Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 48 - English Proficiency

Thursday, May 1, 2025 at 4:15 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 48 - English Proficiency

About This Event

In this episode, we’re joined by Matt Leffler (the Armchair Attorney) and Jack Van Steenburg (former FMCSA Chief Safety Officer) to break down President Trump’s April 28, 2025 Executive Order on English proficiency among commercial drivers. We’ll discuss the history of the issue and what fleets and drivers need to know to stay compliant.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 48 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman, Rob Carpenter, and Brian are joined by guests Matt Lefller, adjunct professor of law at Michigan State University College of Law and senior counsel at Taylor Nelson Law Firm, and Jack Van Steenburg, principal founder of CMV Safety Experts LLC and former chief safety officer at FMCSA, to discuss President Trump's executive order titled "Enforcing Common Sense Rules of the Road for America's Truck Drivers." The order takes direct aim at English proficiency enforcement among commercial motor vehicle drivers, a topic that has generated significant attention and debate across the trucking industry. The hosts and guests explore the regulatory history, enforcement implications, and practical challenges this development presents for motor carriers of all sizes. The discussion establishes that English proficiency requirements for commercial drivers are not new, tracing back to 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2) and its origins as far back as 1937. A key turning point came in 2016, when a memorandum issued under the Obama administration removed English proficiency as an out-of-service criterion, a decision the guests note was politically directed from the Office of the Secretary of Transportation and the Department of Justice. The executive order gives US DOT and FMCSA 60 days to rescind that 2016 memorandum, and the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA) has already moved to reinstate English proficiency as an out-of-service criterion through its own committee process. The guests acknowledge that while the rule has been on the books for decades, consistent enforcement has been largely absent, and significant questions remain about the data supporting the claim that non-English-speaking drivers are a meaningful contributor to highway accidents. A recurring theme throughout the episode is the highly subjective nature of enforcing English proficiency at roadside. Unlike more objective violations, determining whether a driver is sufficiently proficient in English depends largely on the individual officer's judgment, raising concerns about inconsistent enforcement across states. The guests also raise unresolved logistical questions, including what happens to a driver, their truck, and their load once placed out of service for this violation, and how a driver is ever cleared to return to service given that English proficiency cannot be restored in a matter of hours. The panel also highlights the disconnect between the CDL testing process, where some states permit Spanish-language testing or use of interpreters, and the federal regulation requiring English proficiency for all regulated drivers. The hosts and guests offer several practical takeaways for fleet safety professionals. Carriers should closely monitor enforcement activity in the states and corridors where their drivers operate, as enforcement is expected to vary significantly by region, with states like Arkansas already signaling aggressive action. Carriers with non-English-speaking drivers in their workforce must begin thinking through both their hiring and onboarding processes and the legal risks associated with employment decisions tied to language proficiency, including potential wrongful termination claims. The panel recommends developing objective, consistently applied internal criteria for assessing English proficiency, similar to the structured approach used in post-crash review committees. Carriers should also watch for guidance from FMCSA and CVSA, as the full regulatory and procedural framework for enforcement has yet to be established. Among the notable insights from the episode, Jack Vanstein noted that during his time at FMCSA he could count on one hand the number of crash reports where English language proficiency was identified as a contributing factor, raising serious questions about the data cited in the executive order. Matt Leler observed that without meaningful investment in additional enforcement resources, the practical impact of the executive order may be limited largely to warnings and a handful of high-profile cases. Rob Carpenter pointed out that broader highway safety issues such as distracted driving and impairment arguably represent greater threats than language proficiency, and that the topic has gained outsized attention largely because it fits certain political narratives. The episode closes with the consensus that this is largely a wait-and-see situation, but one that fleet safety professionals should monitor closely given its potential to affect driver qualification standards, CSA scores, brokerage relationships, and overall carrier capacity.

Full Transcript

Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Oh, I'm a heat. Heat. Heat. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. E-Riggs is always up todate and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. E-Riggs was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. Try it out for free at e-regs.app. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. All right. Hey everyone. Well, welcome to episode 48 of Truck Safe Live, show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon. That's Rob. That's Brian. We're with Truck Safe, which is dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs. Uh, welcome everybody. Uh, glad you're here with us. If you're here with us, say hey in the comments so we know who's around. Rob, Brian, what's going on? Good stuff. Exciting stuff. Thursday. It's Thursday. Yeah. What kind of exciting stuff do you have going on on a Thursday, Brian? This This was the most exciting thing of my day. So, I've been waiting all day for this. That's what I like to hear. Uh, yeah. Anyway, um, yeah. Thanks again for everybody joining us today. Obviously kind of a breaking news type uh reason for the show with President Trump's executive order coming down earlier this week. Uh put out a detailed article on this on our website. It's already gotten a lot of attention and just kind of monitoring the social media feeds seems to be a pretty polarizing subject for some. Um, and so I thought it would be a good idea to jump on here because it affects trucking obviously and get to the bottom of it, explore it. There's hundred different ways we can go with it. So that's what we're going to do. I'm excited to have a kind of a roundt discussion. Got a couple of friends of ours to join us a little bit later uh here in a few minutes. Uh before we bring them on, a few things going on at Truck Safe that we should mention as always. Uh well, actually, first of we should thanks the sponsor of this show, which is Taking the Higher Road. Special podcast dedicated to addressing the trucking industry's greatest challenges, driver recruiting, retention, and compliance. Each episode, host Jeremy Rymer, 20-year industry veteran, interviews industry experts, and thought leaders who bring their insights to the driver life cycle. Be sure to check them out wherever you get your podcast. Thanks to Taking the Higher Road. All right, things going on at Truck Safe. If you're not a member of the TruckSafe network, I encourage you to join it. It is free to join over at trucksafetwork.com or scan that QR code there and download the app in the App Store or the Google Play Store. This is the space we've built for fleet safety professionals to gather together, learn from one another, ask questions, and also access all of our DOT related content that we push out regularly, including a uh webinar that we just did called Is Your Fleet Audit Ready? Brian, Rob, Jared, Tyler, and I spent about an hour and a half breaking down DOT audits, what fleets should know about those in order to make sure that you're prepared for one. God forbid you get the knock at the door. So, that was a well attended webinar. Uh, I got a lot of great questions and feedback from those who attended. So, that's the type of content that we're pushing out through the network. So, we hope to see you there. Uh, and then lastly, I'll just mention our upcoming fleet compliance boot camp. This is our in-person conference that we do each year. Uh our next one is scheduled for September 3rd and 4th in Indianapolis. This one is presented by Drivewise. Thanks to those folks for helping us out. Um this is the conference where we spend two days talking about nothing but DOT compliance, believe it or not. If that sounds exciting to you, hopefully uh it does to some folks, but probably not. Uh may just be us. Uh but anyway, if you're interested in joining us or if you have anybody on your team that would benefit from an in-depth deep dive discussion of the federal motor carrier safety regulations and best practices for rolling out a uh cutting edge fleet compliance program. We'd like to have you there with us. Um trucksafebootcamp.com is where you'll find out the details and that's where you could register yourself. This always fills up pretty quickly. We usually have around a hundred or so fleet safety professionals in attendance with us and so it's also a great networking event. So, and we've got a lot of stuff in store for this year. So, hope to see you at that trucksafetwork.com. Anything else, guys? What's going on in the industry aside from the big issue why we're here today? The only other thing that really caught my eye this morning was uh fleets are starting to send in their or make note of their quarterly earnings and stuff and some of the big fleets the quarter quarterly earnings are down again looking good. Uhuh. So it was like the one I saw was like seven straight quarters that it's been negative. That's getting tough to absorb, I'm sure. No kidding. Yeah. We're going to try and have a show. I know we've talked internally. We're going to have try and have a show all about kind of the current state of the economy and its uh impact on motor carriers and others in the supply chain here in the near future, probably in the next couple of weeks. Hopefully, we can get that pulled together and that will be an interesting topic for sure. Uh Rob, anything else? No, this was it. Cool. Well, let's do it. Let's not waste any more time. Um, like I said earlier this week, President Trump issued an executive order title entitled Enforcing Common Sense Rules of the Road for America's truck drivers, taking aim primarily at English proficiency among regulated drivers in the US. Like I said, this has caused a bit of a stir in the industry. It seems to be the the talk of the town, uh, so to speak. And so, I'm excited to have with us a couple of guests, uh, on with us who have both been on the show before. So, I'm excited to welcome them back. First up, we've got Matt Leler, the armchair attorney, as well as an adjunct professor of law at Michigan State University College of Law and recently announced senior counsel at the Taylor Nelson Law Firm. Congrats on that, Matt. That was exciting. Thank you, sir. I'm so excited to be here. Thank you for having me. Awesome. Glad to have you back. And then, Mr. Jack Vanstein, principal founder of CMV Safety Experts LLC, and a safety expert helping motor carriers, attorneys, and insurance companies with regulatory compliance. He brings years of hands-on knowledge of the FMCSA's enforcement and compliance program, serving previously as the AY's chief safety officer and executive director prior to his recent retirement. Welcome back, Jack. Thanks, Brandon. It's an honor to be here and honor to be here with your distinguished guest and partners. Yeah, so we've got a uh pretty diverse crew here. um all kind of looking at uh this particular issue from various lights. Um and so yeah, I think it'll be good to just kind of walk through the executive order, talk about maybe its history, what exactly it's doing, what it's not doing, uh clear up some of the misconceptions that we've seen out there collectively on on the executive order, and uh go through it like that. Sound good, guys? Yeah. All right, let's do it. Well, like I said earlier, there's a hundred different ways we could probably take this. So, probably need to keep it pretty structured here. So, I think first things first, maybe we should kind of give a little bit of history of where this executive order is coming from. Uh, and so maybe I'll pitch it over to Matt. I saw you had posted on LinkedIn on your account uh a couple days ago uh the fact that this is not something new. This shouldn't be all that surprising to folks. This has been a rule that's been on the books for many years. So maybe you can kind of break down a little bit the background of where this executive order is coming from. Yeah, I mean I appreciate that. And for those who've been following along with this rule make the the president's order and the rules that have been here previously, this is not new. Since 1937, we have had this kind of a regulation on the books. It requires you to understand and communicate in English when you're on the roads. It's a safety thing. It's not new, but we've seen changes of the enforcement. That's the thing I think is what we might look at as novel right now is how do you enforce this thing and how do you make sure the roads remain safe? Yeah, Jack, uh, similar question to you. Um, having been at the agency um, around the time I think when we saw some developments on this. So, the rule itself that Matt mentioned is uh, 49 CFR 391.11b2. Let me pull it up here. I've got this somewhere. Here it is. Uh, this is the rule that has been on the books as I understand it in some form or fashion dating back to the 1930s. And so you can read it here, uh, if you can read English, u, no pun intended. Um, except as provided in subp part G of this part, a person is qualified to drive a motor vehicle if he or she can read and speak English, the English language sufficiently to converse with the general public, to understand highway traffic signs and signals in the English language, to respond to official inquiries, and to make entries on reports and records. And so my question to you Jack is um this this rule even though it's been on the books for uh many decades as Matt said the question has been is it enforced and to what extent and so as I understand it in uh around 2015 2016 the FMCSA the agency that kind of oversees the enforcement of this regulation in particular came out with some memorandums addressing this particular topic and its enforcement. Were you around the agency during that time? I think you were and if so, did you have any insight into kind of that issue at that time? Yeah, I I was around um and a memo came out in 2016 and if you look at the memo and this is an interesting thing and you know in there at my level I dealt you dealt with the political realm at all the times. So this was two 2016 um President Obama was in office at the time. And if you look at that memo right at the beginning, one of the last sentence is at the direction of the office of secretary transportation and the department of justice. This is why we're removing this. We won't be enforcing this as an out of service regulation. I mean, so I you don't see enforcement memos like that at all. And I I just I couldn't remember it. couldn't remember and then I had to go look it up and I found it and I said, "Wow, definitely." It's it's political. It was coming from the higher ups for sure. Yeah. And you know, I I the author of that, Bill Quaid, he um you know, he took a lot of heat over that memo, but I know where it came from. He knew where it came from. If people read into it and read what I just said, Office of Secretary of Transportation and the Department of Justice, you know why he had to change it. So, this isn't something he just made up out of the blue. Yeah. And then prior to that, that was June of 2016, CBSA took it out as a out of service, took it out of their out of service criteria. And the reason they did that was out of service is supposed to prevent the the regulations in the out of service criteria is supposed to prevent crashes. There was no data that said not speaking English will lead to a crash. So that was the reason they took it out. Um, and I don't know, you know, I wasn't at that meeting when they took it out and so forth, but I know there was a lot of discussion back and forth between FMCSA and CVSA at the time. That data problem is one that I want to get into a little bit later because um, yeah, I I think there are still legitimate questions about whether there is data to support this move or not. Um, if there is, I haven't seen it, but um, we'll get to that in a second. You mentioned, Jack, uh, CF CVS C CVSA's involvement. For folks not familiar, I'll turn this over to Brian because I know you've been in, uh, involved in CVSA. You've attended their meetings and stuff like that. If you can give folks sense of kind of the role that CVS plays in this whole thing and and and without service conditions in general. So every year any updates that are made to the out of service criteria are republished in the handbook that comes out every year. And it's very clear with pictures and descriptions and things like that of out of service. And like Jack said, when in 2016 when this all came down, they they really didn't have a choice but to remove it. Um, so I sitting in those meetings, I'm sure that the conversation was very heated uh from stateto state uh at that time and it almost seems like they're doing kind of an emergency session now uh to put it back into the out of service criteria. will probably see probably see something come up come through them here in the next I would think next couple few days and I'll turn it back over to Matt to kind of highlight the timing of this. So, you've kind of studied the executive order and I I guess my first question to you, Matt, is cuz I've heard I've seen some um some misunderstandings on social media in particular about the what exactly is an executive order and what role does it play and what's its relationship with federal laws and stuff like that? If you can give us a kind of breakdown of of how that that works. Man, that's a great You're a professor of law. I mean, executive orders have the same kind of strength and effect as a statute, right? So, when they put out this guidance, put out this order, it's going to tell you right now, DOT officers are going to start giving you warnings. If they if you're not able to show or demonstrate your proficiency in English, you're going to start getting warnings. This will likely escalate over time. I would put this out there for the audience, right? The FMCSA is a billiondoll a year organization, a thousand employees set to regulate 550 some odd thousand motor cares, 25,000 brokers, 4,000 interstate bus companies, and millions of commercial drivers. And they are struggling, you know, in the environment today to enforce vehicle safety, for example. We have been telling ourselves as an industry, at least some have, about driver shortage. We need to bring in more people from other places. And this is simply, I think, the natural progression of this type of a rule. You get people driving vehicles. And so, we're going to see a lot of things happen. I'm not sure if I'm chopping up here. My internet's unstable, just like my mental capacity. It looks like you're okay. But so, I mean, that's I think that's what we're going to see over the next couple weeks is we're going to see this enforced far more aggressively than it has previously. And we'll have to deal with that consequence. Yeah. So the executive order by its own terms gives US DOT and by extension FMCSA 60 days to uh resend that memorandum from 2016 that Jack mentioned that had uh you know taken this English proficiency violation off the list of out of service criteria. And as we've talked about, CVSA is going to have to be involved because they're the ones that publish these out of service criteria that go out to all of the roadside enforcement officers that are out there doing these types of inspections. So, that's what's to come. Um, Rob, you've posted a lot about this uh on your social media channels, and I know you've got some hot takes on this, so I'm interested to hear your kind of uh, you know, 30,000 foot level view of of this development. It's definitely not law, but it's 30,000 foot for sure. Um, so I think one of the things that I think everybody can agree with. I mean, I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, Jack, but um, we can all agree that it's good to speak and be able to communicate in the English language when operating on the highways. Like, one of the things I put out there is when I go to Wales, if you've ever been to Wales and you don't know Welsh, you're going to look at their road signs and just be totally confused. you're not going to be able to read that jumble that's on that sign. So, it's no different in our country. I mean, I think it's important to be able to read, speak, and communicate the English language. It's always been a rule, like Matt Matt said, back to 1937, and then I think they started actually enforcing it as an out of service in '05, and then they stopped for the same for reasons we've already talked about. But I think um what I don't like about it is I feel like we've got bigger problems on our highways than people that can't read, write, or speak the English language. Right. Um the demographics that I put out from FMCSA's report last year, there's not very many people that operate CMVs that can't read, write, or speak English. So, when I'm thinking about what's actually affecting highway safety, I'm thinking distraction is probably the biggest one in 2025. Everybody's on their phone. Everybody's doing something else besides the driving task that's at that's at hand. And then you've got sobriety with legalized marijuana. And there's so many other things that I think we have bigger issues with than not being able to speak, read, or write the English language. law is important. I just don't think it's one of those I think it's a hot button topic because it fits certain narratives, right? Like it it's drawn a lot of people in. It started the our truck stop rumor mill where I tell other drivers about it, we all get hyped up about it and then it goes to another group of drivers. So, I think it's um I think it's just one of those hot button topics. I mean, if we go to a truck stop right now and and Matt, if you and I talk at a truck stop about the country skillet food killing us today and making us like 300 400 lb, it's not going to spread very far, right? It's not the narrative that we're interested in talking about. I don't think you're going to find Matt at the truck stop. Well, you know, I travel from time to time. I do from time to time. Yeah. So, we even I Yeah, Rob, I completely agree. And it goes back to Jack's point about this being so politicized. And we saw this at Matt at the Matt's conference when we went, Brian and Rob, folks up in arms about it. And you know, FMCSA had their sessions at Matts where they're speaking directly to truck drivers. And the drivers, this was the issue that they wanted to discuss with FMCSA at the time. And it was clear that FMCSA didn't want to discuss it at that time. But here we are a couple weeks later, uh, and now it's coming from top down. So, they're going to have to address it. Um, you all kind of hinted at something that I think it's it's a big part of this that we should talk about, and that's, you know, the the executive order, um, you know, it claims that the 2016 memorandum that took this out of the out of service criteria has led to a decrease in safety. And and this brings to bear the issue of whether there is data to support the idea that non-English-speaking drivers are or their inability to read road signs or communicate with law enforcement is contributing to a significant percentage of accidents or not. If that data exists, like I said, I haven't seen it. There are certainly anecdotal stories about it um out there. And the one that comes to my mind is the um the first ever billion-dollar jury verdict case from Florida uh from 2020, I think is when that came down. And uh that was a case that involved a couple of regulated drivers who were operating near Jacksonville, I believe. And uh one of the drivers that slammed into a line of traffic and end up ended up killing a person. It was coming down from Canada. He had several problems. I think he was over his hours of service limits by by many hours and there were there were all kinds of issues. But one of the issues one of the big issues in that case was he had admitted that he was a non-English-speaking driver and that he wasn't able to read the flashing signs that had been placed uh on the roadway um to indicate that the traffic ahead was stopped due to a previous accident. He admitted that uh and that was one of the contributing factors, not the contributing factor, but one of many that led to that first ever billion dollar jury verdict being warded against those two trucking companies. So certainly there are anecdotal stories like that. But are you is anybody on here aware of any statistics or data that that is out there that addresses the impact of non-English-speaking drivers or their inability to read road signs on on the highway accidents? Brand when I when I was at FMCSA, I looked at the crash data on a regular basis. I mean, what as a chief safety officer, it's I did so much analysis. I had teams and I can count if I can count the five that's the most I've seen where English language proficiency was addressed in any type of crash report. I mean it it wasn't a factor at all. It was never part of a discussion that we have to do. And um you know quite frankly I have not seen any data. When I saw that in the order I go okay where are they getting the data? Um I and I've seen and I've seen other people post that they come up with these statistics and they're like putting out percentages of crashes involving non-English-speaking drivers. I I don't know where they're pulling that data. I don't know if they're just making it up or if that data exists. I would like to see it, but I still I haven't But is that the cause of the crash? I mean, there may be non English drivers, but are they the cause of the crash? You look crash in Colorado that happened. Remember the crash in Colorado where the driver was coming down the hill? Yep. And a lot of people thought he couldn't read the signs. Yeah, maybe that's the case, but he didn't he had bad breaks. Yeah, correlation doesn't equal causation all the time. So, it's like my my my post from the other day where ice cream sales and shark attacks go up in the summertime. Obviously, they both go up in the summer, but are they are they directly correlated to one another? Absolutely not. So, it's it's the same thing here. One of my issues with the Arkansas law specifically was they brought up someone who was supposed to be one of the largest tow company operators in Arkansas to testify for the legislature to get this thing passed. And if you look at them, they have eight trucks. And I'm like, okay, well, maybe that is one of the largest in Arkansas. I don't know, but with eight trucks, it doesn't seem like it should be. And then the data set that he presented, which I don't know where it came from, was 80% of the commercial motor vehicle crashes that he worked as a tow operator were people who couldn't speak English or communicate in English. And my initial thought is how do we come up with that? Is that one of the things like when Rob speaks it's like well 97% of people, you know, it's it's either coming out of thin air or it's coming from somewhere. And being we don't collect that kind of data from crashes to say whether you can speak English or not. I don't know where you get the data from. Yeah, it's an interesting question and I don't know if I'm going to break up. So hopefully I don't uh break up too much. But so the thing is like I was talking to an FMCSA regulator at a conference a couple months ago about vehicle maintenance. And I said, "Why is we have 20% of all vehicles like not satisfy FMCSA safety?" And they said, "Well, we believe that it's the driver behavior that causes fatalities. It's not the maintenance of the vehicle. And so I ask the question like, are we satisfied with 20% of vehicles being unsafe at any speed? And my problem generally with the industry is the barrier to enter is so small. Like we let the states do the testing and getting people certified. It might take you six weeks, might take you 3 weeks, then you can drive a commercial vehicle. And so these regulations, if we don't like them, get rid of them. And if we have them, enforce them. And ultimately it might mean that we lose some capacity. And is that the worst thing in the world? I don't necessarily think so. What I do wish we would see is the FMCSA with more resources to enforce the existing regulations because without the resources, these distinctions don't matter because I think the other guest's point is that we don't see a ton of data around this is what indicated that crash. But is it a contributing factor? Is it part of the calculus of how we think about these things? And ultimately, if we've had this on the books for almost a hundred years in some form or fashion, we can't act surprised if we're going to start enforcing it again. So, I think what we're going to see over the next few weeks and months is more and more warnings and then maybe we start seeing people start making some, you know, out of service criteria, people get knocked out of service. It's it's very interesting though. And Matt, you brought up an interesting point, one that seems to be getting a lot of uh attention in social media. And here, this kind of highlights it. Somebody's asking, "How are these drivers obtaining a CDL to start when the CDL test has to be taken and passed in the English lang language?" That's a question I've had for years. Um Rob, Brian, you guys probably have best sense of how this is playing out uh in the states that are kind of pushing drivers through. I think a couple of the things that I'm seeing, one, maybe the school isn't as ethical as it should be. uh and the testing facilities work handinand with some of these schools. So that's number one. Number two, if you have a Spanish- speakaking driver, you can get a Spanish speaking tester, uh believe it or not, for like the pre-trip, you know, where they have to go through and and do the pre-trip and even the on-road piece of it. So, I think that's how a lot of it's getting accomplished. Uh but I I think that there's there's a lot of side deals going down between schools and testing facilities quite honestly. Yeah. Why is that a thing Jack? It's something I never understood why the agency didn't uh and maybe they did and I just didn't see it dig into that with the CDL schools specifically because you know the only reason generally to get a CDL is to operate a regulated vehicle and to operate a regulated vehicle you are subject to this English proficiency requirement. So, why would states be allowing drivers to use translator apps and stuff like that to get the CDL if ultimately the end result is they're going to have a CDL and be subject to this rule that would probably, you know, disqualify them for op from operating if that regulation were enforced. Well, FMCSA should be there's a couple things they should be doing. I and I know they were. To what extent, I don't know. I can't remember. um doing state CDL audits. Yeah. Um and then they should be doing when I left they were just starting up now I left in 9 or 2003 or 2023 they were just starting up an audit program of the new uh entry level driver training schools which I think is way overdue. Um so maybe you know they'll be looking for that a little bit more now. I don't think they were really looking at it to to build off that point. Oh, sorry. Go ahead, Brian. Thanks, Matt. Um, you know, one of the things that that goes into play with that is, you know, we talked about the thousand Matt, you mentioned the thousand people that work for the FMCSA. That's continuous continuing to shrink. That's right. As people take federal buyouts and early retirements and stuff like that. So, between audits and monitoring the medical examiners and the schools and the this and that, I mean, where are they going to find the people to actually do this? To to build off that point, it's like you and I talked before, Brandon, about the ELD mandate. Okay, now we all have to have ELDs. How do you know it's the right ELD? Well, the manufacturer self-certifies. It's not the FMCSA checking it out and saying, "We've tested it. We think it's going to work." We have entered and we've been since 1980 a deregulated industry letting people kind of do what they want to do. Let the states do the testing they want to do and it we have these rules on the books and people choose or aren't able to enforce them and then you get the supply chain not that you want. You get the supply chain that you deserve and this is the supply chain we deserve and we we ring our hands saying we don't like this particular rule but I don't know if we're going to see a ton of enforcement in this. It'll be interesting over the next few months to see if they actually put resources to it or is it just some political statement to get people riled up and excited, maybe embolden more states like Arkansas did and say, "Oh, we're going to enforce it on oursel." Like, I don't know how this plays out, but it'll be interesting to watch. I think there's like there is one thing that you got to consider too and I don't know if this has been discussed and when you put a driver out of service for English lang language um deficiency where's that driver go yeah what do you do with them I mean service there's no 10hour rule where you you sit in the cab I mean yeah you don't learn English in 10 hours so you download Babel app and then you use the Babel app, I think. And to build off that too, Jack, is okay, now the driver sitting. What do you do with the truck, the trailer, and the load? Yep. Well, I what I see is I mean, the inspector, the state trooper, whoever's inspecting, they're not going to wait there. I mean, they got other things to do. They're going to tell the driver he's got to come and he's got to get somebody to pick him up. Maybe he can't understand that either, but um they're going to slap an out of service order there. The trooper leaves, the inspector leaves, that driver's driving. I mean, that's Yeah, that's what I You hop on gen logs and you watch that truck just start moving again. Absolutely. There's no clearing house for English proficiency yet. But um I think one part of getting licensed like for instance in Virginia if I teach you at a community college in Virginia and and for people who don't know in Virginia like Brian said some of these schools are pretty shady. Um I think up until 2010 most of the community colleges in Virginia were run by a school a third party that was run by the mob. And he his program was eventually put out. It's real story. Rob's not just making this up. But um the other part of that became thirdparty examiners, right? So if I'm going to teach you how to drive a a truck in Virginia for you to get your CDL at John Tyler Community College, I'm going to take you through all of the requirements that I have to take you through for ELDT. Um and then some other items. But then at the end of that, you're not going to test with me unless I'm a third party examiner. Right? So I think one of the big holes is third party examiner. So the school can still be shady, but you're going to get a state examiner unless you have a third party examiner that's doing the exam. And generally a state examiner is not going to let you pass where I think a third party is more likely. So I think part of it is the third party examiner piece. But another important piece with this is the ELD part that I think is a bigger issue than all of this. Um because there's no real time requirement for ELDT. And I know that doesn't really have anything to do with the English language, but earlier when I was talking about we have bigger problems on our highways, I think it all goes back to this root of who are we actually letting get on the highway in a vehicle, whether that's a CDL or whether you're a teen driver. I mean, there's teen drivers that get in a car with me to get their teen license. And in 13 states, there's no requirement for you to drive a car, right? There's no practical knowledge behind the wheel portion. Everybody's like, "What's that got to do with the CDL?" Well, you get that like four years before you get a CDL. If you get a teen license and then you don't know how to drive and you practice for four years not really knowing how to drive and then you get your CDL, what do we expect going to happen out of CDL? Especially if you have ELDT with no time requirement. ELDT is great, but if I can teach you ELDT and cover all the modules for range, behind the wheel, classroom in four hours, what did you really get out of that? Yeah, there uh several comments coming in through LinkedIn. I want to get to some of them. This one goes to the the question I pose um you know, why are we letting CDL schools push through drivers who uh who may run a foul of this regulation? and Tom on LinkedIn is saying uh DPS can only offer the commercial driver's license knowledge test in English or Spanish. Interpreters are prohibited during the administration of the CDL skills test. Applicants must be able to understand and respond to verbal commands and instructions in English by a skills test examiner. Neither the applicant nor the examiner may communicate in a language other than English during the skills test. I think this was for Texas specifically. Uh so yeah, that makes sense. I think those are good checks on the system, but my question still is why are you offering the test in Spanish if you're going to have a regulation on the books that say that driver is not going to be qualified if that's the only language he can understand on the test. Although to your point, if he's having to respond to verbal commands in English, maybe that gets to it. Go ahead, Matt. It'd be interesting to see if the schools themselves can be held responsible for passing somebody who can't pass that proficiency. I mean, this is the cottage industry of these for-profit schools that are pumping out people like a CDL mill, just more meat for the grinder, and then if they get tagged with something, then they disappear. But ultimately, there there has to be some level of accountability. As we talked earlier, there is not enough enforcement resources for everyone who's watching and this big regulation and there's a lot of people have lots of strong opinions. I wouldn't have a strong opinion about this. I mean, realistically, even if it has been not really heavily enforced for a decade, it's still not going to be heavily enforced now because we don't heavily enforce anything in this country. And we continue to watch the same trajectory of vehicle maintenance continuing to be way, way worse than it ought to be. And I just don't think we're going to see a massive change other than some warnings and a few big stories. But without investment in more enforcement resources, I just don't see this being anything major to write home about. It's gonna be I think we're going to see certain locations have a huge spike. Yeah. Yeah. I think you know Arkansas's already said that they're putting their foot down. Well, the thing about Arkansas is as we were talking about before we came on, that's a major thoroughare for people coming from Texas up into the mid Midwest with loads coming across the border through Laredo. and you know there's a lot of non-English-speaking drivers running that route um with auto parts and things like that. So I think we'll see we'll probably see the spike in it's going to lead us into another problem which is a problem we've been complaining about for years which is disparit enforcement across the states and jacking up carriers CSA scores in certain categories when they have heavy operations in those states that choose to focus on a a particular area. So the carriers that have heavy operations in Arkansas, for example, may see a relative spike in their driver fitness category going forward with with them enforcing the uh the English proficiency. Um I've seen an issue come up several times on LinkedIn that I think it's important we talk about and it's the interplay of these federal rules, the federal rule that we've talked about today or or to this point 391.11 and intrastate. We've done a lot of content on the distinctions between interstate and intrastate commerce and the mixap program. Jack, I know you mentioned mixap. Uh, and somebody else mentioned, well, hey, these drivers can operate intrastate in Texas, right? And so that it really brings to bear the question of mixap funding and how that plays into the whole um the whole enforcement mechanism. So, just generally speaking, I'll give kind of the broad answer since I just wrote an article on this not too long ago, so it's fresh in my mind. Um, so generally speaking, I think every state in the country, Jack can correct me if I'm wrong, but every state in the country to one extent or another is part of the motor carrier safety assistance program. Mixap, this is a federal funding program where the federal government is giving the states money to help them enforce their, you know, highway safety initiatives and that type of stuff. But as a condition to receiving those federal funds, the states have made some promises to the FMCSA specifically. And those promises are outlined in the regulations. I think part 350 of the regulations specify to what extent the the states have to comply with these rules in order to be eligible for that mixup funding. One of which is that they have to agree to adopt and enforce the federal motor carrier safety regulations. Um the regulation goes on though to say that there are certain areas of the regulations that the states are free to adjust or modify to their liking. uh and and not lose their federal funding because of it. So this is the reason we see a lot of states have raised the the or or have lowered the age limit for commercial drivers to 18. The federal level it's 21 but most states have lowered that down to 18. That's one area that the regulation the mix regulations allow the states to deviate from the federal rules. But if you look in any state code you are generally going to find their adoption of the federal motor carrier safety regulations. And um in order to keep that funding, they one thing that they cannot do is be more lenient on issues that the FMCSA has not told them they can be more lenient on. They will risk their federal funding if they do that. The English proficiency requirement, I don't believe, Jack, correct me if I'm wrong, is one of the ones that they are explicitly allowed to deviate from and still get their mix funding. Do you am I wrong on that? Do you know off the top of No, you're correct, Brandon. Okay. And so my point in saying that is to the person or to the folks that are saying, "Well, can they can't they operate intrastate in Texas?" I would say, "Uh, no. If Texas wants to keep their federal funding, they have to agree to adopt the federal safety regulations, apply them to intrastate commerce, and not in a way that is more lenient in areas that the FMCSA hasn't allowed them to be more lenient in." And so that's kind of my you know quick I haven't dug into that obviously in any depth but that's my quick take on I would like to get your thoughts on this Brandon. So if someone like is they they have to have the English proficiency officer pulls them over in Texas. It's really the officer's discretion or determination if they're proficient enough to communicate. So yes ultimately this is not the same as like the age thing where it's like ah I feel 18 today or I feel 19. Very subjective. Yeah. Yeah. So that I mean it's going to be up to I think the states are going to continue to have some latitude because if an officer doesn't want to write you up for not being able to communicate in English in a way that's proficient, they're not going to. But if they want to, that's the other thing I would say for the local trucking association, state level trucking associations, if you have a an enforcement arm that is more prone to finding you being less proficient, you want to coach your drivers and make sure you're prepared for that. For sure. Subjectivity is huge. Yeah. Go ahead, Brian. Yeah, I'm gonna jump on on on that a little bit. Matt, was, you know, are they going to put some sort of standardized test together? You almost like a, you know, like a a DUI test. There's certain elements that everybody follows soiety test. You know, there's there's a certain test that that they kind of stay close to. And the other thing that I'm I'm concerned about is the one example that I can think of is the transmitting of logs from the ELD. I don't I would not like to see a somebody get, you know, out of service for the uh English proficiency when it was a failure to understand what the officer's asking for rather than a failure to understand English because we see plenty of those violations come across from, you know, that they're English- speakaking people. They just don't understand the command or don't know how to do it. Yes, it's a training issue for the trucking company, but that request is not necessarily an admission of guilt that they can't speak English. Yeah. So, those are the two things that that I'm I I would rely on the famous test distributed by Dr. Seuss in the one fish, two fish, red fish, bluefish vein. That might be the next pathway forward, I suspect. Yeah, that's a good one. Uh yeah, I thought about a lot about this subjectivity issue because I think that's one of the big um the big questions that's out there and that the FMCSA and the CVSA are going to have to address is how do we how do we take what is such a subjective thing? Are you proficient in this language according to the officer that's stopping you and talking to you? How do we how do we make that less subjective? you know, kind of thinking through I was trying to think through are there any other regulations like this in the federal motor carrier safety regulations that are so subjective? And the only one that I could really think of off the top of my head, there's a regulation that you see cited roadsides sometimes um that pro that prevents commercial drivers from operating vehicles while they are ill or fatigued. And so you'll see a violation occasionally for driver being ill or fatigued. And so I guess that's somewhat akin to it. how to how is an officer to know whether this drive driver is ill or fatigued. Uh it's somewhat subjective, but that's the only one I could really come up with. So I I think the point is and I think this probably lands mostly on CVSA, the body that's kind of generating or or or coming up with standards that law enforcement across the country is going to subscribe to. I think it lands on them to figure out a way to make this less subjective and implement some kind of test roadside or whatever they're going to come up with to uh to to you know end up writing these violations. My I mean my one of my big things with this too is I mean we've talked a lot about the roadside piece of it, right? You're getting pulled over, an officer has to determine whether you're proficient, but then how does that change the workflow of your hiring process, right? like what are you going to put in place as a carrier to decide hey uh obviously I have to do my clearing house then my MVR background check drug test etc etc like what is the proficiency standard that I'm going to build in my fleet to determine whether this person can proficiently speak and read write communicate English before I put them on the road because ultimately if they get a violation for it it's going to affect you too so especially if you get back to Brian hey what do we do with the truck trailer and driver now that it's on the side of the road Yesterday I got a call and I I hit up Brandon and Brian and Jared and was like, "Hey, look, XYZ down in Florida is like all Somali and none of them hardly speak English." So, it's their question to me was, "What do we do here? How do we how do we handle this?" Because we're teams, we're we're mostly Somali. What do we do now? And it's like, well, we have to wait and get some guidance on it first, but you're going to have to develop some kind of way to start weeding out people who can't, or you're going to have to start figuring a way to accommodate it to either teach them English, which isn't quick, right? Um, so I don't know the answer to it, but I think there's going to have to be some consideration on the fleet perspective side for hiring and onboarding and recruiting and how you put these drivers in a truck because ultimately the schools can get them the license. It's ultimately going to be up to you to put them in the truck. I liked your solution for that. Rob, you want to tell people your idea or do you want to keep it confidential so that we can implement it that the uh driveaway towway company that we created? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It was a joke. That's why I didn't remember it. But uh my my my thought process, we could just start a driveaway company. It was like, hey, you don't need to speak English because we can pick you up. But we'll repower your load for you once it gets shut down. Yeah. Yeah. We'll fly out and pick you up. But send that recovery driver out. Yeah, that's right. Recovery driver services. We can't promise that Rob can speak English well enough to pass a test. But, you know, and that was another consideration for me because a lot of people tell me all the time like, "Rob, you have to open your mouth wide and enunciate every word that you say. Slow it down. Cut out the southern and really speak so we can understand you." Because Google and Alexa, you try to talk to them and they do not ever come up with the right thing. So then it gets back to the subjective nature of it. It's like, can you understand me at the roadside? I speak English. It's just not as coherent as Brandon. So one of the big questions that uh that's getting raised in LinkedIn and elsewhere um is what is the potential that this is this executive order is going to face some legal battles by groups like ACLU. I know Brian, you had raised that as a potential concern. Matt, Jack, what are your thoughts on whether we're going to see any kind of uh court cases involving this executive order? You you'll see challenges, but they will be unsuccessful in my opinion. I I think that we have enough we have enough precedent from a hundred years essentially of the same rule being in place. What what I think will happen, and this is my guess, is we'll see most of this be something like warnings as opposed to actual citations. Because if you get a bunch of people getting citations and they want to fight them in court or something and prove beyond whatever the burden of proof is that I can actually communicate in English, I that'll be something really really interesting. My belief is we're going to have a lot of warnings, a lot of fines and then it'll just continue on. But I cannot see a world where the federal government would lose on a rule saying we require you to communicate in English in a country that is speaking English, all the signs are English. I just don't see a world where they are successful challenging it. Yeah, I agree. And Jack, I know you're no stranger to having to fight all these legal battles when these rules I mean, you were around when the ELD rule got tied up in court for years. What's your take on this? I I agree with Matt. I I just I don't see this being a bigger thing. I do see the states, and you talked about discretion earlier, Matt, the states are going to just apply a lot of discretion here. And then you look at the disparit, you know, between um states. And before I got on here, I I I just I was curious. So I went to some bigger states, California, Texas, and Florida. Minimal enforcement. And I say enforcement, roadside violations of the English language. Minimal. And then I go up. I looked at just for the heck of it, I looked at Illinois, Kansas, and New York. And all of them have far more roadside violations than the states that I in Texas, California, and Florida. And you know, I try to think of the reasons why. Um, you know, you may uh be a Spanish- speakaking person in Texas, the troopers all probably understand the language and they're not going to bother you or something like that. So, there is an awful lot of discretion out there. But, you know, quite frankly, there's bigger fish to fry in this world and and to me, the job is to prevent these crashes from happening. Yeah, I think that's right. I've seen a couple people mention on here, I think Brian, you mentioned this, too, that or Jack, maybe it was you, CVS has already started the process of making this change. uh they're in meetings uh either it was this week I think wasn't it Brian where they were in executive committee meetings and from what I understand they just passed it Brandon okay they just passed it so as Brian mentioned earlier it passed out of the driver traffic enforcement committee they voted to send it on to the executive committee the executive committee met today and if you saw me on my phone which I try not to when I'm doing these things I asked if they passed And the word I got back was yes, call me. Okay. All right. Well, maybe we should take the call live on air. No. Uh, okay. That makes sense. And that kind of, you know, on what Matt was saying as far as the citations and the warnings and stuff like that. I I think the big issue when it comes to drivers being put out of service, that's going to be on the inspection reports. you know, whether it's citations or warnings, you know, those can or may not have any financial aspect to them that the out of service on the inspection report, that's going to be even harder to challenge or to do anything with. Because if you get a fine, they send you on your way with the fine, you put you out of service on the inspection report, then that's that is the the death sentence for that load. Yeah. my view that that's the two big outstanding issues that are going to have to get fixed sooner than later or addressed sooner than later, I should say, are the subjectivity of of the enforcement of this and then how does a driver get placed back in service once they've placed out of service for English proficiency. Is that even a thing that's going to be possible? as you guys all said and as we all know from experience in many cases these drivers are just going to continue driving and and just continue driving until they get caught again. And then the question then is there going to be some kind of escalation process? Hey, this particular driver received an out of service violation, you know, two weeks ago for this same violation. What are we going to do about it now? uh he's going to be placed out of service again obviously, but does then that get FMCSA's attention to start looking at the carrier maybe if it's the same driver with multiple English proficiency violations? I don't know. Yeah. Would they write would they write them up for jumping out of service order? They would get that too. Yeah. Well, possibly. I'm really curious to see how the large brokerages react to this once if we start seeing out of service things happening because in the world of the contract rate the old Dominions Pit Ohio talking JB Hunt like they know their drivers they know their processes they're not probably going to have the same issues but in the world of the brokers where they're working with mostly the one to six truck fleets um you start losing a lot of loads and you start having to get a bunch of recovery drivers for that yeah what is TIA going to do how are they going to react because this will impact the brokerage industry far far more than it will on the dedicated contract providers. So this this could have a I didn't even think about this until we're talking about but like now I realize like you could be have CH Robinson in TQL on the phone saying we don't want this anymore. So this will be really interesting. This may contract contracts specifically if it testing the driver before they say can you just fill out this little application before we allow you to go pick up this load. That's going to be fascinating. Yeah. Read your one fish, two fish, red fish, blue fish, you know, before before they This one has a little car. This one has a little star. My what a lot of funny fish there are. All right, guys. Well, we've got a few more minutes left here. We've got a ton of comments and LinkedIn still probably not going to have time to get to them, but I do want to leave with a with a few minutes that we have left. We've kind of hit on this, some of you have a little bit, but I want to give some practical tip tips or advice to carriers. uh the motor carrier uh carriers out there that watch our show, what should they be doing, particularly if they have a driver force that is um you know largely non-English-speaking, what what should they be doing now? Um what should they be thinking about and that type of stuff? So kind of go around the around the horn here. Rob, you want to start out? Uh well, part of me wants to think about like is there a difference in how you look at this? For instance, are they already a driver? are they already employed with us and then how do you handle that one versus how do you handle new onboarding of applicants right so are you going to decide to accommodate them and teach them English or facilitate that educational aspect for existing drivers that's another huge issue we haven't even I haven't even thought about termination wrongful termination yeah so you've got that aspect of it because you can't discriminate right based on age nationality sex etc so there there's all kinds of things to think about that and so do you address it and accommodate it or do you let them go and then have to deal with the fallout from that potential fallout and then there's that aspect of all right now how do we applicant Matt Leler Santiago how do we determine if you can speak read write communicate English proficiently enough to work for us so I think and even that goes back to the broker side of of what Matt was talking about it's like how is that going to affect what carriers brokers are willing to deal with based on how many people in their workforce can't read, write, speak English because the subjectivity issue creeps back into the carrier side of things as well and the employment concerns as well. I can imagine a scenario where you don't give the driver the job or you terminate a driver because you believe that he can't speak English sufficiently, but then is that going to raise the subjectivity question in any subsequent employment, you know, wrongful termination litigation or or that type of stuff? So, There's got to be some objectivity there. It's like when we have crash committees at the enterprise and strategic fleet size level, when I put these in, the whole purpose of that committee after a crash is to decide objectively what have we done with other drivers who have done the same thing in the past. How are we going to judge this? And then you have a committee that decides objectively like this is our criteria. This is what we're going to do. They're going to need training. They're going to need coaching. They're not coachable. This is their third time. Whatever. But there has to be some objective criteria there that's overarching across everybody that's that's actually implemented consistently. So um I think it's I think they have a lot to think about. One from the aspect of are they already employed and two how are we going to start hiring these people? How do we add that into our onboarding? Jack, I'll turn it over to you for closing thoughts since I know you got to jump here soon. Yeah. I mean, and and I look at where you look at the Dreage community, especially out in the West Coast and probably the southern coast, a lot of Ethiopian um uh ethnicity there. So, and I I've seen that firsthand where they can't speak English, they can't understand it. They had interpreters in a room when I was in there. Um, but it goes back to now, you know, when you're doing for the carriers, as Rob said, I mean, if you have a driver out there that's safe, proven to be safe or hers that she's safe, it gives you a little bit more protection. But hiring a new person that um, you know, can't speak English, do you open yourself up to litigation possibility? Um, you know, that's something to to think about. But I I go back to the beginning. I I think Matt said what's changed? I mean, it's been on the books for a while. It's not an out of service um uh well, it is now through the CVSA. It's not and CVS, the North American Standard out of service criteria is mentioned in the regulations. Yeah, it's adopted by um and there are specific regulations that are mentioned in that same section for out of service carriers. So, um, it'll be interesting to see. I've heard a lot of folks get that messed up, too. They say, "Well, the out of service stuff is not even regulation." It is adopted by reference in the regulations specifically. So, it is a regulation in a sense. Uh, one of your former colleagues, uh, Daryl Rubin here is commenting on LinkedIn. CVS shouldn't change anything until the unified process supports the change. FMCSA will need to make a number of changes, but nothing will happen from the executive order until the office of the secretary provides guidance on the executive order. And that will all take some time in my opinion. I don't doubt that in the least. Yeah, it takes time. All right, Matt, you want to give your last words and then uh I'll I'll let Brian wrap us up? Yeah, I think that this is a wait and see sort of thing. I mean, are we going to start seeing people knocked out of service? That's going to be incredibly disruptive to the supply chain. We have a lot of other things going on. I've heard about tariffs moderately some things buzzing about that. This is just another thing that's going to make it more difficult to be a motor carrier, be difficult to be a broker. When we see a profound change in enforcement, if we do see more resources or more states get emboldened, then we're going to have a capacity crunch. We will lose capacity and that might be the thing we want to see happen. But ultimately, um, this is great for lawyers. I think it's great for all of us in the compliance and safety field. We need more things for lawyers to do. So, thank you for everyone making chaos in the supply chain. Yeah, perfect. All right, guys. Well, thanks for joining us. We're going to wrap things up here. Brian, you want to give the last word here since I didn't give you a shot there? That's that's fine. Yeah, the I would say pay attention to how enforcement rules for the routes that you run on. I don't see, you know, companies, especially smaller ones, getting rid of a bunch of drivers uh for all the reasons that were stated before. So, pay attention to where the enforcement is. the ANI site is great and just your your general inspection data. So, yeah, keep an eye on everybody, we'll probably have a lot more to say on this topic and others uh all pertaining to DOT compliance. So, if you want to stay up to date with everything we've got going on, subscribe to our newsletter. That's the best way to do it. Trucksafe.com/subscribe. We push out a lot of content on DOT safety regulations and we try not to spam you. So, uh, we'd love to have you a part of that and stay tuned for further episodes. Truckselive.com is where you can watch all of our previous episodes, read guest bios. Uh, you can also subscribe to the podcast wherever you get your podcast. Thanks for being here, everybody. We really appreciate it. See you.

Event Completed

Thursday, May 1, 2025 at 4:15 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube