Episode Summary
In Episode 9 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress of Trucksafe Consulting are joined by Leah Shaver, President and CEO of the National Transportation Institute (NTI), and Lindsay Trent, Co-Founder and President of the Next Generation in Trucking Association, to tackle two of the most pressing issues facing the trucking industry: driver pay and the growing driver shortage. The conversation explores how these issues are deeply interconnected and why fleets of all sizes continue to struggle with attracting and retaining qualified drivers year after year.
The discussion on driver pay covers the evolution of compensation structures in the industry, from the historically dominant mileage-based pay model to more creative hybrid approaches that combine mileage pay with hourly or activity-based components. Leah Shaver notes that private fleets have long led the way in developing transparent, comprehensive pay packages that account for a driver's full range of activities, including detention time, layovers, and loading. She emphasizes that uncompensated and unpredictable time remains one of the most significant pain points for drivers, and that pay volatility from week to week is a key trigger for turnover. Beyond base pay, carriers are increasingly offering benefits such as pet and passenger policies, pet insurance, college tuition assistance, transition bonuses, and expanded family leave to attract drivers holistically.
On the question of whether the industry faces a true driver shortage or simply a retention problem, both guests push back against the notion that these are mutually exclusive issues. Shaver points out that the industry is losing a generation of experienced Baby Boomer drivers faster than it can replace them, and that fixed supply constraints have only been worsened by the pandemic. Lindsay Trent highlights the importance of identifying young people with the right behavioral traits for the job early and showing them a clear career path, noting that Generation Z is increasingly questioning the value of a traditional four-year college education and may be more open to skilled trades careers than previous generations.
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the FMCSA's Safe Driver Apprenticeship Pilot Program, a joint initiative with the Department of Labor designed to allow drivers between the ages of 18 and 20 to operate in interstate commerce under supervised conditions. The program involves two probationary phases totaling approximately 400 hours of supervised driving and competency milestones, and is expected to open for applications in May. The pilot will be capped at 3,000 spots across approximately 1,000 approved carriers, with the primary goal of gathering safety data on younger drivers operating across state lines. Lindsay Trent encourages carriers to pursue a Department of Labor apprenticeship program as a prerequisite and notes that apprenticeship programs broadly have shown strong retention results, with research suggesting that 89 percent of apprenticeship graduates remain with the same company after nine months.
For fleet safety professionals, the episode offers several actionable takeaways. Carriers should audit their current pay structures for transparency and consistency, addressing unpaid time gaps that frustrate drivers and contribute to turnover. Fleets interested in the apprenticeship pilot should begin establishing or affiliating with a Department of Labor-approved apprenticeship program now in anticipation of the May opening. Engaging with local schools, community colleges, and organizations like the Next Generation in Trucking Association can help build a sustainable long-term driver pipeline. Finally, carriers should revisit blanket hiring policies that automatically disqualify drivers with prior drug and alcohol violations, developing written, uniform processes for evaluating those who have completed the return-to-duty process, as such policies may be unnecessarily narrowing an already constrained driver pool.