Episode Summary
In Episode 44 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman, Rob Carpenter, Brian Runnels, and Jerad Childress deliver their annual year-in-review for 2024 and offer a forward-looking outlook on what trucking fleets can expect in 2025. The discussion covers a range of significant regulatory developments, enforcement trends, and industry news, offering fleet safety professionals a consolidated snapshot of the issues most likely to affect their operations in the year ahead.
On the regulatory front, the hosts spend considerable time on Clearing House Phase 2, which took effect November 18, 2024, and now requires state driver licensing agencies to automatically downgrade the CDLs of drivers in prohibited status due to drug or alcohol violations. The panel notes that while some have overstated the immediate disruption — given that many of the nearly 180,000 prohibited-status drivers have likely already exited the industry — the change closes a meaningful gap in the system. The hosts also discuss oral fluid testing, which remains in a holding pattern until at least two certified laboratories are approved to process results, and the expanded crash preventability determination program, which added four new crash types effective December 1, 2024, including a notable catch-all provision allowing carriers to submit video evidence demonstrating a driver could not have prevented a crash. Additionally, the hosts address FMCSA's increased scrutiny of ELD manufacturers, noting that roughly 250 devices have now been revoked from the self-certified list, and urging fleets to monitor FMCSA notifications closely and be proactive about vendor selection and contingency planning.
The episode also examines two high-profile nuclear verdict cases — Werner Enterprises and Wabash — as cautionary examples of how plaintiff attorneys increasingly focus on company policies, safety culture, and internal standards rather than the facts of a crash itself. The hosts emphasize that even carriers operating in full compliance with applicable regulations remain vulnerable, and that maintaining consistent, well-documented safety practices is critical to limiting litigation exposure. As one panelist noted, carriers should assume a case will turn on their policies and procedures, making periodic policy audits an important risk management practice.
Looking ahead to 2025, the hosts point to the incoming Trump administration as the dominant variable shaping the regulatory environment, anticipating a slower rulemaking pace, potential deregulatory initiatives, and leadership changes at USDOT and FMCSA. The panel expresses skepticism that major pending rules — including speed limiter mandates and autonomous vehicle regulations — will advance meaningfully under the new administration. More likely near-term developments include the rollout of updated Safety Measurement System calculations affecting CSA scores, the eventual launch of oral fluid testing once labs are certified, and early-stage movement on potential changes to the safety fitness determination system that could ultimately tie carrier safety ratings to CSA data.
Fleet safety professionals should take away several concrete action items from this episode: verify that pre-employment and ongoing Clearing House queries are not just being run but actively reviewed and acted upon; confirm that CDL drivers have properly self-certified and submitted medical certificates to their state DMV; audit the current ELD provider against the FMCSA revoked device list and establish a contingency plan in case of revocation; begin submitting crash preventability challenges for eligible incidents under the newly expanded program, including video documentation where available; and stay tuned to regulatory updates as the new administration takes shape, particularly around the anticipated changes to CSA score calculations that could drop with little advance notice.
Full Transcript
up oh
a
up up
if you're like us you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after e-g is the first web and mobile app version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations ereg is always up to date and allows Fleet Safety professionals to not only read the rules but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts highlight bookmark and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules ereg was developed by safety Professionals for safety professionals try it out for free at .a a
all right hey everyone welcome to episode 44 truck safe live show where we and our guests tackle hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon with truck safe children's law both of which are dedicated helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs got a full house today Jared Brian Rob guys what's going on what up what up good to see you Merry Christmas yeah early Christmas um excited to be here today so always looking forward to this particular show this is our year-end review for 2024 looking back at some of the highlights from 2024 from a regulatory perspective uh and then also looking ahead to what we might expect for 2025 uh in terms of rule making activity enforcement um and all of that fun stuff so looking forward to it you guys ready to roll for Christmas you got all your shopping done it's ready my my wife got all the shopping done so I'm good classic Rob how about you Rob's excited all the shopping we're GNA do is done okay which is to say nothing or no no I I I kind of got what I wanted all year long and then it was kind of like a mute point at I don't care about you I care about your kids right up well they get everything all year long too so like you know Christmas every day you got room for one more I know Jared's gonna have to take up an offering for all his kids uh okay well before we get started here I want to say quick thanks to our sponsor which is taking the higher Road a legacy Builders and Freight waves production taking the higher road is a special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and and compliance each week host Jeremy rmer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast thanks to taking the high road appreciate it uh a few things to mention for truck safe before we get into the topic first off is our trucksafe Network as always if you're not a member of this recommend you join it free to join over at trucksafe network.com or if you scan that QR code on the screen there you'll join our Network this is the space we've developed for safety professionals to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also gain access to all of the content the dot related content that we are constantly pushing out through truck safe uh we've got an ongoing webinar series in-depth webinar series that we have done on improving CSA scores still have one CSA basic left to go I think Hazmat we've kind of held off on doing but we've got uh we've got separate 1hour webinars for all of the other seven Basics on our thoughts on how to improve those scores and some of the trends we're seeing so that's just one example of some of the content that we offer to network members so be sure to join that free to join trucksafe network.com or you can download the app in the app store or the Google Play Store um the the other thing I'll mention uh is our boot camps get getting a lot of questions from folks wondering when we're going to hold our next Fleet compliance boot camp we held our last one in Indianapolis back in October I think uh of this year 20124 uh we we've been doing like one of these per year so kind of in the early stages of planning our next one it will probably be uh Sometime Late summer early fall of 2025 don't know where it's going to be don't know how much it's going to cost uh don't have a whole lot of details on that yet but uh we all will be there again and looking forward to uh having safety professionals come and join us probably expecting around a hundred or so this next one is kind of what we are anticipating at least we'll have room for so I think it'll be a great event always get a lot of good feedback on that um and so best way to keep up to date with that if you want details on that is by subscribing to our newsletter trucksafe
docomo camp and you want one that's personalized to your own Fleet or your own group of individuals who are working with these regulations then uh get in touch with us ask us about our boot camp on the road Brian and I have just spent the last two weeks out on the road uh we were where were we Brian Tampa and Detroit Tampa and Detroit uh working with private groups on doing a customized boot camp for them at their locations for their folks and it was a good time uh a lot of great information uh a lot of great back and forth with those folks so if you're interested in something like that give us a call and happy to put something together for you that largely focused on maintenance and actually doing inperson inspection on vehicles it's kind of a different approach very different than the boot camps we normally do yeah Brian you want to give a summary kind of what we did sure yeah so we did our the normal Fleet Safety boot camps that we did and then an additional thing that we did up in the Detroit one was adding on a piece for mechanics to understand the proper way to do an annual inspections what to document it how to document it um what's the difference between things that'll pass a a a roadside inspection without being out of service compared to things that are on the annual inspection list that need to be repaired right away so yeah we spent a whole day doing that there was about half a day of classroom and then the other half of the day was handson and got to get go down and get dirty and play with equipment for a while so that was it was a it was a good day yeah then you got my truck all covered in grease and stuff did well you know price of doing business I guess I'm going to have to add that into the cost of those events repairs to my seats in my truck uh anyway um yeah so if you're interested in anything like that um again got great feedback from the from The Fleets and the teams that we worked with on those so would love to build something out like that for you if you're interested so give us a call anyway uh enough about us I think let's um get into today's topic and uh if you're here with us say hey in the comments and as we go along as always if there's any anything you want to talk about or if you have any thoughts on these topics throw it in the comments and we'll bring it up um but anyway kind of how we've done this in the past and how I'm envisioning we do it today is that we uh first start off with um some uh highlights uh from 2024 so what we saw from a rule making or an enforcement or even just big news in the truck trucking industry over the last year and kind of um you know how that impacted our clients and and how it impacted the industry at large and then we will look ahead to what we could expect possibly in 2025 uh from a rul making perspective or enforcement perspective or anything else so that's kind of how we'll tackle it um start first with looking back at 20124 first one I have on my list guys is um uh clearing house Phase 2 so this is probably actually the most recent one it's actually probably ranks up there as one of the most significant ones from a fleet regulatory perspective um this took effect November 18th of this year 2024 and uh we've got a lot of separate content on this if you're interested in in the nuts and bolts of it you can go back and check that out but Clearing House Phase 2 this uh closed a gap pretty significant Gap in the drug and alcohol clearing house that has been present since it's implementation back in 2020 where drivers who are placed in prohibited status due to a drug or alcohol violation even though they were prohibited from operating because of that violation um this they ended up still having valid CDLs because the state driver's licensing agencies weren't necessarily checking the Clearing House and weren't downgrading their CDLs because of that so what changed November 18th was Clearing House Phase 2 FMCSA told the state driver licensing agency as of this date going forward you have to now be uh using the Clearing House and downgrading automatically downgrading the CDLs of any drivers who are in prohibited status due to a drug or alcohol Clearing House violation so big change thoughts on that do we do we know if the State driers Licensing agencies have already initiated the mass downgrade or is that still yet to happen I I thought it was a 60-day time period where they had to actually do the down ating I'm just not sure if that's already happened or if it's still going to happen I think it's still going I think it's in progress in fact I saw an article come through can't remember what publication yesterday I think where the point of the article was to take issue with the sensation sensationalization of this issue that some others have made of it because it's easy to get in the mindset well we've got 180,000 drivers in prohibited status in the Clearing House so all of a sudden 180,000 aren't going to have a CDL that's some have kind of pushed that but that's really it's really not to say that Clearing House Phase 2 is all of a sudden going to mean that 180,000 drivers now can't drive it's not like you know these drivers have been in prohibited status already so anybody checking their Clearing House status as they should be should have already weeded these drivers out of the industry anyway it's just that now there's going to be an additional check on their uh on them and that they're also going to lose their license which they should have anyway so all that's to say is a lot of these drivers had probably already exited the market they're just not working in this industry anymore but there are still certainly going to be a lot of drivers that are going to see their CDLs downgraded and uh I think you're right Jared I think there was a kind of a I think Clearing House Phase 2 had like a slow roll out to it uh I can't remember what the time frame was but I had already heard of some states starting to to do that well we we all know that there's a a certain segment of the industry that that they don't even know what the clearing house is so you know that that also means that they're not running those reports so now at least when they run an MVR they're going to find that the the driver is downgraded and you know they won't have to wait to find out roadside yeah and that Gap was exploited by certain carriers not actually well they may have run the required query in the clearing house but they may not have looked at it closely you know we've we've come across carriers that kind of check the box and running the full query and they just don't actually look at it and understand what it means and so it's possible that carriers have hired some of these drivers that are then going to have their CDLs downgraded um I never understood that cuz because that's been a problem for years with with the mvrs too right carriers just pull those mvrs you know just to check the box stick them in the files and without ever looking at them you know the point of these things is for you to put eyes on them and see if there's anything that disqualifies these drivers from operating so you can't just stuff it away without looking at it uh you got to be looking at these things and taking action based on what you see in these documents or they never look at them again so it's like you run it the first time and that's it and clearing house is kind of funny because you do get the notification now like hey there's new information that's been added to Rob Carpenter's clearing house and then no one ever does anything with it just like continuous MVR monitoring it's like hey something's new in this guy's MVR and no one touches it but like Brian said I've been pretty surprised that I would say I would say one out of 12 that I that I talk to and go to for not doing the original clearing house I mean one of these people are like a hundredy old Legacy company and they just they didn't know because and and it's been in effect for five years now so how you've gotten by five years without knowing is beyond well I think some places it's because a lot of people have driving as a secondary role whereas maybe their service technicians driving a 33,000 pound Fleet truck with a CD and they just FMCSA isn't like there in front of them all the time like and over the road Fleet for instance where driving is your primary role it's just maybe it's a gap from a from a knowledge standpoint I don't know yeah that's a good point it's probably yeah I I think that's consistent with what I've seen it's mainly the uh you know the private fleets the the ones that aren't traditional trucking companies that seem to be missing it because they're just not tuned in as closely to these rules as a you know for hire trucking company so that's probably well we still see mistakes on drivers that are supposed to take their licenses to the DMV after or take their physicals the DMV after they have one and we see mistakes there and drivers have been you know cited and written violations for having their license downgraded because they didn't put their medical on file yeah so yeah it's just um you know if you're in this industry whether you're a carrier or a driver you got to stay tuned in to at least some source of information on keeping up to date with these rules because you know even though they don't change all that frequently or all that dramatically They do change occasionally so if you're not keeping up with them you're putting yourself at risk pretty significantly I mean if you like you said Brian if you don't give them your med card then they're going to downgrade your CDL then you're going to be out there operating without a CDL next thing you know you're getting out of service violations and God forbid you end up in litigation that's just not going to look good so well and if you don't follow Publications and don't follow like what we do and and maybe your insurance carriers and you know give you information and stuff like that it like Rob said the those 100y old Legacy companies where it's just business as usual every day and they're out of they're out of that Loop of getting that type of information then it's it's super easy to watch this stuff walk right by you yeah go ahead Rob I've been at three in the past two weeks and all three of them had that same Med C self-certification process issue for CDLs it's like hey we've got we've got got a vendor in place that tracks this stuff and they track the expiration and then we get the new med card but then the rest of that process where it's verifying the National Registry or hey did you self-certify and take your med card to the DMV it's like that whole second part of it is there's an ignorance factor to it I think in in a lot of cases especially the same in in secondary fleets but it's it's uh it's more bleeding it's more involved on the primary side too not just the secondary yeah I was going to say I'm hoping that this phase two uh that kicks in hopefully starts a wave of drivers exiting prohibited status and actually starting that return to duty process because once the CDLs are downgraded they're going to have no choice but to do that so hopefully we see thousands of drivers start that return to duty process um and actually get back on the road we'll see I don't have much hope unfortunately but yeah and then then that opens a whole another Pandora's Box then who are they driving for right right who were they driving for is that the question you're asking no who are they're going to drive for now well there's carriers that will take on a driver that's completed return to duty uh testing and they're not in prohibited status anymore but again you're taking on that testing plan in the future and it's up to you as the motor carrier to make sure that it's carried out and that in and of itself creates some risk yeah and they're few and far between those car carers um certainly the bigger carriers bigger the carrier probably less risk adverse uh or more risk adverse and so less likely to bring on those types of drivers but yeah big concern all right so that's uh Clearing House Phase 2 that was like I said most recent um change we saw from FMCSA this past year um I don't have the Clearing House data in front of me that was the next thing on my list but I think the number that we're always just baffled by are the nearly 180,000 drivers that are in prohibited status currently and that number just keeps ticking up month after month after month and it's just a ridiculous number at this point 180,000 Drive CDL drivers not able to operate because of a drug or alcohol testing violation in their past and only a small actually those are the ones that are in prohibited status having not even started the return to duty Pro uh process and then there's a small fraction of that number that have started that return to duty process to get back in the trunck but very very small relatively speaking this will go a little off topic but for as many that are in the clearing house now in a prohibited status for urine only testing or for alcohol testing it's like when you start getting into these other testing methods that are approved like hair follicle or oral fluid and then how many more uh are going to be in there how how how much is that going to increase because you know I was talking to a carrier last week which is a large car I mean 2,000 trucks and big fuel hauler they're doing in-house policy driven oral fluid testing and they did a sample of their drivers and out of 17 positives on hair follicle testing only one of those positives on hair follicle were positive for urine wow so I thought that was pretty interesting so I think if if that ever kicks off I think that 180,000 number is going to go way up yeah if we end up with a more sensitive allowable do test type we will probably it just makes sense we would see those numbers rise even more dramatically and even more quickly than we have with the with the year analysis and you know that's probably a good point to talk about oral fluid testing because that's also on the list um this is something that has been in the works for a long time at this point so I think FMCSA um pushed forward with the final rule back in 2023 so last year that paves the way for fleets to start using oral fluid testing uh in addition to or in lie of your analysis for DOT mandated drug test the thing we've been waiting on though that that has rendered these this useless at this point is that there are no Laboratories set up or approved yet that can process the those test results from oral fluid testing so even though the the framework the regulatory framework is in place for oral fluid testing and less and until we get those labs at least two Labs certified fleets aren't authorized to use it yet and also we've we're still waiting on them to approve the testing device for those types of test and so we've been in limbo now for uh almost a year if not over a year um waiting for that and so it's kind of a look back at this year but also a look forward to next year hoping by we've been saying this for months at this point but hopefully by next year we will have those labs in place and uh and fleets will start being able to take advantage of of those types of
tests any um any thoughts on oral fluid testing as compared to your analysis guys I I mean I definitely like it when it comes to you know no more shy bladder issues for a safety manager to deal with there's no more um you know having to have same sex there for observed uh tests you know because it's all they're all observed so I I I think you're just spitting in a in a tube essentially yeah that's that's the the the apparatus that I've seen where it it you spit into the top and it goes down and it and it splits off into two yeah splits off into two and then there's a way that they take that apart and seal it and all that but you know it it does take all the issues with hair testing away too you know because there's there's a segment of society that you they can't cut the you know they can't take the hair so there's really no issues as far as anything that we've seen that I that I can see uh with like with the other types of testing yeah if you look in that final rule if anybody's interested if you look in that fmcsa's final rule that the way for oral fluid testing they've got some interesting data in there about you know comparing the testing window or detection windows for oral fluid testing versus your analysis um from what I recall I mean I'm no scientist but from what I recall they were pretty comparable to one another um but yeah I think the big deal with it is they are easier to administer and there is less of a chance of um you know some kind of funny business with drivers trying to cheat the system by with your analysis where since they're not observed you know substituting urine with some kind of prosthetic or fake urine or whatever they do uh which has become a big problem with your analysis so the idea I think is oral fluid testing they're all observed so less of a chance for that type of thing so um I think it'll be a good option for fleets I get the sense that maybe they may be a little bit more expensive if I remember correctly than than your analysis but but not prohibitively expensive from what I recall well and I've done it I mean with non nonot fleets when you're doing like a policy driven test we've used it in the past that and eup and both of them are a whole lot faster and a whole lot cheaper I don't know if that'll still be the case but it's a federal um test because then you're obviously going to have to have two specimens instead of one and other things that are going to happen but another thing with this is it'll kill the negative delute piece I mean you're not going to have to about that part so um if that's a policy thing for you but anyway that's that's my take historically on it I think I did see in the final rule you mentioned shy bladder Brian and this doing away with it I think there I think there is something about like dry mouth issues or something like that I can't remember what it said but that would be the you know that would be the the analog yeah um okay so that's oral fluid testing um the other big thing we saw this past year and this is actually this is even more recent than the Clearing House Phase 2 was the expansion of the crash preventability determination program um Brian you w to you want to give a summary of kind of what we saw there sure yeah they added four new crash types um they they had some special wording in those crash types so it you're still going to have to be careful with with how you submit these and make sure the information that you put with them is is accurate like being hit in the side going the same direction that is an accepted one now the loss of control is and being struck by another vehicle but it has to say in the police report or the crash report that the other vehicle lost control um that is that's imperative to that one the third one was vehicles coming out from a like a driveway or a parking lot or something like that and striking this was a conversation Brandon you and I had last week striking the CMV so not the CMV striking the car so if they come out and they hit the side of the truck then that that counts however the fourth one t kind of would take care of the third one because the fourth one is anything video wise that shows the sequence of events that that shows that the driver could not have prevented the crash so you know if if someone pulls out in front of the truck in a side you know on a side street or a stop a uh parking lot or something like that if video shows that there was absolutely no time to react that's where that one would would fall so you know you want to make sure that you file it under the correct crash type and understand the nuances to each one but you know that one with video is absolutely huge that's a big deal uh and then they it it went into effect December 1st although we are still wait as far as I know we're still waiting on the FMCSA to say okay we've updated our site you can go ahead and submit those crash types now yeah it'll be retroactive to December 1st they get once they get the website ready to accept those new crash types right yeah so I don't know if I was breaking up or something during then felt like I was freezing up okay um but yeah I mean that that video one is is a big deal it's a big win for fleets that have um you know forward-facing cameras or or you know any kind of cameras on on the trucks that could show the sequence of events it's kind of a catch all I mean if if you get the video and it shows that your driver wasn't at fault or or or couldn't have prevented the accident then I think you submit that that challenge and with the video evidence and see how it goes so well I think the one of the things with that though is like how subjective will this get with the reviewers because you know there's a lot of videos that I post online where it looks from just an everyday person perspective it's like well there's no way the truck could have avoided that or prevented that but then when you actually take into other in fact other considerations that they may not have thought of like hey looking far enough ahead to say hey there's people merging into traffic I should slow down or I should merge left it's like hey you know when is the how much subjectivity is the reviewer going to put into it to say I don't agree that this wasn't so um you know there's there's that piece of it yeah that's that's a good point Rob and that's that highlights one of the big reasons why you should absolutely submit a letter in addition to this video documentation obviously the police report that's required but um submitting a narrative on what happened and your point of view and why um it shouldn't kind of get scarer I mean you you need to do that on every single crash if you're going to submit it just submit the police report and the video and then a the short little paragraph in the box when you're submitting the RDR I mean that may not be far enough for you so it's really important to submit a really detailed letter yeah but it's a good caution uh from Rob that you know whenever it comes to the de accuse system which is where you file these preventability uh challenges it is not going to be your savior do not do not look to that as as something that's going to you know save your scores or anything like that there's a lot of subjectivity built into it um so but nevertheless these changes were our welcomed changes um you know ex continuing to expand this program so that fleets aren't uh and drivers aren't negatively impacted by accidents that they couldn't have prevented anyway it just makes sense that we have something like that problem is that subjectivity creeps into it and uh and so you end up you know having to uh having to eat the eat the bullet on some of those but it is what it is so anyway that was one other one other thing that they did was they revised some of the existing crash types one of the one of the things that happens frequently that I've seen with carriers and helped them with these filings is when you have someone that hits your truck under the influence and it may not qualify for one of the other existing crash types they actually relaxed that standard of that crash type to where you no longer have to proof of of an arrest and and documentation in that regard um you can have police reported indications of intoxication to qualify for this crash type in the future yeah that's a good change yeah hopefully that will kind of expand it more for fleets that that need to take advantage of that um okay those were changes to the crash preventability determination program uh the other thing I wanted to mention from this past year we saw the FMCSA ramp up it's uh it's oversight of ELD manufacturers so uh we saw several ELD devices revoked from the self-certified list of devices over this past year probably I mean not a ton but probably a dozen or two over this past year which is a dozen or two more than it had done historically um and so you know I think that's important as the list of ELD devices continues to grow the you know the issue we have with our ELD system here in the states is that um there's no third party that has to and certainly not the FMCSA that has to sign off on these devices to ensure that they meet the technical specifications for those devices it's the manufacturers themselves that self-certify that hey yeah we we are certifying our devices meet these requirements Well turns out that some of the devices don't meet those standards even though they been certified by the manufacturers and so we are starting to see FMCSA crack down on that a little bit and I think Jared you know in our experience what we're seeing is usually FMCSA will only initiate an investigation after they get some like repeated complaints about a system or more likely they're seeing lots of problems roadside with a particular device they will go in and uh and ask that manufacturer for documentation and if they decide that it doesn't meet the technical specs then they will revoke it so that we've seen that quite a few times yeah we see you know issues with missing required data points in the logs when they're transferred through eods the FMCSA kind of maintains an exception report list a naughty list if you will um and they'll generate investigations based on repeated you know failures to transfer through e- rods with the required data points industry complaints can also generate investigations um we've definitely I've definitely observed the FMCSA being more aggressive with investigating e vendors certainly in the last 12 18 months they've gotten a little more aggressive um as it stands right now we have approximately 250 revoked elds so if you go to the list of self-certified ELD vendors there's a tab at the top that says um self-certified and then there's also a tab at the top that says revok devices you can click on revoke devices and search that whole list and find which devices have been revoked and again it's it's not indicative of all of those have been investigated and revoked by the FMCSA there's a lot of reasons why a device can be revoked voluntarily you know sales of the business or failed business whatever the case may be so not necessarily all investigations there but it's really important as a carrier that you're signed up to get notifications from FMCSA because that's where you're going to get that email that's says here's the list of revocations for ELD um the last one that they sent on December 11th revoked four devices and they instructed the motor carriers that are using those devices to switch to paper logs and said that they had until February 9th to replace the ELD with an approved ELD and so if you get that notice I mean a lot of times um the vendor will reach out to FMCSA immediately and start trying to work with them on getting uh reinstated um doesn't always work sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't if it happens it happens pretty quick usually but I think communicating with a vendor at that point you know if there's hope that reinstatement is going to occur set yourself like a two-e deadline or something like that where you're going to say okay we're going to use paper for two weeks and then we're signing a contract with another vendor because we can't be you know twisting in the wind with this revoked ELD on our trucks um or paper Beyond February 9th so being proactive absolutely critical there now to be clear the the devices revoked involuntarily so far have at least from from my perspective been like pretty minor players in that industry it's not like they're out there revoking the big boys that that the major fleets have installed on their trucks it's lesser known ELD devices that have been revoked so um maybe some of you can take some comfort from that fact but some of that goes back to what Jared said about being proactive it's not just proactive in like monitoring are you on is your vendor on the list it's vendor selection is Big too so I mean if you're going into this and you're looking for like the $4 Bob's ELD service obviously there could be issues long term so especially if you have a huge Fleet the amount of work that has to go into removing that teaching people how to use a new system reinst calls it's like just pay $5 more a month and you'll have some reputable carrier that's going to be in business for you know hopefully long term but vendor selection's big in it too I just never understood this whole it's you're right Rob it's absolutely huge I mean an easy sanity check that you can do if you're looking at a device see if they're certified in Canada because they have to be certified by a third party there I mean that's not the ultimate test but I'm saying that certainly represents a vendor that has their stuff together they've gone through Canadian testing now there's plenty of vendors that have chosen not to be in the Canadian Market or they've selected a white label to use in Canada um certainly not saying that if a if a vendor is not Canadian approved that they're not a good vendor but that's a sanity check that you can use yeah yeah all right couple other things here and then we'll move on to kind of an outlook for 2025 um worth briefly mentioning some of the major lawsuits that we saw over the past year um not all of these have started in the last year but have kind of picked up steam over the last year uh the wner case we're we're constantly referring to that Werner case uh the Texas case where uh Werner got hit with a hundreds of millions of dollar jury verdict um in Texas this is still under appeal it's been going on for years I think it's at the Texas Supreme Court right now um but werner's driver I mean basic facts of the casee Werner had like a it like a trainee driver right like a a fairly new driver driving in bad weather um and but was but was driving under the speed limit um and was driving in his lane and then a car a passenger car from the opposite uh Lane um spun out of control and entered into the werner's lane and impacted Warner and um ended up killing a couple of folks in that accident I think from the passenger car um was that the was that also the the passengers weren't wearing seat belts right in the in the passenger car I get some of these accidents mixed up was that the wall Bash one W yeah that's the wall Bash one was there alcohol involved in the wner case okay no that was W Bash Too okay so wner that the other car just spun out um because of the bad weather and and entered uh the Warner truck driver's Lane and and uh and resulted in fatalities long story short really in terms of what the wner driver was doing from all accounts he couldn't have really been doing anything more to have prevented that accident in other words nothing he could have done to have prevented the accident in the situation as it was yet Warner ends up with a hundreds of million dollar verdict awarded against it um the the rationale being from what I understand the arguments were that Warner may have ated some of its own internal policies about having trainee drivers operating out in in bad weather uh and so the the the plaintiff's attorney's argument was well if you had followed your own rules you wouldn't had this driver out there operating anyway and could have avoided this accident so point is um you know pretty crazy facts and just highlights how some of these nuclear vertic type cases uh play out and um really makes it t tough environment for fleets to know what exactly is expected of them and what they can do to minimize their exposure when you're dealing with cases like that and also the W bash case so the W bash case was a more recent one um involved W bash trailers um and it was uh from what I understand again basic facts uh a pretty old trailer I can't remember the date it was manufactured but manufactured many years ago uh manufactured to standards that were in place at the time the trailer was manufactured so to it uh in particular the rear impact guards for those trailers the guards that hang down below the trailer to prevent cars from underwriting from from the back um and so the trailer as I understand it had been manufactured according to the standards in place at the time of the manufacturer but uh trailer was was used and then involved in an accident where a car a passenger car underr that trailer and killed some people and the argument of the plaintiffs Journey was that hey even though it met the regulatory standards in place at the time of the accident uh Wabash could have done more to it could have it could have implemented even stronger controls for it or more robust underride guards um and and W bash ended up with a hundreds of millions of dollar jury verdict awarded against it and in that case the I think that was the one that the evidence was that the driver of the passenger vehicle in that case uh had um alcohol in his system and was not wearing a seat Bel so aggravating circumstances on his part so again just another the jury was not allowed to hear that information right yeah that was all withheld so uh it's just these types of cases that make you scratch your head if you're a fleet what could we have done to have avoided these things and there's not a whole lot that you can do to avoid these things I mean certainly what you can do is make sure you're following all applicable laws because if you just if you're not following the laws then you're really opening yourself up in those cases but even in these cases these cases just highlight that even if you're doing what the law requires of you oftentimes that's not enough um the plaintiff's bar is going to be casting you as a bad actor one way or the other and the ways that they do that are you know your historic safety data what are your CSA scores look like are you doing other things that have become industry standard uh and if not maybe that's evidence of of your your negligence so you know just watch out for these things keep a breast of these types of cases take whatever lessons you can take from them and um yeah that's about all I have to say about this I heard the I've heard the phrase multiple times in that in the the Warner case there at Supreme Court do care MH and even to the point where they were arguing what whether or not that truck should have had a CB in it was the company taking due care and yeah so I mean they're getting down because he should have been able to get on the CV and say or you know find out what the conditions were and stuff like that well he had been in those conditions for a serious length of time he knew what they were and that's why he was driving like he was driving um so in my eyes he was taking due care but that is that is a phrase that I think is going to be more prevalent going forward yeah and you know the other point is these cases are you know pushing along what's called tort reform in several States you know Texas is an example Florida is another recent example of states that have recently enacted some level of tort reform aimed at kind of curbing lawsuit abuse not to you know I'm not weighing in on these particular cases and whether there's any kind of formal lawsuit abuse um there may be there may not be but the point of that legis that type of legislation is to put an end to some of the tactics the unfair tactics that the plaintiff Spar has employed to end up with these multi-million dollar verdicts against trucking companies specifically um sometimes this this type of legislation is specific to trucking other times it's broader but the point is to cut out some of the of that type of stuff so that we get verdicts that are that are more fair looking at objectively so yeah and and another thing these cases are really good examples of the tactic PL of Spar often times will use where you know particularly in the Warner case not focusing on the facts of the crash at all make it about everything but the facts of the crash because if you just look at the facts of the crash it looks like the Warner driver couldn't have done anything different but they make it about the policies how they're administered uh the safety culture of the company and you should assume that's how the cases are going to go go if you ever get involved in one so it's it's a good reason to do a sanity check on your policies and and all of those things because they could turn out to be one of the things that the case turns on both of these to me ran like counter to Common Sense and like just personal responsibility especially the wos one it was like if you're drunk and you don't have a seat belt on there's an inherent level of responsibility that you should have accepted obviously you're dead but your family at that point and but going to what you're talking about Jared it's like the emotional extortion of juries where it's like hey don't pay attention to what's really important it's like look over here at this and it just it it gets people emotionally charged and then they they make a decision to hold somebody responsible for someone else's personal decision yeah pay attention to the man behind the curtain yeah yeah and it's the undercurrent too that it's the big bad trucking company and they've got insurance they've got all the money in the world let's let's get a big verdict here jury and you're right it's kind of an extortion of the jury yeah all right so let's move on then that's kind of a look back at some of the major uh headlines from 2024 let look ahead to 2025 with what time we've got left uh I see somebody on LinkedIn is asking a question which I think goes to this um they're asking what do you think about the emergence of autonomous driving and the impact on on jobs and that type of stuff and I I think that's probably a good place to start with autonomous Trucking and what we might expect for 2025 uh frankly I'm not holding my breath that we're going to see anything on autonomous Trucking in 2025 you the last we saw from a regulatory perspective I should say certainly the autonomous Trucking is is taking off in terms of the technology and The Fleets that are adopting it and the amount of operations that are taking root in different parts of the country namely Texas um but in terms of rule making probably I don't anticipate seeing much on that in 2025 if anything I just think FMCSA is so behind on other stuff that they got going on and and Nitsa that I don't know I I I just don't I'm not going to hold my breath we we have seen FMCSA and nits issue a joint advanced notice of proposed rule making probably two years ago on this topic where they were starting to get the ball rolling on it and asking the public what they should what issues they should think about uh for autonomous Trucking uh in terms of developing a regulatory framework for that but the we haven't heard anything on it since that time and so you know at some point we're going to have to get a regulatory framework for that because right now we have no regulations governing it um but yeah I mean that's kind of my outlook for it uh just I don't see it com to fruition in 2025 in any significant form you guys have other thoughts I think in some cases like you you have autonomous vehicles running in like Texas where there's nothing but flat land and um you can kind of you can it the environment is fit for it and I think you know like Elon mus said 50 years you're gonna have all tonos vehicles run the road with no drivers yes I believe that but I think right now and in the near future you're you're talking like specific use cases that will work but not WID spread Hub to HUB makes sense Long Haul Hub to Hub yeah turn like Turnpike operations stuff like that you know they shoot they're pulling twin 53s up there just about anything goes so yeah those types of operations I could see them being used for yeah in in the absence of some large scale regulatory activity I mean the commercialization of AVS to where these companies can actually start making money which is kind of the big deal um it's just not going to happen at this point I mean there has to be some regulation and at some point these companies have been taking in investor money uh doing all the research and the building and the testing and they're not making money how long can that last I think a lot of a lot of the manufacturers welcome regulation because the last thing they want to do is invest all this money in technology that then gets rendered obsolete by regulations that prohibit it being used in that particular way so they want a framework in place so that they know what rules they're playing by just exactly and and my point point being I I think it would be an absolute shame if all this Tech technological advancement died on the vine because the federal government couldn't get it together enough to issue regulations and we can't talk about 2025 without talking about the Trump Administration and how I mean it's almost undoubted there's going to be less regulation under that Administration so it makes it even less likely at that point yeah and yeah let's just move to that uh obviously that's going to be the the significant change come up coming up in 2025 new Administration means big changes for federal agencies of which FMCSA and usdot are are part of that uh and so we know that there are going to be changes um you know we're going to have a new Secretary of Transportation Pete Budaj is going to be out of that job uh Trump has already nominated um somebody else I think a former congressman from Wisconsin um and so that you know that will have to get pushed through the Senate we will probably then see a new FMCSA administrator get appointed and that would have to be Senate confirmed uh and that's just as we know that's a revolving door there at the FMCSA administrator position I don't even I think we've had probably what eight or nine administrators over the last five or six years it's just been a crazy number um and we will likely see another new one um and then the other thing that I think we should expect once Trump takes office we saw this when he took office in 2016 he implemented back then what I think they called his two for one rule which was that for every new regulation that a federal agency wanted to push forward they had to Target Two existing regulations to uh get rid of and so if they want to move forward with a new rule then they have to get rid of two existing rules I've heard I don't know if I haven't heard on anything on this recently but I think on the campaign Trail Trump had mentioned that he was going to do something similar but maybe like a 10 for one rule where if you wanted to push forward one regulation new regulation you had to Target 10 existing regulations to get rid of obviously the point of that is to dissuade uh extensive rule making activity by federal agencies which is part and parcel with a republican Administration um kind of you know the whole idea of being smaller federal government uh larger state activity um so I think we should expect something like that part of that is I think gonna be made better by depends on how you look at it but for me it would be better but um the slower Ru making process because of Chevron and how that that whole thing is going to kind of I think maybe blend together with it to kind of slow things down a little bit I think some regulations like I think speed limiter someone posted yesterday speed limiter was going to happen in 2025 and I'm like not in your life there's a different admitt coming in and that's going to kill that I think but um yeah I mean that's a good point you we didn't talk about Chevron but that was another huge development in 2024 not just for Trucking but certainly significantly impacts Trucking we don't have time to get into it but is a major Supreme Court decision that um significantly uh it it redistributes the balance of power between the brand anches of government um they had been largely a federal agencies have have been given a lot of difference in terms of them interpreting their own rules uh because of a case from the 80s called Chevron uh a lot of federal courts defer to agencies uh when it comes to their own rule making activity well now the case that came out this year I can't remember uh lerb I think was the name of it uh Supreme Court case essentially um got rid of the Chevron difference and so now federal agencies or federal courts are not beholden to agency interpretations of those agencies own enabling statutes so giving a lot less deference to federal agencies going forward and this could very well impact Trucking um we've seen federal courts defer to FMCSA specifically in past rulemaking activities that get challenged in court the one that comes to mind is the ELD rulemaking that got tied up in federal court for for many years and ultimately the the federal courts deferred to the FMCSA and said hey you guys are the experts on this we're going to let you Mo move forward with it going forward now with Chevron not being a thing maybe we don't see that type of difference so should be interesting um a couple other things to look forward to in 2025 if you're a fleet um upcoming changes to the safety measurement system CSA scores this will be a big one um FMC a first proposed these back in 2023 and has been working on them over the last year uh we recently within the last month or so they came out with a new notice that said they're still pushing forward with these they made some tweaks to it but uh fairly significant changes to the way that they calculate CSA scores we've got like a two-hour podcast where we went through all of those changes if you're interested in it but um yeah be on the lookout for that they haven't given us a deadline of of when those are going to take effect but it's probably going to drop in in 2025 so yeah it'll be like the crash stuff all of a sudden hey Friday these are going live okay thanks I think that's about as much as much notice as we're gonna get yeah because it's not a rule making so it doesn't require a final Rule and a comment period or anything like that so uh that will take effect again if you're interested in what those changes are go back and check out our content on it um speed limiters Rob mentioned it you know it's on the Dot's agenda as it has been for the last what 10 years probably it's a joint rule making between FMCSA and Nitsa that would if it ever moves forward would mandate speed limiters on newly manufactured Vehicles after a certain date what the speed would be set to we've only heard you know guesses I think 68 is what most people are thinking is where it would land but the big wild card is is that ever going to get pushed forward I think it's on the agenda for May of 2025 of when the FMCSA and nits are going to revisit it but that keeps getting pushed back uh and it's probably going to get kicked down the line even further now with the change of administration so I'm with Rob I don't see that happening in 20125 any other thoughts on that guys nope I'm with you I don't think it's gonna get I don't think it's gonna get pushed through now or then or even again over then so it's gonna be a while y uh we already mentioned oral fluid testing so then the last one that I would mention are um potential changes to safety Fitness determinations safety ratings The three- tier system that we currently have you satisfactory conditional or unset these are ratings that the FMCSA issues to motor carers that have gone through a DOT audit and um you know they've been toying around with changing up the way that they assigned those ratings for many years um but it has remained consistently the same uh they haven't they haven't made those changes they came out with an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking on this in 2024 saying hey we're thinking about potentially changing the way we assign ratings including potentially tying them to a carrier's CSA scores um but it's very early on in the rule making and so they would ultimately have to put together a notice of proposed Ru making open that up for comments and uh and give us some more details on it you know crystal ball again I don't think it's going to I don't think we're going to see a proposed rule on it we may see a proposed rule on it we're definitely not going to see it take effect in 20125 if I had to guess um but we could see some movement on it in 2025 if if I had to guess what I'm suspecting that they will do is they will drop these uh safety measurement system changes on us here shortly and then they will after they do that then they will start to think about whether they should tie a carrier safety rating to those CSA scores so would that would be a significant shift from the way that we currently do things we would end up with potentially a lot more carriers having a safety rating than the 5% or so that currently have safety ratings which could be worse for some could end up with a lot more carriers getting shut down because of it so all right I know some of us have to go at 3:00 so we're going to wrap it up there thanks everybody for joining us today uh we could have spent probably probably another 3 hours talking about that type of stuff but we just don't have the time uh again best way to keep in touch with us and what we've got going on is subscribing to our newsletter so we hope you do that uh check out our online courses we got a lot of courses on DOT compliance issues for Fleet Safety professionals you check those out and everything else we got going on at trucksafe decom anyway um appreciate you spending time with us looking forward to doing these in the new year thanks guys for joining me we will see everybody next time later Merry Christmas Merry Christmas