About This Event
Brandon and Jerad are joined by Nicole McMurtry, USI's Illinois Transportation Practice Leader and National Vertical Leader, and Hayden Cardiff, Chief Innovation Officer of Idelic, to discuss modern trends in commercial transportation insurance, including skyrocketing premiums and what fleets are doing in response.
Special thanks to Idelic for sponsoring this episode. Be sure to check them out online at www.idelic.com.
Episode Summary
In Episode 8 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress are joined by Nicole McMurtry, President of USI's Illinois Transportation Practice and National Transportation Vertical Leader, and Hayden Cardiff, Co-Founder and Chief Innovation Officer of Idelic, to discuss the state of the commercial fleet insurance market. The conversation centers on the dramatic rise in insurance premiums over the past six years, the factors driving that increase, and what motor carriers can do to position themselves as lower-risk, more insurable fleets. The hosts also briefly cover recent regulatory developments, including a proposed rule allowing oral fluid drug testing, the elimination of annual certificates of violation, new MVR requirements for drivers previously licensed in Canada or Mexico, and a six-month delay in Canadian ELD enforcement.
The group examines key findings from the February 2022 ATRI report, "The Impact of Rising Insurance Costs on the Trucking Industry," which documents insurance cost increases on a per-mile basis from roughly 5.4 cents in 2010 to over 8 cents in 2020, alongside skyrocketing auto liability premiums across all fleet sizes. Guests point to nuclear verdicts, social inflation, aggressive plaintiff litigation strategies, and the exodus of insurers from the commercial auto market as the primary forces behind rising costs. McMurtry notes that some excess insurers have either left the market entirely or significantly reduced the block sizes they are willing to write, while Cardiff emphasizes that carriers on the whole have failed to turn a profit in commercial auto for nearly a decade, creating persistent upward pressure on rates.
A significant portion of the discussion focuses on the relationship between safety technology, driver performance management, and insurance outcomes. Both guests stress that simply installing cameras or telematics systems is insufficient — fleets must actively use the data generated by those systems to identify at-risk drivers, deliver consistent and documented coaching, and align safety accountability across operations teams, not just safety departments. Cardiff warns that fleets choosing to ignore or disable available technology are effectively handing plaintiff attorneys a negligence claim, since the standard of care has risen across the industry and juries expect carriers to use tools that are both affordable and widely available. McMurtry adds that insurers are increasingly looking for fleets that can tell a compelling, data-supported story about their safety culture, rather than simply submitting a bare application.
The guests offer several concrete recommendations for fleet professionals navigating the current insurance environment. McMurtry advises carriers to begin their renewal process at least 120 days out, avoid shopping the market every single year as it signals instability to underwriters, carefully evaluate deductible and captive structures, stay actively involved in the claims process rather than delegating entirely to adjusters, and monitor their CAB report and SMS scores as insurers routinely use these as threshold screening criteria. Cardiff encourages fleets to operationalize safety by integrating data from ELDs, cameras, FMCSA records, dispatch, HR, and learning management systems into a unified platform, then use machine learning and predictive analytics to prioritize coaching interventions. He also highlights driver turnover as an underappreciated insurance risk factor, noting that the highest-risk period for any driver is the first several months on a new fleet, and that strong onboarding and retention practices directly improve both safety outcomes and insurability.
The episode underscores that while the insurance market remains challenging, carriers with strong safety cultures, consistent driver performance management programs, and proactive underwriting partnerships are seeing meaningful relief from the double-digit premium increases affecting the broader industry. As McMurtry puts it, the fleets that are not seeing 30 percent increases year over year are the ones operating well-run organizations where safety is prioritized from the top down — and those are precisely the risks that insurers are competing to write.