Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 42 - Top Industry Issues 2024

Wednesday, October 16, 2024 at 3:40 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 42 - Top Industry Issues 2024

About This Event

In this episode, the Trucksafe team breaks down ATRI’s recently-announced Top Industry Issues from 2024, including topics like truck parking, the economy, driver compensation, lawsuit abuse, speed limiters, and much more!

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 42 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman, Rob Carpenter, and Brian Runnels discuss the American Transportation Research Institute's (ATRI) annual Top Industry Issues report for 2024, announced at the ATA's Management Conference and Exhibition in Nashville. This report, which surveys both truck drivers and motor carriers to identify their most pressing concerns, serves as an important industry barometer that fleet safety professionals can use to benchmark their own priorities and strategic planning. Before diving into the ATRI report, the hosts cover several notable regulatory developments. The U.S. Department of Transportation published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on October 15, 2024, proposing to allow electronic signatures, electronic forms, and electronic storage for drug and alcohol testing records under Part 40 — a long-overdue update that would bring these records in line with the electronic recordkeeping allowances already in place for other safety-related documents. The hosts also discuss FMCSA's upcoming registration modernization stakeholder meeting, which previews a new system that would eliminate MC numbers in favor of a single USDOT number, as well as a standalone bill in Congress that would expand the Pre-Employment Screening Program (PSP) beyond hiring purposes to allow carriers to run driver history reports at any time with proper consent. Turning to the ATRI report, the hosts highlight key differences between what truck drivers and motor carriers identified as their top concerns. Truck parking ranked as the number one issue for drivers, with the hosts noting that inadequate infrastructure, changes in freight patterns resulting in more trucks operating in smaller regional areas, and reduced hours-of-service flexibility have all contributed to the problem. Motor carriers ranked the economy as their top issue, with ATA economist Bob Costello projecting modest growth of approximately 1.9 percent for 2024 and a similar outlook for 2025. Lawsuit abuse reform ranked second for motor carriers, reflecting the ongoing threat of nuclear verdicts and staged accident schemes, while driver compensation ranked second for drivers — a concern the hosts tie directly to how freight patterns have changed and how pay structures have failed to keep pace. The hosts emphasize that many of the top issues for motor carriers are deeply interconnected. Rising insurance costs, which increased 12.4 percent year-over-year even as other operational costs remained flat or declined, are closely linked to lawsuit abuse trends. CSA scores, which ranked sixth on the motor carrier list, were described by the hosts as an underlying factor that touches nearly every other issue on the list, from driver retention and insurance renewability to maintenance scores and regulatory scrutiny. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to view CSA performance not as a standalone compliance metric but as a reflection of overall operational culture. Actionable takeaways for fleet safety professionals include reviewing and updating distracted driving policies to address a broad range of distractions beyond cell phones, monitoring the DOT's proposed rulemaking on electronic drug and alcohol testing records as it moves through the comment and finalization process, and staying informed on PSP expansion legislation that could change how and when driver history reports are used. The hosts also recommend that carriers assess how driver compensation structures may be contributing to unsafe behaviors such as log falsification, particularly for short-haul and hourly-paid drivers. Fleets are encouraged to visit trucksafe.us to learn more about Trucksafe's compliance resources, including their micro DOT audits and the eRegs digital regulatory platform.

Full Transcript

up pap up up if you're like us you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regular ation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after IGS is the first web and mobile app version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations ereg is always up to dat and allows Fleet Safety professionals to not only read the rules but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts highlight bookmark and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules ereg was developed by safety Professionals for safety professionals try it out for free at .a oh hey everyone welcome to episode 42 of truck safe live the show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs got Brian Reynolds Rob Carpenter with me today hey guys hey hey you sound excited man I told Brian right before we got on the not to get too excited cuz his mic uh his mic sounds terrible when he when he gets too excited so he's keeping it calm for me easily distort so what's been going on guys what anything uh exciting going on this past week or so I know Brian you were at the you were at the but Rob's was more important let him start yeah Rob we want to talk to you about it last week but you were in the middle of doing it so tell us a little bit about some of the uh the emergency relief work that you had been doing yeah so we um I'm on a sheriff's office board here in in Yorktown and one of the things we got together with a local roofing company and did was just gather as much as we could and then we got some donations from from other places I think all in all we had like 100,000 pounds that we took down to Hickory for um a location at Hickory airport next to ASU so they were kind of stockpiling everything at ACU which was feeding these aircrafts which was good because it was constantly being sent out and flown out so so you didn't have the stockpile issues that you have in other places so um then we took some to Damascus and then we took some to uh Bristol Speedway so nice good good little haul of stuff yeah you did that for several days did you yeah yeah I took my kids along so it was a it became a family event I needed help sorting after I didn't expect the turnout that we got and then you know when you get that much stuff you got to sort it so it was it was an event for sure did you get a passenger authorization for your kids no I didn't they did you're coming whether you want to or not whether someone else want you to or not all right well that's cool yeah uh thanks for doing that um Brian we'll talk about ATA here in a little bit that's kind of the main topic of today's show today we're talking about uh the American Transportation research institutes recently announced um top industry issues for 2024 this is something they do every year and uh Brian was live and in person at the ata's conference MCE conference in Nashville right it was in Nashville yep and that's where they announced it this year so that's what we're going to get into a little bit later in the show today before we do that I want to say as always thanks to the sponsor of today's show sorry Rob this is over your face uh taking the high road a legacy Builders and freightways production taking the higher road is a special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and compliance each week host Jeremy rmer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle check them out wherever you get your podcast thanks to taking the higher Road I think he was at MCE wasn't he Brian yeah and you know what I one of the things that he's doing now uh is and and I think it's important to get it out there just for the awareness is this project 61 yeah uh the average life expectancy for a truck driver show that thing off yeah yeah yeah proud of wearing it I got my my new uh Fitness tracker and everything so I could get on the uh get on the the board I think there's about 300 people on this shared group uh just trying to bring awareness to what health and fitness for truck drivers like I said the average life expectancy is 61 years old and crazy as a 20-year veteran uh of being over the road rob you it too man it you think dang I'm in my I'm in my well I'm in my 50s I don't know if you are not I can't remember but you know thinking about that it it's scary it's scary and there there needs to be some changes made throughout the whole industry to you know get that number much higher so follow that it's a good good yeah they're doing like a step step challenge I think starting November 1 I think rob you already signed up for that Brian you probably have already as well I need to get signed up for it but uh yeah pretty cool thing that Jeremy's doing so be sure to check that out project 61 if you haven't already um couple other things going on um as always if you haven't joined our trucksafe compliance Network yet be sure to do that this is free to join over at trucksafe network.com or you can scan the QR code there or download the app in the app store or the Google Play Store this is our online space for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also access all of our DOT related content we do a lot of network exclusive content like our webinar seven-part webinar series that we're in the middle of still all about how to improve CSA scores so a lot of valuable information in the network again free to join we'd love to have you over there uh trucksafe network.com also be sure to check out our online courses over at trucksafe academy.com we've got all kinds of online courses that we've developed for safety managers and for drivers we're working on a whole new set of driver courses that that Brian and I worked on here recently Rob worked on helping us develop the content for it so looking forward to pushing that out here soon uh trucksafe academy.com and then also on our last show we mentioned a couple new services that we've uh started to offer and uh if you're interested check it out on our website or uh just give us a a ring um first is our micro do audits uh these are um as the name suggests they are Miniature versions of our standard do mock do audits that we have done for years at this point uh we had a lot of fleets come to us and say hey we want something like that but not quite as extensive as You' being in my facility for two or three days so uh these micro audits are going to make it uh easier for us to get to a lot more fleets and spend uh uh less time looking at them but still enough time to uh dig into Key Safety metrics and and take a look a small sample of your driver records and your hours of service records and stuff like that kind of give you a quick checkup on your DOT compliance and make sure there are no uh glaring holes in it so uh we got that coming up and then our boot camp on the road coming off of our uh truck safe boot camp that we held a few weeks ago we had a lot of uh interest in us doing like private versions of that um for like Insurance Groups or fleets that have you know own team that they wanted to go through that or put through that training and so we're going to start we're going to take it on the road we're going to go do these private training events for anybody that's interested uh again we're calling that boot camp on the road so get in contact with with us if you're interested in either of those two services and we will be glad to jump in and and help you out um anything else I'm missing guys on truck safe related stuff I don't think so unless you want to touch on e-s again EGS anybody uh hopefully saw that uh little intro video that we have playn at the beginning of the uh the episode here but check out ereg it's uh first app-based digital version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations that we spent several years building developing and uh uh finally launched it earlier this year it's a tool a good resource for uh anybody in a Fleet Safety role um to be able to not only read a digital version of the regulations but also access right next to the regulations all of our educational content to help you better understand what it is that you're reading and also to be able to share digitally uh those regulations with your drivers so that they are on top of all of the regulatory requirements so ere. apppp AP check that out all right that's a lot about us uh hey if you're here with us uh live say hey in the comments so we know who's here uh always like to see who's joining us if you have any questions or any comments as we go along as always be sure to throw them in the comments and we'll get to them as we go all right couple of uh important things going on here in the industry safety and compliance related that's worth talking about first we mentioned this on our last show um but I'll mention it again the FMCSA is going to be holding what it's calling a registration modernization stakeholder meeting on October 21st they are doing this in person in DC at their headquarters and then also so uh if you're interested in attending virtually there's a link on their website for you to register for that event again October 21st in the afternoon and this is like a sneak peek look at their new registration system that they are in the process of building to modernize it um anybody who's gotten a DOT number recently within the last several years uh may be familiar with their unified registration system URS system and um like I said last show that thing is showing its age at this point it is it is uh it is a little rough around the edges to say the least so looking forward to seeing what they're going to roll out here soon to take its place uh this is also going to as I understand it see the end to MC numbers we're no longer going to have MC numbers we're only going to have us do numbers and that will uh be the number that designates you not only for safety purposes but also so if you're a authorized motor carrier that will be the one number you use to identify your your motor carrier Authority as well uh or broker Authority so be on the lookout for that again if you want to take a look at it uh see how it's going to function that type of stuff check out that uh meeting coming up on October 21st um the other thing I saw come through recently uh in fact yesterday I believe was this this notice from the US do um this is a long time coming uh folks who are day in and day out in the safety regulations will know that for many years now I think probably 10 years if not more the FMCSA has allowed motor carriers to uh generate and to keep safety related records electronically and to obtain digital signatures on the things that the safety regulations require so things like uh uh what's a good example guys um road tests can be done electronically basically anything the safety regulations require in terms of paperwork the safety regulations have for about 10 years allowed motor carriers to keep that stuff electronically um DQ files and all sorts of stuff you DQ files everything but but but the one hold out has always been the drug and alcohol testing record so like the chain of custody forms everything that's mandated by part 40 of uh of title 49 of the code of federal regulations there hasn't been a an electronic recordkeeping allowance or digital signature allowance under those rules why is that that's because those rules are not uh overseen by the FMCSA they're not they're not enacted by the FMCSA they are enacted by the US do which is the parent of the FMCSA because they apply not just a truck driver but all modes of transportation airline pilots railroad workers that type of stuff so they have just been slow to the game when it comes to electronic record keeping what that has meant for Trucking fleets is that even though you've been able to keep all your other safety records electronically uh whether you know it or not the drug and alcohol testing documents are different um there has been no electronic recordkeeping allowance for them and so long story short here the do is finally making some Moves In This regard they have published a notice of proposed rule making as of yesterday October 15 2024 uh published a notice of proposed rulemaking proposing to amend its regulations to conduct uh for conducting workplace drug and alcohol testing for federally regulated Transportation industry to allow but not require electronic signatures on documents required to be created and utilized under the regulations uh the use of electronic forms and the electronic storage of forms and data so I think that's a good develop um and uh yeah guys any thoughts on that seems like a no-brainer to me yeah that's definitely a positive no I was gonna say everything else is already there so it you know makes sense yeah as far as the the the one last thing I'm going to add to it's not really particularly to this one but I spoke to somebody this week that the PSP for a long time you know folks have been wanting to drop the world the word pre employment out of it yeah and I don't know of how many because I didn't realize it but there's actually a standalone bill that's sitting on the floor of Congress right now to do just that uh it's not mixed in with a whole bunch of other stuff uh so there's not a lot of the idea being to allow carriers to use it for purposes other than just hiring yeah yeah it would it would just be kind of like inquiries on the the Clearing House as far as if you got the right consent form you can run them at will and so that I think that I think that makes sense it never really made sense to me that you could only use that for for hiring purposes the PSP the pre-employment screening program for folks not familiar with it is the FMCSA administered system that keeps track of all driver roadside violations and accident data it's essentially akin to CSA scores for the motor carrier this is the driver version of that that ties violations and accidents to particular drivers and then anybody who is interested in seeing that data for a particular driver usually uh subsequent employers of that driver they can run a PSP report if they get consent from the driver they have to pay for it currently it's not required uh but it does cost something um and they run the report and they will be able to get a report of all uh you know commercial violations and and that type of stuff what happened to Brian here Brian's fruit hold on one second adding Brian back in but that's right but anyway carriers can run those reports uh but yeah historically up until this point they have been uh only for pre-employment hiring purposes technically carriers cannot run keep losing Brian technically they can't run those reports uh anytime other than than onboarding so yeah that just never made much sense to me so maybe they are looking to expand it and if so great um yeah can you can you hear me you just can't see me I can hear you but we can't see you cool um it's got bipartisan support um but the one thing that that I found out also this week when you look at the number of bills that have been passed in this particular Congress it's like 80 and typic the number's up around 300 so they're not making a lot of steps to do much of anything in this particular Congress cycle but yeah it's sitting out there and then I think this would be a positive positive deal yeah I just don't have much faith in Congress anymore wonder why yeah okay well move on hey Brian try and join again uh because I want to get your video up if we can uh Rob I saw this come through I know you posted something about this and so I thought I'd show it but um well first of all this was uh musk yeah musk uh first of all hopefully everybody saw this pretty incredible uh launch from earlier this week did you see this Rob yeah I've never really got into this whole Space thing until SpaceX actually started but um I mean I think one of the things that I took away from it that was probably more important than the actual event was that you know Elon musk is kind of what his team makes him so you're picking the right people it's it's going to get you where you want to go yeah this is just nuts to me they land for folks just listening in they landed this like 250 ton rocket they caught it in midair with like these Chopstick things uh it was just incredible to watch so pretty crazy yeah and then the other thing I saw you did post about this Rob um elon's tweeting that uh his prediction is that Within 50 years All Transport will be fully autonomous what are your thoughts on that well I think you know working with different companies that I work with on the autonomous side and you work with autonomous companies on on on the overall truck safe side I mean just the as far as we've gotten in just a few years it it would be hard pressed not to be there in 50 years or maybe even 30 years but um it just it's progressed so much so fast already and uh it's only getting better all the time well I say better but uh it's getting more advanced let's put it that way so yeah yeah because I saw that other event that Elon did right before they landed that rocket where they were rolling out their new like uh taxi fully autonomous taxi service with cars and uh Vans they they look pretty crazy definitely they've been running those things around Phoenix for what three four years now that wh product there's a few others as well yeah and if you've ever been in one quite honestly once you get over the the shock of not having a driver in it that thing is computer trained to keep following distance and keep speed and things like that you you actually get to feel more safe in it than you do with you know a typical Uber driver yeah I haven't ridden in one have you guys ridden in one of those yeah yeah there's a beep bus too um beep is down I mean they've got some government contracts now like Yellowstone Park and you can Rite I've ridden theirs down in Orlando but um I mean just getting here it was a feat right so I think 30 50 years from now if we're still here yeah I mean that's a long way off lots of stuff could happen in between sure um so yeah we'll have to wait and see how that progresses I know in trucking alone autonomy is a big topic of of discussion the FMCSA and Nitsa uh which is the agency that regulates manufacturers of uh vehicles uh they have been in talks for many years now to push forward some regulations on autonomous uh commercial Motor Vehicles which they have not done to date even though we have autonomous trucks running uh throughout the country namely in Texas in and around Texas is where you see them most often um but they're a little bit behind the the ball on moving forward with those regulations right now there just aren't any regulations and so there's some informal guidance from FMCSA and from nits on that topic but uh I would have to imagine that those regulations are going to be coming out sooner than later it's always on the agenda it's just uh they can never get the thing across the finish line so all has from SAE I think SAE is probably the most advanced in terms of like what's going on in the autonomous world so they're the ones that set the different levels of auton autonomy right yeah yeah what were you gonna say Brian well they they've started putting some like operational guidances in um like you were talking about with cvsa like the one they were talking about this week was um triangles safety triangles oh yeah you know how how exactly do you manage that if the trucks broke down on the side of the road so they they're starting to put in play and looking at the different regulations that they're going to have to Tinker with to to make it autonomous friendly yeah um and and starting starting that process plus inspections like how how are the roadside inspections of those things going to play out uh and also rules about uh rules for the folks that are back in the office remotely controlling those things like they're talking do those folks need to be subject to hours of service rules and drug and alcohol test Tes in um and so there's a lot of a lot of things to think about I know Brian you and I talked about on past shows you know if once we get to that level right now we're in a stage where so many of the violations and so much of the exposure we see and trucking comes from the driver side of things with drivers either not having the right license or not complying with the hours of service rules or being impaired and that type of stuff and once we get uh once the scales start to tip in favor of of autonomous vehicles it's like it's going to be a seismic shift towards more vehicle maintenance type issues and products liability type stuff more so than the drivers obviously so it'll be interesting to see how that plays out yeah that there was a vendor uh this week that was right next to where we were I um I was there with TVC and they do these sensors that go on the inside of tires not on the inside on the wheel they do have that option but these are actually attached to the tire and they measure everything from tread depth to heat to air pressure um and he he pointed it out that you know they're looking more towards the the autonomous vehicles vehicle maintenance uh than the actual person driven I mean it's still a great product for them too but it's aimed at the less Truck Yeah well yeah it makes total sense that we're going to start to see more and more vendors enter this space that are going to be focused on that um the other thing that came to mind while you're were talking about that because I know on our last show we talked about briefly level eight inspections essentially electronic inspections uh kind of powered by like the DriveWise and the prepass technology and how cvsa is kind of starting to Pilot that in various States uh and with particular carriers but you know that that's probably going to be a big part of inspections for autonomous trucks I would imagine is is having them pass through or pass by one of the receivers and then just uh you know sending digital electronic information um about the fleet and uh and that type of stuff and then the law enforcement can decide whether to pull them over or not I guess that's how it would work if I had to imagine but anyway um all right uh one other thing here this is an article that we released uh or we published earlier this week at truck safe if you're not subscribed to our newsletter recommend you do that we're pushing out a lot of DOT compliance related content videos and articles uh we published one this week titled combating distracted driving and crafting an effective policy this is something that came up pretty frequently uh during our boot camp uh Brian did a whole presentation on policies and guidance at fleets and it spurred a lot of good questions and we have a lot of fleets that approach us to kind of look through their policies uh and give our thoughts about it and one that comes up pretty frequently are distracted driving policies and do we need one what does it need to entail what uh you know what are the different types of distractions that we need to address and how do we handle it if our drivers are found in violation of the policy so we kind of laid it all out in this most recent article that is up on our website and we also have a video on it on our YouTube channel so be sure to check that out I mean distraction continually ranks up there as one of the top contributors to um accidents serious accidents so it's a big problem I know rob you talk about it a lot on on uh on your social media and uh yeah big problem that we need to get control of um not not just drivers this isn't just a driver problem this is a a problem that goes all the way up to the carriers as well sometimes the carriers are the worst offenders at causing distractions with all of the messages that they're sending out to their drivers and so uh check out that article if you haven't already um yeah distracted driving man seems like we can never really get uh get our arms wrapped around that that's GNA be one of the big I think that's going to be one of the big um programs that ATA does this coming years they were looking for ideas and suggestions and thoughts behind what what would a good distracted driving program look like or uh and so you know a lot lot of good ideas came up and it's obviously just not the phones anymore they no it came up to what you're talking about all the messages coming in the interactions between company and driver and then you've got your your Tik Tok and your videos and movies and it it's just wide open of all the different types of distractions that are out there Rob you've got like terabytes of video of your drivers in the past doing some crazy stuff while they're behind the wheel don't you you know weird thing that I did last year was there was a girl that got killed she was like 24 like last August and I I went into the company and I looked at their video footage the 30 days post that crash and you're thinking hey as a carrier who was just involved with a fatality that they clearly caused we know they caused it um that you would like mine your p's and q's absolutely for at least a period right but for that 30-day period it didn't actually decrease it increased it was as if it it was of no consequence so um it's crazy to see some of the videos and and how frequently it happens so it's it's one thing to know it exists but it's another thing completely to to manage it and to manage it effectively so it's it can be a tough thing to manage simply because the scalability that you need to be able to manage it so it takes people takes people a lot of people in some cases yeah I mean as we're constantly preaching it all it takes is one of those bad accidents uh caused by Distraction to you know completely screw up your trucking company truck or bus company um and and that's a regular contributor to the so-called nuclear verdicts that we see uh coming up more and more frequently so yeah again uh we can't overstress how big of a problem that is um and as Brian said not just not just cell phones and texting anymore those are still a big problem obviously and and a lot of fleets and drivers don't realize that that that's baked into the regulations now that if you get convicted of texting while driving or using a handheld device while driving um what is it twice in a three-year period you're going to be disqualified from driving a commercial motor vehicle for a period of time not just fines you're you're going to you're not going to be able to drive anymore and then it just you know the consequences go up from there so uh important to get a hold of and um yeah uh we've got a lot of thoughts on that topic so um if you have any questions about your particular policy on that topic or uh anything like that feel free to give us a shout um okay so moving into the topic of today which is uh again the atre's uh annual list of top industry issues was announced at the ATA conference earlier this week Brian was in attendance so Brian you want to give us a kind of a report of the conference overall what you you know you know what you saw what sessions they had what was the conference like who attended that type of stuff sure yeah so this is their big management conference that happens every year uh like you said it was down in Nashville it's filled with uh educational sessions guest speakers Chris spear always gives his kind of the state of the industry address um there's an always an economic piece to it uh yeah that's taken from where our booth was uh like I said I was there with TVC Pro driver and um you know they Carl Rove spoke and it that was an interesting one kind kind of like what what can you expect from trunk Trucking inside of broken politics so that you know you know that was that was interesting um I'm on the I'll bring up the slide for that because you sent us the slide maybe it's kind of related to that yeah this was from the the uh the safety policy committee I'm on that committee and this just kind of went into what can you expect or what they think you could expect depending on which side gets in and you know a couple of the the big ones is the for California drivers and companies operating in California's theirs on the hours of service um the the Democrats don't want to preempt that they want to follow that that California meal and rest rules and the on the Republican side they want to go more towards what the federal man the federal rules are so that that's probably the biggest thing there uh the side underride guard protection that is you know that's something the Democrats would want to look at plus it they'd probably be a lot quicker to rule on the speed limiters than the Republicans would um I think that like anything in business on on the Republican side they'll incentivize um adoption of the the safety Technologies and things like that to where the the Democrats are more for mandates and mandated like with the underride guards and stuff like that to where the Republicans are more interested in a best practice type yeah I mean I think it's you know painting with a broad brush here but generally speaking I think what you can expect with a with the Republican Administration uh when it comes to trucking specifically is usually kind of a roll back of Regulation uh whereas with a democratic uh Administration you tend to see more regulation which is in line with the uh with the mindsets of those two parties anyway so yeah I mean we're coming up on it um you know just a few weeks away from election day here in the United States so yeah we'll have to see how that plays out and whether we end up with yet another FMCSA administrator I think we're on like our eighth or ninth one or 10th one and maybe even more than that I don't know and the agency's only been around since uh 2000 I believe uh no it's been when uh no 2008 I think was when it may been two it's either 2000 or 2008 I don't know why those two dates stand out in my mind but uh very short period of time for that many uh administrators through the FMCSA so kind of like a revolving door so we'll have to because they just put one a new one a Deputy Administrator uh in within the last couple months and so if uh Trump takes office then I have to imagine that we will get yet another FMCSA administrator with his or her own priorities um and then it will certainly influence the agenda when it comes to Ru making so uh yeah be on the lookout for that for sure all right I interrupted you Brian sorry yeah the only the only thing I'll add to that is and I I one of the things that they brought up was whoever gets in you're probably gonna have a divided uh congress senate you know one's going to be Republican one's going to be Democrat so you know with that being said I don't know how much will actually get done but maybe that's not a bad thing either you know we're still waiting on and you know going to atri's deal the the top 10 issues CSA still ranks up there and you know it'll be interesting to see if either side will put any pressure on to get that part of it done so there it is divided between the the that's always an interesting list um how the difference between what the truck drivers said and what the motor carriers said and you know just about anything that atrey does requires drivers and motor carriers and PE stakeholders in the industry to be involved in these um reports so when something comes out get yourself involved and put your put your two cents in because it it does make a difference on this stuff and you know we talked about CSA it's up a couple where I think it was total is eighth but on the motor carrier list it's at Sixth and it's not even on the truck driver list so that tells me a lot every that it's been that way for a couple years now the farther we get away from 2010 when this went into effect the less important it's becoming to drivers now that there are motor carriers out there that do a good job of educating drivers and saying the importance but that is a small microcosm of the industry yeah I mean when CSA was originally pushed out well before it was originally pushed out in 2010 the FMCSA had proposed not only the motor carriers safety measurement system scores the CSA scores but they also proposed what they called a driver safety measurement system dsms uh which would have been a scoring methodology for drivers so drivers would have had CSA scores as well and uh that never got pushed forward the only way it got push forward was in the form of that PSP program which we already talked about uh the pre-employment screening program and so with that being the case the drivers don't get a CSA score it's not all that surprising to me that it doesn't rank up there on the list of of top 10 issues for drivers uh certainly for motor carriers motor carriers feel the pain of their CSA scores pretty much daily at this point so many eyeballs on a carrier CSA score that impact a motor carrier's business whether it be you know the insurance carriers or Brokers or customers looking at CSA scores or certainly law enforcement or FMCSA looking at it the plaintiff's bar everybody wants to know how the carrier is performing relative to their peers from a safety compliance standpoint and CSA is the way to do that and if you have poor CSA scores you're going to lose business you're going to be escalated for audit you're going to potentially uh lose contracts and uh yeah it's going to cause a lot of problems so uh yeah no no surprise there but just to set up this list a little bit before we dig into it a little bit more uh again American Transportation Research Institute is a kind of a a nonprofit body that studies a lot of issues in the transportation industry um and they put out a lot of good reports each year um as Brian said there's a lot of participants in all of their studies they do a really good job of getting a good uh cross-section of of um uh of the industry when it comes to responses to their surveys and stuff like that and so they're the ones for example that put out the nuclear verdict study that we are always referencing in in most of our content um but they do this particular particular study which is the top industry issues every year and uh they put out this list as Brian said they split it in between what are the top what are the top 10 issues as reported by truck drivers and what are the top 10 issues as reported by motor carriers and the list that we're showing on the screen right now is uh those two lists right next to each other so you could see which issues are important to drivers as compared to motor carriers and vice versa so this was announced at the ATA conference earlier this week so so uh you can see here number one the number one issue for motor carriers in 2024 is the economy no surprise there and then the number one issue for truck drivers is truck parking so I'm interested to get your guys' thoughts on uh on those two issues Rob I know you just put out a an article I think on truck parking recently yeah I I've never I I I guess uh I understand like the concern of not wanting to pay for it you know no driver wants to spend more money than they have to especially the fact that we're already paying know how many people have ever been to a truck stop but last time I went to a truck stop was about two months ago I bought a half a turkey sandwich on wheat and two energy drinks and a water and it was $27 so when you're paying that kind of price you're you're thinking that all right well for that price I should be able to park for free um maybe it's the wheat bread that screwed you it was I guess but uh I mean Mikes would have been cheaper but um and it wasn't good so but you know the driver mindset goes to if I'm paying this much all right fine I'm paying this much but I'm paying that much to have parking overnight so I can stay here and um so I kind of emphasize with EMP empathize with that but um on the other hand there's the The Dilemma of paying to park with like truck parking club and some of the other groups that are that are you know charging people to park and I think the issue there is coming where they're going to places that are historically free is the argument and they're turning historically free parking into paid parking and that's where I think is that true because my understanding of it was that they were finding new places that were not even parking beforehand that's the marketing side of it but uh they are I bought into their marketing yeah yeah they are parking you know they are partnering with certain truck stops and places that are all already free or have historically been free um and they're they're kind of turning it into paid but truck stops had already started going that route before you know we have Reserve parking I've never had to pay for parking ever in 20 years so um a lot of it for me goes to trip planning and and I think some of that goes to the difference in driver Persona from like a let's just say a pre2 2005 licensed driver that really planned their trip they kind of knew where they were going to stop versus what we have now today where it's like tell me where to stop tell me where to go um so some of it is I'm split on uh like I think sometimes you need to take the initiative to figure it out and then if you don't figure it out you're going to let someone else figure it out for you you need to be prepared to pay for that convenience so yeah um you just have to be able to self-reflect and say Hey you know somebody's gonna find my parking for me I need to pay them for it yeah what about you Brian Brian and Rob are both drivers in in the past so yeah I I agree with Rob on the point of you know you you plan your trips out the best you can it nothing's 100% And I get that and it's easier definitely easier in the areas that I I drove I I was a guy that went from Ohio West and uh terminals for me were in the worst Parts as far as parking Seattle Portland you know I had terminal to go to so it was I I did that on purpose quite honestly and that was part of the reason why now I will say that states like Indiana they've invested in quite a bit of new truck parking uh if you I don't know if either one of you guys have seen that the new facility up on 65 just south of maraville good Heavens that that new Welcome Center is enormous and I know some of the other states are are doing things like that and the federal government has put out quite a bit of money for states to do this it's not an overnight might fix um and by the time we get it it'll probably we'll probably have outgrown it but at least we're we're doing something but you know yeah the truck parking is is a huge issue the the other part of that issue is too by and large the industry Works mostly days now um and you know there isn't the flexibility in the hours of service I'm that's an argument we can keep going back to but you know there there that flexibility isn't what it used to be to be able to to move in the we hours and you know run a little bit later because you took you were able to take a decent enough break and so I I think flexibility do you mean your second log book no I didn't I didn't have to go that far uh it's just you know I I could the old five and five split or something like that you know I going through Chicago you know if if I saw that I was if I didn't have three hours to get from south to North all right I'll stop I could take a four or five hour nap wait till 900 pm. instead of going in there at 5:00 pm and get through there in an hour and a half that flexibility is not there anymore so now you just got the 73 or 82 split yeah yeah if you know how to do it and quite honestly it's it's a lot easier now than what it was cuz you know the the El will do it for you but yeah once again that comes back to trip planning knowing that okay this is what I'm going to hit up there I either stay here and take a break or I go up as close as I can get and take some sort of break and not burn all that time going through there so you know still our number one top performing video of all time is our split sleeper birth video and Freight quite honestly I I've preached on this now for a long time Freight has changed Freight is much more regionalized it's much more 250 miles at a shot than 500 miles at a shot so you've got more trucks in a smaller area than you've ever had because they're not they're not running as many miles so it takes almost two trucks now to do what one truck did pre 2010 20 whatever that is back when Rob and I were really driving hard you you've got double the amount of trucks doing the same amount of miles so that also means you've got double the amount of trucks trying to find a place to park in a more congested area the go ahead Rob go ahead Brandon I'll remember mine I was just gonna say the um the other thing that I'm just thinking out loud here and I know this is a ways off um if we ever get there but maybe if for nothing else autonomous Trucking will help out with the parking issue a little bit by by taking the number of uh uh of trucks with drivers off the road obviously that comes at at a big cost I realize that as I'm saying those words is uh the benefit of that is is the uh less of a need for parking but the cost of that is fewer drivers so you're going to get canell I'm not going to get Rob you're if anybody's going to get us canell it's going to be you oh yeah the HR piece has to come in somewhere to monitor Rob um no but one of the things that also got a little contentious was um gated ins signed lots and that's one of the things that I always thought was a good benefit of front parking Club because a lot of like those private parking locations are gated and signed private property and you know when I was coming back from Indiana I I still have the videos from it from the dash cam and I tried to stop and talk to one of the state troopers because as I passed it was literally a State Trooper sitting beside every truck going into this parking this public parking lot and they were knocking on the door waking them up and pulling them into the rest area to do a to do a full roadside so I pulled in and said hey you know can I talk to you when you're finished with that and he's like I can't talk about it you got to talk to our media guy but you know I always thought that was a benefit because you instead of parking at you know on that on or off ramp or public parking where it's publicly accessible Highway um where people can get to you you can actually go park at you know a private gated signed lot and you've kind of got some protection there I think yeah makes sense um the other one that was so the that was the number one issue for truck drivers for 2024 and then for motor carriers the number one issue was the economy uh Brian I know you you're giving us an update I think ata's Bob Costello uh who's an economist I think uh he he kind of gave an update you want to kind of relay that information yeah the the long and the short of it and you know definitely paraphrasing what what Bob said is the economy is going to go back to normal or you know he's predicting that it's going to go back to normal pre 20109 uh because after 20 2019 thing has the econom the economy has been in disarray first for the positive and then for the negative and now things are kind of leveling out um he stated that the the US economy grows at about a 2% rate every year and it looks like 2024 is going to be at like 1.9 and they're predicting he's predicting about the same for 2025 um there's sectors of manufacturing and stuff that are up there's stuff that are that's that's down uh I think the the durable goods I think that was up and the non-durable goods were down um and so it's nothing really exciting to report you know we're not going to see a total boom as far as Trucking goes but things are going to look a little bit better you know and you know interest rates have come down a little bit so that is that's got maybe the housing piece moving a little bit again um because there wasn't anything being built when we were at 7% or 8% but now I think sheet of plywood were like a hundred bucks yeah right so now we're down to 5% and you know maybe the house the housing will start up again and that's one of the three big sectors for Trucking is construction yeah so you know that it was a mixed bag but nothing really exciting and it's still something to be worried about okay all right number two on the list for truck drivers was driver compensation this is something I don't really have a pulse on but what are you guys' take on driver compensation if you have a pulse on it well I definitely have a I I have a feeling on this and the driver compensation is suffering for what I just said before Freight has changed however the compensation for drivers hasn't changed meaning how they're getting paid one of Atri reports last year showed that pre25 or something like that it was right around that year it was 2500 miles per truck was the average now we're down at600 miles per truck however the way those drivers are getting paid and quite honestly the amount that they're getting paid hasn't changed all that much so compensation problems are real and and I know some carriers are looking for that alternative way to pay whether it's hourly whether it's by the load whether it's percentage you know there there's a lot of different thoughts behind that um but until we fix how we pay drivers for the most part it's going to be an issue yeah um I haven't done much work in this area but uh but I know that there are many there have been many ways over the years that uh truck and bus companies have have paid drivers um whether it be by the hour or by the mile um uh and it also heavily dependent on what type of Fleet you have whether it's a contractor Fleet or a company driver Fleet and so it seems like fleets are always on the lookout for the the new way to kind of pay drivers and you're kind of balancing several different things with that obviously um trying to make the drivers happy uh trying to make money as a fleet um and uh yeah just a lot that goes into it and uh sounds like it's still up there obviously number two on the on the list of issues for drivers and I imagine that that's going to be perpetually up on the top 10 list for drivers um and the question is going to be where does that land on the motor carrier side I'm looking at it here it's not on the drive uh not on the motor carrier side I think it has been on the motor carrier side in the past but I don't see it up there um this year Rob any thoughts any additional thoughts on driver pay the only one that I have on that is like uh I I've always been more in favor of pay by the hour I mean obviously when I drove getting paid by the mile I'd rather be paid by that but I also had a lot more log books than you're allowed to have now so um in modern day times with RS what they are I think anytime you do like per load pay or per mileage pay it's going to incentivize that that Rogue Outlaw type issue especially with detention time yeah you're not getting paid for sitting there for three hours while you're waiting on the shipper or receiver yeah especially like with uh drivers like port and drage and stuff like that but um the hourly thing has the has the potential to go backwards you know people will possibly milk the clock and then you know to get as much money as they can so it's going to lead to less productive drivers so I think that's always been the argument of a lot of carriers it's like you know I saw this at a I was doing a mock audit for a fleet couple months ago and uh we're looking at logs we're looking at uh actually Time Records for this carriers short Hall drivers and uh one of the things the do does with logs that we do in our Mack dot audits is you check those things for falsification in part by comparing them Against Time Records or bills of lating or whatever you fuel records anything that identifies where a driver was and what they were doing at a particular time of the day that you can cross reference gets their logs and we were I was kind of I had picked my sample of drivers and uh found one guy that um was routinely stealing like three hours of time from this carrier every single day like he he was indicating that he went on duty three hours earlier than he actually did uh when when we started comparing it against the uh supporting documents and so that dude got fired from my mock audit I feel a little bit bad about that for him but not so bad about it for the for the client that had brought me in so yeah that seems to be an issue for sure um all right let's see here Richard's asking a question Richard what are you saying what about people that use inhalers for COPD uh I don't know what you mean by that question um are you saying that uh is that a disqualifying thing under the physical requirements uh I don't know clarify maybe clarify your question and and we can get to it you guys have any idea what he's talking about I don't I've been looking at that one trying to figure it out okay um all right so that was number two for drivers number two for motor carriers is lawsuit abuse reform so this has uh started to creep up on this list over the last several years this is becoming more and more of a problem we saw big news I think it was last year there were like uh I forget how it was over 50 the last time I checked uh people indicted I think for a staged accident in um in uh in Louisiana if I remember correctly yeah where um the state so lawsuit abuse takes several forms including these staged accidents against trucking companies um I think in that case there were lawyers indicted there may have been some insurance folks indicted in this scheme to to defraud the the the carrier and their insurer by staging these accidents and then also these nuclear verdicts that we're seeing um where you know uh this reptilian theory of of liability where the plaintiff's attorneys make the case more about the carrier's reputation than the accident at hand and that leads to these multi-million dollar jury verdicts because the jury gets mad at the carrier for having poor safety metrics and that type of stuff uh an abuse of the legal system uh in many cases and so um it's been a big problem it's becoming a bigger problem and we're starting to see some reform uh it's usually called lawsuit abuse reform or tort reform we're seeing more and more states start to pass legislation on that topic to try and get control of the issue Florida and Texas have have been states that have recently passed that type of legislation uh to try and get control of that issue but um yeah I think that's the solution to it is we got to get control of it um usually through legislation um so anyway no surprise that that's up there uh running out of time here let's at least get to the top five here so oh go ahead Brandon let me let me jump in real quick because I I think I can combine uh some of those if you bring that screen back up number two on the driver's side number two number three no sorry number two number four possibly number five on the motor carrier side those are directly tied to each other they really really are um you know with the lawsuit abuse it makes it harder to get insurance because especially larger carriers where they're trying to build these big towers to protect themselves there's only so many players in the insurance world that will be in those spots on those towers and those companies are leaving left and right out of out of the trucking world because it's not profitable for them yeah um so it on the aty report as far as the operational cost to do business everything was down or stayed the same from last year to this year what like with driver wages and you know all this other stuff except Insurance costs it went up 12.4% yep so even companies that are doing good are still getting hit yeah yeah I was going to say a lot of these are tied to you know I was surprised how far CSA was on the carrier side because the CSA is and and its SMS is is so indicative of how you operate as a carrier how you treat your drivers how you treat your trucks uh what you'll tolerate What You Won't and that that scoring methodology can can often be indicative of how you operate as a carrier which affects like 90% of the things on this list whether it's how long drivers stay with you and whether you can retain them your insurance cost and the ability to renew insurance uh diesel technician shortages and maintenance scores so it's like it affects so many different things on here I'm surprised that it's not at least in the top three so um then again on good no then again on the same token you've got like broker issues is number six under truck drivers when truck drivers not don't always I don't think understand it's often the truck drivers that are undercutting other truck drivers so I think to some extent there was an ignorance into who actually responded to this thing on both sides yeah any surprises from your perspective Brian with the with the list either the truck drivers or the carriers well I It's Curious to me on the truck driver side that they're worried about the truck the the training standards and um I just I find that yeah what are they even talking about there yeah you know I think a lot of truck drivers that respond to your point Rob are probably owner operators so yes the broker issues is a big big deal to them and maybe that's the same thought process when it comes to the are the new drivers coming in trained well um and maybe it's just because they have to share the road with them if it's a if that's the reason why then okay I get it but to have it be that high on the list I'm not I'm not so sure surprising yeah that's the one I find most surprising okay well we are out of time I appreciate everybody joining us today uh it's always good to look at those type of lists to keep a pulse on what's going on in the industry what's important for fleets and for their drivers so uh yeah thanks for being here with us stay tuned for announcements about uh our next shows and uh like I said best way to keep up to date with everything we got going on at truck safe is by subscribing to our newsletter over at trucksafe docomo appreciate you being with me we'll see everybody later see you for

Event Completed

Wednesday, October 16, 2024 at 3:40 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube