Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 6 - The ties that bind

Tuesday, December 21, 2021 at 4:50 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 6 - The ties that bind

About This Event

In Ep. 4 of Trucksafe LIVE!, we discussed the driver qualification, orientation, and onboarding programs and how carriers can leverage them to better retain drivers. After receiving so much great feedback from that show, we decided to put together a sequel of sorts. In this episode, we'll be joined once again by Brian Runnels (VP of Safety for Reliance partners), as well as Jamie Philip (head of recruiting and driver development for Cheema Freightlines). Brian and Jamie will provide some great tips for carriers to build lasting relationships with their drivers and reduce turnover.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 6 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress discuss the persistent challenge of driver retention and engagement in the trucking industry, joined by Brian Runnels, VP of Safety at Reliance Partners, and Jamie Phillip, Director of Talent and Fleet Development at Cheema Freightlines. With industry-wide driver turnover approaching 100 percent and the ATA estimating a shortage of roughly 80,000 drivers, the episode makes the case that carriers too often focus on recruiting to solve a shortage problem when the deeper issue is a failure to build lasting relationships with the drivers they already have. A central theme throughout the conversation is the difference between retention and engagement. Jamie Phillip introduced the distinction, arguing that carriers tend to be numbers-driven at the expense of nurturing their workforce. Guests emphasized that drivers want structure, not just independence, and that the onboarding process sets the tone for the entire employment relationship. Brian Runnels stressed the importance of honest recruiting, noting that overpromising on miles, pay, or home time destroys trust early and accelerates turnover. Both guests agreed that orientation should involve a rotating cast of knowledgeable department representatives rather than a single instructor, and that leadership visibility, including appearances from the CEO or president, sends a powerful signal to incoming drivers that they are valued. The episode also covered the role of technology in sustaining driver engagement after onboarding. Jamie described Cheema Freightlines' use of Workhound, an anonymous text-based feedback platform that allows drivers to share concerns without fear of repercussion. He emphasized that collecting feedback is only half the equation and that closing the loop by communicating back to drivers what actions were taken based on their input is what builds credibility and trust. Brian added that smaller carriers are increasingly using telematics, LMS platforms, and ELD data to replicate the engagement practices of larger fleets without the associated overhead costs. On the subject of training, guests highlighted that hands-on ELD instruction using a physical test unit in the classroom, paired with a content library drivers can revisit later, dramatically reduces compliance errors and roadside violations. Jamie noted that drivers retain only a fraction of what is covered during orientation, making accessible reinforcement training essential. The group also pointed out that carriers with no formal training policies are effectively relying on whatever knowledge a driver brings through the door, a practice one commenter described as a recipe for disaster. Fleet safety professionals walking away from this episode should consider auditing their onboarding process to ensure it goes well beyond regulatory basics, investing in anonymous feedback tools to surface issues that may never reach management, closing the feedback loop with drivers to demonstrate that their input drives real change, and building a video or LMS content library that drivers can access in the field. As Brian Reynolds summarized, if a carrier signals through a careless orientation that it does not care about its drivers, drivers will mirror that attitude right back, and the revolving door will keep spinning.

Full Transcript

do so so hey what's going on everyone welcome to episode six of truck safe live the live stream show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation i'm brandon this is jared we are with truck safe consulting and childress law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs super excited for the show today obviously gearing up towards christmas here so this will be the last show of the year for us and we got some great guests on uh if you're here watching with us live make sure you uh say hello in the comments so we know you're here and then um as we go through the show if you have any questions or thoughts on the topics that we're discussing just drop them in the comments and we'll try and get them up here on screen jared you ready for christmas i am ready my kids are ready too they remind me every day yeah you got all your shopping done uh thankfully my wife has all the shopping done so i did nothing um she did it all how about you i'm pretty good i think we're pretty good we um we've got two boys as jared knows and i think we've got him way too much as usual that's a good problem to have though right yeah for sure from their perspective yes well hey uh before we get too deep into the weeds with the show we want to take a second to thank the sponsor of this episode which is netra dyne netrodine's vision based driver eye safety camera platform captures and analyzes all drive time removing the guesswork and providing critical insight to fleet managers advanced ai and edge computing reduce driving risk protect against false claims reveal the true cause of events and recognizes and rewards drivers for proactive decision making so your drivers stay safe stay satisfied and stay on your team so if you're looking to get into cameras in the addition of an ai ai-based platform for cameras interests you definitely take metrodyne system for a spin you can go to their website at www.netradine.com and reach out to schedule a demo so before we dig into today's show and bring on our guests let's let's look at some of the facts and figures that we have in front of us that kind of relate to today's topic um we know that the ata estimates we're about 80 000 drivers short across the industry obviously there's some people that would dispute that figure for different reasons etc but that's the figure that we have in front of us from the ata also among the atri top industry issues for carriers the industry itself has identified that driver shortage and driver retention are again top 10 issues it's been that way for years turnover we know that turnover industry-wide is just under 100 and many of the carriers listening probably have turnover near 100 or maybe even over 100 so with the issue industry-wide this revolving door with that comes more effort and expense to onboard drivers properly and to train the drivers properly you know also i mean this this revolving door concept really negatively impacts the morale of drivers uh simply because they're unhappy being caught up in this industry churn if you will yeah we see i think jared you and i see the frustration on both sides when we when we talk with our motor carrier clients quite a bit on the carrier side frustration with you know the the investment that they're continually making in drivers and especially through the onboarding process and all of the expense that goes into you know getting a new driver set up in the system uh you know doing all the drug and alcohol tests the background screening but then on the same thing on the driver's side we see frustration with drivers who and we talked about this on on episode four if you haven't seen that episode make sure you go back and watch it it was kind of the uh the the prequel to this episode where we had um brian reynolds who will be joining us here in a second on along with hayden cardiff from idealic they talked a lot about the uniqueness of our industry where we tend to bring drivers on board spend a few days with them put them out in the truck and then never really talk to them again unless there's a problem and and we talked about you know what in what other industry do we treat our employees or our or our colleagues like that where we're only going to talk to you if there's a problem it's and so obviously frustration from the driver's side of things that being in that type of work relationship and and feeling like nobody's really got your back um can be like you said jared a real um drain on their morale so that's what we're going to that's going to be the topic we're going to talk about today we're going to tackle it um or how how carriers can build lasting relationships with their drivers to help reduce turnover um we're lucky to have with us two individuals who are who are really passionate about this subject and have been working to solve this dilemma for years first up we have um brian reynolds back with us he's the vp of safety for reliance partners and then we also have jamie phillip with us who's the director of talent and fleet development for chima freightlines out of sumner washington so let's bring him on board here hey guys hey guys hey thanks so much for joining us brian thanks again for being here uh it seems like you're kind of the perennial guest on on truck safe live nowadays so we're glad to have you and jamie welcome hey thanks appreciate you guys having me on the show happy holidays merry christmas merry christmas hey before we get too much in the weeds here i want to uh give you both a chance to uh let the listeners know who you are tell us a little bit about yourselves and about your companies if you would go ahead oh thank you gentlemen yeah as you said jamie phillip uh i'm with chima freightlines director of talent fleet development been here about five years prior to that uh is where i crossed paths with uh our common friend brian the reynolds out uh when we work together at gordon trucking so i've been in the industry for about 18 years i spent half of that time in dispatching operations kind of getting my hands beat in the dirt and the nuts and bolts of it all learning a lot uh transportation was brand new to me i was kind of hired green but then um halfway through my career i made the transition to the onboarding and development side of the business my education is in um the classroom training and so um taking all that knowledge and putting it to good use now i oversee our driver services team which includes um onboarding driver engagement and our talent that supports our drivers their overall development as well awesome thanks jamie bryan hey uh brian reynolds i'm the vp of safety for reliance partners and like jamie said we crossed paths and and we stayed in contact through the years but we've known each other for about 14 years now i think is what we determined and you know it's i like you brandon i i spend a lot of time in front of customers and and i hear many of the same things you know how how do i solve this problem how do i keep my drivers and i tell every one of them that if i had that answer i probably wouldn't be sitting here talking to y'all right now because i'd have packaged it up and sold it and made a billion dollars doing it but you know all we can do is give them the tools and the the ideas that we see from very positive carriers like chima and some others that you know they do a good job bringing folks in and keeping them for the most part uh yeah you know we've talked about it before that the there is no such thing as the perfect trucking company because if it was we'd all worked for him and stayed there and you know that it just doesn't happen so you gotta they've got to find the right one that fits for them and you know the carrier they have to be the best that they can be but they can't try to be something they're not and and i think that might be leading to some of the the problems with with driver retention as well is you know they're they're making promises that maybe they necessarily can't keep because it's not what they do or it's not who they are yeah and i think i think that's the trick right i think we as an industry don't do a good enough job of paying attention to the retention issue we focus our attention on the shortage issue and this is something i think i've learned for myself over the last year and really delving into this topic and seeing both sides of it you know those that say there's a shortage those that will argue that it's a retention issue and and and i see the point on the retention side i think i think it's true that motor carriers as a whole don't do a good enough job of of working to build relationships with their drivers and keep them on board rather than just churning through drivers and working to fix the shortage issue so obviously that's what the show is all about today is building these driver lasting driver relationships and managing turnover so can you brian you've kind of already given this to us but so maybe we'll start with jamie but jamie can you give us a general sense of why this is a important and important topic especially in our industry absolutely well because i've been doing a very similar role for my last two carriers you know and i'm sure brian had attested this we see drivers come in day one with all sorts of war stories and horror stories about how they've been treated how they've been mistreated by other carriers they've worked for um and so as some of my colleagues have discussed you know we're kind of shooting ourselves in the foot as an industry trying to make a professional career for the drivers we want to bring on as you guys mentioned in the lead-in you know drivers um you know they want to make a home um and sometimes we're just like here are the keys here's a couple days of orientation and off you go and we'll talk to you if something goes wrong and there's way more to it than that um and so that's kind of what the industry really needs to begin to wrap our brain around is um maybe not focusing so much on the word retention uh but maybe a little bit more focused on the word engagement which i think is kind of part of our solution to the the dilemma um finding ways to generate engagement with our driving associates with our team that supports those folks to bold community so that they know that they're not just out there on their own as much as they might like their independence to kind of foster that community environment um so they know they're a part of something bigger brian anything else to add to that yeah i think when you know jamie talked about the the drivers having their independence um they do want that that that is something that they strive for but i've said it once and i'll say it again drivers want structure by and large when somebody comes to a quality carrier uh you know a quality trucking company the reason they went there is they thought the structure was going to be something that was going to work for them and you know they want to have that rules to work by and if there isn't any and if it's just a situation where here's the keys and go all of a sudden that goes out that goes out the window for them and it it's almost well if they don't care why should i care and it i really believe that and yes they they want to be left alone until it's time to not be left alone and you know then they then they need that not necessarily a helping hand but they they need that guidance and assistance uh in whatever they're dealing with so so why is this such a hard industry for most or a hard issue for most motor carriers to grasp i mean at the start jared had mentioned the hatchery study and this being constantly at the top of the list issues with drivers whether it be the shortage or the retention why are these issues not going away in your view i can start with that i i it requires a lot of effort there's a lot of effort that goes into this and there's a lot of time that's taken away from running the day operation of a company to work on these driver engagement pieces i i love that term so i'm gonna i'm just gonna go ahead and steal it thanks jamie um so you know it's when there's capacity issues all over the place and you know company trucking companies are getting in getting inundated with more freight than they can handle um it's go get this load it's not worried so much about you know the engagement piece and maybe what's going on at home or that the driver didn't understand his payroll or you know somebody forgot to put in that he needed two hours detention time um because the driver manager or dispatcher was trying to do 20 other things which you know they got a business to run i get it but it's those little things that fall through the cracks that cause wider chasms jb anything yeah to take that one step further i think there's a natural friction that exists in our world that's very number centric it's kind of numbers versus nurture right and so we live and die by um load count and length of all and rates and you know making sure that we take care of a driver getting the number of miles they're hoping to get on each check um and so sometimes if we keep our head too much in the weeds we might lose sight of the overall like wellness of that employee and so i think part of the answer and of course the answer is not as simple as just one thing but there's a really focus on the nurture because i think we've got the numbers thing down i think it's easy for a bunch of trucking heads to get into a room and say hey if you know we're in the red that's not good we need to be in the black and we need to make money as a company and loads have to deliver on time and these are the rates and the margins and so on i think we've got enough of that down but i think the deficit is on that nurture side right really trying to take care of that employee you know giving them assurance giving them structure and making sure they feel like a valued member of the team i uh i wanted to ask about something here brian you brought up a really good point earlier about how sometimes recruiting makes promises that the company just cannot keep and and it seems like in most companies that that i work with uh sales leasing those are the sexy sides of the company and everyone else is a cost center right so if a company wants to ensure that recruiting is not recruiting at all costs and making these promises that the company company can't keep i mean what would you recommend how does a company start to get that under control because some companies are even using third parties to do their recruiting for them i mean how do you get that under control you know you just have you have to be truthful with yourself you have to be truthful with with what your capabilities are and it will be right for the right drivers it's not necessarily look if we tell them we can't do can't get a driver here okay you don't hire somebody out of there you and you don't try to figure it out because that's going to be too difficult you just have to flat out be truthful with who you are what you do and starts at the very beginning because if a driver comes in and he's been told the truth about everything that he's going to get my guess is the retention ability goes way up uh because he knows what to expect and you know i i hear it and jamie does too jamie hears it way more than i do uh about the war stories where you know somebody comes in and they said oh yeah i was going to get 3 200 miles a week and they they toughed it out for two or three months and we're lucky to get 18 and but that's what that company does and if they were told that up front maybe either the driver wouldn't have made the decision or um to go there or you know something like that it wouldn't be a situation where you just have to keep burning through guy drivers guys you keep burning through drivers to hope to find that one that's going to take what you're willing to give them but i'm also going to say and we all know this drivers sometimes hear what they want to hear yeah so you know i'm not going to lay the blame 100 on the companies because there is a selective hearing process um and you know we all know it yeah i was going to ask one thing that you both mentioned earlier was this idea that that trucking companies and it's my experience as well particularly with smaller trucking companies you know the the management is wearing a lot of hats right there they're the safety director they're the sales person they're the they're the recruiter they're everything and so maybe part of this is an issue where they just don't have the capacity to be able to do this on this on their own but at the same time i got to think that there are some some ways that they can handle this better so i wanted to put it to jaime you know it sounds like uh at least at chima you guys have have thought this through and have developed a whole department that's devoted to this i want to get your thoughts on how what steps can a a smaller trucking company that isn't to that point yet what what steps can they take what advice do you have for them to to better engage with their drivers when they don't have a whole department of uh devoted to it yeah well great question and you know kind of piggyback off of brian's comment you know that first impression is a kind of a make or break deal it's going to be their first understanding of does this company back up what they speak or or am i going to be disappointed i'm going to be let down and every step of that process is either going to you know reassure that they've made the right decision or it's going to invite them to shop around and so on the recruiting end there's really no benefits to overselling obviously you want to facilitate engagement i get the purpose of it you obviously want to paint as accurate of a picture as what to expect but i think the best benefit is to be straight because again you're going to establish integrity in that relationship which is going to build a longer lasting higher in the process yeah i mean because that's an issue too right you got you when you're considering hey how are we going to advertise this to potential candidates you're you're obviously looking at your your competitors out there and all the promises they're making and you're thinking i got to be able to to make similar promises or there's not going to be any way i'm going to get anybody in the door so how do you deal with that how do you i mean you know you got all these trucking companies out there making these huge promises and and we want to be more truthful about what we're able to offer how do you communicate to the driver pool that what what you're offering is is more realistic than what everybody else is on well you hope that the people you're currently doing business with your current driving team is saying good things on your behalf and so we we really value our driver input you know the culture that we promote you know we broadcast on our social media channels you know we encourage our drivers our current driver force to be putting google reviews out and reviews anywhere that they're available um and fortunately that has been working very well for us um and so that that that to me is key and so having a focus on culture and investment in the relationship um has to be present if you don't have that then um there's one major miss and if they think they're just looking for a paycheck then they can get that just about anywhere else yeah yeah so jamie um i love the fact that you started in dispatching operations it gives you a really unique perspective into the you know daily things that drivers deal with and you understand a lot more than a lot of folks like me that have transitioned right into like safety and compliance and things like that so um 18 years in the trucking industry and trucking industry years are like dog years so you've been in the industry for a very long time i'm not saying you're old but so when you started in dispatching operations were you observing the same level of churn of drivers and and this you know retention issue that we're seeing now or has that progressed over time and how do you how do you explain the difference if there is a difference no great question i mean as we would be talking about today if this wasn't kind of like a generational type of industry-wide concern uh and so certainly those concerns were present just as much then as they are today i found that where i have landed here at human freight lines the offering the comprehensive offering is going to be feathers in anyone's cap and so if you've got an outfit that you know can provide good miles and can pay their drivers on time and has a driver support team that is really driver-centric and has new reliable equipment to drive and can get the drivers home reasonably and just has a great support team i mean that just makes it that much easier to recruit a driver and i don't have to have like a sales mentality when i want to go out and recruit a driver i'm just telling them what we have to offer and and what's not to desire about most of all those things unless the pay is like far off from where they can get it somewhere else and so it it's a benefit to start where you have all the check to be able to check all the boxes now if there is an offset if there's a deficit like we got all these other great things but you know your pay is really off that's always going to be a challenge to work with so you know as a company whatever company you're working working with they're going to have to do a cost analysis to say how do we need to move this to stay competitive but over the 18 years i've been in the industry yes the insight from operations has served me very very well has allowed me to talk very knowledgeably in the classroom about the job expectations for a driver very knowledgeably no matter what carrier it's been for about the different fleets that we run so i can set adequate expectations in the classroom and again it certifies that integrity so they're not showing up on day one to an orientation classroom and hearing from an instructor that has no real knowledge of what the company does it's just somebody that knows a bunch of presentation content run you through an agenda or a schedule somebody that actually has been there planned the loads seen the freight knows the delays at certain customers and is talking again as they know it as they've experienced and i think that was a topic that brian hit on in our in our earlier show on this topic was getting the right person in the room during orientation somebody who can communicate this gets into what you're talking about jamie communicate the culture so i'm curious to get both of your thoughts on who it is that should be in the room communicating with drivers and and how how at that recruiting stage the very early stage how is it that that carriers can can communicate about their their corporate culture to uh prospective drivers well i think you know one of the things that that we touched on in that earlier show was that welcome comes from the highest person you can put in there if the ceo is available then he comes in and says hello and uh you know makes himself visible to the to the driving force it there is a conception or and it's true there there is some truth to in many operations the c-suite people your ceo your cfo your president you know those types of people they work out of an ivory tower and the drivers never see them drivers don't know who they are um to have that person come in and at least say hello spend a couple minutes introduce himself maybe even put that's where the expectations come from look i own this joint and this is what i expect out of everybody there is no room for misunderstanding when it's that guy doing it so you know if you can bring in your maintenance guys to talk about maintenance and safety and then you know the safety folks the compliance folks your operations i know that you know when when i came to gordon as a driver in 2006 you know they brought in i think just about every driver man or uh i should say yeah driver manager that anybody that was in orientation whatever fleet they were on they knew um by the time they left who the persons who the people were they were supposed to talk to so anybody that you can get involved or the more people you can get involved the better to have one person up there just droning on and on and on and then start a video and then drone on some more that is not a recipe for success at all yeah steve says from linkedin he says right off the bat provide the driver prospect with a fact sheet of what the company does expects and offers and what the driver can realistically expect so i think that feeds right into what you're talking about brian jamie any thoughts on on that topic yeah i've seen it done a multitude of ways i've seen it done uh you know a to z with one instructor i've seen it very video centric and i've also seen it with department leads coming in rotating throughout and obviously that's the best avenue i mean if you can get people that you know are very knowledgeable um out there delivering the content people that deal with the content the content masters out there engaging with the new higher classroom that's always going to be your best bet uh video is always a distant far distant backup option um only kind of desperate times would require those desperate measures because that needs to be facilitate live conversation that's going to be better engagement for learning it's going to build relationships um but you also want to keep in mind there's got to be some degree of engagement and so as brian even suggested you don't want some monotone i'm thinking of the the i think it's the teacher for the penis cartoon so you got like you know eight hours a day with that guy or gal uh you know you have to be mindful of who you're putting in front of your new hires there has to be that kind of culture something it's a little bit of an ambassador you know rah-rah-rah you know enthusiastic but knowledgeable as well so i've found the most successful combination of that having a engaging facilitator and then rotating in kind of key department speakers yeah because you got to keep in mind the competition that's out there what what are other carriers doing and and how are they kind of structuring this uh recruiting and orientation process and even if you can't make the same types of promises that they're making or or it doesn't make sense for you you can you can control things like this you can control who you put in front of the drivers you can control how much time you spend with them how much information you're giving them to to set them up for success because as we talked about brian in our last show i i think that's the key is giving them the information and setting them up for success because the way that we've historically done this in my view is pretty much setting them up for failure just you know smacking them on the butt saying good luck to you and not really having any more touch points after that yeah that's that's true and you know the one other thing you have all those class times this was something else that we touched on some of those most important pieces to the driver engagement side is the brakes the lunch you know those times there spend that time with those drivers you can find out a lot about who they are what their experiences have been um what they're expecting and maybe what they've been told and you know even if you're talking to one person you know if you're an active listener and you're you can actually listen to some other conversations going on you might pick up something that you can nip in the bud you know maybe that that didn't go so well through the recruiting process or maybe they're having a hard time with through orientation or you know whatever that process is uh you might be able to get a hold of that and act on it before that driver even leaves so those times there are so critical to be involved with with the new people coming in and just getting to know your your workforce and and who it is that's working for you and getting to know their families getting to know their kids getting to know their sports teams we talked a lot about that jamie how do you all handle once we've kind of gotten through the recruiting process how do you all handle making sure that you're continuously engaging with your with your existing driver workforce several ways we have a tool that we've uh implemented called workhound i don't know if you guys are familiar with workhound at all uh third party that uh uses text as a medium to outreach to your driving personnel and so uh they have a list of all of our associates their driving associates uh and at our request they'll ping them maybe once twice a week uh how's your day going you know give us on a scale of one to ten how's it going they might say five six seven uh and they might have a pointed question if we want to get some intel based on gps or um you know what these particular customers are like give us some feedback it's pretty open-ended but what that does is it generates a feedback loop gives us an opportunity to address issues that may not be escalated to the decision makers one of the benefits of workhound is that although a driver could just as easily send an email or maybe call their driver manager to communicate these types of concerns sometimes as as busy as dispatch operations can be somebody might have a fairly casual suggestion for improvement and it might get lost in the busyness of a day and so the way the workhound works is it it takes the text replies and it removes all the contact information so we don't know who that intel is coming from it's coming from one of our drivers um and so it's just anonymous feedback it's just the content that they provided and then it comes up to a dashboard and we can see all the text responses that come in and obviously as an executive leadership team we review that content weekly and sometimes real time and we can decide hey that's not the first time we've heard that let's definitely investigate that and we can you know show them again to establish street credibility and integrity uh that we take their feedback and we make actionable items based on it so we'll delegate who's responsible for what task based on that feedback that we get for them so that's one big thing that we've done this past year is they take full advantage yeah so that's interesting i mean that sounds a lot like what we do jared what we recommend on the safety side of things it's almost like prioritizing issues based on trends you're seeing in the data so from a safety side we're constantly looking at the carrier csa scores and trying to identify you know not not at the violation by violation level because if you're a big carrier it's going to be impossible to be able to manage those on a violation by violation basis except the most serious ones obviously but if you can really look for the trend in the data just you know we're seeing a ton of 14-hour violations across our fleet and prioritize those for action then you're you can kind of work down the list uh and fix things so it sounds like that's kind of what you've got in place for uh driver engagements as well which is interesting brian what are you seeing in terms of i thought that was an interesting point in in using technology to help with the process it's something that we've talked about in the past what are you seeing other fleets doing in terms of kind of uh using technology to help them with this process you know they're trying to get feedback through through elds they're trying to do proactive outreach um when they're seeing trends in safety things they're also if they're hearing there's issues with payroll or you know they're they'll address it through the payroll system um trying to update that i've got a couple small carriers that there's actually a a couple really nice lms systems out there now for um small carriers you know you you've got your big ones but they're not really suitable for somebody with 50 units and there there are a couple of those out there now so you know they're doing that to try to streamline their process to try to make things easier for the driver so i think that's probably the biggest thing we're seeing with the small carriers is how can we act like a big carrier um but not go broke doing it so it's you know how do we get these um how do we get these telematics and and different types things to uh reach you know to make the driver's life easier yeah brian uh interesting you mentioned telematics i was curious i was gonna ask uh jamie so when you're on boarding drivers are you using first are you using a camera system and then also second do you spend time during onboarding actually rolling out what that camera does when an event is triggered just so drivers understand that they're not being watched at all times um in kind of a weird invasive kind of a way yeah so to answer your first question we are using forward-facing only cameras presently not much really to share on that obviously because it's not you know in cabs so that would obviously be a little bit more conversation heavy but um you know the liability it's kind of common practice nowadays for a lot of carriers to have that forward-facing camera and i think as long as as most safety departments have discovered drivers have as well that's going to help you more than it's going to hurt you um and so that's not had a difficult time getting much buy-in on that at all well to kind of dovetail off what you're talking about earlier about communicating with the drivers via technology um what kind of areas are you seeing the most feedback so i'm sure some subjects you send out a blast and it's really no response at all and then others you send out a blast and it's just tons of feedback what are the areas that are generating lots of feedback usually customer based questions you know what what what customers are you getting the most delays at um those are typically the ones that have a plethora of responses that trickle in um and sometimes you know stuff to deal with our mobile comp solution because sometimes those can be as much of a blessing as they are a curse you know because technology can always sometimes you know pending updates and eruptions and stuff like that and so those are the two areas i think we get the most feedback on i think i want to make a point here before we gravitate off topic to it's one thing to use a tool to identify some tool whether it's technology or otherwise to to elicit a request this input from your driving force it's another thing to demonstrate to them that you're actually going to do anything with it so i don't want to i'd be remiss if i didn't point out the fact that it's the feedback loop like the entire 360 degree loop that i think really matters because if you don't recognize that then you just it's all receiving and no provision of integrity to say hey what would you guys ever end up doing with that and so as a part of how we utilize this we make sure to send a regular newsletter out to our team saying this is what you have said and this is what we have done and so i think again just to kind of foster that culture of like we're listening and we're actually you're helping us shape this company with your feedback and input and that's an excellent point because that thought popped right into my mind when you talked about the customer related issues i mean sure a carrier may do something about that and do the right thing and do great things for the drivers but if you don't communicate that to them they're just never going to know that you did that and that's going to contribute to frustrations and then also that churn yeah so that's a great point yeah especially missed opportunity right there if you're not telling them what you're doing with their feedback exactly yeah especially on that detention issue we hear this a lot i mean it was one of it was in hatchery's list of top issues for drivers where they're having issues with customers you know detaining them and them having to sit forever waiting to be loaded or unloaded and and get a sense from a lot of drivers that they're not happy with their carriers for not doing anything about it and not and not really caring about that issue it sounds like you guys all have a protocol in place where you know there are situations where you you go to bat for your drivers well again because of the challenged market right now there's just not enough capacity to go around i mean we've had the blessing of having so much freight to choose from so if there is a customer that's causing significant delays uh whether it be detention or even misloaded freight if they're not loading the trailers properly and drivers are having to get it scaled and return to rework you know if we see that more than a handful of times obviously the first recourse is talk to the shipper find out what the issue is if they can't correct the problem i mean the market has been very kind presently and we can decide hey well we don't need to continue doing business if that's the way that you're going to delay our drivers that hasn't always been the case but the current market has helped us in that favor hey i was going to ask in situations so putting aside the workhound technology that you all have implemented or do you all have a system in place that where your drivers can can you know get in touch with the person they need to get in touch with on particular issues like brian mentioned if they're having payroll issues is there some way that you communicate to them here's who you need to talk to and here's how you get in touch with them for me yeah we have a phone list that we hand out on day one so they have all the departmental listings so they know who to reach for whatever breakdown payroll safety human resource related conversation might be necessary of course their driver managers their one-stop shop so if they aren't quite sure who would address their concern they would start with their driver manager and they could certainly put in contact with the appropriate party and they also have access to it on our mobile com they want to instead of having a verbal conversation you know via transfer phone call or something like that our mobile com allows them to communicate directly via email they can message directly the person they want to reach great right that's yeah i just wanted to jump in real quick and it's so important when we're talking you know take kind of taking a step back back into orientation to where they're using that workhound program and stuff like that it in chima is if the drivers aren't taught how to use that and how to use the technology that is going to be uh in front of them then it's you might as well not even have it so you know when you're talking about building out a unique orientation program and one that's going to set you aside from another company one that is beyond the basics to where you're explaining okay this is how our feedback chain works and you know laying those types of groundwork down that is a huge benefit and they and they leave there with something that they didn't know from the other x number of orientations they've been through in their career yeah that's that's good insight kind of along those same lines i i suspect that and you you guys would know more than i do but um i suspect that training plays a big role in kind of this idea of setting your drivers up for success and making sure that they have that they're trained on you know whether it be your customer specific procedures or dot compliance what what are you all seeing in terms of uh fleets that are that are good at this this idea of engaging better with their drivers what do they all kind of roll out in terms of training you know just high level what types of training are they doing how often are they doing it uh that type of stuff well i i think that from my driving past and you know the last eight years with with gordon they did a great job with the with the training and it's not even so much and we really didn't have much of the video training back then it was more of there was safety messages that went out there was postings put up there was stuff sent out but there was always a constant communication about what was going on in the world whether it was wintertime weather announcements it would go out every morning and you know if you were in that part of the country you know if you're in one of the mountain areas or you were in an area that was prone to bad weather you could count on getting a weather report every morning now everybody can look it up on their phone now but it was something that kept the engagement going and um it was something that was so important and you know as we found out recently in colorado um training a lack of training can lead to some severe consequences and you know it's that's something that i've been very blessed with the companies that i drove for that that was a continuous thing uh it was it was weather it was okay how to chain it's it's winter time so we gotta know how to do that slips trips and falls all the time um because until work comp injuries go away everybody should be getting that training over and over and over again uh but it was it was just a constant flow of all sorts of different topics jamie how do you all handle kind of the training for your fleet of driver well let me ask you first is your fleet an employee driver fleet are you independent contractors um mostly employee okay we have a handful of independent contractors but that's minority it's a majority company obviously a big difference in the way training works for independent contractors employees so for your employee fleet how do you all handle kind of your training do you offer you know training at the on the onboarding process and then remedial training how does it work for your fleet yes to all the above there's different layers obviously obviously it begins at onboarding and orientation um there's certainly stuff that can be accomplished remotely via fleetwide messaging and best practices so this constant voice whether it be from the training development team or our safety team uh this is the best practices the way we want to do this oh by the way reminder scanning your paperwork oh by the way when you have osmd this is the process for that or you know you know three points of contact to avoid slips trips and falls like brian mentioned some of that can be handled you know through regular messaging and obviously email traffic as well um lms's obviously technology can step in certainly and you can utilize some of the systems that are out there um with video content or other generated content whether it be a guided presentation we've invested all those types of things so you can roll out a package of training and it can be a remote situation which is very convenient and trucking but then there's the things that are more significant which may be seasonal or it could be more based on occurrence that would warrant you know definitely coming back in on a 90-day training thing or a seasonal winter driving tips kind of a chaining um training type of occasion um so we utilize all those things uh so that we can i mean it depends on kind of what we're trying to tackle whether it be a quarterly safety training agenda or if it's just something we want to kind of reinforce because we've seen some of the data trending with slips of trips and falls and like work comp related things we want to speak to something specific yeah you know i think from our perspective in looking at carrier safety programs i i i get the sense that that not many carriers or at least maybe the smaller carriers don't appreciate the interaction between the safety and compliance world and the in the driver engagement and retention world so what we'll see a lot of times is is carriers who don't have any type of training platform uh and in my view that's that's definitely not setting your drivers up for success because what ends up happening is those drivers go on to have compliance problems whether it be uh you know getting their their cdl downgraded for for some reason or another not paying child support or something something like that and then the carriers just you know they end up cutting them loose without really giving them the tools they know to understand the consequences of the various compliance issues whereas if they would have had a system in place where they they train their drivers on all of the compliance issues early on in the process and then they take a you know have some kind of a remedial training process in place where they identify through their safety metrics that you know driver john doe is having a problem with this particular issue let's send them through that particular lesson again i think that goes a long way in in setting your drivers up for success and not having to just cut them loose whenever they have these problems you're you're training them and avoiding issues that pursuant to your policies or because of your insurance requirements or whatever you would otherwise have to cut them loose yeah on the training subject oh go ahead jimmy sorry well i was just going to say i mean the real challenge at least in the world of over-the-road trucking is you know just the mobility and the frequency of actually seeing your employees so to not have some sort of like mobile training solution uh presents a real challenge and so it's kind of like you need to have an answer for both you have an answer for somebody that can on-site at your various locations be trained and ready to walk somebody through a particular training module you also need to have the ability i mean there's some drivers that actually never get through a terminal location unless they're specifically given a load because they need to come talk to safety or or someone else of that nature and so you need to kind of be suited to be able to address both yeah i was i was going to comment on the training subject i mean it seems like elds are a huge area that when you're on boarding a driver they may be coming into a new system getting to know that system and some of the pitfalls that they can get themselves into personal advance policy all those things like that but as far as getting to know the device before the wheels start turning are you using third-party provided training materials are you doing like a walk-through in the classroom with the drivers what are you doing jamie and then brian what are you seeing in that to that end fortunately i'm very familiar i'm kind of one of our points of contact for our mobile com solution and so i'm very well acquainted with our device um we have a a test unit in the classroom for both of our orientation locations and so that certainly helps yeah i have built the content um and that has continued to like develop over time um and has changed over time um because the content has changed as well that actually the way the device works um so yes it's not third-party content it's basically something that i have drafted because i i just think uh what would what one a driver driving professionals that has never touched this device need to know like what do the buttons do i mean it's a touch screen thing but it's got four buttons what does this one do when i touch it what's that do how do i where's the keyboard there's no keyboard oh when you tap a field and the keyboard virtually pops up okay so it's kind of starting very general and working to the specifics which can get really oversaturated with detail if you think about like the complexity of like a log an eld uh you know having the shipments and the trailer detail in the eld side of your logs not just over on your messaging side so there there's a lot that goes into that and so um fortunately my classroom experience and my education has really supported that way of thinking so that's where the content comes from but i think you have to incorporate some version of not just a content presentation but also that hands-on experience so having those training units in the classroom i think is an absolute must and of course the drivers all go out for a drive test and so they're getting that experience reinforced when they climb into the truck we have them log in so they're getting reinforcement of that hands-on experience when they go out to the right brian what are you seeing you know honestly we don't see one that for the most part i i work with a lot of smaller carriers and then than what chima is so i don't see stuff that is that detailed but even when it's that detailed you know let's not forget they're getting bombarded with information um and there's a possibility they're going to forget stuff so you know the eld is probably the most complicated thing especially if someone's stepping into a new platform and they're not as tech savvy as the next guy um so when they're starting to push buttons and it's not doing what they hope it would do it the frustration level goes way up maybe now they're running late you know there's a whole bunch of things because they maybe just didn't remember um what was explained to them and how they were supposed to do it and you know that even down to the the littlest things is remembering to put your load information in and you got to do it after you got to do it every day just like you did on paper log and you know that was kind of the way i tried to explain to them anything that you would do on a paper log every day you have to do that on an electronic log too there's no difference there um but even with that it they still you know people still forget and it's so it still has to be a uh that's where the engagement piece is so important and maybe before that phone calls made with the on the engagement side you take a look at their elds and look for the form and manner stuff is it there and you ask the question the low-hanging fruit on on those violations do you have extra log pages do you know where your instruction cards are do you know how to transmit your logs just those types of questions with the engagement of dealing with the actual problem that they may have um can go a long way to avoiding some frustration down the road yeah it's crazy and i love i love the concept of having the test unit in the classroom because the hands-on learning i mean everybody's different some folks are going to learn with the video some folks are going to more folks i'd say will learn with the test unit in their hand and then to take it one step further putting that you know same eld in the unit when you're doing your road test that's just taking it one step further but i would encourage the small carriers to reach out to the eld vendor because you can get your hands on a test unit that you can onboard your drivers with and show them hands-on how do you handle personal conveyance how do you log in and and switch to drive time etc etc um try to get your hands on that test unit it's not as hard as you might think yeah and to both of your points i think it's it's critical that carriers have whether it be a video walkthrough like jamie mentioned or even just kind of a sheet that they keep in their truck that says here's what you got to have in the truck eld related because it's crazy how many of those violations you see where they just didn't have the instruction manual they didn't have the transfer manual they didn't have the blank supply of logs those are within the top 10 violations driver related violations that are discovered roadside we just did an article on this and that is so easy to correct it's just a matter of the driver not really understanding what it is they need to have in the truck and so if you can develop something like that that's going to save you a lot of headache uh down the road i know jared you and i have started working with a lot of our clients to develop sounds like similar videos to what jamie's putting together for his fleet where we walk them through the specific type of eld that they have in their truck and here's how you get into an inspection mode and here's uh here's how you pull up or how you transfer logs here's what the officer can and can't get to when you're in inspection mode that type of stuff i think that goes a long way to uh especially in such a stressful situation right so the drivers are are automatically stressed when the lights are on behind them and so any way that you as as the carrier can kind of uh you know minimize that stress for them i think is going to be for the better well i think also you know no matter how much time you devote to onboarding and first you know higher orientation they're not going to soak in i mean i'd be interested to find out how much they actually retain is it 65 70 i don't know so to have some sort of a video library or some sort of reinforcement training via lms they can go back to and just say you know i remember most of that most of their i don't remember anything about that you know or like you know maybe they were just so overwhelmed by the mobile comm stuff they're like oh we talked about um how to report an accident so yeah to have that available even if you cover an orientation you know for them to be able to go back to a directory of video content or a content library of any kind be able to get reinforcement and any all that stuff will only serve the company better their development yeah steve steve agrees here he says you'd be amazed how many carriers i've audited or assessed that have absolutely nothing in place no training policies procedures they rely on the driver's knowledge and experience they bring with them uh that's that's a recipe for disaster that's for sure um yeah for sure so kind of wrapping things up here we're running out of time oh go ahead brian that's setting the mentality for um the how the drivers are going to act about the company and that that shows that if you don't care we don't care yeah if if you're going to be ad hoc about your orientation program and and just slapping them on the button saying good luck to you that's how they're gonna uh that's what they're gonna know and that's how uh they're gonna how they're gonna operate and that's just gonna lead to trouble so hey we're out of time here i really appreciate you both uh being on today really great insight um thanks so much for all the all of the information you're able to provide um we're gonna finish things up here jared you wanna kind of give a preview for what's to come next year yeah so we are in the works cooking up our different topics for the shows in 2022 we're very excited but we do want to hear from folks so if there are topics that you think would be a great fit for the show or just stuff you want to learn about uh please please uh send us an email and just let us know those topics that'd be great uh we do have some guests teed up and some exciting shows coming up so definitely watch out for those invites yeah and hey make sure if you haven't already checked them out be sure to check out our courses over at trucksafeacademy.com we're running a deal now through the end of the year we get 15 off with the coupon code holiday 15. check out some of our courses we've got compliance related online courses for safety managers and for drivers that go through the nuts and bolts of the federal care safety regulations everything from registration issues to hours of service driver qualification and everything in between they're a great way to um to to give this training that we're talked about a lot in this episode to as kind of an onboarding tool or as a remedial training tool so be sure to check that out also be sure to follow us online on social media linkedin facebook twitter pretty much all of them were constantly posting free content on dot safety and compliance issues so with all that said we hope you all have a merry christmas and a great new year and we will look to see you next year thanks everybody

Event Completed

Tuesday, December 21, 2021 at 4:50 PM EST

Watch on YouTube