changes and so uh I know we're about out of time here and so to kind of wrap things up here here is my kind of crystal ball outlook on this where I think this is headed and fmcsa's most recent notice about the listening sessions and everything like that has pretty much all but confirmed what I've been thinking the FMCSA was going to do for the last year or so uh FMCSA has proposed those SMS changes uh I have to think that their thought process is hey we've now taken the steps that Congress told us to take to fix SMS and once we get those rolled out then Congress should have no more concerns with us potentially tying a sa carrier safety rating to the SMS scores that's that's got to be their thought process and so I think they are starting to then move both balls down the court right they're moving the SMS changes down the court now right behind it is going to be the safety safety Fitness determination and what we see in the notices that FMCSA has published on it so far is that they are again toying with potentially tying a carrier safety rating in part to their CSA scores what that will look like we don't know all we can do is guess based uh at least partially on that 2016 proposal but I think that's where we're headed and that's one of the main questions that they're asking in the uh in the advanced notice of proposed rulemaking and in the listening sessions uh that was a lot of me talking Rob any thoughts on tying carriers safety rating to CSA scores if that's ultimately where we land with this no not really not unless I mean provided they have their their uh their Kinks worked out I think it'd be all right yeah I think that's a question right I mean my biggest concern with it has always been the due process uh putting aside the problems with the CSA platform that we've been complaining about for years and some of which the FMCSA is ostensibly fixing with their SMS proposed changes my concern Still Remains due process the lack of due process available to carriers to be able to rectify erroneous violations from roadside inspections that data is what's generating CSA scores and it turns out that a lot of those violations it's just a matter of fact a lot of the violations are incorrect that get written up on roadside inspection reports uh I don't think anybody at FMCSA could deny it or at this at their state law enforcement Partners a lot of them are incorrect either factually or legally and the problem we have now is that the data Q system is the only system available for carriers to contest that erroneous data and as we know over the years the success rate on data cues is very low because there is no due process there's no appeal process it's those appeals are decided by the very same agency that wrote up the violations to begin with they are not inclined to change their mind on it regardless of what evidence you present to them that they got it wrong they are very biased and so until we get that system fixed I see in no way could we tie a carrier safety rating to their CSA scores if the carriers do not have effective due process to challenge erroneous violations that are jacking up their CSA scores how could we possibly tie their their ability to continue operating to erroneous data with nowhere to appeal it now obviously FMCSA has started to think about this because they have proposed a a an independent appeals board for the data Q system they proposed that last year uh haven't heard anything more about it I suspect that they would plan to move forward with that appeals board kind of along the lines of the CSA changes and also the safety rating changes but until we see what the the independent appeals board is going to look like and where carriers can take those appeals of their roadside violations I just do not feel comfortable tying a carrier safety rating to to CSA scores yeah that's those Kinks and then there's the other aspect of of some carriers we I actually had a call this morning which we'll talk about later uh from LinkedIn a guy on LinkedIn just called and said hey what is data que I can challenge these things so there's all there's also the ignorance aspect to not all carriers have the knowledge base to say oh there is some form of due process maybe it's incomplete um and mostly unsuccessful but there's a lot of carriers that don't exercise that due process that does exist yeah and there is certainly a possibility I think this was proposed in 2016 that um if even if we tie a carrier safety rating in part to CSA scores that that there would still be some other appeals process a available to them similar to what we have now an administrative appeal through fmcsa's headquarters or some kind of a Safety Management plan corrective action type plan I think those absolutely have to be part of the equation uh I just worry though if if if we're going to say a carrier that has a has CSA scores at a certain level they automatically get an unfit rating and now they're out of business while while then they okay now they have the option to go appeal it or do corrective actions well they're out of business what incentive do they have anymore that their workers aren't getting paid they have no Revenue coming in we got to get all that figured out and that's the biggest part that I'm concerned about um but we'll just have to see where that goes again we're very early on in the rule making process advanced notice of proposed rul making uh be sure to attend those listening sessions um uh if if you're interested in participating or at least learning more about what the FMCSA may have in store I'd encourage you to do that we will continue to report on it I'm going to attend the listening sessions and and see what I can glean from it but stay tuned uh best way to keep up to date with everything that we got going on at trucksafe including those types of updates is through our newsletter uh trucksafe dcoms subscribe and uh you will get that type of information sent right to your inbox so I'd encourage you to do that anything else we need to hit Rob before we wrap things up you got to get back out on the road I don't think so I think that's it all right well thanks everybody for tuning in today really appreciate it stay tuned for announcements about future shows you can read guest bios watch prior episodes and everything over at trucksafe live.com we will look forward to seeing you next time uh thanks everybody see you thanks

Event Completed

Tuesday, June 18, 2024 at 3:25 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube