Full Transcript
Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
Ah, ah. Heat. Heat. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're After E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. E-Riggs is always up to date and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts.
Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. E-resg was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. Heat. Heat.
All right. All right. Hey everyone, welcome to episode 53 of Truck Safe Live, the show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon with Truck Safe and Childress Law. Both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs.
Got Rob Carpenter, Brian Reynolds with me today. Guys, what's going on?
Howdy. Howdy.
Howdy.
Not a whole lot.
Rob, your house is falling apart.
It is. cuz I had we had like nine inches of rain in one one day and then like my daughter's uh ceiling collapse. So, we've got construction going on and then I I didn't get home till like 1:00 in the morning. So, it's like a mad race.
Sounds pretty serious. You don't have a roof.
It's always serious.
Brian, what's going on in your world? Hockey season starts up here soon, right?
Yeah. Starts uh preseason preseason games next week and then the regular season starts the week after.
Nice. keeping busy as always. Sounds like both of you all over the place. I see you. So, um yeah, welcome uh to everybody joining us, tuning in today.
Appreciate you being here. Say hey if you're here with us in the comments so we know who's around. Um got a lot in store for this show. Very um hot button topic obviously. Um non-domiciled CDLs was big news last week and into this week and um a lot of questions being raised by our motor carrier clients.
So, we thought it would be a good idea to jump on here and try and answer as many of them as we can. Spoiler alert, I don't think we're going to have all that many answers cuz uh FMCSA hasn't really answered them, but we'll do our best. So, that's what's in store for this show. I want to first say thank you to our sponsor, which is Project 61, uh which aims to improve the life expectancy of CDL drivers by raising awareness, providing resources, and educating drivers on a healthier lifestyle. org.
So, thanks to project 61. Um, few things going on truck safe. Just wrapped up our uh was it our this was our fourth annual boot camp uh in Indianapolis a couple weeks ago. Uh thanks to everybody who attended. Great turnout.
Uh I got a lot of good feedback from everybody in attendance. Spent two days talking about DOT compliance. Brian couldn't make it this year unfortunately, but Rob was there with us and um yeah, it was a good time. Two full days, had a great reception with folks. So, yeah, we hope to catch you at the next one.
If you weren't able to make this one, um we usually do them in the fall once a year. com is where you'll find information on that if you want to join us at the next one. Check that out. Uh Rob, did you have a good time boot camp?
Yeah, it was good. And it was it was it was a more interesting boot camp. We had some drivers actually.
you you know anytime you throw drivers and driver perspective in there, it's uh it makes for a different event.
Yeah, for sure. It was Yeah. Great cross-section of the industry. I think at the event we had insurance representatives, we had um you know safety tech vendors there, we had drivers, safety managers, owners. So yeah, a lot of good perspective on a lot of those important topics.
So yeah, hope to catch you at the next one. Um, next thing I'll mention is Truck Safe Network. If you're not a member of our Truck Safe Network, I'd encourage you to join. It's free to join. Uh, this is a space we've built for fleet safety professionals to gather together, learn from one one another, ask questions, and also gain access to all of our DOT related um, compliance content, videos, articles, um, discounts on all of our events, that type of stuff.
Check it out. com is where you can join or download the app on the App Store or the Google Play Store. That's where you could find it. Hope to see you over there. Uh I think that's all I got.
Oh, last thing for Truck Safe. com/subscribe. We send out routine uh newsletters on all kinds of DOT compliance topics, including this non-domicile CDL and English language proficiency issues that are, you know, clogging up our news feeds nowadays. So, I'd encourage you to do to do that as well. I hit everything there, guys.
Truck Safe Wise.
Thanks.
all right. uh a few things going on in the industry before we turn to non-domicile CDLs that I thought were worth mentioning. Obviously, uh when we're recording this October 2nd, 2025, we're in the midst of a government shutdown. Uh not much to say there really other than I just wanted to address it. I've had some people ask whether this is impacting FMCSA and from what I can tell, it's not.
I don't think that they've had to um I don't think they've had to shut down any of their critical systems or anything like that. Have you guys noticed anything?
No, they the only thing that I've seen transportationwise I think they did say and the maybe even a little bit more concerning on the FAA side that a bunch of them are being furled and the um air traffic controllers will be working without pay. So yeah, let's fly.
there you go.
That was the only thing I saw as far as the FMCSA, there was like 25 of them that are working under or that are basically taking an early retirement.
Uh, 25.
This is on top of the Yeah, I was going to say this is on top of the hundreds that have retired recently with the administration change.
Yeah. Yeah. This puts us really really close at that exact 1,000 uh personnel point with the FMCSA. It's getting critically low. Yeah.
Never a good thing.
I was gonna say how many people are left at the FMCSA for it to actually affect.
Yeah. I don't know.
Yeah. Hard telling. Well, uh if we do hear anything in that regard, we'll certainly push it out uh on the our various social media pages and in our newsletter, but for right now, it doesn't seem to be affecting FMCSA or its rule making or enforcement of its rules. Uh, the one thing I did see is actually kind of related to the topic we're talking about today. Client was asking me about the E-Verify system to run a citizenship check on on drivers and I just went to the website to look at it.
It's been a long time since I looked at it and it said it was shut down during the uh the government shutdown. So, apparently you can't use E-Verify at the moment which is probably compounding this problem. I mean, usually when you use that, you enter the person's information and it kind of spits something back. I mean, it's not instant. I mean, sometimes it is, but to me, it's like that should be one of those databases that's always up.
somebody sitting back there
on it, you know,
pulling the documents out of the filing cab.
Yeah. Feeding it in like a fax machine.
I don't know. That's just what it said on the website. So, who knows? Uh, okay. Another important thing coming up is we've talked a lot about in the past, in fact, I think we have had a whole show dedicated to it, the changes to the medical certification process for CDL drivers.
Remember, this was kind of a debacle that was um big changes to the way that CDL holders get the results of their medical exams transmitted to their state licensing agencies. That was all supposed to change in June. supposed to move to a completely electronic process and uh pretty well botched. Um many of the states weren't ready for that transition and so weren't able to accept the results and that led to FMCSA having to issue a temporary waiver to allow motor carriers and drivers to uh to continue to accept paper copies of the meds for um for those CDL drivers. And that waiver is set to expire on October 12th.
And so, and I haven't heard anything about FMCSA extending that any further. And so, assuming that's going to be the date that it ends, motor carriers, if you got CDL drivers, you need to be prepared to um make sure that they're getting those electronically transmitted from their uh medical examiner to their state licensing agency. and then you running an MVR as the only valid proof as of that day that that driver is medically certified. That paper medard will be useless to you as of that day going forward unless FMCSA steps in and uh extends that waiver, but I haven't heard that that is a thing that they're planning on doing.
So, just be aware October 12th is that date. Have you guys heard anything on that?
other than it's probably going to be a mess.
Yeah, I'm a skeptic still. I mean, if they didn't have it right after 10 years, what's the odds of having it right with an extra month or two?
Yeah, for sure. So, um yeah, just be aware of that. That'll be a big issue. If you uh have not gotten an MVR on your drivers and all you have is their paper medard as proof that they are physically qualified, that's, you know, it's not going to be good enough effective October 12th going forward. So, be aware of that.
Um, two other things here. I saw this article come through. Wanted to hear your guys's take on it real quick. This was um, uh, an updated study on truck crashes. Looks like it was a list of the top 10 or so states.
U, this was a study by Truck Safety Coalition, their deadliest truck crash states report released this past Monday. uh 12 states in the latest worst fatal truck crash states table rankings. This is a list you probably don't want to be on if you are a state. Um according to this list, Wyoming tops the list of the worst states for fatality crashes involving large trucks. Uh followed by New Mexico, Mississippi, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Idaho, Nebraska, Arkansas, Kansas, Montana, South Dakota, Alabama.
Thoughts on that, guys? Yeah, a lot of thoughts on that. Um, you know, Wyoming's got some incredible mountain passes that when they freeze up, a lot of it's due to the wind. It's not necessarily how much snow they get, but the wind comes whipping across there, freezes the ground, and you know, we see those 20, 30, 50 car pileups because of the windb blown snow, and you can have multiple fatalities and a lot less wrecks. I I I got a feeling if you just did the total number of wrecks, they're kind of low on the list, but when they have one, it's pretty catastrophic just due to the weather up on those mountain passes.
Yeah, Rob, what your experience operating out there?
Same thing. But I mean, I think you've got you've got a lot of grade there, too. And then the speed there, I think, is like 80 miles an hour in general in a lot of places. So speed and grade um which goes back to the mountain pass piece. So it's kind of like the the perfect recipe for disaster especially when you have snow wind combined with that.
yeah. Yeah. I'd like to know just how many of those are on Elk Mountain.
Yeah.
Yeah. Um okay. Steve on LinkedIn is asking if we, this is going back to that Medcard issue, is asking if we have heard of any states being added or or taken off of the list of states that aren't ready for uh the electronic transmissions. I just pulled up the website. If you just Google FMCSA um NRI, National Registry 2, that's the name of the website, you'll you'll get to this website.
And on this website, they've got a list of these states. It's cut off here for some reason. But here are the states there. There are still 12 on the list as there have been for the past several months. So, no, as of now, the uh the same the same states that have been problematic are still problematic.
Alaska, California, Florida, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Oklahoma, Vermont, Wyoming. If you've got CDL drivers doiciled in those states getting their med cards, um they're going to have trouble getting those results uploaded to their state licensing agency and that's going to cause problems. " Don't take my word for it because I'm just guessing that's what's going to happen. They're going to have to do something about those 12 states.
yeah, it'll be it'll be at the 11th hour.
Yeah, it'll be last second. So, um yeah, that's the current status of that. All right, last thing before we bring on Danielle. Um I wanted to give a brief update on English language proficiency. This is kind of wrapped up also in the very politicized nature of the non-domiciled CDLs.
English language proficiency is right there next to it in terms of, you know, top of- mind issues in trucking regulations at the moment and the nationwide attention they've gotten. So, one of the things that we do over at Truck Safe is we're tracking the English language proficiency enforcement data on a month-to-month basis. FMCSA has this data, but it doesn't they don't make it very user friendly to look at or to find. So, as a service to our motor clients, um we've been gathering this data and putting out some visualizations to help you know what the data or or what the enforcement looks like.
So, here's the latest. Um the data lags by a few weeks. Um and so we have data going through August at this point, but the blue line here is the total number of English language proficiency violations written up across the country month by month, 2025 year to date. and the orange line are the number of those total where the drivers were placed out of service for an English language proficiency violation. So that orange line there is is kind of the real important one.
It's showing how many drivers essentially have been placed out of service for lack of English language proficiency. You can see that in June, the first month, June 25th, was supposed to be the first date of heavy enforcement of the out of service condition for this violation. There were 328 drivers put out of service that month and then that rose pretty significantly in July to over 1,700 and then dipped down a little bit in August to around,300. I expect that August number will go up. We tend to get some late reports in on the data.
So, next month's data will probably show a an uptick in August. But, yeah, we're right around uh you know, 3,3500 drivers placed out of service for English language proficiency violations over the last few months. So, I mean, not a huge number of drivers, but not insignificant either. So, uh, you guys heard any more from clients or anything on English language proficiency challenges?
We had one in, uh, in Florida. I mean, our one of our favorite clients down in Florida, um, they they've had they had their first one, um, whatever day I left last week, they called as I was on the airplane. So, it's uh, it's becoming a thing. And then I think a lot of times these people, these carriers are getting to the point where it's frantic like, "Oh, I didn't actually plan for this. I didn't expect my driver to be sitting on the road and not be able to leave.
" And then you have to start thinking about the expense of that.
yeah.
And then do what we should what what you what we've kind of told you to do all along. And it's make sure that you're you have drivers that are working for you that are actually able to speak English before you put them on the road.
Brian, have you guys started through TVC? Have you guys started challenging any of these yet? Have you had any brought to you that?
Well, we don't we don't aren't really able to challenge too much.
uh Yeah, exactly. So, you know, kind of the eye of the beholder on whether or not the the person's able to speak English. You look at what was it?
U-turn crash.
There was
Yeah, there was a total of four.
No, I'm sorry. That's one that we're dealing with. There was a total of four inspections. two of which he was put out of service for non-English and two that he wasn't.
That's what I'm curious about. How are you going to handle that one?
It's I mean we can they're all in different states so you know it's we can say well in this state and you know state patrol loves to hear it well another state's doing this.
Yeah.
Yeah. They they love to hear that.
Um
yeah exactly that that's kind of the answer that we're getting is sorry.
Yeah. Sean's asking the same question. Do you know of anyone challenging the officer's results? Because that would be another situation I would I would probably recommend a data challenge. I think it's probably low likelihood of success.
But if you have a driver that you you're a motor carrier, you assess them when you brought them on board. You did your own English language proficiency assessment. Maybe you've got some documentation that you did that, but then that driver gets stopped and placed out of service for an English language proficiency violation. I think that's worth a data cues challenge. and you submit proof that you had done your own assessment and according to your assessment they were proficient.
Again, probably very low likelihood of success, but at least in that case, you've got some documentation that that you assess them and and then yeah, it's it's your word against the officers. I think the officer's word's going to prevail on that most more often than not.
" Right.
Well, that actually happened with the U-turn crash, right? Because then there was subsequent officer footage, uh, body cam footage from a New Mexico officer that had stopped that same driver. And uh they published that video and it looked like he was able to answer all of the officers questions in English. I mean I I understood what he was saying. So that kind of that I think that went uh not the way that the DOT wanted it to go.
So but yeah, I think that's an important point.
Well, I think that was definitely New Mexico trying to cover themselves, you know, because they were being lumped in with a couple other states. Yeah. Yeah. and dealing with this guy and they wanted to say, "Hey, wait, wait, wait.
Yeah. Um, okay. Well, then turning to today's topic, which is, like I said, non-domicile CDLs. Obviously, the talk of the town in the trucking circles over the last week or so. Big news from Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy on a crackdown on um on the issuance of these non-domicile CDLs.
uh had have had a lot of questions come in to us about what exactly are these things, who gets them, how's this going to impact our fleet going forward. So that's what we wanted to talk about today. Um we wanted to bring on a guest. Uh so we want to welcome Daniel Schaefen, uh senior sales solutions engineer with Revanova and uh essentially a de facto investigative journalist on this issue. uh from what I can tell, she spent a lot of time over the last few weeks, even before this hit the news cycles in the last couple of days kind of digging into these related issues and and some of the, you know, fraud that seems to be pretty rampant uh and starting to be unveiled in various states when it comes to the issuance of these types of licenses.
So, Danielle, thanks for joining us.
Hi guys. Thanks for having me on today. It's one of my favorite topics.
All right. Well, it's not one of mine, but I'm glad that it is somebody's favorite topic to talk about.
Well, not favorite in a way that I love it, but favorite in a way that there's so much in my head.
So, how did you get into this? I mean, that's my first question to you is how what what brought this to your, you know, top of mind that you wanted to start digging in and and doing your own investigation where it looked like nobody else was really digging in quite yet.
Yeah. So, where it started really at the beginning, it would have been back uh beginning of the year. I get really frustrated with buzzwords and umbrella terms that can mean 500 different things. And freight fraud was one of those. And I was getting so frustr I still get frustrated with people that just say freight fraud and we're trying to solve freight fraud.
There's so many different types of freight fraud that we will never solve freight fraud. We can solve the types of freight fraud and the things that are going on, but in general, we'll never solve freight fraud. And so that's where it started. I just started digging in and trying to figure out what types of fraud or criminal activity is going on that's being lumped under freight fraud, which took me into the 2 million rows of registered US DOS, which can be trucking companies, electric companies, lawn care, whatever. So, I started I was just doom scrolling through those 2 million rows and I started organizing by names, by addresses, seeing how many of them matched up.
That's where I initially found this no-name given and from it's all a snowball at this point. Um, but the first no-name given came from the actual trucking companies in registered with the US DOT. " When I started looking at other corporate filings within like um open corporates or there's corporation wiki, trucking or transportation is the only industry in America where you have the majority of these no-name given filings. Um I think I found 113 in the corporate filings. We are the only ones that allow someone to register a business with no name given.
So these are the either the owners or the registered agent, whoever setting up these companies.
because for people not familiar, when you set up a new motor carrier entity, you have to list a contact person. And what you found in that was several of them with no name given listed as their name in those.
Yep. And so it's not it this isn't something that's been happening for 20 years, 45 years, regardless of what people on X try to argue with me about. It really started happening in 2020. Prior to 2020, I think there's 25 US DOS that were registered with no name or FNU, LNU, first name not or first name unknown, last name unknown. There's only 25.
starting in 2020 to the present day October 2nd. I just pulled it again.
US DOT records with the some variation of no name given. Um and there's a few of them. No name given, no given name, FNU, LNU, there's an unknown of some sort. Um but 623 of them since 2022, which is insane. Once I found all that, my next step in this, I was interested like where is this name coming from?
Is it real or are they just typing it in? Because I know registering a US DOT is pretty loose and you can they're changing it. It's getting better, but essentially you can do whatever you want to start a trucking company. And I stumbled upon um about 500 copies of CDLs. And so I put all of them in a folder and I just started going through them one by one and sure enough I found 10% of those um probably more than 10%.
I probably have 50 you uh non-domicile CDLs. Yes. With no given name.
And it's wild. I mean if you look on Facebook or look in anywhere else, no one has like Rob no given name as his Facebook profile.
It's not real. It's insane.
the it was more on the ELP. I was very hopeful for that press conference that he was going to do something about the non-domicide CDLs. I was very disappointed. So, I set my expectations at essentially zero for this one last Friday and I I can confirm he has received most of my reports that I've sent in to the DOT and they are also watching X which is phenomenal that we have an administration that pays attention and they actually read and they hear us. " I never thought that he would that this audit would actually come out and confirm everything that I've been posting about the no-name given and the non-domicile CDLs.
Yeah.
One of the things that I could never confirm on these non-domicile CDLs other than New York is that they are issued illegally. For New York, they print the work visa or the visa expiration date on the CDL.
New York's the only state I found that does that. By law, the CDL expiration date is supposed to be the same as that work visa expiration date. And so for New York, I think there's one. Yeah, in the top left corner. for New York.
I can quickly tell and confidently say that that one was issued illegally because the CDL expires years after the work visas expired.
And that's been a requirement with these non-domicile CDL. This that's not that hasn't been changed. Yeah, that's been the case. The the non-domicile CDLs weren't supposed to extend past their work authorization that they had to show to get it.
Correct. Correct. And so with the California and Utah, I could only suspect that those were being issued just as fraudulently as New York. But of course, I don't have access to immigration data or documents. So I had no idea if those were issued fraudulently and that in the press conference last Friday, that's what he said is that they had matched up the immigration documents for those in California and they were in fact issued illegally.
Here, I want to show a clip from that press conference. Now seems to be a good time to show that. So hang with me here. I'm going to show this is just a couple minutes.
We have a government system designed to keep American families on the road safe, but that system has been compromised. I'm talking about non-domicile commercial driver's licenses that are issued across the country. So, in plain English, this is a license to operate a massive 80,000lb truck that's being issued to foreign drivers who are not US citizens or lawful permanent residents. The process for issuing these licenses is absolutely 100% broken. It has become a threat to public safety and it is a national emergency that requires action right now.
So this year alone, a series of horrific fatal crashes have been caused by dangerous non-domicile CDL drivers. So I want to go through a couple of examples. On March 14th in Texas, a truck driver failed to break and crashed into a long line of traffic. This caused a 17 vehicle pileup that killed five people, including two children, and 11 were hospitalized. A postc crash investigation revealed a history of unsafe lane changes, ignoring traffic signs, and multiple violations of our of service rules.
It was alleged that the open border policies of the last administration has led to an exploitation of our nation's trucking licensing system. So today, I'm here to tell you after our audit that those reports, they're all true. What our audit has already discovered should anger every single American. So, here's what we've learned. We just want to walk through it.
First, our audit revealed a systemic breakdown among states to follow the law and issue licenses properly. States are failing to follow even the most basic procedures. We even uncovered widespread procedural errors, computer programming flaws, and a gross lack of oversight in the states that issue CDLs. This means that thousands of licenses that should never have been issued actually were issued. This is not the ending.
This is just the beginning. Our team identified non-domicile CDLs that were issued improperly in Colorado, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Texas, and in Washington. Those states should know that enforcement actions against them are forthcoming, and we expect the list of states to grow as our nationwide audit continues. So to every other state, uh, consider this your notice. Fix your system, fix your rules, comply with the law.
Every governor must immediately begin a toptobottom audit of every non-domiciled issued CDL in your state. And if you find any license that was not issued properly, revoke it. Get rid of it.
All right. Some pretty tur words there from Secretary Duffy. Was that your reporting that he was calling out there, Danielle?
I I can't say that it was all me. I can say that much of what he referenced in there were things that I posted like down to the Rex. Um I I I can't claim all the credit. Um and I I don't want to.
yeah,
but I have I have have wow have spent many sleepless nights digging into the stuff and posting it. And when he said all of the reports are Oh my gosh, it makes me almost cry now. When he said all of the reports are true, I I I'm a woman.
and our industry is a mess right now and it breaks my heart every time that there's a legacy family generational trucking company files for bankruptcy. It's heartbreaking and trying to get some of this stuff done and clean up the mess. That's all I want to do. And so to hear him say that and confirm that everything I've been posting and found is true, it was it's amazing. I hate it, but it's amazing.
Yeah, it's awesome. Um, there's several questions coming in. um some of them for you specifically Danielle. But before we get there, so Secretary Duffy's press conference kicked off uh an issuance of what's called an interim final rule, an IFR by the FMCSA that went into it's essentially an emergency rule that went into effect this past Monday immediately which kind of bypassed the normal uh agency rulemaking process. And so we'll get into what the requirements are of that rule.
But before we do that, I thought it would be helpful. Some some folks call me and they just don't even know what a non-domiciled CDL is. So I thought it would be helpful if we could just take a few minutes here to just break it down. com if you're interested. But I'll just uh give you the the highlevel overview here real quick.
Guys, jump in if I get anything wrong or if you have anything to add. But um as most will know the CDL program more broadly uh the entire program itself is a federally regulated program. It's been in place since the late 80s early 90s. Uh it's a program that is regulated by FMCSA but it is administered by the states. And so that makes it kind of a unique program where you've got both the federal government and the state governments kind of you know vying for power which is never a good thing.
But uh that's how it's been running for the last few decades here. Non-domicile CDLs are a component of that program. Um and they have been historically authorized by rule in two very specific cases. There are two lawful instances where a non-domiciled CDL would be appropriate. One of which is the much more common.
In fact, the the second instance I don't think has ever been used. But the the first would be a foreign driver non-Mexico and non-Canada. I'll mention that here in a I'll discuss why that's important here. But a foreign driver who's not a resident of any particular state can get one of these non-domicile CDLs uh if they have certain documentation available that they can provide. I'll get to that in a second.
So that's the first use case would be a foreign national non-Mexico non-Canadian licensed driver getting a non-domiciled CDL in the US. Those are essentially the what who is under the the microscope here. Uh the second group of drivers that could theoretically get a non-domiciled CDL would be drivers from any states that the FMCSA has deemed non-compliant with the CDL rules and that the FMCSA essentially prohibits from issuing CDLs altogether. Like if a state were found to be and they're we're actually California is actually kind of at risk with this at the moment. Um, this has never happened is is my understanding.
FMCSA has never taken away the ability of any states to issue CDLs, but they theoretically could. And if they were to ever do that and there are drivers in that state, they can't go to that state anymore to get their CDL. So, they would have to go to another state of which they are not a resident and they would have to get one of these non-domicile CDLs to be able to continue to drive trucks in the US. So those two categories are what the program was designed for. Now for those foreignbased drivers, uh first thing I'll mention, like I said, these are non Mexico doiciled and non-Canadian doiciled drivers.
Those drivers are in a different category. they are subject to um NAFTA and treaties in place with those countries that allow those drivers of those countries to operate in the US under either a Canadian CDL, Canadian issued CDL or a Mexicanissued CDL. So th those drivers that hold those CDLs from either Canada or Mexico, they are not caught up in uh this non-domicile issue. They shouldn't be. Although I think Secretary Duffy mentioned one instance where they found that a non-domicile CDL was actually improperly issued to a Canadian or a Mexican driver.
But regardless, they're not supposed to be able to get non-domicile CDLs.
it was the state it was the state of California issuing non-domicile to uh Mexican drivers.
Yeah.
So So that would be an invalid issuance of a non-domicile CDL that should have been revoked. Uh but assuming it's a driver from a a different country, here's what they normally here's what the historical guard rails have been that have been set up in the rules for many years. Foreign nationals were supposed to have shown unexpired work authorization either in the form of an employment authorization document, an EAD, or a foreign passport and an I94 form to to get the non-domicile CDL in the first instance. Beyond that, they would also have to pass all of the same things that a US driver would have to pass to get a CDL, namely entry- level driver training if they needed it and also the skills and knowledge test are supposed to be administered to those drivers as well.
Also, non-domicile CDL holders have historically been ineligible for certain endorsements on their CDLs, namely the hazmat endorsement. Um, and then lastly, the rules have required that these non-domicile CDLs be clearly marked on their face as non-domicile. And we saw Secretary Duffy raise that as an issue. I think we saw that in some of Danielle's examples. Some of these states aren't clearly listing on their face that these are non-domicile CDLs.
They'll use other terminology like limited term or something to that effect. So those are the rules that have been in effect for many years and as Danielle was pointing out that many not many but some of the states have not been following when issuing these uh these license particularly that unexpired employment authorization document. That's the one that seems to have let slip through the vast majority of these um impermissible non-domicile CDLs. So did I about capture it there what the kind of the landscape of these were? I miss anything?
Anybody? I think it'd be interesting to know from the time the ELDT went into effect in comparison to how many non-domicile CDLs were issued if they had to go through an ELDT program. You know, I know people are calling for an audit of the the driver training world.
Yeah.
Um I'd be interested to see how many of those were just pencil whipped as well. Unless Danielle, you've already done that. Maybe that's her next target are the training schools. Uh oh, she frozen.
I'm so sorry it cut out. I thought it was I'm so sorry.
Yeah.
the entry level. Are you doing any investigation of training schools, CDL training schools and looking into their issuance or their passage of of students who don't qualify?
Yeah. Um, a lot of it is really really deep. Um, some of it is not so deep and they're not or pretty brazen with their like corporate filings and what they do. I will say for the CDL schools, Google reviews is a gold mine of intel about what's going on in these CDL schools.
they've highlighted highlighted one of the big issues that we've always had concerned about which is that the federal rules didn't end up with a mandatory time and so you know they do say that if a state in which the school res uh is is doiciled has its own times then they have to follow that but there's no federal guidelines on how many hours
these folks have to spend going through the knowledge part or the or the skills part. So I think that's one of the big problems. It wouldn't surprise me if we saw that changed in the near future.
yeah, I do foresee I I don't know what will happen, of course, but um I I do foresee anyone can just spin up a CDL school and say that they're doing the right thing and then you
Yeah, Brian.
Yeah, I had but it was for a carrier itself. We were doing it strictly for that carrier.
to that school or to that carrier.
Yeah. everybody that we trained stayed there at that company. So, it really was in our best interest to make sure that we we did a decent job with them because they were driving our equipment.
Yeah.
Yeah. Um Okay. So that kind of sets up the problem which Secretary Duffy mentioned in his um in his presser. But looking at the interim final rule, um it indicates that there according to the DO's audit of this program, there are now over 200,000 non-domicile CDLs issued in the US currently. Um, and then as he started to get into, we didn't play at all, but several high-profile accidents in in recent months have really brought this to a head.
And so that's kind of where we ended up here with this interim final rule. So, um, before I get into the nuts and bolts of that, I'm looking at some questions here that we're getting from LinkedIn.
just a note, oh, so sorry. Just a note on that 200,000 that estimate is based on the five states. that they have audited thus far.
Oh, okay. So, it's likely higher than that.
I suspect it to be much much higher.
Okay. Yeah, that's a good point.
I saw a number I Danielle, tell me if you'd seen this too. The state of Illinois, I think it was in up to this up from January till now in that state, something like it was either 46 or 64% I can't remember which way the numbers were.
Yes. of the the licenses issued were non-domicile. Wow. Did you see that number, too?
Yes. I don't remember the exact number, but it was significant.
Yeah, it's 50% or better. That's unbelievable.
Yeah. Well, I saw the news article. In fact, I think I've got it here. Uh cuz since we're talking about this, I saw an article come out um that Texas had announced that they had stopped issuing non-domicile CDLs effective this week. Um, and it included some of Texas's numbers.
Texas was one of the states that was under audit by FMCSA, if I remember correctly. Um, let's see what the numbers said for Texas. 2 million total CDLs, including 51,993 non-domiciled CDLs. In 2024 alone, Texas issued over 6,000 non-domiciled CDLs. So, uh, fairly significant numbers.
Sorry, I keep going to that. Uh, fairly significant numbers in Texas, but they have cut off issuing them, as I think was the instruction from Secretary Duffy, particularly to those five states, that they needed to pause issuing them and start a top- down audit of their programs and whether they comply with the new rules. And I my my solution to this from the beginning is that we're going to have to just cut them off until we can clean it up. There are so many immigration like NOS's or organizations within the communities that give out the papers needed to get your work visa.
yeah,
we we're going to continue reacting to those broken systems and we got to stop the bleeding system.
I think that's one of the good things about this rule is that the the EADs are no longer they're not going to qualify anymore. That that's one good thing about it.
it's a phase out, not an immediate, hey, we got to stop this.
it it kind of is one of those things like this is it's broken so why not fix it immediately. like let's just shut this down and instead of it being a phase out, let's let's fix it and then like restructure and restart.
That's what would have been awesome. But it was kind of like kind of like ELP in Texas, right? Like EL Texas could have done this right historically for all time and they haven't. What they ended up doing was creating a state carveout to where if you were an intrastate for ELP, you couldn't even ask under state law what someone's ability to speak English was. Can you speak English?
You couldn't even ask it. By state law, enforcement could not ask you, could not even inquire. " Well, you've had a carve out in Texas forever. So, until you repeal that law on ELP, people are still going to be able to have this like foothold to challenge ELP enforcement under intrastate CDL rules.
Yeah. See, this is this is the problem I highlighted with this being a federal program that's administered by the state. You've got the states vying for power versus the federal government. It's going to end up in litigation. I have no doubt.
And then we're going to have to see how the courts end up. Uh, I I'm not aware of any being filed yet. Um, but I suspect that that will probably happen if if not by one of these state DMVs themselves, then certainly by um probably some interest groups for these drivers that are going to be potentially losing their ability to to drive. So, um, okay. I wanted to be because we're running out of time already, I wanted to hit on what exactly is changing now that this interim final rule, again, this is pretty unprecedented where FMCSA publishes a an emergency rule.
Uh, it is now open for comment, but these are postimplementation comments. So, this rule is in effect as of this past Monday, September 30th, 2025. So, here is what the rule is changing. So, number one, as um as Rob kind of already started to get into, the big part of this is that going forward, this rule now limits individuals who are eligible for these non-domiciled CDLs to foreign individuals in lawful status in the United States in certain employmentbased non-immigrant categories, certain individuals doiciled in a US territory and individuals doiciled in a state that's prohibited as I talked about.
So, in order to now getting into number two here, in order to get one of these non-domicile CDLs or renew one going forward, here's what these individuals would have to present to be able to get one. For non-citizen applicants, except for lawful permanent residents, so we're excluding green card holders here. for non-citizen applicants to provide an unexpired foreign passport and an unexpired form I94 or I94A indicating one of the specified employmentbased non-immigrant categories H2B, H2A, and E2 visas. So, in other words, it's doing away with the ability to use an employment authorization document in EAD alone to be able to get one of these licenses.
they have to show um the valid foreign passport and the I94 form indicating that they are in one of those categories H2B, H2A or E2 treaty. So this will exclude from eligibility folks that had been getting them previously on an employment authorization document. Folks like asylum seekers as I understand it and um I think there are a few other categories as well. But um yeah, so that's that's the first big change. Anything to note there, guys?
I think making sure that you add in the DACA recipients that are getting these two because I mean DACA became big obviously under Obama. That that's where it was ultimately created.
um it's it's refugees, asylum seekers, DACA people. Um but I think the biggest part of this that I liked was the elimination of being able to use the EADs. Um, but I wish it was more instant.
Yeah, Melissa's saying refugees and DACA are included.
included as in not eligible to get the non deals.
Yeah, fake. That's what I thought too. Yeah. which is kind of wild because just a few years ago, I think maybe during CO, right after CO, we were pushing as an industry to get these workers in because of the proclaimed truck driver shortage. And refugees and asylum seekers were two of the suggested solutions.
And so we have government funded pay programs or taxpayer funded programs that we were funding the tuition for drug driving school.
Yeah. Which is a little bit crazy when you think about it.
reasonable minds,
" and then just a few years later to completely flip the script on them and and potentially leave them uh you know without the ability to do what we entice them to come to the country to do. So to the extent that that is accurate I think that's a problem and shouldn't have happened.
Um but it is it is at this point. Yeah.
Another problem with that though is whenever free money is offered now there's going to be people around that are going to try to find a way to take advantage of it.
and I would say a chunk of those drivers that were supposed to receive that training never did.
Yeah.
Like you said, somehow they did it in 4 days
and they got a pencil whipped uh CLP and then the companies took advantage of them too is putting them in a truck with somebody for a couple weeks and and honestly it's probably not one of the bigger, you know, not some of the bigger carriers that did that.
many small carriers that were just looking to to fill those trucks at that time.
Yeah.
Well, the other piece of that is you're going to anytime you take the barrier away, you're going to take I mean, I've talked about this in terms of manual transmissions. Like we had these this natural barrier. We have these natural barriers. It's like pedophiles in schools. All right.
" And if you have been a pedophile anywhere in your history, if you're on the registry, you can't be a school teacher. You take that away, what's going to happen? You're gonna have a bunch of pedophiles that go to be school teachers because that's what happens. You invite the bottom of the barrel. It's no different here.
Like the you have people who pedal a problem that's in this case, I believe, fictitious. We have a shortage of skilled drivers, not a shortage of dock bumping drivers. I mean, there's a never- ending supply of those. But when you do that and you take away the barriers, you're inviting the bottom of the barrel.
justice involved. Yeah, that's literally the two slides of like, hey, we we still have the shortage. These are going to be our two two demographics that we're going to focus on next.
is this like maybe we should like focus on other populations of people, right? I mean, I just I just feel like when you start inviting the bottom of the barrel, you get exactly what you asked for.
Yeah. All right, let's push through this here. Uh final requirements for the rule. Um, so another thing the state licensing agencies are now directed to do is run all of these applicants through the systematic alien verification for entitlement system, uh, also known as SAVE. Um, SDLAS will have to retain copies of the application documents for 2 years.
And here's the other big one that they're really hammering home. As Danielle said, this is been a requirement in the past, but now it's increased emphasis on it. requires that the uh expiration date for any non-domicile CDL match the expiration date of the form I9494A or to expire in one year whichever is sooner.
but they were already limited to one year
okay
yeah I think the longest work visa is it's rare but it's 2 years. Okay.
Um
common is 6 months and then there's a 18month I think.
Yeah. But as you pointed out the issue is just states not following it and not taking action to either print it on the thing or down have a system to downgrade it or revoke it after the expiration of the employment authorization. So that will be a big focus. Um, and then Yeah.
Well, and they were issu
they were issuing them from the get-go for three and four years out.
Mhm.
Yeah.
I've seen them issued for the full eight years.
Yeah. Crazy.
Y
Yeah. And then obviously the the last big one here, state licensing agencies are to downgrade the non-domicile CDL if the state becomes aware that the holder is no longer eligible to hold one for any of those reasons. Um, so that is what is in effect as of this past Monday. Um, and so we, like I said, we've gotten a lot of questions for our clients. I wanted to pitch some of these.
We've answered some of them, but I'm going to throw them out here and get your guys' thoughts on them as we wrap up the show. Um, first question I've gotten is how many drivers will this impact in our estimation? Um, thoughts on this? How many total drivers should we expect to to lose as a result of this crackdown on these? My estimate is very much an estimate, but I would say 500,000 if not more.
Okay.
And that's that's just existing ones, too, isn't it, Danielle?
potentially could have gotten a license coming in that are no longer going to be coming in.
I feel like we're playing prices right here.
one
I'm going to say like a million because if we're we're only looking at five five states and 500 or 200,000 right now.
my guess is it's going to be it's going to be higher.
So you guys are going much higher than I would have expected. Brian, do you have any thoughts on this?
The thing too to remember is that there are some states that they don't Florida is one of them. I got so frustrated with the Newsome and Dantis back and forth on X. Dantis said that they don't issue non-domicile and they don't per se. They issue limited term licenses. It's the same thing.
Same thing. Yeah.
And so those I don't even know if those are included in account as of now.
Yeah, it's a good point.
But I know there's hundreds of thousands. Now, I will say the one thing that was posted in the actual IFR, that was where that 200,000 number came from, but to your point, Danielle, that may just include ju just the five audited states.
at least double that, maybe more. But then the the IFR went on to estimate that 194,000 of those 200,000 they would expect to leave the freight market altogether for not being able to renew based on not getting a new work authorization. So the FMCSA itself is saying a significant portion of those 200,000 from those five audited states they are expecting to no longer be available uh in the freight market at least when it comes time for renewal for those licenses if not sooner. One of the things I have thought about in line in that line is kind of like with clearing house, right? When when you have a driver who's in the clearing house in a prohibited status, one of the things that they're frequently known to do is jump to a non CDL driving role because they still have to be employed, right?
But they can go somewhere where they're not ha where they don't have to have that query done and they'll work for lower money just to keep a paycheck coming. So in some cases, you can take that and then go work somewhere else that you don't have to have the you don't have to have that CDL anymore. you can just work on highway in a different capacity. But um that that's one of the the loopholes that I think that that might get extorted.
Danielle Steve on LinkedIn's asking Danielle, he has uh what about a hired driver that has a current work authorization and a current CDL, but the expirations do not match. What would you recommend to a carrier that's in that situation that has that driver? What should they do now? as of right now and because of the new rule, I would I wouldn't let that driver on the road um just because of this enforcement, if he goes through a state like Oklahoma, um probably Texas coming soon, they're going to pull him out of the truck because when they look at the CDL and that visa expiration, they're going to know or think that he's not legally present.
that support getting it.
It's good advice. We didn't even have time to talk about it, but yeah, that was another article that came out this week.
over three days who whose immigration papers weren't up to up to date. So yeah, I mean that's something that's another big question is what do we do immediately? Is there anything we need to do immediately if we have these drivers now? You're you're running a risk. I mean, they are technically lawfully able to operate because they still have a valid non-domicile CDL, at least according to their state.
And so, if you keep them on the road, you've got a little bit of legal argument behind you that justifies that. But you're running a pretty big risk because at any moment if that state is auditing their system and they see that that license he's he's beyond he or she is beyond their work authorization, they're supposed to revoke that immediately. And so if you've got that driver continuing to operate, you run the risk of having an unlicensed driver out there. Um and so that's a big risk.
well, and it's easy it's easy pickings for ice, too. I mean to just set up in a scale house and you know the way I understood it the the reason they stopped at 130 is they ran out of space. So you know that they could definitely go and pick some of the different major thoroughares on I 10, I40 um you know coming up from Mexico on 65, 55, you know all those different areas running 95 um and just start pulling them out of the trucks there. Well, my my my re what my action plan for what we've been what I've been pushing to these carriers who call and ask for this is one it's it's managing it like you would hazmat because like my hazmat expires in December my license doesn't expire till 28.
So manage it that way and actually create a roster of hey our our work authorizations expire x and our license expire here and they differ. So now why is that the case and should we keep them in the truck? And then basically tracking those renewal dates and then developing some kind of succession planning and then budgeting to replace these drivers as you're not going to be able to get them renewed.
Yeah.
So that's kind of been the action items for for carriers.
And I mean by law those two dates are supposed to match.
Yeah.
So the fact that they don't match that is a huge red flag.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I think some states are going to try to keep do do some enforcement as well to try to keep themselves out of the crosshairs.
Yeah.
Uh you know, losing their federal money or like you said, California is in danger of having their ability to give out CDLs taken away from them. So in his in his press conference, yeah, uh Duffy warned California in particular that that they have 30 days to get this fixed or they are going to pull their federal funding and it was tens of millions of dollars.
160 million the first year, double that the second year.
Yeah.
and they get the most in transportation funds government.
Yeah. So and we're out of time here, so we'll leave it here. But one of the other questions we get is what's our outlook on this? Is this going to uh get stayed through some kind of federal uh you know court case or anything like that? I don't know.
I don't have a crystal ball. It wouldn't surprise me at all, like I said, if if some of the states start to file lawsuits and try and get this stayed by a federal court judge, but we're just going to have to wait and see. You guys have any last thoughts on outlook of where this may be going next? What what fleets should expect? I think we're going to see some real stiff enforcement the the first few months of this until up and until a stay gets issued or someone files a lawsuit.
I think there's going to be a pretty hot and heavy enforcement on it.
Yeah. Closing.
Mine's different. No different than Brandon's and and and yours. But I think the only thing that would just about any of these things that are changing administration to administration is we change it now and then what happens in 2028, right? Because the rules very well could change because the agendas are going to change um if that happens. So, um in the short term, I think I'm with Brandon.
The long term I think there's there's like who knows what could happen.
All right, Danielle, closing thoughts. Uh mine are no different than what you guys said. I'm just anxious to see what's actually going to happen.
Well, uh on behalf of all of us here, we appreciate all the work that you've done, the hard work that you put in, Danielle, and thanks so much for sharing it with us today. Thanks for being with us. Thanks for everybody who tuned in. Obviously, there's a lot that goes into this. We could have spent another hour talking about this probably, but we won't bore you to death.
com or give us a call or reach out on LinkedIn or wherever you uh wherever you find us. So, thanks for being here. We'll see you later.