Full Transcript
Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
Ah, heat. Heat. Heat. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations.
Is always upto-date and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. Was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. Heat.
Heat. All right, everyone. Welcome to episode 51 of Truck Safe Live, the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon, Truck Safe and Children's Law. Both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs.
Welcome everybody. Brian, Tyler, what's up? How you doing Brandon? Good to see you. Good to see you.
Tyler, how are you guys doing? Doing okay. Ready for the fourth? A long week. Yeah, gonna be a long weekend.
Looking forward to that. Tyler, you said you just spent a bunch of money on some fireworks. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Gotta gota got to do the fireworks show.
All right. Nothing nothing more American than buying a bunch of Chinese fireworks, right? You're going to be exercising extreme caution, I assume. Oh, yeah. Safety.
I mean, I'm If I lose some digits, I I don't know how I'm going to do my job. Yeah, no kidding. Well, uh yeah, happy fourth to everybody tuning in. If you're here with us live, say hey in the comments so we know who's here with us. Um we got a lot to talk about on this show.
A lot went down uh last week from when we're recording this in the regulatory space. So, I'm talking about some new driver initiatives that the FMCSA announced recently um as well as some uh changes to the data Q system and then also the decision in the Wernern case coming out of the uh Texas Supreme Court. All of these kind of uh got some attention in the news in the industry publications last week. So, we thought it would make sense to jump on here and uh talk about those for a while. Let's see.
I think Rob tuned in. Rob, you here with us? I am. I'm here. Nice.
We're all here then. All right. So, that's the plan for today. I want to first thank the sponsor of today's show, which is Project 61, which aims to improve the life expectancy of CDL drivers by raising awareness, providing resources, and educating drivers on a healthier lifestyle. org.
Thanks to Jeremy and his team for sponsoring this episode. Appreciate it. Uh, a few things going on at Truck Safe that I'll mention before we jump into the news. First up would be our upcoming fleet compliance boot camp. Uh this is our two-day in-person conference where we talk dig deep into DOT compliance.
September 3rd and 4th in Indianapolis near the Indianapolis airport presented by Drivewise. Thanks to Drive for sponsoring it. com. Great networking opportunity, great continuing education opportunity for anybody in a fleet safety role, whether that's a safety manager, safety director, uh dispatcher, owner, uh insurance folks, anybody like that, we'd love to have you there with us. Truck safe team is going to be there.
Uh and we dig deep in DOT rigs, best practices, that type of stuff. So, hope to see you there. com is where you'll get the details. Uh, also mention our trucksafe network. If you're not a member of this, I'd encourage you to join it.
com or scan that QR code on the screen and download the app in the App Store or the Google Play Store. This is a space we've built for fleet safety professionals to gather together and learn from one another, ask questions, and also access all of our DOT related content that we push out. Uh, would love to have you part of that. com. Last thing I'll mention about Truck Safe is um you know, we've talked about this on the last couple of shows, but this was another big news story last week was the roll out of the enhanced enforcement of the English language proficiency requirement.
Um effective June 25th, drivers who are found to not be able to proficiently engage in English with law enforcement during roadside inspections are supposed to be placed out of service nowadays. So obviously that's a big deal and uh and there's a lot of open questions about it. Um and so we've published several different resources that are available to carriers. com/p for English language proficiency, you'll find all of the resources we have available, including some educational information about what this new enhanced enforcement entails. U but also beyond that, we are also offering an ELP assessment pack.
So, this is something that we recommend all fleets uh have as part of their driver onboarding process, a way to assess the proficiency, English proficiency of your drivers before you put them out on the road so that you don't run into trouble during roadside enforcement. So, we put together this assessment pack that um allows you to to test their proficiency at the time of hire. It kind of models the FMCSA's uh ELP enforcement. Uh it includes a driver interview, so some questions you can ask the driver and document the responses and then also a traffic sign recognition part of the assessment where you show them some signs and uh have them explain what they are.
So we've got that available for fleets that are interested. We also just recently launched our um our ELP monthly ELP enforcement survey. This is a monthly report that we're going to push out to anybody who subscribes to this. Uh we are tracking ELP data across the United States and seeing how ELP enforcement is playing out in the various states, including like a heat map that shows what states are being particularly aggressive with enforcement. Uh we found that a lot of fleets are interested in that type of data so that they can be aware of where they may run into trouble in the United States.
comp. So, check all that out. Did I miss anything, guys? I don't think so. Well, that's everything.
All right. Well, um we'll just jump right in then to today's topic. Uh as I said at the start, a lot of new things coming down, um from a regulatory perspective last week, uh and then also from a kind of legal perspective. And so that's kind of where I want to start. I know Tyler's going to leave a little early today, but thought we would start with this story.
Uh if you haven't heard about this, then um you're not tuned into the news because this has been the talk of the town lately. So uh Texas Supreme Court overturns nuclear verdict against Warner. I'm just going to read some of this article here. The Supreme Court of Texas on Friday, June 27th, reversed a lower court's $90 million verdict against Warner Enterprises in a driver in a case over a fatal 2014 crash. And so this was a case that had been um going on, making its way through the Texas court system since 2014.
Um, and uh, I'm going to turn it over to Tyler to kind of give us a sense of what the case involved, where it originally landed, and what this new Texas Supreme Court overturning of the lower courts means for could mean for others in the industry. Tyler, yeah, so I'm like you said, I I think if anybody hasn't um been tracking this to at least some degree, they've been living under a rock. Um, obviously this came about through a a highway accident where um an F350 during icy conditions in Texas um lost control, went across the median and ran into a Wernern truck and the Wernner truck was below the speed limit at the time.
However, you know, there was some opinion that the truck was going faster than it should have for the icy conditions. At any rate, um, jury trial, jury awarded, um, you know, that was 90 million, I believe, you know, with interest and everything was well over 100 million. Um, and awarded, you know, the plaintiffs and it, you know, it's tragic these these highway, you know, that's why I could never be a defense attorney, you know, reading about these people whose lives are just destroyed. You know, it's it's incredibly sad um when this happens. But, you know, looking at this from from our perspective, you know, as an industry is that, hey, just because we were involved or just because the truck was involved in the accident doesn't mean they approximately caused the accident.
And again, so from the jury, this was appealed by Warner to um a Texas appellet court. Um the Texas appellet court, there was a split. I think it was a 5-4 decision. And um again, upholding the jury decision. And then Warner uh you know, appealed to the Texas Supreme Court.
And that's, you know, really been the news is, hey, the Texas Supreme Court was saying, hey, we're looking at proximate cause. And in non-legal ease, it's really, hey, we're trying to assess whether or not, you know, the defendant actually was the cause of the accident, was the cause of the injury, right? Could have could have reasonably foreseen that consequence of their actions. Yeah. and and you know being on the road of course they've got a duty um to everybody else in the motoring public to to be safe right and you know these are some icy conditions and and that's tough but really you know it it wasn't the Warner's driver that lost control it wasn't the Warner driver that was speeding it they didn't they were on the road in their own lane um Warner's driver was and and this vehicle again lost control and hit the Warner truck and and you know it's it's a it's It's a great decision for for the industry um to have some common sense of again just because the truck was involved in the accident doesn't mean it should be responsible for these especially huge amount of damages.
And I get it, you know, you put, you know, a quadriplegic little kid and and a and a dead seven-year-old and some of those things like, man, that that's hard to, you know, as a jury, you know, that that's that that's what they're doing. And that's why things like bifurcation of jury trials and things like that I think are really important from a tort reform standpoint. And if you're not aware of this and you're listening. So in terms of tort reform, bifurcation of jury trials means we have a liability portion of the trial. And all right, so like let's say here, hey, we're going to determine whether or not you know the the trucking company is is you know they if they cause the accident if they have liability and then only then you know if there is liability then we go to a damage portion to the to the to the trial to determine you know what damages are appropriate.
And that's kind of the problem with with these accidents is that man, yeah, there's a lot of emotions, right? And tugging on people's heartstrings and it's going to make the jury feel like gosh, we should give them something, right? Absent that bifurcation of the trial, the the risk you run, and you still run in a lot of states that haven't taken this action of bifurcating the trial, is that the plaintiff's attorney is allowed to put on their full case, including their case, to try and assess damages and put that on even during the liability phase. And what we see happen under this reptile theory of litigation is that that ends up with the plaintiff's attorney putting out all of this evidence about the trucking company's um you know safety record, their CSA scores, their policies and procedures.
All of those things are not relevant to the damage shouldn't be relevant to the damages for the accident at hand. Um and yet they are they are shown to the jury and as you say Tyler that starts to inflame the jury. they see that they start to see this company as a bad actor because they have bad CSA scores. Maybe not not I'm not saying that's the case for Warner or anything like that, but that that's typically what you see. And so then they get mad at the company itself for all of this stuff that has nothing to do with the accident at hand.
And then having seen all of that evidence, then they end up assessing these multi-million dollar jury verdicts uh just to punish that company for doing the stuff that had nothing to do with the accident. That's not how lawsuits are supposed to work. The lawsuits are supposed to be about the the controversy between the parties at hand. And so by bifurcating those issues, you take away the the concern of the jury hearing all of that evidence about the carrier's history and stuff like that during the liability phase of the trial. And there and then the jury is just tasked with whose fault was this.
Yeah. And I think more than anything in terms of tort reform that that if if more states can pass that and it's fair, right? Hey, are you liable? Were you liable for this? If it's a if it's a thumbs down, you weren't you didn't cause the accident, then we're not even going to talk about damages, right?
Because you weren't you weren't responsible for for whatever damages were caused. Um yeah, I mean it's it's it's it's definitely a huge decision for the industry. Um, now it's it I think a lot of other um, you know, it's this decision can't be used in other states necessarily as binding precedent um, in other cases, but I I'm certain that you know, defense attorneys throughout the nation are going to try and use this this same approach and cite this case as kind of a common sense. Hey, if we're looking at proximate cause, this is how we should look at. If it would have stopped at the appellet court level, am am I remembering right that the original trial and the appellet court are both in the same venue and that venue is very ugly to trucking companies.
I think it was Harris County, was it? I believe it was Harris County and I believe that's one of the judicial hell holes. Yeah. So, I mean it it's just a a good thing that the Supreme Court isn't based out of there or who knows if it would have ended up the same way. Yeah.
Yeah. And and there's a number of jurisdictions in the US that are like that, you know, including um St. Louis, um which again, that's where the um or the Wabash, you know, huge, you know, judgment um more recently. Also, you know, there there's these places where it's like, yeah, if you've got an injured plaintiff in in one of these counties, it's going to be a tough sledding. Yeah.
And it it's unfortunate because it's going to have you're going to have to take everything to the Supreme Court level to get it out of those particular venues. And you know how how much time are we looking on this thing? It was 2014. Yep. Uh the crash.
Yeah. 11 years. 11 years it took it to get in there and then the money spent just doing this. Yeah. Hundreds of thousands of dollars if not millions in attorneys fees.
I have no doubt. And that's why I mean, you know, a lot of time, you know, things will get settled, especially in those types of venues. " This is why didn't they didn't they give their didn't Wernern offer their self-insured retention piece of 10 million as the settlement? I'm pretty sure I read that. I that could be right.
I'm honestly not. Yeah. " So, yeah. Good on good on Wernern for taking this all the way up. Man, that was they spent they spent a lot of money, but they did the right thing and, you know, it's going to be a positive for the industry at whole.
and and they had good facts, right? I mean, good facts make for better cases. I mean, again, they had to take it to the top, but you know, where it's, you know, really plausible here, hey, that the driver didn't do anything under the speed limit. You know, maybe maybe a little too fast based on someone's opinion that you should have been going a little bit slower in IC conditions, but he wasn't the one that lost control. He was the one that was out of his lane.
If I remember correctly, I think the hook here that convinced the trial court or the jury and then convinced the appellet court was, if I remember this correctly, I may not, but something about this was a driver trainee that had a trainer asleep in the sleeper birth. And something about Warernner's internal company policies would have prohibited this driver from driving in those conditions um unobserved by the trainer. And so I think the argument was, hey, this was a violation of the company pol company's own policies and had they just been complying with the policies, then this driver wouldn't have been in that place at that time.
Uh, and that was the hook on which the liability and the damages were premised. And um, you know, so that's still a cautionary tale to I don't want fleets out there to get the misimpression that this decision by the Texas Supreme Court somehow tempers that concern. We still have that concern that if you have company policies in place, you need to be following your company policies because failing to follow your own internal policies that you've set or processes or procedures or whatever is is uh you know lowhanging fruit for a savvy plaintiff's attorney to pursue these types of cases and win a lot of them.
um you know they that the story that's told to the jury is what you know this company has these policies that are clearly intended to uh make for safer roads and they don't even follow their own policies. How can we let them get away with this? And that's that's convincing to the jury and leads to a lot of these jury verdicts. So the word of caution still stands. uh if you've got internal policies, you know, first of all, if you haven't dusted off your policies in a while, be sure to look at what policies you have in place.
And uh if there's some in there that you aren't following or that are outdated or that are, you know, things that you don't really need in in your handbook or whatever, do put in the effort to get those revised and and uh help minimize your exposure. Yeah. and Brandon. So that piece of it led to the jury had awarded or I think on liability assigned it was something like 70% of liability on Warner to Warner. Yeah.
And it was due to its policy, you know, not not the driver. Um it was Warner due to its policies. It is liability of the trucking company based on their policies and who who they were putting in the truck. So yeah, 100% agree on that. Yeah.
Yeah. What do you got? And speaking of policies, I know we do a lot of policy reviews and just, you know, Rob and and Brian, turn it over to you guys. What are you seeing? What what are what's the current state of fleet safety policies?
What what's your current recommendation with how to handle these from obviously this is not legal advice and and you should, you know, look at it on individual level, but do you have any general advice for how to handle fleet safety policies nowadays in light of these types of cases? articulate it well and be consistent. Don't use a one-sizefitsall. You know, there there's places that you can download a fleet safety policy. And there's a reason that it comes in a word document when you uh download it.
That way, you can adjust it and add things as you need to take things out that don't apply to you in any way, shape, or form. And, you know, make sure they're enforceable. whatever you put in there as a policy. Now, if you have a best practice or you have, you know, an industry standard or something like that, you know, the wording on that is important, but if you're having a a straight policy on it, make sure you can enforce it because if you can't, that's where you'd that's the whole basis of this. My favorite is when you get a get a a hold of a fleet safety policy and it says like insert company name here.
They haven't even taken the time to put their company name in. They just pulled it off the internet. Yeah. Yep. And you know, it's one of those things and as soon as you fill it out that first time in that line, it it autofills everything else.
Yeah. And so it's just blank lines all the way through there. So yeah, I I I've seen those. And you know, when you talk to the some of the bigger companies, the mega fleets if you will, their policies are about a page page and a half. Yeah.
You know, they Yep. And they've rewarded everything. It's basically follow the FMCSRs. Yeah. Okay, there's the policy.
Now, let's talk about things that we think are best practices that that we we're going to imply or our our procedure and things like that. I think I've said this on the on the show before, but uh a long time ago, I was a client asked me if I could review their their driver handbook and their policies. " And then they proceeded to send me over a handbook that included 119 standalone policies that were each like two or three pages. And th that was their policies. 119 separate documents that they apparently distributed to all of their drivers.
I said, uh, let's not review this. Let's just start from scratch because, uh, yeah, nobody's reading that stuff and, uh, that is just unwieldy. So anyway, all right, Tyler, I know you got to scoot, so uh feel free to do so. We're going to move on. Uh thanks for joining us.
And uh yeah, so next up, guys, we um Oops, didn't mean to turn that music on. Um the other the next thing I want to talk about was these um protrucker driver initiatives that the FMCSA well that Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy announced. uh last week from when we're recording this. Let me pull this up here. He made a series of announcements.
Um and these are on our website if anybody's interested in checking these out, reading about them in depth. com is where you'll find it. But there's about five or so announcements and uh I was going to play the audio for this, but I forgot about it. So, wanted to just walk through these, let folks know what they are and what to expect. We don't have the full details on these obviously at this point.
Uh so we'll have to see how they play out uh over time as the DOT starts to publish um you know rulemakings or or guidance documents or whatever it's going to take to implement these things. But first thing that was announced was um expanded grant money for truck parking. Obviously truck parking huge issue that has been an issue in our industry for many years. It's routinely on the top of the list of, you know, driver and carrier problems. Um, when Atri does their study about top industry issues, the lack of truck parking is always at the top of that for both lists.
And so, first thing Duffy announced was $275 million in grant funding um to expand truck parking capacity nationwide. And he also kind of highlighted a um a project in Florida on the I-4 corridor set to add 917 new truck parking spaces across Valuchia, Simol, and OciOla counties uh with an estimated cost of 180 million. Uh so does that I guess what does that mean that Florida's going to get three4 of that funding just for those three counties? That doesn't make much sense, but that's what the announcement said. So yeah, thoughts guys on on this?
Obviously this is good news. Um but any other thoughts on truck parking in general? They've kind of let it the private people kind of run it. I mean truck parking club and and and other entities like that have kind of led the led the charge on it. I think to draw more interest to it than I think we definitely definitely more interest than we had before that.
But with I I think the statistics like one one parking place for every 11 trucks. Um and then his example was the 40% of drivers waste more than an hour a day hunting for parking. Yeah. Yeah, some of this we we go back and forth online with truck drivers, me being a truck driver and them still truck driving is I my argument is always that if you trip plan, you're probably not going to run into this issue as much as if you didn't. But you're still going to run into the issue from time to time, which does, you know, lend credibility to these these payto- park organizations having it when you need to have it.
So yeah. Did Did you guys struggle with truck parking when you were driving? I think it's depends on when you stop. I mean like if I if I know that, hey, this is my schedule and I plan my schedule to be at a truck stop. I mean, barring like serious shipper issues that are unforeseen or traffic or anything crazy.
I mean, I usually try to get to a truck stop by like 4:00 or 5 in the afternoon. If you get there after that, then yeah, you're going to have a problem truck parking. But if you plan your trip generally I I didn't I didn't as much uh over the last 13 years I drove it was split between a private comp a private carrier private fleet and the other one the last eight years was driving between Indiana and the Pacific Northwest. So I spent most of my time above I80 and typically you didn't find too much trouble up there. Yeah.
Yeah. So overall, I mean, welcome news obviously from the Secretary of Transportation that they're starting to focus on this. Whether that two how far that $275 million will go, I don't know. It may be exhausted pretty quickly. If three counties in Florida are going to take three quarters of that, then maybe it doesn't go very far.
But, uh, something is better than nothing, obviously. Another part of that that was announced was that, uh, there's apparently a new US DOT memorandum. I haven't seen this yet. I need to find this, but supposedly reaffirms truck parking as a national priority under Jason's law, which is a a law enacted with MAP 21 several years ago, uh clarifying the eligibility of federal highway funds uh and discretionary grants for truck parking projects. So maybe that kind of addresses it beyond that $275 million that's been earmarked for truck parking.
maybe that additional change will open up general federal highway funding for for truck parking. So, um yeah, good news. Hopefully we start to see more and more spots pop up and we can kind of get a hold of this because obviously the concern is, you know, if we got drivers struggling to find parking, then we end up with drivers potentially in violation of their hours of service rules trying to find that parking and then, you know, potentially fatigued trying to find the parking or just parking in areas where we don't want them to park and being essentially sitting ducks on, you know, shoulders or or on exit entrance ramps, stuff like that.
So, just creating some more exposure than they need to be by not being able to find the parking. So, hopefully we can get some infrastructure to get that taken care of. So, over the last over the last year or so, Brandon, real quick, I you know, we you and I live here in Indiana and I I don't get a chance to get out of the state much anymore, but my goodness, the the rest areas that they're putting in now, they are massive. Yeah. Yep.
Yeah. I think I saw I live in Greenfield, which is just east of Indianapolis, and I saw that they were considering a huge uh project on I70 for potentially a big rest area in Greenfield. So, yeah, it that seems to be the case at least here in Indiana. Um, next thing up in this announcement that came down, again, these are on our website if anybody's interested in kind of reading the details. We also published a video of this on our YouTube channel.
um regulatory relief for greater driver control. So slashing some regulations or some red tape. Um the first one that Secretary Duffy mentioned was the withdrawal of the much maligned speed limiter rule. So this has been a proposed rule I want to say 10 years close to 10 years a joint rule making between Nitsa and FMCSA that would have had it passed mandated speed limiting devices on heavy trucks and buses. So anything over 26,000 lbs.
Now granted a lot of fleets particularly the larger ones are doing this voluntarily. They are already using the speed limiting devices or technology that's installed in the trucks that they purchase. But this is not a current regulatory requirement that heavy trucks be equipped with this. And that had been in a proposal stage that that be mandated across the board for about about 10 years. And um the docket for that for the public docket for that rule making had thousands of comments submitted most of which were negative.
A lot of groups not in favor of the speed limiting uh rule but other groups in favor of it. So kind of mixed reaction but seemingly um more heavy on the negative side. So uh according to Secretary Duffy they are scrapping that alto together um and they will not move forward with that. So thoughts on that guys? We can stop talking about it.
Yay. Yeah. That's that's the big thing. I I don't know if it was ever going to get enough traction to actually do anything. So it's good that it's finally done.
It's over with and you know, let's just move on for this administration at least. Right. There's I mean there's a lot of there's a lot of argument back and forth. , where you might have to um overtake other vehicles or or whatever the case is. And um when you get limited on speed, you you can't always do that.
You can't always do what you need to do. So, it's kind of kind of goes back to that other other automatic braking system deal where you lose control of the truck u or some some element of control of the truck. So, you don't have as much you don't have the ability to control it the way you want to control it. Yeah. Yeah.
There's no question that speeding is still a huge problem. I mean, it's routinely the number one violation discover or listed on roadside inspection reports. Um, but you know, as you guys already pointed out, speed limiters wouldn't necessarily fix that. Um, because sometimes the speeding is is still speeding even though they are within the the speed limiting devices capabilities. Just depends on what area of the roadway they're operating in, construction zone, stuff like that.
So yeah, so to Brian's point, we won't have to talk about this any longer, at least for the next 3 years or so. And uh you know, all this is subject to change obviously with a new administration. Um unfortunately, that's kind of the way the federal rule making goes. Uh kind of goes with the administration. Um but yeah, so that's the current status.
We're not going to be pursuing a speed limiting mandate here in the near future. another uh regulation slashing initiative here. The FMCSA, they had announced this a while back, but he included this in his announcement last week. Ongoing reg deregulatory efforts uh aimed at eliminating burdensome regulations, slashing over 1,800 words from federal rules. Uh they say in the announcement that in 2024 these regulations led to nearly 25,000 unnecessary violations and the proposed changes are projected to save motor carrier industry millions annually.
I thought it was a little weird that they you characterize this as slashing 1,800 words. Why is it slashing the words that you would highlight? I mean maybe you're just slashing some of ands that that are not You know, it seems like you should focus on what you're actually slashing. what's the substance that you're slashing? We have another article on this on our website about what it is that they're they they've essentially issued 18 new proposed rules.
Uh many of which are aimed at either clarifying existing rules or taking away some others. For to give you an example, one thing that they are proposing to get uh to take away is the requirement that drivers have with them in the cabs of their vehicle, a a copy of the instruction manual for their ELD. " And the driver just doesn't know where it is. It's usually on the device itself. um but they they don't give it to the officer and then the officer writes them up for that violation.
So there are a lot of those violations and that's probably a lot of these 25,000 supposed violations that are unnecessary according to this announcement. But um yeah, it's that type of stuff. None of which I would characterize as uh substantial deregulatory initiatives. They all seem pretty minor to me. You guys have any thoughts on those?
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. It's not like we're getting rid of the ELD, right? I mean, this is this is it's a lot of petty stuff. I mean, it sounds big and maybe that's why they drove home, 1800 words, but um yeah, let's focus on the c the word count instead of the substance of what Yeah, because EL is one word, electronic logging device is three. Yeah, I'm just looking here at our article to see what else was included in these 18.
um some changes to the way to what constitutes a DOT recordable accident. They had already done this through guidance, but now they're talking about implementing it into the regulation itself where you know one of the categories of a DOT recordable accident, an accident that has to appear on your accident register or accidents involving um injury, bodily injury to any person that requires immediate medical attention away from the scene. for a while there that you had to treat an accident as DOT recordable if a person was transported to a hospital even if they didn't receive any treatment at the hospital even if they just went there to get like an X-ray or for observation or stuff like that.
But then they changed that in guidance that said if they are only transported away for observation or X-rays and and they don't receive treatment then that's not DOT recordable. So this change is that they're kind of going to incorporate that into the regulations itself rather than in in the guidance. So I wouldn't consider that a substantial change. However, yeah, how do you get that information? You're right.
Violate rules and things like that trying to access that information. I don't even know how you get that unless there was a lawsuit that showed up. Yeah. If you're the carrier that has to decide, is this a DOT recordable accident that I should include on my on my accident register, how am I to know that? The police report isn't going to tell me whether that person received treatment away from the scene.
It'll say maybe they got transported by ambulance, but it's not going to tell me whether they got treatment or not. So, how am I going to find that information out in the first place? That's a good point. Uh, another one was driver vehicle examination reports. So, the roadside inspection reports.
So many will know that, you know, there's a section of that report that you have to sign that you certify any of the violations have been corrected and you have to return that to the state that issued it within 15 days of receiving that roadside inspection report. This new change is going to only require carriers to return those signed reports to the states that require that. Apparently there there's a group of states that don't require that. I guess I wasn't aware of this, but apparently there are some states that don't require a returned inspection report. Did you guys know?
California stamps California stamps the inspection report. Please do not send this back to us. We don't want it. But yeah, they they put a stamp on it. Okay.
Well, so yeah, they're going to clarify that those only have to be returned to the states that require it. uh they're going to put in some rules that that make clear supposedly that driver vehicle inspection reports uh can be kept electronically. I thought that was clear for the last 10 years, but apparently they need to clarify that some more. Um these other things aren't even really worth mentioning here. Spare fuses, vision standards, grandfathering provision.
Yeah, the spare fuse is a good one. That What is that one? That that actually is a violation for a driver not to be carrying spare fuses. What I think a lot of drivers either forget or don't realize that in the fuse panel there are there are slots for spares and they've usually got the spares already in there. And then the the most Most trucks now with just a few exceptions uh in the truck, they're all on circuit breakers.
So, you know, there's that's kind of a they couldn't find anything else type violation. Yeah. Yeah. And then the last one that probably is of interest because I know we've talked about this in the past, Brian. Um rear impact guards.
proposed rule would remove the requirement that rear impact guards be permanently labeled with the manufacturer certification. This eliminates citations for illeible or missing labels which wear off over time. That would be the change. Yeah. And since those were vehicle specific, if you had one that fell off or was worn away, you had to get with the manufacturer to get another one.
So, you know, and then just trying to get drivers to check that because that's not part of a normal pre-trip, at least for most drivers. They don't even know that plate exists. Yeah. Yeah. So, point is all of those are kind of in a proposal stage.
Again, there were like 18 proposals, all of them of that variety. com. You'll find our article on it. Um, another thing Duffy announced last week, the ELD exemption for pre2000 model year trucks is here to stay. Apparently, there was some concern or some talk uh in the industry about the FMCSA considering doing away with that exemption.
I think they actually published a notice. It was like an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking. We reported on it probably 3 years ago or so where the agency was starting to ask questions about whether they needed to make any changes to their ELD rules. And one of the questions they asked for public input was about the pre model pre2000 model year exemption. And I think that got people thinking or worried that they were going to do away with that particular exemption.
So, Secretary Duffy here is announcing that at least for this administration, again, that pre202000 model year truck ELD exemption is here to stay. So, you don't have to worry if if you are driving a truck with an engine that has a model year of 1999 or older. So, there you go. There's a good market for those trucks. I mean, there's even Facebook pages dedicated to those trucks and the sale of those trucks.
So, there's a lot of people that pay good money for it. So, it would be a shame to to drop $150,000 or $200,000 on a glider kit and then it makes no difference. Yeah. Those are the big biggest advocates for that exemption staying are the folks that are making bank off of those those older trucks. Yeah.
I mean, there's some online that are insane. I mean, there's some old school cabovers out there that are going for like $50,000. It's it's insane amounts of money for these old school trucks. Yeah. Um, and then the last regulatory relief that they are mentioning here is combating unlawful double brokering.
So, this is a whole other topic that we've had other shows on. I'm not going to spend a lot of time on it, but you know, a lot of fraud in the industry, uh, a lot of problems with double brokering. Uh, you'll hear that term thrown around a lot. Uh, in most cases, it doesn't mean what you think it means. Um, but regardless, for unlawful double brokering situations where the entity that brokers it to another carrier doesn't have the required broker authority, that is unlawful.
And so, it sounds like the FMCSA is going to look into that and potentially crack down on that some more. you don't see a whole lot of enforcement uh on FMCSA's part against folks that are tendering loads to other motor carriers without possessing the requisite property broker authority to do that. So maybe we start to see some teeth to that requirement and maybe that starts to weed out some of this fraud that we're seeing for those situations. What I don't think this means is that the FMCSA is going to get involved in private matters where um where lawfully licensed brokers are uh handing off freight without the approval of the shipper.
I I don't foresee FMCSA getting in inserting itself into those commercial disputes. Um so for what it's worth. All right. And then a couple other things that Secretary Duffy uh announced last week, a couple of pilot programs, hours of service related pilot programs. First would be uh is called flexible sleeper birth pilot where participating drivers can once this pilot program launches and if you happen to get approved to be a part of the pilot program could split their mandatory 10-hour offduty period into more flexible combinations like 64 and 55 splits allowing better alignment with individual rest needs.
So, another topic that we don't have nearly enough time to talk about, split sleeper birth uh provision, but under the current provision, if you have a a truck that has a sleeper birth, um you can take advantage of the split sleeper birth provision where you could split your 10 at your required 10-hour rest break into two separate segments. But those two separate segments have to be either a eight and two split or a seven and three split or somewhere in between those two. You can't do anything the the longer break has to be at least 7 hours and the um and uh and that's how it is under the current rules.
Now they are under this pilot program. It would allow for more flexibility in that sense and that the longer break could be 5 hours or it could be 6 hours or seven or eight. So kind of trying to you know throw drivers a bone when they to get that 10-hour rest break to reset all of their substantive time limits in different combinations than they are currently. So I imagine Well, that was a Yeah, that was a big deal quite honestly in in my family because that's when they switched it originally, you know, there you used to be able to do a 55. Yeah.
And that's how my parents ran team. Uh but when they switched it and you had to do these longer ones, it was it was too hard on my mom to run those longer hours. So um that I think that's beneficial to be able to split it. Because once again it especially for a solo driver that hauls refrigerated freight going to grocery warehouses at oddball hours. They could keep you anywhere between five and eight hours easy but it never seems to be enough.
Yeah. Or you know keep you five or six hours but it's never long enough to actually get either a break longer break. Yeah. So at least this way that would that would uh get those guys rolling again. That that's huge.
Yeah. Yeah, I think the rationale that drove the move away from those different splits was some studies that showed that it's the consecutive rest that seems to be more beneficial than splitting up a consecutive rest into smaller chunks. So, they wanted to see a longer consecutive amount of time resting, but I I think they're starting to come off that obviously now that they're going to open this up to a pilot program. And just so everybody knows how the how these pilot programs work. So pilot program.
When the FMCSA stands up a pilot program, it's really just a kind of a short-term interim deal with limited participation. Folks will have to be approved to participate. They're going to they'll probably cut it off at a certain number of participants. And they use these as studies to see, hey, is this going to negatively impact safety if we roll this out more broadly to everybody? And uh bugs flying around me.
Um, and if it turns out that the study yields some results that that don't look great, then they'll just scrap the program. But if it turns out that the study reveals that the that it may not adversely affect safety, then the idea is that they will eventually, you know, broaden it to others. So that's how this will work. So that's first one. The second one is called a split duty periods pilot.
And this would permit drivers to pause their 14-hour onduty period for between 30 minutes up to three hours, providing opportunities to rest or handle delays without cutting into driving time. I think this one would be particularly useful. This is the one that a lot of folks have been clamoring for for the reason you mentioned, Brian, for years, which is this systemic problem we have in the industry with shippers and receivers detaining drivers for long periods of time at a at the shippers or receivers facility. And as it stands now under the current rules, unless you're taking advantage of the split sleeper birth uh provision, that time that you're just waiting there to be loaded or unloaded is wasted time.
it counts against your 14-hour clock and so you don't get to extend your your duty day by the time that you are detained. And so that ends up cutting in severely to that driver's work day and uh to really no benefit to anybody. Um, and so this would address it by allowing if I show up to a shipper facility and I'm waiting to be loaded and they detain me for 2 hours, participants in this pilot program would be able to pause their 14-hour window by that amount of time, by those two hours. So, they would get an extended uh duty window by the two hours. So, um, I think that'll be useful.
Thoughts on that? Can they only use that once in a day or can that be used multiple times? That's a good question. I don't know how they'll how they'll end up with it. So, because they had originally toyed around with this type of thing back in 2019 when they when they uh published some changes to the hours of service rules.
They had originally included a 14-hour pause in those 2019 rule changes, but that ultimately got scrapped. And I think back then, if I remember correctly, it had to be a uh just um I think it had to be one per day. I I don't think you could use it multiple times per day, but we'll just have to wait and see the the the conditions of this particular pilot program. Rob, any thoughts on that one? No, I think it's good, especially the 14-hour deal, extending it up to three hours because the um it just gives better flexibility like you were saying.
So, um, for those cases where you can't plan to park because you didn't plan your trip, maybe you can use that to help better plan your parking. Yeah. Um, there are a couple other instances where the 14-hour clock can get paused right now under the current rules, and that's like through the adverse driving conditions exception, um, which is fraught with its own problems. But yeah, so it's not like this is an unprecedented thing where we would pause the 14-hour clock, but it would certainly be expanding that into more broad situations. So, um, and then lastly here in terms of the announcements made by Secretary Duffy, um, modernizing driver resources and data systems.
And this will take us into our next topic. So, uh, first up, the FMCSA has, um, a new, apparently, so I haven't looked at it, but FMCSA website supposedly is now more userfriendly and mobile optimized for driver resources pages with clear sections for truck and bus drivers. Um, I can't say I've known many drivers or carriers to really leverage any resources that the FMCSA has available on their website to begin with, but apparently now it's more user friendly for those that want to do that. And uh maybe there are some good resources there. The one that we always talk about that a lot of folks don't even know about is um what's that thing called, Brian?
Um oh, the safety planner. The safety planner. Yeah, that that is a valuable Yeah. valuable resource for anybody looking that up. just Google FMCSA safety planner.
I don't know if that's one that has new userfriendly uh mobile friendly view to it. But um that's a good way to better understand the safety regulations because they'll list out all of the requirements for driver qualification for example and then they will have forms available to help you meet those requirements right there in that safety planner. So uh a lot of folks don't know about that. I think it's good for carriers, but I think a lot of times it causes carriers a lot of trouble, too. Especially when we're talking about driver resources because you've got drivers who are like Supreme Court lawyers and they'll come to work and say, "I am not subject to this.
" Um, and they'll give you every reason that they read online that Google or Chat GBT told them that they were not subject to FMCSA federal drug testing or hours of service or why they shouldn't or should have an ELD and then it creates an issue where carriers have to combat that and then sure enough that guy's going to be a champion for every other driver in the company and it's going to spread like wildfire and then you've just got this big issue, right? So yeah, some of it's good. Like it's good to have the information for carriers, but a lot of times on the driver side, it can be terrible.
Yeah. Uh and then the last thing here, and this moves us into our other topic, are announcements for proposed revisions to the data cues system. And uh we have a whole other article on this on our website if anybody's interested. Uh this will be a big deal and we've talked about this in the past but data Q system for anybody not familiar with it is the FMCSA platform that carriers and drivers and others in the industry can use to challenge any erroneous data that exists in the system. Um and most notably it's used to challenge roadside violations and also the preventability of crashes.
And so if I'm a carrier whose driver gets written up for a personal conveyance uh false log violation and I have reason to dispute that, I think the officer got it wrong, I would use the data Q system to go in there and challenge that violation and if I prevail, then I can get that violation taken off my account and then it doesn't weigh on my CSA scores and potentially escalate me for enforcement. problem with the system that are well publicized problems. Um there are many uh most notably that this is a state administered program. Even though this is an FMCSA system, it is run by the individual states.
And so if it was the Indiana State Police that wrote my driver up for that violation and I challenge it, then it's the Indiana State Police that get the final say on my appeal through the dead accuse system. and sometimes the very same officer that wrote the violation to begin with is the decision maker in my appeal. So it um the lack of due process is something that many including us have have had a problem with over the years and have complained to the agency about. And so the agency announced uh what do we decide Brian in 2023 some changes to this system. Um back then they had proposed setting up kind of um an appeals board like a second level of appeal where if uh if you lose your initial challenge with the state then this appeals board would be somewhere else you could take it kind of like an appeals court and it would be an independent appeals board that would review your challenge and that's what they had proposed back in 2023 and they opened that up for public comment back then and received a lot of comments and Now they are revisiting the issue.
They never moved forward with those changes but now they are revisiting the issue based on the comments that they received and making some tweaks to it. There are quite a few tweaks that they are announcing um including um the big the big idea is that uh trying to insert some impartiality into the system to address that concern with due process. So things like taking the the officer who wrote up the violation to begin with, removing him as the sole decision maker in the process. So the states will still be able to consult that officer and in reviewing the legitimacy of the violation, but he won't be able to be the sole decision maker.
And then there will still there will be a second level of appeal. If you lose that first level, then the second level under this new proposal would would be an even more independent board. It would have to be somebody um who was not that officer, who was not his direct supervisor, who was not in that same chain of command putting eyes on it and making an independent decision. And then there would be even a third level of appeal that would even make it more impartial. The the extent to which or or the details about how they're going to accomplish that are still a little cloudy.
And so the FMCSA is publishing this for public comment um in the Federal Register. I think comment periods open for 60 days until like September 2nd of 2025. You can submit comments. So, I'd encourage everybody to go in there, read the uh information about what they are proposing when it comes to these changes for the data Q system. And uh if you've got any thoughts on it, submit your comments so that they can further tailor the system.
So, Brian, I know you got some thoughts on this. Yeah, I do. I I know that one of the things that I've heard from law enforcement through like CBSA is that all those different appeals processes require people and they don't necessarily have, you know, when you when they start talking outside the chain of command and not a direct supervisor and stuff like that, some of these commercial vehicle divisions are relatively small. Yeah. when it's com when it's compared to the rest of the state, you know, rest of the the state officers.
So, the chain of command could very well funnel up through one person. Yeah. Yeah. Where are they going to go? Are they just going to go get a guy off the street?
Yeah. Exactly. Now, I I know that they've given some options as far as who they could put on these boards, whether it's motor representation from a motor carrier or safety professionals or something like that. Um, I I just don't know how well that'll play with law enforcement wanting to bring people in from the outside to make law enforcement decisions. So, I'm I'm curious to see how that'll work.
But yeah, that's their biggest concern is okay, who who can we have do this. But I think one of the biggest things because we see a lot of these at TBC. This is kind of what our main business model is is is helping carriers with these challenges is I like the idea when they say no, we're not changing it. They have to give a basically a detailed description on why. Yeah.
Because a lot of times we get no no correction made. Sorry. Yeah. Not even sorry. We just get sorry.
No, we didn't change it. And at least with that detailed, if we're going to submit a rebuttal, at least we'll maybe have an idea of what they're looking for. Yeah. Exactly. So that that's that's going to be a really big deal for us.
Yeah. Yeah. And the other thing is they're the if you read the proposal, you'll see that they're trying that the FMCSA will be tying this into the mix program, motor carrier safety assistance program, the federal funding that FMCSA grants to the states to help them fund highway safety initiatives. But as part of that mix act program, there are conditions to receiving that funding. And so they will be tying the data cues process deeper into that system such that a state's federal funds will be put at risk if they don't do if they don't administer the data system in the way that the FMCSA is expecting them to.
I think that's a good change. And then also, as I understand it, the states will have to develop a a data cues plan for how they how they're individually going to structure this, what their appeals boards are going to look like, who's going to be involved, how they're going to handle these things. And that has to be in a written plan that gets submitted to the FMCSA and that will be published for everybody to see. That that's the proposal. And then some other proposals like the timing of things like there will be set deadlines on w on uh at which the state has to respond to an initial request and then to any subsequent requests things like that.
So, uh, that will hopefully help, um, prevent these things from, you know, dragging on for months on end, which sometimes we encounter with data accuse appeals. So, go ahead. I think it was interesting they also made a point of saying about the adjudicated citations that, you know, states have to follow that program. I'm I'm wondering if they've received some kickback that states are not following that part of the program. Yeah, that wouldn't be surprising to me.
So yeah, it I think the last thing you'd want to do on a challenge though is say, "Hey, remember your mixup funding is at stake here. " Yeah. Just a reminder, you may not get Yeah. Right. In case you didn't know.
Unfortunately, the person deciding your data accuse probably doesn't really care. They're just uh getting a paycheck. Uh I'm just looking here at the LinkedIn comments. " Yeah, that was another big news topic from last week. June 23rd was when the process by which CDL drivers get their mederts tied to their driving record changed pretty dramatically to a strictly electronic system.
Um, I'm already hearing lots of problems across the country. There are lots of medical examiners who apparently didn't get the news that this was changing and so they are continuing to issue drivers, CDL drivers, physical meds. And that process doesn't work anymore. They there's nothing the driver can do with that physical med. They can't take that to their state licensing agency and get it associated with their license.
That information has to be electronically transmitted now by the medical examiner up to the national registry and then down from the national registry to the licensing agency. That is the only valid proof of that CDL driver's medical certification status nowadays. with the exception of the states that haven't pulled the trigger on these changes. There are, last I checked, 12 states that aren't ready for this change, even though they've had 10 years to prepare for it. And they're listed on the FMCSA's um medical or national registry website.
If you got drivers who are doiciled in those 12 states, then this then the process still works how it has worked with the physical meds. But drivers in any other state, CDL drivers specifically, uh the only way that their new mederts get transmitted to their license are electronically directly from the medical examiner. That physical med is has no value anymore um to them. And so, yeah, it's a big change. com, if you want to dig into the details and and uh and try and get it under control.
I think that is makes it even more important for those carriers to run that MVR two weeks later. That is critical now. Yeah, they definitely need to be running MVRs. In fact, that's a requirement. Uh and it has been for a while, but a lot of carriers don't know that.
You have to run those MVRs and that's your proof of those CDL drivers medical uh certification. Um so anyway, be sure you're doing that. Uh we are out of time, so thanks everybody for tuning in. Thanks Rob and Brian for joining me today. There's a lot to talk about.
com or social media and we'll uh try and help you out. Stay tuned for future shows. com is where you can find the details about future shows. Also watch prior episodes or subscribe to the podcast wherever you get your podcast. Thanks everybody.
We'll talk to you later.