About This Event
In this episode, we’re joined by Brandon Minert, president of United Commercial Insurance, to offer some tips for fleets when it comes to preparing for insurance renewal and/or placement.
Episode Summary
In Episode 40 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Brandon Miner, President of United Commercial Insurance, to discuss one of the most pressing operational concerns facing trucking fleets today: insurance renewal and placement. With insurance consistently ranking among the top five operating expenses for motor carriers, and with costs continuing to rise amid a turbulent market, the conversation offers timely guidance for fleet safety professionals looking to better position their operations in the eyes of insurers.
Miner provides a thorough breakdown of the core coverage types fleets need, including commercial auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, workers' compensation, general liability, and excess or umbrella policies. He and Wiseman discuss the current state of the insurance market, pointing to two primary forces driving premium increases: the skyrocketing cost of vehicle repairs and replacements following COVID-era supply chain disruptions, and the continued rise of nuclear verdicts fueled in part by third-party litigation financing. Miner expresses particular concern about the role of private equity-backed lawsuit funding operations, which he argues have weaponized the legal process against trucking companies in ways that ultimately harm the broader industry and American consumers alike.
The conversation also touches on the debate over raising federal minimum insurance limits, which have remained at $750,000 since the mid-1980s. Miner argues that increasing the minimum would likely drive premiums higher without meaningfully improving outcomes for accident victims, noting that a significant portion of claim costs are consumed by legal defense rather than direct compensation. He also addresses New Jersey's recent move to raise its state minimum to $1.5 million, expressing concern about the potential for a patchwork of state-level requirements that could complicate interstate operations.
On the topic of positioning for renewal or new placement, Miner advises fleets to think in terms of two categories: emerging fleets and established fleets. For emerging fleets, he stresses that no compliance program or insurance strategy can substitute for a genuine culture of safety built from the top down. He also introduces two alternative insurance structures worth exploring: large deductible programs, which transfer more risk back to the carrier in exchange for lower premiums, and captive insurance programs, which allow groups of similarly situated fleets to essentially self-insure one another and potentially recover a portion of their premiums in low-claim years. For established fleets, Miner recommends conducting a detailed analysis of claims data to identify patterns and implement targeted operational changes, and urges all carriers to routinely monitor their FMCSA SMS scores for errors, noting an unusual uptick in incorrect data assignments to carrier DOT numbers in the current year.
A key takeaway from the episode is that insurance carriers are scrutinizing fleets more carefully than ever, and that proactive compliance, clean safety records, and demonstrated safety culture are among the most effective tools a fleet can bring to the table at renewal time. As Miner puts it, insurance carriers want to insure fleets but are afraid of bad ones, and the underwriting process increasingly reflects that tension. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to work closely with a transportation-specialist insurance agent, stay current on their SMS data, and explore alternative risk structures that may offer both cost savings and stronger alignment of interests between the fleet and its insurer.
Full Transcript
oh
up up up
if you're like us you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand understand the rule or guidance you're after e-g is the first web and mobile app version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations ereg is always up to dat and allows Fleet Safety professionals to not only read the rules but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts highlight bookmark and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules ereg was developed by safety Professionals for safety professionals try it out for free at .a
oh
hey everyone welcome to episode 40 of truck safe live show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs looking forward to Today's Show been wanting to do this topic or cover this topic for quite a while now all about insurance and what fleets can do to best position themselves or placement with a new insurance carrier or renewal with their existing carrier so excited to have a special guest on with us today to talk about that in a little bit but uh first of all a few things to talk about here before we get going uh also if you're here with us say hey in the chat would love to know who's here uh let us know where you're watching from um and obviously as as always if you have any thoughts or questions about the topic that we're discussing throw them in the chat and we'll get to them as you raise them uh first of all I want to say big thanks to the sponsor of this episode which is taking the higher Road a legacy Builders and Freight waves production taking the higher road is a special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and compliance each week host Jeremy rer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast thanks to higher uh not higher right thanks to taking the higher Road for sponsoring this episode we really appreciate uh a few things going on at truck safe always worth mentioning here first up uh we'd love to have you uh join us at our upcoming trucksafe Fleet compliance boot camp this is our two-day in-person conference that we hold a couple of times a year uh our next one is going to be September 25th and 26th in Indianapolis uh join us for for uh several sessions all about do compliance we're going to be breaking all of the main components of do regulations down driver qualification hours of service vehicle maintenance drug and alcohol testing CSA scores all of that fun stuff um we'd love to have you there we usually have around UH 60 or 70 safety professionals there in a group and uh we talk a lot a lot about improving your policies and procedures and uh developing an overall um uh robust safety and compliance program at your Fleet so you can find out the details register yourself online at trucksafe bootcamp.com seats are filling up so if you want to join us please register as soon as possible all right that's the truck safe boot camp um I also want to mention our truck safe network if you're not a network member I recommend you join this is uh the space that we've built for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also access all of our do related content including our videos articles webinars we're in the middle right now of a seven-part free webinar series all about improving CSA scores uh we just wrapped up our fourth one in that Series this week and uh network members have access to that along with all of the resources that we've developed to go along with it again free to join you can do so over at trucksafe network.com or scan that QR code and download the app in the app store or the Google Play Store would love to have you there so check that out uh okay enough about us some other things going on in the industry that are worth mentioning uh over the last few weeks here before we move on to today's topic uh first up I saw this come through either last week or earlier this week the FMCSA has announced a new Deputy Administrator or has a appointed a new Deputy Administrator uh article here says uh us Transportation secretary Pete budich announced Vin white as the Deputy Administrator of the FMCSA uh he will also serve as the agency's acting administrator a member of the Biden Harris Administration since 2021 white also currently serves as the US Do's acting Chief artificial intelligence officer where he oversees implementation of an executive order to advance and govern the development and use of AI in accordance with the administration administration's guiding principles and priorities um so this uh announcement came alongside I think they also appointed a new general counsel the FMCSA did and I believe her background as well was was in um technology so you can kind of get a sense of where the FMCSA is moving here with the appointments to their um to their upper Offices here clearly they're going to have uh a more heavy Focus than they have historically on um artificial intelligence things I got to think that this is POS positioning them to do more when it comes to autonomous trucks and uh and Technology installed in in the trucks that our fleets are operating so we'll see how that goes uh I don't know Vin white I haven't had any experience with him in the past um so we'll we see what his priorities are here in the coming days um so that's first article I wanted to mention second thing I noticed come through earlier this week was that the FMCSA is kicking the can on some of the rule makings that we have talked about in the past some of the rule makings that were supposed to move forward either this year or early next year have been moved down the road which is not all that surprising frankly as we've talked about in the past this is an election year and um administrative priorities tend to change around this time of the of this cycle and um and we see things start to get kicked down the road a bit and that is what is happening now at FMCSA this particular article is notif is mentioning that according to the fmcsa's spring 2024 unified regulatory agenda FMCSA is now projecting a May 2025 publication date for speed limiter notice of proposed rule making you'll remember maybe that this rule making has been in the works uh I think since 2016 if I'm not mistaken um we've seen talk about a mandatory speed limiter um rule since that time and uh to date it just hasn't ever moved forward it's gotten a lot of blowback in the rule making process a lot of folks thousands of folks have filed comments mostly negative from what I could tell uh against this Ru making but the agency persists with it along with this would be a joint rule making between the FMCSA and also the national highway traffic safety administration uh Nitsa and so anyway um it was supposed we were supposed to see it this summer in 2024 but now it is being kicked down the road until next summer at least May 2025 uh let's see what other rule makings are getting kicked down the road here well apparently I can't because I'm not a subscriber to this particular publication so I've hit a pay wall but uh the other ones that I know that have been kicked down the road here are the automatic emergency breaking rule we were supposed to we were anticipating a final rule that would have mandated aeb technology uh we were we expected that late last year and then certainly earlier this year but it's my understanding that one has been kicked down the road as well and we've got several pending rule makings that we would have expected to have progressed at this point including things like the um proposed changes to the safety measurement system CSA score uh platform that wasn't a Ru making but it was something that the agency said in early 2023 that they were going to do make these pretty sweeping changes to the way that carrier CSA scores are calculated and um to date that we haven't heard any more on the progression of that particular initiative and uh I have to imagine that it is being kind of sidelined for now as well with with these others along with potential changes to the safety rating methodology you may remember um earlier this year the FMCSA published an advanced notice of proposed rulle making actually I think it was late last year um that they published that where they indicated that they were thinking about making sweeping changes to the way that they calculate carrier safety ratings satisfactory conditional unsatisfactory those types of things um and they have already held I think two listening sessions on that proposal I haven't been able to attend either of of those so I'm not exactly sure how they went but they have another one scheduled for the end of July um you can find the details for that on the fmcsa's website I believe if you want to join that and and listen into what the FMCSA may be thinking in terms of how it might change the way that it rates motor carriers I'd recommend you do so I will attend it and then we'll probably have a a podcast episode about that uh later this year um spoiler alert we've talked about this on other shows but they are probably thinking about moving towards a system that scores motor carriers at least in part based on their roadside performance you know historically safety ratings have only been driven by on-site or off-site audits where the FMCSA is actually reviewing your compliance related records and based on the violations they discover in those records or the non-existence of violations that's what ends up giving you a rating and so practically what that means because it requires an audit the vast majority of carriers in this country are not rated because the FMCSA just does not have time or the manpower to go around and audit any significant number of motor carriers so I think upwards of 95% of the 700,000 Plus motor carriers that operate in the US have no safety rating and that's a problem obviously um and so the FMCSA is trying to figure out a way to revamp the way that they rate motor carriers one of which is to potentially tie your safety rating to your CSA scores I've got a lot of concerns a lot of heartburn about that Prospect given what we know about CSA and what we've observed over the years about how it works um but that uh if if they end up going that route they will hopefully implement the changes to the SMS that they've proposed and hopefully that will take care of the major problems I don't know I'm not holding my breath about it but we'll have to wait and see all right lastly I just wanted to mention that earlier this week we at truck safe published an article on the topic of multiple employer drivers this is a topic that comes up pretty frequently for us and for our clients where we have drivers who are working for more than one regulated Motor Carrier uh on any given week we see this quite a bit in certain segments of the industry uh a lot of driveway towway drivers work for multiple different carriers at a time uh also employe uh uh temporary drivers so drivers that are working for a temp agency or a driver Leasing Company you know they may be working for multile motor carriers in a week and so the question comes up what are what are are the obligations what are the regulatory obligations for motor carriers that hire those drivers temporarily um what is anything different about the way that we have to qualify those drivers or the way that their hours of service works and and as you expect it is different in those context and you got to be pretty careful about it because at least in our experience we see a lot of gaps in those processes in that context where drivers are working for multiple carriers so there is some Nuance to it and there are actually specific regulations that detail how this process can work for qualifying multiple employer drivers or drivers furnished by other motor carriers so we uh we put together a video on the topic and we drafted a detailed article on how it is supposed to work and some of the gotas to look out for in that context so you can check that out over on our website trucksafe doccom and also be sure to subscribe subscribe to our newsletter trucksafe decom subscribe that's the way to keep up to dat with everything we've got going on and uh constantly sending out information on breaking regulatory news in our analysis of it so um subscribe to that if you haven't already all right let's move on to today's topic which is Insurance um everybody's favorite topic right so uh obviously Insurance plays a critical part in regulated Trucking whether we like it or not federal safety regulations mandate that four higher motor carriers maintain certain levels of commercial autol liability coverage and file proof of that coverage with the agency carriers have long lamented the costs of coverage uh and it continually ranks in the top five operating expenses for fleets across the country but it's one of those things that you hope you never have to use uh but you better have the right types and the right coverages in case you ever do need to use it uh really should go without saying but safety and compliance are topics that go hand in and with insurance and so that's why we wanted to hit on it in today's episode and we are excited to be uh joined today by uh Mr Brandon Miner president of United commercial insurance welcome Brandon uh oh I got you muted sorry welcome back anticlimactic there sorry for that there you go glad to be here hey appreciate you joining me and uh looking forward to the discussion today uh by the way um I think this is correct but uh I've been informed that today is the National Insurance nerd day have you ever heard of this are you are you celebrating uh we should if I was nerd enough I would be but I didn't know that so yeah no it's a great day then man we should all celebrate right yeah congrat congrats this is your day so anyway everybody should read their policy documents today in celebration yeah that should be that should be mandatory on insurance nerd day everybody pull out policies if you can find them dust them off read through them and uh and uh cry some tears for um having to go through that but anyway hey Brandon um for those not familiar with you I wonder if you could start off by kind of giving us your background and how you found yourself uh at least partially in the transportation industry yeah absolutely so uh United commercial insurance it's the agency that I started in 2013 I've been in and out of the trucking industry my whole life in fact my dad he was a long story here he was a Jag in the Air Force in the 80s in the 90s uh and what happened was he kind of was dealing with drug and alcohol issues with Airmen and the Air Force and when he got out so a Jag is an attorney and when he got out was about the time some regulations came into Trucking and so he started a drug and alcohol third party administ ation company and he catered a lot of it to trucking industry professionals because Reagan you know created the the regulations for drug and alcohol and all of the different things that that came involved with running a drug and alcohol program and he was familiar with at least the government side of it so he came in and started a drug testing company based out of boy Idaho and so that's sort of how I grew up my dad drug tested me through middle school and high school and all throughout but um out of college I ended up working there for a little bit of time we worked with large fleets we worked with large employers all across the Northwest we're based in Boise Idaho this insurance agency is and so for six years prior to starting this agency I worked with carriers uh setting up running coordinating drug and alcohol testing programs doing trainings on how to comply with regulations there and then from that I you know wanted to go out on my own and I said insurance was something that is nerdy enough for me to do and uh and so I started that in 2013 we uh have grown quite a bit we we represent most insurance carers all over the country we're in almost all states we don't do Alaska Hawaii and and a few states in the Northeast but we're in 46 States uh we represent like I said most major carriers we have a couple thousand customers and you know we're really well experienced in the trucking and transportation industry that's our specialty that's our Niche United commercial insurance we have 21 employees here including myself and yeah that's kind of us in a nutshell we're you know we like Insurance we're here we're young we're growing we we uh just kind of like what we do nice yeah and genius move by your dad there to uh for for any parents out there this is an idea for you if you got kids that are in high school start up your own drug and alcohol testing company so that you can drug test your kids yeah I mean all me and my so I have I have five boys in my family and I was the youngest of five and it was you know I was in sixth grade and I'm like I don't know what any of this stuff is right but I mean it was kind of always that running joke where you couldn't come over to my house because my dad would have a drug and alcohol test ready for in a cup exactly that in the breathalyzer so it's like you couldn't get away from it but now is a good time that's hilarious well I know when uh you and I have just been introduced recently to one another and uh one of the things that caught my attention about you guys is uh it seems like um you know like you said you're kind of new and up and coming and and you seem to put an emphasis on getting like quality content out there to your to your customers and and that was intriguing to you don't see that a lot um you're starting to see it more and more with with some of the more traditional uh Brokers out there but I thought that was interesting can you tell us about that and kind of pushing out content to your to your customers yeah absolutely so we have conversations every day we have I think nine producers and we have conversations with customers every day about subjects on you know deductibles and liabilities and costs and coverages and claims and we have these conversations over and over and over and so for us we know these subjects inside and out and while it's not a dumb question we you know we we repeat ourselves a lot and as a human being you kind of grow the expectation that why don't why doesn't everybody know this right like why doesn't everybody know why this particular a vehicle maintenance breakdown usually isn't covered in a tow or or why these problems with Towing are an issue or what's going on and so I don't know why it took us forever it took me for forever to decide hey look we're just having that one conversation with that one customer and so we really need to record these conversations and put them out and YouTube is such an easy platform to throw these out so that in our conversations in our emails with customers we can send them a video and say hey here's sort of a recap of what we discussed or here's some more information on on auto hauling or Towing and some of the subjects that we have and the conversations that we have over and over and over and mainly you know insurance and you probably have seen this Brandon all industries that sell services to truckers the phone and email method is a bloody kind of red ocean and for us we compete in that space we get it you have to do calling you have to call these guys and let them know of your services but I would prefer to meet a lot of these guys where they're at which is on the platforms that we're posting content to yeah and so that's important to us and so for us if a customer or potential customer can see us and say oh these guys look like a decent option there's so many options in Insurance uh you could you can get confused easily I think it's important for me obviously for my job you know where are a trucking specific firm a commercial specific firm it's easy to get a quote from somebody that isn't and then when you purchase well now you know do you get all the service that you need Trucking is so specific on certificates and coverages and certain situations it's really frustrating to not have that service and so we like to highlight like we we offer that and you should know about it and so I think these platforms offer a really good way to communicate that in a way that's not so annoying as a caller you know all the ways we typically get marketed too yeah I mean we were the same way I you know that's one of the re so I was at a large Law Firm before I started truck safe and went off on my own but one of the primary driving factors for why I wanted to go off on my own was because I just felt like kind of the same way that there just wasn't that great of a quality or quantity of of content out there about all of the DOT regulations so less less about insurance and more about the regulations just like Insurance when it comes to the regulations there's a lot that goes into it and you can handle it the the traditional way and explain that on the phone or by email hundreds of times over and over and over but why don't we just put it together once in a piece of content that can then live on forever and obviously making updates as as things change this isn't static information it's Dynamic but at least we've got a base of good content out there that then we can then uh get out to the masses the people can find it on their own time and then also that we can just send it out to our clients that have a specific question that we've already addressed so it's been it's been very helpful to us as well well yeah and it gets it gets my agents my a lot of my agents are participating and it it allows our customers to get to know them better if we're marketing to somebody in Indiana or North Carolina or Florida the odds of us ever meeting face Toof face almost zero I mean oftentimes our customers will come in if they're driving through but it gets them an a chance to meet them and get to know them better and know that they're going to be part of the industry longer than just a couple months so yeah yeah makes sense well you mention mened uh you know all of the types of coverages that are available to fleets and um you know as I mentioned at the start and and I'm sure you agree uh you know insurance is always top of mind for for fleets and so for those who are just kind of new to to the industry or new to trying to get their minds wrapped around Insurance coverages wonder if you can help us break down the the most popular types of coverages that fleets need yeah of course so you have the main three everybody is most likely familiar you have your auto liability which covers the the damage that you cause based on your actions to another party either it's their bodily injury or their property damage so it could be their vehicle or their home or whatever damage that you're causing that's the liability typically your you know most carriers are at around a million or two million you have your physical damage which covers the cost to replace the vehicle the trailer uh any of the the equipment that you're using there which has been a big concern with insurance has been a big problem last two years the physical damage you have your motor car or your motor truck cargo which is obviously the cargo that you're hauling that's a big everybody's going to require that if you don't have that you're in a big problem so those are the big three in addition to that fleets typically add on you know the workers compensation for the employees the general liability for the operations that are happening outside of just the Trucking and then the big you know Fleet expense on insurance that they're most likely all going to have is the excess which is essentially an umbrella type policy that takes your limits of insurance so if we say you have a million dollars in Auto liability fleets are a big Target for lawsuits we can talk about this fleets are a big you've seen signs I don't know how many are in Indiana as far as hit by a trucker yeah anyway so they're a big Target and so typically some of these situations could cost more than a million dollars and so an excess policy will take that million and raise it up two three four five million and so essentially you have $5 million of insurance coverage for any particular situation and that can either go over one aspect of your policy or an umbrella and cover all aspects of the policy whether it's the motor cargo or the physical damage meure the liability so yeah those are the main coverages that insurance carrier that that fleets typically have or require yeah and that excess coverage is is critical for the reasons you've mentioned we work with so many fleets that just have the minimum that they need in order to be able to get the license from the dot to be able to operate so they end up with you know the minimum for General commodity carriers is 750,000 of commercial Auto liability insurance and that's it the unless you're a household goods mover the RS don't require you to have cargo coverage uh the RS don't require you to have uh any other coverage except commercial autol liability insurance but what we see and what we've harped on for years at this point is that minimum coverage is if you get involved in any significant accident and it doesn't even have to be fatality accidents it could just be injury or significant property damage you're very quickly going to exhaust that first level of coverage and you're going to be in trouble because then they're potentially going to be coming after your assets and so that umbrella policy is critical as you start to get into accidents of any significance whatsoever and then you start to look at the rise of the so-called nuclear verdict cases that we've seen and and these are on the rise up over a th% over the last 10 years uh jury verdicts in excess of $10 million rendered against trucking companies specifically in these cases where they're most often about non-compliance issues or failing to live up to Industry standards uh trucking companies are clearly in the crosshairs and they're in the crosshairs for significant exposure and so it's it's you know I can't overstate the importance of working with somebody like you guys to make sure you understand the exposure uh to your Fleet and then also make sure that you're you're fully covered and it's going to cost you um there's no two ways about it it's going to cost you and it's going to be a significant if not the most significant expense for you it's going to be up there with them and so I guess that's my other question to you Brandon it seems like you know pretty tumultuous few years when it comes to insurance cost for fleets I wanted to get your take on what the current landscape is yeah I I mean there's so much to unpack I know going back to what you're were talking about I think in ' 09 or 08 a typical fatality May cost an insurance carrier two or 300K $300,000 in payout and that wasn't uncommon and it didn't take long I think it was 15 or 16 where you're a million dollars out the door on a fatality no problem I mean that was just once the once the precedent started coming through on the lawsuits then it was a million dollar out the door I I go back and forth me you know just personally I think an insurance limit you know every everybody should have adequate Insurance to where if you if you get into a situation and you don't have enough coverage you don't go out of business right and so I like the one and a half to two million but I personally struggle just because often times as an insurance agent the the attorneys that are going after our customers they only want to know the cap of the insurance policies that they have and so you know I the too much work to go after assets we're we're going to go after the policy and then maybe we look somewhere else for the the additional recovery maybe we lick up the chain to the Brokers or the shippers yeah they just are chasing down all the policies they can on it and so for me if you're a large Fleet you have to have as much coverage as possible I mean you have assets that are easier to get after you know our customers we we walk a delicate line because if you're a smaller um Trucking Transportation Company sometimes I think it just paints a bigger Target on your back if you have a high excess policy uh large Fleet owners if you don't have if you don't have five million you're at a significant uh risk if you have 10 million I think you're in a better situation for sure fleets but for the you know one to three truck guys we talk about it all the time so anyway to address your question it's been an incredibly difficult year and a half in trucking and you could point to a number of different aspects of it I think the if we go back to covid trucking was on the rise nobody could get enough stuff they couldn't get in time reimbursement rates were really really high and then you fast forward to the Whiplash when you're coming down that line and now costs are shooting up through the roof as far as the vehicle equipment on purchasing a truck purchasing a trailer the cost to repair the cost to maintain the cost of you know basic or fuel and operations and employees and inflation those costs drove up the operations on a not just a truck but on the claims of an insurance carrier and so we'll I guess we can look at two areas in particular if we talk about physical damage so physical damage is the reimbursement of the value of the vehicle or the trailer that you're operating the equipment that you're operating and I don't know that there was ever a time like covid that affected physical or the value of Assets in trucking in the automotive industry like covid did right I mean you could purchase a vehicle and it was worth more after you purchased it than I mean they appreciated in value I don't know of a time that that ever happened ever and so you know some of our customers they would purchase a vehicle in in 2018 let's say for 80,000 and they got into an accident in 21 they would get let's say 70 80,000 back well to purchase that same vehicle they'd have to pay 100,000 or 110,000 and so put yourself into the situation of a fleet that were you know purchasing if they weren't Leasing Vehicles if they were purchasing vehicles at a higher physical damage value or at a higher value and then the cost to repair in a total loss or just any repairs skyrocketed for these insurance carriers and they weren't accurately rating for that so the prices that we seeing the increase in in insurance rates that we're seeing across the board are in a large part driven by a physical damage correction on so you know every insurance carrier is going to say we're losing more money on liability we're losing more money on cargo or we're losing on workers comp right now almost across the board insurance carriers are getting you know handed to them with physical damage costs you know they'll charge let's say they'll charge uh four or $8,000 a year for just the physical damage on the vehicle well they could be spending $20,000 on a small repair yeah right and that's on a small repair and so it's been really difficult for them to adjust they have to go in and readjust their systems physical damage calculations on how that works on the on how new it is and then they have to say Okay we can't have anything that's prior this year we can't have any thing that operates in this area we can't have these specific sensors and so it's been a big adjustment game for us there um that's been a big Drive factor of the increase in prices it's been tough for them to adjust and then the second oh yeah go I was just gonna say yeah I mean I don't know if you've seen this report but the American I talk about this all the time the American Transportation Research Institute atrey put out a study in 20120 I believe on the rise of nuclear verdicts in our industry and um and they put out a related study about insurance costs and stuff like that and it's consistent with what you're saying which is it's almost like we're playing catchup now for the the the insurance companies their margins are are thin already and so now we're trying to catch up and the way that we're catching up is by jacking up premiums and that's ending up hurting fleets um I'll let you finish your thought and then I've got a a related question yeah it's been tough I I think the second aspect has been nuclear verdicts and then particular thirdparty financed uh lawsuits has been on the rise for some of these guys and what that means is um a private Equity or an invest type organization this is a personal opinion I think often times those private Equity groups comprise attorneys and trial attorneys uh because I don't know who else would do this look for a return in this segment but what they do is they fund lawsuits and they work with specific trial attorneys who go out and search for lawsuits against Trucking firms and they have a Playbook they have the exact plays that they want to run what they're looking for there's a term in the industry called reptile um Theory and you've probably talked about it before but reptile theory is this just where they uh find a case that has negligence on the trucking firm and they attack that case in a specific manner to get the most return out of it as possible it's regardless of what the victim went through regardless of what the carrier is actually doing if they're you know can if they're really have having considerable negligence or not they're just going to go after the highest judgment possible and that's been on the rise there's a number of states that are trying to set rules against that I know Louisiana was a big one just recently that Florida just did recently as well yeah so some states are leading the charge I think I think the American trecking association's been doing a good job I I wish so bad I you know if we were to I wish so badly the the largest insurance carriers in the country like if you were to say Great West and Progressive and you know National Indemnity and whoever right Northland I wish they would all go to Vin white or Buddha judge or whoever and say look we're gonna stop we're gonna stop ensuring anybody if you don't take this away because it's a clear abusement abuse of the process of the system it's not needed it's only hurting everybody and it's only helping these trial attorneys that have their you know private jets that are flying around to the conferences teaching everybody how to do this and you know they have 15 homes and they're just getting incredibly wealthy of it I wish that they would do that uh we went to a conference with with at a progressive conference and they're they're probably the largest insurance carrier now they don't have a lot of Fleet but as far as commercial insurance carrier in trucking they're probably the largest out there and uh and it the CEO was there Tri and and she was asked hey when are you going to cuz that was a complaint they continue to bring up that they're getting hammered on these and they're paying out not just in defense costs obviously the rewards and the penal violations that they're getting that they're paying out on but the it was asked hey when are you gonna actually step up and say we're gonna get out of here if you don't stop this and and she kind of danced around it I I I was surprised about it she said hey we work with this lobbyist organization that does this and that and we support you know different trade organizations the ATA and to go after it but I just think they have more power personal opinion I think they have more power than they're using I think a lot of these Regulators would see hey if if we have the biggest carriers all combined to say this is hurting the American Consumer theer the average American our voter base we need to we need to get rid of that I think that would help quite a bit I mean something's got to change something has to change in this area I don't know how much higher these costs can go yeah um yeah I mean really the only ones getting rich out of this is the plaintiff's bar like we've talked about on um you know if anybody's interested go back and watch our episode 20 it was called combating the reptiles and we had Alex Miller on who is the um CEO of the Florida uh Trucking Association and we also had on Bill kasasi who um who is a psychiatrist who specializes in um like uh uh jury uh jury coaching or witness prep for these types of cases he does a he does an excellent job of explaining the psychology of of these plaintiffs attorneys who who implement this reptile Theory and how they get into the heads of the witnesses and that ends up blowing up the case in the favor of the plaintiff's bar and we talked with Alex about the steps that Florida has taken uh to get legislation passed Tor reform legislation to try and get control of this but yeah I completely agree unless we get control of this across the country this is just going to it's a runaway train we're going to continue to see these cost Skyrocket yeah I mean for your listeners that are a fleet the safety person at a fleet doing the training that reptile Theory I mean I I need to go back and watch episode 20 seeing the difference of how they set it up you know we went to one last year and it was so fascinating because they had a good and a bad example and the bad example was the trial attorney was saying or the uh the plaintiff's bar was saying hey is a Truck heavy yes is it hard to stop Yes is it a danger to society yes right and then and then he stopped the tape and said we just lost that case you know just because he said yes every time right and then the good example was is a Truck heavy well well it depends you know is a truck Fast well I don't know how fast they're go you know and so there's such a strategy that you have to have and your employees have to be aware of it I had no idea of it until we saw it it reallyare Bill does an incredible job it was probably him that was presenting if I had to guess because he's got all of those videos of here's where things can really go wrong if you don't have your Witnesses appropriately prepped and here's the better way to handle it so yeah he does a great job but um along similar lines I'm curious your thoughts on because something that we've heard the FMCSA talk about uh several times over the years we've heard Congress get involved with this um is this this idea of raising the minimum insurance limits for for carriers um we've had the same minimum insurance limit of 750,000 in place since the mid 80s the minimum has not risen since the 80s and so it's been artificially suppressed it hasn't tracked with inflation or anything over that same time period so now every once in a while there's Congress comes out with a bill toying around with a new limit of a million dollars I've also heard $2 million we're also seeing some states like New Jersey go out on their own uh and raising the minimum limit for carriers operating in their states so I'm curious to know your thoughts on that and how that may impact the cost of of insurance going forward yeah it's a big subject and you know we'll talk I'll I'll kind of end with the New Jersey portion I went to a I listened to Jim Mullins he was the FMCSA director under Trump uh this was in March and we talked about that subject and he said number one 750 is kind of like the Amazon Prime $75 they didn't know nobody knows why that number was that number and I think in the 80s that was a high number you know it was kind of overestimated to what any damages could could get to um you know his point of view was it'll never happen it'll never increase and and I get why he said that there's so many organizations that are that are going to challenge that I mean look at some of these rules I you and I have been involved in the trucking industry for so long and you can you can pull up probably five or six subjects I know there was one specific rule that was interesting it was the drug testing Consortium um of positive test results and it was it was down the down the road maybe seven or eight years yeah it was a clearing house and we didn't see it coming until until 2020 yeah right and I remember hearing about that in 2010 2011 and it made sense it was it was a perfectly reasonable Rule and so uh I I don't know it take a pretty strong personality to push that through I any any increase will drive prices up and and if you think about it this way if you have 25 trucks on the road Road let's say you just have a million dollars in liability that's $25 million that an insurance carrier is on the hook for right and that's a tough thing to swallow if that were to go up to two million New Jersey's at 1.5 with New Jersey doing that I kind of expected the federal government to take notice and say hey we can't have New Jersey at 1.5 Colorado at two Idaho at 7 we can't just have Yeah a different I mean because essentially you got to drive around a state to deliver a package or deliver a load and so I could see after a certain point you know if there is a a lawsuit that goes through or if there's a subject uh a specific scenario go through that the FMCSA is GNA adjust it but I get why the states are doing it I just think I don't know if it's the answer I actually think a million dollars is a good amount of coverage to have I think yeah a million dollars a lot of the the claim a lot of the cost of a claim goes towards a lawsuit to goes towards defense you know very little actually goes towards the cost of the vehicle the cost of the bodily injury damage and a traditional claim um but you could be spending two three $400,000 just in defense of that uh claimant or of your customer and so the more money that you have to that you have to hold aside uh that the actuaries have to calculate and say okay now we have a $2 million liability for every vehicle that we Ure on the road well it's just I mean the premiums are just going to go up across the board I would be really worried about it I get the reasoning but I don't think it's the answer I really don't I I don't think I don't think the majority of the money is actually going to the per the person injured in the accident and the the equipment and the property that has to be repaired yeah you know yeah that's a good point um and I'm curious to you know the New Jersey deal is fairly recent still it's happened within the last couple of months uh I still don't know enough about it to know how they are applying it I think there was a an initial question of hey does this only apply to fleets that are physically operating uh in New Jersey or that have a location in New Jersey or does it apply to trucks that are just passing through New Jersey I don't know if you know how they've applied that practically but it does seem I mean to your point it does seem like something that would be ripe for FMCSA preemption we see FMCSA do this in other areas where they say hey we can't have a patchwork of state laws on this particular topic because Trucking is by its nature Interstate in nature so we can't have a system where the laws change from state to state as your trucks enter those States and uh it seems like depending on how New Jersey is interpreting their own statute or applying it that that is a real risk if state if you know maybe one State's not a big deal but as more and more States enact different limits uh and they try and impose them on fleets that are just passing through it seems like it would be a big big problem yeah I guess I just wonder who's pushing for the increase like what what's the what groups are really pushing hard for that increase if it's if it's the trucking industry then I'd have more comfort in saying okay maybe that's something that we need if it's the bureaucrat I don't I just I'm so deathly scared of inflation I am and the upward pressures of inflation uh I I think that would contribute to it so I I wouldn't support it I really wouldn't I would rather let's try to figure this out under a million and if they wanted to increase it to a million these insurance carriers play funny games too because you know what they'll do is they'll um they'll post your filing at 750 even if you pay for a million right yep and most car most it doesn't matter to most carriers sometimes a broker will ask for an updated filing and then they'll have to do that but the reason they do that is I was gonna say do they do that to make them less of a Target to make it look like they have less than they actually do that's exactly well what they do is if if a smaller carrier goes out of business and a claim is filed like let's say they stopped paying their bill four months in and a claim is filed after that then they're only on the hook for 750 yeah so it limits their liability a little bit there so they game it a little bit which is nice for them it saves them it could save them 250k on a policy they lost just incredible amount of money on so right yeah I'm well the other thing that doesn't help is is the fmcsa's process for filing Insurance because you know they have a kind of an Antiquated registration system that requires you to go in and tell the FMCSA what types of Commodities you're hauling and you know if you pick the wrong commodity uh it it may then uh you know tell you hey for that type of commodity you got to have a million on file or or or this and that so uh usually if you're just selecting General Commodities then then the system should only tell you that you have to have 750,000 on files and then that's what ends up getting filed so yeah uh with what we're kind of running out of time here but I definitely want to hit on so that's kind of the current landscape I'm curious for your thoughts on you know with that being the picture and that being what fleets are up against what in your view are some some of the things some of the key things that fleets can do to put themselves in a better light when it comes to either getting placed with a new insurance carrier or when they're up for Renewal what concrete steps can they take to make them a a more attractive candidate yeah well so you have to break break out fleets in a couple different groups let's just let's just separate it into two groups so you have your established fleets traditionally speaking your established fleets have a very good relationship with their carrier and you're making marginal changes to your operation to like kind of macroeconomics to affect the whole and so those changes for large fleets are fairly small it could be you know you but you have to assume the culture of safety is are in those fleets already to where you have your safety department you have your paperwork up in your maintenance group and everybody's locked in and dialed in to say hey we're trying to get this goal to lower our rates and lower our our our claims and lower our crashes and our accidents we want to get everybody safe home that's the culture how do we get there so that's that's always going to be on in front of mine in a large Fleet right so um I'm going to focus a little bit more on the let's call it the emerging Fleet let's say you're 15 25 50 vehicles and you're getting into the role of a safety you're kind of you're you're where you need a full-time safety person um well number one you got to go to truck safe you got to get on there you gotta figure out what what compliance issues you're gonna have there you go um but number two there's really no there's no replacement for culture and it's such a shift for new fleets because you're growing you're trying to raise money you're trying to hire you're trying to recruit you're trying to do all these things operations you're trying to do everything to grow the company well a big part of that is you're going to have to get to a point where you need a full-time safety person that focuses on reducing the number of accidents and claims and crashes that you have and it has to get to the point where the person that starts in that role or at a different role and transitions to the this new role they have have to be good at instilling that culture in the company so it's not just a fake thing that you talk about in an audit when uh the insurance guy comes and say and goes over your safety practices it's a weekly you talk about it in meetings you talk about a daily you're you really truly want everybody to come home safe you really truly want to reduce the number of accidents and the number of crashes and the number of claims so that's the underlying issue that you absolutely you have to have that in your company in your Fleet if you're going to be successful yeah we talk about it a lot about having the the foundation there um you have to build the foundation and it takes work you have to have the right people in place you have to have the right policies and procedures in place because it's it's as you said it's easy to get quickly over your skis in this area where you're you you've been worried about the operations and the finance and that makes sense you're running a business but if you don't take the time and the effort to put in the safety and compliance related foundations then you're just going to be putting Band-Aids on things as they go along and you're not going to have the the underlying things in place to keep those things from occurring and so they're just going to keep piling up and piling up until now all of a sudden you've either got the dot knocking at your door to do an audit and potentially shutting you down or or issuing serious fines but you know obviously the the the bigger concern is that you get involved in one of these serious accidents and now it's lights out because of a you know nuclear verdict or a nuclear settlement in those cases so it's a it's it's key that you have those foundations in place sure yeah and and it's something that insurance carriers want fleets but they are afraid of fleets they're afraid of bad fleets because that could sink them I mean that could put the that could let those Underwriters and those managers lose their job so they're going to be very strict especially right now on what they're looking at and what they're interested in entertaining because if if they feel like hey there's going to be a severity problem you know how high of a claim can be and then they add a frequency to that there's more than one in a year or more than a couple in a a certain time frame I mean you're you're going to be in a very difficult situation and then if you don't have insurance you're you're out so a couple things I don't know how much time you you have or you can let me go on this um if you are an emerging Fleet there's a few policies that you can you you may not be familiar with that we can talk about right the traditional policy guaranteed cost everybody's familiar with that here's your price that you pay for the year if you don't make any changes right let's say it's $88,000 a truck all right you have 10 trucks you're paying $80,000 for all the coverages that's guaranteed cost okay so that's what you're familiar with let's talk about a large deductible or kind of a self-insurance policy okay these are more common as you get in a higher vehicle um Fleet situation where you're sharing the cost of insurance okay a typical situation would be your deductible would be $25,000 right so you're sharing the cost to repair any of these vehicles potentially a liability claim as well you're going to pay the first 25,000 and they'll pay everything after that but it's very common on a physical damage situation insurance companies love that because yeah right now the risk is transferred back to the to the customer exactly and you could say hey I like my maintenance guys I like my area of operations we don't get in a lot of accidents around town right let's say you're in Florida but you're not Miami you're in the Northwest right and you're you don't get into a lot of accidents you could negotiate and say I want a higher deductible right than what we currently have and you could go25 5,000 very common you could go as high as you want so long as you can afford that if if multiple Vehicles were getting into an accident you don't go out of business right that is a really good cost savings method for negotiating your insurance policy at renewal for these lower Fleet guys right okay that's number one number two if you're not familiar with what a captive insurance program is you need to find out what that is not everybody qualifies not everybody is a good fit for it but it is incredible way to typically when you find somebody in a captive they will never leave that situation like period and just to explain what a captive is so let's say Brandon and Brandon right here we we share we have a similar company we have 100 trucks each we're going to go and self-insure each other right so we're going to put a million dollars in every year for insurance so there's $2 million that goes towards insurance payments on physical damage liability whatever that is right um if we have a good year and don't have many claims we could get up to 40% of that money that we've paid in to Insurance back at the end of the year so that's a 30C explanation of what a captive insurance program is there's a number of very popular ones Great West has a really good one uh Wheels there's a number of of captive Trucking specific captive programs out there now here's the deal it's like a dating a dating site right like you have to absolutely dress your company up and you have to make your put on lipstick on every driver you got to make sure you're showing the best of yourself because they don't have to let you in their Club yeah and you have to be big enough you have to pay enough premium it have to has to make enough sense to add you but then on the other end they're going to say look your claims affect me and so they don't want anybody that's just going to be flying by the seat of their pants that has you know no real plan or no real culture and they're really going to make sure each member is kind of the insurance underwriter and they take it personal yeah and then you know they have their uh yearly visit in the Cayman they all fly their their planes too it's a kind of a cool deal but um well the other good thing with captives that I've seen uh because we we work with a lot of them is that most of them will will also be there as a resource to these fleets obviously everybody's interests are align in terms of minimizing the occurrence of non-compliance and accidents and so what that means practically is that they'll bring in resources and then make those available for captive members whether it's you know some kind of Technology deals on technology deals on cameras for for trucks or deals on compliance Services uh from from Consultants or like us or or whatever that captives are great it seems like from an outsider's perspective of of providing those Resources with the hope of making all of the members uh better from a safety and compliance standpoint yeah so that if you've never heard of that uh talk to your agent talk to us whoever you need to talk to look into it if you have enough in premium you may qualify you it could take you a couple years to qualify and then there's a decent amount of investment involved but once you're fully vested once you're a couple years in uh it's tough to beat I mean there's no way they're exiting unless they're kicked out okay if if we're going to a more established Fleet couple things number one you have to know your stats you have to know where your claims are happening so let's say all claims are H or 90% of claims happening on reverse right so I've I've seen a company that it's not a trucking company contractor Builder 90% of their claims were when they were reversing so they never uh reversed out of a parking spot if they ever parked they had to reverse into that parking spot and they would pull forward out of it and that's all they talked about for 30 minutes of every meeting it was like how to reverse out how to pull forward out of your parking spot right but for most trucking companies uh for most large fleets you got to know where your claims are happening firste drivers are typically no matter how much experience they have the largest risk of a claim right how do you improve that process right ups only turns right so many of these different companies do little things in their operations that take away a large portion of their claims so identify what's happening in every single claim it's monotonous it's difficult your insurance agent should help you line up all the claims you've had in a certain time frame and say you know categorize it right was it what did the driver do where did they mess up where did we mess up was it a maintenance thing and then make one big change to fix that right and see how it affects it we talk about this on the compliance side too looking for Trends because if you find a trend a negative Trend in your compliance data that's the thing you need to tackle first and get control of that Trend and then you can worry about the other things that are contributing less to your high CSA scores for example if you if You Buck the trend that is that is the name of the game I mean and that that's going to give you the most brownie points for your insurance carrier for I'm sure upper management they're going to see wow that was a big change you know from there it's just small changes and then this last thing is for everybody there has been an increase an incredible uptick in issues with SMS scores and their their Federal I you know you were talking about it earlier today I think the federal government is uh inadequate at best at tracking safety for each carrier for carriers in general but there has been an incredible uptick on incorrect assignments to dot numbers on safety scores and it's it's really added a lot of extra work on our end on the insurance agent side because we have to we go back to the carrier and say you know take us through these situations and they said those situations never happen all right well now we got to go to dataq we got to take those off we got to adjust those well if you only have a couple weeks left to Renewal we're in a tough spot yeah so it's not getting done in that time frame no and so you for a fleet and for a small carrier check your public records check everything that's going under your do these guys I think these state troopers are overwhelmed they're putting the wrong dot numbers in they're putting the wrong information in and that's going against your score we've had this year I don't know why this year for whatever reason a an incredible increase in incorrect safer scores and um you know almost all insurance carriers they just take a quick you know of their 10 things they look at safer scores one of them and they just take a quick view of where they're at and then they rate the the company and it could go you know up for no reason so that's a big thing that everybody needs to be checking on that yeah at least monthly uh those right the the the system updates monthly and so you need to be checking what data has been put on your so it it drives me crazy how many fleets I talk with don't even know about SMS um and it makes sense for some fleets that that don't have a ton of inspections but if you've got any if you've got a sizable Fleet and your trucks are getting pulled over for inspections you need you better be sure you understand what violations are being put into the system because those are driving up your scores and those scores are are used by so many not just Insurance they're used by your customers your your broker and shipper customers to determine whether they want to do business with you uh they're certainly used by the plaintiff's bar if God for you get involved in a bad accident so yeah you got to be watching that stuff yeah and even if you're plugging along and no inspections you don't know how many are being put under your dot erroneously right and it's so it's so odd it's happening quite a bit now and so you just have to be checking it yeah well Brandon we're out of time uh we could have talked about that probably for two more hours so we'll have to have you back on at some point for sure um but before we leave here where where could folks find you find out more information about UCI so they can get into touch with you if they have any questions yeah check us out you can check us out online www. United commmercial insurance.com United commercial insurance.com you can search Us on YouTube also Facebook and Instagram uh LinkedIn and then 208 229 8222 uh yeah would love to help you out give us a call awesome well thanks so much for joining me really appreciate it we're going to wrap it up here everybody uh thanks so much for tuning in uh stay tuned for updates on future shows you can check all out all of our past episodes over at trucksafe live.com submit new show ideas if you've got any of those we'd love to hear from you um what else we got going on we mentioned a lot of the stuff that we got going on up up up front at this of this episode so uh if there's anything we can ever do for you don't hesitate to reach out and we'll happy we'll be happy to jump in and help out as we can thanks everybody we'll catch you next time I