Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 9 - Show me the money!

Thursday, March 31, 2022 at 2:56 PM EDT
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 9 - Show me the money!

About This Event

Brandon and Jerad are joined by Leah Shaver, President and CEO of the National Transportation Institute, and Lindsey Trent, Co-Founder of the Next Generation in Trucking Association, to discuss recent trends in driver pay, as well as the Safe Driver Apprenticeship Pilot Program.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 9 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Jerad Childress of Trucksafe Consulting are joined by Leah Shaver, President and CEO of the National Transportation Institute (NTI), and Lindsay Trent, Co-Founder and President of the Next Generation in Trucking Association, to tackle two of the most pressing issues facing the trucking industry: driver pay and the growing driver shortage. The conversation explores how these issues are deeply interconnected and why fleets of all sizes continue to struggle with attracting and retaining qualified drivers year after year. The discussion on driver pay covers the evolution of compensation structures in the industry, from the historically dominant mileage-based pay model to more creative hybrid approaches that combine mileage pay with hourly or activity-based components. Leah Shaver notes that private fleets have long led the way in developing transparent, comprehensive pay packages that account for a driver's full range of activities, including detention time, layovers, and loading. She emphasizes that uncompensated and unpredictable time remains one of the most significant pain points for drivers, and that pay volatility from week to week is a key trigger for turnover. Beyond base pay, carriers are increasingly offering benefits such as pet and passenger policies, pet insurance, college tuition assistance, transition bonuses, and expanded family leave to attract drivers holistically. On the question of whether the industry faces a true driver shortage or simply a retention problem, both guests push back against the notion that these are mutually exclusive issues. Shaver points out that the industry is losing a generation of experienced Baby Boomer drivers faster than it can replace them, and that fixed supply constraints have only been worsened by the pandemic. Lindsay Trent highlights the importance of identifying young people with the right behavioral traits for the job early and showing them a clear career path, noting that Generation Z is increasingly questioning the value of a traditional four-year college education and may be more open to skilled trades careers than previous generations. A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the FMCSA's Safe Driver Apprenticeship Pilot Program, a joint initiative with the Department of Labor designed to allow drivers between the ages of 18 and 20 to operate in interstate commerce under supervised conditions. The program involves two probationary phases totaling approximately 400 hours of supervised driving and competency milestones, and is expected to open for applications in May. The pilot will be capped at 3,000 spots across approximately 1,000 approved carriers, with the primary goal of gathering safety data on younger drivers operating across state lines. Lindsay Trent encourages carriers to pursue a Department of Labor apprenticeship program as a prerequisite and notes that apprenticeship programs broadly have shown strong retention results, with research suggesting that 89 percent of apprenticeship graduates remain with the same company after nine months. For fleet safety professionals, the episode offers several actionable takeaways. Carriers should audit their current pay structures for transparency and consistency, addressing unpaid time gaps that frustrate drivers and contribute to turnover. Fleets interested in the apprenticeship pilot should begin establishing or affiliating with a Department of Labor-approved apprenticeship program now in anticipation of the May opening. Engaging with local schools, community colleges, and organizations like the Next Generation in Trucking Association can help build a sustainable long-term driver pipeline. Finally, carriers should revisit blanket hiring policies that automatically disqualify drivers with prior drug and alcohol violations, developing written, uniform processes for evaluating those who have completed the return-to-duty process, as such policies may be unnecessarily narrowing an already constrained driver pool.

Full Transcript

do call me the joker call me the fool when she calls me don't you know don't you know got no class all i'm attributes bout me baby don't you know that love fun you know it's true is give me your retention and your sweet redemption i will never let you down it doesn't take my affection and my same protection hey everyone welcome to episode nine of truck safe live the monthly show where we and our guest tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation i'm brandon this is jared hey everybody we are with truck safe consulting and children's law both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting-edge safety programs uh so we've had a couple uh a good weeks here we had a show just recently two shows this month absolutely yeah keeping busy here um if you didn't catch our last show it was earlier this month uh we talked uh what did we talk about uh that was the insurance show the insurance show yeah it was very pretty good yeah it was very riveting show again just uh just uh we're trying to hit all of these issues that are causing motor carriers a lot of problems and insurance is very high on that list as you can imagine so we had nicole on from usi and we had hayden on from idyllic and they gave some some great insight on where we're at with the modern insurance market commercial auto liability insurance for motor carriers and what's kind of contributing to the skyrocketing premiums that a lot of our motor carrier clients are are experiencing so if you haven't caught that go catch it on youtube or spotify wherever you get your podcast you can check it out there so thanks for joining us today if you're here with us live make sure you say hi in the comments so we know that you're here and as we gonna go through the show today uh feel free to drop your comments or your thoughts uh and we will try to get to them as we're as we're able yeah in addition to that last show that we did on insurance that we focused a lot on that hatchery study about rising insurance costs and how that's impacting the trucking industry we've had a number of other shows kind of at this point where we have kind of too many shows to list all in one sentence but we did shows on nuclear verdicts independent contractor related issues telematics that show is titled drinking through a fire hose and as brandon mentioned we do have all of our previous shows on apple spotify google podcast so check those out you can also find them on youtube as well and as i mentioned we're just trying to hit on all of the hot button issues that impact fleets we do a lot of work with fleets of all all different sizes all across the country and we know that there are no shortage of of issues that that impact you on a daily basis so we're trying to bring on the experts to talk about those issues and and really dig into them and figure out solutions to them kind of along those lines we've got something exciting going on uh over at truck safe we just today uh opened up registration for our first annual fleet compliance summit so we wanted to uh do a little promo for that so here we go hey everyone i'm brandon wiseman president of truck safe consulting wanted to let you know about something super exciting we've got in store for later this year which is our first annual truck safe fleet compliance summit now this is going to be a multi-day virtual conference unlike any other where we'll be joined by some of the most prominent thought leaders in our industry to discuss and develop strategies for addressing the most pressing issues that fleets face today including things like nuclear verdicts independent contractor reclassification dot enforcement cargo damage and freight claims and so much more we're going to be offering fleets practical tips for mitigating the risk in several key areas which is great for fleet owners executive teams safety directors and managers and risk advisors alike i want to personally invite you to join us for this one of kind event which will take place on august 11th and 12th as i said at the start this will be a virtual conference unlike any other i really meant that aside from the fantastic educational sessions we have planned we're also going to feature a virtual event lobby an expo hall where attendees can network and connect with one another and also visit dozens of vendor booths to check out the latest and greatest products and services offered by our great sponsors you'll also have an opportunity to speak with vendor representatives download helpful content and see product demos you definitely don't want to miss this opportunity registration is now open and seats will fill up fast so be sure to check out the details and register online at trucksafesummit.com we look forward to seeing you there all right so be sure to check that out uh like i said registration is open now you can check it out at trucksafesummit.com jared i think we've got like 18 speakers booked for that and we've got dozens of sponsors so it should be a pretty great event a lot of great topics so looking forward to that yeah yet again bringing on the experts to talk about the issues so really exciting yeah we get sick of hearing our own voices talk so we bring on other people to talk with us uh okay so that brings us to today's topic um the show is is called show me the money so we wanted to talk today about another big issue that impacts uh fleets and that is kind of this ongoing theme that we've talked about in a few different shows which is uh kind of a combination of of issues that all kind of roll up into one you know we're talking about driver shortage we've had shows we've talked about driver retention and so in this show we want to talk about driver pay which is one of those other issues that ranks on the list of the top issues impacting motor carriers and drivers that hatchery list that we've talked so much about over the last few shows so we know it's kind of you know this issue of driver pay is a pain point for carriers and drivers alike uh it's an ever-evolving issue something that that we can never really seem to get our hands on uh or to get a grasp on and then um you know we see carriers developing new ways uh constantly to try and compensate drivers particularly creating you know creative new ways to pay them and to to come up with new programs to entice them to to bring them on board so that's one of the issues that we wanted to cover in this show and then also kind of a related issue is this new uh fairly newly announced apprenticeship program that the fmcsa in partnership with the department of labor is going to be rolling out it's a pilot program to start we've talked about it in prior shows but we want to kind of hit on that and how that all plays into this and and what it'll mean for the industry so uh that's what we're going to talk about in today's show yeah the uh the apprenticeship program i mean it's just it's just one way that congress and the fmcsa are starting to step in and try to address the driver shortage issue and of course you know we've talked about in the past and we have an article on our website as well that kind of gives a deeper dive into the apprenticeship program but essentially the goal is to allow those drivers that are under 21 to operate and interstate commerce in certain circumstances and we know now certain drivers that are under 21 can operate in interstate commerce only at this point but the apprenticeship program is going to have kind of a two-part apprenticeship uh portion to it that's going to total about 400 hours of uh kind of supervised learning and apprenticeship for those drivers and then eventually when they graduate from that program they'll be they'll be able to drive in interstate commerce by themselves so it's really exciting and it's going to allow some of these younger drivers to drive and hopefully alleviate some of the driver shorters that a lot of people believe is reality at this point yeah definitely so definitely hot topic in the industry let's try and get to the bottom of it with our guests so we want to welcome them on first up we have leah shaver president and ceo of the national transportation institute hi leah hey good afternoon good afternoon and then we have lindsey trent co-founder and president of the next generation and trucking association hi lindsey hi hey we appreciate you both joining us uh we're excited to talk with you both about these issues we know uh you all are very entrenched in these particular issues so wanted to get your take on them but before we do we wanted to spend some time getting to know you so maybe if you spend a few minutes or so telling us about yourself and and your companies and how you got into transportation so leah do you want to start us off sure um first how i got into trucking i started as a recruiter this is my 21st year working in the industry i loved my job as a recruiter in fact i felt like it was my life's work assignment to offer jobs to drivers that would succeed and stay at the company which means unlike the high volume needs that a recruiter needs to fulfill um i didn't focus on numbers but rather on the the best match for the company folks that i thought would be retained and in fact when i left them 14 years later there were many that were still at the company so um the picker is is good um but i i transitioned in year two um at my company for um to to hr overall and risk management retention later manage driver marketing and and recruiting teams as well but um never really gave up on that recruiting fever just really tried to focus on the lifespan of a driver and and uh recruiting in order to retain from hire to retire i left the motor carrier side to run nti and for the last seven years instead of supporting one company i serve fleets all over the us and canada we focus not only on paying appropriately for the job but also as i said effectively retaining from hire to retire so in terms of our company um nti provides uh folks that employ drivers and technicians data and support so that they can effectively recruit and retain from hire to retire it starts with that information on appropriate compensation and it leads to communication for ongoing engagement uh we see in the trucking industry a lot of of forward-facing engagement on the front side but it needs to continue through the lifespan of the career for the driver for 26 years 27 years this year nti has focused on professional driver wages best practices and programs and we analyze nearly every aspect that relates to professional drivers from before they started in the industry to training to perks and programs to owner operators and everything of course that impacts the trucking industry and market most importantly what's going to influence driver supply um and capacity and and demand so to do that we track pain over 600 different markets in north america we do that by trailer type and job description so that no matter where a company is located or they're expanding their operations we can hone in on appropriate compensation for drivers or techs no matter the experience the requirements the equipment the qualifications you know teaming etc so really quick nutshell of all of the work that we do at nti awesome thanks so much lindsay hey so i've been in the trucking industry for 10 years and i started off doing driver staffing um i didn't really know anything about the trucking industry and i applied for this job and i got it and i actually just fell in love with the industry the people um the mission of what we do as an industry and throughout my career doing driver staffing obviously the needs were just immense people needed drivers to hire um they needed to fill in for vacations i mean you have to have your products delivered this is an essential job and everybody from the receptionist when you walk into a company to the president of the company would say oh we're in dire need of drivers we could hire 10 today um and it was the aging workforce population and just not enough people getting into the industry and we were very successful at driver staffing and i did that for six years and then i started work for rider and i worked for a writer for the last four years and it was the same thing there's not enough drivers we can't buy equipment because we need more drivers it also morphed into hey we've got to hire diesel technicians and we could hire more diesel technicians if there were any out there so um we saw this problem and um i talked with people at a lot of different conferences and brainstorming somebody at some point mentioned dave dying to me and i and i said oh his program sounds really neat so he teaches a high school program um for cdl driving at patterson high school in paterson california and so dave so i called dave one day and we started talking and we kind of dreamed up this idea what if we created an industry-wide solution for this industry-wide problem created a trade association where we're focusing on getting young people aware of trucking careers but also creating programs so that they can get trained to become cdl drivers and diesel technicians and that is when we formed the next generation of trucking association we you know we've been working on the last few years creating our board of directors our bylaws and working on our mission which is meeting with schools and informing them about the uh trucking industry about cdl programs and how they can start a cdl program at their high school um and so that that's where we are and today i'm full time with the next generation and trucking association and we are just working hard every day meeting with schools across the country um and a lot of schools are very interested they want to provide good jobs for their students and the communities that they serve and so we're meeting with schools and helping them start cdl programs and diesel tech programs it's really exciting and really it's a great time to be in trucking that's awesome well hey thanks again to you both for for joining us today we really appreciate it appreciate it and we definitely have the right folks for the job here i think yeah absolutely and you know next gen that's one of those companies that you know i just heard about and i was like that's an excellent that's awesome you know i hear about this all the time in rubbing shoulders with folks in the transportation industry i hear about you know new things that people are doing and next gen is no exception to that so it's really cool you seem very passionate about it you're excited every day when you go to work except for monday i am very excited i love it every day it's so fun what we're doing i mean it's really fun because the thing is and and i say this is you know is this is good for our economy because we're providing jobs for people and we're keeping freight moving across the country it's obviously good for our industry because we need a skilled workforce but the biggest win and what we're doing is the student because a lot of these students um they're not succeeding in traditional education and if we can introduce them to a career in trucking then we can literally change their lives and the upward trajectory of skills that they have and what they can do for their future and it just changes their entire family tree and so it's so fun every day because we're impacting students lives yeah that's awesome and we're glad to be a part of it now so uh happy to be a member of the association so um want to kind of get into the topic here you heard us kind of do our intro and talking about you know the the issues and uh you know unsurprisingly driver pay and turnover continue to top the list uh of top industry issues leah we've heard you uh talk about the issue at length on other podcasts and various industry publications can you give us a general sense of why this continues to be an issue year after year well um you know i i know you want to talk about pay and turnover and i feel like those are two categories that get unpacked individually they do they do morph into each other inherently but but both have their own individual issues within the industry um first i'll say at nti though we focus on compensation studies pay is not everything right i call it the handshake agreement that leads one to accept a job we all take a job based on the fact that we know it's going to meet our minimum life criteria um most of us uh is it live to work or or work till you know we we we have to work to live right um and some of us that are extremely passionate do end up living to work but but ultimately for for most of the workforce they accept a job based on on the components that are being offered and sometimes pay doesn't align with the job so let's say we have a work agreement and you accept a position with a particular salary based on a certain job description and you show up and and you start the job and there's a change in conditions and it leads you to question your decision about this particular company or that particular income so um you know whether it's unsafe conditions if it's a lot of labor uh if it's teaming and living and managing a lot of personal and work elements all in the very small space uh whatever that is you know sometimes the pay just doesn't align a lot for with the job in in the industry in terms of the highest turnover related to comp um let's say specifically a new driver wages that's improving um and it's in areas uh also that are really out of a driver's control so unpaid uncompensated time and so when you think about that you're looking at detention or which is historically there's a gap period where there's unpaid um detention time and the pay that does get uh shared with the driver for detention is is typically a very small percentage of of the total and so the the total amount of time versus the time on the road or or productive behind the wheel is is marginally different um the unscheduled layovers due to traffic weather maintenance no load etc essentially anything that's not turning miles is something that costs a driver in their paycheck and so um while we've seen some improvements as i said like with new drivers or inconsistency with pay um in in setting up dedicated runs or offering guarantees it's just not consistent across the board and overall where do folks really want uh to see the end result whether you're a driver or a carrier or you know a fleet that employs your driver you want them productive you want them turning those miles and so ultimately the best reward no matter uh you mentioned new ideas and new ways to pay people ultimately the very best reward is when uh the driver is is highly productive and and typically that's with miles or at least the wheel is turning yeah for sure and before we even get into the weeds of of new ways that are that carriers are looking to compensate drivers can you give us a sense of you know historically or traditionally what have been the most common ways that that carriers have compensated drivers just to kind of set our base here yeah i mean it's obviously mileage is the the historic way to pay a driver that's in the forefront still that's the most predominant way that we see drivers paid we also track uh pay that in you know in terms of like the major silos would be uh mileage percentage um by the load by the hour and then growing with popularity would be a hybrid pay or a blend of hourly inactivity pay yeah so in in researching this show and listening to a couple of your podcasts that you've done previously leah i learned a whole lot about the different ways that you know private carriers in particular are starting to pay drivers and they're almost the the test lab if you will for these hybrid arrangements of pay can you talk about why that is and what we're seeing kind of developing and evolving in that area yeah so um for for uh clarification for folks that are are kind enough to join us today we've got four higher fleets and we've got private fleets um you know four higher fleets being our traditional trucking companies and then we've got private fleets that are maybe manufacturing companies retail organizations they uh manufacturing companies they thrive in other industries and they happen to also own some trucks or lease some trucks anyway and employ truck drivers to do the work um private fleets have we've also been studying for 27 years and historically they've paid um more to a professional driver they increase pay more consistently year after year like uh most of us in other industries um they or job job type types and functions private fleets because they're serving their own internal needs the driver is going from you know plant to dc or dc to dc uh and and then maybe a for hire fleet takes it from dc to store so the the the private fleet driver just has historically had what we've promoted as being transparency in their pay and their schedule when a driver leaves with a private fleet they know when they're going to be home not the number of days they know the day the time they know the schedule it's all very predictable and that aligns then with their paycheck and and their salary so private fleets have also been very thorough in pay um i know we're going to talk about flsa later but um ultimately a private fleet typically doesn't um you know carve out overtime or extra work in fact they have some of the most thorough and complicated pay packages in the industry they pay a driver for every activity and so um private fleets have really kind of led the way with activity pay packages where a driver is incented to run more miles and they're paid by the mile when they are highly productive and then when they are um stopped at uh the dc if they are in the sleeper birth if they are loading if they're um you know moving uh freight etcetera i mean whatever the activity is it then reverts to either an hourly pay package or to a flat figure for that particular pay attribute they vary across the board lindsay with this being such a big issue uh for drivers is it something that that when we start to think about bringing up new drivers and getting them involved in the industry is this issue of pay i imagine it's got to come up at some point in in how we teach drivers about the industry and and having just you know frank discussions with them about pay yeah well pay they they say that gen z is not as concerned about pay they might be concerned about a few other things but interestingly you know we were just at the mid-american truck show we had 240 students come to the show to do a scavenger hunt one school system that had 35 students they we got them a classroom and they talked to some industry partners about careers and the big thing that they wanted to know is how much will i make so you know pay is important to young people they want to know how much they're going to make um but gen z some other things that are important to them are technology and we have a lot of technology in our trucks to offer so that's a good thing they want to make a difference in their career and know that what they're doing makes a difference and trucking is essential it keeps us our shelves stocked um they want to know what they're doing is helping the the country in terms of the environment and we often know that air that goes inside the trucks comes out cleaner than it went in so there's a lot of things that are important to gen z and money is one of those things they do want to make a good living and to be able to enjoy life with that income yeah i think they also want to know their career path though too um and so that's something that we've been promoting for a long time at nti and something that i i bring up in every conversation possible um you know gen z especially but not restricted to that generation they want um they want to know the money it's not necessarily number one value yes but they do want to know what does the career path look like and what will i make at each level and so to that companies have to better articulate not only the compensation plan like you get paid this particular you know nominal fee for this this particular attribute but rather what does the overall you know total benefit package look like what's the end result to you today in this stage of your career and tomorrow and the next day and the next we have to continue to map that out for folks i've always felt like the carriers that do this best are the ones that put an experienced driver in front of the new drivers that they're bringing in so that the experienced driver can give them like a behind-the-scenes type look at here's how it actually works so we've got a number of clients that do something like that put them put an experienced driver who's been there for 10 15 years in the orientation program and kind of walk them through these issues of pay here's how the pay works here's how the benefits work that type of thing yeah and i was curious lindsay do you get questions from uh these students that are related to how how am i being paid or how much am i gonna make so do they get into the details of am i being paid by the mile or anything like that do they know to ask those questions are they just concerned with the overall bottom line dollar right so more so the bottom line dollar until they get educated and seeing all of the different things out there yeah that makes sense did you want to tackle that question yeah clive was asking how about some who get a cdl after two so after february 7th so he's talking about the entry-level driver training rule that just went into effect kind of goes into what we're talking about which is you know we think about drivers as being a fairly a pretty heavily regulated group and now we're just adding more conditions on to them including you know if they're going to be a cdl driver they got to go out and get specific training now and that's adding to the cost of doing business essentially so uh i guess that kind of filters into the whole conversation yeah would you think that his question was kind of driving at in addition to this apprenticeship program are these drivers going to have to complete the eldt as well uh yeah probably so i mean the answer is yes so if if the driver if we have drivers that are going to participate in the apprenticeship program uh they're they're certainly going to have to complete the in the new entry-level driver training requirement in order to get their cdl to be able we would say that's a good thing right you know back to the turnover issue um all of the pay complications that exist out there they're even further complicated for new entrants whether they're 18 19 or 39 years old um you know inconsistent and incomplete training across the board has plagued our industry for decades and so um while you know lindsay and i kind of talk often about why didn't they put this in the eldt i thought they were going to and it really would have improved things but ultimately um you know having some standardization to the training only helps the rest of the industry kind of know what to expect but it also helps the new entrants that are joining um you know we also know that in terms of impacting turnover with new entrants we see huge turnover that kind of i don't know which direction the camera's going to be up on but you know from zero to 120 days you see a spike you know that kind of filters slowly down and it somewhat improves after 120 days but ultimately um you know historically new entrant roles are team requirements so they're over the road their irregular route and schedule remember all that transparency that we talked we're talking about being appealing um that typically hasn't existed for new entrants they've had unpredictable home time the jobs ultimately that are the hardest to fill um you know that's where new entrants tend to get put now in the last year and a half with such a a terrible shortage uh in terms of labor we see a lot of folks even private fleets starting training programs and they are offering local jobs they're hiring uh you know gen z um they are they are hiring uh you know folks that are experienced in training to to run a training program within their company that's unheard of i mean we used to look at their requirements as being the most elite of drivers but they realize that they have to start building a a new generation from within so whether that's warehouse to driver dock to driver um school to to driver school to warehouse to driver you know they are creating and articulating that career path in order to encourage new drivers in the industry yeah that's exactly right i know just in our conversations with our clients we're hearing a lot of clients who larger motor carriers who have traditionally had minimum qualification standards that say we only hire drivers that have two years worth of commercial driving experience now getting to a point where they're saying well we're kind of desperate for drivers so what you know can we can we deviate from those standards and the lawyer in us is all we're always a little hesitant to do that but at some point you've got you've got no option really yeah come on man you've gotten to that you know we you know why why do i serve on the board with with the next generation and trucking association my greatest passion is is that we um for all of us that have thrived in trucking that we can we can approach that um across you know the board and promote why trucking should be a first choice career it cannot be a first choice career when a minimum standard requirement is above 21 years old or at least two years of experience we cannot it just won't happen we're not going to change so um get the lawyer in you to start promoting trucking in your community in your high school at your technical schools within families you know i i'm you i'm sure you've heard i'm pregnant my kid has no choice but to be a trucker that's just that's the thing to do dynamic here right um you know we've got we've got all the stuff ready all the books we registered for about promoting trucking and and you know he's gonna know what's up um in the shaver family but but ultimately every trucking family we gotta get back to that you know when i recruited drivers 21 years ago they were a third generation driver second generation driver today um when i talk to drivers on the air i work for siriusxm on the road dog trucking radio channel they don't want to promote trucking to their kids because it's been so hard and that's changing we're evolving as an industry and um we ought to get lawyers and insurance companies and carriers and and fleets um and vendors like us all on board to to be a whole lot better at promoting why we love trucking right well it's not sustainable right because with an aging workforce and if everybody had a requirement that you got to have at least two years experience then then you have nowhere else to pick from at that point yeah i have a i have a slide in my deck um that's really popular and it's got the lead funnel right so if you picture that lead funnel the top and the widest part of the funnel is those inexperienced drivers and they outnumber um applicants and interests three to one um the problem is as you said a lack of of opportunities for them and it's growing it's getting better but it's still very competitive because we need trainers to train the new entrants um but as that lead funnel narrows you know a two-year driver is getting to a pretty narrow point and so um you know if if you've got a high number of companies that have that that is a minimum requirement think of all of the folks that are waiting to poach your driver at year two so here i'm i'm focused on um you know hiring and and recruiting you know to retain from hire to retire how can you do that when um there's this large pool waiting to to take you away you know at that that two years so um there's just so much that's not sustainable about the current model but but that is is one big factor in our in our opinion yeah i think we may have lost lindsey for a second but hopefully she'll get back on here but um one of the things so we know you talk with a lot of drivers on your xm show and through nti and one of the things i know you've heard a lot about is the volatility and unpredictability of driver pay from week to week week to week how big of a factor is that and what can be done about it it makes them weep i'm just kidding um you know it's it's really big um and it's it's a trigger for turnover i don't know if we got into that but um ultimately uh they they most the biggest complaints that i hear and that shapes what we research we make sure that the the attributes that we're tracking are the ones that are really driver sensitive why because if you're looking at data in order to recruit and retain you want to watch the factors that drivers really care about and pay is important and equipment is important and safety is crucial um but but you know shortening detention wait times communicating um you know paying for for the work that's done i get a lot of emails after the show asking about overtime and why you know why and how do we get away with not paying that um anything that that relates to unpaid unproductive time is a pain point for drivers and while our our workforce historically has kind of taken that as acceptable um you know we we've got an aging workforce in our baby boomers and the generations that come after them have very different expectations about pay about the value of their time about you know again their career and um and you know the how we perceive the value of their time is certainly something that they take into account when they're choosing a company but more importantly when they stay at the company yeah thanks for that um leah i had a quick question for you and i'd love to get lindsay's take on this as well let's see if lindsay's back lindsay are you back there's she she's back we've only got half of her face though here we go all right so i wanted to get both of your takes on this and so i've talked to a handful of people that in the industry that you know i respect that have the point of view that it's not necessarily that we really have a true driver shortage it's a churn it's a driver retention problem and i'm not saying that's valid but what would you say to that sentiment how would you respond to that that there's not really a driver shortage it's just a driver retention issue you want to pounce first or do you want me to [Laughter] sir well i you know i hear that over and over again and i'm really still forming my opinions on that um one of the things that i think and leah touched upon is that we we need people young and early on in our industry that are going to be good fits for our industry and that's why we try to identify good fits by using the job behaviors assessment that assesses whether or not the person has the the safe behaviors to make a good truck driver we can teach the skills um through the training but the assessment that we use to identify young students to invite them to take the training course it really does assess if they have those behavioral traits which in turn makes them more retained in the industry um so we're trying to get those young people that we feel like will be can be retained but then also show them the career path um they can own their own trucks and they want to be their own boss and so how can we show them the path of starting here and then you're going to end up there you'd be a good politician lindsay leah is there a driver shortage or no um you know the um i i wondered if this would come up and and what your position would be uh ultimately what i would share with you is that um we have less than a handful of fleets that tell us we are having an easy time hiring um and even when they claim that they've had an easier time when we unpack it um they've got 30 trucks that they need to fill and ultimately there's this dire need of a b c and d so um take that for for what you will um that that said every door that all four of us have have entered in any commercial business um in the last year has been desperate for workers every trucking company trailer that we pass on the road um or are you know are behind whatever says we're hiring drivers and blasts even their pay their offerings etc um private fleets are are advertising um private fleets actually have had to get a whole lot better at recruiting in the last few years than they ever have before and ultimately um when it comes down to it we cannot replace the exits that are occurring and so do we have a driver shortage absolutely um it's we've talked about the age issue in trucking for years at nti it's been it's been a a dominant slide in my deck for the seven years that that i've run the company and um it's always something that has to be part of our our review when we when we meet with a carrier but you know baby boomers were a very large percentage of our workforce before the pandemic the pandemic has complicated that there are what we call fixed driver supply constraints and there are ones that were exacerbated by the pandemic and and overall some of those exacerbated by the pandemic are now a fixed driver supply constraint so do we have a driver shortage absolutely and ultimately um it's not as simple as numbers to seat a truck it's just not and i there's a lot of economists that we know we're friends with we we listen to and see their their charts on social media etc you can argue that we have enough people to do the job but now the conversation shifts to what role they're in what their expectations are what the type of work it is and now the churn conversation the age issue the health issue health issue is mage um you know the training the the lack of first uh choice career options the more that those folks age out where out of the job we are losing you know what was 26 of our workforce and so that's a serious problem that is not going anywhere well the other thing i think that's interesting that goes into that same debate is if you look at the numbers from the drug and alcohol clearinghouse of the number of drivers that are currently disqualified from operating a commercial motor vehicle because of a drug and alcohol uh violation it's about 80 000 which just so happens to be the same number that the ata estimates that were short on drivers um so you know that's another factor though and the tiny percentage of those drivers with those violations that have actually initiated the sap process it's a very very small number so you know it looks like those folks are leaving the industry um unfortunately a point that doesn't come up enough at you know augmenting that last one is then the companies that could potentially take them back um or take them you know after even after going through a sap program it is truly not that many um so you know you talk about an ex about experience as a requirement i frankly um you know i don't mean to be crass but i don't even understand why we talk about the failure to rejoin the industry when there's so few companies that even could or would take a driver that had failed um a pre-employment or a uh you know a drug and alcohol i i totally agree with that and we've had discussions about that in the past on shows where you know we've encouraged management that that's open to having that conversation to actually have that conversation in advance so that way they have some kind of way to uniformly approach those drivers when they get in front of them because if you are desperate for drivers and a driver has completed the regulatory requirements to rejoin the workforce you're just going to stonewall all of them no questions asked or are you developing a process on how to do that of course the lawyer brain of both of ours is kind of going off right now you know you qualify a driver that's gone through the sap process and you know has had issues with alcohol or substances in the past you kind of have to have a written process to do that so yeah and and certainly we see the same thing carriers have those policies that say we're not going to hire any driver that's had a drug and alcohol violation in the past some of that i suspect is driven by insurance which is a whole number a whole other conversation and we kind of had that before before our show today but yeah it's definitely something carriers need to take a closer look at rather than just automatically throwing that in their policy and leaving it there there's a lot of complications that come after even looking at the policy carriers tell me even if they have adjusted the policy and they will take that driver back or take someone who has failed um the process of requalifying and what's required in that first year to get to like show up for random testing and etc it's very location exclusive and complicated for the nature of the job um you know there's just a lot of other factors and then when it comes to the carriers themselves if the driver failed the test they typically see that driver exit all together even if they would work with her and requalify her and put her back in the truck they it's ghosted you know the the opportunity is gone so it's really this is a it's an issue that's going to evolve but it's frankly um there's just too few companies that even could or would work with with that type of violation so what else do you all see carriers doing to try and kind of ease this pain uh for their drivers and attract new ones we we here talk about you know sign-on bonuses and safety bonuses and that type of thing can you give us a sense of what kind of creative things fleets are trying to do to to get more drivers to come through the door yeah i mean we track we track over 100 different attributes of pay not only in over 600 locations and by trailer type and job description but then it goes into that complicated pay package right so um i mean sign on bonuses and safety bonuses are just the beginning if you go beyond um those as being frankly kind of an expectation today um of course there's guaranteed pay and um you know salary pay uh hybrid activity pay packages look at things like easy to understand benefits legal plans you know so the driver has support if there is an issue ahead of time rather than dealing with it after but more trendy in the last year has been more generous um passenger and pet policies um those are really at the forefront um you know frankly when i worked at a carrier pet policies were just horrifying um the damage to equipment um you know i still i look back and when i see how much they're thriving now i just wonder about you know the equipment but but that said we it's not only a comfort and and um and you know uh you know having your pal in the truck kind of thing it's also a security issue for women we find that women um really love having their pet with them as a security blanket as well so um pet policies have really been thriving and so have uh flexing on passenger policies whether we still see companies implementing them for the first time which shocks me but also adjusting the age to allow for even younger um or multiple passengers in the truck um pet insurance like health insurance for your dog um you know that's a big deal i have that but only because we have a bulldog that has eaten a ton of baby pacifiers and has had surgery like three times to extract the baby i mean you start to have bills and you think i might need a policy for that right um so i can't believe it but pet insurance is new um college tuition has been new um in a variety of different ways any kind of support for secondary education not only for the driver but also for um you know sometimes even two dependents um transition bonuses rather than sign on bonuses i mean these are just a few but ultimately kind of how can we look at a driver you know if we say trucking is a lifestyle then um i think companies are looking at what really impacts a driver holistically not just in the truck or in the standard of the the work paycheck and the health insurance package um so if that's you know family leave you know medical leave prenatal care you know maternity leave and maternity um job uh you know accommodations for a woman so that she's not completely exiting the industry um obviously i could go on but you get it we're we're evolving to um to kind of put a little spice into what we're offering yeah and i think for the next generation it's about companies need to be engaged in their local school system they need to do the touch of truck events they need one thing we're putting together is this powerpoint career presentation all about careers in the trucking industry and we hope to be able to unveil that in the fall it's going to be awesome interactive it's going to engage young people so they'll think wow i think i might want to become a truck driver or i might want to become a diesel technician and we are going to put that pet in there in photos because they they do want to bring their pets with them so it's engaging the next generation it's having your drivers maybe post on tick tock or post on instagram about their job a day in the life so we have to get these young people engaged and they're on social media so how can you create a program so you're reaching the next generation with your company and your brand through social media yeah and speaking so so amazing how much we need to promote more in our community and i i totally as you know making trucking a first choice career it starts in the family and with our own people in our community etc so um that should be listed as a benefit lindsay i love that point yeah i wanted to ask lindsay actually um could you kind of walk me through any given week of outreach activities that next gen kind of engages in and then also for anyone that wants to tap into what nextgen is doing and help or actually plug next-gen into their community how can they get involved with that yeah so um we are meeting with schools daily for instance i had a meeting with a school from texas earlier today about starting a cdl program and it's brainstorming what works in that community it's meeting with community colleges and the high school and so we do that daily talk to schools talk to them about trucking programs um and what they can do and then also talk to them about you know how we can promote trucking as a career by using this presentation that we're gonna have most of the time it's in eighth grade when they take career classes and learn about different careers out there and so we encourage the industry to get partnered with their local school and go teach about the trucking industry and maybe bring some trucks with you because that's going to get young people excited um and we've got to get more young people excited about it um so we are trying to raise awareness that way trying to raise awareness through social media we are also trying to get young people to come to our website um and explain about careers in trucking and what they can expect to make what they can't expect to do um so anything in terms of reaching the next generation for tracking careers we know not everybody's going to go to college and today each student that graduates from college has 30 to 50 000 of student loan debt and gen z is questioning whether or not that is the pathway they want to take we're going to see that more and more every day and so we have to provide them other outlets besides the college route now maybe they want to eventually go to college but why can't they go to college while becoming a truck driver and while driving and paying their way through college so we need to start thinking outside the box and engaging young people engaging educators and really starting to to work within our communities where we hire where we hire people so that's probably a good segue into kind of the apprenticeship program the other topic we wanted to kind of hit on and i know we've kind of already hit on it a little bit but can you both give us a sense of what is the apprenticeship program i know we've only got a little bit of time left and i know we could spend an hour talking about the apprenticeship program but just give us a sense of what it's going to be at the start and and how you all uh especially next-gen uh envision kind of participating in that yeah so um think of the safe driver apprenticeship pilot program is twofold one is through the fmcsa and the other is through the department of labor so you need to have a department of labor apprenticeship program to get into the fmcsa pilot program now you can use a company like the next generation and trucking association you can use the american trucking association tca just came out with a with an apprenticeship program or you can have your own apprenticeship program and so we're all just trying to work through the department of labor to have more apprenticeships to happen and they are a good thing they help with retention um it is identifying and and highlighting and celebrating people who go through apprenticeships and reaching steps and there it's a crazy statistic that i think 89 of people that have gone through an apprenticeship program after nine months are still with that same company so you should consider an apprenticeship program it's competency based and if you use um an intermediary like we do like fast port or if you go through us um it's it's a simple process so they take the hard work out of it the other part is through the fmcsa and so the fmcsa has two probationary periods for that 18 to 20 year old driver and the first one is 120 hours and they have to be driving for 80 hours of that and the rest they'll have to be on duty and then they have competencies within that that they have to master um and then the second probationary period is the same um it's 288 hours that time and they have other competencies within that that they have to master all while mastering the department of labor apprenticeship competencies so they go hand in hand um and they work together um and they it's supposed to open up in may through the fmcsa so if you want to apply for it um be on the lookout for may and i'm sure lots of people will be posting that that it's open if that's something that you're looking to do and it's a pilot program right at the start so it's going to be limited participation 3000 spots and it's three years and really the point is to try to get some data to see are these young people safe and can we trust them to drive over state lines leah it has nti are you all gonna do any kind of data gathering with the apprenticeship program do you have any plans in store for for kind of studying that we'll ask the fleets that participate if they're if they are participating and how many they have one of the questions that i had asked lindsay a couple weeks ago was you know 3000 spots in this environment you'd think that would go really quickly um you know how how are we going to track that or or know exactly um you know like does does you know number three fleet in the nation get 60 spots because they're huge or do they get one one spot you know i did you do you know lin's did you ever find out if if it's allocated in any way i don't that is a good question yeah we'll just have to monitor the volume you know when we survey um yeah the fmcsa's notice gives a little bit of info on that i think it says that it's 3 000 spots and they're anticipating approving approximately a thousand carriers to fill those 3 000 spots so but they they recognize in the notice that that number is going to go up and down as as some of the apprentices leave the the program then we obviously got to backfill that so it'll be interesting to see sure all right well we're kind of running out of time here again uh we really appreciate you both joining us wanted to both give you a chance to kind of wrap things up here and let us know what you got going on how folks can find you where they can find out more information so leah you want to start sure it's uh our website is driverwages.com social is at nti driver wages um i'm on linkedin at libby shaver and um social for serious with my driver audience is at least shaver siriusxm you can catch me on sirius on the first thursday of every month for payday until i go on maternity leave for a brief moment um but uh i'm pretty i'm pretty uh engaged and i would i would hope if we're not connected that you take this as an opportunity to get connected excellent lindsey yeah and you can reach us on our website nextgentrucking.org you can also connect with me on linkedin or on all of the social media pages and we are at nextgen truckers um so come and find us send me an email i'd love to connect with you my emails lindsay at nextgentrucking.org and we are just really excited about what we're doing and there's a good chance that we've met with a school in your area and we'd love to get you connected so um message me and let's start really reaching the next generation and letting them know about these great jobs that we have to offer and i have to add a plug for that you know i've had lindsay on siriusxm with me several times and the driver interest in mentoring and engaging with the next generation in advocating for trucking on their company's behalf is very high so just like we talk about being in the school and promoting to your employees families in the community what mom and dad do at the trucking company whether they're a truck driver or working in dispatch or hr recruiting whatever it is you know we want to be promoting that your drivers do want to be your best ambassadors not just to recruit more drivers but also to coach and lead and encourage the next generation so joining nextgen is a really good retention opportunity as well to um solicit mentorship within your own organization which hopefully you have some sort of program already but um tagging that program for the next generation in your communities is also a great opportunity to retain your drivers long term definitely hey well thanks again so much to both of you thanks for everything that you're doing for the industry we really appreciate your insight on these topics always great to hear from you so thanks again thank you thank you all right so wrapping things up here thanks everybody for joining us uh you know and next gen we're really excited to partner with them as i said at the start truck safe partnering with them one of the things that we're offering to next-gen members is a compliance package for carriers that are interested in participating in the apprenticeship program we've developed a bunch of policy related documents reporting documents that you'll need in order to participate in that program so check that out if you're if you're a member of nextgen you get access to that compliance package and then the other thing we're excited to uh to be raising some funds for nextgen uh trucking through our uh fleet compliance summit that we mentioned at the start we will be uh doing a fundraiser for them so so be sure to check that out as well uh lastly wanted to mention one other one other thing that we've got coming up here uh next month in fact april 14th we have uh we're going to put on a free webinar where um jared and i are going to be talking about the mechanics of a tot audit how dot audits work what fleets need to know to uh to prepare for one or uh you know just have your your things in order in case you ever get that knock at the door so um visit our website trucksafeconsulting.com if you have any interest in attending that it's going to be april 14th at 2 p.m eastern time you can get the details on our website you can register there why did you make me a giant in that sorry that's just how it turned out no we got a lot of things going on excited about that webinar it's going to be a great one talking about audits and how to survive an audit and the things that you need to know do's and don'ts about an audit very exciting and then the fleet compliance summit like brandon said august 11th and 12th we're very excited about that if you're interested in any of our courses we also offer courses on uh driver training safety manager trainings reasonable suspicions supervisor trainings getting ready to roll out a new hazmat training so check out our website we've got a lot of trainings there and let us know if you have any questions for us if you have topic ideas that you want to pitch to us we'd love to see those so you can send us an email or drop a message to us yeah topic or guest ideas if you if you know anybody that you want to see us talk with feel free to to send us their names and yeah we'll get them on so other than that thanks everybody for joining us and we'll uh we'll see you next time thanks you

Event Completed

Thursday, March 31, 2022 at 2:56 PM EDT

Watch on YouTube