About This Event
In this episode, we’re joined by Mr. Jack Van Steenburg, founder of CMV Safety Experts, LLC and former Chief Safety Officer of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration to discuss the inner workings of the FMCSA, including how it prioritizes issues to address via rulemaking, how it ushers in new rules, and what fleets might expect in terms of regulations in light of the upcoming election.
Episode Summary
In Episode 43 of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman is joined by Jack Van Steenberg, former Chief Safety Officer and first Executive Director of the FMCSA, for an in-depth conversation about the inner workings of the agency that regulates interstate trucking and bus companies. With a potential change in administration on the horizon, the episode offers fleet safety professionals a timely look at how FMCSA operates, how it prioritizes enforcement, and what regulatory shifts may be coming in the near future.
A significant portion of the discussion centers on FMCSA's resource constraints and prioritization challenges. With roughly 1,200 employees responsible for overseeing approximately 800,000 regulated motor carriers, the agency relies heavily on its CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability) system to identify and target high-risk carriers for compliance reviews. Van Steenberg notes that only about 8,000 to 9,000 compliance reviews are conducted by FMCSA annually, with states contributing another 4,000, leaving the vast majority of carriers without a formal safety rating. He also highlights the persistent problem of state-by-state disparities in roadside enforcement data, which continues to distort CSA scores and undermine the system's reliability as a risk measurement tool.
The conversation also covers several upcoming regulatory developments, including FMCSA's planned overhaul of its registration system, which is slated for a 2025 launch and will phase out MC numbers in favor of a unified USDOT number system with enhanced identity verification to combat fraud. Van Steenberg and Wiseman also discuss the long-anticipated Safety Fitness Determination rulemaking, which aims to modernize the current three-tier safety rating system. Van Steenberg advocates for a negotiated rulemaking process — similar to what was used for entry-level driver training — to bring a broad range of industry stakeholders to the table and improve the likelihood of a workable outcome.
On the topic of a potential change in administration, Van Steenberg draws on his experience navigating multiple presidential transitions at FMCSA. He explains that transitions involve extensive preparation of briefing materials and that rule making activity effectively slows or halts in the months leading up to an election due to the Congressional Review Act. He predicts that a Republican administration would likely result in fewer new regulations and accelerated advancement of autonomous vehicle policy, while a Democratic administration would likely maintain the current regulatory trajectory and move forward with rules like the automatic emergency braking mandate.
For fleet safety professionals, the episode offers several practical takeaways. Carriers should not assume a satisfactory safety rating provides adequate legal protection and should continuously work to improve their safety programs beyond minimum compliance thresholds. Safety managers should also be aware of the CSA warning letter program, which Van Steenberg confirms has a meaningful track record of prompting voluntary carrier improvement. Finally, fleets should stay informed about the FMCSA registration modernization project, as the elimination of MC numbers and new identity verification requirements will have operational implications for carriers, brokers, and others who interact with the registration system.
Full Transcript
up
up
up up
if you're like us you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regular ation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after e-g is the first web and mobile app version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations ereg is always up to date and allows Fleet Safety professionals to not only read the rules but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts highlight bookmark and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules ereg was developed by safety Professionals for safety professionals try it out for free at .a oh
all right hey everyone welcome to episode 43 of truck safe live show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs excited to be back for another show this month uh we're doing a lot more shows uh as of late uh just a lot to talk about recently so today I'm excited to have a special guest with us today Mr Jack Van steenberg uh former Chief safety officer for the FMCSA I'm interested to talk with him particularly now in election season we're getting pretty close to a potential change in administration obviously we'll have to wait to see if that actually happens but I'm more interested in what that might mean for um FMCSA and uh and what carriers might be able to expect if that were to happen here here come 2025 so looking forward to that discussion should be a great one um if you're here with us live make sure to say hey in the comments always like to see who's around and as we go along as always if you have any questions or thoughts on the topic be sure to throw them in the comments section and we'll get to them as you raise them first up I want to thank the sponsor of the show which is taking the higher Road Legacy Builders and Freight waves production taking the higher road is a special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's great greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and compliance each week host Jeremy rmer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast so thanks to taking the high road really appreciate it uh a few things going on at truck safe and in the industry before we get into our main topic today as always if you're not a member of the truck safe compliance Network I recommend you join that it's free to join you could scan that QR code there or download the app on the app store or Google Play store or just head over to trucksafe network.com this is the space that we've developed for Fleet Safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also access all of our DOT compliance related content that we have pushed out over the years hundreds of videos and webinars and articles all on topics that are important to anybody that is managing regulated drivers and trucks or buses all available for free in the app so we'd love to have you there trucksafe network.com um also check out our online DOT compliance courses that we have through our truck safe academy uh these are the courses that we have for both safety managers and drivers over at trucksafe academy.com these are indepth uh educational courses on things like driver qualification and hours of service and vehicle maintenance and drug and alcohol testing and Hazmat compliance and reasonable suspicion testing um hours and hours of detailed content on those important topics helping you if you're a safety manager to understand the complexities uh breaking it down into layman's terms and helping you to more effectively manage those processes so that you don't end up in the crosshairs uh that's the goal anyway so check that out check those out over at trucksafe academy.com if you have any interest okay enough about us um one thing I wanted to mention from earlier this week uh we we kind of pitched this on our last show the FMCSA has been holding these informational sessions on their upcoming uh overhaul of their registration system they're calling these the registration modernization meetings and they had one earlier this week that I attended I think this was their third or fourth um uh meeting on the topic where they are giving a sort of preview of what the new registration system will look like this will be U taking over for the unified registration system or the URS system which has been in place for a few years or several years now um and obviously by the name of these meetings the the big part of this is to modernize that system and hopefully make it a little more user friendly for carriers that are look or or new carriers that are looking to register for a new usdot number or get a new operating Authority that type of stuff but there's a lot more that goes into it as I found out in uh in this meeting earlier this week um I will tell you a few things that I learned from the meeting this is kind of uh what might be in store uh come the first release of this updated system which is now slated for uh 2025 they didn't get into specifics on the date that it will be released or even the month that it will be released they did say though that it is slated for 2025 um you know and generally speaking again it will modernize that registration system but also a big part of this is to try and get a better hold on or better handle on fraud which appears to be ramping up over the last couple of years and even more so in the last several months and so some of these potential changes or proposed changes are ostensibly going to address the issue of fraudulent actors um trying to get new DOT numbers or purchase numbers or uh whatever they do to uh to defraud carriers and and others in the industry Brokers and stuff like that so that's a big part of it one of the big takeaways here if you're not familiar with these changes um is that the FMCSA is planning to do away with MC numbers which have historically been the designation for um operating Authority so if you're uh if you've got if you're For Hire Motor Carrier and you've got Interstate For Hire Motor Carrier operating Authority or if you've got brokerage Authority then those authorities have historically been tied to an MC number uh and that number is in addition to your usdot number which is uh which is your registration number that you also have to have as a regulated motor carrier that that usdt number has historically been more about safety and and you're it's it's kind of where your safety metrics live your CSA scores and all of your registration details like what types of Commodities you haul stuff like that but it's been separate from the MC number but going forward the plan is to get rid of the MC number uh MC numbers retire those and transition to a system where we just use the US do number as the designator for motor carriers um of any type and from what I understand from that meeting that I attended um there will be some kind of a suffix on the end of the usdot number to designate what types of operating Authority you have if any I don't know what those will look like uh but they did say that you won't have to change your truck markings um because of that suffix it will still just be a requirement that you uh Mark your vehicles your commercial motor vehicles with your usdot number so these These are going to be pretty significant changes obviously and I didn't even get into really but again the big part of this is the fraud prevention so there's they are uh beefing up the efforts to cut down on fraud through things like things they've already done two Factor authentication through login.gov nowadays they require whoever is applying for the operating authority to submit a copy of their driver's license from what I understand going forward in addition to that there will Al they have also con uh contracted with a company that will help verify identifi uh identities by not only uh taking a copy of the license but also making you like take a selfie of yourself next to the license or something to that effect to verify you are who you say you are um so there's going to be a lot of that uh and a lot of Kinks to work out which they are doing now and like I said uh the idea being that this will go live sometime in 2025 and um yeah there's uh there's going to be a lot to it it seems like so and just keep in mind that that's coming up uh Matt saying is that document on the CFR website FMCSA website so they do have a set up that particular slide I showed was just a a a slide from the presentation I don't know if that specific document is available on the website but they do have a specific website set up for these uh potential changes to the registration system I think if you just Google FMCSA registration modernization um you should be able to find that website I I was on it yesterday so it's got some pretty good information about what's in store all right so I just wanted to mention that because that will be a significant change uh and then also you know in terms of kind of what's coming down the line um uh from a Ru making standpoint usually towards the end of every year we do a show where we kind of have a put together an Outlook of what's to come what carriers might expect uh in the New Year from a rulle making perspective so we will plan to do that probably sometime in December so be on the lookout for announcements about that best way to stay up to date with everything we've got going on at truck safe and all this type of industry news is by subscribing to our newsletter you can do that over at trucksafe
docomo on then to the main topic of today which is uh getting a better understanding of the FMCSA the agency that uh regulates uh interstate trucking companies truck and bus companies um you know it's the agency that we at truck safe are primarily working with on behalf of our Motor Carrier clients on a day in day out basis and uh you know we've got a good understanding of how they work and we've worked with several Folks at the agency over the years and uh but what I find is that a lot of the motor carriers we work with a lot of our clients um just don't really have a good feel for how things work in the agency how they pass the rules how they prioritize issues to address through rule makings or how they enforce those rules and so I thought it would be good to uh get an inside look at that about the inner workings of the FMCSA and and that type of stuff so I'm excited to to bring on Jack Van steenberg he's the principal founder of CMV ex uh safety experts LLC safety expert who assists motor carriers attorneys and insurance companies with Regulatory Compliance safety planning crash analysis labor broker and litigation matters uh before starting his own business Jack spent 15 years at the FMCSA including as the agency's first executive director and its Chief safety officer Jack welcome to the show appreciate you being here thanks Brandon thank you for the invite and I learn an awful lot from you every week too well I don't know about that but uh yeah I appreciate the kind words and thanks so much for being here um can't see your your shirt now but you showed me beforehand you're you're rooting for the Yankees you're ready for the game tomorrow right here we go all right all right all right yeah just uh like I told you my boys are are excited about that game because they're or about that series because they're big Aaron judge fans so yeah looking forward to that um but anyway just uh wanted to start out maybe for those who aren't familiar with you maybe you can give us a little bit of background about yourself how you got into the industry in the first place well it's interesting how I get into the industry um I uh I know you know I worked for the New York State Police for 25 years started out as a trooper came up the ranks but I was about to make lieutenant and the super Superintendent at the time says I'm going to make you a lieutenant and I'm going to put you in charge of the mix app program I said to myself Jack what is mix app I didn't know so I accepted it it was a promotion that transferred up to headquarters in Albany New York and learned out learned a little about the mix app program and what I found did you learn what it stood for I did um I actually did so a lot to learn on that and then I did find out a lot of acronyms but I got involved I got involved with the commercial vehicle safety Alliance and I took an interest in the motor carrier safety
program in its entirety I got to work with a lot of federal employees at um you know motor carriers at the time originally it was with Federal Highway and I got to know a woman named Annette Samberg uh uh and that and I talked she was the chief at the Washington State Patrol went on the Nitsa and then FMCSA and you know her and I talked and there was an opportunity to go to the DC and I uh interviewed for a position and it just so happened I had 25 years on with the state police and I could have retired at 20 but I stayed and I'm glad I did and at 25 years there I went to FMCSA I was fortunate enough to get selected for a position and that position was the office director of the safety and compliance program and three years after that I uh was elevated the chief safety officer and then my last two years you read it I was the executive director and that was a great role I loved it and but I I loved every every role I had with FMCSA a great organization with a great you know Mission Brandon yeah it's great yeah and for folks who aren't familiar with Annette anet's been like I told you jack a good a great mentor for me and for Jared over the years she W after she uh wrapped up her role with the Washington State Patrol she was with Nitza for a short period of time and then she ultimately landed as the administrator for the FMCSA and uh it's just been a pleasure working with her over the years uh she's also a lawyer so Jack of all trades for sure um but uh anyway I was curious so you mentioned that you you held a few different roles at FMCSA um wondering for those that aren't may not be familiar with the agency um you know kind of How It's structured and you know when you talk about a a chief safety officer like what does that role entail and that type of stuff so it's it's evolved a little since I made Chief safety officer and it's actually in the in the um legislation that FMCSA has to have a chief safety officer approved by the uh White House and it's so it's not a political position it's highest career position in the uh FMCSA and basically the role for I had in that was to oversee all the safety programs um and that include our compliance programs our enforcement programs new entrance safety audits Intermodal programs anything to do with safety and it involved working with the industry it involved working with the safety Advocates it also involved um uh working with the motor carriers and I and I did that and the States uh one of the roles too which is in the legislation is the chief safety officer will be the assistant administrator and that rle is solely working on adjudications and I know you're familiar with that and we can talk a little bit about that but at the end what happened was dot was transitioning to every agency to have an executive director and at the time this was this was early 2021 20 or 2020 um and I was selected to be the executive director so I kept the Dual roles of executive director and uh Chief safety officer the difference with the executive director was that basically I oversaw every single office in the uh FMCSA so not only safety but I was day to day day to-day on the budget Personnel hiring um research registration as you mentioned earlier and you know again I loved it I loved every role that I served in there and it was a lot of fun and I I learned an awful lot and quite frankly Brandon I'm still learning an awful lot wow that's a lot on your table I I can imagine one of the things that we're always experiencing um and that we know to be true is that the FMCSA comp at Le even just compared to other sister agencies for example the FAA and and and others like it is a relatively small agency do you remember like how many total employees they had around the time that you were there yeah um about 1,200 employees 320 maybe safety investigators there and you're absolutely right about small agencies because when the bipartisan infrastructure law was coming out I was in weekly meetings with the secretary's office on all with all the other agencies and hey the emphasis was always usually on Federal highway or Federal Highway and I understand and uh FAA so you know we took a back seat obviously uh prioritize the programs but a lot of emphasis was on Federal Highway you know they got billions and billions of dollars for infrastructure and FAA so yeah well and yeah I mean and what I think a lot of people Miss is you know that 1200 employees or so are responsible for essentially regulating being almost I think if it's not over it's it's close to 800,000 regulated trucking truck and bus companies in the United States so it's it's a huge Universe of regulated entities that that relatively small agency is is in charge of and I and I suspect that that's kind of where the mixat program that you mentioned comes into play along with some other um prioritization efforts you mentioned that word and I think that's an important part of uh the fmcsa's uh inner workings nowadays at least from my perspect perspective is you know given that it's a pretty small agency and that it's got such a big universe of carriers to manage how is it that the FMCSA prioritizes its time and ensures that it is able to go after uh what would be the most you know risky carriers in its view so you're you're right about the universe and I always used the word I always used 800,000 and and I I you know there's ways to look that uh look that number up on the uh FMCSA database um I always go look up at the handbook the safety handbook that they put out every year and and that's my staple where I go look up my data and you talk about prioritization and I'm G to bring it up but you know we have to Prior wanted somebody asked me when I was at FMCSA what do I do on a regular basis what bothers me and what bothers me and what I do what I think about was what carrier that I have to visit on a daily basis and it was all about evaluating risk and for FMCSA risk ties into the CSA program compliance safety and accountability program and that started as a prioritization based on risk for FMCSA on how they're going to schedule compliance reviews and they broke you know they they prioritized it based on high-risk carriers which is there was a legislative mandate to um conduct compliance reviews on those highrisk carriers U then they broke it down into moderate risk and then they broke that further down into risk and so it's all about CSA to FMCSA was all about risk and FMCSA does about eight to ,000 compliance reviews a year um schedule them based based on risk there's other ways to get yourself you know you're in a crash FMCSA could visit you or a complaint they could visit you and then the states do about four so there's about 13,000 compliance reviews a year and that's not a lot compared to the 800,000 you know universe that FMCSA has to uh regulate yeah and I think the last numbers I saw is you know and something we always say is historically the the audits the on-site compliance reviews were the primary way that the FMCSA and its predecessors kind of uh enforced its regulations and those are the things that result in what we know as safety ratings today which we can talk about here in a little bit the three- tier rating system satisfactory conditional unsatisfactory and the LA the latest numbers I saw is like upwards of 95% of the 800,000 regulated carriers don't have a safety rating because they have never gone through one of those compliance reviews that would result in a safety rating so you know we've got a huge Universe of carriers that have never been visited by the FMCSA and so I think that's what a lot of carriers Miss is you know the CSA for all of its problems over the years you know widely derided for for many reasons some of which are Justified others of which probably not so much I think your point is is is valid which is that you guys had to find a way to prioritize carriers because you're just not getting out to audit a sufficient number of carriers to to have a pulse on how folks are complying with the regulations or not well well that's correct and I don't know if a lot of your audience knows this Brandon but FMCSA and I may say we once in a while because I think I'm still there but I'm not but they send out a warning letter too if if the data in CSA starts getting um bad put you near the riskier side or maybe a basic that's in alert status they'll send out um a warning letter just to let you know hey we're seeing negative Trends come up negative safety Trends come up and I'll make it up on unsafe driving want to bring it to your attention there's no action that the carrier has to make but the response has been very very favorable you know thank you for bringing this to our attention and then we look at those carriers after that letter goes out we look at it maybe six months later a year later and what we see is the carriers in most cases really improve so that warning letter letter has an impact on it too so it's not just the on-site compliance reviews that we do or um or the you know off-site compliance reviews we do touch them with those letters yeah one of the um what I have to imagine is what was an un unintended consequence of the CSA platform that I'm sure you're no doubt familiar with is how many other stakeholders in the industry would latch onto that system and start using it for their various Purp purposes we regularly see shippers and Brokers using the system to try and judge whether they want to do business with a carrier or not you know uh and then we also see it in the insurance world for sure as well with insurance carriers kind of using that as a tool to help them you know maybe set the rates for the for the premiums for the insurance uh what what was the agency's uh reaction to that when that started be become more and more prominent it and what are what's the current thinking in whether that system is suitable for those those particular purposes well actually initially and and still may be today but initially those unintended consequences we thought were good you know more people are paying attention to the trucking industry the motor carrier industry and you know that would make the motor carrier industry you know pay attention to her own operations a little bit more because not only were the feds paying attention but like you mentioned the broker industry the shipper industry the insurance industry you know household goods industry attorneys you know a lot of people were paying attention to it but that also brought more scrutiny on FMCSA with the flaws in the CSA system and and and yeah I hate to say it and I remember back then when I was there I was talking to a couple people that were very close to CSA at the time I said hey I get the data I get where the the um maybe the errors were where you can improve it and I realized it's not that big to me it wasn't that big but it was all also very big to Congress and in DC perceptions can drive a program and I remember at a at a uh hearing I think it was well was I know we're testifying I don't know who was testifying at the time but the congressman asked I think it was the administrator the Deputy Administrator you're telling me that a piece of concrete fell off a bridge and hit a truck that that carriers getting charged with a accident on their CSA even though it was minuscule it wasn't going to change anything and the answer was yes so that started it all you know then everybody came up and I I get it there was flaws in the system um and hence the Congress said that you know we have to do a study of the CSA program and the nationaly of science was awarded that contract that you know B was written into law and you know they came up with their their recommendations and so forth and basically said CSA is not a brad program there is issues that you should be addressing and then look at the item response Theory yeah if you can understand it right well that's why it's it's never going to happen I mean it was to me it was a ridiculous recommendation from a bunch of Scholars that had nothing to do with you know no knowledge of the industry um and and I I know FMCSA wants to change it going forward I see some of the changes I like some of the changes but I have to point one of the things that was not addressed and I really think it needs to be addressed is that Statewide disparity between um you know the the enforcement and I want just can I give I want can I give you an example of that sure driver out of service California 3.70% Arizona 4 14.27 look at the range over 11 about 11 uh percent and the driver you know the driver out of service rates are around 6% so what a difference there then you go to the vehicle out of service vehicle out of service nationally is 22% Mississippi 99.78% and Nebraska 4 2.77% I mean 33% difference so you know that's a huge difference and I get the impact on the industry and what they're saying is hey if we drive in Nebraska you know it's not or it's really gonna we're going to get hurt yeah you know I'm from Indiana and the thing we were always arguing with it because Indiana was big on speeding violations so if you would look at Indiana relative to other states you would see a disproportionate number of speeding violations written up for carriers with large operations in Indiana and so the effect of that in CSA that we saw through the data was that carriers with heavy operations in Indiana relatively speaking had a worse unsafe driving score than carriers that didn't have oper as much operation in Indiana and so yeah I I was right there with everybody kind of trying to make that point it's like you know we we shouldn't carriers it doesn't make much sense to to have them prioritized for audit just by ha happen stance where they happen to be located in the country and how those particular state agencies choose to prioritize issues to enforce in roadside inspections so I agree that's one issue that uh to date has not really been addressed and that I think the FMCSA specifically declined to address in what they are proposing to to change the system here coming up and they have and you you know who knows it might catch on in Congress again and they have may may address it but um you know Congress does drive a lot of the programs that FMCSA does and you know you go back to we talked about safety Fitness determination you and I and past conversations and there was a s push to you know do safety Fitness determination I think there was a rule making out years ago and I'm the one who pulled it I'm the one who said we have to pull it because it was solely on based on CSA that was when all the flaws were and I said we can't put out a safety Fitness deter termination based on the flawed Foundation that was going to drive it so I said that was bad timing because that was right when I think Congress mandated the study by the National Academy of Sciences so uh right around the same time we're still dealing with that I mean it's you know CSA has been in place since 2010 and here we are almost 15 years later and we are just to the point where FMCSA is uh ready to pull the trigger almost on changes based on what the National Academy of Sciences uh recommended and so 15 years long time to but it's a significant system a pretty complex system and so I imagine that there's a lot that goes into uh you know making changes to it well I mean I can tell you why it's delayed I mean you look back at the last two administrations you had the Trump Administration Biden Administration politics aside we've had seven maybe administrators or then at times you had the the chief safety officer acting you've had the deputy administrators acting we we've gone through more administrators an administrator is going to come in you know we talked about politics administrator comes in they're going to have to get caught up and administrator doesn't want to come in and start learning about CSA and to try to teach or you know bring an administrator up to speed on CSA is very difficult so in eight years maybe seven or eight administrators it takes them about a year just to get up the speed on regular day-to-day operations so csa's always been in the background it's always in the background so hence the delay so it comes down to priorities yeah and that's something we've we've mentioned on past shows as well is kind of that revolving door unfortunately in that administrator position and you know I think they just installed is is the current one it's a Deputy Administrator right the one that's in in place right now Vin white yeah there's you know they can at some point they can make and I don't know if he was at one point an acting administrator but you can only stay in the acting administrator for so many days and then it reverts automatically back to the Deputy Administrator but he's the person in charge right now so he's been in charge for I want to say less than a year and now we've got this is kind of a good segue into this is obviously an election year here in the US and election day from when we're recording this is you know a couple weeks away and if we were to have a change in administration then we're looking at a likely change another change in FMCSA administrators um because like you said at the start the administrator is a politically appointed position right has to be appointed by the president confirmed by the Senate and so um I want to ask you about that you being with the agency for 15 years like you said you've you were there through several different Administration changes walk us through what that looks like uh you know from from the top down well from the top down I look at it in our role what you know I did and what the team did every four years you're doing you're working on transition so this TR you have to prepare a transition booklet um basically an FMC sa 101 on everything about FMCSA you know I'm talking budget major priorities major rule makings um operations and it's a very indepth um uh and then then you know you got to do bios for the the executives of FMCSA the you know the career Executives um so that takes a lot um you know there's frequently asked questions so you're preparing that probably starting you know they probably started about three months going on doing that and every office is involved with that and my last two times I was very I was basically coordinate the whole thing and that's got to go up to OST there's a transition person up in OST um and there's a lot of back and forth and then at the transition I'm going to tell you day one if there no matter what who if if a Democrat wins or if a republican wins I guarantee you there's going to be a transition um I'm you know because the president has to appoint their cabinet members so this is not a you know we're going to renew it guarantee so you're going to see a whole change you're going to see a whole change of Administrators for the Department I mean you see them all they're all leaving um they're leaving they've been leaving for the last you know year and a half now um I don't even know if there's any any still in the same place that were there at the beginning of the Biden Administration but um so that's what's going out right now is total transition um the rul making work still goes on but you've seen it no rule makings going out the door and that's basically I've learned that over the years and that's basically because of the Congressional review act where so many days out I think six months before an Administration changed um there's a requirement that Congress can review any Ru making that's passed and they have to justify it so that's what's going on is Rule making still going on but you've seen by the delays in the dates the projected dates that nothing is going on before this election coming out so but right now it's transition Brandon yeah I think the other thing we see often when a when a new party takes uh takes control we also we often see them put a freeze on regulations that had been recently passed so even if FMCSA were to pass uh you know get you know final approval for regulations here it's possible that if a new party takes effect that they would just freeze those anyway and then potentially just they they go away uh into the sunset after that it seems like and so yeah just not much going on um at the agency and not really for the last 6 months or so and we saw like you mentioned we saw a lot of things get kicked down the road uh on the agenda we've seen one of the ones that you mentioned one of the one one of the ones that I think will be the most significant ones coming up would be a potential change to the way that we do safety ratings um this is in the advanced notice of proposed rul making stage the agency has already held a couple of listening sessions that I've attended on that and this would be uh and this is something that you mentioned that the agency had already started back in 2015 or 2016 that you ultimately pulled the plug on but now they are revisiting the idea of potentially changing up the way that we do safety rating so I'm curious I know you have thoughts on this because I've seen you post on it I'm curious on your thoughts on the um efficacy of the current safety rating methodology and where you think it might be going here in the next couple of years or so well the date that I think they put out now for the notice um is June of 2025 I think and what I know and what I feel they're going to tie it into CSA again and the carriers inspection history uh maybe out of service history but they got to get the CSA they got to change that CSA program first so they can work out all the Kinks of the new um proposed CSA or CF CSA program keep in mind CSA is not a Ru making it's just a it's it's a system that FMCSA uses you know I mentioned and then obviously everybody else uses it as well but so they got to get CSA out first the changes to that work out the Kinks and then go forward with that um new um notice of proposed rule making on safety Fitness determination you know I don't know where they are specifics but I know what we were looking at was getting rid of the conditional um getting rid of that maybe just have a not unable to operate or can operate which is the today's unsatisfactory um and maybe get away with this satisfactory you know I don't know where they're going to go I don't know what the comments are going to be that I think a lot of people will agree with getting rid of the the um the conditional they do want to tie it into Road inspections
PR versus non-preventable um and I also know that they plan on updating the critical and acute violation list which is terribly outdated I mean I think you and I talked um you know even before he even asked me to be honest was the um um you know some of the things I picked up that are not there not having a cell phone it's not an acute it's not even it's not a critical or using the cell phone right um text they don't have any Clearing House stuff on there nothing nothing and they they have a lot of uh they have a lot of uh or they don't have the uh the different speeds you know if you look at the CSA the severity points for driving I think over 15 is like 10 they don't have that they don't have speeding in work zone so that's where you're going to see and how to tie this in um and I know the last time they were going to do it they were going to have a rating process you could get a rating without a compliance review so we'll see where they go with that yeah it'll be interesting so they don't have they're very short on the details at this stage at the advanced notice and proposed rule making stage they're essentially just Gathering feedback from the industry on where the industry thinks it should go and uh We've provided our feedback on that and uh yeah it'll so it'll be interesting to see what they end up with with the notice of proposed rul making uh we're still a long way off anybody watching this is not going to happen any anytime soon um the notice is they're supposed to get the notice out in June of 2025 um I'm not a betting man um don't have any luck in that but I bet you they're not going to get that out June of 2025 you don't have any money on the Yankees I gotta go all out on them in seven okay all right but I do want to say so one of the recommendations I've made I'm very I believe in this is if you're going to go with the safety Fitness determination Ru making I think a negotiated rule making could help with this I really I wanted to ask you about that because I've seen you post about that I'm not that familiar with a negotiated rule making process have we seen that FMCSA do that on any recent rule makings was it El yes I don't do it too often but the last time they did it was the um entry-level driver training oh okay and that's a whole another story I mean it they actual they they really work together on this and you get the you get bright people from the industry and all all parts of the industry the owner operators the small Trucking and the large Trucking you get the safety groups on there um anybody who has an interest in the subject but what happened I just I go back to the eldt the negotiated rulemaking it was a success everybody came up with a agreement that agreement went to OMB and that agreement had hours built into it especially behind the wheel om says nope we're not going to approve it and the administrator at the time was Scott darling had to make a decision do I let it just sit and no go nowhere you know like you see speed limiters and so forth like that and he made the decision to go along with OMB and basically it's a performance-based program the entry-level driver training and so OMB has an awful lot of influence on these rule makings so if we were to pursue that with safety Fitness determin I agree with you I think that would be the way to go because then we get more people at the table to express their concerns and then hopefully we end up with a system that uh that that works for everybody is the idea yeah you could have Brokers on in that rule mate or that negotiated committee Insurance um people professionals so I just I was advocating that when I was there and you know the the risk I have to imagine is that you don't really get anywhere because nobody can agree on anything well they did it in ELD to eldt so it it was successful and there is an FMCSA representative and that was Larry Miner that was overseeing it so there is someone that's facilitating it all the time so you don't let the conversation straight sure sure uh I want to talk to you about um appeals and adjudication through FMCSA but first we got a couple question questions from the audience here I wanted to run them by you so Michael on LinkedIn is asking will the reversal of the Chevron Doctrine have any meaningful impact positive or negative on FMCSA operations do you have any thoughts on on that yeah that's a really good question and a lot of times we make a decision um we do our own interpretations on a rule that we passed or um I'm trying to give an example uh make a decision based on uh a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety standard but and we have that final decision they the courts left that up to FMCSA on a lot of points so now with the Chevron decision I think it could take a lot of discretion away from FMCSA and all the federal agencies and get the court involved I mean you're going to get the court involved it's long enough with FMCSA but you get the court involved it's just going to extend um that interpretation of a rule or a policy but yeah I think it can have a lot of impact on that yeah for those who not familiar with Chevron Doctrine we've done a couple we've done some articles and videos on the topic very very important Supreme Court decision that came down earlier this year that will have a major impact on agency rul making uh across the board not just FMCSA um but essentially the question is how much difference do we give to the agencies in terms of them interpreting their own statutory mandates that Congress has has given them and uh for the last 40 some years the Chevron Doctrine had been in place and gave a lot of difference to the agency uh the idea being that they are they are ostensibly the experts in the area they should know better than anybody what Congress meant by these uh these broad statutory mandates but that got overturned with the uh Chev uh with the um was it the lber Brite case I think um and so now the idea is that the courts are not going to be required to give the agency so much difference so it's an important question that we haven't seen play out with FMCSA yet I think the last I think when I looked at this the last time Chevron Doctrine had been um had been implicated in an FMCSA case was when the ELD mandate got tied up in court at the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals I think I think the court relied on the Chevron Doctrine in deferring to the agency on its handling of the privacy concerns with the ELD mandate so uh that's the last I can remember that issue coming up okay but uh that's Chevron do Brian's asking does the agency have thoughts on increasing staff to handle the additional work in the way of medical examiner management along with getting more carriers out of the non-rated status I I suspect what he's talking about is we had that we had that issue I think recently where several of the medical examiners got removed from the National Registry of medical examiners because they hadn't gone through the process of of getting their uh two-factor authentication set up so I think there were thousands of medical examiners removed and then there ALS we also hear regularly Tales of medical examiners pushing through drivers who shouldn't have gotten pushing through so or or who haven't who shouldn't have gotten pushed through so I think historically to date there's been relatively little oversight of the medical examiner so I think that's where he's going with the question so a great question and I mentioned 1100 1200 employees with the bipartisan infrastructure law um FMCSA was going to hire and I'm going for memory which is problematic because I was very involved with that I put up a hiring we put together a full hiring plan so we had maybe an extra 400 FMCSA employees we're going to hire um a lot of them are going to go into the field for safety investigators a lot of them are going to go to field to work on the 38517 process you know the upgrade safety rating upgrades y yep a lot of them were going to go to audit elt uh trainers training providers and a lot of them we're going to go for the medical examiner trainers but what I I think I think you said Bob was it or something that Brian it's Brian our friend Brian rynolds who's on the show with us quite a bit so oh Brian so the I don't know if you know this but they they do have contractors and they do have databases I think bup is running the database in the medical examiner reviews so they run this on a regular basis and try to Red Flag um medical examiners that are maybe doing 20 Medical exams a day or they they look at things like that and then that's when they start assigning somebody to it but there is more resources to put towards that but there is data review behind the scenes on a regular basis yeah okay um okay so I wanted to talk we're kind of running out of time here but I I definitely want to talk to you about adjudications because that's where I became familiar with you when you were in your role with as Chief safety officer and assistant administrator one of the things that we have done for our clients a lot of over the years is file what are called 38515 appeals of safety rating so if for whatever reason the trucking company trucker buus company goes through a compliance review and uh the investigator makes some mistake in the methodology or the investigation that leads to a downgraded safety rating uh a lot of carriers don't know that there's an appeal process that they could go through which is separate from that 38517 process that you mentioned where you're essentially admitting to the violations and you're saying hey we've corrected the problems here's evidence of our correction uh please up you're begging the agency for Mercy at that point but with the appeal process you're actually challenging the findings and so we would put these appeals together uh it would go through an administrative review process that you were kind of over so curious if maybe you could kind of break that process down and what it was like kind of sitting uh you know presiding over those types of appeals so it was interesting the 385 that you describe it and it's based on FMCSA making an error in the rating or something like that and maybe assigning the wrong point system in one of the categories or the factors um and then so the system you know you would appeal it to the assistant administrator who was me and I have to tell you they did a great job of firewalling me from being an assist administrator and heading up the safety programs I thought it was a conflict so I was always trying to get out of being the assistant administrator and focusing on safety and and at some point I think it was under Jim Mullen they did that and Jim says you know we need you at safety we'll have the adjudication team take over as an acting admin assistant administrator but a lot of time went into that and and I've always said and I don't know if I said it to you but I wanted to get the decision right and if I made a mistake in that decision and if somebody appealed it I I didn't take that personal you know you go to data accuse you hear all that stuff but I wanted my bottom line was to get that decision right and I was very open to it and what we did you know we had a team and I have to tell you very very bright team that were uh attorneys that are attorneys and they would discuss these it would be assigned the case would be assigned to a attorney in the adjudications team then they would meet with theud ation attorney Chief and then they would go and meet with in some cases the FMCSA Chief counsel and that Chief counsel firewalled themselves between the safety programs as well and then they'd bring me in and I would meet with the chief counsel um I'd meet with the adjudications team on a regular basis going over these cases and it was an interesting and you know usually the attorneys are right and they make they they have the you know the right opinion I thinking um yes we're going to overturn it no we're not um and one of them that bothered me from earlier on I don't know if you remember it was something about should the carrier have known you know I'm a carrier you do your pre- driver's license check before you hire somebody three months in he gets in a crash or and he has a suspended license yeah the carrier didn't know and that always bothered me you know how was that carrier supposed to know and I was always kind of arguing with the I was always playing Devil's Advocate and that and and what I liked about it was that the attorneys liked that I asked a million questions because I wanted to get it right I wanted to be fair to the industry but I wanted to make sure that we're doing it safely so that was that was an interesting issue in particular I remember several appeals dealing with that issue I think they actually changed the regulation on that because it used to be used to have that knowledge component to it and then they took that away so now it's like a strict liability violation where even if you even if your MVR showed that the driver had a valid license if he later loses that license even though we're only required to run an MVR once per year we are still charged with the violation the idea being I think that hey we have responsibility for hiring these drivers they should let us know if they lose their license we've got a and so that's how they enforce it nowadays but yeah that's interesting issue for sure um with the just a couple minutes we have left here I wanted to ask you uh if you have given any thought to and what carriers might expect uh if anything um if we get an Administration change what what what do you think's going to happen if Republicans take office uh from an FMCSA standpoint that carriers should be most aware of anything in particular well based on history I mean the Trump Administration was they had the two for one deal so I think you're going to see less regulations um I think you're going to have to they're going to put in a lot more scrutiny into the economic analysis on regulations and I think you're going to see autonomous vehicles I mean I'm just putting two and two together um musk is friends with Trump so I think you're going to see the advancement of autonomous vehicles and I actually think there's a place in um the commercial vehicle industry for autonomous vehicles so and they you know quite frankly they are safe there are some flaws with them so I think you're going to see that and I think if you see that um vice president Harris gets in uh you're going to see some of the status quo when it comes to um the uh violations I think you're going to see automatic emergency breaking get passed pretty soon after that um and so I I think it'll be less regulations Trump um status quo with uh Harris okay well there you have it well hey Jack I really appreciate you joining me um if folks have any questions for you if they're interested in and maybe hiring you to help them with their safety programs where can they find you so I just you know thanks for asking that I do have the commercial vehicle safety experts you read it in the beginning my email is Jack VS1 outlook.com that's j a k v is in Victor s is in Sam the number one outlook.com um I don't have a website because I'm retired and I want to be retired but I've told every carrier that I'm working with and every attorney that I'm working with that if I'm working with you you're going to get 110% and I've I've seen an awful lot of what goes on in the industry and let me make this point to the carriers that are out there satisfactory rating isn't good enough when it comes to litigation and that I can help you with and I know you can too Brandon and I appreciate the partnership and friendship yeah that's a great great Point don't rest on your laurels when it comes to safety ratings for sure so anyway yeah like I said Jack really appreciate it uh Jack's been great to work with from our perspective as well so if you have any questions he's also on LinkedIn I know and and Facebook and stuff like that so don't hesitate to reach out to them Jack appreciate it we're going to sign off here uh thanks everybody for joining us today uh like I said best way to stay up to date with what we've got going on is through our uh newsletter trucksafe dcom subscribe you could stay on the lookout for future show announcements uh you can watch past shows stuff like that over at trucksafe live.com uh that's all I got thanks everybody for joining we'll talk to you later see you