Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 57 - CDL Training Crackdown

Wednesday, December 10, 2025 at 1:57 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 57 - CDL Training Crackdown

About This Event

The Trucksafe team breaks down FMCSA's unprecedented removal of 3,000 CDL training providers from the federal registry.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 57 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by Brian Runnels to examine FMCSA's recent crackdown on entry-level driver training (ELDT) providers, including the removal of nearly 3,000 providers from the Training Provider Registry (TPR) and the placement of another 4,500 on notice for potential non-compliance. The action, announced by Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy in December 2025, is framed as a sweeping enforcement effort targeting fraudulent and non-compliant CDL training providers. However, the hosts dig into the details and raise significant questions about how impactful the move actually is for highway safety. The panel is skeptical of the announcement's framing, noting several discrepancies, including the government's citation of 16,000 providers on the registry when the actual number is closer to 35,000 to 36,000. Upon reviewing the list of removed providers, the hosts find that many are municipalities, fire departments, hospitals, Boy Scout troops, and other entities with little to no relevance to commercial trucking. They draw a parallel to similar announcements around ELD self-certification and the National Registry of Medical Examiners, where headline-grabbing numbers of revocations were largely driven by administrative issues like outdated contact information rather than meaningful enforcement action. Brian Reynolds also raises concern about a subtler fraud risk: legitimate community colleges lending credibility to third-party CDL programs that are operating deceptively. A broader discussion follows on the structural weaknesses of the ELDT program itself. The hosts note that the original FMCSA proposal included minimum hour requirements and more detailed curriculum standards, but those provisions were largely gutted before the rule took effect in 2022. What remained, they argue, is a program designed primarily to get drivers through the CDL skills test rather than produce road-ready professionals. Reynolds emphasizes that the real failure in driver development happens after the CDL is issued, at the carrier level, where finishing programs and on-the-road mentorship are inconsistent and often inadequate. He describes characteristics of effective carrier-based training programs, including trainers riding alongside students rather than teaming with them, and trainer compensation structures that incentivize student success. The hosts offer several actionable takeaways for fleet safety professionals. They strongly recommend that motor carriers not rely solely on a driver's CDL as proof of competency, even though regulations permit it, and instead conduct their own road tests before placing new drivers in service. They also encourage carriers to track the quality of graduates from specific training schools and avoid those consistently producing underqualified drivers. Reynolds argues that carriers should bear meaningful regulatory responsibility for the training and readiness of the drivers they put on public roads, particularly given the catastrophic consequences and legal exposure that come with negligent hiring and entrustment claims. As Reynolds put it, "Who you hire, what you buy, and ultimately who and what you put on the highway is what's going to and should govern your mentality." The episode also briefly covers three other regulatory developments: FMCSA's efforts to more rigorously vet ELD manufacturers following widespread fraud on the self-certification list, the current legal status of the non-domiciled CDL interim final rule, which remains under a court-ordered stay while FMCSA works toward formal rulemaking, and the rollout of FMCSA's new MODERNIZED registration system aimed at streamlining carrier registration and improving fraud prevention. Hosts encourage fleet professionals to subscribe to the Trucksafe newsletter at trucksafe.us/subscribe for ongoing updates on all of these developing issues.

Full Transcript

[bell] Sing it out. [bell] Oh yeah. Oh. Oh. If you're like us, You're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. -igs is always up todate and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. Developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. [singing] [music and singing] Hey everyone, welcome to episode 57 of Truck Safe Live, show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon with Truck Safe and Children's Law, both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs. Got Brian Reynolds, Rob Carpenter with me today, guys. What's up? Not a whole lot. Howdy. What up? Do you Do you like that new intro? You both made the cut on the new intro video there. About time. Yeah, it was good. I I uh I forgot you changed the music. Yeah, I had to cuz they were we got uh got a video pulled for a copyright strike on royalty-free music that I had purchased. So, I don't know what was going on with that. But yeah, anyway, I just said screw it and did a whole new intro video. It was time anyway. Um not that anybody cares, but uh appreciate you all tuning in today. If you're here with us, say hey in the comments so we know who's around. Uh got a lot of shows going on this month. We did one last week. We're going to do one next week. We've got this one here in the middle. A lot going on from a regulatory perspective that uh is worth commenting on. So, I appreciate you taking some time out of your day to join us. Today, we are talking about crackdown on CDL training providers. That was the big news from last week, uh, December of 2025 when we're recording this. So, it's what we're going to break down here in a minute. Before we do, I want to thank the sponsor of this episode, which is Project 61. It aims to improve the life expectancy of CDL drivers by raising awareness, providing resources, and educating drivers on healthier lifestyle. org. Thanks to those guys for helping us out. Um, a few things going on at TruckSafe. Again, if you're not a member of the Truck Safe network, I'd encourage you to join it. com or scan that QR code and download the app in the App Store or the Google Play Store. This is the space that we've built for safety professionals, fleet safety professionals to gather together, learn from one another, ask questions, and access all of our DOT related content. So, hope to see you over there. com/subscribe, which is where we send out u breaking news, our analysis of it, and again, all kinds of free content that's available to help fleets better understand this regulatory environment. So, yeah, do that free. Um, before we get to the topic, the main topic of today, there were a few other news stories, as I said, several that are worth mentioning. The first [clears throat] that I will point out is this one which we actually highlighted in our show last week. Um, and it has to do with FMCSA tightening the reigns on the electronic logging device self-certification process. If you missed the show, it was a great one. Uh we had Tom Cuthbertson on as a guest to talk about um this crackdown and what FMCSA is doing in terms of um more thorough vetting hopefully of electronic logging device manufacturers. What we're seeing is pretty rampant fraud when it comes to these devices not meeting the technical specifications and allowing drivers and carriers to improperly edit drive time on their devices and also offshore actors getting involved in you know editing drivers duty status all you know falsification log falsification type issues and that has gotten FMCSA's attention and it is a byproduct of the way that we uh certify these devices in the US, which is completely different than how Canada does it. In fact, ours isn't any kind of certification process at all. " And so, you end up with thousands of devices on the self-certification list. Carriers buy up some of the lesserk known devices and turns out they're not compliant at all. And then that leaves the carriers and the drivers in a bad place because those devices get yanked from the list and now uh that carrier is going to have to go reinvest in a new solution anyway. So um because of those problems, FMCSA has announced that it intends to more closely vet these training providers or not training providers, EL providers uh going forward. what exactly that means. It's uh a little too early to tell, but um yeah, we had a great conversation about that on the last show of what it could look like and how it differs from Canada's system. So, be sure to check that out. com. Guys, you have any thoughts on that crackdown? Go ahead, Rob. You're the Yeah, you're the ELD guy, man. You you go ahead and touch base on that one first. No, the only thing I was going to say, it kind of kind of touches on our show today. Everything is self-certification. Everything is self attesting. So, I think at some point you have to kind of say at u there has to be some point where there's some kind of validation besides self attesting or attestation. So, yeah, whether it's ELDT or u uh ELDs, it's same issue. Yeah, FMCSA likes its self-certification list coming to find out. So, we've got the ELD, we've got the training provider registry, and we've also got the National Registry of Medical Examiners. All of which are self-certified list, folks claiming that they are compliant with the rules. And then if it turns out that they're not, then we only catch them after the fact, if we catch them at all, after folks have already had problems, run into enforcement problems and stuff like that. So, huge issue. I mean, that's just the nature of a self-certification process. And so now we're starting to see that there have been enough complaints raised to FMCSA that it is stepping in not only in the ALD context, but as we'll talk about here on this show, the training provider registry as well. So that was one issue I wanted to mention. Again, go back and watch that show if you're interested. com. Here's some other news I saw come out uh within the last couple of weeks. This is kind of the ongoing saga of the non-domiciled CDL uh interim final rule that FMCSA passed um a couple months ago. Uh this is something we've been following at Truck Save and also Childress Law. Um, folks will remember maybe that the FMCSA issued that emergency rule which severely cut back on the eligibility, who's eligible to receive these so-called non-domicile CDLs. And it went into effect immediately. It essentially bypassed the normal notice and comment period that typical rulemaking goes through, federal rulem, and um, and made pretty big splash immediately. Several state licensing agencies stopped issuing them alto together as a result of that move and had lots of people up in arms about it. Well, unsurprisingly ended up with a federal lawsuit being filed against FMCSA by some drivers who were impacted by the rule and also some interest groups. Um, and the court in that case, DC circuit court of appeals originally put a pause on the FMCSA's rule, a temporary stay. And then more recently, the development that we've seen is that the FMCSA actually went in and filed a motion to hold the case in obeyance, meaning holding it paused until it could essentially go back and review the 8,000 comments that were submitted in the docket for that rule, and go through the process that it should have just gone through in the beginning, which is the formal notice and comment period. And it's and it indicated to the court that it intends to go through that process now and issue a final rule. based on its review of those 8,000 comments. So, that's what it's working towards. Um, you know, I don't know why they didn't just pursue that uh from the beginning cuz now they've just had to spend a lot of money defending themselves in this lawsuit and it's left people uh carriers and drivers and state licensing agencies with a lot of uncertainty over the last couple of months and so here we are. So, that's the latest development. That rule is not effective right now because it's under stay by that DC Circuit Court of Appeals. So FMCSA is going to go back to the drawing board potentially after it reviews those comments and come out with a final rule that if I had to guess will probably be similar to but probably not quite as [clears throat] as um I don't know what word I would use. Probably not quite as aggressive as the interim final rule was. That that would be my estimation. thoughts on this, guys? Yeah, a couple thoughts on this real quick. One, that doesn't stop the enforcement of, you know, drivers that are out there that are already on the expired work visas and even though they have a current license, that's not stopping the enforcement of pulling those drivers off the road. And another a thing that we we've started to see uh quite honestly at TVC is drivers that have been cited for this roadside. The officers are not pulling them off the road right there. They're not getting involved in this immigration side. They're issuing citations. And this is this has happened in Alabama. They're issuing citations where the driver has to appear in court. It's not an issue where they can hire an attorney or they can um or they can hire an attorney, but the driver still has to show up in court and then they're getting arrested at court. What are they cited for? What's the violation you're usually seeing? Um I I think it's not having a active work. You know what? I don't know exactly what the citation is. um recently and then the driver has to show up in court and they're getting arrested there. Yeah. I mean, it's just another one of those debacles where the way that it was handled ends up with all kinds of confusion from all different stakeholders that could have probably been avoided had we have just gone through the process, the normal process that's set out to avoid this type of confusion, which is the normal rulemaking process. Cuz now, you're right. " And so, now you're left with a patchwork of state laws and how they're handling this issue. And so, if you're a carrier that has operations in multiple states, now you're having to look up what are the rules in all of these different states, how are they handling it? So, um, not a great not a great look for the agency, not a great place to be for carriers or drivers who are, uh, who are using these types of licenses or drivers that have these types of license. I think I think we'll see more targeting for targeted enforcement like we saw in Oklahoma, Indiana, Arkansas, uh, where ICE is setting up in scale houses and they're checking CDLs and they're going to check them against work permits and they're they're going to pull drivers off the road. happen. Yeah, we saw that in Indiana, too, right? A big blitz. Yeah. Yeah. It was like 93 drivers, I think they got. Yeah. So, be on the lookout for that. We will continue um posting any updates that we receive. We're tracking that lawsuit. There's not going to be much development on that lawsuit because, like I said, it's held in obeyance pending the FMCSA's action on the rulem. If I had to guess, the next thing that we'll see is going to be some kind of a rule making notice from FMCSA probably in January would be my best guess. So, be on the lookout for that newsletter. Our newsletter is where you could get um up-to-date information on that. com/subscribe. All right, last thing I wanted to mention before we move into today's topic. Uh Rob's been publishing a bunch of articles over at Freightways. Be sure to follow him over there. Rob, you posted this article about FMCSA's new modus registration system and kind of a modernization of their registration system. You want to kind of walk us through basically what it what it entails? Um, yeah. Do you even remember what you wrote? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's uh it's it's really meant to streamline registration process for for carriers. That's that's really it. I mean, we're kind of in the in the stone age. we've kind of used the same one forever and and now they're updating it. It did kick off this month, but I think it it really truly rolls out in January, I think. And it rolls out in a kind of a staggered or or a step pattern, right? So, the first roll out is really a change from for insurance providers and BOC3 agents um and how they have to register in the system to be able to make filings on behalf of their motorare clients. if I understood correctly. Yeah, basically. Okay. But eventually it's going to roll out. It's going to be a whole new system for even motor carriers too. And then from what I could tell, um, and you know, we covered this back at Matts. I remember talking about this because they had a whole team, FMCSA had a whole registration team at Matts talking about this roll out and it's heavily focused on fraud prevention. And so there's going to be some level uh additional levels of identif uh identity verification baked into the new system once it rolls out. And this is also the same change that was originally supposed to see the end of MC numbers [clears throat] uh for carriers that have to have four higher operating authority. It was originally uh planned that we're going to do away with those and instead just have the US DOT number serve as the single point of you know single identifying registration number, but I think they came off of that, didn't they? That's not going to take effect in in anytime in the near future. It was supposed to go in in effect in a in October and it didn't. " And they honestly said they responded back and basically said, "It's to be determined. we haven't made our mind up yet was essentially the written response that I got. Stay tuned. Yeah. And then here we are with modus. gesture we we got a we are not changing this world. Not going to happen. Okay. That's what it sounds like. Well, we'll have to wait and see. Um okay. So obviously like I said a lot going on in the industry from a regulatory standpoint. Uh on today's show, we wanted to touch on another one of those topics coming out of FMCSA this month, again, December of 2025 if you're watching later, which is the announcement that it is tightening the reigns on entry-level driver training providers and has taken action to remove 3,000 training providers as of the date of this recording uh from the training provider registry with 4,000 more providers in the crosshairs. So this move raises many questions including some foundational ones like is the CDL training system as a whole broken? And so I know you guys have lots of thoughts on this having both been training providers in past lives yourselves and also CDL holders yourselves. So uh you guys wrote a great article um that we published over at Truck Safe. If anybody's interested in checking that out, you can check it out there. But I also wanted to get you on here to get your thoughts about this. I know you've got lots of them. So, I guess um first things first, maybe what we'll do is we'll start off by looking at this announcement from FMCSA to clear up any kind of um uh fake news that's out there on what exactly it does. So, here I'm just going to read the notice that FMCSA published. Actually, US DOT published this. It's titled Trump's Transportation Secretary Shawn Duffy cracks down on illegal providers of commercial driver's license test training centers. Um, then it goes on to say that Shawn Duffy has announced the removal of nearly 3,000 CDL training providers from the FMCSA's training provider registry for failing to equip trainees with the Trump administration standards of readiness. Another 4,500 training providers were placed on notice due to potential non-compliance. And here's a quote from Shawn Duffy, transportation secretary. He says, "This administration is cracking down on every link in the illegal trucking chain under Joe Biden and Pete Buddhajedge. Bad actors were able to game the system and let unqualified drivers flood our roadways. Their negligence endangered ver every family on America's roadways and it ends today. " goes on to say, "Training provider registry lists all providers authorized to offer federally required entry-level driver training for CDL students. It's the first step in FMCSA's review of the 16,000 training providers listed on the registry to identify and remove non-compliant providers. These providers are being removed from the TPR due to what US DOT says is falsifying or manipulating training data, neglecting to meet required curriculum standards, facility conditions, or instructor qualifications, and failing to maintain accurate, complete documentation, or refusing to provide records during federal audits or investigations. Um, notice goes on a little bit, but that's about all the detail they have on on the action that they are taking at the moment. I have talked with um some clients that have reported that they have gotten audit notices about uh about these types of audits and I know you guys have looked at the training provider registry and see some familiar names on on the registry that have been revoked and so they are doing something here and uh but I think after discussions with you guys the question is is it really as aggressive as it seems in in that notice so that's what we'll talk about um but maybe we'll start with initial question here. What surprised you guys most about this announcement of the nearly 3,000 training providers that were removed from the registry? Well, for the for the notice, I would say what surprised me the most was where they got their numbers from. So, it's it said in the notice that there was 16,000 in the registry, but there's actually like 35 36,000. Yeah, that didn't make any sense to me. I don't know where they got Yeah, I don't know where those numbers came from. um especially since it was the government that put the numbers out. But it's their ELDT program that has 36,000, not 16. But then it's how many actually got yanked off, right? There's only uh three or 4,000. I mean, some others got put under notice, but that's a drop in the bucket to 36. So there's a lot lower when we're talking public, but after Yeah, there you go. over close to 35,000 providers. that doesn't even get close to 16. So yeah, I'm with you. I don't know where they got the 16,000 number. But I I think what's kind of the the bigger shocking factor beyond the data element is um you have to look at who's in the registry. I mean, there's all kinds of there's church groups, there's Boy Scouts, there's things that really make they don't affect us hardly at all, right? So I I don't know. I don't know to what extent it'll it'll actually help the the issues. Um I think for me, if you go back and look at ELDT as a whole, one one issue for me is the duration of it. It it really is just a two a two-piece thing from the federal government. One, you have the registry, which is all the feds do. They have a registry where you can go in and log in and sign up to be a provider and that's it. And then they provide a curriculum, but they don't even provide duration times for completion and they do not provide any content to go with the curriculum. So it's a really fractured system across the board. of required topics, right? Yeah, that's it. So it's all relying on what each individual state is actually putting together. yeah, somebody on YouTube, somebody on YouTube with the handle broken CDL system. Wonder what his thoughts are on on this system is saying the FMCSA must look at themselves how they have watered down the ELDT program. I think uh we are all kind of in agreement that that is the truth. Although I will say, I mean, remember back, you don't have to remember back too far before ELDT, which was just prior to 2022. We didn't have any kind of entry- level driver training requirement. Um, anybody could go as long as they could go past the test at their DMV, they could get a CDL, you know, maybe with no training whatsoever. And so watered [clears throat] down, I guess, in the sense that watered it down from what it could have been based on the original proposal. I think that's what Rob is getting at, which is in the original proposal for the ELDT that the FMCSA had envisioned, there were things like minimum hours requirements and maybe some more indepth uh discussion of what the curriculum would require, but not watered down in the sense of what we had sometime in the past. Yeah. And I I think I think even his comment, what was the name of that guy? Broken CDL system. Yeah. Um, in terms of looking at FMCSA, actually Jack was there at at the time at FMCSA and I know that they they put a lot of effort into this program and the way that it was originally drafted, like you said, it had a lot of these pieces in it originally and then you had policy makers who gutted it and then when it became an actual rag, it was completely different than the original intention. policymakers likely at the behest of the interest groups that inevitably get involved in the rule making process and lobby to get things taken out of the rule that the FMCSA had originally intended. No doubt. Yeah. I'm not going to name who those interest groups are, but I'm just saying. Yeah. All right, Brian, I know you're chopping at the bit here. Let's hear it. Yeah, they there's a couple things that that I want to address on this. You you kind of touched you kind of touched on it. The job of a school is to get a someone to pass the test. That is all. And you know, they put all this extra theory in to the ELDT. Well, as long as that can be done online, there's going to be fraud. Um, you know, if I'm not that strong in that stuff, shoot, I'll have Rob do it and Rob can make a few bucks doing it for me, him, anybody else that wants to do it. The actual behind the wheel stuff, that didn't change all that much from what was previously put out there. So, if you can pass the test, the job school is or the school's job is complete and they succeeded in what they had to do. And you know, I know we're we're kind of leading down towards what happens after that. Uh and that that's where the epic failure is in the program. So, you know, let let's kind of keep it in context of what these training providers job actually is and how much blame we should actually put there because it's not near as much as somebody that takes these drivers after the fact and completely fails them on training them and getting them ready to to have a job out on the road. So, let's go there. So you've run a training program uh in the past. Was it for a carrier specifically or was it an independent training program? I can't remember. It was for a carrier. Okay. So what when you were running that program, I mean what was your philosophy behind what it was that you were doing? to put a driver out there better than any school could possibly do? And you know we we had it set up. They came to us with a permit and that was it. And we trained them to the test to get them to pass the test. And then our trainer program was very well put together. Our trainers did a great job. And we would have them out with a trainer for somewhere four to six weeks as a solo. And even when I was training over the road, I I I didn't think of this program all, you know, on my own. This was a program that I was involved in. A driver doesn't learn, a new driver doesn't learn if the truck's being operated as a team. I'm I I'll argue that with anybody. Uh a student's not learning if the trainer's in the bunk and vice versa. So, you know, giving them the four to six weeks of one-on-one instruction instead of trying to make your training program a profit center by running extra miles with cheap labor because it's a student. Um, that makes a world of difference. And you know, it all comes it even comes down to pay structure, how you pay your trainers. if if they have a vested interest in a student succeeding and they're seeing a piece of that for a certain period of time after the student gets out, that's your profit center, both for your trainer and for the company. " And those are the ones we see the videos of that they can't even back up because they haven't had experience backing more than two or three times. " Or, you know, somebody that went through a a quote unquote four to six week program but was completely exhausted because they were running nights the whole time while their trainer slept. Um it it it happens every day. I know it's happening, but you know, programs that I put together, they were not set up like that. they were documented weekly. Uh, and you also have to give your trainers the ability to say this isn't working out and not override them. If you can't trust your trainers, then either a you shouldn't have a program or b that driver shouldn't be a trainer. So, let me ask you this. Do you think it was a mistake then that we even came out with this whole ELDT concept? Because if it's not serving a purpose other than to get somebody to pass the test and it's [clears throat] it's not making them a safer driver, then then what's really the point of it? Why why do why would regulators be concerned about putting a program in place that just teaches to the test without generating or were they under the delusion that this was going to result in safer drivers? Yeah, they're ignorant to the fact that of what the school's jobs are. uh they just saw, you know, it's lowhanging fruit. Hey, we'll put all these extra rules on the very very beginning of a driver's career and that'll make everything better. So, I I don't think that it was very well thought out. it's probably a band-aid, you know, cuz FMCSA is always under pressure. Um, usually after bad accidents, especially if the NTSB gets involved, NTSB starts making recommendations to how do we prevent these really bad accidents from from happening. If I remember correctly, there were several NTSB recommendations to FMCSA specifically that they mandate some type of formalized training uh in order to get a CDL. " But it seems like the result is just a uh, you know, a bunch of red tape that doesn't make us safer on the back end. Well, I think one of the one of the ways you can make things more efficient and to make people more proficient is to to have a centralized platform and that's I think really what they were shooting for is hey if we put this curriculum out there where everybody has to learn and become educated on the following items then we can at least make it somewhat centralized of what they're learning instead of it's still a fractured program but it's still not as fractured as it was before because before you it was really the wild west like you said we didn't have any standards so it was every school and every state for itself it's still every state for itself but they at least have a curriculum that they have to say yes, we are covering the following modules for behind the wheel theory and u so I I think all that's I think that's good. I just think after it got gutted it kind of eliminated the need for the entire program because there wasn't enough in there to actually guarantee proficiency with what was in there. Well, and it also led to what should have been easily foreseeable, which is this flooding of the market. You know, anytime the DOT sets up a required something that's required and the DOT is not offering the resources to help carriers meet that directly, then it sets up an incentive for the market to be flooded by all these people who just want to make a buck from the fact that carriers and drivers have to check the box in order to meet that standard. And you end up with this inevitable situation where you've got all these training providers trying to make a buck off the fact that the that the drivers have to just check this box in order to take the next step, which is to go take the test and and to pass it. So that seems like an inevitable byproduct of this type of of rulem unfortunately. " And on the other hand, when we get drivers from certain schools, as a trainer, we didn't have to do a whole lot because, man, they were good and, you know, they they knew what they're they were doing and it was a really pleasurable experience to to train them. So, I think that falls on the motor carrier as well to to keep track of those and stop using training providers that are putting out garbage. Yeah. because they can put out thousands and thousands of drivers, but if motor carriers aren't using them, they're going to go away. Yeah. Few comments here. Let's see. Lesie on LinkedIn saying, uh referring back to something you said, Brian. She said that's a big deal regarding team training, which we did not do at Melton. When I give presentations to students, I highly recommend they avoid teaming. our trainer sit next to the student to help guide coach and learn the lifestyle of otr driving. That's 100% correct. If you know that the trainer should be sitting there on duty, not driving that whole time. And you know, she's exactly right that teaching them the lifestyle. I know trip planning is a complete lost art. So, you know, teaching a driver the trip planning, how to do what to do with your downtime as a solo driver, um, and things like that, that sets them up for success just as much as knowing how to back into a dock door. Yeah. If not more. Tyler, our colleague Tyler on LinkedIn is saying, "But driver shortage, right? " Tyler's being sarcastic. Yeah, he is. backing away from that terminology over the last few months from, you know, associations where it's now it's quality over quantity. Mhm. But yeah, I think he's right that I'm sure that had a lot to do or that factored very heavily into the rule that we ended up with, the ELDT rule that we ended up with. Why would we put all of these pressures like time, minimum time requirements, and detailed curriculum in place if we're dealing with a so-called driver shortage? Uh that's just going to eat into the capacity issue. And so, yeah, I have no doubt that that played into it. I mean, there there was there was some other programs that kind of went long. I had touched on this in in a group chat that we had was and I've never heard anybody mention this program, but when I was in the private equity side when ELDT came out, we were like, well, what are we going to do? Where are we going to come up with all these, right? We already have an issue finding drivers for the mode that we're operating in. So, I did some digging, created matrixes for the requirements for every state to open these ELDT schools as providers in different states that where we really needed it. in California has the California employer testing program where as long as it's not paid, you can train your own employees and you can be a third-party examiner internally and get them their license. So, everything is completely in-house as an employer. So, it's kind of like the the fox guarding the hen house, so to speak. So, I always kind of programs are crazy, but it's not the only one that exists. yeah. I don't know. It's it's kind of like who's who's running all of these programs and it's still so fractured that it's really not one, it's 50 plus. Yeah. So, something uh I know both of you already kind of touched on this, but just to get at it more directly, something I wanted to highlight, you both looked through the list of training providers that have been removed and had some interesting findings in in the ones that were listed as as having been removed. So, let's talk about that. Brian, you want to go through that? Yeah, sure. There's a ton of municipalities in there. Uh, police, fire, ambulance training. Uh, like Rob said, there was we found a a few boy scout troops. Um, hospitals. Um, what other was it? Church groups. Um, so yeah. And the amount of different construction type. There you go. Right there. There's a construction company. I know there's a list of the revoked ones. Where's that at? I was going to pull that up. [clears throat] you you keep I'm gonna I'm gonna find it. Yeah, I just I actually just Googled that um and then went through the list. So, you know, there's a there's a ton of the village of XYZ. There was a bunch of those. Uh U-Haul had eight. I'm not exactly sure why, but they they had eight entries. Uh because you got to remember that each and you you were informed me of this earlier today. I I couldn't remember if you're doing behind the wheel training, each location has to be registered. And I had forgot about that. So, you know, there's a lot of duplicates, triplicates, and types of vehicles that we're not talking about when it comes to what the FMCSA is going after and, you know, what the associations are are concerned with. It's ambulances and fire trucks and police cars and you know different stuff like that. Yeah, this is to be a little critical of the US DOT and FMCSA with all due respect. We've seen this a lot with some of their announcements that they've made recently on a lot of this reg a lot of these regulatory developments. They'll put out these press releases that will highlight the sweeping supposed sweeping action that they've taken to crack down on enforcement. I'm thinking things that come to mind, English language proficiency, non-domicile CDLs, uh, ELD self-certification, this issue. But then when you start to dig into any one of those, it's pretty quickly obvious to anybody that puts any amount of effort into it that it's not quite as dramatic as what it seems like if you're just to read the press releases for many of the reasons you mentioned here in this context, Brian. Um, a lot of these uh and we also saw this with the um ELD self-certification. If you true enough, there have been hundreds of devices revoked from the self-certification list. But if you start to dig in, you quickly realize that most of those are in or voluntary revocations by the manufacturers themselves because either they've come out with a new model of the device or they're just out of business. And so when you look at the ones that the DOT itself revoked, the list gets down to like 60 or 70 within the la over the last 6 years. So, and the same thing seems to be true here as we're looking as we're digging into the list of training providers that have been removed from the registry. You start to see uh some things um popping out at you like that. Like, hey, a lot of these are probably entities that aren't even pushing out any drivers. And if they are, maybe it's one or two here or there. These aren't the ones that are pushing out thousands of drivers, at least from what we could tell. Um so, I think that's a problem. I I think we should be a little more transparent in the way that we characterize what exactly has been done and what is being done to to really get to the root of the issue here. Well, and I think the lowhanging fruit on this stuff is they probably didn't keep their just some of their paperwork requirements up to date. So, it made it real easy to take them off. and we saw that with a medical provider registry, right? So, earlier this year, I think it was earlier this year, they removed like 15,000 medical examiners from the registry. But then when you dug into it, the reason that they were removed is not because they were doing bogus medical exams. It's because they failed to update their email addresses on the registry. And so likely many of those have been put back on um because it was just a a paperwork issue. So I don't um I don't want to say I don't know why we do that, but because I think I do know why we do that, but I think being a little more transparent in the notices is warranted. That's just some friendly advice. I think one of the things that I found in this in the in the registry period is I I think they're focusing on a lot of this lowhanging fruit that is clearly whether Boy Scouts of America, construction companies, things that fire and life and emergency responders, these are all lowhanging fruit, right? Like we kind of may have the idea that this is not necessary. We can remove them easily. I think one of the bigger problems they're going to have is in in fraudulent schools is when you have community colleges and universities that are legitimate and then they're basically contracting out their CDL program to a third party CDL school and it's basically the school lending credibility to a bad program that are that you're not seeing. Right. So I I think those are the scarier ones. We we've had some in Virginia, one of which I I played a part in closing down, but it was actually run by the mob in a [snorts] community college. Didn't know it. And they were basically charging. As your lawyer, I'm going to advise you to not not be talking about your mob connections here on this podcast. Like 36% interest these people were charging for student loans. So it was u it was basically a contract arrangement with community colleges. So people were seeing community colleges, they're thinking, "Hey, it's got to be legitimate. " So it's um that's the bigger issue, I think, is trying to weed through the ones that aren't as apparent u apparently fraudulent. All right. So, we've identified the problem and some of our concerns with the action that's been taken and I think we all agree that the system as it is is broken and it's leading to drivers who shouldn't be getting their CDL getting their CDL and operate and drivers who have their CDL who shouldn't be out there operating without more in-depth training out there operating. It's leading to uh you know safety issues. And so, if you guys I'll put it to you guys. If you could go back to the drawing board and design the system from scratch, how would how would you recommend or what are some of the major things you would recommend the DOT consider uh if we were to rework the system? One would be some sort of I don't know if I want to use the word registry again, but some sort of program that finishing schools are put in and they have to actually submit what they're doing and you you know all this stuff that was supposed to be on the front end you know for ELDT but now it's on the back end puts the responsibility on the motor carrier that if you're going to train these drivers and you're going to put them out there. That's where the risk comes in. So, they should be responsible for the risk. if we've seen crashes with big verdicts, how often do they go back to the school that got them their CDL? Never. because it's it's really it's not I hate to say it's not that big of a deal as it is who's finishing that student and putting them out there. Um and if you're if you're training drivers and and you're doing a crappy job of it, man, you you need to be taken out of the system. Yeah. Putting putting aside training obligations on motor carriers, [clears throat] one of the things that we always harp on, I know all three of us do um that motor carriers should be doing now that many of them aren't because they're taking advantage of an exemption in in the regulations. If they hire CDL drivers, there's an exemption that says they can just accept a copy of their CDL as proof that they're safe to operate in lie of doing a road test of the driver, actually putting eyes on them in their ability to safely operate their trucks. So, a lot of carriers take advantage of that exemption. They don't even put eyes on the driver before they just let them turn them loose in the truck. They just get a copy of their CDL. They think, "Okay, they got their CDL. They must be properly trained. " We all think that's a mistake. We think you should be, even though the regulations don't technically require it, we think you should be putting eyes on all of your drivers that you are putting in the seats. Um, again, that's putting aside the whole training issue. It's it's just something it's lowhanging fruit. It's something you could do easily to mit mitigate your exposure as the motor carrier that hires those drivers and puts them on the road. There are some insurance carriers as well. We touched this base on this a while back on a different show. But there are insurance carriers that don't require a driver list. Yeah. So, you know, you don't road test them. You don't have to really worry about them on your insurance. So, sure, why not? That stuff's got to stop. Yeah. Tyler's responding to something you said, Brian, I think. He said, "How can FMCSA meaningfully investigate the training schools for compliance? " I think that's that's the truth. I think that's a big problem. Huge huge issue. And you know, it comes down to any of these registries or any of the initiatives that they want to do. You know, I think are we down below a thousand people now in the FMCSA? Mhm. Yeah. I mean, and there's 700,000 carriers and three and a half million drivers that they're supposed to be in charge of. you know, we talk about all this stuff, but it'll it'll it won't happen because they just don't have the manpower to enforce it. Yeah. All right, Rob, let's hear your thoughts on some of the big picture items that FMCSA could think about if it were to go back to the drawing board on this. You're muted. Muted, Brandon, I cut my voice off. Um, I think it's about the substance of the program really because you have to go back to the drawing board. There's so much that's not here. It's one thing to develop a curriculum, but then to not have some kind of centralized assessment, whether it's formative or uh otherwise, that's universal for everybody that's overseen by one centralized source. So just throwing a curriculum out there and telling everybody in 50 states that are under 50 different rule structures to go register as a provider and then say we promise to obey the rules of instructor qualifications and school and education requirements for the state of Virginia um or California or wherever. So I I think the big part of it is just like any other fractured program, you have to fix the fractured part of the program and make it more centralized. And that's why a lot of people are saying, why don't we make the CDLs more federal instead of statebystate CDL license um and then you could have that centralized federal basically review of the whole process and control of the process. " Like, just make sure you kind of follow the policies as you interpret. The CDL program, yeah, to respond to that specifically, you know, CDL program, as we all know, is a federally regulated program. And so the baseline rules that govern the different types of classes, class A, class B, class C, all of the different endorsements, all of the different restrictions are developed and implemented at the federal level. So they are uniform from state to state in that sense. But you're right in terms of administering the program and actually you know administering the test and who get and deciding who gets to get these licenses that are governed by the FMCSA that's all up to the states and it leads to the inevitable kind of patchwork of uh quality control at the state level. So yeah good point. Clint here is also raising another good point. He says the lack of a clear definition of proficient is a huge problem. Current definition is too subjective. Huge part of the problem. Do the regulations use the term proficient in this context? Not that I'm aware of, but I think the point is still well taken. How do we decide whether somebody who goes through one of these programs should have been allowed to progress through the program or not? Well, I mean, it's pretty easy to go CDO, right? I mean, if you if if we're looking at test passing centers versus education providers, you're really looking for basically three things. One, can you name at least what 120 parts of a truck? And what can go wrong with those 120 parts? If you can complete that part, can you back straight? Can you back at a 45 and 90 degree within so many attempts? And then, can you go out and drive on the highway for 10 minutes with an examiner? And if you can do all three of those things, then you have a CBO. That's not difficult to be proficient in those three things. And and that's why a lot of times I say that it was 80% of what I learned was on the highway, not in a school. So I I think I think how you're going to structure the program is going to make a big difference, but there has to be an element of that program that's a lot more than 10 minutes of behind the wheel time examiner. and can back up. And to make clear make sure I'm clear on your thoughts on this, Brian, when [clears throat] you say that you think carriers should take a more active role in this, are you envisioning a regulatory scheme where they have a regulatory obligation to do that? Or are you just saying as best practice they should be more hands-on with this stuff? Boy, it would be great to say, hey, as a best practice, we're going to do this. But the problem is is there's so many bad actors that there needs to there has to be something in place that keeps them accountable. Um, you know, I I know what we say, you know, we're already regulated to the hilt. Well, agreed we are, but what's stopping anybody from putting horrible drivers on the road there? Right now, there isn't anything stopping that cuz like Rob said, if you can do the memorization part of the pre-trip and you can make do some basic maneuvering and do a road course, you've got the CDL. So, what happens after that? Yeah, it's it would be great to say, yeah, everybody has not only the students best interest in mind, but the motoring public's best interest in mind. And frankly, that's just not the case in in many many cases. Folks may not remember, but before the ELDT as we know it today went into effect in 2022, there was a carrier requirement on the books to provide what was called entry- level driver training to any drivers that they hired, any CDL drivers that they hired that had less than one year of driving experience at another motor carrier. And that regulation said that it was the motor carrier's obligation to provide this training to those that group of drivers. And the problem was it went on to say here's the topics you have to train them on. And it was like four topics. And all it said was like hours of service, driver qualification, vehicle maintenance, and driver wellness was on there. That's what I remember from the rule. And so then it just completely left it up to the carrier to decide what how to satisfy their obligation. What it essentially amounted to in many cases [clears throat] was, you know, just like a half hour conversation or video that they showed to the drivers and then had them fill out a five question test and then they stuffed that in the file and that's what you ended up with for the carriermandated training that existed at the time. That went away with this ELDT requirement. But yeah, I mean that's that's tricky for all the reasons you mentioned. I think you have to look at car carriers like not everybody is going to be concerned about the moral and ethical responsibilities of sharing the road with other drivers, right? So like you have hope trans out there, you have White Hawk, all these other carriers out there that that catastrophic crashes because they employed people they shouldn't have been hired. And that's why a lot of times when when I speak at these conferences or or we're out there, the big point that I that I push out there is who you hire, what you buy, and ultimately who and what you put on the highway is what's going to and should govern your mentality of that hiring and buying equipment and and what you're putting out there. But again, not everyone's going to think about that. Yeah, Dusty on What is the cheapest thing I can do? Dusty on LinkedIn is echoing that. He says, "Wait until you're sitting on the witness stand trying to explain why your driver killed someone and you don't and you have to say, "I don't know. Yeah, that's that's right. Um that situation, you're going to be forced in that situation and you're not going to have a compelling story to tell. And so that's probably going to be lights out for you. That's all it's going to take to end that carrier. But yeah, I mean that's that's all that's the that's the only motivation really to get carriers to buy into this now is that potential exposure. But so many motor carriers nowadays are so shortsighted that they're not even thinking to that. This is the battle we all fight on a daily basis with our uh you know with our platforms and the motor carrier clients that we have is we and we've said this a million times, but we're such a reactive industry when it comes to these types of things that we don't even start to think about these things. until the bad accident happens and now it's too late to implement any of these best practices that we all have have preached about for years. And so, [clears throat and cough] you know, without without having the regulatory mandate to do these types of things, you're really relying on them being more proactive. And I just worry um I'm cynical that getting carriers to that point where they can be proactive in that regard is is just not going to happen. Well, and as a a thought here towards the end, you know, he just stated it there and on that that uh chat, imagine if the threat of, you know, we all hate these nuclear verdicts. We hate the the big cost of all this stuff. Can you imagine if the threat of that went away for some carriers? You want to talk about turning trucking into the Wild West? Because as we've seen regulatory wise, it it's mediocre at best. And if the threat of of those types of things went away, you imagine what carriers would do? Yeah. You mean if carriers weren't on the hook for the negligence of their drivers? Yeah. [clears throat] No. No. Nobody would be doing anything. Yeah. Right. Exactly. So, I mean that is a hor it is a horrible thing for carriers, those big verdicts, but giny Christmas if if that's the only thing that's keeping them semi in line for some of them. Um, it's almost got to be there because we can't can't seem to do it regulatorally. Yeah. Right. All right. Final thoughts, Rob, as we wrap up here. No, I think that's probably it. just who who you hire and what you buy and who and what you put on the road is is important. It's got an effect on carriers and then everybody else that you share the road with. All right. Well, like I said, this is kind of a developing issue. We will continue to track any uh breaking news in this regard and report out on it. So, stay tuned. Uh subscribe to We're posting all this stuff on all of our um social media channels and also our newsletter stuff like that. So, if you want a source for that, check it out. Also, be sure to tune in next week. Like I said, we got another show next week. Uh next week, we're doing our uh annual year-end review, looking back over the last year, what has happened from a regulatory standpoint, what are the big developments, and also a look into 2026, what fleets and drivers can expect in terms of rulemaking activity and that type of stuff. So, that's always a pretty popular show. m. Eastern time. com. We'll hope to catch you then. Other than that, anything I missed, guys? I don't think so. I think we're good. All right. Well, thanks for everybody for tuning in. Really appreciate it. We'll catch you next time. See you.

Event Completed

Wednesday, December 10, 2025 at 1:57 PM EST

Watch on YouTube