Trucksafe LIVE! Virtual EventFree

Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 60 - Catching the Chameleons

Wednesday, February 11, 2026 at 1:57 PM EST
Trucksafe LIVE! | Ep. 60 - Catching the Chameleons

About This Event

Chameleon carriers—fleets that shut down and reappear under new identities to escape enforcement—are posing a growing safety and fraud risk across the trucking industry. On this episode, we're joined by former FMCSA Chief Safety Officer Jack Van Steenburg to break down how these operations work, why they're so difficult to stop, and what fleets and regulators should understand about the evolving threat.

Guests

Watch the Recording

Episode Summary

In Episode 60 of Trucksafe LIVE!, hosts Brandon Wiseman and Rob Carpenter are joined by Jack Van Steenburg, former FMCSA Chief Safety Officer, to break down the growing problem of chameleon carriers — motor carriers that use affiliated entities or new identities to evade regulatory oversight, sanctions, and negative safety compliance histories. The topic has gained significant national attention following a tragic crash in Indiana that killed four members of an Amish community and triggered a federal investigation into a network of affiliated companies. The hosts emphasize that while chameleon carrier activity is not a new issue, a confluence of factors including social media, advancing technology, and high-profile crashes has pushed it to the forefront of industry and public discourse. The discussion clarifies an important regulatory distinction that is often misunderstood: having affiliations with other motor carriers is not inherently unlawful. Under 49 CFR Part 385.337, FMCSA must satisfy a two-part test before taking action — first establishing that an affiliation exists, and second demonstrating that the affiliation is being used for an improper purpose, such as avoiding an out-of-service order, evading a civil penalty, or hiding a negative compliance history. The hosts stress that loose accusations of chameleon carrier activity based solely on shared addresses or common ownership are often misplaced, particularly given that large, legitimate carrier networks routinely share officers, addresses, and equipment under proper intercompany agreements. Van Steenburg and Carpenter also highlight the systemic gaps that allow bad actors to enter and exploit the industry. These include the low cost of obtaining operating authority, the ease of obtaining instant-issue insurance without meaningful underwriting, the open marketplace for buying and selling MC numbers through platforms like Telegram and purpose-built websites, and the limitations of FMCSA's carrier registration systems. Rob Carpenter discusses his independent research replicating the methodology behind FMCSA's little-known "Archie" system — a congressionally mandated screening tool developed in 2013 — and notes that a functional version of such a system could identify patterns of common ownership, shared VINs, and reincarnated entities before bad actors gain a foothold in the market. For fleet safety professionals, the episode surfaces several actionable themes. Carriers operating legitimate multi-entity structures should ensure full transparency with FMCSA, maintain proper intercompany lease agreements, and document the business rationale for affiliated entities. Those involved in carrier vetting — including brokers, shippers, and insurers — should look beyond shared addresses and examine deeper data points such as VIN transfers, license history, and registration timelines when assessing whether a carrier relationship raises red flags. The hosts and Van Steenburg agree that stronger barriers to entry, including a mandatory pre-authority knowledge exam, in-person new entrant safety audits prior to receiving operating authority, increased registration fees, and more rigorous insurance underwriting requirements, represent the most effective long-term solutions to keeping bad actors out of the system. Van Steenburg offered a pointed recommendation that FMCSA make more aggressive use of its imminent hazard authority to pull dangerous carriers off the road quickly, noting that even if such orders face legal challenge, they remove unsafe operators during the period needed to build a fuller enforcement case. The hosts also previewed an upcoming episode featuring FMCSA Administrator Barrs, which promises to shed light on the agency's current priorities and where the chameleon carrier problem fits within its enforcement agenda.

Full Transcript

Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. Is always up to date and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. E-regs was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. app. All right. Hey everyone, welcome to episode 60 of Truck Safe Live, show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon with Truck Safe and Children's Law, both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs. Got Rob Carpenter with me today. Rob, what's going on? Not a whole lot. How's it going? It's uh it's warming up here in Indianapolis. How about over there in Virginia? It is. It's like 55 here, so it's good. You still got some snow on the ground? We've got some ice. I mean, because we had that snow, then it was supposed to be like snow and then it turned to rain, then it turned to ice, and then we had an ice rink in the entire yard. So, that's been that's taking some time. Yeah, we had like uh like six inches of snow in the ground up until yesterday. And uh it's starting to melt finally, so that'll be nice. Yeah, I uh I had pipes freeze, so that was that was the first time for that, which was an event. That's no good. Did they burst or No. No. No, they didn't. It's just problematic [clears throat] when you don't have any water. Well, that's good. Yeah, that's not good. But, uh, okay. People didn't come here to hear us talk about plumbing. Um, appreciate you all joining here us here. If you're here with us live, say hey in the comments so we know who's around. Um, and obviously big show today talking about chameleon carriers. This is another topic that's been all over the news uh of late, including a bunch of articles that Rob has written on the topic. So, I'm excited to talk to him about it. An increasing issue in our industry as if we don't have enough issues to deal with. This is yet another one. Um, and so wanted to get to the bottom of it and so excited to welcome back on here in a in a few minutes uh, Jack Van Steinberg, former chief safety officer from FMCSA to help us walk through it. What is contributing to the problem? What exactly are Chameleon carriers first of all, I think a lot of folks just don't even understand what they are. So, we'll kind of break that down, get into the nuts and bolts of it, where things are going wrong, and that type of stuff. Before we get there though, uh, a few things to talk about. com or scan that QR code there on the screen. This is the uh app that we've built for safety professionals to gather together, learn from one another, ask questions, and also access all of our DOT related content. So, hope to see you over there. Secondly, we just opened up today, in fact, registration for our next Truck Safe Fleet Compliance boot camp. This one will be September 16th through the 18th in Indianapolis. Uh we're super excited about this. com. Uh all of the TruckSafe team will be there. Jack will be there. Um and we've just got a great agenda planned for this year's event. If you're not familiar with the boot camp, this is our uh this will be our fifth annual boot camp. It's our two-day, two and a half day in this case, uh in-person conference where we spend the entire time talking about nothing but DOT compliance uh with a group of fleet safety professionals, insurance folks, risk advisors, and uh and that group. and we just really dig into the details of DOT compliance and helping fleets uh to develop cutting edge safety programs. So, looking forward to that, Rob, you looking forward to that again? Yeah, it's it's usually a pretty good time. See if we can get some more. Super excited about it. You know, me more drivers. Yeah, we had the one driver last year that was that was unique. I think we had a couple couple drivers. Yeah. Yeah, we we didn't have that historically. Yeah. this year, new this year, the uh so it's normally a two-day conference, but this year we're adding a a third half day event that will be a simulated deposition of a fleet safety director so that uh folks in attendance can observe what a real life deposition looks like of a safety director following a highway accident uh or or in the context of highway accident litigation because obviously that's a a big deal. uh if you end up if you're a fleet and you end up in one of those and so you don't ever want to be trying to plan for that right on the fly. So um we found it's it's good to give fleets a glimpse into what that process entails, some of the traps that are involved in it. So we think that's going to be a big hit with not only attendees, but we're also opening up that half-day session just to the general public if folks just want to show up for that. Uh again, this will all be in Indianapolis in September at the Crown Plaza Union Station Hotel, downtown Indianapolis. Great venue. Uh should be fun. So again, check out the details. Spots will fill up quick, so be sure to register if you're interested in joining us. We usually have around a hundred or so in attendance. com is where you'll find the details. All right, enough about us. Couple things going on in the industry before we start digging into Chameleon Carriers. First up, I wanted to mention Rob's just been knocking out the articles recently. I don't know how how you have time to put all these articles together, Rob, but um some of the recent ones you posted that I wanted to just highlight. This one was I I know a big undertaking for you, but uh it has to do with insurers, commercial auto liability insurers and um how they are uh getting involved in some of these or getting wrapped up in some of these discussions about the crashes that we're seeing with commercial motor vehicles. So, give us the quick and dirty here rundown of the story. Yeah, the the the quick and dirty is, you know, one of the things that I've looked at. I mean, we, you know, we you, me, everybody else in our group, we kind of we we go to a lot of different carriers and there's a lot of times that I I started to see carriers that are smaller and they're still getting into the market, but almost all always they're nonunderwritten coverage. So I started to look at fleet size and then history performance. And then what I started to notice was large legacy fleets that have been in business for years. They've got larger fleets. They're generally in captive groups whether sole member or group captive. And then on the bottom end of that spectrum where you see more crashes, more violations, worse history um and of ultimately more un less underwritten coverage is that that bad side of the spectrum. So the the methodology we basically said is generally this should be a barrier to entry and somewhere we got to a point where we started just giving out insurance instant quote without underwriting the coverage or to review what you're self attesting to when you get coverage and that's allowed a lot of bar of bad actors to get into the market. So it's it's becoming a bigger thing actually. So we'll see where it goes. Yeah, I think that barriers to entry issue is something, if I had to guess, that FMCSA is going to have to tackle here in the near term. I know they've hinted at it in the past with things like um knowledge exams for folks that are wanting to establish a new trucking company. That never ended up going anywhere. We've obviously got the new entrance safety um uh audit process. Now, I don't know how effective that is, if at all, um, given our experience with it, but nevertheless, that's what we've got. Um, beyond that, free to get a DOT number. Uh, only $300 if you want some operating authority to go with it. And then, as you say, um, insurance was historically the big hangup and the big barrier to entry. Can you source insurance at a cost that is, um, affordable to you? And as you pointed out in the article, everybody should go over there to Freight Waves and read it. Um maybe [clears throat] not so much of a barrier to entry anymore given what the data is showing. So yeah, big issue for sure. All right, so great job with that article. Uh one other thing I saw come through this past week. Uh this wasn't one of your articles, but I thought this was interesting nonetheless. You probably saw it. group has filed um a petition for an exemption with FMCSA to the ELD requirement. Uh this is just an article on Overdrive. Says the Federation of Professional Truckers petitioned the FMCSA for an exemption from the electronic logging device requirements. Um let's see here. They say that the the group has requested an exemption from the ELD requirement to allow cover drivers to record their records of duty status manually with a paper log book rather than with an ELD. They argue that paper logs remain enforceable and are understood by enforcement officers nationwide and that small carriers face disproportionate financial burdens from the ELD requirement. Thoughts on this? I mean, um, I I haven't read the exemption request itself, but, um, I don't know. Some of these issues that are just pointed out in the article seemed like they were raised and addressed through the rule making for the through the painful rulemaking process for the ELD mandate itself. So, I don't know what's new here. No, I'm kind of torn on this one obviously because the shirt that I have on, but then there's the second piece of it is from uh from somebody that drove trucks there long before ELDs even was discussed. I mean, obviously ELDs have their issues and fatalities and and crashes haven't gone down. they've gone up since they since they came into existence. But um just knowing like I used to run seafood and I was probably one of the most illegal seafood haulers and that's just the name of that business. And um the funny thing about that was you you can site malfunctions and other issues with the ELD which in some cases they're accurate but you still have issues with people that do grid logs. Yeah. Um, so you're I think you're damned if you do, damned if you don't, but there's there's obviously benefits to both, but yeah. Are they gonna get their exemption? Yeah. [clears throat] Call me cynical, but I I don't see any way that this moves forward, especially all of the headache that went into getting the ELD rule passed. It was caught up in litigation for years. FMCSA got it through that. I just don't see any world where we come off of that. Um, but regardless, that is currently pending. If anybody has anything to say about it, they can go file their public comments in the docket for that. Um, so yeah, I just thought it was interesting. So, all right. Um, all right. I think that's all I had. Anything else that we missed there, Rob, that you think we need to talk about? I don't think so. I think we could go on all day on news, though. All right. Well, in recent weeks, the issue of chameleon carriers has moved from an industry talking point to a national headline. A tragic crash in Indiana that killed four members of an Amish community has drawn intense scrutiny not just on the drivers involved, but on the carrier, the driver involved, but on the carrier and the broader network of affiliated companies now under federal investigation. Today, we're going to take a closer look at how chameleon carriers actually work, what they are, why they remain so difficult to stop, and what cases like this reveal about gaps in enforcement and oversight. To do so, we're excited to be joined once again by Mr. Jack Van Steamberg, former FMCSA chief safety officer and principal of CMV safety experts. To break that down, Jack, welcome back. Thanks for inviting me, Brandon and Rob. Good seeing you again. Good seeing you. It's always great to get your perspective on these um on these tough issues, Jack. Obviously, uh we would like to not have to be talking about fraud like this and and these issues that end up leading to the types of accidents that we're seeing, but it's the reality of things and so here we are having to deal with it and obviously these are complex issues that the FMCSA has to um figure out ways to get a hold of it. So, appreciate your insight as always. I think where we should start with this, unless you guys have a better thought, is what exactly is a chameleon carrier? Because like I said at [clears throat] the start of the show, what I found is there's it seems to be uh there seem to be a lot of accusations being thrown around from what I can tell on social media about affiliations between carriers or among carriers and and uh somehow tying that to that alone, those affiliations alone to being chameleon carriers. So, let's clear up some of the mess here and first define what we're talking about when we are talking about chameleon carriers. Jack, you want to give that a go? Yeah. And I'm just I'm going back to the FMCSA days and you know there is a difference between chameleon and reincarnation. So, I'm just going to read you one sentence. It's a definition that chameleon activity is an action by an existing registered enterprise to use of multiple for use of multiple US do numbers operating in partnerships to hide evade safety performance problems or avoid sanctions. Whereas a reincarnation is an action by an enterprise new applicant to obtain a new US DOT number or operating authority for existing number using a new identity to hide evade safety performance problems or avoid sanctions. Yeah. Yeah. So, I think it's important there to point out um it's it's a two-part analysis and um when this was first highlighted through legislation and ultimately ends up in the federal motor carrier safety regulations, as Jack's pointing out, kind of the difference between the two. The the Congress and FMCSA saw fit to break this out into a two-part analysis. And I think this is where things go wrong. So the first part of the analysis, as you could tell from Jack's discussion there, is there has to be a finding of uh an affiliation or um or that this carrier previously existed depending on whether we're looking at reincarnation or chameleon carriers. But that affiliation alone is not sufficient in and of itself to then that's not unlawful. It's not unlawful to have affiliations with other motor carriers. And so I thought what would be helpful is to actually pull up the regulations here because I don't think many folks have actually looked at this. 73. That's where you'll find the standard that the FMCSA has to meet in order to pursue enforcement against these so so-called reincarnated carriers. And you'll see when you read the regulation that the FMCSA has two options available to it in handling reincarnated carriers. It can either issue an out of service order, shut them down entirely, or a record consolidation order, which is essentially if it's a if it's one carrier that gets shut down and then uh reincarnates as a different carrier or the affiliated situation where you got two um related carriers being used to continue an operation that gets shut down, they can consolidate the record. So if the first one gets shut down, then the the out of service order that was issued to the first one can be ported over into the second one consolidated with the second one. But my point in bringing this up here is that you could read the regulation here. It says for the out of service order option um if FMCSA may issue an out of service order to prohibit a motor carrier from conducting operation subject to its jurisdiction upon a determination that the f uh by the FMCSA that the motor carrier uh operated or attempted to operate a motor carrier under a new entity or as an affiliated entity. So that's the first part. You have to find an affiliation. And then the second part is the more crucial one and this is the one that I think a lot of folks miss which is that it has to be that affiliation has to be being used for an improper purpose. And what is an improper purpose? They are listed out in the regulation. They're they're clearly defined. An improper purpose would be to avoid complying with an FMCSA order. These are generally going to be out of service orders. Avoid complying with a statutory or regulatory requirement. Avoid paying a civil penalty. avoid responding to an enforcement action or avoid being linked to a negative compliance history. So, two parts, you find affiliation, number one, and then that in and of itself is not unlawful. Step two is you have to find that the affiliation is being used for an improper purpose on this list. And so, that's kind of it in a nutshell. Rob, Jack, anything there that you would highlight beyond that? [snorts] No, I think for me it's always just boiled down to I mean not just but one of the big pieces of it identity. It's are you who you say you are and are you going are you doing what you're supposed to be doing? And I mean I know that sounds kind of basic but really that's kind of what it boils down to. Brandon, I got I have a case right now I'm looking at and I got one motor carrier registered with FMCSA has had operating authority, one driver, one vehicle. It opened up in early 2025. They were shut down, no insurance in nine, September of 25 and then they were issued a out of service order for no new entrance safety audit in January of ' 06. One carrier, one driver, five months operation, 1,047 inspections roadside. and I'm looking further and you know so I do see affiliated carriers from the same address and obviously they're avoiding they're avoiding a lot of things obviously so but the system is definitely broke so but I mean one driver one carrier I'm seeing multiple inspections daily from this carrier but all over the all over the country and you know I have that carrier mapped out with all the inspections. Yeah. So, I want to dig into that in a little bit. Um, before we get there though, I'd want to kind of get a backdrop on the Chameleon carrier issue. This hasn't been uh I'm sure it's been an issue for a long time, but it's really only been baked into the regulations for, I don't know, 10, 15 years or so. Do you recall when the agency first started tackling this issue and what kind of um what kind of sparked the debate? Yeah, I do actually. there was a bus crash I believe in Texas um Angel Tours. 17 18 people were killed and it was operating under it was Angel Tours and then it switch had its name the new carrier was Iguala Tours or something and it caused a lot of media uh frenzy on that and I remember the administrator at the time time John Hill he brought me in the meeting and says this is what we call chameleon carrier he goes remember that term because you're going here for the rest of your career. And that was 2008. And then we had a crash, I believe, on 95 and it was the motor coach companies up in New York. And they were switching drivers, switching vehicles, you know, intermingling hours of service and so forth like that. And then we found it hard, Brandon, to to actually consolidate those records. And as you said, at some point, I'm going to take a guess without looking around, probably had to be about 2015 or 16, we got the authority to consolidate and put these carriers out of out of business. yeah, Rob, you I know you just recently on another Freight Waves article kind of broke down this whole problem with Chameleon carriers and kind of the background and how it came to be. any other insights on how we got to where we're at now? Well, I I had written an article and and the reason I as soon as he said where, you know, he was going to the 2008 crash, I kind of knew exactly where we were going with it. But the there there's been a number of these major crashes throughout the years. It's not just it does. It comes up, everybody gets enraged about it, something might happen, but it's usually something small and then everybody forgets about it until you have the next one. And um with this one, it was kind of it's it's a huge network and it gets bigger every day that I dig into it. But the we probably had more kickback on this article than any of the others. We've had a number of people reach out to Freightways and say, "Hey, we're just this one company. we're just we just have one truck in the same building and it's like you have shared VINs, you have shared plates, can you explain any of the following things and then they never respond. It's like they don't think you have the ability to research into these very micro elements to just say it's not just about the building that you're in, it's about all the other things that you have shared in common. So, it um it can get pretty deep, but that was that's been one of the big pieces that I've tried to push in terms of classifying them as chameleon carriers. It's not always about being at the same address. Yeah. And like we said, I mean, regulation's clear. I mean, that's only one part of the two-part analysis. So just sharing addresses even though it sounds sketchy and probably is sketchy in most cases without an intent or uh not just an intent but actually using that affiliation to achieve one of the improper purposes that is specifically listed in the regulation is just not a chameleon carrier under the regulations. I mean maybe we call it that colloially but um under the regulations it's not a chameleon carrier until that has been used for an improper purpose. The reason I keep harping on that is because [snorts] um back in a different life when I was dealing with these issues more directly through in my capacity as an attorney and looking at these uh these cases actually get litigated out in the administrative appeals process. First of all, we were dealing with a lot fewer of these over the first 15 years of my career. I could probably count on one hand the number of times I dealt with a chameleon carrier case. And I've heard more about it in the last 3 weeks than I did probably in the first 15 years. But regardless, in those circumstances where we were actually prosecuting the case or pro or defending the case before the FMCSA, it's a and Jack can attest to this. It's a thorough case that the FMCSA has to build in order to prosecute these cases. They can't just do it willy-nilly. They have to first build a case of affiliation through the things you're talking about, Rob. They have to link up all of these different operations that they want to consolidate through things like addresses for sure. Uh ownership, common ownership, bank account information, phone numbers, all of that. And it and it has to be, you know, a look at the full universe of evidence, not just one thing here or there. But then the harder part for them is to show that the affiliation was used for that improper purpose. And when I was dealing with this, the handful of cases that I remember, the improper purpose that always came up that in the cases I was involved with um were just avoiding a unsat rating. I mean, I never saw it come up in any other context other than one carrier gets shut down uh due to an unsat rating and then reincarnates or tries to move equipment over to an affiliated entity to avoid that unsat rating. that was the quintessential improper purpose that led to the prosecution of of those cases. Um, Jack, any other insight on how you actually saw these play out when when you were kind of litigating them through the administrative appeals process or anything like that? Yeah, I mean, even before we had the regulation, it was very difficult to prove. Um, but I also saw it, Brandon, you mentioned I I I saw it in a couple cases where um, just like you said, it was a conditional rating. you lose your contract. So, they switched over to another DOT number and authority they had in the bank. well, I think I think one of the things that I've harped on is and and I've discussed this on other shows that I've been on this week and last week, but when when I was in the private equity side, we there was a lot of times we would have mergers and acquisitions. So there's times where you may share you may legally share the same address, phone number, officer, everything. This is how this is how how most large carriers are set up. thing to see affiliated carriers that are sharing drivers, that are sharing equipment, that are sharing addresses, that are sharing ownership. It is a exceedingly common structure in our industry albeit for the larger motor carriers. I'll give I'll give it to you that when you start to see that type of affiliation with smaller carriers, it starts to raise an eyebrow. Is this really being done appropriately with intercomp agreements, that type of stuff? Probably not. Yeah. And that that was us. We I mean we had 20 all together. I think it ended up being 20 before we started merging some of them together. But they were all based at the same office in Richmond. They all had my name on them. They all had my phone number and my email on them. So to look at it from from a position without context, Rob is a owner of a chameleon carrier network with 20 DOS in it and he should go to jail. But once you add the context of this is done totally legally. We're not trying it's full disclosure. The FMCSA knows what we're doing. They understand how we've done it. And then when we do happen to share vehicles across entities, it's usually under some in basically a lease agreement. So everything is on the up and up. It's full disclosure. There's nothing that we're trying to do that's nefarious or hidden or under board. So I think that's that's got a lot to do with it in terms of the context piece because it can be done legally and it can and it's and it's fine. It's just how you go about it. Yeah. Um, I'm curious how you guys are seeing and and Rob, I know you've really dug into this recently, Jack. Uh, to get back to your earlier point about some of the dots you're starting to connect for that one case. I'm curious, number one, why we're why it seems like we're starting to see this become a bigger issue within just the last few months. And then also, how are you seeing these Chameleon carriers, if that's what they are, using the Chameleon um the Chameleon structure to what gaps are they trying to exploit through that structure? Well, what I what I see, Brandon, and you know, in several instances, I mean, what brought it to light, I I think it's Secretary Duffy and some high-profile crashes and then some articles written by a famous author named Rob Carpenter. Um, and I mean that. I mean, I think Rob's brought a lot of attention to this right now. Um, and I I just think that they're highprofile. It's getting the public's attention and DOT and there's a lot more people on the bandwagon too looking at this. I mean, you look at Dale Pra um freight validate. I mean, he's all over the uh on this subject. So, it's getting a lot more media attention as well and DOT's exact they've acknowledged it. Um they're changing the registration system. How much that will help I don't know. But the current regul registration system is broke. It's only identifying um it's supposed to identify carriers who are applying to get the DOT number, not their authority. And I don't know if the new motive system is going to try to resolve some of those issues with the authority or not. yeah, I know you've written about that too, Rob. explain to folks kind of the background with the registration system, the Archie system, and and you know, from what we could tell, what they're planning to do on that in the future. Well, they did update the the registration system to modus. But, you know, one of the things that I've the other system, which is Archie, which nobody seems to know about, but I pulled this memo, we we had a memo mid last year that said, "Hey, we are I don't know who dropped it. It was somebody from the FMCSA. It wasn't an administrator. It was just a guy that does the the techy stuff. " And I read it and I was like, well, we already have this. Like I just did an article on this like five months ago and we just don't have much data on it. So back in 2013, Archie was developed under under congressional mandate. They paid like $4 million for it. It was supposed to do all of these things that this new memo said was going to happen. Well, we had data showing that it actually it existed at some point because we had data that showed that all of these new carriers had been screened through this process and a number of them had been detected as chameleon carriers. Um, and then we haven't heard anything about it since. So, I I think the uh that piece I think I'd like to know more information on, but we don't have that information. So, one of the things that I did do recently in my my coding ventures was I developed I used the same methodology. I just pulled the methodology that they built Archie off of and then created a code to basically reinvent that system on my own. And that's how a lot of the data that I've pulled has come from. So, I mean, I've found that it works. It's just do we have it? I don't know. And these systems are just kind of pinpointing commonality among registrant existing registrants or past registrants and new registrants looking for common ownership common. The current archery system what what do you know what data points it's actually looking at? Yeah, in the methodology it looks at pretty much everything. It looks for commonality amongst u ownership bin transfers, license transfers, um even churn rates. It looks at pe like re like from a reincarnated aspect. Maybe you've been revoked or put out of service and have you then tried to restart as another carrier. So it it it was supposed to evaluate this. There's a long list of these things, but um and I think if it was in place, it it makes logical sense based on the methodology. But one of the things that I liked about last year and I think this was a big move forward is a lot of the freight fraud that we have is Serbian and Malddovven and Armenian and tied to that is often chameleon carrier operations. But one of those pieces is are you who you say you are? And there's a lot of people that are that'll license a trucking company as no name given or Mickey Mouse or F the FMCSA or whatever they decide to put in there. in order to register for a DOT number. Yeah. Yeah. And I think that was a big piece. And then if you let that lapse to get your authority, not for DOT number for authority. If you let that lapse, you've got to obviously pay the you've got to pay the $300 again and go back through the verification process. So I think that piece just being able to identify who we're dealing with and that we know who you are um is one thing. So I think that was a good step. just to go on, Rob said, you know, he talked about the registration system and the $300. If you look under the URS rule and if you look under the authority for the URS rule, safety loo and map 21, FMCSA can raise that registration fee to any dollar they want to help pay for the entire registration system. And [clears throat] I went as far as saying that the new entrant process is part of the registration system. And I've recommended several times and I know I get a lot of push back. Um raise that registration fee to $5,000 for the operating authority. And I don't know if it'll deter some of these uh it will deter some, but you know, some of these people that are buying up DOT numbers and operating authorities, they're they're an organized crime element, and I don't know if the 5,000 would even bother them at all. well, it's it depends on how it depends on the fallout from it, right? Like you can look at broker bonds when it went from 10 to 75,000 and the idea was if we go to 75 that'll push out all these small like less legitimate actors in the broker market. Well then we had companies like Pacific Financial and other shity bond brokers that would come in and say well for $1,000 a year we'll finance that $75,000 bond. So you can basically be a broker for $1,300 and have instant access to unlimited freight on the market. Right. which I think has been a huge driver of cargo theft. But it's no real different than car than being a carrier than getting a carrier authority. You go rent a Pinsky for $700 a week, pay $300 for your authority, you have unlimited access to freight 21 days later. So I I think as long as you had a way to keep people from subverting that $5,000 piece, I think it would be pro I think increasing it would be a good thing. whether 5,000's a number or it's something different. U whether maybe it's a scaling number. I I don't know. Maybe if you're going to enter the enter the market with a 100 trucks, it's something X versus if you're just one guy with a truck, it stays at a thousand, 5,000, whatever. So, I think what you guys are both pulling on, it seems like there's probably a confluence of several different issues that are converging over the last couple of years. At least that's what it seems to be. So because we're we're not only talking about chameleon carriers now, we're also just talking about barriers to entry more generally and getting keeping bad actors out of the industry altogether. We're also talking about uh insurance and its involvement in the equation and the cost of insurance and and uh also wrapped up into this now just more recently things like English language proficiency, non-domicile CDLs. I mean, I just put up on the screen a second ago um Secretary Duffy's response to the Indiana accident that uh Jack was mentioning. And in that one tweet, he talks about not only um English language proficiency, but also chameleon carriers as if they are, you know, linked together somehow. But obviously, they don't necessarily have to be linked together. But it's just like all of these things are either um becoming a bigger problem or they're just all being broadcast more broadly through things like social media and they are seem to be becoming a bigger issue. Well, I think that's it. Like I mean we've talked about chameleon carriers, Brandon, for five or six years, right? Or or longer. " Well, no, we didn't start talking about it in 2025 or 2024. I mean this has been an ongoing discussion in the industry for a long time but obviously with the growth of technology, social media, everybody has a platform and then you have people who as techn as technology evolves and your newer generations who are tech proficient and and they can just code a website to create something that tells you all of these things are connected. I mean that in in itself drives you know huge awareness of the topic. Um, but I still think the barrier to entry piece is a huge part. And insurance, that's one of the reasons I wrote the article on the insurance piece because, you know, when I started as a carrier, one of the hardest things to get myself into business was finding someone to insure me and to be able to come up with the money for the down payment to get insurance. It wasn't the $300 that was not prohibitive. It wasn't anything else. It wasn't getting the truck. The one thing that kept me could have kept me out of the market was whether someone outpriced me in the market for coverage or if someone wouldn't cover me at all. So when we started getting to this point where we're not even willing to look at the carrier outside of what they're self attesting to say, okay, you have a truck, you are a driver, we're going to give you instant issue insurance. It that's a that's an issue. You're removing the one of the biggest barriers, most costly barriers to entry into the market. So if if you just made everybody have an underwritten policy or you increased the cost of coverage or the minimum of coverage, it's going to have an effect on who can enter the industry. And and you look at back when ICC was here instead of FMCSA, we had far fewer carriers, but everybody knew everybody else and it was up to them to let you into the into the trucker group. And now it's like it doesn't matter. You want a truck, you got a truck, welcome to the industry. you're a trucker. So barrier to entry is a huge part of it. Rob, would what I know I'm not supposed to be asking the questions, but you just with the insurance industry, do they talk to each other? Do they have a common database? Because what we see in a lot of these chameleon carriers is same vehicles, same drivers, and insurance company looks at vehicles and drivers. " you know, the company we just insured or that company down the road just insured the same drivers and same vehicles. So, what's going on? Yeah, there there's certainly there's certainlyformational systems out there that they can look and see different things like that. But one of the things that you have to think about, too, is and we've kind of figured this out over time where u and I'm about to put another article out about this. So, and I don't know how many people it's going to make mad. I made some mad last week, but we might as well keep the ball rolling. But with a lot of a lot of these uh chameleon carriers or or less compliant carriers, what they'll do is they'll come in and they'll say, "All right, we it's a once a year. " And say we have, let's just use it's chub. One of the ones that's doing it chub. And they're going to end this they're going to end this process because what's happening is people will come in, they'll declare we have 20 trucks. These are the 20 bins that we have. And then when next year when they come to renew, they've somehow come up with 400 more trucks somehow somewhere throughout that year. But the price of coverage never changed because only one time a year were they required to update the bin. So for that whole year, they were only paying for 20 trucks of insurance when they actually were running 400 trucks. Nobody knew. So part of that is um is just having lack of like a clearing house. And and we we have this issue in a lot of ways. It's like do we have a clearing house of like bad actors in the industry or bad vins that we know have been swapped and u I think it would be worth looking at for sure to kind of add and some kind of clearing house of you know bad equipment or bad people or or however we could do it. So, um, kind of going back to an issue I I raised, but I don't think we ever got to talking about earlier was kind of how you're seeing it evolve. The chameleon, the complexity of these chameleon operations evolved. Like I said, when I was dealing with these more directly uh probably 5 10 years ago, we were seeing them mostly used to just avoid an out of service order or uh a conditional rating as Jack said. How are these complex fraud fraudulent networks being used nowadays? It's not just to avoid uh safety ratings. Obviously, we don't have very many carriers in the country that even have a safety rating. So, Rob, Jack, how are you seeing these networks using their affiliations and stuff like that to avoid regulatory oversight? They're they're selling the MC number and the DOT number. Um, and and that's what I see in this one case I have, you know, 1,047 and I'm looking at shippers and everything like that, but they're sell that $300. They're, you know, telling their people that are in this organized network, hey, don't bother getting the registrations, you know, you don't really need it. You can use mine. You know, just give me the $300 and, you know, we'll call it even. And they're selling it. They're making money on these. You know, I looked at these 1,047 inspections and all of them with the same DOT number. There's no doubt. I mean, they are selling. So, that's how they're they're making profits that way as well. And then you get into the you get into the um the fraud issue, cargo theft and so forth like that. I mean, they're not who they say they are. yeah. And and one thing that I one of the things that that I've kind of watched unfold is um there to talk more about what Jack's saying, there's a site there's a woman online named Maria. She a lot of this is done in like Discord groups and Telegram and signal chats and I'll join a lot of these groups because I am a truck driver. I'm probably already in most of the truck driving groups out there. But they'll, you know, you'll find these leads to different places and you go to these sites and Maria used to sell these things on I mean MC's. You go in there, she tells you everything you need to know. She sold 300 of these things last year. It's a marketplace for DOT and MC businesses. Go on there, she'll sell it for you. But Maria got so busy doing this on Telegram that she started a site called Dalia. Like vibe coded this herself, started it. It's out there. They're not even trying to hide it. So that's part of it. But the other thing that I see sometimes you go to carriers who and and a lot of times they operate under the premise of I'll open I'll remain completely uncompliant. I have no interest in doing anything I'm supposed to do and by the time new entrant comes around between 12 and 18 months. I'm going to have burnt all the compliance bridges that I have with enforcement. Time to close that one down and move to this other one that I've got sitting in the wind. I've already got a DOT that's dead on it. I pay the $300 and upgrade it to an authority. move all my equipment over and now the business that probably would have been shut down can now re kind of basically reincarnate itself. So I I think there's a lot of different ways to look at it. So putting aside kind of avoiding the enforcement part of it, it sounds like and I think this is true and it's probably the impetus for a lot of those MC sales. It sounds like it's mostly to get access to business that they wouldn't have gotten otherwise had they just been had they just started up shop from the from the very beginning. I know there are several shippers out there, we won't name them, but shippers and brokers out there that won't do business with newly registered entities or entities that just have gotten their MC number within the last year or so. So, is that what's driving a lot of this from your perspective is trying to get access to business that requires um that these entities have been around and have experience operating over a certain amount of time? Yeah, I think so. I mean, if you're if you look in the Telegram groups when they're selling these things, I mean, the the listing is just like a classified ad. I like that dramatic zoom in to your face. Oh, my AI didn't run me down. But, um, so what happens is you have like this classified ad and it basically breaks down everything. But one of the things that's almost in all every single one of them is other retailers will work with you because they have agreements with these people already. So, and and some of these are really bad they're really bad authorities. Then she spells it out like, "Hey, this is not a good authority. " And it's like, okay. Yeah. so I mean I think that's the important point though. It's that, you know, these chameleon networkers are not always used for a per se unlawful purpose. It it's not unlawful for them to to it's not unlawful. It's it's not a violation of the safety rags, I should say, for them to use that that affiliation or that purchasing of the MC's to go and solicit business from uh from a shipper or a broker. it may it probably breaches the contract that they ultimately enter into with that uh with that retailer, but it's not unlawful per se. And so I think that just adds to the complexity of this issue. We've got [snorts] carriers that are using these affiliations for a truly unlawful purpose to avoid a negative safety compliance history that FMCSA rightfully has to start with those, right? I mean, that's what its regulations allow it to target. But then you've got this whole other group, probably a bigger group of folks and carriers using affiliations just to get other other business. And so it's almost like we've got those two separate issues that both need tackling, but when it comes to FMCSA, it's always already short staffed. I mean, it obviously has to focus on the first group. Yeah. Yeah. I think there's got to be some priority. But um you know there's other ways that you can track these things down too because you know you can sell some things but some things you can't sell. You can sell an authority. You can't sell a DOT number. So one of the ways that that I've kind of tracked these things is to kind of watch the sales of these entities is you can look at an aged uh you know one number's aged, one number is new and they don't match it. You know, obviously there's disparity there and and when that happens, there has to be a reason, right? Why do you have an an old number, an old DOT number, but a you know, not an not an old C number. So, there's a lot of different tales in this thing. And maybe Archie is the answer to that. You bleed all these into the same methodology and put it back out and use it. But you got two different problems. And you know, when I was up in DC and I was talking to bars about this, administrator Bars said, you know, we've got buckets that we're looking at and you've got buckets that are, hey, we've got problems in our industry that that are long-term problems that we need to solve, but we also have to keep problems from entering the industry as well. And then there's critical buckets versus things that we would like to get done that have to be focused on because ultimately you only have three more years of this administration before you possibly end up having to change. It'll be interesting. Um, uh, breaking news here. We, uh, we've got, um, administrator bars scheduled to be on on our Truck Safe Live podcast in a couple of weeks. So, for sure, it'll be interesting to hear his take on kind of the prioritization issue. What issues are top of mind for the agency and tackling and where this Chameleon carrier issue kind of fits into the mix. Um, running out of time here, Jack, Rob, if you all I know we've kind of hit on it uh here and there as we've gone along, but if you all were um in the middle of crafting legislation or regulations to try and get control of this issues, what major things would you see would you want to see baked into those to give you the tools, if you're the FMCSA, the tools to really get a hold of of the problem? Well, I'll just start out twofold and it's, you know, the make the entry a little bit difficult. Brandon, you touched on in the beginning the pre-authority exam testing and the new entranted safety audit. I'd make them first. I'd start that pre-exam. It's way overdue, but I'd make the new entrant a a a requirement before you actually get the authority and then make it on person in per or in person and make it a little bit more difficult. And then the second thing is when I was at FMCSA, we were going to and I we were doing this when I left, they were trying to name designate what we call senior safety investigators, those that have a lot more experience to investigate the tougher cases and these chameleon cases would be the tougher cases. And I guess that never came through. It fell through the cracks um after I left. And you know FMCSA has some good talent that could you know you can start looking at the principal place of businesses and where they match up where there's 50 people in one place just branch out and see what type of activities stone through them. So I would you know with the resources they have to limit it. I would try to focus a little bit more on chameleon carriers and um see where we go from there. Rob I'm not I'm not much different. I'm thinking the barriers to entry is the big piece. And then um I mean if you can focus on [clears throat] if you can focus on keeping people out and you're not constantly putting trash in then you can clean up the trash that's already in the system. And and I think it has to start with it has to start with the spot, right? Like we have to cut off bad people from getting in the system or we're never going to get the system cleaned up. So I I think all of those are big things and and u being screening carriers and actually seeing who they are and knowing who they really are when they get into the system is is going to be a good thing. Yeah, maybe they can hire you to vibe code them some kind of solution, software solution that'll take care of that. I've been getting in trouble with that. But um yeah, I I think um I think that's really the answer to a lot of it is I think if you can limit who who gets into this thing, who gets in the club, right? Like there's barriers to everything. And they they shouldn't be a they shouldn't have to identify what systems they're using, the technical specifications for something like that. Um I I know they do it because of the the rule making and the privacy issues, but there's got to be some exception to that. " So, yeah. Yeah. And and that's another thing, you know, like you mentioned Dale Pra earlier and Dale Pra, we they started a freight fraud task force and with that freight fraud task force, they don't put anything out. Like they they they've made it a point that we don't want to put out anything that anything that we do to actually solve what we solve and fix what we fix. Yep. For that reason. Tyler from our team is uh pointing out something on LinkedIn that's worth mentioning. He says, "Should FMCSA have the authority to approve change and control of entities with operating authority? " I I think that kind of goes right into it, which is what authority does FMCSA have here? He's pointing out kind of a gap that we've seen exploited over the years, which is that like he says, arguably FMCSA doesn't have the authority to uh require that they approve changes in control uh for motor carrier authority. So, we could just that that's what facilitates the sale of these MC numbers is that they don't have to get the sign off from FMCSA to change the owner of this MC number from one person to the other in the context of that sale. I think that's a good idea. But I think the problem is that you have to think about too is a lot of times on the black market for these for selling these businesses is you have proxy ownership, right? So when these are sold, it'll clearly say in the advertisement, this company is being sold with an owner with an active bank account and all you have to do is buy it. yeah, you basically you become the owner because you bought it. But on paper, the ownership that has always been the ownership remains the ownership. So there really isn't a a public display of who the actual owner really is. And we've seen this in other instances where people will set up five or six companies, they'll be the owner, no one knows who they are, and then there's five individual owners that are proxy owners that don't even know they own trucking companies. So there's that's an issue in itself. Yeah. And I also just use that imminent hazard authority a lot more and even before you go through the records consolidation. I mean look at the crash in Indiana. Just use that authority. Yeah, we don't see FMCSA use that all that often. Again, another issue that I could count on one hand how many times I saw it over the last 15 years used or so. But yeah, I mean technically FMCSA has the authority to immediately shut down a motor carrier or a driver for that matter if they think they are an imminent hazard to public safety. The regulations define what is imminent hazard. Uh as as you would imagine there are concern there are legal concerns with doing that obviously because you are taking away something that you granted to somebody namely operating authority without first giving them a hearing to dispute any evidence that you may have. So that's the concern. But you're you're right Jack. We don't see it used that often and it probably could you use be used um more frequently than it is. And I think even if FMCSA gets called to task on on those on the back end in some kind of litigation or something that that you know spurs up after that, I think they would be I think they would be able to defend themselves with a lot of these cases that we're seeing. well worst case if you if you put out an imminent hazard order and you take someone off the road, they're off the road. Even if it ends up going to court and you've got to you got to battle it out. uh you have them off the road for a period of time and in that time you can use that time to figure out everything else that you need to figure out to actually back up even more so why you did what you did. Yeah. All right guys, we're about out of time. Anything else that we haven't hit on that we should. I don't think so. I'm sure there is. yeah, another topic we could just talk for days on. Uh anyway, Jack, always as always, we appreciate you joining us and hearing your insight on it. Uh, like I said, Jack's going to join us at this year's boot camp. I'm excited about that. yeah, Brandon, it'll be great. Uh, we've got a lot in store, like I said. So, if anybody wants to come meet Jack in person, that'd be a good place to do it. Otherwise, you can, uh, you can shoot him an email or, uh, if you need to get in contact with them, you could always reach out to us and we can put you in contact. So, Jack, thanks for being here. Uh, really appreciate it. All right, that's going to wrap up this show. Thanks everybody for tuning in. Um, be sure to follow us on our social media pages where for updates on upcoming shows and articles and videos on all kinds of DOT compliance topics. Also, subscribe to our newsletter if you need a resource for that type of stuff. com/subscribe is where you can do that. Anything else, Rob? I don't think so. All right, that's it. We'll sign off here. Thanks everybody. See you later. Thanks.

Event Completed

Wednesday, February 11, 2026 at 1:57 PM EST

Watch on YouTube