Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 58 - 2025 Year in Review & 2026 Outlook

Wednesday, December 17, 2025 at 1:57 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 58 - 2025 Year in Review & 2026 Outlook

About This Event

On this episode, we break down the top 10 regulatory developments of 2025 and what they mean for fleets heading into 2026.

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 58 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman, Rob Carpenter, Tyler Bidd, and Jared Childress deliver their annual year-end review of the most significant regulatory developments affecting the trucking industry in 2025, while offering a forward-looking outlook on what fleets and drivers should expect heading into 2026. The episode covers a wide range of topics, from new agency leadership and enforcement priorities to pending rulemaking and emerging legal issues, making it an essential listen for fleet safety professionals preparing for the year ahead. The hosts begin by examining the impact of the new DOT and FMCSA leadership, including Secretary Sean Duffy and newly confirmed FMCSA Administrator Derek Bars, noting that while the administration has been active, some of its initiatives reflect repackaged or revived policies rather than entirely new ones. They discuss the formal withdrawal of the long-debated speed limiter mandate and contrast it with the finalized emergency automatic braking requirement for model year 2029 vehicles, with the group largely agreeing that automatic braking represents a more meaningful safety intervention. The episode then turns to the significant crackdown on English language proficiency enforcement, which has resulted in over 9,000 driver out-of-service violations since enhanced enforcement began in June. The hosts highlight ongoing inconsistencies in enforcement across states, particularly California's near-total refusal to place drivers out of service for ELP violations, and note the lack of clear guidance for carriers and drivers seeking to remediate ELP violations. The hosts also address the controversial non-domicile CDL interim final rule, which was stayed by the DC Circuit Court of Appeals after legal challenges from drivers, advocacy groups, and states. Despite the stay, the rule has already had a measurable impact on driver capacity and freight rates, with several states voluntarily pausing issuance of non-domicile CDLs. The group anticipates FMCSA will move relatively quickly to issue a revised final rule through the standard notice-and-comment rulemaking process. Additional topics include the troubled rollout of the fully electronic medical examiner certificate system, the agency's crackdown on ELD self-certification and fraudulent devices, and ongoing scrutiny of entry-level driver training providers listed on the Training Provider Registry. Looking ahead to 2026, the hosts identify several issues deserving close attention from fleet safety professionals. These include the Supreme Court's upcoming ruling in Montgomery v. Kuribbe on broker liability under the Carmack Amendment's safety exception, the potential rescheduling of marijuana by the federal government and its implications for DOT drug testing programs, and the continued absence of federal regulatory guidance on autonomous trucking operations. The hosts also emphasize that carriers should closely monitor the evolving medical examiner certificate transition, ensure ELD devices remain on the active certification list, and track any changes to non-domicile CDL requirements that could affect driver qualification files and hiring decisions. Fleet safety professionals are encouraged to review their driver qualification processes in light of the medical card transition, audit their ELD providers for continued registry compliance, and develop internal English language proficiency assessment protocols to reduce roadside enforcement risk. The hosts recommend subscribing to the Trucksafe newsletter and joining the Trucksafe Network for ongoing regulatory updates and analysis as these issues continue to develop throughout 2026.

Full Transcript

Oh. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. Is always upto-date and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. Was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. Hey everyone, welcome to episode 58 of Truck Safe Live. show where we and our gas tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon with Truck Safe and Children's Law, both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs. Got Rob Carpenter, Tyler Bidd, Jared Childress with me today. Merry Christmas, guys. Almost. Yeah. Merry Christmas. All right, this is it. This is our annual year-end review show. taking a look back at everything that has happened from a regulatory standpoint. Worth noting I guess uh over the last 12 months and then looking ahead to what fleets and drivers uh may need to be planning for come 2026. So always excited to do this show. Uh it helps to kind of you know prepare us for the new year and what to expect from a rule making perspective and also litigation that type of stuff. the the big issues impacting motor carriers. So, that's what we're going to do today. If you're here with us live, say hey in the comments so we know who's around. Want to of course thank the sponsor of today's show, which is Project 61. It aims to improve improve the life expectancy of CDL drivers by raising awareness, providing resources, and educating drivers on a healthier lifestyle. org. Um, couple things going on at Truck Safe. As always, if you're not a member of the Truck Safe Network, uh, I'd encourage you to join it. It's free to join. com. It's the space we've built for fleet safety professionals to gather together, learn from one another, and ask questions, and also access all of our DOT related content, including these podcast, but also all of the free videos we push out, articles. Rob's been writing a lot of articles for us recently on some important topics, so you'll get access to all of those. And then also discounts [clears throat] on any kind of in-person conferences like our boot camp that we put on each year. So, it's a great resource. Hope to see you over there. And lastly, I'll just mention our TruckSafe newsletter. If you're not subscribed to it yet, I'd encourage you to do that. comsubscribe. And that is just the newsletter we push out usually weekly. um touching on any breaking news and our analysis of it when it comes to trucking regulation. So, hope to see you there, too. Guys, anything else going on before we kick the show off? I know we got a lot to talk about. Anything else we should talk about before we get to the main topic? Nothing for me. Nope. You guys are lively today. [snorts] All right. Like I said, we've done this show now. this type of show going on about 5 years sort of year-end review and regulatory outlook for the new year. Taking a look back at the most significant developments in trucking regulation and enforcement in 2025 and what fleets and drivers might expect in that regard in 2026. So, I figured best place to start is taking a look back at uh some of the major news stories we saw in 2025. many of which has have happened in the last few months for anybody that's following these news stories. But in no particular order here, uh, first thing worth mentioning is of course the new administration both from USD do perspective with Shawn Duffy being installed as the new secretary of transportation and then also Derek Bars more recently getting confirmed by the US Senate to the position of FMCSA administrator. So, um, you know, it's been, as we've said in the past, pretty much a revolving door at FMCSA. Had a ton of different administrators in that position since the agency has been around since 2000. We've had over a dozen different administrators, I think. But, um, yeah, guys, thoughts on, uh, this new administration. We've seen quite a bit of activity that they've already started to roll out um over the last several months, which is a deviation from what I can tell from the last several years where we haven't seen all that much new regulation or crackdown in uh in enforcement or anything like that. Thoughts? I mean, they've been busy for sure. Um, but I I think some of it is some of it's new stuff, but some of it's regurgitated old stuff that looks like new stuff. And one of the things that that's almost verbatim is the um the Archie system for Chameleon Carriers, which we we'll get into. It's on the list. But um you know, when Archie came out, that's been 12 years ago, but if you look at the memo that came out this year, it's almost identical to the Archie setup that was put out in 2013, 2014. So, some of it's brand new. Some of it I think people just forgot about. Some of it is just repackaged. Um, I think that's been the consistent thing I've seen. You know, some of this stuff, if you just read the, we talked about this last show, uh, but if you just read the press releases that the DOT and the FMCSA push out on all of these big crackdowns that they're talking about, if you really start to dig into those things, you'll quickly find out that they're not quite as dramatic as those press releases may make it seem. For example, in the last show, we were talking about the crackdown on CDL training providers and the 3,000 that had been removed uh from the training provider registry. And just taking that at face value, it sounds impressive. But then when you start to dig into which training providers were actually removed, we discovered it was a lot of training providers that weren't active at all. They weren't providing any training, so they were just removed because they weren't active. and then also several that were like private entities like boy scout troops and stuff like that. So not sure how many, you know, nefarious actors were actually pulled out in that first group. And so just reading the press releases, you wouldn't be keyed in on that fact. So yeah, I think that's an important point. Anything else, guys, what you've seen in the this administration? Um, no, just noting uh administrator bars. I mean, he's got a law enforcement background. Used to be heavily involved with CVSA, probably still is. Um, the administration's coming in pretty hot, like Rob said. Um, we'll look forward to seeing what they're going to do in 2026. But so far, like you said, Brandon, some of that lowhanging fruit, they're pulling off the tree, which you got to start somewhere. Yep. " I had to pull this comment up. Anybody that leads with that, I got to pull it up here. company hired us to do a mock audit. Not sure this who this is, but uh yeah, if you're a motor carrier unsure about regulatory questions or procedures at your company, hire them. Appreciate that, user 19. little Christmas present for you. Yeah, there you go. All right, I cut somebody off. Rob. You had something? I I I was mainly I was just going to follow up on on Jared to say that, you know, obviously the lowhanging fruit's the lowhanging fruit, but I think where they go with it. I mean, obviously some of the training schools they took out of in out of um operation, some of them obviously were, like you said, Boy Scout troops, but I think the idea is good if they if they continue to follow through with it and get into the the nuts and bolts of u not closing down the Boy Scout troop pieces, but maybe the ones that are actually nefarious. you got to start them young in trucking, Rob. Yep. Yep. Well, I I and I I do think D Mars um had put out a statement or was being interviewed and even noted that like kind of acknowledged, hey, yeah, we did take out a lot of probably participants who weren't really even participants, but um I'd read, you know, made a note like, hey, we we kind of need to figure out how do we evaluate these schools, you know? So, I I you know, I get it. You know, it's a first step. And I think the agency, I mean, lack of enforcement ability is is kind of problematic or like, hey, how do we actually regulate this thing? Um, so I I think that's on their mind and and a lot of the activity has been within the past four months, you know, four or five months that we've seen. So, um, you know, this is the first year of the administration and actually getting Derek Bars in. Um, I'm I would anticipate seeing more steps on some of this, but yeah, time will tell and we'll see. Yeah, for sure. and we'll hit on that topic specifically, training provider registry crackdown here in a minute. Uh, next thing I had on the list, moving on from the new administration, this happened earlier this year. Uh, this was the formal withdrawal of the speed limiter mandate. So, this had been the talk of the town for several years. um whether FMCSA and Nitsa were going to push forward with a mandate that um newly manufactured commercial heavy commercial motor vehicles be um installed with and and turn on speed limiter devices and set them at a particular level whatever the level was going to be set in the final rule. It pro it progressed to a notice of proposed rulemaking and I think they had a couple of supplemental notices of proposed rulemaking and we were waiting on a final rule but then the new administration took office and uh Sean Duffy pretty quickly put uh the axe to this mandate and said that this administration is not going to pursue it anymore. So they formally withdraw the rule making on that. We've talked about that in the other shows, but thoughts on that, Rob in particular. I mean, you're the only driver among us. I mean, I was pretty glad to see it go. I think from a from a safety and risk standpoint, I don't know that anybody would disagree that speed plays a big role in causation of crashes, but u when you start adding in speed limiters, especially if you're getting down to like 65 miles an hour, it it causes other issues. not just from a speed perspective, but from a vehicle control perspective. It was this and then there was the auto braking piece that kind of they didn't go hand in hand, but they kind of did. Uh they kind of creeped up at the same time. But my argument was the same really for both of them. It was um you're taking too much control away from the driver. And in in 2025, maybe the driver persona that we have now versus the one we had in 1990, maybe they need a little control taken away. I don't know. But um usually when you start taking control away from the person that's actually maintaining and running the vehicle, it it can cause problems. Yeah, it's interesting on the auto braking, the emergency auto uh emergency automatic braking requirement. uh a final rule mandating emergency automatic braking. I just don't know why. It's going to be starting with model year 2029s. Okay. All right. So, that is going to be a thing, [clears throat] but not so much speed limiters, at least under this current administration. Well, I think I think the refocus from speed limiters to automatic braking is appropriate. You know, I think that's kind of what Rob's driving at. Uh, a lot of fleets already choose to limit the speed of their drivers, and that's up to the fleets to do. But I think automatic braking, I mean, that reduces tons of catastrophic crashes right there. So, I mean, if you're going to really focus on a big problem, I mean, the old adage, speed kills, not going to disagree with that 100%, but uh the automatic braking thing solves a lot of problems. Yeah. Uh folks talking in the chat here, training schools don't have a set standard anymore when they rolled out the ELD requirements. Seemed like they loosened up the hours of training requirement. Yeah, they eliminated them completely. We'll get to that here in a minute when we talk about the training provider registry, but yeah, that that's certainly a big deal. Tyler, anything else on speed limiters? No, nothing for me. All right. Of course, the probably one of the biggest uh things we saw come down in 2025 from a regulatory perspective or from a FMCSA perspective, I should say, was the crackdown on English language proficiency. This, of course, started out with Trump signing an executive order earlier this year, uh, essentially mandating that the US DOT restore this type of violation as an out of service violation, meaning that any drivers who are tagged with English language proficiency violation, roadside, be prevented from continuing to operate. And so then that set in motion, the FMCSA putting out an enforcement policy. We've got a ton of content on this where we've spoken at nauseium adnauseium ad on it. Um, but the enforcement policy went into place setting up the tests that officers are to administer roadside if they think that the driver is struggling with ELP and then CVSA restored it to an out of service condition. And so, um, you know, [clears throat] I just got the most recent numbers from FMCSA's data here, just looking at it on the screen. This is kind of a month overmonth for the last year. How many ELP related violations have been discovered? Uh roadside, that's the blue line, total ELP violations. And then the orange line, how many of those ELP violations ended up with the driver being placed out of service. And you could see that starting in June after the enforcement policy, new enforcement policy went into effect, we started to see a pretty significant uptick in drivers being placed out of service for English language proficiency. And now over the last uh five 6 months, we have now over 9,000 drivers being placed out of service for English language proficiency violations. and it continues to be an issue that has attracted the attention [clears throat] of national media. I know that uh um we're routinely seeing it in the news. It's very politicized issue obviously, but um yeah, it seems to be just kind of looking at the industry news here um that it's from an industry standpoint a pretty well- reggarded change. Looking outside the industry, you start to see quite a bit of criticism of the rule. But I think within the industry, generally speaking, we've seen favorable response to this. Thoughts on this guy's English language proficiency crackdown? Mine's more of a question, I guess. How do you explain the disparity between the ELP violations at Roadside and then the actual out of service? Because that gap, it's difficult to understand why that gap exists. Because if you get an ELP violation and it's an out of service violation, why are drivers not being placed out of service for all these violations? Is it subjective to enforcement varying from stateto state or what? The biggest reason for the disparity between the non-outs of service and the out of service ELP violations is border zone violations. uh the new ELP enforcement policy carves out certain categories of drivers who even if they are not proficient in English, they'll still be written up for the violation, but they won't be placed out of service. namely those that are operating in the so-called border zone which is a zone set up through um international treaties we have with Mexico for example that allow for crossber operations near near the border and drivers operating there that get tagged with an ELP violation are written up for the violation but not placed out of service. So that's the biggest explanation. It's not it doesn't explain all of them. doesn't explain the entire dis uh disparity between those two lines. And I don't know what the explanation is for the others that don't end up with the driver out of service other than I think Rob there's some hearing impaired drivers that um if they get uh if they get cited for ELP that that they're not placed out of service, but I wouldn't think that would be accounting for much of that disparity. So, you're right. I mean, there still is an issue with some law enforcement. We see this a lot in California. This is one reason why California is under the gun with FMCSA. Um FMCSA has pulled federal funding from California in part because the state has only placed one literally one driver out of service for English language proficiency since June since this enforcement [clears throat] enhanced enforcement went into effect. And so they lost uh tens of millions of dollars in federal funds because of that. And now they have sued FMCSA um saying that you know they don't think they have a legal obligation even under mixap to place drivers out of service roadside for ELP. They claim that they do it through their CDL um you know testing program but regardless I think that's the those are the main reasons for the disparity though it doesn't account for all of it. Yeah, I'm want to know who the one guy is, right? Like if I was that one guy, I mean, you would think like, hey, why did you pick me of all these people who've been, you know, actually had the violation? Why am I the one that got put out of service? I I like to think of it as how how egregious was that stop? I'd love to see the body cam footage on that. Good lord. Either that or it's one rogue CHP officer who is a Trump fan and uh and wants to enforce the rule and then he he got he got shut down after the one out of service and they're like no more he got fired. Yeah. Yep. He's gone. That's probably it. Uh so yeah, I mean English language proficiency huge deal will continue to be a huge deal going into 2026. We saw a little bit of a dip in the enforcement numbers there in November. You probably saw that. Although with that said, there's a delay in the reporting of these numbers when it comes into FMCSA system. So usually what we see is an uptick uh in the prior month when the subsequent month's data is released. So I suspect that that November number will go up slightly when we get new data in January, but uh yeah, it's going to be uh continue to be on at the top of mind going into 2026. uh we've got at least three more years of this administration and so that's going to be uh I don't think anything is going to bring them off of this enforcement posture when it comes to this particular issue. In fact, I don't know where this stands currently, but I have think I have heard of certain bills being written in Congress that would further solidify this um this enforcement posture on this issue. In other words, it would give FMCSA some statutory support to do what they are doing through their uh enforcement policy and through their regulations. And we'll have to see if that goes anywhere. I don't know if it will, but um yeah, so that's where it stands now. I'm I'm actually more curious on, you know, you say over 9,000 drivers have been put out of services, you know, what, you know, going forward if there's going to be any guidance on rehabilitation or how many of those drivers were put out of service, but you know, we're still driving even though they were put out of service because of one violation. Um, I think that's something to maybe look out for, you know, going forward. Yeah, it would be interesting to see. You know, they um they say that they've placed over 9,000. I think they have been saying they placed over 10,000 drivers out of service for ELP violations. It would be interesting to know are any of those repeat offenders in which case it would be a jumping and out of service violation more so than an ELP violation, but you would think that the FMCSA's data you would be able to see that. But um I don't know. It's something I haven't looked into, but it would be interesting. But also to your to your other point, that is something that I think FMCSA should do sooner than later, which is to give some guidance to fleets and drivers that do get placed out of service for ELP as to what they need to do specifically in order to get back in service if they intend to stay in the industry, which I assume at least some of them intend to do. um what what do I need to do to become more proficient in English and then prove it to you law enforcement that I've done that and that I I I'm now proficient because the big issue with English language proficiency as we've talked about in past shows is the subjectivity of of the rule, right? I mean, it's just kind of up to the officer who is assessing the proficiency at the in the moment as to whether that driver is speaking proficiently enough to that officer's taste or not. And so, it's going to differ from officer to officer. And that leaves drivers and carriers in a bad spot because, you know, maybe they've already done their own proficiency testing. A lot of motor carriers do proficiency testing at the time of hire and maybe that driver passed the proficiency test at the time of hire. I've had some clients who've who've said that, but then they the the driver gets caught up with an ELP violation roadside. Now, what's the carrier to do? You know, it's it's their word against the officer's word, and how do you get that driver back on the road? So, that's a question that we don't have an answer to. m. Stay overnight because they're out of service, can't move the truck, can't go anywhere. m. Tells him he's fine, he's good, as far as he's concerned, he can speak and communicate in English, and then he lets him go. Yeah. So, u we I've we've had that happen at least three times, similar stories like that where one officer at at the same scale um that level of subjectivity. So, um it's it's going to probably continue to be an issue. Yeah. And I have no doubt that CVSA is also wrestling with these questions and hopefully coming up with some more concrete guidance for their for their members and the law enforcement officers who are um in the unenvi unenviable position of having to administer this politicized issue. Um so we'll see where that goes, but again suffice it to say this is going to continue to be an issue for the foreseeable future. Yeah. One other quick thing to point out, if you're really interested in this data, this enforcement data related to ELP, you can actually subscribe to this uh through trucksafe's website. Yeah. com/p. We've got a bunch of resources on this issue specifically, including an assessment that fleets can administer uh at the time of hire if they want a resource for that. And then also, yeah, our data tracking service where we are parsing the FMCSA's ELP data on a month-to-month basis and looking at the hotspots where these issues or where ELP violations are being written up the most in the country. So, um, yeah, do that. comp. All right. Next up on the list here, uh probably right up there, uh with ELP as the most significant trucking regulatory initiatives we saw take place in 2025, which is um FMCSAs and US DOT's new um interim final rule on the topic of non-domicile CDLs. Uh obviously with this show, we don't have time to get into the nitty-gritty of this. We've we had a show dedicated to this issue specifically a ton of articles on our website about it and videos and that type of stuff if you're interested. But uh long story short here, FMCSA within the last few months um issued what's called an interim final rule. It's essentially an emergency rule based on some auditing that they did of states issuance of these so-called non-domicile CDLs. And uh according to that audit, the US DOT allegedly found pretty rampant fraud um improper issuance by the states of these non-domiciled CDLs to individuals who allegedly are not eligible to receive them, ending up with drivers operating on these CDLs when they shouldn't have gotten them in the first place. And so we've seen the US DOT call out certain states in particular. Um I think the most recent one I saw was New York. I think the the numbers that they gave was over 50% of the non-domiciled CDLs issued in the state of New York were allegedly issued improperly, which is just crazy to me. And so in light of that problem, the FMCSA issued this emergency rule which cracked down on who on the eligibility criteria for these licenses. It it it significantly reduced the population of eligible folks um to certain types of visa holders. And then it also put some tighter restrictions on the states when it comes to vetting these drivers who are eligible or not for the non-domicide CDLs and how long they are eligible for and that type of stuff. Um, to make a long story longer, the FMCSA was sued by some drivers and then also some interest groups and some states or counties, I think, um, who argued that their issuance of this interim final rule was unlawful for many reasons. [clears throat] And that ended up with a federal court, the DC Circuit Court of Appeals, putting a temporary stay of the rule in place, meaning that the FMCSA could not enforce it. And that is where we are at currently here at the end of 2025. That stay is in place. So, this rule, even though the FMCSA issued it, is not effective uh and won't be effective for the foreseeable future because the FMCSA has essentially agreed to hold off on enforcing the rule until it can go through and look at all of the thousands of comments that were submitted in the docket of this rule and potentially rework the rule and come up with a a modified one. We don't know what that's going to look like. That's something to watch out for in 2026 is what the new non-domicide CDL rule is going to look like. Who's going to be eligible for these licenses going forward, who's not, and um yeah, another very politicized issue because it targets primarily foreign drivers, uh drivers who are not doiciled in a in a US state who get these licenses. That's primarily who's at issue here. And uh yeah, this one has drawn national attention as well. Um, I know uh me and Rob have been talking with national media on these issues and we'll continue to do so. It's just a it's a crazy time in trucking. Yeah. I mean, this the non-domicile CDL thing wasn't just about risk and compliance. I mean, it it's had an effect on people's money, too. I mean, obviously, there are people now not making money because they have illegal non-domicile CDL, so they're unable to work. But the people who are still able to work um you know the difference between the capacity and the volume issues have have caused rates to rise and for the first time in a long time we're at like 254 today for per mile rates. you think that's directly correlated with this? Yeah, if you uh if you follow Craig Fuller it is. But u basically the way Craig lays it out according to sonar data and the sonar data makes a lot of sense. He's got a good system there. But essentially, you're watching people leave the market and you have now you have more volume with less capacity. So, u it's forcing rates to go up. I think the estimate that the DOT gave in its interim final rule was that it anticipated around 200,000 non-domicide CDL holders exiting the market over the course of the next year if this rule went into effect. So potentially losing out on 200,000 uh drivers to your point about capacity is what FMCSA anticipated. yeah, and a lot of those are working on lower wages, too. So the fact that they're able to charge lower rates and and kind of depress rates, it's uh it's helped on that side of things. It's it's actually made uh the people who are still able to drive pretty ecstatic. I mean, they haven't seen rates this high in a long time. Yeah, one thing we also saw as a result of this rule was several states uh start self auditing themselves and their issuance of non-domicile CDLs. And you know, frankly, it's it's kind of divided along political lines. If you look at the states that are being aggressive on their own, it's going to be the red states. uh those red a lot of those red states, not a lot of them, but some of them have decided to put a pause, a complete pause on the issuance of non-domicile CDLs. I think what what Rob I think Texas did that I think they've got a pause on issuance of these. I think Minnesota was say they're not a red state, but yeah, but as a blue state. Yeah. And and I think there was quite a bit of news surrounding that. I was a little surprised, but you know, I'm kind of looking at some of these states, red or blue. Hey, if the FMCSA is potentially going to withhold our mixab funding because we're doing this, maybe we should just go ahead and and take a look at these things. Yeah. Yeah. But I mean, even from a driver perspective, it's like even if you could go and get it from California DMV, would you want to go through the the headache of go going and getting it only to possibly having it turn into a final rule again anyway and then it be ganked back from you? So it's it's kind of like I'm not going through that only to know I might have it for six months. yeah, so I think all of it I think all of it together has generated probably some fear among, you know, foreign nationals of, hey, do I want to get into trucking right now? You know, it it may may not be a long-term solution. Yeah. Yeah, cuz even though the FMCSA um I mean one way you could view it is the FMCSA got its wrist slapped by the by the court and it is kind of you know running away with its tail be between its legs on this. But if you're looking at it from another way, it essentially got what it wanted. It got many states to put a more critical eye to their issuance of these non-domicile CDLs and to voluntarily get themselves in line and stop issuing them altogether in some states. So the impact of the interim final rule is already being felt even though the interim final rule is currently not effective. We're we're seeing that in many states. And so, you know, going forward to to your both of your points, I expect [clears throat] what we'll see in early 2026 is the FMCSA coming out with um a new final rule on this topic. If I had to guess, it's probably going to be a little less aggressive than the interim final rule. um they're going to have to take into account some of the the issues that the court raised uh the problems that the court had with the rule and the way that they went about doing it. Um and so it wouldn't surprise me at all if we end up with a final rule that's a little less aggressive than the interim final rule, but still some kind of crackdown on non-domicile CDLs in the state's issuance of them. So, you think we're going to see some pretty quick activity revising the rule and issuing the final rule, or do you think we're going to see a slow play? I think what uh if I had to guess, I would think it would be fairly quick. Um because, you know, FMCSA's now got this lawsuit by California um that's now pending in federal court in California where uh California is suing FMCSA for the withholding of the fund. So, I think it's that's going to be uh kind of tied up in that as well. So, I think they want to just I think they if I'm the FMCSA, [clears throat] I want to just disarm my opponents by going through the actual rule making process and getting it done sooner than later and just uh and just, you know, doing it the right way, the way that they should have done it uh from the beginning. Frankly, they should have just gone through the rule making process, but they deemed it an emergency, so they bypassed the typical notice and comment period and we ended up with that emergency rule that is now stayed. But that's just my take. I have no idea if that's going to play out. But to your point, I think impact, I mean, there was a period of time of a couple months where that was the rule before the lawsuit was filed and the whole thing was stayed. Um, and I think, you know, going forward, you know, to the extent FMCSA is going to go through the rule making process, um, I, you know, I think we talked about this, one of the big things, how do you tie the safety piece to it, right? It was the FMCSA couldn't really I don't know where that data is. Yeah. Are they less safe? They admitted it. So, FM FMCSA admitted in their briefing in that court case that they have no that the data just does not exist to correlate um crashes to the driver's uh either English language proficiency or non-domicile CDL status. So, they admit that. So, the the data just doesn't exist. And so without that safety case to make for for the rule, they have to make slightly different cases. I think the case that they made, if I'm remembering correctly in the You're going to have to remind me, Tyler, I think the FMCSA was arguing that the that the justification for the rule is that with a non-domicile CD with with normal CDL holders, states are required to look at the driving history of that driver by looking at, you know, motor vehicle reports from Yeah. looking at their motor vehicle reports, looking at violations that they've incurred, looking at crashes they've incurred. And the agency's point is with these foreign drivers, we can't compel them, we can't compel their country of origin to produce to us the driving history of these drivers. So the states can't fulfill their obligation under the regulations to check the driving histories for these foreign drivers. And so they said that's the safety case for it is that the states are blind to the driving history of these foreign drivers. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. I I I agree with you. That's probably where they're going to have to focus their efforts. Yeah, I think so. I think they will continue to use that as the basis for the safety case for the rule making and I think they will proceed rather quickly with it. The other thing to uh that came to mind while you guys were talking is uh to the point of the impact of the rule even though the rule is stayed Tyler you mentioned that hey if I'm a foreign driver you know that kind of scares me off but also look at this from the employer perspective the motor carriers if I'm a motor carrier right now and I'm hiring drivers I'm very wary of hiring anybody with a non-domicile CDL right you got to be because at any moment that driver's non-domicile CDL could be yanked and now you're potentially on the hook for having somebody who's unlicensed out there driving the truck. So that creates tremendous exposure just that uncertainty and the volatility with this issue for the motor carriers that have drivers holding these licenses. and I mean one of the things is the the states have started to take had started to take these back during that period of time where it was in effect. I mean Florida and and other states were sending out letters to drivers and carriers were sending them to me saying hey what do we do with this letter? it's telling him he has to surrender his CDL because it was issued illegally and he's no longer a CDL driver. Um, so they were already letting drivers go and taking them off the road and and DMVs were already asking people to surrender these illegal CDLs. So, um, some of it's already done and maybe that's the reason they did they bypassed the rule making process as normal and and went the route they went. Yeah, the cynic in me could say, "Yeah, they got what they wanted. they they got the impact that they wanted just by threatening this emergency rule and now it becomes the you know the scarlet letter that nobody wants to be around. Um and so yeah I mean that could be but hard telling I I think they'll still pursue the final rule but we'll have to wait and see. All right, non-domicile CDLs. Moving on. This was um one of the more uh frustrating things if you're a fleet or a CDL driver probably from a uh that happened from a rulemaking, you know, procedural perspective over the last year. And that was the long awaited changes to the medical examiner card, medical examiner certificate, medcard process for CDL drivers. This is something else we've covered in depth in in a lot of prior content. Uh the nutshell here is that the for 10 years the FMCSA has been planning to fully digitize the process by which a CDL driver's medical qualifications get associated with that driver's driving record via the state licensing agency. So, for 10 years, we've been living in kind of an interim period where these CDL drivers continue to get their paper meds and they carry those around with them and uh they give them to the motor carriers they work for and that paper medard then is then evidence that the driver has passed a DOT physical and is physically qualified to operate a commercial motor vehicle. The whole goal though for the last decade has been to move that in to digitize that process so we don't have paper medards anymore and we don't have to rely on those drivers physically taking those meds to their state licensing agency and getting them associated with their driving record because that's you know uh something that could end up with fraud and and also just failures by the state licensing agency to get that properly uploaded. So anyway, that change was supposed to take effect earlier this year. Um, we were supposed to move to that fully electronic process, but it turned out, as anybody could have expected, it was just a disaster. Um, several states, dozens of states were not prepared for it despite having 10 years to prepare for it. Their systems couldn't accommodate the digital or the electronic transmission of the data. Also, hundreds and probably thousands of medical examiners weren't even aware of this change that would have required them to digitally electronically submit these records up to the National Registry. So, it ended up with a lot of um drivers being sidelined because the medical examiner didn't get it uploaded or the state couldn't accept it. So FMCSA had to step back in and issue a temporary waiver that once again allows us to continue using the paper medards. I think that waiver now extends till the end of January of 2026. They've had to extend it a couple of times. Last I checked, there are still at least 10 states that aren't able to accept the electronic transmissions of these meds. But point here is that's something to look out for in 2026 is hopefully by then we will have moved to away from that waiver into this fully electronic process. But that's going to come with its own hiccups. Yeah, I've been kind of skeptical about this one the whole time because I just don't trust the government. But I um I did go get mine renewed like two weeks ago. So this was this was the first time I've done this process and they actually uh so my doctor stopped doing these. So, I had to go to one of these concentras to some doctor who didn't know me and um they actually have admin there that are managing this. They've got their own computer just to upload these to FMCSA. They let you stand there and watch them do it. Um and then I went to DMV to take my hazmat test last week and made sure that it was done. It was done. So, I guess we can trust the process at least in Virginia. But um essentially the the med examiners are update uploading it to FMCSA and then the FMCSA is spitting it back down to the state agency and then you have to run the MBR. So um it worked for me. I think a question everybody's asking though, Rob, is you were able to get your med card with your missing finger. I did. I I got a two-year. That that's the crazy part. I'm usually been getting a one year and the year I didn't have a finger, I got the two-year. So it's all good. Lower BMI. There you go. There you go. All right. Any other thoughts on the MedCard overhaul here, guys? What a cluster. No. Yeah. Fleets just need to be staying up to speed on the current status of this as we head into 2026. If you've got drivers all over the country, unfortunately, you're in a in a period right now where how it's handled in one state is different than how it's handled in another state. And so you as the fleet are kind of in charge of keeping track of all of that and making sure you're not running a foul of the rule based on where your drivers happen to be getting their physical exam. So hopefully once this waiver goes away, we'll all be on the same system. But you need to keep on top of that. Keep on top of which states are able to accept the electronic transmissions and which ones aren't. I mean, we're still recommending to our clients that um your CDL drivers as they go in for new physicals, they still request a a copy of the paper medard. FMCSA is um recommending that they do that as well for the time being. Even though under this new system, that paper medard is is not the valid proof of the physical qualifications anymore. It's still good to have. uh going forward, the motor carrier will have the obligation to run the motor vehicle report and that motor vehicle report showing the new physical exam information is the source of truth for that driver's physical qualification. So carriers need to be aware that that is a thing going forward. No longer hopefully you're already accepting the medsards and you've got those in the driver qualification files. Many [clears throat] fleets are not doing even that. Um, assuming you're doing that, that process is going to change going forward. And in 2026, you're not going to, even if you get the paper med card, you haven't met your obligations, your driver qualification obligations. You have to run the motor vehicle report on that CDL driver and show that the on the MVR, it lists their new medical exam. So, be aware of that. [snorts] Otherwise, that's going to be an audit risk for you. All right. Next up, uh these next few things here are things that have been announced within the last couple of months. So, these are pretty fresh. We've done some other content on these all as well. Um first up here is the FMCSA's announcement that is cracking down on electronic logging device self-certification. So, ELDs have now been mandated uh what for six years or so um for most regulated drivers in the United States as the means for tracking their hours of service. And the system we have in the United States, which differs from how Canada handles this, is a self-certification program uh or system for the manufacturers of these devices. [cough] They have to self-certify that their devices meet the technical specifications that the FMCSA has baked into its regulations. How these devices have to function, what what how how they have to track drive time when the vehicle's in motion. All of that technical specifications are very detailed in nature. Um there's no third party certification. There's no certifying body that has to look at these devices and give them the the green light before they can be sold to carriers and drivers in the United States. It's all just us taking the manufacturer's word that their devices meet the uh technical specifications. Um not surprisingly, that has led to many devices being listed on the self-certification list that never should have been listed. They're not compliant with the technical specifications despite the certifications made by the manufacturers. And so that leaves carriers and drivers in a bad spot because they're out there operating with non-compliant devices. Then those devices ultimately get revoked if the FMCSA investigates them and then the carrier has to then purchase a new device anyway and replace the old device. So it's left a lot of carriers and drivers in a bad spot. And um it has also led to a lot of fraud. We had a whole other show where we talked about all of the different ways um that we're seeing bad actors, use or exploit ELDs to end up with drivers violating the hours of service rule. Big issue, huge issue. And so the FMCSA announced within the last few weeks actually that it is going to enhance its vetting of devices that want to be listed on the certification list. What exactly that entails, we don't quite know yet. They list a few bullet points in their notice of what this is going to entail. It's still not a thirdparty certification. It's still not going to be an independent body looking in depth in the devices, but there's going to be some additional vetting and also um some new steps to make sure that if a device gets shut down or taken off the list that it doesn't just reincarnate and become uh you know the same device listed under a different name or something to that effect. So, this is a a big deal. um it's likely going to cut down on more devices that are on the list and also prevent um certain new devices from being added to the list. I saw somewhere, I can't remember where I saw this, but somebody published an article that said that the FMCSA has prevented over 200 new devices from being added to the list over the last couple of months, which was [snorts] surprising to me. But um yeah, so this is just something to to to watch out for going into 2026. thoughts on this one, guys? Yeah, I can tell you if you're a current ELD vendor and you had a device revoked and then you try to add a new device, FMCSA is most likely not going to allow you if the companies are tied together with that new submission for a new device and self-certification. You're probably not going to get it. Uh you're probably not going to get put on the list of approved devices. And so, they do pay attention to that. But the biggest thing that you pointed out there, the fraud concerns, I mean, there has to be a mechanism in place to stop devices from reincarnating, changing the company name, using the same software that could be used for, you know, nefarious purposes. You know, some of these vendors are purposefully trying to edit drive time and they're selling their product as such. um investigating those vendors, you know, aggressively and then preventing them from reincarnating in the future. I mean, that's a huge concern and it's I'm glad I don't have to figure out how to do that, but FMCSA does. Yeah. I think the big question here is where does it go? because you've got um Derek Bars was in Florida and in his speech that he gave in Florida, he he made it pretty clear that he's not a big fan of uh self-certification and self attestation program. So, um with him going to be there supposedly for the next three years, um I'm interested in seeing where it goes. Yeah. Could we see the end of self-certification? Yeah. Yet yet to be seen. the the difficulty there. I mean, in watching Canada's process of thirdparty testing, I mean, it's very expensive to go through this third party testing process and to to say that now all of these ELDs, if you want to stay on the list, you now have to go through third party testing, which could cost $50,000, and there's very few bodies that can do it. You have to be ISO certified. there's there's a lot of requirements they have to put in place so that way you're not having random third parties providing certification on these devices. So, they're going to have to put a lot of thought into it. And if they flip the switch and say that anyone that's a registered EL has to be third party tested, that's going to be a really big deal. I think it's going to change the landscape overnight. Obviously, your big boys are going to do that third-party testing process no matter what the cost to stay in the market, but some of the smaller ones could sell product um could combine with other companies or just self-revoke their device. I could easily see FMCSA being sued by several manufacturers if it were to flip the switch. you know, something like like a regulatory takings type lawsuit where, hey, you allowed us to do this and now all of a sudden you're changing the rules and we're gonna have to pay all this money and look at all this money we already invested in these devices, blah blah blah. So, yeah, FMCSA is going to have to think about that carefully. It's not going to be something that's going to be done lightly, that's for sure. Um, so we'll have to see how that plays out next year. Um, another certification program that is under additional scrutiny now, this one we kind of already hinted at earlier, but this was also within the last few weeks was an announcement from FMCSA that it is also cracking down on CDL training providers, those that are listed in the training provider registry for folks who are providing entry-level driver training to individuals who are getting CDLs for the first time or who are looking to upgrade their CDLs or get certain endorsements. Those drivers now have to go through this mandatory entry- level driver training that is required by FMCSA. And that training is provided by this huge universe of third-party training providers who it's another self certification list. It is the training providers who are guided by a regulatory framework that essentially just lists out the mandatory curriculum that has to be followed and they are certifying on this list that their their program meets that curriculum requirement. And then the obligation of the driver who's looking to get the CDL is to find a training provider on that list and go get their training. and then um they have to have that training in order to then go take the the test at their DMV to get their CDL. Well, again, another byproduct of self-certification is that inevitably you end up with training providers who despite their attestations are just not compliant. Or it's [snorts] not even so much that they're not compliant, they're just not good at what they do. They they don't have a thorough program. I don't want to say they're non-compliant because the regulations don't say a whole lot about what what what it takes to be compliant. Um, but we end up with training providers that are pushing, you know, these students through in, you know, 48 hours or something crazy, while others, the more legitimate providers are taking weeks and and sometimes months to push their drivers through. So, we've got this huge spectrum of the quality of the training providers on this training provider registry. And it's um you know inevitably leading to drivers who shouldn't be getting a CDL ending up getting a CDL because they have been taught to the test. We did a whole other show on this. It was our last show. In fact, if you're interested in checking that out, check it out. Um but yeah, FMCSA is cracking down on this. The announcement that they made was that they've already removed 3,000 training providers from the registry and that they have 4,000 more that are under scrutiny. And um yeah, so they're going to continue to be aggressive in in terms of removing rem removing training providers uh over the coming months. So that's it. Thoughts on that? Well, I think it's I think the biggest issue is that it's really a fractured program. I mean, at the federal level, you're only doing one of two things. It's the curriculum and the registry sign up and certification that you're going to go along with their program, that minimal program. But then the fractured part really breaks down at the state. I mean, you've got 50 different states doing it 50 different ways. I mean, some states don't have minimum requirements for training duration just like the the feds don't. So, um it's really just get through the the moduled curriculum and if you can do that in 10 days then or eight days then you're now CDL driver. So I think the root of both of those ELD and the training provider is the selfcertification attestation piece. I mean, yeah. Have you guys what what kind of a pulse do you guys have on what training providers are being audited or looked at by the agency or state partners? because I've heard from some of our large clients that are training providers that they've been audited multiple times, but I I I don't know if you're hearing of smaller training providers being looked at and audited as well, but it seems like a bit of a waste of resources to at the really huge training providers buttoned up. So, I don't know. What are you hearing on that? Yeah, it's probably just the nature of the work we do, Jared, but I've heard the same thing. It's it's the large well-known carriers who have their own training providers who have reached out to us to tell to tell us that that they're at least some of their locations are under audit which seemed odd to me but again that's probably because that's who we work with mostly so I don't have a sense of you know the small guys h how how many of them are under audit by FMCSA. Rob have you heard anything in that regard? No, we I know some locally here in Virginia that have had it done, but I think if I had to guess, it's largely based off kind of the same scenario that kicked off a compliance review, like how complaints, etc. Because the one that I know that has had three of these here locally, they've had all kinds of issues historically. So, I I'm assuming it's probably along the same lines. Like, you get complaints, you might get an audit. You kill somebody, you might get an audit. So, I don't know, but that's that's kind of where I'm at with or what I've heard with it. All right, guys. We're about out of time. We haven't really dug into um we've looked at a lot of the things that happened in 2025. We And some of those are going to roll over into 2026. That's obvious, but I want to do some rapid fire here. Some things that I'm looking out for in 2026. And uh we'll each just uh I'll assign these to one of you to talk briefly about. First one, Tyler, I'm going to send to you, broker liability, the issue of broker liability sitting at the Supreme Court of the United States. You want to give us the quick rundown on that? Yeah. So, um currently there's a circuit court of appeals split on whether brokers can be liable for state law claims like negligence, um associated with highway accidents. Um, finally, it's the Supreme Court um has certified a case um coming out of the Seventh Circuit. Uh, CH Robinson's the broker in that one. Uh, Montgomery versus Kuribbe. So, really, they're going to be looking at the F4A um, uh, exemption. It's the the safety exception to F4A preeemption. Um, whether or not, you know, injured plaintiffs can can bring these claims against brokers, these state law-based claims against brokers. So huge huge huge thing for anybody who has brokerage operations. Um it it it's defin it's going to be big news um when the Supreme Court rules on that. Um I don't think anybody has a real good idea of which way it's going to go. " So, plaintiffs should be able to bring these claims. Um I think in conjunction with that, these this was one quick one, you know, depending on what happens with broker liability. um you know, hey, if if brokers can be liable, there's going to be a whole lot of more insurance on that um kind of non-owned auto. Um so, the insurance market's going to change. And I think in conjunction with all this is, hey, on your local level, if you're a fleet, be be paying attention to what your state is doing for tort reform in terms of um you know, what things are states, I know Florida, Iowa, there's been Texas, other ones that have been doing things to um help limit some of these these massive um uh accident cases and and the damages that are being um awarded by juries in there. So, I it's all kind of tied together, but you know, tort reform and this broker liability and and cost of insurance, I think, are all kind of tied together. Um, and then real quick on on two very other m well minor important broker issues. 3. You know, what records a broker has to um maintain and make available to carriers. Um, we haven't heard much about it since earlier this year. Um, we'll see if the FMCSA does anything on on that end. Um, and then just pay attention to any brokers going out of business as the market changes and carriers making sure they get paid and if they don't, what are their options? All right, next up, this one's for you, Rob. Uh, you wrote an article on it today in freight waves. Marijuana rescheduling potential. Talk to us about that. Yeah. So, this has hasn't even really gone too far u bes outside of Trump saying that he wants or he's considering doing and he thinks it's a good idea. Um when what they're looking at doing is rescheduling marijuana from a class one to a class three which basically is what Tylenol and and codin and a few other over-the-counter basically almost over-the-counter substances are. So if health and human services were to do that, then DOT um basically would have to change their testing policy and no longer test for marijuana. So um that that obviously creates a need for a carveout to what do we do in the in the trucking industry? Do we have a bunch of uh people who are driving around smoking pot all day while they're in their truck? you are testing your drivers by from a policy perspective versus a regulation. All right last one I'm going to pitch to Jared and then I'll wrap us up here. Jared, you expecting to see anything in terms of autonomous trucking regulation in 2026? Um, ideally we'd see some at least some guidance put forth. I mean, I I'm not holding my breath for a formal rule making, but you know, at this point it's largely been left to the states what you can and can't do testing wise, driverless, etc. Uh, whether or not you have to have a safety driver. A lot of these things have been left to the states. And so we have seen a lot of the states that are a little more friendly uh down in the southwest like Texas, New Mexico, places like that where the operational domain's pretty consistent. Uh we see a lot of operations there and the states have pretty robust uh laws surrounding the testing. Uh ideally we'd see some uh groundwork laid from the FMCSA and Nitsa on those activities in 2026 and hopefully that's the case. All right everyone, we're out of time. Appreciate you joining us today. Obviously, that was a lot to go through, but like I said, we've got content on all of these different topics. com. We will continue to follow the breaking news, anything coming down in 2026. com/subscribe. com, or subscribe to the podcast wherever you get your podcast. In any event, that's going to wrap it up for the show today and for this year. We hope to see you in the new year. Thanks everyone. See you. Thanks.

Event Completed

Wednesday, December 17, 2025 at 1:57 PM EST

Watch on YouTube