Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 59 - Marijuana Rescheduling

Thursday, January 15, 2026 at 1:57 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 59 - Marijuana Rescheduling

About This Event

In this episode of Trucksafe LIVE!, we're joined by special guest Patrice Kelly, former Director of USDOT's Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance, to discuss what marijuana rescheduling could mean for DOT testing programs and where things stand with oral fluid testing.

Guests

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 59 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman is joined by Patrice Kelly, former Director of the U.S. Department of Transportation's Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance, to examine the potential rescheduling of marijuana and what it could mean for DOT-regulated fleets. The conversation centers on President Trump's executive order directing the Attorney General to resume the marijuana rescheduling rulemaking process and the serious, often misunderstood implications that rescheduling could have on the DOT drug testing program for commercial drivers. Kelly explains that the core issue lies in the chain of authority governing DOT drug testing. Under existing law, DOT may only test for drugs using HHS-certified laboratories, and those laboratories are only authorized to test for Schedule I and Schedule II controlled substances. Moving marijuana to Schedule III would eliminate HHS's authority to certify labs for marijuana testing, effectively stripping DOT of its ability to mandate testing for the drug altogether — unless Congress or the executive branch acts to create new authority. Kelly notes that this authority traces back to a 1986 executive order signed by President Reagan, and that President Trump's current executive order does not include the "safety carve-out" that would be needed to preserve the status quo for safety-sensitive transportation workers. The hosts highlight data from the FMCSA's Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse showing that marijuana accounts for more than 60 percent of all positive drug test results among CDL drivers since 2020, underscoring just how significant the loss of testing authority would be. The discussion also addresses common misconceptions about the executive order, emphasizing that it does not legalize marijuana or change anything immediately. The rescheduling process must still work its way through a formal rulemaking, and Congress could potentially act in the interim. Kelly stresses that the preferred path forward is a legislative safety carve-out that preserves HHS's authority to certify labs and maintains DOT's ability to test safety-sensitive employees regardless of marijuana's scheduling status. She also raises the concern that if testing authority is lost and employers continue testing without legal backing, they could face significant legal exposure, including constitutional challenges and potential liability to employees who tested positive after the authority lapsed. The episode also touches on the stalled rollout of oral fluid testing under DOT's 2023 final rule. Kelly explains that the holdup is an FDA certification issue, with U.S. laboratories caught in a burdensome clinical testing process that Canadian labs are not subject to — meaning HHS is currently closer to certifying foreign labs than domestic ones. She expresses frustration that despite industry readiness at the time the rule was finalized, the bureaucratic bottleneck has prevented oral fluid testing from becoming a viable DOT-approved option more than two years later. For fleet safety professionals, the key takeaway is to hold the course for now — no changes to existing drug testing policies are warranted until the rescheduling process concludes and the regulatory picture becomes clearer. Kelly and Wiseman both advise carriers to stay closely connected with trusted sources, including state and national trucking associations, third-party administrators, and compliance consultants, to ensure they receive timely and accurate information as this issue evolves. As Kelly put it, the fight for a safety carve-out is far from over, and those who care about highway safety have every reason to make their voices heard with legislators and industry associations.

Full Transcript

Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. a down. Heat. Heat. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're After E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. E-Riggs is always up todate and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. Was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. right. Hey everyone, welcome to episode 59 of Truck Safe Live, show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon with Truck Safe and Children's Law, both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs. Happy New Year to everybody tuned in. Uh glad to have you back. If you're here with us live, say hey in the comments so we know who's around. Hopefully your 2026 is off to a great start. Excited to kick things off here at Truck Safe Live with the first episode of the year on an important topic as always, one that's been in the news over the last few weeks, and that is the potential rescheduling of marijuana and all of the headache that that could cause to regulated fleets. And so, uh, a lot of unanswered questions in that regard. So, I thought it would be important to jump on here, talk about that, what it could mean for fleets coming up this year if marijuana were to be rescheduled. So, that's what we're going to hit on today. Before we get there, a few things to talk about going on at Truck Safe and also in the industry. So, we'll do that. Um, first up, if you're not a member of the TruckSafe Network, I'd encourage you to join that. com. This is the space we've built for safety professionals to gather together, uh, ask questions, learn from one another, and access all of our DOT related content that we're pushing out, including podcast episodes, videos, webinars, uh, and discounted access to our in-person uh, events, including our upcoming Truck Safe Fleet Compliance Boot Camp. Um, this is the next thing I wanted to mention. If you haven't been to one of our boot camps, I'd encourage you to to check that out. com is where you'll find all of the details. We are in the planning stages for the 2026 boot camp. It'll probably be in the fall uh of this year in Indianapolis. Uh but this is the two two-day in-person conference that we put on each year. We usually have about 80 to 100 fleet safety professionals in attendance. um where and we spend those two days talking about nothing but DOT safety regulations and digging into the detail of topics like driver qualification and vehicle maintenance and hours of service and all of that fun stuff. Uh so we hope to see you at one of those. com is where you'll find the details. We will push out uh through our newsletter um once we have finalized the details for this year. We're getting close and so I hope to be able to share that on the next show, but also our newsletter and which is the last truck safe related thing I'll mention. com/subsubscribe is where you can do that and we push out uh usually a weekly newsletter on all things DOT safety uh related breaking news articles, analysis of of all of the the fun topics that we deal with as fleet safety team members and that type of stuff. So, uh we try not to spam you. comsubscribe is where you can do that. Hope to see you there. All right, a couple things going on in the industry before we move to today's topic. The first thing I'll mention, I saw this come through. FMCSA continues on its path of um more closely scrutinizing electronic logging devices and removing them from its list of self-certification um if it finds that they are non-compliant with the regulations. And so just this week, the FMCSA announced the removal of four additional ELDs from the list of certified devices. So they are listed right here on this web page. Premier ride logs, DSG e- logs, state e- logs, and state e- logs, too. If you're using those devices, this is bad news for you. You have to cease using them immediately, and you have 60 days to replace them with a different device. And during those 60 days, your drivers can transition to paper logs. But uh at the expiration of those 60 days, so before March 15, 2026, you got to have those devices replaced. Uh next thing I'll mention here, FMCSA, uh well, US DOT more broadly announced its random drug and alcohol testing rates for 2026. com. FMCSA for its uh for its part, its rates will remain the same. So, if you are a regulated fleet, uh the random testing rates for 2026 will remain at 50% for drugs and uh 10% for alcohol. com and read our most recent article on that. But the rates will remain the same this year as they have for the past uh several years. So, just that was important. Uh what else we got here? Um, the FMCSA also announced within the last couple of weeks that they have extended the waiver that is in place. Supposed to be a temporary waiver, but it's starting to look pretty long term. It's been extended several times now. This is the waiver pertaining to um meds for CDL drivers. And recall from last year that the plan was to eventually move this over to a fully electronic process for CDL drivers whereby they would drivers would go visit with their DOT doctor uh get their DOT medical exam and then the results of that exam would get automatically electronically uploaded from the uh physician or whoever is performing that medical exam up to the National Registry of Medical Examiners and then from the medical uh from the national registry to that driver's state licensing agency to get associated with their license automatically rather than h the current process which is those drivers having to get a physical paper medard and then taking it to their state licensing agency and getting it associated with their license. Uh so the plan was to move to that fully electronic process back way back in June of last year. And then it turned out despite having 10 years to prepare for that many states and many um medical examiners were not ready for that transition and so they couldn't process the electronic uh results and so FMCSA has had to step in with this temporary waiver that allows fleets and drive CDL drivers to continue using those paper medards as evidence of their physical qualifications but only for 60 days after they are issued at which point they have to be on their on their uh uh driving record. And so that waiver is now extended until April of 2026 at which point hopefully that'll be the end of the waiverss and we will have transition to the fully electronic process. But just be aware that if you have drivers, CDL drivers in one of those states who still isn't able to process electronically those results, I think there are 10 or so states that are still on that list that they're probably still getting the paper medards and having to manually associate those with their driving record, which is kind of a pain, but uh that's how that's the world we're living in until those states get their act together and get the issue fixed. uh we will continue to push out information on that as that issue continues to evolve. All right, so those are the stories, those are the DOT compliance issues going on in the industry at the moment. Uh we'll transition then to the main topic. Again, today we're diving into an issue that's raising serious unanswered questions for the trucking industry, and that's President Trump's executive order directing marijuana rescheduling and what that could mean for US DOT drug testing for CDL drivers. This conversation goes well beyond politics and gets to the core of how DOT drug testing authority works and what could change if marijuana is rescheduled. To help us unpack all of that, we're joined uh once again by Patrice Kelly. Uh she is the uh longest serving director of the US Department of Transportation's Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance and a top authority on DOT drug and alcohol testing for many years. Patrice helped shape many of the US DOT's drug and alcohol testing regulations that carriers rely on today and there are a few people who are better positioned to discuss what marijuana rescheduling could mean for trucking. So Patrice, thanks for joining us. Welcome. you. Thanks, Brandon. And thank you to your audience for listening. It's a pleasure to be back with you guys. Yeah, when I saw this issue come up um late last year, I knew immediately who I needed to get in touch with to discuss all of the unanswered questions that we still have. I know a lot of my fleet clients have reached out with uh the same questions that I've been asking, and unfortunately, I don't think we have great answers to them yet. But I wanted to unpack all of that with you. So, um I guess we'll kick things off by when you first saw that executive order come down directing kind of a fast track for marijuana rescheduling. What was your reaction to it from a US DOT drug testing perspective? Well, first of all, let me just be clear for the listeners purposes that I'm no longer with the US government. So, everything I'm um speaking about now is truly my own opinion. before I left as the director of the office of drug and alcohol policy and compliance. What I said was the word of the department. So um looking at the executive order coming down the way it did, president was trying to satisfy a need that was expressed to him from a certain part of his constituency in the um marijuana industry. However, even though we had given him some heads up through our channels that um there would be negative repercussions for safety. Um the executive order did not include what we call a safety carve out. And that was kind of disappointing cuz what it means is that the president is going to allow the rescheduling of marijuana to continue. But there really isn't an action plan when it comes to DOT. And I guess it might be helpful if I stepped back for a minute and explained why would rescheduling of marijuana matter. I mean, right? Because it still would be under a schedule. So what's the big deal? And the big deal is that the US DO is required by Congress to rely on health and human services for the drug testing. Health and Human Services only has the authority to test for schedule one and schedule two drugs. Right now, marijuana is schedule one. So, when you move it over to schedule 3, HHS loses its authority to certify laboratories. And by congressional statute, DOT can only test for the drugs that the HHS certified laboratories are approved to do. So basically, moving marijuana from schedule one to schedule 3 would pull out your underpinning. There would now be no long there would no longer be any HHS authority to certify the labs. So there would now be only uncertified labs, therefore no DOT testing. And that's important because when President Reagan issued the executive order that created essentially drug testing in the federal government, President Reagan couldn't conceive of anything beyond schedule 1 and two for things like marijuana, cocaine, um the other drugs that uh are considered to be very serious, very addictive, not a high potential for legitimate medical use, etc. Those are your schedule one and two tribes. Yeah, I was going to say for people who may not be familiar with how the scheduling works, if you can give us like a 30,000 foot level of what the different schedules mean. Yeah, schedule one is something that has no medical use and is highly addictive. And marijuana is in that category right now. They want to skip category two, schedule two, which are are drugs that are highly addictive like opioids right down to fentanyl. You know, you want they want to skip over that level. Now, the opioids, there are very good reasons why doctors prescribe opioids and somebody's recovering from surgery, somebody's in terrible, terrible pain. And it's meant to be a shortterm prescription because when it becomes a longerterm prescription, that's when you have addiction issues. So, schedule 2s are able to be prescribed by a doctor. And that's why you'll hear sometimes somebody has a positive drug test result that a medical review officer will report to the employer as a negative. It's because the DOT program is looking for people who are using illegally. They want to deter illegal use. If you're engaging in legal use and you have a prescription, then you can go ahead and operate. It may be a safety issue that your especially in trucking. Let's go to that example. but schedule two is possible, but still it might knock you out because of your medical certificate. Yeah. where they essentially report it out as a negative based on the fact that you've mentioned, which is they presented a a valid prescription for whatever, but the MRO is essentially telling that driver and their employer that, hey, we we have a concern with you driving a heavy truck while you're using this type of of uh drug. And so to your point, then it makes a lot of sense for the fleet in that situation situation to then turn it over to that driver's medical examiner to weigh in on whether they are also concerned that the operation of an 80,000lb truck on this particular medication is a problem or not. So um that's where schedule one and schedule two fall. Schedule three, like I said, your number one problem is that the federal government cannot test for it because there's no authority. President Trump would have to create that authority through an executive order and he chose not to do that in this executive order. It's possible the attorney general when she proceeds with addressing the rescheduling, she could still put in a safety carve out that would say, "Hey everybody, status quo. " But again, it's going to be a little bit tricky because who gave the laboratories the authority in the first place? President Reagan through the executive order. I think the safer solution on this is going to be congressional. Yeah. Because I just don't think that the White House and um the executive agencies are absorbing what they're doing and what the repercussions are on all of us out here. So what you're hitting on is a point that I think a lot of folks in the industry miss when they say even the DOT when they say, "Oh, nothing's changing. " And it's it's a point that I've tried to raise through my channels and I know the American Trucking Associations has raised this in a letter that they sent to the Department of Justice when the DEA had proposed something similar uh last year. And I wanted to show this to you and read this section of it. see if this is what you're getting at. So, this was the ATA's concern that they raised [clears throat] to the Department of Justice. They say that the the DEA's proposal back there has serious ramifications because it could altogether eliminate employers ability to conduct and report marijuana testing of DOT designated safety sensitive workers, including truck drivers that are currently subject to DOT drug and alcohol testing rags. Current DOT drug and alcohol testing requirements are governed and therefore limited in their testing authority by the Department of Health and Human Services mandatory guidelines for work federal workplace drug testing programs which allow regulated employers to test only for those drugs listed in schedule one or two of the controlled substances act. Therefore, without additional action, deregulation or rescheduling of marijuana would have the likely consequence of precluding testing for all professional drivers and transportation workers as part of the DOT testing program. So, that was ATA's concern. It sounds like that's the one you're you're raising as well. and I had nice job pulling that one up. Thank you. Um but yeah, AT and I ATA and I had worked closely um together kind of formulating ideas and positions and again where does HHS's mandatory guidelines get the authority to test for schedule one and two and not schedule 3? That's from President Reagan's order that goes all the way back to 1986. Yeah. And so unless we get something that clearly re or essentially restructures the DHS DHS's authority, then that's still in place. DH. Basically, you know, to boil it down, somebody's got to give the government authority to test for schedule 3. And you know, we can debate who is going to give it, but somebody's got to give it. And the original authority came from the president. This president has decided not to do that at this point in time. Um, I hope that there's room for further negotiation on this and consideration. We got a big safety issue. You know what a lot of people don't realize is what brought DOT drug testing into existence was a series of marijuana related accidents. There were New York City subway accidents. There was a huge accident in Chase, Maryland, where a Conrail train hit an Amtrak train when the Conrail train operators were stoned and they missed the signal lights, three of them, warning lights, saying, "Uh, you got to change tracks. " And they missed them. And they killed an awful lot of people. and they created a lot of survivors who to this day are completely traumatized by what happened to them. So, you know, I think everybody who owns their own trucking company and pays insurance appreciates the need for the roads to be safe. Um, you know, we have a lot of family members who are involved in the trucking industry and I thought one of them said it very nicely to me. And he also happens to love hair testing, but he said, "I don't want people using on the road around me." He said, "Because my truck and my driving is also at risk when somebody else is not in full control of their capacity to operate safely." Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I've heard those same concerns expressed by by several different interest groups and I know they were submitted in the comments uh to the DEA's earlier rule rulemaking and I have no doubt that that will continue to be a a topic of discussion at least in in our industry. the FMCSA's data from its drug and alcohol clearing house. Uh so folks not familiar with the clearing house, this is the central repository of all drug and alcohol testing violation data for all CDL drivers operating in the United States. This database has been in place since 2020 and it tracks how many violations are reported, what types of violations uh or what types of drugs were at issue in the in the violation. So here looking at the most recent numbers reported through the clearing house since 2020, we've had a total of 345,45 violations uh drug testing violations reported to the clearing house. And of those 345,000 uh 204,000 of those were marijuana for marijuana. So over 60% of the positive drug tests that we are seeing for CDL drivers are because of marijuana. So it is clearly um a big part of the DOT drug testing program to say the least. And to your point, if all of a sudden DOT is left without the authority to allow motor carriers to continue testing for that, then it becomes a big issue. um all of a sudden that employers would have to contend with. Um backing up a little bit, I was curious. I I um I attended a webinar that you presented at a couple of weeks ago on this same topic and you you made note of a lot of things that I think are important for our audience to hear as well, which are putting aside for a second this issue of testing authority. I'm wondering if you could clear up for folks who who may just be, you know, casually reading about this issue what this executive order does and more importantly what it doesn't do because I've seen a lot of confusion out there. Oh, this is going to legalize marijuana. Um, I was wondering if you could give us a sense of of what the executive order actually does. So, good question. First of all, the executive order doesn't do anything today. The executive order tells the attorney general of the US to resume the rulemaking activity that actually the Biden administration had started and uh once the attorney general follows through processes then the president would like to see marijuana rescheduled. So it doesn't change anything today. It doesn't change anything until the rulem process is completed. Possibly Congress could do something in the meantime. I've been watching it and there's an awful lot of marijuana related legislation kicking around. Rescheduling is not a great idea. I thought the battle 15 years ago I saw this battle coming at the federal level and 15 years ago I anticipated it would be regarding full legalization. when you reschedu marijuana, the argument that's being given is that um from let's say the administration standpoint, well, this allows marijuana dispensaries to act more like businesses. We can collect federal taxes from them. They can use credit cards because right now, because it's illegal activity, they're not allowed to use credit cards. If you go to a dispensary, apparently there are ATMs there and you withdraw cash and then you do your purchasing that way. Um, so this was the idea is around banking. The silly thing is where are our schedule three drugs coming from today? They're coming from your local pharmacy, your Walgreens, your CVS, your Wraid, your, you know, um, Tom Jones's far local pharmacy and candy shop. They're coming from places where there's a licensed pharmacist who dispenses quantifiable amounts of a prescribed medication in response to a doctor's prescription. What is Well, first of all, I guess big pharma, I understand, is cheering. The large pharmaceutical companies are saying, "This is great. " Mhm. It really leaves your local dispensaries in limbo because they don't have licensed pharmacists on the premises. And so, does that also mean that we're going to give out other schedule 3 drugs at your dispensaries? You know, it creates a mess. right? And then again, we would be talking about a safety carve out. But because we anticipated this about 15 years ago, I worked with folks on Capitol Hill and the Marijuana Opportunity Reinvestment Act, the more act, it comes up about every year or two and it's for full legalization. Yeah. We're not going to allow school bus drivers and tractor trailer operators and airline pilots and railroad engineers to use marijuana the day after legalization anymore than we're allowing them to use it the day before. Yeah. So those folks as well as federal employees because you have to tie the HHS piece into it to get the lab certified. Um that's what the safety carveout makes the most sense in is in a legalization standpoint. putting it in rescheduling is just really odd. Yeah, it's a weird way to do it. It's side it's sideways stepping into it. It adds an additional layer of complexity cuz right now I mean we have what you're describing which is essentially the DOT saying we don't care what the individual states are doing in terms of legalization of marijuana for safety sensitive workers. It's going to continue to be illegal. uh and and you're not going to be qualified to drive a truck, for example, if if you're using marijuana, even if it happens to be legal in your state, even if you happen to have a prescription for medical marijuana. " But that's really a separate issue from it's one thing for the for the DOT to say truck drivers and safety sensitive employees can't use the substance. It's a completely other thing to say that the the DOT no longer has authority to mandate testing for that substance. Right. And so I think that's where a lot of people are missing the point here that even if DOT were to step in and say it's going to continue to be illegal quote unquote for for truck drivers, there's still a question of whether we're going to be able to test for it going forward or not. And that's where we need that DOT carve out that you've you've talked about. So I guess from your perspective, what would be what would be a responsible safety focused path forward from regulators or Congress to put in place that type of protection or that type of DOT carveout that that you would that you would need for that? Well, there definitely needs to be this safety carve out. And I just want to drop a footnote here. The National Drug and Alcohol Screening Association and DESUP has been tremendous in trying to reason with folks in the executive branch, with folks in the congressional side to say, look, this is about safety. This is not about anybody's opinions about marijuana legalization. And and DESA does not take a pro or con position. And I agree with that. I think that's wise because the issue is safety. So what does a carveout look like? A carveout looks like a provision that says regardless [snorts] of the current status of marijuana, DOT and the federal agencies will continue to test their employees and there needs to be an authority provision to certify the labs. See, Congress put up a barrier by saying DOT can only test using HHS certified labs. So, if you don't have an HHS certified lab, who can test for marijuana? And you can't because HHS will lose their authority. Mhm. So, the safety carveout needs to keep the federal employees in because that's what drives the HHS program. If there is authority for HHS to test feds, then there's a authority for DOT to test the regulated audiences. And that's the missing piece. That's the piece that needs to be plugged in. And I'll also say, you know, all of this has a profound impact on non DOT testing. Why? Because a lot of states require employers to either follow HHS or follow DOT for their testing. Yeah. And when you are going to remove marijuana because there's a lack of authority, then it's going to fall out the bottom in those states that require non DOT testing follow the federal standards. This is another concern, right? that if let's say we move ahead with no safe with no DOT carveout marijuana gets rescheduled even if I've heard some advise motor carriers I've heard other motor carriers say that they think it's a good idea that they put in place their own company policy that says we're going to continue testing for marijuana regardless of what DOT says but my concern with that is then you run into certain states in the country as I understand it have prohibitions on employers testing for marijuana, particularly the states where it's legal. And so it becomes an employment law issue at that point if you're an employer that wants to put that type of policy in place across the across the board. No, that's a good point. And you know what else adds complexity is you don't know where your post accident test is going to happen. And if your post accident test is happening in a state that bans marijuana testing, you got a whole lot of mess going on. And I'll just also mention hair testing. When I was with the federal government, when I was with DOT, I actually supported hair testing. It was Health and Human Services that did not support it. But I supported it. What is the best? What is the longest window of detection under hair? What is hair most effective for? Marijuana. Yeah. " You know, there's legislation pending right now to allow um employers to count their own company tests for actual knowledge. Yeah. And I fully support that. Well, yeah, that makes sense. Yeah. At and I at and I talked about this for years before it became a reality. And I'm grateful to the American Trucking Association for pushing that forward. Yeah. But the reality Yeah. I mean, that makes that makes total sense because if we're not going to allow hair testing as a to to meet the DOT drug testing, we should at least allow employers who are voluntarily doing it to report positive hair test results to the clearing house as actual knowledge because otherwise that it doesn't get reported to the clearing house. that CDL driver who has failed a hair test for whatever drug then can move on to the next motor carrier, apply there, and that subsequent employer of that driver may never know about that positive hair test result because right now folks aren't allowed to report it to the clearing house, which makes no sense. That's right. Yeah. you know, you've you've lost something huge out of hair testing. hair testing is so effective for employers. I mean, I've seen the the data from the trucking industry and how hair testing for pre-employment tends to lead to lower, if not zero post accident rates. so it's very effective but if you pull that out of the panel for marijuana for if you pull marijuana out of the panel for hair testing you lose a lot of the argument for the effectiveness of hair testing right so again I think it's forcing people to understand the this reality of rescheduling is forcing people to understand what it means to their company programs what it means to hair testing what it means to in the broader sense overall transportation safety, right? So, if you are a betting woman, what are the chances of us getting a DOT carve out uh to whatever final rule we end up with to reschedule marijuana? I don't know if it's just betting or if it's I'm stubborn as I'll get out because I'm not giving up on this fight. I was the one who came up with the safety carbell 15 years ago and I had proposed it to a congressional staffer who was extremely intelligent and extremely effective and she got it into the legislation and today she's the head of the national transportation safety board Jennifer Hmedy. So the fact that the chair of the NTSB really supports the safety car and understands the safety need for it is far more important about than whether I care about it. Yeah. Please. Working with Nesa to get the word to the legislators, working with also on my own to get the word through. I'm not a lobbyist. I'm just somebody who dedicated her life to transportation safety and I really care. So, I am going to bet at all on getting the safety carve out just because I'm willing to risk it all. This is part of my job that I get paid for. I I just started after I retired from the government. I started into consulting. I own my own company. This is not the part of my job I get paid for. Yeah. right? So many have lost people to these kinds of impaired driving, these kinds of lifestyles that I mean marijuana is a drug that leads to other drugs. So the reality is the more we're able to create deterrence, the more we're able to maintain safety. And that's the bottom line. So I'm just envisioning the comment section of our YouTube channel, which I know is going to blow up because we have a lot of truck drivers that watch our channel and uh I know a lot of them have strong feelings about marijuana legalization and and their assertions that marijuana use is no more dangerous than alcohol use. and we allow alcohol to some extent. Uh, you know, obviously not while driving the truck. Why do we treat marijuana any differently? And I know that's not really the topic that we're here to to discuss today. And and um, you know, I for those folks that have that mindset, I would encourage them to read some of the studies that do exist out there. Many of them will assert that there are no studies, but there are studies out there. I think the last one I saw, and I think ATA cites it in their letters to the DOJ and to the DOT, it was a significant percentage of commercial motor vehicle accidents end up involving positive marijuana test. Um, you know, in the post accident testing, whether that was the contributor to the accident, obviously they're not one to one correlated, but it's a significant finding, I think, from those studies if you just do the homework to go out and search for those studies. well, and marijuana behaves differently than alcohol does. And again, I'm not um saying anything about people's personal views of marijuana use. What I'm saying is don't use it if you want to drive a truck commercially because alcohol is water soluble. Everybody's body reacts the same. Alcohol washes out. You excrete it and it's gone. And impairment and intoxication go together in alcohol. So when you're when you're intoxicated, you're impaired. Yeah. In marijuana, there's a split. Yeah. And I think that's one of the the reasons why we one of the main reasons we treat them differently, right? Exactly. For for alcohol, there's an easy way to test for an for impairment, which we do through, you know, BAC tests and stuff like that roadside. Whereas, as I understand it, marijuana, there's just no great way to to do that. Exactly. And when you are no longer feeling the effects of the marijuana, you may still be impaired. Eye hand coordination. Um, so the ability to stop your peripheral vision is affected, but you're not feeling it. But the effects continue on past intoxication because it's fat soluble. Yeah. And our brains are made of fat. It goes to the brain. It goes to other parts of the body and it retains. But the idea is there are continuing impairment symptoms that go on. There's just not a test and every for impairment and not everybody's body reacts the same way to it. So until there is a solid way to test for impairment, it's different from alcohol. If anybody can come up with a solid way to establish impairment, then I think we're having a whole different conversation. Then I think truck drivers who would like to use marijuana and operate would be able to know legitimately what the bounds of safety are, right, for them. And fair enough, we're not there. Yeah. And then may Yeah. Maybe once we get there then it becomes more akin to alcohol where the regulations allow it but only you know to an extent. curious where what the current status of this is now. Um we've got the executive order. We previously had the DEA's um proposed rule. So what's the next step here? Well, the DEA rulemaking in and DESA, the National Drug and Alcohol Screening Association, was very very active in um in that proceeding and they moved forward with an administrative law judge to actually conduct a formal rulem. And formal rulemaking, it's just a weird animal. You don't see them. I mean, in 35 years with the federal government, that was the only actual formal rulemaking I had ever seen. And I was tremendously involved in regulations. So, um I think that process is over for this regulation. It's not going back to a law judge for decision. I think there are a couple of different ways the attorney general could approach this. She could move forward with it in a full notice and comment rulemaking. She could fall back on the notice and that the Biden administration gave and take the comments from that time and make her decision. Yeah. And just issue a final rule. which would probably be the worst of all and that's where they say oh it's rescheduled what do you think of that well FMCSA just found out the hard way why not to go with an interim final rule uh with their with their non-domicile CDL rule that got shut down by federal court and is now in the crosshairs still but in any well and none of my interim final rules ever got shut down when I was director of Odapsy, but it's because they were all cost and burden reducing. And when you're saying to the trucking industry, we want this to cost you less and be easier for you. Nobody's going to say, I'm taking it to court over that. Yeah. So, that's the appropriate type of change to make in an interim final rule where they're re you're not harming anybody and you're only making things more clear and more effective and less cost burdensome. But in this, yeah, this would be pretty devastating, but it's possible. So, we're kind of watching it, monitoring it, talking to people on the hill. " Because Congress can give the executive branch authority. the executive branch can't really a lot of the time define its own authority and we just lost the whole line of cases that they call the chevron cases. That's where um the courts would say okay federal agency you can pull your authority from this and you can move forward and we don't need to see what Congress said. We defer to you we defer to you right now that's gone. Yeah. So, I really think ideally Congress would be the right way to do it, though we know it takes a while to move Congress. Um, so I think that there are a lot of different wheels in motion right now. And I'll just also say when the when the rescheduling first came out under the Biden administration, the marijuana industry said, "No, no, no, no, no. This is not what we want at all because we don't want it to go toarmacies. We don't want this, that, the other thing. we want legalization. So, it'll be interesting to see where this moves forward, but like I said, there's ton of legislation being um put out right now. And they're all bills. They're not nothing's gone to um full um full com full agreement in both houses, but meeting Senate and House. Um, but a lot of different proposals are kicking around out there and um, I'd like to see something where we've got clear safety carveout language in legislation to protect and define this issue. So, let's go the other direction. next month? Yeah. What happens? Well, the DOT regs won't suddenly change. Yeah. Mhm. Trucking companies and airlines and others who are subject to the testing should not proceed with marijuana testing because there's no authority. Yeah. And if somebody tests positive, you got a big problem. See, the whole drug testing regime that goes on through the federal government is considered to be a warrantless search and seizure. The federal government is coming to you without probable cause and taking your urine. Yeah. And in the future, your oral fluid, we'll talk about in a couple minutes, and your hair. Um, which would be somewhere in the future, I hope. Um, but the federal government doesn't have a warrant to do that. They're doing that by balancing safety with the constitutional protections on the individual. Right? If you start subjecting people to testing for which you have no authority to do, you're not going to maintain that constitutional balancing. That's unconstitutional. Yeah. All it's going to take is one one lawsuit by an agrieved driver after the fact after that authority is lost to blow the whole thing up for the for the entire industry. So, yeah, I agree with that. what about all the other drivers and airline pilots and flight attendants and others who tested positive after the rescheduling? Yeah. Every one of them is going to be able to get back pay, reinstatement, and probably compensatory damages. And not from the US government, from the trucking company or airline or other company that put them through the testing without authority. Yeah. So, that's worst case scenario. Yeah, the employers are losing their protection if this happens. They get protected because the courts all the way up to the Supreme Court have upheld this as constitutional warrantless search and seizure. But you take away that authority and it's not constitutional. That's my opinion. Yeah, I agree. Um, so what's your advice to I've got I know you work more broadly in the industry with other transportation modes and stuff like that, but I've got a lot of trucking companies that come to us asking what our advice to them is at the moment. My advice so far has just been sit tight because I don't think it it warrants any modifications to any policies at this point or anything because we just don't know how it's going to turn out. Is that good advice in your opinion or what do you what would you recommend to anyone? You think so? Nothing's changed yet, but I'll also say to trucking companies, don't try to go it alone. Work with others. Stay in tune with your associations. Stay [snorts] in tune with the National Drug and Alcohol Screening Association, with your state trucking association, with the American Trucking Association. Rely on their consultants like you in truck safe. You're keeping them invol informed. You're doing podcasts. you're doing newsletters. com/subscribed. So, I'm going to go do that, too. But, um, you know, that's that rely on your consortium third party administrators also to keep you informed and trusted parties. I mean, who are you getting your information from? , um out to the West Coast. I mean, if you tell your state trucking associations that you really care about this and then they're working with the American Trucking Association, I think that's a way to get your voice heard as well as going within DASA. But I think they really need to rely on their trusted sources like you. Yeah. So Doug on LinkedIn is asking a question here I think we should address. He says, "How can we not have authority to manage our own company policy? If our policy says you can't be under the influence of marijuana, how can we not have the authority to test for it? And I would say, Doug, my concern from, and I know Patrice shares it with me, as lawyers, our concern would be that one I raised a little bit earlier, which is let's say we we go the route of rescheduling and you want as a company policy to continue testing for marijuana and make it illegal for your drivers. My concern at that point is a state law concern. because there are some states in the country that say it is unlawful in this state for you as an employer to test for marijuana. Uh particularly in the states where marijuana is legalized. So if you have that as a policy that applies to all of your drivers across the country, you're you're going to run yourself into a potential employment lawsuit or some kind of state enforcement action for having an unlawful policy. That's my concern. because what changes Doug is that this [snorts] is going to become a prescription med that can be prescribed and if you choose to fire somebody over prescri a legitimately prescribed substance then you may have Americans with Disabilities Act right actions filed against you because they're not illegal drug users. Today they are. Yeah, that's another huge issue. You know, I would I agree with you completely, Brandon, but I would tell Doug, that hey, you know, that's that's a fair point to raise, but you got to look at your state and then you got to consider what would happen if this is actually considered to be a legitimate prescription medication. Agreed. But to hit this home again, Doug, we're we're obviously speculating here because we're assuming in your question that we don't end up with a DOT carve out that leaves a status quo with marijuana. If we do get the DOT carve out like we want, like we're petitioning for, then you will still obviously be able to for your regulated drivers continue to have that in your policy. So, um, okay. So, Doug, you may also have it if your state requires you to follow DOT in your non DOT policy. If they require that for company policies, then this would take care of you there, too. All right. With what little time we have left here, I wanted to talk to you about oral fluid testing. two years ago that we were talking about what at the time was a final rule um ostensibly allowing trucking companies and others to leverage oral fluid testing as part of their DOT drug testing program. And here we are two almost two years later and they're still not able to. So I was hoping you could give us a status of why they still aren't able to. What's going on here? Well, on this one, it's honestly classic bureaucracy and it's pretty gross. So what happened is it's all stuck at the HHS side of things. The Department of Health and Human Services has the part that certifies labs, the Substance Abuse Mental Health Services Administration. They have that part of it. They also have the Food and Drug Administration. And the Food and Drug Administration has decided that if you're going to do company testing, you only need a simple clearance process for your oral fluid testing. But if it's going to be federal, then there need to be clinical tests. And I kid you not, when I say over 10 million, sometimes tens of millions of dollars are being sent spent to try to do these clinical tests. It's kind of hard to administer PCP and other things to people so that you can test and make sure the oral fluid testing device works. But in short, what needs to happen is the FDA needs to stop this. what's called 510K compliance certification in the federal context and they just need to fall back on the regular clearance process. And you know, I do think it's pure bureaucratic nonsense to say if a large trucking company wants to test its employees using an oral fluid testing device at the set cutoffs that you don't need any more clearance. in getting this approved. So, it really is purely an FDA issue and I'm very disappointed that DOT has not been able to move the ship on this. And so, again, I'm doing what I can behind the scenes to raise some awareness on this issue. If we keep going the rate at the rate we're going, the only labs certified will be in Canada. You know why? Because those labs don't have to follow what the FDA says. So right now HHS is working on certifying Canadian labs. Great. and it Yeah, exactly. but not US labs because US labs are stuck in this bureaucracy about additional certification. That's what it is. I'm really disappointed because as the DOT's primary author of the oral fluid final rule, it was my understanding from industry that everybody was ready to go. When the rule came out, we were like, great, we should have it in place by the summer of 23. It came out March of 23, effective May of 23. We thought that summer we were going to be good to go. Uh-uh. That's not the way it happened. And again, because of this FDA blossoming process. Crazy. All right. Well, we're about out of time. Patrice, as always, really appreciate you joining me on all the insight you're able to uh provide to to the folks that watch. So, thanks again for coming. If if folks want to reach out to you with any questions, how can they get in touch with you? com. Perfect. All right. Well, we're going to wrap it up there. Appreciate everybody for tuning in today. Uh, stay tuned for announcements about future shows. com. You can also follow us on our various social media channels uh for the latest news on highway compliance, DOT safety regulations, that type of stuff. I think that's all we got today. Thanks to everybody tuning in. We'll catch you next time. See you.

Event Completed

Thursday, January 15, 2026 at 1:57 PM EST

Watch on YouTube