Episode Summary
In this special episode of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman of Trucksafe Consulting breaks down breaking news from the FMCSA regarding proposed changes to the Safety Measurement System (SMS), commonly known as CSA scores. The SMS, which has remained largely unchanged since its implementation in 2010, is the primary tool the FMCSA uses to prioritize motor carriers for enforcement. Wiseman explains that these changes stem from a 2017 National Academy of Sciences study commissioned by Congress, which recommended improvements to the system. Notably, the FMCSA has declined to adopt the study's recommendation of an Item Response Theory (IRT) model, opting instead to improve the existing framework.
Wiseman walks through five significant proposed changes to the SMS. First, the seven existing "BASICS" will be reorganized into "safety categories," with the Drug and Alcohol category merged into Unsafe Driving, and the Vehicle Maintenance category split into two separate categories — general Vehicle Maintenance and Vehicle Maintenance Driver Observed. Second, the 959+ roadside violations will be consolidated into 116 violation groups, meaning carriers will no longer be penalized multiple times for violations describing the same underlying safety issue. Third, the current one-to-ten severity weight scale will be replaced with a simplified two-value scale, where violations are assigned either a one or a two based on whether they involve an out-of-service or driver-disqualifying violation.
The fourth proposed change involves raising intervention thresholds in the Driver Fitness and Hazmat Compliance categories, effectively narrowing the FMCSA's enforcement focus in those areas to the highest-risk carriers. Wiseman notes this is supported by data showing a weaker correlation between those categories and actual crash risk. The fifth change introduces proportionate percentiles, replacing the current safety event group structure to prevent dramatic score swings when carriers move between groups due to minor changes in inspection data. Additionally, carriers with no violations in a safety category within the last 12 months will no longer be assigned a percentile score in that category, rewarding fleets that have demonstrably improved their compliance.
For fleet safety professionals, Wiseman recommends logging into the FMCSA's new SMS preview website to see how their scores would look under the proposed methodology and to compare that to their current performance. He also encourages stakeholders to submit comments to the FMCSA docket before the mid-May deadline. While characterizing the changes as generally moving in the right direction, Wiseman cautions that implementation is likely at least six months away and that the true impact will only become clear once real-world data is applied to the new model.
Wiseman closes with a candid concern that these changes may be setting the stage for the FMCSA to once again attempt to tie a carrier's safety rating directly to SMS scores — a proposal that was previously withdrawn following significant criticism. He argues that before any such step is taken, the agency must address serious due process deficiencies in the existing DataQ appeals system, which currently allows the same law enforcement agencies that issue violations to adjudicate challenges to those violations. Until carriers have access to a more independent and robust appeals process, Wiseman warns that linking safety ratings to SMS data risks unjustly threatening the operating authority of carriers based on potentially erroneous roadside inspection data.