Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Special Episode: SMS Changes

Friday, February 17, 2023 at 1:55 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Special Episode: SMS Changes

About This Event

In this special edition of Trucksafe LIVE!, transportation attorney and Trucksafe President Brandon Wiseman breaks down breaking news from the FMCSA concerning proposed changes to its Safety Measurement System (SMS) and the way carriers are prioritized for enforcement.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In this special episode of Trucksafe LIVE!, host Brandon Wiseman of Trucksafe Consulting breaks down breaking news from the FMCSA regarding proposed changes to the Safety Measurement System (SMS), commonly known as CSA scores. The SMS, which has remained largely unchanged since its implementation in 2010, is the primary tool the FMCSA uses to prioritize motor carriers for enforcement. Wiseman explains that these changes stem from a 2017 National Academy of Sciences study commissioned by Congress, which recommended improvements to the system. Notably, the FMCSA has declined to adopt the study's recommendation of an Item Response Theory (IRT) model, opting instead to improve the existing framework. Wiseman walks through five significant proposed changes to the SMS. First, the seven existing "BASICS" will be reorganized into "safety categories," with the Drug and Alcohol category merged into Unsafe Driving, and the Vehicle Maintenance category split into two separate categories — general Vehicle Maintenance and Vehicle Maintenance Driver Observed. Second, the 959+ roadside violations will be consolidated into 116 violation groups, meaning carriers will no longer be penalized multiple times for violations describing the same underlying safety issue. Third, the current one-to-ten severity weight scale will be replaced with a simplified two-value scale, where violations are assigned either a one or a two based on whether they involve an out-of-service or driver-disqualifying violation. The fourth proposed change involves raising intervention thresholds in the Driver Fitness and Hazmat Compliance categories, effectively narrowing the FMCSA's enforcement focus in those areas to the highest-risk carriers. Wiseman notes this is supported by data showing a weaker correlation between those categories and actual crash risk. The fifth change introduces proportionate percentiles, replacing the current safety event group structure to prevent dramatic score swings when carriers move between groups due to minor changes in inspection data. Additionally, carriers with no violations in a safety category within the last 12 months will no longer be assigned a percentile score in that category, rewarding fleets that have demonstrably improved their compliance. For fleet safety professionals, Wiseman recommends logging into the FMCSA's new SMS preview website to see how their scores would look under the proposed methodology and to compare that to their current performance. He also encourages stakeholders to submit comments to the FMCSA docket before the mid-May deadline. While characterizing the changes as generally moving in the right direction, Wiseman cautions that implementation is likely at least six months away and that the true impact will only become clear once real-world data is applied to the new model. Wiseman closes with a candid concern that these changes may be setting the stage for the FMCSA to once again attempt to tie a carrier's safety rating directly to SMS scores — a proposal that was previously withdrawn following significant criticism. He argues that before any such step is taken, the agency must address serious due process deficiencies in the existing DataQ appeals system, which currently allows the same law enforcement agencies that issue violations to adjudicate challenges to those violations. Until carriers have access to a more independent and robust appeals process, Wiseman warns that linking safety ratings to SMS data risks unjustly threatening the operating authority of carriers based on potentially erroneous roadside inspection data.

Full Transcript

foreign thank you foreign foreign thank you all right thank you foreign foreign foreign log Rock builds technology tools to help trucking companies stay compliant with federal and state regulations log rock is easier we connect to multiple systems like your FMCSA account and ELD so you only have to use one system log rock is faster we automate tedious tasks so you can use your time more effectively log rock is smarter we notify you of issues like expiring or missing documents before they happen so you can be proactive rather than reactive setup is easy and most of our customers are online shortly after signing up request a demo now at logrock.com all right foreign hey everyone welcome to a special episode of truck safe live the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation I'm Brandon truck safe and Childress law excited to be here with you today like I said a special episode talking about some breaking news that came from the FMCSA earlier this week um regarding their SMS safety measurement system better known as CSA scores and so wanted to spend some time breaking that down and kind of give folks my thoughts on it for what it's worth probably nothing um uh based on what I've read about these changes so far um didn't have a whole lot of notice that this was going to be coming down the pike we knew you know every year the FMCSA comes out with its regulatory agendo kind of what it's planning in the future and this was not on it we knew that they were contemplating some potential changes to their safety Fitness determined patients their safety ratings and we expect to see that sometime later this year in March or so but didn't really have any notice that this was coming along we knew over the last several years that FMCSA was directed by Congress to start to work on revisions to the SMS but we just at least I didn't have any heads up that this was happening so it is what it is we have it now we have a notice from the FMCSA about its what it is proposing changing about that system and so wanted to spend some time walking through that there's a lot to it and so we will just kind of walk through I don't have anything formally planned for this for this video today so my plan is just to walk through the fmcsa's website that it has set up talking about these changes kind of walk through them step by step there's five big changes what I would consider to be fairly significant changes that we walk through and that will be how we go about this uh this episode of truck safe life if you're here with us um say hey in the comments we'd love to know who's here with us and then as we go along certainly would love to hear your thoughts on these potential changes and how they are likely to impact fleets whether it's your Fleet or some fleet that you would work with I'm interested in hearing your thoughts before we do that before we get to the topic of today just a couple of things I want to mention um if you are not part of the truck safe compliance Network I would encourage you to join it trucksafenetwork.com is where you'll find more information we also have an iPhone and an Android app that you can download for free on the App Store or the Google Play store and get access to all of our DOT compliance content that we are regularly publishing not only trucksafe live the podcast but also our in-depth dot articles and all of our video content that we are publishing but more than that the network is meant as a space for safety professionals to gather together and learn from one another ask questions uh that type of thing it's a forum for those folks to get together and learn about all of these important topics that um that help to keep our roadways safe so like I said join the network if you're if you're not already part of it yesterday we did a network exclusive webinar where we covered the top hours of service related pitfalls that are that are affecting fleets and how to get control of some of those issues and help minimize your exposure both to dot regulatory enforcement but more importantly the highway accident litigation so those webinars are just a benefit of joining the network free to drawing completely free to join and all of that content is free so check it out if you haven't already the last thing I'll mention is our Fleet compliance boot camp this is really excited about this it's coming up here it'll be here sooner uh um sooner than later it'll be April 19th through 20th it's going to be in Indianapolis uh we're going to try and do these twice a year these are in-person conferences where we are going to spend two days diving deep into DOT regulations dot safety regulations and how fleets can better manage their compliance programs in a more effectively manage them and build out you know Cutting Edge safety programs so that's what we're going to do it's going to be a small group of us we're limiting it to 25 we've already we just opened up registration not too long ago we're already halfway full so if you're interested in joining us check it out over at trucksafebootcamp.com we would love to have you there with us like I said we're going to try and do those twice a year so this one is April 19th and 20th in Indianapolis trucksafebootcamp.com if you are interested all right that wraps it up for um for the other things going on let's talk about the the revisions to safety measurement system that's why you're all here let's get into it so we've posted a pretty detailed article on the changes on our website um so if you want to read up on this after the discussion today feel free to head over to trucksafe.com you'll see it in our list of articles uh where we break it all down essentially just some quick background here what what is it that we're talking about um so the safety measurement system like I said is is sometimes better known as CSA but CSA is actually the broader program that encompasses not only the safety measurement system but also other enforcement tools that the FMCSA uses to prioritize motor carriers for enforcement including things like safety ratings and roadside inspections and stuff like that SMS is the scoring system within the broader CSA program and it has been in effect in largely unchanged since CSA was first implemented in 2010 the FMCSA implemented it back then at the direction of the U.S Congress as a way to priorit better prioritize regulated motor carriers for enforcement I've said this many times before the reason we have this prioritization system in place is because the FMCSA is a fairly small agency relatively speaking even compared to other agencies that fall under the umbrella of the federal or the United States Dot and so it just doesn't have the reach that it needs to effectively keep keep tabs of the 700 000 Plus Motor carriers that fall under its jurisdiction so it has to prioritize the most high risk carriers for enforcement so that we can keep them off the roadways and and that way we can work our way down with the highest risk carriers first and so SMS has become the primary way that the FMCSA does that it is a scoring system it it brings in violation data for all regulated motor carriers primarily from roadside inspections so your trucks are out there your drivers are out there they get stopped for roadside inspection by FMCSA state law enforcement Partners violations get you get written up for violations all of those violations filter into the federal database and that then lands on your SMS scores your CSA scores you are currently scored in seven categories um known as the basics and we'll get into exactly how that's changing here soon but that's kind of the the system in a nutshell it is scoring you in seven categories you're being scored against similarly situated motor carriers what does that mean it means that carriers that are incurring similar numbers of inspections with violations in each of those seven categories you're being scored against them it's a it's a one to a hundred percentile scale so um that is the system that we're talking about that SMS system like I said it has remained largely unchanged for the past 10 years or so um there have been some minor changes here and there but what we have seen over the years is a lot of criticism about the SMS system for a variety of reasons a lot of legitimate reasons I have complained about a lot of the problems over the years just as loud as anybody else and so what that ended up doing is uh it resulted in the U.S Congress stepping in back in 2015 or 16 somewhere around there U.S Congress steps in and directs the FMCSA to commission and independent study of the SMS platform and then to um to implement whatever recommendations that that independent body made about the SMS platform and so we saw that happen in 2017 the National Academy of Sciences came in did a comprehensive study of the safety measurement system issued a detailed report about uh its findings and recommendations and since that time since 2017 we have kind of been in limbo according to Congress FMCSA is supposed to be implementing those recommendations and it will ultimately be up to Congress whether it is satisfied with fncsa's efforts to implement those recommendations so that's where we're at we've been waiting since 2017 for the FMCSA to implement the changes that the National Academy of Sciences had recommended now importantly and we mentioned this here in the article the big finding from the National Academy of Sciences and I think this is why we haven't seen we haven't seen anything sooner than we are now is here here was the finding from the National Academy of Sciences about SMS that the system is structured in a reasonable way and its method of identifying motor carriers for alert status is defensible I think the FMCSA took comfort in that it was essentially kind of justifying their system despite the criticisms that we've had about the system over the years now they went on to go ahead and make certain recommendations namely that the FMCSA should consider moving to a different statistical model for the way that it handles violation data so it had recommended the National Academy of Sciences had recommended that the FMCSA consider what's called an item response Theory IRT model for purposes of handling the data I won't lie and say that I know much about the IRT model I've had Experts of that model try and explain it to me numerous times and I've sat through those discussions and I I don't feel like I can uh can explain it to you all any better than I did when I before I had those discussions it's a very complex model um but suffice it to say that was the Nas's recommendation to FMCSA you should consider that model it's a model that's used in other Industries as I understand it a lot of standardized tests testing platforms use that model and there are some other Industries so that's why they recommended it all that's to say is this is the first takeaway from fmcsa's notices notice earlier this week is that they are declining to adopt an IRT model despite the National Academy of Sciences recommendation that they do so they say in their notice that they had a they they tested the an IRT model they said they gathered together experts on that model they tested it out and here was their conclusion you can see it here as a result FMCSA has concluded that IRT modeling does not perform well for the agency's use in identifying motor carriers for safety interventions and therefore does not improve overall safety and so they are declining to move over to an IRT model which essentially would have kind of completely revamped SMS as we know it as I understand it would it would have not looked anything like it does currently had they adopted some kind of an IRT model but apparently we don't have to worry about them because they are not adopting an IRT model they went on to list their five main concerns about the model um and I'm not going to go through them all here but essentially it's kind of what I just said IRT modeling is not readably understandable by most stakeholders or the public in other words it's just confusing as hell and so we're not going to use the IRT model so that's what you need to know about that we are not moving to an IRT model according to FMCSA so what are we doing instead well we are uh we are according to the agency going to continue to improve the existing SMS system so in other words we are not going to get an entirely new system we are just going to improve upon the existing system that we have and that is where we come to the changes that they are proposing like I said earlier from my perspective here it's five main revisions to the existing SMS as we know it so let's start to walk through those I think the best way to do that is by looking at this new website that the FMCSA has set up if you go to that to our article on this topic on our website at trucksafe.com it has a link to the fmcsa's website it's essentially a preview website of what the system uh once these changes are implemented is going to look like and it does a pretty good job of getting in depth about these changes and so that's what we're going to spend our time looking at today as noted in the FMCSA docket where they they are putting all of the materials about these changes they have very detailed documentation about this in the docket if you're interested in diving even deeper we're not going to have time to get through all of it today but just know that if you want to really dig into how the calculations are changing and the methodology that they're that they're moving to those documentation or that documentation is available to you including a list of all of the violations that we're going to be talking about today that are that are going to be changing a little bit in the new in the new methodology so that's all available there but this is a look at the fmcsa's preview website for the changes that are in store for SMS and I should take a step back and say when uh or at least hit on when do we expect to see these changes it's hard telling we know that it's not going to be within the next few months because the FMCSA in its notice said that it is accepting comments from the public on these proposed changes uh up through May 15th I think and so we're not going to see this take effect at least until then but then even after they that comment period has expired presumably the agency is going to do what it normally does in a traditional rule making and it's going to review those comments and figure out whether it needs to make any revisions based on those comments and then at some point after that is when we would see them roll out the changes so if I had a crystal ball which I don't but I am not anticipating seeing any kind of changes to the existing SMS system probably for the next five or six months would be my guess if not longer but that's kind of what what to expect at least from my perspective I will mention that this is not a traditional rule making normally when an agency like the FMCSA a federal agency is is thinking about making changes to its existing rules it has to go through this notice and comment period where it it publishes a note notice of proposed rulemaking it then opens that up to the public to weigh in with comments and then they they have a regulatory obligation or a legal obligation to then review those comments and then eventually publish a final rule that's not the process that they're really following here um I haven't done an independent analysis to know whether they should be following that procedure but the notice that they issued is not a notice of proposed rulemaking it's not an nprm as we would as we're used to seeing when they propose new rules like when they propose the ELD rule that was done through the traditional rule making process an nprm Etc here we just have a notice where the agency is saying hey we're making these changes and presumably their rationale for doing it that way rather than formal rule making is that hey we are just responding to what Congress told us to do we are not initiating these changes on our own accord and so it doesn't have to go through the regulatory process to do that I assume that's the rationale I am not their lawyer so who knows um okay so let's walk through what these uh what these significant changes will be if they end up looking like they are proposed right now so here they are if you navigate to the fmcsa's website preview website you'll see that they've got the main ones listed out here they've got nine of them I think about five of them are the ones that are the the most significant and we'll start here with reorganized Basics so as I said earlier under the current SMS methodology we have seven Basics these are the behavior analysis and safety Improvement categories first up first thing to know is that we are changing the name of that we no longer have to remember what Basics stands for we're getting rid of Basics and we are moving to calling them just safety categories which I think is a welcome change um I think we've got too many acronyms the way it is so we're going to call these safety categories now in terms of the actual categories themselves like I said we have seven of them currently what are the seven currently we've got unsafe driving we've got driver Fitness hours of service vehicle maintenance crash indicator drug and alcohol and which one did I leave out or did I list seven I don't know I forgot that's basically it there may be one more that I missed there but those are the seven that we have currently we are still going to have seven uh even despite these changes but the what the 7R is changing a little bit and how are they changing well first and foremost that drug and alcohol basic that we have now is going away entirely oh yeah uh thank you somebody says Hazmat is the one I missed thanks for that uh so those are the seven um the one that's going away is the uh drug and alcohol basic and why is that going away here's why it's going away of all of the basics drug and alcohol violations are the one with at least according to the FMCSA the least amount of uh violation activity that is in the system why is that because law enforcement is not discovering a ton of drug and alcohol violations while drivers are operating commercial Motor Vehicles those may be pretty common in a driver's personal vehicles but it turns out they're not all that common when it comes to drivers operating commercial Motor Vehicles so what that means practically is we just don't have a ton of violations that are popping up in that category so what the FMCSA is proposing to do is to move that category combine it with the unsafe driving category so now it will be subsumed by the unsafe driving category and why is that because the underlying conduct that we're concerned with in the drug and alcohol category to begin with is the the unsafe operation that comes because of intoxicated drivers and so we can put that in unsafe driving it's an unsafe driving activity so now those violations are just going to be shown in the unsafe driving category so that's the first big change so you know that takes us down to six safety categories where's the seventh one if we're going to remain with seven the new category is going to come about by splitting out the existing vehicle maintenance basic into two separate categories we are taking that one basic and splitting it out into two you can see here on the fmcsa's website they've got them listed here we will be moving to two vehicle maintenance Basics safety categories one called vehicle maintenance as it is today and then one called vehicle maintenance driver observed why are we doing that FMCSA says that vile the vehicle maintenance basic currently is the biggest basic of them all it is the one that is capturing the most data these are things like you know brake violations light lighting violations Tire violations everything that could go wrong with the commercial motor vehicle itself those violations are being filtered into the vehicle maintenance category and it turns out that that's the biggest one it's got the most data and so what that means according to the agency is that it makes it difficult for motor carriers who have a lot of vehicle maintenance violations a lot of motor carriers have a lot of vehicle maintenance violations to really get their arms around what is the problem what what are the systemic problems that are causing us to fail in that basic and so fmcsa's hope as I understand it is to split these out uh these these different types of vehicle maintenance violations into two categories so we can get a better picture of exactly what where things are going wrong from a vehicle maintenance standpoint and so you could see that that vehicle maintenance driver observed will be the new category essentially that is going to be capturing um vehicle maintenance violations that could have or should have been discovered by a commercial driver had he or she done a thorough pre or post-trip inspection as the regulations require of them uh as opposed to the other maintenance violations which will continue to be just in the general vehicle maintenance category that could not have been discovered by the commercial driver in a pre-trip or post-trip inspection in other words they are more latent vehicle maintenance issues that are essentially not the driver's fault that's what we're breaking this down into we're breaking the vehicle maintenance category into could this have been the driver's Fault by not discovering it or is it something that the driver couldn't have discovered despite him or her doing a thorough pre-trip inspection that way we know that if we are having a problem with the driver observed category that the fix is probably to better educate our drivers and hold them accountable to conducting more thorough pre and post trip inspections whereas if we are having problems in the general maintenance category then it says more about the actual the the mechanics of our truck rather than the driver behavior of not doing a thorough inspection so that's it in a nutshell we are breaking vehicle maintenance the safety category into two just general vehicle maintenance and then vehicle maintenance driver observed uh the last thing I'll mention about the reorganization of the basics into these new safety categories um is the moving of certain out of service violations So currently under the current SMS if your driver essentially jumps an out of service order which is to say that your your truck or your driver has been placed out of service for a serious safety violation yet that truck has continued it continues to operate despite that order being in place or that driver continues to operate despite that out of service order being in place that's called jumping and out of service order right now there are several jumping and out of service order types of violations that are spread across the seven different Basics so for example if you have a driver who is put out of service for an hours of service violation and then he or she jumps that VI or that order and continues to operate in flying in the face of that out of service order that will now be written up as a separate violation jumping in out of service order but it will impact your hours of service basic because it's really that the service order was related to out of service or hours of service sorry and so that's how it is under the current system but what the FMCSA is saying with its changes is that really the underlying conduct that we're concerned with with drivers jumping out of service orders is more of an unsafe driving concern so what we're going to do is anytime there's been a jumped out of service order that subsequent violation for jumping the order is now going to put in be put in the unsafe driving category rather than spread out across all of the other Basics so relatively minor change there but that that just means you're going to have more potentially more violations in the unsafe driving category whereas they would have previously been spread across all of your Basics but hopefully you're not having many drivers or trucks jumping they're out of service order that's bad news if you've got that going on all right so that's the first big change let's talk about the second one which is a reorganization of roadside violations this is a fairly significant change here FMCSA under the current safety measurement system methodology there are 959 separate violation types that a driver could be written up for during a roadside inspection 959 possible violations that they could incur during a roadside inspection and those 959 violations are set out in the SMS methodology and then they are tied to a one of those seven Basics that we have currently what the FMCSA is proposing is to reorganize those violations we're still going to have all of them 959 in fact I think they're adding 14 more violations so we're going to have 960 some whatever the number happens to be roadside violations where your drivers can get still get cited for them roadside but what we're going to do is we're going to console validate them down into 116 violation groups and what does that mean it means that even though you may have multiple violations on written up on a roadside inspection report we're going to group violations that are similar to one another down into 116 violation groups and so let's just read here what that means while any of the 959 violations can still be cited during an inspection for prioritization purposes in other words for scoring purposes under SMS violations that identify the same or similar underlying safety issues would be grouped together if a motor carrier receives more than one of the violations in a violation group during a single inspection the new methodology would treat that set of violations as a single violation when calculating the carrier's measure in that safety category they then go on to list this example which is an hours of service compliance violation if your driver is pulled over for a roadside inspection and they are in violation of several hours of service rules 14-hour violation 11 hour violation 30 minute rest break and a 70 hour violation you know those will continue to be written up as four violations on the roadside inspection report under the current system that would hit you four times in your hours of service basic but under the pose changes here those would all be grouped together or some of them would be grouped together as very similar types of violations and therefore you would not be hit for them more than once when they are in the same group with one another because the the underlying conduct that we want to punish is the same for those similar violations so it says here if a motor carrier is cited for two or more of the violations above in the same inspection these violations would all appear in the inspection report however when FMCSA analyzes the carrier's data to determine if the carrier should be prioritized the new methodology would count this set of violations as one violation under the hours of service hours of service requirements violation group I want to show you how this looks because this is another part of the fmcsa's preview website if you go there you can actually see how the new system is going to look and that's what we're looking at here this is just a sample carrier that they give you can actually if you're a carrier you can go put your own you can log in into your account and actually see how you would be performing under this new methodology if it ends up taking effect I recommend you do that you could see right now how you would be performing and then compare that to how you're performing under current SMS that'll give you a good feel for whether these changes are moving in the right direction or not but here's the sample the sample page for the how the new SMS will look and I wanted to show you we're talking about these grouping of violations here's how it would look if I were to log into a carrier's account and I go to the inspection history you could see each inspection broken down into a row here normally under the current system you would then see a bunch of violations and how those are weighing on your scores from that inspection but now you could see that they are being grouped into common types of violations and then we'll talk about severity weights in a minute but the the big news here is that we are now grouping similar violations into one so that you're not getting penalized when you've got multiple violations that essentially describe the same underlying conduct that we want to punish uh why is this important I thought this was uh interesting of the FMCSA to note why are they changing this why are we moving to a grouping of violations for purposes of calculating your CSA scores they say there are often multiple ways to cite a carrier for the same underlying safety issue their analysis of SMS indicated that for prioritization purposes in other words for scoring purposes determining whether a safety issue is identified is more important than determining how many ways that it was documented so ultimately grouping is the way to account for this we are more concerned that there is an issue if there is an hours of service issue for example then how many issues or how many times that manifested in a particular inspection hopefully that makes sense but that that's what we are doing with this proposed change is we're going to be grouping violations uh let's see here let's see what comments we've got we've got a quite a few folks weighing in here Dylan is saying if the violation is not considered observable by a driver would violations then be written differently at roadside than directly to the carrier instead of issued to the driver and carrier simultaneously he's going back to what we talked about a second ago which is the vehicle maintenance driver observe category I don't get that impression that we're going to be changing the way that these are written up roadside I anticipate that they will still be coded the same way that they are coded in a roadside inspection report that report will still be directed to the motor carrier and then through the SMS system is when I think that they will be split off into either vehicle maintenance or vehicle maintenance driver observed that's kind of how we have the system now where you know roadside the officers aren't figuring out what categories these violations belong in they're just writing you up for the violation and then on the back end the SMS system is categorizing them into the right basic I think that's how it will still work even in the driver observe category in other words I don't think it's going going to be a case where if it's a driver observed vehicle maintenance violation that it only hurts the driver somehow it is still going to impact the carrier and I think that's the right way to do it because even though it could have been observed by the driver FMCSA has always taken the position that you as the motor carrier it's still your responsibility to make sure that your drivers are following the law we can't just try and push that off on the drivers themselves we still have an obligation to make sure that we are training our drivers and holding them accountable to these rules so I think that's how it'll work uh Eric's saying would a carrier vehicle maintenance violation still show on a PSP for the driver I don't know about that that's an interesting question so PSP pre-employment screening program is the program that lists out all of the violations and all of the crashes that a particular driver has incurred and it's used by subsequent employers of that driver when that driver is applying to them a lot of it's not mandatory but a lot of motor carriers pull those PSP reports so that they could get a feel for what types of violations and crashes that driver has occurred the question is what about vehicle maintenance violations that are not driver observed that happened to happen when a driver is driving that truck in other words this wasn't my fault if I'm the driver this was something that was latent I couldn't have discovered it even with a thorough pre-trip inspection is that violation of vehicle maintenance violation still going to show up on my PSP report I don't think FMCSA has addressed that um I haven't gotten through all of the materials on these changes yet but I don't think they've addressed it it would make sense to me to not put that on their account this kind of is the opposite the other side of what Dylan was asking should the motor carriers account still show driver observed violations so should the motor carrier still be getting a slap on the wrist for the driver observed violations Eric is asking should the driver be slapped on the wrist for violations that should be attributed to the carrier I suspect if I had to guess that these violations will continue to show up on both sides of the equation they will both show up on the driver's PSP report and they will certainly both show up on the motor carriers CSA scores that's my that's how I Envision it will work Michael's saying the driver is the captain of the ship I generally agree with that though certainly there are certain situations where a driver is going to be written up for a violation that was completely outside his or her control I don't think there's any denying that I don't think that's what you're saying but um yeah so there that that's kind of the other side of that all right so that is the the let's see the reorganized roadside violations is the second big takeaway from the fmcsa's proposed changes let's move on to the third again I think there are five main changes that we're talking about here the Third main change proposed by the FMCSA are simplified severity weights this is the one where I think the FMCSA comes the closest to actually addressing long-standing concerns about SMS it has long been argued that a big problem with the SMS platform as it exists currently is the subjectivity of the severity weights that are assigned to all of the 900 plus violations that are in the system if you're familiar with the system now you know that every conceivable violation is listed out in the SMS methodology and it is assigned a severity weight of between 1 and 10. more serious violations have a higher weight of 10 or whatever more minor violations have a lower weight and what that practically means is that if you have if you incur a more serious violation it's going to weigh heavier on your CSA scores and it's going to be more likely that your scores are going to escalate and then you're going to get prioritized for enforcement the concern has been who is setting these severity weights who's to say that a particular violation is more serious than another one especially when you jump across basics for example who's to say that an 11 hour driving violation is more serious than a a tire tread depth issue on the vehicle maintenance side of things so there was a lot of concern expressed about the subjectivity of the severity weights they were essentially just set by FMCSA and and people on its payroll and so folks had problems with that who's to say that one violation is more serious than another well the way that the FMCSA is now proposing to address that by the way that was a criticism that the National Academy of Sciences had about SMS one of the main criticisms that they actually had in their report and so FMCSA is now purporting to address that by simplifying severity weights and what does that mean let's walk through it here the new methodology would replace the one to ten weighting scale for violations in SMS with a two value scale a severity weight of either one or two severity weights would be determined by the set of violations cited during an inspection within a violation group if a motor carrier receives one or more violations within a violation group that set of violations would be assigned a severity weight of two if any of the violations meet the following criteria number one it's out of service in any category except unsafe driving or number two it's a driver disqualifying violation um so what that means essentially is that um well here let's just keep going here and then we'll break it down if none of the violations are if none of the violations in a set are out of service or driver disqualifying violations then that set will receive a weight of one why is this important after conducting analysis on multiple approaches FMCSA determined that assigning a customized weight to all violations was not as important as noting that the violation actually occurred this simplified approach identifies carriers with higher crash rates for prioritization and makes it clearer why a specific violation is weighted more heavily than others I think we could break this down by looking back at this sample motor carriers report here and looking at how the weighting is displayed if you log into your SMS account now you will see a similar calculation but you will see when it comes to severity weights you will see that each violation has a severity weight of between 1 and 10 the ones with a higher violation or severity weight are impacting your scores more heavily going forward we're only going to have two severity weights either a one or two we're still going to have a Time weight which we have currently so more current violations are going to carry a greater weight than older violations but the severity weights are much more simple they are either one or two and most of them are going to be one and so if again and this goes back to the grouping if you have multiple violations written up on a roadside inspection report and some of those violations turn out to be in the same grouping the 116 new violation groups then you're only going to get potentially one point for that even though there may be multiple violations in that particular group so in other words how it would work normally is you would have a separate severity weight for all of those violations so if you have three hours of service violations that are essentially describing the same conduct then you would could potentially have a severity weight of 30 10 for each of them I think it maxes out at 30 now under the current methodology but now we're talking about something entirely different if you've got a bunch of violations some of them are grouped together then you potentially have just a severity of weight weight of one for that entire group The instances where you will have a two a severity weight of two are those two instances that are listed out here either there's an out of service violation in one of those groups which are the more serious violations where your truck is actually put at a service roadside or your driver is put out a service roadside because of the seriousness of that violation if there's an out of service violation in one of those groups then the severity weight will be changed to like we see here this is an operating while at a service violation it has a severity weight of two because that is an out of service violation so if there's an out of service violation in any one of the groups that group is going to have a severity weight of two if there's no out of service violation in that group then your severity weight is going going to be 1 unless that group also contains a violation that is a driver disqualifying violation what's that mean the regulations have a list and it's the citation is listed here of certain types of violations that will that will render a driver disqualified to operate a commercial motor vehicle because of the seriousness of the violation these are you could you could pull up this list if you're interested in what they are but uh the the one that always comes to my mind when I'm thinking of those is instances where a driver is using a handheld device while operating a commercial motor vehicle that is a disqualifying offense now the way that the disqualifying offenses work currently is that it usually takes a conviction of that offense and and sometimes multiple convictions of that offense for the driver to actually be deemed disqualified so in other words if a driver gets tagged for operating a commercial motor vehicle with a handheld device once uh that's not going to disqualify him from operating a commercial motor vehicle he actually has to be convicted of that by a court and then I think that's one of the ones where he actually has to be convicted more than once for that same violation for the disqualification to kick into effect I don't know how that's handled here I I haven't dug that deep into this yet I don't know if this is saying that in order for this to carry a severity weight of two the driver has to have been convicted of these disqualifying violations according to this regulation I suspect that's not how it works I suspect rather that the way that this works is If a driver is sighted on a roadside inspection report for any of these disqualifying violations that are listed in 383.51 regardless if he ultimately gets disqualified because of those it's still going to carry a severity weight of two I suspect that's how it works so those two instances if there's a violation of of those varieties that are that appear in one one of your inspection reports then that violation group will have a severity weight of two all other ones will have a severity weight of one and then they will be multiplied by the time weight and that will give you the total weight for that particular inspection that's how it will work under the proposed changes a much simplified version of severity weights so at least in that regard it seems like FMCSA is pushing SMS in the right direction based on the criticisms it has received in this regard specifically all right so that is the third big change we've got a couple more here let's see if we've got any more comments um someone's saying what I find concerning is the raise thresholds for each basic we'll get to that in a second uh okay so let's move on here um the fourth we got one more driver disqualification offense a list is on the new prioritization review spreadsheet yes if you go to this website the one that we're talking about here the one that we're looking at here they've got a lot of good resources including a list of all of the violations and where they will appear in in the in the revisions and also of the driver disqualification offenses so check that out if you want to see the details all right so let's move on then to the fourth significant change about SMS proposed change and that has to do with improved intervention thresholds this is one that was just mentioned by uh by someone watching uh you will know under the current system that in each of the seven Basics there is an in what's called an intervention threshold sometimes called an alert threshold it is a percentile score that has been set by the FMCSA in each of the basics where if you are a carrier and you in your score exceeds that intervention threshold on a particular month you're going to get a nice big warning triangle on that basic on your SMS account and what that means is you're prioritized for enforcement you're you're doing not so great in that particular basic and that's a hint to FMCSA and to its law enforcement partners that there may be a problem here where there is smoke there may be fire and so that moves you up on the prioritization list for a potential audit for example um my in my experience usually having one basic in alert status rarely leads to anything more than just a warning letter it use usually takes a couple of Basics being above the intervention thresholds before you'll actually get a knock at the door for an audit that's been my experience that's not to say that's always the case if you have even one basic in alert status then you you could theoretically see further enforcement but that's been my experience historically so those intervention thresholds have been set there's a different intervention threshold for it for each of the basics and then there are different intervention thresholds based on what type of motor carrier you are whether you are a general commodity carrier a Hazmat carrier or a passenger carrier so there's essentially three thresholds based on your carrier type within each of the basics and that's how it is currently we're changing these up a little bit but not not a ton with these proposals here what are we doing well first of all we should know that the current intervention thresholds for I want to get this right here um current intervention thresholds for unsafe driving crash indicator and the hours of service Safety categories those Basics are not going to be changing they are going to be remaining the same what is changing is we are changing the thresholds for certain types of categories in the uh in the driver fitness category and the Hazmat compliance category and by the way we're also grafting on the existing intervention thresholds for the from the vehicle maintenance category to the new vehicle maintenance driver observe category so it will take the same take on the same thresholds as the current vehicle maintenance category the ones that are changing are the driver Fitness and the Hazmat compliance Basics how are they changing you can see it here for the driver fitness category for General commodity carriers the current threshold is 80 percent it will be moving to 90 percent for passenger carriers it is currently 65 five percent in driver Fitness it will be moving to 75 percent and for HazMat couriers it is currently 75 percent it is going to 85 percent what does that mean well like I said earlier they're intervention intervention threshold is essentially targeting the highest risk carriers in all of those categories these are percentiles so right now the intervention threshold for General commodity carriers is set at 80 percent in the driver fitness category that means that we are going to Target the worst performing 20 carriers in their safety event groups in the driver fitness category for potential enforcement so the worst performing 20 percent of carriers in the driver fitness category will have that warning triangle on their driver fitness category that's how it is currently what we are saying with these changes is we're we're moving that up to 90 percent so now going forward we're only going to be concerned about the worst performing 10 percent of of carriers in that category rather than the worst performing 20 percent so essentially I kind of look at at it as FMCSA is tightening its focus in these particular categories specifically driver Fitness and hazardous materials compliance it is only going to be escalating a smaller group of carriers in those categories who are who are having problems in those categories this is essentially what it comes down to let's see how FMCSA justifies this here why is this important fmcsa's analysis showed that every safety category has a different relationship to crash rate with some having a higher correlation than others so essentially it's taking the two Basics where it turned out that there wasn't a great correlation between poor performance in those categories and crash risk and it is tightening its focus there in fact I think there were some data out there to suggest that the driver fitness category had an inverse correlation to crash risk carriers that had a higher driver Fitness score were less likely to be involved in a crash which was just crazy but they are recognizing that fact here and they are raising the thresholds in these particular categories because they turn out to be the categories that have uh less correlation to Future crash risk adjusting the thresholds ensures the FMCSA focuses its enforcement program on the carriers with the highest crash rates So that's its justification all right uh someone's asking when will these changes take effect yeah I said earlier you may not have been on then but we don't know precisely when they're taking effect yet um this is we're in a notice uh we're in a comment period now the FMCSA is soliciting comments from the public at least until the middle of May uh they're they are opening up their docket to receive comments so if you have comments about these make sure you go in there and file them that's how you get your voice heard about if you've got problems with these changes and I expect we will the FMCSA will be receiving a lot of comments in connection with this with this notice but suffice it to say we don't know yet when these changes are going to take effect and if this is going to be how these changes look ultimately what we have to do is wait to see how the FMCSA addresses those comments and like I said earlier if I had to guess I would say we're probably not going to see these changes take effect uh at least for six months if not more so all right let's wrap up here with a couple of the last uh significant changes here this one is is arguably the most significant change and it has to do with those percentile scores and making them proportionate um this has to do with the the way that we currently um try and group motor carriers together in the current SMS I mentioned early on that motor carriers in each of the basics are split out into what are called Safety event groups the purpose of these safety event groups is because it would be fundamentally unfair for us to try and rank motor carriers one motor carrier on the one hand that has very little inspection uh inspection data in a particular basic with a carrier that has thousands of inspections with violations in that category it would be unfair to try and rank those two carriers it's just not Apples to Apples is the point and so we fixed that or we purportedly fix that under the current system by breaking Motorcars out into safety event groups and then ranking them only within their safety event groups so that carriers with similar characteristics are ranked against one another rather than carriers that are apples to oranges but the problem that that was causing and this was another big criticism of the current SMS system is that what it meant is that a carrier that happens to change safety event groups for example you know if they're teetering right on the edge of one safety event group and the next one up and then they get one more additional inspection with a violation in the category now they're thrown into that higher safety event group now they're being compared against a much different subset of motor carriers what was happening practically was that when they jumped up to the next safety event group you would see huge swings potentially huge swings in their CSA score in that basic because of the fact that they simply jumped up to a different group and that wasn't really fair because the fact that they got one additional inspection with a violation shouldn't really they shouldn't be penalized for that it's not saying a whole lot about in other words that one extra violation is not saying that now they are they are a terrible carrier all that's saying is now they're in a different safety event group so we shouldn't over penalize them for that well the system as it is currently does that it over penalizes for that type of thing and so what the FMCSA is doing is moving to a different type of a way of handling safety event groups I'm just going to read it here this is probably the most complex change that the FMCSA is proposing um and there's uh there's detailed information about this on the fmcsa's website preview website and in their more in-depth um uh methodology document if you're interested in the actual calculation of this I'll pull it up so we can at least see it but it's pretty complex here's what they say proportionate percentiles use the exact number of inspections and crashes to assign a percentile for a motor carrier rather than relying on the cutoffs in SMS established by safety event groups this methodology has several benefits compared to safety event groups which are used currently including they are customized to a carrier's exact number of events it ensures stable results for carriers by only allowing for a gradual percentile changes from month to month when dropping or adding events and it allows an individual carriers change in measure to have greater influence on their percentile there will no longer be substantial percentile increases without a corresponding measure increase that's the big takeaway with this change is that we're trying to temper those big swings that we would see when a carrier moved between event groups based on just one additional or one less inspection with a violation for example why is this important FMCSA says it's important because this approach would improve the agency's ability to compare carriers with similar carriers and more precisely and accurately indicate how a carrier's performance is trending from month to month and so I said I would show kind of the calculation here it is um I'm still racking wrapping my mind around this um it's it's not all that intuitive but if you're interested this uh this chart here is on our uh article on this on our website at trucksafe.com essentially they're going to be um I'm not even going to try and uh explain it you'll just have to look at that for yourself it's it's it's pretty complex but just know that the point of that change is to try and eliminate or at least temper those big swings that would come when a carrier uh just move between safety event groups without anything significant happening with regards to its violation violations in that particular category all right and we are running out of time here so I want to hit on the what I consider the last most significant change that the FMCSA is proposing with SMS and that has to do with a greater focus on uh or did I skip one here nope we hit all those okay so this is the sixth one I guess I would consider six seven six of them to be fairly significant and this is a greater focus on recent violations so you may know that under the current SMS methodology the system uh has violation data in the system going back 24 months so all of your violation data from the last 24 months is impacting your your scores currently it's still going to be that way even with the changes we're still going to have 24 months worth of violation data in the system but we are going to focus more heavily on violations that have occurred in the last year we do that currently Through Time weights but how are we taught what are we talking about changing here here's how FMCSA describes it uh the new methodology would only calculate percentiles in a safety category if the motor carrier has received at least one roadside roadside violation in that category within the last 12 months this means that a carrier with violations in a safety category that are all 12 months or older will not be assigned a percentile and would not be prioritized in that category based on roadside inspection data alone the proposed change applies to these safety categories it's hours of service vehicle maintenance vehicle maintenance driver observed Hazmat and Driver Fitness so what does that mean well that means that if you have violation data in the system in one of these Basics that are listed here one of these safety categories but all of your violation data is older than a year in other words if you've improved things you have fixed the problems that you were previously plagued with and you haven't incurred any violations in the last 12 months then you're not going to have a percentile score at all in that basic you will just have no score whereas if you have a a violation in that category within the last 12 months then you very well could have a score depending on some data sufficiency protections that are built into the system so we are putting a greater emphasis on activity within the last year we are rewarding you if you have taken steps to fix those problems and you essentially have clean inspections no violations with in those categories over the last 12 months we're not even going to give you a percentile score so there's no risk of you being prioritized based on your activity your prior activity in that particular basic all right that wraps up what I consider to be the most significant portions of the fmcsa's proposed changes to SMS I have a lot of folks asking for my opinion on this my opinion on this is so far what I have read uh I'm okay with I think it is moving SMS in the right direction based on the criticisms that we have had about the program uh over the years at least on paper it looks like they are taking the FMCSA is taking those concerns into consideration and it is working to fix them it's yet to be seen whether it actually fixes them right because we won't really know until carriers start to put their data or log into the system and see how this actually impacts their scores and so I'm going to reserve judgment on this until we start to really dig in and see how this will actually in the real world real world impact motor carriers but I think generally speaking it's moving in the right direction the other thing I have said is that I fear the next up of this and what I mean by that is I worry as I start to dig into this that FMCSA is setting the stage for even more drastic changes that I would not be a fan of those drastic changes are they haven't proposed this so don't go out and say that that this is going to happen but this is what I fear is going to happen I fear that FMCSA is going to take the position that SMS with these changes is fixed and that therefore going forward they can try and tie a motor carrier safety rating to their scores this is something that the agency tried to do probably six five six seven years ago they actually came out with a proposed rule where they were going to tie your safety rating to your SMS scores and that got a lot of a bad press and it got a lot of negative criticism and ultimately Congress stepped in and said no no no no you FMCSA are not going to be doing that until you fix the problems with SMS and so they they withdrew that former rulemaking and we haven't heard anything about it since they haven't said anything about it since and they have they don't say anything about it in this notice but I fear that this notice is setting the stage for them to then take it that next step and once again try and tie a motor carrier safety rating to these scores somebody's asking will they change safety rating to fit unfit rather than the three-tier system that we have now which is satisfactory conditional or unsatisfactory that was The agency's Proposal six or seven years ago was to move away from the three-tier system into a binary system of the of either fit or unfit depending on your CSA scores uh so it could very well could be we know FMCSA in its regulatory agenda as I said earlier they noted that they are contemplating changes to the safety rating process also known as the safety Fitness determination process we just don't know what that looks like but putting the puzzle pieces together here I suspect what that means is they feel comfortable with these changes to SMS that they can then tie a motor carrier's safety rating to these scores in some form or fashion why does that scare me it scares me because I anticipate that that will result in a lot of motor carriers being shut down based solely on roadside inspection data which for a variety of reasons give me a lot of heartburn and and here's a big reason why it gives me heartburn one of my major criticisms and I know a lot of folks share this concern with me with the way that we handle SMS now and violations that impacted Motor Carrier scores is the lack of due process available to motor carriers to challenge erroneous violations that get written up roadside law enforcement is not infallible when it comes to writing up these violations they make mistakes they are only human you would hope that there is a system in place that would afford motor carriers and drivers in those situations with due process to challenge those erroneous violations and get them removed from their account the system that we have in place is the data queue system that is the only system that's available to them to challenge erroneous violations that program suffers from a lot of problems in my in my opinion namely the people reviewing your appeals that you submit through the data queue system are the very same agencies that wrote the violation in the first place it is not an independent a disinterested third party or even the FMCSA that's reviewing your data queues appeals if the Indiana State Police wrote you up for that speeding violation and you have some reason to challenge it it's the Indiana State Police that is serving as the jury the judge and the jury on your appeal through the data Q system they are inherently biased in my opinion and so what we see through the data queue system at least in my experience is a fairly low success rate on those Appeals and I think for what it's worth again probably not much but this would be my big concern if we move to that next step of trying to tie a motor carrier's safety ratings to this new and improved SMS is that we should not be doing that until we give Motorcars uh more robust system and a more independent a more unbiased system to challenge erroneous data that inevitably gets uploaded to the system officers making mistakes happens every day I filed probably a dozen data queue challenges every week for my motor care clients and uh and in my estimation um Motorcars have a right to be challenging those violations because they are wrong in the cases that I review I I don't think it's right for motor carriers just to challenge all violations they need to have a good faith basis for for doing it that's always my recommendation so when I'm filing these data queue appeals on behalf of my clients it's because I believe we have a good factual or legal basis uh to to say that the officer got it wrong and what I'm finding is that despite our best evidence and our best attempts to get those removed those officers are disinclined to Grant those requests and those violations stand and those violations in my view are wrong they should not be impacting that motor care score so what I'm saying is that if we're going to move to a system where we are tying the carrier's lifeblood its safety rating its ability to do business to the SMS system we better be sure that we have a robust due process system in place for them to challenge and get the erroneous violations removed from their account otherwise we're going to be unjustly uh shutting down motor carriers based on potentially erroneous data so that's just my two cents on it um we'll see if that's where we end up like I said we uh are expecting to hear what the FMCSA has in mind in terms of changes to the safety rating process in March at least that's what was listed in the regulatory agenda so enough rambling from me um appreciate everyone joining me today for this special episode of truck safe live we do these truck safe live episodes we try and do a monthly a lot of times we have guests on here so it's not just me rambling on and on um we like to have guests to come on and give us their Insight on hot button issues impacting Highway Transportation so tune in if you're interested you can find more about the our future shows on trucksafelive.com follow us on social media we're pretty active on LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Youtube and and we talk pretty much exclusively about matters concerning DOT compliance and running a regulated Fleet so follow us there subscribe to our newsletter trucksafe.com if you're interested in getting the latest Highway Transportation news and Analysis delivered right to your inbox and that's all I've got appreciate you joining me today reach out if you have any questions about this a particular topic or want help drafting comments or understanding how this is likely to impact your Fleet I'm always happy to discuss those issues thanks everyone see you later foreign

Event Completed

Friday, February 17, 2023 at 1:55 PM EST

Watch on YouTube