About This Event
In this episode, we’re joined by transportation attorney Tyler Biddle to discuss key legal issues impacting fleets in 2025. Tyler will address topics like transportation contracts, corporate structuring, independent contractor classification, lease agreements, broker transparency, and more!
Episode Summary
In Episode 45 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad are joined by newly hired Trucksafe Consulting and Childress Law attorney Tyler Biddle to kick off 2025 with a discussion of the top legal issues facing trucking fleets, freight brokers, and motor carriers. The conversation covers five significant legal and regulatory topics that industry professionals should be monitoring closely, many of which are being shaped by the recent change in presidential administration.
The first major topic is the FMCSA's proposed broker transparency rulemaking, which would amend 49 CFR 371.3 to require brokers to disclose transaction records to carriers within 48 hours and would call into question the enforceability of waiver language commonly found in broker-carrier agreements. The hosts and Tyler discuss the origins of the issue, including the well-publicized Pink Cheetah Express vs. TQL dispute, and raise significant questions about whether the FMCSA has the statutory authority to regulate what are essentially private contractual arrangements in a deregulated marketplace. The hosts note that with a change in administration and new FMCSA leadership, this proposed rulemaking may not advance to a final rule.
The group also discusses lease-purchase agreements, highlighting the recent Truck Leasing Task Force report issued under the Biden Administration, which characterized these arrangements as "irredeemable tools of fraud." Tyler and the hosts push back on that characterization, noting that while bad actors exist, many lease-purchase programs serve legitimate purposes and benefit owner-operators who prefer the independence the arrangements provide. This topic flows into a broader conversation about independent contractor misclassification, where the hosts explain that the Department of Labor's classification test has shifted with each administration, creating a persistent patchwork of federal and state standards with no clear resolution in sight. Fleets operating independent contractor models are urged to review their agreements for compliance with the truth-in-leasing regulations and to adopt operational best practices that reduce the risk of reclassification.
Tyler highlights two additional areas of concern for fleets. First, he urges carriers to carefully review their customer-facing transportation agreements, particularly provisions related to cargo liability limitations, offset and payment withholding rights, and insurance obligations. He notes that carriers frequently sign agreements requiring insurance coverages or limits they do not actually maintain, placing them in immediate breach. Second, he addresses nuclear verdicts, encouraging fleets to examine their corporate structure as one layer of protection against catastrophic jury awards, alongside investing in safety and maintaining adequate insurance coverage.
The episode's key takeaway is that fleets face a complex and shifting legal landscape in 2025, and proactive legal review of contracts, corporate structure, and independent contractor programs is essential. As Tyler notes, understanding what you are agreeing to in a customer contract, even when leverage is limited, is a critical first step in managing legal and financial risk. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to consult with transportation counsel, stay engaged with regulatory developments at the FMCSA, and take a comprehensive approach to risk management that combines compliance, insurance, and sound corporate structure.
Full Transcript
up oh
a
up up
if you're like us you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after - is the first web and mobile app version of the Federal Motor Carrier safety regulations helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations ereg is always up to date and allows Fleet Safety professionals to not only read the rules but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts highlight bookmark and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules ereg was developed by safety Professionals for safety professionals try it out for free at .a oh
all right hey everyone welcome to episode 45 truck safe live show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon that's Jared we are with truck safe children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain Cutting Edge safety programs Happy New Year to everybody this is our first show in 2025 took a couple months off there had some stuff going on had a new baby in that time period so um yeah so yeah exciting things going on there and then also at truck safe for sure we got a lot in store for 2025 so a lot to talk about but uh glad to be back um Jared your year is going okay so far hopefully yeah going good so far I didn't really have time off as you say I wouldn't really call having a baby time off but my uh my Year's been uneventful compared to yours yeah you just got back from Australia though no I did yeah little bit of jet lag this week so uh doing pretty good all right well that's all that matters um uh let's see I for kind of forget how to do the show here so let me try and remember how to do this if you're here with us watching live say hey in the comments so we know everybody who's here and uh yeah excited about today's show we've got a a good topic to talk about exciting news on our Law Firm side of things hired a new attorney uh who Jared and I have worked with for many years so excited to have him on the show today to kind of break down some of the key legal issues that fleets need to be aware of for uh 20125 and Beyond so looking forward to that before we get to that though few things going on here at truck safe that we should talk about well first of all let me say thanks to the sponsor of this episode taking the higher Road a legacy Builders and Freight waves production taking the higher road is a special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges driver recruiting retention and compliance each week host Jeremy rer 20-year industry veteran and founder of driver reach and Legacy Builders interviews industry experts and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast so thanks to taking the higher Road uh one thing that we just announced on the truck safe side of things that uh that we're really excited about is our next uh Fleet compliance boot camp so this is our in-person conference two-day in-person conference that we do once a year this is our four fourth boot camp uh this one is presented by DriveWise so thanks to the DriveWise folks for sponsoring this year uh it's going to be September 3rd and 4th in Indianapolis like I said two-day conference we're going to get together with a group of around a 100 or so safety professionals safety managers safety directors risk advisors for insurance companies those types of folks to talk about nothing but DOT compliance so it's been a good uh a good thing for the last few few years here get a lot of great feedback from it every year looking forward to doing it again we've got a bigger venue this year so uh we ran out of room last year at our last spot so um yeah looking forward to that uh hopefully you are too Jared I am indeed the fourth one that we've done um they uh they're always fun events they they actually get easier and easier each time so I'm glad that the event growing a little bit more incrementally uh not necessarily just for you know the amount of people coming just because the demand for it is growing a little bit so that's good to see yeah so if you're interested in details on that or to register and join us in Indianapolis in September check out the details over at trucksafe bootcamp.com and we hope to see you there uh next up I'll mention the truck safe uh network if you haven't joined the network I really encourage you to do so this is our uh Network that we created for Fleet Safety Professional to gather together learn from one another ask questions and also access all of our DOT related content that we push out through truck safe videos webinars we just did a a long webinar Series last year all about improving CSA scores that was really well attended uh so all of that type of stuff is available to network members it's free to join uh you can get the details over at trucksafe network.com or scan that QR code there or download the app in the app store or the Google Play Store uh great resource for Fleet Safety professionals so hope to see you there too uh lastly I'll mention um our newsletter if you're not subscribed to our newsletter that's a great way to stay on top of what we've got going on at trucksafe which is a lot more nowadays than it used to be um but trucks safe.com subscribe is where you can get all of our you know breaking industry news and our analysis of it that we push out uh usually kind of on a weekly basis so if you are in a Fleet Safety position I or a risk advisor or anything like that and you want access to you know what's going on in the industry from a compliance standpoint that's a great way to keep on top of that stuff so check that out again trucksafe outcom subscribe all right did I miss anything Jared no I think you remembered how to do that pretty well actually came back to me came flooding back to me there so I think we're good to go um but anyway um moving on so as I said topic of today's show is key legal issues for fleets in 2025 thought this would be a good way to kick things off for the for the new year at least for our show here um you know we ended last year the last truck safe live we did in 2024 was kind of a look back at 2024 what we saw from a regulatory standpoint what kind of rules the FMCSA was pushing forward with what we saw from an enforcement standpoint but we um we didn't really look at it so much from like a legal standpoint what are some of the legal challenges that fleets are facing and so I thought that would be an interesting way to kick things off this year uh so I'm excited to have with us today uh Tyler bidd Tyler welcome to the show can you hear us thank you all right here we are to be on thanks for having me on yeah I I thought we were gonna have intro music he requested Rocky like a hurricane but that didn't happen sorry about that yeah sorry we we're not that technical here um but anyway uh yeah so as I mentioned Jared and I have worked with Tyler for many many years now and um and we're excited to finally have him on board with us uh kind of been wearing them down for the last couple years trying to get them to come over and he uh he finally broke down and did it so we're excited to have him on board um I'm going to let you Tyler go ahead and introduce yourself kind of your background how you got into transportation that type of stuff yeah um thanks Kev for having me on and uh and and happy to happy to be working with you guys again so just by way of background um I started my legal career um working with Brandon and Jared uh at our my first firm um Boutique Transportation Law Firm dedicated to the transportation industry representing Transportation companies motor carriers freight brokers warehousemen um Freight forwarders um from there I actually went to a a much larger firm about 700 attorneys for the past three and a half years um did a lot of corporate um transactional work there a lot of mergers and Acquisitions um corporate restructuring um again a lot of a lot of that type of work and then you know after you know a number of conversations with Brandon and Jared just really um I'm excited to be working with them again join them uh at the beginning of this month February and it's uh it's it's been fun so far and obviously this is a really really great opportunity to join you guys on truck Safe Life so you went from mediumsized firm to large firm to tiny little Law Firm this is where you're at now yeah I've really gotten the flavor of it all maybe uh who knows what's next no I I I really uh hope there is no more law firm jumping yeah no we're excited to have you and also on the truck safe side of things so forgot to mention that Tyler is going to work with us on the truck safe side of things so all the resources we've got available at at truck safe Tyler is going to help us push that forward he's going to be at the boot camp speaking at the boot camp with us so really looking forward to that but um Tyler while we got you here we thought it would be a good time to talk about some of the top legal issues you've got a better pulse on a lot of these things than than Jared and I do on the law firm side we tend to stick to our lane which has been do safety regulations uh primarily but you have kind of a broader base understanding of the legal issues impacting a lot of fleets and Brokers and shippers out there so I'm just going to turn it over to you and maybe we can hit on maybe like the top five legal issues you're uh you're seeing and that Fleet should should be considering so I'll turn it over yeah um and I think there are some really um you know I say exciting for me from a legal standpoint in terms of what could happen but there's some really um kind of hot issues right now um for fleets to kind of be tracking considering um I think the and some of this is really politically driven and so after you know having this election you know a prior Administration you know proposes rule making um or you know has has has some laws passed and things change when you get a change of administration and and some of it will be really interesting to see how things develop in light of who's running you know especially right now the FMCSA um the first thing um to to anybody who's following it is the the proposed fmcsa's proposed rule Mak making on broker transparency um this happened late last year um the FMCSA proposed some additional rules to 49 CFR um 3 71.3 which you know requires Brokers to um provide certain records to carriers upon request um they had opened it up for comments they had received over what 3,500 comments or no 5,300 comments so far um the FMCSA re of those were from you you know 5100 yeah 5100 um no I mean there's it's it's clearly a huge issue um and and really the the thing that prompted this was really you know oida um wanted some some transparency here because um you know the fleets small fleets especially that that work with Brokers kind of feel like felt like they've been getting screwed in in in large part um because they don't the uh you know what kind of cut the Brokers are getting off of the movements and that type of stuff well that's it and that's some of the the problem is is you know the the you know smart fleets are saying hey you know these these Brokers they're they're taking way more than they should um you know we're the ones actually moving the goods you know what what do they have into it um as if you know they they you know large freight brokers have invested a lot of Technology a lot of money into developing these customers coord yeah I mean Devil's Advocate what they have into it is the relationship with the shippers which the carriers aren't going to get on their own so no no but but some transparency you know I get it and and some of this really kind of originated and if anybody's really been following it um from a from a real detailed perspective there was a specific shipment um carrier named pink cheetah Express um uh was hauling a shipment of ice cream for for total quality logist istics tql and the owner of the company she had requested hey tql give I want the records for this shipment and after you know tql obviously denied it their their their broker carrier agreement that pink cheetah Express agreed to it's got a waiver it's got a waiver of you know the carrier's right to records in in in 371.50 that that waiver is in every single well written any any well-drafted broker carrier agreement is going to have that waiver right and and I think that's really the key to any Ru making going forward um so anyways pink cheetah Express didn't get the record she she filed a complaint with the FMCSA FMCSA started communicating with tql saying hey look we don't think your waiver is valid you're you're you're from a regulatory standpoint you are obligated to provide these records to this carrier and after you know there was some email Communications back and forth apparently or allegedly the FMCSA threatened to show up at tql and get the records um so then tql you know turned the records over and it showed that they had you know a pretty high profit margin it was like 40 some percent right and and I think that's that's the concern that the small fleets have is gosh we are getting screwed right we have no idea you know in what these Brokers are are are getting and we feel like we should be getting more right yeah I mean makes sense but I I don't know I always come back to this on these types of issues it's like what why is FMCSA being dragged into this because in light of deregulation I mean that just it it bugs me to no end that we are asking the FMCSA to weigh in on what is essentially a private dispute between Contracting parties this is the Federal Motor Carrier safety administration whose only obligations or only tasks are to improve Highway safety why are they and they don't even have the resources necessary to effectively do that job but now we are having them spend some of their resources to essentially asking them to more deeply regulate the aspects of trucking that Congress expressly deregulated back in the 80s and 90s I don't understand why we're doing that yeah I think that's going to be a big issue um for the proposed broker transparency rules going forward setting aside you know Defence to administrative agencies that's changed you know in 2024 via you know Supreme Court rulings but hey do does the FMCSA really have the the statutory authority to propose these rules I mean if anything if you i' I'd have to look into it a little bit more but the surface Transportation board tends to be the entity the the another you know sub agency that sits under the dot that deals with the economics of Transportation right I mean they they they you know regulate you know rail ter tariffs that regulate household goods um antitrust issues um it may really more realistically fall under their purview um in this regulation specifically um here's a question for you somebody on YouTube's asking uh by the way any any answer that Tyler gives to this is not legal advice and should not be taken as such he's aon's asking what type of liability does a brokerage have if they opt to create a bill of lading for their customer do they need documented approval of each bill of lading created on the customers behalf so this is this is interesting so if you go back and look at it there's there's a bill of lading act and I it was probably sometime in the 1930s actually the carrier the motor carrier is obligated to issue a bill of lading and you may say well what are you talking about the shippers do that all right yeah in practice shippers create the bill of lading but pursuant to federal law it's actually um incumbent upon the motor carrier to issue it right now typically right we've got we've got your you know your standard bill of leting terms and conditions carrier signs it okay um yeah there's nothing prohibiting a broker from creating that bill of lading right um often you know and it's it's not and something that they like is when they're listed as a carry on of bill of lading that's something that they try and avoid if they can but there's nothing saying that they can't create that bill of leting that doesn't change their liability um for either payment or or you know cargo liability yeah the one area where I could see it potentially impacting them uh always kind of my mind always goes to do compliance is if it's a Hazmat bill of leting um the Hazmat regulations are very specific on in terms of the paperwork the shipping papers applicable to Hazmat shipments and if you as a broker take on the responsibility for preparing the shipping papers that contain hasmat shipments you take on regulatory responsibility for filling those out correctly and if you don't fill those out correctly then fima is going to be on you potentially for screwing that up so I would be I would watch out for HazMat shipments in particular yeah so I mean essentially there the broker is taking on a shipper responsibility for the Hazmat regs right yeah uh you know the um Hazmat Rags man are are we think the federal motor care safety regulations are dense the Hazmat regulations I do not envy any Hazmat carriers out there having to comply with both rules sets having to understand both rule sets but yeah I mean there's all types of uh traps in the Hazmat regulations like that where if you perform a Hazmat function a pre-transport function then you take on regulatory responsibility for whatever function you take on as a broker or a shipper or a carrier so yeah something to watch out for question from me on broker transparency kind of in the vein of the comment that Brandon made earlier about limited resources with these additional requirements like requiring electronic recordkeeping and you know implementing a 48 hour timeline for record disclosure things like that how first of all how is this going to be policed is this going to be another thing unloaded on FMCSA to police and how how are Brokers going to be held accountable that's a good question I mean uh yeah who's going to regulate this now arguably there's a private right of action that you know a carrier could sue right but but that requires some some resources to to do that right to to enforce it via VIA litigation but yeah I think that's a great question who's who's going to enforce this because I mean shoot the the FMCSA doesn't even uh enforce illegal brokerage right now I mean really practically speaking you know you talk about issues with you know legal double brokering you know carriers brokering shipments without brokerage Authority that's happening all the time and contributing to the to the massive amount of fraud we have and FMCSA can't even regulate that what they're going to regulate this I I I don't I don't see how they could do it quite frankly Jack on uh Jack Van steenberg on on LinkedIn is saying oh why does point is that with more money carriers get from Brokers they will put towards safety LOL he says this regulation is left over from the old ICC days yeah I agree I mean that was my point is that these are holdovers from the commercial regulation that the Interstate Commerce Commission before the FMCSA used to have the authority to regulate these things and some of those aspects of it are holdovers that are still on the books but are not enforced um because the FMC that that part of transportation is deregulated so it's matters of private contract that it's the market that is to figure this out and private lawsuits and stuff like that so yeah I you know I don't know well and I think you know again this this has nothing really do it all with safety but from from a you know Market perspective and and if you look at most of the comments I mean I think most people are in agreement yeah this this isn't going to make sure that it's not going to like level the playing field or make things more fair or ensure that carers are being paid more you knowy if if the if the if the if the lad doesn't pay don't take it right and I think that's it's not it's not like the rule they would come out with would say it has you have to pay this x amount it it's just going to say have to disclose what you're paying so yeah and and I don't I don't know you know for for for any Fleet you know you no nobody's holding a gun to your head and saying you must accept that shipment right if if it doesn't pay don't take it and I think we've seen a lot of that over the last couple years you know with the market being um as bad is especially the spot Market as bad as it is is you know people are taking taking loads that may not pay just to keep the wheels turning and and that's you know that's that's Market dictated there's there's a glut of capacity and and you know not as much need so you know people are taking shipments you don't have to take that that load if it doesn't pay you know you don't have to work with Brokers that that you don't think pay right so you've looked at some of the comments I I can't imagine this is very popular among the broker uh interest groups out there no definitely not I mean they most of the large Freight brokerage um entities have have filed comments you know Transportation intermediaries Association you know of of course they they and I think their their biggest problem you know confidentiality hey I don't want to be sharing all of my customers name you know all of that information because you know quite reasonably in their own you know customer facing agreements they've got confidentiality obligations and well this kind of kind of messes with that a little bit um and then I you know the the turnaround it's as of right now there is you know we do have the regulation on the books that broker is required to provide these records okay it's on the books this is that's what it is right now these broker transparency rules are are kind of you know amending that to a degree so you know right now unless there's a waiver in the agreement hey they've got to provide these records I think the 48 hour turnaround is is a pretty tough one right yeah um because quite reasonably they may not have all those records from their customer within 48 hours is that an ongoing request then um you know maybe all that information isn't compiled in the same place um so I think it would be pretty difficult to comply with and you know assuming that waivers are not enforcable okay you know is every carrier requesting records after every shipment I mean that that could really create a a maybe an impossible administrative um burden on a broker to be able to actually comply with that yeah a question whether the FMCSA has the authority to say whether something is wable or not seems like a legal question up for the courts but yeah it it it really is and and I'm glad you brought that up so continuing The Saga of p pink cheetah Express is uh what two days ago two days ago pink cheetah Express um filed a lawsuit in The District Court of the District of Columbia that's a federal court and and DC against tql related to this you know this whole shipment and the records and and there they they pink cheetah requested that you know tql turnover I think it was Rec related about 16 shipments but also and this was part of it was the FMCSA had ordered uh tql to remove the waiver language from their broker carrier AG yeah I don't think they can do and and and that's pink cheetah is asking the FMCSA to to or asking the court enforce that to enforce that um that gets into a really really and I think that gets to the heart of these whole broker transparency proposed rules is hey that this is great we've got some new rules if if somebody wants more transparency okay great if if it's something that can be waved in every agreement it's pretty much ineffective because because every broker is gonna have that waiver in its agreement um there's actually specif a specific a specific statute that that allows shippers and carriers to wave rights and remedies and doesn't say broker it's and and that's why I'd love to see um the court be able to get to the merits of that I I'd be surprised if it does at some point um but hey is that waiver effective because if it is none of this really means a whole lot yeah okay that's broken transparency what what's the status of that I think they just recently extended the comment period is that right yeah they extended the comment period a couple weeks ago so probably have another couple weeks um if you want to add to the 5300 plus comments I'm I'm sure FMCSA will read each and every one in detail so so this is a noce the proposed rule making right so next next step would be a final rule which would establish the rule if they end up doing that so that's what we will be on the lookout for yeah and and I think the you know you I mentioned the political piece of this is you know the proposed Ru making was under an FMCSA under the Biden Administration we've had a lot of change um in Personnel in in these agencies including the FMCSA they actually have a new special counsel um which is kind of the agency's attorney so um I would assume that they were looking at this and maybe even reconsidering you know that that's a possibility that this doesn't move forward Chuck on LinkedIn is saying while you can reasonably argue whether or not FMCSA should be regulating broker contracts the fact is that they currently do uh I would disagree with that can both parties they certainly regulate brokers in the sense of requiring Brokers to have brokerage Authority but I would argue that they don't have authority to regulate the terms of their contracts uh and haven't had that Authority since deregulation but in any event can both parties do any contractor legally wave any safety regulation completely different issue no can't be done any other thoughts on that no I uh yeah I mean the FMCSA agree doesn't doesn't really regulate you know broker carrier agreements or those relationships um yeah and i' I've never heard anybody being able to wave a SA safety requirements that' be nice right you can contract for whatever you want but is it going to be an enforceable contract and in the fact that the safety regs are there doesn't mean that a individual contract can wave them away absolutely yeah because safety regulations are not the are not the matter that's being contracted for right whereas The Brokerage terms that we're talking about you know the disclosure of the payment terms stuff like that is directly an issue between the two parties safety regulations sit out there as a third part issue so I can't even really see that coming up but in any event uh okay so that's broker transparency let's move on what's your second top legal issue for fleets to consider in 2025 second um lease purchase agreements um there was a Truck Leasing task force um it was authorized as part of a by bipartisan infrastructure bill in 20121 um so this truck leasing leasing task force created by the FMCSA again under the Biden Administration and it's uh it was created to investigate and you know and assess truck lease purchase agreements um these these have become a kind of a you know big issue because um you know there there's a lot of failure right uh in these these lease purchase arrangements and and um you know frankly the the truck policing task force was was full of I would say um plaintiff friendly uh type people right I mean there were a couple plaintiff's attorneys on there there was a director of Economics from the teamsters Union um OA had a had a seat at the table um and unbiased so far A little pretty biased um so they issued a report um in January was January 17th of this year you know they had spent some time you know researching um to the extent they could you know various least purchase arrangements and then they just pretty much decided hey look these are bad they should be outlawed they should be banned um and that was you know from a high level um what their findings were uh now what what will come of that you know again we've got a change in administration um I I suspect not much will come of it you know H how is how is again what the FMCSA Congress is going to ban uh lease agreements lease purchase agreements um I'd be be surprised if kind of same issue because we're essentially what we're talking about well partially is you know the federal leasing regul truth and leasing regulations uh play into it somewhat um but again another issue that is under the fmcsa's regulations but not entirely clear why it's still under the fmcsa's regulations another thing that doesn't really have all that much teeth from a regulatory enforcement standpoint but more kind of a an issue between private parties and you know potential private rights of action stuff like that but yeah but these least purchase agreements that we're talking about are very common particularly uh for owner operator large owner operator fleets where uh they will enter into you know the the trucking company or an affiliate of that trucking company owns the commercial vehicle leases it to the owner operator the owner oper operator in turn leases it back to the motor carrier pursuant to those truth and leasing regulations to operate under the carrier's Authority but a component of those lease agreements gives the the has a purchase option at the expiration of the lease agreement assuming the the owner operator meets the terms and conditions of the agreement is that it in a nutshell yes yeah that's it and I think the in the the truck lacing task Force's report I mean the focus is on kind of that leaseback Arrangement when you know Motor Carrier itself is leasing the equipment that is leased back or an affiliate of the motor carriers because then that owner operator is pretty much stuck they're stuck with the truck and the truck must be operated with that motor carrier right or else they're in breach of their agreement and and that's I and from from a high level I get that it's like hey that you know maybe that doesn't seem fair fair okay um but the the the where seen fleets that you know operate lease purchase programs which I mean those you know provide the ability for people to you know run and have a have their own you know business um I've seen fleets get into trouble and this is where they get sued and usually it's you know truth and leasing regulations claims um when that owner operator doesn't make money right if you're structuring it in a way that that these guys aren't really making any money like don't be surprised when you get sued you know because that that's where I mean look there's there's good and bad actors in every industry and in in this industry is no different um you know if you're setting somebody up for failure that's just not right you know it's it's not right from a business standpoint and it's it's probably going to not turn out that well for you yeah the other area where I I see this come up quite a bit the legitimacy of these lease purchase programs is in the IND been a contract classification I know that's one of the items on your list kind of flows into it but you know we used to see this all the time back when I when we were all at the same firm and I was kind of in that area um you know State agen work comp boards or unemployment agencies or the plaintiff's bar would get a hold of these lease purchase programs the carriers that employ them and would essentially say um you know that's just a sham that is you you have set that up as a way to try and demonstrate that the owner operators have some skin in the game that they are their own business but this is ultimately your asset and they are beholden to you as you mentioned Tyler and so this is a sham Arrangement and so we're not treating it as a legitimate independent contractor uh relationship and so now carrier you're responsible for work cop or unemployment or overtime or whatever context it's in so yeah big issue and something fleets that have that type of program really need to pay attention to yeah absolutely and you know I think the direct leaseback Arrangement is is obviously kind of the worst way to do it you know hey you know I'm I'm my entity has Motor Carrier Authority I've got the equipment I'm going to lease it to my owner operator and they're just going to lease it right back to me you know at least have Affiliated leasing companies I think some some State statutes specifically carve that type of an arrangement out from a legitimate like an owner operator exemption in work comp statues they will say this does not apply to leaseback Arrangements I think or correct off the top of my head off off the top of my head Illinois I know is one of those in Illinois is even specific enough where hey look I've got an Affiliated Leasing Company let's say it's owned by my brother instead of me I own the carrier my brother owns the Le the Affiliated leasing company that's leasing the equipment you know to the owner operator who's then leasing it to me as the motor carrier it gets into that detail that family members you know that is not a a you know that doesn't meet the the requirements for the exemption for unemployment tax or workers comp um for for owner operators um so yeah that that's absolutely true yeah Brian on LinkedIn says companies have used lease purchase agreements to hide employee status I don't disagree with that I I think that's probably accurate for some carriers but certainly not all carriers uh structured correctly I think it serves a legitimate point in the industry and and can actually work to an owner operators benefit I don't think all of these this is just my opinion obviously I don't think all of these arrangements are as the lease task force has described or as the state agencies or the plaintiff bar make them out to be uh I've I've personally uh deposed I've personally ridden in trucks with owner operators that work for carriers and they are in the midst of a lease purchase program and they wouldn't have it any other way I've talked to them directly they love it they love the freedom that it that it affords to them and uh and a state coming in and telling them that they are an employ rather than an independent contractor seems like a slap in the face to them they have told me that directly and I I find that to be the case uh in many instances so uh I just don't think it's as pervasive as this task force made it seem to be at least for my perspective no I agree I agree go ahead jar I was gonna say the task force report which you can actually find online pretty easily and and read it they actually describe these agreements as irredeemable tools of fraud which I thought was pretty extreme kind of to that point I mean how do you get far far away from being an irredeemable tool of fraud other than just ensuring that this owner operator is able to make money under this P purchase agreement how do you take that even farther away from that statement in the terms of the agreement yeah I I don't they're they're probably looking at a very limited subset of the bad ones right and I'm sure that you know any any carrier that's running a legitimately Le purchase program isn't gonna didn't you know hey here you want to see my program you know hey federal government you want to come in and and look at my you know my program my success rates my agreements and all that you know I the data they were looking at I'm sure was again you know Bad actors or people who don't have things set up in a way to to be fa you know to to enable these owner operators to um succeed um and they had cited various success rates um in the report but you know I was kind of thinking about that you know hey you know all right so you have and when I say success rates I mean contractors that actually um you know participated in the lease back and got to the end of the lease and yeah right and and there could be a lot of reasons why that doesn't happen you know reasons one of them could be hey the equipment you know we just didn't end up wanting that equipment or you know uh hey we wanted to had to quit driving for whatever reason I mean there could be a plethora of reasons why you know somebody doesn't get to the end of a of a lease purchase um Arrangement um you know it doesn't make sense financially but but also I was thinking about it just from a high level how many businesses businesses any business what's what's the success rate of a business what's say you're starting a restaurant what's the Su success rate of a restaurant after you know four years my understand depends if Gordon Ramsay shows up or not yeah right uh but you know so I you know I don't I don't really put much weight into those those success rates that the the task force qu quotes but again I think it comes down to if if you're running one of these programs you're gonna have to take a close look at it try and structure it in a way that makes sense that you're compliant with the the truth and leasing regulations especially um that you're not opening yourself up to to some risk of non-payment and then if you're structuring it in a way that the guys can't make money yeah it's just the one come that comes to mind is the one you mentioned Tyler um we saw this pretty commonly I understand why carriers would want this and it's it's putting terms in the agreement that say this truck can only be operated for us it can't you can't take it and operate it for yourself can't take it and operate it for another motor carrier and that's where I tend to see carriers get themselves in trouble particularly in the independent contractor situation because at that point they are beholden to you and so they can't it's not their truck they can't take it and operate elsewhere and so you know there are ways to address that in a way that still kind of minimizes your concern as the carrier of course you're concerned that if they take it elsewhere and operate it somewhere else um maybe we have some liability if they get involved in an accident over there or maybe they go and damage the truck over there and and insurance doesn't cover it and that type of stuff but there are ways to minimize that uh and we would see it commonly carriers would build in protections that would say Hey you can use it under your own authority owner operator or you can operate it for another motor carrier but there are certain things you have to do to be able to do that from a regulatory standpoint and what we found is a lot of drivers owner operators and their interest groups read that language and just throw their hands up and say well practically we can't do that you can do that is you just have to jump through some hoops obviously you can't be if I've got ABC Trucking placards on the side of my truck and then I want to go run that for XYZ Trucking obviously I have to cover up ABC trucking's placards and put on xyz's placards that's basic Trucking 101 and so to say that that is an impediment to me being able to do that is just ridiculous it should be expected that that you're going to have to do stuff like that obviously so yeah uh okay so we we kind of hit on independent contractor classification maybe you get us a a kind of a handle on where things stand from like a federal standpoint I know there's been a lot of talk about the Department of Labor uh and kind of their policy on that as it pertains to trucking yeah a great again change in administration um is going to change things so um just recently the Trump Administration um there there's been there's a number of lawsuits but one in the fifth circuit um Trump Administration has asked you know the court to postpone some oral argument um and really that lawsuit is challenging you know Joe Biden's you call his Department of Labor independent contractor rules so kind of the way all this has gone is Trump first term um revised the Department of Labor misclassification rules and again from a high level misclassification can H happen in a number of contexts Brandon you you had mentioned it could be workers comp could be State unemployment could be you know State wage an hour federal wage an hour so there's different contexts um within which an individual could be considered misclassified as an independent contractor and that's just to say hey they're really an employee um and there's a a bunch of tests in in these different contexts you know California probably yeah test you got your ABC test in California and for federal uh like overtime you know let's say there's overtime claims the you know Department of Labor rules or generally these the economic realities tests now Trump 1.0 in his first term uh revised the Department of Labor's economic realities tests made it made it a five Factor test um and focused on especially whether or not the contractor had control over um you know the duties what they did for work and and their earnings if and and those were kind of the focus of those those five factors in the economic realities test and Biden last year the Biden Administration um in the Department of Labor changed it back to a six Factor test um and they call it the totality of circumstances so it's pretty much whatever the judge thinks is what I think um so so the Biden Administration changed it um kind of changed it back and now Trump is the Trump Administration is gonna kind of probably re-evaluate that um all's that to say is is who knows you know where it's going to go in terms of that and again that's limited just a roller coaster ride for for IC fets and and but this again it's limited to this is limited to you know wage and hour claims you know brought under federal law where you know court is going to look at the Department of Labor's test and guidance related to that test you know this this if you're talking about California we're it we're not talking about the same thing so you know I always tell people what respect to you know independent contract or misclassification there is there is no Silver Bullet to make sure that you're going to comply with any given test let alone any all of the tests that you could be subject to now you know we talked about State specific exemptions with respect to workers comp and and unemployment you know those are a little bit more you know if you can meet the meet the the the standards for those those are a little bit more clear but other than that you know it's it's you know I think you try and mitigate your risk and and reduce control and things like that um there are best practices that you know The Fleets that don't have trouble with this you know a lot of it as you said comes down to where you happen to be situated in the country or where you primarily operate but beyond that as you said there are best practices to be aware of when it comes to your contracts certainly and also your operations and how you interact with the owner operators and uh if you don't if you don't know about those best practices you need to get informed about them and so that's why talking with somebody with like Tyler uh about those types of issues is important if you are an independent contractor Fleet because all it takes is one of those cases to spring up and then your all of your drivers all of a sudden get reclassified now you owe all kinds of back taxes uh or you owe some kind of a big judgment or settlement in a wage and hour case uh it's just a a huge problem for a lot of fleets yeah absolutely and the other thing that I'll plug and it's you know tangentially related to you know contractor classification is you know I look at a lot of agreements and you know the agreement is probably the first place you want to start in terms of you know looking at your potential risk and mitigating that risk is compliance with the with the truth truth and leasing regulations I see a lot of independent contractor agreements that are just just not compliant and that doesn't have to be brought on you know certainly classwide basis you know you have a couple contractors filing suit in federal court saying that you know hey our dependent contractor agreement isn't compliant with the leasing RS you're going to have to spend some money defending that for sure yeah is it is it possible that we're going to see for the industry Clarity in the issue of independent contractor classification because you know I feel for the industry it seems like every time the political pendulum swings so does IC classification issues is is Clarity even possible for the industry in the future I mean I I don't think so I mean again you're looking at so many different tests in in different contexts in different states and federally that you know it's it's a real Patchwork um I I don't think that there's there's ever going to be like hey if you do XYZ this this is this is the test right this is it and and I think things will will change I mean we've seen you know even the changes in California over the past number of years right um how they their test has has pivoted and that's just you know that's just California and and we're seeing it federally based on change of administration I don't think there's ever going to be you know real true Clarity on on I see classification um or consistency going going forward I don't think we'll ever see it it you know because presumably the only way to get to that would be some kind of a federal preemption of the issue but when you mix in things like work comp and unemployment things that have been historically regulated by the states within their police powers and their their you know that type of stuff I just don't think it's a suitable topic for federal preemption but who knows yeah I agree I I I don't I don't think that'll ever happen all right well we yeah uplifting show here Tyler um all right we got 10 minutes left you got two items left to talk about let's let's hit on them cool um one thing I I wanted to talk about was you know Fleet fleet's taking a look at their transportation agreements and I say you know your customer facing agreements whether it be with a broker or a shipper and and I I see this too often is you know fleets just agreeing to whatever agreements put in front of them um I understand you know hey there's there's there's a lack of Leverage a lot of times now especially right now where where the Market's been you know uh you're not going to be able to push back on on agreements necessarily um but at least understanding reading those agreements and understanding what you can be liable for what your rights are what what the other party's rights are um is really important because I think you know and I S we saw this I think in 2020 through 2022 was you know if you had a truck you had a lot of Leverage people were begging for capacity and and you actually and and this was you know at least the first time in my career that I saw that you know motor carriers were able to push back on some of these agreements we need another pandemic well I don't I don't neede got no um no but at some point at some point you know the pendulum will swing back to some degree and where capacity is going to be in higher demand and and if you've got you got some trucks you know hey you you do have some leverage you do have some leverage um and and you know a few of the things you know when you're looking at your your customer contracts that that you want to either try and focus on again you're not going to probably Redline a whole agreement or hire an attorney you know spend a few thousand dollars to redline an agreement necessarily but you know probably top things you know if if you're a fleet and you're looking at your customer agreements number one limitation of of of liability for cargo loss look at that the carac amendment um 49 USC 1470 14 706 allows motor carriers to limit their liability for cargo loss and damage you can do that try and do that you know don't don't agree to you know unlimited cargo uh liability especially in excess of your your cargo Insurance yeah um and try and make sure that your insurance your cargo Insurance limits are going to match whatever liability you have for a given shipment this otherwise you're gonna be on the hook potentially yeah and and and you know I think a lot of people what are you you shipping what are you transporting what are you carrying right and and knowing that knowing the value of it is is really important towards limiting your your your liability you know if you're hauling a load of electronics and you have you know unlimited cargo liability and you know I've seen it you know entire truckload of cell phones gets stolen in outside of Miami Florida who would have thought um and you've got 100,000 in cargo coverage you're on the hook for that other 900,000 and it's it's safe to say that when you're looking at contracts like this Tyler there's Provisions that are what you would call Battleground provisions and then Provisions that are kind of like whatever happens with this provision is fine what you're mentioning here with limiting liability that's one of those Battleground Provisions that you should expect to fight on and it's worth the fight probably is that correct absolutely yeah absolutely and and again just because you you think you don't have the leverage doesn't mean you shouldn't try to push back on some of these things you know unlimited liability that's not even really that's not even really standard I mean if you're if you you're maintaining a cargo liability you know policy of a 100 try and limit your liability to 100 you know and that that's why you're paying for that policy and and if they want something higher okay well go go out and get coverage and understand the value of the goods because I I find and I do represent you know some manufacturers and retailers and I I routinely I ask them I say you know and what's the value average value of your shipments we got no idea no idea is it 100 is it 200 is it more um and and understanding what you're hauling and what the value of that is and and what your your customers's expectations may be for that um is really important um so if you can try and limit that liability to what your your cargo Insurance um is carrying and if they want more up your up your insurance rates uh are limits a little bit um so I I think that that's one of the most critical ones uh another one you know that I think is reasonable to push back on though can be difficult is you know offset or deduction um rights you know whether whether you know again your customer is a shipper or or freight broker you know that they have the ability to offset your payment for whatever reason it could be related to a cargo loss or Indemnity or some other reason um that they just have a right to to withhold your pay um uh or offset it against whatever liability that is you know I I think you try and push back on that because that that's going to affect your cash flow um it could be withheld for you know maybe not legitimate reasons or at least not legitimate reasons in your mind let's take it you know standard hey I had a you know there was a cargo loss but let's say it was caused by something you know that was completely out of your control and as an exception under carac uh you know tornado came and destroyed the whole ship shipment I'm just using a you know extreme example well if they're going to withhold your pay because you know a tornado destroyed the shipment well that's not legitimate you're not liable for that you know pursuant to the carac amendment and and and your pay shouldn't you know shouldn't be withheld because of that um so again offset rights to to payment is is one to to try and push back on or limit to the extent you can um another one that I see a lot and I think this is more just being aware um instead of necessarily pushing back are Insurance obligations so when you look through your customer agreements and you're required to maintain XYZ insurance coverages I see pretty frequently carriers agreeing to maintain coverages that they don't maintain or limits that they don't maintain like like what kind of coverages well let's say uh you know I I see it you know hey you you Motor Carrier you're required to maintain uh 5 million and and excess liability coverage yeah and and we know that they don't maintain now I think I think carrier should maintain at least that in excess liability coverage with the verdicts that we've been seeing but and they won't they don't have that coverage but they're still agreeing in the agreement to say yeah I've got that coverage well guess what you're an immediate breach of the agreement and I think it's a a pretty simple thing to push back on and say hey look I don't maintain that coverage or revise it and say Hey you know you want me to maintain 5,000 or 500,000 and and cargo liability coverage I only maintain 250 well just revise it that's okay to revise it and say hey this is what I maintain you know because you don't you want to sign that agreement you're an immediate breach of the agreement because you're not maintaining the insurance coverages that that you're agreeing to yeah all right we've only got five minutes left what's your last item on your list of top five legal issues to watch out for um you know I I think in in this I feel like gets discussed to death are you know new nuclear verdicts um related to highway accidents I my only comment on that is is for for fleets to consider their corporate structure towards protecting their assets um now we we've had some some to Tor reform in a number of states Florida Texas Indiana finally passed this the seat belt um law uh kind of helping with evidentiary concerns there um I know Iowa and and there's been a number of other states where we've we've had some successes and and Tor reform with respect to Highway accidents but but look you know these these these extreme jury verdicts aren't going away um anytime soon and uh you want to take a look at your corporate structure to ensure that you're protecting your assets both personally you know as an owner of a of a trucking company um and you know other Affiliated companies um that you may have or assets you may have if for example if you own real estate and you know it's owned by the the the same entity that has the motor carrier operating Authority well guess what happens if there's a judgment lean they can take that real estate right and and just taking a look at that you know even your Rolling Stock and and different assets that you may have um you know let's say you've got Affiliated you know you do some Freight brokering you got Freight brokerage Authority um getting that into a separate enemy and just taking a look at your your your corporate structure to try and avoid some of these these verdicts that aren't again aren't really going away anytime soon yeah they they definitely are that the perception from a jury now that someone was injured severely or killed someone has to pay that perception is there and it's not going away um the answer for me and Brandon typically is more compliance more safety cover yourself in that respect others would say more insurance so it's nice to hear corporate structure is something to look at to help you as a company in mixture of yeah mixture of all three is yeah I'd say all all three all three very important all right guys well Tyler we appreciate you joining us today like I said we're looking forward to uh working with you if anybody's got any questions or wants help with any of these topics where can they reach out to you um well thanks for having me on guys and yeah you can uh find me at TB at Children's law pllc.com uh I think you can find me on the on the website you can Google children's law and and you you'll probably find us find us there and on LinkedIn if you're on LinkedIn follow L I'm on LinkedIn connect with Tyler and uh we'll get you squared away but anyway thanks for everybody for tuning in appreciate you being here um like I said early on best way to keep up to date with future shows and everything we got going on is through our newsletter trucksafe
docomo compliance related content so uh hope to see you next time thanks everybody later