Full Transcript
Heat. Heat.
Never.
Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
Ah, heat. Heat. Heat. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations.
Is always upto-date and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. Was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. Heat up here.
All right. Hey everyone. Welcome to episode 54 of Truck Safe Live. Show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon with Truck Safe and Children's Law, both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs.
Got Tyler, Rob, Brian here with me today. Guys, welcome.
Howdy. Howdy.
Good afternoon.
At some point, I should probably add you guys to that intro video since it's been me and Jared on there for a long time. Jared never shows up anymore.
Yeah, I was going to say, who's this Jared guy? Uh yeah, we give him a hard time. Um anyway, thanks for everybody for being here. If you're here with us, say hey in the comments so we know who's around. And want to start things off as always by thanking the sponsor of this episode, which is Project 61.
It aims to improve the life expectancy of CDL drivers by raising awareness, providing resources, and educating drivers on a healthier lifestyle. org. Thanks to those folks for helping us out. Um, lots going on in the industry this week, guys. So, uh, wanted to jump on, talk about it all.
Obviously, the big news over the last couple of weeks was the US DOT's and FMCSA's announcement that they are withholding uh, a lot of money from the state of California for failing to um, enforce adequately enforce the ELP mandate. So that's the main topic of today's show and excited to have special guest with us today to talk about that in a few minutes. Before we get there though, few things going on at Truck Safe. As always, our trucks safe network. Uh if you're not a member of the Truck Safe Network, I'd encourage you to join it.
com or scan that QR code and download the app in the App Store or the Google Play Store. This is the space we've built for fleet safety professionals to gather together, learn from one another, ask questions, and access all of our DOT related content. Uh, I've been excited with the app or with the network recently, seeing a lot of participation from other folks in there, asking questions, answering questions. Uh, a lot of activity going on in there. So, seems to be a pretty good resource for fleet safety professionals.
So, um, yeah, I'd encourage you to join that if you haven't already. Uh, I'll also mention our newsletter if you're not subscribed to our newsletter. com/subscribe is where you could do that if you want uptodate. uh DOT compliance, breaking news, our analysis of regulatory topics, updates on these shows, anything like that. I'd uh recommend you subscribe to that and we'll try not to spam you um with any uh spam.
So, there you go. All right. Some things going on in the industry that are worth talking about. We mentioned this on our last show. Um medical medical certification issue for CDL drivers.
This has has been going on in the background for several months at this point. Recall that back in June, the rules for how medical cards for CDL drivers are transmitted to their state licensing agencies were supposed to be changing. In other words, we were transitioning to a fully electronic process. For the last 10 years, we've been working with a hybrid process where CDL drivers go and get their med cards from a DOT doctor and then they have to physically take those meds to their state licensing agency and get it associated with their driving record. In June, that was supposed to change to an electronic process whereby the medical examiners upload digitally upload the results of those exams to the national registry and then from the national registry to the state licensing agency.
And it was just a a debacle. Um many states weren't ready for it despite having 10 years to prepare. Uh many medical examiners didn't even know about this change for some reason. And so this led to FMCSA having to issue a temporary waiver which essentially said that hey for the time being we're not going to penalize you motor carriers or drive CDL drivers if you are continuing to follow that old process where you physically take Med card to the state licensing agency and then present it to the motor carrier as proof of your physical qualifications. That was originally supposed to expire this month in October.
Um, but no surprise it got extended again this time until January 10th of 2026. There are still 12 states that are not ready to accept these electronic transmissions of medical exam results. Does that surprise you guys?
No.
January
for the January? If they did, I didn't see that. But it wouldn't that was going to be it.
Yeah. I mean, if we get enough push back.
Yeah. Well, well, given the topic of today's show, which is FMCSA dropping the hammer on California, it wouldn't surprise me if we started to see some tougher uh deadlines and stuff like that. But yeah, so that's where we're at. January 10th is now the new expiration date of this waiver, after which time that fully electronic process is supposed to be followed. So anyway, be on the lookout for that.
Another thing I'll mention is an update to the English language proficiency enforcement. Obviously, this plays big into our topic today. Um, but one of the things we do at Truck Safe is we are month on on monthly basis. We are pulling in the FMCSA's ELP enforcement data and making it a little bit more user friendly to view by motor carriers and drivers and anybody who's interested in looking at the data. So, we just got the data for September.
It lags a by a few weeks. So, um wanted to share the latest ELP enforcement data that we're looking at. So, this is um showing total ELP violations written up in the US. That's the blue line that you're seeing on the screen. 2025 year to date.
The months at the bottom are cut off, but each of those lines is a month. And then the orange line is total ELP violations where the drivers were placed out of service for the ELP violation um over that same time frame. So you could see here that in June that's when we started to see the numbers tick up as would be expected since June 25th was the first date of enhanced enforcement and then um steady incline up through August which is the 6352 number for the total ELP violations written that month and then a slight dip in uh September but that what we have been seeing is that due to late reporting by some states.
Um, with the next monthly update, I would expect that number to go up and it would probably be somewhere near those last two months, July and August. But, uh, and then looking at the out of service line there, obviously that's the more important one, showing how many drivers are being sidelined for these ELP violations, as is supposed to be the case now, except in limited circumstances, like at the border, in the border zone, and for some hearing impaired drivers. Uh but yeah, over the last few months here, roughly 5,000, a little over 5,000 drivers placed out of service for English language proficiency.
Any other thoughts on that, guys? Surprising? Not surprising? Well, I think what's surprising to me is or I guess not surprising is the inability to really do any sort of challenge on these and there is Have you heard of anybody that has just been put back out on the road and caught for a second time? Have we heard of quote unquote jumping the out of service order from the first one?
Is there civil penalties? Is the company getting looked at? I mean, do do we have any of that information yet?
I have I haven't heard of any of that yet, Rob. Have you?
No, we we did have an instance where a guy got taken out of the truck and arrested because he he was he overstayed his
nonile license, work authorization, and right to be here.
Well, we saw a bunch of that in Oklahoma, right? Oklahoma and I think maybe a couple other states had stings similar to that.
But in this specific case, he was from Haiti and they arrested him. Um, and then they let him go later on and they said that because even though he was expired, even though it was illegal, they couldn't do anything with him because Haiti is in a temporary protective status category. So they let him actually go, get back in the truck and go.
Really? Well, that doesn't make any sense.
No. No. So there's there's been a number of those temporary protective status things pop up.
I could see them letting him stay in the country but not getting back in the truck if he's not
drove it to Florida from Texas.
Interesting.
our ears out for how the FMCSA is handling that. Yeah, to your point, Brian, I haven't seen any jumping out of service orders for EOP violations quite yet, but it won't surprise me if we start to see those, particularly the more drivers that get placed out of service. Obviously, the more likelihood of of that happening. So, Tyler, anything to add on you seeing?
Yeah, I mean, I think that's I haven't seen anything, but you know, how to re-qualify a driver, right? I think that's the big question is, you know, hey, how do we how do we demonstrate that since they're out of service violation that they can indeed um identify signs and speak English?
It's still the million-dollar question, right? How do you rehabilitate these drivers if that's a thing?
Um, and we're just guessing at this point because we don't have any official recommendations from FMCSA or CVSA or anything like that as far as I'm aware. Um, and so, you know, the advice we've given to all of our clients is you got to do something. Can't just put them back in the truck. Um, so what is that something you got to do? Probably some kind of pretty extensive English language training.
And then having a certificate of completion of that training at your disposable at your disposal to be able to submit in a data Q challenge if he if he gets sidelined again. Um, so yeah. Um, okay. That's an ELP update. Another thing I saw come through the news channels this past week.
Um Rob, I think you posted about this on Freight Waves or somewhere. Um a bunch of unions are suing Let's see here. I've got this up here.
Yeah, it's actually uh Tyler, who was it?
It was Teachers Union or something.
Yeah, National Teachers Union was one of the plaintiffs. There were a couple other um drivers associated with some pretty small carriers based on what I saw, but just essentially they filed a petition in the DC circuit to challenge the FMCSA's um non-domicile um CDL rule making.
Yeah.
On what basis do you know? So, and and this may be something that, you know, an attorney who routinely practices in this area of law in terms of petitioning um you know, administrative agency final rules.
" I mean, it was like a two sentence petition.
No substance to it.
no, no substance to it. There's some dates. What was it Rob? November 19th and December 5th that there's various motion practice pleadings.
um obviously what the FMCSA their basis um
for for you know for the rule making and the final rule.
Yeah. Well, it's not all that surprising given that this was kind of a shortcut to the rule making process. So, this was people may recall. com if you're interested. But this was what they call an interim final rule, an IFR that the FMCSA issued, which essentially bypasses the usual notice and comment period that is usually required to pass an administrative rule.
Um, and it pushes that to the back end of things so that the rule goes into effect immediately and then the agency accepts comments and and then maybe or maybe not changes the rule based on those comments after the fact. And so you can imagine that an agency that decides to go that route um is kind of opening itself up for lawsuits for because it the way that the administrative procedures act works is that it's very limited situations where that type of emergency rule making is warranted and you have to meet pretty strict standards. And so I have no doubt that those groups will be challenging that as part of their lawsuit that this was not the appropriate, you know, vehicle for getting this type of rule passed in addition to, you know, the more substantive claims about FMCSA's authority to do this with regard to non-domicile CDLs.
So just have to wait and see.
But yeah, pretty big news.
Um, okay.
Yeah, go for it.
Yeah, Brandon, real quick on that. So, let's say the either the lawsuit's successful or they they turn around on this, all the drivers that were put out of a service and arrested and stuff like that, they get their license back or they do they still, you know, they've outstayed their welcome, so to speak, with their the CDL. Um, so does that all stand?
It's hard to tell.
Is that a whole separate lawsuit?
Yeah, it's hard to tell what the remedy would be since we don't even know what the what the basis of the lawsuit is. It's hard to know hard to forecast what an appropriate remedy would be if they were to prevail in that lawsuit. Plus, there's other issues involved like, hey, even if the court says that FMCSA didn't have the authority to pull the licenses, there is still a question of whether they're here in the country illegally. And if they're in the country illegally, then regardless of FMCSA's action rule making in that regard, I I think there's an argument that they shouldn't be able to drive for that reason.
gotcha.
Uh, all right. So lastly, wanted to briefly touch on this news coming out of the Supreme Court of the United States. Uh, big news a couple weeks ago. They finally granted review um on a broker liability case. So I'm going to let Tyler kind of explain what's going on there.
Yeah. So, this is huge news um for the brokerage uh industry and brokerage firms. Um there have been at least three, I believe four uh prior instances where the Supreme Court has denied um a petition to hear hear of essentially when we say broker liability, it's whether or not brokers um can be liable for state law claims like negligence in instances of highway accidents or cargo damage and theft. Um so it's it's big news. Uh the the court did grant um review of uh a case out of the seventh circuit Montgomery versus Kuribe to at the same time or about the same time there was another case out of the sixth circuit Cox versus total quality logistics that also petitioned for review um of pretty much the same issue.
are they getting consolidated in this?
It's really unclear right now. " Um, so kind of waiting to hear on that.
how did that seventh circuit court rule?
Uh, where was the seventh circuit in favor of preeemption?
Plaintiff or Yeah. In favor of preeemption. Yeah.
Okay. So, in favor of the carrier or in favor of the broker.
Yeah. So, um, there's a split, uh, which is probably why the Supreme Court took it up. I mean, we've got the 11th and seventh on a previous case that, you know, negligence claims are preempted and and the the in the Sixth Circuit and the Ninth Circuit are kind of on the other side of that. Um, saying that, you know, they're not preempted. And when I say preempted, it's preempted by the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, specifically uh 49 US code uh 14501, which um provides pretty broad preeemption um for, you know, motor carriers, freight forwarders, and brokers related to, you know, routes, prices, um services.
Um the key to this is what's called the safety exception. Um so that's what, you know, they're the Supreme Court's going to be looking at. So obviously this is just huge in terms of you know whether or not brokers can be held liable you know for negligence related to highway accidents and cargo loss essentially. So yeah really really huge that the Supreme Court has taken this one up.
Yeah. Hopefully this will resolve the circuit split and at least regardless of which way it goes, at least we'll have some clarity for brokers and possibly even shippers out there about whether they are potentially on the hook for hiring unsafe motor carriers that they then tender the freight to. So, we'll see. But yeah, big news.
All right. Um, like I said, a lot going on in the industry. So, um, wanted to touch on that all briefly. Steve on LinkedIn is saying, "We had a team that got put out of service at a way station New Mexico. " Well, that's crazy.
Um anyway, uh big news obviously this past week was the US DOT's and FMCSA's announcement that agencies have uh that those agencies have elected to proceed with withholding over $40 million in federal funding from the state of California for what they claim is the state's failure to adequately enforce the English language proficiency rule. Since then, we've had a lot of folks come to us, each individually, asking about federal funding in general and the mix program, what it is, what it entails, how it works, and what this announcement will mean for California. So, I'm excited to have with us a special guest today back on the show for second or third time, can't remember, Mr.
Jack Vansteinberg. Jack, thanks for being here with us.
Um, my honor, Brandon, and thanks for having me.
Yeah. Um, Jack is former, you're going to have to help me with this, Jack. Former chief safety officer and executive director for FMCSA. Correct.
Yes. Correct.
And assistant administrator as the chief safety officer. Correct.
Correct.
And then before that, you were uh with the New York State Police. True.
Yep. 25 years with them. And uh I retired in 2008 from New York State Police.
this is feeling like a deposition, Brandon.
Yeah. My gosh.
I got to knock off the leading questions here. Yeah.
Shine a bright light in your face.
I just wanted to set up the your your experience obviously. Um, and given that you've been on both the federal side and the state side, you've got a pretty good idea of how this mixab program functions and some of the political wrangling that goes on between the federal government and the state government uh, in that regard. So, thought you would be the perfect guest to join us today. So, thanks for being here. Um, for those who may not be familiar with MixApp at all, and that may be a lot of folks watching, I was wondering, Jack, if you could just walk us through what it is at its core, um, and and what its purpose is.
Sure, Brandon. And let me just start out by talking about the FMCSA budget. It's a$1 billion dollar budget. 500 million of that that budget goes to the mix program and then about another hundred million goes to various other grant programs at FMCSA. So, the MixApp Motor Carrier Safety Assistance Program, it's a formula grant that every state gets and it the the formula is based on roadway miles within your state, um vehicle mile vehicle miles traveled, um gasoline consumption, um number of registrants, and vehicle miles driven in the state.
So, it's a formula. So obviously the bigger states are going to get the bulk of the money. Texas, California, Florida, New York, and so forth are going to get the the bulk of the mix money. And the mixap program is regulated in the federal regulations. If you look at part 350, it spells out the criteria that the states must adhere to and the programs um that they actually have to do.
If you look at 350203, um that's what really lays out the programs that the states are required to do. So I mentioned $500 million that goes to the states. California gets about $31 million each year and that's without the match.
All right. So here's that regulation you mentioned. So, yeah, it's showing uh I think what you're talking about now, which is where some of the money goes. Driver inspections, vehicle inspections, traffic enforcement, investigations, new entrance safety audits, and a whole list of items.
Yeah. Look at the last one.
Other elements that may be prescribed by the administrator. That one.
Yeah. That's your That's your catchall.
Yeah.
Um we used to have that with the state police in the best interest of the division of state police. There's always a catchall.
Yeah. So, there's your catchall there. But, um, so just getting into that, you know, I mentioned $30 million. I think Secretary Duffy took away 40 million.
So, there had to be some rollover money involved with this. And, you know, uh, in the mixup grant program for California and I know what the secret so I know what the secretary did. Basically, it's another regulation in part 350. And that regulation has to do with compatible laws. And the way I read the letter, and I didn't look at California laws, and it's 350,303.
And in his letter, he mentioned 350 303 A, B, and C.
Yeah. Right here.
There. There you go. And I don't know if California adopted the English language proficiency laws or they excluded it, but obviously they're not enforcing it. So, are they not enforcing it because it's not a law within California? I don't know the specifics, but that's what was in the secretary's letter is A, B, and C that they didn't comply with AB and C.
Yeah, I was going to bring that up. I got that here. So this is the letter of nonconformity issued by FMCSA to the state of California. Uh it kind of breaks down what Jack just mentioned here uh about mixab program. Then it says uh FMCSA data shows that a California is not enforcing the ELP standard during roadside inspections failing to place uh drivers out of service.
From June 25th, 2025 through August 21st, 2025, FMCSA identified that out of nearly 70,000 inspections conducted by California, 34,000 resulted in at least one violation being issued. Of those 34,000 inspections, only one contained a violation relating to ELP, with that one violation resulting in the driver being placed out of service. Now, I think that's a bit misleading to be honest. Uh because like I said earlier in the show, one of the things we do is we track the ELP data uh that FMCSA itself publishes and anybody can go find this and you will see that California over the last few months has indeed written hundreds of ELP violations.
The problem is, however, that as the letter accurately pointed out, only one of those instances was a driver placed out of service for that ELP violation. So, the state, it's a little misleading to say the state's not enforcing ELP, but what is clear is they're not placing drivers out of service for ELP. So, I think that's the genesis of it.
Well, you saw that in your graph earlier that you did, and I was, you know, you saw the number of violations. I can't remember what it was. I already lost my 6,000, you know, each month or something like that.
And then you see the disconnect without or out of service.
some point you're hopefully those lines will come together and show that you know there is out of service with all those violations. So obviously it's just not California. Um and a lot of those a lot of those are are border zone ELP violations. So rightfully written up as non-outou of service in Texas mainly is the one. But yeah, you're right.
I mean that is a big disconnect for sure.
So I looked at, you know, I looked at some of the history. So all this money is available. It it's in the law. It's available to the states. Every year FMCSA puts out what they call a planning memo for the mix program.
Here's what our priorities are. States. you have to do a commercial vehicle safety plan and basically the the planning memo that FMCSA puts out um talks what the priorities are. So I went and looked at 24 and I looked at 25 planning memos and then I looked at 26.
you know kind of right after everything hit the fan on the English language proficiency but um that this planning memo which is now for 26 you know we're technically in fiscal year 26 so the planning memo did address there's a whole section on English language proficiency in the planning memo for the states but in 24 and 25 There was no
not even mentioned. I mean there was no highlight in it. No mention. There's a whole paragraph in this this year's planning memo. So it wasn't that important to the states.
It wasn't that important to the um FMCSA at the time because we had an order at the time through the secretary's office way back when that you're not going to enforce English language proficiency.
But now it's a priority and I understand. I mean, I remember back then, I mean, I always thought it was a a safety impact to um the inspector or the law enforcement officer, you know, because you're giving that driver commands and god forbid that driver doesn't understand it and, you know, backs up or runs over somebody. That's I always thought that safety trumped everything, but but that, you know, it gets political and it's something that, you know, I just dealt with in my position over the years, but but that's it. 26. They put the planning memo out.
This is key. And the mix money should have been awarded by now for 26. Um, obviously they got the letter that they're withholding. And I think everybody's talking $40 million. So again, California gets about $31 million a year and then they have to put in a 5% match.
And by the way, California, I have friends in the CHP. I've had friends all my career in the CHP and I remember California just they used to tell me we put so much more money into the program than what the federal government gives us. And if I I looked at California's um commercial vehicle safety plan, they have almost 1,000 personnel dedicated to commercial vehicles. And I'm not saying it's all on the road, but obviously there's got to be administrative people, data analysts, you got borders in California, but 1,000 personnel assigned to that.
Yeah, that's probably is that the biggest group, biggest state in terms of commercial vehicle enforcement as far as you know,
California and Texas always ran side by side. And I remember crashes. Texas is number one in crashes. Unfortunately, California is number two. So, but and I can't remember if California is one or Texas is one.
6 million is virtually the entire amount that FMCSA would normally allocate to California.
No, California gets about 31 million um a year. 5 and there was gradual increases but not that much.
that they're getting.
6 million would that be?
grand.
in one year you get an opportunity to roll over another.
and then you get a year or two to spend it. So there's always rollover money.
I gota
So I'm assuming there's some rollover money in that, especially if we're just strictly talking mixup funding.
Yeah,
because there are other grant programs, but that letter just talked about mixap funding.
Sure. Go ahead, Brian. I cut you off.
Yeah, I was going to assume I'm going to assume, Jack, like with the the state of California, the money that they're putting in, they have to support that bit program themselves. that the mix that funding doesn't go to that. Correct.
Correct. And and I looked at what California spends the money on. A lot of its overtime, um, a lot of its, um, equipment, a lot of its computer, you know, the computers for their mix people, um, it needs and so forth like that. And I'm not saying some of the mix money doesn't go to personnel. I'm sure it does.
you know, California. I mean, just I just imagine how much it costs between, you know, 1,000 people doing commercial vehicle funding and then you got the, you know, you tie in the indirect cost with benefits and so forth like that. They far exceed their required match. So, but what I'm getting at was California always said, hey, we have such a big program, we really don't need mixup. And that was years ago with, you know, the ne any discussion of never, you know, not accepting it either.
hey Jack, one thing you mentioned that I wanted to uh to kind of double click on. I hate when people say that. I don't know why I just said that, but uh to to dig deeper on is compatibility. And I know it's baked into the regulation, but it's it's a topic that our motor care clients sometimes come to us with and and I always have to go back and reread the mixap regulations, but um the regulations, if I recall correctly, do have quite a bit to say about areas where the states are entitled to deviate from the federal requirements. Uh, and I think it's split off between interstate and intrastate regulations.
So, a lot I think a lot of folks get confused. They think, hey, if this is just truly intrastate commerce, the states have free reign to do whatever they want with their state regulations. But that's that's not the case because under these compatibility regulations, if I've got this correct, if they're agreeing if they're receiving mixup funding, they have to agree even for their intrastate regulations to adopt compatible regulations for the intrastate operations as well. Is that true?
Yes, they have. They have to. And there's always except there's always an exception. They could always request an exception for something. Um but yes, and they have three years, Brandon, to um adapt those regulations.
Like I know in New York it used to be three years. They always went to the wire.
California does that quite a bit, too. One of the issues we're dealing with with one of our clients, Tyler and I have been dealing with it, is um there's a regulation under the federal regment of camera devices in the windshield of commercial vehicles, like how far down it can be from the the top of the of the windshield. And FMCSA changed their regulation a few years back to give a bigger uh area on the window that the that the device could be placed. and California has not changed their state regulation um to mirror that requirement and so it's still a smaller area on the window. Um and so California is continuing to site our motor care clients for having devices in a place that meets the federal rags but doesn't meet their state rags.
And so that's one area that's that's typical of the situation that we're dealing with when we're looking at these compatibility regulations is stuff like that. Yeah. And and you know to me there's the letter of the law and the spirit of the law. And I mean if we're getting that picky some of these reg there's over 900 regulations on a book. I mean I think you could cut half of them out without you know hurting anybody.
Anybody noticing?
Yeah probably.
So Jack, my question is how does California get this money back? How do you know it's being withheld?
Well, I'm assum I'm assuming they're going to hold it. I mean, you know, they have So, right now we're in fiscal year 26. I believe FMCSA has another year. They can wait an extra year into 27 to uh give that money back. So, they're not giving it away right now.
And, you know, I'm sure there's some negotiations going around. And I don't know. I mean, I it's certainly political. And you know, Brandon, you asked me the other day, you know, do I see other states getting in into this? I I I just the state of this country that we're in right now with being so decisive or indecisive and split, it bugs me.
I just wish we can come together and, you know, work together and find some type of uh collaboration and consensus. So, I think there's going to be other states down the road and um, you know, I have I have to agree with Secretary Duffy. I mean, he he stood his ground and I I truly believe English language proficiency is a safety uh issue that has to be addressed. So, um agreed. Uh that's that's the DO's position.
Um that's very been made plain to California. I did want to briefly look at California's response to all of this. No surprise, California has refuted FMCSA's ELP enforcement claim. And this is an article uh just reading from here. California Governor Gavin Nuome responded, "Facts don't lie, but the Trump administration sure does.
" And then they submitted a 25-page letter to FMCSA explaining their position, which I did everybody the favor of reading so you don't have to. It essentially boils down to them arguing that FMCSA doesn't in its regulations require ELP testing roadside. Their claim, California's claim is that it only um mandates that drivers be proficient and it doesn't tell law enforcement where they have to check proficiency. And so their claim is, hey, we do that when we are issuing CDLs to CDL drivers. We have um we have we issue the test in English, although I think they also issue it in Spanish if I remember correctly.
But uh supposedly they don't allow CDL drivers to to get a CDL if they're not proficient English. And they claim that that meets the intent of the regulation and the plain language of the regulation. And so I wanted to get your thoughts on that, Jack. I think the obvious one that comes to my mind uh that that just sticks out like a sore thumb is the ELP rule applies not just to CDL drivers. It applies to any regulated drivers including non-regula uh nonCDL drivers.
So if you're saying you accomplish this through your CDL program, well my response is what about for nonCDL drivers? What are you doing for them? And they didn't address that at all in their regulation. So that was my quick thought, but thoughts on that, Jack? Their response?
No, that's and I've been saying that right along. You've seen some of my comments that we're always dismissing that 10,0001 driver up to 26,000. So, you're right, Brandon. And and then, you know, in a way, the guidance is not part of the regulations. It's just what it is is guidance that testing that that memo that went out, you know, and here's the testing.
Here's what you test roadside for. So, it's not guide or it's not a regulation. It's not a law to me. It's an assist of, you know, how how to enforce that regulation. So, um, and I hear where the states, you know, are are coming from in that respect.
it'll be interesting because if you look at just the compatibility regulation that we were looked in looking at earlier, it says a state must conduct a review of its laws, regulations, standards, and orders to make sure that they're compatible. So, it it seems to be pretty clear that, hey, if you want this money, because that's really what we're after. We're not telling California um we're not it's not like the FMCSA is suing California for not enforcing the law. They're saying you volunteered to be part of this federal funding program that we offer and as a condition to participating in this federal funding, you've agreed to certain things.
One of which was to make sure your standards and orders are compatible with ours and FMCSA saying that they're not. So I I see like you Jack, I see both sides of the argument, although I I tend to fall on FMCSA's side here when it comes to that argument in particular. So, one of the big issues too, Brandon, is, and I'm hoping this it doesn't go this far, is the unintended consequences.
8 million. So they do quite a bit of the inspections nationwide. Um they do a lot of safety audits. They do um some investigations or compliance reviews. But those inspections if they don't start if they don't submit them, that's going to impact the CSA program and SMS and you're going to have skewed data with nothing in from California.
I hope they don't go that far. I know Oregon several years ago they didn't take MixApp money um for whatever reason, but they still continued to submit data through the mix program through the roadside inspections program.
Yeah, that would really screw them over with CSA, right? Because how could you reliably compare carriers if a state in which a lot of carriers are doiciled isn't reported? I mean, it would it would completely break the CSA system.
it would it wouldn't. I'm hoping it doesn't go. And then, you know, and I remember when I was around, we were always talking about withholding funding. You know, you're putting funding in for safety, but now you're withholding it. So, now you're not doing anything.
But I I I think California still, you know, they're going to continue to do roadside inspections and so forth. They got the personnel and, you know, they're not going to compromise safety um uh roadside.
I think that was Oh, yeah. Gro, go ahead. I think we're on the same page on this.
Yeah. 7 million either you're going to have to reduce your re uh increase your revenue or reduce your workflow. Right? So if you're doing 453,000 inspections a year, which I think is what they did last year, that 80% of that activity is funded by mix funds. So if you're taking an 80% hit just to that part of your business, you have to you have to resolve that financially somewhere, right?
So are you going to pull money from your $3 billion CHP budget and and reduce other programs because some you have to pay for it some way, right? So, are you going to reduce your activity in your workload by not performing as many inspections, or are you going to pull money from the other three billion in your CHP budget, which is going to reduce other safety or law enforcement programs? Well, one way or the other, you've got to rectify that loss, right?
So, Rob, so about three years ago, they changed they officially changed the match. You don't need it. Used to be 15% across the board. At the discretion now of the administrator, you can lower the match and California is a 5% match where most of the states are 5% match now. 5 million that California is supposed to get in 26 or something like that and the 40 million they withheld, when I looked at their budget and looked at their plan, most of that money was for um equipment.
It was for um overtime. It was for computers. So, obviously, they're not going to get that. So, they're going to have to take that from somewhere else in their budget. Um if they want to, you know, uh keep going and so forth like that.
Um yeah, you lose $40 million, you're going to make it up if they want to keep up to that same level of effort. And then within the mix program they they have what they call the mainten maintenance of effort which is that you will pledge that you'll maintain your effort that and the maintenance effort of effort goes back like six seven eight years ago where you got to have and I I think the years maybe are um 18 19 and 20 where you have to maintain that level that you did back in those three years. So, California is not going to have any problem with that maintenance of effort. Um, anyway, but they're they they're if they want to keep up the same exact program with the same exact equipment and same functions, they're going to have to make up for that $40 million that was taken, you know, withheld from them.
Yeah. that I mean that was my big focus on it because I know when we had terminals especially on the passenger side in California and Monterey and and Soma and S and San Diego you still have terminal inspections for passenger carriers and bit inspections and things like that. So that was my concern is like are you going to start letting coach bus operations or or regular passenger operations fall apart and not stop servicing PU um because you don't have enough money to do it.
I think they do what two two bit inspections a year for each trucking company there.
I think that used to be true. Is it just for bus companies now Rob? I think for truck for for property carriers I think they move to a CSA like intervention prioritization system if I remember correctly.
Yeah. Yeah. For the most part you have to earn a bit inspection.
Yeah.
On the trucking side.
Got it. Yeah. And then California, California also notoriously has their 90-day vehicle inspection requirement, which is more stringent than the federal annual inspection requirement. kind of also plays into that compatibility review. That's something I've always thought was um because what I've seen, so this is getting in the weeds, but if you go to that compatibility regulation, if it's if we're talking interstate drivers and fleets, the state is only entitled to uh impose more stringent regulations if the secretary of transportation determines that that um more [clears throat] stringent regulation will have a safety benefit and won't impede interstate commerce essentially.
And I've always taken the position that California's imposition of that 90-day vehicle inspection requirement to the extent they're applying it to interstate regulated vehicles go runs a foul of this of these compatibility regulations. They could do it for intrastate commerce, but for interstate I think it's a problem for them. California has several areas where they do that more so than really any other state I've seen in the country. So, I think they've got several mix concerns that I've seen over the years. It's kind of an aside.
It's just me venting. Um, okay. A couple questions here on LinkedIn. " Yeah, as we said at the start, that's that's the million-dollar question, right? Is, you know, what are fleets to do about this if it's such a subjective standard?
And uh I think FMCSA has done all that it's going to do. It has issued an enforcement policy that lays out the two-part test and gives some instruction to law enforcement on how they see them enforcing it. And that's what they've done to address the subjectivity, but it still leaves a lot of open questions. I haven't heard any talk of them clarifying any of those questions. Have you, Jack?
I haven't. But, you know, I go I go back to I remember looking at the video and I think it was New Mexico at the time.
Yeah.
A lot of this got highlighted and I started thinking New Mexico, Texas. A lot of people down there, a lot of the officers are bilingual.
Yeah. Right.
And bilingual, you're going to understand someone a lot more than I am because
Yeah. So again, it's it comes out to being subjective.
Yeah. Because because they get the pass bilingual.
Yeah. They get the pass by that bilingual officer and then they continue on into Florida or wherever they're going and that officer next officer's not bilingual. Well, they're in they're, you know, it's just going to be the the truth that they they see it differently based on their backgrounds and what they understand. So yeah, it makes it tough for carriers and drivers. Um, Michael on LinkedIn is is raising a point that I've seen others raise in the past and it's one that that's probably too far in the weeds for this conversation, but I think it is a legitimate issue, a question that kind of weighs in favor of California's point on this.
I don't I don't think California articulated this in their letter response to FMCSA, but if I were their lawyer, I would have told them to raise this as well, which is, and I don't know if you've looked into this or not, Jack, but if you look up where in the federal safety regulations the FMCSA has adopted the CVSA's out of service criteria, you will only find it explicitly mentioned in one place in the regulations, and that's in part 385. And if you read that regulation, it only adopts the out of service criteria as applied to transportation of highway route controlled quantities of radioactive materials.
And so it doesn't specifically explicitly adopt CVSA's out of service criteria for anything else other than highway route control quantities of radioactive material hazmat essentially.
Yeah. I think may maybe you and I have talked about this, but that's the level six inspection.
Yeah. Right.
5.
If you look at the definition, if you look at the definition of out, this has always been my counter to that. 5, it implicitly adopts the out of service criteria in that definition because it defines out of service order as the CVSA's, you know, North American standard out of service criteria. So, I think that would be FMCSA's counter to it. But, I think it's a good point and it's something I don't know why FMCSA hasn't just done explicitly in its regulations, which is just adopt the out of service criteria.
I agree. I thought it might have been in that interim final rule that they would put it in there. Thought maybe they would do it to make it clear.
Still not
and talk it to the CBSA folks, you know, the leadership there and they wanted to see it made clear and explicit in the federal regulations.
Yeah, that's been a gap for I mean decades at this point, but it has.
um, all right, guys, what else am I missing? Tyler, Rob, Brian, any other questions for Jack?
The other one that I had was I I wrote an article on this in June. This was uh kind of at like when this all kicked off. 043 and it specifically has a law like the governor can't repeal the law, right? Governor Governor down there can say anything he wants in terms of we will enforce ELP, but their transportation code 522043 says you cannot ask intrastate drivers to val to verify that they can speak English. That's what the law says.
So my question had always been, well, if we're going to hit California, Texas actually has a state law that says we are not enforcing this. Our our state law is actually contrary to it. So even though they're saying they're enforcing it, the law says something different. So I guess the way I looked at it was how do we hit California but we don't hit other states like Texas when you actually have a law on the books that says we're not going to ask.
I think the difference I think Rob you and I may have talked about this briefly.
Yeah.
But I think the difference I see is that that law that you're referencing isn't in their motor carrier safety regulations. I think it's, if I remember correctly, I think it's in their DMV regulations. And I think it is essentially prohibiting the DMV from testing English proficiency as a condition to getting a driver's license in the state. I don't think, if I'm recalling correctly, that it prohibits law enforcement from uh enforcing English language proficiency roadside. I think that may be the difference.
Yeah, I think there's an easier answer.
What's the answer?
Blue state and we've got a red state.
[gasps]
You think that's
I think that's the easier answer.
That's probably right.
I wasn't gonna go there, but I bet
Rob has more faith. Rob has more faith in the government than Tyler does. Jack, I heard that that and somehow with the mixup funding that this was another claim that I think I may have heard from an inspector um that the voluntary inspections that they don't get paid for those through any sort of funding. It's it's almost like they're doing them on goodwill.
I mean I was always against voluntary inspections like you know I'm going to set up an inspection for trucks all one day to come in because you're going to get the best. It's not a true reflection of what the So I didn't like that. I always used to when I started looking at some of the data I always just looked at the time how long it takes to do a level one inspection. And trust me, we looked at them. I saw I saw some that were under 10 minutes and you flag those things, but I I didn't really like the voluntary inspections because I don't think it was fair um and a true reflection on that motor carrier's operation or that truck's operation.
Yeah. Do you think they'll start attacking the or start attacking the the threat of we're going to pull your funding to different pieces of different pieces of either legislation or um rulings that are coming down if if this is quote unquote successful.
You know, I don't know what they're going to do legislation. I can't figure out, you know, the Senate and the House on either side. So, I don't know what they're going to do, but you know, I I I have to give Secretary Duffy support. Um, you know, he did it and we'll see where it goes to other states, Brian. And, you know, if there's other states that are, and I'm assuming, you know, if he does it for one state and they're just as bad as California or he's claiming California is, they probably should do it for another state.
But I don't know the details.
One question I did have, this just came to me. Um, I've thought about it in the past, but um, it's it's slightly unrelated, but it has to do with so obviously FMCSA through the mix program has a hammer it can drop on the states obviously as we're seeing here when the state law enforcement is not enforcing regulations or has different regulations, that type of stuff. But what about the issue of like non doiciled CDLs and also the medical certification integration rule that we talked about at the start of the show where it's the state licensing agencies that are uh that are being required to do something and they're failing to do it.
What does does FMCSA have any hammers it can drop on state licensing agencies and what would be the mechanism for doing that? I mean the only hammer that I could see without thinking through it is the high priority grant and where all this money and then there's technology grants that is made available for the state licensing agencies to fund some of these programs.
Yeah.
However, in saying that the mix program they can have so each state has a lead agency.
Yeah.
The mix program can bring in and I'll just use New York. We worked together with the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles. The state department of transportation's lead agency. State police was a a grant recipient. DMV was a grant recipient.
Okay.
So, some of these funds going to a mix agency may be going to the state licensing agencies anyway. But, you know, so that's one means, but the high priority grants that go to um the states, a lot of them are, you know, they set up for the um the licensing agencies, so they could withhold funds that way, too, or just not grant or give them those grant funings.
Yeah, that makes sense.
Um, last question for me and then we're about out of time. Um, so another announcement that came through in the last couple of weeks, Derek Bars was finally confirmed by the US Senate as uh the the next administrator of FMCSA after several months of of waiting. Um, and so, you know, that was kind of exciting news, but my question to you is how much do you envy him now that all this stuff is he's stepping right into the middle of all these political debates?
Well, I wouldn't want to be in his shoes, but that's me. I mean, Derek is a person that I know that can work with all avenues of the motor carrier industry, and he's proven that. And I think if anybody can get this done, if anybody if anybody can get the states to come together with the federal government to enforce the laws or adapt the laws, I think it's Derek. He's got to get his team in place. And over time, he will.
And I just hope he, you know, cuz he came in what, nine months into the administration, so he lost nine months, but the guy knows FMCSA, so he's not going to have and he knows the programs, so it's not going to take that much time for him to get caught up. So, you know, I think he's the person to get the job uh done, especially with the support of the secretary.
Yeah. Uh well, somebody on YouTube said they had a question, but I haven't seen the question come through, so uh and we are out of time. So, uh, anyway, wanted to thank you again, Jack, as always for being with us, taking some time out of your day to be here. Really appreciate your insight on all of these topics. So, um, where can folks find you if, uh, if they need some help with whatever they got going on from a compliance perspective?
I know you help fleets with that currently.
Yeah, I I'm doing my own um CMV Safety Experts LLC. com. com if they want some help in a matter. Give me a call and u or give you know send me an email and I'll be glad to talk to them.
Sounds good. Thanks Jack. Really appreciate it. All right guys, wrapping things up here. com.
Uh, stay tuned for information on our next episode. com. Appreciate you all being here today. Tyler, Rob, Brian, thanks for being here. Anything else before we close it out?
No.
All right. See you guys. Thanks.