Full Transcript
Heat. Heat. Heat.
Heat.
All
right.
If you're like us, you're probably tired of flipping through outdated and expensive regulation books and struggling to understand the rule or guidance you're after. E-Riggs is the first web and mobile app version of the federal motor carrier safety regulations, helping fleets of all types and sizes better access and understand their regulatory obligations. E-Riggs is always up todate and allows fleet safety professionals to not only read the rules, but also dig into FMCSA guidance and learn more about complex regulatory topics from industry experts. Highlight, bookmark, and take detailed notes right from the app and access them on any of your devices and easily share a digital version of the regulations with your drivers so that they too can better understand the rules. Was developed by safety professionals for safety professionals. Try it out for free at e-regs.app.
All right, everyone. Welcome to episode 62 of Truck Safe Live, show where we and our guests tackle the hot button issues impacting highway transportation. I'm Brandon, that's Tyler. We're with Truck Safe and Children's Law, both of which are dedicated to helping motor carriers develop and maintain cutting edge safety programs. Tyler, how's it going? Doing well. Indy500 this weekend. Oh, yeah. You going really excited. Oh, yeah. You got your uh cut off jean shorts and your um American flag all over the place. Oh yeah. Yeah. Got ready. You got your cooler packed. It will be. All right. Ready to roll. Uh yeah. Tyler and I both live near Indianapolis, so it's kind of a ride of passage here for us each year. Uh yeah, it should be great. Um well, welcome to everybody who's here with us live. Say hey in the chat if you're around so we know who's around. And um yeah, got a kind of a breaking news type show for today with the US Supreme Court handing down its decision in the Montgomery versus Caribbe. How do you how do you pronounce that? Is it Caribbe Transport? Is that how you pronounce it, Tom? Something like that. Something like that. Okay. Well, Matt will tell us later how you pronounce it. Um but yeah, we wanted to break that case down. We have a lot of clients both on the broker side of things and also on the motor carrier side of things asking us how this decision will impact them if at all. And so we thought we would share our at least our preliminary thoughts on this and also hear from um Matt Leler who is making the rounds these days talking about this case. He's got a lot of good insight on it and what it could mean for the industry at large. So looking forward to hearing from him here in a few minutes. Uh before we get there, a few things to talk about going on at Truck Safe. Worth mentioning here. First up, if you're not a member of our trucksafe network, I'd encourage you to join it. Free to join trucksafetwork.com. Um this is where this is the space we've built for fleet safety professionals to gather together, learn from one another, ask questions, and also access all of our DOT related content that we push out pretty regularly. Free to join trucksafetwork.com. Hope to see you there. Then we've got our upcoming truck safe fleet compliance boot camp. This is our two-day in-person event. This is our fifth annual boot camp that we will be putting on in Indianapolis September 16th through the 18th. Uh great continuing education program for uh safety directors, safety managers, owners of small trucking companies, insurance folks. Uh anybody who has any interest in DOT safety regulations, we spend two days talking about nothing but that. Um, we've got a lot of great speakers lined up for this and also some hands-on exercises, DQ file reviews, that type of stuff. So, it's actually useful to you um to get a better sense of how uh fleets are protecting themselves from a DOT safety and compliance standpoint. So, details over at trucksafebootamp.com filling up pretty quick um even though we're still a few months out. So, if you want to join us, uh, I'd recommend you go over there and register yourself as soon as possible. Um, two other things I'll mention, then we'll get on with the show here. Uh, a new service that we launched at TruckSafe couple months ago, our compliance plus program. This is our monthly subscription service. Check it out over at trucksafe.com. This is another great resource for fleet safety professionals. Um that includes things like uh access to exclusive webinars, access to all of our online courses on DOT safety regulatory topics, uh and also um periodic regulatory updates delivered right to your mailbox and also an analysis of your fleet safety metrics, pulling in your data from FMCSA, evaluating it, presenting it to you in a format that uh is useful to kind of keep tabs on how you're performing uh roadside. So that's our compliance plus platform. And then lastly, I'll just mention our ELP ready partnership. So English language proficiency continues to be a hot button issue for a lot of fleets. We are continuing to see uh a ramp up in enforcement across the country. This is something we're tracking. If anybody's interested in how many ELP violations are being written up, this is something we track over at trucksafe.comp. It's updated daily. I think the last I checked, we're at like 20,000 out of service ELP violations written up since last June. And so it's becoming a a big issue for a lot of fleets. And so, uh, one of the partnerships that we developed was with a company called ELP Ready. It's the first um AI based English language assessment that is quick and easy for fleets to administer to all of their drivers. You just send your drivers a link to their mobile device and the system runs them through an English language proficiency assessment just like if they were roadside. talks to them like it's an inspector, asks them questions, shows them some road signs, asks them to explain what they mean, and then uh grades them not only just on their proficiency, but also on their comprehension of the questions being asked, and then spits out a certificate that you could keep in their driver qualification file as good evidence that you actually did something about English language proficiency, which turns out to be important. So, check that out. Uh, you can either find it on trucksafe.comp or elp ready.com. Anything I missed there, Tyler? No, I think the ELP ready thing is great though. I took it and I I passed. That's good. That's good. Super easy to use. It was really good. It was going to be an awkward conversation if you were struggling with English proficiency here for the rest of this discussion. But uh in any event, um like I mentioned at the start, today we're digging into the Supreme Court's May 14th, 2026 uh decision in a case called Montgomery versus Caribbe Transport and what it actually means for freight brokers, shippers, and motor carriers. Um as you've probably seen, there's already a lot of noise around this case and we want to try and cut through it uh as best as we can. And to help us do so, we're excited to welcome back the armchair attorney, Matt Leler. Matt, what's going on? I was going to bring the noise, Brandon, and you just said not to bring the noise, so I have to dial it back. No, you guys also didn't mention uh we had international road check last week. That was exciting. How could we forget? How could we forget that? Most fleets forget about it, too, to be perfectly honest. That's true. What What's the data showing? I know that's something you watch pretty closely. Yeah. So, I mean, the national average of out of service is 22%. We've seen reporting of up to 32% of commercial vehicles being knocked out of service. Uh this is for things like uh brakes, lights, and tires. The things that make the vehicle stop and then also show you when it's stopping. So it's a tasty sandwich. Yeah. Delicious sandwich. Not great for your vehicle maintenance if you're not hitting those numbers. So this is the world we live in. And now brokers are going to be way more uh interested in what happens with vehicle maintenance. I suspect third of all commercial vehicles operating on the roadways have some kind of out of service condition. At least for those couple weeks. We all want to get home in the same condition that we left. And driving a truck is the eighth most dangerous job in the United States. And it's something we have to kind of keep in mind as we look at this Montgomery case. Does passing liability to another party make people safer? Uh I don't know. I suspect we'll find out, but it's a question that we're going to be asking for a long time. So, to get right into it, I know, like I said, you've been making the rounds here, um, breaking down the case, and I've appreciated watching your breakdown of this because it makes it pretty, uh, as intuitive as it can be. I mean, the decision itself is not that long of a decision, which is great. Um, and it's a bit unique in that it was a unanimous decision, 90 decision from the Supreme Court. And so, maybe what we could do to start out is if you could kind of set the legal landscape for us. What led up to this case? What was the case about? What was the landscape when it comes to broker liability leading up to this? Yeah. And the reality is we have all been addicted to cheaper and faster freight. That is what we started off with. And when you look at deregulation in 1980, that was the the movement towards making the industry a lot more agile and lowering the barriers to enter. And now prices can be done uh through negotiation as opposed to the government setting those prices. It continued into 1994 where we had what became F4A. That's an aviation statute that that kind of carved out brokers. Now, brokers are new to this industry. I mean, they've only been around in any meaningful sense for maybe 30 years. And as they've grown market share now, today 25 to 30% of all freight moves through freight brokers. And this question became uh really really uh polarizing. Under what circumstances can a motor carrier be liable? We had we know that, but when can a broker be liable? And so F4A had this safety exception that would basically preempt claims against the broker, but the safety exception let you bring them back to life if it if it related to a motor vehicle. And that phrase relate to a motor vehicle has so much meat in it. And that's what really we were talking about at Scotas. But before we even got to Scotas, we had a very specific split among the federal circuits. So you had the ninth circuit which is California, Washington, Oregon. The sixth circuit which is Michigan and Ohio and others. Uh they said brokers should be liable for the negligence of a motor carrier or hiring with a negligent process. And then you have the seventh circuit and the 11th circuit that were like no uh claims against brokers are going to be preempted. Brokers do price route service. They don't inspect vehicles. They don't maintain vehicles. They don't own vehicles. They don't operate vehicles. And that was the the place where we finally got the Supreme Court to grant Sir Shiari. And then we had unanimous decision, which blew my mind. I never would have guessed a unanimous decision from the Supreme Court. Crazy. Yeah. And I appreciate you kind of going down the road of deregulation because I think it's some it's an aspect of the case that doesn't get talked about enough, not just this case, but any case involving F4A. You hear the term F4A, but I think it it just kind of goes over most people's head and in terms of what it is exactly. Maybe Tyler, Matt, one of you, do you want to kind of explain generally speaking what it is that F4A preeemption is actually doing? If it doesn't cover negligent selection by brokers anymore, what good is it in any other case? Well, you're still going to have preeemption presumably in cargo claims. So, there's still going to be things that are are are going to be valuable with F4A. But the idea of negligent selection process, this is the big question we're all struggling with right now. Even before we started recording, Brandon, it was what is a safe motor carrier? Like what is a safe motor carrier? We don't know the answer to that. What is a reasonable carrier vetting process? We don't know the answer to that either. So the Supreme Court, I believe, um, thought this was a much easier question to answer, thinking the government, the FMCSA knows this information, but that's not the case. And so F4A was giving brokers this kind of level of protection. And what we had seen happen was motor carriers were underinsured, poorly maintained, and who else are you going to go after? And that's what ends up bringing this this thing all the way to the Supreme Court is you have a bunch of states that want to hold brokers accountable and do not believe that their negligence claims, which are really safety claims, should be prevented in federal court. So, how do you typically see these types of uh allegations against brokers styled? I mean, what in essence, what is the allegation against brokers in cases like these? Yes, this is the part I think is going to be the most important for everyone to understand. You do not know a motor carrier is unsafe until the accident takes place. And so what ends up happening in this industry is a broker is going to try to find a a motor carrier to move freight for them for a for amount of money that they've agreed to and they're going to look at the federal database and say, "Okay, is this person licensed? Do they have insurance? Are they certified? Are they have all the qualifications?" And off you go. If you simply rely on the federal government's data, you will lose. And so these cases kind of boil down like this. And I'll use the example with this Montgomery case. There's a truck driver, Shawn Montgomery, who was stopped on the highway. He stopped on a rec on the shoulder. And another vehicle operated by Carab Transport is traveling, loses control, and smashes into him. Uh, that company was hired uh by CH Robinson, and ultimately you sue the company that hit you. And most motor cares carry the minimum insurance of $750,000, which was established in 1985. And then they say, "Who else can I go after?" And the brokers have money and so they go after the broker say this carrier was unsafe. You should have known they were unsafe and because you selected them you caused this accident and you are jointly and severally liable for the the damages. And this is going to be a major shift for many brokers across the country. Yeah. I mean that insurance go ahead. I was going to say one thing I I kind of think will be interesting is you know how plaintiffs attorneys um make those allegations and their complaints. There was a case out of um district court in uh Wisconsin yesterday where the court granted a motion to dismiss. This is a negligent entrustment case against the broker and the plaintiff even on an amended complaint didn't actually provide any factual allegations of how should the broker have known that the carrier was negligent. Court said, "Hey, one single accident by the carrier doesn't doesn't meet that standard of pleading, right? You got to allege something uh to show that the uh the broker should have known that the carrier was unsafe." I think that'll be interesting in terms of, you know, how these things are pled on the, you know, on the outset by the plaintiff. Absolutely. And I think Yeah. Yeah. I I think you're exactly right when you're talking about what you plead to get past the motion to dismiss. Yeah. Maybe you don't plead enough and the the negligent selection is is dismissed for that moment, but you're still going to have discovery. And plaintiff attorneys are going to say, "I want to know what the process is for you vetting motor cares." And they're going to say, "I want to depose somebody." and then they may amend their complaint. The challenge that so many brokers have right now, not the big ones, the big ones already have insurance, but many of the small ones don't. The only legal requirement for a broker is a $75,000 shy bond. If you don't have liability insurance and you get tagged with process, you are litigating this thing out of pocket. So, insurance for anyone who loves insurance, and I'm one of them, uh, duty to defend and duty to indemnify. The duty to defend is much broader than the duty to indemnify. It's the most important part of the insurance, but indemnification is important, too. But you want to have a lawyer who can represent you for the for not out of pocket. And that required shy bond is only answerable to freight charge claims, right? It wouldn't even do it would do nothing for highway accident litigation. 100% correct. I thought that was an interesting um note in Kavanaaugh's concurrence was hey look even though we're saying all right there's no preeemption. It's interesting that you know brokers were never required to maintain liability insurance. You know this was the argument that suggests right maybe that does suggest that it wasn't intended. This is the argument advanced by the US Chamber of Commerce and TIA as well as all the others who jumped into this thing. the DOT, the FMCSA, they were all on the side of CH saying they are not in a position to tell us who is safe and who is unsafe. But I think what ends up winning the day is two things. One, the 29 states in the District of Columbia filed an Amikas brief in this case and said, "We want to hold people accountable that injure our citizens." And that that held a lot of weight. The other thing as I think is interesting which we're kind of feeling the last couple of days is somehow this story of broker liability got wrapped into English language proficiency and non-domicile CDL holders. And now the thing is well we're going to hold brokers accountable for hiring people that are undocumented or can't speak English. And when you start this program up Brandon I think it's really great to note it's 20,000 or so citations for English language proficiency. There is no pathway for a driver to get back into driving that vehicle. There's no test that you give them and say, "Oh, here you go." So, is it security theater? Is it safety theater? I don't know. But I do know that there's a million trucks and trailers on the road right now that if you stopped and looked at them, you'd say, "Oh, I didn't think the airlines are supposed to rub together and have air leaks. I didn't know that was a problem." So, I'm hoping this this verdict, this this order from the Supreme Court gets us accelerated to do something about what actually matters, the safety of motor vehicles. Brokers do not understand the safety of motor vehicles, but they're going to have to figure it out. I want to take a step back and ask you uh I guess what would be some kind of procedural questions, more of a kind of behind the curtain look at how lawsuits play out for folks. Obviously, we got three lawyers sitting here and so we're fairly wellversed in in because Matt, you mentioned what brought this to mind was you mentioned uh motion to dismiss and then discovery. I don't think folks who are just looking at this casually uh appreciate necessarily. Some may do, some may, but some may not. Appreciate what it is that preeemption got you in terms of the strategy for the case and vers and how that has been removed and how that sends you further in to a case and cost you more money. I was just wondering if if one or both of you could kind of break down the practical implications of no preeemption when it comes to how these lawsuits will play out going forward. I can jump in there. So, preeemption broadly says the claim is done. like I don't care what you're arguing, whatever happened done before it even starts really before it starts. Like you you have your preeemption argument and the story is over for you as a party to the litigation. Now, there was always these questions of well, what if it's gross negligence or willful wanting conduct? The broker was drunk when he hired the trucking company who was also drunk. Should we all sue each other? But preeemption was this broad way to say categorically, you cannot find me liable for negligent selection. My job is straightforward. finding a motor carrier to move these things at the price we've agreed to. So, so common point of confusion there, I think, is you'll hear a lot of folks say, "Well, it was a shield from being sued." It was never a shield from being sued. I mean, there was always the possibility you're going to get dragged into the lawsuit. It was more a matter of how quickly can you get yourself out of that lawsuit. And preeemption lets assuming it's viable, gets you out pretty quickly. Essentially, the earliest stage you could get out in a case, which is a motion to dismiss. Yeah. It's it's a silver bullet that ends the story. It's like, okay, we you can sue me. Great job. Here's the motion to dismiss. Here's the federal preeemption language. We're going to be done. Now, that wasn't winning in two of the circuits. So, there were two circuits that already had like we're going to look at what brokers are doing. And the challenge we see kind of going forward, of course, the litigation practice. So, you get your claim, you have your motion to dismiss, you have maybe some limited discovery, then you have broader discovery, and then you have all the motions after that, and then you have a trial. Um, the longer you're in the litigation, the more expensive it's going to be. So, you guys probably have better knowledge about this than I do, but in litigation, it can be $20,000 a month you're spending just to defend yourself, not to say what your liability would be. And because that that preeemption argument is gone, now you're going to be arguing the facts, which is I did this, I did this, I did this. And for us lawyers, we're going to be okay. We're going to be just fine. We're happy to help you. That's a long drawn out process at that point. Absolutely. One of the things I think we're going to find which is not widely reported yet but will be absolutely all over the news is when brokers get renewals on their liability insurance. Anecdotally we have heard of brokers that have liability insurance and the number goes up 300 to 500% because of the new way we see liability. And that is something most brokers cannot sustain. Big ones they're going to be okay. You mentioned duty to defend. So the ins so for the brokers that have that type of insurance which presumably provides coverage for exactly that type of incident now that insurer is on the hook for all of those litigation costs potentially. Uh and so yeah it would just make sense that they were banking on getting out out of the case early with preeemption and so they're they they kind of hedged their cost against that. But now the new reality is you're probably going to be stuck in this litigation for longer. the costs are going to go up. That necessarily uh is going to have to result in insurance premiums going up 100%. I mean, now we're going to be looking at brokers likely spending on perhaps even parody with what motor carriers spend on a price per mile basis, 12, 15 cents a mile. That might be what brokers ultimately find out. And what I I worry we're going to see happen, just like we do with motor carriers, you get a judgment, you your insurer tenders the policy, you go bankrupt, and a couple months later you start up a new trucking company. Chameleon Carrier Brokers. Chameleon Brokers. That's right, buddy. Like, we have done nothing. This case does nothing to raise the bar for safety at all. Now, maybe privately some brokers will be much more skeptical of a of a conditional uh rating for safety, but the vast majority of motor cares have no safety record. like we have no safety rating for them. And so you're still kind of throwing that dart against the wall saying the federal government thinks that they're good. Is that enough? Absolutely not. I think you made a crucial point that I know Tyler and I have talked about internally and I think it's something to your point, Matt, that I think the court misunderstood or or just didn't spend enough time thinking about it is the available data that now we are going to be expecting brokers to look at, namely safety ratings and CSA scores and underlying inspection data. The FMCSA itself, the entity that publishes that data, has said very clearly for many years that the data is not valuable to assessing the safety of a motor carrier. So what exactly are we doing here? What I love about Kavanaaugh's concurrence, I think it speaks directly to what you're talking about. Kavanaaugh says, "Hey, listen, uh, there is going to be these claims of negligent selection, but we don't think it's going to be an epidemic. We don't want a bunch of litigation." And it's like you're opening the floodgates and you're looking at the water and saying, "Okay, you flow slowly. Don't go fast. You can't stop it." So the question your answer like, "Okay, what is a safe motor carrier?" It'll be found out through case law because the feds are not going to establish it. It'll be done through litigation. And just like we have tests for are you a contractor or are you an employee, we will have tests. Are you a safe motor carrier or are you not? And it might be 50 different tests. And the same will go for the selection process. What is a reasonable process? Is it every single tool? Is it half of the tools? Is it three of the tools? No idea. And it's going to be something that will only be determined either through an act of Congress, which does not seem likely, or you're going to have a litigation, and every single time a broker's involved, they're going to be sued. Um yeah, just to give an example of this, uh you know, safety rating historically, even prior to this decision was kind of the the marker that was used in in carrier selection for brokers and shippers. The the thought being that a carrier that has a safety rating has at least been through a DOT audit. There has been an investigator at their site or off-site looking at their records and has either signed off on them and let them continue to operate or not. The problem with that is is severalfold. Number one, I think upwards of 95% of the carriers in the country have no safety rating. They are unrated because it takes a FMCSA compliance review to get a rating and they just do not have the bandwidth to audit any significant percentage of the carriers that they regulate any given year. Secondly, those ratings by the FMCSA's own admission are snapshots of compliance that are stale the minute they are issued, right? Because they are looking at historical documents when they come in to assess a motor carrier's compliance up to the date of that rating. So, you will see this fairly commonly, more commonly with private carriers than with four higher carriers, albeit um that a carrier may have a conditional safety rating, the middle tier rating, and they may live with that rating for decades. I saw a conditional rating last week that was 30 years old. Carrier had lived with a conditional rating for 30 years. What good is that rating to us now looking back? Are we assuming that they are in the same compliance posture now that they were 30 years ago? That's essentially what you're doing when you're looking at safety ratings. Now, granted, the newer it is, maybe the more telling it is of the carrier's current compliance posture. But that's just an issue with the safety rating process in general. And if we're going to say, and if we're going to tell juries that they should be looking at that, I mean, I think the defense has to be the limited value that those things really really bring to the equation. I I can't agree with you enough because one of the big facts of the CH Robinson case with Montgomery was that Carb Transport had a conditional safety rating. And what that means practically is any broker who hires someone with a conditional safety rating is going to be on the hook for liability because that is clearly established, at least in this case, you're not going to be able to plead and say, "Oh, I did a good due diligence." So people the plaintiff's attorney is is just gonna say this is the exact same case that the US Supreme Court has already decided even though it's not really and and this is the thing I think that why the Supreme Court I'm not going to say they got it wrong. I think that they had the right idea that we want people to be safer. I do believe that. But there are no tools that help you solve this problem. And if you're looking to find private tools, and you're going to find a whole bunch of them, they're never going to be good enough. There is no way. The only way we know you're not allowed to hire or move freight in this country is that the FMCSA revokes your authority. And if the if the FMCSA says you have authority to do this job and you hire them, what is negligent about that? Now, if it's the government doesn't have the resources to audit or get more compliance, that's not solved by brokers. That doesn't that they're not here to solve that. I use the analogy before we had uh the computer booking for airlines. If I called a travel agent and said, "I want to fly to Chicago to New York and the plane goes down." I'm not suing the agent and saying, "Why'd you put me on a dangerous plane?" You'd say, "That's not how this works." If the plane goes down, you're probably not suing anybody to be honest. Well, my my estate my estate will take care of me. But like what I look at is like brokers are in an impossible situation right now. If you exert too much control, you are responding out superior. you're a hiring entity, you're liable. If you don't do enough, you've negligently hired a motor car and now you're also liable. So, it's this two-sided sword that I don't understand how you thread that needle. That's an important point I really want to press on because I think it's something that gets lost in all of the noise. Uh because you'll see a lot of uh folks out there advocating or or maybe not advocating, but at least suggesting it as something that brokers should consider doing. things like vetting at the driver level, asking for driver qualification forms, asking for ELD records, asking for drug and alcohol testing records. And they're not looking at the concern you've just raised, which is you swing the pendulum too far in that direction where you are essentially becoming a motor carrier in and of yourself by doing these things that are expected of a motor carrier. Now all of a sudden you're not run maybe you're not running the risk of negligent hiring anymore. You are running a real risk of so much control over that motor carrier's operations that you become the motor carrier in a legal sense and now you're just directly liable for the negligence of that driver. Absolutely. And the same story goes for shippers that work directly with motor carriers. Like the reality is this F4A didn't just protect the brokers, it protected the shippers who also had the same challenge of selecting motor cares from a pool. Now the numbers are wonky. Maybe there's 600,000 motor cares somewhere in that neck of the woods and about 6,000 or so enter the business every month. So it's a it's a feast or famine. A pendulum moves really quickly and our regulators are behind the eight-ball trying to determine if someone is compliant or not compliant. All of these carrier vetting tools are designed for fraud and cargo theft prevention. They're not designed to say, "Oh yeah, this company has a great safety record. Their maintenance and repair is terrific. You're hiring one of the best." That's not what they're designed to do. And those companies that jump into that space, oh woe be to you when we come after you and say, "You told them that they were safe and they weren't safe. Maybe you should be sued, too." And this is what's going to happen. And another thing I noticed with Go ahead, Don. Oh, go ahead. I was going to say that the problem with those platforms, especially ones that purport to recreate CSA scores, you know, with some level of accuracy maybe, but they're saying, "Oh, yeah, you know, you can trust these." And then however they designate these carriers in their program, you know, red, green, yellow, um, you know, safe, unsafe, whatever is, you know, it just seems really problematic. And and you know a lot of brokers they want a binary decision of somebody tell me yes this one's safe no this one's not I don't you know how much do I look at out of service scores do I request CSA scores you know what else do I do which obviously is part of the question here but you know they want to rely on a tool like that but Matt kind of like you said you can't you can't just rely on on one of those platforms to to guarantee Medicare is safe yeah as we're talking about this I just wanted to pull this up because this goes to the issue we already highlighted which is the FMCSA itself noting the limited value of its own CSA data and so if you can read if you're watching here you could see the screen I'm showing here this is the FMCSA's CSA website the very first thing that pop up pops up when you pull up this website to even start to search for a motor carrier is a notice that says pursuant to the FAST act it was an act of Congress from 2015 certain information about the FMCS SA's safety measurement system related to property carriers compliance and safety performance is no longer available for public display. It's been no longer available for public display for uh about 10 years now. Property carrier data available to the public includes inspection the underlying inspection data. Um uh let me get to the gist of this here.
So it goes on to say that the the data is going to remain hidden from public view uh and is only available to um to the motor carriers directly if they log in with their accounts or to FMCSA certainly and also to uh to law enforcement if they wanted to pull it up. And the reason they are doing this is because of a settlement that they reached in a case. And Tyler, you had just looked at that recently. What was their language? I thought it was on this notice but I'm not seeing it here. um what was their reasoning for putting up this type of notice? Did you have that handy? Yeah, I'd have to pull it up, but it was effectively and the the the lawsuit was basically towards getting the CSA scores to not be public. Um was, hey, look, these scores are meant for um you know, regulatory enforcement. They weren't necessarily meant for safety or for determining that any carrier was safe. So it was really a tool for all regulatory enforcement. Now of course you know what's a if if you have access to even you know recalculated CSA scores all regulatory enforcement for safety. Okay. Um but at least at least the FMCSA has said that you know look they're they're not meant to be relied upon as a measure of a carrier's yeah they are meant as a prioritization system. Right. We we've talked about how small of an agency the FMCSA is relative to the universe of carriers it regulates. It has to find a way to prioritize motor carriers for its attention uh in the form of audits usually. And the way that it does that is it prioritizes them based on their roadside inspection data. And so in putting up that notice and taking these scores down from public view, it's essentially saying it's a prior prioritization system. We view it as such. It helps us push to the top the carriers that we need to take a closer look at. That's not to say if we go do take a closer look that we're going to find something. It just pushes them up so that they get our attention and we can can use our resources there. And so now we're in a in a place where um brokers and shippers are they're even a step removed from this because we they can't even get access to the public scores. So the only way they get access to some semblance of these scores is through these third parties that at best are simulating the scores based on the underlying data. So they are having to build their own systems to estimate what the actual scores are. They're not the actual scores. They are estimates of what the scores are. Scores that aren't even really intended to assess the the safety of the motor carrier. So big problem all around. It's a fascinating topic because you see what the FMCSA is basically admitting to is hey we don't really know the motor cares that are authorized to hire. We we know of them. They filed documents with us and those documents are in good standing as far as we know. And what I think this kind of highlights where the broader problem that I have with the Montgomery decision is that we're passing blame to somebody who is illquipped to take that liability on. You have the ATA for years saying the barriers to enter are too high. We need to have more people, more meat for the grinder. And ultimately, you look at a case like Delila Coleman. I I talked with Delila's father, Marcus, at a um at a a broker carrier summit event, and the story he told me was heartbreaking. His family was in a vehicle. It was hit by a trucking company. The trucking company was hired by CH Robinson. They had a million-doll policy. A third of that went to the lawyer. A third of that went to the hospital bills. and a third of that went to someone who was catastrophically injured and they can't go after CH because of what we have with broker liability. Now, he certainly can, but ultimately what drives this litigation is that the trucking companies are underinsured for the risk that they create. And so, you have to pivot and say, who else can I sue? If I can use any platform I can, there's three things that I would do to fix this industry or at least solve some of the problems. I'd love to get your guys' reactions. First one, adjust the minimum liability to inflation. It was set at 750 in 1985, the year I was born. Great year to be born. Not a great year to benchmark your insurance in perpetuity. And so it sounds like a great idea. The problem is going to be that first jump, right? After 30 years of no inflation adjustment. Abs. Well, and this is a problem that we as an industry have caused. Um, you right now there's a bill in Congress called the Fair Compensation for Truck Crash Victims Act pushed by the Truck Safety Coalition and uh I think Chewy Garcia is a rep sponsoring it. Uh, it would go to 5 million. That'll never happen. That'll never happen. But 2 million, could that happen? Maybe. It would certainly take capacity out of the market because that's what that would functionally do. The other one you and I have talked about before, Brandon, which is uh the FMCSA and the Federal Highway Administration require one commercial vehicle inspection per year done by an independent qualified mechanic. It could be one of your fleet mechanics. It could be a dealer or travel center. I was going to say, yeah, not even independent. Could be your own in-house mechanic. Exactly. As long as they satisfy the requirements of being trained for, you know, brake inspector qualification and brake certification. But if you have two of those a year, then you'd at least catch more issues in a preventative maintenance side of things. And then the last one, which I think is the one that's the most uh least controversial, is increase the budget for the FMCSA. Yeah. If you can't audit what you have, then you need to get more things like that. That's the that's a fundamental question. If you can't maintain something, why would you own it? And that's where I I feel we could have some actual solving of the safety issue as opposed to let's pass on this $10 million Berg to a broker who's never operated a truck in their entire life. It just baffles me. Yeah. Yeah, I think in that 60-minute episode they said that the FMCSA at any given time has only a couple hundred safety investigators that can do the compliance reviews compared to uh the last numbers I heard is we have roughly 700,000 truck and bus companies operating in the United States. And so you end up each year with around a thousand total audits conducted against that 700,000 number of of trucking companies. So yeah, getting the FMCSA some more resources I think would help. Um uh assuming they put those resources to good use, obviously that's the that's the trick. Um but absolutely. Yeah, I think all three of those things I think the most likely would be FMCSA maybe getting an injection to their budget. Uh insurance uh rate increases or uh limit increases has been on the table many times before as we all know. It's always failed decades. Um but but and to to speak to that point of why it fails typically OIDA and the American Trucking Associations oppose increasing the limits. They oppose this because their thinking is if you make it higher amounts of premiums or higher minimum policies, then they're just going to pay out more in terms of settlements. And like that's an interesting argument, but wouldn't it be nice to just insure for the risk that you create in the industry? Yeah. Speaking of insurance and and taking a step back, uh we talked briefly, but I want to hit in closer on it, uh with respect to the insurance products that have been available historically for brokers and that may become available um more prominently here after Scotas' decision. I know Tyler, you've you advise on on this topic a lot. what what types of insurance coverages have been available to brokers that would kind of capture this type of risk historically and where do you see this going now after the decision? Well, I mean I think every single freight broker needs to have liability insurance coverage. It can be called different things. Truck broker liability contingent auto. Um but if you have to have that coverage and any shipper that's contracting with any freight broker should require that anyways, right? um cuz it you know the liability could go up the chain. Um even in those situations where shippers using a broker obviously in between um this is coverage specific to your liability in the event a carrier you hired correct uh is found to be negligent. It's based on your negligence in selecting that motor carrier or retaining them or Yeah. Okay. Yeah. No, I mean I think everybody's has to have that coverage and and I know I would so it's not it's not general liability coverage. It's not your own commercial auto liability coverage. It's a specific product coverage. Not, you know, it's broker liability or contingent auto, whatever name it's used. It's that that specific type of coverage. Yeah. If you can afford it. We don't even know if that a lot of uh insurers are going to get those policies to market. We've seen a lot of insurers pull out of trucking generally. So, this is a But I agree 100%. you have to have the insurance because if you don't, the duty to defend is lost and you need that duty to defend. Yeah, I think the cost of that is going to be really interesting. I was um texting with a buddy of mine um at a large brokerage um and he said, you know, I think they were in in the course of renewals and, you know, requ 3x. That's what I heard too, you know, and it's like and and this is, you know, a a firm that's big enough that, you know, they they have, you know, presumably some controls in place and, you know, they've been doing it long enough that it's not just a small shop, but, you know, three three times immediately. Um, you know, almost overnight. Uh, that's that's going to be tough for for a lot of freight brokerages. And then I kind of worry too, it's like, hey, if you know, kind of like what we see in the in the in the primary auto market is, you know, hey, you get one claim, you're going to get dropped, you got to try and find other coverage, you know, kind of getting to the potential chameleon broker thing. But but frequent changes in insurance coverage and people, you know, freight brokers just having to price shop that every year towards trying to find some sort of coverage. Yeah. So, at that point, we're talking about insurance fraud, right? Not so much cuz cuz to Matt's earlier point, FMCSA doesn't require them to file any proof. So, it's not like they get denied insurance or they can't afford it and and now they're trying to reincarnate to appease FMCSA. They're they're doing they're they're going to be potentially at risk of insurance fraud by getting denied coverage and then probably not answering truthfully on their next insurance application about their their previous dealings with other insurers, stuff like that. When you don't address the underlying issues that cause unsafe motor carriers, you're just going to have more unsafe motor carriers. It doesn't change any calculus other than if there is an accident, now you have another person you could absolutely target with litigation, but it doesn't change the underlying mechanics of running a trucking company. So, I want to ask you about the Montgomery case specifically. What happens to it next? Where does it go next? This is not the necessarily the end of the case, although it it may end up settling. But what what what's the procedural hook now? Remanded the district court, buddy. We're going to go back to the district court where F4A was preempted the discovery and the litigation around the hiring process. That issue will then be litigated. And what CH is likely experiencing, I I cannot speak for CH, but I do admire the team over there. They probably have dozens, maybe more of these cases actively right now that now have to be looked at through this new lens. And this is going to emphasize just how important it is to have a written process that you do not deviate from. If you have a process, do not deviate from the process. If you deviate, that's how me and Tyler, not us, we're more defense people, but we get the hooks into you and you can't get out. if you deviate, oh, your process is absolutely negligent if you if you start deviating. Well, and I I think that's kind of the the balance that, you know, people are going to have to find um of, you know, how much data and information do we review so that a we're trying to, you know, make sure we're selecting safe carriers, whatever that may be, and not making it so complicated that you can't follow it on a consistent basis every time. Um, you know, I I think there's some difficulty with that. you know, it's like, "Hey, do you want to review uh out of service rates?" Okay. Well, there's a little bit of nuance if you're looking at that depending on the number of inspections or the type of out of service violations that happened. And to consistently do that every time you're vetting a carrier, I think that's, you know, Matt, you're you're dead on. If you're not following your own policy, wow, that's gonna that's a really great fact of negligence for a plaintiff's council. Absolutely. I mean, I see a world where I don't want this to happen, but I can see it gradually moving to this way. Driver qualification files, which have privacy rights. You shouldn't have you should never send that to somebody, but that might be the expectation because if you're going to be on the hook as a broker, for the individual driver that moves that load, you might need to know about this. Maybe you want to see truck inspection records, not from the government, but from like your mechanic, like what's the last PM site? What was the write up for the truck? Because if you're trying to establish a process that gets rid of unsafe motor carriers, and the reality is no one can tell you what is a safe motor carrier. There is no definition of what safe is. And it could be one trucker's bad day versus a pattern in practice of a company that doesn't know what they're doing. But these companies are still legally authorized to move freight in this country per the FMCSA. So you're going to have to be more rigid than the government. and there's no guardrails. You don't know what it's going to require. So, we're going to see a lot of experimentation. And golly, will that be fun. Speaking of the no definition of what is a safe motor carrier, there's two topics I want to hit on before we run out of time here. one is gets to that point which is and I think Matt already kind of touched on this but the outlook for Congress to potentially step in in some form or fashion and either I I think the more likely thing that we could see I guess I could see on one hand maybe the the maybe the Congress stepping in and trying to tweak F4A somehow. I I don't think that that's likely. What I think is probably more likely, though I don't know how likely, is that Congress steps in uh and proposes something that they have proposed many times before and it's always failed, which historically has been called some kind of a national hiring standard, which is a, you know, a list of things that a broker or a shipper is going to be expected to do when vetting motor carriers before they turn over the freight to them. Maybe it's a list of like six things they have to look for. Safety rating, insurance filing, valid US DOT number, those classic things. But then at least it sets a standard that they meet that standard, then they should be good to go. Do you guys foresee any uh legislation to that end being raised in the near future? And what do you think its likelihood of success is if it were to be presented? So my initial two cents is because shippers of goods can face the same liability and those pockets are deeper, I could see the potential for um some legislation, you know, not just being pushed by, you know, people in the transportation industry, you know, TIA or anybody else, but you know, to the extent shippers start seeing a lot of these claims related to the carriers they hire. Now, maybe a little less likely due to the, you know, shippers are if they're contracting with a motor carrier. Generally, they're a little bit larger, more wellestablished enterprise carriers, but I could see that being the kind of being the push, you know, to to actually get Congress to do something about that because if if they're facing these claims too, they've got a, you know, pretty good incentive um to try and protect themselves. And I I don't know if there's, you know, Matt, maybe you can tell me. If I'm a shipper, I don't really necessarily have a contingent auto coverage in place necessarily. Certainly, um, might be a little bit more of a nuance type coverage for a shipper of goods that hasn't, you know, faced this liability before. But, um, I could see it. I'm far more cynical, Brandon. Like, I look at the Waw Bash case with the rear impact guard as a federal standard. and we said, "Well, the federal standard is just the bare minimum. There's more you can do, and you chose not to do more." I think that our Congress doesn't want to understand how our industry works. I think what they're likely to do is they're going to look at Delila's law as and say this is the what's going to solve these problems because the narrative in our industry has been these people who can't speak English or who who can't who are not doing our country legally are the dangerous ones. And again, it's not the case. Like this is a very dangerous industry that is underinsured and poorly maintained. I don't see Congress stepping in to jump on this one because I think it is a political grenade. Like it's not going to be helpful. What I think practically happens, and I hate to say this, um brokers are going to carry the minimum liability the trucking companies do a 750 and they'll just roll the dice and they'll see what happens. And the big ones like your Echo and your CH's and your TQLs, they got all the liability you could possibly imagine. They have trailers that they that they lease and operate for their customers. So, they've been in this business long enough to know how this story goes. But I do not think in in the next couple of years you see any activity that really says this is the threshold for what is considered a a a reasonable vetting process. I think it's going to continue to evolve and it's never going to be a static number. Yeah. So, it's it's pretty it's going to be pretty turbulent to say the least over the next couple years in terms of for lawyers just like Kavanaaugh wanted. Just like Kavanagh wanted. All right. So, Oh, go ahead. I heard Craig Fuller. What did he say? We don't need more attorneys. Am I Are we the villains of the story? Is that what I'm getting? Because I don't feel that way, but maybe. I don't think we are. We're the good ones. We're the good ones. All right. So, to wrap things up here, uh I think it's been a great conversation. Appreciate you both jumping on here. Um obviously, Truck Safe, uh and and me and Tyler specifically, we work a lot with motor carriers. And so to this point, we've talked a lot about, you know, the likely impact to brokers and to shippers. I want to ask you both about what do you see the impact being, if there's going to be an impact on the motor carrier side of things? What should motor carriers be thinking about as they assess how this decision may potentially impact them? Well, I'd love that. Oh, go ahead. You go. No, you go ahead, Matt, please. I think one of the things we're going to find is that brokers are going to require freight brokers Brokers are going to care require motor carriers to have higher levels of insurance. Um that their exposure as a as a broker is predicated on how much insurance the motor carrier has. And if we see that brokers are like, "Hey, I don't want to have bare minimum. I want to have higher thresholds." They're already doing that because shippers are telling them to do that. So brokers are already starting to push on motor cares and say, "I want this and this and then you can work with me." So, I think that'll be a a pretty interesting change for motor carriers that generally work with small brokers. Um, you might have a struggle finding freight because I think the bigger brokers are going to be the ones that are control even more than that. For the motor carriers that are part of big fleets, this is going to be great for you. I mean, shippers are going to realize like they already have that I need people with who are stronger intermediaries with way more insurance that can cover this liability if something catastrophic happens. So for big motor carriers, it's probably going to be good for all of you. Tyler, any any other thoughts on that? Yeah, other thought, I think, you know, motor carriers that work with brokers should expect to um face some additional questions uh regarding their safety, you know, data, their, you know, inspections, you know, whatever else. Um could be accidents, accident rate, you know, some brokers might request CSA scores. Um, so I think I think carriers should expect some additional vetting um and questions um from both brokers and shippers. To that end, um, something I've been advocating for years, obviously by the date of this article, I wrote this article in 2021, but I think it's even more pertinent now than it ever has been, which is that if you're a motor carrier and you don't have a pulse on what your enforcement metrics are saying about your fleet, you really need to spend some time now more than ever understanding what all of these all of this publicly available data is saying about your fleet. number one, understanding what data is out there. And then number two, understanding what your data is, what what kind of story it's telling about your fleet because that's what's going to be looked at now even more closely than ever by your customers. And so to that end, I mean, we've got this article here, five enforcement metrics carriers must track. It's on our website, trucksafe.com. It it talks about the ones that brokers and shippers are going to be looking at. inspection selection system, accident rates, out of service rates, CSA scores, and all of that type of stuff. If you want a resource for better understanding what these metrics are, what they say about your fleet, I'd recommend you go check that out. Also, something we we are working on moving back into to the broker side of things. Um, if if anybody's interested, we've already had several folks reach out to us and ask us for something like this. So we are in the uh in pretty deep into developing an online course specific to brokers and shippers and helping them understand these metrics and how to use them, what they say, how to access them. Uh this is going to be an online course that we're going to offer for anybody that's in working in a brokerage that needs to understand what they're looking at when they're pulling down this data. Uh so we're hoping to have that available here in the next month or so. that's going to be available at trucksafe.com/broker. Uh it's not up yet, but it will be here uh soon. So, trying to push out educational resources for folks that are going to now find themselves in a position of having to understand what these metrics are and what they're saying, even if you don't want to be in that position. I'd like to do one quick uh thought for both of you guys. I want to put my aluminum foil hat on for a moment. Uh, last week was the last day, May 15th, to comment on the FMCSA's waiver of the, you know, placard. So, the beacon for the robots. I have a feeling I have a feeling that we're going to see regulations promulgated in the next couple of maybe end of this year, early next year about autonomous trucks. I think if you look at the Montgomery case, you look at the ELP and the non-domiciled, everything is moving to this question of there's too many unsafe motor cares. We give it to the robots. We got to go to the robots. We got And I I welcome our robot overlords. I I I freely admit this. But what do you guys think about that? Do you think that is a a part of this story we're going to see unfold? I don't know what what what was that Avengers episode with the uh was it the Age of Ultron? That Ultron? Yeah. Go ahead, Todd. Well, um believe there was a um act proposed in Congress, Build America 250 act that does include a bunch of autonomous spending bill. Yep. Yeah. So, so I think it's Matt, I think it's already started and and I I'm I'm with you. I mean, for for long haul right now, I mean, it looks like things are progressing pretty well with the technology and you know, I feel pretty good about technology being potentially safer than most humans who are constantly distracted. You can't have a 20% out of service rate with a robot. You got to have that 99.9% working. So, I'm with you. I think this is going to help drive that adoption of the technologies that'll hopefully keep us all safer. Yeah, highway bill. I I misspoke. Uh highway bill, if anybody's interested in that, I think uh Rob from our team just put out an article on that in the uh in freight waves breaking it down, but it has a big provision in there related to autonomous trucking. And I mean, sorely needed regulation. We have no framework whatsoever as it stands now for autonomous vehicles despite the fact that they're out there operating. Yeah, there was um Oh, go ahead. Oh, there was there was also language in there about actual promulgating regulations on um brokerage requirements and that's right requirements as well. So definitely um kind of timely there. Yeah, there was a discussion bill in Congress for the self-drive act, autonomous trucking bill for that. And in the text it said it would be essentially selfcertification by the OEMs that this product and this technology itself. Isn't that great? Isn't that great? I love it about self-certification. We love us some self-certification in this industry. I looked at my belly button. I did everything right. Can I have the money now? All right, guys. We're out of time here. Uh like I said, appreciate you both jumping on here, hearing your perspectives on these. If anybody's interested in following you, Matt, where where can they follow you? Just find me on the interwebs. I'm screaming into the oblivion. Sometimes the oblivion screams back at me. Then you can find me and Tyler over at Truck Safe for Children's Law. Uh we're going to have a lot to say about these topics. I have a feeling over the next uh over the next few months here. So stay tuned in to everything we're doing at Truck Safe trying to push out a lot of content various forums. So yeah, I appreciate y'all tuning in today. Uh that's going to wrap it up for this show. We'll see you next time. See you.